(62) Toronto Housing Approvals: What’s Changing - Jag Sharma - Deputy City Manager - City of Toronto
47 minAudio
Send us Fan Mail What is changing inside Toronto’s housing approval system - and what will developers actually notice? Jag Sharma, Deputy City Manager for Development and Growth Services at the City of Toronto, joins Payam Noursalehi to discuss development review, site plan changes, coordination with utilities, and the effort to move housing projects toward occupancy. The conversation connects City Hall’s reform agenda to the practical concerns of small and mid-sized developers: inconsistent comments, late surprises, connection delays, financing constraints and the risks of taking on a first project. In this episode: Why Jag wants industry feedback to determine whether process changes are working. The reasoning behind different site plan review streams and associated fees. How some engineering reviewers connect Development Review with Toronto Water. Why cooperation with utilities matters even where the City does not control their decisions. The distinction Jag draws between development-charge relief and purpose-built rental incentives. His outlook for multiplexes, mid-rise housing and modern methods of construction. Why Payam believes new development opportunities need to be accompanied by education and practical preparation. Jag’s point about measuring the journey to occupancy runs through the discussion. For developers, the useful question is what still stands between the current application and a building people can use. Listen to the full conversation with Jag Sharma on Real Estate Development Insights. This discussion includes proposed changes, forecasts and programs whose details may evolve. Check current City documents and obtain project-specific professional advice before relying on timelines, incentives or eligibility assumptions. Resources Toronto development charges information Council decision addressing DC reductions and Phase 2 rental incentives August 5, 2026 federal-Toronto rental housing announcement For more information, please refer to RealEstateDevelopmentInsights.com Join Our Workshop: MultiplexWorkshop.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Solmazis no one lives in a development application. they live when we actually issue an occupancy permit./
PayamGood morning, Jack. Welcome to our show. How are you doing today?
SolmazOh, And yourself?
PayamFantastic. Thanks for being here. Can I ask you to please introduce yourself to our audience here?
Solmazyeah. My name is Jag Sharma. I'm the deputy city manager of Development and Growth Services. It's a relatively young service area. It's about three years old. started, with, Mayor Tory and then, certainly was put in place by Mayor Chow, and we-- she's continued to invest in this service area. And once again, about three years old, but, I'll say highly impactful years
PayamAnd I'm happy you started there because when I was reading about your role and what it was basically meant to bring about to the city was it was a kind of a restructuring, breaking maybe a m- more central s- department or s- group or team, I don't know exact wording for it, into more specialized. And I think that one of the, things that I read online was that the purpose was to se- create a little bit of a separation between strategy and implementation. It does that... Did I get that right and was that the point?
SolmazI think the, the main point was, that I think the city struggled for, I'm gonna say well over a decade in order to make the progress that our political leadership was looking for from a development perspective. They were hearing feedback from industry and all. So I think the o-overarching objective was to try and align all services that were associated with development, housing, and, broadly, any type of development into one area. that was the overarching. when I had the opportunity to take the role and, consider what, the group should look like and how it should function, that's where exactly what you just said started to my future state to say, Toronto is big, Toronto's complicated.
SolmazWhat I need to do is create enough space for these great leaders that we have,'cause we have the best of the best. And by giving them the appropriate space and I'll say scope of control, then essentially they were able to focus more and deliver greater results. And so that was a little bit of the separating of the strategy and the operations because both of them together was just unmanageable for, for... It didn't, matter how great a leader we had, just too big
PayamAnd then when you mentioned both, what, which functions are you specifically referring to? Are you ref-referring to the planning, uh, and the housing development versus infrastructure and, con- building department? Is that how you're referring to?
SolmazSo a bit of both. so for example, even with the infrastructure folks, we've got technical, I'll say the engineering, the development engineering related folks. So formerly, they were referred to as a commenting division. So essentially, whether it be Toronto Water or engineering, they would have folks that would comment on development applications. That group from the infrastructure side of things has been brought into development, development and growth services under development review. But as well, the chief planner and, development review, they were all part of one umbrella before, and that's been separated.
SolmazWe've done something very similar, so it wasn't just about the chief planner role or anything. It was, we've done the same thing with our housing secretariat, where we have, housing secretariat, now the housing development office. And so very much, in that vein of saying, how do we create the right space for all the strategy, policy, future-looking work that we need to do? then the day-to-day need to get it done, need to execute, and we need to deliver side of the business.
