Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Full Comment

Full Comment artwork

Mark Carney can’t be honest and upfront with Canadians...

Sep 19, 202621 minAudio

Mark Carney had some good moves this week. His investment summit was a success. Expanding trade with the European Union is a good thing, Stephen Harper negotiated the free trade deal. But two things bother me about Carney’s way of operating. He can’t tell Canadians what is really going on until caught, and even then… He’s also one of those Canadians who can only define being Canadian in negative terms against the United States. That’s not how I think, how I view our country. Listen to the full explanation in the video. This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.brianlilley.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02Mark Carney and the crazy stories he's been telling Canadians all week. Hi, I'm Brian Lilley. You can read me at torontosun.com or brianlilley.com. Make sure you subscribe there. That way everything goes direct to your inbox. That's the newsletter. We're going to talk about Mark Carney and the crazy stories he's been telling Canadians because he's a bit Unfamiliar with the truth, but I do want to hammer home on that signing up at brianlilley.com because the algorithm is constantly changing. You've got the Liberal government in Ottawa changing how tech operates

SPEAKER_02in this country and making it more difficult for you to find. So let's talk about Mark Carney. It's been a very strange week. I'm sitting here. It is Saturday, September 19th. It's just after 6.30 p.m. Got a nice little glass of wine to sit with you in the mornings. You know, I have coffee, but it's about 630. So why not have a glass of wine? Dinner's in the oven. We'll get to that in a bit. Yeah, I eat late. That's just the way life is.

SPEAKER_02So let me talk about Mark Carney's week. It started Sunday morning. We knew the investment summit was coming up. We knew that he was going to He was going to speak to the European Parliament. He was going to be there for Ursula von der Leyen. State of the Union speech and then wake up to this from the Wall Street Journal. Mark Carney's audacious bit to make Canada an associate member of the EU. That's not closer trade.

SPEAKER_02We already have a free trade agreement, one that was negotiated by Stephen Harper in 2014-15 and implemented after he left office, implemented badly by the Trudeau government. But we have a free trade deal with them. Carney wants to take us to the next step. What does the next step mean? We don't really know. But the Wall Street Journal, in a very well-sourced piece, very well-written piece, there was a lot of backstory in it for Americans that don't understand Canadian politics, don't know the history behind it.

SPEAKER_02But there was enough in there. Stories about Carney calling European leaders on his British cell phone. Remember that? That came out a few months ago. Carney loves talking to leaders on his British cell phone. He... Stop this. He ended up, you know, he's talking to all these world leaders trying to do an end run around Trump, trying to get that middle power thing going. And they had it down. He was seeking a an associate membership with the EU.

SPEAKER_02Now, that comes out Sunday morning, exclusive from Wall Street Journal, the most widely read newspaper in America, more than New York Times, more than USA Today. And what did Carney do? Well, he spoke to CBC later in the day. He's at the Toronto International Film Festival. He did a reception for his investment summit. He did a liberal donors fundraising event. And he went to the Toronto International Film Festival, where CBC catches up with him. And he He tells them, no, we're not looking for membership.

SPEAKER_02It's a unique Alliance. Interesting that that's the, the language that he went with because it was just a couple of days later on Wednesday, when the EU president Ursula von der Leyen says this.

SPEAKER_00In short, we want to bring the relationship with Canada to the highest level possible and dear Mark. I said we must urgently reimagine our partnerships. So I would like to work with you on opening the door for Canada to being the first associate member of the European Union.

SPEAKER_02Associate member. Look at Mark Carney smiling there. Carney smiling. And what does he do? Gets up, gives her a kiss. Standing ovation for him. That's on Wednesday. On Thursday, Carney gives a speech. And what language does he use? Yeah, he uses unique alliance.

SPEAKER_02He uses alliance for the future. But he also said he welcomes the idea of associate membership. Well, that's not what he was telling Canadians. On Sunday, he told CBC that we were not seeking any sort of membership. On Monday, he tells a reporter at his investment summit that he's not, don't expect a big reveal. I'm sorry, but that is a big reveal. The EU has never had an associate member. In fact, the status does not exist.

SPEAKER_02What we do know is that if you want something deeper than the free trade agreement that we have, you have to give up sovereignty. What did Carney say that this was all about?

