Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

History Impossible

History Impossible artwork

Power, Presidents, and Refusing the Crown (w/ Richard Lim)

Sep 7, 20261 hr 23 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this newest episode of History Impossible we’re joined a second time by Richard Lim, host of the This American President podcast, who last appeared on this program a couple years ago to discuss the insane, contentious election of 1876. He is also the author of a new book, Refusing a Crown: How George Washington Changed the World, which releases on October 13, 2026, and covers the most significant aspect of America’s first president: his restraint from seizing power that almost certainly would have remained his. In this episode, Richard and I spoke about his new book, about Washington’s enduring character, the best and most important of the Founders, the role of deism, the constitutional foundations of the American experiment, and why figures like Washington prove that this experiment endures for a reason, even as it has faced many trials and challenges until this very day (among other topics). The polarization that plagues United States politics in the 21st century is, after all, nothing new, and Washington was among those who recognized this potential, and yet created an example that is easily forgotten. Richard aims to - and I believe succeeds - remind us that there was more to Washington than his supposed inability to tell lies about cherry trees and crossing a river during the Revolution, revealing that he was far more than some “presidential messiah.” ... History Impossible has been made possible by the following generous supporters on Patreon, Substack, and PayPal. Please consider donating today if you want to show some love for what I do and make and what to help keep the show and all my written content going: David Adamcik Monica Almirall David Alsbach Gregg Anderson approso1999 Rajan Athul Robert Babeon Michael Beach Benjamin Greg Bosai Johannes Breitsameter Carol ABC Carol Chappelle Charles C Chomo the Clown Curtis Christiansen Jason Coleman Clayton Connell Click Cliffydeuce CR Craig Crawford B.Cyr daddygorgon Lynda Davis Paul DeCoster Regina Dick-Endrizzi Neil Dickens Nathan Diehl Bob Downing Dramicas Eastone Gavin Edwards Snow Farmer Howie Feltersnatch Matt Gassner Pierre Ghazarian Josh Goedert Elena Gomel Sam Graham Jayson Griesmeyer Nathan Grote Benjamin Hamilton Peter Hauck Jack Henneman Eric Hodges Mike Jarulic Joe6245 Lionel Joseph Thomas Justesen Mike Kalnins Bryn Kaufman Leah Kodner Constance Loucks Maddy Mounty of Madness Jose Martinez Mike Mayleben S.M. McAvoy Judy McCoid Mike Kyle Mohney Kostas Moros Ryan Mortenson John Muller Cameron Needham Sean P Skip Pacheco David Page Molly Pan Philip Pomerantz Sr. Powell Brian Pritzl AnaR737 PJ Rader Gleb Radutsky Aleksandr Rakitin Reptilycus Matthew M. Rice Phillip Rice Cheryl Robertson Terry Rosen Run Tough Mindset Andrew S Dan S Jon Andre Saether Jake Scalia Emily Schmidt Julian Schmidt Scryptar Andrew Seeber Shiran Joshua Simpson Cameron Smith Jerry Spangler timetosuccedd1995 Thomas Squeo Athal Krishna Sundarrajan Jared Cole Temple Ann Tout Mike US Ward Van Roy Pierre Vorupuni Robert VS Nate Wade weaverap Jonny Wilkie Christian Wilson Janora Winsor M. Yao Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/history-impossible--5634566/support.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Hello, everybody. Yet again, ladies and gentlemen, brothers and sisters, comrades and friends, thank you again for tuning in to History Impossible. We are here with another special conversation with my friend Richard Lim, the host of the This American President podcast. This is actually a really special episode because Richard's first book is being released in, well, as of this recording, just over a month, on.

Speaker 2October 13th, 2026.

Speaker 1And that book is Refusing a Crown, How George Washington Changed the World, which is a really amazing book, really amazing topic, honestly, given the year it is, the 250th anniversary. And Richard adds a lot of really interesting depth to this first president of ours without deifying him, something he actually stands firmly against when it comes to presidents. We had a really good, wide-ranging, basically freewheeling conversation in a

Speaker 1lot of ways, though I did have some questions for him about George Washington, the Founding Fathers, aspects of their religious beliefs, and so forth. There was a lot of ground that got covered in too short of a span of time, so I do hope to speak to Richard again in the near future. But yes, his book is coming out very soon, and I highly recommend you guys get it. It's very interesting stuff. Before we get into that, I want to give a quick shout-out to the patrons of History Impossible at the executive producer level, and that

Speaker 1would include... Monica Almaral, and Mike Malabin. You guys are doing amazing stuff keeping this show afloat, as is everybody who supports this show on Patreon and Substack. So if you want to support this show like them, if you're listening to this and enjoy what I do and enjoy what you're listening to, head over to patreon.com slash historyimpossible and become a patron, or head over to historyimpossible.com and become a paid subscriber. Or if you can't afford to throw any support this way, financially speaking, Just spread the

Speaker 1word about the podcast. You know, spread it far and wide. That's what I'm hoping for here. I want to get some more people listening to this. We have some really good stuff coming down the line very soon. And yeah, that's really all I have for you guys this time. So please sit back and enjoy this conversation with Richard Lim of the This American President podcast.

Speaker 2An ancestor of mine maintained that if you eliminate the impossible, whatever remains, however.

Speaker 3Improbable, must be the truth.

Speaker 2I wish I could say tonight that a lasting peace is inside.

Speaker 3I don't see any American dream, I see an American nightmare.

Speaker 1Some say the world will end in fire.

Speaker 2Some say in ice.

Speaker 1From what I've tasted of desire, I hold with those who favor fire. But if it had to perish twice, I think I know enough of hate.

Speaker 2To say that for destruction, ice is also great and would suffice. This is History Impossible.

Speaker 1Yeah, no, I was going to say, like, I had the feeling that this was that Washington's your favorite founding father, because everyone has theirs. But you were saying that you might have a different one.

Speaker 3You mean as far as writing another book?

Speaker 1As far as writing another book, but also maybe just in general, just of the ones you admire, you know, cause there's so many out there.

Speaker 3Sure. Yeah, no, I mean, it's an incredible generation of Americans and you have, you know, it's funny because I recently did a project on the founding fathers, the signers of the declaration. And most people, when they learn about the fathers, there's the founding fathers, there's a handful that they know, right. Washington, Franklin, Jefferson, et cetera. But, and then there might be kind of this, second tier of people that they might know. Oh, I remember Patrick Henry said that famous quote about whatever. And there's all those guys, right?

Speaker 3Sam Adams, John Hancock.

Speaker 1I was going to say John Hancock is the most visible one.

Speaker 3Sure.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 3And those guys were all amazing. I mean, they, you know, had it not been for a few circumstances, they might've become president. And, you know, we tend to remember presidents as but it's one of those things where, you know, John Hancock, governor of Massachusetts, Patrick Henry, governor of Virginia, you know, they, they weren't any less brilliant than James Monroe. I mean, they were, they were brilliant and that's not a knock on James Monroe. James Monroe was very accomplished man. But then you start getting down the list. And as

Speaker 3I was doing this, this project, you learn about the ones that nobody knows about. Like, John Witherspoon or Francis Lewis or I mean, there are just so many of these guys. I mean, Francis Lewis was a founder who I mean, he literally his home and his properties were destroyed by the British. His wife was jailed and then she died as a result of that. I mean, the amount of sacrifice that these guys did. we don't really talk about. We kind of just see them as this elite,

Speaker 3upper-crust group of people that had it really nice and whatever. No, a lot of these people had to make real sacrifices. And so, yeah, it's really an incredible generation. And then there's this other group of people, if they weren't the signers, a lot of whom were lawyers, accomplished figures in, let's say, like John Witherspoon, head of Princeton, in academia. Then you have a guy like Henry Knox, bookseller turned general. You have a guy like Nathaniel Green. And then to say

Speaker 3nothing of the other military heroes like Daniel Morgan. There's so many of these guys that the more you learn about that generation, it's really true what they say. It's just incredible that this incredible assembly, not just of intellectual talent, but also just guts of I mean, guys that just had guts. It's incredible that they were all together at the same time.

Speaker 1Yeah, and you're just listing off all these names, and it's true. As soon as you get past that second tier, Patrick Henry, John Hancock, and so forth, I'm just like, I don't recognize these names that he's listing off here. So yeah, there's a lot of good stuff in there.

Speaker 3And that's not even to say second tier meant that they were second rate.

Speaker 1Right, yeah.

