Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

History Impossible

History Impossible artwork

Millennials: The Trauma Generation

Sep 30, 202652 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Hey everyone. No preamble here. Just a nice bonus as a thank you for your continued support. As the title suggests, this is an audio adaptation of an essay I wrote about the 25th anniversary of 9/11 and how it led me to reflect on my generation, that is millennials, seems to believe about itself regarding trauma, adversity, and the future. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/history-impossible--5634566/support.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Hey everybody, I'm glad to be back with you again so soon, and it's really just because I wanted to give you guys something special before we wrap up September of 2026. I know I just released a big, massive episode all about the firebombing of Tokyo, moral assessment of war crimes, etc. It goes over three hours, so I figure a lot of you are probably still working on that. And please do, you don't have to feel the need to rush into this one But I wanted to get it out before the end of the month because this is the 25th anniversary month of 9-11. And honestly, like

Speaker 1a lot of people out there, this anniversary just felt different. I mean, maybe it didn't for a lot of you. I don't know. I mean, especially those of you not living in the United States. But for a lot of Americans, myself included... There was just a different vibe. It was different than the 20th, different than the 15th, different than the 10th, though I was obviously less conscious of a lot of those things at the time. But yeah, there's something just reflective about the mood, the attitude around this anniversary.

Speaker 1And I ended up writing something about this over on Substack and Patreon that a lot of you probably have seen, and I wanted to give an audio version, an audio adaptation of this like I often do. But, you know, I feel like it's worth mentioning, like I did in the sort of intro of that essay, that this isn't really a deeply researched piece that I usually try to put out. I was able to get this written in one day because it was mostly a personal reflection. It's a sort of generational assessment, and I felt comfortable being

Speaker 1pretty loose with this because, frankly, the idea of generations is a pretty loose concept, I think we can say. As much as I enjoy reading things like Strauss and Howe's Fourth Turning, I also think that stuff is a little woo-woo, to put it mildly. But it is fun. It's fun like astrology, so to speak. So, tangent on that aside, I'm coming at this from a personal perspective, more personal than usual in a lot of ways, because even though it's been 25 years, and I would say

Speaker 1that puts 9-11 in the realm of history rather than current events, we're still living in the world, I guess we could say, that 9-11 created. Though, as you'll hear very soon, I don't think that it was just 9-11. And in fact, I think the reason why this piece seemed to resonate with a lot of people is because the people who read it and were most, I guess we could say, interested were my fellow millennials of a particular cohort, those of us born in the mid to late 80s. And boomers seem to really like it too,

Speaker 1but that's because they're in a more reflective mood anyway, entering their twilight years. And that's not an insult. I'm just saying what's true here. So I think that that is a helpful way to look at this, to look at 9-11. It was helpful for me. It was, it allowed me to get that reflective vibe out of me. And I wanted to share that with all of you. Thank you all for, you know, sticking with me and, you know, this isn't a normal episode, so I'm not going to do any announcements or any outro or, specific

Speaker 1patron or sub stack thanks or anything like that. Just if you really like this stuff, please consider subscribing. If you haven't already, I really enjoyed doing this, uh, essay and I really enjoy recording this stuff for all of you guys, uh, whenever I do it. So thank you again to all of you. So my thoughts on the 25th anniversary of nine 11. Permit me to tell you what you would have seen and heard.

Speaker 2It will not be pleasant listening.

Speaker 3If you're at lunch, or if you have no appetite, now is a good time to switch off the radio.

Speaker 4An ancestor of mine maintained that if you eliminate the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must.

Speaker 5Be the truth.

Speaker 4The European races were the destruction of the Jews in Europe.

Speaker 2I wish I could say tonight that a lasting peace is inside.

Speaker 4I don't see any American dream. I see an American nightmare. Some say the world will.

Speaker 1End in fire.

Speaker 6Some say in ice.

Speaker 2But what I've tasted of desire I hold with.

Speaker 6Those who favor fire.

Speaker 2But if it had to perish twice, I think I know enough of hate to say that for destruction, ice is also great and would suffice.

Speaker 6This is History Impossible.

Speaker 1Back in 2006, Christopher Hitchens wrote his own reflections on 9-11.

Speaker 7And.