PayamGotcha. So if I wanna go back, let's say five to 10 years, again, like your, your role in this setup has existed for three. When we used to do applications, being it, uh, site plans, zoning bylaw, or anything that we went through, we used to get massive amounts of comments, many different points of contact, and a lot of times the, the, even the comments or questions for these projects, especially like my, my background was on mid-rise projects and the mid-rise guidelines and the projects we did there, there were somewhat even conflicting end points.
PayamWould you say that has changed significantly as a result of this restructuring, restructuring?
SolmazYeah. So I would say it's changed significantly, but what I would also say is there's no lack of work to be done. So yes, we've made a, a significant step forward. There's no doubt about that. So not only, the questions that you would, receive, or the comments that you would receive, one of the areas of focus under what used to be Valessa and now Orin is essentially establishing greater consistency. So what we're looking for is not only, consistency of comments so that, you...
Solmazover time, th-these will be predictable, as well co- the appropriate comments when you should have them less of the surprises because we've heard very clearly from industry that, there'll be k- later in the process and there'll be comments that will seem to be very, out of the blue and surprising to them and basically contribute to delays. these are the types of things that I'm working with the team to say we need to actually, and we are, we're actually tracking this information. We're putting the appropriate streams in place.
Solmazbefore, our development review process was I think on average seven hundred and sixty something days. It was something, pretty incredible. We are now down into that, like we've got, development reviews that have happened in sixty-nine days and,
PayamRight
Solmaze-even faster than that.
PayamAnd these are the same scale projects you're saying?
SolmazOh, these are larger scale projects. So
PayamGotcha
Solmazyou know, for example, the, the two... twenty-four forty-four Eglinton was, done, I believe in sixty-nine days and it's, the largest co-op project and it is a, very large development. But once again, with the right focus and with the right intent possible and, delivered a massive success there as far as being able to push that project ahead, demonstrate commitment and, see it, see it through to success
PayamGotcha. So with that, I wanna take a step back. You have a background as an engineer. You, I believe, have some sp- uh, have some specialty in the lean, uh, setup, Six Sigma setup, and you also have worked with some bigger brand names in your previous life on private-- in private sector, including Ford, um, I think there was Maple Leafs and, other industries. If you were to, and I, I think this might be a hard question, if you were to compare the current state of what we have as an organization in the city in terms of lean and how efficient it's working compared to pr- private sector, from one to 10, how would you compare it and how much room to im-improve do we have?
Solmazso that's a little bit tricky'cause it's not an apples to apples comparison. to be very transparent, I wish I had my public sector experience
PayamRight
Solmazprivate sector experience because the complexity of what happens in the public sector is not, something that we can, I'll say compare directly with the private sector. Private sector, when-- whether it be Ford or Maple Leaf, it's a product, it's making sure there's customer satisfaction. it's, it's, ensuring that you are, delivering not only profit margin, but the, the quality product and reducing With the public sector, the number of inputs, the number of intersections and everything are so much more complicated. so what I wouldn't necessarily be able to do is a direct comparison.
SolmazWhat I will say is just like any organization, private sector or otherwise, there is a great amount of opportunity to improve, and that's what, the team is truly focused on, is what we're not doing is, comparing against the other municipalities. What we're doing is comparing against ourselves. We're setting our benchmark, and then we are targeting our improvement. And once we've actually delivered on that improvement, and this is a c- a conversation I have with industry, whether it be Build, Rescon or others, and essentially what we talk about is let's not be shotgun about this.
SolmazLet's talk about our top three priorities
Payamمhm
Solmazwith their input as well. And then as I put improvements in for those top three priorities, the validation is through industry and through the feedback that we're receiving. It's not just self-told, improvement from a municipal perspective
Payamclosed loop that is providing you feedback basically
SolmazClosed loop that, traditionally municipalities will make changes and not be necessarily accountable directly to the result. What I'm trying to do is introduce that very firm change to say,"Yes, we're making changes, but we only celebrate the success when industry tells us that they felt the difference, therefore we've removed another obstacle for, essentially whether it's time." and what we know is time is also money and cost and delays of, essentially what it takes to get things done.
Solmazthose are the types of measures that we're using in order to make sure that we are delivering greater and greater successes
PayamFantastic. if I got it-- if I get it right, you're saying that the, not the shotgun approach, the priority approach right now is to make the applications go faster and, maybe just confirm what are the top two or three priorities that you're s-you're chasing right now and you're f-chasing feedback right now?
SolmazSo the, the big improvement that we've seen, of course, is the development review timeline. industry is certainly experiencing it. The next area is the site plan. so site plan will be substantially improved. So they-- It'll all be in place for January first of twenty twenty-seven. However, they're already, putting the streamings, in place for site plan, and that will be a materially different experience. and then post, into twenty twenty-seven, we'll be doing committee of adjustment and improving those, areas.
