Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

History Impossible

History Impossible artwork

The Third Reich Diagnosis

Nov 19, 20262 hr 8 minAudio

Understanding evil is something that has preoccupied humans for a long time. By the mid-20th century, the desire to root it in firm, social scientific terms became the norm, particularly in the field of psychology. The reason for this was simple: World War II. More specifically, the Third Reich and its genocidal campaign to dominate Europe and wipe out its Jews. No one could wrap their heads around something that had become so destructive and violent and what kind of people would willingly, even seemingly enthusiastically, engage in such barbarism. It was something many believed we had somehow transcended. And yet, it was clear by 1945 that we had not. Tens of millions lay dead, and most of the leadership responsible for those crimes were part of that death toll, often by their own hands. But several remained, and in the year that they spent in jail cells and on trial for their participation in these crimes was going to be well-spent, with psychological experts probing them in order to understand their impulses. Two of these experts - Dr. Douglas Kelley and Dr. Gustave Gilbert - became central figures in reaching a diagnosis, not just of the men they studied, but of the Third Reich in general. The debate that emerged between these two men would then echo across history, even when later scholars and observers - including Hannah Arendt - weren’t even fully aware of it. This is the story of the attempts - foolhardy or noble - to diagnose the Third Reich and its crimes. ... History Impossible has been made possible by the following generous supporters on Patreon, Substack, and PayPal. Please consider donating today if you want to show some love for what I do and make and what to help keep the show and all my written content going: David Adamcik Monica Almirall David Alsbach Gregg Anderson approso1999 Rajan Athul Robert Babeon Tony Bauer Michael Beach Benjamin Greg Bosai Johannes Breitsameter Carol ABC Carol Chappelle Charles C Chomo the Clown Curtis Christiansen Jason Coleman Clayton Connell Click Cliffydeuce CR Craig Crawford B.Cyr daddygorgon Lynda Davis Paul DeCoster Regina Dick-Endrizzi Neil Dickens Nathan Diehl Bob Downing Dramicas Eastone Gavin Edwards Snow Farmer Howie Feltersnatch Matt Gassner Pierre Ghazarian Josh Goedert Elena Gomel Sam Graham Jayson Griesmeyer Nathan Grote Benjamin Hamilton Tong Xu Han Peter Hauck Jack Henneman Eric Hodges Mike Jarulic Joe6245 Lionel Joseph Thomas Justesen Kilian K Mike Kalnins Bryn Kaufman Leah Kodner Constance Loucks Maddy Mounty of Madness Jose Martinez Mike Mayleben S.M. McAvoy Judy McCoid Mike Kyle Mohney Kostas Moros Ryan Mortenson John Muller Cameron Needham Sean P Skip Pacheco David Page Molly Pan Philip Pomerantz Sr. Powell Brian Pritzl AnaR737 PJ Rader Gleb Radutsky Aleksandr Rakitin Reptilycus Matthew M. Rice Phillip Rice Cheryl Robertson Terry Rosen Run Tough Mindset Andrew S Dan S Jon Andre Saether Jake Scalia Emily Schmidt Julian Schmidt Scryptar Andrew Seeber Shane Shiran Joshua Simpson Cameron Smith Jerry Spangler timetosuccedd1995 Thomas Squeo Athal Krishna Sundarrajan Jared Cole Temple Ann Tout Mike US Ward Van Roy Pierre Vorupuni Robert VS Nate Wade weaverap Jonny Wilkie Christian Wilson Janora Winsor M. Yao Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/history-impossible--5634566/support.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Hello everybody, ladies and gentlemen, brothers and sisters, comrades and friends. We're back with another very special episode of History Impossible. I shouldn't say special episode, it's not a bonus or anything like that. I guess you could consider it a bonus, but it's really part of this ongoing sort of sub-series that I'm doing that deals with the after-effects, the aftermath, and the fallout from the Second World War. as we lead into the final episode of the Muslim Nazi series,

Speaker 1which deals with those themes quite a bit, as I said in the last episode when talking about the firebombing of Tokyo. I figured that this, that is, an audio adaptation of the final piece of original research I did for grad school, apart from the thesis, which actually is in review right now as of this recording. I have submitted it, and hopefully very soon I will get the green light on it, and I will have the much-vaunted master's degree in history. So, cross your fingers for me, guys. Anyway,

Speaker 1this last piece of research I did was a bit of a departure from what I had been studying in grad school, but not really a departure at all from, honestly, what a lot of you have come to expect from me here in History Impossible, because it deals with the Second World War and its fallout, like I was saying. But in this case, I was looking at the more intellectual history behind coping with the fallout of the Second World War, specifically with the crimes committed by the Third Reich.

Speaker 1There's a lot of commentary out there that claim to understand how we make sense of the world via the end of the Second World War, including, in my opinion, a very dismissive idea that we have a cartoon vision of how the Second World War was conducted and how it ended. And while I certainly agree there are elements of our historical understanding that are woefully inadequate when it comes to the Second World War, that's not a really good diagnosis of it. A word we'll be using a lot in this episode, actually. I think it's fair to

Speaker 1say that our understanding of the world was changed forever by the Second World War, and we can see that in how it affected fields that supposedly had nothing to do with history. At least not apparently. And that's why I ended up doing this research, because, partly inspired by the excellent film Nuremberg, starring Russell Crowe as Herman Goering, that I actually believe I did reference and put a clip of in the Firebombing of Tokyo episode I just did, relevant here too. But in part inspired by that, and

Speaker 1inspired by a book I read, just on a whim, honestly, which is Jack L. High's book that that movie was based on, where After reading, and after seeing that film as well, I came to realize that our attempts to understand the Third Reich from a legal perspective at Nuremberg was only scratching the surface. There was something much deeper going on. The work of Douglas Kelly, played by Rami Malek in the movie, is evidence of that, but he

Speaker 1wasn't alone. In fact, he was part of something much bigger, like I'm saying. And What he and his fellow psychologists and psychiatrists studying the Nazi war criminals ultimately uncovered was a precursor to some very famous observations made some decades later and tested, however imperfectly, by a lot of social psychologists, primarily in the 1960s and 1970s. And those tests, the

Speaker 1studies they produced, ended up becoming some of the most influential evidence and infamous, more importantly, in the field of psychology, specifically social psychology. In other words, trying to understand and diagnose the Third Reich had long-lasting effects, and those attempts to diagnose the Third Reich, to pathologize it in this sense, or to not pathologize it, for that matter, carries a lot of weight throughout history since the end of the

Speaker 1Second World War. The impulse of psychologists back in the 1940s to pathologize the Third Reich, or to at least diagnose it at a deep, fundamental, psychological level, was understandable. It is understandable. What the Third Reich did, what the Nazis did to so many millions of people, was unthinkable, especially when the details of those horrors were gradually uncovered. Gradually, but quickly, it should be noted. But there were limitations

Speaker 1to that. And that's essentially what I am looking at with this episode here, with this research I've done. How else could we best understand the scale of such evil without resorting to the newest cutting-edge fields of research at the time, that is, psychology? There had been no shortage of attempts to use psychology to understand the Third Reich even while it was going. I don't want to get too much into my own, you know, views on this

Speaker 1at this point. I don't want to spoil anything for what we're about to get into. So before we get started, I do want to thank everybody for listening and for supporting this show. Those of you who are able to financially support History Impossible, you can do so at historyimpossible.com or patreon.com slash historyimpossible and be like the amazing folks like Monica Almaral and Mike Malabin, longtime supporters of History Impossible at the executive producer level. If you subscribe or support the show on Patreon, you get access to all

Speaker 1of these episodes early, especially in the case of longer ones, and without any ads, which I know is very appealing to some people. You also get various goodies and souvenirs of sorts, depending on what level you support the show at. So if you want access to that kind of stuff, or you just really like what I do and want to show some love and help me pay off the student loans that are going to start piling up very soon, the due dates of which I should say, please consider

Speaker 1becoming a supporter of History Impossible. Again, historyimpossible.com or patreon.com slash historyimpossible. And if you can't support the show financially, that is totally fine. I understand you can only spend your money in so many places. I have to make those considerations myself. So if that's the case, just spread the word. however you can. Let people know who you know who are into history or who you just think would find this kind of stuff interesting about the show. Send them a link. However you decide to support History Impossible,

Speaker 1I want you to know I really do appreciate it. Truly, really appreciate it. So, with all of that out of the way, I think it's time we get into some impossible history.

Speaker 2Permit me to tell you what you would have seen and heard.

Speaker 3It will not be pleasant listening.

Speaker 4If you're at lunch, or if you have no appetite, now is a good time to switch off the radio.

Speaker 5An ancestor of mine maintained that if you eliminate the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must.

Speaker 6Be the truth. I wish I could say tonight that a lasting.

Speaker 4Peace is in sight.

Speaker 7I don't see any American dream, I see an American nightmare.

Speaker 4Some say the world will end in fire, some say in ice, but what I've tasted of desire I hold with those who favor fire.

Speaker 3But if it had to perish twice, I.

Speaker 5Think I know enough of hate to say that for destruction ice is also great and would suffice.

Speaker 2This is History Impossible.

Speaker 1Is evil something you are, or is it something you do? Bredy Sinellis The social psychologist of the future will have a number of classes of schoolchildren on whom they will try different methods of producing an unshakable conviction that snow is black. When the technique has been perfected, Every government that has been in charge of education for more than one generation will be able to control its subjects securely without the need of armies or policemen. Bertrand Russell Kelly

Speaker 1found some darkness in every person. Gilbert found a unique darkness in some. They were both right. Joel E. Dimmesdale It was June 11th, 1945. The Second World War had yet to fully conclude in the Pacific Theater, but the Allies had been victorious in Europe for over a month. Despite the finality of this victory, and of the Fuhrer Adolf Hitler's demise at his own hand, it had quickly

Speaker 1become clear that there were more questions than answers forming among the Allies. How had things escalated this much? How had the Nazis managed to exceed the destruction of the First World War so quickly and completely? How had so many crimes on a never-before-seen scale, the crimes that would come to be known as the Holocaust, managed to occur under the very noses of so many Germans? What kind of men could even do these crimes? Were they mad?

Speaker 1Or were they just truly evil monsters? Answering these questions had vital importance to many within American academia from a variety of different fields and including medicine, neurology, the arts, administration, and psychology. Leading a group of professors was the psychiatrist Dr. John Millett, and on that day, June 11th, 1945, he drafted a letter to be sent to the chief prosecutor

Speaker 1in what would become the famous Nuremberg trials, United States Supreme Court Justice Robert H. Jackson. The letter's primary purpose was requesting that these experts get hold of the war criminals' brains after they had been executed, with the letter reading as follows, Detailed knowledge of the personality of these leaders would be valuable as a guide to those concerned with the reorganization and re-education of Germany. In addition to the psychiatric interviews, it would be desirable to make a

Speaker 1number of psychological tests, such as the Rorschach. If and when the accused has been convicted and sentenced to death, it would be desirable to have a detailed autopsy, especially of the brain. Therefore, it is urged that the convicted be shot in the chest, not in the head. Signed, John Millett.

Speaker 8Unquote.

Speaker 1An agent for the Office of Strategic Services, the OSS, named Sheldon Glick, echoed and even spelled out these sentiments three days later in a letter written to Major General William Wild Bill Donovan, the founder of that organization, the OSS. Glick wrote that, quote, For the first time in history, a thorough scientific study of the types of mentality possessed

Speaker 1by the German military, political, and industrial insiders will be made.

Speaker 7Unquote.

