I love the idea of expanding trade with the EU, I hate the idea of us joining the EU in any way shape or form. I break down why in this video and in the column you can find at the link below. Definitely there will be more to say on this down the road. Here is the original Wall Street Journal article. Here is my column following the WSJ. If you want to read up on trade between Canada and the EU, here is the report from the Library of Parliament that I mentioned. This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.brianlilley.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Mark Carney really has European ambitions. He truly wants to make us the most European of non-European nations. Hi, I'm Brian Lilley. Read me at torontosun.com. Sign up for the newsletter at brianlilley.com. And wow, do we have something for you today. Breaking news this morning that Canada is close to becoming an associate member of Now, I always say, read me at brianlilley at torontosun.com.
SPEAKER_00Subscribe at brianlilley.com. You subscribe to the newsletter, you get stuff right to your inbox. But why do I tell you to read me at the Toronto Sun? Because this morning was able to jump on after seeing this story break in the Wall Street Journal and was able to get into this and And write it up, but let me give full credit, as I said, first to the folks at the Wall Street Journal because it was them that broke
SPEAKER_00the story this morning. Mark Carney's audacious bid to make Canada an associate member of the EU. Here's my thinking on this. It's not a good idea. It's a good idea to expand our trade with Europe. It's not a good idea. To become a member or even an associate member of the EU. Why? Because there's so much that we would have to give up. People are worried about giving up sovereignty to the US if we deepen our trade connections with them.
SPEAKER_00Wait until you hear what's going on with the European Union. So this story breaks this morning. They've got a reporter in Ottawa, a reporter in Berlin, a reporter in Brussels. They're talking about The phone calls that Mark Carney's been making, you probably heard the story a while back about how Carney still has a cell phone, a British cell phone, and that's what he uses to talk to European leaders. Turns out European royalty as well, you know, just text them, you'll call them. And he's been trying to, you know,
SPEAKER_00use his conversations with them to, uh, You know, bring them in line with his anti-Trump way of thinking. And that wasn't difficult for many of them, like Emmanuel Macron. But Keir Starmer was kind of gun shy about that because he didn't want to anger Trump. He wanted to get a deal. Italy's Georgia Maloney. Same thing. She didn't want to anger Trump. Well, Starmer's gone. He doesn't matter anymore. Carney's off on Tuesday to meet Andy Burnham, the new UK prime minister. And Maloney out of Italy? Well, after Trump, you know, was posting images of him being the Pope and things like that.
SPEAKER_00And he said, she begged me for a photo. Apparently she changed her mind. All of this is in this piece in the Wall Street Journal, which it's very long, it's very detailed. A good chunk of it is just explaining Canadian history, Canada-US relations to an American audience that doesn't pay any attention to that. But within there, there are things that... That do matter. And let me bring it back up. Once I find the right spot, I'll share it on the screen for you.
SPEAKER_00But yeah, here we go. We'll go with that. All right. So let's share the screen. This isn't just about trading more. Here's what it says. Two officials familiar with those discussions said.
SPEAKER_00The two sides are talking about laying underwater cables to link Europe and Canada in jointly constructing data centers, cloud storage, and new satellite networks beyond the reach of American tech giants. Carney is pushing to lay the pipelines Canada needs to redirect gas, normally pumped across the U.S. border, to European allies still struggling to replace Russian energy. Icebreakers, in his vision, would clear an Arctic path for Canadian fertilizer to sail east over the Northwest Passage that lured centuries of explorers All of that's good.
SPEAKER_00We should be laying pipelines to export LNG. Notice they didn't say oil, though, to export liquefied natural gas. Should be selling that to Europe as much as possible. We should be selling that to Asia as much as possible. Even after a year and a half of Carney promising to make things like that happen, we're not really moving forward. And so many of Trudeau's bad laws, which hamstrung the industry for a decade, are still in place. There's been some movement, and I give them credit on that.
SPEAKER_00Minister Hodgson last week, essentially pulling back a lot of Bill C-69 for Alberta's oil and gas industry. But that's a sector-specific carve-out. It's not repealing the law or repealing and replacing, as Premier Smith has said to me before. She said there needs to be some law. So it needs to be repealed and replaced. Instead, we're getting one-off carve-outs and, you know, Bill C-69 can still interfere with a mine in British Columbia or Ontario. It can interfere with forestry projects in Quebec or New Brunswick.
