Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Full Comment

Full Comment artwork

Carney tells all to the New York Times...

Sep 24, 202617 minAudio

Mr. Carney goes to New York. It’s clear that Mark Carney likes foreign journalists better than Canadian ones. He turns to the BBC, Bloomberg, and now the New York Times when he wants to get out points. In today’s edition of the Times, a major interview with Mark Carney. Carney went to the Times offices in Midtown Manhattan and spent more than an hour there talking with them. That’s not something he affords to Canadian media outlets who need to make due to short, and curt, answers that often show his dislike for having to answer their pesky questions. The interview talked about reviewing plans for a possible invasion of Canada by the Americans, reducing reliance on American products and supply chains from the F-35 to Starlink, but at the same time talking once again about forming a bloc with the Americans and Mexicans on potash and other fertilizer inputs. All of that is interesting, but the thing the Trump administration will take away from this is that once again, Mark Carney is looking at doing away with the US dollar as the global reserve currency. Mr. Carney on Wednesday also reiterated his long-held view that a global financial system wholly dependent on the U.S. dollar was unsustainable. A move to a multipolar system in which there are several reserve currencies would “provide more flexibility,” he said. He acknowledged that there was a “directional shift” underway in which countries were re-evaluating their exposure to the U.S. dollar, but he conceded that any pivot would be limited until there was “proper liberalization” of China’s currency and financial system. Still, Mr. Carney said he expected the demand for U.S. dollar alternatives to grow, in part because of the Trump administration’s decision to rewire trading relations and use integration as “leverage.” This isn’t a new way of thinking, Carney pushed this same kind of thinking when he was Governor of the Bank of England. The bits about the invasion by the United States and dropping the F-35, that was for the domestic audience. This part about the US dollar is a message for the Trump administration, people like Scott Bessent and Jamieson Greer. Let’s see how it is received. Understanding the American side… I mentioned and played part of the Jamieson Greer interview in the video above, but if you have the time and haven’t watched him yet, it’s worth your time. I find Greer to be well spoken and reasonable even when I disagree with his conclusion. Watching and listening to him, you get a better understanding of the thinking behind their trade moves. Funding failed promises and rewarding terrorism… Did you know that Mark Carney has pledged another $100 million of your tax dollars to the Palestinian cause? Did you know that since the October 7, 2023 terrorist attacks launched by Hamas against Israel we have pledged $600 million. I was writing about that in the Toronto Sun today. It’s revolting, it’s sickening, it rewards terrorism - especially since Hamas has no disarmed and none of the promises they made in exchange for Canada providing money and recognizing a Palestinian state have been met. Don’t worry, we can still spare another $100 million. This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.brianlilley.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Mark Carney showing once again he prefers foreign media to Canadian media. Yep, a big interview with the New York Times with some nuggets dropped in there that I don't think are particularly aimed at us, but at informing the Trump administration. I'm Brian Lilley, writer with torontosun.com and of course, brianlilley.com. Make sure you sign up for the newsletter there. That way you don't miss columns, videos, everything straight to your inbox. Algorithms always changing by text, the tech giants, and of course, the Liberal government in Ottawa constantly changing the law.

SPEAKER_00They've got another one coming out to regulate the internet. So this is why it's important to sign up. So let's get to that big story. Here is what it looks like on the New York Times webpage. We'll see what it looks like. Mark Carney's balancing act. And it's a pretty wide-ranging interview. Carney, let's stop that. Carney went to the New York Times,

SPEAKER_00their Midtown Manhattan offices on Wednesday as he wrapped his UN appearance that went from Monday to Wednesday. And before flying back to Ottawa, According to the Times, he spent more than an hour talking to their journalists. Now, why does this matter? A couple of reasons. One, once again, we're finding out about Canadian policy from an American media outlet, much like we did with the Wall Street Journal informing us that Canada was seeking associate membership, something Carney denied until Ursula von der Leyen Announced it at the EU Parliament

SPEAKER_00and he stood up applauding, smiling and gave her a kiss. But don't worry, we're not going for associate membership. It's just a unique alliance that we're going to call associate membership. So what are we learning from this New York Times interview? A couple of nuggets. As I said, he talks about the fact that he examined potential Invasion plans to prep for the United States invading Canada. He called it a long tail possibility,

SPEAKER_00you know, something that not really all that probable, but, you know, it's responsible for him to have reviewed them. You know, to a degree, I'm going to agree with that. I have never thought the idea of a military invasion was feasible. You know, Trump basically asked us to become the 51st state. We said no. He moved on, except when He's trolling. There was never a serious thought of actually invading us. But, you know, he had to get that nugget out there.

