Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Real Estate Development Insights

Real Estate Development Insights artwork

(6) How to Build Quiet High-Rises: Acoustic Secrets of Mass Timber- Simon Edwards

Jul 9, 202458 minAudio

Send us Fan Mail In this episode of the Real Estate Development Podcast, Simon Edwards, an acoustical engineer at HGC Engineering, shares his insights on the intersection between acoustics and mass timber construction. Simon discusses his background, transitioning from a career in music to becoming an acoustical engineer, and emphasizes the importance of considering both direct and indirect sound transmission in building design. He also highlights the complexities and benefits of using mass timber, such as the potential for construction efficiencies and aesthetic appeals, while addressing common concerns and misconceptions about acoustical performance. The conversation dives into practical advice for developers, best practices gleaned from European standards, and the significance of acoustical engineers' early involvement in project planning. Simon thoroughly examines specific projects, such as the YW building in Kitchener, shedding light on innovative solutions and evolving industry standards. Here are some of the topics we cover in this episode: What is the Role of an Acoustical Engineer? What are the Challenges in Building Acoustics? What are the effects of a Mass Timber structure on building acoustics? Testing and Evolving Acoustic Solutions for Mass Timber Buildings Challenges with Gym Noise in Buildings, some easy solutions. Key Acoustics Considerations for Real Estate Developers https://mid-rise.ca/acoustics-and-mass-timber-construction-6/ For more information, please refer to RealEstateDevelopmentInsights.com Join Our Workshop: MultiplexWorkshop.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

PayamHi, Simon. How are you doing?

SimonI'm good, how are you?

PayamPretty good. Pretty good. thank you very much for being here and why don't we start by giving some introductions? Maybe tell us a little bit of yourself, your background, where you're coming from.

Simonsure thing. so my name is Simon Edwards. I, I'm an acoustical engineer. I've been, I've been working in acoustics for a little over eight years. I work for a company called HGC Engineering, which is based out of Mississauga. and so a little bit about me and background. I. Actually, I used to play music full time. I, my background academic background is in mechanical engineering. I studied mechanical while I was studying. I was in a band and we got a fair amount of success pretty early in our careers.

SimonAnd so we leveraged that success into a full time music career. I was with the band for about 10 years during which I also did a master's degree at U of T and then, and then somewhere towards the end of the band, I decided that I wanted to, you know, I was passionate about engineering and I wanted to kick off that engineering career. I actually had no idea that acoustical engineering existed. I think a lot of people don't. you know, there aren't, there aren't many programs at university, that specialize in acoustical engineering. So I had one acoustics course, but I kind of thought that was it.

SimonI was applying for mechanical engineering jobs. And then I saw this acoustical engineering job posting and I thought, wow, that looks cool. I'll apply, but I'll never get it because I didn't study acoustical engineering. sure enough, I later found out that not many people do. A lot of people who work in acoustics. from mechanical, but we also have people that come from civil, environmental engineering, different engineering paths that have sort of developed this acoustical, foundation. And,

PayamSo you went from making a lot of noise for about 10 years in demand to trying to figure out how to not make too much noise or at least not to transmit too much noise in the building, right?

SimonThat's right. It's a, it's a, you know, it's funny. A lot of people who at HTC are musicians, even you know, is not an inherent part of my day to day. I think, you know, there are certain aspects, things like, you know, understanding reverberation and appreciating differences in frequencies. you know, that comes from maybe having a certain musician's ear. But other than that, you know, I'd love to, you know, I wish there was more music people, you know, when we bring speakers on site to do testing, often we're playing things like pink noise and, you know, contractors will crack jokes and say, you know, which album are you putting on for this test and whatever.

SimonSo,

Payamha, ha,

Simonyou know, they're not, yeah, they're not as related as, as some people, they're a little related for sure, but, it is definitely a path that, you know, I'm passionate about for sure. it's definitely a different, unique experience for me, especially, and this really ties to music and, And acoustics. I mean, my mom is deaf. My dad is,

PayamRight.

Simonyou know, it was always kind of been a bit hard of hearing as well. And so I really grew up with, Very little music in the house at all. Very little, like almost no instruments until, you know, maybe I was in a teenager and just, you know, no appreciation for, for acoustics, you know, for sound transmission in the house or, or, or, or hearing, you know, and, and, and, you know, feeling different vibrations. And so once I got into acoustics, I could start to play around with. you know, with my, my mom, who, who I suppose, I mean, I, she is deaf, I think she has maybe, you know, a couple percent of hearing in one of her ears, and, that allows her to maybe pick out a doorbell once in a while.

SimonAnd so, I, you know, I was able to kind of put, You know, headphones in her ear and play around with different frequencies and see how she perceives sound. That, that's really, once I got into acoustics, I started to really appreciate even for the hearing impaired, how, you know, how importance of recognizing frequency content and things like that

PayamAs much as, as much as you think that you fell from mechanical engineering to acoustic by chance, it doesn't look like that. It almost seems that there was a trend in the background that was running. But, you know, we'll, we'll explore that in a different, different episode.

Simonyeah. Fair

Payamwe

Simonthat I found the industry for sure. It's been a good industry to me.

PayamAnd I think the industry is sharing some of that sentiment with you. So with that segue, I'm gonna, I'm gonna go to a little bit more of a, industry topic. So,

SimonMm-Hmm.

PayamI want to go back to how originally you and I connected. I think it was about a year or so ago, then I, it was probably right after the whole change in the mass timber, regulation that happened. And I was doing some research and trying to figure out who, who's working in the, in this business, who's, who knows what they're doing and what knowledge is out there. And, I came, I came across your name and, so that's how basically I tracked you down and I'm like, okay, seems like, there are a lot of questions about acoustic, and mass timber, which I want to really dive into in the next few minutes.

PayamAnd, so I came across your name and you guys have, have done a few things there, but before we dive into, mass timber, and hopefully we do that at the end. In detail, why don't we just set up some definitions and some broad expectations of what what is it that an acoustic engineer do? What is, what does someone who is not necessarily in the industry need to know about what you do to be able to use your expertise? And, I'll also put this into context that it's a proverbial or anecdote out there that says that probably number one A claim that residents have from the building is acoustic claims and especially in the world that condo world.