SPEAKER_00These are all problematic and they make investors wary. You know, those investors that are going to be showing up here in Toronto on Monday and Tuesday, the laws, the bad laws haven't been fixed. Are they really going to be looking to open up their wallets? But back to Europe. We should be selling them all of these things. But why do we want to join the EU in such a way that they're now in charge of our regulations? Despite our trading relationship with the United States,
SPEAKER_00we, for the most part, are in charge of our own regulations of industries, of food. The food, packaged food that we have in this country, very different, even when it's the same product or brand. Very different ingredients than what they have in the U.S. I mean, if you've paid attention to what Robert F. Kennedy Jr. is doing with the Maha movement south of the border, he's trying to get rid of ingredients that we don't allow here. Well, some people might say the EU is even stricter and, well, they'll get out some ingredients.
SPEAKER_00Sure, that might be part of it, but there's going to be all kinds of industrial regulations, manufacturing regulations, privacy regulations. Some of them will be good. Some of them will be bad. But you know what they won't be? Decided in Canada. They'll be decided by nameless, faceless European bureaucrats in Brussels and Strasbourg. We're worried about the United States saying you can't sign a trade deal, free trade deal with China to bring in their steel and dump it in our market
SPEAKER_00if you want to have a free trade deal with us. That's what the Americans are worried about. And we're saying, oh, we can't give up our sovereignty. But we can join the EU. Now, if you think that I'm exaggerating, take a look at Norway. Norway is not a full member of the EU, but they do have deep trade access. I don't even think they're called an associate member. As far as I know, that isn't a category that exists, but they have deep trade access. They have to submit to the EU's regulatory regime.
SPEAKER_00They don't get a vote. They don't get a say. That's what we'd be signing up for.
SPEAKER_00Do we have to submit to the European Court of Justice? Do we have to submit to the European Human Rights Commission? Do we have to submit to European immigration rules? Because that's what member countries have to do. And all of that is part of why Britain left the EU. We shouldn't be going down this path. Again, it's just like China. I criticize the Agreement Carney signed with China because it commits us to being
SPEAKER_00a strategic partner with China. It commits us to police and military interaction and cooperation with China that I'm very concerned about. But I don't disagree about trading with them. I think we have to be cautious trading with China. I think they're a bad partner. Just look at what happens every time they're upset. We do something they don't like. On politics, on trade, on anything, they slap big tariffs or block our exports of canola, pork, seafood.
SPEAKER_00It's their standard operating procedure. And I've had to explain this. I was just in Saskatchewan last week, as many of you know, I had to explain this again. Because I'm always being asked, why are you against us being able to sell our canola to China? I said, it's not that. It's that they are awful to you. And I rhyme off all the times they've done it. And I'll have a politician or a farmer say, yeah, you're right, but we want to sell them a lot of canola. That's fine. But remember, they're a bad partner and they will continue to be. What about the EU? Are they a good partner?
SPEAKER_00Are they going to buy the things that we're selling? Well, in that bit that I read off to you, It already noted that they didn't mention oil. They just said liquefied natural gas. Oil is our number one export. Oil and gas combined about $150 billion a year in exports. This is just to the US. And in terms of the number two export, it's about a third of that at $50 billion.
SPEAKER_00That's autos. Unless we completely change our auto industry, The Europeans aren't buying them. They're not going to buy Chevy Silverados or GMC Sierras. They're not going to buy Ford F350s. They're not even going to buy the SUVs that Toyota makes in Cambridge and Woodstock. We make larger vehicles here and they're not interested in them. So unless we start making small, compact, subcompact, small SUVs, things like that, we're not going to trade Our number two export to the EU.
SPEAKER_00Well, that's a problem, isn't it? Because we're doing this to make ourselves less dependent on the US. We're going to have to find something else to trade with them. Let me show you a chart, this from the library. Well, first I'll read off to you some stats from my column. I've made this point a couple of times, but it does bear repeating because we do export. Roughly 400 billion US dollars. And since trade is always stacked in US dollars, that's what this is as well.
SPEAKER_00So we've got $400 billion of exports to the US. And that was 2025. It was like 403 billion that we exported to the US. And that was with a dip. But in 2025, we sent just shy of $31 billion. I think it was $30.8 billion USD to the entire European Union.
