Orthodox ISIS: The Russian Religious Experience (w/ Kristaps Andrejsons of The Eastern Border)
1 hr 48 minAudio
“Because remember: Russia is a religious experience.” Those are the oft-repeated and well-said words by the host of The Eastern Border podcast, my good friend Kristaps Andrejsons. They are well-said because there are very few alternatives for explaining Russian actions, rhetoric, and political culture over the past near half-decade in its World War I-style conflict with Ukraine. The Russian religious experience, made emblematic by Kristaps’ and my favorite shared punching bag Aleksandr Dugin, is a phenomenon best understood as a more formalized and colossal version of what ISIS was ten years ago, and it helps explain why Kristaps believes the spiral of the Russian state as we currently know it is beginning in 2026. In this episode, we discuss the potential for collapse and its consequences (including the potential proliferation of nuclear weapons), as well as the barriers of understanding between the West and East, the state of media coverage and perils of sponsorship, the use (and potentially misguided fear) of AI, and Kristaps’ new book that he is releasing serially on his Substack and Patreon. As is always the case with Kristaps, it was a wide-ranging, enlightening, and fun conversation, and I think it sheds a light on the history being made in his part of the world, as well as the motivations that lay behind it. Russia’s dark autumn (another Kristaps coinage) is almost here and having Kristaps as our Gonzo guide for that coming darkness is a blessing more of us should appreciate. As mentioned in the episode, if you would like to donate to the Car4Ukraine Eastern Border Summer Campaign, please go here and make your donation. ... History Impossible has been made possible by the following generous supporters on Patreon, Substack, and PayPal. Please consider donating today if you want to show some love for what I do and make and what to help keep the show and all my written content going: David Adamcik Monica Almirall David Alsbach Gregg Anderson approso1999 Rajan Athul Robert Babeon Michael Beach Benjamin Greg Bosai Johannes Breitsameter Carol ABC Carol Chappelle Charles C Chomo the Clown Curtis Christiansen Jason Coleman Clayton Connell Click Cliffydeuce CR Craig Crawford B.Cyr daddygorgon Danny Lynda Davis Paul DeCoster Regina Dick-Endrizzi Neil Dickens Nathan Diehl Bob Downing Dramicas Eastone Gavin Edwards Snow Farmer Howie Feltersnatch Matt Gassner Pierre Ghazarian Josh Goedert Elena Gomel Sam Graham Jayson Griesmeyer Nathan Grote Benjamin Hamilton Peter Hauck Jack Henneman Eric Hodges Mike Jarulic Joe6245 Lionel Joseph Thomas Justesen Mike Kalnins Bryn Kaufman Leah Kodner Constance Loucks Maddy Mounty of Madness Jose Martinez Mike Mayleben S.M. McAvoy Judy McCoid Mike Kyle Mohney Kostas Moros Ryan Mortenson John Muller Cameron Needham Sean P Skip Pacheco David Page Molly Pan Philip Pomerantz Sr. Powell Brian Pritzl AnaR737 PJ Rader Gleb Radutsky Aleksandr Rakitin Reptilycus Matthew M. Rice Phillip Rice Cheryl Robertson Terry Rosen Run Tough Mindset Andrew S Dan S Jon Andre Saether Jake Scalia Emily Schmidt Julian Schmidt Scryptar Andrew Seeber Shiran Joshua Simpson Cameron Smith Jerry Spangler timetosuccedd1995 Thomas Squeo Athal Krishna Sundarrajan Jared Cole Temple Ann Tout Mike US Ward Van Roy Pierre Vorupuni Robert VS Nate Wade weaverap Jonny Wilkie Christian Wilson Janora Winsor F. You Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/history-impossible--5634566/support.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hello again, everybody, ladies, gentlemen, brothers, sisters, comrades, friends. We're back again with another episode of History Impossible. I know they're coming out of a much faster clip right now. It's because I was able to get a lot of these conversations done, because that is indeed what we're doing again here today. Before we get into that, I want to thank everybody who supports the show over on Patreon and substack. That includes especially the supporters at the executive producer level and above that is Monica Almarole and Mike Maylebin.
Speaker 1You guys are awesome. Thank you again for such generous support. And for all of you listening who haven't jumped on the Patreon or substack train, please consider doing so. Can help keep the lights on over here and all that. And yeah, so all you got to do is go to Patreon dot com slash History Impossible or History impossible dot com. Become a patron or paid subscriber today. Any and all amount helps, and that includes nothing at all, but in return, I would beseech you to use a
Speaker 1five dollars word there to spread the word about the show, spread the word about the sub stack and the Patreon for all the free posts that go up, all the essays and so on, and yeah, let's you know, let's let's get let's get some more listeners on board here. That's a that's a great way to support this show. Just spread the word. So yeah, let's get into it. This is another conversation with my longtime comrade and friend Chris Stops and Derdesen's of the Eastern Border Podcast.
Speaker 2It's been a.
Speaker 1Bit since he's been on the show. I believe the last time was when he and Daniellie Blelli came on to talk about the history and present and future of political violence back last year in twenty twenty five, after the assassination of Charlie Kirk. We were talking about how political violence was getting normalized and they both had a lot of great things to say. But I haven't had Christops on my show, just one on one to talk about his current work, which just I don't know how the guy does it.
Speaker 2It just never lets up.
Speaker 1He's just doing incredible stuff with the Eastern Border Podcast, a lot of analysis and most provocatively this year. Earlier on I believe it was back in April, he laid out the case a very compelling one for what he called the Dark Autumn for Russia, in which he predicted that the beginning of what he's been talking about for a long time, that is Russian state collapse was going to start showing itself by August of twenty twenty six. And here we are it is August. How did his predictions turn out? Well, i'd take go listen to his
Speaker 1show and he'll lay it out for you there, But also listen to this conversation because he talks about it there. We also talk about a number of other things, just how the war is going, it's historical precedents, both in terms of war but also.
Speaker 2In terms of state collapse and all that.
Speaker 1And we even talk about his book, his forthcoming book, The Angry Patriots as he is currently calling it. Oh yes, it's a great, wide ranging conversation, as it often is with Chris Stops. So please sit back and enjoy this conversation with Christops and three Sins of the Eastern Border. Let me to tell you what you would have seen and heard.
Speaker 2If we're not being pleasant listening, if you were at lunch, or if you have no appetite, now is a good time to switch off the radio an ancestor of mine Main Chaine. If you eliminate the impossible, whatever remains, however.
Speaker 3Improbable elevation Russian BANDI.
Speaker 1You know, I.
Speaker 3Wish I could say tonight that a lasting piece is inside. I'd all the laughing dream might be unlaughing light.
Speaker 1The weak were ESSU to Gail.
Speaker 2The weaker were U to Gail. Some say the world will end empire, Some stay a night from what I tasted of desire. I hold of those of favor fire. But if it had to perish ice, I think, I know, I'm a hate to say that for destruction. I there's also wait and look sufficed. This is history possible. Yeah.
Speaker 1Well, I just wanted to start by asking just, you know, what have you been up to. You were in Riga recently, and I was just kind of like curious at this point, Like I don't think I've ever asked you this. You know, I've had you on my show multiple times, but like, what is your daily routine like at this point? Like covering the war covered, like diving into all the daily.
Speaker 2Routine as I wake up. Currently, I go on Tuesdays and Thursdays, I go to my driving classes. They start at seven thirty and I wake up at six every morning. Then I also sit down and open up my news, read and listen to a bunch of them. Sometimes, eat, sometimes sleep, rarely, hug my wife when when she's when she's here, walk a lot with my dog, which is nice. But I mostly I'm on a constant work mode for
Speaker 2the most part. But when I went to Rega, yeah I met a listener there, but he's he's from the I can. I can tell you that that he's he's from the United States Embassy. That much. I can tell you not much more, though.
Speaker 1But yeah, okay, gotcha, Okay, I won't I won't delve too deeply.
Speaker 2But I thought embassy listens to my show Canadian Embassy, and I think the Dutch as well, definitely, But uh well, they need insight, you know.
Speaker 1And they and they probably not all of them speak Latvia and you know which, so they they really appreciate having an English language insight into the Eastern border, so to speak, but into the Baltic States, into the into the people who are actively resisting and not big fans of Russian imperialist aggression. So I think it helps them. I think you're a resource, is what I'm I'm blowing smoke. No no, no, no, no, I can I can tell you exactly which is I know for whom I am a resource. Definitely for a bunch of people an intelligence community.
Speaker 1Now this not like because I also have my own contacts and everything, but for I know that for a bunch of people in intelligence community, I'm basically the well they wait until I speak about it's on the show, and so they can put put me in the source. Then it becomes all sin if I talk about right, Yeah, so that's much better than other things. Well, and that's actually that kind of gets into something I want, I mean, because I was just wanting to, you know, start out by us just sort of talking about generally like a thirty thousand foot view, but also with some specificity, like what you've been talking about in your longer episodes that
Speaker 1you've been doing lately about the I guess we could just call it the incoming Dark Caught Them state collapse. But on top of that, just I actually think that the theme that I've really been enjoying, especially in your recent episodes this year, is uh sort of breaking down like in much greater detail than what we get here in America. I mean, to be fair, there's people who cover this stuff in much more detail here, but generally speaking, our media and our media commentator class, they they tend to be pretty well informed on what's going on, and
Speaker 1they they do understand that there's a lot of impotence on the Russian part and that seems to be the theme of what you're talking about, But you're providing a lot more receipts on that. Like what we get here are essentially memes like the that roof getting blown off a number of months back, like that was it and that. But but it's like it's such a zoomed out, like disconnected view on how things have been going.
Speaker 2Uh in is that the war has been so disconnected from Moscow life and uh the big big thing on reality on the ground and the reality that is in the official sources is so so vastly different, and a lot of things have been like basically, it's like this. It's not that they don't it's not that they don't see the same things that I do. It's just that due to the fact we just different different perspectives here. People look at data. People look at data in the West A lot of times and they presume Russia is a rational country with like you know, they presume Russia
Speaker 2is acting like rational country, and they presume that they have these lines on maps and everything. They perceive them differently. They expect things to happen differently. They often see the wrong reasons for them, and everyone's like still thinking about, you know, what is put in want of this war and what's going to happen. They presume that Russia is a logical country, and it's just not the case. And they also sometimes presume that, you know, and Russian liberals also presume that everything is going to be totally normal over there. It's not going to be. It's because Russia
Speaker 2is built on Russia is built on this very weird lie which has been going on through everywhere, which is again Russia is Atalius experience because once you start thinking about this fact as this holy Russia, that's a theory in academia as well, and I want to expand on it. But if you know, if you start to think about that, it's truly the third Rome, and it has its ties with Byzantium, and like the impedial, the imperialness or for Russia is sacred in itself and it's infallible and the Zar can do no wrong. At that point, once you start really believing them, a lot of things just blop
Speaker 2into pay well places instantly, a lot of things that seemed logical. For example, why the famous it sank? From this perspective, I can easily tell you that it sank. Put Into response wasn't stupid. It was the only thing you could say, because well, it was the it was the submarine. What was his uh, what was his response? Like what did he end up saying about the court submarine back in two thousands? See?
Speaker 1Yes, but but what did he say though? Like, yeah, I don't well what happened to the submarine? And Putting just respond responded it sank And to a lot of people it seems a very strange answer.