SPEAKER_01This is about sovereignty. Our ability to live as we wish.

SPEAKER_02Huh. Huh. Sovereignty. He went on to talk about adopting common standards with the EU, which is what you have to do if you want something more than what we have now. Britain does not have the deal that they want with the European Union after Brexit because they refuse to allow the EU bureaucrats in Brussels and Strasbourg to control British life. Norway, in order to get not memorized, But the deep access that Carney desires, Norway,

SPEAKER_02Iceland, Liechtenstein, Switzerland, they all had to agree to adopt European standards. So product safety standards, food safety standards, environmental law, corporate law. Norway adopts two thirds of EU legislation. They have been able to keep agricultural rights and fishing rights and things like that. But on most things, they just have to follow the EU to get the kind of access that we have. Now, if you listen to Caillou, I mean, David Cochran on CBC said, Well, he will tell you that no, no, no, no.

SPEAKER_02We are not going to adopt. We're not going to follow EU rules. He is adamant that we're not doing this because the liberal government told him so. And there's one thing that you can assure yourself of. It's that David Cochran will repeat liberal talking points on CBC's power in politics. And there's a it's not a huge audience for it. In fact, I often hit more people here than than they do. But There are an awful lot of folks that watch it and believe everything they say.

SPEAKER_02The truth is, we don't know. We don't know what it's going to be because it doesn't exist yet. And yet we're just being told everything's great. And the polling would show that 80% of Canadians want closer relationship with the US or with the EU. I want that. But I don't want to be following EU rules. I don't want we elect officials. We elect politicians to go to Ottawa and represent us. And they make these types of decisions.

SPEAKER_02I don't want to hand that over to nameless, faceless bureaucrats in Europe because that's who decides it. That's how the EU works. It's not we would not get a vote on new legislation. We would not get a vote on new safety standards. So I don't know if you've been to Europe lately, but you get a bottle of water, plastic bottle of water. You get a bottle of pop. Um, have you noticed that you can't take the cap off? I mean, you can, but you really have to work it. I, you know, found that out the hard way because I yanked on it and spilled the thing everywhere.

SPEAKER_02It has to be attached. This is an EU rule for plastic, uh, Drinking bottles. Just a weird small thing. Famously, they had to retract one of the rules after they were talking about you couldn't sell cucumbers with too much of a curve and they're going around measuring cucumbers. They were mocked so roundly that they got rid of Just before the Brexit vote, they were looking at bringing in regulations to stop fast boiling kettles. And of course, the British press got a hold of that. We're writing about it.

SPEAKER_02They held it back because they didn't want that to affect the EU Brexit vote. Why? Because what? The Brits love their tea, don't they? And they also like a fast kettle. They'd regulate how powerful your toaster can be, your oven, your vacuum. You can't have a very powerful vacuum in Europe because climate change. All of these things, it goes on and on and on. What level would we be willing to give up? Mark Carney said he walked away from the deal with the Americans over sovereignty.

SPEAKER_02But we're talking about a deal with the EU, which does not give you deep access without you giving up sovereignty to them. And when he talks about common standards, do you really think that our 40 million? Like with the US, we're about a tenth their size. Well, not I mean, we're they're nine times bigger in the US. It's closer to 10 with the EU. Do we do you think that we're going to do that? For Carney, this is as much about politics, progressive left wing politics as it is about trade,

SPEAKER_02which you can hear in this clip as he's talking about collective resilience.

SPEAKER_01The economics of this are clear. The leverage of the powerful and an exploitive relationship collapses well before complete independence is achieved because diversity confers advantage. The objective is not self-sufficiency, it's collective resilience.

SPEAKER_02Collective resilience.

SPEAKER_01The economics of this are clear.

SPEAKER_02Let's get rid of that. Collective resilience. Unclear what that means other than, well, collectivism. He's big on that. But he also talked about Basically abusive relationships early on in that clip. And this is a big part of my problem with Carney and his speech at the EU when he was talking about deeper trade, deeper ties with Europe. I thought he was at his best. I thought he was doing well. And yes, we do need to do more trade with Europe.

