Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

History Impossible

History Impossible artwork

The Riddle of American Identity (w/ David Josef Volodzko)

Jul 15, 20261 hr 6 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

I recently wrote a piece exploring the concept of American identity, primarily through the prism of the immigrant experience, and it got me thinking more about the complexities of American identity, so I wanted to chat with someone who I know has discussed these matters at length. This resulted in a great conversation with the awesome David Josef Volodzko of the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE) and The Radicalist Substack, where we tackled all sorts of angles, including ethnic enclaves, assimilation, patriotism, the collision of values, and the nuances of free speech and freedom of association, all in the context of understanding American identity and the importance of what David calls the constellation of our values. There were some moments of (very mild) disagreement, but I felt like I learned a lot and it helped me defend my own position while considering alternatives that had not previously. Because it is America’s 250th Anniversary Month, I felt like this would serve as an excellent addendum to my Fourth of July reflections, and wanted to share it with all of you amazing subscribers and supporters, completely free. Please check out and support David’s work, and, if you can, support what FIRE does. And please stay tuned very soon for a new episode of History Impossible! Also I will be in Philadelphia at FIRE’s Student Network Conference July 17-19, so if you’re in the area, drop me line here; I may be able to venture out for a meet up. Thanks again, as always, for listening. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/history-impossible--5634566/support.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Hey, everybody, I'm just here to give a quick introduction to this very special and very impromptu conversation that my friend and comrade David Joseph Voladsko.

Speaker 2And I had. It was sort of like something we were both thinking about a lot during this two hundred and fiftieth birthday of the United States, and that is American identity. You guys might have caught my recent post on the History Impossible subsecond Patreon where I was talking about quote unquote beer and hot dogs, and yeah, it really got me thinking about a lot of things, and I thought there was no one better to talk to about this stuff than David, who has been writing a

Speaker 2lot about this. David, in case you guys have somehow missed it, is not only the man behind the Radicalist and a guest on History Impossible a couple of years back, and one who's had me on his show, but he also works with the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression head of their news department, and he's doing a great job there too, And yeah, I just wanted to talk to him about this stuff.

Speaker 1We cover all sorts of.

Speaker 2Things, including history, immigration, American identity obviously is the big topic, but also free speech and a lot of just varied topics that we didn't really prepare in any depth for We just wanted to have a sort of free, willing conversation and I wanted to share it all with you. Find people who subscribe to the show, both freely and through paid subscriptions and support on Patreon, this is a great bonus. I want to say Happy Birthday to America, and that's sort of what prompted this. So I guess

Speaker 2what we're doing here. So thank you again for listening, and please enjoy this conversation with the amazing David Joseph Voladsko. So, David, let me ask you a very very tough question that I think we all grapple with a lot, and I know you and I have talked about it in our respective life and also with each other. What does it mean to be an American?

Speaker 3Oh? Well, different things to different people. I suppose you have the civic nationalism belief that we all share certain values, we all are bound by the contract of the Constitution, and beyond that, you could be you could be anything else. You know, there's the there's the expression that you know that person's an American, they were just born in the wrong place, meaning that they they have these values and will take anyone from anywhere as long as you're willing

Speaker 3to come here, join the party, we want you. And I think that's that's the kind of pluralism and diversity and sort of bring in all the immigrants that I tend to subscribe to with well, with maybe one caveat, but generally my attitude is like, yeah, look, you want to be an American, then brothers and sister, you're already half Roay an American just just because you want you want to join the club. This is not a this

Speaker 3is not blood and soil. This is this is more about ideology, and so if you believe it, come on over. And then there's always then there's ethnic nationalism, which I'm not opposed to. There's Israel and Japan or examples of societies that I think are excellent places, and they are ethnic nationalist societies or ethno states, more or less.

Speaker 2Sometimes by default, not by design. Because in Israel's case, it's interesting because that gets into the complication of Jewish identity, which is a whole other conversation because obviously being a Jew means a lot of things. It's religious, of course, which has its own separations, you know, reform conservative Orthodox to be as reductive as possible. But ethnic Jews have ethnicities like within themselves. Obviously, I believe the I think it's a plurality in Israel as Mizrahi or Erab essentially.

Speaker 2And then you have Ashkenazi, who I believe you and I are both descended from, if I remember correctly. And then you have you know, the other ones like Ethiopian Jews and Sephardic Jews, and those are all for all intents and purposes, ethnically diverse. But it is a sort of, like I said, like like I was saying, it's complicated, and like you were saying, it is still an ethno state in that sense, or a religious ethno state, and that does make it controversial with a lot of people and allows it to become kind of a talking point

Speaker 2against its validity. Japan's a great example, though, because that's just you know, that just kind of happened over time and just naturally, especially as an island nation. And I get the feeling, and I know you've spoken about this, so maybe you can speak to this a little better than me. But that's sort of what happened with England or Great Britain perhaps for a while until recently it started to change in the last fifty years or so, and that's been obviously very controversial. Adding with like the layers of complexity with you know, things like the colonial

Speaker 2and imperial past that they had, can make it a little harder for them to like have their idea of being British see be seen as a defensible in a lot of cases. But yeah, I think what you're saying is ethno nationalism isn't necessarily a bad thing. But I assume, and I'm sorry to have jumped on this, but it just was really interesting to me. I assume what you're saying is that that doesn't really apply to the United States. We can't really look at it that way, ethn No,

Speaker 2unless we're going to start say, in America is an ethnicity, which maybe it will be.

Speaker 3It's no, No, I don't, I don't. I wouldn't go there. I wouldn't say. But I did say, there's a caveat, and the caveat is that I'm a civic nationalist who is not who doesn't think that ethno nationalism is inherently evil, as some people do, to the degree that Japan is an ethno state. I don't regard Japan as being evil, and I don't think that Japan has to become more white, or more black, or more Latino in order to be more acceptable to us morally. I don't think so at all,

Speaker 3perfectly fine for it to stay ninety nine percent Japanese forever. But I do think that there are certain ethnicities that putting aside. Obviously, let me do a little throad clearing here. Individuals, individuals are different. Individuals are to be taken on an individual basis. I'll give you an example that is in the news cycle of late Somali's so one of my great heroes who I had the honor of interviewing Ion here. Cili is Somali, but her value system she embraced. She

Speaker 3did not choose to grow up and come to the West and be an avatar for Somali values in Somali tradition. She came to the West and embraced those values. And we are I mean, thank god she did. We're all better for it. That's what I mean. So, But but if you ask the question, okay, well then that's great. Let's bring over as many Somalis as we can possibly take. Then I would say, wait a minute, Wait a minute, no, uh, as a group, generally speaking, Somali culture is not compatible with American culture. They don't share the values that we share.