Speaker 1Both of these letters demonstrate the enthusiasm that many had for trying to understand the very nature of those they rightfully saw as the embodiment of evil on Earth. Such measurements— the brains post-mortem and the Rorschach test— They were considered the cutting edge for their time. It's important to note that. There had been a growing chorus of speculation surrounding the psychology of the Third Reich itself since its very beginning, in 1933. And now that the Third Reich had been defeated, the victors, the Allies, could study their enemy, their seemingly

Speaker 1bizarre and strange enemy, up close and, so the thinking seemed to go, with few ethical limits or questions. the professors finally got their chance to study the literal mind of a Nazi. Justice Jackson had ultimately supported both proposals from Glick and Millett, and had already allowed the army to send in a psychiatrist in August of 1945, when the unthinkable happened that October. One of the accused war criminals held at Nuremberg, the Nazi politician and the head

Speaker 1of the German labor front, Robert Lay, had hanged himself in his cell, using a towel that he had turned into a noose by ripping it into strips and and fastening it to his toilet pipe. Within hours of his body being removed from the cell, Lay's brain was extracted and sent to the Armed Forces Institute of Pathology in Washington, D.C. The neuropathologist there found evidence of damage to the frontal lobe, likely caused by a head injury Lay had incurred during the First World War, and which was exacerbated by chronic

Speaker 1abuse of alcohol, confirming what many assumed. Lay's brain was abnormal. When the media learned of these findings, they began to trumpet the news, with the Washington Post proclaiming in their headline, Surely this helped explain, many reasoned, how and why the Nazis' reign of terror had seemed so deranged. Despite another neuropathologist named Dr. Nathan Malamud of San Francisco offering a second opinion, backed up by microscopic analysis, that Lay's brain

Speaker 1did not show any signs of true pathology, the American media continued to promote the idea of a diseased Nazi brain, in the most literal terms, but also figurative ones. However, no one actually studying the Nuremberg criminals was resting on their laurels just yet. Lay, along with the other defendants, had already been analyzed by the U.S. Army psychiatrist, Dr. Douglas Kelly, as well as the Army psychologist, Dr. Gustav Gilbert, among others. Both of these men were developing their own

Speaker 1ideas about the nature of the war criminals' minds, men who included the Reichsmarschall himself, Hermann Goering, and other high-ranking Nazi officials and military figures. But Dr. Kelly had put it most bluntly after Robert Lay's suicide, writing in his preliminary report on the Rorschach tests that had been conducted, quote, unquote.

Speaker 1It had become a matter of course that the Third Reich and its crimes would not just be understood, but quite literally diagnosed, and Dr. Kelly, along with Dr. Gilbert, would be at the center of finding that diagnosis, arriving at what seemed to be completely different conclusions, but what would, with time and despite some later setbacks, be demonstrated to be complementary ones. Arriving at a diagnosis of the Third Reich and its leaders has been at the root of

Speaker 1many questions raised about the history of the Nazi years, but it had a much wider impact on many fields of study that go beyond history, not least of which, psychology. With the collapse of the Third Reich, the destruction wrought by World War II, and the realization of the Holocaust's extent, deeper questions about human nature were given a new lease on life. thanks to many developments and advancements in the relatively new field. The famous Sigmund Freud had long been

Speaker 1a household name, and had indeed made his own commentary on the Nazis known, alongside many of his followers and critics alike. However, the Nuremberg trials and the role of psychologists in their judgments made a much more lasting impact on the field. This impact would experience a number of diversions, beginning with Hannah Arendt's reportage of the SS man Adolf Eichmann's trial in Jerusalem in 1961. But it found its origins in the differing interpretations of the two main psychological

Speaker 1experts that spent time with the Nazi war criminals in 1945-1946, that is, Drs. Douglas Kelly and Gustav Gilbert. What I was trying to do with the original paper that this episode is based on was to address the extent to which The Kelly-Gilbert debate shaped the development of the theoretical frameworks that experimental social psychology used to explain perpetrator behavior.

Speaker 1I also looked at how Hannah Arendt's banality of evil thesis that a lot of you have likely heard or remember hearing at one point or another, it actually overrode the influence of the Kelly-Gilbert debate on social psychology's perpetrator frameworks during the subsequent decades of intellectual development. And finally, what I hoped to do was assess what was potentially lost in the intervention created by Arendt's observations of the Eichmann trial. Namely, what I have come to see as

Speaker 1the missed opportunities in understanding crimes against humanity. I ultimately argued, and continue to argue here, that the Kelly and Gilbert debate offered vitally complementary insights into Nazi ordinariness, but their debate, that is, went cold after 1958, which missed an opportunity for intellectual synthesis, and this allowed Arendt's provocative reframing as mere banality to fill this void, which directly inspired the

Speaker 1most influential social-psychological studies for decades to come, and thus shaped the development of of social psychology, and perhaps psychology in general. That is, at least until recent challenges that resurrected both Kelly and Gilbert's assertions and revealed their complementary nature. When writing this paper, I was hoping to contribute to the pre-existing historiography, which often connects the work of Kelly and Gilbert to later observations by Arendt, but has so far neglected, at least in my view, to interpret Arendt's

Speaker 1contributions as a potential diversion from in the development of social-psychological theories of evil. In other words, the intellectual through-line that I observed I think is pretty novel. I believe that this through-line bridges the gap rather than simply notes the continuity. Simply noting continuity is fine, that's a big part of history, but it's also not very interesting in a lot of cases. In this case, I think there was a gap that, hopefully, what I found here does bridge. So,

Speaker 1in attempting to chart this intellectual history of modern social scientific attempts to diagnose evil, I think it follows the lead of historian Peter E. Gordon, who wrote that, quote, as historically conditioned features of the world which are best understood within some larger context. In other words, our psychological

Speaker 1understanding of evil did not sprout from the ground unbidden. Our current understanding of evil, I argue, was thanks to our attempts to diagnose the Third Reich itself.

Speaker 6In bombed-out Nuremberg, preparations go forward for the trials of Germany's major war criminals, and the shrine of Hitler's Nazism becomes its tomb. In Nuremberg's court building, where the trials will be held, German prisoners work at enlarging and rebuilding the courtroom. Under American supervision, they install broadcasting booths and press facilities to carry the proceedings throughout the world.

Speaker 4Robert H.

Speaker 6Jackson, Associate Justice of the United States Supreme Court, made preliminary arrangements for the trials. From the jail to the courtroom, a covered corridor has been erected. The war criminals will be screened from sight except in the courtroom, protected and saved for the disposition of United Nations justice. The big names of Hitler's Third Reich are kept under heavy guard. 20 minutes daily, the prisoners walk out of doors. Constant

Speaker 6vigilance prevents attempts at suicide or escape. Heavy nets guard against death leaps. The prisoners are kept in common cells.

Speaker 2Gurring. Bunribbentrop.

Speaker 6The leaders of Nazism faced United Nations justice.

Speaker 1Attempts at psychologically diagnosing the Third Reich occurred well before the Nuremberg Trials themselves, beginning even before the Second World War began in earnest. In fact, these attempts appeared shortly after the Nazi party seized power in 1933. Most psychological commentary at that time, in general, but in this case too, was based heavily on the principles of Freudian psychoanalysis. The

Speaker 1unconscious mind held the key, many of these analysts believed, to understanding how and why Germany had transformed so completely in such a short period of time. It held the key to understanding the people who led this new Germany, particularly its Fuhrer. This was why Hitler inspired so much close behavioral scrutiny from psychoanalysts. As medical historian Daniel Pick writes, It was noted by a number of commentators that the

Speaker 1personality of Hitler, his style of performance, and the panoply of rituals that surrounded him and his henchmen inflamed his followers far more deeply than they knew. unquote, leading to what many of these analysts believed was a, quote, an erotic and destructive enjoyment at stake in politics, unquote. It mystified many observing the Nazis' rise to power that there seemed to be so little resistance, at least effective resistance,

Speaker 1it should be said, against their ascent and increasing belligerence. Because obviously, there was resistance against the Nazis leading into their seizure of power. The Communists didn't just stop existing, at least not right away. And while the Social Democrats did their part in enabling the Nazis' rise to power, it should be noted that they still existed as opposition to them. Nevertheless, the Nazi seizure of power was rapid and surprising to a lot of people, and it did

Speaker 1seem like they had completely captivated the entire nation, at least from the outside looking in. Therefore, the explanation, a lot of these analysts believed, had to be internal, thus psychological. Those searching for the key to Hitler and the party's continued successes acknowledge political realities and historical grievances. But, as Daniel Pick writes, the unconscious, charismatic effect of the Fuhrer

Speaker 1was widely recognized to be of central importance. which was reinforced by the widespread coverage of Nazi propaganda material that depicted quote-unquote mass enthusiasm, such as the footage of the Nuremberg rallies of the mid-1930s. The Third Reich's and the Fuhrer's popular support was thus frequently conflated with psychopathology, at least by those who were shocked and horrified even by what they were seeing, or at least disturbed. And therefore,

Speaker 1the rise of the Third Reich was seen as something alien, the party was seen as something alien, understood the same way as one might understand a novel virus. Contemporaries in government and media certainly, in Pick's words again, quote, wondered if the Chancellor Hitler was out of his wits, unquote, which included the likes of George Orwell, to whom, quote, the madness of Hitler was assumed, unquote. As a more pointed example of The famous American journalist Dorothy Thompson wrote

Speaker 1an article for Cosmopolitan in 1931, followed by a book in 1932 called I Saw Hitler! in which she famously characterized Hitler as a, quote, little man, unquote. She later doubled down on her charge in an interview with the New York Times after the Nazis' seizure of power some years later, in which she called the dictator, quote, the apotheosis of the little man in Germany, unquote. Further extending her analysis to include the German people, who were, quote,

Speaker 1the victims of a war defeat psychosis, unquote, who, quote, were taught to believe the German military machine could not fail, unquote, and that, quote, when Hitler tells them it did not fail but was betrayed, they believe it, unquote. These sentiments had intellectual merit at the time. Within the dominant Freudian psychoanalytic school of thought, this was completely normal. The Nazis and those who followed them were the mass embodiment of illness,

Speaker 1which was seen as, quote, the price of the impossible conflict between unconscious desire and social restraint, unquote, and leading to, quote, fears of sociopolitical degeneration and a wider sense of cultural malaise, unquote, in the decades following the First World War. To use Dorothy Thompson's words again, Sigmund Freud's daughter Anna Freud, a psychoanalyst in her own right, wrote in 1936 that victims of aggression often identified with their aggressor, representing, quote, a

Speaker 1preliminary phase of superego development and, on the other, an intermediate stage in the development of paranoia, unquote. This observation, among others, was, quote, soon taken up in interpretations of the psychology of Nazism and even sometimes of concentration camp inmates, unquote. to use the words of Daniel Pick again, demonstrating the influence of a psychoanalytic approach when trying to make sense of the nascent and eventually dead and buried Third Reich.

Speaker 1The psychoanalyst's assessments of the Third Reich were mostly theoretical, especially before the outbreak of the war, but military intelligence officers with the Office of Strategic Services, the OSS, interested in psychoanalysis decided to turn theory into practice. with the analysts' help and guidance, especially after the outbreak of the war in 1941.

Speaker 8Dr.

