Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Full Comment

Full Comment artwork

CBC’s sneaky “change” on their 9/11 language policy...

Aug 29, 202612 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

On Wednesday afternoon, at 12:22 in the afternoon, the Toronto Sun published Warren Kinsella’s column breaking the news about CBC telling their journalists not to call 9/11 a terrorist attack. It quickly became our most read piece online. People began sharing it and commenting on it, whether at our site or on social media. It was picked up around the world with Forbes, New York Post, the Daily Mail, the Telegraph, Jerusalem Post, the Economic Times and Times Now both in India, an many more media outlets picked up on it. Not a lot of Canadian coverage outside of Postmedia - owners of the Toronto Sun and National Post - until CBC changed, but more on that later. As news spread, so did the outrage. Maureen Basnicki lost her husband Ken, then just 48 years-old, in the 9/11 terrorist attacks. We seem to forget that 24 Canadians died in those attacks. We had leading scholars on terrorism and anti-semitism denounce CBC’s policy. In Washington, where Republican feelings towards Canada aren’t the best at the most, things got worse as Kash Patel the Director of the FBI and several prominent people surrounding the Trump administration voiced anger at the policy. “I never thought Warren Kinsella would cause an international incident 😅” was the text I got from a friend. Kinsella did create an international incident simply by reporting the truth on CBC’s policy. He didn’t create the policy, it’s not a new policy, but they restated it badly and at the worst possible time - two weeks before the 25th anniversary of 9/11 and as tensions between Canada and the United States are high. Watch the video above, if you haven’t already so you can see me break down how this all happened, as I answer our critics and as I explain the deeper problem. Below you can find links to follow-up columns from myself, Warren Kinsella and Lorne Gunter. LILLEY: CBC’s 9/11 retreat doesn’t fix its terrorism problem KINSELLA: CBC’s 9/11 climbdown acknowledges historical reality GUNTER: CBC flip-flop on calling 9/11 ‘terrorism’ exercise in disinformation This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.brianlilley.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00We need to talk about this CBC terrorism thing, what they did, what they didn't do, why we're saying some things, not others, and motivations. Okay, let's get into all of this. Hi, Brian Lilley from torontosun.com, brianlilley.com. If you're not subscribed there, please do. That way you get everything sent direct to your inbox between big tech changing the algorithm and... The liberal government in Ottawa constantly changing the laws. Things get tougher to find to see. So brianlilley.com, you get the columns, videos sent right to your inbox.

SPEAKER_00OK, so let's talk about CBC. We're now being accused, myself and people like Warren Kinsella, who broke the story about CBC refusing to call 9-11 terrorism, were being accused of going after CBC. The guy who wrote the latest memo, and that's a key point, the latest memo, were accused of going after him based on his last name and supposed ethnic identity by some people and saying that's the only reason we did the story. And we're being accused by others of saying,

SPEAKER_00you're not telling us the full story because you won't tell us about his ethnic identity and where he's from. But let's back up and talk about what happened. Earlier this week, Warren Kinsella broke this story in the Toronto Sun. 9-11 wasn't a terrorist attack, according to the CBC. What did he base this on? Instructions by CBC management not to call the 9-11 attacks a terrorist attack. Let me just scroll down here,

SPEAKER_00show you the part, because some people don't believe that it actually said that. I'll show you in the column, and then I'll show you in the actual article. Memo, do not refer to the September 11th terrorist attacks or the September 11th attacks as terrorist attacks. What did the memo say? Well, Here it is. I posted this screenshot on X the other day, right there. I've seen the entire email, by the way. This is the part of it near the end that deals with this.

SPEAKER_00There's a whole bunch more in it. Nothing that takes away from this, but not publishing the full email because trying to protect the source who leaked it from retribution by CBC management. So the memo says, do not refer to the September 11th attacks as terrorist attacks. The hijackings led to passenger jet crashes in Washington, D.C., Pennsylvania and Manhattan. The World Trade Center was destroyed. Blah, blah, blah about the digital archives. And if you have questions, contact your editor. That's pretty clear, isn't it?

