Send us Fan Mail What changes when the architect becomes the developer - and takes responsibility for getting the project built? In this episode, Payam Noursalehi speaks with Noam Hazan, architect and founder of Noam Hazan Design Studio in Toronto. After designing multiplexes for clients, Noam is developing a fourplex and garden suite of his own, taking on the roles of co-owner, architect and general contractor. Noam shares what the experience has taught him about selecting a site, hiring trades, managing construction and deciding where to save - and where spending more may be worthwhile. He reflects on a foundation contractor decision he regrets, the demands of managing the site alongside his architectural practice, and what he would approach differently on his next project. In this conversation: Moving from designing multiplexes to developing your own. Why Noam chose to act as general contractor - and what he would delegate next time. Site-selection considerations, including trees, easements, existing tenants and setbacks. How a lower foundation bid led to delays and winter construction challenges. Bringing construction lessons back into architectural drawings and coordination. Investing in acoustics with the future tenant experience in mind. Noam’s perspective on development charges and the alternative-solutions approval process. At the time of recording, Noam’s project was approaching completion. The discussion reflects his experience to that stage, rather than final construction costs or stabilized operating results. About Noam Hazan Noam Hazan is an OAA-licensed architect, developer and founder of Noam Hazan Design Studio. His Toronto practice focuses on multiplexes, missing-middle housing and custom residential projects. His work as both architect and developer connects design quality with feasibility, construction coordination and the practical responsibilities of ownership. Planning a multiplex or small mid-rise project? Solnik Construction Group helps GTA developers plan and deliver projects through development advisory, preconstruction and construction management. Learn more at SolnikConstruction.com Subscribe to Real Estate Development Insights and share this episode with someone considering their own development. For more information, please refer to RealEstateDevelopmentInsights.com Join Our Workshop: MultiplexWorkshop.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Noam Hazanthat was my biggest regret. And I, I-- kind of looking back, it was so stupid not to pay. It was a twenty grand difference, I think. And at the time, you think twenty grand is a lot of money.
PayamHi, Noam. Welcome to the show. How are you doing today?
Noam HazanI'm great. How you doing?
PayamFantastic. Thank you for being here. Would you mind introducing yourself to our audience?
Noam HazanSure. I'm Noam Hazan. I'm an architect and, I guess new multiplex developer. I run a small practice. we do somewhere between 30 to 40, projects a year, and I would say about 80% of our projects are multiplexes. and I'm also building, a multiplex right now for myself, as a personal project. Four- a four plus one
PayamYeah, very hands-on experience from what I can tell. you and I had an offline conversation and, yeah, you've been pretty active. is architecture is one of the branches that you're, working on. The second one that you just mentioned is development, and we're gonna talk about third one that you've had done in the past. this interview is part of a series of interviews that we're planning on doing with people who are transitioning into the space. And I guess one of the, one of the best pl- places, one of the best places to transition from into becoming a development, a developer and doing a multiplex development and becoming a citizen developer essentially, is where you came from, is from the f- from the architectural background, having been involved in these projects.
PayamWhy the jump?
Noam HazanI think it goes that back to development's always been of interest to me. every time I see a space, and I think really why I did architecture as well to start with, why I studied architecture, and decided to pursue that career. I have this thing wherever I go into a room, into a space, into a city, and see things where I think can be improved, I automatically imagine, what can be done here? How can we, enhance the space? a house, an institution, a school. So I think naturally I'm-- my mind is always racing. I remember actually one-- my first day of architecture school, the professor got up and he said, After this course," after I've done your undergrad,"you'll never look at the world in the same way."
Payamhe ruined it for you, basically.
Noam Hazanhe ruined it. He
PayamYeah
Noam Hazanbut it, but ultimately, everything I see, I'm always thinking about, like, how can we re-improve it, refine it? What can be done to make it more efficient? already something that I always think,"Oh, I could develop that." But it's always been like,"Okay, but you need money to develop, and this and that." And I think that this missing middle space has become quite-- make-makes it quite accessible for someone like me who's never developed before. I've done a few small developments. I had a mult-- a multiplex a few years ago where I lived in one of the units, something like that when I first started. But really the-- it allows you to take that first jump into deve-the development world.
Noam Hazanand, at relet-relatively low cost, and easy to do. and, I think because of all the government programs and then when I select and see an HST rebates, gives you a little bit more of a-- It reduces the risk a little bit slightly to kinda get into that. And that's basically the, the reason I got into development. I would say the other reason-- So I'm also GC-ing the project myself.