Speaker 1Walter Langer was one of these analysts. He had studied with the Freuds in Austria and assisted in their escape, as well as the escape of other anti-Nazi activists in 1938, developing a keen personal interest in finding a psychopathological explanation for what was unfolding in Germany. Back in the United States in 1941, Langer, with the help of his brother William, applied for and received funds from Wild Bill Donovan, chief of the OSS. Langer mostly did work on troop morale,

Speaker 1but he also produced a, quote, report on the unconscious phantasmagoria in Hitler's mind, unquote, that would, quote, finally see the light of day after decades as a secret document. The mind of Adolf Hitler became a surprise bestseller in the early 1970s, unquote. as Daniel Pick puts it. Langer's report had a number of issues, to put it mildly, frankly, mostly involving the use of speculations and assumptions that could not and still cannot be proven or disproven, but it

Speaker 1does make for a compelling document, historically speaking at least. It's certainly steeped in hindsight to point out, but it is noteworthy that Langer's report accurately predicted, based solely on his interviews and observations of Hitler, that, quote, one outcome was highly likely, the German leader would carry on to the end, staying true to his desire, unquote, finally seeing a clash, quote, between his wishes and reality, unquote, leading to, quote, his mind collapsing altogether, even as his political regime and

Speaker 1military organization came apart around him, and a final, total breakdown, unquote. Langer also interviewed figures like Hitler's old friend, and then later enemy, the industrialist Ernst Putze-Hampfstangl, who was able to sketch out a fairly detailed image of the Fuhrer and his personality characteristics, at least as he saw them. As Daniel Pick summarizes, Hampfstangl would, quote, recall how the leader would enter in states of what he called destructive madness, unquote, and, quote,

Speaker 1claimed that Hitler was a madman who understood life through the muzzle of a gun, unquote. But most significantly, Hampfstangl understood presaged a similar diagnosis of the German people when he warned that, quote, German culture was producing a nation of machine beasts, unquote. While Langer's report had and has its limitations, it should be said again, it was a hit at the time of its production in the 1940s

Speaker 1with military intelligence. It seemed to be providing a vector for understanding the enemy and particularly its leader, at a fundamental level. The idea of the Führerprinzip was understood by U.S. military intelligence as a very real thing, not simply propaganda, so understanding the Führer was therefore key to understanding the German people who supported him, which, again, it should be said, seemed from the outside to be the vast majority of them.

Speaker 1putting aside those who were just going along for the ride, keeping their heads down, or who were actively or subtly resisting them, because those existed too. Basically, the theories of crowd psychology from the likes of Gustav Le Bon would only take military intelligence so far in trying to understand how the enemy worked, how the German people seemed to be supporting a complete madman. So, grasping the inner world of the Führer became paramount to them. This was, after all,

Speaker 1part of the shared premises of Nazism and Fascism, in which, quote, the party would gather the people into a unity, unquote, with a, quote, ideological promise of unity, singularity, and resolute direction. Only through total allegiance to the masterful leader could the hopeless confusion of modern life be ended, unquote. To use Daniel Pick's words again, Basically, the notion of, if you understand the Fuhrer, you understand the people, thus became the

Speaker 1sort of intellectual lodestar for the intelligence community during the Second World War. Unfortunately for everyone involved, they would not get the chance to fully understand Hitler as a psychological specimen. While Langer had written nothing specifically about suicide as the likely outcome of the When Hitler and much of the upper echelons of the Third Reich, including Joseph Goebbels and Heinrich Himmler, killed themselves, this assessment of Hitler reaching a

Speaker 1total final breakdown likely felt eerily prophetic to those who had read Langer's report. Nevertheless, as it quickly became clear in the months that followed VE Day, there were other high-ranking Nazis who could be questioned and profiled, and, hopefully, provide the diagnosis that so many had been trying to find. Even better, all of these Nazis would be in a completely controlled, that is, experimental environment. The jail cells at

Speaker 1Nuremberg's Palace of Justice.

Speaker 9Nuremberg, Germany is carefully guarded during the prosecution of the terrorists of the Nazi regime who ravaged Europe and committed unbelievable crimes against humanity. Brought before an international tribunal, the leaders of Hitler's Reich, including the still defiant Hermann Goering, the former number two Nazi, Rudolf Hess, and ex-foreign minister von Ribbentrop, face their accusers. Newsreel and Signal Corps cameramen

Speaker 9are privileged to sit in on this historic scene. These pictures reveal the arrogance with which the German warlords meet the charges of criminal injustice to civilized people. Prosecutor Robert Jackson of the United States opens the trial with a strong indictment of the defendants.

Speaker 2The privilege of opening the first trial in history... for crimes against the peace of the world.

Speaker 5Imposes a grave responsibility. The wrongs which we seek to condemn and punish have been so calculated, so malignant and so devastating that civilization cannot tolerate.

Speaker 2Their being ignored because it cannot survive They're being repeated.

Speaker 9Following the indictment, the presiding judge summons each defendant. The defendants are to plead.

Speaker 2Guilty or not guilty to the charges against them. Hermann Wilhelm Goering.

Speaker 10Before I answer the question of the court.

Speaker 1Little did the two psychological professionals at the center of the coming debate likely know, the essence of their debate had already emerged, and not exclusively from fellow psychologists and psychiatrists. It had actually come from two very influential media commentators, the aforementioned Dorothy Thompson and George Orwell. Echoing Puzzi-Hampfstangl's lament about Germany becoming a nation of machine beasts, Dorothy Thompson had,

Speaker 1while still assigning Hitler the role of proverbial bandleader of the Third Reich phenomenon, described the German people as, quote, the accompaniment of a tom-tom of mechanized howls from a drilled mob, howls that seemed to come from the throats of 10,000 robots, unquote. While Thompson's early assessments of the Fuhrer suggested a belief in his madness, she had become more concerned with exposing the danger of a charismatic leader who could, in all likelihood, whip any people up into

Speaker 1a frenzy. Conversely, George Orwell had become less concerned with drilled mobs and more with the idea that, quote, creatures out of the Dark Ages have come marching into the present, unquote. and that there were those out there who did indeed simply possess a, quote, fascist streak, unquote. These interpretations echoed the growing split among psychologists and psychiatrists regarding the particularity of the Third Reich and its crimes that had become

Speaker 1clear by 1943, with the publication of two separate inquiries by New York psychiatrist Richard Brickner and Vienna-born psychiatrist and former prisoner of the Nazis Bruno Bettelheim. As Daniel Pick summarizes, quote, Brickner's is Germany incurable, and Bettelheim's work on camp inmates, individual and mass behavior, pointed the way towards two different trajectories of post-war thought. The former concerned with localizing the horror of Nazism to the German case, in quotes there.

Speaker 1The latter suggesting that, under given conditions, certain victims, perhaps any victims, might start to think and even function like perpetrators, unquote. the latter case logically expanding into the idea that anyone could become a perpetrator of heinous crimes. Apart from the pointed allusions of media commentators like Thompson and Orwell, this diagnostic split had remained confined to academic journals and monographs like those written by Brickner and Bethelheim. But it was

Speaker 1about to grow in notoriety and significance thanks to the arrival of two men, Drs. Douglas Kelly and and Gustav Gilbert at Nuremberg. That debate emerged from the needs created by the Nuremberg trials, which sought to create a new precedent in which the international community would, collectively, charge a foreign state with a crime, and a crime that had to be defined, that is, crimes against humanity. We talked about this in the last major episode of History Impossible,

Speaker 1in essence, creating a law to help define a crime, Putting aside how problematic that is from a legal perspective, especially from a classically liberal perspective, that was what needed to be done. And in that spirit of expanding the purview of a typical court, the judges and prosecutors had to first address the basic question of whether any of the defendants were in fact mentally ill, and therefore unfit to stand trial. While there was some controversy with Deputy

Speaker 1Führer Rudolf Hess's fitness due to his claims of amnesia that had been going on for years at that point, and other more outlandish behavior from figures like the propagandist Julius Streicher, none of the 22 defendants at Nuremberg were deemed unable to testify. However, there were more practical, legal reasons to consider that had more to do with providing answers to a deeper question that many psychologists had been trying to puzzle out for years. In the words of

Speaker 1historian Lawrence Reese, quote, unquote. The incentive to address this question, as previously covered, had been in place for over a decade. Finally, quote, Now, here at Nuremberg, there was a chance to find answers, at least it seemed to be the case that there was a chance to find answers, but they would come in pieces rather than as a whole.

Speaker 4Dr.

Speaker 1Douglas Kelly was the first to arrive at Nuremberg in August of 1945, and immediately he got to work trying to make sense of his subjects as he saw them. Again, subjects, as part of an experiment. There might be a bit of irony there, but we'll Put that aside. By Kelly's own estimation, he spent around 80 hours with each prisoner, though, as psychiatrist and historian Joel E. Dimmesdale explains, quote, he may have stretched things a bit, unquote, in his telling, since, quote,

Speaker 1the defendants arrived in Nuremberg on August 12th, 1945, and Kelly left in January of 1946, unquote. For him to have spent 80 hours with each defendant, it does stretch credulity a bit, provided that we... Don't just assume he went largely without sleep during that time. Now, based on Kelly's notes and the number of pages dedicated to each criminal, Kelly certainly, almost certainly, spent the most amount of time with Reichsmarschall Hermann Goering, but he provided assessments of every

Speaker 1one of the defendants in his 1947 memoir, 22 Cells in Nuremberg, A Psychiatrist Examines the Nazi Criminals. This memoir provides insight into Kelly's assessments of the defendants themselves and how he saw his own role in assessing them. In his words, Kelly believed that, quote, as a scientist, I regarded my duty in the jail to be not only to guard the health of men facing trial for war crimes, but also to study them as a researcher in a laboratory, unquote, because, quote,

Speaker 1Nazism was a sociocultural disease which, while it had been epidemic only among our enemies, was endemic in all parts of the world, unquote, and thus required, quote, preparing a vaccine or serum that will protect against it, unquote. Kelly concluded his psychobiographical sketches of the 22 prisoners with a relatively speculative portrait of Hitler based on the testimonies of his subjects and preserved medical records, writing that, quote, The

Speaker 1Hitler legend can be rendered relatively harmless only if we help all the world to see Adolf Hitler as he actually was, unquote, or as he would later put it, quote, an abnormal and a mentally ill individual, unquote. This framing Kelly was giving there was, in essence, an early version of the never-again argument, intended to inoculate the reader from manipulation by a Hitler-like figure in the future. Despite labeling

Speaker 1the Fuhrer as mentally ill, Kelly was quite insistent that the people who followed him, including his closest followers, were anything but. He painted a picture of a country enthralled by a capable, intelligent, and socially adaptable madman of extraordinary skill, certainly unique as an individual, but by no means different in terms of those capabilities. There were, in other words, no shortages of human beings who had possessed similar qualities

Speaker 1to Hitler, who possessed them at the time, and who would possess them in the future. And given that the prisoners under Kelly's care were all sane by most measures, and thus recognizable to him even as an American, there was no reason to doubt that, quote, there is no real difference between the individual German and the individual American. unquote, psychologically speaking, to use Kelly's words from his memoir. Most powerfully and famously, perhaps infamously, depending on where you're coming from,

Speaker 1Kelly claimed that, quote, the Nazi leaders were not spectacular types, not personalities such as appear only once in a century, unquote, and they only shared three things, quote, overweening ambition, low ethical standards, and a strongly developed nationalism which justified anything done in the name of Germandom, unquote, plus, quote, the opportunity to seize power, unquote. And dramatically concluding, Kelly proclaimed the following, quote, Let us look about us. Have we

Speaker 1no ultra-nationalist among us who would approve any policy, however evil, so long as it could be said of advantage to America? Have we no men so ruthlessly eager to achieve power that they would not quite willingly climb over the corpses of our minorities if by doing so they could gain totalitarian control over the rest of us?

Speaker 8Unquote.

