The Ideological Pathology of Antizionism (w/ Kile Jones)
56 minAudio
Antizionism, as it has become, has been having a bit of a moment for going on three years. It is a tough nut to crack, given its various claims of varying legitimacy and, as we have covered more than once on History Impossible, its increasing tendency to veer into outright antisemitism, especially by those looking for a supposedly intellectual and moral veneer for their racial and geopolitical fixations. Part of the reason for this confusion is the complex intellectual history of the position, which, after 1948, became more complicated than the relatively straightforward debate over Jewish statehood before, during, and after the Holocaust. To help make sense of this complicated intellectual history, I was thrilled to be joined by Kile Jones of The Inverted World Substack, which, along with his work for the Times of Israel, has helped map out this historical trajectory and challenge many of the preconceived notions held by many who take their anti-Israel positions for granted. We discussed this trajectory, as well as a number of other subjects, including the time Kile met with Noam Chomsky, his transition from card-carrying Marxist to an old-fashioned liberal, and many other things. It was a great conversation, hopefully the first of many, and I hope you all enjoy the journey we go on together. ... History Impossible has been made possible by the following generous supporters on Patreon, Substack, and PayPal. Please consider donating today if you want to show some love for what I do and make and what to help keep the show and all my written content going: David Adamcik Monica Almirall David Alsbach Gregg Anderson approso1999 Rajan Athul Robert Babeon Michael Beach Benjamin Greg Bosai Johannes Breitsameter Carol ABC Carol Chappelle Charles C Chomo the Clown Curtis Christiansen Jason Coleman Clayton Connell Click Cliffydeuce CR Craig Crawford B.Cyr daddygorgon Danny Lynda Davis Paul DeCoster Regina Dick-Endrizzi Neil Dickens Nathan Diehl Bob Downing Dramicas Martin E. Eastone Gavin Edwards Snow Farmer Howie Feltersnatch Matt Gassner Pierre Ghazarian Josh Goedert Elena Gomel Sam Graham Jayson Griesmeyer Nathan Grote Benjamin Hamilton Peter Hauck Jack Henneman Eric Hodges Mike Jarulic Joe6245 Lionel Joseph Thomas Justesen Mike Kalnins Bryn Kaufman Leah Kodner Constance Loucks Maddy Mounty of Madness Jose Martinez Mike Mayleben S.M. McAvoy Judy McCoid Mike Kyle Mohney Kostas Moros Ryan Mortenson John Muller Cameron Needham Sean P Skip Pacheco David Page Molly Pan Philip Pomerantz Sr. Powell Brian Pritzl AnaR737 PJ Rader Gleb Radutsky Aleksandr Rakitin Reptilycus Matthew M. Rice Phillip Rice Cheryl Robertson Terry Rosen Run Tough Mindset Andrew S Dan S Jon Andre Saether Jake Scalia Emily Schmidt Julian Schmidt Scryptar Andrew Seeber Shiran Joshua Simpson Cameron Smith Jerry Spangler timetosuccedd1995 Thomas Squeo Athal Krishna Sundarrajan Jared Cole Temple Ann Tout Mike US Ward Van Roy Pierre Vorupuni Robert VS Nate Wade weaverap Jonny Wilkie Christian Wilson Janora Winsor F. You Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/history-impossible--5634566/support.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hello everybody, ladies, gentlemen, brothers, sisters, comrades, friends. I am back with all of you, and I'm delighted to be back with another conversation with a fellow creator, historian, reporter Kyle Jones from the Inverted World substack. We had this conversation some weeks back and it was a very good one, and such a good one that I hope to have Kyle on again so we can continue this conversation where we break down the for lack of a better way
Speaker 1of putting it, pathologies of anti Zionism and its historical intellectual origins and whatnot. We also talk about the time that he met Noam Chomsky and a number of other really interesting avenues that we go down for you guys. Before we get going with this, I want to give the usual shout outs to the patrons and subscribers paid subscribers over on the History Impossible Substance, and those include, especially at the executive producer level, Monica Almerale and Mike Maleban.
Speaker 1I really appreciate all of the support you guys have been giving me for so long at this point, and if any of you listening like what you hear here and you like the work that I'm doing and want to support it, especially as I start to have to pay off those student loans. You guys should consider subscribing over at historympossible dot com, becoming a paid supporter there, or joining the History Impossible Patreon at whatever level you find doable. Obviously, not everybody can fork over cash every
Speaker 1month or even a one time payment, though that is also an option if that's more your jam. But if you can't afford to support the show financially, please just spread the word and you know, get this out there, send it to somebody you think would find it compelling or informative. So yeah, that is is really all I got for you, guys. In the way of an intro, I really hope you enjoyed this conversation that I had with Kyle Jones. Well, let me to tell you what
Speaker 1you would have seen and heard.
Speaker 2If we're not being pleasant listening, if you're at lunch, or if you have no appetize, now it is a good time to switch auf the radio.
Speaker 3An ancestor of mine maintained that if you eliminate the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable.
Speaker 1Banji, I'm.
Speaker 4Thousand.
Speaker 1I wish I could say tonight that a lasting peace is inside.
Speaker 2I don't see the laughing dream.
Speaker 5I feel a laughing night Moore.
Speaker 6If we hear were issues to Gail, if we were au to Gail say the world some say and I from what I tasted of desire, I hold.
Speaker 5Of those of favor fire and have it had to perish twice. I think I know I'm a fok. Hate to say that for destruction, I say is also great.
Speaker 7And look, sufiaed, this is history or possible.
