Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Full Comment

Full Comment artwork

Carney’s move to align with Europe...

Sep 30, 202616 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

A lot of people commenting on things that just aren’t so. A few clips of Carney to share with you today, so it’s pretty much all video today. That said, here’s the chart I show in the video. It shows where things are at in terms of Canada’s largest export markets. Add up the next four biggest markets after the US and it’s $75.9 billion USD which is worth just 18.9% of what we sold to the Americans. Take out the Netherlands and put in the EU and it comes to $99.49 billion USD or 24.89% of what we sell south of the border. This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.brianlilley.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Mark Carney looking to align our standards with Europe. Hate to say I told you so. Oh, why lie? I love saying I told you so. Hi, Brian Lilley here. You can read me at torontosun.com. And of course, sign up for the newsletter, brianlilley.com. That way you get stuff straight to your inbox. You bypass the tech algorithms to keep blocking stuff or, you know, the ever-changing legal landscape that the liberal government in Ottawa likes to play with in the online world. So let's get back to Mark Carney.

SPEAKER_01Aligning with Europe. Remember, he said, we weren't looking to become any sort of member with the EU after the Wall Street Journal reported we were seeking associate membership. And then it turned out, yeah, both sides were using that language. But Carney said, well, no, no, we're not doing that. Not happening. No big announcement. Then in Ursula von der Leyen's speech, she says, dear Mark, I want to offer you The first associate membership in the EU, and he uses the same term the next day,

SPEAKER_01but don't worry, we're not giving up any sovereignty. I mean, the talking heads at CBC have said this repeatedly, and I said, well, wait a minute, it's difficult to get closer to the EU than we already are without giving up sovereignty whatsoever. In terms of things like setting our own standards, and you can willfully align standards, absolutely. But do you think when it comes to Canada and the EU, that 41 million people is going to have that big a say in the standards?

SPEAKER_01Or are we just going to have to accept what the EU puts forward? Well, that brings me to this. And Politico today has this story. EU in Canada to announce partnership, sweeping new partnership pact. Now, if you go into it and you scroll down, I'll have to switch over to that tab myself. You scroll down and right here,

SPEAKER_01we will align strategies and standards, connect industries and focus our ambitions on sectors with the greatest capabilities. Returns for our peoples. This includes development of low-carbon, reliable energy that much of the world is hungry for, from liquefied natural gas to hydro, solar, and nuclear. It talks about how they are, you know, Canada and the EU are buying 50 de Havilland water bombers, and we're going to jointly own them. We'll have shared custody, I guess, for forest fighting and the like, and that'll take effect sometime in the 2030s.

SPEAKER_01So all of this is going to come out in Montreal at the Canada-EU summit that's happening at the end of the month. This has been what I've been saying, though, is that if we want to be closer, we're going to have to align standards for Norway, Iceland, Switzerland to get the access they have, which is deeper than a free trade deal. They have to just accept EU standards. Maybe we'll have to do that. Maybe some of them are better than our own standards.

SPEAKER_01But maybe some of them are worse or don't quite work for the whole country. Do we get a say in it? Norway, Iceland, Switzerland, Liechtenstein? They don't get a say, but they have to accept those standards. So, look, I'm trying to have an honest and real conversation. Carney's being vague, and too many of his supporters are just being emotional and saying, well, yeah, but at least we're sticking it to Trump, huh? Yeah, that's an entire... Country running on emotions around this one issue right now and rarely sitting down

SPEAKER_01and looking at the facts. Well, Carney was asked on Tuesday about this issue of standards, but it was from an activist reporter at the National Observer. If you are not familiar with the National Observer, you are a blessed person. This is a far left activist group that masquerades as a media outfit. And if they were on the right, they would not be given any credence. They wouldn't get press gallery credentials, all of that. They're pure activists.

SPEAKER_01And you can hear it in the question. Courtney looks rightly annoyed in the second question, which I won't play for you. It looks like he wants to tell the guy to F off. And I wouldn't blame them if he did. But, you know, listen to his answer.

SPEAKER_02In the last few weeks, there's been a lot of talk of Canada getting closer, having a rapprochement with Europe. How do you intend to integrate our pesticide regulatory regime, which your government has been kind of gutting, with the more stringent European measures?

SPEAKER_03Well, I'll say a couple of things. One is that, and it follows from The world wants to do more with Canada and there's a tremendous opportunity that is being created with an alliance for the future with the European Union. That's an alliance that will make us stronger, make us more independent and really in our view and I think the view of European Union provide an example for the world.