Speaker 3Again, it's just circumstances that led When you want to win an election, a presidential election, you need people from the key states, right? So that's why Virginia and New York dominated. But that's not to say that a guy like little old John Witherspoon from Princeton was not important or not brilliant. These guys were all brilliant. It's just incredible.

Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah.

Speaker 1I mean, that's funny too, because I was just thinking like, cause you know, making it more about the presidents in general, it's like the go-to for me has always been Thomas Jefferson, mostly because of, you know, he wrote the declaration of course. And I mean, I, I don't know how long ago I read it, but I remember what first got me into Jefferson is when I read Christopher Hitchens is a small biography of him, author of America, very good book. And, and it's funny because like the, I've always like, it's funny because he's always considered the most controversial founding father

Speaker 1because of the Sally Hemings issue and the slavery issue, of course. Not that there were other, you know, issues of slavery with the other founding fathers, including the one that, you know, you're focused on to a, to a degree. But when I say issue, I just, I find Washington's relationship with slavery pretty interesting too. But with Jefferson's, the thing that he's often lambasted for as a hypocrite, I find that to be the most compelling thing about him. Like the fact that he was so aware of what he would, of like his own hypocrisy on the issue

Speaker 1and just struggling with like understanding the importance of, you know, human freedom and flourishing and all that and how slavery contradicted it. I just, I've always found that contradiction so fascinating and that's what makes him the most compelling of the founding fathers to me. But, I did semi-recently, it's been about a year now, watch that, at this point it's like almost 20 years old, that miniseries on HBO about John Adams.

Speaker 3John Adams, sure. Yeah, that was a.

Speaker 1Very, I really loved that series. And it really gave me more appreciation of Adams, especially thinking about things like his defense of the British soldiers. After the so-called Ballaston Massacre, it wasn't much of a massacre. It was important, but there was only a couple of people got killed. But still, it was– I find his story very interesting. And then that just starts to make me realize when I'm thinking about that. It's like, oh, I like John Adams. Well, you made a case for Washington very– however briefly I

Speaker 1was able to read some of your manuscript. I mean so I'm thinking, no. Richard's right. It's really all of them. They're all impressive or interesting at the very absolute least in all of them. I've heard people make the case that Monroe is the most underrated of the presidents from that generation too. So at a certain point, it's kind of hard to figure out what the hell am I going to write about? Well, let's start with the basics and that's why you have this book coming out. That was my attempt at a transition there because I should probably... Very, very smooth. Very smooth.

Speaker 3I like it.

Speaker 1About I think it was like two years ago we talked.

Speaker 2Oh, wow. Yeah. Yeah.

Speaker 3That's a throwback.

Speaker 1It's a throwback.

Speaker 3And that election is always a good reminder that if you think things are crazy now, you know, that election was nuts. I mean, they literally had to come up with a solution outside of the Constitution to figure it out.

Speaker 1Yeah, and I'm not looking forward to that happening again in my lifetime. I have no idea if it will. I don't want to think about it.

Speaker 3Well, you know, the last few elections have been very normal and boring.

Speaker 1Yeah, totally, totally normal. No controversies there, yeah. But if I remember right, 1800 was pretty contested, right?

Speaker 3Oh my gosh, yeah.

Speaker 1I mean, that's its own podcast, I'm assuming.

Speaker 3Well, that's a fascinating election because you have a situation... I mean, just the fact that you have the first turnover from one party to another... And then the fact that the presidential nominee of a party tied with his vice presidential running mate, who was added to the ticket to, you know, they were talking about, you know, Aaron Burr added to Jefferson's ticket. He was Jefferson's running mate. And he was, as I said earlier, he was added for political reasons because, you know, Jefferson, southerner, you know, was

Speaker 3likely to carry the South. So they needed a northerner, get a northerner from the most populous state, New York. And suddenly Aaron Burr becomes potential president, you know, and here's this guy who I don't think most people would consider him a top rate founder, but he very nearly became president, the third president of the United States. So he would have been elevated to top tier status just on that alone, which is incredible. I mean, the whole story is wild. It went to the House of Representatives. The guy who had to decide it was a guy

Speaker 3who hated both men. you know, Hamilton being the Kingmaker leader of the Federalists had to decide between Jefferson and Burr, literally his two greatest enemies, you know? And so yeah, endlessly fascinating election.

Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Speaker 1Especially considering what happened between Burr and Hamilton, not too long after if memory serves. Um, but yeah, no, that's a, again, that's a, that's a whole podcast in and of itself. It's a, from what little life I know, I've learned about it. I, I, people usually bring that up in alongside the 1876 election, as far as the controversial contested elections go. But, but we're here mostly to talk about, um, the book you have coming out, uh, refusing the.

Speaker 3Crown, um, and, uh, on a quick side, a crown refusing.

Speaker 1A crown, excuse me. And, um, all about George Washington's significance in that respect of having opportunities to be a King in so many words and just, consistently saying no and that in and of itself is one of the most incredible things about that man um i just wanted to know one thing i noticed uh when you were um telling me about it that you're getting it published uh through regneries and.

Speaker 3Alfred regneries publishing firm which is called republic book right.

Speaker 1I just finished reading the amazing sam tenenhaus biography of buckley And, um, and, and Buckley's, uh, first book and his, uh, more infamous second book that he co-wrote with Brent Bazell. Um, but his first book got a man at Yale was through Regnery's and, um, and, uh, I was just, I just noticed that connection. I was like, oh, that's cool. That's a, that's a story house right there. But, um, I think just to, uh, uh, get us started. Um, I actually was really struck of all things by your

Speaker 1author's note at the beginning where you talked about, You know, meeting with a family in China, talking about specifically a cousin of yours talking about Washington and and and I was really struck when you said that he spoke about Washington in odd tones. And I'm honestly I focused on that because my partner Molly's family is Chinese as well. And most of their feelings on America have more to do with the culture than the history that I've noticed.

Speaker 1with some exceptions. So I'm just curious if your experience with your cousin's view of Washington was unique, or if you've encountered other people, maybe not just in China, but in general, that also share this appreciation of our founding fathers, because that did surprise me a little bit, honestly.

Speaker 3Yeah, absolutely. So yeah, this was in 2007. So it was many years ago. And I Basically, it was during a family reunion. It was through my stepdad's family. So not blood related, but obviously still family. And so basically, I had just gotten to know this gentleman. He was middle aged, a cousin of my dad's.

Speaker 2Oh, I see.

Speaker 3And this was, again, in 2007 during the administration of George W.

Speaker 2Bush.

Speaker 3And he spent most of the conversation just bashing Bush. For the Iraq War, which was a style of the time. Well, yeah, it was a popular thing to do around the world.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 3In America and some to some extent. And so it's like, OK. And for me, I just I was just listening. I was interested in his perspective and how people see America and American foreign policy. And then, but we both realized, and this was with my dad translating because he didn't speak any English. I don't speak any Chinese. Sure, sure. So the conversation kind of veered into history. He mentioned that, yeah, you know, he really loves history. And just out of nowhere,

Speaker 3he said, you know, the American I admire so much is George Washington. And that really struck me because he clearly was not a fan of the contemporary decisions made by America's leadership. But He really admired an American who lived 200 plus years ago. And from that moment on, it just kind of had me thinking, well, why would somebody from a different culture 200 years after the person lived admire that person? And he spoke in very reverential tones.

Speaker 3And it had me realize that George Washington's story to Americans is kind of a cliche. It's, oh, he was the first president. Okay.

Speaker 1But.

Speaker 3You know, it has this incredible story to inspire. And I found that you here you have this American figure who obviously wasn't perfect. He was a human being like all the rest of us. And he reflected a lot of, you know, the positives and negatives of his time. And as you mentioned, he owned slaves. And how did someone like this become such an inspirational figure? to people around the world. And I think Americans have forgotten that. They've

Speaker 3forgotten just how powerful that story is. It's often been said that during Washington's time, the world was filled with kings and emperors. And that's true. In China, speaking of China, at that time, the person that was ruling during Washington's lifetime was an emperor named Chen Long. And he was in power for about 60 years. That's normal. You know, his grandfather, I think grandfather, great grandfather, Kang Shi, who ruled during the previous century, he was in there for

Speaker 3about 60 years as well. So if you're the average person living in the world at the time, you'd probably live under somebody that ruled for a really long time. You know, maybe not 60 years, but several decades. Russia was ruled by Catherine the Great at the time, decades long.