Speaker 1It had been about five years at the time of his writing, and what he said was very interesting. And like I said in the intro, it resonates today in a lot of ways. It feels prescient in a weird way. So I just want to open with reading what Hitchens wrote back in 2006. Quote, The time for commemoration lies very far in the future. War memorials are erected when the war is won. At the moment, anyone who insists

Speaker 1on the primacy of September 11th, 2001 is very likely to be accused, not just overseas, but in this country also, of making or at least implying a partisan point. I debate with the anti-war types almost every day, either in print or on the air or on the podium, and I can tell you that they have been war-weary ever since the sun first set on the wreckage of the World Trade Center and the Pentagon in and on the noble debris of United Airlines 93. These clever critics are waiting,

Speaker 1some of them gleefully, for the moment that is not far off. The moment that when the number of American casualties in Afghanistan and Iraq will match or exceed the number of civilians of all nationalities who were slaughtered five years ago today. But to the board's cynical neutrals, it also comes naturally to say that it is the war that has taken and is taking the lives of tens of thousands of other civilians. In other words, homicidal nihilism is produced only by the resistance to it. If these hacks were honest and conceded the simple truth that it

Speaker 1is the forces of the Taliban and of Al-Qaeda in Mesopotamia that are conducting a Saturnalia of murder and destruction, they would have to hide their faces and admit that they were not anti-war at all. That is all very well said, and it is more to do with the debate that that was still raging when Hitchens wrote that piece about the war in Iraq at the time, which at that point was only about three years old, and the war on terror, which was almost five. But I

Speaker 1think what he was getting at was, again, that word he used, primacy of 9-11. Because it was a moment of primacy, or a primal moment, maybe, or primary moment, however you want to put it. It was significant. 9-11 was significant, no matter what, people might say otherwise. And like a lot of people out there in the world, I realized that, and I was trying to find a way to write about 9-11 on that anniversary that we've

Speaker 1passed since this recording. Frankly, it's not particularly interesting, at least I don't think it is. I mean, maybe in conversation it is, to talk about where I was and what I was doing. I mean, for what it's worth, I was 15 years and walking into Spanish Level 3, and I saw the TV on, and that kind of put a pall over the rest of the day. I remember there being talk of the towers falling, but I didn't see it happen. In fact, I remember being skeptical that they fell, because I imagined they had tipped over,

Speaker 1which I couldn't imagine happening. I had been to the World Trade Center as a kid, and I was just sort of aghast at that. I'm kind of shocked I didn't become a truther after that, given that I didn't understand how physics or structural engineering works. Not that I understand now, but that I have a better idea of how it works. Putting that aside, though, it was kind of an unreal day. And it did hit home eventually, especially when I saw the infamous photo of the Falling Man. But regardless, what I just said there, that's a variation on what many other people have said, many times, and

Speaker 1especially this year, on the 25th anniversary. There is a corner of the discourse, though, particularly on Instagram Reels and likely TikTok by extension. I don't use TikTok, but I know that there's a crossover there. And that discourse really piqued my interest, which has been mostly millennials talking about the disconnect between Zoomers' perceptions of 9-11 and that of my generation, millennials, particularly of the older vintage, like I was saying, having freshly turned 40 here, by the way, guys.

Speaker 1So Maybe that's also put me in a more reflective mood. I'm sure that's not too uncommon. But the point is, Zoomers apparently just don't get it. Like, that's the sort of general thesis, I would say, of these videos and of people who talk about this disconnect. They don't get why there was such importance attached to that day by boomers and Xers, obviously, but especially with millennials. And honestly, I can't blame them. Why would Zoomers... have any connection.

Speaker 1Why would they get it? They were either in diapers when the Twin Towers fell, or they didn't even exist yet. We can't expect them to understand, just as I'm sure that they can't expect Gen Alpha or or whatever comes next, Gen Beta, I guess we can call them, to fully grasp the enormity of the COVID-19 pandemic. We'll be getting back to this, but it is important to remember that every generation has its trauma embedded in its collective memory. But this discourse, this reflective mood that I've been talking about,

Speaker 1did get me thinking. about more than just 9-11, but more about the historical place millennials like me occupy and how cultural markers existed during our childhoods and early adolescence. This is the case with every generation. We're not unique that way. But the narrative that has emerged around the world that we grew up in is very interesting. That narrative was that we lived in a largely uninterrupted parade of optimism and throughout the late 1980s and early 1990s,

Speaker 1really throughout the 1990s. There were certainly problems and conflicts, no era of history is completely idyllic, but the 1990s in particular were a very positive time, by most objective measures. It was the only time in my life that there was a budget surplus in the United States, just to give you an idea of how remote that time actually feels, those of you who are tapped into such things. But it was actually a time of innovation as well, particularly

Speaker 1around technology, which millennials were at the forefront of using. Many of you have no doubt heard about that, and it's true. I remember my first dial-up modem connection at home. It was 1998, I want to say. And it was remarkable. As slow as that 56k modem actually was. I remember using Google before there was even an I'm Feeling Lucky button. Now that's crazy to me to think about. There was also a cultural renaissance at the time, particularly with film. I mean, that's sort of my hobby horse at the time.