Speaker 1I am here with Kyle Jones of the Inverted World sub sect, but he's also written for the Times of Israel, Philosophy now the Humanist number of academic journals. We discovered before recording that we share an interest in religious history, or at least religious studies, I guess we could say. And yeah, so I actually wanted to have you here, Kyle, because I've started following your work ever since. I think it Honestly, if your subseact started only a couple months ago, I think I might have started reading it when you
Speaker 1started it or around thereabout. And yeah, so I'm a really big fan of what you're doing. You've been cataloging anti Zionism as we can, I guess kind of call it right now. We were also kind of getting at that before we're recording to sort of try to even define it, which we'll get to. But I think people should get an idea of who you are with your background and who you are, what you do, all that stuff. And I can't let you not talk about the story
Speaker 1you talk about on your substack about when you met Noam Chomsky, So who can add that into the biography here and just what that experience was like and maybe also merge that into just sort of what your exposure and experiences with whatever it is that we call anti Zionism actually was as a concept and as a position. So yeah, I guess I'll just let you take it away with the autobiography here.
Speaker 5Sure, sure, So I let's see.
Speaker 4I did my graduate studies at Boston University in religious religious studies and philosophy.
Speaker 5I was an anti Zionist.
Speaker 4I didn't hold a placard or a cardboard cutout. I went to one protest at Boston Commons against the Iraq War, and I lasted about twenty minutes and everybody irritated me there, So.
Speaker 5I left.
Speaker 1That reminds me of I went to I did a high school while I was in high school at the time, and I did a we did a walkout, you know, and I went to a protest. But the problem is I was in high school and I didn't have a car, so I was stuck there after. I got annoyed after about twenty minutes or so because I was just hearing these like slogans and chants. It just didn't make any sense to me.
Speaker 4And that's the thing too, is this protest culture is so privileged, like I have, I have work to do, people like.
Speaker 5I got something to do.
Speaker 4So, you know, but I was an anti Zionist in the sense that I my education was you know, quite liberal, and as you know, in academia, the culture itself is generally anti Zionists in the sense of settler colonial theory, post colonialism, people like Edward, said Rashi KHALIDI. You know, but what mom, Donnie's father, right, You know, a lot
Speaker 4of the post colonial narrative and and ways of discussing enlightenment power and in Western knowledge and this sort of this sort of stuff, it lends itself towards that leftism. You know, a lot of professors that are leftists.
Speaker 5And I was. I was. That's how I met Noam Chomsky is I was.
Speaker 4I was a communist. I was a young, young, actual communist, like a card carrying member.
Speaker 1You're part of cp U s A.
Speaker 5No, no, no, exactly no.
Speaker 4Which which I I yes, ironically despise the gathering of them.
Speaker 5So but I was.
Speaker 4Yeah, I was young and rambunctious, and I was twenty you know, twenty three twenty four out to you know, say the world make a difference.
Speaker 5And and I was a communist.
Speaker 4You know, I started out with socialism and then I just sort of investigated a lot of leftist philosophy. I found it very great intellectually to study. It's very it's very beautiful on paper. When it gets you know, incarnated in the real world, it's very atrocious. But I didn't know that. I found ways to compartmentalize that. But I so I'm at BU and you know, I had read everything that Chomsky had ever written, literally everything, you know,
Speaker 4from manufacturing consent on and I was.
Speaker 1Doing his denial of the Cambodian genocide and yeah, that was boy.
Speaker 5That was fun. You know, it's easy.
Speaker 4It's just easier to blame the CIA, all right, it's just yeah, more simpler to blame the CIA for basically everything. He he gave the CIA so much power. Yeah, But anyway, so I I was a fan in the sense of at least in the sense of his anarchosyndicalism, because I also considered I was almost anarcho communists, because I didn't believe in a repressive state communism, which is it gets into nuts and bolts and we don't have to go there.
Speaker 5But anyway, I was.
Speaker 4I didn't like him for his deniala of the Cambodian genocide. I liked him for his anarchosyndicalism, and I liked him for his discussions about media and media's influence.
Speaker 5So I emailed him.
Speaker 4I just randomly thought, you know what, I'm just gonna email this guy. I found his email on MIT's website. I was at Boston Verse it's literally, you know, a mile down the road.
Speaker 5So I emailed him.
Speaker 4His secretary responded, of course, and she said, yeah, you could meet with him.
Speaker 5And I was blown away, like, what do you mean? I just emailed him? How do they know? And so I guess it was my bu email, you know.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, he's a professor after all at the time. I'm right, he is a professor at the time.
Speaker 4Yeah, yeah, absolutely, Well, I don't know if he was he was teaching like he was tenured, and I don't think he taught that much. He kind of he kind of he kind of just could do whatever he wanted to.
Speaker 5Be honest at that point. At that point.
Speaker 4Yeah, So anyway, so I go and then what ends up happening is he he emails me, and I was blown away. I still got my email of his and I was super excited. Right, a young leftist at grad school. I'm gonna go meet Noam Chomsky and literally no one else is just me, and I didn't even tell anyone. And so I I'm there in his office that I'm there outside of his office at MIT, I'm at a secretary. There's CNN reporters, there's uh, there's all these reporters sitting
Speaker 4with me, and they got their cameras and their tripods and you name it. And they're all sort of annoyed and like they've been put up, they've been waiting. They're just eager to bust through the door and do their thirty minute interview and get the heck out of there. So I guess I don't know if he had him waiting, I have no idea, but I sat down. I was there late, or I wasn't there. Like what I mean is I was behind them. And he opens the door and they all sort of like hop up ready to jump in, and he tells everyone. He just quietly, He's like no, no, no, no no, and he points to me
Speaker 4and he says, come on in. And I walked past all these reporters. He literally held off all these like six or seven reporters just to let a grad just let me in.