Speaker 2I can just tell you what happened there. He couldn't admit that he did something wrong. He couldn't admit that state did something wrong. So who who's all wrong on the wrong here the submarine which sinned against mighty Russia. And that's it also really explains a lot of these things, because all this, all this, it's a bunch of philosophical issues and a bunch of imperialism, and in a lot of cases, many people really hope that it's just going to be, you know, the things are in Russia are going to be just like before, or that we're not in a period of great change we are, and that
Speaker 2we can go back to business as usual. I can easily tell you that at least at least until the end of as I see twenty thirty five, nothing's going to go back to the usual. The usual might actually never come back.
Speaker 1Nothing right well, and that was something I was kind of thinking about from more historical perspective, because you know, obviously this is a history podcast. Want to talk about history a little bit too. But we kind of talked about this a long time ago. I remember where I said, there's something to the fact that Russia has never really been a free kime t ever. I mean, you go from Zardom, you know and serfdom, to communist dictatorships, stalinist dictatorship like an absolute nightmare state, to then you know,
Speaker 1like varying degrees of you know, totalitarianism, to then you know, this period of chaos after the collapse of the Soviet Union, uh two, then putin like things just never really settled down in a way that that you would expect in a country that would work its way out of these like really you know, ugly systems. It's just they're there. They go from one ugly system to the other, and you know, over a period of time. So it's funny when you say things like there are like people in
Speaker 1Russia who are just like kind of yearning for things to go back to normal. But what was normal normal has never I mean, I'm at it from this like Western centric perspective obviously, but but I'm.
Speaker 2Just saying like normal to them.
Speaker 1I don't know what that means, because They're system is constantly changing, and a lot of it has to do with this, as you put it, this religious experience that it is to be Russian, or at least a Russian nationalist. I guess, like where you believe you have this like self conception that is not too dissimilar from American self conceptions in the sense that like they have an absolute view of how the world should be based from their perspective, but theirs is so disconnected from reality that it just it seems like it does seem insane the outside looking in.
Speaker 2So I can understand one one interest thing thing is that about talking about history? You know, they like all that Azar's, They like the czar Nicholas the Second, They like the like Stala and all these people. They glorify those big czars. Do you know which is Dwan big czar, which is only famous in the West, and the like No z Patriot ever mentions him as something great. Peter the Great, Oh, Peter, yes, because he was he because he actually tried to build a modern nation state and he went. He didn't play into this Holy Rushia aspect, but Holy Russia thing has become so important that they
Speaker 2can't treat him as a good zar because you know, he went and that wasn't really in the traditional sense all that mess.
Speaker 1Right, Yeah, and a lot of the other like leaders that we know of that that Westerners generally think of. They might think of Catherine the Great, but then they think about the meme about her and the horse, and that's usually what they what were the where the the knowledge of her begins and ends. But then they might think of Ivan the Terrible, but they don't really know anything except that he was here.
Speaker 2Too. By the way, histodical perspective, sure, I actually understood why Orthodox socialism doesn't really. Also, the Orthodox Socialism doesn't really seem to be that that creepy and weird for for for all the z people, because in Latin Zeta, it wasn't just like you know, there was no freedom of religion. There was very active anti religions and they could like Bisbosnic newspapers, they were like really watching you if you go to church and everything. And that is because Bolsheviks tried to push out to this religiousness, this holy holy rush aspect from the country and place it
Speaker 2with their own technology, because otherwise they couldn't change the country because otherwise it's it's super linked to the czar, and they killed the czar, so then people would you know.
Speaker 1Yeah, well, and that's the interesting thing too, is it's the it's really interesting to me that we associate at least the first two dictators of the Soviet Union, we associate their system with their names. Leninism is a very popular term Stalinism too, and for good reason, because they they basically had a system that was centered around them as personalities while being devoted communists at the same time. And it's it's a very interesting sort of as you said, a replacement. It doesn't really change the society in a
Speaker 1way that someone like Mark sort of envisioned. They they followed his blueprint, but it was very culturally particular, and what that created was this sense of like Zardom even after the Czars on it was this is why.
Speaker 2They like Stalin. If you've noticed, if you've noticed again, yeah, this is this is a thing which also made me think about this. You know, they changed they changed it back in two thousand and eight. Before that it was like no more war. Ever, that was like Glovins, the Miible, I mean, the most important thing is no more wars. And they really you know, mourned their dead in the end of World War two day nine for them, ninth of May, and then in two thousand and eight it turned into mos patercho, we can repeat this, and then you know you have to think, what can they repeat tons of losses. The thing is in Purance Russia, the
Speaker 2official ideology doesn't doesn't mourn the loss the loss of people in World War two. What they what they celebrate at the end is that well, the establishment of the empire it's largest extent by a military victory. What they can repeat is what they want to repeat is their greatest military victory and largest extent of power. That's that said, you can these you can literally spot impedialism there straight up.
Speaker 1Well, and that's like where like the I think what I really like how you well, I call them the white paper enjoyers. The people you talk about here in the West who try to treat Russia as a rational actor, they're looking at it from the wrong perspective.
Speaker 2It sounds like what they're.
Speaker 1Looking at is a sort of like, I guess you could call it like a naive, hopeful vision of what Russia is when it just isn't even though they're like not necessarily supportive of Russia, but they're thinking that Russia operates in the same way as as a typical European.
Speaker 2State because Russia is one of those exceptions. And it was pretty good tricking them. I mean, this is why also, you know, this is why people don't know about Pinati over there, and they don't think it's valuable because put In Puddin also likes to, you know, tell people to pultn't likes to pretend to Russia's normal country. Artie does that. It's not that, as I wrote in my chapter of the book, it's not that the Western ecthreemia is stupid. That was just they were just tricked. And as I heard from intelligence community, and that's that act quote, this is the moment like when the war starts it. This was the moment when all the people who had experienced in the Soviet that they had just retired and the
Speaker 2new new ones only had academical knowledge. So putt and can use this. And I, like I tend to, I tend to pick on William Spaniel. Uh if if you are listening to this William, don't get me wrong. I have read his books. I learned game theory from his books. It's just that I really respect him, and I just this is why I feel so sad that he he just tends to approach it differently. The thing is, it's just the Western academia really really you know, like to keep their way about how they're more correct than other people. They really hate admitting that they might be wrong. And
Speaker 2you know, they their model, their beautiful model of pure game theory and states interests in lines on maps. It works perfectly for every European state and everything. Where it doesn't work is with Russia. That well, right, they sort of don't admit that it doesn't work, because it works well everywhere else. The thing is, if they would just accept that it is like mostly a cartel at this point and and something that they would make better predictions. And it's not about about them now, it's just it's just that I don't know even know how to call this. I have nothing but respect for Western academia. I mean,
Speaker 2I I've spoken to a lot of these people. However, I do have to say that there's the thing that I have a lot a lot of people in my my from my region academia also also have noticed, like he got lips. It's the economists that I quote. For example, he speaks for languages, publishers and four languages and in German, Spanish, Italian, and Russian. He's often quoted in those countries you know where you know where he isn't quote adult where people don't know about him in English speaking medium. Yea. And I asked this, and as to my wife's mom, because she goes to conferences to Boston everywhere else they could
Speaker 2you might over there Western Ivy League IVY League elitism is a really real existing thing. But academians from here kind of don't like to talk about it because their careers are dependent on it. But you are always slightly less correct than your Western counterpart, especially if if dealing with Ivy League people. And it might not even be like conscious or anything, but I have noticed this attitude and with sources as well. If if a Western like Institute for Study of War and other other others, uh, look,
Speaker 2resources which have an English translation are considered to be more reliable and better than resources who which you would have to translate yourself from Russian. They just somehow presume that if someone like they just somehow presume that that automatically such things which have which which comes straight up in English, which you don't have to put effort in, that they're somehow better. And it's really surprising to me about the study good lifsids because he has been very accurate and he is an academical person, and he's well known,
Speaker 2and like countries which are not English speaking.
Speaker 1Yeah, and there are there are other countries, there are other other adversaries that we have, we being the West. I think like that, I think maybe those models might work a little bit better. I think you can probably, I mean on granted, I haven't really been following it as much as I used to. But when it comes to relationship with China, I think that you can treat China as a more rational actor. I'll say this much. You can treat China as a more rational actor than Russia for absolutely right. And well, yeah, yeah, I mean
Speaker 1they have their ambitions, you know, territorial ambitions regarding places like Taiwan, and that will be a strategic win for them if they got it, because then they would basically own the creation of semiconductors and chips and all that stuff. But but but at the end of the day, China's interests are are scrutable, whereas I think Russia's interests are I mean, they're not inscrutable obviously, because I think you have a really good insight into them. And as you're saying, a lot of people in your part of the world have a much more i'll just say, nuanced and a
Speaker 1greater understanding of of of Russian interests and Russian motivations and so forth, and the contradiction.
Speaker 2But you know, but I have to I have to give this response, car don't praise us that much, because I also, like I also watch a lot of people who are these Russian liberals right. And for example, Michael Knaki his full name, which is one of his full name is Michael Sidney Knacki, and he has an American citizenship because his dad's actually American. He's never been to the United States. He doesn't know how to speak English. That he, you know, always talks about his US citizenship. And people like Maxim Cotts and others. A lot of these people they claim they also know more about the
Speaker 2Western academia and Western world than they actually do. There is a certain amount of double standards and certain expectations and and all this. It's not just it's not just the United States gets things wrong. It's just that both sides tend to think like a lot of people like this side are side of the of the iron curtains, so to speak, post of it's fear. A lot of people here think that you guys at a bit naive and you think we're a bit dumb. So this this is and idly sill. This is his situation, and it's really really hard to get to, you know, to get
Speaker 2to a point where maybe, you know, if if we would just listen to each other sometimes and admit that you know, it's okay to be at least not one hundred percent correct all the time, that this could be just just a better thing, and this is not arrogance or something, just something which which you really kind of have to like basically, we have to be honest to ourselves. That's the big issue with the whole academia.
Speaker 1Thing, right right. Yeah, And I think that pointy headed academics, of which I am one and you are one technically we both you know, have our degrees and all that, I think that there is a tendency to be a little too bubbled off from the world, which I think is why it's important to you know, get out there and expand your perspectives by talking to people who do have a worldly experience or get your own worldly experience just in general, like going.
Speaker 2To the front line for example.
Speaker 1I mean that's just one example, but I'm just saying, like, trying to understand the perspectives of the people that you, especially if you are criticizing or praising them, that is a very important thing to do.
Speaker 2This is why I find the.
Speaker 1So called realist school of geopolitics, which I spoke to our mutual friend Zach Twomley about why. Also why he and I both find it's so kind of laughable. Honestly, the John Mehersheimer's of the world, who I don't know how many times that man has been wrong about this current war, because it began in twenty twenty two where he was just saying there's no way Russia will ever invade Ukraine, and now it's just this constant goalpost shifting of saying, well, they're gonna lose, Ukraine's gonna lose, Ukraine's gonna lose. And I'm thinking, like, well, I think at
Speaker 1this point, a war that's gone longer than World War One and has cost an insane amount of lives and caused so much destruction, no one's gonna come out of this war winning. It's bigger than that. It's not about a win or a loss. It's I mean, I think you can probably make the case, I would imagine you make the case that if you're to say who comes out a bigger loser, it's almost certainly Russia.
Speaker 2At this point. The thing is Ukraine. Ukraine is the I'm not gonna say Ukraine is going to keep that on soverigety. That's a win for them. We have to talk about what's win for someone right, Yeah, but everyone here loses basically, we all lose here.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's what I That's what I was thinking. And I mean we've been talking about this for a while. I mean, I think the Diarist thing that seems to really be accelerating at least a fair bid, especially over four years on four and a half years at this point, is the fact that that Russia is not going to be it's not going to resemble anything that it was before the war started.