Speaker 1It's hard not to get any cinephile going about 1999, and for good reason. And there was also a renaissance with television. Star Trek was at its peak, and The Simpsons was creating a comedic vocabulary, just to name my two favorite titans from that era. Video games were coming into their own. 3D graphics were finally normal by the late 90s. And music... I mean, you can't leave out music when talking about the 1990s. It was exciting. It was always feeling fresh and new. Grunge, pop-punk, alternative, hip-hop,

Speaker 1R & B, and electronic music, they changed everything. That cannot be overstated. Now, obviously, again, I will be the first to admit that this is a lot of nostalgia that I'm throwing at you. But it's also indicative of how the pre-911 world was something truly different than what came afterward. Because it was. It was very different. 9-11 was not just a national trauma. It was a national trauma, but it was more than that. It was a generational trauma,

Speaker 1where we, as in millennials, all realized, or came to believe at least, that our safety, that we had taken for granted, was no longer guaranteed. This was hardly an uncommon observation. by millennials or otherwise, but it was particularly acute with millennials. I part with the apparent consensus, though, in that I think the traumatic process for millennials began earlier than 9-11. Al-Qaeda's attack on America was a significant moment, globally,

Speaker 1for sure, but for millennials, I believe, it served as confirmation of something that we had already suspected for a few years. That was because, in 1999, something unthinkable and seemingly unprecedented had occurred.

Speaker 9The investigation into the high school massacre is slow moving and dangerous. The two gunmen who went on the rampage booby-trapped the building and even themselves. All day long, investigators have searched the homes of both teenage killers. In one of them, police say they found bomb-making materials. Specially trained officers searching the school today found close to 30 explosive devices all around the building. Authorities have also revised the death toll, now saying 15 people were killed, including the two gunmen. Most of the bodies are still inside the school,

Speaker 9but families of the murder victims have been notified. NJ Burkett begins our coverage. He is live in Littleton, Colorado.

Speaker 8NJ. And, Roz, we're being kept far away. The building off in the distance is still sealed off. As you said, the bodies have not yet been removed. A total of 15 people are believed to have died here, 12 students, one faculty member, and the two young killers. Investigators say this attack appears to have been carefully planned for a long time.

Speaker 10One by one, students returned to Columbine High and left bouquets of flowers in a park half a mile away.

Speaker 1A little bit of pain, a little bit of everything at once.

Speaker 3It's deep, you know, but.

Speaker 1It's got to be strong.

Speaker 7Parents, hug your kids. Pray to be happy that you're with them. Kids, grab your friends, hold them tight, and never be mad at people because it could happen in a second that they'll be gone.

Speaker 10Investigators found their first pipe bomb in the parking lot, and the Denver Bomb Squad immediately sealed off the building. Robotic cameras later found the entire school was booby-trapped. Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold had apparently committed suicide, but investigators say they spent their final moments rigging the building and their own bodies with more than two dozen pipe bombs. Amid the gunshots and bomb blasts, hundreds of students ran for their lives. stalked in their own school by two

Speaker 10of their own classmates who went on a rampage.

Speaker 6People were getting shot.

Speaker 9All around me.

Speaker 2There was a guy at a table right next to me and her, and they just shot him, and then walked away, and then he was just sitting there in a pool of blood.

Speaker 10Detectives now believe they entered the school through a back door and stormed down the hallways. They cornered students in the cafeteria and the library, where there was nowhere to run. Witnesses say they laughed as they fired their weapons, executing their classmates who begged for their lives.

Speaker 8They were shooting anyone of color wearing a white hat or playing a sport, and they didn't care who it was and it was all at close range.

Speaker 11Screaming after they'd shoot up something, they'd go, woo! Just a pleasure for them.

Speaker 10This morning, students packed a prayer service at a local church and stood in the parking lot, embraced one another, and wiped away their tears. Graduation was less than two weeks away. Amber Burgess is Columbine High School's homecoming queen.

Speaker 2I don't even know if people are going to be able to walk back into school again and see empty chairs.

Speaker 6It would be horrible.

Speaker 1I want to say right up front that mass shootings at schools in particular did not begin at Columbine. In fact, the first reported school shooting I found out was in 1840. when the law professor John A.G. Davis was assassinated by a student taking part in the riots occurring at the University of Virginia at the time. And there were many other after that, including in the 20th century into the 1990s, before Columbine. But Columbine, in a way, and probably a very important way, was different. And that was because of

Speaker 1the media coverage, but also because of the scale and the mythos that began to surround the event, thanks again to the media coverage. While it took many years for the reality of the Columbine Massacre to emerge, namely that the main perpetrator was a true psychopath with annihilationist tendencies and his buddy was largely just a lost loser along for the ride, the response to this mass killing was one dominated by external explanations. It was the music the

Speaker 1killer supposedly listened to, usually claimed to be Marilyn Manson, though the killers had no interest in his music. They were into harder industrial stuff. It was the violent video games they played. I mean, it's true that they did play Doom, but they became more fixated on mods that replicated their future crime after they decided to commit that crime. It was the lack of meaningful security at school. It was access to firearms. It was literally anything that had nothing to do with the reality of the situation, which

