Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Full Comment

Full Comment artwork

Canadians angry at Florida tax plan need to look in the mirror...

Oct 4, 202612 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Canadians are outraged that Florida Republican Governor Ron DeSantis wants Canadians to face a tax hike to subsidize Florida residents. It’s outrageous, but it’s also a little rich. Canadians are angry at Americans for wanting to do something we’ve been doing to them for years. A story from CBC’s J.P. Tasker is making the rounds. There is nothing wrong with it, no bias or misinformation, but it does lack some important context. “Florida weighs ditching property taxes and sticking Canadians with the bill,” reads the CBC headline. It then details a proposal, backed by DeSantis, that would see non-school property taxes drastically lowered for many homes if they are valued below $250,000 and occupied by a Florida resident. That means living there most of the year, voting there and having a Florida driver’s licence. “I want Canadian tourists and Brazilian tourists subsidizing the state and making it so Florida residents pay less taxes. I don’t want to give Canadians a tax cut,” CBC quotes DeSantis as saying. CBC’s article understandably focuses on Canadians, but this measure applies to everyone not of the Sunshine State. That would include the thousands of people from Columbia, Brazil, Argentina and the United Kingdom - all big foreign buyers of Florida properties. Florida’s new message to Canadians… I don’t get DeSantis. His state sees a lot of money come in from Canada. The latest stats from Visit Florida show that despite a slight decline, 3,174,000 Canadians still visited the Sunshine State in 2025. In normal times, DeSantis, like most elected officials in Florida, would care about making Canadians happy. It’s not because Canadians can vote for him; it’s because they support the jobs and businesses of the people who can vote for him. In the past, both Democratic and Republican politicians have worked hard to make snowbirds happy, to make them feel welcome. Not DeSantis. He’s gone out of his way to do the opposite. To be blunt, he’s been a jerk, made a ton of inflammatory comments and has turned many people off. I get it. He’s not making you feel welcome, but is this really something Canadians should be upset about? Canada already does this… Here’s the part many Canadians seem to forget: we already discriminate against foreign homebuyers. Did you know that we have a federal ban on foreign property buyers in residential areas of urban settings? That means that while I can go to Tampa, Orlando, Miami, Fort Myers or elsewhere and buy a house, townhouse or condo, it’s actually illegal for Americans from those cities to come and buy a similar property here. The Trudeau government instituted the ban, which started on January 1, 2023, and then extended it in February 2024 until January 1, 2027. I’m not sure how stringently this is enforced, but let’s say you were able to bypass it and buy a condo in Toronto. The Province of Ontario would hit you with a 25% Non-Resident Speculation Tax, while the City of Toronto would add another 10% tax on the purchase price. On a $1 million two-bedroom condo, that’s an extra $350,000 in taxes before you even move in. Then, if this were a secondary home, a place that you didn’t live in full time, the city would charge you an additional 3% vacant home tax. Vancouver has a similar vacant home tax, as does Ottawa. British Columbia has its own vacant home tax, which sits at 3% this year and is going up to 4% next year. In the middle of the provincial election, NDP Leader David Eby threatened another tax hike on non-residents. And if you ever want to have a vacation home in Nova Scotia, expect to get hit with a 10% non-resident provincial deed transfer tax. So why is it so outrageous for Florida to do to Canadians what we already do to everyone else? It reminds me of the line from the Bible in Matthew 7:5, where Jesus says, “You hypocrite, first take the plank out of your own eye, and then you will see clearly to remove the speck from your brother’s eye.” The politics of making someone else pay… What DeSantis is proposing is wrong and unfair. So, too, is what we have been doing to others for years. You know what, though? These ideas, wrong and unfair as they are, remain politically popular, which is why politicians propose them. Anyone who has owned a cottage knows there is a similar tension over tax rates between full-time residents and seasonal cottage dwellers. We all want someone else to pay. In Canada, we have banned foreign buyers, slapped massive surcharges on foreign purchases and increased their property taxes. When we do it, we call it housing policy. When Florida does it, we call it discrimination. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.brianlilley.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Can you believe that Ron DeSantis, that Republican governor of Florida, is doing to us what we do to people from Florida and everywhere else, except that while ours is much broader and arguably worse. Hi, Brian Lilley here. Read me, of course, at torontosun.com, brianlilley.com. That's where you can subscribe. Make sure you don't miss anything as tech, big tech, keeps changing the algorithms and the liberal government in Ottawa keeps changing the algorithms. Well, the laws and how these things have to work in Canada.

SPEAKER_00There's a big story going around. It's got lots of people outraged, and I understand why people are outraged, but it's missing some context. The idea that Florida is going to lower property taxes for residents and stick the bill to people who aren't from Florida. Do you know what we do to people from outside of Canada, especially in Ontario, in British Columbia, in Nova Scotia? Okay, let me dive into this. Okay. Here's the original story that got tons wagging. It's from JP Tasker at CBC.