Speaker 1Well, and just, I mean, even later, Queen Victoria, she was in power for going on.

Speaker 3Right, exactly.

Speaker 1And just to throw out the China example, just because you got my brain going and I'm really interested in that era of Chinese history, the Qing dynasty. It's like, that's a foreign occupying force too, on top of that.

Speaker 3Well, people forget that George III ruled for 60 years. He was the longest serving king in British history. So this is all going on a very long time. If you want to, be technical about it. Who were the heads of government at the time? In Great Britain, the office of prime minister was really solidifying, but those guys rarely stepped down voluntarily. They usually lost the confidence of parliament or the king. And so that's the norm. And

Speaker 3then to see this American experiment where you have orderly, regular elections in which they're accepted in a peaceful manner over and over, And the guy that's in the middle of that is George Washington. And what do we say that he refused the crown? In my book, I get into all these technicalities. Is that true? Kind of. I mean, it's not like America came together and said, hey, here's a crown. Do you want it, George? I mean, it wasn't literally like that. It was more circumstantial. There was

Speaker 3a situation where one of his officers suggested that he take the crown and he said no. So If you want to be pedantic about it, if you want to get into splitting hairs, okay, did he technically refuse a crown? It depends on what you mean by refusing a crown. But the point of it is that throughout his entire career, he facilitated through his decisions this incredibly linear progression from monarchy under the British monarchy to republic under but a

Speaker 3very specific republic under the Articles of Confederation with him as commander in chief and completely respecting civilian authority, which was a very new concept at the time, to then becoming the first president and actually having to implement this government as a civilian leader. He facilitated all that. He made it so that it could be orderly. And it starts during the revolution when he gets appointed. He's a member of Congress, so he's a member of the civilian leadership.

Speaker 3And then he is appointed commander in chief. And that whole time throughout all the pressures of the temptations of taking more power than he needed to do, you know, he needed to take perhaps for a good reason. You know, maybe he could have just declared martial law across the country because this would help win the revolution. Throughout all of that, he always maintained his the principle of civilian authority, which is an unprecedented accomplishment. And I think what somebody

Speaker 3from China sees that they see that essentially he didn't fudge, you know, most leaders at some point kind of fudge. They say, well, look, I, you know, the laws are nice, but I have to do this. I just have to, you know, it's for the good of the, the fact that he never did that is incredible. And I think, you know, you have people in America that want to scrutinize him for not being a perfect person while you have people, uh, somewhere else around, you know, in China, who are used to being under dictatorships, to people where

Speaker 3fudging is the norm, fudging it and saying, look, I have to do this for the people, I have to stay in power for the rest of my life. That's the norm. And the fact that we had a guy right from the start that didn't do that. I mean, it, you know, it's something that sometimes I think people from other countries see more clearly. And in my book, I cover that I cover not just the story of Washington giving up power, but I also just cover that impact around the world. You know, you had in Europe during

Speaker 3the Napoleonic era, constant comparisons that Napoleon had to deal with. And this is not to denigrate Napoleon. I mean, he was a person who had to make decisions within his context. The fact of the matter is, is that he had to deal with unwelcome comparisons to Washington. Hey, why are you crowning yourself? Washington didn't. he would make the argument, look, I had to because, you know, we were being threatened by monarchies, blah, blah, blah. Again, I'm not making any judgment on that, but the fact of the matter is he had to deal with those comparisons. Same thing in South America or even in Hungary, you know, where their

Speaker 3revolutionary leader would, he came to America and claimed lineage to Washington and his values. And then, as I said earlier, in China, not just, my relative, but in 1911, when they had their revolution, led by Sun Yat-sen, and then Yuan Shikai took power, and Sun Yat-sen, knowing Yuan Shikai was a military man who would eventually become a dictator, Sun Yat-sen said to him, you could be George Washington.

Speaker 3You could be George Washington. How many Americans know that? How many people know.

Speaker 1I've heard that story, but I'm, I'm weird.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 3Yeah. How many Americans know that that's the standard, you know? And so I think, you know, the point of my book is to say, we don't, we as Americans don't actually appreciate how much power our founding father's story has around the world and how much that resonates with people.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1You really made the case. And I was actually, that was going to be my next question was like, what, you know, what is it about Washington that you find so compelling in general? I think you kind of answered that and he made a really good case for that. I mean, I, but you did get me thinking and I don't want to jump the gun on anything, but it just got me thinking like about the counterfactuals, what might've happened had he done, had he fudged as you say.

Speaker 3Like, that's a great question. And we know historians hate that, but, but, uh, you know, it's funny because I talk in the book about the historical impact of, of what Washington did. And part of it, there's a cultural element to, um, The game Assassin's Creed, there's literally a scenario where you can fight, where Washington becomes a king, right?

Speaker 1I never played it, but I always thought it sounded really fun.

Speaker 3Oh, totally, yeah. So here's the thing. Obviously, we can't know for sure, but I have to imagine that in a nation where people expected of Washington to act in a Republican way, that there would have been so much opposition. There was definitely, as people like to say, which is true, there was so much trust in Washington. And during the revolution, when things were going not well, and people were wondering if the country could actually survive without a monarchy, there

Speaker 3were suggestions that Washington take the crown. But from what I know, that was a minority. Minorities can still be dangerous. But the majority was... you know, we're a public. Um, and I would say that that would have created so much opposition that you would then potentially have a civil war before we even started.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 3Now that argument has been used by people like Napoleon to say, well, look, Washington lived in a Republic. Of course he was going to give up power. What choice did he had kind of denigrating Washington's accomplishments? Um, I think certain stories like you on Chicago story, show that even though the country had turned towards a Republic, uh, it's not a guarantee that the leader is going to do the right thing. You know, there are lots of times when a leader has every incentive to do the right thing, but he doesn't because of selfish ambitions and,

Speaker 3and all of that, you know, people miscalculate. So it's, I don't think it's as simple as that. I think, you know, there's a reason why Washington was unanimously elected, uh, president and, you know, twice. And so with that said, um, I would say, yeah, that it's one of those things where, yeah, that story, it's interesting because had he taken the crown or had he tried to take a crown, at the least it would have showed the world, hey, they still

Speaker 3can't get it together.

Speaker 1They're no different.

Speaker 3They're no different.

Speaker 1Yeah, yeah. And that is kind of like the running theme when you hear people being, at this point, I mean, it's so funny because I do think that criticisms of american leaders in history are totally valid but it's become so knee-jerk.

Speaker 3Well i think it depends which criticism right there's some criticism that i think is is born of you know certain ideologies or just right if a country's successful that therefore they they did it in an unfair way i don't think those are valid other criticisms can be valid sure Right.

Speaker 1Well, and that's– what I was getting at there is it's like you would– you get this kind of sense that there's people who are criticizing the founding fathers in particular from the position of the people in this hypothetical scenario where it's like, well, what did you expect? They're no different than anyone else. But they're talking about things like, well, they're slave owners and so forth, to which I say, well, yes, but they are different because like I mentioned earlier with– at least in the case of Thomas Jefferson– he was

Speaker 1fully aware of the inconsistency there and he grappled with that and he didn't succeed and get in getting over that very much washington and my as you can you know give me some more details on this but as i understand it was washington he did have slaves but he was one of those people that freed his slaves went in his will for when he died um yes and and uh Maybe you can give me some historical context on that because people do find that interesting. Was that normal for him to do that? Was that something

Speaker 1that increasing numbers of people in his socioeconomic position do that? Or was that more connected to his political outlook as the first president of the United States? Or was it something completely different?

Speaker 3Well, so I don't really get into this as much in my book, but just on my own research, I would say, I mean, he's the only major, major founding father to free a slave. So that's one thing. And I think, you know, it's one of those things where, you know, there's always fair criticism. There's always this idea that could the founders have done more, right? Sure. I think you have to put that, I think you have to put that in the broader context of, the founders were trying to create a new world out of an old world and all attempts to create a new world and,

Speaker 3you know, immediately to destroy all the things of the old world have ended in failure. So, you know, if you want to criticize the founders for not abolishing slavery immediately, well, to me, the choice, and Joseph Ellis has said this, the Pulitzer Prize winning historian, that the choice really- Yeah. The choice during the founding was between you can either have a country and allow slavery to continue for the time being, or you could try to get rid of slavery and have no country. It's literally the argument.

Speaker 1So that was something that Thomas Jefferson was concerned about.

Speaker 3Right.

