Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Full Comment

Full Comment artwork

Pierre’s good day in NYC...

Sep 11, 202619 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Pierre Poilievre had a good day in New York, appearing on CNBC and talking up Canada and the benefits of tariff free trade between our two countries. He also appeared on Fox Business with Larry Kudlow. Neither station is widely available for most Canadians, but they do have impressive audiences stateside. Here, courtesy of CBC Watcher on X, is Poilievre’s interview on CNBC. Here is part of his appearance with Kudlow. Poilievre did a good job of pushing his points on how to improve the Canadian economy, why tariff free trade is best and he did it all without attacking Mark Carney on foreign soil. That’s important, because if he had personally attacked Carney in the United States, he would have been pilloried here. This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. When Liberals steal your policies… The Liberals have a habit of stealing, or half-stealing Conservative policies. Their latest one, not quite repealing Bill C-69, the no more pipelines bill, but pulling it back enough to not be an impediment anymore. The people I am speaking with, not fans of the Carney government, are actually happy with where they are going on this. They see it as a return to the old Harper policy of one project, one review. Harper’s policy was smart but the Liberals railed against it in opposition and then reversed it in government. If they bring back one project, one review for environmental assessments it will be a very good thing with provinces taking the lead. Anyway, here’s Carney’s energy minister Tim Hodgson talking about exporting Canadian oil that none of us would have expected 18 months ago. We are fighting, but can we win… This week on Batra’s Burning Questions we tackled the issue of the trade war. I’ve been clear, I don’t think that’s the right language or framing, but that’s what most people are calling it including our prime minister. So… Has Mark Carney picked a fight he can’t win. I hash that out with Toronto Sun editor-in-chief and Lorrie Goldstein, editor emeritus for the Sun and a fellow columnist. The midterm myth… Doug Ford shuffled his cabinet on Thursday morning. It wasn’t a major shuffle, the most important players in finance, health, transportation, etc. all stayed in place. In his Q&A with reporters afterwards, Ford invoked the midterm myth that so many Canadians seem to believe. “This guy’s been going after us,” Ford said. “We’re coming into the midterms. Hopefully, he’s going to lose the Senate. He’s going to lose Congress. I hope so, and hold him accountable.” I keep saying it but most Canadians keep listening to the talking heads that say if the Democrats win the midterms, things will change for us and tariffs can be removed. I explained why this is false in a column for the Sun. If the Democrats take control of the House and Senate, they could try to repeal that law or pass new legislation requiring congressional approval for tariffs. Yet, even if such a bill passed both chambers, Trump would simply veto legislation that would take away authority Congress has already granted him. To override a veto would require two-thirds of both the House and Senate to vote against the president, and there is no scenario in which Democrats pick up that many seats in the midterms. The midterms will change nothing, which is why the Canadian strategy of trying to wait Trump out until November was always foolish. Read the whole column at the link, because as always, I make many good points, not just one. Can you trust a Democrat… A theme for both columns today could be, don’t trust a Democrat. Canadians are really stupid about American politics, see above, because they constantly think Republicans are our enemies and Democrats our friends. That’s not the case and while on trade you could argue that historically Republicans have been better, in reality, neither party is Canada’s friend. Maybe they were back in the days of Reagan, Clinton and both Bush presidents, but not lately. Obama blocked Keystone. Trump approved it. Biden blocked it again. In 2009, Obama tried to use the bailouts of GM and Chrysler to force all auto production stateside. In 2022, Joe Biden tried to do the same with the Inflation Reduction Act, which if passed in its original form would have killed auto production in Canada. Trying to force auto assembly plants south of the border is not something Donald Trump just came up with, he’s just more brazen about it. Now comes Gretchen Whitmer, the Democrat governor of Michigan. You know Michigan, the state that we are supposed to be so chummy with, all that cross border trade, all that integrated auto industry stuff. Yeah, she wants to kill off Ontario’s main source of oil, jet fuel and more by permanently shuttering Enbridge’s Line 5. Read my column on why this matters. This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.brianlilley.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02Hello, good evening. It is September 10th, 2026. Brian Lilley here from torontosun.com. And of course, brianlilley.com. Please keep reading me at the sun. And of course, sign up for the newsletter at brianlilley.com. The tech giants constantly changing the algorithm. They've just done it again. And the liberal government in Ottawa constantly playing with different laws,