Speaker 1Kelly had clearly developed a very dim view of the sociopolitical nature of humanity. informed largely by his time spent with the 22 accused war criminals at Nuremberg, particularly the time he spent with Hermann Goering. According to Kelly himself, quote, of all the Nazis tried at Nuremberg, the one who made the greatest impression was Goering, unquote. Some scholars tend to put an even finer point on it. given Kelly's

Speaker 1own mental deterioration in the decade that followed the war, marked by severe alcoholism and a deep, enduring depression, culminating in a dramatic suicide in 1958 that actually mirrored Herman Goering's own method, the ingestion of cyanide. The only difference was Goering had done it in private, shortly before his planned execution. Kelly, after having one of his alcohol-induced fights with his wife at the time, went up to his office,

Speaker 1then stormed back downstairs, and dramatically crushed the cyanide capsule between his teeth in front of his wife and children, dying almost immediately. The writer Jack L. High points out that, quote, there was more behind Kelly's choice of that particular poison and that exceedingly rare form of suicide, unquote, considering that he kept a loaded gun in his office, strongly suggesting that it had been, quote, a deliberate evocation of Goering's defiant suicide and the Reich Marshal's pose of a hero

Speaker 1backed into a corner, unquote. Jolie-Dimsdale concurs, going even further, by citing contemporaneous articles covering Kelly's suicide, which were, quote, quick to note the link to Nuremberg and Goering, unquote, leading to, quote, dark questions and speculations as to where Kelly got the cyanide, unquote, including the San Francisco Chronicle reporting that Kelly's poison, quote, was brought back from the war criminal trials, unquote, and the New York Times taking

Speaker 1the matter even further, stating that, quote, the cyanide was one of several capsules Dr. Kelly had brought home from Nuremberg. The capsules had been discovered on Herman Goering, unquote. In the aftermath of Kelly's death, rumors of who supplied the cyanide to whom became more notable than Kelly's own work. But Kelly's own assessment of Goering's suicide carries with it the most weight. When he wrote that, quote, Goering's suicide,

Speaker 1shrouded in mystery and emphasizing the impotency of the American guards, was a skillful, even brilliant, finishing touch. completing the edifice for Germans to admire in time to come, unquote. It is a striking addendum to his otherwise critical assessment of the infamous Reich Marshal. Goering's influence was at the center of Kelly's diagnosis of the Third Reich, as most scholars and Hollywood screenwriters, like those who wrote the really excellent

Speaker 1Nuremberg film from 2025, as they all tend to claim. During their interviews, Kelly found the Reich Marshal, a man of charming manner, when he chose to be charming, of persuasive speech, and of excellent intelligence bordering on the highest level, with a keen imagination and good educational background, which was paired with, no sense whatsoever of the value of human life, of moral obligation, or of the other finer attributes of civilized man, when they conflicted with his own egocentric aims.

Speaker 8Unquote.

Speaker 1Even as a prisoner, quote, he still maintained his extroverted reaction patterns, his need for attention, his narcissistic bodily fixations, unquote, as well as, quote, his dominant drives, his ability to visualize clearly his goal, and his willingness to attain the end regardless of the cost, complete with, quote, all the forcefulness, brutality, ruthlessness, and lack of conscience which made him the ideal executive for Adolf Hitler.

Speaker 8Unquote.

Speaker 1These broader observations largely fall in line with Kelly's eventual replacement, Dr. Leon Goldenson, who characterized Goering as, quote, up and down, always playing to the public, unquote, and one who, quote, can turn on a smile and turn it off like a faucet, almost at will, mechanically.

Speaker 8Unquote.

Speaker 1In addition, Goldenzone observed that Goering's, quote, attitude toward Hitler was quite different in reality than it seemed to be from his testimony in court during his defense, unquote, to which Goering replied that, quote, as a loyal German and a follower of Hitler, I accepted orders as orders, unquote, and that, quote, I am a man who is basically opposed to atrocities and ungentlemanly actions, unquote, which quickly contrasted with his callous sentiment that, quote, The drunken Robert Lay did us a favor by hanging himself before the trial started,

Speaker 1because he was not going to be of any advantage for us defendants when he took the stand. It was these characteristics, as well as those of Goering's compatriots, that led to Kelly's own counterintuitive conclusion about the relative normalcy of the Nazis, as far as their mental health went, the Fuhrer's notwithstanding, of course. Kelly's own compatriot, though, Dr. Gustav Gilbert, would ultimately come to a much different conclusion.

Speaker 4Here at the microphone today, I have as my guest, Dr. Douglas M. Kelly of San Francisco, California, who is the present psychiatrist and knows all the Nazis involved.

Speaker 12Dr.

Speaker 4Kelly, the mental state of these prisoners is of great interest to all. During their confinement, what have been your observations?

Speaker 12In general, the prisoners are no different from a group of intelligent executives anywhere. In contradistinction to popular opinion, they are neither crazy, nor are they supermen.

Speaker 4What about the extroverts and the introverts? Who are the great exhibitionists, and who live largely within themselves? Here in prison, as one would expect.

Speaker 12Their reactions are essentially the same as in their public life.

Speaker 4Going, strikers, and Ribbentrop are still showmen.

Speaker 12The military group and the professional types, like Frank, Tyson Clark, Fear, and Frick, are reserve types.

Speaker 4Dr. Kelly, from your professional point of view, who are the most interesting characters? Goering is of interest because of his strong.

Speaker 12Personality and his extreme egocentricity. He is a forceful leader without thought of consequence or consideration for others. Stryker is also interesting because of his intense belief in his fanatical ideas.

Speaker 4He truly thinks that Jewish people are a special race.

Speaker 12And can be distinguished by facial characteristics, body configurations, and even by their odor. In spite of his statements, though, Stryker himself doesn't do so well on identification. We tested him with an interpreter who is tall and blonde and has blue eyes, and who escaped from Germany in 1939 because he was a Jew.

Speaker 4Stryker accepted him warmly, and one.

Speaker 12Day gave him a special document to be translated, and I quote, only by an Aryan, close quote. Apparently, his judgments are only emotional.

Speaker 4Well, now, what about the military men, fellows like Keitel, Yodel, Rader, and Zenitz? We talk about Prussian militarism. How does it reveal itself?

Speaker 12As a group, the military and naval men are much more formal than the others. They keep themselves neater, too, and complain less. At times, though, they become very upset when they feel their dignity is being attacked. They make a much better appearance than do the ex-salesmen, ex-farmers, and ex-lawyers.

Speaker 4These fellows, some of them at least, seem rather cheerful. Take Goering, for example. A person would think that with their outlook they would be depressed. How have you found them?

Speaker 12On the whole, at present, their outlook is cheerful. Since the trial started, a group spirit has begun to develop. This is especially obvious in Goering, who looks on the trial as a type of intellectual combat. Only the other day, Goering said, and I quote, the defendants.

Speaker 4Form a team, close quote.

Speaker 12Then he added in his typical egocentric fashion, and I quote, and naturally.

Speaker 4I shall lead them. Well, thank you, Dr. Kelly, for your very enlightening answers. This is Arthur Gates speaking from Nuremberg, Germany.

Speaker 1Dr. Gustav Gilbert arrived in Nuremberg in October of 1945. And like Kelly, he, in the words of Joel E. Dimmesdale, quote, desperately wanted in at Nuremberg. to study and characterize the depravity of the Nazi leadership, unquote, but where Kelly saw them, the Nazi leadership that is, as specimens for his lab, quote, in Dimmesdale's words again, Gilbert didn't find them interesting in Kelly's dispassionate way, but loathed them and told them so, unquote.

Speaker 1This almost certainly colored his impressions of the accused criminals, but he did take diligent notes and produce two books out of his experience profiling them, unlike Kelly's one. A fluent speaker of German, of Austrian-Jewish heritage, Dr. Gilbert took his position at the prison very seriously, which contrasted with Kelly's own manner, and this actually led to clashes between the two men that were likely just as personal as they were professional. The two men's ultimate conclusions also differed,

Speaker 1though not in the sense that Gilbert believed the Nazis were insane. Quite the contrary. Generally speaking, Gilbert, quote, In the words of Joel Dimmesdale again. They were not insane, in other words, but they were different from everybody else.

Speaker 1Gilbert's first book was more detailed than Kelly's, more resembling Goldenzone's own work, in which he reproduced the questions and responses of the defendants and recapitulated the trial proceedings as he recalled them, including the prosecution's and defense's statements, quote, refraining from, in his words, quote, And indeed, this was the point. As Daniel Pick writes, quote, unquote. It was

Speaker 1not until he later published The Psychology of Dictatorship in 1950 that Gilbert clarified his conclusions on Nazi psychopathology. Gilbert claimed that, quote, so that the individual level of explanation cannot be fully understood without reference to the social, and

Speaker 1vice versa. Gilbert's framing allowed him to explain that the Nazis were, in fact, unwell, as individuals, as an organization, and as a culture, but all thanks to the singular influence of a dictator. To help make his case, Gilbert spent much of the first section of his book exploring the psychology of Adolf Hitler himself, with a lot more detail than Kelly ultimately did, pointing to the, quote, dark recesses of Hitler's libido, there lay the smoldering ashes of violent, unresolved,

Speaker 1Oedipal conflicts, unquote, leading him, that is the Fuhrer, to embrace, and thus encourage others to embrace, a, quote, rigidly obsessive development of aggression, unquote. By placing Hitler at the forefront of his argument, Gilbert telegraphed his conclusions about where the Third Reich, and the German people had gone wrong. As Gilbert saw it, understanding Hitler was key to understanding and thus diagnosing the Third Reich itself. Drawing from his experiences

Speaker 1interviewing the Nazi war criminals at Nuremberg, as well as the growing body of knowledge and scholarship about those who had died, Gilbert finally concluded that, quote, the irrational behavior of the crowd may not determine the decision to wage war. but the emotional tensions of the leader in an authoritarian system do determine it, unquote, and that the evidence available, quote, leads inevitably to the conclusion that that the final decision to go to war and to commit genocide was determined by the irrational obsession of a dictator to exterminate my enemies, unquote.

Speaker 1In addition, unlike Kelly, Gilbert was not convinced that dictatorship was as easy as Conversely, Gilbert characterized, quote, the struggle between democracy and dictatorship as fundamentally a struggle between the two modes of social organization and value systems developed in the process of adaptive social behavior, unquote. In other words, the Third Reich could not just happen anywhere at any time. Authoritarianism and dictatorship needed to be value systems in and

Speaker 1of themselves, Gilbert argued. The United States was thus not akin to Nazi Germany, no matter how tempted one might be to draw parallels. They had distinct cultures and distinct value systems, in which one produced democracy, however flawed it might be, and the other produced a violence-obsessed dictatorship. Gilbert had more reason than Kelly to come to this conclusion. While Kelly was looking at the accused war criminals with a detached eye that placed everyone on a morally neutral

Speaker 1playing field, basically in a vacuum, one could say, Gilbert had no interest in doing that. Evil was evil, and the evidence was right in front of his eyes. That's how he saw it. In addition to that, Gilbert had witnessed far more than Kelly had, having stayed in Nuremberg many months longer than Kelly did. In particular, Gilbert witnessed a Soviet Union's prosecution during the trial, and what he witnessed was far more disturbing than than even the film that had been shown during the United States' prosecution. One

Speaker 1of the Soviet prosecutors named Lev Smirnoff displayed a film titled Atrocities Committed by the German Fascist Invaders of the USSR, which depicted, in historian Francine Hirsch's words, a basement where, the narrator explained, human corpses had been rendered into soap, as well as, quote, These images had a profound effect

Speaker 1on the court, and this likely included Gilbert, who even, in Hirsch's words again, agreed that the film had hit the mark even more than the one the Americans had shown. Gilbert also clearly came to this conclusion before finishing his time at Nuremberg, believing that the defendants were always paying attention to how their circumstances changed during the trial, thus showing that he saw most of those in his charge as more calculated than they might let on, therefore exhibiting what he would later define as an authoritarian personality. Gilbert's

