Send us Fan Mail In this episode of the Real Estate Development Insights podcast, Edward Skira and Ash Navabi from Urban Toronto discuss the comprehensive data and trends in the Greater Toronto Area (GTA) real estate market. The episode delves into the founding of Urban Toronto, the types of data they track, and the significant impact of policies on development. The conversation highlights current market trends, approval processes, the shift from condo to rental developments, and the surprising complexities of urban planning and policy implementation. Listeners are also guided on effectively using the Urban Toronto platform for real estate investment decisions. The Origins of Urban Toronto Urban Toronto's Data and Insights Clientele and Usage of UT Pro Impact of Policy on Development Parking Policy Changes and Effects Provincial Policies and Their Outcomes Multiplexes and Minor Variances Understanding the Complexity of the Housing Crisis Biggest Challenges in the Housing Market Economic Factors Affecting Housing Toronto's Housing Market vs. Other Cities Navigating the Development Process Using Urban Toronto's Platform for Development Trends in Rental vs. Condo Projects The Role of Developers and Public Perception The Growth of Toronto's Skyline For more information, please refer to RealEstateDevelopmentInsights.com Join Our Workshop: MultiplexWorkshop.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
PayamHello everyone, and welcome to another episode of the Real Estate Development Insights podcast, where reviewing the ideas, experiences, best practices from the real estate development industry. My name is Payam Nhi, and I'm your host here. This episode, I have two guests. This episode, we are gonna have a conversation with Edwarda and Ash Nabi. They're both from Urban Toronto, and if you have been listening to our podcast, many of our guests throughout different episodes have referred to Urban Toronto, the website platform, and their information products as their go-to resource.
PayamTo keep themselves up to date with the industry trends, learn more about projects, data access databases, and comments. And in this episode, I figured why not? Let's go to the source itself and talk to people who are doing this great work for our city in Toronto and the region. Greater Toronto region and they are creating this valuable resource. We talk about Edward's background, he's the founder and how he came about starting this almost 20 years ago. Also, Ash, who's the economist, who is responsible for analyzing and putting together all the data.
PayamReports and that information products that are offered through the platform. We talk about some of the trends that they're seeing in the market based on the data they have at their fingertips. We talk about the role of a policy. We dive into a very interesting conversation about how. Policy matters and how you can actually track the effect of the recent policy changes in market trends and the development applications that have been happening. We also talk about what's happening as of right now in market, like some of the data that has to do with the construction and new development projects.
PayamI hope you find this episode. Useful. They do also provide a little bit of insight on how to best use their platform to be able to gain the most out of the, all the information that's on the platform. Frankly, there's ton of it, and if you don't know what you're looking for, you could be lost there. So it's helpful to have a little bit of a guidance. And as always, you can find all the relevant information on our website, realestate development insights.com. Realestate development insights.com. That's all one phrase. And. Please subscribe to the show. If you're really enjoying it.
PayamPlease let others know and help us grow the show. Thank you as always, we appreciate your support. Hey guys, welcome to the show, Ash and Edward with us today from Urban Toronto Edward, I'm gonna start with you. I'm gonna ask. You to give us, give our audience a little bit background about yourself, what you've been up to and then we go to Ash.
EdwardAlright. I'm Edward Kira. I'm the co-founder and co-publisher of Urban Toronto. We track real estate development across the greater Toronto, Hamilton area, the greater Golden Horseshoe. My background is in magazine and web publishing in the music industry, and I did that for about 20, 15, 20 years and transitioned over to. The real estate space around 2002 and my, my history is, again, publishing and, uh, content creation and stuff like that.
EdwardThat's what we've been doing since the beginning. Thank you, Ash. How are you doing?
AshMy name is Ash Nabi. I'm an economist here at Urban Toronto. I've also been deeply involved in building our data products, and I'm hoping to use some of the insights we've generated there to help inform this discussion.
PayamPerfect. Thank you. Both for being here, for audience that are listening to this episode, and maybe this is the only episode they're listening to so far. The reason we have these great, gentle with us today in this episode is that pretty much all of our previous guests on the podcast have mentioned their website as their go-to resource for getting up to date and getting information about what's happening in the industry with development and also particular, in particular in GT's, greater Toronto area. With that being said, I want to start digging into it. Maybe for those of our audience who are not familiar, what you do, maybe dig us, take us through Urban Toronto.
PayamWhat does it do in like in detail? What benefits does it provide
Edwardand how do you get all the info you have? Okay. We began in 2002 and we began as a discussion forum, and I've always. Been a big fan of development and architecture. When I was a kid, my dad took me down to City Hall because he had a parking ticket or something, and I remember seeing this big wall of wood ab hoarding on the south side of Queen Street, and I was intrigued. And we went over there and my dad lifted me up and it was the pit for the Sheridan Center being under, uh, being constructed. And it just blew me away. And over the years, I've spent countless hours sitting in front of construction site watching them build it.