SPEAKER_02different pieces of legislation surrounding internet discoverability. Well, you might not always find me. So you sign up at brianlilley.com. You get the columns, links to them, videos, everything sent right to your inbox. You don't have to worry. So. There, we have that out of the way. But a good day for Pierre Polyev today. The conservative leader was down in New York City. He's going to be down there for the 25th anniversary of 9-11. I'll have thoughts and reflections on that tomorrow. But today, he was making the rounds on business news networks, CNBC and Fox Business.

SPEAKER_02You know, neither one of them are really huge in Canada, but they have big audiences in the States. Both very impressive networks, if you like watching business coverage. And so it was good for him to be down there. I remember Stephen Harper going down in 2008, 2009 during the financial crisis and making sure that Canada's story was told there. It might be a good idea for Mark Carney to go on these networks. Instead, he talks to BBC. He talks to, you know, old journalist friends and very liberal outlets.

SPEAKER_02He should be talking to the business media about tariffs because that's what Pierre Polyef was talking about how Canada can fix its economy and why we need two-way trade, no tariffs.

SPEAKER_00Here is a short clip. We can be the richest country in the world. We have the longest oceanic close line. We're fourth in oil reserves, fifth as a natural gas producer, third in uranium, first in potash. We have the fifth. Fifth biggest supply of farmland anywhere in the world per capita. What we need to do is unleash free enterprise by cutting taxes on work, investment, home building and investment. We need also to have the fastest permits anywhere in the world, open up more competition.

SPEAKER_00I've proposed getting rid of capital gains tax whenever an investor rolls over their investment back into Canada. These are all things that I'm talking with our Prime Minister about. And I know that his mission is also to bring back investment to the country. So we can and I believe will be the richest country anywhere on Earth. And one of the ways that that can happen to the benefit I mean, if we believe in free markets, then we have to believe in free trade. Do you agree with that?

SPEAKER_01I respect you for not saying, we have, our opposition party goes abroad, trashes Trump on a daily basis. But it's nice that you actually have a little bit of class.

SPEAKER_02All right. Interesting to see them say that he's got a bit of class there for not insulting Mark Carney on foreign soil. And I applaud Pierre for that. Very good move and great message. Like, look, at the beginning of that clip, he really got out the same message that he was selling during the last election about what he believes we need to do to fix the Canadian economy. And I still think he's got the right prescription. So he was talking about, you know, cutting taxes, cutting regulation, the getting rid of the capital gains on anyone that reinvests in Canada.

SPEAKER_02I think that is a brilliant idea that I wish the Carney team would steal. Because look, they're going to be in government for the next little while. Pierre does say, steal my ideas, and we'll get to that in a moment. But unfortunately, the Carney government doesn't always steal the ideas fully. But when he was asked to be critical... He wasn't. That's important because, you know, when we leave our borders, our politicians are Canadians first, partisans second.

SPEAKER_02That's the way it should be. And if Pierre had not done that, he'd be pilloried in the Canadian media. Stephen Harper once went on Fox News years ago before he was prime minister and was very critical of Jean Chrétien. I believe it was Chrétien. And, you know, He took a beating for that. It did not go over well. So this is probably, you know, the right way for him to play it. I've got a podcast coming out on Monday, full comment,

SPEAKER_02recorded earlier today, speaking with Ian Brody, Stephen Harper's first chief of staff, professor in the political science department at University of Calgary, Jenny Roth, who worked on Pierre Polio's campaign, Staunch defender of Pierre. She is a partner at Crestview Strategy. Very smart political operative as well. Talk to both of them about the situation that Pierre finds himself in. When the whole world is just dealing with Trump, when the Canadian political landscape is all about Trump, what does he do?