Speaker 3So that's an example of an ethnicity that as a generalization, let's be clear, but still as a generalization, they're not American, and they're they're not. I don't mean they're not American by citizenship. I mean in the deeper sense like they're they're almost antithetical to American And so if they were to come over and maintain their smaller identity, they're not Americans in that deeper philosophical sense, and they can't become Americans unless they give up a significant portion of those

Speaker 3things that are in direct conflict with American values. So there are certain ethnicities out there. To the degree that they are you know, that they have those traditions and those values and those religious practices or whatever that are just antithetical to things like you know, equality under the law, do process, freedom of speech, or what have you. Then no, that's not those are not American values. And then to the degree that we choose to define America as having those values rather than being racial or or you know,

Speaker 3by by simply virtue of the fact that you were born here, then then they're not Americans. So in America, however, we under the fourteenth Amendment, we have you know, we have the right of soil, We have the idea that if you're born here, you're American. Yes, of course I wouldn't want to see that taken away. I am a product of that myself. But I am an Americ. But there but I'm an American. I'm a citizen, but I'm also an American in the deep sense like I and I don't mean a legacy. I'm very much not. Both

Speaker 3sides of my family immigrants, Like I'm the first generation on one side, and my father was a first generation. My mother is not American. So you don't go far back at all, and so you until it's not American. So but it's important. So I very much am in favor of that. But also I think it is incumbent upon all people who are here and who come here to not treat it as merely an economic zone, to

Speaker 3not treat it as merely a place to take advantage. And we should certainly be concerned about people who are coming here to take advantage or even do harm to America, which is a serious concern. But so.

Speaker 2Well, can I can I jump in really quickly because I think I might have met me. Yes, I know you now because you published a piece I wrote about this. I'm from Minneapolis, which is I believe the highest percentage of smalling in immigrants in the country. Maybe that's shifted over to Michigan or something in the past. I'm not sure, but I mean I grew up when the first wave of I mean there were refugees really because of what was going on in the early nineties in Somalia, not

Speaker 2just famine, but just you know, seems like constant civil war and unrest and everything too. But what you're getting at is something I wrote about in the piece I wrote on fourth of July because I had to spit something out because I was like, Okay, it's two hundred fiftith anniversary. I got to say something. I got to think about this, and then it got me on this tangent of what does it mean to be an American? And I think what you're describing is a product of enclaves, ethnic enclaves or religious enclaves to a certain degree, though I think that that's a little different because that is more credal And we have, you know, religious enclaves all

Speaker 2over the country and there's no issue. But I think that when immigrants come to this country go into enclaves, which can be normal, I think that that makes sense, especially if not everybody speaks the language, It makes sense to do that as a practical concern. But when those enclaves don't diversify and or disintegrate, that's when it becomes a problem because then what is happening with that enclave is by being part of it and by being outside of it, it's a reciprocal situation. I think what's happening

Speaker 2is you're essentially communicating to the majority and I don't mean ethnic majority, I mean the majority of everybody outside of the enclave, that you are not interested in absorbing these values that you're talking about this American News. What you're saying is, well, no, I want to keep everything that made my old culture what it was, for better or worse. And while I might follow the law, and in a lot of cases it doesn't happen. I mean, we had a controversy, it's almost like a decade ago

Speaker 2now about I don't want to call it epidemics. I don't know the numbers, but there was a controversy about a non zero amount of female genital mutilation going on within the Somali community in Minneapolis. And ilhan Omar, who I was a of long before everybody else was, because she was a local city council person, I want to say she famously voted famously in Minnesota at least voted against criminalizing FGM because it would have unfairly targeted the Somalian community, to which I'd say, well, maybe they shouldn't

Speaker 2be doing something that we that's against the law, you know, and something that's oppressive in a lot of ways. So and that's what I'm getting at is that I think that like when things like that happen, and especially when nothing is done about it to reinforce this idea of cultural heterogeneity but also civic homogeneity, I think what you're going to get is a clash, and that clash can't be overcome unless people start to I think engauge in

Speaker 2what I was calling reciprocal enthusiasm for each other's cultures, and an enclave prevents that an enclave, and maybe it doesn't prevent it literally because you could maybe go into some enclaves and then have a sort of give and take situation, but that's not what the what the messaging is when there is an enclave, it is a way of making oneself a part. And I know the French have done have gone to some pretty extreme lengths culturally and I think even legally to prevent things like that from happening, not very effectively from what it sounds like.

Speaker 2But where like you become a French citizen, you have to be French like, you have to really adhere to these standards and these ideas of being a French person, you're ethnics.

Speaker 3I think they I'm not.

Speaker 2Going to say what they do, but they look down on the idea of ethnic identifiers in a lot of ways. They have historically. I don't know if they still do as much, but.

Speaker 3They don't really. My understanding is that the French, they don't French society, you don't. They don't really do much to eliminate these enclaves at all. I mean, if you run France like, they're quite it's even more severe than American in some ways. But they have a very sharp line between public and private life, so you'll see like teacher in high school removing their wedding rings or their crosses off their necks or things like that. If you're Jewish, you don't wear a yeomac, you know, so publicly everyone is this kind of neutral French and there's even a

Speaker 3kind of I mean, it's not a stereotyde like, there really is a kind of French uniform of like the black turtleneck and this sort of like a lot of French people dressed similarly. It's not as popular in France as it is in America for every single person to have their own kind of look, and I actually find that kind of attractive. You walk around France and you see everyone kind of dressed somewhat. There's like an aesthetic to the society. Where's in America it's just such a jumble of everyone doing their own thing. It doesn't have that beauty. But the point is we also express who we are wherever we go. So, but going back to

Speaker 3one of the things you said, I think I wanted to push back a little. I'm not even sure if pushback because maybe you'll just readily agree with me. But I don't see the problem with an enclave. In fact, I like a little bit of the salid bowl instead of the melting pot. I like if I'm driving along and I say, oh, here's the Korean neighborhood. Cool, Like you know, if I see the Italian neighborhood, that's great. My way of looking at it is that we just need to have a constellation of values that are non negotiable, and if you can't subscribe to these values, you need

Speaker 3to get the fuck out of here. But those values should be as few as they can be while us while still being able for us to maintain a healthy society. So there's going to be we want that to be a very short list so that we can maximize the wiggle room that people from different cultures have to be themselves and have their own claves and have their culture and have their different practices and they're different religions and they're different whatever, and do their own thing. But there's a few non negotiables, like you're not going to come

Speaker 3here and mutilate women. We will arrest you, if not kill you, if not to port you. But you're not doing it here. We're not tolerating that. Although, of course, if you're illin omar, then you think we should tolerate that. I find that disgusting. There need to be certain like we protect the people who are here, we protect their basic rights. Similarly, we wouldn't want someone to come here. We wouldn't want people from some European country coming here and importing a bunch of like white supremacist violence, terrorism or something.