PayamInteresting I have mixed feelings about that, by the way, so we can talk about it later. But let's hear your side of it
Noam Hazanlot of, I have a lot of feelings about it and it's been a really interesting experience. Obviously, it adds a whole level of stress and, adds a whole level of
Payamso you're the architect, you're the developer, and you're the GC. who holds the train cor- who holds the trade meetings then? that's the question.
Noam HazanSo I meet with all the trades. I have, an assistant who helps me. She writes the checks. I ha- I have partners in the project, so they're very much involved with the financing side, or one of them is at least. so he deals with all the finances and the HST rebates and all these things. I deal with the planning, architecture, and construction. but yeah, it's been an, it's been a lot. definitely more than I anticipated, for sure. I built my own house in the past, so I have a little bit of experience in it, but never as a business, never as-- A m- and a multiplex is a different beast to building a house as well.
PayamAmen. You can say that again. Okay, before we dive in too much into your ongoing experience, because that's one of the things I wanna do in this episode, you have a lot of international experience. you've, you studied in the UK, I think, in Manchester and London, different places you've studied and lived. If you were to zoom out and look at what we're doing in Toronto from an urban perspective, from a housing providing perspective, how are we doing compared to the world?
Noam HazanI w-, I've always said this and like from the day I moved here, what now, 12 years ago, I think, Toronto's always a little bit behind. we're always catching up. obviously Toronto is a newer city. You can't compare it to places like London and Paris and even Manchester where, Manchester is where the Industrial Revolution started, basically. so very different, planning and architecture and needs for people back then and how that's been able to evolve. Like the roads are much narrower there, that, that kind of thing.
PayamGood or bad? I- is that good or bad? Sorry to interrupt you
Noam HazanI like-- I think that cities thrive on density. I think that cities become interesting. There's innovation when things are dense, people are living on top of each other. everything's... When things are walkable. that-- I believe in like the 15-minute city, where you can walk anywhere, your groceries, your office, within 15 minutes. I think that's a, something to strive for as a city. I think that because of, because the way that London was built, Manchester, I lived in New York for a bit, all these places are very walkable, and you have all the amenities you need within walking distance.
Noam HazanIn Canada, you have a plaza that's a 10-minute drive away. you can't usually walk there for the most part, especially in the suburbs. so you know, things are very different in how we have to build and design here than you would in a place like Europe where... or New York, for example, which is a lot more dense
PayamOkay, so I take that as we're on learning curve and we're hopefully there are better days to come and there's lessons to be learned, compared to the other world-- other parts of the world. Let's go back to-
Noam Hazanone other thing I wanna add to that is that I find there's a lot of like NIMBYism in like downtown Toronto, for example, like Parkdale, all these areas. and what's interesting to me is that people accept single-family homes in almost like the downtown core. Doesn't really exist in places like London, New York, Tokyo, Paris, you know, other major metropolitan cities. If it does, and there is a home there, it's extortionate amount of money for that house, and it's a very expensive home. So I think that the idea of all these single-family homes or these row housing or whatever, becoming multiplexes is a very normal transition in a growing, busy metropolitan city like Toronto.
Noam HazanAnd I think that if we can embrace that and understand it, like Toronto will get there and we'll become this more bustling, busy city. And I... What, just to add, I know I'm blabbering on a little bit, but to add, I always find it interesting for people that li- that have come, moved to Toronto from smaller cities, they always see Toronto as this like big, amazing city. people that come from places I've mentioned like New York, London, they always see it like like a town in a way. It's it's it's a funny, it's a funny perception of like also where you come from as well. So maybe I have a dif- a special bias, one way or the other, but I always find that interesting, that, that perception of
PayamI,
Noam HazanWho is
Payamremember when I landed here and I was, we're driving up from Pearson on 401, toward Yonge Street, and I literally looked at down, looked at the city, and I told my wife, like:"This is a blank canvas. Why haven't, hasn't anyone touched it? there's so much potential here." And hopefully, what is happening right now is gonna touch some of that canvas and try to... Not that it doesn't, represent something that we like, and it is beautiful, it's a great city, and, it has a lot of things going for it, but it could be better, and that's what we're talking about. So going back to a comment you made earlier about why you're doing what you're doing right now.