SPEAKER_02How does he deal with that? I think today was a good example of how he can do it. Funny, I saw Gary Mason, who is The Globe and Mail's columnist in British Columbia. You might remember him. He was the one who, sitting in his residence in Palm Springs, California, was saying, doing an interview with CBC, was saying that Canadians shouldn't be going to the United States ever. The locator said Palm Springs. By the way, I have not stopped going to Palm Springs, and I'm not going to.

SPEAKER_02I don't let politicians decide where I go on vacation. I don't let politicians decide where I go to eat or any of that. Can disagree with them, can agree with them, but they're not deciding what I do in my daily life. Let's talk a little bit more about the liberals stealing conservative policies. This is a real problem. Most of the time they do it halfway. You know, they didn't Really get rid of the consumer carbon tax.

SPEAKER_02They put it to zero. They could put it back up at another point. I doubt they will in the near future because it would be politically toxic for them. They talk more than they do. That's a big problem with the Carney government, similar to the former Trudeau liberal government. Chris Selle at National Post used to say the news release is the policy. There's no policy follow-up beyond the news release. There's no... There's no there there. It's just all about the news release and the announcement, and that's it.

SPEAKER_02Carney and his team are not as bad as Trudeau, but sometimes it's not far off. Well, I hate to break it to you, but this week they actually appear to be moving in the right direction. They are not getting rid of Bill C-69, but my understanding is that they are pulling it back enough that we're headed towards one project, One review. What does that mean? One environmental assessment for major projects, pipelines, etc. Why does that matter?

SPEAKER_02That's what Stephen Harper brought in when he was prime minister. And the liberals hated it. They absolutely hated it. They railed against it. They reversed it when they came in. They wanted a federal environmental assessment on top of a provincial one. The federal view under Harper was if your environmental assessment is sufficient, we'll go with that. And that's the way it should be. And so the Carney guys are moving in that direction, not repealing Bill C-69, but paring it back enough that it's not going to get in the way as much.

SPEAKER_02Now, that said, I was at a breakfast recently with a bunch of business executives and someone working on a very major project that made a lot of news recently was telling me that despite the rhetoric that bureaucrats and You know, let me be clear. It is the bureaucrats still getting in the way. So is that at the direction of the Carney government or is it just habit? Because if they really want to unleash the economy,

SPEAKER_02the Carney government has to instruct the bureaucrats to get the hell out of the way. But here's the problem for Pierre Polyev and the conservatives. On this issue of oil and gas, The carny liberals look like they're starting to not only talk the talk, but walk the walk. And I'm going to play a clip for you here. It's a bit of a long one, but it's Natural Resources Minister Tim Hodgson being asked a question by a journalist who clearly doesn't like the oil and gas industry and saying,

SPEAKER_02okay, well, why are you doing this? This industry pollutes. You will be shocked at what Hodgson says and you will think, is this a liberal government? Here's Tim Hodgson.

SPEAKER_03I was wondering if this, well, you can both answer. I was wondering if this talking facility serves to justify the expansion of more fossil fuel production when we take into account that even the tax on industrial emissions have been lowered.

SPEAKER_01So, Here's where we are. We're in a rupture. We're in a world that is becoming increasingly unsafe and unsecure. Our allies all over the world are shutting down factories, are shutting down schools because they don't have access to conventional energy. We have chosen and we've shown the world we can be the best producers of conventional energy anywhere in the world. We do it cleaner.

SPEAKER_01We do it better than anyone in the world. And when our allies in Germany, because they don't want to buy it from Vladimir Putin, or when our allies in Asia are trying to keep their factories open because the Straits of Hormuz are closed, and they say they want to buy it from Canada because Canada's a trusted partner. Canada's a partner that doesn't sign its contracts in pencil. Canada's a partner they can rely on in this time of geopolitical uncertainty.