Speaker 1was the fracture that existed in the killer's minds. No one, or very few, could face that possibility, because what do you do about something like that? So, the blame turned outward, and millennials, most of us being kids at the time, remember, largely encouraged by media coverage and their parents' worries, came to believe, however subconsciously, that even the relatively safest place outside of home, that is, school, was a potential combat zone,

Speaker 1where we could be killed at any moment. We lived with this perception of unsafety every day for two years that followed Columbine. Emergency procedures in the case of such an event were drilled into school staffs. In early 2001, when I was a freshman in high school, my school experienced a bomb threat. And despite the incredibly flimsy evidence that the threat was actually real, and it turned out that it wasn't, all 2,000 or so students were evacuated

Speaker 1across the street to the YMCA gymnasium within 15 minutes. Herding 2,000 teenagers into anything is like herding cats. So basically what I'm saying is, the teachers were well-prepared, and the chaos one might expect from a bunch of teenagers being told that they didn't have to go to class for the rest of the day was minimal. It was a really fun day, actually, and everyone was in good spirits. I have vivid memories of this, but that was because we had internalized a potential threat that we had drilled

Speaker 1into us ever since Columbine. It had normalized. We'd had two years to normalize it. But that threat was still confined to one thing. That is, schools. The trauma of the Columbine mass shooting was a disruptive force, and it affected the wider culture for sure, but the threat remained relatively contained, at least in our minds. That all changed on September 11th, 2001. American 11, are you trying to call?

Speaker 6The cocktail is not answering.

Speaker 9Is there a problem?

Speaker 6Our number one is in staff and our five is in staff.

Speaker 8I am going to call from Washington.

Speaker 9I am in a situation where the Americans learned a possible hijack.

Speaker 3What's going on, Betty?

Speaker 10Their craft is erratic again.

Speaker 5What's the problem?

Speaker 11Are you ready?

Speaker 2Betty, talk to me.

Speaker 3Betty, are you there?

Speaker 10Betty?

Speaker 9Betty?

Speaker 5The plane just hit 737.

Speaker 7What?

Speaker 2The 737.

Speaker 10It what?

Speaker 7The world just hit 737.

Speaker 1Who are you talking to?

Speaker 4Oh, God.

Speaker 8Oh, my God.

Speaker 6United 175, New York.

Speaker 1We have some problems over here right now.

Speaker 10We might have a hijack over here, too.

Speaker 1Jules, this is Ryan.

Speaker 3We're on an airplane that's been hijacked.

Speaker 6Things don't go well.

Speaker 1I'm looking good.

Speaker 4I just want you to know.

Speaker 6I absolutely love you.

Speaker 2I want you to be good.

Speaker 6Go have a good time. Same to my.

Speaker 8Parents and everybody.

Speaker 6I just totally love you and I'll see you later. Bye, babe.

Speaker 1What are those people going to do?

Speaker 11All the elevators are blocked out.

Speaker 7Oh, my God.

Speaker 1So both towers are now.

Speaker 4Okay, I got an aircraft six miles east of the White House.

Speaker 10Crystal City, just north of Crystal City.

Speaker 6Just to the north of your town.

Speaker 8Yeah, stop all departures.

Speaker 6Pentagon just got hit.

Speaker 4God damn it, I can't even protect my NCA.

Speaker 6United 93, that traffic for you is 1 o'clock, 12 miles eastbound, 370.

Speaker 11Negative contact.

Speaker 8We're looking at United 93.

Speaker 2United 93, Cleveland, if you hear the sound, right down.

Speaker 9I got that piece of dust.

Speaker 2You put it right next to me.

Speaker 9We have a ballpark.

Speaker 2Get out of here.

Speaker 9Get out of here.

Speaker 10Get out of here.

Speaker 6Tuesday, 9.47 a.m. Hi, baby. Baby, you have to listen to me carefully. I'm on a plane that's been hijacked. I'm on the plane. I'm calling from the plane. I want to tell you I love you. Please tell my children that I love them very much. And I'm so sorry, babe. I hope to be able to see your face again, baby.

Speaker 10I love you.

Speaker 8Bye.

Speaker 2We're 56865.

Speaker 5We have a, I believe it is a Boeing 757.

Speaker 9Can you see him up there, sir?

Speaker 10That's confirmed. It looks like he's rocking his wings.

Speaker 7Roger.

Speaker 6He's rocking back and forth.

Speaker 3Number five six eight six five five five, as you stay away from that aircraft, go north as fast.

Speaker 6As you can. United nine three, have you got information on that yet? Yeah, he's down.

Speaker 2He's down?

Speaker 1Yes. When did he land?

Speaker 9He did not land. Oh, he's down?

Speaker 6Yeah, somewhere up northeast of Camp David.