Speaker 2Zero tolerance or the British tolerance for a lack of free speech, so to speak. Right, that's more that's a political thing. But I mean, I've talked to British people who legitimately like kind of think our idea of free speech is insane, which I think is fascinating. And I you know that that's a whole like cultural thing too. I think that is non negotiable, and they tend to be better at, you know, just sort of accepting that.

Speaker 2But I've met more than one British person who just does not like our values it comes to free speech. They really believe in the idea of we should be doing more to curb hate speech, to which I always say, well, if we did that, Martin Luther King would have been suited to oblivion, because that was a real concern. And I don't even like calling X that gives it credence, but that was a concern white supremacist liked the voice about him and other civil rights leaders back in the day. If memory serves, it.

Speaker 3Really comes down to a kind of almost libertarian way of looking at it, whereby what we want to do is set up a framework or have this constellation of value such that if we maintain those few values, then that's what gives people the freedom to do all the things and be all the things that they want to be. So freedom of speech is a great example of that. As long as we have that, everyone will have the ability to express themselves under those protections. They'll have the ability to where what they want to wear, and be

Speaker 3who they want to be, and all of those things. So that's something that if we want to have this diverse salad bowl or melting pot or whatever you like, if we want to have that, then we really want to protect something like free speech.

Speaker 2Well, and this is where I go so far as to say that if community leaders in the Somali enclave communities in Minneapolis, if they want to have FGM female general mutilation legal under the law under the you know, we could say, you know, religious protection. If they really wanted that they are free to advocate for it. I mean, and we're free to say that's insane and horrible, but they're free to advocate for it and try to push it forth through the legal channels. They can't just do it.

Speaker 2That's sort of the distinction there. But I only say that I think because I'm confident that it wouldn't get very far. But at the same time, you know, political rhetoric is the way it is that it could help manipulate people into agreeing that that is something people should be allowed to do. And also it involves children, which is you know that that kind of takes agency away, so it kind of gives a life of a free speech issue in that respect.

Speaker 3This is why I think that there is some intersection there's like political intersectionality where you can't so for instance, I don't think I think that if you are a there's plenty of people who will disagree with me. But if you are a stout defender of certain rights such as freedom of expression or do process or whatever, then that's going to determine your position on other issues that may not seem immediately related, like immigration, Like you simply

Speaker 3cannot say that you are a free speech warrior and have a very liberal attitude to immigration, where you're willing to allow in, let's say, an unlimited number of people who support sharia, because that's the end of those freedoms, right, So obviously you have to think ahead just one step. Okay, we don't want that. Similarly, I'm in favor of democracy, of course, and but I am not in favor of democracy to such an absolutist extent that if people decided

Speaker 3to democratically elect in sharia law, and now my daughter is going to have to live in a literal rape. No, no, actually, I think that's time for us to pick up starts and go to war and democracy. Okay, now we have to kill some people because we're not going to just stand by and let a bunch of people like democratically elect in the next Hitler or something. You don't just say what that was democracy? The problem is so then the tricky part is that this is these some of these arguments are the things that you hear already on the left with regard to people like Donald Trump or

Speaker 3Charlie Kirk, like we need to we need to get violent because it's gone too far. My response to that is not. Well, they're completely wrong. My response is, actually, yes, there does come a time when war is just, even civil war can be just. We had a civil war in this country, and we fought over something that was worth fighting for the liberation of our black brothers and sisters. But where they get it wrong is they just draw the line in the wrong place. They're just way too

Speaker 3early or too sensitive. I would argue they're willing to kill over an opinion rather than over something like what I'm talking about is like the actual literal physical destruction of women's bodies, or you know, genocide or something like something at that level of extreme. But there does come a point at which there have to be limitations on democracy, limitations on things like freedom's limitations where other things. In order to preserve those we have to make other considerations

Speaker 3so that there's back to the argument about like who's an American and who should we let in? Well, if we want America to be this free place where everybody can come in and everybody can get along, because we have a system that makes it so that we can all be who we want to be and say our thing, and you can go to a restaurant, you'll have like ten different people from different parts of the world, and it's like, that's beautiful. You want to have that. Then you can't allow people in who are going to want to.

Speaker 2Well, I'll bend the values that we all share. Yeah yeah, well.

Speaker 3Or you sorry to right. What Israel has done, which is not my it would not be my number one choice. But what Israel has done is they basically put in place certain legal structures such that they will not lose control. So it's like, yeah, sure, you can let people in as long as you know you can maintain control and you can always have those freedoms. Or you can just stop them at the gate, which is what I would prefer, so that we don't have to we don't have to compromise our democracy on the inside. But then you have

Speaker 3to stop people at the door and say you're not coming. Look, you're not coming into my house. You're obviously, I could see you've got some knives in your back pocket. I can see you're drunk like this, there's kids inside. You're not coming in this house, all right, you know. But and if you and if you stop them at the gate, then you can have a much more peaceful, open, high trust society. On the inside, you can have that utopian diverse whatever the problem is, it seems, and I see it especially in the left, people seem to want to have it both ways.

Speaker 2Yeah, I don't think they think about it very carefully when people start thinking about those things, like what you're saying. I mean, I do think though, that we do have some good structures in place. I mean, if I remember correctly, the Founding fathers were not exactly fond of democracy, either democracy and the literal sense of the of the of the term. They they were very I mean I think some were more democratic than others, Like Jefferson was maybe a little more democratic than Adams, and that was like a big among many things, that was a big source of their sort of division on stuff. But yeah, the idea of tyranny of the majority is a very real thing.

Speaker 2And if the majority comes to believe something that by definition upends the values that has kept us going for two hundred and fifty years, then that is something concerning. And I don't think we have that. In fact, some ways, I think our polarization protects us from that right now. But at the same time, I think polarization breeds a lot of desire for easy answers like what you're talking about. I think am a far too liberal or a far too restrictionist view on immigration. For example, I think, yeah, you're right that having like a sort of values test

Speaker 2is it makes me squeamish as an American. But I also really like the anecdotes of I believe it was the I think it was either the Netherlands or Denmark. They had a test essentially that was basically saying, can you assimilate to our values? And one of them was saying, okay, watch this video of two men kissing. Can you handle that? And if you can't, well, that's a mark against you. I'm becoming a citizen here, and I think that something like that is silly as it kind of sounds. Also is a sort of way to deal with those kinds

Speaker 2of issues. But people get around that by line, I suppose, but I don't think they We're going to lie necessarily.

