The fact that the B.C. Conservatives won last weekend wasn’t the shocking part, it was the size of their win. The party took 63 seats to the, while the NDP took just 28 and the Greens 2. There were people who were working on the campaign who believed they would win but didn’t think they’d reach 63 seats. I haven’t written or said much about the B.C. win over the past week, it’s been a crazy week in politics. On Friday, I appeared on Glenn Beck’s show stateside and he asked me about the election, but that’s been about it. So today, I gathered some of the people responsible for the win. Angelo Isidorou was chief strategist for the party, Jeff Ballingall looked after digital communications and Anthony Koch handled media and comms. Unfortunately, Anthony’s connection crapped out and he had to leave. Also, I really wanted to hear from Katy Merrifield who played such a central role in the campaign but she was taking some much deserved rest. I’ve still got a request in to interview Lorne Doerkson, hopefully that can happen soon. Enjoy our Sunday afternoon chat. This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.brianlilley.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01It was just over a week ago that the, well, political ground shook in British Columbia. It's not that people weren't expecting the BC Conservatives to win the election. David Eby foolishly called early and for his own benefit. It's the size of the win, 64 seats. I don't even think people inside the party were expecting that many seats on Election Day. So I wanted to round up a few of the people who were responsible for that win. No, not Lorne Dirksen. We'll get to him eventually. But the people in the background helping make things move.
SPEAKER_01Angelo Isidoro, Anthony Koch, Jeff Ballingall, all part of the campaign team. And gents, thanks for joining me. I told you it'd be a Sunday afternoon casual thing, so I'll just kick it off and say cheers. There's a good Canadian beer for you. Cheers to you guys for your win.
SPEAKER_00Thanks.
SPEAKER_01Thank you very much. I've got water. Angelo, let me start with you. You were helping organize this party for a long time. You were booted out. You were brought back in. How were you able to bring everyone together? Because most folks that are watching this will remember that two days before the election was called, there was a leader. The leader resigned. You had already been pushed out. People were scattered to the wind.
SPEAKER_01Lorne Durtzen himself, my understanding is, was flying back from a vacation on the other side of the world when he finds out he's interim leader. Were you literally building the plane as you were flying it after David Eby called the election?
SPEAKER_00We were once again, to use that analogy, once again, building the plane as we were flying it. We used that in the 2024 election. I think it goes again here. You're exactly right. The credit ultimately goes to Lorne Dirksen. He was in Africa, actually, with the Speaker of the House, speaking at a conference in Cape Town. He spent some time there with his wife, flew back, landed in Vancouver late at night. And surprise, you're the leader. You're the guy that both caucus and the board of directors chose. Did anyone talk to him ahead
SPEAKER_01of that?
SPEAKER_00I think he got a couple of calls or text messages, but then he was just offline for like 15 hours. You know, Lorne, Lorne was really the man for the moment because you just talked about how everybody was so scattered. He is ultimately the only one that could bring people together. He is so universally liked both inside and outside caucus that when you looked at sort of the blueprint of the party at that time, just to take us back 40 days, it was a fractured party. It was leaderless.
SPEAKER_00You had at least three MLAs who were fired very unceremoniously. You had several MLAs who had quit to form their own party called Centre BC. It was a disaster and it was an opportunity, a craven opportunity for David Eby that he took. And Lorne, basically within the first 48 hours, you can argue he won the election by virtue of how well he unified everybody together again.
SPEAKER_01So before I get to the other two guys, I'll ask you this question. At the beginning of the campaign, I had Von Palmer, longtime columnist with the Vancouver Sun, and Les Lane, his counterpart at the Victoria Times Colonist. And these two guys have been covering B.C. politics going back to the 80s. And even they were saying this election call in the first week were the craziest thing they'd ever seen. And I think it was Les that said to me, It's insane how well Lorne Dirksen's doing. Everyone likes him,
SPEAKER_01but his job previous to this was assistant deputy speaker, which in legislative terms is like being in the witness protection program. Nobody knows who you are. How did you take this guy that nobody knew who he was and make him electable as premier of one of the biggest provinces in the country?