PayamEssentially, what you said summarizes a lot of incentives, initiatives through different levels of government, from CMHC, from city, from planning, from potentially even federal g- government that are coming together and enabling someone like yourself and hopefully a lot more other citizen developers to take on such projects and put a dent in our affordability and, supply side issues that we may have. and quite frankly, de-deliver housing that people wanna live in, not j-just shoeboxes, which unfortunately we did for a long time.
PayamThat being said, you-you've been doing this as an architect for a while. You moved to the development side, and I'm gonna guess, and you please correct me if I'm wrong, I'm gonna guess that there was a moment in time that something hits you and"Oh, we've never done this before. I've never been in this position trying to make this decision on the project." Do you have one of those examples? That is basically where it hits you that now you're the owner, now that you're the developer
Noam HazanYeah, there, there are a lot of things as the builder that we don't consider as our-- when we-- on the architect-- with the architect hat, basically. things like roughing in your internet, conduits before- beforehand or even, we try to plan for this, but even the bulkheads, like you don't really know where the bulkheads are gonna be. it's hard to really plan ahead so much until you're on site and you can see and everything know, is, is-- you're in the space and you can feel the space and there's things you can change. I can't think of anything specific, but there are a lot of these little incidences where you're in the space and it's"Oh, maybe we should do that," or there's some sort of clash, between the trades and then we need-- you know, there's solutions that can be fixed on site.
Noam HazanI think that happens on any, every project. but I think that now that I've got my architect hat and my developer hat, we can plan for some of those things. Like one example for, I can think of is put our air handling units, onto the facade of the building. we raised them about 10 feet. We put them on the facade. had to, at that point, go and get structural drawings for those air handling units'cause they are so heavy, and we didn't plan ahead of that. So things like-- these little things that we can plan ahead and, be mindful of where they go, from the outset are important.
Noam HazanAnd I think going through and experiencing this, as a developer, as a builder, and also as an architect gives me that like holistic, that holistic view of the project to be able to now incorporate that into the earlier stages of the project as well.
PayamGotcha. So you haven't had that moment, thankfully. I guess you were prepared enough that you haven't had that moment that,"Oh God, what did I get myself into?" kind of situation. And I guess that's a good thing, and hopefully people, more people can be in that situation when they prepare enough or, engage enough or expose enough to the elements of the industry that they don't have that moment, because unfortunately, sometimes we do see that. So let me ask that question in a different way. I'm guessing, and correct me if I'm wrong, as an architect, there were, there would have been a whole bunch of instances where you wanted to do something in the project, but the owner necessarily didn't see, the benefit or they didn't wanna do that or didn't wanna pay for it.
PayamWhat are you doing as a result of you being the developer owner that you were not able to do as a architect?
Noam HazanGood question. I gotta think of some examples. I think one basic is really like sometimes you get clients who have a very kind of tunnel vision about what they want. we're dealing with a project right now, it's already-- we've already got permits for, but, the way that the project evolves and the design is not something that we love because the client was very, adamant on the way that he wanted the project to be. and I think, you have to go back and forth a little bit and be open. And I always find that when the clients are a little-- they come in a little bit more open and we can experiment, we always end up with a better product.
Noam HazanAnd I don't mean that in an arrogant way, but I think that from a s-- a, an objective view of what a floor plan looks like at the end of the day, or what the actual facade and curb appeal looks like at the end of the day, I always think when the client's a lot more open and doesn't come in and think they know-- you know, they wanna design the project, they know exactly what they want, they just want you to sign the drawings. But they're open to ideas, they're open to thinking about, how the space lays out and how we can create a functional, usable space, and a beautiful space. We always end up with a better product, a product at the end of the day.
PayamRight
Noam Hazanof a collaboration. Whether-- when it-- where-whereas it's when the client comes in and"This is a plan I saw you know, there's like new plans that just came out. just I have a whole thing about those plans, but we won't discuss that now. when they come in with these
PayamS- so you're seeking, flexibility to be able to improve the quality is basically what you- you're saying. And in this particular case is you have the ultimate flexibility
Noam HazanYeah, but I would also say it goes back the other way. I do think sometimes clients challenge us as well. you
Payamمhm
Noam Hazanfor example, make a bathroom a little bit smaller. Can we fit extra storage in this space? Like clients, especially developer clients, are always thinking about how to maximize and utilize every square foot. So this kind of collaboration, this conversation, we push them, they push us, and that's how I find we get the best product. When everyone's open to, to change and to considering other options then, we u- usually end up with something slightly better
PayamSure.