Speaker 1view on the authoritarian personality was also shaped by his time spent with the Nazi leaders, and like Douglas Kelly, it was deeply informed by his interactions with Hermann Goering in particular. According to Jolie-Dimsdale, they, as in Gilbert and Kelly, quote, both agreed that Goering was venal, corrupt, and brutal, unquote. However, unlike Kelly, Gilbert ultimately saw Goering in relatively simple terms, as a criminal psychopath, unable to muster any real empathy

Speaker 1or humanity. In describing him in his second book, Gilbert believed that, quote, Goering continued to use the Nazi ideology as a camouflage for his own aggressive narcissism, unquote, thus connecting ideology with psychopathology and making it clear that he saw the two as codependent. According to Gilbert, this was further evidenced by, quote, the persecution of scapegoats serving a threefold purpose, A, distraction and suppression of criticism of the Nazi regime, B, the conditioning of public opinion to accept

Speaker 1an aggressive defense against our enemies, C, material incentives for the faithful, unquote, all of which satisfied Goering's narcissism. As Gilbert puts it, while genocide was, quote, something that shattered Goering's entire frame of reference, unquote, that did little to shatter his, or by Gilbert's estimation, Germany's, complicity in it. For it was part and parcel with Hitler's own ambitions, and Germany was enthralled. In the end, Gilbert assessed Goering as, quote,

Speaker 1a ruthlessly aggressive personality camouflaged by a disarming amiability when it suited his purpose, cyclothymic in effect, extremely narcissistic in his ego gratifications, but lacking in moral courage, which might have given his heroic fantasies more than theatrical substance, unquote. All of this helped explain Gilbert's attitude towards Goering, which was less detached interests like Kelly and more moral disgust, something that he could not hide. As the other psychiatrist

Speaker 1Goldenzone reported, quote, I knew that Gilbert, the psychologist, had been on rather strained terms with Goering, unquote, which likely came from the fact that Gilbert did indeed see the Reichsmarschall as a deranged criminal at a deeper level than one simply of socialization, and he treated him as such. Goering did little to dissuade anyone from characterizing him this way, proclaiming to Golden Zone during their time together that, frankly, it is my intention to make this trial a mockery,

Speaker 1and adding later that, if I really felt that the killing of Jews meant anything, such as that it meant the winning of the war, I would not be too much bothered by it. For Gilbert, Goering represented the Nazi personality and the perversion of German culture. As Gilbert bluntly concluded in his first book, Nuremberg Diary, In the end, Kelly's and Gilbert's interpretations of the war criminals could not have sounded more different. The garrulous Kelly saw the potential for a Nazi war criminal in everyone, while the dour

Speaker 1Gilbert saw a developed distinct Nazi personality. As historian Lawrence Rees summarizes, quote, Douglas Kelly maintained that the Nuremberg defendants were not only essentially sane, but that such personalities could be duplicated in any country of the world today, unquote, while, quote, Gustav Gilbert believed that the psychological evidence showed how diseased elements of the German culture were inflamed to epidemic proportions under the Nazi regime, unquote. While both men emphasized the

Speaker 1importance of social forces in their work, it was clear that what divided the two interpretations was either a greater emphasis on nature versus a greater emphasis on nurture in generalizing the Nazis. Kelly clearly came out in favor of the nurture argument, writing that, quote, insanity is no explanation for the Nazis, unquote, and that, quote, they were simply creatures of their environment, as all humans are, unquote. This aligned with his later infamous warning about how, in essence,

Speaker 1the Nazi menace could just as easily happen in the United States. Conversely, Gilbert carefully laid out, quote, unquote, which included, quote, unquote, Unquote.

Speaker 2Unquote.

Speaker 4Unquote.

Speaker 1According to Joel E. Dimmesdale, the debate quickly turned into, quote, acrimonious arguments between Kelly and Gilbert about the nature of the Nazis' diagnoses, unquote, resulting in a lack of mediation between the two schools of thought, which both had validity. Dimmesdale continues, quote, Kelly saw little to be gained by including narcissistic psychopaths in the same boat as patients with depression or schizophrenia, unquote, while Gilbert merely saw criminals like Goering as, quote, psychopaths who bore the mark of Cain, unquote,

Speaker 1and could not be helped in their deeply rooted pathology. This difference of biases proved unshakable and turned into, quote, squabbling and accusing each other of having purloined each other's notes, unquote, in Dimmesdale's words, and later threats of lawsuits over the matter, as well as accusations of ethical violations. The two men went their separate ways, with Gilbert writing his second book, and Kelly turning to, of all things, a career in television. Their well-publicized debate's essence became forgotten, and in 1958, when

Speaker 1Kelly committed suicide, there was no chance it could ever meaningfully reignite again. The door had been left open for a new diagnosis to be applied to the Third Reich, and in 1961, a very famous philosopher named Hannah Arendt would provide it.

Speaker 11Six proselytists certified him as normal. One of them remarked, and I find this almost funny, that Eichmann was more normal than I am after having examined him. His attitude toward his family was described as, not only normal, but most desirable. The minister who visited him in prison declared him a man of very positive ideas, and this was the man who sent millions to their deaths. The longer I listened to him, the more obvious it became. Eichmann

Speaker 11was not stupid. That is not the point. He was simply, genuinely, completely incapable of thinking from the standpoint of anyone else. He spoke exclusively in clichés, in what he himself called officialisi. When he tried to construct a sentence of his own, he would repeat it until it too became a cliché. He was surrounded as if by armor, by stock phrases that insulated him entirely from reality. This is what I

Speaker 11mean by the banality of evil. not that evil is ordinary or unimportant, not that it is excusable, but that it can be committed on a massive scale with bureaucratic precision by someone who is not motivated by hatred or ideology or psychopathy, by someone who simply stopped thinking, stopped asking, what am I doing to whom?

Speaker 1Is Eichmann in all of us? wondered the New York Times headline on May 26, 1974, reflecting on the controversial claim that had been circulating for well over a decade. Discussing the series of experiments run by Yale psychologist Stanley Milgram from 1961 to 62 that claimed, quote, to show that the ordinary person in situations of normal obedience to authority would do things which go against decent or humane behavior, unquote, The article summarized CBS's 60 Minutes co-anchor Morley Safer's own

Speaker 1assessment during the show's segment on Milgram that, quote, Had the Kelly-Gilbert debate remained active during the previous two decades, this summary would have been redolent of Kelly's own claims regarding the nature of Nazi evils. The New York Times article's author, Daniel Bell, however, did not agree, and in fact took major umbrage, writing that, quote, unquote. And that

Speaker 1all the experiment had revealed was, quote, unquote. Bell's refutation of Milgram's experimental methods, ethical dimensions, and ultimate conclusions were not,

Speaker 1in fact, unique for the time. They had been inspiring debate within the psychological field for many years, and would for many years to come. Bell's outrage had simply helped maintain the controversy's mainstream status and keep it in the public consciousness for longer still. However, the reference point was perhaps less clear. Most understood to what was meant by Milgram's references to the Third Reich. But why was there a reference to Eichmann, that is, the infamous SS-Obersturmbannführer Adolf Eichmann,

Speaker 1by then many years dead, when discussing an experiment conducted by a Yale psychologist? The reason was simple. Eichmann, and specifically one woman's assessment of him as he sat in a Jerusalem courtroom in 1961, had inspired Milgram's obedience experiments in the first place. The famed philosopher Hannah Arendt had arrived in Jerusalem in April of 1961 to cover the trial of Eichmann for the New Yorker magazine. Eichmann had been tracked down and captured by Israel's Mossad in Argentina

Speaker 1the year before, with the sole purpose of putting him, a supposedly key functionary of the Nazis' Final Solution, on trial for his crimes. It had been 15 years since the Nuremberg trials, but the moral imperative of putting Eichmann on trial, and too many participating, arriving at an inevitable guilty verdict, was as strong in 1961 as it had been in 1945-46. Hannah Arendt did not exactly know what to expect, apart from her own gut-level disgust at Eichmann's

Speaker 1monstrous crimes, that is, arranging the transportation of millions of European Jews from all over the continent to the locations where they would be slaughtered en masse. but as she watched the middle-aged, bookish-looking man in the glass box at the front of the courtroom, she was shocked at what she heard. According to historian Rebecca Lemov, she was, quote, surprised to discover on the stand a nondescript man who did not even distinguish himself by a special dislike of Jews, unquote,

Speaker 1and believed that, quote, the most striking thing about Eichmann, for a supposed criminal mastermind, was his dullness, unquote, making it clear that, quote, Eichmann was was monstrous precisely because he was not a monster, unquote. Everything about Eichmann, and therefore by extension the Third Reich, was deeply and unsettlingly evil, Arendt began to believe, because of how normal the personification of that evil appeared to be. Following the trial, and

Speaker 1after Eichmann's unceremonious execution in 1962, Eichmann Arendt adapted her New Yorker coverage into a full-length book, which was published in 1963 under the title Eichmann in Jerusalem, A Report on the Banality of Evil. In her book, she fully fleshed out her case for Eichmann's normalcy, her book's subtitle previewing exactly what she was about to lay out. Eichmann had made an impression on Arendt and a number of other observers in the Jerusalem courtroom for a number of reasons.

Speaker 1First was his plea of innocence. In Arendt's words, quote, to each count, Eichmann pleaded, not guilty in the sense of the indictment, unquote, along with protests that, quote, with the killing of Jews, I had nothing to do. I never killed a Jew, or a non-Jew, for that matter. I never killed any human being. I never gave an order to kill either a Jew or a non-Jew. I just did not do it, unquote. Though Arendt also wrote that by the end of the trial, quote, he left

Speaker 1no doubt that he would have killed his own father if he had received an order to that effect. Eichmann's splitting of hairs regarding the question of his guilt or responsibility left less of an impression made by, quote, half a dozen psychiatrists who had certified him as normal, more normal at any rate than I am after having examined him, one of them was to have exclaimed, unquote, leading to the, quote, hard fact, that his was obviously no case of moral,

Speaker 1let alone legal, insanity. Ultimately, Eichmann was banal, both as a criminal and as a man, who only spoke one language. That is, the language of the soulless bureaucrat, one focused only on his career. As Arendt explained, officialese became his language because he was genuinely incapable of uttering a single sentence that was not a cliché. leading to the perception by psychiatrists and others that he was indeed normal. This

Speaker 1made it clear that Eichmann's inability to speak was closely connected with an inability to think, namely, to think from the standpoint of somebody else, to use Arendt's famous words diagnosing him there. In Eichmann, Arendt saw the depth of evil that could only be explained by this banality. His cliches lasted to the bitter end, as he headed to the gallows and proclaiming that, quote, we shall meet again, unquote, to the gathered observers, offering a, quote, lesson of the fearsome,

Speaker 1word-and-thought-defying banality of evil, unquote. Perhaps most disturbingly of all, Eichmann's case was generalizable, supposedly, perhaps to the scale of the Third Reich itself, because, as Arendt famously put it, quote, the trouble with Eichmann was precisely that there were so many like him and that the many were neither perverted nor sadistic, that they were and still are terribly and terrifyingly normal, unquote. Indeed, suggesting that, quote, this normality was

Speaker 1much more terrifying than all the atrocities put together, unquote. The intellectual power of this assessment across time, as well as Arendt's clever arguments, cannot be underestimated. I guarantee that most of you listening, if not all of you, frankly, have heard the phrase, the banality of evil. It's famous for a reason, because it took off. In the words of Daniel Pick, Arendt's quote, courtroom portrait of that quintessentially

Speaker 1obedient Holocaust manager became a classic. an indispensable starting point of discussion, unquote. It was felt in all fields, particularly in history, where Arendt's claims created a bit of controversy, including, in Joel Dimmesdale's words, quote, a storm of denunciations and threats, unquote, with the celebrated historian Barbara Tuchman, quote, giving voice to the public anger, unquote. writing in the introduction of Gideon Hausner's Justice in Jerusalem in 1968 that, quote, the attractiveness

Speaker 1of the thesis is that by shifting guilt onto the victim, it relieves everyone else, unquote. But As well known as the banality of evil phrase is, and as culturally influential as it's become over the decades, the real power of Arendt's argument was probably felt most keenly in the world of psychology. The Third Reich and the Holocaust had certainly not been forgotten among psychological researchers, but it did not

Speaker 1still possess the same moral imperative that it had in Kelly's and Gilbert's days. Gustav Gilbert had continued to practice and write, and was even called to testify during the Eichmann trial. But beyond that, there had not been much in the way of motivation to litigate or relitigate Nazi evil as there had been directly following the war. Eichmann's trial and Arendt's coverage had changed that, particularly with the young psychologist Stanley Milgram.