Speaker 1Sean, it's me.

Speaker 10I just wanted to let you know I love you, and I'm stuck at.

Speaker 6My building in New York.

Speaker 10There's lots of smoke and we just want to get it out, but a lot of people are.

Speaker 2Waiting.

Speaker 6Number two, we'll chase them right.

Speaker 1Ladies and gentlemen, we're not ready to die, but it's getting bad.

Speaker 9Go, go, go!

Speaker 5I'm on the 85th floor.

Speaker 4I'm gonna die, aren't I?

Speaker 9No, no, no, no, no, no.

Speaker 2I'm gonna die.

Speaker 6Ma'am, ma'am, ma'am, say your prayers. We're gonna think positive because you gotta help each other get off the floor. I'm gonna die.

Speaker 2It's a new type of war.

Speaker 6That's what it is.

Speaker 1To say that 9-11 changed everything is an understatement. I think I've made that clear throughout this. Outside of the school setting, things previously taken for granted, things like freedom from surveillance, freedom from buffed-up state security apparatuses, and freedom from rampant and performative patriotism, just to name a few, quickly became normal. War was no longer an abstract idea, or something that would conjure memories of the smashing 100-hour

Speaker 1victory of the Gulf War, and it instead became tethered to the cultural memory of the Vietnam quagmire, thanks largely to war-skeptical boomers. Millennials, at least those old enough to vote, were now the fighting generation, and there was a very real, if ultimately deeply misguided, fear of a resurgent military draft, especially after coalition forces engaged with Iraq in 2003. Dissent

Speaker 1against that war took on a new meaning, but in my memory, it was mostly driven by the aforementioned boomers tapping into their own experiences with Vietnam, and less by a bubbling awareness of war-anxious millennials at the grassroots. I'm not saying millennials were manipulated into being war-anxious. As the bodies of American servicemen began to pile up, it certainly became a very real concern. But the boomer-driven anti-war rhetoric certainly fed into and off of all of that concern.

Speaker 1The best way as I see it to illustrate the, we could call it the post-traumatic malaise that began to fall over millennials in the years following 9-11, is not to point to large-scale geopolitical developments, but rather to to look at the culture we consumed and eventually created. While there were certainly exceptions, some of the most popular films of the era, especially produced after 2003, were relentlessly pessimistic, cynical, or otherwise dark, seeming to peak in 2007, and contrary

Speaker 1to the fans of 1999, that's the best year for films in my lifetime, sorry. But you had releases that year like Zodiac, about the Zodiac Killer, or the assassination of Jesse James by the coward Robert Ford. or Michael Clayton, or Gone Baby Gone, or There Will Be Blood, or No Country for Old Men. All of those films, in one way or another, plunged us into some of the bleakest views of the human condition seen in films since the heyday of the late 1970s. Music popular with millennials, particularly those who had dabbled in the 90s and early

Speaker 12000s incarnations of the goth and punk scenes held over since the 1980s, that music took on a similar edge, if only in aesthetics. but also lyrical content, in a lot of ways. I haven't bothered to look at the actual numbers, so forgive me if I'm wrong, but I find it hard to believe that Hot Topic did not see its best years in sales from around 2001 to 2008. The rise of emo and screamo bands, known for trafficking almost exclusively in a kind of anguish, as well as

Speaker 1the persistence of hard industrial rock and angry punk music, that was a testament to this stuff. look no further than Gerard Way, directly citing 9-11 as the inspiration for him to quit his illustration job to form his monumentally successful pop-punk screamo band, My Chemical Romance. Can I see you right here next to me? With my dark body.

Speaker 5I'm not afraid.

Speaker 6I'm not afraid.

Speaker 3I'm not afraid.

Speaker 1Culture in the 2000s, even at its brightest, always had a harder edge. Even the sun-dappled, underrated in my opinion, soap drama masterpiece, The O.C., rarely paused in its indulgence. of teenage characters grappling with things like alcoholism and drug addiction, suicidal stalkers, and even attempted murder. This was also the height of cynical turptitude, with shows like Law & Order SVU, Special Victims Unit, where the monster of the week formula

Speaker 1pioneered by the X-Files in the 90s, was copy-pasted but with the twist of depraved sexual crime of the week. And lest we forget, this was the era of self-destructive reality and competition shows like Fear Factor, The Swan, and the beginning of the nightmare we call the Real Housewives franchise. The point was always seemingly the same. People are vile animals. How can we dispute this? See with your own eyes. And nowhere and no one is safe. Now, this isn't

Speaker 1to say that millennials were all miserable. You could probably hear it in my voice. There's a bit of nostalgia there, even for all this dark stuff. Like I said, 2007, best year for cinema, in my opinion. So it's important that we shouldn't generalize too readily, but it's safe to say that most of us weren't beyond the usual angst that accompanies adolescence. We were in high school and then college, and despite all the disruptions that 9-11, the war on terror, and the Iraq war had wrought, The world kept turning,