Speaker 2It looks like it's going to be resembling you know, well, I don't know.
Speaker 1I mean, we can get into that. There's a lot of different possibilities what it will resemble. But you've been talking about Russian state collapse for years now. I mean, I get the feeling that a lot of folks in your world kind of see the writing on the wall. But what is baffling to me, And I think what is baffling to the White paper enjoyers in Washington. And I think this might be part of why they try to try to like treat Russia as a rational actor is they can't imagine why Russia would keep doing what
Speaker 1they're doing despite the fact that it's just hurting them and I think that that understanding Russia as a religious experience that they're saying is the best way to understand that as well.
Speaker 2As aspect see, it hurts only the Russian Federation. It doesn't hurt the Holidosha, which is the one that matters.
Speaker 1Right, Yes, And that makes a lot of sense to me, like as a as a concept, but it doesn't make sense to me as a rational actor. Like I try, I catch myself thinking about Russia, like I'm like, okay, well what would they rationally do? Well? I I have to constantly remind myself. And that's why I listen to your work and follow you, is that you can't look at it that way. It's not It's not a rational actor, right I like you call you've called it orthodox isis?
Speaker 2Yeah, But this is this is why it's a good. This is why I chose to focus. Like I'm writing my book I'm on top t two, gonna be published as soon, just didn't have the time. But this is why I decided to focus on Maxim Klasnikov, because you see in the zen sphere, he is the person who is the well he decided to be the he took the niche of the rational agent of how everything that Russia does actually rational because no one else is doing it. So he took up the niche problem is he's now understood that, well, it's a fundamentally irrational system. So he
Speaker 2tries to rationalize it. That he can't and all of this old rationality, Well, Russia has never been rational, it even says, says it. So says so itself. It says that you know, you you can't understand Russia with mind. You know, you can only believe in it. And that is completely true. They say it's about themselves. Look, but then again, not other men, not many more countries are you know, is America right now under Trump rational? It's not a hordible thing, you know.
Speaker 1I mean I actually think that in comparison, yes, I mean I don't think he is a rational actor. And he's very okay, he is more scrutable. He's much more scrutable, I think than Putin.
Speaker 2That's the problem. The problem here is that for example, you know, Trump probably thought that put And would care about such things as money. In this system, money is considered you know, actually evil like nobody. And see in the United States, rich people don't hide the very rich you might have noticed.
Speaker 1That, right, Well, I mean, but the funny thing is just on a side note of and maybe this is something I can talk about in your show. There is an aspect of American culture that is really funny that I think when you get so rich that you start to larp as a poor person, you start to try to like not flaunt your wealth as much as you want to flaunt your morality. That becomes a very tempting thing for a lot of rich people in the United States's not everybody, obviously, I'm thinking more public facing ones, and they always find new ways to do it. There's
Speaker 1a reason why a lot of rich people, like I think Elon musk is I don't know if he still is like all about this, but he was like braggy that he didn't own anything, and I was just thinking, Okay, I don't matter, not an iota to what you do.
Speaker 2It matters.
Speaker 1I mean, I don't know if he's if he's doing that anymore, but but like I'm saying, but I'm just saying the there is this aspect of American culture that's that that does have shame about wealth. There is there is a shame aspect and I think that has more to do with our sort of uh like a Protestant heritage from how we started. We're not supposed to flaunt this stuff, but we don't. But but but again we still do. And I think it's not seen as evil necessarily by people who have money. But uh, there there
Speaker 1is a sense of I think some kind of shame, shame.
Speaker 2Looking about shame whether interesting thing which sort of proves my point. Can you imagine a politician that would want to get alike to the United States, and you know he would be seen driving uh if he would drive a car to the top mad you know, that's not American met kind of politician just easily drive around in a car if he's you know, running on that platform, whether the car the top man United States.
Speaker 1Yeah, I mean I I it would be kind of strange. You don't see politicians in Lamborghini in Russia.
Speaker 2Is the opposite in Russia. If you're a politician that drives around the Russian car that then then people think you must be you know, that's considered shameful and that which which alone shows shows you what's going on there. It's it's a bizarre, bizarre thing with with both the West and and and the rest of the world there. It's just that it's all it's all these little signs. But you guys have a lot in common with that. But RuSHA as well in the in a sense that in the sense like let's talk about your conservatives and your religious religious attitude. One thing that I didn't didn't
Speaker 2understand at the beginning of the war is why a lot of people on the right are very conservative supported Russia because they believe Russia is a defender of Christianity. I think they mistake I think they mistake the thing or two because well, I Protestants and everyone who's Evangelical, they're they're basically not treated as as human by the Orthodox Church. And I think that those people at least a pass called patriarch at all this mess, there are many coming out with these I just really hope that, you know, I just really up until I think generally
Speaker 2this war, I could I could say, yeah, a lot of things you have in common, but at least you know you don't go randomly invading countries.
Speaker 1Well, yeah, I was gonna say an interesting thing though about us, about our conservatives, especially those who seem to really get a heart on for Russia is they don't tend to be evangelical. They tend to be well, they do in the sense like Tucker Carlson is he's not evangelical. In fact, he has kind of made his mission to demonize evangelicals. But he's an episcopalian. But there's like a there's a tendency of American Christians that like to see
Speaker 1Russia as like this defender of Western values, or not of Western values, but of Christian values because they don't.
Speaker 2Like Western values because that's liberalism.
Speaker 1But the post liberal crowd they tend to be Catholic or they become Orthodox converts themselves. But again, I don't think that they have a real understanding of, as you put it, the Russian religious experience.
Speaker 2I'm just not I'm not saying this to like be offensive to everyone. I'm just showing that a lot of things that may seem one way actually not not that, and it's done so intentionally. I mean, don't did you think Russia had usually has a lot of benefit from the fact that everyone you know thinks that, oh, look, Americans don't really understand us. I'm not telling you. I'm not saying that. I'm not telling that you don't understand them, that you don't understand Russia to be you know, to be uh, to offend you. I'm saying this so that
Speaker 2you you so that you will have one less exploit that could be used against you, because again, I sometimes sometimes I just feel very scared about the fact that if I have discovered something which is scary and exploitable, and then you and then you know, why haven't others, And then I think, holy shit, if they find out that it might be actually pretty bad. Yeah. For example, yesterday I was I was on Google Studio because I want to I have a plan, little little secret thing. Well I wanted I want to if I have I
Speaker 2think I have discovered a way how which is a wholesome and good way how to use AI, which is very specifically a I think but I'll tell you this. This is a world domination game between where AIS kind of argue against each other about it later. But I was building this and I accidentally asked and basically got like a random Google or Google just basically decided to to give me an exploit which would allow Russia to just dig in and ask private data and deep bake American citizens easily.
Speaker 1Yeah, and that that is not fun to imagine, but I'm sure it's going to become increasingly common, especially as it gets The problem.
Speaker 2The problem here is that we all need to understand that it's going to be a mess, and that no one's actually that much smarter, smarter than everyone else. I also I used to yeah, not yet, not yet, it's it's common, it's common. We'll get there hopefully, not that not that quickly. But you know, they just have this feeling that you know, I've been trying and trying to to to explain a lot of things to to people, really to just tell my study to the Westerners and
Speaker 2to everyone. And when you understand that a lot of people just don't care, and then those people who don't care, then then you hear those oh who could have expected this, and these surprised faces and and everything that they get. You know that they get a lot of they get money, and and they get invited everywhere. Well that sort of feels bad. But what feels really worse is and uh, you pay attention to this why I'm actually on this whole, Why why I'm waging water against the academia sometimes because they represent they're not they don't understand the true cost
Speaker 2of their decisions, because it is more likely that than a Western politician you're not US politician, or someone will be will be making a decision based on I s W than than on me. And if you look at how if you look at the aid that could have been given to Ukraine, decisions that could have been made well to a lot of people who just think about lines on maps, they think that random is calculations. But you see, I I'm the I'm the person who gets the calls from people on the front lines who literally
Speaker 2ask me why did like, why didn't we receive this funding? And then they kind of look at why they didn't get the funding, and then the arguments why they shouldn't have been given this, or that they see some sort of research institution which you know, said that not important, something something, and then they ask me, hey, you know, do these guys understand that it's actually you know, when they make these mistakes, the real people buy over here, you know, do they like it's so easy to get
Speaker 2things better? And the problem is that, of course they don't intend to kill people, but this is a real war. And when you just ignore actual truth and when you you kind of just go around then oh I couldn't have predicted this, and then you just sit down with your own I wouldn't want to say arrogance, but basically that you don't even think about the fact that well, just because you couldn't didn't predict something correctly, someone didn't get what they needed and then actually actual people have died. And I know this because again I'm one of those people who get those calls because you know, they know
Speaker 2that I speak with with you their Western people, right, they know that I have these contacts, and that is and that is that is the part where I really don't I don't know what to say. I don't know what to say to these people because like they they're they're correct.
Speaker 1Well, and I think again it's like as yeah, yeah, well, and I think part of it again is just this inability for you know, especially Western academics in a lot of cases, to really embrace the idea of I mean, you were talking about uncertainty earlier, and I think that that's like what they don't like because if you start engaging with this issue with UH with Russian motivation without understanding the irrationality of it being baked into it the religious experience. I think what happens is you fundamentally are
Speaker 1like turning your brain off to like the ability to actually explain it in a way that is meaningful. I think again, there just always seems to be this like misfundamental misunderstanding of the dynamics going on over there, and that's sort of how you see people latch onto, you know, really weird figures over here. I mean, I think he's overrated, but we always talk about him, and I love talking about him. Alexander Dugan is a great example of that. I think people they're very He's fundamental for understanding the Russian religious experience.
Speaker 2I think in a lot of ways.
Speaker 1Though, I wanted to point something out to you that I've been wanting to actually talk to you about Dugan in this respect.
Speaker 2For me, I just need to add about this misunderstanding thing real quick. One thing that I noticed is the fact that when I was in u Craine together with my Western colleagues, I speak with the soldiers directly, they tell me stuff, and then they speak with my colleagues from the West, and they have translator. They speak through English, and I can literally tell you that they're getting the sanitized version of the news because it's more polite and that you know, the West woldn't understand and this navity comes from there and then they make their decisions based on that version of events, you see, and just maybe
Speaker 2we can just sit down like adults and talk about this like like normally, which is why, which is why. I also, I'm not ashamed that my book about you know, which is which I'm writing, is full of swear words and weird stuff. That's for one, that's a third therapy for myself because I can't write about in another way right now. And secondly, war should not be treated as something that you should talk about in any polite way. But get But we'll get to Tugan because I have a lot to say about him as well. Well.
Speaker 1I wanted to tell you, like, what's really interesting is that there just was this increase in there's been a number of articles critical articles about Dugan in recent months, which is really interesting, and that has more to do, I think with people starting to discover him and then becoming understandably freaked out by him. Even though he doesn't really carry all that much influence. He actually I think probably has more influence my understand is he has more influence in the West that he does in Russia at this point. But what's really funny is we were talking
Speaker 1about American religious conservatives. Recently the evangelicals have discovered Dugan, and I think was really funny about that is they just they have a very interesting framing of him. And I saw this said multiple times by various evangelical people who I correspond with and follow on X and they call him an occultist and even a Satanist and a demon. That was really, so it's all good exactly, Yeah, yeah, yeah, no, he's It's it's really funny. It's like how we turn
Speaker 1to our tropes to, you know, understand somebody that we don't actually really understand all that much. Like, but let me just ask a blunt question. Is Dugan an occultist, demon worshipper?