SolmazJust recently, I'm not sure, but on LinkedIn and from a city post perspective, we just launched, Toronto Buildings, and AI, permit submission process for not all of our building permits, but some of our smaller and medium-sized ones to begin with. And so that's, intended to deliver great results. But the same sort of process improvements that we're making in development review, we're putting in place in buildings as well, so that it's not just about doing the review. 'Cause, the, one of the common things I say to the team is no one lives in a development application.
Solmazthey live when we actually issue an occupancy permit. And Kamal Gogna, who's our chief building official, I have him very focused on time to occupancy permit. And we know we don't control all the factors, but if we're not measuring it,
Payamمhm
Solmazable to make the informed decisions that we should
PayamI love that approach, and I know we've had this discussion with your team on the planning side that yes, there has been a lot of great initiatives, mainly as part of EHON, at least in our area of focus and the, the, the multiplexes, the small mid-rises, the major avenues, sorry, major streets, and the formerly expanded guidelines on the avenues that are opening up a lot of new opportunities. But to your point, opportunity and permission versus actually peopling-- people living in those buildings are not necessarily the same, and I'm happy to hear that has...
Payamthat's on your radar. can we double-click on site plan for a second? I don't know if you have more details that you can share, because to your point, it has been a somewhat painful process throughout the years dealing with site plan, mainly because of what you touched on and has w-- it was many different partners, many different people commenting and not necessarily, being under the same roof. is this the major change that is happening and we can anticipate that if now we go through the site plan approval, there's been like be, like maybe a single point of contact that will facilitate and champion the process?
PayamIs that the thought process?
SolmazAbsolutely. So one, we're creating not only speed and, greater consistency as to the individuals that are reviewing. 'cause of course, with the... when the site plan process took so long, the risk of having a different planner, on the file, which was another source of frustration for industry, is significantly higher. But with expedited timelines, the risk is sig-significantly diminished. And as well, what we're doing is we're creating, of course, our traditional stream, which is the more complicated, larger projects.
Solmazthe mid, I'll say mid-complexity stream. And then we have, an, an as of right stream, so for, projects that need a very light touch. And then we al-almost have, and I'm, and I apologize, I'm pretty sure I'm not using the right terminology, but a voluntary stream. So example, our post-secondary partners, what we find is that they still want to go through the process even though that they're not required to. we are ensuring that we are looking at the breadth of site plans that we have, streaming them ap-appropriately, and we're also adjusting the fees associated with them so that not, essentially a traditional application will get more of a full fee.
SolmazBut a more, a lighter touch, an as of right or something else would be a very light, fee that would move, that much faster. So these different streams will help put things into the right stream, just as we've, indicated, them at pace, a fee that's appropriate, and essentially give, clarity. Along with that, it's that everything that we've talked about, the consistency of comments,
PayamRight
Solmazthe, the timeliness of the comments, and essentially being able to make sure that, once again, we are moving at pace so that there will be a different experience. So I can't tell you necessarily exactly what we, think the, the outcome will be, but I do believe this will be a material difference to the experience, for our development partners
PayamI would say site plan has been a very sticky point, so any improvement on that, in that realm will, I'm pretty sure it will have a significant effect on what the development industry experiences. And I guess a follow-up question to that is part of the issue on the site plan, it wasn't necessarily the city or the staff, which quite frankly, all of the staff I know-- We've said it on this podcast before that they're all doing their jobs. They're just making sure that they're making the best decision at the time of the, the application. They're reviewing, they're being diligent. So there's nothing personal, there's nothing... It was just a process of being, like this process was just too cumbersome and slow and maybe disconnected, which sounds like what you're describing.
PayamBut there are also external parties that had a very big say into the process, such as Toronto Hydro, such as Enbridge, such as, I'm not sure if like how Toronto Water, because Toronto Water was a very big choke point at many points in terms of bathtubbing, waterproofing, dis- long-term discharge, short-term discharge capacities. Like it created a lot of actual, aside from planning or zoning requirement, actual servicing concerns for the projects. Do you see that getting better? I know Toronto Hydro is having some initiatives mostly focused on the mu-multiplexes.
PayamI'm not sure if they're working on call it the mid-rise or more, larger projects. Do you have any insight into those entities and other partners?