PayamYeah, and so yeah Let's start with that.

SimonSure. So, you know, what does an acoustical engineer do? Well, there's a few different kinds of acoustical engineers. I mean, at HTC, we have a team of acoustics that focus on industrial acoustics and others that, focus on environmental acoustics that has a lot to do with planning studies, noise and vibration feasibility, you know, addressing rail and, and building foundation isolation, things like that. And then, and then I specialize in building acoustics. And so. Really, that has to do with sound transmission, often, you know, in the residential context, sound transmission between suites and other areas that could be suites that could be amenities, mechanical, electrical rooms, also vibration, isolation of mechanical, electrical equipment, things like sound.

Simonyou know, sound impacts from many equipment as well. So if you have, you know, a chiller, you know, how does the, the chiller noise or fan noise through a duct things like that. so those are some different ways. you know, the, we get involved in the building, you know, things like gym floors, other, other really, like, architectural and many. Recommendations and then that comes into a bit of a specialty items as well. Things like garbage shoots, elevator, vibration and noise is a really big one, especially, you know, when I think about buildings where we get calls after they're built

PayamRight.

Simonyou know, often we get a lot of calls about things like elevator noise and gym floor noise and things like that. I'm skipping ahead a little bit. But so in terms of what an acoustical engineer does, that's a little bit about. you know, what we do, what we bring to the table, I think, you know, what is really important for a developer, what would I like a developers to know? I think that, as you said, you know, noise is such a common complaint. In buildings, you know, I, we get involved in a lot of legal scenarios where, unfortunately, lawyers have already gotten involved and things like that.

SimonAnd that can cost a lot of money for a lot of people. And so I think that our goal coming in to the design in design of a building is to be involved as early as possible to provide feedback on addressing acoustics. In as cheap a manner as possible. I mean, before we built the building, even before we've

PayamYou still can do something about it.

Simonabsolutely. I mean, you know, to, to address these things on a, on a practical, a clear and practical level early is so important because later on, it just becomes such a huge headache. And the other thing is that. The, you know, the reality is that what people actually, you know, budget for an acoustical engineer on a job and getting that design feedback is really very little in the context of the

PayamMm

SimonYou know, what the rest of the design team, especially the primary consultants, and not only that, but also the costs associated with not doing something with doing too much. you know, I, I've gotten involved on a lot of projects where. architects are being relied on for acoustics and, you know, architects are Very good at architecting, but, you know, when it comes to acoustics, fair enough, their knowledge and experience level is only going to be so limited. And in some cases, what that leads to is actually over designing certain

Payamhmm

Simoninvolved in a project a couple of weeks ago and the first thing they sent me, they said, we're very, very tight on budget, but we have some questions. And the first thing they sent me, I said, well, let's value engineer a ton out of your, you know, floor ceiling assembly. I, I'm not sure how much money I sent them, but I, I know I for sure save them more than they're paying me over the life of this design. So, you know, I, I think that some people, you know, that is certainly something I want. I think developers should keep in mind when they're exploring is acoustic something important to budget for to keep in mind, you know, during the design is, is how much of an, a positive, a net positive impact that can have not only during design, during construction, and of course, after occupancy as well.

PayamRight, right. And, and that's, to be honest with you, that's the, one of the reasons I wanted to have this episode definitely with you is that, I've been seeing it throughout the years that I've been working in the industry that, like you mentioned, not too many people, first of all, know that there is such a thing in this acoustic engineer that has been changing over the past five to 10 years, say it's, it's been more becoming more common, but still, I, I agree with you 100 percent that it is, it is looked at like a secondary, subset of consultants, if you may, which, it might be in terms of the overall, scope of work, which is fair, which is, which is fair,

Simona less, on less involved basis as, as, you know, architect and many structural engineers. And

Payamcorrect,

Simonbecause that really allows us to work on more projects. you

Payamright,

SimonI can imagine only works on a, a, a few, a couple of projects at a time. So, you know, we get involved when it makes sense. You know, we'll, we'll provide a design review typically. Go through that with the design team. Make sure that's incorporated into the drawings. And then at that point, you know, we can sort of sit back from that, you know, knowing that the design has incorporated the appropriate acoustical features and then, you know, the next stage we get involved would be, you know, shop drawings and site inspection. So there's

Payamright.

Simontime there where the primary consultants are continuously involved and meeting, you know, every week and continuing to out kind of little last minute details. Whereas our scope is a lot more limited in that effect.

PayamAnd and that's that's very true. Because what one thing you mentioned that I want to emphasize is that, there's a right time for you for people like yourself. And there are other disciplines that share the same situation as an acoustic consultant that there's a prime time. There's the right time for them to be involved in the project where you actually can still make the changes very cost effectively. You don't have to go back. And, like you mentioned, I've I've I know of projects that they've had to go back and fix an acoustic issue at, at a hundred, hundreds of thousands of dollars cost and rip whole things open and try to fix it.

PayamAnd yeah, none, no one wants to be part of that nightmare situation.

SimonYeah.

PayamBut So that being said, let's dive into mass timber, which is, I, is it fair to say that's your main specialty or, how, how would you talk about, I know, I know, I'll put a context that you are one of the people who is at least in the, in the industry in GTA and Toronto that I know of, which is further ahead of everyone else in terms of the data and the testing that you've done and the work you've done, but, is it fair to say that's your specialty?

SimonYeah, I would, I wouldn't, I wouldn't say that's the majority of my time. I hope that it will become that. The truth is, you know, we started the first mass timber building in Canada, I believe, was built in 2019 on Queen Street in Toronto. And so

PayamMm hmm.

Simonyou know, that's how we got started. Nobody really knew mass timber, much about mass timber before that. And then since then, it has certainly ballooned out. You know, I have yeah. Upwards of at least 10 mass timber projects on the go right now. And, you know, a few that recently have been completed and then even some more, you know, that are coming up. And so a really exciting time for the industry, but, the reality is that it's, it's still, we're still working our way up until, you know, maybe you have, you know, I'm not sure if we have a crew school consultants dedicated only to mass timber.