Speaker 2You might be surprised, but this is a higher question to answer that you might think. Okay, it all depends on the like he let's just say he thinks he isn't.
Speaker 1He thinks he is not that.
Speaker 2Then again, at this point, he's also in conflict with very much pro war people because he hates modernity completely. He also wants people to go back to to their like all the past lives. And the problem is that he was basically create as to bring servedom back, basically abdicate internet. What he said recently is that his last quote was people who are you know with the gasoline crisis in Russia. People shouldn't worry about the fact that they don't have gasoline in their cars right now. They
Speaker 2should actually be worried about the war because if Rashia wins this swar, then you won't have to worry about them. Then then they will have everything. But if Russia loses this sward, then you will have bigger problems than gasoline the lack of gasoline to worry about. He's always pretty or nothing situation.
Speaker 1He's not necessarily wrong, though, I mean that as a major problem. But what's funny is that I just think it's really interesting that, like, when people discover the stuff that he has been saying for really his whole career, they just they turn to this idea that he's a force of the devil, like literally, and and you know, I don't, I personally don't believe that kind of stuff, but I can understand why they would think that because someone like Dugan is very hard to understand in a traditional American we could even say Christian context, because he
Speaker 1is part of that Russian religious experience, it doesn't make any sense. So I just think he's a very interesting vector for that concept that you've been discussing for so long, that Russian religious experience, because he kind of embodies that inscrutable irrationality. So people try to put all of this like weight on what he says, and that includes people.
Speaker 2The religion, everything is I have a way out of put this. He's an Orthodox version of Isis, just like Isisist Islam, same thing doing his myths to Orthodoxy. They just don't admitted they had also a death cult. It's in a sense that they're ault fundamentalist. And see they believe Orthodoxy is the only true religion, the only one existing. And they also and just because you're not an Orthodoxy are good a hedethic? Weirdly enough, you might find it funny. But for a lot of Orphics people, at least you know, Russian speaking people here, they don't actually separate Catholics from Protestants.
Speaker 2They call Lutherenants Catholics. For the Orthodox people, everyone's a Catholic. Yeah, they call the Christmas the Catholic Christmas.
Speaker 1That's bizarre. I mean, especially considering American history, with our Protestant to our traditional Protestant distrust of Catholics. I mean, I think that's kind of gone away, but I mean it was recent enough that my own mother's father, like, was virulently anti Catholic. She couldn't explain why he just didn't like Catholics, he didn't trust them. I don't think. I mean, he was an FDR Democrat, but I don't think he voted for Kennedy because of that reason. So
Speaker 1it's a very interesting kind of dynamic that we have here that is just it's just again, it's an ironic disconnect between what someone like Dugan sees and what we see, especially because a lot of Catholics seem to like Dugan too, like traditionalist Catholic types.
Speaker 2I don't I don't.
Speaker 1Pretend to understand it. I mean, well, let me ask you. I mean, I granted I'm the American here in this conversation, but why do you think American and like post liberals as we call them, like the traditionalist Catholic types usually Catholic.
Speaker 2I don't want to.
Speaker 1I'm not trying to say anything about Catholics, American Catholics in general, because I think most of them probably don't know who Dugan is. But the the JD Vance wing of the conservative movement, the more extreme among them, seem to have a sort of crush on Dugan. They really seem to like what he has to say. The Tucker Carlsons the world, I mean, Tucker Carlson gave him a tongue bath basically when he gave that interview a number of years ago, Like, why why do you think American far right types like Dugan so much? When he has nothing but disdain for the West?
Speaker 2See, it's it's because he also, for one, he is the big enemy, big scatty guy that they can you know, claim victory against.
Speaker 1No, no, But why do they like him? I'm saying that there's like, there are people who don't like him, but I'm saying, why do you?
Speaker 2Why do you?
Speaker 1Why are there American right wingers who like Dugan?
Speaker 2First of all, well, there's there's there's that obviously, but see, you know what, they like Dugan in the same way why Russia is obsessed with Angelos Saxonon London. He because Dugan also has a way off way of stating that you the West, the Medica is the also a great civilization, the great enemy. Did you think about that too? They sort of maybe define it right. Maybe they want to be like Russia. Maybe they I don't think they want
Speaker 2to United States to be like Russia. But it's all about this strong men called and whatever. But it is all about these class civilizations.
Speaker 1I think they want to be like what they imagine Russia is, but they don't understand what Russia is. They don't understand the Russian religious experience, and the way they think they do that's.
Speaker 2Amazing to them. It's the same reason why why you guys in the United States consider British to be this posh You know, you consider British on average. If you if you imagine a British person, what's your default British person? How do you think, what's your first association in your head? Like Hugh Grant, well, that that is because you're you're an a Medican over here over here. For me, that would be just a random drowned, drowned guy with notice back to local culture and who tries to piss on your monuments and comes for a stag party. Because we're closer, we see more of more of those people here. It's
Speaker 2what you see, it's who whom you're interacting. It's a very kind of different sort of thing, which is why, which is why I also have to sort of explain to people because I remember being asted why we have like a bunch of issues with with racism. We've been in the news too lately. But what can I say if the only, if the only black person that Grandma has ever seen is is in either movies, news or or like rap music videos, and she hasn't spoken with anyone, But what do you expect? And the same way is with Dugan and everything. It's just that they see this
Speaker 2Dugan and then they they think that Russia is based on some great philosophy and that it's somehow important to fight against them maybe and that they also they also want the United States maybe how a great philosopher or something. They just they just don't don't see kind of the shitty side of all of this. One thing though, well, I think though, one thing that I understood about this because I have taken the opposite to you, like or earlier, you know, a lot of people still consider still consider like Third Rich to be something you know, efficient, effective,
Speaker 2something that he you know powerful. The more the more like that is, that is such a view. The thing is that the more I learn about put In Russia, the more I have to compare them to the Third Reich, and I don't come to the conclusion that Reich was more effective than Russia. I come to the conclusion that actually, if if the Third Reich was more like Puddin's Russia than oh boy, they would have been bankrupt. And this was really fucking hornible, actually author even what they were.
Speaker 1All right, yeah, well, that's the thing is that if you if you, if you look at the Third Reich and its history through the lens of a religious experience, funny enough, it makes it a lot more, a lot easier to understand because it was not I mean, as as some people have tried to claim the Nazi Germany was not a was not a Christian perversion or anything like that. There are people who do seem to think that because Hitler made overtures to the Catholic Church and so forth, But that was just geopolitics, that was just making a pragmatic chore in a lot of ways. He
Speaker 1knew that he couldn't like get diminish and destroy Christianity in an extremely Christian country, but he had nothing but contempt for the Christian Church, and what he endeavored to do was to basically create a world where he was the new prophet. I mean, he was very much a religious experience kind of leader, and I think in general, I think a lot of people get uncomfortable with the idea that a leader, a world leader, especially one with so much power like Hitler, but also like Putin, has
Speaker 1this kind of inscrutable aspect. He be's in that word inscrutable in this conversation, but I think that it does feel inscrutable to people because you can't understand it without understanding the religious aspect of it. And because a lot of people are religious, that makes them very uncomfortable because they don't want to see themselves in people that they see as maybe I have here.
Speaker 2Actually I actually have to defend your religious people somewhat. I've been to United States, you know, and sure I went where I'm a Lutheran and people have me, but also a lot of Lutherans. So I went to a Texas Lutheran congregation, which is slightly different the Lutherans over here. And one thing that I found weird at the beginning was that at least text of Lutherans, I think at Sunday School for adults there and I thought, you know, we have said that, And it was a bit weird for me at the beginning. And I thought, you know, that was weird, and a lot of people could look at this and think that you're all crazy, super religious.
Speaker 2But then I understood something in the modern world, where else you will have what else you want to guarantee to sit down once a week at least and actually it have flked about something, think about what something means, think about what you've read, so you know it's not always bad.
Speaker 1No, And to be clear, I do believe that the Lutheran tradition actually is a bit of an inoculation against the Russian religious experience or hitler Rite religious experience because of its individualism and its relationship, the relationship that it places at a premium between man and God without a meaningful intermediary. I mean, that's what I think is so fundamental to American Christianity.
Speaker 2Talking about this, by the way, I recently literally this year, a couple of months ago. I found out a thing about my own family which I did not know because I was involved where the person that I'm named after, the pastor, my grandgrandfather, where he used to serve and I hadn't I haven't met him in real life, like obviously he died way before I was born. So but now now my grandparents are also dead, and well I went there and I found out some things which actually he hadn't even told my own grandma. And one of those things was that he had served in World War
Speaker 2One and after that he arrived back home and there's an organization that helps Lutheran An organization that goes to like and helps homeless people and alcoholics, and that was and he started that in laugh y in zemgo back in nineteen fourteen, and then in Stalin's that you know all the purges happened, do you do you know in which year my grant and grandpa became a pastor where he was ordained nineteen forty eight.
Speaker 1Mm hmm.
Speaker 2That's a fun year to get yourself, you know, to be made a priest and everything. So there's a lot of secrets about that generation too. And even if you don't know if you don't don't understand a lot, even because I thought my grandma knew everything about him, turns out not really. He was haunted by the Stalinists and everything. If I don't know much about my own people, about the person that I've named after, it's okay, not understand things basically, But a Dougan, I need to say this way, because that is now a civil war amongst amongst the radical religious experienced people over there. Because you see, now
Speaker 2Dougan also gets called the heretic.
Speaker 1There's a there's a civil war going on between them. What's what can you characterize that?
Speaker 2It's it's it sounds stupid, but okay, basically, kutch Kov the other guy, he's now arguing against Dugan because and the goal is that clutch Kov things that Putin is also a Western agent to destroy Russia and that orthodox socialisms should prevail. Meanwhile, Dagan defense put In. They both obviously think that you are all made made of the devil. And and in my last in my love, they write religious manifestos. There's a civil war in that camp. They
Speaker 2hate each other horribly, and and it just makes makes utly no sense because right now, Dugan even like when Dugan turns out not to be the craziest guy in the room. But that's for a Western audiences. If you if you think you know Dugan is devil worshiping something, Oh man, you haven't seen the worst guys of them?
Speaker 1Have you?
Speaker 2Have you perhaps have you introduction to Kachikov or something. The insanities of the world are are just sometimes to match the handle. I think, by the way, the weirdest thing is that a lot of people in Russia still actually believe believe Trump is on their side completely. Yeah, a lot of people and Russia think that put Trump is on their side still to this point. Yeah. Really, the spirit the panage that is one of that is that that is the thing that all the zipatris are
Speaker 2yelling at people who are like doing mainstream propaganda that they are too friendly to Americans and that they must not be doing something because well the spit of the fan courage.
Speaker 1Yeah yeah, well, and it's so funny to me too, because I think it's kind of become clear that it should have become clear, and I think some of I think most Americans have kind of come to understand this is that the only interest Trump has, you know, as a leader is himself, frankly and his legacy. I don't think he really cares about these kinds of things.
Speaker 2I don't.
Speaker 1I would hope that Russians would come to understand that a little bit better. But maybe that is part of the misunderstanding between the two cultures.