Speaker 3And even if it enrages you so much you can't even cover it up to get into the country, then you definitely should not be allowed in the country, right, Yeah, And your outrage and you're just you wanna I mean, let me think about that. I'm not against homophobic people coming into the country, because that would be you know, that's a belief. It's just if there's an indication that they would act on it, right, right.

Speaker 2Yeah, And how do you test for that? That's the difficulty, because I mean, behavior is something that is I mean, I've talked about this actually with regards to free speech. I was very inspired by should we call him the Fearless Leader of Fire, Greg Lukianov and what he's talked about in a lot of ways. And I read the founder of Fire or co founder of Fires book Shadow University about this stuff and talked about it, and I was just thinking, like I think, when it comes down to it, I end up taking kind of a maximalist

Speaker 2position on free speech related to these things where I'm honestly convinced, and maybe you can push back because I have honestly, I don't think I've ever met anybody that fully jumps on board with this with me. But I don't think that rhetoric causes behavior. I just I don't see the evidence for it. I base it on stuff I did when I was researching for my psych degree years ago. I was more looking at media exposure and violent behavior with adolescens, and there just isn't evidence for it, at least from the you know, studies I was looking

Speaker 2at back then, which are many many years old now, so maybe things have changed, but there doesn't seem to be good evidence for the idea that something like hate speech, for example, causes people to become hateful. They tend to already be hateful and it just reinforces their belief and now that can be you know, questioned and interrogated and you know, condemned even But at the same time, I think it's either we have free speech include all of these things, or we don't. I really kind of have a binary view on this stuff. And when it comes

Speaker 2down to this idea that maybe people coming into this country who are going to say things that are going to convince other people to be less democratic, I just don't really buy it, for example, or be less American. I guess I think that most people who buy into that self destructive stuff are already self destructive in terms of their national identity, if that makes sense. That's why you see the so called Red Green Alliance or Green Brown Alliance that I will bang on about a bunch,

Speaker 2where you see people who are for all intents and purposes, a lot of the time quote unquote heritage Americans espousing some of the most anti American stuff that you can see out there. They're already on board with anything that is anti American. So they will make common cause with in the case that I'm in the example I'm making with Islamists, with outright America hating Islamists because they see this sort of enemy of my enemy is my friend mentality being beneficial to them, which is obviously naive. All

Speaker 2you got to do is look at Iran's history for how that worked out with the you know, the the leftists and and even just straight up democrats who aligned with uh Kamani and the Islamist they how did that work out for them? Well, they were killed by the thousands after the revolution occurred. So I just I'm I'm kind of spinning my wheels here in a lot of ways. So and I think I gave you a lot to respond to there. But that's sort of how I see it is that I don't think we have to be worried about people convincing anyone to be less democratic. I

Speaker 2think it's just more people who are already in that place.

Speaker 3I disagree.

Speaker 2Oh interesting, Okay, Okay, I'm going I'm gonna have to defer to you a little bit more too, because you're you're with fire officially.

Speaker 3Oh no, not not in that capacity. I just okay, okay. My view is that I think that uh, rhetoric does influence behavior. I think that we've I think that we've seen in countless ways overton windows shift. I think rhetoric of a teacher, for instance, can influence the students, and that's how indoctrination often happens. I think rhetoric of people around you. Now there's a phrase that I like, it's useful and we didn't have it before, which is to talk about permission structures. Yeah, and grant, I think that

Speaker 3you can create permission structures in the way that you talk. I think that within two years, if everybody started like using racial epithets more often, it would become more common, simply because you sort of see in the in the in the waters you're swimming in that it's just oh okay, so that's okay to do.

Speaker 2Now.

Speaker 3One example of this being the return of the word retard. Yes, it was like untouchable. Now, well, the people on the left don't really say it, but people on the right seem to be using it like they used to in the eighties. And this is just, this is just, I mean, this is how lang which operates. It's very much and language influences how you think about things and the way you describe things. And that's sort of the truth of the political correct movement is the recognition of the power of language, which is true. So I think that it is very much the case that rhetoric does have a

Speaker 3profound impact on behavior. The question then is okay, well, if that's I mean, oh. Another example is Gregory Stanton's Ten Stages of Genocide. He highlights the importance of rhetoric as a central part of the escalation up the stages through genocide. It's how you talk about people, it's what you call them. So when people complain in America about anti white rhetoric, that's not something to be brushed off and say, oh, that's not going to translate into behavior.

Speaker 3It already has, and we already see violence towards white people. We see in the in the UK and other places where there's a hesitance to even punish people if the if the victim is wide, or if it's turned around the other way. And I don't doubt for a second that a lot of this, if not all of it, is the result of the kind of woke rhetoric that has convinced so many people that if the attacker is black, let's say, they must be oppressed in some way, or they don't fit into the oppressed box, then we have

Speaker 3to sort of rethink or you know, all of this has to do with the rhetoric around these things. The question then becomes, Okay, then should we have like hate speech legislation if that's true, and because the argument of for hate speech legislation is that rhetoric does translate into negative behavior and we don't want that behavior, so we don't want that rhetoric. And I suppose one way you could argue that would be to say, well, there is no connection there, so we shouldn't have those laws. It's

Speaker 3like saying video games have no impact on behavior violent video games.

Speaker 2That was mainly what I was studying when I when I was doing that, as video games and just violent media in general.

Speaker 3There is there is act that is the data there is a little more mixed. Based on what I've looked, it's a little more mixed, like there is there is something behind if you if you are exposed to enough violence and enough violent villaid games, video games, or enough violent movies, it does have a cloying effect.

Speaker 2You do. There's a desensitization that does occur that was already found for real like that, that's that's without question true. But there is also evidence that suggests that violent video games in particular help curb violent behavior. I don't know how strong that evidence is and I haven't looked into that. So the fact that it's kind of both ways there does kind of make me err more on the side of what I was going with there. But I like how you put.

Speaker 3It too, because quick, I mean, I just wanted to say, you still have to answer the question about what do we do about hate speech laws?

Speaker 2Right right right?

Speaker 3And so for me it's not I think it's it's wrongheaded to say, well, rhetoric has no impact on behavior, therefore we shouldn't have these laws. For me, the argument goes like this, rhetoric does have an impact on behavior. So the other side, I mean, as much as we can, we should always try to give credit where credit is due on the other side or your side, or what you know. So the other side from where I am on this issue, people who want these laws and acted like they have a point. Rhetoric does lead to the things that they're worried about. They're right about that, but what they've forgotten to consider is the harm of having

Speaker 3those laws and what that does and how that can be abused by the state. You have to do a cost benefit analysis on both sides. And so although I acknowledge that some rhetoric can lead to certain types of behavior, I don't. For instance, I would not fall into the Viymar fallacy of saying that oh was it was having people walking around and saying hateful things that led to Nazi Germany. No, Actually, the first thing the Nazis did and they got in power starts censoring things.