SimonI don't think we're quite there yet, We, we developed. you know, we understood the importance of developing a database of testing, which just didn't exist at that point. And so being able to learn more to, to, to get out into the field and take measurements that hadn't been taken before gave us a new level of understanding of how can we get exposed CLT ceilings, you know, whereas a lab will tell you that CLT panels, Have a lot of sound transmission going through ceiling to ceiling. but, but yeah, you know, continuing to expand that experience and, and, and data to support different people.

SimonI think mass timber has certainly become a very exciting part of my portfolio, and I'm excited to see it continue to grow.

Payamone of the questions that I, I get asked, I guess quite often is, what is mass timber? Like, should we, especially when you talk about mid rise projects, something that's like four or five, six, maybe.

SimonYeah,

PayamShould we start switching them to mass timber? Whereas for the past five or six years, most of these projects have been, I want to say primarily on the, on the smaller side, they've been hybrid structures and on the, on the taller sides, they've been a concrete, which has been the king there for, for a while. And, so I guess let's start with this question that if, if I'm a developer, if I'm thinking about doing a mid rise project, let's say if, Five, six story, eight story building, and I want to go to mass timber. How worried should I be about complaints, noise and acoustics five year, 10 year down the road or two years down the road, considering that, not too many residential buildings are currently built and are being used with that purpose.

PayamRight.

Simonconcrete, you know, including wood frame have. acoustical deficiencies, you know, important concrete, you know, Usually you get pretty good STC, which is airborne noise transmission that refers to things like voices, music, but, you know, poured concrete can notoriously have quite poor, you know, impact transmission, excuse me.

SimonSo a lot of footsteps, that's a very common complaint. The other thing about something like poured concrete is that, you know, the entire structure is highly coupled. So once something like elevator, Machine vibration gets into the port of concrete or weight drop vibration gets into the port of concrete. It can travel three or four floors away you know, you can get complaints from a whole assortment of suites and so different types of structures have different advantages and disadvantages. Timber is no different in that sense. You know, there are certainly Areas of mass timber that, require more consideration early in design.

SimonSo it's important to take a look at, things like, you know, direct sound transmission, make, you know, choosing your assemblies to, you know, address, you know, Sound and airborne sound and impact sound coming straight through, but also looking at indirect sound transmission. And that's also called flanking sound transmission. That's something that's really important in mass timber. A lot of people, and especially, this is especially the case when developers are relying on architects to provide that acoustics knowledge. A lot of people think only of direct sound transmission.

SimonThey think, I have a suite beside a suite or above a suite. my wall? What's my floor ceiling assembly? Is that, you know, what are the ratings? What are the SDC and IIC ratings for airborne and impact sound? Is that, you know, are we meeting our targets and is that it? that is a great place to start, but the next step after that is, okay, well, what are my Indirect sound transmission paths, you know, what's going through the ceiling, through the floor, through the exterior wall, through, through the corridor wall. I mean, there's a ton of different indirect paths that can certainly result in, you know, when you're in the field, when you, when you have somebody standing on one side and standing on the other side.

SimonYou know, you can hear conversations. You can hear a lot of sound because somebody hasn't thought of that indirect sound. So really, when, you know, when thinking of mass timber, you know, specifically, I think that, you know, taking a look at those indirect sound transmission paths, making sure that you're addressing the sound going through the ceiling, making sure that. You have something, you know, usually a lot of mass timber buildings include some type of topping. So making sure that topping, whether it's dry or wet topping, is interrupted at demising walls. That's important for limiting sound going through the floor. So, you know, these types of considerations for indirect transmission is really important with really with any lightweight structure, including wood frame.

SimonBut, this is also the case in mass timber. then, but some of the benefits of mass timber acoustically in some sense the modular ability of it. So. Coming back to that elevator vibration, example with poured concrete, you know, you have the opportunity to isolate mass timber panels from each other, which is something you can't do in a poured concrete building.

PayamThat's true.

Simonprovides you that extra stage of isolation, whether it's pipe isolation or conduit isolation, equipment isolation, you know, flexibility of designing the mass timber building with isolated That the vibration or reduce the amount of vibration traveling through those joints and through the structure. That's something that you can't get out of a port concrete building. So certainly there are advantages and disadvantages, but those are just some of the kind of early things to wrap your head around when exploring mass timber from an acoustics perspective.

PayamSo, so what I gather from what you just said is that, yes, there are a lot of things to think about, but while you're thinking about it, don't, don't despair because there are some, upsides that you can probably only gain from something like Mass Timber. And, I guess, let me take that as a segue and I know, and one of our conversations that we had earlier on, if there's any, A few months back, we went through this whole effect of the actual concrete itself that, I think originally it was introduced to help mass timber with fire rating at least as, as one of one of the initial thoughts, but, but my understanding is that that actually ended up working both ways and help a lot with acoustics and maybe, maybe walk us through that.

PayamAnd I want to use that as a segue to go into your, I can't remember the name of the project, unfortunately, but the one in Kitchener and, maybe walk us through that. YW. Yes. Yes. Maybe walk us through that. And, yeah, I have a couple of follow up questions coming up there.

SimonSure thing. So, you know, concrete have certainly helped guide the early days of mass timber with respect to both fire and acoustics. And I think there's a lot of things, you know, I'm familiar with a few, fire engineers who work on a lot of mass timber with me. And, you know, we, we often kind of make jokes about how we're fighting the same battle to get

PayamMm hmm. Mm hmm.

Simonso the, so an isolated concrete topping. Provides a huge benefit in any lightweight structure that includes wood frame that includes, you know, something like a steel deck You can get a lot of low frequency booming impact noise. So think about, you know, somebody walking around in socks upstairs.

PayamRight.

Simonmore of a thumping that is very, very hard to address without any sort of mass above your floor ceiling. And, and mass timber on its own is really not that heavy in the context of things. And so at addition of an isolated concrete topping above in addition to adding your fire rating gives you that extra, extra sound installation that you need from an airborne perspective as well for voices and music, but also from that footstep and thumping perspective to improve, really both, approaches.