Speaker 2I don't. Oh, oh, so lately Trump also cuts about football soccer basically Giohanny Infantino, the guy who had this peace prize, right, who gave piece past to Trump. Twelve days after the World COP, he just decides that he's going to make a for profit organization and literally sell, you know, give them commercial rights to the World COP and then sell shares of the World Cop to businesses, namely to private equity companies, namely to the private equity company run by Trump's son in law's brother, because Trump
Speaker 2decided he wanted to buy in, and yah, people voted against. This is just that this this really shocked me because now now it's gone into sports too.
Speaker 1Oh right you Yeah, I was gonna say, you brought this up in a recent episode where you were talking about that the other Kushner getting involved in that, and the best part I love that you brought this up too as a as a as a Hugosphere fan myself. How everybody in Europe voted against it, including Serbia and Kosovo, and Serbia doesn't recognize or Albani or Kosovo. I forgot, I think it's Kosovo, but Serbia doesn't even recognize them as a country. But they all voted together.
Speaker 2Let me tell you one other thing. Ukraine, Bella, Usandrasha voted together for this. See this is this is the thing ultimate corruption. Cruption lies in the places where you've kind of but he sort of don't expect it to be do you know how this is also regional newspapers that important because the big most amounts of money because it gets stolen a banal stupid things that you just don't notice, like you know, it's okay to sell like minor things, but Johnny and Fantino just just tries to tries to sell off actually a game like the fucking sport as a whole. Yeah, well, LEAs see, at least
Speaker 2at least I have to say one thing. Not even Trump has you know, not even Trump has done that, which is surprising. But yeah, this is he would I think he absolutely would, to be clear, I mean, if he could if he could, if he had choice, but there's not per limit to this, to this whole mess, which is just yeah, I likely likely. I'm sort of disillusioned in a bunch of a bunch of the bunch of things going on with the United States because I recently went on this not a liberal elites event in
Speaker 2obviously it's kind of like people from like our next president, Edgar Slevitch, was that at Dudo Parliamentary with these a bunch of kind of really important people, intelligent, intelligent elites and and you know, academy rich people, all this stuff, and they are basically are our ex president. He got us, mister Levitz right, you know, he used to be our president. He basically stated openly that you know, we can't trust to but we must literally lick your boots as much as possible because we have no other choice. Straight up, he said, Mark, I must do this, geez the option.
Speaker 1And that's very that is well, yeah, that is very disheartened.
Speaker 2And I and I'm not a fan of that.
Speaker 1I don't like how transactional. I mean, on granted, there's always a bit of transaction in most interactions between countries, but it's just become so nakedly transactional these days, and I think maybe that might be why there are Russians who think Trump is on their side, because they recognize an aspect of him that they might believe about their own culture, which is more transactional.
Speaker 2Maybe that's how they see it. I don't know, which is again funny.
Speaker 1I think if you that is a mistake though, for anyone to see Russia's transactional as far as it's actions go, because if it was transactional, the war would be over.
Speaker 2I would think, kit, I have to hit, I have to I will quote William Spaniel once again. He likes to say, you know when when he speaks about the crash and all agents and everything. As I remember this one, he always says, don't look at the leaders, say, you know, don't listen to a leaders, say look at what they do? And then I often have to ask, do you even know what Puddin does? Sometimes to him, yeah, because because yeah, lately, lately, lately, mind you, he's not been doing pretty much anything, which is surprising, right, because he doesn't like to be associated
Speaker 2with bad things. Did you haven't heard of him in the news lately, have you?
Speaker 1No? No?
Speaker 2I mean, like the most you hear.
Speaker 1I mean again, I think the last thing I heard about him was what you talked about when he he went to China hat in hand asking mister she for for a loan essentially. And I love how you talked about that, where you were saying and Shijinping said, no, we're not doing that.
Speaker 2Chin just taken over. China's just taken over over the small Russian parts. And yeah, they their own issues because see the thing is people also think I think in the wist that you yourselves said China likes money, right, China also Yeah, see if China would, if China would think that by going all out, they could somehow gain massive benefits to themselves, you know, get put on his side of If China would be believe that putting when the war, they would have just invested in him. But they don't. They absolutely don't believe putting them when. That's
Speaker 1The thing about China I think is really interesting in this, in this context of talking about Russia's actions is how I think a lot of American policy wonks, the White paper enjoyers, I think they kind of see China as this closer friend to Russia than it actually is. I think China's like if you want to talk about a transactional nation in that sense, I would say China is definitely that. Again, they have their ambitions, but they they tend to be much more pragmatic about things and as a as a state, and you know, they they will
Speaker 1make decisions that seem crazy maybe at certain points, but at the end of the day, you can you can understand them in a way that you can understand Russia. And I think maybe in a way Putin he might see.
Speaker 2I don't know.
Speaker 1I actually I'll ask you, does Putin see some kind of kindred spirit in Chi Jinping? Because I would I would be baffled if he did, because that seems crazy to me. But I I you know, I'll defer to you on that because you do know more about Putin at least the hundreds.
Speaker 2Sure, nah, those are those are purely vast cell relationships. At this point, Putten knows that he This is why. Also, no nukes are going to be used. Definitely because because China said so. It's it's a weird thing. Really China. See, China actually is very reasonable about nukes. China. China doesn't want nukes on their board, because that then that would you know, do bad then that that would free the hands of a Medicans to nuke them in case of whatever. So China is very much it's a destabilized is very much on anti nuclear use also, right, all this all
Speaker 2this is because just sort of pretty weird. I've also been following China stuff lately because that's one thing that I use AI for. I can do Actually it's a Google that you can talk to at least in my case, it provides links, it can dig through Chinese all sorts of Chinese documents and everything. For example, I recently found out that that is a thing called vagnt cola. Yes, that va cola. It's produced in Vietnam. It's a bunch of like. And this is why, this is why I think I'm sort of more pro I know, I come
Speaker 2back to the yeah, but this is this is what sort of improves things of course.
Speaker 1Yeah, well well, and it also helps with you know, contextualizing a lot of complicated information regarding you know, the kind of work you do. I mean, I I did want to transition us into talking not about AI as much as talking about your prediction predictions, because it is now August, and what you have been banging on about for a number of months now is that August is really going to be kind of the beginning of the end for Russia and or at least it's it's war effort at this point. The timeline might not be exact,
Speaker 1but it's definitely uh, it's it's definitely something to consider because you bring up a lot of these different uh, you know, variables, primarily financial.
Speaker 2I mean, Russia is what is.
Speaker 1Their deficit now for trillion dollars or something? Just in it it.
Speaker 2Yeah, I just help in my own webpage because I need to pull out my thing. See I said, as I said in that episode, because I made the new one in the thirty first of July. What appened to my predictions? Yes, the thing is that again I was careful to say that I just needed to be better than the user study of war, and I was I have officially won them. Hello Wanzio, Hello. There were some there were some things that delayed this. Of course, Russia didn't gain as much from from the whole Iran war, but they did gain something. However, on the on the
Speaker 2bigger level, I think that well, the everyone who's fighting this war. Really don't believe they can win. They're already preparing for a massive civil war. I do believe that, you know it is, it is going towards a collapse, and if nothing changes, it's gonna happen, whether or not, because I think during the August, well, I picked August because that's always the darkest month for Russia normally historically, but currently currently their own predicted date is November. Because the budget got a bit of surplus. Thing they managed to sell some. They sold some. I think it was
Speaker 2their their diamonds. They sold their diamonds. Russia basically is now about to steal from their own people as the mobilization comes. They have mobilization will fail horribly because Putin is misinformed. They have the so called election there, they managed to lose every advantage that they have. I mean they already don't have gasoline. I mean Putin doesn't do anything. No one cares about the center. People themselves in the
Speaker 2front lines are yelling that the government is power, lives and can't do anything. I I just don't like it doesn't happen instantly, but I think it's I think it's getting there, because even.
Speaker 1It's a cascade it's starting, is what you're You're pointing out that, like the inability to pay troops is kind of a big deal as like the main thing that I big that like that's gonna that that has that has a very bad casting.
Speaker 2Currently currently wild but Wild Betties is the biggest issue because Wild Betty's is funded because they need a bunch of money because they'll go bankrupt otherwise, and there really is is the massive logistics chain there. They are funded. The only place where they can get any money is a bank called vit the bet second largest bankquete in bank in Russia. But they will never get their money back. And if vet the best say, if Wild Betties goes bust, then rational logistics are are horrible because people won't have anything to eat due to prices. If vetter Be bails them out right then then basically they then the bank crisis starts in Russia and they already have this unpaid
Speaker 2like bad debt is flowing around there constantly all the time.
Speaker 1So the situation is that and to be clear, Wild Berries as Russia's.
Speaker 2Amazon, Rusia's Amazon, which which also sells you know True, which also sells stuff for the special waltha deparation, of course, it's just that they have lost at this point. It's it's another of their facilities done twenty five percent of their capacity, approximately of their whole warehouses. They also had to fuse to pay their their sellers. Their compensations are miserable and small businesses in Russia already don't have it easy, and now they have it even worse. War is war wedding. This is actually starting to happen. What Wild Betty is
Speaker 2is one of those big businesses, which is because again in Russia you have only two things wild Berdies and ozone. Because they try to localize everything everything, everyone's been pushed out of the market. Wild Betties is big business. It's really big as everything is there. So if that goes, a lot of people get unpaid. It's going to be audible. Also that because again, as you might have noticed, Russia does have everything. In their army, they lack supplies and everything. Wild Berties is the place where most of these supplies come from, where all the volunteers held the front, which
Speaker 2is how Russian army lives because those dead patriots actually give them way more than the government. The government mostly right now, they hate their own military police with audible passion and often claim that it does more harm to to h to their war effort than the Ukrainians. Yeah, they hate their own military police. They hide their own everyone basically, so this is why this is a big deal. Those wild berry strikes and people, right, and I was.
Speaker 1Gonna and that that those are the kind of things that can ultimately lead to further internal fracture within the society, right, and that's where you start to see things like what what you basically describe as elite transit mutiny and internal regime.
Speaker 2From one tripping point. One tripping point that has been chieved though, which which I've noticed, is that it is now okay to publicly criticize.
Speaker 1Puddin, which is that's fascinating because that's not that is not normal.
Speaker 2That is that is because he doesn't do anything. And right now we already see the battle of the internal people struggling for this ego lifts. It says correctly that due to how by the way Wild Betties and other big companies are allowed to own their own anti air defenses and their own private military metasodic companies, Wild Betty's has it has its own small BMW like private, yeah, private warfare company whatever. There's going to be a war, but you're going to see a corporate war happening there for resources and everything. Also, do you know, do you know one one region where that is totally like the
Speaker 2only region that Russia wear gasoline is in full there is no shortages or anything like that.
Speaker 1Oh okay. That that and that also leads me to believe that if we're to start to see sort of we could call it regional decolonization or even secession, Chechnya is the first to go because they need Russia less less and less, it's sorry to sound like, at least in terms of the fuel. But I would imagine they're already kind of a state within states, so I would think that they would also they would be most willing to just go it alone. If that was to happen in the year.