SPEAKER_01And we need your energy. And Canadians say, hey, our allies need it. It pays for our health care. It pays for our dental care. It pays for our $10 a day day care. It pays for our pharmacare.

SPEAKER_03But it pollutes.

SPEAKER_01Done properly, it reduces overall global emissions. In that world, in the world we need to live in, not in a magical world, in the world as it is, not as we wish it to be, this is the most productive way to be a clean and conventional energy superpower, and it makes complete sense to do that.

SPEAKER_02Can you believe that that is a liberal cabinet minister? That sounds like Andrew Scheer circa 2019. If you followed that campaign, Scheer was trying to say Canada should be exporting LNG to China to displace coal. The liberals laughed at that. Oh, no, it will just increase emissions. Scheer said, no, it will lower emissions overall because natural gas burns fewer emissions than coal. This will lower global emissions. And we keep hearing emissions don't know boundaries. No, no, no, no, no. We can't do that. Tim Hodgson sounding like Scheer back in 2019.

SPEAKER_02He's sounding like a Harper cabinet minister from pre-2015. I am just gobsmacked by this. And this is part of the problem and part of what we discuss in the podcast that will come out on Monday. How does Pierre Polyef fight against that? You know, they're stealing your policies. So in some ways, Polyev is winning the argument, if not winning the election. It's cold comfort to him.

SPEAKER_02But if it moves the country in the right direction, that's good. Mark Carney has his investment summit Monday and Tuesday next week here in Toronto, just a few blocks from where I'm sitting, up at the Four Seasons. No, I don't live in the Four Seasons or anywhere near it, but I can walk to it. Yeah. Going to have hedge funds, sovereign wealth funds, all kinds of big groups. Also, Stephen Harper is going to close it out. Harper is, of course, in addition to being running his own business now,

SPEAKER_02is also the chair of the board for the Alberta Investment Management Corporation. So that's part of why he's going to be there. Also, well-respected internationally still. He does. Still does a lot of work on the international stage, travels the world advising governments on investment, on regulation, so on. So anyways, that's of interest. Let me run through a couple of things that are working on right now or have been working on.

SPEAKER_02This is from yesterday. Diversify, yes, pretend Europe can replace America. No, no. This idea, and so right after his investment summit, Carney is going to head to the European Union, address their parliament, announce a big deal with the EU. I go through the numbers. If you haven't read this column, please go read the column and share it with your friends and family. Because I go through the numbers and I detail why Europe and the EU replacing

SPEAKER_02the US just isn't on. I'm a big fan of diversification. I have been advocating for 20 years that we should have a free trade deal with India. Forget China, India, because it is a rule of law country. It is part of the Commonwealth. It's more familiar to us than China, which you never know what you're dealing with when it comes to China. Big fan of diversifying trade, but it's hard to do. And I detail with hard numbers, with facts in this column,

SPEAKER_02What our trajectory has been like for the last 10 years with the EU after we signed a free trade deal with them. So go and check that out. Kind of a theme, and I put this in the newsletter, a bit of a theme is that you can't really trust Democrats and the midterm myth. So Doug Ford had his cabinet shuffle and he was... Going off on Donald Trump more than he was going off on or talking about his cabinet shuffle.

SPEAKER_02And he started talking about midterms and how he hopes Donald Trump loses the House and the Senate in the midterms. This is in the newsletter. Again, brianlilley.com. If you're watching this on YouTube and you're not subscribed to the newsletter, brianlilley.com, you'll get all of this. It's in the column as well at thetorontosun.com. This is a myth. I have explained it umpteen times and people keep believing that, oh no, not the Democrats, they're going to take the House and they're going to take the Senate and then everything's good and then we'll get rid of tariffs.