SimonAnd so that's, that concrete topping has been really important. I mean, I, we see that on almost. Almost all mass timber projects, not all, there has certainly been a shift in the industry and, and I think it's a really interesting shift that I, certainly not discouraging. I am encouraging it where it makes sense, to dry toppings.

PayamMm

Simonwhere we try to avoid concrete completely. I mean, of course, there are sustainability, components to that, but from, purely an acoustic sense, you know, the dry topping. make for a little bit more of a simple installation. You don't have to worry about Concrete being over poured and seeping around

Payamhmm. Sorry to interrupt you, but can you, can you walk me through or walk us through what is a dry topping? Like how, how do you define it?

Simonand stuff so Whereas you might a concrete topping might look like something like an inch and a half or two inches of gypcrete or concrete Above, you know, usually about a half inch of of dry concrete Rubber isolation material below that would be a typical concrete topping, whereas in a dry topping, you replace that concrete with something like two layers of plywood or cement board or

PayamMm hmm.

Simonproprietary material. So these are things that don't involve any pouring of a cementitious topping. and so those dry toppings also have a pretty interesting acoustical performance. And they are, you know, I was just talking to somebody today at lunch about how. You know, they're developing, you know, new research, new R and D, new technology coming out to To reach higher performances, you know, with with still relatively thin dry toppings, not having to build it up too much above the CLT, but being able to avoid concrete altogether still get your fire rating with the dry topping, you know, with The,

PayamInteresting.

Simonwith the proprietary type of plywood, while also getting your acoustic performance. So from a purely direct standpoint of, you know, a room above a room and direct SDC, direct IIC, you know, the conversation of a wet topping, such as concrete or gypcrete versus a dry topping, such as plywood or cement board or something proprietary. That's been a really interesting conversation so far. And it's great to see more, more, Acoustic suppliers, I'll say, coming out with different data for their dry topping, you know, isolation materials and and to see how that can continue to promote sustainability in the industry and and, promote modular construction and decrease construction times potentially.

SimonAnd, and so that's been an interesting trend. Now, one thing that is important and, Yeah. I might be getting a bit of myself again and that that is still very relevant in the wet versus dry topping conversation is that When it comes to wet toppings something about mass timber that has been, you know, probably to me my favorite Development I will say over the last few years is that a lot of lab data for continuous CLT panels or Over a suite demising wall. So this is where you have one CLT panel that, for example, can span two suites as the

PayamRight.

Simontwo suites, a lot of data in the lab suggested that you will get a huge amount of airborne flanking through that panel. And so if you're doing an STC test, an ASTC test, you put a speaker on one side, you measure on both sides, you're going to measure an ASTC result that does. You know, in the low 40s, something that doesn't meet the national building code, the Ontario building code, the international building code, you know, compliant, not compliant in a lot of areas. that was really the big fear. I mean, that, that's how I think that's partly how mass timber got its rep as, you know, a scary acoustics endeavor.

SimonAnd so when we started flanking testing with an isolated topping above. We started getting in multiple buildings, this phenomenon of damping from this isolated topping above on this continuous CLT panel that we are able to boost that up around, you know, S ASTC 50, a very notable increase from what they're getting in the lab. And,

Payamis that without, without the topping you said, or with the topping? With the topping.

SimonAnd so, and so the, the question comes down to like, you know, the effects of the specific differences. We actually have some testing coming up which will be really great where we're doing the same test in three very, very comparable situations on three different floors of a building where we're doing. a flanking sound transmission test with no topping above whatsoever, one with a wet concrete topping, and one with a dry topping above. And

PayamInteresting. Mm hmm. Mm hmm.

Simoninformation on dry toppings and if dry toppings work. Can provide that same benefit where you have continuous CLT panels, so that's a little bit of a hole right now when it comes to dry toppings. Can we can we use continuous CLT panels with dry toppings and and not have to worry with exposed ceilings, of course, and not have to worry about ceiling to ceiling flanking. So, yeah, we hope to answer that question, pretty shortly in the next, in a matter of a couple months. But in the meantime, you know, the, the isolated concrete toppings have really proved to, be a huge improvement to lateral sound transmission.

SimonAnd, and that's been a, a very significant benefit to the mass timber industry as more and more people strive to build these buildings with, you know, these beautiful exposed ceilings.

PayamAnd, and to just put things into a little bit more perspective from, the reason that continuous CLT is important and it's worth looking at is because, from an efficiency of construction perspective, you basically, you could span over two units with one, One length of C. L. T. I know some companies locally they are capable of producing the C. L. T. Panels that are long, like 50 ft in length, right? And but we are breaking them up just because what you just mentioned that of the because of the fear of potentially the noise transmission from one unit to the other.

PayamAnd they're also I think there might be some code implications right now that won't really allow us. But that's that's definitely worthwhile. Actually, I'm really interested to know what that result come back with, because hypothetically, if I can drop one piece of CLT and cover two bays, two full bays, and two

SimonMm hmm.

Payamspan over two units, that's going to cut my crane time in half. That's going to cut the trucking in half,

SimonI mean, we're seeing that on a

Payamreally.

Simonalready where they're spanning a couple suites at a time. and so that's been That's been great to see now you get into a bit of an interesting situation on the top floor you know, some of our projects are pouring concrete toppings on the roof because because Otherwise, we can't guarantee that you're gonna meet, you know, we we we Because the lab suggests that without a concrete topping above, you're not going to be able to meet code in that lateral sense. And so we have some projects that are adding the

PayamOh, I see.

Simonwe have other projects that are changing the CLT panel layout only for the roof, so that on the roof, you have CLT panels spanning only one suite, whereas on all the other floors, you're, you're going to a couple suites. And so there's a couple different approaches there on how we can address that. But yeah, no, it's been an interesting, You know, a journey, I would say,

PayamRight.