SolmazYeah. So absolutely. We are working very closely with all of those partners, so whether it be, Enbridge, Toronto Hydro, Toronto Water. So Toronto Water is part of that group that we spoke of earlier, the commenting division. some of the engineering staff from Toronto Water are actually within development review now to streamline that whole process and make sure that we are being, quicker with it. To be clear, though, there's, the, those folks, those commenting division folks, the engineers and all, they essentially have a dual role. They need to stay up to speed with Toronto Water engineering and others so that they are at pace with what's happening in those areas.
Solmazthey also need to deliver quick comments, for the development application. So it's-- they're in a very, unique position where it's not
PayamThey're wearing two hats and they're liaising between two functions
SolmazAnd but they're in-- but it's intent-- it's working very well because, of course, they're part of both families, and they're helping to deliver that better service. we meet regularly with Toronto Water, and Enbridge as well just to talk about sticky points. In fact, I have a meeting with the city manager in Toronto Hydro tomorrow. we unpack different issues, where, we share industry feedback and all. And what I'm finding is Toronto Hydro is incredibly responsive. They're, listening to, what we're sharing with them, and they're focused on trying to improve their processes as well.
Solmazso this is all about, delivering a better, experience, and we've heard that from industry is: Why does it take so long to get a connection? Why does it cost so much? How come there's a surprise at, from a connection cost at the end? All these sorts of things, and we are sharing that feedback directly with them. I don't have direct control, but we have a great relationship, and my belief is that they are very interested in wanting to make those changes and improvements.
PayamFantastic. Thank you for saying that. So I wanna move forward from the process to some of the things that we've heard on the news and some of the changes and incentives. Uh, last time when you and I met on, at the July 28th event that you guys had held to announce some of these incentives, you made a comment to me that you guys basically have pulled all the stops that you could have at this point in time to incentivize new projects and get more projects built at this point. So I'm gonna start, and we did a full episode here for, for people who are listening, they can go back and listen to that episode about the incentives that you launched about the, the EC reductions and everything.
PayamMaybe just walk us through what is not on inside those documents. Like, yes, we have 40 to 60% reduction for a period of time for like two, three years. I think it ends August 2029. But I'm pretty sure you guys have a bigger picture of things that you're also working on in terms of how do we make this, problem essentially not happen again? Or what are the things that are not inside those documents that you have published?
SolmazSo once again, one, I want to say I'm very proud of being part of the team with our CFO to, essentially get our, our development charge relief program going as quickly as possible. It was great to be the first out of the gate with the province. essentially, it's not just the forty to sixty percent, and that was intentional. Forty percent for, essentially one-bedroom studio, sorry, studio and bachelor units and then, sixty percent for the larger units because we know that we need a different mix of product for the city of Toronto.
SolmazWe've got way too mu- too many small units within the city, and it's not driving to essentially small families, mid-size families, and being able to continue to live effectively in the city. So the forty to sixty percent range was specific and intentional. Beyond that, what we did with our finance colleagues is what we were able to do is some math behind the scenes to say, with this program coming in place, it created some, relief points for us. So what we're able to do is put in our next round of purpose-built rental, funding for that program to incent the next ten thousand units to be built.
SolmazSo the first round was approximately ten thousand units as well. I think we were just shy of that. and then this round is, another ten thousand units, with two thousand of them being affordable, so that twenty percent target. we expect s- yeah, a very significant uptake. When we had our first, um, uh, P-PBR stream launched, we, essentially we were able to accept seventeen projects that passed the post. Not all of them have, been successful, but I think we had north of fifty projects as far as applications.
SolmazAnd so there was a significant pipeline of product, essentially very interested in purpose-built rental. So what we have now, though, is, essentially we're running-- launching the next, phase of that, and we're expecting that significant turnout again. And we'll have sig- similar provisions as far as, they need to be shovel-ready, they need to be ready to essentially move and all those sorts of things. And, and they'll have a timeline in which they have to be completed in order to meet, the criteria for the funding and-
Payamso I know your team held an information session about a week or so ago, and they-- we went through the application. So application is pretty straightforward. It's a lot of documents, a lot of paperwork, but it's pretty straightforward. People can go through it. But one of the things when I was reviewing the numbers, especially from PBR1, like you just mentioned, was that when you go through the number of projects that were approved versus the number of units that w-were basically approved in those projects, these were extr-- I would guess, I don't have the details on the projects, but by the law of averages, these were pretty big projects that got approved the first time.
PayamThese were like three hundred units, four hundred units. Am I correct in my deduction from those numbers?