Speaker 1and adulthood was fast approaching. For a clear majority of millennials, college was a foregone conclusion. It was a logical continuation of the education we were receiving even as the world seemed to fall apart after the Twin Towers collapsed. This was before, right before, the 2010s bloat of higher education administration, Title IX overreach, and the rise of safetyism. and other things that we kind of take for granted in 2026. Individual expression and freedom were still, at least on paper,

Speaker 1at a premium, but also in practice, and we all believe that our personal development was just part of the process, enabled by the collegiate experience and of becoming gainfully employed adults. Then, the autumn of 2008 came around. and the Great Recession we had been hearing about for around a year finally reached its apex, just as many of us graduated from college and matriculated into the job market that was supposedly going to be waiting for us. The generational trauma associated

Speaker 1with the Great Recession was different than the ones felt immediately after the Columbine Massacre in 9-11, in that it was more slow-moving and and one that millennials began to discover for themselves on an individual level, as opportunity after opportunity for gainful employment seemed to just disappear, especially for those of us who saw fit to pursue a degree in the liberal arts. Now, given the proliferation of memes, some pretty funny memes, I'll admit, out there about feminist puppet theater majors and the like, it might be surprising

Speaker 1to learn that the degree itself was what was supposed to matter. Not the area of expertise that we studied. Was that naive?

Speaker 9Sure.

Speaker 1Probably. But that was not the message that we were given. You get the degree, you get the job. That was the narrative. And while my own degree, psychology, was plenty useful, especially if I deigned to try to continue my education, I knew many other people whose own degrees became woefully inadequate to face a more specialized job market. which was inevitable after the recession hit, and a lot of those people simply re-entered academia as students to weather the economic storm.

Speaker 1It might have worked in the short term, but many were not spared from the economic devastation that awaited us, and the downstream effects continued for the next several years.

Speaker 2The class of 2009 is facing the toughest job market in a decade. Six million jobs lost and a 9.4 percent unemployment rate. But despite those bleak numbers, new grads are trying to stay optimistic. A day of celebration for these Eastern Washington University grads. Pictures with friends and family, a sense of accomplishment and joy.

Speaker 1Very proud of her.

Speaker 2So excited for her, too. Four years of hard work to get to today, walking away from their alma mater with a diploma in hand. But ask anyone in the sea of caps and gowns what they'll be doing after graduation, and you'll most likely get this answer. Looking for a job now.

Speaker 7Just nervous because the hygiene market isn't so great right now, but definitely excited to be graduating.

Speaker 5I plan to start looking for a job. Hopefully some special education spots will open up around Spokane.

Speaker 2According to CareerBuilders.com, 43% of employers intend to hire new college grads this year. That's down from 56% in 2008 and 79% in 2007.

Speaker 1A lot of graduates.

Speaker 5Are pretty nervous, especially with teaching. It's a budget concern. A lot of teacher positions are getting eliminated or cut back.

Speaker 2Despite the crash course in Life 101 that's waiting for thousands of new grads in the Inland Northwest and across the country, these Eagles are staying upbeat and proactive.

Speaker 5Economy is really bad, you know, there's not too many jobs, so we have to just go for it.

Speaker 1Employment certainly bounced back as the years went by into the 2010s thanks to the rise of the gig economy, but a third painful lesson about the perpetual uncertainty and danger was being drilled into the heads of millennials in the late 2000s and early 2010s thanks to the recession. The mileage on how well we rode this period out varies, of course, but The explosion of late aughts, early tens party culture helps reflect our desire, millennials' desire that is, to live in the moment and not concern ourselves with

Speaker 1the potential consequences for pounding shots, snorting powders, and swallowing pharmaceuticals of which our parents' generation frankly could only dream. The irony of engaging in risky, perhaps even nihilistic, self-destructive behavior while also being imbued with the sense of the world's danger is about how none of us are safe ever and that people are vile animals, is not lost on me, but it's not an uncommon coping mechanism. Thus,

Speaker 1if anything, it adds weight to the notion that we were a generation that identified itself with subsequent mass traumatic events in the midst of adult development. As best I can tell, this helps explain a lot of cultural trends that that began to become mainstreamed as more and more millennials entered the workplace, including radical redefinitions of things like harm and justice. Such things, I wager, would not have

Speaker 1taken on such a radical purchase if the world the millennials believed they were promised had not changed the way it did, after Columbine, after 9-11, and certainly after the Great Recession's downstream effects, the last of which simply seemed to be the final confirmation of of everything we had become conditioned to believe about the world. Every generation, like I was saying before, loses its innocence in one way or another. For the greatest generation, it was the Great