Simonyears with this, but it's been, it's been great. You know, it's been great to work with architects, developers, you know, project managers, such as yourself, who are passionate about mass timber and and who are passionate about, you know, about leaving ceilings exposed in an industry where for, you know, for a few years, the rep, the, the, the, stigma I'll say in the industry is that, oh, you know, acoustics is going to be terrible unless you put a drywall ceiling in and, and even the mass timber suppliers, you know, are, are so excited by the data that we have to support, Leaving ceilings exposed that that you know That's part of the reason why we get some of these referrals is people saying you've got if you want your ceilings exposed You got to give these guys a call and you know, they can support

PayamIt is a big deal. Like when you, when you think about it in the broader context of the cost and the project, obviously not having to do drywall ceilings in both cost and time on site, it's, there's a saving. There is certain, aesthetic appeal also where you, where you have all the wood and you get the warmth of the wood. That's, I think that has always been one of the many main selling points when it comes to, using mass timber. So, I want to go back to the Kitchener project and I remember that you were at some point, thinking, and I think it's worth exploring a little bit more that you might have to, use a checkerboard pattern on, on, was that, was that on the.

Payamwas that on the wall?

SimonThat

Payamof all, that's Right.

Simonthat so yw had mass timber everything it had mass timber exterior walls sweet demising walls and floor ceilings excuse me and so The the sweet demising walls had to be covered. They were only three ply You And really, even from a direct sense, they had to have some type of insulated partition on both sides or else we weren't going to get the direct performance. So that sort of covered the risk of flanking from that perspective. But then we had these continuous CLT panels. We did not yet have the data.

SimonIn fact, YW was one of the first projects where we developed some of this data, because we Because we did some testing before they built the ceilings. But in the meantime, in design, the, the theory was, you know, the lab data was that you could not have continuous CLT panels with no ceilings. And so what we did was we did a checkerboard ceiling pattern where every. Pair of suites that are connected by a continuous CLT panel have a ceiling in one of the two suites in order to address that ceiling to ceiling planking path.

SimonAnd then on the, on the flip side, we also had these CLT exterior walls that again, were these continuous panels that go up and down the building. And again, the same concern of flanking through this exterior wall panel. and so we, you know, had to address that by. Leaving some of it exposed and again doing some type of checkerboard that, you know, we tried to expose the exterior wall in suites that didn't have exposed ceilings. And so it was a bit of a. exercise and a learning opportunity and Matt who was Matt Bull who was the architect on that project, you know, he and I know, we we give presentations together sometimes and we chat a lot architect very big supporter of mass timber and and you know, he he likes to joke about the You know level of professional conflict, especially now that we that we've grown a great personal and professional relationship but he jokes about sort of the professional conflict that during YW You know, I was the bad guy, you know, everybody wanted the exposed mass timber.

SimonAnd, and I was the bad guy who came in and said, look, I like the data is showing that we can't do this. We, you know, in order to meet code, this is what we're going to have to do. And so I accept that. I accept the,

PayamBut, so, so was it you who was, who were pushing for actually leaving it open as a circuit board or was it Matt?

Simonwell, no, I mean that I, Matt wanted no ceilings at all, you

PayamOh, at all. Oh, everything gone. Gotcha.

Simonso the checkerboard was, was sort of me that said, I, you know, The data suggests that leaving everything open is not going to meet code. And what's interesting is that finally we were able to get out and testing. They had built almost all the ceilings except for a couple. And we tested in the suites without the ceilings and we got really good results. And so the next building I did, you know, with Matt, we did it differently. We did it with, without the ceilings. And so it, you know, certainly, or even in block two, right. Block two, YW had a second phase.

Simonand so we were able to, you know, explore things differently in future projects, and that, and, of course, you know, get into more projects to test the same thing. It was hard to rely just on, on one, you know, one or two tests in one building. We want to make sure that we're really establishing a, a A baseline of experience, but beyond that, you know, we've definitely been able to impart that on a bunch of different buildings to avoid that checkerboard pattern. But certainly that, you know, that pattern started with with me and, with me pushing for, you know, for the acoustic standpoint and the lack of understanding that the North American mass timber industry had at the time.

SimonAnd I'm glad that. That I can, contribute this knowledge to the, to the rest of the industry, the, you know, the rest of acoustics, the, and, and developers to, you know, Sort of open up some opportunities. Now I will say, you know, now that the industry kind of gets, keeps, stays ahead of me. Right. So we started doing this testing with five ply and we go, Oh, great. Like, I think we have this data to support leaving five ply exposed. No need for drywall ceilings. this is great. And, and, you know, next thing I know, I'm getting calls about three ply floor ceilings and I'm going, well, hold on a second, like we haven't developed, we haven't developed that database yet, so, so I think,

PayamThat's, that's one of the beauties of our, our, our industry is that we keep pushing. If you can do it for five, why, why, why not for three, right?

SimonAnd so, and so, you know, that's more data that we're looking forward to getting this, this summer, or even, you know, the effective green roof. I mean, does the weight of the green roof give you the same damping as the

PayamRight.

Simontopping? I have no idea, but we're going to find out in the next couple months of testing. So,

PayamYou know what? That's actually a very good point.

Simonas the, as the industry progresses and, you know, we gain more data and then the industry changes and goes three ply. And, and so, you know, that's been, been a lot of fun and very interesting. I continue at some times to be the villain, I think, unfortunately. But of course, you know, it's all in, it's all in good intentions. I want to

PayamAs engineers, I think we have that role. Sometimes we have to have that roles from time to time to say the unpopular ideas that not everyone wants to hear, but you touched on a couple of things that I don't mind expanding on if you're okay. One of them is, this whole mass timber and like we're diving into this mass labor quite a bit, but, mass timber has been around for quite some time. It's not new. It's, it's true that in Canada a couple years ago, a few years ago, the code started allowing more use of mass number, but it has been around.

PayamEurope has been using it extensively for decades in many more applications than we have. I guess, is there an area of concern or I should say area of improvement that you might think of and say, you know what, it would be really good If our code in next iteration or our industry or our design community would think of this, this way or that way to basically pick up some good practices or best practices, what, from what people are doing in Europe or other places for that matter, does anything come to mind?