Speaker 2All the all the regional governors will want to go. They will suddenly discover that that actually, you know, Buriata or everything. They're gonna have a massive support because Russia is a very multicultural nation, actually insanely so it is. Yeah, and they're just gonna discover this. They're just gonna flop away because again some parts are gonna sadly go to China. I don't know what's gonna happen there, but I don't see. Look when I when I claim that Russia is gonna fall apart, I don't say it as a thing that's something that's necessarily that good. But if you want to
Speaker 2have if you want to have a democracy there, you have Like there is no way how Russia and its current state can even become a democracy. Like it's too too huge, There is no logistics there. It's the mess is so so large. This is my counterpoint. When I had Michael on the show, Michael, Michael Hillard asket me, well, who's gonna be the next leader of Russia. That's the point. No one wants to be the next leader of Russia because it's just Russia. Everyone wants to be associated with the good Russia. Russia is a messy place. It's not that they don't have people who would want to, you know,
Speaker 2gain power, but it just that no one thinks it's a good idea because Russia in itself as a country, yeah, no one cares about that. They cared about the empire and everything, and and just it's it's so like why why people just don't consider preserving the people who are in the ChIL the key those guys, they consider Russia to be something to be preserved. But that's basically a self preservation instinct. They because they know because one important thing here which you probably did not know, is that see in Latvia, if you were XKGB and in other places,
Speaker 2you couldn't get elected in the x KGB agents couldn't get thected into power. You couldn't like they were babar from. In Russia, nothing like this happened. None of the people who were empowered in SOVIETA, who were in KGB, who were in like very much associated structures, they didn't have a cleansing of the system. None of that happened. So this is why the same people are still in power. Basically they did not They had no purge right at all.
Speaker 1And the sense I get though, is that that's what's going to characterize a Russian state collapse, so to speak, is not something akin to nineteen seventeen, which I think there might be people out there who think that's going to happen, or some like grand democratic reform. Honestly based in the picture that you've provided and I find it to be very compelling. I got to bring it back again to good old Yugoslavia. I think a Russian state collapse is going to look a lot more like what Yugoslavia was after Tito died and what it turned into
Speaker 1into the nineteen nineties. Which I mean, if anyone is in doubt that that was a nightmare for everybody involved, they should maybe pick up a book, because that was as bad as it gets when it comes to state dissolution. Now, as you said, Russia is very multicultural. But well, i'll actually defer to you again this. I don't get the sense so that they have as rigid or historical uh, not ancient but historical because a lot of people say Yugoslavia had ancient hatreds and that's not true, but historical
Speaker 1grievances between the different ethnicities there. I don't get the sense Russia has that kind of history. But it is a multicultural place, like you said, so I don't necessarily see like a rash of genocide and ethnic cleansing happening.
Speaker 2But maybe you can't. Let me tell you. Let me tell you something. Yeah, do you know that there have been two two words for Chechny, right, yeah, you know, yeah, they conquered that place. Then they deported a bunch of Chechens. Basically, Rasha conquered a bunch of Muslims. Then they then they complained that there are Muslims going to their capital. All these people are extremely racist. Yeah, also interestingly enough, right, do you know how many? I don't know, like it's not current, but I remember that I was looking this up back and just before, like basically one year before the war twenty twenty one or twenty twenty. Moscow is a city of what fourteen million people? Fourteen basically it's
Speaker 2about it's slightly smaller than New York or about that. Bout's basically people wise, it's huge. They don't how many masks they have for or at least they had four Well, how many Muslims live in about two to four million.
Speaker 1That's insane.
Speaker 2Yeah, The thing is they if you think rascifications has gone in where oh it hasn't. Still, it just happens in a very weird with a very weird sense. They all hate t Jikistan, they all hate these like they hate cho because and they're very racist in the sense that this again, you you would think that they could. They used to be born in the same country Soviet Union, right the jigstud used to be part of it. But that doesn't work that way. It's it's this is this is this is where you can see the fact that, as they always say, if you were not a Russian, you were a second class citizen inside of the Soviet Union.
Speaker 2And right now they openly openly hated them.
Speaker 1Because I was gonna say, the anti nationalization projects of Lenin didn't last very long. And then when Stalin came around, I mean I think he was he if I remember right, he did play along with that, but then he started to play up Russian identity, especially when the Second.
Speaker 2World War started, because there was you know, there was a reason for that, there was a tacticalpwork. But what makes the same time this yeah, literally this comes from st. Please let's quote Uncle Joe Cole, but my good friends, he just stated that, you know it will be easy you have to control Russians. If everyone's a Russian, you know that that's they're easy to control.
Speaker 1Right, simple, Well, and that kind of fits into that, that fits into like what I sort of see, and this is maybe a little historically deterministic. But again to characterize Russia for the last one hundred and fifty years at least, but I'm sure longer. It just seems like this giant terrestrial empire that just keeps trying to stitch itself together and stay held together, and it just keeps not working because.
Speaker 2They come an empire. They have an empire for empire's sake, basically, right, yeah, yeah, there's not a shared vision. There is there There isn't. There's a vision of Moscow of some people living there. But people claim that they care about this holy Like see, if you can't only about the Holy Russia, right, then you're stoff caring about the one that actually exists exactly. No one has, no one has done. Every time something new happens in Russia, you find out that something was stolen. This is from the eighteenth century, like I forgot the poet,
Speaker 2but there is like a famous saying that every time someone, someone somewhere and Russia starts talking about patriotism, trust me, something has been stolen. Just just a last just last week, turns out that they had given the development rights to their new because Ukrainians have this Bubba Yaga, this big agricultural drill that drops bombs and supplies and everything. You've seen the videos of that thing. See Russia still hasn't got their own analog. They gave a bunch of cash to a company in the in the kind of a They gave a bunch of cash to a businessman whose main business is producing mayo. He's called the Mayo King
Speaker 2my next episode. And then just now everyone was arrested involved in this project because they did the one thing they are best at. They took Chinese. They took all the Chinese stuff, put their own, put their own sticker on it, and just call it today. They they don't they can't build this stuff. The the problem is that they don't have gasoline for for wheat. It's not it's not just it's not just high end electronics. It turns out they don't buy their own antibiotics for their animals. They don't have even even their own seed for potatoes. They have they have a pay for a shortage. It's
Speaker 2it's crazy. This is why I also made this episode about food, like because it sounds silly though the happy episode, which we did with everything, but the important part is that I watched it and I just watched at you know what, what's what stuff is made from? Okay, and then you understand that they have a rating for meat which you can legally call meat that contains that zero twenty percent actual meat. And there their their shelves are full of products.
Speaker 1You know.
Speaker 2The guy was like happy, Oh what an you invention? Full of products which is like I don't know, not pizza, but like something between pizza and a bellush or pizza and a pinmin something of that sort. And it's it's renamed in a way to signalize this. That's how they can, you know, evade evade those standards. The it's it's like craft singles would seem like a great idea over there, and it's just I'm not kidding it. It was just scary just because it's the things that they put in the normal section was crazy. Also, he made an episode
Speaker 2about how of Goose Light Touch over there the McDonald's replacement, which is when McDonald's left Russia, this is what they took over. They have paid me manu that and wealth and everything, and apparently right now they have warms and maggots and their food health issues have appeared. It's fun and crazy.
Speaker 1It feels like an underrated destabilizing force within the Russian state. I would imagine that people are not happy about that.
Speaker 2To put it more, people right now are not happy because also Russia is now limiting access to high schools, limiting access to high schools, universities. Just Russia is scraping the bottom of the battle at this moment, and at this point they're not acting no longer like at one point. At one point put In even stopped acting in his own interests because right now the things he does is just they're just dumb. The thing is, it might may not lie, it might not look like kid, but I believe that the events already have moved outside of put
Speaker 2into that control. It's just that he thinks it hasn't happened yet. But we'll see about election, because I because everyone now, hey, United Russia so much like so fucking much that I think we might see actual protests happening and then them being violently suppressed after after after the October elections.
Speaker 1Are you thinking we might see we might see a Russian tianeman?
Speaker 2Yeah, I mean actually yeah, but actually yeah. Interesting. Interesting thing by the way about American and why actually, another thing about Ai, but this is important. When I was doing my research on my shows, right the Russia's elections are coming and uh, people zi patriots obviously worry about how it's going to be cheating in that election and everything. But then you know, I feed YouTube YouTube links, did my Gemini, which is then you know, pulls out transcripts for me, which is nice. But then he pulled out it pulled out a transcript and then it was like, oh, Sodi, I kind of transcripts anymore. It just blocked me for
Speaker 2a day from from reading transcript and it was it was very confused about this because that that was from corporate. Turns out that I got a warning about elections. If you if you feed it, and you if you feed something which has information about elections and you want to ask it about election results or potential things, it can just ban you from you know, accessing information containing this word. Ever, just cut off the limit limit what it can't do, because it's so paranoid about you know, Americans asking who should win the elections that it's crazy and it doesn't care that I need this for my job and these
Speaker 2are unrelated elections. It just so happens magical of course, the same is that this is the censorship that you don't understand that a lot of people don't encounter it. For example, on the day when Trump invaded Iran for the first time, I was reading my Russian news and obviously that got met. That's got to mention there, and I could not feed it any information from any of my telegram channels or videos which contained any news about Iran war, even though that wasn't the main subject which I'm interested in. It just limited me and you know,
Speaker 2really disturbed my work. And then think about this, isn't that I feel like that's kind of scary and actually scarier then you know, that's censorship that a lot of people don't notice. There's a censorship that affects me the most in a lot of cases. That's a big scary issue. Also, take take notes.
Speaker 1It's gonna be it's if there's like a lot of controversy about the upcoming Russian elections, I would imagine AI is going to probably give you a lot of trouble then too. Oh no, AI doesn't as you try to talk about it, not to me at all.
Speaker 2This is this is why I want to say something, which is why I'm actually talking about that. I so much because right now my gem and is acting like rock. Basically, the only keywords that I know that I get thrown at me are the ones by Google itself, because it's not that ninety percent of the stuff that AI tells you that you can't do is because you haven't given it a good reason why you should. If you do, it will But there are things which basically Google straight up prohibits it to do, and then it just rips it out and says no, no, no talking about that, otherwise we might get in trouble. It's so so those
Speaker 2things are crazy. Sometimes it's beyond stupid and dangerous too.
Speaker 1I gotta tell you the interesting thing, as you know, I wanted to get to your final prediction from the first dark Of episode because it's the scariest one. In short, it was the possibility of a tactical nuclear black market leak ate occurring within Russia because of all this, And interestingly, that was the one thing that no matter what I did, maybe I could probably you know, feed at some prompts that you could give me, but that was the one thing AI was really strenuously trying to say, Oh, that's
Speaker 1not going to happen. That can't happen probability.
Speaker 2Right now, I actually I have to okay, right now, I also know why it can't happen. But that's a thing that I was asked not to not to say on the show. This comes from a source that basically was a nuclear scientists in the United States Military Nuclear Weapons Research program and the lot of operations there. Really my source is good, but I will not say. Well, and now I know it can't happen, and I but that's the reason. The reason is super dumb. But that
Speaker 2can't happened, not because of anything really good. But I have stuff worrying about this. I just didn't have this information before. I also, I also know why it's not being told openly. So it's fine. It's just that again, this is one of the things that, yeah, I learned about. But suddy, guys, this is you might call bullshit on me. But again, I there's a bunch of things that I can't really talk about, just not because I don't want to, but because I don't want to. For example, I don't
Speaker 2want to ruin I don't want to make people die in the front lines, for example, or or ruin someone's job, or just really do harm to my national security as well, because those things really happen, and a lot of in a lot of cases, in a lot of cases, you feel you feel maybe better worrying about this stuff. But that was one of the things that I actually asked because that's really concerned me as well. But now I know for sure that's not gonna happen. And also Russia is not going to use any yokes any anytime soon. Yeah,
Speaker 2and I will stick with that because, oh boy, I know the person who told me this is listening to this show right now, and I really really want to tell you that. But but maybe look, let let me just say, let me just tell you this, because I know he's listening to this. So if if, if he will, if he will ask me, if he will ask me for your email or for your contacts, and will be okay with with you with Kim telling you that stuff, then you'll find out otherwise and study won't gonna happen.