SPEAKER_00That's after a decade of having a free trade agreement with them. After you adjust for inflation, our exports increased by about $8.4 billion, or the equivalent of a week's worth of exports to the U.S., Let me bring up this chart from the Library of Parliament. Now, this is in Canadian dollars, but you can see Canadian merchandise trade with the U.S., all right?
SPEAKER_00Now, U.S. dollars, so 2016 before the trade deal, we were at about $52 billion worth of stuff that we imported and $22.9 billion that we exported to them. Last year it was 91.58 or about 66 billion US. And we exported 42.7 billion, which works out to about the 31 billion. We buy more than twice as much from them as they buy from us.
SPEAKER_00It is a, the United States is really the only major trading block that we have a balanced relationship with. Um, Everywhere else, we just import a ton from them. So this is not going to replace the U.S. And people said to me last week when I wrote that, Carney's not trying to replace the U.S. Yes, he is. And right now, we're just not making what they want to buy.
SPEAKER_00And as I said, if we want to integrate with them, then we're going to have to come up with or accept Taking their regulations. What do we mostly sell to them? Well, Our number one export are about $4 billion worth of ores, slag, and ash, nickel, iron, uranium ores, that sort of thing. We also sell them about $4 billion worth of machinery, nuclear reactors, borders. Then it becomes minerals, fuels,
SPEAKER_00oils, distillation products, crude oil, aircraft and spacecraft, $3.2 billion. Pharmaceutical products, about $2 billion. And then oil seats and grains, about $1.7 billion. They're not interested, as I said. The list with the U.S. is vastly different. So after a decade of free trade, we still don't have the EU buying the kinds of goods that we manufacture here.
SPEAKER_00They all go to the U.S. There's also another problem, and that is that there are 27 member countries of the EU. Ten of them have yet to ratify the trade deal. This trade deal was negotiated by the Stephen Harper conservative government back in 2014. When Trudeau came in, it hadn't implemented yet. So it's getting finalized in 2015. Trudeau wins the election. They decide they've got to add some things to it, like gendered language and the like,
SPEAKER_00because he wanted to be even more progressive than the Europeans. That delays its implementation. But then the EU member countries all have to individually vote on it and ratify it. Ten of them have not. Including France, Ireland, I believe Italy, Greece. Why? Because they have issues with us on agriculture. Specifically, not all of them, but most of them, dairy. Same trading issue we have with the United States. Dairy.
SPEAKER_00When Britain left the EU, we went to negotiate a free trade deal with them and Britain said, well, why don't, you know, we were part of the EU free trade deal, why don't we just copy and paste that, change the names? We said no. Do you know why? Dairy. Even though Britain had been allowed to export cheese and other products to us, our farmers said no. So trade talks with Britain actually stopped a couple of years ago over dairy. And we think we're going to get associate membership and not have to give up more?
SPEAKER_00We are fooling ourselves. Here's the problem with this. Most Canadians aren't going to think about the fact that we're going to have to allow European regulators to set regulations in Canada. They're not going to think about the fact that, well, depending on how far we integrate, we might give up our monetary policy. I mean, are we going to adopt the euro or are we going to go that far? If we do, we're giving up the Bank of Canada and our monetary policy. We're not going to be setting our own interest rates.
SPEAKER_00Will we have to have budget conditions set by the EU? As I said, immigration regulations, things like that. But also, the whole idea that we can pivot like this, I think Carney is not being forthright with us. The EU is growing at about half the rate of the United States. Depending on how far we go down this path, what's the possibility that the United States just says, you know what?
SPEAKER_00You're really not worth it anymore. We're gonna pull out of Kuzma completely. If they do that, our auto industry is cooked. And as I said, the Europeans are not gonna buy those cars. This could have knock-on effects. Again, not saying don't expand trade, yes. But becoming part of them, But what I think will happen with this, if Carney pulls this off and he flies into Liverpool on Tuesday, meets with Andy Burnham, then he's off to Strasbourg.