Speaker 5And I walked past them like.
Speaker 4Sorry, sorry, guys, I didn't he's him, So I walked in.
Speaker 5I thought that was really cool.
Speaker 4First of all, it is cool, yeah, and you could tell he cared about whatever anyone thinks about him. I mean, because right now I obviously am disappointed. But whatever anyone thinks about him, My experience with him was he was very warm, he was very hospitable, smart, uh, just fantastic. I had a fantastic experience that with him. We had this long conversation. It was like I don't know, maybe forty five minutes, and it felt like two minutes. We
Speaker 4talked about We talked about Bertrand Russell, We talked about Archbishop Oscar rod Mero's assassination.
Speaker 5We talked about Sam Harris.
Speaker 4Oh yeah, we talked about Sam Harris and how we both didn't like him because he was having he was having this email exchange debate with Sam Harris at the time.
Speaker 1I remember that that was very frustrating to read it. It was it was just two guys talking past each other, and I was it was, it was it was sort of a it was like a preview of what was to come when he when Harris had his like what is truth argument with Jordan Peterson, essentially like people speaking two different languages about two different things. It was just very frustrating. And but the Chomsky argument was a lot like that too.
Speaker 4Yeah, it was, and he so but I found him to be very very warm, and it was you know, I'm a young grad student and here I am with Noam Chomsky for forty five minutes, just shooting shooting the hay and yeah, it was fantastic, It was great. And then we talked about Israel a little bit, not much, but his view, you know, his anti Zionism is extremely heavy handed, and I was an anti Zionist at the time,
Speaker 4but I wasn't as heavy handed about it. I was more into the leftist political philosophy more than you know, directly something about Israel. Of course I was against colonialism. Of course I was against you know, French and Algiers.
Speaker 5And right British.
Speaker 4Yeah, colonialism and things like that, because it's it's it's obviously been used in very wicked ways historically, and then exploitive, exploitive, exploitative. But anyway, so that was my meeting with him. So now I over the last I mean, big leap ahead. You know, I finished grad school, stayed a leftist for a long time, and sort of slowly edged the way at that. My views on Israel changed after the seventh Yep,
Speaker 4October seventh was the galvanizing point for me and.
Speaker 1A lot of people for obvious reasons.
Speaker 5Yeah, yeah, and it took me.
Speaker 4And now bear in mind, I'm an atheist, so I don't have any sort of connection in terms of like a faith tradition or anything like that to the Holy Land.
Speaker 5And I'm liberal. I'm a liberal.
Speaker 4I'm sort of politically homeless as far as parties goes, because I can't stand both of them. But I socially speaking, I'm a liberal individual, so I don't exactly fit in with the pro Israel lot.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, a lot in a lot of ways, because yeah, it tends to be pretty classically right of center. I guess we would say yes in that position. I mean, they're the evangelical connection is the big one. I think for a lot of people it is.
Speaker 4And I used to just I used to, and and I'm just gonna say this, I used to.
Speaker 5I still kind of do despise that.
Speaker 1But there's an unsettling aspect to like sort of seeing Jewish presence as a key to salvation, you know.
Speaker 4Yes, in the super sessionism and the sort of weird the weird using of.
Speaker 5Them, like they kind of use each other.
Speaker 4But but but as far as Jews using or not using them, but as far as Jews having them as allies, as far as I'm concerned right now in the world, Jews need every ally they.
Speaker 1Can get right and and beggars can't be choosers. As you know, any you know, any figure in Wish history would tell you.
Speaker 4I mean the fact that, let's just put it this way, the fact that they trust fundamentalist Christians more than they trust the average liberal is telling.
Speaker 1Yes, it absolutely is. I mean, but the thing is someone like Chomsky, I mean, he is sort of one of the last remaining old guard of those who mainstreamed and for lack of a better word, traditionalized the leftist position on Israel. I actually haven't read it yet. Adam Lewis Klein just posted an article in The Atlantic. I think it's called like the Leftist Case for the Leftist Case against anti Zionism or something like that. I haven't read it. Yeah, So, I mean I can't speak to that,
Speaker 1but I was going to say, generally speaking, it's just become a sort of de facto position for anyone on I will say left of centersse. I think a lot of left of center people are pretty pro Israel a lot of the time too, But a lot of I think, if you're a leftist or or a socialist or someone in that miliu, to be pro Israel is just anathema to that position, because, as you said, it's it's connected rhetorically with things like settler colonialism and all the other bugaboos. Ye,
Speaker 1those people tend to be so wrapped up in and concerned with. So yeah, it's it's that. That's sort of how I've like kind of found myself just sort of annoyed with the position because it just feels like a tradition similar, perhaps not coincidentally to anti Semitism itself, which I see is more of a tradition, a conspiratorial tradition, rather than typical bigotry. But it just it seems to be sort of a not thought out position. It's a it's received wisdom essentially.
Speaker 4It really, it really is, and that fast. I like the way you phrase that because it's so you don't have to use ten dollars words to describe it, because when it comes down to it, yeah, I can tell you about you know, settular colonial like Patrick Wolfe's settlar colonialism, you know as a structure not an event, or I can you know, I can talk about one hundred years War with KHALIDI, or you know Orientalism by Sayid or
Speaker 4Frances Fan on the rest of the Earth, things like this, But when it comes when it comes down to it, I'd say most of the purveyors or just the people that parrot it or think they understand it, everything I just told you is all they know. Yeah, and so basically when you if you start dissecting it, maybe they've read an article, maybe, but that's about it. And it to to make such a because it's such a lofty claim.
Speaker 5It's you're literally erasing not only.