SimonSure. So I, I mean, you're, you're a bit, it's a bit difficult sometimes to compare, especially even the test data, because Not all mass timber is created equal. And so, you know, we, you know, here we see a lot of 5 ply that's 7 inches 175 mils, you know, versus Europe where a lot of it, you know, I see 5 ply that's 95 mils or, you know, in,

PayamRight,

SimonIn BC, where it's 105 mills. So, so you get different depths of five ply, of course, all of those have different acoustical performances and different acoustical, you know, characteristics. So, so from that respect, there's, you know, we, we can only sort of draw so much comparison once we start changing the CLT too much, but in general, you know, you, The guidelines and the, you know, even sort of municipal requirements are certainly much more stringent in Europe, you know, one area in North America, Canada, actually, specifically, because the U.

SimonS. is a lot better, but one area in Canada. the codes are really quite relaxed is with, with footstep noise, with, with impact noise. So that's

Payamright. I I see. Yeah,

Simonthat applies not only to Mass Timber, of course, that applies to really every residential building. And, and so right now the code has it as a requirement. Now what's interesting is that, I will say, That the National Research Council has, submitted a code change request, I believe for 2025 to add IIC to the building code. And that would be quite a big deal in acoustics. I mean, I, you know, to everybody else, it would be go unnoticed, but to us, it'd be, you know, a huge change to how things go.

SimonIt, I don't know that that will happen. It hasn't been confirmed yet. And one of the reasons why it hasn't been confirmed yet is that the ISC metric is a bit flawed in

Payamright. Mm

Simonnoise. Like I was referring to earlier, it sort of has two, there's two types of impact noise. There is the low frequency thumping that I was alluding to earlier, where you kind of think about somebody walking heavily in socks, but then you have like the high frequency. Tickety tacks of, you know, somebody walking around in high heels on ceramic tile.

PayamMm hmm.

Simonthose two things are completely different. So when you So when you just see something that has a low IIC rating, it doesn't tell you if it's

PayamToo much. Mm hmm. Mm

Simonand the something. And by the way, the tickety tacks, that's of course a very technical term. And so, and so, you know, and so that, so from IIC, you know, they've developed a new standard only in the last few years called H IIC, so high frequency IIC. And, and they're. In development on a low frequency standard called L. I. I. C. I can tell you that the folks at A. S. T. M. are quite opinionated during those meetings. so I guess, you know, acoustical engineers are very passionate about making sure the standards are right.

SimonAnd so, you know, that's been developed. So as I see shifts a little bit into L. I. I. C. And H. I. I. C. I think it becomes a lot easier to argue certain requirements in the code and, you know, You know, because then you don't have to worry about something meeting IIC, but still having way too many, way too high thumping sound, you know, to get those requirements right. But that is a big, that is a big thing that I think we Would benefit the industry right now. The reality that I see is not a code requirement. It's only a code recommendation that we get tons of calls from people who are property managers and existing condos and somebody is complaining about footstep noise from the people living above or furniture moving or, you know, things dropping on the floor, especially when they have kids and.

Simonthe reality is that there's not a, you know, sometimes there's IIC ratings and condo documents. I do, recommend that. That means that if somebody's going to rip out their carpet, excuse me, if somebody's going to rip out their carpet, they can't just install any floor they want. They have to think about the underlayment. But other than that, you know, that, that is a very common call that we get. another thing that's not really a code requirement, And that paint, you know, that leaves it in a gray area are really noise from building services. So when you think of things like elevator noise in a suite, you know, right now My life would be a lot easier if there was some big black and white know, 35 DBA limit.

SimonAnd we showed up and said, yep, this is 36. That's too loud. Have a nice day. But the reality is that that's not the case. And so what a lot of acoustical engineers draw on when they are, when they are outlining their targets, when they're addressing and, and, you know, evaluating whether or not a sound is too loud or not, you know, things like garbage chute drops, weight drops, you know, an engineer is looking at a lot of different resources that come into it. So that could be codes in other areas. That could be. Things like ASHRAE or or ANSI criteria for different things.

SimonSo pulling together guidelines and resources. That's how we develop our criteria. And that's what we would, you know, when we go to court, that's how we would have to establish that criteria. But those are certainly some things that are missing from a potential, you know, from well, not from potential, but from the Canadian building code and hopefully would be added in a potential, you know, code amendment

PayamRevision or something. Yeah.

SimonThat's right. Thank you to firm up those things. And I think that that would. Hold the industry, you know, a little bit, it would hold the industry to a higher standard and, and reduce, you know, complaints from those things to more of kind of a hand wavy approach to design.

PayamAnd you hit it on the head. Like, I think, especially when we get more, more, innovative systems like the mass mass timber, I'm pretty sure like what we're seeing in the mass timber, hopefully I shouldn't, I shouldn't say I'm sure I'm, I'm hopeful. That this is just the beginning of a new spectrum of products that are going to come out, hopefully more sustainable, more sustainable way of building buildings. And, you make a great point that, without clear cut criteria that says, yes, this is good.

PayamYes, maybe this one is gray and the other one, no, it leaves, room for too much judgment, which frankly, looking at it from a developer's perspective or a builder's perspective, you, we're in the business of risk management. We're in the business of having bright minds, like yourself, trying to tell us what's right and what's not, so we don't take on more risk than we absolutely should, right? And, yeah, so that would be a welcoming change, and hopefully we see it sooner than later.

PayamI guess Mm

Simondoes, you know, a lot of these types of things depend on the area, you know, background sound in the area, how often it happens. So,

Payamhmm.

Simonthat we get, you know, I do a lot of actually, you know, fitness, like weight drop investigations and fitness investigations with gym floors. And that's a very common source of complaints in existing buildings where somebody will call us. And, and of course weight drop, you know, noise can travel a few floors up. So the unfortunate thing is that a lot of developers and, you know, ID, professionals, people who, who design gyms have sort of been duped by the industry a little bit to think that, you know, any rubber floor is good enough to address weight drop noise.

SimonAnd, and it's unfortunate because it's, it's pretty far from the truth. I mean, the, the reality is that. a thin 10 mil rubber tile, you know, is great at reducing noise in the gym. You drop the weight in the gym and it doesn't really sound that loud, but the re it can travel four or five floors up and start shaking somebody's picture frames. And so, and so, know,

Payamdo you deal with that? Actually, that's a good thing. Mm hmm. Right. Mm hmm.