Speaker 2Well, and I was going to say, there was a lot of hate speech laws on the books in Vymar, and that didn't really do much to stop them exactly.

Speaker 3So the hate speech laws is a cure that's worse than the disease in my opinion. Yes, you're right, rhetoric can lead to certain behaviors, but giving this state a gigantic club to prevent that very real thing from happening is far worse situation than trying to combat that rhetoric. As has famously been said, the solution to bad speech is good speech. So you combat that rhetoric by jumping

Speaker 3into the marketplace of ideas and entering the debate. That's the best way to do it. One of my favorite examples is Frank Capra was commissioned by the War Department to produce propaganda to sort of counter the likes of Lenny Riefenstalls, which it was Nazi propaganda, but it was still incredibly good film work.

Speaker 2I hate to say it every time it comes up, but I'm like, Triumph of the Will is a really good movie.

Speaker 3It's very well I mean, yes, revolutionized Hollywood, Like a lot of the things you see in modern action filming is from that movie. And so yeah, so again credit where credit is? Do? I suppose? But the War Department recognized, like we need our propaganda needs to be not just morally correct, but it needs to be like good watching and lost sight of that. I think made a series

Speaker 3of movies and or clips. I should say they weren't like full length, but anyway, he made this series and in the series he included Nazi speeches and Nazi reports and all this stuff, And the War Department was like, what are you doing. You can't be putting Nazi propaganda into our propaganda. That doesn't make any sense. You're giving your as they would say in modern parlance, you're platforming their views. What are you doing their views like, ignore them, censor them? And he I think he was correct. He said, no,

Speaker 3you don't censor them. The best thing you can do to a Nazi argument is hold it up on high so everyone can see it. Because if you don't have enough faith in humanity to believe that humans properly informed will make the right decision, then why are you even fighting for humanity in the first place. If you think that what's in their heart truly is that they're going to lean in the direction of nazisom then why are we even fighting. You know, you have to at least fundamentally believe that humans are worth saving and that if they just have the right information, that we can reason our way through this. So so yeah, So my argument

Speaker 3is that's why, even though rhetoric can lead to those things, more sunlight would be my response.

Speaker 2Well, and that actually is interesting because the premise of that, I was going with the rhetoric doesn't cause behavior. I should be clear, it's correlated, But I'm taking the side of like, well, because it's not causal, like definitively least as I saw it, That's why I would go with, say, and it doesn't cause it. But that's just that's splitting hairs. The broader point I think is interesting is that I made the conclusion I came to when I when I wrote that and podcast about that, is well, look, I could be wrong, and I'm open to being wrong, and

Speaker 2you made a good argument that I want to jump back to in a second. But my concluding point was, even if it's true that rhetoric causes behavior, that's a trade off, Like I'm willing to take that trade off for the principle of free speech because it's so vital and because, as you said, it allows us the opportunity to hold up, say, for example, Nazi propaganda films and let them be self evidently scrutinized and obviously be given a counter So I think that at the end of

Speaker 2the day, like, even if it's true, we are engaging in a unique experiment in i'll say, human history. But I'll just say political history of maximizing freedom of expression. To I would say about as good of an extent as we can. I don't want to get rid of the imminent threat provisions. I think that those are good, those should be in there as restrictions on free speech. So I do have a line. But I do think that there is a reason that we are unique in

Speaker 2respect to our beliefs on speech, and I think it's that we are saying, most of us, that we like the trade off or are willing to live with that trade off. But you did mention a really good way of framing disagreement with what I was saying, which is that rhetoric creates permission structures. And that is interesting to me because I think that that is probably true. My gut instinct is to say that that's probably true, or at least it helps contribute. I mean, I will never say that it doesn't contribute, because it absolutely contributes to

Speaker 2creating new permission structures. So to that, i'd say, really, then, yeah, the best solution to dealing with those permission structures is I would say, both sunlight like you're saying, we'll keep it concise with that, but also reinvigorating that sense of civic nationalism that you were talking about earlier on. And I think just having to be a free for all without advocating strongly for the civic nationalist virtues of being

Speaker 2an American, that's what creates disintegration or self destruction, or if you want to get really edgy with the phrasing, as many authors have, suicide like national suicide or civilizational suicide. Even you can't live without standards. So even though I'm a pretty big free speech maximalist, I do believe that you need to establish standards and practices, so to speak. And that's really what I think is at the core of the tension when it comes to identifying what it

Speaker 2means to be an American, is really making those standards and practices felt. And I just don't think we've been doing that very well. And there's all sorts of reasons for that. I won't speculate. I haven't thought about that too deeply. A lot of it has to do with academia, though I do agree with you on that, and you know, those people then getting into media and therefore having an outsized influence on creating these permission structures just by virtue of existing in a lot of ways. So yeah, I think that's the that's the difficulty there. I want to

Speaker 2let you respond to that, But I also wanted to jump into what we were initially talking about before we recorded, as a sort of perspective on what it means to be an American being easier to understand from an international perspective, particularly from people who are international in and of themselves, like family members who have immigrated here and then have done the immersion, the reciprocal enthusiasm, the buying into the civic nationalist ideal of America. But yeah, if you have anything to respond to is what I was saying a

Speaker 2moment ago, please do and otherwise we can jump into that international p.

Speaker 3I largely agree with what you were saying.

Speaker 2Okay, great, so I'm right good.

Speaker 3This circles back to an earlier point I was making sure about how when different groups of Americans, if I'm reading the question correctly, different groups of Americans come here to join this civic nationalist project. Fantastic. The right veers into racism on this topic. Sometimes that's the danger I see on the right. There's a protectionism that can become over the extreme and On the other side, what I see as a liberalism that becomes blind, where they're not

Speaker 3able to acknowledge the fact that not all groups are the same, not all groups are equally amenable to what we have going on here. You know, a South Korean is going to blend into America modern day South Korean far better than a modern day Pakistani person. It's not to say that there aren't many, many, many Pakistani people who would be wonderful and welcome editions that would make it.

Speaker 2You're not saying that people can't. You're just saying that there's cultural incentives that make it harder for some groups to do so.

Speaker 3Yes, pistically speaking, a randomly selected Pakistani person is probably not going to be a very good addition to America, because they are if they are culturally if their values are of Pakistan, or their values are of Somali. I mean, ninety nine point six percent of Somali women are undergo female genital mutilation, and it is the most brutal, butchering version of female general mutilation that exists.