SolmazAbsolutely. So the program isn't limited to those size, projects. But yes, there was, it-- and what we saw, of course, is you have developers that are traditionally building condo that were pivoting from condo in order to take advantage of the purpose-built rental program and be able to move their projects ahead. that's essentially why you saw such large and, I'll say more of the traditional size projects and everything. And, now this round, we- I think we will see some more of that. I'm not sure if we'll see, some, some more of the mid-size projects as well, but they're all, they're all, all-- they all have the opportunity to apply for the program.
PayamYes
Solmazbut one thing's clear, though, and that when I've been, we've had the discussions with the team, is the PPR program is to incent private sector projects. What it isn't,'cause there was, essentially a little bit of, I'll say, background conversation around, is the city just going to support their own projects where they have their own land or things of that sort? We were ver- I was very clear with the team that, no, this program will not... Like we have already invested in those projects. This is for our private sector projects.
Solmazthis is for our industry partners to make sure that we are turning on the projects that are stuck
PayamPerfect. So you're not in-incentivizing already incentivized projects which are, the city's in- internal projects?
Solmazespecially if we've already invested in them so that, essentially now all we would be doing is taking care of ourselves if we were to do that. That's not the intent. This was specifically-- And, Mayor Chow is, of course, this is one of her, if not her top priority, it is certainly one of her top priorities. But she's always been very intentional about, the work that we are doing essentially from a political leadership, making sure that we are focused and, and essent- removing the barriers for the appropriate streams of product.
SolmazNow, for the purpose-built rental, once again, this is for industry, private sector, and essentially removing the barriers there
PayamGotcha. so I would say our focus in our podcast and our content has been more on the section of the market that is more prone to smaller developers or first-time developers. So anything that was done un-un-under the EHON really helps. We're seeing great movement in terms of multiplexes. I know recently Citi published a re- new report back in June that, uh, we-- uh, Citi has received more than two thousand application on the multi- on the multiplex section, which to me is a great sign, and hopefully people are doing, going through a learning curve.
PayamAnd the other part of the same conversation are the mid-rises. So we have, we've had the mid-rise guidelines for, oh, I guess at this point, close to twenty years. The, the first round mid-rise guideline was, I was gonna s- I'm gonna say it's le- was less than successful, like less successful than anticipated because it was just too complicated, and the economies of scale were very hard to make work. I know there has been some updates on the general up, guidelines, but there's also as, as a result of EHON, there's a very specific section that has been, I think, put a spotlight on, and that's the small mid-rise, these are six storey up to sixty units on major streets.
PayamDo you see any meaningful change in a year or two for this segment of the market?
SolmazAbsolutely. So it's a little bit of the, I'll say, the experience that we talked about with So we had so many projects apply. Not all of them were perfectly successful because you have individuals that they're out of practice, whether it's muscle memory or however you wanna talk about it. essentially they're, they were building condo for the longest time. gears to rental isn't necessarily a straight line, and there's a time, there's a timeline and there's, I'll say muscle memory that needs to be developed, with a change. Even with our, mid-rise, guidelines and all, this is about essentially making sure that the tools are there to enable it for the future and also continuing to look, to see what-- where the barriers are.
SolmazSo just with the mid-rise guidelines and all, w- what we haven't done is stop there. We've been investing, and I think the mayor had announced it, when we put out the, the pre-approved designs for our garden suites and laneway suites, that we were gonna take the next step, under her leadership in order to look at pre-approved designs for, mid-rise, for multiplex designs as well.
SolmazAnd so that work is almost complete, so you'll see something on that soon. But it's once again us not si-sitting back and saying,"Oh, no, we put out the standards. We've enabled the development. We're done."
PayamRight
SolmazWhat we're doing is we're assessing at every turn, trying to understand where the, sticky points are, what could enable, what would help it the first projects, just because what we know is that as soon as you start to see the, some of the projects come in, how much interest, watch how it picks up, watch how it begins to transform those neighborhoods. And we truly believe that, essentially all of these things that we're investing in order to remove those traditional roadblocks are going to pay off significantly in the future.
SolmazAnd what you'll see is, essentially it will pick up in a couple of years. And I don't think it's just going to be, the large buildings.
Payamمhm
Solmazdo think, the, the smaller, the mid-rise buildings are gonna play a very important role. Jason, Thorne, our chief planner, and I talk about it very often. Oren Tamir and I, we, what we do is debrief, any applications that we see in order to understand how they've flown, flowed through the system and, is there complexities. We hold industry roundtables where we do have some of our smaller developers, work, working on those mid-rise developments and those smaller developments that will give us feedback around those, sticky points as well.