SPEAKER_03What comes with that is high standards. Now, the specific aspects, specific pesticide standards or phytosanitary or other standards, it depends on the nature of the part And you will hear more about the nature of the partnership at our summit, a Kennedy EU summit in Montreal at the end of October. But so it depends on the breadth and the depth of that. It's not clear that those specific areas would necessarily come to pass

SPEAKER_03and be included, given all the other opportunities that are there.

SPEAKER_01Okay, now he didn't directly answer the question, but he somewhat answered it. It was a fairly reasonable answer. Talked about how... You know, aligning standards. He gave away a hint, though. Higher standards. It comes with higher standards. Carney is a Europhile, and Europhiles tend to think that everything Europe does is better than Canada. Again, I'm not sure on some things. Yes, their standards can be better. Others, ours. We won't be picking and choosing. Maybe we'll pick and choose where we align, but when we align, we will be accepting theirs. That is giving up sovereignty, right?

SPEAKER_01We need to have a conversation about that. Now, The other thing that I've been talking about is that right now the EU is not replacing the U.S. in terms of our trade. And, you know, I wrote about this in the newsletter the other day and people were still writing back in and I showed you some of the reaction and people were still writing back in and saying, no, no, we can just pivot and we don't have to deal with the U.S. So, um, I redid a chart that we ran earlier this year in the Toronto Sun.

SPEAKER_01And at that point, we just had the 2024 details. It was early February, I believe, that we did this chart up originally. So I pulled the numbers again, had it done up. These are where our exports go. And really, that's what we care about, the exports, because these are goods that we're selling. This is good for the country's economy. Makes us a prosperous nation to be able to do this. We dropped $18 billion in what we sold to the U.S. last year.

SPEAKER_01Now, 2024 was $419.75 billion. This is all U.S. dollars. And then 2025, it was 401. Now, is that because we stopped trading with them? No, a lot of that was because the price of oil fell. If you remember 2025, price of oil dropped dramatically. Alberta was worried about Massive deficits, and they weren't sure when it was going to pounce back. And, well, the government of Canada and the government of Alberta are doing very well, thanks to Donald Trump's invasion of Iran.

SPEAKER_01But there you have it. $419 billion in 2024 is what we sold to the Americans. $401 billion in 2025. Price of oil's gone up. We'll see what the numbers are in a little while for 2026. But compare the other Next biggest trading partners, right? United Kingdom, last year, 33.5 billion. China, 20.5 billion. We sold them. Japan, 10.4. Netherlands, they jumped onto the list last year.

SPEAKER_01In 2024, it was Mexico, but Netherlands sold us 6.9. Now, you add all of that up for our four biggest trading export markets after the United States, And you get about 75%, sorry, about 75 billion. 18%, 18.9% roughly is of the US total is what we sell to our next four biggest trading partners.

SPEAKER_01Now, if you take out the Netherlands and add in the EU, you have to take the Netherlands out because they're part of the EU. And it comes in at $99 billion. So just under 25% of what we sell to the United States. I am all in favor of expanding trade. I have been advocating that for about 20 years. I've been advocating for a free trade deal with India. Looks like we might finally get there in December, and that's good news. Our free trade deal with Europe is now more than 10 years old,

SPEAKER_01and 10 out of 27 countries have not ratified it. But these numbers show you that we're not Pulling away from the United States. Nor should we. We should expand. But you're not going to replace $400 billion. In a down year, we sold them $400 billion worth of goods. And we think that we can suddenly pivot and sell all of that to the European Union. Well, they don't want our heavy oil. They don't want our cars. And those are by far our two biggest exports.

SPEAKER_01Globally, not just to the U.S. But all of that goes to the U.S. We've got a lot of Canadians tell themselves sweet little lies, and we've got to have realistic conversations. Because, you know, Prime Minister Carney... Here's what he said in the New York Times. Oh, no, I've got it on another spot there about immigration. In the New York Times, he said there is the way towards a deal.

SPEAKER_01That's why I keep advocating. We should get back to the negotiating table. There was one main issue that stopped the deal from happening on August 21st, and that was the 25% duties on medium and heavy-duty trucks. Is there a way to get past that? I'm sure there is. The U.S. is in the middle of investigating the Medium and heavy duty trucks, considering whether it's a national security issue for them, that so many of them are not made in the United States. Why would they consider that a national security issue?

SPEAKER_01Because of how many are used within the military. And do they have secure supply? Right now, based on how things are going with Canada, they probably say Canada is not a secure supplier. But if we get back to the table, we can find a way around that. We can find a way to negotiate. It's remarkable how many Carney supporters say there's no path to a deal. Prime Minister says there is. The Prime Minister also says we should form a fertilizer independence block.