SPEAKER_00It's do not call them terrorist attacks. Now, This memo was put out by a guy named, identified there as BB. His full name is Basim Bhashra. His title is Senior Director of Journalistic Standards and Public Trust at CBC News. For years before he joined CBC, he worked For the Montreal Gazette, Post Media. So, yeah, the company that I work for now being accused that, oh, well, if his name wasn't Basem Bashra, you wouldn't be going after him.

SPEAKER_00Really? Then why have we gone after CBC News for years over this policy? It's not a new policy. Here's Brody Fenlon, who started out his career at the Toronto Sun. He's now editor-in-chief of CBC News. How CBC News is the word terrorist and terrorism. And this online blog post from October 2023, you can scroll through it, and it describes how they don't use the word terrorism or terrorist

SPEAKER_00by their journalists or anchors, but they can quote people who use that word. This is longstanding CBC policy. This is not new CBC policy. So Mr. Bosher's last name, his ethnicity, where he's from, I don't know. But it doesn't matter to the story, either for those of you saying that's why we went after him or those of you saying we're not telling the full story. This is a policy that CBC has stood by. And I want to point out that former CBCers like Keith Bogue,

SPEAKER_00who was their parliamentary bureau chief for years when I was on the Hill, he was out there on X talking about all of this. Let me go back. Where's his original one? He says CBC's capitulation in the face of criticism of its carefully considered policy on whether journalists should make decisions Judgments about contentious issues is cowardly pandering. It's an embarrassment to journalism. It's weak when we need strength. Snap out of it, please. No, no, Keith, you're wrong.

SPEAKER_00Now, he got into a back and forth with Travis Danraj, another former CBCer, who pointed out that it's not a matter of opinion. 9-11 was a terrorist attack. Full stop. It's long been established. Calling it one is not editorializing or making a judgment call. I want to point out that Keith Bogue goes on to talk about should they be taking stances on other political issues? And eventually he gets to the point of saying,

SPEAKER_00should we be making judgments and implying that these could all be considered terrorist issues? Israel, Gaza, the ANC, that'd be the African National Congress, Dresden, Hiroshima, Nagasaki, and on and on. It's unbelievable that this is where he went. If you have time and you're on X, I do highly recommend this very long takedown by Lord Black, Conrad Black, taking Keith Boak to the woodshed. This way of thinking is pervasive at CBC, but not just there.

SPEAKER_00It is pervasive in journalism. It is pervasive in academia. It stems from the one man's freedom fighter is another man's terrorist mentality. Look, for the longest time, CBC used to call groups like the Irish Republican Army terrorist groups. They don't anymore. Of course, the IRA isn't what it used to be. Now, I'm someone who supports the end goal of the Irish Republican movement, that there'd be That doesn't mean I support one.

SPEAKER_009-11 was a terrorist act, but... You know, there's a lot of anger and blowout at CBC from American officials from I mean, this was picked up in the United States, in Europe, in Israel, all over the place. There was a lot of blowback.

SPEAKER_00You had liberals like Anthony Housefather bravely coming out. And this was before the government rejected it, saying it was a terrorist attack. Rational leadership at the CBC should ensure it continues to do so, calling it a terrorist attack. Well, eventually we got to Gary Ndesangri, the Minister of Public Safety, putting out a statement. He doesn't mention CBC at all, but he does blast the The idea that 9-11 wasn't terrorism.

SPEAKER_00That statement is posted here at 422. It was emailed to the Parliamentary Press Gallery at 414. At 444, we had this. A new statement from Basim Basra on how and why CBC News will adjust its 9-11 language guidance half an hour later. So very coordinated by the government, which was feeling all kinds of heat. I mean, you had CSIS and other levels of government putting out statements.