PayamGotcha. Well, that's, that's great news. We need a lot of, lot of these buildings, and the good thing that I'm firsthand witnessing, is on the multiplex side, we have a lot of smaller investors, a lot of smaller money coming together, creating pools. it almost re- reminds us, I obviously wasn't here back then, of the MERP in the 20-- uh, sorry, in the 1970s, 1980s, that, what-- from what we hear, that's what was happening at that, that point. so that's generally good news. The other thing that has happened recently, we've had a very busy couple of months.
PayamOn August 5th, there was the whole announcement that, uh, prime minister made in Toronto regarding additional funding and additional units. Can you elaborate on that, and how does that affect this whole scene?
SolmazSo that's the Build Canada Homes announcement, and that funding, approximately two point seven billion, essentially enables fifty-six hundred units. And so that's a combination of funding that, we would be working through our partners at Build Canada Homes as well as, CMHC. And, it turns on a number of projects that once again, have those affordability targets and meet the requirements that not only the, the city has in place, but the federal government wants to see, as outcomes as well. So we were thrilled to, to have that announcement.
SolmazI believe it's the largest agreement with Build Canada Homes, of any municipality or any region, thus far. And, so we are very thankful for our, go-- other level of government partners, specifically the federal government in this case, for that partnership, because it is enabling, substantial projects, and it's keeping the industry moving forward. and it was a wonderful day, with the Prime Minister, the mayor, and, of course, BCH and CMHC in order to make the announcement
PayamPerfect. So just to recap, right now we have ma-- like multiple streams that hopefully are gonna make a difference, and definitely they will. So there is the forty to sixty percent DC reduction is one s- one stream. There is the PBR2, which is ten thousand units, um, that the-- it's happening under that I think it's one point five billion, dollars worth of incentives from city
Solmazoh, just to clarify, and I apologize for jumping in, but, they're two separate initiatives. So the one point five, does not fund the, purpose-built rental. The one point five is the purpo- the development charge relief program. That's our deal with the province. is solely a city-delivered program.
PayamI see
Solmazessentially, there's an intersection, but the, the development, charge relief program does not fund the purpose-built rental program
PayamGotcha. So the development relief program, the purpose-built re-re, the purpose-built program, then you have the BCH program, and, the fourth one is basically the reorganization of site plan in-inside the city, which touches on site plan and other stuff that we talked about. So they have, from my perspective, there are four different avenues that city is pursuing at the same time. Did I get that right?
Solmazyeah, and the other one, maybe the fifth one that I'd put in there, because of course, it is focused on the smaller and medium-sized permits to begin with, is the AI initiative with Toronto Buildings. And if we wanted to talk about a sixth, very soon you'll see those pre-approved designs. But essentially, all of these, and... are being put in place to make sure that we're looking across the spectrum, and those last two will benefit those smaller m- smaller and medium-sized, builders significantly
PayamGotcha. that's great news. Okay, so if I take all of those six of them, and then we say, let's say fast-forward to the end of the decade, which is about four years from now or three years and, and a bit, what will Toronto look like at that point, hopefully, if these things go according to plan?
Solmazon a positive note or maybe not, for some it'll be seen as positive, for some it'll be seen as not quick enough. But I think by the end of the decade, what you will not see is transformed neighborhoods. What you will see is the diversity in those neighborhoods of different builds starting to actually appear, then the future vision of what those neighborhoods will look like. When we look a-across the world, whether it be, Barcelona, when other, countries, other cities that, essentially density looks different than it does here in Toronto, what you will begin to see, say, four years from now, is you could almost envision, oh, will be a transformed street where you will see kind of density along the major corridor.
SolmazYou will f- have a different feel. will be moving more to, that call it that 15-minute city, that, that idea of essentially that community will function and how it will look and feel different. we spent a lot of time talking about not only the physical form around what it will look like, as, as we move through the years, also how the public will interact or how they will experience the neighborhoods as well. So that's a significant conversation with many of our political leaders, many of our thought leaders such as Jason Thorne, such as Doug Rollins, such as, essentially a number of folks where, it's not just about, one type of housing, it's also affordable housing.
SolmazIt's also supportive housing. it's how does this complete community look? How will it feel? And how will it function? a number of different dimensions that we consider. And so I think four years from now, what you're gonna start to be able to do is see examples in the city of saying, Hey, I could... I've seen this in another city, across the world or something, and, y- I can see where Toronto is going and, and I can see how this neighborhood will transform in the future."