Simona concrete building, which is especially where it travels the farthest, that's where you have to get into it looking at the gym floor itself. And so looking at retrofitting that gym floor, you often get into much thicker gym floors, which becomes very complicated when the building is done. You know, if it's a poor concrete building and, you know, or the building is poured, you could, you know, you could have added a slab depression in advance, but now it's too late. and so adding transition pieces and accessibility ramps and all of those things that can get a bit complicated. And so, when it does come to assessing weight drop noise, you know, we recently were involved in a pretty contentious court case and we were going up against somebody else and the lawyer, you know, was saying, you really need to.

Simonoutline your methodology, you know, to the judge in such a clear way. And it really kind of forced us to get even more resources. You know, when we were drawing upon a few things and we were like, okay, well, we need like 10 resources. We need more resources to draw upon this. And when you're evaluating weight drops, because it's not as easy to say weight drops shouldn't be more than 30 DB or whatever limit you want to say, because the question is, well, How often does the weight drop happen? What kind of gym is this? Is this an, you know, an F45 where you have classes every single morning and throughout the day?

SimonOr is this a condo gym or is this a gym in a seniors residence where nobody's ever going to lift a weight more than 10 pounds? And so this becomes, you know, not a simple exercise of asking yourself, is it. Above or below 30 DB. I mean, you can't just set that target because it does come down to what kind of gym is it? How often is the weight drop? What is the, as you said, it's, it's risk management. What is the risk of complaining and what we. have to say in these situations is that, what we're doing is we're trying to evaluate typical gym activities and typical gym activities is in itself very difficult to define

PayamYeah, it's hard to answer that question.

SimonAnd so, you know, if somebody comes in, even if you install an amazing gym floor, even if you put in like a three, four inch, very soft gym floor that, you know, That you can walk on properly, but, but we'll like, you know, absorb a lot of that vibration. If somebody comes in and starts throwing kettlebells from above their head, you know, dead ball slams or whatever, you're going to hear it pretty far. Like there's no gym floor that you're going to install. That's going to address that. And so, you know, you have to kind of explain not only to a judge, but even just to the developer, to the design team, that what we're doing is we're doing risk management.

SimonWe're trying to. to address the risk of complaints by essentially saying gym activities will be inaudible or quiet or, or marginally audible, whatever, whatever our target is will be acceptable in the nearest suites, nearest receptors. But if somebody comes in and goes crazy, it's going to be too loud. And so The idea is A, people shouldn't be allowed to do that, and B, if they do that anyways, it should be rare enough that nobody's really gonna complain. And, and

PayamRight.

Simonreality. I mean, the reality is that when you do have a good gym floor in, you know, the odd time that, I mean, people hear lots of noises in, in multi family buildings. I mean, they hear a

PayamThat's part of it. That's part of the whole package of living there, right?

Simonhear a truck drive by, you hear people

PayamYeah.

Simoncorridor, and so if you hear a bang once a month, From the gym, you're not going to complain, but if you hear

PayamHopefully you don't have a neighbor who does kettlebells all day every day, right?

SimonYou hear it at six o'clock in the morning repeatedly because you have no Jim Flora. And then, of course, you're going to get, you know, complaints about that. So from that perspective, it's less about, you know, a black and white number criteria. And it's more about, as you said, risk mitigation and risk management and protecting the developer and the owner of the building from future from future complaints and from future, you know, legal defenses and trying to address it all in design.

PayamRight. And you obviously don't want to overdo it, like you mentioned at the beginning, because, there's always the cost associated with this. We could potentially eliminate way more of the sound than if the noise, but it does come at a price. And at the end of the day, the consumers are going to have to pay a good chunk of that price, right? So, being efficient and being within reason, I guess, whereas, within reason, within reason, it's, it's, that's a key point, right?

Simonand that's the truth. Sometimes, you know, we work on gyms where you have a gym on slab on grade. And when your gym is slab on grade, then, you know, instead of putting in an amazing gym floor, it's a lot easier to just cut the slab. And so you just run a saw.

PayamThat's true.

Simonjoke. I mean, this is a

PayamNo, that's, that's very true. That's very true. Yeah.

Simongyms and so, and so, you know, developers will say to us, wow, that's brilliant. Like, I'm so glad we didn't spend all this money on this fancy gym floor.

PayamYeah.

Simoncut the slab and, you know, fire, stop it. And then you're good to go. And then you don't have to worry about, then you can put in your, you know, 10 mil gym floor, whatever you want to put

PayamAnd have a kettlebell class every single morning.

SimonAnd there you go. There's your dead ball flames. Have a nice day. So it's, sometimes it is about, you know, the right type of design exercise and, and guiding the developer to not overspend where they, where it doesn't make sense to. 100%.

Payamlet's say I'm a new developer, I'm someone who wants to come into this mix or, or maybe I've, I've done a few projects and I want to take my game to the next level. What are the top, let's say one, two, three decisions That I need to make when it comes to the area of acoustics, or maybe I should, I could also reframe it and say, what are the top three questions I should ask my acoustic engineer if I want to make sure that, my end product is within reason.

SimonSo I think that, you know, an important thing is sort of in the question itself is to, is to work with an acoustical engineer. You know, like I said, architects, do learn a little bit about acoustics during their training. Some of them have gone over and above the, you know, a lot of them, most that I've spoken to certainly have a pretty decent understanding of things like STC and IIC, but really it is limited and it's, and it's not their fault, you know, it's not what they specialize in. right off the bat, even just getting an acoustical engineer involved is right away going to provide that level of guidance.

SimonAnd then the other thing is, you know, really properly defining the target market. You know, is it a luxury market? Is it a condo? Is it a rental, but a luxury rental or not luxury rental? You know, are you going to be involved for 20 years or are you walking away after 5 years or 1 year? And so, you know, kind of well defining that helps. you know, the engineer understand what the target end goal is. then in terms of conversations with the engineer, you know, the type of acoustical, engineer or consultant, I suppose, not all engineers, but the entire, the, the acoustical expertise that you would want on these jobs is somebody who is not only looking at STC and IAC.