Noam Hazanfinal product.
PayamThe-- I guess that's a little bit of a back and forth that you might be missing at this point in time. But let me go back because it's interesting. I guess that has to do with your prior history that you seem very comfortable with what you're doing right now, and I was expecting for more of a challenge considering that you haven't been through this process. What was about the site or the type of project or the location or maybe your team that gave you the confidence that,"Yeah, you know what? let's do this. We're ready. We have it covered. We know what we're doing"?
Noam HazanI have a tendency to underestimate the challenge in front, the challenge in front of me. I always think it's no big deal, I'll get it done. And I, it's like that you shoot first and then you aim after kind of thing.
PayamRight
Noam Hazanthat's how I've run my life in a professional side for, my entire career. and it usually works out. it's like taking that first step, taking that risk. look, has it been draining and challenging? Yes. I have a great team that I know I can rely on in the office. there's been a little bit more of my time that I've needed to be on site than I'd hoped for, but I think, ultimately it's a learning experience. Now we're being more efficient for the next ver- next multiplex if we do it. There's things I know to plan ahead that will save time in the future. lining up trades in the right way and making sure that everyone is out of each other's way as well is helpful.
Noam Hazanagain, like I just, I have the vision, I just do it, and then I figure it out after. And I think that's what I've been doing
PayamYou're ju- you're taking-- You're good at, you're good at taking the leap of faith it sounds like. So let's talk about that decision to be the GC on the project. What prompted the decision and, how do you feel about it right now?
Noam Hazantwo reasons. One is obviously cost. I think if I'm it myself, there's... there's two-- there's actually two fa- factors to go with that. One is I really control the budget, and make sure that the trades, there's no inflation in any of the prices. I'm getting really the best, absolute best price. so that's number one. And number two is obviously there's a big fee you pay to a contractor. and I thought, I could-- I've done this before. I did it for my house. I can do it again. I'm gonna do it. And then so that's on the f- the financial side. then I saw this as an opportunity to get my hands dirty and really understand the ins and outs of building a multiplex from the ground up.
Noam HazanAnd there are things that I learned along the way that you don't really see when you're looking at your plans on a screen. Like there's little intricacies of the project. thank God all our projects work out. We have-- we work with good builders, but there are little things that I think that I've learnt that I can make builder's life a little bit easier. I'll give you an example.
Noam Hazanwhen you do-- when you have your fire separations between units, there's a bulkhead, you have to fire separate in the bulkhead or if you're, your lines through the joists, you have to fire separate that whole area. some of our clients who have hired homeowner, builders, those things get missed,
PayamYes
Noam HazanSo these are things that... and to be honest, like it wasn't even something I really considered, when we're doing our drawings. We obviously write the fire separations, but the intricacies of if you go into a bulkhead, you have to So all these things are things now that on our drawings, we can make a little bit easier for a builder that, let's say, has never done a multiplex before. Like little annotations, little things that we will add to our drawing just to, just to make the life of the client and the builder easier, so they have everything that they need from day one,
PayamSo you took a-- y-y-you're basically getting paid to learn is what you're doing as a GC. Is--
Noam Hazanmyself to learn. Yeah, basically. yeah
Payamin a way, and, is that a r-- is that an ongoing situation? Are you going to do it again? Just curious
Noam HazanI don't think I will GC again myself. I think I will manage a-- I might GC, but I'll definitely bring on a site super or I'll bring on a, a project manager. I might still manage the construction and the trades and that element of it, but I prefer to be in the office more and less on site if I can.
PayamFair enough. I can't blame you on that
Noam HazanYeah, no. So I think from that, I actually like going on site, go-- and this was quite strategic, so the, the property is like a five-minute drive from my house and a five-minute drive from my office, so everything's very close. So th- from that perspective, it worked out. and then also we're growing as an architecture firm, and I need to be here a bit more. So I think the next project, like I don't, I don't-- I do wanna continue to develop, but next project will have someone who will probably be a dedicated site super or part, will share the GC role, at
PayamGotcha. So I guess going back to, going back to your prior experience and also looking at the property, you just mentioned the property is very close to you. I'm gonna guess that you looked at multiple properties before you made an offer, and picked this one up. What was about this property or location or the demographic of the area that you said,"You know what? This is the one, and we're gonna g- say no to the others"?