Speaker 1Like that was like all the founders.

Speaker 3I mean, they saw it as look, we need to look. You have to. when you create a country, it has to happen in stages, right? So what can we do now, right? Well, what we can do now is to get rid of the British rule and then create a constitution and so on and so forth. They felt slavery was something that had to be dealt with over time, that if you restricted it to a certain area, that it would die naturally. The same year that they ratified the Constitution, they banned

Speaker 3slavery in the Western territories. Then my question is, why did they do that? Because That's what they envisioned for the country.

Speaker 1They didn't want to expand the institution.

Speaker 3Yeah, which is why Frederick Douglass makes the argument that the Constitution is a glorious liberty document, which is why he opposed William Lloyd Garrison, who said that the Constitution is a deal with the devil. So he understood that the best way to get rid of slavery was to keep the nation together. because that way the Northern anti-slavery influence would have an effect on the South. Well, the only way you keep that together is to, for the moment, make a compromise with Southerners and then, you know, find

Speaker 3ways to deal with slavery. By the way, a lot of founders were anti-slavery, like Alexander Hamilton.

Speaker 2And John Adams.

Speaker 3But here's the interesting thing. They were anti-slavery. Yeah, great. Let's applaud them. But they... did not see themselves as morally superior to people in the South. You know, Alexander Hamilton, John, Abigail Adams, they all opposed slavery, but they all admired George Washington. Well, why is that? Because they knew that had they lived in the South, they would have been in the same situation as the Washingtons. They didn't look at it as looking how high and mighty and superior I am to these people, you know? And so, I

Speaker 3would say that I think you have to look at it in kind of that nuanced way. Now, here's the reason why I believe George Washington was anti-slavery. Because in his will, again, you can make the argument he could have done more in his own lifetime. That's fine, whatever. But in his will, when he frees them, he stipulates that not only that the elderly are cared for by his estate, but the young are taught not just trades, but also how to read. And to me, there's nothing

Speaker 3more deadly to the institution of slavery than to teach the young in it how to read because no look at Douglas, you know, no literate slave is going to be content continuing to be a slave. And that's to me. And Washington talked about his own relationship with slavery in regretful terms. He said it was the only unavoidable subject of regret. And so much has been made that, oh, he just he turned against it because of economic reasons, whatever. I think that he starts talking about it in moral terms. He says that he hopes that the measures he has

Speaker 3taken will be pleasing to the justice of the creator. You know, I think he evolved into somebody that became anti-slavery. And one of my good friends who's a historian, Jane Cook, makes the point that had he lived longer, because he died two years after his presidency, had he lived longer, he probably would have been more involved in taking stronger stances against slavery. Yeah, and.

Speaker 1it's so funny too, because I really liked that you brought up the, um, by design, how the, uh, the founders created a, um, a system that was meant to, uh, be a gradual process rather than something that was just an upending of the old world. It was unlike, um, I'm forgetting the name of the, um, I think it was Sean McMeekin wrote that book about the history of communism called to overturn the world or overthrow the world. And I, and I, I feel like that's a very, very modern concept of revolution born from the French Revolution,

Speaker 1I think, to a pretty significant degree. But just generally speaking, this idea that revolution should be this immediate overturning of the world is something that I don't think is necessarily it's become the norm, unfortunately, but it was not the norm before. necessarily with uh at least in the case of the american revolution that's what makes the american revolution so significant and great.

Speaker 3Uh in a lot of ways because thomas west go ahead yeah yeah well historian thomas west says that uh you know an attempt to to create perfect equality for all during the founders would have crashed the entire experiment and led to equality for none and so you had a situation where you either seek to have equality for some which would lead to equality for all which was

Speaker 3the founding of America versus let's try to make equality for everyone and have no equality or at least equal misery and so that was the real choice because we live in the real world and that's one of the reasons why Washington stands out as a revolutionary figure I always say that the people that did the most to guarantee the rights of man, the founders, they had the most cynical view of human nature. You know, they, they, I mean, why did they create a system of checks

Speaker 3and balances? Because they knew humans had to be checked. Why do they have to be checked? Because they're inherently selfish. And so, and they, they checked everybody. At least that was the way the system's designed, you know, executive checks, the legislature checks, the judicial, and then all, and then that's, horizontally and then vertically. The states check the federal government, federal government checks the states, yada, yada. We all know this. This is Civics 101, right? They had the cynical view of human nature and their system ended up being the one that guaranteed the most freedom. A lot of these

Speaker 3people that advocated, you know, whether it's the French revolutionaries or the communist revolutionaries of the 20th century, they had this idea that man could be perfected and all this stuff. And that led to the most misery.

Speaker 1So And necessitated tyranny in a lot of cases, or at least maybe not necessitated, but at least– well, I think in the case of communism it did because that's always what communism becomes. But regardless, I was thinking more specifically about the French Revolution because it maybe didn't necessitate it, but it inevitably led to– rise of someone like Napoleon. And that's what I'm thinking.

Speaker 3Well, Robespierre first.

Speaker 1Well, yeah, of course. But then we know what happened to him. Deservedly so in a lot of ways. But yeah, the thing with Washington that I find so interesting, not just Washington, but just him as an example of what you're talking about is like, had they pushed for that, something that radical? And when I say radical, I'm trying to think of a better word because I think what the founders did was radical. Because it was radical in its restraint as far as revolutions go, as far as rhetoric goes. But when I'm saying radical in this case,

Speaker 1I just mean in the more general sense, or typical, the overturning of everything. Had they tried that to make everything perfect and equal and perfect human nature all at the same time, it would have turned into maybe not Washington himself, but someone like him becoming king because that would be, in their minds, the only solution to the chaos that that would unleash. That seems to me to be what would have happened if they had tried for.

Speaker 3Something like that. And I think this goes to the idea that what was underpinning society was the Judeo-Christian ethic. And that ethic posits a duality. The first is that, yes, man is created in God's image and therefore is entitled to these rights that we talk about in the Declaration of Independence and later on in the Bill of Rights. But at the same time, man has fallen. So man's greatest obstacle to realizing those rights is actually himself, because

Speaker 3he has a tendency to oppress, to tyrannize, to seek advantage over others. And so, you know, it's interesting because my book, it's interesting because I've talked to other historians about this. I wrote this book because this is the book that I wish had been written. And what I realized was that, look, Washington was a great man. He did amazing things but he obviously wasn't he didn't exist in a vacuum he uh he was a product of

Speaker 3the country that he was from to some extent he shaped it as well it's a feedback loop well with that said uh you have to look at the country i think the the country that he he he's from i think it's to the country's credit that it we had a guy like washington who But there's a broader kind of story here. And what that story is, is not just of Washington refusing a crown, but of America going from, like almost any other group of people at

Speaker 3the time, colonies, being content under a monarchy in which Washington and Jefferson and Franklin, they all professed loyalty to a monarchy for several decades. to suddenly becoming rabidly anti-monarchy. Not just anti-British monarchy, we don't want the British monarchy, but being anti-monarchy as an institution. And so there's this broader shift in America from one to another, and Washington

Speaker 3is the key figure in that transition. And the question is, how did that happen? Why did that happen? And I get to that in my book. And one thing I found interesting is that Thomas Paine, famous book, Common Sense. If anyone's ever read the book, he actually uses an argument from scripture about why monarchy is morally indefensible.

Speaker 1And Thomas Paine being a, he was at least as secular as if not an atheist, right?

Speaker 3Well, later on, he wrote a pamphlet bashing Christianity. And I think a lot of people would argue he basically became a deist. Now here's like a lot of the founders.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 3Uh well i don't know if i agree with that um.

Speaker 1Well not a lot well i know ben franklin i mean that's the one i'm.

Speaker 3Well what's your definition of deism.

Speaker 1Oh i i was thinking i actually might be pulling it from franklin uh basically the ability you can maybe correct me on this uh but i think it was franklin who had the quote saying that i can worship god in my own backyard and so many Am I talking about there? That's basically like a belief in God, but not requiring the use of a church. That's that's the sense.

Speaker 3Well, I would say it's more specific than that. Being a deist means it's the the the clock maker. You got God. God, you know, creates the universe as a clock and then he steps away and lets the clock govern itself, which, by the way, is a very convenient God because you have a God. But then you get to say, well, I can do whatever the heck I want. And one of the fundamental tenets of deism is that God doesn't intervene. And yet you have Franklin saying, the

Speaker 3more longer I live, the more I believe that God intervenes in the affairs of man. Oh, sorry, not a deist. Yeah, not anymore. Here's the thing. Was he a Christian? He explicitly rejected Christianity as, you know, the definition of Christianity is belief in Jesus. But did he believe that Christianity was a good moral force?