Speaker 4Miss Rahi voices, right, and which are over half of Jews in Israel are mizra you know, come from Amina countries. But you're basically implying that Jews are white Europeans and they colonized their ancient homeland.
Speaker 5And say what you will.
Speaker 4About the occupations in the settlers and the territorial disputes with the West Bank and Gaza.
Speaker 5But.
Speaker 4That's that's different. That's a that's a different discussion. Then did the early Zionists come in by force or did they buy property and farm? That's really non controversial historically.
Speaker 1Yeah, it is, I mean, it's it's well, it is controversial, but it's not controversial to explain it that way because that's exactly what happened. I mean, and there was forcible removal of Palestinians. It's just that that wasn't the only story. There was a lot more to it.
Speaker 4No, and they didn't go there with the intent of of of of displacing the entire Arab population. I mean, for so long Palestine, you know, there were Jewish Palestinians Arab Palestinians and they yeah, they may not have gone along that well, but they did live in the same area, right, right, and Jerusalem had been that way for a while. Yeah, So it's it's also I think a big issue when
Speaker 4for the for the in academia, the professors can be so heavy on theory.
Speaker 5I mean, I'm sure you're.
Speaker 4Aware of this, yes, right, uh, from what you're studying. And and don't get me wrong, I like theory. I think it's fun. I think it's it really stimulates your cognition. But it can oftentimes be too lopsided and too ethereal. And when you start getting into brass tacks, nuts in bolts, like real heavy history, they don't always fit.
Speaker 1No, I mean, and that's the thing is like you need a theoretical framework when talking about history, but only up to a point. And also that framework has to be its limitations need to be acknowledged.
Speaker 5Do you do that? Do you have a theory or a lens by which you view history.
Speaker 1I try not to be restricted too much to it, but generally speaking, my bias is inclined towards human psychology because that was actually what my undergraduate degree was, So it was I did not study history starting out. That became an interest over time, gotcha. So yeah, like human motivation incentives. I mean, I guess there's a little bit of behavioral economics in there too, But okay, I feel like it is important to look at, you know, history through as rational lens as possible. But there is use for,
Speaker 1you know, certain ways of looking at things that allow you to things you might not have otherwise seen. And I think sometimes you know, yeah, like the I think if you use someone like friends Fanol, you can We did actually read you didn't read Writchet of the Earth? We read what was the one he wrote before that?
Speaker 5Oh I'm blanking in the name event but an article or a book?
Speaker 1A book? It was his I think it was his first book.
Speaker 5I've only read The Red of the Earth.
Speaker 1Well yeah, not say og one the classic, but yeah, we read another one by him. I'm forgetting the name of it. But the point is is, you know, his perspective was valuable, ironically because he was a psychologist, so he psychologized a lot, not very well, but that was the limitations of the field at the time.
Speaker 5Sure, but you.
Speaker 1Really get a good insight into how someone like him might have perceived the situation, you know what I mean. So I was a fan of learning that perspective, even if I didn't see that it could provide any insight site beyond him himself and his way of looking at.
Speaker 5Things and that.
Speaker 4And that's the thing is I think it's it's definitely important to to use different, different perspectives in different theories to take the good parts of them.
Speaker 5But you don't have to take everything with it.
Speaker 1Right exactly. Yeah, it's not gospel, so to speak.
Speaker 4Absolutely once you start and but this is the thing, some of these professors become ideologues for theory. And once you once you be once you think of a theory as like metaphysically complete, like I would say something like or principled, I say something like Hegel's dialectic, you know, like the Hegelian theory of history. It's so totalitarian that and it's so comprehensive.
Speaker 5Comprehensive is a nice way of saying.
Speaker 4It's it's so all consuming that everything has to be it's not falsifiable, every thing has to get subsumed under it, and there's nothing outside of it by which you can judge it.
Speaker 5So it becomes problematic.
Speaker 4It becomes basically a god in a certain way, and those become unhealthy.
Speaker 1Yes, exactly. So I think that that's a that's a good transition point because I just kind of wanted to. I mean, we've been kind of getting at it, but I think it's kind of hard to explain what anti Zionism is. I mean, I don't think it's necessarily as simple as saying believing Israel should not exist, because I think that there's different versions of it. But maybe that is the essence of it. I don't know, but I want it since you that this is kind of your beat, Yeah, I just I want to know what how would you define anti Zionism? Like what are we.
Speaker 5Talking about here?
Speaker 4Yeah, So I definitely don't think. I think maybe at a time, the before the pre state Jewish tradition, anti Zionism with a hyphen, right, you know, with a sort of inner Jewish discussion about you know, about whether they should have a nation state, you know, created in their homeland or or or have a different setup, right like so Hannah or Rent for instance, was opposed to it, but she believed that it should just be like a
Speaker 4bi national a joint state with Arabs. Yeah, which is which is what you know, which is sort of I mean it's it's not separate states. It would have been one state, but it would have been something closer to the two state solution than what we have now. And she got a lot of negative things set about her because of it at the time.
Speaker 1My bigger issue with Hannah or Rent is how she mischaracterized Iikman.
Speaker 4But that's a total story. Yeah, that's a whole nother one there.
Speaker 1But but I do love a Rent. I think that she is one of the great thinkers of our.
Speaker 5Time, absolutely absolutely brilliant.
Speaker 1And I and honestly, i'd actually of all things, I like, I I know a lot about her. I read a lot of her work. I've never really looked into what she said about Israel.
Speaker 4So yeah, I mean basically her her I mean, yeah, she got people really didn't.
Speaker 5Like her after the Iikman.
Speaker 4But yeah, she believed in like a bi national federalism with a meaning.