Speaker 1Depression and World War II. For boomers, it was the killing of JFK and, arguably to a lesser extent, the Manson murders. And Vietnam, in its own way. But for millennials... We were sold this notion, fairly or otherwise, and came to believe that we had gone through a trilogy of traumas, and none of them seemed to have a silver lining. That's the one area where I feel like there is a little bit of uniqueness to what millennials experienced. The

Speaker 1greatest generation saw unprecedented wealth creation. The boomers further reaped those benefits and were largely able to replicate them and instill that optimism in their progeny, however misguided it was. I know I'm leaving out Xers, but they're kind of a cusper generation, and they probably deserve their own analysis, and I don't feel like I'm equipped to talk about it, so I defer to them and to the much elder millennials who were born in the early 80s to talk about that stuff. Millennials, though, those of us born in

Speaker 1the mid to late 80s and early 90s, everything just seemed to get worse. I don't want to make too much of these traumas or start engaging in the unearned existential performative pessimism that has become such a tiresome shorthand among many of my cohort. But I do understand such sentiments about the world ending and so forth. The supposed norm of school shootings, the greatest attack on American soil

Speaker 1by a foreign power since the War of 1812, and the greatest financial crash of living memory since the Great Depression, were very effective at embedding within the generational psyche that no one was safe and that there was no light at the end of the tunnel. By the time the epilogue, I like to call it, of millennial generational trauma hit, that is the COVID-19 pandemic, there was less shock among millennials than there might otherwise have been. It was shocking in a lot of ways, but Most millennials I knew

Speaker 1were just kind of, they went with it. They didn't find themselves at too much of a loss. They adapted as best they could pretty quickly. Obviously, that didn't last very long, but it still wasn't the kind of shock that I think it was to younger generations, we'll say. The pandemic and how our government handled it, in other words, was just further confirmation of what these previous traumas suggested was the nature of our existence. As annoying and even dangerous as I find trauma discourse, I actually find it

Speaker 1less surprising as a trend when I think about the historical events that punctuated the cultural gestation of millennials. Similarly, the meme about millennial drinking patterns and drug use being, well, kind of crazy, because it was pretty crazy, makes a lot more sense. Not as an excuse for those things, but as an explanation for the mindset of that drove so many of us to those behaviors and the pessimistic outlooks I'm describing. Unfortunately, though, I do believe it did

Speaker 1inculcate within us a fatalistic attitude that has robbed many my age of the ability to meaningfully take ownership over our lives and express real agency as we enter our 40s. It's not that millennials were coddled. I'm kind of done with that characterization. Some certainly were, but I don't think that was the problem. It's that many of us became convinced that the world happens to us rather than the reality,

Speaker 1which is that we engage with the world, which is sometimes hostile. Parenting and education definitely play parts in this dynamic, but bad parenting and bad education are is really more guilty of reinforcing the attitudes created by events outside of human control. One can see how this has manifested long-term with at least some millennials, specifically those who feel the need to announce their desire not to have children as

Speaker 1some sort of act of divine selflessness. It's usually paired with a vague invocation of the world today, in so many words, sometimes supported with references to abstract dangers like climate change, systemic racism, war and genocide, and now especially, seemingly every day, with AI, but with very little effort to meaningfully address the agency being enacted with the decision to not have kids. My partner Molly and I, you guys who are supporters of this show, know her from

Speaker 1the pop quiz or from the infinitesimal possibilities subseries that we sometimes do, We've been together for over 16 years, and she and I have no desire to have kids. Having children is just not on the table. When this comes up in conversation, which thankfully has been relatively rare, one can sense a sort of excitement on the part of people who immediately assume that it's because we can't bear the thought of bringing a child into the world today.

Speaker 1For a while, I simply shrugged that off and let people believe what they wanted to believe about my and my partner's decision. But I've come around to simply being honest. We are not having children because we don't want to have children. As the kids like to say, it's not that deep.

Speaker 11Climate change is a hot topic in Washington and around the world with millions of people changing their habits to help save the planet. But would you give up having children because of climate change? Joining us to talk about birth strike is the host of In Case You Missed It by HuffPost, Heather Gardner.

Speaker 4Happy Monday.

Speaker 11Okay, so this birth strike phenomenon is something that I've sort of had like casual conversations about with friends, but I didn't know that women were actually considering this.

Speaker 3Yeah, it's not just women either. It's a lot of men, couples specifically, who are talking about all of the reasons why they will or will not have children, and now they're just considering climate change. And for these birth strikers, that is the number one reason. And they have declared, signed it into the universe, that they will not have children or have any more children because of climate change.