SPEAKER_00Liberals here in Canada will love it. Liberals in the U.S. will love it. And of course, The New York Times is a liberal leaning paper, but still a serious one. And that's why this interview matters. He talked about the F-35 decision that we might not buy all 88 that we have on order, that we Are constantly trying to move away from American technology such as Starlink. But it was the comments that they published towards the end of the interview about

SPEAKER_00the US dollar as the reserve currency that stuck out to me. So US dollar is the reserve currency for the entire world. It's why all kinds of foreign countries buy up US treasury bonds. Balance of payments are settled in U.S. dollars for global trade. Some people have long wanted to get away from that. Mark Carney is one of them. Going back to his time as governor of the Bank of England, he tried to bring China and China's currency into the City

SPEAKER_00of London financial payment system. He tried to integrate them more. And guess what he's talking about here? Mr. Carney on Wednesday also reiterated his loan-held view that a global financial system wholly dependent on the U.S. dollar was unsustainable. A move to a multipolar system in which there are several reserve currencies would provide more flexibility, he said. He acknowledged there was a directional shift underway in which countries were re-evaluating their exposure to the U.S. dollar, but conceded that any pivot would be limited until there was proper liberalization

SPEAKER_00of China's currency, So again, what's he doing here? Some of the things in this interview that he's releasing that he hasn't talked about with Canadian media, who he doesn't give that much time to, who he gives short, curt, dismissive answers to when he does deign to take their questions, some of those things are aimed at a Canadian audience in the When a Canadian leader is speaking on foreign soil,

SPEAKER_00there's always two audiences, the one in front of them and the one back home. And so things like the F-35 and potash and things like that, with the invasion plans, that's really for the Globe and Mail readers who are still writing letters to the editor that they'll be there to defend against the U.S. Army with their backhoe or their garden hoe, not even a backhoe. That's aimed at that audience. The currency bit? That is aimed at the administration.

SPEAKER_00Smart people in the administration like Scott Besson, the Treasury Secretary, is going to be very concerned about that. Jameson Greer, the U.S. Trade Representative, is going to be very concerned about that. We'll see how that plays out. So that's all in New York Times today. I'll have more on that with the Toronto Sun later on. Probably a column occupied for a bit of the morning, but, you know, I'm going to think on this and look at reaction, see what happens.

SPEAKER_00And we'll have more to say on that later today. I do want to look back a little bit at, you know, when Carney did decide he would speak to Canadian media, what he was saying. You may have noticed that he's talking about He's talking about privatization, but not really privatization of airports. And he's making changes to the labor code. Mackenzie Gray with Global News was traveling with Carney and he put the question to him. He said, look, I went through your election plans for last year.

SPEAKER_00None of this is there. Do you have a mandate? Check this out.

SPEAKER_03Do you think you have a mandate to move forward with those key things that you've been proposing over the last few days? Short answer is yes. We have a mandate to build Canada strong, to diversify our partnerships, to make Canada stronger, more independent, more resilient. All of those aspects are doing so.

SPEAKER_00Okay. So he believes he does have a mandate. And he goes on to say, look, things change and we send officials to Parliament to vote on these and make these decisions. All of that is correct. Does he have a mandate, especially on the EU thing? Look, I vaguely support his plans for the airports. It's concession. It's not selling them off. It's not full privatization like Heathrow. It's more like Charles de Gaulle, Rome, Athens, part of Atlanta.