Speaker 1Which I think would have made sense early on. And but like by the time she was saying which I assume was around the Aikman trial in the sixties, because I did. I did read Iikman in Jerusalem, and she does talk about a little bit, but I haven't read anything beyond that about her thoughts on Israel. But I think to talk about a sort of bi national state in Israel, like a like a like a you know, basically, I don't know what you would call it, a non Jewish Jewish state, like just an actual a one state
Speaker 1solution actually might be the best way to put it.
Speaker 5Yeah, if you gave him fifty to fifty.
Speaker 1Right, which I think that that might have made a lot more sense for her to make that argument. Maybe fifty years earlier, you know, before the Navi Musa riots. I think definitely before the massacres. Well yeah, before sixty seven for sure. But I'm thinking like it had to be before. I mean, I can never not bring him up. It had to be before Hajimin al Husseini got his claws into the you know, into anything. I mean, oh, yeah, that that's what we'll We'll jump back to these these nefarious figures.
Speaker 5That's a fascinating character that.
Speaker 1He He has been at the center of my attention for well I've been doing my series where he's the main character for five years ago. Yes, but I've been studying him since twenty eighteen, and there is still more information coming out about him in terms of his complicity with the Third Reich and everything he tried to do and and and all that, and.
Speaker 4It's you know, the the rumors that he started.
Speaker 1That was something that that Benjamin net and Yahoo. That was actually the first time that I was like, I despise this man because he he repeated the lie that Haja Mean was the inspiration for the Holocaust.
Speaker 5That is just not.
Speaker 4Yeah, yeah, he what if? I mean he, I don't blame you. He is such a facet even though I despise him.
Speaker 5The man.
Speaker 4Okay, yeah, I'm gonna not talk about him because then we're just gonna end up talking about him forever.
Speaker 1I was gonna say, And that's fine because that's you know, my listeners are well acquainted with my obsession with the with the guy's history. But yeah, let's let's get back to anti Zionist.
Speaker 4So the pre state Jewish tradition that was primarily like the you know, reform tradition was saying, no, we we need to sort of uh, you know, blend in and do the best, not blend in, do the best we can in the similation.
Speaker 5That yeah, a similation.
Speaker 4Some people don't like saying assimilation because it has a negative connotation, but I don't know, it's like integration, integration with the surrounding environment.
Speaker 5So you had the reform creation going no, let's just integrate.
Speaker 4And then you had because in a lot of places, Jewish communities were doing all right, they were doing pretty like for instance, like you know, the Weimar Republic.
Speaker 5I mean there were still problems, of course, but they weren't.
Speaker 1Right well German Jews were, I mean tragically and well German Jews infamously and tragically were very anti Zionist at the time when that when that word just simply meant you know what you're talking about going to.
Speaker 4Ye, they didn't know, they couldn't see the impending doom, right and but okay, So that's that's one form of anti Zionism. That's a primarily Jewish discussion prior to the state.
Speaker 5And then we have all of.
Speaker 4The the anti zionism after the states established, and that is usually what we associate with Arab nationalists, discussions about them being foreign occupiers, them being colonial, and a lot of Islam is connected to that in a lot of ways. So you have the Islamic and you have the Arab nationalist critique of the establishment of the nation state, which
Speaker 4gets wildely heightened at sixty seven. Yeah, but you also get that early Soviet anti Zionism that was a state. You get the Zionology, you get the Zionism is racism, you get the Zionism is a Western chauvinistic you get Zionism as a proxy for jew right.
Speaker 5Yeah, yeah, you know.
Speaker 1I think I might mention this to you in a comment on Subsack or something, but I think the underappreciated role of the Third Reich in blurring the lines between anti zi Zionist and jew I should say the labels cannot be overstated that that essentially was birthed in the Foreign Office and the Propaganda Ministry, specifically with the direction of Hajimin al Husseini, like he is instrumental in creating that blurred line. And I did want to hone in
Speaker 1a little more detail on the Soviet angle, because I think that's an underappreciated element of this. But it feels like they were just picking up the threads essentially at that point.
Speaker 5Yeah, it's hard.
Speaker 4It's hard to say because you have them developing these things that at similar times. So you have Lenin, you know, in you know, nineteen oh three, in nineteen twelve talking about Zionism as imperialism. You know, they had the Russian term that they would use for which was basically had it was basically a precursor to colonial But imperialism gets gets more of a of an idea of force, of
Speaker 4militaristic force, whereas colonialism can be a bit more subtle sometimes, especially settler colonialism, because it's supposed to be this sort of slow, arduous grinding of the indigenous people out. But which is which is a whole nother thing.
Speaker 5But what we have now is we have a I.
Speaker 4Like to call it modern anti Zionism. And I dropped the hyphen for a specific reason.
Speaker 1But I think what is that reason. Let's let's like, because I've seen that becoming more of a of a of a thing.
Speaker 5Yeah, yeah, it is, it is. I mean, well, there's a couple of reasons.
Speaker 4One is, sometimes you'll hear people say it's not it doesn't have anything to do with Jews, right, it's it's a political critique of the nation state of Israel, right, which bear in mind, I have met people that have had fair, as anyone does, fair criticisms of Israeli policy.
Speaker 5That's I mean, they exist.