Speaker 1Yes.

Speaker 3But I would say if we want to get our category straight, I don't think, you know, people have tried to say Washington was a deist. The guy in letter after letter, private letters to private letters. So we're not saying posturing for the public, but like to a buddy, like he would say the finger of Providence is in this. He's talking about during in the early years of the war, the finger of Providence. Providence is a term Christians and non-Christians alike used for God at the time. Well, so he's essentially saying God is intervening in the situation. Sorry,

Speaker 3not a deist. Now, you can argue whether he was a Christian or not. I think that's something, you know, that's a fair debate. But was he a deist? You know, now people would say that.

Speaker 1We're getting to the territory of actually, I want to let you finish what you were saying about Thomas Paine earlier. Sorry, but I mean, we're getting into like my thesis territory that I've been working on for the last couple of years and about the very question of, And I don't think there's much of a question of the Judeo-Christian or at least specifically the Protestant Christian origin of, I guess, well, I don't get into the connection to the revolution, but I do believe that the Protestant Christian tradition is what

Speaker 1led to a lot of impulses that could be connected to the revolution. But we can put a pin in that. I want to let you finish what you were saying earlier about pain. Yeah, yeah. Well, he....

Speaker 3Makes the argument in common sense that he, he looks to the Israelites in the, in scripture when they, uh, basically when, uh, before, during the time of judges, before they had a king, how they were governed and said, this is the ideal government without a king. And when the Israelites asked for a king, uh, that was essentially a middle finger to God. And, and that it's something not, you know, that monarchy is essentially a pagan institution. Now, say whatever you want about Thomas Paine, but the point

Speaker 3is that, well, why did he feel compelled to use that argument, you know, in America? Well, the reason is because America, Christianity resonated in America, right?

Speaker 1There were only a couple of decades away from the great awakening and that's what I get into.

Speaker 3And why would that pamphlet be so influential? No one doubts the influence of common sense, you know, and people often whatever political persuasion people or religious persuasion, yeah, common sense had a huge impact on the country pushing for independence in 1776. But it literally uses an argument from scripture saying, hey, actually, if we really want to follow scripture, monarchy is, we're actually partaking in this anti-Christian institution. Now,

Speaker 3not everyone agreed with that argument. Some, like John Adams, would say, well, you know, Israel, God got mad at Israel for choosing a king, but that was because Israel had a special relationship with God that other countries didn't. Fine, whatever. But the point is that it was all taking place within a Christian worldview. And that whole story is very interesting because that's part of a very long trend. And I actually get into the book about What did monarchy

Speaker 3mean in America in 1776? Well, in order to figure that out, you have to look at what monarchy meant in Europe and how that was transplanted to America. We all probably have heard the term divine right of kings, this idea that a king has a right to rule because God gave him that right. There are really interesting arguments about the origin of that. Most of those arguments are kind of... look, kings just wanted to rule and then they added some sort of Christian justification to it afterwards.

Speaker 3That's just the way it goes. That's history. That's politics, right? That's power politics. But people started thinking deeply about it. And once you get to the John Locke era, people started saying, you know, I think actually it's the divine right of the people. They didn't use that phrase, but it's the same concept that the people are the ones who rule and God has given them the right to rule. And they started pointing to situations in scripture where they said, look, the Israelites had a collective, they governed essentially as a republic. Again,

Speaker 3you can argue whether that's true or not, but that was the argument.

Speaker 1Well, you got me thinking there because I'm trying to, because you mentioned John Locke and I believe he was a little bit removed from it, but it just, the impression I've been getting and that I've been studying, I've been thinking about it more in the American context, but just the Protestant element of this shift in idea, this like idea that man can be directly connected to the almighty, so to speak, is something that really, I mean, I'm sure there's precedents before this, but obviously it got its

Speaker 1biggest manifestation with Martin Luther and everyone who came after him. The idea that there is no mediator we don't need. I mean, and that's the thing about, and that's what I get into with, because I'm still finishing up this chapter in my thesis about the great awakening and it's different manifestations and how there were different levels or gradations of radicalism within the the awakening from the moderates like Jonathan Edwards to the extreme radicals like James Davenport, like basically rejecting preexisting authority, illegitimate authority, in so many words,

Speaker 1as a sort of matter of course in a lot of ways. And like I said, I think that there's gradations. I think Jonathan Edwards thought that authority mattered, but that there was a personal relationship to be had between man and the divine and this belief i think is at the core of what you're talking about in a lot of ways where like you are essentially making um the case that what washington and the founders recognized was the

Speaker 1divine right of the people is much more important than the divine right of kings and that is derived from this protestant understanding at least of um of uh of of uh of power, I guess, of divine power. Am I, am I, am I on the right track there? Yeah.

Speaker 3Well, I, you know, it's interesting. There's a historian in Harvard, um, Eric Nelson, who, uh, you know, was very instrumental in my research and he talks a lot and I have no idea what his persuasion is, but he's a professor at Harvard and not to say all professors at Harvard are right, but he talks about how he has a book where he talks about, uh, the proliferation of Christian literature and a greater understanding of the Bible fueled in

Speaker 3many ways the rise of republics in the West. And I quote in my book, Washington Circular, in 1783, which would have been, it's at the end of the war, it would have been his farewell address had he not become president and issued his more famous farewell address. But this document, it's a remarkable document because he talks about how He talks about all these trends that led to America existing. It's really a wonderful speech. It's very underrated.

Speaker 3And in this document, he says that there are many reasons why we should celebrate how America came into being. And he traces these long historical trends. He says, you know, the wisdom that we have from the ancients and the modern and the practical experience we've had whether it's from, you know, governance in England, going back to the Magna Carta or in more modern, you know, more recent years,

Speaker 3the colonial legislatures who had self-government. So he talks about the practical experience. He talks about the, you know, the free cultivation of letters, which is kind of a discussion of, you know, the fact that we've had increasing free speech the, the increasing liberality sentiment of, uh, you know, liberality, this idea that people care more about the rights of man than ever before. So he talks about all these great trends that led to America, but he says, what is the biggest trend of all that led to America? And he says, uh, the, the benign light of revelation. So

Speaker 3he's talking about scripture. So he's basically saying scripture is actually the, the biggest influence on how America came to be. Now here's the thing. And, and, You mentioned gradations. We can talk all about the various different theologies out there. I mean, America had everything from Anglicans to, you know, separatists, you know, descendants from the separatist Puritans. They had, they had Baptists, they had, you know, Presbyterians.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 3Presbyterians.

Speaker 1Like, yeah.

Speaker 3And, and were there differences? Yeah, of course. I mean, you know, Sure.

Speaker 1But I was going to say my argument, uh, ultimately that I hope to expand into a dissertation one day is that those gradations just continue to expand and expand and expand into greater, greater, like individualistic expression of, of faith in something. And I think that becomes problematic, the more secular it becomes because you're using absolutist language to talk about things that are not absolute. Whereas, you know, you know, maybe not scripture, but you know, Ideally, the word of God is absolute. So therefore, when you start

Speaker 1to apply that to secular things, it becomes dicey. And I think that that became more clear as time went on. But at the time we're talking about, you see a very, in my opinion, I don't want to use the word perfect, but a very good balance, especially in the form of people like Washington, the founding fathers, because they recognize the importance of of a secular rule and of freedom of conscience, freedom of religion, which.

Speaker 3They saw as part of the Christian worldview. Right. That's what I'm saying. They didn't, they didn't see refute it.

Speaker 1And that's what I, because you can give.

Speaker 3To God was God give to Caesar with a Caesar. There's a legitimate role for both now. Now.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 3And it's interesting. And, but even within that, there were grades. I mean, this goes back to Roger Williams, who was an absolutist when it came to religious freedom, but who also was a Christian.