Speaker 2I will just tell people to read Ion's book in Fidel, her first book, where she describes it. It was one of the most skin crawling things I've ever read in my life, and I've read a lot of really nasty stuff.

Speaker 3That means that basically, you know, we're not generalizing at ninety nine point six percent, Okay, when I talk about Somali men being scumbags, being a part of that system, not standing up to stop that system, I'm talking about virtually all. Like, once you get above ninety nine percent, I don't think you have to throw it clear too much anymore and say, yeah, it's all of them, It's almost all of them. So can we still go through and pick and choose and find the people who are who are going to be great additions.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 3Sure. But as a general rule, if we were to say no to this group, generally speaking, no, I think that'd be fine for us to do so that we can prioritize groups that are that would, that would, that would be grateful and willing to join it, would and would celebrate our values and would and are dying to live in a place that has such values, rather than dying to go to a place where they can make more money and bring their own values and then degrade whatever part of our community they come to. And the problem that I see is it. Just as on the right it veers into a kind of overstated bigotry against

Speaker 3certain groups. On the left it veers away from that so sharply you can't even have an honest conversation about the differences between groups.

Speaker 2So you're well, because I'm just going to tell you, like, there's gonna be people who listen to this who are like, oh, he's clearly being just a racist against you know, Africans, And I would say.

Speaker 1I get the feeling.

Speaker 2David wouldn't say the same thing about Nigerians, for example, who are the highest performing I believe still the highest performing immigrant group in America once they come here. Maybe maybe Indians about outdone them or something.

Speaker 3I know, if they're the highest performing, I thought the statistic was that they have the highest per capita number of PhDs, which is one way of measuring performance, right exactly. Yeah, yeah, like to have a bunch of pH But there is a selection bias there. I mean, I don't know that that's I mean, that's not reflective of Nigeria. That's reflective with the Nigerians who come. Nevertheless, if we're getting a ton of PhDs from Nigeria, let's keep them coming. What's the problem.

Speaker 2Well, I was going to say, there is something that I would say about I would be a little uncomfortable if we started seeing a big influx of Chinese Nationalists or CCP members.

Speaker 3They wouldn't.

Speaker 2I mean, that's a this is a fantasy, but.

Speaker 3You know what I'm saying, Yeah, yeah, but if they're fleeing, if they're like right, I would rather be American than a CCP the loyalist. I mean, my attitude is, if you want to be American, then we should try to make room for you to the degree that we can without overstraining our own system. We should try to make room for anyone and everyone who wants to join this wonderful project. But we should be very wary of just letting anybody in simply because they want to come in.

Speaker 3That's and there is very much a subgroup of the left that that is that's what they think about it, you know. And also this steers into the essay I recently wrote for the Fourth about the fourteenth and that, you know, with the recent Supreme Court decision, I mean that was almost ruled out on a technicality in a sense, but the idea I think that the right does have a point like, we really need to think carefully about the idea that, oh, well you just you know, if you just get one foot across the finish line, one toe boom, I'm an American, and then there's just nothing

Speaker 3we can do about it, even if we know for a fact that you're ccp parents brought you over here, had you Hassan Piker is a good example, right, Yes, his parents hate America, would like to see America burn to the ground. Bring him over here, drop him off, and then he's born, drag him back immediately. I think he grew up his whole life in Turkey. He's completely He's completely of the same cast as his as his father, who I mean, he is for all intent, as far as I can tell, what thinks of America is evil, should be burned to the ground. He is essentially at

Speaker 3a foreigner with foreign values, who is not just foreign values, but explicitly anti American values. It's not just that he's not American in the philosophical sense. He is an enemy of America in the philosophical sense. And yet he could hypothetically be president of America.

Speaker 2Because he was born here. Exactly that should.

Speaker 3We not think, for two seconds about whether or not that's smart. What is it? I mean, is it smart to have like a white supremacist as the head of your like, I don't know. Let's say you're you have a student group on college for black students. Should you have a white supremacist as the head of that group? Should a white supremacist be even allowed to join the group? Or should you have the freedom of association to say no?

Speaker 2Well, that's another thing too. Freedom of association is a is a major thing that is forgotten when talking about things like American identity and immigration in particular, because I think that that gets now granted that that's more about you know, private business and private life and everything as I and.

Speaker 3We should still I'm not saying that that that Hassan biker should lose his citizens. I'm just saying that, well, we should. We should be able to this. Everything I'm describing should be actively in the marketplace of ideas, and to a degree it is. But that's what we're doing. The two sizes are not really We're not we're not really having the kind of mature conversation about this that I would that I wish that we were.

Speaker 2That's all right, Yeah, And I think that there is something to the idea that when like I think, I don't I want to say always, but I think it's a generally I'm optimistic in that I think it's a general rule that if you go out of your way to come here and stay here and be a citizen. It's different when you're talking about refugee situations and whatnot, though not so much in some ways, because a lot of Vietnamese Lao among people came to Minnesota. Again, Minnesota is like a refugee state in that sense too, and

Speaker 2they seem to have integrated over time a lot better than Somalians have. And I actually would defer to people who have studied this in Minnesota because there's a lot of reasons for it that I've heard said, and I don't know which ones are true or next. I haven't looked into it too deeply, but the fact remains is that the integration is lopsided in that sense. So I think that putting that example aside to I think people who voluntarily come here, they're the ones who I think are best able to articulate what American identity is a

Speaker 2lot of the time. That's what I was essentially talking about when I was writing my piece about where I was referencing my partner Molly and her family coming here from communists China, from bread China, as we like to say, and it was much more read back then. Actually that was the new Thing's reforms.

Speaker 3How much value do you place on assimilation, because again going back to my earlier point, sure, I want a minimum number of stars in this constellation that I say, you gotta. This has to be your constellation if to be in America.

Speaker 2Oh yeah, that's what I mean. I place a lot of value on assimilation. I think that you are free to believe whatever you want, even retrograde beliefs and everything, of course, and advocate for what you want, but you have to do it within the framework that we have established. And when I say we, I mean our our forefathers and so forth.

Speaker 3I think that what I'm saying is if you just if you, if you embrace that constellation of let's say, five stars, sure you don't have to assimilate, as far as I'm concerned, you can. You can be completely living in a Chinese bowl in the middle of New York and you never brought to Chinatown and you only speak Chinese and like, I'm that stuff.

Speaker 2I see what you mean.

Speaker 3Ye right, You don't have to similate, but you have to. You can't be trying to erode, break or push push back against the stars and the constellation, which would be things like you know, freedom of speech, do process, like if you're actively trying to undermine and destroy those things like those are the non negotiables that we have to keep in this society. Otherwise our ability to have everyone over for this backyard barbecue will it will very quickly turn into madness and violence, and the whole thing will be over.