Speaker 1I have long suspected that the people who proclaim their desire not to have children for abstract, external reasons are actually kind of ashamed about not producing progeny. That is, of course, their business. But it reflects what I'm talking about when it comes to how millennials have been affected by a full decade of traumatic events, to say nothing of the profound disruptions created by the COVID-19 pandemic, where it has conditioned many of us to believe that Not just that we have no agency, but that for us

Speaker 1to believe that we have agency is an exercise of dangerous naivete. One can see how this has fed into politics with very little trouble. This attitude, spanning the entire political spectrum, by the way, with an ever-present acceptance of illiberal means at best and authoritarian prescriptions at worst. It is not worth relitigating anymore. 21st century American illiberalism here. There are far better places for that, and the evidence

Speaker 1has existed in polls for many years and continues to exist in a troubling way. The point is that the pillars of individual liberty, which are built on a belief in individual agency, have lost their appeal with a lot of people, especially younger people, millennials and Zoomers included. And the reason for this, above all other reasons in my opinion, lies in mass psychological disposition. Any Psychology 101 class will teach you that dispositions have many ingrained aspects, personality in

Speaker 1other words, but that they are also conditioned over time. The malleability of personality is a very long-standing debate, and the consensus of personality psychologists at this point is largely that it is indeed a mixture of both, but that we can't discount how it's molded over time. When an entire generation is conditioned to believe that nothing is certain, and therefore nothing is safe as a matter of course,

Speaker 1thanks to a rapid succession of generational traumas, such an outcome of personalities trending towards the illiberal and the collective is hardly surprising. As fundamentally dishonest, irritating, and, well, frankly, silly, as I find this rise of performative pessimism on the part of millennials and the Zoomers rapidly following suit, I want to make it clear. I get it. My choice

Speaker 1to not engage in such apocalyptic prognosticating was simply that, after a while. It was a choice. Admittedly, my natural contrarianism has played a part as well. I have been hypersensitive, probably too hypersensitive, according to some people, to serious complex concerns becoming social signaling trends for decades at this point. It took me all of 20 minutes to tap out of the anti-war movement on the day of the Iraq invasion back in 2003, largely because I felt really creeped

Speaker 1out by the speaking in unison. So, sue me, that is a dispositional trait on my part. But it is still important for me to say that not engaging in this kind of, I guess you could say, rote pessimism was still a choice. It was a hard choice, but it was a choice. And it really wasn't an easy choice for me to make, especially the longer I studied history and politics. As anyone who reads or listens to my work knows, there are some dark periods in history

Speaker 1that I engage with, where the human condition reveals itself to be little better than the kind seen with chimpanzee tribes in the wild. And yet, We aren't chimpanzee tribes in the wild. We are subject to incredible forces much larger than ourselves. My fascination with pandemics and natural disasters in past episodes should probably make it clear that I do accept this reality. But at bottom, we are all the same. Creatures uniquely capable of making conscious choices, even if those choices are bad ones. The idea of a

Speaker 1coddled generation or two, that doesn't scare me. The idea of a generation that believes we can't make any meaningful choices for ourselves without being destroyed, that is an idea that does. That does scare me. As Cormac McCarthy wrote in Blood Meridian, we look out at the world and see a land of some other order out there whose true geology was not stone but fear. But McCarthy wasn't

Speaker 1saying that we need to despair at the darkness. of that vast, uncaring universe to which we are all subjected. He was invoking the awe that we should feel at that universe. With awe, one hopes, comes respect. And respect is a choice. And that respect allows us to engage with that universe instead of just cowering in fear and waiting for it to make our decisions for us.

Speaker 2Thank you.

Speaker 8Thank you.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Third Reich Diagnosis

    Nov 19, 20262 hr 8 minAudio

    Understanding evil is something that has preoccupied humans for a long time. By the mid-20th century, the desire to root it in firm, social scientific terms became the norm, particularly in the field of psychology. The...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Firebombing of Tokyo: Our Imperative Atrocity

    Sep 22, 20263 hr 21 minAudio

    We often hear about how the Second World War was more morally nuanced and complex than we have been led to believe. This is, to a certain extent, very true. The Axis powers meted out a level of genocidal destruction and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Power, Presidents, and Refusing the Crown (w/ Richard Lim)

    Sep 7, 20261 hr 23 minAudio

    In this newest episode of History Impossible we’re joined a second time by Richard Lim, host of the This American President podcast, who last appeared on this program a couple years ago to discuss the insane,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Orthodox ISIS: The Russian Religious Experience (w/ Kristaps Andrejsons of The Eastern Border)

    Aug 18, 20261 hr 48 minAudio

    “Because remember: Russia is a religious experience.” Those are the oft-repeated and well-said words by the host of The Eastern Border podcast, my good friend Kristaps Andrejsons. They are well-said because there are...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Ideological Pathology of Antizionism (w/ Kile Jones)

    Aug 11, 202656 minAudio

    Antizionism, as it has become, has been having a bit of a moment for going on three years. It is a tough nut to crack, given its various claims of varying legitimacy and, as we have covered more than once on History...

    Credit the people on this episode