Speaker 4This obviously exists, there's people and Israelis do this. But they then they usually slide from that into something more severe, like something like the dismantlement of the state, or saying there should be a one one state, one air or one Palestinian state, which basically would amount to October seventh over and over again. Right, So there's that, So they'll slide really quickly too, from from oh I'm just criticizing
Speaker 4the state to basically wanting its destruction if you think think about it though, right, If if they're right, then that would be the moral thing to do. If if this is a genocidal, a heart height regime, uh that's everything horrible that they say it is, then yeah, then then I mean it doesn't it's if it's as bad as North Korea or or worse. I think most people are gonna be like, yeah, well, that's the solution it needs to be. But the problem is is that they
Speaker 4don't they don't see the difference. When they do that slip, they don't notice it. And they also don't notice the slip when they use Zionists as a proxy.
Speaker 5For jew right.
Speaker 1So sometimes that that blurring of the lines is unconscious.
Speaker 4Sometimes it is, and a lot of and to be honest, a lot of these I would say younger too, people that are at the protests, they're parrotying Soviet propaganda and they don't know it.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah, well let's let's hover on that, because one of your amazing resources that you've created for the inverted world is your glossary. Yeah, the Forgotten Right is propaganda books and language that survived them. Was a nice subhead of the short History of Long Hatreds, as you call it. Yeah, and there's a lot of figures on here. I mean some are more familiar to at least to me than others.
Speaker 4Oh yeah, I remember you liked it because it's because they had some obscure people that you knew.
Speaker 1And yeah, Johann von Leers or omar Aman von Leers, he's my personal favorite.
Speaker 6Yeah.
Speaker 1He was a member of was he well, he was he was in the He was a Nazi and then he fell in love with Islam. Yeah, not only did he escape justice via the rat line to the Middle East ones go to Egypt exactly, he converted and changed his name and to his dying day, I believe in the seventies or eighties, he he was a practicing Muslim. Yeah, while you know Bill never renouncing his you know, national
Speaker 1socialist faith.
Speaker 4Well, and that's that's the whole interesting thing here is that if we look at these different strands of anti Zionism, the Soviet State state anti Zionism, the Nazi propaganda, the Arab nationalists, and Islamic and we see them all converge, and what they all share in common is a hatred for Israel and Zionists or.
Speaker 1Jews right or Jews exactly. But there does seem to be a lot of crossover when you get deep into the weeds here. And and that's what I was going to say about your glossary here, is that there are people, namely those who had the connection to the Soviet Union in some cases who helped propagate a lot of these talking points. So you kind of already touched on it, but what specifically, like, like who were the figures like most associated in the Soviet Union with this proliferation of anti Zionist propaganda and terminology.
Speaker 4Well, I mean, obviously you get the big leaders, you get Lenin, but Lenin wasn't even a big He just equated for him Zionism. He did make the separation between he's the whole, I'm not an anti semi and I'm an anti Zionist.
Speaker 5He's the he's the og there, Yeah.
Speaker 4Nineteen oh three, right, yes, actually the first person, the first well known person in history to associate Zionism with imperialism ever in the world. So, right, want to if you want to say, if somebody says Zionism is imperial or imperial state or imperialism, that's Lenin and so. But him and Stalin obviously, But then you get like Kissko, you get these propagandists, yeah, Kisko, you mentioned Kisko. Yeah,
Speaker 4you get these propagandists that were set up through this state run Zionology department where they were trying to make anti Zionism sound scientific.
Speaker 1Yeah, like the Soviets were wont to do.
Speaker 5Yeah, they very very much were.
Speaker 4Like and interestingly enough, on the other end, same with the development of the.
Speaker 5Term anti semitism. Uh huh.
Speaker 4You know, they're trying to make it sound clinical. So there's these the propagandists. But what I find really interesting, this is one thing that got me after the seventh too, was how can it be that Soviet Russian propaganda, Arab nationalists, Islamic polemics from the fifties sixties, let's see Nazism, Western leftism.
Speaker 5How these all get.
Speaker 4Blended together and become a social movement down the street from me.
Speaker 5Is fascinating. It is, It truly is.
Speaker 4And so to get to your point, a lot of people don't know what anti Zionism is because there are so many different facets to it. You can have the just the basic pro Palestinian movement. You can have a sort of hodgepodge of leftists, you know, leftist thinkers or groups, and they're gonna be anti Zionists. You're gonna have different strands, you know, the code pinks, the you know pikers, Oh god, yes,
Speaker 4you're gonna have the pretentious hipsters for sure, the Williamsburg anti Zionists you're getting.
Speaker 5You have all these different people. Then you got you've got the right wing ones.
Speaker 4Right where they're generally more associated with anti Semitism. Because we will say this, like, modern anti Zionism is pretty leftists.
Speaker 1Typically, Yes, I mean like on the on the American right, I would say, I mean, yeah, it's almost always steeped in anti Semitism more nakedly. And I'll in a perverse sense give the far right credit that at least they own it when they are experiencing it but or expressing it. But uh, it is also again that kind of gets in what I was calling it earlier, a tradition. There is a tradition of being a quote unquote anti Zionist or just being opposed to Israel in the paleo libertarian space,
Speaker 1which is like and they love to invoke the attack of the USS liberty.
Speaker 5That's their thing, Oh, the liberty.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, which it's you never really hear the leftist wing talk about the liberty. It's a very interesting sort of like how everyone like sort of compiles their symbols, you know what I mean.
Speaker 4Yeah, No, that's actually a fascinating I can see why. It's still I wonder what the history of that is.
Speaker 1But yeah, I would be really interested in seeing the sort of yeah, the genealogy in the paleolibertarian space. I don't know enough about it. Honestly, I'm much more familiar with the sort of alliances that got de facto created by all of the various leftist movements of the seventies, particularly that it really was after the sixty seven War that you saw this coalition start to Yes, you had.
Speaker 4It all the way from from Cuba to all through Southeast Asian countries. You would see these Asian countries protests with signs against Zionism, and they're so far away, in such a thoroughly removed country that it just became this globe that's what.