Noam HazanSo good question. We-- all the properties I looked at were all within the vicinity of a 10-minute drive. So that was like number one criteria. I didn't wanna do a GC project which was like downtown or in Scarborough, wherever. Needed to be somewhere close. I knew that would be a challenge if I did. we looked at a few other properties. This one stuck out'cause it was actually-- there were actually two properties for sale at the same time next to each other. one was an existing triplex, and then this building next door, which was a, a single family, like one and a half story house, split.
Noam Hazanthey were both on for a really good price. So we were looking at both. we were trying to see if we could tie up both at the same time. in the end, we got it for a really good deal. that was really what it came down to. we got it for eight fifty in a really good,
Payamthat's a good deal
Noam Hazannorth of Eglinton, we-just west of Marley. Really good pocket. a lot of development going on in the Marley Corridor as well. We felt there was an opportunity there and we pounced on it. and that
PayamRight
Noam Hazanwe did look at a few, but all in, all within the same area. Some a little bit more expensive, some in that range, but it was the best deal we got for the size of the lot that we found.
PayamSo let me flip the question. knowing what you now know about the development, and obviously you knew a lot about the design of these buildings prior to this, what would you-- what would have made you walk away?
Noam Hazannot much. I, I-- we, we got very lucky. So on the one side we had this-- we had one neighbor that was very like, didn't really care, just very easygoing. The other side was a multiplex. He was-- He just-- The-- So the neighbor now is the guy who bought the building that was next door. Also very easy, so we've been able to utilize his site and everything. really the main things are, I guess any m-major trees, any big trees that could have impacted the development site. any other big right-of-ways or easements, those would've been something to flag that could've, made us walk away.
Noam Hazanand I guess tenants. There were no tenants in the building. We got it vacant. So all those three factors alone were enough for us, for me to be confident that we can basically have a carte blanche and do what we want, on the site or maximize the site as much as we can.
PayamGotcha. So you were less worried about the design aspect of it, just being second nature at this point, and more, mo- the, the factors you just mentioned are more on the development side of things. Interesting s-
Noam HazanSorry, Payam. The, the other thing I want to mention is when I look at sites,
Payamمهم
Noam Hazannarrow sites, twenty-five wide, thing that you always want to is how far the existing building is from the lot line.
PayamOkay
Noam Hazancity-- So if you want to utilize the side yard setback beyond the variant, like beyond your bylaw. So I think we had a zero point... It's either one point two or zero point nine meter setback, on that site. We ended up going for zero point three five meters.
Payamآ
Noam Hazanthe way we were able to achieve it was we utilized the existing building. We didn't do it as a reno, but we argue or I argued at committee that we're not decreasing the setback. And I find-- And we've done that on a lot of projects. So if we would have had a building with a one point two meter setback and we would have wanted to go in, I would have been a little bit hesitant
Payamهمم
Noam Hazanabout the site because the city are not always so open to reducing setbacks if there isn't an existing building with a reduced setback there already.
PayamRight. okay, so now let's get a little bit more hands-on about the process. I have a few guesses what the answer's gonna be, but I would like you to walk us through and say you've been through this project. What, what stage is your project at right now?
Noam HazanWe about four to six weeks away from completion.
Payamso you're pretty much there
Noam Hazantrim is mostly in. kitchens are coming next week for a couple of the
PayamPerfect.
Noam Hazangetting
PayamSo looking back, what were some of the biggest obstacles that maybe you underestimated?
Noam Hazanthe foundations, to be honest. we hired a, a trade which we shouldn't have hired. We-- They gave us a really attractive price. we-- I found them, they-- Maybe one rule is never use a ins- a company you find on Instagram. they had a really, flashy marketing, you know, campaign with, drone footage of their sites and t- and testimonials. one of the red flags was they didn't have any reviews on Google. I should've-- That should've clocked it. Anyway, we ended up getting a bit shafted with this one company that delayed the whole project. So right now we're four-- we're thirteen months in.
Noam HazanI was hoping to be done by a year. I was actually hoping to be done by ten months. I was trying to,
Payam13 months into construction is what you're saying?