Speaker 13A decade earlier, Psychologist Stanley Milgram had also looked at how we respond to authority. In order to understand how people were induced to obey unjust regimes and participate in atrocities such as the Holocaust, he set up an experiment. Volunteers were told they were taking part in scientific research to improve memory.

Speaker 7Separated by a screen, The teacher would ask the learner questions in a word game.

Speaker 13And administer an electric shock when the answer was incorrect. He was told to increase the voltage with each wrong answer. Cloud.

Speaker 8Horse.

Speaker 6Rock.

Speaker 4House.

Speaker 11Answer.

Speaker 4Wrong.

Speaker 11150 volts.

Speaker 13Answer.

Speaker 14Horse.

Speaker 8Experimental.

Speaker 7That's all.

Speaker 6Get me out of here. Get me out of here, please.

Speaker 3Continue, please.

Speaker 12Go right on.

Speaker 4You refuse to go on.

Speaker 10Let me out.

Speaker 4You refuse to go on.

Speaker 12The experiment requires you to continue, teacher.

Speaker 7Please continue.

Speaker 13Participants didn't know that the learner was really an actor and the so-called sharks harmless.

Speaker 10You're going to get a shot.

Speaker 7180 volts.

Speaker 2I can't stand the pain.

Speaker 4Let me out of here.

Speaker 10You can't stand it.

Speaker 7I'm not going to kill that man, is there?

Speaker 3I mean, who's going to take the responsibility if anything happens to that gentleman?

Speaker 7I'm responsible for anything that happens here. Continue, please.

Speaker 10All right, next one, slow.

Speaker 2Walk, dance, truck, music.

Speaker 13Two-thirds of volunteers were prepared to administer a potentially fatal electric shock when encouraged to do so by what they perceived as a legitimate authority figure. In this case, a man in a white coat.

Speaker 14375 volts.

Speaker 10I think something's happened to that phone in there.

Speaker 3I don't get no answer.

Speaker 2He was hollering for less voltage.

Speaker 7Can't you check in and see if he's all right, please?

Speaker 13Milgram's findings horrified America. They showed that decent American citizens were as capable of committing acts against their conscience as the Germans had been under the Nazis.

Speaker 1Whether he was aware of it or not, Milgram had become part of the intellectual lineage forged by the forgotten Kelly-Gilbert debate. This is not to suggest that the interest in diagnosing the Third Reich had waned. Indeed, as psychologist Robert M. Farr writes, For his part, Milgram had been following the Eichmann trial with great interest. and, in historian

Speaker 1Rebecca Lemoff's words, had been, quote, moved and fascinated by Arendt's controversial thesis, unquote, beginning his experiments only three months after the start of the trial. He was among those, like Kelly, who wondered, in the words of Daniel Pitt, quote, what if there was nothing demonically special about any of the Nazis at all, unquote. And Arendt's observations of Eichmann seemed to suggest this, observing as many had, quote, the machine of the state and the chemistry of the group

Speaker 1that was most horrifying, unquote. After all, so many Nazis had claimed and continued to claim to have been just following orders, and there was no reason to disbelieve them, including Eichmann, whose supposed thoughtlessness had been so pointedly observed by Arendt. This was how Milgram conceived of what became known as his series of obedience experiments. conducted between 1961 and 1963, though they were being planned as early as 1960.

Speaker 1There were some variations with the experiments, but the general procedure described by Stanley Milgram's biographer Thomas Blass went as follows, quote, Under the guise of an experiment on the effects of punishment on learning, the teacher subject, seated in front of the shock machine, was instructed to give increasingly painful shocks to the learners. who was seated in an adjacent room and not visible to the subject, each time he made an error on the word-matching task that he had been given.

Speaker 1The most famous variation of the experimental design involved the learner, who was an experimental confederate, that is, who was in on the deception, crying out in pain at increasing severity, and then eventually going silent, as if to simulate their having lost consciousness, or perhaps even dying from the shocks. Dave Grossman, who we quoted from and talked about in the last episode of History Impossible, where we talked about the ethics of area-bombing, and the significance of the distance factor,

Speaker 1actually wrote about this in his same book, On Killing, writing that at the conclusion of the experiments in 1963, Milgram, quote, found that in a controlled laboratory environment, more than 65% of his subjects could readily be manipulated into inflicting a seemingly lethal electrical charge on a total stranger, unquote, far outweighing the estimated 1% predicted by a group of psychologists and psychology students that Milgram had interviewed prior to the experiments.

Speaker 1The results were staggering and disturbing to many when they were first published in 1963. Milgram himself claimed that, quote, obedience is a psychological mechanism that links individual action to political purpose, unquote, and believed that the results suggested that, quote, the tendency to obey those whom we perceive to be legitimate authorities could very easily override the disposition not to harm other people, unquote. This was a difficult prospect for

Speaker 1many people to accept, and it became a national story, especially when the New York Times reported that the experiment had, quote, also shown, however, that such people do not enjoy being cruel. In fact, some of the subjects became distraught. This led to a greater backlash, both because of the dark implications suggested about human nature, namely the apparently then-open question, was there a hidden Nazi in two-thirds of the good citizens

Speaker 1of New Haven, but also because, quote, some deemed the experiments unethical, thanks to the distress caused to the subjects of the experiment. As reported in a New York Times review of Milgram's later book on the subject, quote, The experiments themselves were a cause of distress and debate among professional psychologists, and Milgram came in for harsh criticism for having both devised and gone through with them, unquote, and he was, quote, accused of unethical practices in manipulating his subjects and in not protecting them beforehand from what might

Speaker 1be the consequences upon them of their behavior in an extremely stress-filled experimental situation, unquote. These accusations have followed the Milgram experiments ever since. Nevertheless, Milgram seemed to have proven Hannah Arendt right, and demonstrated that his experiment had, in the words of his biographer Thomas Blass, provided the scientific underpinnings for her banality of evil perspective by insisting that such behavior could indeed be studied and, by applying the

Speaker 1tools and language of social science, helped forge a new perspective. Milgram directly addressed the Arendt connection in the book he published in 1974 about the obedience experiments, in which he stated that, quote, After witnessing hundreds of ordinary people submit to the authority in our own experiments, I must conclude that Arendt's conception of the banality of evil comes closer to the truth than one might dare to imagine. The ordinary person who shocked the victim did so out of

Speaker 1a sense of obligation, a conception of his duties as a subject, and not from any strange aggressive tendencies. This is perhaps the most fundamental lesson of our study. Ordinary people simply doing their jobs and without any particular hostility on their part can become agents in a terrible destructive process.

Speaker 8Unquote.

Speaker 1Little did Milgram seem to realize that His perspective had already been suggested, at least to a certain extent, during the Kelly-Gilbert debates in the post-war years, but had indeed become largely forgotten by the 1960s and 1970s. Milgram's obedience experiments may have been controversial both then and now, but they nevertheless, quote, endure as a powerful form of folklore, useful in explaining situations in which a person suddenly finds herself doing something untoward, unquote. in the words of historian

Speaker 1Rebecca Lemoff. The suggestion about human nature, and thus the explanation for the Holocaust and the diagnosis of the Third Reich, was compounded by similar experiments, also with a lot of notoriety, conducted by other social psychologists, including the bystander apathy experiments conducted by John Darley and Bibb Latané in 1968 and which revealed the bystander effect phenomenon, in which intervention becomes less likely with greater numbers of people present, and even

Speaker 1more infamously, the prison experiment conducted at Stanford University in 1971 by Philip Zimbardo, a fellow graduate student of Milgram's, it should be noted. Many people likely remember at least the basics of the Stanford prison experiment, at least how it was set up. As Julie Dimmesdale describes, quote, And what people likely also remember about the experiment is that it quickly ran out of control, with many of the volunteers assigned as guards engaging in their roles as guards with a very disturbing zeal, leading Zimbardo to cancel the experiment before it had even been completed. the drama that

Speaker 1had unfolded had not necessarily been part of the experimental design, but it supposedly had disturbing implications. As Zimbardo himself later explained in the New York Times, quote, normal, healthy, educated young men could be so radically transformed under the institutional pressures of a prison environment, unquote, and this suggested that, quote, the subject's abnormal social and personal reactions are best seen as a product of their transaction with an environment that supported the behavior of To translate Zimbardo's, we'll say, florid

Speaker 1description of what happened, what he was saying was that the guards' disturbing behavior, which we should remember included abusing and humiliating the prisoners in increasingly creative ways, was not indicative of anything wrong with them psychologically. They were, in fact, merely inhabiting roles. As Joel Dimzell explains, the experiment suggested that, quote, social context alone could foment a phenomenal amount of nastiness, unquote,

Speaker 1which in turn suggested that, quote, power corrupted and brutality emerged, unquote. Zimbardo's prison experiment, even more problematic in its implementation than Milgram's, it should be noted, had added to the notion posited by Arendt, and by extension Douglas Kelly, that normal everyday people, and even people deemed intellectual elites like students at Stanford University, were perfectly capable of engaging in monstrous behavior due to socialization. Everyone had, in so many words, an inner Adolf Eichmann.

Speaker 3I had really thought that I was incapable of this kind of behavior.

Speaker 5I was.

Speaker 3Surprised you know i was dismayed to find out that i could i could really be a that i could act in a manner so so absolutely unaccustomed to anything i would even really dream of doing and i and while i was doing it i uh i didn't feel any regret i didn't feel any uh.

Speaker 2Guilt.

Speaker 3It was only afterwards when I began to reflect on what I had done that this behavior began to dawn on me, and I realized that this was a part of me I hadn't really noticed before.