SPEAKER_00And quite frankly, there's nothing wrong with the story. There's no bias. There is no, well, they completely missed everything, but there's some context missing. So here's the basic rundown headline. Florida Ways Ditching Property Taxes and Sticking Canadians with the Bill. This is a proposal that is going before voters in Florida saying, hey, would you like to pay lower property taxes and have foreigners pay the bill? Doesn't apply just to Canadians. It applies to Everyone from out of state, everyone from out of the country.

SPEAKER_00And so for that could be if you're from New York State or from Michigan, lots of people from those states go to Florida, would apply to them. On foreign buyers, it would include, well, Canada is the biggest source of foreign homeownership in Florida, followed by people from Colombia, Argentina, the United Kingdom. They're all going to face the same thing. But, you know, I get it. Ron DeSantis is actually quoted in this article saying, I don't want to give Canadians a tax cut. In the full quote, he's also saying, I don't want to give Brazilians a tax cut.

SPEAKER_00He wants people from Brazil to pay more. Another source of Florida residents from out of the country. So that's what's going on. If your home is right now, there is a threshold of $50,000. If your home is worth less than that, you're not paying full freight. If you're a full-time Florida resident, you still pay your school taxes, but your local property taxes to pay for roads and paramedics and police and fire, you know, you're going to pay lower.

SPEAKER_00This proposal would up that to $150,000 and then eventually $250,000. And if your home is worth less than that, you're not paying full property taxes. And if your home is worth more than that, you're going to pay, but it'll be reduced based on the 250 threshold. That's going to leave about a $12 billion hole for local governments across the state of Florida. Strange thing about this proposal is right now, if you are a foreign property owner in Florida, they've capped the amount that your property taxes can be increased at 10% a year.

SPEAKER_00In this proposal, they lower that to five, making it more difficult to fill that $12 billion gap. So on the one hand, it sticks it to Canadians. On the other hand, it gives them a bit more protection. All said, it's going to be popular because it says, hey, let someone else pay your property taxes. And understandably, Canadians are upset at this. They feel like they're being picked on. Well, they're not just picking on Canadians, they're picking on everyone. And as I'm about to show you, we've been doing this to anyone from outside the country or our province for

SPEAKER_00a long time. I mean, do most people even know that there is a ban on On foreigners buying homes in urban areas. So I'm sitting here in downtown Toronto. Lots of people from outside of the country like to spend parts of the spring, the summer, the fall in Toronto. Not so much the winters. Thus, so many of us go to Florida or elsewhere. So there is a ban right now. And it's been in place for a couple of years. Let me show this to you because a lot of people will not believe this.

SPEAKER_00But there is a ban on foreigners. Foreign Home Ownership. It was instituted. It came into effect January 1st, 2023. February 4th, 2024. Here's the news release from the Department of Finance. Then Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland. I really don't miss her announcing that the ban would be extended. So originally it was supposed to go January 1st, 2023 to January 1st, 2025. They've extended it to January 1st, 2027. That's a full ban.

SPEAKER_00So, anyone from Toronto or Vancouver or Montreal or Ottawa can go down to Tampa, to Tallahassee, to Miami, to Fort Myers. You can buy a home, a townhouse, a condo. None of those people can fly up to Toronto or Montreal or Ottawa or Vancouver or Calgary or Saskatoon. And buy a home. They could buy a cottage. You could, you know, they could go up and buy a place in Muskoka, but they can't buy in an urban area. And they say, well, it's for housing affordability. We want to make sure that people are living there.

SPEAKER_00Now, let's say that somehow you managed to circumvent this. And honestly, I don't know how thoroughly it's being enforced. Well, if you circumvent it, then here's what you get hit with. In Toronto, anyway. Ontario has a 25% non-resident speculation tax. So you buy a million-dollar condo here in Toronto. You find a nice two-bedroom condo. It's going to be your little spot to enjoy the city in the summer.

SPEAKER_00That's not an outrageous price, by the way. And it's not outrageous that people would want to do that. But they're banned from doing it. And then if they do it, they get a 25% tax. From the province of Ontario. This was brought in by the Ford government a couple of years ago. And not long after that, well, the city of Toronto brought in a 10% non-resident speculation tax. So what does that mean? You're looking to invest some money in Toronto. You want to have a place here that you and your family and friends can go to enjoy

SPEAKER_00the city, spend your money in Toronto. Nope. That million-dollar condo is going to cost you $350,000 in extra taxes before you even move in, before you unpack a box. $350,000 in extra taxes. I'm betting that's a lot more than what the Canadians, the Snowbirds in Florida, are going to be asked to pay with this ridiculous change that DeSantis wants to bring in. But, okay, so you've circumvented the federal ban.