SPEAKER_00The international ENF tournaments in Atlanta are run by one of the companies with Canadian ties. So I have no issue with the airports. The labor thing, by the way, I'll get to that another time. Supreme Court will not accept this, I don't think. Not based on their 2015 Saskatchewan Federation of Labor decision when they said there is a constitutional right to strike. Justice Rosalia Bella overturning decades of precedent at the Supreme Court and just saying it is time to give benediction to this idea.

SPEAKER_00Not a legal argument, but that's what every government has to deal with now. But back to the EU. Does he have a mandate to make as a member? No, I don't think so. And therefore, is he going to seek another one? Is he going to look to do an early election after his EU summit where they hammer out a deal to give us some kind of form of membership? And after the midterms, when it doesn't matter what outcome there is, Carney will be able to spin it as, well,

SPEAKER_00I need a mandate for the EU and for our changing relationship with the United States and goes to the people early. Potential could happen before Christmas. We'll have to wait and see on that. While Carney was there, by the way, and this is something that I'm writing about in my column for the Toronto Sun today. Let me just bring that one up for you because this is not going to make an awful lot of people unhappy.

SPEAKER_00Some will cheer it on, but this is my latest in the sun. There we go. We'll get rid of that. Okay, so Carney's $600 million check for broken Palestinian promises. Since October 7th, 2023, we have offered $600 million to the Palestinian cause. That's not my calculation. That's not a media-led calculation.

SPEAKER_00That's the government's boast. And they put in the October 2023 date into their news release. That's been the reward that we've been giving them. So this week we announced another $100 million, 80 million for humanitarian aid and 20 million for security. We're still using groups like UNRWA, which has ties to Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad. UNRWA was forced to fire 70 members for their ties to terrorism, alleged ties to terrorism earlier this year.

SPEAKER_00And it has been well-documented by the Americans, by the Israelis, The evidence has been presented to Canada time and again. We just, we never stopped funding UNRWA. There are other actors in the area that we could fund that are not completely mobbed up with terrorists. We prefer going to UNRWA, the UN agency that, well, their school workers and health workers took part in October 7th. And what we've been doing since October 7th is rewarding them.

SPEAKER_00So that is in the sun today. Um, Please do check it out. Share it on social where you can. Obviously not Facebook, but maybe one day we'll get to that. I want to play a couple of clips here. One of Donald Trump, one of Argentinian President Javier Millal. I am not a big fan of the United Nations, and I wrote about that the other day. As the world burns, the UN still burns.

SPEAKER_00Failing to do their job. This is an organization founded in 1945 to stop war. And they're horrible at it. You can look at the way the vetoes are used and abused on the Security Council. You can look at all kinds of ways that they fail. There's some decent stuff. UN World Food Program still gets high marks. But a lot of the other stuff is far too political. The outgoing Secretary General, Antonio Guterres,

SPEAKER_00Said that he's never seen such devastation as he's seen in Palestine, Gaza. At most, and it's horrible, but at most you're talking 70,000 people have died in that war. He's also in charge of the UN at a time when fighting in Sudan has displaced 14 million people. And far more people have died in that war than... In the war between Israel and Hamas, far more people have died of starvation in the Horn of Africa in that same time.

SPEAKER_00And he doesn't speak about it. Why? Because, well, like certain CBC folks, obsessed with Israel. I don't know if you noticed that CBC's Evan Dyer is constantly talking about Will Canada stop Benjamin Netanyahu? Now, I got him to admit he did not want, got him to admit this on X, that he did not want Canada's scrambled fighter jets to try and force a landing

SPEAKER_00of Netanyahu's plane when it flies through Canadian airspace and arrest him because he's always talking about executing the arrest warrant. That's the only way that could happen. But he did say, well, what about blocking? And so the Kearney government was asked, Are you letting Netanyahu fly through Canadian airspace? If a foreign leader is going to fly through the airspace of another country, they're supposed to give two or three days heads up, and they have to get approval. You know what he didn't push for?