PayamI'm very happy to hear that because that was actually one of my questions. Because we've had guests on the podcast who have compared Toronto to other major cities in the world, and there were concerns that we might not be moving in the right direction to be comp- pe- com- be able to compete with them in terms of quality of life inside the city. So it's good to hear that it's on your radar
SolmazYeah, absolutely. And it is, it's-- When we talk about complete communities, it's not just about the built form. It truly is about how does, our-- how do Torontonians experience their neighborhoods, then how do visitors to the city get the opportunity to experience this great city? And, as much as we can be critical of ourselves, if we use FIFA as an example, what an outstanding representation for the world to see Toronto because, by and large, people were just amazed with how great this city was.
SolmazAnd so it's good for us to be critical of ourselves, but we also need to step back and recognize how amazing this city is, too
PayamPerfect. So I wanna bring this great conversation to a more practical level. If, because again, like my dealings and our audience are more toward smaller developers, first time developers, citizen developers, there are many different segments, but they're all in that group of people. If you were, and by all means, our audience should not take this as financial or investment advice, they should always talk to the qualified people when making such decisions. But if you were to talk to someone who either is in the, call it, uh, development business, then they have small-- maybe they've already done, they've, uh, done custom houses and they wanna move to a multiplex, or they maybe they've done multiplex and they're looking for the next projects and map out their next five to 10 years of them- their projects for themselves.
PayamAt least maybe, maybe 10 is too much, maybe let's say five years. What would you incentivize or tell people,"This is a great opportunity. Go buy this. Go to find this type of project. This will happen in the next few years." What will your advice be?
SolmazYeah, and I'd certainly put the disclaimer out there to say I, I am not advising anyone based on, I'll say, my opinion, solely, and yeah, absolutely they should, their-- do their due diligence. But I truly believe that you are going to continue to see modern methods of construction. For example, modular, panelized, all of those types of, approaches. I truly believe that you are gonna see way more, mid-rise and multiplexes, and I think those are areas, those are growth areas from a city perspective.
SolmazWe will have our traditional builds. We will still have our large buildings. I think that there will be, call it the next five years will be, pun intended, the foundation those smaller, mid-size developments to truly begin to, to be a, a more significant part of what it is that we see through-- coming through the city. And I have to say that we're preparing for it too. So we are planning to see more of these applications. We are looking at those processes and everything else to say, for example, those ty- those types of developments will likely not go through our traditional stream of site plan.
SolmazThey will be through one of the reduced streams. And I wanna just pull on that thread for a little,
PayamSure
Solmazto say, those changes that we're putting in place put pressure on ourselves as well because it means that when we actually streamline and leverage Lean Six Sigma and continuous improvement and improve our processes, that means when we do our next fee study, will collect less revenue. So it means that, essentially I'm putting that much more pressure on ourselves as a city to say in the future I will collect less revenue essentially I will have to rethink how we-- continue to rethink how we de-deliver service, an exceptional service, even though we will have less revenue coming in.
SolmazAnd so it's not as simple as just turning to the tax levy because these aren't services that are intended to be levy funded. This is about us essentially holding ourselves accountable and saying, in, in the future we need to... In the current state, we need to continue to look at our processes because in the future we will need those improvements to continue to deliver the way that we do.
PayamAnd that's a great point because we did a full episode here on development charges, the revenue, how, where it comes from, and how it gets spent. So to your point, once you're reducing what you're collecting, city might need to get a little bit more creative in terms of other re- other sources of income and, and also, efficiency in terms of where it gets spent. So that is all music to, uh, the, my ears and, uh, great news. if we, Would you like to have a magic wand for five minutes, Jack?
SolmazSure.
PayamIf we give you a magic wand and you could make, um, a wish that would basically put our city in a best position possible to deal with the housing from a quality, from a quantity, from a affordable hou- af- affordability perspective for the next five to 10 years, and this could be a change in mindset, paradigm, guideline, law, bylaw, you pi- take your pick, whatever you want, and this could be at any level. This could be at city level, provincial level, or government, uh, or federal government level.
PayamWhat would be that one wish?
Solmazthe one wish I would say, and this is once again my-- a bit of my private sector coming out, is I still feel like there is, significant redundancy within the different levels of government. I'm very thankful for the partnership that we have with our provincial colleagues and our federal colleagues. There... I do believe, though, that there is further simplification opportunities between all levels of government to deliver on housing in that very intentional way that we can be that much faster, that much more streamlined.
SolmazWe can reduce costs further. And it's, desperately needed because, of course, from an industry partner perspective, from a Torontonian perspective that's on a wait list waiting for housing or needs a different option. we know that the housing, crisis is real. I guess if I had one, one wish and a wand, I would basically say, how can we, amongst all levels of government, reduce those additional layers and actually move things even faster?