Speaker 2So I think, yeah, I think that when I think of assimilation, to go back to the words I've been using a lot, is the reciprocal enthusiasm. You can't mandate this because then you're getting into like social engineering territory. But what I want is interaction. I want there to be an interaction. You can be as non assimilated as you want, but I want you, as as an immigrant, to interact with the culture that you are a part of and enjoy the salad slash melting pot, enjoy what

Speaker 2that is, accepting it for what it is and not resenting it. You can't control how people feel, obviously, but that's what I want, that's the ideal I have in my head. Yes, this is what I'm saying.

Speaker 3But if somebody one more slightly push okay, please, if somebody comes over and they are they say, you know what, love I love these values. I love the freedom and the opportunity. I love free speech, I love due process. I love all of these things. Not interested in interacting with anybody who is in Chinese. Really, I love Chinatown, New York City. I don't want to leave it. I don't want to learn English. Not interested in meeting the Italian Americans, not interested in meeting Black Americans, not interested

Speaker 3in any of that. But you know, let's say we're talking about some you know, seventy something grandma, so we just can be loves American values, the main ones that make America what it is that I described as the concept. But has no interest in anything outside of a Chinese life within America. No, I'm completely down with that. That's fine by me.

Speaker 2I would say, I mean, I think if it was, if it was, I mean, she's talking to me for some reason. But let's just say she's talking to me about it, I would and she'd be.

Speaker 3Like, you need to make friends with some Irish people.

Speaker 2Yeah, that's well, that's what I would say, is I would say, like, well, obviously, do what you want. That's part of what we're doing here. You associate with who you want, do what you want. But I think you should go try to interact with some other people. You don't have to, but I think you should. I mean, I'm speaking idealistically here, not realistical.

Speaker 3But isn't aesthetic isn't it almost like an esthetic preference at a certain point where you're kind of like saying like, look, uh, it could be food, Like listen, I know you love your Chinese food, but like do you have are you only ever going to have Chinese food your whole life? Like just try it? Like, just try pizza once in your life.

Speaker 2If my late my my late mother in law was like that, she was she knew what she liked. She would try things, and she would very mostly politely be like and then just like she literally remade her son made burgers and the grill ones and my brother in law and she was like it's good. And then she just went to the kitchen and just stir fried it with a bunch of Chinese stuff, and I was like, that's really rude, mostly because it's your son. But but

Speaker 2but it's what you're talking about. And I actually think food is it's the great introductory conversation I think for that kind of thing. And it doesn't mean you have to like. I mean, I don't like you know, I don't like certain kinds of seafood, and I don't like dairy very much, you know, And that's my choice. I'm but I appreciate people wanting me to try things. I guess is what I'm saying.

Speaker 3And that's sure. And I agree with you about the benefit of trying other foods. I think even far more strongly about the benefit of interacting with other cultures. It's one of the greatest educations. So I would very much recommends strongly to some to this grand this hypothetical grandmother, like that she should interact with other groups. But at the end of the day, if she's like, I don't like hamburgers, I don't like that, I'll be like, okay, you know, yeah. It would be the same as if I was interacting with some southern white racist who says he doesn't like black people. It's like, I strongly make

Speaker 3you yeah, I strongly disagree with you. But if that's the if that's the row, you're gonna ho oh okay. But also I think the principles that we have that allow you to live that life, which I don't approve of, those principles happen to be stars in the constellation that I think are the most fundamental thing in this country. And so I defend, just like I defend your right to be a Nazi and say Nazi things, although I find it reprehensible, I don't want the government to be able to prevent you from doing that. So if she

Speaker 3if that's a much more extreme example, but the benign example being the grandmother in Chinatown, Like, sure, if that's what you want to do, lady. In fact, my sister in law is kind of to a degree, very much not not to that extreme, but very much prefers a She's Chinese, and she prefers sort of as much of a Chinese world within America as she can get. But she's in America because of the constellation. And so I mean,

Speaker 3what well, I mean, you could ask for more, you could like to see more, but at the end of the day, that's all you need. That's civic that's being an American. That's civic nationalism. That's ah to ask for more or to require more is already putting one foot into something authoritarian.

Speaker 2Right, I mean, And I think one thing that I assume your sister in law. I know that my my partner and her family, you know, the ones who have at least come here. Her father comes and goes as best he can. But actually, funny enough, I would I always jokingly say that my partner's father is the most American person I've ever met, and he's still a Chinese citizen because he's just he just has that kind of vibe which is hard to define, but it's because he

Speaker 2buys into the constellation. He really does. He's a big fan of it. And and I think that that's like something that people like that. I think they tend to have gratitude for what they have here that they don't have where they came from. In a lot of cases, I think that's a big part of it. That's why I am very much a maybe an assimilationist in a lot of ways, where I'm just thinking, like, if you can appreciate what we have here more than even I can,

Speaker 2or than people who are many generations rooted here. Can I think there's something to that, And that's what I That's what I mean by when I say I think the international perspective is the best way to really appreciate what patriotism is. Maybe to even go so far as to say that, again, it's not in every case.

Speaker 3You mean.

Speaker 2You bring up a san Piker, though I think he's weird in terms of his upbringing, like you were mapping out there. But people who like come here and then stay here, they're not brainwashed. Like That's the thing that I think a lot of people might assume is that the patriotic immigrants are just brainwashed. If they're brainwashed, they brainwash themselves, is how I see it, in the sense that they understand what the values are, they went through the citizenship process, and they really appreciate what they have here, and in a way that I just don't think a

Speaker 2lot of people do after they've been living here for many generations. Not always, but it definitely does. I think that's a generalization I'm willing to make, and maybe there could be pushback on that from you or from anybody, But I really do believe that they are a lot of the times better suited to understand what they have here versus what they would not have elsewhere.

Speaker 3Yes, and also as just as there's a sort of there's a salubrious effect of having people who love the constellation come over like this. In this piece I wrote Home of the Brave for the fourth It starts off looking reflecting on a lot of these Instagram videos of people who came here for the World Cup, and how warming and wholesome it was to see foreigners falling in love with America and the kinds of things that they choose to fall in love with. Ranch dressing or school buses.

Speaker 2And raising canes was what I saw.