Noam HazanInto construction, So still good. And w- w-- I think I budgeted, a performer fifteen months, but I was really hoping to be between ten and twelve months. Anyway, it is what it is. what happened was they-- we signed them, and they told us they were delayed by two weeks. Those two weeks turned into, a month. And then, and then as soon as they basically managed to pour the foundations, it com-- it snowed. We had to, like-- We just got stuck. And then we had two foot of ice in the basement that we had to melt before we could get the drains in and move forward, and we just got really stuck with it. And the winter was pretty bad last year.
Noam Hazanthat was my biggest regret. And I, I-- looking back, it was so stupid not to pay. It was a twenty grand difference, I think. And at the time, you think twenty grand is a lot of money. It goes, on th- on these projects that are very tight. but it came from a reputable company. It was one that my partner had worked with in the past. we took the risk, and it really bit us in the end. and that was, that was my-- I think my biggest learning point in this whole project is, obviously we're trying to get the cheapest prices wherever we can'cause the, the, the, the margins are tight. But something like foundation plumbing, which is, critical, like drainage is critical.
Noam HazanIt's a critical element. just spend a bit more money if you have a-- or make sure you get at least a couple of referrals. Make sure you're working with someone that you can trust and you know will do a good job. That, that's my biggest regret in this whole project, basically.
PayamThis was not what I had guessed you would say, but that's also a very valid, answer because unfortunately, it happens more than I would like to admit that when you go to un- untested, on, reviewed, trades and not-- there's nothing against them, but typically the reason they're the cheapest one because they're spreading themselves too thin and that the same reason that they are too low, they pick up a lot of more jobs and becomes challenging in terms of resources, coordination, mistakes happen. And yes, so h- I'm happy you said that sometimes that twenty thousand dollars ends up costing you two hundred thousand dollars if you get unlucky, right?
Noam HazanCorrect.
Payamthat's one of the lessons there. In terms of-- let's go back, let's go back a little bit. You had a previous, entrepreneurial e-experience that I know of. It might have been more. You had a company called North Space, if I'm not wrong, which was a co-working space, and you did that a while ago. You built it, you grew it, and you got out of it. And now you're almost through the same cycle with your development project. How do these two compare from a personal risk and also entrepreneur spirit?
Noam HazanYeah. So let's go back to, my appetite for risk and why I felt so comfortable, taking... I moved to Canada in 2014 with the mindset that I was leaving Canada by 2016, approximately. So I came to Canada with this idea that it would be a short-term, I, I-- So just to give you context, I married a Canadian. she studied law in London. She had to article here, and I figured, we'd come here for a year or two, and then we'd maybe go back to London or go somewhere else. I didn't come here with the mindset I'm gonna come here and settle down and establish a business.
Noam HazanSo took a little bit of risk in the beginning'cause I was like, if I could... she was working. We didn't have any kids at the time. I had the opportunity to take some risks. So I did this co-working space and, my idea was to go get in, get out, build this company. It was a high-risk business'cause it didn't really exist. WeWork weren't in Canada yet at that point. this was 2015. and the idea was like something new and something pioneering in that space. I like building things. I had another company which I don't necessarily wanna get into, but it was like a, a vending business for a couple of years where we did some experiential vending.
Noam HazanSo I like to... And the whole idea was just like have an entire store that's completely vending machines, no people. I like to kinda push boundaries, rethink how things are done. I think where this different-- this is, differentiates itself, the development side, is this is obviously a much more tangible, historical business that, has been going on for hundreds if not more, thousands of years, in the real estate development side. and it's something I've always been passionate and interested in. and I think there's a lot more of a connection to what I do with architecture, and development than there was necessarily for co-working or vending, to my core, background, which is architecture.
PayamYou're saying it was closer to home basically, so it was less of a departure from what you're working with, and that's generally speaking, that's typically a good thing. So let's go back right now and look at this bigger picture. Noam, before doing the picture, I would go to him, ask for a proposal to draw a multiplex for me. Noam, right now, I go to him after having done a development, I ask him to do a multiplex for me. What would you do differently?
Noam Hazanare you saying for myself?
PayamFor my client,
Noam Hazanfrom--
Payamas a client
Noam Hazanfor you as a client? I think one benefit is obviously that we have-- I have now that experience. So where it's not just the buildability of the building, but it's also value engineering. So we-- I, I, I don't get involved in the cost of things once we've submitted the drawings. We have an idea, of course, and we try to do things at a-- in a costy way. But the ability to the value engineer project now with the developer hat on is something that I've gained through this experience. like a few examples, one is like your wall assemblies. there's different wall assemblies. You don't have to necessarily use the OBC, prescriptive wall assemblies.