Speaker 1Given the pre-existing ethical questions regarding Milgram's own experiments, even more scrutiny was given to Zimbardo's, both on ethical grounds and in terms of his conclusions. with many, in the words of Joel Dimmesdale again, critics arguing that such studies cannot generalize the Third Reich, and that Zimbardo's experiment was like a fraternity hazing gone bad. Now, this is certainly possible, and much evidence was gathered in the decades that followed

Speaker 1that challenged the social-psychological findings of these various studies, and by extension, Arendt's assessment of Eichmann and the Third Reich. critics suggest a flattening had occurred, in which, according to scholar Jan De Vos, quote, Milgram had set up the scene. Zimbardo started from the already scripted scene, unquote. And, more problematically, that, quote, Milgram had psychologized the past of the Nazi era, unquote, while, quote,

Speaker 1Zimbardo preempted forms of torture to come, creating, as it were, a rationale for so-called psychological torture, unquote. These sorts of problems are rooted in the criticism of the most high-profile social-psychological studies conducted in the field's history, particularly those from Milgram, and those were essentially derived from Hannah Arendt's observations of Adolf Eichmann. There were indeed problems with both interpretations. In

Speaker 1the decades that followed, more information about Nazi war criminals, as well as their motivations, had continued to come to light. Milgram's conclusions in particular had been challenged on psychological and historical grounds over the decades, with S. Alexander Haslam and Stephen D. Riker pointing out that, quote, the banality of evil thesis loses credibility under close empirical scrutiny, unquote, by its ignoring of, quote, copious evidence of resistance even in studies held up as demonstrating that conformity is inevitable, and of the evidence that those who do heed authority in

Speaker 1doing evil do so knowingly, not blindly, actively, not passively, creatively, not automatically, unquote. Other, broader critiques of Milgram's conclusions involved his use of strictly monocausal terms to use the words of Daniel Mandel, as well as an assumption that, quote, the process of obedience to authority operates uniformly across levels of a social hierarchy, unquote, and a failure, quote, to describe the type of gradual and irreversible conversion process, that

Speaker 1transformed basically ordinary medical professionals into autonomously evil actors, unquote. Other critics pointed out that socialized genocide was insufficient as an explanation because it provided credence to the Nazis' frequent defense of just following orders. In fact, as Alan Fenikstein writes, quote, the orders may have provided an opportunity for the expression of more powerful emotion-based motives. while there was little or no evidence of moral opposition or distress by the killers, unquote,

Speaker 1which contrasted with the behavior of many of Milgram's subjects, whose experience in a college psychology lab, it must be said, was a bit different than that of a Wehrmacht soldier on the Eastern Front of World War II. There was also the matter of Adolf Eichmann and Hannah Arendt's own conclusions about him. As more information became revealed about the supposedly banal face of evil, it became clear that he was not as much of a boring, cliche-spouting bureaucrat as

Speaker 1Arendt had suspected. Indeed, while hiding in Argentina, Eichmann was interviewed by the Dutch Nazi collaborator and member of the Waffen-SS, Willem Sassen. During the course of these interviews, which were eventually published in Life magazine in two parts under the title Eichmann Tells His Own Damning Story, Eichmann frankly admitted, as the titles of each installment suggested, quote, I transported them to the butcher, unquote, and quote, to sum it all up, I regret nothing, unquote. More consequently, tapes of

Speaker 1the Sassen-Eichmann interviews were uncovered in 2022, revealing that Eichmann believed, quote, had we put 10.3 million Jews to death, then I would be content and would say, good, we have destroyed the enemy, unquote, and that, quote, I didn't care about the Jews deported to Auschwitz, whether they lived or died, unquote. What we hear in these tapes, and what we can read from their transcripts, completely runs counter to the picture that Hannah Arendt painted of Eichmann. What this shows is

Speaker 1that it was not as clear as Arendt or Milgram or Zimbardo's observations. See, to imply. Their observations were simply not as definitive as they typically appear to many experiencing them for the first time. Nevertheless, despite all of these valid critiques of the post-Arendt boom of social-psychological assertions, about the learned capacity for evil, including Arendt's own assertions, these assertions remained not just valid, but in a lot of

Speaker 1ways doctrinaire and popular, especially when seemingly supported by historical evidence. An example of this is the evidence provided by the likes of Christopher Browning in his landmark great book, Ordinary Men. This persistent popularity and, again, doctrinaire-ness, to make up a word there, I suppose, helps explain the resistance experienced by later psychologists when they tried to explore the idea that some things in the human experience were perhaps more ingrained

Speaker 1than many liked to admit. The developmental psychologist Simon Baron Cohen observed that human cruelty is very much connected to psychopathic characteristics. That is, that psychopathic individuals have psychopathic brains, and thus, when they engage in cruelty... they are doing something that is as much a part of their inner nature than it is to something to which they have been socially conditioned. In his book, The Science of Evil, Baron Cohen explains that, quote, psychopaths are blunted in their

Speaker 1moral development, unquote, thanks to a number of factors, including an inability to, quote, fear punishment, unquote, and, quote, less of a startle reflex to a loud sound or to an object looming toward them, unquote. leading to a diminished or even completely absent capacity for human-to-human empathy. Their brains even register differently on neurological scanners, such as fMRIs and MRIs, particularly in a major part of what Baron Cohen calls the empathy circuit, or more anatomically, the ventral part of

Speaker 1the medial prefrontal cortex, or VMPFC, which activates when people think about their own or other people's feelings. In Psychopaths, Baron Cohen writes, quote, Just as we might predict, abnormalities in the empathy circuit are seen, producing a problem in the frontal lobes because these are meant to provide executive control over action, stopping us from doing what could lead to punishment. Unquote. It seems likely that, based on many

Speaker 1of the previously described assessments of many of the most notorious Nazi war criminals, like Eichmann or Hermann Goering, that they too would have shown similar abnormalities. The lack of available insight, or technological capabilities at the time of both trials, certainly makes this impossible to say beyond speculation. And it certainly is not to say that the diagnosis of the Third Reich begins and ends with psychopathy. Measurable psychopathy, that is.

Speaker 1But it does suggest that after Hannah Arendt's intervention in Jerusalem, there had been a lack of psychological insight that could well have been a boon to everyone interested in diagnosing the Third Reich. That is, of course, accepting the insight that had been provided already by Drs. Douglas Kelly and Gustav Gilbert.

Speaker 8You imply to this court that you lost some influence with Adolf Hitler in 1942, is that correct? I believe this to be the case, yes. but you were still Reichsmarshal of Germany in 1942, Hitler's successor, yes?

Speaker 4Yeah, I was the Reichsmarshal.

Speaker 8And you're telling me that you were totally unaware three million Jews were murdered in 1942. I was unaware of.

Speaker 11This.

Speaker 8In 1943, at least 800,000 Jews were executed in the camps. You were still Reichsmarshal in 1943, is that correct? Is that just correct? In 1944, an additional 800,000 Jews died in the camps. You were still Reichsmarshal in 1944, is that correct? Is that just correct? In 1945, 250,000, an

Speaker 8estimated six million Jews in total, as well as Soviet and Polish citizens, Romany people, artists, scientists, writers, journalists, photographers, filmmakers, people killed, not in combat, not in enemy fire, but exterminated by the state of Germany, the state which you were the Reichsmarshal of, the preeminent political post of your country. You contend that you had no knowledge At least give

Speaker 8me this. Knowing what we know now, knowing what happened to six million Jews, I have to ask, would you still follow the Fuhrer, Adolf Hitler? I have fought. Order!

Speaker 13Order!

Speaker 8Heil Hitler. No further questions. I think this is as good a place as any to adjourn for the day.

Speaker 10Herman Wilhelm Goering, on the counts of the indictment on which you have been convicted, the tribunal sentences you to death by hanging. Joachim von Ribbentrop.

Speaker 14Death by hanging. Fritz Schaukel, death by hanging. Julius Streicher, death by hanging. Wilhelm Frick, death by hanging. Hans Frank, death by hanging. Alfred Rosenberg, death by hanging. Wilhelm Keitel, death by hanging.

Speaker 12It was not a tribunal of general jurisdiction.

Speaker 1Primo Levi once stated that Auschwitz defies understanding, or at least understanding in terms of the culprit's rationality. While at the same time, in the words of medical historian Daniel Pick, quote, rejecting the idea that the perpetrators could be categorized, for the most part, as abnormal, especially sadistic individuals.

Speaker 3Unquote.

Speaker 1Nevertheless, as we have seen, many tried, especially in the decades following the Second World War, to thread this needle, this diagnostic needle, so to speak. They wanted to explain why so much suffering existed had been caused by people so supposedly normal in their disposition. That seeming contradiction was explored most famously by Hannah Arendt as she covered the Eichmann trial in 1961, and, also as we saw, was

Speaker 1furthered by the social psychologist who, instead of looking for previously obtained evidence, simply appeared to take Arendt's observations at face value and find evidence that confirmed those observations. What these psychologists like Stanley Milgram and Philip Zimbardo and others discovered was valuable insight. I want to make that very clear. It was very valuable what they discovered, what they observed, both about the nature of phenomena like obedience and role fulfillment,

Speaker 1but also in how studies such as theirs are designed and how we interpret data and the ever-present threat of confirmation bias. affecting interpretations of these kinds of findings. But that's more of a meta-analysis. That's something that was discovered after the fact, and not necessarily by them, at least not intentionally. But really what I think they accomplished, at least in the context of studying history, was that they

Speaker 1appeared to be providing a scientific basis for Arendt's observations, and thus they were able to to provide a lasting and profound diagnosis for the Third Reich that, in its own provocative way, implicated everybody, rather than those who committed the atrocities of the Third Reich. One can only speculate why the Arendt framing was so intellectually attractive to so many scholars and experts in various fields, but it seems

Speaker 1likely to me that it was an attempt to essentially refute Primo Levi's observation. After all, to say something so profoundly and tragically human as the Holocaust defies understanding feels like abdicating responsibility. And yet, in making these observations that supposedly implicated everyone as a refutation of Primo Levi's observation, Arendt, Milgrams, and Zimbardos, and all these other social psychologists and experts

Speaker 1who have echoed them, their observations ended up implicating no one. After all, if everyone, if all of us, have a little Eichmann within them, and given how banal he supposedly was like all of us, what made him, an actual war criminal, even partly responsible for the murder of millions, special, or even worthy of meaningful condemnation, to say nothing of needing the death penalty applied to him? That's the implication

Speaker 1of the banality of evil when you really think about it. If anything, by morally flattening the Nazi war criminal into something recognizable in all of us, it calls into question human agency itself, and thus our ability to make destructive choices that deserve punishment of any kind. To say embracing this paradox opens a window for nefarious apologia, revisionism, and justification of unspeakable crimes is, well, it's putting it mildly.

Speaker 1Not only were Hannah Arendt's observations misguided, something I should note she eventually admitted to far less media attention after witnessing the Frankfurt trials of 22 SS guards who had been stationed at Auschwitz. She, that is Arendt, in the words of historian Thomas Blass, gave recognition to the fact that there was another face of the Holocaust besides that of the dutiful bureaucrat. So not only were Hannah Arendt's observations misguided in something that she admitted later on, but

Speaker 1the downstream effects from her observations on the intellectual history of the Holocaust were profound. As Eichmann biographer David Cesarini once wrote, quote, Her notion of the banality of evil, combined with Milgram's thesis on the predilection for obedience to authority, straightjacketed research into Nazi Germany and the persecution of the Jews for two decades. Unquote. Arendt's provocative reframing of Eichmann,

Speaker 1and thus Nazi war criminals in the Third Reich in general, as generally banal, was such that it inspired the most influential social-psychological studies for decades to come, that is, the Milgram and Zimbardo experiments, as well as others following their lead, which there were many, and thus ultimately shaped the development of social psychology as a subfield with very little resistance in either the psychological or historical fields. The impressive work by Holocaust scholars such as Christopher Browning and others who

Speaker 1demonstrate that the horror of the final solution was the result of social pressures, if only in part, helped reinforce what had become an intellectual tradition, perhaps even a dogma, with only slight challenges. With this story that I've been telling you guys, I've attempted to make the argument that the true Third Reich diagnosis had already been achieved by the time Hannah Arendt made her observations, at least in a complementary sense, by the psychological experts Douglas Kelly and