SPEAKER_00Well, you know what's funny is you look at a leadership race, right? And you basically have the base of the party determining who the leader is. And this is a case where the person that was chosen to be the leader was just objectively the best at leading. You know, for those of us that are in BC, we know exactly who Lauren Dirksen is. Like, Lauren Dirksen was the guy who... Who wouldn't forget at Christmas time to get a chocolate bar for every single staffer. Like he was just this beloved, nice guy who was perhaps very antithetical to what was there before. So he was primed for the job in a way.
SPEAKER_00But, you know, I could see how it's a big surprise to the rest of the country. I mean, this has never happened before, as far as I know, to have an interim leader actually wind up.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, but what you're talking about is everyone at the legislature knows him. Anthony, Jeff, you guys are on the comm side. You got to convince people who don't spend every waking hour thinking about BC politics.
SPEAKER_00Hey, see this guy over here you've never heard of? He's the man. Like, what was that like?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, we'll come back to Anthony. But Jeff, let's go to you. You've been around a bunch of campaigns. You know that people sitting on their hands can be a real thing as well. And so... That helps you win or it forces you to lose. I think Paul Martin, when he lost in 506, 2 million liberals, there were 2 million liberals fewer than had been there two elections earlier because people just get turned off.
SPEAKER_01So yeah, I get Anthony's point, but if the BC conservatives were seen as unacceptable, those 270,000 people would have come out in favor of The BC NDP or found a different way to vote against the BC conservatives. So obviously you have to have an acceptable alternative there. And voters said, yeah, this is acceptable.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, certainly. So that was part I knew that going in. I knew I knew the rest of the team knew that there's a lot of unspoken things that we didn't really need to say that we needed to lean in the fact that we had our leader was normal. And we needed to make him socially acceptable. And so we did that we we know we leaned into who he is as a person, which is he's very authentic. He's the type of guy that will, you know, plow your snow, get you get your car out of a ditch. Those are the things we lean into. Yeah, fighting the fire. So we lean into those aspects of him.
SPEAKER_02But we also knew that we needed to broaden our appeal as a team. And that's where we lean into candidates, especially female ones, too. We had to speak to women directly about issues that matter to them. And we had a shotgun approach. My team, my mobilized media team and the rest of the campaign that was on the digital team created just a litany of That we were able to slowly build out into our ad sets. And by the end, it was getting it was we got more efficient as we went along because we had
SPEAKER_02so many different types of material going out to our target writings. And whether it's, you know, speaking You know, DRIPA, those were all incredibly important ways to activate people. And Facebook's algorithm is very important in determining what gets seen by whom.
SPEAKER_01Okay, let me ask you about that. And just a quick note, Anthony's just sent me a message. He's having connection problems, doesn't want to jump back in. So we'll just continue on without him. But, you know, Social media is incredibly important. If you talk to a lot of people that watch politics, they'd say, well, Facebook, people aren't on Facebook anymore. Facebook's still incredibly important, especially for the most reliable voting demographic. Am I correct?
SPEAKER_02Well, boomers are a big part of our strategy. This is a very big boomer election might be the last one we ever see in BC of this importance. And boomers are on Facebook. But you know, we also know that millennials and Gen X are on Instagram in a big way. And so that was also a big part of our strategy and making sure Making sure that we were prominent in reels and, you know, also leveraging Twitter like X to an extent was incredibly important to ensure that media and activists and the political class saw what was important in the campaign, whether it's an EB misstep during Angelo,
SPEAKER_02early on, it was an attempt by David Eby to say,
SPEAKER_01Part of his analogy for saying why the province needed him to protect them from Trump was using the firefighting analogy. And you got to cut breaks and you got to be ready to fight the fire. And then it was a legacy media click. That resurfaced on social media that kind of turned the narrative on that. I've never seen such a bad example of OPPO research. I mean, they should have been doing OPPO research. Don't use the firefighting example.