Noam Hazanthere are the staircases at the back of the building that, can be very costly. There's, there's design hacks or design-- There's ways to design, multiplexes that can avoid, the requirement of having a wheelchair-accessible elevator, which could cost you seventy thousand dollars. Those are, some of the things we already considered, but some of the things we, you know, as a developer, I'm like,"I don't wanna spend money there." I wanna save the cost. or on the flip side, where money is to spend is for example, in our project, and we haven't done this on other projects yet, but I will definitely recommend it to clients is, a concrete layer, like Gypcrete layer on our floors for extra sound protection, right?
Noam HazanLike sound is a big thing One of the things, we would now add for our clients, which actually costs a little bit more but I think adds a lot of value is, Gypcrete, for example. the ability to-- Like, one of the reasons tenants leave, or one of the main reasons tenant, tenants leave is because of sound. so a thin layer of Gypcrete on e- every floor, will give the ability to add that STC layer a little bit higher. You're still gonna do the, the batten, the, the safe and sound or whatever you need to do to get that fifty. This is an additional layer of Gypcrete. Actually, it's also better for fire protection.
Noam HazanIt has some fire protection qualities between the units. so the idea is to just, for our project, it cost us$8,000 to add that layer of Gypcrete. It's not a lot, and two months' rent, two and a half months' rent of no tenants there or having to change over, that, that's-- there's your investment right there anyway. So
Payamwith you more. and for our regular listeners, we've talked about this multiple times on the podcast, that if you go onto Tarion website, for those of you who are familiar with Tarion is the entity that looks after the purchaser's interest basically after they've purchased a condominium, which is a lit-little bit different from what we're talking about in terms of rentals. What the most common complaint from a, from building is acoustical com-complaint. And it's very real, it's very live, and I could not agree with you more that in any new project that we do, it's one of the biggest things that we say,"Guys, let's talk about acoustics first." And that quite frankly, Gypcrete is one of the measures.
PayamWe've tested multiple different assemblies, technologies. At what point... At, at, at one point when we were working on a Masterman project, we tested I think or eight different assemblies and, products from different manufacturers. And it's really har- it's not an easy thing to get it right the minute you step away from concrete, because concrete obviously is the best when it comes to STC, IIC, flanking, and everything else. But once you step away from that, it becomes a little bit more tricky. So I'm 100% with you, and I think, like you said, the, the getting it back or pay back, pay-paying yourself back for the additional cost through, less ros-loss revenue is probably a good way of looking at it because you get to keep your people, in place longer, or tenants.
Noam Hazan100%. and the other thing about the Gypcrete is one-- a sound engineer once told me,"Sound is like water. So if there's like cracks or slight openings, the water seeps through, the sound comes through." The beautiful thing about Gypcrete is it c- it really fills every nook and cranny on the floor. It's like a, it's like a, what are they called? Like a self-leveling concrete in a way. It's not exactly, but it literally fills up every little gap. So from that perspective, it's a very effective tool
Payamto that comment would that be, would be you need to get the right thickness for the type of structure you're using, because if you go too thin and your vibration is too high, you-- it will start cracking. So
Noam HazanYeah
Payamthat's that. But you're absolutely right. it's a good product. It's a good way of dealing with this. okay, so let's take a step back. We have a question on this podcast or a, a closing tradition on this podcast that, if we were to give you a magic wand and ask you to make a wish would make the life, in this particular case, make the life of a citizen developer, multiplex developer easier and put us in a position that we can have way more of these with better quality units, with better quality buildings, would that wish be?
Noam HazanIs this a question about like policy or just like general
PayamYou can take your pick
Noam HazanI think if I had a magic wand, I could do anything to encourage development, in the city and make it easier to get into that. the one thing I would tackle immediately is development charges. I think that the logic behind development charges doesn't make any sense. for example, we have a project right now where we have, two side-by-side, two side-by-side, triplexes, and the idea is that they're not equal-sized units-- equal-sized properties. So rather than just, getting rid of the, the-- like they're merged on title, but they're still two separate, properties.