SPEAKER_01How do you draw closer with the U.S. if you're supposed to be elbows up and running away? There is a vast difference between what the PM actually says and what he emphasizes and what his followers and supporters You know, true believers here and they hear rupture, runaway, don't have anything to do with the U.S., which is what he emphasizes. But he also talks about there is a way to a deal and we can get to them. And you know why we should be getting to them?

SPEAKER_01Because of the 500 workers laid off at Stelco this week and at other plants. There's going to be more layoffs coming. Paperboard factory up into Miskimane in Quebec. There's going to be there's furniture. Maker South of Montreal that departed and moved down to the U.S. because they just wouldn't be able to survive otherwise. You're going to see that sort of thing happening. If we've got bans on products, bottling jobs are going to move, we need to be taking this seriously. In that same news conference from the clip I played a view of Carney earlier,

SPEAKER_01he chastised Stelco for laying off the workers. And... Yeah, Trump's tariffs are the reason for this, but also we're not blocking Chinese steel, which is dumped into an Indian steel, dumped into our market at unfair prices. And guess what? Out in the Western part of the country, they use a lot of cheaper steel imported from India and China, which is dumped into the market, subsidized by their governments. It's unfair trading practices.

SPEAKER_01We should have tariffs on those or higher tariffs on those. And we're not doing it. So Carney chastises Stelco for laying off the 500 workers. But he was also asked, because this was an announcement about expanding the LNG in Kitimat, will the steel used in this be Canadian steel?

SPEAKER_00Georgie Smythe, CBC. Is phase two of LNG Canada going to be built with Chinese steel, like phase one, or will it be built with Canadian steel?

SPEAKER_03Okay, so for them,

SPEAKER_01They get to decide. If you're building an oil pipeline, you have to spend billions of dollars to do capture carbon in storage. I know that if, you know, I've already heard from the people who want a pure free market response to this. It's up to them. No, this is a major project. And he's doing this for Alberta, dictating terms. He could have said, look, if you want approval on this, give us a commitment. You'll use Canadian steel. Um, You know, it would have been a no-brainer, or at least he could have said something supporting Canadian steel.

SPEAKER_01You know, the federal government is running a program to subsidize the transportation of steel from eastern Canada to western Canada to try and deal with the dumping I was describing earlier. There are other steps they could take. That was a very strange and weak answer, considering that just moments later, he was attacking Stelco. Not saying he's wrong and saying Stelco is letting people down. They are. 500 jobs lost. Maybe those layoffs, you know, people get callbacks later. But right now, it's 500 layoff notices going out.

SPEAKER_01That hurts families. That, you know, people worried about will they be able to pay their mortgage, pay their rent, put food on the table. Those are real world concerns. Carney failed on that answer. Anyways, that wraps it for today. And back at it tomorrow. Make sure you read in the Toronto Sun. Make sure that you are subscribing at brianlilley.com and sharing this on social media.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. How the B.C. Conservatives won big a week ago...

    Nov 1, 202622 minAudio

    The fact that the B.C. Conservatives won last weekend wasn’t the shocking part, it was the size of their win. The party took 63 seats to the, while the NDP took just 28 and the Greens 2. There were people who were...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Canadians angry at Florida tax plan need to look in the mirror...

    Oct 4, 202612 minAudio

    Canadians are outraged that Florida Republican Governor Ron DeSantis wants Canadians to face a tax hike to subsidize Florida residents. It’s outrageous, but it’s also a little rich. Canadians are angry at Americans for...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Carney is playing games with people’s jobs...

    Sep 25, 202618 minAudio

    Canada faces a pile of new trade actions that start next week. Why isn’t Mark Carney trying to get a new deal. Instead, he’s putting good paying jobs at risk because he prefers politics to economics. Odd for a man...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Carney tells all to the New York Times...

    Sep 24, 202617 minAudio

    Mr. Carney goes to New York. It’s clear that Mark Carney likes foreign journalists better than Canadian ones. He turns to the BBC, Bloomberg, and now the New York Times when he wants to get out points. In today’s...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. BC Conservative leader resigns as leader, stays on as by-election candidate...

    Sep 20, 202611 minAudio

    The chaos in the Conservative Party of BC continued on Sunday with leader Kerry-Lynne Findlay resigning in the afternoon. Her resignation came as yet another MLA left the party taking them down to 24 seats, 20 below...

    Credit the people on this episode