Speaker 5I would call global South.
Speaker 4Sure, anti Zionism, but all these strands from the un to you can go almost anywhere across the world, and I remember thinking, how are these converging, And they're converging in such a way that modern anti Zionism. At the protests or at the university or at city hall, they all share one thing in common, and it relates to
Speaker 4the Jewish state.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, well you can have how.
Speaker 5Would this here happenstance?
Speaker 1It's it's it's can I don't think it is necessarily a conspiracy, but I do think it actually is rooted in human motivation. A lot of the time because I'm just thinking aloud here, I didn't even you know, Yeah, it's I think the best way to look at it, and I can see why. Then it becomes very easy to just conflate anti Zionism and anti Semitism. But it's a form of scapegoating because it's I think what's going on is that we are in a transition point in
Speaker 1human history. We're in a very particular transition point where I think, whether we like it or not, the post World War two order is basically dead or very close to dead. It's dying, and we're coming to grips with the next sort of phase of whatever human history is right now. With the proliferation of information technology and the way it is, I mean, we're living in a period of time that has not been matched insignificance in terms of how information is proliferated since the printing press. It's
Speaker 1very I think I don't want to overrate AI. I think that's I think it's often easy to do that. It becomes its own kind of little automatic invocation, just like Zionism is for a lot of people. But I do think things like AI social media, if you go back ten years and just the internet in general since the nineties, and the amount of data that is getting spread everywhere, all at once and with very little filtering, is causing a sort of mass uncertainty, which leads to panic,
Speaker 1It leads to a lot of things. But looking for a way a lens to make sense of something so complex, so endlessly complex, that just the human mind can't really wrap itself around these transitions that we're going through, and a lot of the problems that come from that need a cause or need an explanation, So that explanation gets outsourced. The explanation for the discord, for the uncertainty, for all of this stuff gets outsourced, and we kind of have
Speaker 1a tradition of outsourcing that onto the conspicuous minority that is the jew at least in the European tradition. Now, that doesn't really explain the global nature of it. But maybe I just answered my own question here by saying, well, information has gone global in a way that has never really existed before.
Speaker 4So I think you just gave a pretty sufficient, interestingly sufficient answer.
Speaker 1I think that might be part of it. I'll go so far as to say I think it's part of it.
Speaker 4It's a large contributing factor definitely, not just globalization, but like the diffusion of technology.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, and the description that that causes. Yeah.
Speaker 4But the so what I saw happened after the Seventh is I saw the world completely change and it was it's it's almost like a religious experience and I'm an atheist.
Speaker 5It's like it's like having a conversion to Israel almost what you know, Hey, I was almost the Statust once. Maybe I can be again, but yeah, exactly.
Speaker 4But it's it's the idea that I was looking around and seeing the media fire, rain, hell fire and brimstone on the state of Israel, going headlines murderer like killed Israel, killed Israel, bombed Israel, genocide, colonizer apartheid, genocide, colonizer apartheid, and these libels get thrown around, so the repeated so often. That's why I got into the language of it, because I feel like one way to understand the subculture is
Speaker 4the language they use. And so in I know, Left being one and the former anti Zionist so globalized, the Antifada from the river to the sea, imperial state, all of these setular, colonial, apartheid regime, the Zionist entities Zionism itself.
Speaker 5These this is the whole language.
Speaker 4Yeah, And so that's what cultures do. Cultures develop their own language. And so this if you want, for me, if you want to understand this modern iteration of anti Zionism, you understand the language.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 5Yeah, So that's what I've been doing.
Speaker 1Well, and I think you've been doing a really good job with that. And I you know, honestly, I've been trying to make sense of a lot of this stuff for a while because, like I was saying before we were recording, you know, I don't consider myself what I guess that I mean, the other the people who were talking about would probably called me a Zionist. I'm just de facto a Zionists because I tend to support Israel more than I don't. But like I said, I'm in the atrium of Zionism just by default. I'm a Zionist in nineteen oh three vintage, you know, I'm not. I don't. I don't really have. Again, we were talking about the
Speaker 1practicality of the question, and where I think we both remember correctly that that was where Hitchens fell on the question of Zionism or of Israel. Where it was like look, whatever you have to say about the state doesn't really matter. Like we shouldn't be talking about whether the state should exist or not. It does exist, and we are not the ones to dismantle we no one is going to dismantle it unless they dismantle it themselves. And yes, and that would be that would be something I.
Speaker 5Don't and it's it's truly frightening.
Speaker 4I will say this though the I know that Israeli is in Israel, citizens of Israel have gotten used to the amount of direst they live under, right But at the same time, right now, globally speaking, it's a very precarious situation that they're and the amount of vitriol and global disdain is reaching astronomical perportions, and it's so galvanizing
Speaker 4that it forces you.
Speaker 5To make a decision. It really does.
Speaker 4You can it's almost impossible to stay on the sidelines anymore and be like, well, I'm out of that one, and so you do kind of really have to make a decision these And when I look around and see synagogues being shot up, when I see the rise of anti Semitism correlating directly correlating with this huge rise.
Speaker 5In anti Zionism.
Speaker 4I realize that I know where I stand, and where I stand is Jews not having to worry about sending their daughter to college because she'll be harassed or attacked, having to hide her you know, her Megan David necklace. You know, these sort of things are wild anti American, they're wildly inappropriate, and they're they're uncalled for. So whether that's anti Zionism, anti Semitism, or anti Judaism, I want
Speaker 4to know what it is to call it out because it's fascistic and it's inappropriate, and I don't I don't want to use to feel unsafe.