SPEAKER_00You ended up shortly after this with Mark Miller, about 45 minutes after 40 minutes after CBC announced Mark Miller announced. Reposted CBC's new guidance with this line, a welcome change to what was a piece of pedantic and foolish guidance that caused legitimate anger. Get that? Legitimate anger. Mark Miller was right on this. Kudos to Mark Miller. Kudos to the Carney government for doing what's right. I think they should have acted sooner and not allowed this anger

SPEAKER_00to fester this legitimate anger. But it's there. But here's the problem with it. Where is. My latest piece on this. Okay, so I'll scroll up to the beginning so you can see the headline. This was the piece published on Friday night. It is in Saturday's print edition of the Toronto Sun. They didn't fully change the policy, and that is my issue on this.

SPEAKER_00What they did is they simply changed the policy regarding 9-11. They're not allowed to call other acts of terrorism, terrorist attacks. Now, they are imperfect in their use of this. And I point that out in the column. And they acknowledge that it sometimes slips through with all the content they publish. And I get that. But they seem to be politically selective. And that is a real issue. This policy is driven by politics.

SPEAKER_00It's driven by an ideology that tries to give moral equivalency to everything and not take sides. And yet people do take sides. And whose side are you taking in trying to say that 9-11 wasn't terrorism or that we can't possibly pass that judgment? Because that really was their policy, that they couldn't possibly judge that to be an act of terrorism. When even the people that carried it out believed it was an act of terror. That's a real moral ambiguity and that's a problem.

SPEAKER_00But this is an organization that takes $1.6 billion tax dollars every year. You know, I've had people say to me, ignore them. It doesn't matter. Just ignore them. If they weren't taking $1.6 billion tax dollars. If they weren't the government approved state broadcaster, if they weren't at most times when they are acting, they are acting as an agent of the Liberal Party. That's how their news comes across. So I can't ignore them. They take $1.6 billion and they're going to keep taking more of it every single year.

SPEAKER_00They deserve the scrutiny. They did a half measure to put it back into place. Line with where the public mood was. But what about every other act of terror? That blog post I showed you from Brody Fenlon, October 2023, he posted that about 10 days after the October 7th. Attacks by Hamas on Israel to explain why they were not calling the Hamas attacks terrorist attacks, to explain why they don't call Hamas a terrorist group,

SPEAKER_00as they target innocent civilians, as they murder seniors, women, children. That's the mentality at CBC and is going to continue to be. And that's the bigger problem. Not where Mr. Bashar is from, whether you support him or oppose him. It's about the mentality at CBC that is held by so many, but thankfully, not all. Because the fact that people disagreed with this policy is why we found out about it in the first place.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. How the B.C. Conservatives won big a week ago...

    Nov 1, 202622 minAudio

    The fact that the B.C. Conservatives won last weekend wasn’t the shocking part, it was the size of their win. The party took 63 seats to the, while the NDP took just 28 and the Greens 2. There were people who were...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Canadians angry at Florida tax plan need to look in the mirror...

    Oct 4, 202612 minAudio

    Canadians are outraged that Florida Republican Governor Ron DeSantis wants Canadians to face a tax hike to subsidize Florida residents. It’s outrageous, but it’s also a little rich. Canadians are angry at Americans for...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Carney’s move to align with Europe...

    Sep 30, 202616 minAudio

    A lot of people commenting on things that just aren’t so. A few clips of Carney to share with you today, so it’s pretty much all video today. That said, here’s the chart I show in the video. It shows where things are at...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Carney is playing games with people’s jobs...

    Sep 25, 202618 minAudio

    Canada faces a pile of new trade actions that start next week. Why isn’t Mark Carney trying to get a new deal. Instead, he’s putting good paying jobs at risk because he prefers politics to economics. Odd for a man...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Carney tells all to the New York Times...

    Sep 24, 202617 minAudio

    Mr. Carney goes to New York. It’s clear that Mark Carney likes foreign journalists better than Canadian ones. He turns to the BBC, Bloomberg, and now the New York Times when he wants to get out points. In today’s...

    Credit the people on this episode