Speaker 3On the flip side of that, it is also healthy to have critics who come with a different worldview and say, you guys are screwed up in this way and that way, and that's wrong, and that can make us better. I mean, one of the greatest maturing processes that we ever went through was an aggressive and times violent pushback by the black community forcing us to confront our arguably America's great sin,

Speaker 3and we are better for it. And there could be more of that to come from people who come here not as fanboys and fangirls. Although that's great too, because then it reminds, I would argue, especially the left, it reminds us what's good about America. Don't forget there's a lot to criticize, but we are still the greatest. But we need the critics too. We just have to be careful about how where that criticism's coming from. There's a

Speaker 3difference between a critic who comes to make you better and an enemy who comes to tear you down, and we don't especially, we don't always make the distinction. We're uncomfortable being honest about that with regards to immigration. But I think that to circle all the way back to the beginning of the conversation, what it what it means to be American is on some level to always strive to maintain and to create and foster a place where

Speaker 3everyone can be American and everyone can come. It's almost it's not like a religion, but it's like an ideology where anybody can can say I want to go there, and I want to be American, and I want it, I want to join it like that's that's that's what makes us great, and not just in the ideological sense, in a very real, hard concrete sense. I mean most of our billionaires were immigrants. To give just one example, Like, there's like a lot of the things that we've done that we When I say we, I mean all the

Speaker 3people who weren't legacy Americans, who weren't born here, who came here because they wanted the ideology. A lot of the things, like things that America's accomplished were those people doing it. And those are people who today the voices on the right who are very harsh on this topic would not count them as Americans.

Speaker 2And I would be I would be remiss not to mention because you mentioned constructive criticism in so many words, and I think that's great. I have never met an immigrant who doesn't have criticism. The most patriotic immigrants I've met, they always have issues, but they're always thinking, well, yeah, because everywhere has issues, and in a lot of cases, where I came from has worse issues or different issues that I would prefer not to deal with. I'd rather deal with the ones here. Something my partner brought up that I thought was it was just so beautiful in

Speaker 2its simplicity. That sounds condescending, but it really was just a very concise way of putting it is that if you don't like something here, you can do something about it.

Speaker 3Is how she frothed it like that, And.

Speaker 2It's that like, when you think about it, it's true because if you don't let's let's just be fair. I guess, or I'm not going to be fair, but I just let I'll give has Piker because we're beating up on him a bit, and for good reason, but I'll give him the benefit of the doubt. He is able to like he doesn't like America. He's able to try and do something about it. Now, I don't like that, and I think it's incompatible, and I think it's reprehensible in a lot of ways what he does. But the fact that he can is essentially what's so great about it,

Speaker 2and that does kind of invite us back to these paradox as we're talking about and some have been thinking about. I haven't really fleshed it out yet, but I've been wanting to write about Thomas Jefferson recently because he's my favorite founding father, precisely because of how much of a hypocrite he was regarding slavery. In particular. I find his hypocrisy fascinating because there's no shortage of writings he had where he deplored slavery on moral terms. He was very anti slavery. And yet there's a big yet there, not

Speaker 2just sally Hemings and his illegitimate family, it's the fact that he never freed his slaves and continued to use them. And I find that paradox and contradiction to just be really compelling In a way. It's frustrating because it's hypocritical, but it's fascinating and does it lessen what Jefferson was able to accomplish as the writer of the Declaration, as you know, the third president of the United States, as any number of the accomplishments he had. It's I think

Speaker 2maybe what I see in that is and what I see in that kind of paradoxical thing is that it creates an appeal that is hard to understand. And maybe that's what I like in a lot of ways about American identity is it's full of paradoxes. Like I said, I haven't really fleshed it out yet, but that kind of uncertain that that tension, I think is very fascinating and maybe not unique to America, but definitely a significant part of it, if that makes sense of its history.

Speaker 3Yeah, definitely, I think that's yeah. I think that's well put. I think that we the boundary. This is why I keep coming back to the idea of the constellation.

Speaker 2These I like the constellation metaphor by the way, it's a good one. It's the constellation that includes the Constitution, maybe to.

Speaker 3A degree, perhaps, Yes. I always think of it as more specific values than that, Like, for like, one star would be freedom of speech, one star would be due process something like that. But there are these fundamental rights that allow for everybody to kind of live together and to let myons be bygones and to let everybody to have I mean, if you protect that, it's kind of like it's kind of like rules in a playground. It's like, look,

Speaker 3you follow these three rules, and you can do whatever you want, and anyone can play here and everyone can come and it's cool, but you have to follow these rules, like there's no hurting the their kids, you can't you can't push anyone, you can't pug like that stuff. But if you just follow these few basic rules, you can do anything, and you can play on anything you want to, and you can make friends with anyone you want to on the playground, or you can go sit by yourself on the seesaw and just not talk to anybody. You can do whatever you want. You can be in you know, the Chinatown example, where you just isolated, or you can

Speaker 3be going all over the country and meeting all kinds of different people and know what, different cultures. But these few playground rules are not negotiable, and if you break them, you have to go or I mean maybe that's not a consequences of something like yeah, once you're out, but you get the idea. It's it's, you know, we have to maintain these principles. We have to guard these values ferociously so that everybody can play and have a good time.

Speaker 2It's very well said, and I think that's a good place to end on that. This has been a really good conversation and I feel like there's many more angles we can take too. And we were talking about stuff earlier that just got my brain going about ideas of ethnic nationalism and its perils, but also it's normalcy in a lot of cases in human history, and that's just another subject I'm really interested in. But yes, with all that said, thank you again for chatting with me David

Speaker 3Always, I'll look forward to next time

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Third Reich Diagnosis

    Nov 19, 20262 hr 8 minAudio

    Understanding evil is something that has preoccupied humans for a long time. By the mid-20th century, the desire to root it in firm, social scientific terms became the norm, particularly in the field of psychology. The...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Millennials: The Trauma Generation

    Sep 30, 202652 minAudio

    Hey everyone. No preamble here. Just a nice bonus as a thank you for your continued support. As the title suggests, this is an audio adaptation of an essay I wrote about the 25th anniversary of 9/11 and how it led me to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Firebombing of Tokyo: Our Imperative Atrocity

    Sep 22, 20263 hr 21 minAudio

    We often hear about how the Second World War was more morally nuanced and complex than we have been led to believe. This is, to a certain extent, very true. The Axis powers meted out a level of genocidal destruction and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Power, Presidents, and Refusing the Crown (w/ Richard Lim)

    Sep 7, 20261 hr 23 minAudio

    In this newest episode of History Impossible we’re joined a second time by Richard Lim, host of the This American President podcast, who last appeared on this program a couple years ago to discuss the insane,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Orthodox ISIS: The Russian Religious Experience (w/ Kristaps Andrejsons of The Eastern Border)

    Aug 18, 20261 hr 48 minAudio

    “Because remember: Russia is a religious experience.” Those are the oft-repeated and well-said words by the host of The Eastern Border podcast, my good friend Kristaps Andrejsons. They are well-said because there are...

    Credit the people on this episode