EdwardPour concrete and so forth. I was living downtown and one king was starting construction and I was intrigued. So Urban Toronto grew out of that and, and initially it was just a, a small little discussion forum. People were just like me talking about what projects were coming and stuff like that. For a few years, it ran like that. We slowly started to grow. As I mentioned at the beginning, I was in the music business and those were really good times in the early two thousands in the music business.
EdwardAnd then when Napster came around 2006, it started disrupting everything. We were doing web stuff and we were still doing print, but print got hit hard and you've seen it ever since. Print is, is has in a lot of ways disappeared or is declining rapidly. Uh, and we have this discussion form and the traffic was going through the roof, and so we decided to see how we could turn it into a business. And the first, when that idea popped up, we, I sent a, a message to all the four members. Saying that we were gonna start running banner ads and within an hour I had Monarch, Tridel and Citizen as customers.
EdwardAnd we thought, okay, music industry's gonna be tough for a long time, and it's only gotten better recently. But we transitioned into that. We added a database so we could track all the projects that we were talking about in the form. We added a news page so we could talk about it and let people know about that. And that was 2006, 2007. I don't remember the exact dates. And that was the beginning of what today we just celebrated 25, 20 years, a couple of years ago, and we're approaching 25 years. So that's the general background.
PayamOkay. Thank you for sharing that with us. And I guess I want to turn to you Ash and. Give us some high level trends and data in insights from the data that you have. Obviously, like we were talking offline, that you guys are sitting on a gold mine when it comes to having data. You have almost too much data in some cases, and yeah, talk to us about that. Like how should one go about. Using the website, what should, what questions should we be asking? How, what is the best way of using it?
AshSo I'll just give a, give you an overview about the, the data that Urban Toronto collects and tracks and reports on. There are a lot of businesses and services available to your customers and others who track land sales and everything earlier than that sometimes. And there are even more services that track condo sales and pre-sales and stuff like that. But there's not so much a lot of information and data and service built around. What we call the missing middle of the development pipeline process, which is everything after somebody purchase, purchases the land, and then has to go through the planning and the construction and then the completion process in order to actually build and bring online some of these mega projects.
AshSo that's where we come in and we track everything that requires a development application or a site plan approval, rezoning, official plan, amendment, official plan amendments. Things like that through the application process. So when the application comes in, any updates made to that application, how it gets handled at city council, is it approved or is it refused? Whether there were any appeals to the Ontario Land Tribunal OLT and what the final decision was. And then once those decisions are made, we then switch to construction. When does construction start through the building permits?
AshWhen was shoring applied for? When was it issued? And then when the new building permit was applied for, when was it issued? And then when do these permits close? And then when do people start moving in? Then when is cladding finished on the outside and when is the whole project complete as a whole? And we track this through various ways. Initially, how the website started was, as Ed was saying, it was a forum, so people were just enthusiasts that they would just go up to as, as ed as a child would say that he was just wowed by that hole in the ground. People are wowed by the renderings, the holes in the ground, the, the process of it going up.
AshAnd then they not just talked about the planning about this stuff. But they also go out of their way to take pictures of these sites as well. They go online and find the documentation and post screenshots from these documents, and they post'em to our forum. And if your audience is old enough to remember using forums in the nineties and two thousands, they're not great ways of keeping data, right? So we had forums, we have threads on our forum that were very busy. The busiest thread we have right now is for the one. Initially by Ms. Rahi. Now it's taken over by Tridel and that has hundreds and hundreds of pages of discussion, of photo updates of the news.
AshWhat's happening on that site and what Urban Toronto did initially was we started reporting on these, on these projects like journalism, and we would use some of the discussion and the, the documentation brought up in the discussion threads as some of the primary source documents to, to basar. Journalism with, but over time, as the threads got bigger and bigger, it became harder and harder to keep track of. What page was the renderings on? What page was the first picture of? Of excavation or the shoring rigs going up?
AshSo we built the database on our end initially just to keep track of things for our journalists. After several years, we figured out that our database as a service was extremely valuable. Mm-hmm. And we started building out the database more professionally. More rigorously with the intent of having pros proper data, not just for journalism, but for proper data analysis. And I'll be talk talking to you later, I'm sure about exactly how we come across the data. But we track applications as they come into the city, not just for the city of Toronto, but for virtually all the municipalities across the GTHA and a little bit beyond, including Wealth Kitchen Waterloo.
AshSome other, uh, municipalities in the Southern, Southern Ontario, and we are trying to grow every day and we keep track of not just when the application comes in, but any changes made to it, and not just, here's just the application, here's the link to it. Good luck. We actually go through the trouble of quantifying that those applications actually typing in the numbers, how many units there are, how many square meters in the project. How tall is the building? And sometimes rectifying errors in those documents because sometimes there's human error, right?