SimonI mean, that, that's just like the, you know, that's the, that's kind of where you start, that's day one. And then the rest of it is getting into the flanking. And some of these. ways to address flanking are not expensive. You know, this is something like something like in making sure that your suite demising wall interrupts the corridor wall and interrupts the exterior wall, dry piece of drywall, like make sure that drywall is not continuous on, in, on the corridor, like past the suites, you know, that is not an expensive thing to do. All you do is you just. Interrupt the

PayamJust cut it. Yeah

Simonyou just cut it. So some of it's not like all of these things are money, money, money, money to make your building better acoustically. It's just about having somebody who has the ability to look at these things from the framework of not only direct but indirect sound transmission as well. so somebody who can really wrap their head around that. Also, you know, it's not only architectural, you certainly want An acoustical engineer who can take a look at, you know, M& E equipment, sound data for some of the big, equipment, make sure that they're addressing not only, Isolation of the equipment, but also things like piping, conduits, ductwork.

SimonI mean, these are like major things that are connected to the equipment that also can transmit vibration into the structure. So that's another thing where you really want an acoustical engineer to bring that, you know, knowledge to the project, the benefit of the project. And then probably the third thing comes into, yeah, that other territory of elevators and garbage chutes and compactors. And somebody who's. You know, pool isolation is another one. I mean, somebody who's going to think of the things that you don't see on all of the architectural, mechanical, electrical

PayamRight, but they have an impact on the building.

Simonhave a big impact on the building. Absolutely. You know, car stackers, like,

PayamOh, huge.

Simonyeah. So you, you know, somebody who's going to look at. Things that aren't as obvious on the drawings overhead doors is another great example, but but, you know, still a very common source of complaints, a significant acoustical, you know, source of vibrations or something sounded vibration. So those are all things that, you know, I would definitely be talking to an acoustical engineer about when you, when you bring them in early.

Payamif I want to, educate myself on the topic of acoustics, not to become an acoustic engineer per se, but just to learn more. dig more and keep ourselves up to date. Are there any websites, resources, books, articles that you would point people to?

SimonAbsolutely. I think that, you know, a lot of acoustical engineers have blogs. I mean, you know, we have a blog. A lot of others, I'm sure, have blogs with really helpful articles as well. And so, you know, making use of those resources, if you're in Canada, I really, if you're not in Canada, you know, this still applies, but the National Research Council, the NRC has public, which is a government affiliated research lab, I will say, for those who are less familiar, NRC has published a bunch of really great guides, with respect to acoustics.

SimonAnd so if you were to Google something like NRC publications, and then you look through those, you know, that that will take you to their website and then looking, you know, searching for things like acoustics that will really guide you through, you know, acoustics in, in, composite steel deck buildings and lightweight steel frame buildings and a different, you know, very specialized guides in there, you know, for mass timber, a great resource. Woodworks has a guide, a list of acoustically tested assemblies. This is just for direct STC and IIC, but

PayamYeah,

Simonsaid, that's where, that's where we start. So that's a great, resource there of a ton, a

Payamwoodworks has a lot of material. Yeah, woodworks, both in Canada and America. Yeah,

Simonthose, those, Compilations of test data from WoodWorks is really valuable if you're not, if it's not mass timber, if you're looking at something like a wood frame floor ceilings or steel stud assemblies, then the on the national building code, the Ontario building code in Canada. Those all have some great, Tested assemblies as well in the SB three table at the back. So there's, you know, 50 pages of tested assemblies, a lot of which have fire ratings as well. And so, you know, coming up with just some simple STC and I see ratings. Those are some great resources.

SimonAnd then, you know, a lot of those blogs. That's where you can get into more information about mass timber acoustics or fitness noise and vibration. You know, sound transmission between suites, you know, addressing property manager complaints, all of these different you know. You can find in different blogs.

Payamwhere, where can people find you, if you want to share some information?

Simoncan find me. So I, I work with HGC engineering, and. that's where you can find, you know, our blog and a bunch of that info. And if you want to reach out to me, my email address is s, S for Simon, Edwards, S E D W A R D S at hgcengineering. com. And if anybody has any questions for me, then just, send me an email.

Payamyou very much, Simon. It was a fun episode. I learned a lot. I took whole pages of notes here and I'm sure we're gonna have very good feedback from our listeners. any follow up questions, anyone listening, please feel free to reach out and ask the questions and thank you again, Hopefully we will do a round two in the near future.

SimonSounds good. Thanks for having me, Paim. I appreciate it.

PayamThank you.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. (65) Toronto Mid-Rise: What’s Changed and What Still Holds Projects Back? - Claire Malcolmson

    Nov 12, 202633 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Where does the garbage truck go? On a tight Toronto mid-rise site, the answer can change the ground-floor layout and how many homes you can build. In episode 65 of Real Estate Development Insights, I...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. (64) From Architect to Multiplex Developer: Lessons from the Site - Noam Hazan

    Oct 27, 202639 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail What changes when the architect becomes the developer - and takes responsibility for getting the project built? In this episode, Payam Noursalehi speaks with Noam Hazan, architect and founder of Noam...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. (63) Building Small Mid-Rise in Toronto: What Developers Need to Know - Heather Dubbeldam & Derek McCallum

    Oct 7, 20261 hr 5 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail What should you investigate before turning a Toronto major-street property into a small mid-rise apartment project? Heather Dubbeldam and Derek McCallum of Dubbeldam Architecture + Design join Payam...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. (62) Toronto Housing Approvals: What’s Changing - Jag Sharma - Deputy City Manager - City of Toronto

    Sep 22, 202647 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail What is changing inside Toronto’s housing approval system - and what will developers actually notice? Jag Sharma, Deputy City Manager for Development and Growth Services at the City of Toronto, joins...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. (61) Should You Build a Multiplex? 5 Checks Before You Commit

    Sep 9, 202641 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Should You Build a Toronto Multiplex? Five Questions to Answer First I run a construction company, so it may be against my own interest to say this: not every multiplex project should be built....

    Credit the people on this episode