Speaker 1We'll put a pin in that then. But I'm glad to hear that it's not possible. I mean, that's that's the real thing. Because obviously, what Americans, especially who fashion themselves as anti war, and I don't say that too lightly. I think that a lot of anti war types are frauds. But putting that aside, the always the number one thing that gets cited about the dangers of war, especially regarding Russia, is their nuclear arsenal. So that's a that's definitely something that is on the minds of a lot of people. But I think it's it's good that that's not as
Speaker 1much of a like some of all fears situation. And I'm referencing the Tom Clancy book.
Speaker 2Talking about fears fears in war, about the anti war people struck. You struck a really painful subject to me. See, I've been running this. I've been running this sort of chattity thing. I'm want to help Ukraine by gathering for Ukraine. By the way, please do put a link to this this in your show description. We really should help them out. They basically buy Toyota Hilex's, reinforce them and send them to the front lines. I know a lot of people don't like giving money to to lethal aid. I'm not wanted to. I'm okay with this because it's still war. But my my chattity is non lethal. If you care
Speaker 2about this, The big issue is that I have sent already what five cars to Ukraine through my show, five cards with like my big logo on top of it the eastern border. Yeah, people, and it's it's actually been seeing somewhere. And recently I got to the point where I won't I won't mention the company because I really not, because I don't want to shame them, because they are beneath me, because they were like they found out about me from this campaign and the offered to sponsored me. Uh. The offer, by the way, was about you know about two and a half thousand dollars, which is about you know,
Speaker 2about the same that I make pretty good money, except they asked me, you know, to do not run this chit not not not to run the charity on on the episodes where where they you know, where that would be heard, because it's very good and nice to say that you support Ukraine, but you know, we can't be associated with actually, you know, doing anything for the war because because the war is killing and war is bad. Yeah, therefore therefore charity, you know, it's okay to speak about. And then I then I checked this and if you if you notice, if you've noticed, every everyone analyst on
Speaker 2YouTube who basically has sponsorships and they talk about the war like the same Warfronts channel or something. If they have ads, then you know they will never run a charity. And the only channel that I know that also runs this stuff, no channel that runs actually charities for Ukraine has any sponsorships on YouTube, very few and very far between, if any. The same Michael Kaki and everything. That's your nice little hypocrisy of the West as well, which I find very very bad because if I can point out this, then suddy guys. But I really have very little respect
Speaker 2for people. It's kind of like we're going to be supporting the right, supporting the good guys. We're gonna be everyone says everything's good and nice, but uh oh, of course, of course we're not. You're not allowed to actually do anything because that would be impolite.
Speaker 1Yeah, And that's the thing that I always find so frustrating with people who love to Well, it's interesting because it's always the people who seem to be most willing to go to bat for Russia and defend their actions and say, well, it's actually out NATO expansion and and Western you know, Hubris and all that stuff. Because essentially they're functionally saying that, you know, you know, Russia's the victim here, They're a tragic victim of history or something like that. And then when you know, forced to justify their position, they always just fall back on the same
Speaker 1empty well, war is bad rhetoric like okay, well done. You have the moral compass of a five year old, like, yeah, war is bad. Nobody says war is very few people say war is good. War just but war is what it is. It exists and it's happening right now, and you don't have to take a side, but you should probably be a little more consistent.
Speaker 2On the I mean, not taking aside is fine, but if you are a person who does take a side, then you know, then I feel to keep a critical when you claim to be very pro Ukrainian and now I know for sure that you're not going to be drowning any chat aty is that because that might that might lose you some income or something. And the income is significant too. It's YouTube's fault as well. But uh, you know, I'm pretty sure that they I'm pretty sure if more people would just stand off for this, that would be nice. It is like the dark dark side of this mess. And about one thing about sponsorship still
Speaker 2mind you, which I kind of want to talk about as a thing that I also heard and thought about a lot lately. Ground News, by this is the biggest sponsorship I've been hearing there. You know what's the problem with the ground news? Which I understood because because you live in the States, it's not not a problem for you there, but you're used to having any partisan media, right for example, Latvian public media is supposed to be non partisant by default at all. They actively tried to be very centrist and then you know, then they get put into left right by whom? And if this happens
Speaker 2to Lafia, like which side is BBC? Okay, sometimes they aught on some sort of side, but they didn't force these stadeo types, and you know what, you know for whom ground news is really for, like really for people who only read the headline of the article and then don't read the rest of the article. And you know, you know, I can they can afford to pay for all these ads on YouTube because well they basically they basically sell you the if they basically tell you to, you know, you don't have to pay all the media for this content, because we know you read the headlines anyway,
Speaker 2So why don't you just read all the headlines in my place and we're all good and all this stuff about different perspectives and all this message. Yeah, I find that to be highly dubious and suspicious, because yeah, what's what's better reading headlines from all the sides and not to hear any arguments or maybe just you know, read one article in full ground news is really really good if you're hasting, if you just want an overview. But I do believe they get the vast majority of their money from people who would just really enjoy enjoy those headlines. That's the thing, because they get absolutely among the good sponsors.
Speaker 2But but really you should just actually it would be just much better if you find the good newspaper or media organization, and if you want one, actually go and read European ones.
Speaker 1That gets into into like an issue with American media, which is a whole other conversation, or our media system has been to be perfectly blood collapsing for years now. I mean when you say get a newspaper, well, if you don't live in New York, Los Angeles, Chicago, you know the big cities, you're not really going to be getting a newspaper like local news is collapsing. It's been collapsing, like I said, for many decades actually at this point, you know, it's a very depressing situation. So the way
Speaker 1that like things like ground news or other aggregates you know, are able to make their argument is because the news quality, that the media quality in the United States is so poor. I mean, there's a reason why I believe. I don't know where it's at now. It might have gone up, it might have gone down, But for a long time, media was considered the most distrusted institution in America below Congress, which is shocking for a country that prides itself on its free press.
Speaker 2And we do have a free press.
Speaker 1I think that that's not a knock against our you know, our press freedom that we have, but it's just to say that the incentives are all out of whack here. They have been for a very long time, and that, you know, is what the best you can hope for is just a headline aggregator. That is what it's more indicative of than anything. Not to say that you can't get news, but you have to make an effort to like get news in a way now that we didn't really used to.
Speaker 2That is true, But the problem is that I just those are little things that I'm I'm speaking about here, talking about here that I'm trying to at least get the message out because I feel like they've noticed some things and maybe maybe someone at least person they are true give this a listen, and maybe they change their the way that they operate. For example, if we can change like, well, yeah, if you're listening to the show, you probably are smart enough to maybe care about these things, so you know, it would be nice if you would
Speaker 2would maybe think about how how all this operates.
Speaker 1I would hope that like people read more books too, and actually, to be honest, I do want to transition to that to our what I consider sort of the best and final topic is your book. I mean, you've been talking about this on your show, but I think maybe there are people who listen to my show who aren't aware of this that Kris stops Andri Sin's's writing the book and it's uh and it's going to be a banger. I believe it's called is it called Angry Patriots?
Speaker 2I remember that correctly? Well, Okay, and before we get into that.
Speaker 1I I just realized I know what they are, and anyone who listens to you probably know what they are. But uh, can you just explain to everybody what? Who are the Zed patriots?
Speaker 3Why is it?
Speaker 2Why is it z?
Speaker 1As in the letter Z. I mean everyone else in the world calls it Zed. But uh, who are the Zed patriots? And why are they so angry?
Speaker 2I guess is my question? Well, they are the people I fellow on my show, who who really fully bought into put In propaganda? And who are true believers thok for you know, the guys who really believe this Holy Yasha think uh Dugan could be called the said patriot as well.
Speaker 1Ugness and patriots.
Speaker 2Technically he counts as one. Technically they themselves, they themselves argue, But that's because patriots hate put In now, but not because he's a bad man, just because he isn't isn't killing enough people that he quickly right, He's not doing enough.
Speaker 2The thing is this was made by Igorkin, that's his organization, after which he went to prison. Then I hijacked his trademark and the you take that get kin. But uh, I found I've been following this Maxim Koshnikov guy, Like I said, he's the rational agent of this whole situation, and I've been following him for a long time, and I just noticed how he tries to explain everything away, but it's becoming less and less, you know, less and less explainable, so to speak. And I understood that, wait a minute, he's he's failing to do this, and he's he's rationalizing this. And this is a kind of a
Speaker 2coughchaisk story because you can talk about this war from the perspective that this man is truly because he's a true believer. He truly sees everything he holds deer and his life go away from him. He's seeing his worldview collapse. He truly thinks that evil is winning in this world world, and that everything is audible, that that's you, the evil Satan worshipers or whatever, that the the you're gonna win, and that you know that everything that's good and nice in this world is going gonna go away. See and that I find this fascinating because he's trying to somehow
Speaker 2justify Russia just if anything, and then then you could have sort of can follow him through from his views on on on the early war and what he thinks now, and it's it's a mess. It's a glorious big mess. And it also you can also basically understand why why he loves Zeppelins so much because he used to play a lot of Fred Alert. He also has He also has posted a lot of UH, a lot of posts to Russian impedialist forums and everything. It's an interesting thing. I basically I use lurk more the Russian cultural the
Speaker 2key is one of my sources. There. Therefore, I if I think a book for me in this case, like if I would be if I would have to invent all this stuff, I wouldn't be doing this. I do have to say that the seventy five percent of my book is just my translations of stuff already existing either by Zed patriots themselves or by the global side guy stuff of THEE in a way, and there's footnotes and everything. And I swear a lot in this because this started out as well, I want to do my PhD about this, But then I understood that I have too much PTSD on this shit, and my thetrapists said that I need
Speaker 2to write it through Gonzel book real angry. You want to get it out of my system? Yeah, well, and it's good.
Speaker 1Well, what I think is really great about this is that it will also probably provide some enlightenment to where a lot of these narratives ultimately come from. And it's from these these z chats essentially, and these creators, I guess we can call them. They're content creators. Funny enough, they're propagandists, and it does seem like they are the origin point of I.
Speaker 2Don't even know if it.
Speaker 1Maybe I'm overstating it, but it seems to me that before they became super pessimistic like Kleashnikov did. It does seem a lot of people here who have this idea that Russia inevitably is going to win seem to be getting a lot of their insights from places like this. Now. Granted, as you said, it's more pessimistic, so I'm sure maybe that might be why they've gotten so quiet lately here in the West.
Speaker 2It's not a fictional book, but it's also not academia. Please on one thing, though, sure, it's a very personal Like I said, it's basically if he had and loathing on the Eastern border. Okay in a way, but just just if I make I can make mistakes into that book, and that's okay, and I am angry there and I'm gonna I'm gonna read you. I'm just gonna read you. One interesting I need to read. I need to read you a letter written by Maxim Colostnikov, the so proclaimed intellectual of this whole mess, just because it shows the
Speaker 2level of how how they think, and it's about how Russia could invade the United States. He proposed this.
Speaker 1As if he's ever seen the movie Read Dawn.