SPEAKER_00He's there for their State of the Union address. They're going to announce some deals on Thursday. If he pulls this off, I think his polling, which is currently at 49%, I'll show you the polling numbers in a minute. I think it goes into the stratosphere. I think he goes above 50% because the Canadians who... Mark Carney's
SPEAKER_00Polling numbers, the liberal polling numbers will go above 50%. And the 60% of people 55 plus that like him now will go even higher. He'll be in the 70s. It's going to be crazy. Now, I'm going to show you some of these polls because I wrote about polls yesterday and people were complaining, saying they're not true. So this is from Leger. There's their latest survey. And 49% say that they will vote for Mark Carney and the liberals if an election were held today.
SPEAKER_0033% for the conservatives, 7% for the bloc, 6% for the NDP. They're on life support. And then you get to the smaller numbers and it can be tough to see, but right here, 60%, 60% of people 55 plus supporting Mark Carney. Approval rating of Mark Carney's performance, not the government, but his 58% approve, 22% strongly, 37% somewhat approve, and then you've got 34% who disapprove.
SPEAKER_00Now, I know, heard from many of you, I saw the comments, you don't believe any polls and they're not accurate. Well, every pollster claims they're the most accurate. Some are better than others. This is Leger's result. So, Last election, their last poll said the liberals would get 43%. They got 43.7. They had the conservatives at 39. They got 41.3. Not unusual for conservatives to get a little bit of a ballot box bump. That's been happening a long time. British Columbia election.
SPEAKER_00They pretty much nailed it there. 46, no, 45, 42, 43. It's all within margin of error. In the U.S., they called it 49, 49. It was 50, 48. One point off for each election. Polls are a snapshot in time. And there's mathematical formulas that you use to survey enough people to say this is a representative sample. I know that you haven't been polled. I hear that. Well, I've never been polled, so therefore it's not real. I'll get one of the pollsters, one of the top pollsters on to explain how this works.
SPEAKER_00I've been at this a long time. The parties use polling. All the parties use polling. Um, Why? Because it is an accurate reflection. You don't have to like the results. And you know, something I noticed is that during the 18 months that Pierre Poliev and the conservatives had a double digit lead over the liberals. I never once heard somebody say, I don't believe the polls. They're not real. Well, actually I did, but they were liberals. Liberals were then telling me that and conservatives were, you know, basking in the glow.
SPEAKER_00And now it's reversed. And liberals love polls and conservatives think that they're all broken. Just because you don't like the result doesn't mean they're not accurate. But as I said, I'll get someone on to explain this in a bit. But Canadians seem to love, too many Canadians seem to love Carney because they're not looking for results. They're looking for vibes. And this idea that he can hitch our wagon to the EU and Which grows at half the rate of the U.S., which used to have an economy that was a third larger than the U.S. and it's now a third smaller than the U.S. 15, 20 years later.
SPEAKER_00You're jumping onto a sick man instead of a healthy man to save yourself. That's why this is all bad policy. It's being done for feelings, not for rational thought. And unfortunately, when it comes to anything involving Donald Trump these days, feelings matter more than facts. There's that great saying from south to the border. Ben Shapiro was one of the people that helped popularize it. Facts don't care about your feelings. The reverse is also true. Feelings don't care about your facts.
SPEAKER_00And for a lot of voters, they would rather feel good than be right. Sad, but true. Thanks for watching. Thanks for being here, being part of this. TorontoSun.com will have more out tomorrow. Make sure you sign up for the newsletter, brianlilley.com. Everything right to your inbox. Thanks for watching. Remember, I'm on your side.
The fact that the B.C. Conservatives won last weekend wasn’t the shocking part, it was the size of their win. The party took 63 seats to the, while the NDP took just 28 and the Greens 2. There were people who were...
Canadians are outraged that Florida Republican Governor Ron DeSantis wants Canadians to face a tax hike to subsidize Florida residents. It’s outrageous, but it’s also a little rich. Canadians are angry at Americans for...
A lot of people commenting on things that just aren’t so. A few clips of Carney to share with you today, so it’s pretty much all video today. That said, here’s the chart I show in the video. It shows where things are at...
Canada faces a pile of new trade actions that start next week. Why isn’t Mark Carney trying to get a new deal. Instead, he’s putting good paying jobs at risk because he prefers politics to economics. Odd for a man...
Mr. Carney goes to New York. It’s clear that Mark Carney likes foreign journalists better than Canadian ones. He turns to the BBC, Bloomberg, and now the New York Times when he wants to get out points. In today’s...