SPEAKER_00Because coming from Tehran or Algiers, where he refueled, there's a good chance that Iran's Petra Canyon's flight would have gone through Canadian airspace. There's a good chance that it did, even though he went through Algiers and you don't have to go as, you know, the arc isn't as far north. It's a good chance he went through Algiers. Where's Evan Dyer on that? Where's all the folks down at the UN on that? Well, they're nowhere to be found because, well,

SPEAKER_00we know why they're concerned about Netanyahu, but not the leader of a theocratic regime that is the largest sponsor, state sponsor of terrorism. So here's what Donald Trump had to say about the U.N. And I think for the most part, he's right on this.

SPEAKER_02The United Nations has great, great potential. I've said that for many years, but it must stop imposing the far left agenda of globalist bureaucrats who nobody ever elected. Last year, my administration was forced to intervene to stop an obscure U.N. body, the International Maritime Organization. From secretly establishing a first ever global carbon tax, very expensive tax, to raise international shipping costs by 10 to 20 percent and maybe more than that.

SPEAKER_02There is no global government and while I'm president there will be no global taxes. The United States is equally opposed to the out of control. Thank you. Thank you

SPEAKER_00very much. There is no global government. There should be no global tax. One of the fundamental measures of our governing system, and this is not American. This goes back to the Magna Carta. There is no taxation without representation. When King John was forced to sign at Ronymead, the noble said, you're going to tax us. We have to get a say. That has expanded over the years to include the common man and not just landholding nobles.

SPEAKER_00It remains part of Canada's view of doing things. And yet Canada was pretty much on board with that global tax. Who collects a global tax? Who gets a say in a global tax? As Trump said, useless bureaucrats. Here's Mulally. I'm saying his name, Ron. I'm butchering at the UN as well, talking about an organization that never really helped his country when they were in bad shape.

SPEAKER_01That's to say, it's become a useless organization whose only purpose is to sustain a cast of fatally arrogant parasites masquerading as well-intentioned bureaucrats. I would remind them of what Mises said, good people do not think about controlling the lives of their fellow human beings. Those who were supposed to guarantee collective security and human rights failed in their task. Instead, they allowed chaos, violence and international terrorism to flourish.

SPEAKER_00Couldn't have said it better myself. I remember speaking with John Bolton back when, it was just after he stepped down as the UN ambassador for the United States. We had long conversations about how to reform the UN. Could it be done and how it would have to be done? It requires holding back money, which most countries have not been willing to do, but you hold back the money until the reform happens. Canada is a major donor to it. We could be having a good influence on this. Unfortunately, we're not.

SPEAKER_00As I said, I'll have more out later today on Carney's New York Times musings. We'll have more out on what he has to say. Again, torontosun.com, but really sign up for the newsletter, brianlilley.com, so that you never miss a thing. Thanks for watching. Remember, I'm on your side.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. How the B.C. Conservatives won big a week ago...

    Nov 1, 202622 minAudio

    The fact that the B.C. Conservatives won last weekend wasn’t the shocking part, it was the size of their win. The party took 63 seats to the, while the NDP took just 28 and the Greens 2. There were people who were...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Canadians angry at Florida tax plan need to look in the mirror...

    Oct 4, 202612 minAudio

    Canadians are outraged that Florida Republican Governor Ron DeSantis wants Canadians to face a tax hike to subsidize Florida residents. It’s outrageous, but it’s also a little rich. Canadians are angry at Americans for...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Carney’s move to align with Europe...

    Sep 30, 202616 minAudio

    A lot of people commenting on things that just aren’t so. A few clips of Carney to share with you today, so it’s pretty much all video today. That said, here’s the chart I show in the video. It shows where things are at...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Carney is playing games with people’s jobs...

    Sep 25, 202618 minAudio

    Canada faces a pile of new trade actions that start next week. Why isn’t Mark Carney trying to get a new deal. Instead, he’s putting good paying jobs at risk because he prefers politics to economics. Odd for a man...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. BC Conservative leader resigns as leader, stays on as by-election candidate...

    Sep 20, 202611 minAudio

    The chaos in the Conservative Party of BC continued on Sunday with leader Kerry-Lynne Findlay resigning in the afternoon. Her resignation came as yet another MLA left the party taking them down to 24 seats, 20 below...

    Credit the people on this episode