SolmazBecause we're just not keeping pace with how desperate this, this crisis is.
PayamFair enough. Fair enough. Thank you f-for sharing that. And if I may add, if I may add my, uh, wish to your list would be that what I'm seeing boots on the ground, a lot of newer citizen developers are picking up on the opportunities that the city is opening up, which I personally find to be amazing. It's a great opportunity. It brings in money, it brings in ingenuity, it brings in c- uh, creativity from different sectors, from different people, and they get to do something about their own neighborhoods if they want to.
PayamSo this is all good and bright and amazing. There's one downside. The downside is a lot of these new folks have not done this before. They don't have the experience, they don't have the know-how, and they're exposing themselves to potentially a lot of l- risk that they are not geared to deal with on the smaller side. So my wish would also be for some sort of an educational informational arm to go along with everything that you guys are doing to kind of mitigate that risk.
PayamBecause what we've said on this podcast, and I'll say it again, is that the last thing we want is bad examples, failed projects, and people who have put things on the line and they have lost it. So that would be my wish on top of yours.
SolmazI think that's a great wish. and just as I talked about less bureaucracy, I'm almost gonna say, and we could use a little bureaucracy here. so private sector, developers where if they're using their own home or if, it is that smaller developer, I think there would be, value in having some criteria, some, whether it be certification or controls in place because as you said, it's exciting, it is a great opportunity, but it also needs to have, the right impact, the right results because the last thing we want is poor product out on the market and a reason why, this isn't working or why we have to get heavy-handed from a government perspective.
PayamPerfect. Thank you. Amen. Is there anything that I should have asked you, Jack, that you think that we've left out and there's anything that our, our audience should know about it?
SolmazI think once again, I'll just reinforce that the whole development and growth services initiative and setting up the service area, the, the city doesn't, set up a new service area on a regular basis. This is, once in a very long period of time that they do so, but it was very intentional. What I'm thrilled to say with, with our political leadership, our city manager support, we have, I'll say, been making changes that I think in- the industry has been desperate for, I'm gonna say decades, not just a decade.
Solmazso this is, essentially the momentum that we needed. I wish had come, call it five years sooner, just because, of course, timing is everything, and of course, we see our industry partners continuing to struggle. and so what I can assure, you, your viewers, your listeners, the industry, is that we are not being stagnant from a city perspective. We are not resting on the changes that have been put in place. Every time there's a change, once again, we validate with industry, but then we're focused on what is our next step, and we are essentially as, as committed to this not being the one-dimensional approach of we are the city, we will give you our answer.
SolmazThis is a collaborative approach to say, we are industry-- industry is our partners. We're working with all levels of government and our industry partners to deliver significant successes, and I expect that the, that you'll continue to see the next great change that will, truly transform the experience of what it means to do business with the city of Toronto,'cause that's been my goal from day one, which is the city of Toronto will have a different repu- reputation with industry in order to produce great housing options and essentially lead the country in the way that we change things.
PayamFantastic. Thank you very much, Jack. We appreciate you being here, and I hope that we can have you back here in some time with more good news and more practical, implications that, uh, from that feedback loop that you mentioned and, uh, we build the city together, a much better city for all of us. Thank you for doing this.
SolmazThank you very much, Payam. This has been, this has been awesome. It was a lot of fun, and I look forward to sharing more results with you in the future
PayamFantastic. Thank you
SolmazThanks Jag Sharma is the Deputy City Manager of Development and Growth Services for the City of Toronto,
Send us Fan Mail Where does the garbage truck go? On a tight Toronto mid-rise site, the answer can change the ground-floor layout and how many homes you can build. In episode 65 of Real Estate Development Insights, I...
Send us Fan Mail What changes when the architect becomes the developer - and takes responsibility for getting the project built? In this episode, Payam Noursalehi speaks with Noam Hazan, architect and founder of Noam...
Send us Fan Mail What should you investigate before turning a Toronto major-street property into a small mid-rise apartment project? Heather Dubbeldam and Derek McCallum of Dubbeldam Architecture + Design join Payam...
Send us Fan Mail Should You Build a Toronto Multiplex? Five Questions to Answer First I run a construction company, so it may be against my own interest to say this: not every multiplex project should be built....
Send us Fan Mail Toronto has announced residential development-charge reductions of 40% to 60%, backed by $1.5 billion in funding. But the commercial question is not simply how large the headline discount is - it is...