SPEAKER_02We do need to lessen our reliance on the United States. This is not stopping trade with the U.S. or reducing trade with the U.S. This is increasing trade elsewhere so that there are more options. We're baking a bigger pie, as Belinda Stronick once explained to everyone. But he couldn't stop taking shots at Trump. And you heard that. Early in that clip about basically describing it as abusive relationship. Listen to what Carney says here as he's trying to say,

SPEAKER_02you know, you know, as far as whatever this is, a unique alliance, an alliance for the future or a an associate membership. Here's what it's not, he says.

SPEAKER_01I also want to be precise about what I am not proposing. I'm not proposing a third block in order to become a great power rival only with better manners.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, better manners. And they all laughed. It was one of his biggest applause lines. All his biggest applause lines were passive aggressive shots at Trump. Now, I described it this way with Bill Carroll on CFRA in Ottawa on Friday morning. Not saying you got a tiptoe around Trump, but. He's over there talking to the Europeans about deepening trade with them, and he won't stop talking about his ex. So he's out on a date with someone new, and he just wants to talk about his ex.

SPEAKER_02It's kind of off-putting, isn't it? Well, not to the Europeans, because they just want to beat up on Donald Trump as well. It's like, come the hell on. Let's talk about what we have to offer the world. Let's talk about why working with us is good. Let's talk about what we are doing is that is great instead of always having to measure against the Americans. I mentioned this in Bachelors Burning Questions the other day. This is a book that actually that's its spot right there.

SPEAKER_02Normally sits right there. And I brought it out. It's called Canada's Founding Debates. It is edited by Janet Asienstadt and Ian Gentles, William D. Gardner, Paul Romney. Very academic book, but it's a fascinating one because this is a collection of the debates on confederation. And if you look back at her history, you do realize that there's always people that want Canada to join

SPEAKER_02the United States. And there are people who define Canada as not being the United States. And then there are people that define Canada as being something distinct and great and good and Going forward from a positive element. Well, that's where I am. That is how I view this country. I don't define us as Justin Trudeau once did. Somebody asked him, well, what's a Canadian? Well, we're not American. That's a pretty crappy answer, especially from a prime minister.

SPEAKER_02But Mark Carney seems to be in that same camp because he can't talk about anything without making it about the Americans. So fast forward to Friday. He's back in Canada. He's in Ottawa, speaking of the Liberal Caucus, and starts talking about some of the great things that we're doing. Look, this guy is doing some good things, some great things. You know, Moving to one project, one review, one year, and you get an answer. That's fantastic. I mean,

SPEAKER_02it takes us back to where Stephen Harper had us in 2015 before he lost the election and Justin Trudeau screwed everything up. But it's great to get back to that. And he's doing that. And I think the investment summit was a great idea. But then he's talking about another project that's great, Churchill Falls, the expansion of Churchill Falls and the jobs it's going to generate and the economic activity and how it's going to be good for Quebec, good for Newfoundland and Labrador, good for the Inu people, good for the whole country and how much power it's going to generate.

SPEAKER_02And of course, nobody does at the end. He's got to go after Trump while talking about something good about Canada.

SPEAKER_01A few weeks ago, we partnered with Newfoundland and Labrador. Quebec and the Indian nation to announce the largest clean energy investment in North American history. 14

SPEAKER_01gigawatts of hydro wind storage, the functional equivalent of 18 Hoover dams. 18 Hoover dams. Enough. Enough to light.

SPEAKER_02Okay, so that's the clip that I can legally use. If you see the CPAC clip, he's doing the Trump thing with the hands. He's mocking Trump on Parliament Hill for no reason. Like, there's no benefit to doing that. People say, well, I don't care. Trump mocks us all the time. Yeah, and we think it's beneath him. We think it's beneath the American president to do that. So, you know, just because he does it, Carney does it. Didn't your mother teach you two wrongs don't make a right?

SPEAKER_02It's beneath the head of government to be doing that. And it doesn't get us anywhere. And he's doing, he will not do that in the United States, by the way. You've seen how he kisses Trump's ass when he's in the United States or when he's next to Trump. Whether it's in Egypt or in Washington or Kananaskis, wherever he is with Trump. And if he sees Trump at the United Nations General Assembly next week, because he really won't be in Parliament much to talk about all the things he's doing without parliamentary approval.