SPEAKER_01There's a global news story out there of Lauren Dirksen fighting a fire as an MLA. Was that just a gift handed to you? How happy were you when you saw that come out in the very early days of the campaign?
SPEAKER_00I think we were ecstatic because at that point we were still trying to define who Lauren Dirksen was, right? Like, again, I gave you the legislature example. Who is he to the general public? And that clip exploded. That clip became the guy that we all know. In fact, we even took that clip and put it into our TV ads. So it became a huge part of it. But yeah, it felt like a gift. I mean, the NDP called the snap election. And in that circumstance, you would assume the party calling the election would be prepared for it. And I think Jeff would probably agree.
SPEAKER_00Like the first week we were sort of cautiously optimistic because we thought, you know, here we go. They're going to throw everything they have at us. They've managed the province for a decade. They're not going to just gently go into the good night. But they were more sloppy than I thought they would be. I think we overestimated them, which goes to show that maybe this was really a last minute decision to call an election.
SPEAKER_01To me, it didn't feel like they had a plan. As Jeff knows, I'm old. And so I've been doing this a long time and I compared it early on the election I mentioned earlier, Paul Martin 0506. Yeah, Stephen Harper and Jack Layton and Gilles Doucette brought down that government. But the Martin guys knew it was coming and they'd been planning and preparing and I went on. Paul Martin's election tour bus and we left Ottawa, drove to Montreal,
SPEAKER_01parked at the Queen Elizabeth Hotel for three days because they didn't know where else to take us. They're literally calling every day from the hotel trying to find places to take their leader. At one stop on a drive from Montreal to Toronto, there was a whistle stop and I said to I knew one of the organizers. I said, when they call you about this, they said, as you guys were leaving Montreal. So, I mean, they had zero planning. And that's what the EB election felt like to me. Zero plan, even though they called it. And in the end, I'm watching it from afar,
SPEAKER_01but I would say, objectively, it's the worst campaign I've ever seen prosecuted by any party at that level.
SPEAKER_02I think it speaks to the little things they couldn't get right. I mean, they weren't running good Facebook ads early on and they weren't running very good ones at the end, although they were spending money. But it's the little things that I keep on coming back to that are massive. And that is like, think about the debate visual where you had, they couldn't even get them a lecture and that was at the proper size. So the cutaway on the TV screen was you had Lauren, He is an incredibly tall man. There's very little he can do about it. But his team should have known how to put a lectern up, right? That's my point. And they didn't put a lectern up properly.
SPEAKER_00Another example was he did this speech in front of the media, media availability, where he talked about the need to buy BC. We need to buy things that are not American. And he was saying this while dressed up in apparel that was all, I think it was Patagonia. It was all American apparel, right? And it's like, how do you just, you just keep blunder after blunder after blunder. The daycare thing was really, we found the daycare thing to be pretty catastrophic.
SPEAKER_01In another interview, Anthony called that the TSN turning point. The fact that David Eby, who What's the premier make? About $220 a year in BC. His wife makes over $300,000 as a doctor. And in a province where very few people have access to a $10 a day daycare spot, he and his wife, making more than half a million dollars a year, they got one. Yeah. So did you find that that really resonated with voters, either turning them towards your team or just turning them off eBay?
SPEAKER_00I thought it was both. I mean, Jeff may have some metrics. I remember watching that. And again, he makes over half a million years a household. And to give people context, not in BC, 90% of BC families do not have access to $10 day daycare. It's like this highly select thing. And one of the girls that works for us turned around and said, my kid is in daycare. I'm spending over $2,000 a month. And this guy is spending next to nothing. Women were absolutely beside themselves. And I think it did two things. For some women, it brought them to us.
SPEAKER_00But I think for many women, they just said, screw this. I'm not voting for this guy. I'm not certain about the conservatives, but I'm definitely not voting for this guy. And they may be part of that quarter mill that stayed home.