SPEAKER_00You decide, yeah, you know what, this $350,000 tax, it's worth it. I really want to be in Toronto. Well, now you're going to pay an additional 3% tax on your municipal tax bill. Because the city of Toronto says if you're not here full time, doesn't matter how long you're here. If you're not here, at least six months of the year plus, you're going to pay a 3% vacant home tax. Guess what? Similar taxes exist in Vancouver at the municipal level, plus at the British Columbia provincial level for places like Vancouver.

SPEAKER_00They exist in Ottawa. British Columbia has a similar non-resident speculation tax to Ontario's. Nova Scotia has a 10% non-resident deed transfer tax. So even if you're from Toronto and you decide you want to get a plot of land down in Nova Scotia where your family hails from, oh, you're not really from here, is you? You're going to pay a 10% transfer tax for the deed to your property. We do this to people from outside of Canada, outside of our jurisdiction, all over the place.

SPEAKER_00But now, now Florida is looking at doing this. Maybe they already do and they're expanding it, but Canadians are getting outraged. That's the context missing from that CBC piece. I don't think there's anything wrong with the piece. It's not biased. It's not an attempt to say, hey, You know, Republicans are evil. Nothing like that. But when you add in this context, it becomes, oh, yeah, that Florida idea is really bad. That Florida idea is wrong. It's unfair.

SPEAKER_00But you know what else is wrong and unfair? The Ontario non-resident speculation tax, the Toronto non-resident speculation tax, the vacant home tax, the BC taxes, the Vancouver taxes, the Nova Scotia taxes, and on and on it goes. It's funny, the CBC article actually quotes someone from Ottawa upset that they have to pay higher taxes because they don't live in Florida full-time, and yet Ottawa has a tax just like that.

SPEAKER_00I get that people are emotional. I get that Ron DeSantis is the first Florida politician in my memory. And my family's been going to Florida for decades. I don't really go to Florida. My parents did until recently. They've recently sold up, not related to Trump. So I know Florida well. And Florida politicians were always welcoming. They wanted to make sure Canadians were happy, not because Canadians could vote for them, but because their spending supported the people working the jobs and owning

SPEAKER_00the businesses that, well, would vote for them. So DeSantis has taken a completely different view. By the way, let me show this to you because Canadians believe that nobody's going to Florida anymore. Has there been a drop? Absolutely. But look at this number here. Revised actual 2025 Canadian visitation, 3.174 million Canadians went to Florida in 2025.

SPEAKER_00That is less than 10% of the number of Americans, 36.54 million. American tourism to Florida has always been the strongest. Canada is the largest foreign group going. But this idea that we are somehow bringing the Americans to their knees and we're going to protest them and now they're being mean to us. Look, they're doing to us what we have done to them and to everyone else for years. But we actually do it on a bigger scale. They're saying you're going to have to pay more taxes.

SPEAKER_00We ban them from buying here. Then we impose punitive taxes on the purchase and then higher taxes if they happen to get through those first two loopholes. Why are we complaining? If we're willing to do this, if we're willing to support it, if we're willing to vote for politicians that do this, I'm going to bet that over the next little while, you hear a lot of Canadian politicians complaining about Ron DeSantis and what he's doing. And most of them will have backed these very same policies. Anyways, that wraps it for now. Thanks for watching. Remember, subscribe at brianlilley.com.

SPEAKER_00If you are watching this on YouTube or Facebook or elsewhere, you can get all of the details and the links to what I talked about. At the actual post at brianlilley.com, make sure you subscribe there. That way you get the columns from the sun and the videos and everything else direct to your inbox. Thanks for watching. Remember, I'm on your side.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. How the B.C. Conservatives won big a week ago...

    Nov 1, 202622 minAudio

    The fact that the B.C. Conservatives won last weekend wasn’t the shocking part, it was the size of their win. The party took 63 seats to the, while the NDP took just 28 and the Greens 2. There were people who were...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Carney’s move to align with Europe...

    Sep 30, 202616 minAudio

    A lot of people commenting on things that just aren’t so. A few clips of Carney to share with you today, so it’s pretty much all video today. That said, here’s the chart I show in the video. It shows where things are at...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Carney is playing games with people’s jobs...

    Sep 25, 202618 minAudio

    Canada faces a pile of new trade actions that start next week. Why isn’t Mark Carney trying to get a new deal. Instead, he’s putting good paying jobs at risk because he prefers politics to economics. Odd for a man...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Carney tells all to the New York Times...

    Sep 24, 202617 minAudio

    Mr. Carney goes to New York. It’s clear that Mark Carney likes foreign journalists better than Canadian ones. He turns to the BBC, Bloomberg, and now the New York Times when he wants to get out points. In today’s...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. BC Conservative leader resigns as leader, stays on as by-election candidate...

    Sep 20, 202611 minAudio

    The chaos in the Conservative Party of BC continued on Sunday with leader Kerry-Lynne Findlay resigning in the afternoon. Her resignation came as yet another MLA left the party taking them down to 24 seats, 20 below...

    Credit the people on this episode