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 3And, and, So, you know, there were times where a number of founders, Washington included, had no problem with with local taxes being used to support local churches. I mean, you know, so and different founders had different viewpoints on that particular issue. But I think sometimes the gradients can kind of lead us to forget the the broader consensus. And so going back to that to that circular issue. he ends that speech after saying that Revelation was actually

Speaker 3the biggest factor, you know, a greater understanding of Revelation. He then, which is consistent with what Eric Nelson says, Harvard professor, he then ends the speech by saying that, well, the circular rather, he never delivered it as speech, but he ends the circular by saying that, with a prayer, saying that he prays that God would incline Americans to do justice, to love mercy, which is a direct reference to Micah. the book of Micah. And then he says, and to demean ourselves with the same characteristics as the

Speaker 3divine author, divine author referring to Christ, without whose example we can never be a happy nation. Essentially saying in order to be a happy nation, Americans need to imitate Christ. Now he's not making a theological argument that in order to be American, you have to believe in Christ, but he's saying in order to for a country to succeed, you have to have an imitation of Christ's characteristics. Now, here's the counter argument to that. Well, Washington didn't really believe that. His aides wrote that. He signed off on it. Okay.

Speaker 3I mean, I think you're making an assumption there. But Mary Thompson, who I know personally, she was an archivist at Mount Vernon, knows his writings better than anyone, has written on Washington as a slaveholder and has made no bones about Washington's flaws. She says from everything she's read, there's no way Washington, given how meticulous he was, would have allowed that to be in such an important paper without, unless he believed it. And so, you know, you can make what you will of that. And I talk about all this in my book. Ron Chernow, Pulitzer Prize winning historian,

Speaker 3affirms that he's referring to Christ in that document. So all of this is kind of part and parcel of what I write in my book. And, and I think what's so interesting about it is that when you have a country that says the citizen is actually the highest station here, you know, in England, we have a, we have nobility and there's, there's a social hierarchy in America. We're not going to have that. The key to that is for the leader to play that role as citizen

Speaker 3and not to fudge it, You know, not like Caesar Augustus, who says, I'm citizen, but really I'm the dictator. But to have a person that, you know, if we're going to say citizen is the highest station, even a president, even the head of government, even the head of state is going to act in a way that truly shows himself to be a citizen. That proves whether it's really true. The republic really is a system based on equality, on people ruling, the people ruling. Well, for Washington to give

Speaker 3up power, that, that allowed that to be a reality that showed the world.

Speaker 2Yes.

Speaker 3Citizen really is the highest station here.

Speaker 1Yes. Something you mentioned in your book that I want, cause this connects to it kind of, um, that I was really, uh, cause I have heard this argument made before and, uh, I really wanted to get you to relitigate a little bit. Cause you said, uh, it is tempting to think that when the founding fathers created the American government, they did so with a full embrace of democracy, but they did not. So, uh, like How do you, can you expand on that in general, but then also explain like how that fits into what we're talking about here? Cause I think that's a really interesting, another question of balance. I think that they, that they really understood that most

Speaker 1revolutions don't seem to revolutionaries don't seem to.

Speaker 3Yeah, absolutely. I, you know, it's one of those things where when Americans look back at the influences on the founders, they usually say ancient Greece, ancient Rome, um, mainly greece though well what's interesting is is that the founders actually were not huge fans of ancient greece to them ancient greece was an example athens uh specifically of democracy gone awry because democracy and and i mean this has been it's not like this is original to me i mean this has been talked about a lot that the basically

Speaker 3they saw democracy as as tyranny of the majority um and but then they look at all the other systems and said well uh You know, ancient Rome is a better example as a republic, but Rome essentially turned into tyranny of the one under Caesar. They looked at Great Britain as this great example. I mean, a lot of the founders still continue to admire Great Britain and just say, well, with a few tweaks, we could have a better system.

Speaker 3but they saw that with the nobility and the king as a tyranny of the few. And so they believe that this system of mixed government that essentially allowed, that had features of all three, an element of democracy, an element of, I don't want to say aristocracy, but some form of that, and an element of monarchy, if that could check each other, if they could check each other, then you'd have the best that you'd have the best,

Speaker 3like the pros of all of them without the cons, right? Now, in America, we don't have an aristocracy. The founders didn't want that. They wanted it to be a republic. So in their view, there would be a natural aristocracy that would arise because of their merit. And so the it's interesting because the founders themselves, they oscillated within that. It's not like they all came to this agreement immediately about what the government should look like, but you have, you have this system where they overthrew, they, they, they declared independence,

Speaker 3no King. And then they essentially had ruled by legislature kind of with the articles of confederation, but not really because it was really ruled by the States.

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 3And then that created an anarchic situation, which I talk about where, And the government had certain tasks to do to win the war, but didn't actually have the means to do it. So it incurred massive debt. The economy plunged. The country had zero credit, etc. So then they're like, OK, well, look, we need we need something similar. We need a more stable system with a stronger central government. but still diffused

Speaker 3a balance, essentially, right? You need an executive because they had no executive. You need a functioning government, but you still need the states to have their rights protected. So thus they gave us the Constitution. And what's interesting about all of this is that when it came to the office of the presidency, here's the dirty little secret, people won't tell you it, The monarchy, the British monarchy was a model in a sense that because the monarchy in

Speaker 3Britain at the time, for all the talk about how evil George III was, his power was relatively constrained, right? I mean, they already had the office of prime minister. Parliament was really oftentimes in the driver's seat. This is centuries after the Magna Carta, right? And this is about a century after the English Civil War, where the king's power gets more and more constrained, his power to tax, his power to make war. And in order for him to act, I don't want to say the king had

Speaker 3no power, but in order for him to act, the king had to build more of a consensus among his ministers, among parliament, right? So he was not an absolute monarch like in France, right? To the founders, that king... had a certain role and there are certain advantages to that. The first advantage was that parliament was a collection of factions, right? It represented the people per se. I mean, you could argue, I mean, it actually more or less represented kind of

Speaker 3like the upper crust of society, right? And okay, that was good in the sense that Parliament allowed more from the realm to be represented. But what happens to parliament? Well, it just becomes a bunch of factions that seek advantage over each other, right? And so the leading factions don't, you know, they represent certain groups. They don't represent the majority.

Speaker 1It becomes more insular. It doesn't, yeah.

Speaker 2Yes.

Speaker 3Well, it's an aggregate of many groups that are competing, right? Then what happens to parliament? Well, gosh, it's a Congress. It gets corrupt. People want to stay in power. It's the same old story. We see it today, right? So who do you need to check it? You need an executive.

Speaker 1Why?

Speaker 3Because the executive being a unitary figure not only has more energy, but that figure has incentive to represent the whole realm and to check the factionalization of Parliament. And not only that, but that figure becomes a transcendent, unifying figure, right? When Queen Elizabeth II was in power, you had liberals, you had conservatives in the UK, but what's the one thing that about 80% of... people in the UK could

Speaker 3agree upon. Well, we all love the queen, right? Unifying figure, right? Well, the founders felt that the president could play that same role when George, to some extent. Now, when George Washington famously talked about factions and political parties are bad, he was kind of mirroring that image of what a monarch does. A monarch checks the divisions within the country and tries to build a consensus and is a symbol of So that the whole country, whether they're federalist or anti-federalist, whether they're federalist or Jeffersonian, that they can all agree on.

Speaker 3And that was the vision. And Washington, you know, posed as that figure. People talked about how there's a quote where I forgot who it was. I say it in my book that people literally said, you're a monarch in all but name.

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 3And this idea that, I mean, the Constitution actually didn't have a two term limit at all. So the president could theoretically just keep running and almost be an elective monarch. Now, here's the difference, though. I was going to say FDR. You want the positives of that, unifying figure, etc. But the way you mitigate the downside of that, well, why did the founders believe that the monarchy was so corrupted? Well, they believed that the king had a lot of patronage powers because he had a lot of influence, a lot

Speaker 3of informal influence, a lot of influence over the nobility, which then he could have do his bidding. So in America, we didn't have a monarchy. I'm sorry, we didn't have a nobility so that the president couldn't use that. And not only that, but we didn't have massive bureaucracies at the time. Washington had more people working for him in Mount Vernon than he did as president of the United States. He had, what, Jefferson, Knox, Randolph, and Hamilton as his advisors. That's four cabinet members, right? So you'd have the positives

Speaker 3of a monarchy, unifying figure, national, you know, checking factions without the negatives, you know, bureaucracy, corruption, all that kind of stuff. Unfortunately, what then happened was that the country divided so quickly into parties and the presidency ceased to become a unifying figure because then it got captured by the battle of politics, of partisanship. And then in addition to that, over time in the 20th century, we started developing bureaucracies that give the executive branch so much power. Ironically,

Speaker 3people have voted for presidents to fight against that bureaucracy. Just like now, fighting against the deep state.