SPEAKER_02It also helped us set the stage that the guy, he was opportunistic. It was an opportunistic election call, right? And he'll say one thing and do the other. He pretends to be morally righteous, but at the end of the day, he's craven. And that's what it fit into, right? People, it's just visceral. Politics is all visceral, but it's vibes. We all know this. And it just felt wrong, and it fit into the narrative that we were casting him as as opportunistic. And so, you know, did I think it was the final nail in the coffin? No, I don't. I don't think any of us were that certain, but we certainly knew that it was going to be a big deal.
SPEAKER_02And from that point on, you know, every day I had never seen a politician like this, maybe since Kathleen Wynne, where you go to their social media feeds and every single comment on his Instagram post, every single one were negative, like just completely negative. No, everyone had, it stopped being socially acceptable to defend the guy. And that's how I knew that we could be on, we were on the cusp of a potential huge win.
SPEAKER_01I'm not going to say that you had the media on your side, but you didn't have them against you. And for conservative parties, that's sometimes, you know, all the difference. I remember watching his opening news conference after he visited the LG and he comes out all smiles. Oh, I've just visited the lieutenant governor. And he gives his speech and he's still all smiling. And by the end, after those questions, including, I think it was Ben O'Hara burned from Global. You've talked an awful lot about Trump.
SPEAKER_01I'm paraphrasing. You said you've talked an awful lot about Trump. Very little about your own record. How afraid are you to run on your own record? That was a devastating comment from the media that was not partisan or anything like that. Sorry, go ahead, Angelo.
SPEAKER_00No, I was just going to say, like, it was so self-evident to the general public what he was doing that I think even the media got frustrated because he came out and said, this is all about Donald Trump. Like, he was hoping to run the election on Donald Trump. And what we did, you know, in turn is this novel, crazy idea. But Lauren just came out and said, yeah, you know what? I don't like Donald Trump. I think he's a bully. Don't like him. And that issue was essentially cauterized. And from there, he couldn't really define anything. But the other piece to this, and then I'll let Jeff speak.
SPEAKER_00Is the municipal elections. A lot of the media here were also covering municipal elections that were overlapping and they had to deal with mayors and councillors. They were a week apart. Like it ruined the election. Like we would see door knockers knocking on doors, people frustrated. Who are you with? Which lawn sign is this for? It pissed everybody off. So the media were hearing a lot about that too. Like it was just a magnificent cell phone on Eby's part.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it was just, again, it was so self-evidently craven and opportunistic that there's zero chance that the media or anyone else could let him get away with us. It was just, it's just obvious on so many fronts. And there's no way that EB was crazy to think he was going to get away with it. And
SPEAKER_00he was. Well, the last thing I would say on that piece is he thought he was running against somebody else. Like he prepared to run an election against a leader who is no longer there. And he just couldn't really get that message across, that narrative across on Lauren Dirksen, who was just a normal guy who stood up on the debate stage and even in his opener said, hey folks, I'm actually kind of nervous, right? Like it just wouldn't stick. The accusations of conservatives are evil. They're going to make cuts to healthcare. It's like, well, Lauren's kids work in the healthcare system, right?
SPEAKER_00Like you just didn't believe him. So I think, again, he prepared to run an election against Carrie Lynn Finley and he couldn't pivot.
SPEAKER_01Look, it's beyond me why he didn't, after she resigned, just say, okay, let's milk this for all it's worth and keep pushing the fact that the party's splintering, the fact that there's all this infighting. Just why not keep pushing all of that and allow yourself to look better by comparison? Maybe in January or February, it could have called an election and still been Now,
SPEAKER_01Dirksen was named interim leader. I know there's party rules. The NDP tried to make that an issue. Well, you can't vote for that guy. He's only an interim leader, which, of course, only brought back the, yeah, because you called an early and unnecessary election. But I'm still getting questions. So maybe you two can answer this. Is Lorne Dirksen going to be premier of British Columbia or because he's interim leader, do you have to have A leadership race. I think he's earned the right to be premier. He ran the election.