Speaker 1Yeah, and I think that that's a that's a noble enough uh goal, I think for good.
Speaker 5I hope no one argues against that.
Speaker 1I don't think anyone would. It was being reasonable. I think some people might say that you're overstating the problem, but I don't think that we can say that. I don't think that we can say the problem is overstated. When you know, two Israeli embassy staffers are shot by an extremist in Washington, d C. Just to name that's that was the most I mean, there's so many or the.
Speaker 5You know what, you know, you know what he said.
Speaker 4He said when he was being arrested, he said free, Free Palestine.
Speaker 1Of course he did.
Speaker 5And you know why he said the free twice? Oh no, I don't because it's a group chant.
Speaker 1Oh so it's something that like the people who might be part of these organizations or protests that he probably also attended. It was so they knew he was one of them. Yes, and yeah, I think generally speaking, most Americans are horrified by what happened there, but there are a set of Americans who, you know, really do support this stuff. And I just remembered there was that that thing that you wrote an article about the people who were arrested in Michigan.
Speaker 2Oh yeah, have the Michigan eight because I I that is a fascinating story and I hate to leave my listeners with that, but people should go to the Inverted World substac and I believe it's called Emergency.
Speaker 1Post or something like that, and it's you talking about that. It's a fascinating story of a thwarted ring of violent radicals in uh, they were involved in academia if I remember, Yeah, University of Michigan. Yeah, it's it's fascinating. So but yes, we'll, we'll, we'll, we'll put a pin that for another time. I think that this is a good place to wrap for this one, because I do want to have you on again, because there's a lot of stuff to cover and a lot of other interesting avenues I think to exploring what I
Speaker 1think is a deeper problem with I guess I would go so far as I say American socio politics that where I think anti Zionism, such as it is, is the best way to understand where it's going. It's an attempt to make sense of something much more complex, and like I said, it's a form of scapegoating I think is the best way to look at it these days. So I think you're doing a great job though, Kyle, with your project, and I, like I said, want to have you on again. So thank you again for joining me.
Speaker 4No, thank you so much for having me. I really enjoyed it and I definitely think we should.
Speaker 1Talk again for sure. Thanks again.
Speaker 6I'm lucky. Go babbie, your love, Go me at night when you're sleep into your turn agreed must tars that shine ab all will lie away till life.
Speaker 5You rule land with me.
Speaker 6Marcy of a Rubbie. Here is mister Churchill's latest song, I'm afraid of Germany. Her brains are beating me. At night when I should sleep into Deanersen, I must creep.
Speaker 6Although I'm England's leading men, I'm let to the cellar by ten, a leader in the cellar each night. That's the only dame way I can fight made in Germany.
Speaker 3That trademark is beating me.
Speaker 5Everything the people do.
Speaker 3Is successful and really comes true. Although I like and I shout, I don't know what's all about. My charming boar is a tragedy. I'm at the mercy of Germany.
Speaker 1All right, everybody, thanks again for listening. I am really happy to have had Kyle Jones on this show, and as you no doubt heard towards the end of our conversation, there there is a lot more to cover on this subject that we find ourselves both really interested in. I highly recommend you go check out the Inverted World substack if you haven't already, and if you discovered me through his recommendation from the Inverted World, welcome and thank you for joining us. Like I was saying, though, I really
Speaker 1hope that we can pick up this conversation where we left off. If possible because there's just so much stuff that Kyle's been putting out that's really interesting. Obviously, this is a very contested subject, but you know, most of you listening know where I stand on things, and honestly, I'm always open to getting more education on the subject. So if you guys have any recommendations for other interviews that I could do for History Impossible, especially on the subject of Zionism and anti Zionism, let me know. I'm open to all of them, within reason. Of course, I
Speaker 1hope I don't get flooded with recommendations. But anyway, that was a really fun conversation. Like I said, hoping to pick it back up again talk about things like the Michigan Eight and you know, by then maybe there'll be even more updates on that case. But with all of that said, I want to before I let you get going, shout out the amazing supporters of History Impossible at the comrades and friends level and above on Patreon, and those people include Bob Downing, Sam Graham, Greg Hunter, s so
Speaker 1skip A Chaco, Molly Pan, John Pisano, Ana R. PJ. Raider, Matthew m Rice, Philip Rice, John Andre Saither, Emily Schmidt, Pierre Vapuni, and as always f you. You guys are awesome. Everyone who supports this show is awesome, even if all you do is subscribe for free, to which I would just ask, please shoot my work to people that you think would like it or find it interesting or even debatable, if it's something that you think that they might react
Speaker 1to at least in some way and make them think. I'm always hoping for things like that to happen.
Speaker 5With this show.
Speaker 1So with all of that said, thank you again for listening to this conversation I had with Kyle Jones, and stay tuned for the next episode of History Impossible.
Understanding evil is something that has preoccupied humans for a long time. By the mid-20th century, the desire to root it in firm, social scientific terms became the norm, particularly in the field of psychology. The...
Hey everyone. No preamble here. Just a nice bonus as a thank you for your continued support. As the title suggests, this is an audio adaptation of an essay I wrote about the 25th anniversary of 9/11 and how it led me to...
We often hear about how the Second World War was more morally nuanced and complex than we have been led to believe. This is, to a certain extent, very true. The Axis powers meted out a level of genocidal destruction and...
In this newest episode of History Impossible we’re joined a second time by Richard Lim, host of the This American President podcast, who last appeared on this program a couple years ago to discuss the insane,...
“Because remember: Russia is a religious experience.” Those are the oft-repeated and well-said words by the host of The Eastern Border podcast, my good friend Kristaps Andrejsons. They are well-said because there are...