Speaker 1Or the swamp, as they called it.

Speaker 3Which you could argue was something the founders envisioned because they wanted a president to fight. They created a president in part to check entrenched interests in Congress.

Speaker 1But I was going to say what they also probably would be disgusted by, and this is always the favorite subject of historians and people who love founding father talk, is what would they say about us now? But I really do think they'd be disgusted with how little our legislature is doing its freaking job.

Speaker 3There's a reason that they gave the legislature the power of. going to war, you know, and the power of the purse.

Speaker 1Not that it matters, but, you know.

Speaker 3Yeah, there's a reason. And it's a balance because the founders did give the president significant powers, especially when it comes to being commander-in-chief and chief diplomat. You know, Hamilton in the Federalist Papers talks so much about energy and dispatch and discretion that only a president, only an executive can have. But At the same time, I think especially domestically, you know, there's this great quote that Washington says that he says that when it comes, he says that the

Speaker 3machinery of government is such that the Congress is the first wheel that moves everything else. I think he was mainly talking about domestic legislation that because, you know, the Congress is designed to be closest to the people. So that legislatively, they have the they have the driver's seat, which makes sense, because You want the body closest to the people to drive legislation because you want them to have to debate that. The minute they start creating agencies, they then delegate the power to raise fees, a.k.a. taxes.

Speaker 3That's when you start departing from the founders, which, by the way, they're able to do that because they don't want to have to debate raising taxes.

Speaker 1I was going to say agencies that are not beholden to the American people. I mean, that's, that's one of those, I mean, that's where I think that, you know, not to get into contemporary politics, but I've long been open about my contempt for the administrative state and like how unaccountable it is for, to the people.

Speaker 3And I'm not an antithesis of the system because it's a state that Congress created with the help of the executive and to remove responsibility for themselves, but to still implement their agenda, i.e.

Speaker 1Which I just, yeah, again, I'm not going to get into, that gets me worked up thinking about that.

Speaker 3But I mean, I do think the founders- You think about the unitary theory of the executive, which is the idea that the president has the power over the executive. And they've made this, there's been this attempt to make this some sort of evil, tyrannical thing that, oh, unitary theory, that means the president is a king. No, no, no. What it means is that Congress can't just create bastions in the executive branch that are unaccountable to anybody and that the president has control over the executive branch because guess what? He is the one who's held accountable to

Speaker 3the American people for the executive branch. So if he doesn't have control over the executive branch, then he can't be held accountable. And that's the idea behind the unitary theory theory. but it's been portrayed as this evil thing that, you know, the president is a king and it's like, no, it, all that does is say the president has authority over the executive branch and therefore he can be held accountable for it.

Speaker 1Right.

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 1I mean, and the sense I get though, too, is that I would be more concerned about, you know, you know, all of these things if we didn't have such a strong judiciary. I think that that's another one of those elements that, I really think the founders were extremely prescient about and probably would be happy about to see them not only doing their job, but also in the case of Justice Gorsuch. Basically, I forgot which case it was

Speaker 1because there's been so many, but where he spent most of his time, in his opinion, basically lecturing Congress, saying, you know, we're doing your job here.

Speaker 3Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 1And I love that. That made him my favorite justice right now, just because.

Speaker 3Of that alone. One of my favorite things about Washington, and he set the precedent that the next several presidents followed, was that the president was not the main driver of domestic policy.

Speaker 1Right.

Speaker 3Again, it's the whole clock mechanism. That's a good metaphor, yeah. The Congress... is the first gear that moves everything else. Everything else turns domestically, but only after Congress turns, only after they respond to what the people want. Washington vetoed two bills as president. In both terms? Yeah, yeah. He signed legislation he disagreed with because he believed that, well, if the people want it, they want it, so long

Speaker 3as it's consistent with the Constitution. You know, when the president takes the oath and says, I solemnly swear, execute the office and preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution. Half of that entire oath is preserving, protecting, and defending the Constitution. And that was his job. He was not to input his political views into legislation because that was the purview of Congress. His job was to be a constitutional check on Congress. And so in a letter he wrote Yeah,

Speaker 3there are times that I sign legislation I don't agree with, but that's not my job to agree policy-wise, which I think it takes remarkable restraint. And, you know, one of the ways Washington refused the crown was the fact that here he is at the end of the American Revolution with very clear views on what the country should look like, but he left power because he wasn't going to force it. Well, when he leaves office in 1797... you know, there's an election to replace him, 1796. He has very strong views

Speaker 3on who he prefers personally, never says it in public. This is something the people decide and that election was close the first election to replace washington was the electoral count was 71 to 68 it was like 52 to 40 i mean as.

Speaker 1You mentioned earlier 1800 is even.

Speaker 3Closer yeah well in the in in the contingent election yeah yeah so by then he was dead but in 1796 the election to replace him was very contested he didn't say a thing about it that's not my job that's not my job yeah and and not even again he could have fudged it right he could have been like hey americans uh this is your choice by the way, you know, but, but he didn't. And to me, that is one of the many ways he refused a crown. Uh, not,

Speaker 3not just the literal action of refuse of, of stepping down from power, but you know, he didn't have, he didn't, um, he didn't use the influence that he had that he could have to the extent that he did because he believes so much. And this is what my role is. This is what I'm called to do. And I will go no further. Yeah. Yeah. You know what?

Speaker 1I think that, uh, the best way to, um, close this has been a great conversation and it, it totally went into directions I hadn't intended, but I thought, I think it's much better than whatever I had in my notes there. But, um, it's kind of an obvious question. Um, do you think we should really be hoping for holding out for, or maybe advocating for, uh, you know, future presidents, uh, to be more, uh, inspired by Washington than they perhaps have been for probably both of our lifetimes.

Speaker 3Yeah, absolutely. I mean, you know, it's the thing is, is, is that Washington knew that he was in creating a Republic. This wasn't going to be a situation where he could dictate what should happen or, or even that he would be the model for everything, right? This was going to be a team effort, you know, that, that was the way it was. Um, I think, you know, it's one of those things people don't realize that when he was president, he was criticized a lot. I mean, he was called a traitor to the American revolution.

Speaker 1He was called a tyrant a lot.

Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah.

Speaker 3I mean, that's what happens. That's what happens in a Republic, right?

Speaker 1Of course. Yeah.

Speaker 3In a free society now, but how stunning was it to the world that he did nothing to, you know, attack, like, uh, attack his opponents. Um, with all that said, I would say that, um, I actually wrote an op-ed about this several years ago. I think one of the unhealthiest parts of American politics is the hope that Americans put in their president. I think it's good to expect certain things

Speaker 3out of a president consistent with his job description. You know, important to read Article 2 of the Constitution. But For so long, from the 20th century on, there's been this idea that, oh, once we get this guy in office, he's going to solve our problems. And I think that's so unhealthy. And there's this kind of funny thing that we do every four to eight years where we elect somebody. And it's like, oh, I can't wait. This guy will save us from this or that. And then four to

Speaker 3eight years, the majority of Americans are disappointed. And they keep doing this thing. Or outright angry. Yeah, yeah. And they keep doing this thing. And I just think to myself, well, you know, maybe you shouldn't have put your hope in one person. By the way, that's not how our system works. Maybe you should be putting your.

Speaker 1Hope in your representatives, you know, the first gear, the ones who are closest to you.

Speaker 3Well, you should expect certain things from your representatives. Sure, yeah. But there's... you know, uh, it's one of those things that, but, you know, again, there's also a danger in putting too much hope into them too, you know?

Speaker 1Of course.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1Well, again, it's, it's the whole mosaic. It's the three branches. They need to be working in tandem. One can't be doing more than the others. They need to be a unit. Right.

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 3Right. And, and, you know, there have been presidents that have promised to end war itself, you know, uh, Which, by the way, requires a complete change in human nature, which I don't think you have the part. There have been presidents that have promised to change the, quote, nature of our politics, which again is a promise to change human nature. There's been presidents that have promised to end poverty itself. Not alleviate poverty, but to end poverty itself.

Speaker 3Or to guarantee perfect equality. Not just equality of status, but you know, with the law, but literally like equal outcome. And that's... Which.

Speaker 1Doesn't exist in nature beyond human nature.