SPEAKER_01He won the election. People did not say I'm voting for the BC conservatives on the caveat that during the road, you have a leadership vote. What's the deal there?
SPEAKER_00Well, I can give you like the constitutional answer. I mean... The practical answer is that he's the premier and he's the leader, right? Like if you earned a mandate for almost a million voters, you've certainly earned a mandate from the 20 something members that would have voted in a leadership race. From an administrative standpoint, there's a million and one different ways the party can just declare him as the leader. And I assume that's what they're going to do. It is a weird attack because again, they called the election. And what I found is every day they spent saying he's not really the real leader.
SPEAKER_00They missed the part that's important that maybe Jeff deals with in sort of the world of Facebook and just ordinary people. No one knows what you're talking about. No one knows what interim leader means. Like no one knows what you're saying, right? Most people think he's clearly the candidate. If he wins, he's clearly going to be the premier and the leader. Like it doesn't make any sense to them. And that is the case. The guy is the premier. He's going to be the leader.
SPEAKER_01Jeff, is that the sort of thing that when people are talking on Facebook, on Instagram, on X, outside of the You know, the weird ones on X, like all of us, like normal people on social media. Is that how they're looking at it?
SPEAKER_02I think the I think EB really he got confused and he thought that people care about politics a lot more than they do. I think they thought, you know, they're these conservatives. They had a messy leadership. They had a messy summer. And the whole public knows this. Yeah. And we're going to call an election and the public will understand this. And even if KOF isn't leader anymore, they're going to know that this party is a circus, just like we think they are. And it was wishcasting, right? In the same sense that they want to believe that, you know, all conservatives are Trumpets.
SPEAKER_02And everyone knows it. They think it's common wisdom. It wasn't true. And the public has better things to do with their lives than care about the mechanics of an opposition party. And that was clearly demonstrated when the election was called. People were kind of awoken from their slumber. Why are we having an election? And suddenly, okay, well, this Lauren Dirksen guy seems pretty good. And Evie seems pretty craven.
SPEAKER_02Not to use that word again. And then it was a crystal clear framing from that point. And we just had to not mess up and reinforce our positives and try to expand our reach in terms of our reach and appeal by using caucus candidates.
SPEAKER_01Well, you guys have an awful lot of work to do in turning BC around. I don't know if either one of you are going to be part of that, but Lorne Dirksen and his team will be. You've got a budget to get back into balance or at least, you know, sanity. You've got a healthcare system that is broken. You've got social unrest driven by the horrible drug policies of the NDP for the last decade. You've got Dripit to deal with and an awful lot of people wondering, do they still own their homes? Those are the big issues going forward. But thanks for taking the time to talk about one of
SPEAKER_01the most bizarre election campaigns I've covered in my 25 years of doing this. Thanks so much.
Canadians are outraged that Florida Republican Governor Ron DeSantis wants Canadians to face a tax hike to subsidize Florida residents. It’s outrageous, but it’s also a little rich. Canadians are angry at Americans for...
A lot of people commenting on things that just aren’t so. A few clips of Carney to share with you today, so it’s pretty much all video today. That said, here’s the chart I show in the video. It shows where things are at...
Canada faces a pile of new trade actions that start next week. Why isn’t Mark Carney trying to get a new deal. Instead, he’s putting good paying jobs at risk because he prefers politics to economics. Odd for a man...
Mr. Carney goes to New York. It’s clear that Mark Carney likes foreign journalists better than Canadian ones. He turns to the BBC, Bloomberg, and now the New York Times when he wants to get out points. In today’s...
The chaos in the Conservative Party of BC continued on Sunday with leader Kerry-Lynne Findlay resigning in the afternoon. Her resignation came as yet another MLA left the party taking them down to 24 seats, 20 below...