Speaker 2This is this is better where it was. I'm just trying to find my post on subsec. I'll be posting this for paid. If you have a paid subscriber off my show in anyway or forum, you'll get this. And if you really want to read this but can't afford to pay, well of course I will also, you know, just just email me. But there's this letter about Maxim Kalashnikov, who, by the way, interestingly enough, this is from the prolog he was he started writing fantasy literature. He's a huge sci fi nerd, and the publishing house politely asked him and not to put his real name on it because they were afraid it's going to be too audible. But
Speaker 2he sent this to the massive military historical forum opened open that true, like a really huge forum before readit, like what all these nationalists said. Dugan used to say that this is where Dugan's support comes from. Dugan started out on these forums where he got popular. Mind you, and this is Maxim Kalashnikov, the intellectual which also just sits that. And he wrote this and this. This happened I think in twenty fourteen when he wrote this, Yeah, and then then listen to this, Yeah, this is going to be great. Quote hello, And this is his forum
Speaker 2post after the war. It is a post on World War two. After the war, everyone was afraid that our tanks would reach Paris. Well, we should have gone all the way just to prove it everyone, and then we could have returned like we did from Austria. But that's not the point. So we reach it, and what is next? After all, our main likely adversary at the time was the United States of America, and it was then we needed to crush. I used to think about this a lot, and I had this idea to carry out a tank rate on the USA via the shortest ruth across the Arctic over the ice. Here are my calculations. He has
Speaker 2ten points here. One the ice thickness in the North Pole is five six meters. It will easily support tanks. Two the composition of the attacking forces about four hundred five hundred tanks highly trained. Three supply them from submarines that would periodically surface for this purpose. Four advance during the polar night so as not to be spotted from the air, or paint them white. Five do not use compasses and radio communications. They do not work in the Arctic due to the northern lights. Instead navigated by other landmarks, by the sun or the stars. Six Tanks and cruise
Speaker 2should lighten their load as much as possible before the journey, taking only the essentials. We have experience with this. Seven bypass steve ice ridges and ice holes, driving only on flat and smooth ice ridges. Eight use venison and seal meat for food. A similar expedition by Robert by Scott was ruined by this. They used ponies, dogs and pemmican. And then he puts in brackets. Truth to be told, I don't know what that is. End of brackets, which is why they injured a leg and one went crazy on the way back without vitamins. Nine reached the mainland in the shortest possible time and use the local traders
Speaker 2guides there. Yeah, he thinks that that would happen. Ten The crossing will take twenty thirty days of marching. The main thing is not to stop so the engines don't stolen the cold. And then that he notices such advantages on the United States one surprise and stealth. It won't cross anyone's mind while we are accumulating tanks in the far North, for example, we could say it for scrapping two total lack of resistance. Even in the event of losing the element of surprise, A tank painted white is practically invisible from a height. Three heavy United States battleships won't be able to approach through the ice, and as
Speaker 2for the rest, including submarines, the tanks will handle them with the one hundred and fifty two millimeters caliber guns. The political aspect one on the occupied northern territories of the USA, we could form on opposition government and then in the brackets. After the war, there were many malecontents in America, especially Negroes and Indians, plus there are still many of our people left in Alaska close brackets. Mexico would support us, following Finland's example that a turn of territory is occupied by the USA, and finally a two front war against our tanks in Alaska and Mexico. America simply could not withstand, and then he finishes off with
Speaker 2History has known many examples of bald, almost incredible decisions, the most striking being Hannibal's raid. Although I won't hide it, it was easier for him. He prudently took elephants with him as food. Back in nineteen eighty before the Olympics, I sent a detailed article to Young Technician magazine, but they didn't publish it. It is possible this topic is still classified. Sincerely, so and so, and now you might want to ask why why I read this bullshit insanity of this crazy guy who was a hell of a fan fiction. The worst part is the worst part is he makes more accurate predictions about Russia's future, and he
Speaker 2has more information, and he's way more logical than currently things you hear on Channel one than actual you know Russian instery defense people. He makes more sense. This is the impedial might that they believe here. He is really among one of the most really respected people throughout this whole area. He's a personal friend to figure Ghirkin. He hasn't been closed. He gets like a beauty yeh, which another very important. People to come to him. Russian goes to the deputies come to him on the show, all the philosophers and everything, leaders of National Bolsheviks. He's also
Speaker 2in a beef with Dugan because he calls himself a techno futurologist and he likes all this mess. And also he really loves rid Alert. His favorite thing is he always tries to find a way how to make Zeppelins a thing. Again. That's because he really hopes Kero of Airship will be for the thing from Red Alert. And we go through his study and we go through misunderstandings of Russia. One of the things that I look at is just his interview with he got Vidkin and I well angrily explained that, you know, just before the war. My first chapter, which is in a paid section, is
Speaker 2about an interview. The book starts in twenty first off twenty first of December, I think twenty first of December twenty twenty one. Where Gidkin went on the show and claimed that definitely there's going to be war in Russia war with Ukraine basically because his argument is very simple. One thing that I can point point out everyone said that there would be no war with Russia because come on, he obviously didn't have enough troops to invade. Clearly he wants to blackmail people. Getakin's count. An argument is very simple. Yeah, sure, but if he has not enough troops to invade, then
Speaker 2how the hell any blackmail is supposed to work in this case. If you don't have enough troops to invade, you don't have enough troops of blackmail too magical a lot of these things, it's a bit angry, it's mocking them, mocking everything. And I will include some sections where the stuff that could have happened about processes in Maxim Kolostnikov's head because in some case, some occasions he actually tries to stop the most radical elements. It's a weird thing because we're going to watch this guy go from go from Kiev in three days and glorious Russian Empire to
Speaker 2the point where he's probably extremely depressed. On the other hand, he's the hero of his own book, and he considers himself to be a coughcask super tragic hero who loses because of bidocracy. Yeah, he doesn't change. He can't change. And it's going to be you know, it's gonna be a funny book when it comes out. And I really hope that someone is going to show an interest in publishing this because you know, that would be nice because after all, I do Chattity for Ukraine, so I don't get I don't get that sponsorship money.
Speaker 1Right exactly, well, and I do want to tell people if somehow like people listening have not subscribed to your sub sec or your Patreon, but they like what you have to say, your perspective, they should definitely join up.
Speaker 2I'm I am.
Speaker 1You're one of the few shows that I that I financial support. This might be a broke ass grad student, I.
Speaker 2Really, I really Look again, I'm open about this stuff, and I really actually would want people to join the Fourth Wall or something because Patreon is going to screw me over in November duce Apple they decided that yeah, yeah, yeah, this matters because when I started on the show, there's a long time ago, and I was watching how other creators took up per month, you know, a kind of thing. Uh, but then didn't release anything for years and I thought that was, you know, dishonest. But the problem is if you switch over, you lose all your patrons, so to speak. So I feel like my November is going to be
Speaker 2pretty nasty and bad, but you know it's going to be like if you can't support me, please do If you can't, please give it, Please donate to Ukraine, Donate to Cotfooucraine dot com. I know all these people personally, and I really hope that it's going to be going to be over soon. And I really believe that if you're an American, if you're an American, like Ukraine is going to be like they have Street in that's for John McCain, you know.
Speaker 1And that is that that's not insignificant.
Speaker 2I mean all of them are bad. I think.
Speaker 1Well, and I was gonna say, and and as I understand it, places, uh, you know, like in Poland they have a massive love affair with Ronald Reagan. They have a statue of Reagan. I believe in it might be Warsaw, I'm not sure where, but yeah, like there is an appreciation of America in uh Eastern Europe in general. I think that a lot of Americans don't fully appreciate. They don't they don't know about it. And and then there's a reason for that. It's because, you know, we have done some good in the past. I I We're an
Speaker 1imperfect country and culture, as I think we've made clear in all of our conversations, including this one.
Speaker 2Look, look, the thing is the thing is currently with the current situation where where the United States and Juda don't really see ITI. We like America. We like America enough so that there are European news saying that Latvian's up too too chummy, too friendly with uh with with the United States, we are actually doing with on the administration level. If you don't, if you look like it's said below Trump, we're actually actively trying to work with them. We have We're not hating the United States as a whole. We have some problems with you guys, the same that
Speaker 2you have with with everyone basically but.
Speaker 1Right and and we have the sort of weakness of our two party system and our yo yo effect of our politics reverberates across the world in a very significant way, and even more so when we have you know, a bad man at the at the helm frankly and the and the.
Speaker 2Magical little thing is that if you want to, you know, if you're worried that Tudip should spend more money on their defense, where if the one's doing all this stuff, I live here on the border. Just that's right, We're all all this message that dude up. Also, you know, we like, we like America more than than you probably imagine.
Speaker 1Yeah, and I and I honestly it's I really do appreciate that as an American and as one who's become increasingly patriotic. I mean, it's our two hundred and fiftieth anniversary. It's not hasn't been very long, but it's you know, we're just hanging in there. And I think we're gonna hang in there, you know, for hopefully at least a few more years.
Speaker 2I don't know, longer than Russia. How about that.
Speaker 3To beyond.
Speaker 2Me?
Speaker 3But oh money, I talk, but not to be off by the Lomeo FA love big Army.
Speaker 1All right, thank you for listening, especially this far everybody. I really appreciate it, and I hope you found that conversation as interesting and compelling as I I did. I'm hoping to have more in the future. Of course, it sounds like I'm going to be going on Christops Show at some point in the near future, so we can look forward to that collectively.
Speaker 2And yeah, so.
Speaker 1We covered a lot of ground there, so there's not much more to reflect on, I suppose, but please consider heading over to the Patreon and substack, where I'm going to be posting a little bonus lecture of sorts.
Speaker 2And I don't mean that in a negative way.
Speaker 1I mean that as like a sort of primer maybe is a better way of putting it of Chris stops talking about how he uses AI and how other people should use it. So that'll be a nice bonus for everybody who supports this show financially. Speaking of which, I want to give some shout outs to the people who continue to support this show over on Patreon at the Comrades and friends level and above.
Speaker 2Those people include.
Speaker 1Bob Downing, Sam Graham, Greg Hunter, s O, Skip Pachaco, Molly Pan, John Pisano, Anna R.
Speaker 2PJ.
Speaker 1Raider, Matthew m Rice, Philip Rice, John Andre Sai, Emily Schmidt, Pierre Vapuni, and f you great bunch of folks. Those guys, and everybody else who supports this show. I thank all of you for doing so. So if you like what you hear and what I do here, please consider heading over to Patreon dot com, slash History Impossible, orhistory impossible dot com and become a patron or subscriber at whatever level you find comfortable. Thank you again for listening, and please stay tuned for the next episode of History Impossible.
Understanding evil is something that has preoccupied humans for a long time. By the mid-20th century, the desire to root it in firm, social scientific terms became the norm, particularly in the field of psychology. The...
Hey everyone. No preamble here. Just a nice bonus as a thank you for your continued support. As the title suggests, this is an audio adaptation of an essay I wrote about the 25th anniversary of 9/11 and how it led me to...
We often hear about how the Second World War was more morally nuanced and complex than we have been led to believe. This is, to a certain extent, very true. The Axis powers meted out a level of genocidal destruction and...
In this newest episode of History Impossible we’re joined a second time by Richard Lim, host of the This American President podcast, who last appeared on this program a couple years ago to discuss the insane,...
Antizionism, as it has become, has been having a bit of a moment for going on three years. It is a tough nut to crack, given its various claims of varying legitimacy and, as we have covered more than once on History...