SPEAKER_02How? It's not going to happen. Congress cannot get rid of the Section 232 tariffs that are on our steel, aluminum, and autos. They cannot. They will not have the votes to overturn that legislation, and they do not have the authority to repeal the tariffs. I explain it all in the column. Do go check that out. And then finally, the other part of why you can't trust a Democrat, Michigan's Democrat governor,

SPEAKER_02Gretchen Whitmer, is trying to shut down Enbridge's Line 5 pipeline. So Line 5 connects to the Enbridge network that comes out of Western Canada, out of Alberta, through Saskatchewan, into Manitoba, crosses over into Superior, Wisconsin, then goes through Wisconsin, through the UP, the Upper Peninsula, in Michigan, down through the rest of Michigan, and over into Sarnia, where it disperses into Line 6, Line 7, Line 9, etc.

SPEAKER_02Line 5 provides Ontario with more than 50% of its crude oil, with 100% of the jet fuel that is used at Toronto Pearson International Airport. It provides jet fuel for Montreal's Trudeau International Airport, for Jean Lesage Airport in Quebec City, probably for McDonald Cartier International Airport in Ottawa, plus propane for home heating in Michigan, oil for refineries in Detroit and Toledo, Ohio.

SPEAKER_02Whitmer doesn't care. She wants it shut down. And she just is railing against it. She is supporting all kinds of legal challenges against it. And now she is trying to get Enbridge to shut it down within months. This would be devastating for Ontario's economy, for the economy of Eastern Canada. It would shut down a supply route for Western Canadian oil and gas. This is not good. She's a Democrat.

SPEAKER_02I keep saying it doesn't matter Republican or Democrat. Traditionally, the Republicans were actually nicer to Canada, even though Canadians love Democrats. Democrats are not our friends any more than Republicans are. They're looking after their own backyards. And Whitmer is dealing with the far left wing of the Democrat Party. She is dealing with environmental groups and greenwashed what we would call First Nations, what they call tribal groups. Aboriginal groups saying, we don't want this pipeline going through anymore.

SPEAKER_02We are at risk due to this. I detail why in the column. I detail some of the solutions. I talked to Ontario Energy Minister Stephen Lecce, got some quotes from him. Do check it out. Back again tomorrow. Thoughts on the 25th anniversary of 9-11 and looking at doing an Ask Me Anything on the weekend. We'll figure out if that's for everyone or paid subscribers. We'll figure that out soon. Again, thank you for watching. Remember, I'm on your side.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. How the B.C. Conservatives won big a week ago...

    Nov 1, 202622 minAudio

    The fact that the B.C. Conservatives won last weekend wasn’t the shocking part, it was the size of their win. The party took 63 seats to the, while the NDP took just 28 and the Greens 2. There were people who were...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Canadians angry at Florida tax plan need to look in the mirror...

    Oct 4, 202612 minAudio

    Canadians are outraged that Florida Republican Governor Ron DeSantis wants Canadians to face a tax hike to subsidize Florida residents. It’s outrageous, but it’s also a little rich. Canadians are angry at Americans for...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Carney’s move to align with Europe...

    Sep 30, 202616 minAudio

    A lot of people commenting on things that just aren’t so. A few clips of Carney to share with you today, so it’s pretty much all video today. That said, here’s the chart I show in the video. It shows where things are at...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Carney is playing games with people’s jobs...

    Sep 25, 202618 minAudio

    Canada faces a pile of new trade actions that start next week. Why isn’t Mark Carney trying to get a new deal. Instead, he’s putting good paying jobs at risk because he prefers politics to economics. Odd for a man...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Carney tells all to the New York Times...

    Sep 24, 202617 minAudio

    Mr. Carney goes to New York. It’s clear that Mark Carney likes foreign journalists better than Canadian ones. He turns to the BBC, Bloomberg, and now the New York Times when he wants to get out points. In today’s...

    Credit the people on this episode