Speaker 1Gustav Gilbert, appointed to the prisoners at Nuremberg, If it wasn't obvious from what we were discussing before, neither Kelly nor Gilbert's arguments were solely persuasive on their own. Kelly's heavy focus on the ordinariness of the criminals, including the likely psychopath of Herman Goering, led to him seeing more of himself and others in them than he probably would have liked, and subsequently underestimated what it would take to convince regular citizens, American, German, or otherwise, to commit monstrous crimes. Conversely,

Speaker 1Gilbert's focus on the criminal's pathology as part of an authoritarian and dictatorial value system, inspired by a psychologically unwell Fuhrer that attracted similarly unwell individuals to positions of power, led to Gilbert seeing something deeply wrong with German culture at the time of the Third Reich, and likely missing the role that general socialization, significantly part of Kelly's equation, provided. But instead of contradicting one another, These were complementary insights

Speaker 1into Nazi ordinariness and pathology, and later research, inspired by Arendt's flawed interpretation of Eichmann, missed this opportunity for synthesis, thanks largely to the debate going cold after Kelly committed suicide. As much influence as Arendt's thesis and the subsequent psychological studies by the in both Holocaust studies and in psychology, bear this out. What was also lost without the synergy

Speaker 1of the Kelly-Gilbert debate leaving room for these developments is the role of agency and the actions of criminals, both in the context of an authoritarian state and in the context of pathological behavior, even outside of authoritarian states. As Daniel Pick has explained, quote, Something like Nazism might be commonplace in us, quotes there, but this thought has always had to be balanced against the fact that there is no equivalent of or precedent for Auschwitz, unquote. This balance

Speaker 1was never properly struck, of these two interpretations, despite a few less-known monographs engaging with the Kelly-Gilbert debate in the decades that followed that mostly focused on Kelly and Gilbert's use of the Rorschach tests. But, that balance might have indeed been struck if the arguments made by Kelly and Gilbert had been synthesized into one. And we do see this when looking at both the margins of historical and psychological research. For example, in the 1980s, the psychologist and

Speaker 1historian Robert J. Lifton had interviewed many former Nazis, especially those who had taken part in medical experimentation and attended atrocities. And he came to the conclusion that that things were much more complex than learned or socialized savagery. Contra Arendt's and by extension Milgram and Zimbardo's assertions, Lifton explained that the Nazis were not, quote, faceless bureaucratic cogs or automatons, unquote, and were in fact, quote, actors and participants who manifested

Speaker 1certain kinds of behavior for which they were responsible, unquote. In other words, Lifton's theory of the case was that while the Nazis were indeed ordinary human beings, they fundamentally made themselves extraordinary by doing what they did. Lifton emphasized the fact that, quote, unquote, and even went so far as to reframe what killing innocent people actually meant. a

Speaker 1medicalized form of, quote, killing as a therapeutic alternative, unquote, all in service of a biomedical vision of the world driven solely, particularly, uniquely, in other words, by Nazi ideology, which could be called, in Lifton's words, a biocracy, or a type of, quote, theocracy, a system of rule by priests of a sacred order under the claim of divine prerogative of cure, through purification and revitalization of the Aryan race.

Speaker 8Unquote.

Speaker 1Lifton had managed to nuance the arguments that had been taken for granted among many social psychologists and a growing number of historians by particularizing Nazi ideology in this way. He also particularized the perpetrators via his observations on the quote-unquote doubling that so many of the titular Nazi doctors engaged in to justify their actions. where there is a, in Lifton's words, quote, division of the self into two functioning wholes, so that a part-self acts as an entire self,

Speaker 1in which the humane self can be joined by a professional self, willing to ally itself with a destructive project, with harming or even killing others, unquote. Thanks to the biomedical vision of Nazism, this allowed them to believe that, quote, If you are curing a sickness, anything is permissible.

Speaker 8Unquote.

Speaker 1When examining Lifton's arguments, one starts to see a pretty striking similarity to Gilbert's own assertions about the war criminals' socialization playing a part in allowing them to develop a true pathology, which was indeed unique to Nazism, but never downplaying the notion that the Nazis were indeed human beings. with motives and defense mechanisms recognizable to the rest of us, recognizable within all of us, per Douglas Kelly's own assertions.

Speaker 1Insight like Robert J. Lifton's, however unwittingly synthesizing the Kelly-Gilbert debate, would echo not in history or psychology as much as in the emerging field of perpetrator studies. which aims to bring nuances like Lifton's to bear when explaining the human capacity for evil in a way that avoids the monocausal trap unwittingly laid by Arendt and those following her lead. As the criminologist Augustine Branigan explains, given the wealth of

Speaker 1both historical and psychological evidence we have gathered over the decades since World War II, the Nazis' ability to, quote, produce an over-control over their citizenry, unquote, to make them complicit in participants in genocide was, quote, not a function of obedience to bureaucratic authority, but an over-identification with the political leadership that cultivates a powerful sense of duty characterized by both pathological altruism and a sense of fatalism, unquote, which was, as it happened, quote, reflected in Eichmann's testimony, unquote,

Speaker 1in 1961. In other words, Hannah Arendt missed some key components to the Nazi pathology, if you want to call it that, something that Branigan just pointed out there. In addition, perpetrator studies expert Alette Smulers, ultimately a defender of Arendt's thesis, I should note, does also acknowledge that, quote, obedience, conformity, group dynamics, unquote, do indeed play a part in genocide, but so too do, quote, many other social psychological mechanisms, unquote.

Speaker 1leading to a true multivariate explanation lacking in the previous scholarship derived from Arendt's conclusions, namely the scholarship conducted by people like Milgram and Zimbardo. However, synthesizing Kelly's and Gilbert's arguments made 80 years ago accomplishes the same thing. Kelly and Gilbert both saw the criminals of the Third Reich for what they were, complicated human beings that were part of a singularly-minded ideological system that, in the end, necessitated

Speaker 1the genocide of a supposedly eternal enemy. While it is certainly a shame that an opportunity for a more accurate Third Reich diagnosis was missed as the Kelly-Gilbert debate moldered following the Nuremberg trials, leading to decades of compelling, if still inadequate, theorizing, one can also reasonably say Better late than never, though this may be, this delay in diagnosing

Speaker 1the Third Reich, if it's even possible, may also suggest something deeper. That there were, and thus always will be, limitations to psychologizing history. As someone who does it a lot himself, that actually makes me a little uncomfortable to say. But I do recognize there are limitations. especially after looking into this story. Because the limitations of psychologizing historical figures long dead is problematic enough, but let's really think about this.

Speaker 1How does one psychologize something as complex as a society, particularly one as truly chaotic as the Third Reich, in its birth, in its administration, and in its destruction? A society is a collective. For sure, it's a collective unit, that's how it's defined. But it's made up of individual people, each with their own motivations, dreams, fears. That level of granularity makes it incredibly difficult, maybe even impossible, to generalize,

Speaker 1especially many decades later. And lest we forget, cultural and political norms, as well as historical circumstance, can easily overwhelm our understanding of individual psychology and cause us to neglect, if not outright reject, the role of agency. But we can't forget that human agency is always there. Choices are always made, regardless of what you believe about things like

Speaker 1free will. In addition, by focusing on the pathologies of the leaders or individuals focusing on the social forces that help facilitate their will, and not making any meaningful effort to synthesize both of those approaches, we potentially neglect factors like institutional capture, or even institutional breakdown, and the subsequent effects that come with those things. While it is certainly possible that understanding the mind of an all-encompassing personality like

Speaker 1Adolf Hitler can be accomplished through thorough biographical analysis, How can one be certain that understanding him, or understanding any of the Third Reich's leadership, will allow us to accurately understand, or to keep using this word, diagnose, the whole of German society that lived under their collective boot? We may be able to understand the psychological contours of the Third Reich's system, and the personalities of those who directed it, but...

Speaker 1To claim that this gives us a window into the soul of an ordinary German, from the small-town baker that voted for the NSDAP in 1933, to the Einsatzkommando with the blood of a hundred innocents on his hands, is quite possibly a fool's errand.

Speaker 10Thank you.

Speaker 1Thanks again for listening, everybody. This one was actually kind of tough to record, because as I've come to understand, the more academic writing I've done, the harder it is to adapt into something that's actually listenable, but I'd like to think I accomplished that here. As I've said before, I really enjoyed the research I did for this particular paper when I was working on it last semester, and the additional research I did when forming this into an episode. It's a really good subject, and honestly, there's a lot more to say, and maybe one day I'll try to

Speaker 1expand everything into something even more comprehensive. I don't know how I would do that, but I really do find the intellectual history of psychology, especially in the context of understanding World War II, the Holocaust, and the Third Reich, just endlessly fascinating. It's partly what kept me interested in history all those years when I was studying psychology. But in this case, I think, honestly, the best inspiration for this was when the film Nuremberg came out. I've referenced that a couple times now on this show. I do

Speaker 1recommend you guys go check that out if you haven't already. It's a very solid film. It completely fictionalizes a lot of what we discussed here today, but it does a very good job at it. Super accurate historical films are rare, and they're rare for a reason. A lot of the time, history does not really help itself by being narratively clean in a lot of ways. But with all that said, I really did enjoy this, and I hope you did too. Before I get going here, I want to give a

Speaker 1couple shoutouts to the really kind and generous people who support History Impossible, both on Substack and on Patreon. Those people include Bob Downing, Sam Graham, Greg Hunter, These are really awesome people who have been sticking with me for a really long time, and I really hope those of you listening who like what I have to offer, you know,

Speaker 1consider joining them and become a supporter of History Impossible. It'll really help me as, you know, time goes on here in the you know, student loan bills start piling up. Joking aside, that actually is something I'm going to have to consider very soon. So please consider supporting the show if you like what I do and want to keep it going here. I don't really have much else in the way of announcements. We have another episode coming. Not quite sure when. I am working hard on it. It will be yet another sort of analysis of the sort

Speaker 1of end conf of World War II, so to speak. and the aftermath, and how we cope with it, because that will lead very nicely into the finale of the Muslim Nazi series, which I expect will be coming your guys' way next year, hopefully early on. But I have learned not to make too many promises when it comes to saying when bigger episodes are coming out. I'm always looking for people to chat with as well, so some interviews will be coming in the coming months. But with

Speaker 1all that said, I don't really have anything else apart from just saying thank you again for listening, for spreading the word, for supporting the show, and for always staying tuned. Thanks again, guys.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Millennials: The Trauma Generation

    Sep 30, 202652 minAudio

    Hey everyone. No preamble here. Just a nice bonus as a thank you for your continued support. As the title suggests, this is an audio adaptation of an essay I wrote about the 25th anniversary of 9/11 and how it led me to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Firebombing of Tokyo: Our Imperative Atrocity

    Sep 22, 20263 hr 21 minAudio

    We often hear about how the Second World War was more morally nuanced and complex than we have been led to believe. This is, to a certain extent, very true. The Axis powers meted out a level of genocidal destruction and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Power, Presidents, and Refusing the Crown (w/ Richard Lim)

    Sep 7, 20261 hr 23 minAudio

    In this newest episode of History Impossible we’re joined a second time by Richard Lim, host of the This American President podcast, who last appeared on this program a couple years ago to discuss the insane,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Orthodox ISIS: The Russian Religious Experience (w/ Kristaps Andrejsons of The Eastern Border)

    Aug 18, 20261 hr 48 minAudio

    “Because remember: Russia is a religious experience.” Those are the oft-repeated and well-said words by the host of The Eastern Border podcast, my good friend Kristaps Andrejsons. They are well-said because there are...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Ideological Pathology of Antizionism (w/ Kile Jones)

    Aug 11, 202656 minAudio

    Antizionism, as it has become, has been having a bit of a moment for going on three years. It is a tough nut to crack, given its various claims of varying legitimacy and, as we have covered more than once on History...

    Credit the people on this episode