SPEAKER_02If he sees Trump, he's going to kiss Trump's ass. That is the way Mark Carney operates. But when he's not near him, he needs to mock him to feel superior. And you heard the Liberal caucus just lap that up. Why? It gets us nowhere. It accomplishes nothing. Eventually we do have to get back to the table. Eventually we do need to get a deal with the Americans. Because if not, well, goodbye to the GM plant in Oshawa that's currently making Chevy Silverados and is

SPEAKER_02about to make GMC Sierras. Goodbye to the Ford plant in Oakville that is being retooled to make the F350, the F450, etc. And do you really think Honda and Toyota are going to feel such great affinity for Canada that they decide... Yeah, we're having trouble getting our product across the border and almost all of it goes to the U.S. But yeah, don't worry. We'll keep employing all the people that we do.

SPEAKER_02By the way, Honda and Toyota, that's the majority of cars made in Canada now. And they have less of a connection than Ford GM and, well, Chrysler, now Stellantis. We need to get back to a deal. But this guy just can't stop it. I wrote about this in a column about Carney's speech in Strasbourg to the EU Parliament. He's great when he's talking about what Canada's good at, but he can't stop talking about Trump and taking shots at him.

SPEAKER_02Again, for no apparent reason. He's still Mr. Elbows Up. He is still just... Let me pull up the clip. I mean, this is still Mark Carney. Yeah. Remember that? Yeah, he's still in that mentality. Might explain why we are where we are. And I'm still hearing Canadians tell me that don't worry,

SPEAKER_02the midterms will come along and that will change everything. As I've explained to you many times, it won't. The midterms, even if the Democrats win, There will not be enough votes to overturn the Trade Expansion Act of 1962, which allows the president to impose Section 232 tariffs on things like steel, aluminum, and autos for national security concerns. There is nothing that can happen in the midterms that can take away his ability to do that. You are just cheering on...

SPEAKER_02A change in parties. And by the way, my friend Carlo Dade, you'll hear about this in the full comment podcast. It comes out Monday. Carlo Dade, University of Calgary School of Public Policy, head of the last election in the U.S. He studied the America First MAGA movement to find out what they wanted, what they were about, what they were pushing. And he was the most informed guy on that in Canada. And now he's studying the Democratic Socialists of America. The Green and Red Revolution documents that they're putting out because guess what? They don't like free trade with Canada either.

SPEAKER_02And that's where all the excitement is on the Democratic side. We're not in a good space, people. And our politicians just seem to want to play political games while regular little people get hurt. Anyways, that's it for now. I'm going to go get dinner out of the oven. I'm going to continue to enjoy this wine. Hope you enjoy your weekend. We'll have something out more tomorrow as well, because, well, these days, no shortage of news. Thanks for watching. Remember, I'm on your side.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. How the B.C. Conservatives won big a week ago...

    Nov 1, 202622 minAudio

    The fact that the B.C. Conservatives won last weekend wasn’t the shocking part, it was the size of their win. The party took 63 seats to the, while the NDP took just 28 and the Greens 2. There were people who were...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Canadians angry at Florida tax plan need to look in the mirror...

    Oct 4, 202612 minAudio

    Canadians are outraged that Florida Republican Governor Ron DeSantis wants Canadians to face a tax hike to subsidize Florida residents. It’s outrageous, but it’s also a little rich. Canadians are angry at Americans for...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Carney’s move to align with Europe...

    Sep 30, 202616 minAudio

    A lot of people commenting on things that just aren’t so. A few clips of Carney to share with you today, so it’s pretty much all video today. That said, here’s the chart I show in the video. It shows where things are at...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Carney is playing games with people’s jobs...

    Sep 25, 202618 minAudio

    Canada faces a pile of new trade actions that start next week. Why isn’t Mark Carney trying to get a new deal. Instead, he’s putting good paying jobs at risk because he prefers politics to economics. Odd for a man...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Carney tells all to the New York Times...

    Sep 24, 202617 minAudio

    Mr. Carney goes to New York. It’s clear that Mark Carney likes foreign journalists better than Canadian ones. He turns to the BBC, Bloomberg, and now the New York Times when he wants to get out points. In today’s...

    Credit the people on this episode