Speaker 3I'm sorry, but that's dumb. I mean, it's just dumb. And the proof is that every time you're disappointed, you prove that you put your hope in the wrong place. And so I think a guy like Washington, here's a guy that said constantly, hey, my job as president is to... defend the constitution, execute the will of the American people as passed by the representatives. But, you know, it's not any more than that. I'm not your national Messiah. He

Speaker 3constantly talked about his own deficiencies and wanting to leave and saw power as a burden. And I think having that kind of humility is, will go a long way in just improving our mental health as a country.

Speaker 1Because our political mental health. Yeah. Cause we shouldn't be connecting our mental health to politics as much as we have to. I mean, that's, that's a whole other conversation.

Speaker 3But I'm not saying we shouldn't have expectations. I'm not saying we shouldn't, we shouldn't try to improve. I'm not saying that at all, but, but I think there's, it's important to, to examine, well, what is, what is something that, that we can actually accomplish? And what is something that, hey, you're just promising me the moon to buy votes, to get votes from me? And to me, when someone promises that, I think that's a very unhealthy thing. And it's going to lead to disappointment, disillusionment. And we wonder why every

Speaker 3institution in America, there's less trust in it than literally ever before in our history. We wonder why. And it's because people have not tried to imitate Washington's humility. They've tried to imitate They've tried to found false messiahs, essentially.

Speaker 1Yeah, and that is a problem too, especially when it's clear that– I would go even further. Maybe it's a little too cynical, but I would say that most people who make those promises– they're fully aware that they can't achieve them either. It's just about like, as you said, winning votes.

Speaker 3Now, I don't know what is worse if you did believe that or if you didn't and you, and you're, you know, and yeah, anyways.

Speaker 1Yeah. I mean, I think if you're not, if you don't believe it, at least there's a chance that you could be pragmatic at some point, but I, yeah, I don't know. I, but yeah, I think like being, I mean, I think that would be the, if I was to say based on what you've been saying and what I've read of your book is that if I was to reduce Washington to one word, which I don't know how you do that, but if I was to, it would be pragmatist. Like, and that's really, and I don't mean that in the cynical sense. I think a lot of people have called our presidents pragmatic. I don't think that's

Speaker 1the same kind of higher order pragmatism.

Speaker 3And I think the word for me, I've always thought of the word realist, but, but, but, Because pragmatist has a certain more ideological idea that you can kind of find a middle way between two different views. I don't know if I would agree.

Speaker 1I think realist might be a better word then.

Speaker 3Realist. But here's the thing. Realist is a term that often is associated with lack of.

Speaker 1Morality, right?

Speaker 3Foreign policy, especially. That, I don't think... I think he was a moral realist. But I think the Christian worldview... is a realist worldview because it's a worldview that says, yes, there are uplifting things about us as humans. We're all made in God's image, entitled to rights, but we're all you know broken sinful people and so to me that like it's it's not like realism is like when you look at like let's say like kissinger realism people think

Speaker 3of that yeah it's like divorced from morality i don't see washington like that at all no i don't i mean i.

Speaker 1I did a whole podcast with another uh a conversation with a fellow podcaster uh this um this irish podcaster his friend of mine named zach twomley who um has a podcast called when diplomacy fails and we spent almost three hours talking about less Kissinger realism and more, um, uh, John Mearsheimer style, but it's all the same family. And it's, it's not, I would not associate that with Washington or even morality altogether.

Speaker 3Well, there's, there's this quote. I mean, there are two quotes by Washington. The first is, um, well, there's several, the first, there's a quote from his first draft of his inaugural address, which he, he ended up shelving, but it says that, you know, Americans, uh, should not, um, uh, like seek, uh, you know, to expand.

Speaker 1I have the quote because I wanted to bring it up actually. Cause I can read it to you. If you want me to.

Speaker 3Unless you want to go for it.

Speaker 2Okay.

Speaker 1The American people should guard against ambition as against their greatest enemy. We should not in imitation of some nations wish to aggrandize our own Republic at the expense of happiness, the rest of mankind.

Speaker 3Well, and then, and then in his feral address, he says, um, observe good faith and justice toward all nation, uh, cultivate peace and harmony with all religion and morality enjoying this conduct so he's talking about more you know like this is there's a moral imperative. And then later on in the speech, he says, um, it'll be worthy of a free enlightened and at no distant period, a great nation to give to mankind, the example of a, of a magnanimous people, something to that extent. So he, you know, I don't think he, he was like a non, an

Speaker 3amoral realist, but I think he was a, a moral realist. Um, and so anyways, yeah. And, and, uh, no, no presidential messiahs, please.

Speaker 1Yeah. I think we just prove that, uh, you can't reduce Washington to one word just.

Speaker 3While trying to. So, but, uh, yes.

Speaker 1So thank you again, Richard Lim for talking to me about Washington, this book, Refusing to Crown.

Speaker 3Thanks for having me. Oh, of course.

Speaker 1It's coming out in October, you said. Yes. And obviously I'll be promoting that once it comes out. But in the meantime, people should go check out this American president podcast. You are still doing that podcast, right? Oh, yeah. Okay, just making sure.

Speaker 3It's a little tougher. I became a dad about 10 months ago. Oh, congratulations. Oh, thank you, thank you. That's great.

Speaker 1And doing a book on top of all that.

Speaker 3Well, I mean, I wrote most of it before we were expecting, but my wife gets all the credit there.

Speaker 1Of course.

Speaker 3She's, yeah, and she's taking the brunt of it. But yeah, that's... I mean, getting published is great. Being a dad, even better. Of course.

Speaker 1This is a good year for you.

Speaker 3So, yes. Well, I'm deserved.

Speaker 1Yeah, I'd love to have you on again talking about God knows what. Maybe once I finish this thesis, we'll have a lot more to talk about with America's Christian history because it is intense, to put it mildly, as I've been learning. But anyway, thank you again, Richard. And we will speak again soon.

Speaker 3Thanks again. Thank you for having me.

Speaker 2Thank you. Hey, everybody.

Speaker 1Thanks again for listening. And as always, please remember to subscribe to History Impossible if you haven't already. And please consider supporting the show if you like what I do here. Just a nice thank you to all the lovely people who have been supporting this show at the Comrades and Friends level or above. And that includes the following. Bob Downing, Sam Graham, Greg Hunter, S.O., Skip Pacheco, Molly Pan, John Passano,

Speaker 1Anna R., PJ Rader, Matthew M. Rice, Philip Rice, John Andre Sather, Emily Schmidt, and Pierre Vopouni.

Speaker 3If you want to.

Speaker 1Support this show, head over to patreon.com slash historyimpossible or historyimpossible.com and become a paid subscriber or patron at any level that.

Speaker 3You see fit.

Speaker 1Thank you again for listening to this amazing conversation that I had with Richard Lim of the This American President podcast and the author of the forthcoming book, Refusing a Crown, How George Washington Changed the World, coming out this October in 2026, on the 13th specifically. So yeah, if you really liked what you heard today, consider picking that up. I think it's worth it. It's a really good book, and Richard's a good guy, and I love chatting with him. So yes, please stay tuned for future episodes of History

Speaker 1Impossible coming very soon.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Third Reich Diagnosis

    Nov 19, 20262 hr 8 minAudio

    Understanding evil is something that has preoccupied humans for a long time. By the mid-20th century, the desire to root it in firm, social scientific terms became the norm, particularly in the field of psychology. The...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Millennials: The Trauma Generation

    Sep 30, 202652 minAudio

    Hey everyone. No preamble here. Just a nice bonus as a thank you for your continued support. As the title suggests, this is an audio adaptation of an essay I wrote about the 25th anniversary of 9/11 and how it led me to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Firebombing of Tokyo: Our Imperative Atrocity

    Sep 22, 20263 hr 21 minAudio

    We often hear about how the Second World War was more morally nuanced and complex than we have been led to believe. This is, to a certain extent, very true. The Axis powers meted out a level of genocidal destruction and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Orthodox ISIS: The Russian Religious Experience (w/ Kristaps Andrejsons of The Eastern Border)

    Aug 18, 20261 hr 48 minAudio

    “Because remember: Russia is a religious experience.” Those are the oft-repeated and well-said words by the host of The Eastern Border podcast, my good friend Kristaps Andrejsons. They are well-said because there are...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Ideological Pathology of Antizionism (w/ Kile Jones)

    Aug 11, 202656 minAudio

    Antizionism, as it has become, has been having a bit of a moment for going on three years. It is a tough nut to crack, given its various claims of varying legitimacy and, as we have covered more than once on History...

    Credit the people on this episode