Noam HazanRather than just building a nice, t- the, the client wants to build two sixplexes. Rather than building a twelveplex, we now have to re-sever, move the line just so we can get these two sixplexes in. We have to deal with the now setbacks between the units, all these things. it's a whole headache and hassle just to get your, the same kind of similar massing, maybe slightly less, optimal in these two lots than you would if it was just one lot. A-and the reason people sever the lots is because they want to avoid development charges. But it doesn't make any sense because you can get just as nice a building, maybe a little bit more density, maybe an extra unit or two by not severing, and now you have to go through the whole headache of severing, setbacks, all these things just to avoid development charges.
Noam HazanIt s- it sounds counterintuitive, basically. So that's the first thing I would do. the other thing I would do to make everyone's life easier, including mine, is, have a open-sourced, let's say, database, where anytime a permit, is granted with an alternative solution... So for your viewers, basically an alternative solution is basically something that would comply with the building code, but it's not necessarily sp-specifically mentioned in the building code. So you'd have to create a s- a solution and demonstrate why your solution complies basically with the building code.
Noam HazanNow, I know on our end, we've done alternative solutions for some clients. I know there's other colleagues of mine have done lots of alternative solutions, but we never see the other people's solutions that have been approved at the City of Toronto. So if there was a database that had all the approved alternative solutions, other clients, archit-- other architects can go there and say,"Okay, this is something that has been approved. This has been demonstrated that it works. Let's use it on our site. We can save some money. We can design it from the outset." All these things would make everyone's life so much easier
PayamPerfect. And I have to say, your second wish is a very popular one. I don't know if you know that, because there are multiple people have asked for that, and I have a feeling that there's something hap- is gonna come in the near future, hopefully soon, sooner than later. Because to your point, I'm actually involved in one project right now that we have an alternative solution, situation, call it, and there are other properties within ten feet of our property or 100 feet from our property who have gone through the exact same thing. They got it approved, and now we have to go through the same thing, but n- this time we have a n- different examiner, so the requirements are slightly different and which has caused three months of back and forth, which could have been avoided there was that standard central situation that everyone, here, this works 100 feet over there.
PayamWhy not over here? And I do agree with you. Thank you very much
Noam Hazantell you even like even more absurd-- Sorry, I'll tell you even more absurd about that whole, that point. We have one client, that client we have about seven projects or eight projects with, maybe nine now. of that client we have, four of his projects had a, had this different solution basically. Two of the projects no one asked for anything from the city. We just got it. We got it approved and the inspector didn't ask for it. One we submitted for a revision with this. so just to tell you what the solution was, we did, We had a lot of windows that needed to be fire rated.
Noam HazanInstead of putting a fire shutter, they found it to be more cost effective to actually sprinkler the, the windows themselves. Now we've got a fire engineer, we managed to get a solution for it. We ended up going to a code consultant for one of them. That is still underway right now. One we got the code consultant we-- Actually we didn't get the code consultant. We just got the fire engineer. We submitted for a revision and they granted it to us. One we had to get a code consultant for and then two of them they just gave it to us without any requirement. So yeah, and then the projects are all very similar. It's absurd that we have to go through these hoops and hurdles for the same project, the same type of project basically, even though they're different properties
PayamFantastic. Thank you for openly shar-sharing your experience, Noam. I appreciate that, and hopefully in the near future, we can have a round two of this conversation and see what you think after you have your tenants in, and hopefully you've stabilized and talk about future plans. This was awesome. Thank you for being here
Noam HazanSounds good. No worries. Thanks so much. Thanks for having me
Send us Fan Mail Where does the garbage truck go? On a tight Toronto mid-rise site, the answer can change the ground-floor layout and how many homes you can build. In episode 65 of Real Estate Development Insights, I...
Send us Fan Mail What should you investigate before turning a Toronto major-street property into a small mid-rise apartment project? Heather Dubbeldam and Derek McCallum of Dubbeldam Architecture + Design join Payam...
Send us Fan Mail What is changing inside Toronto’s housing approval system - and what will developers actually notice? Jag Sharma, Deputy City Manager for Development and Growth Services at the City of Toronto, joins...
Send us Fan Mail Should You Build a Toronto Multiplex? Five Questions to Answer First I run a construction company, so it may be against my own interest to say this: not every multiplex project should be built....
Send us Fan Mail Toronto has announced residential development-charge reductions of 40% to 60%, backed by $1.5 billion in funding. But the commercial question is not simply how large the headline discount is - it is...