AshWhen you're looking at a blueprints or whatever. So we gotta rectify those documents and we standardize this information across all our municipalities. So when somebody's going into our database and they wanna figure out what are all the. 10 story and above offices that are currently under construction, they can do that knowing that we measure 10 stories the same way in Toronto as we do in Miss Saga and Oakville and Hamilton and beyond. And then we go beyond there to the building permits, tracking those as well. And we we're constantly staying up to date on these applications.
PayamSo that's pretty good. I guess on a granular level, you go as deep into an application or a building or potential project per se. As the designers and the people on the team would the ins and outs. And I guess from our audience's perspective, I'm gonna assume that many of our audience, or many people, or many users, and maybe you have information in the background on how people are using this data and how people are using your database for it. And what they're using it for, but my assumption is they will be using it for comparables, for trends, for overall market movements.
PayamIs that a fair assumption?
EdwardSo we actually have three, three client bases or three types of clients and the product we're talking about, which is part of urban Toronto's called UT Pro and so forth. Certainly that is one of our big. Client bases. Number two is suppliers. They're looking for leads. They wanna know what projects are coming so that they can bid on them. And we are tracking everything from the moment of initial application. So if you are a supplier and you're using our service, you're gonna know about everything at the very beginning, and that gives you plenty of time to get in front of the potential clients for themselves and make a bit.
EdwardThe third one is we have a map with the service that allows you to actually see where the growth is happening. And you can easily customize reports that will tell you that this intersection, one kilometer radius has, let's say 10,000 units proposed, and that's potentially maybe 15,000 people when it's all built out. So visualizing where the P population is gonna grow is a big part of what we do too. So we have. Retailers who have signed up for it. We have some government entities that have signed up for it, and they're using it in that way to be able to plot where everything is happening, which areas are hot, which areas not as much, where they need to be.
EdwardSo those are the three main clientele.
PayamThat's, that's, that's pretty good insight. So I guess I'm all start with the last one. If you were to talk about what's happening on the heath map of Toronto and GTA in partic particular, I don't know if, can you share with us what are some of the major hot areas that are having, are experiencing that growth more so than the others?
AshI guess I'll take that. So the number one place is, I guess the, the easiest way to answer that question. The hottest places are the places where growth is being allowed. And in the city of Toronto, it's the mixed use areas that's downtown core, that's along the Queens way, and other specific pockets in the city that are subject to these secondary plans that that allow for more mixed use. That's actually one of the major themes we've been, we've been touching over the years as we do the analysis, is that policy really matters when it comes to growth.
AshAnd a lot of times developers don't really appreciate how sensitive development is to policy itself. But, but it's very striking when you look at where, where the activities happening. It lines up almost perfectly with where the activity is allowed to happen. And that's just because of, you know, I'm an economist, so I'm always thinking about how decisions are made. We say on the margin jargon for basically where is it just enough to pencil just enough to be profitable to, to make that call or not.
AshSo these policy decisions, sometimes they seem minor. They can be enough for some smaller players to come in and then they can start building a reputation and a portfolio and a profit base in those areas. And that it's not just for one small player. There are many small players. They come in and that's enough to affect the markets. So that's the bottom line that like growth happens where it's allowed to happen. Just broadly geographically, that's the downtown core, that's parts of the, along the Queens way. North York, and I'm
Payamactually very happy with your answer there, and I'm excited, I should say, because that lines up perfectly with what we're trying to promote and what we're trying to do through the website and through the podcast, that we need a lot more smaller developers or new developers or entrepreneurs to come into the market and do what you can pretty much take your piece, whatever you wanna do, treat it as a buffet. So to go into what you just said, I will in interpret that as a. PO stickiness of a policy. If, if you,'cause that's one of the things I wanna talk about, and maybe you have a particular policy in mind or not, I don't know.
PayamBut hypothetically, were, have you seen any of the policies more sticky than the other ones have? Are there ones that you saw what this happened and next month or next three months after that we saw reason like going up the number of applications in that area go up, or some of them maybe nothing happened. Does that, so that's one question. Does anything come to mind? I. And I guess the other side of that is, or a continuation of the same question, is that if you were to push, I guess is the better word, if you were to encourage.
PayamPolicy makers to say, you know what, you did this area. Okay, here is, here's what we saw the best movement after such and such happened. Is there any suggestion, are there any suggestions that you might be wanna be sharing with the policy
Ashmakers? I'm not gonna be advocating for any specific policy here, but we published the paper last year, I guess it was January of 2024. It was called Policy Matters, like you searched that up on Urban toronto.ca. Where I did look at some local, provincial and federal policies and the effects they've had on development in, in the Toronto area. And one thing that was, I guess I'll touch on one aspect from, from each level here. So at the municipal level, if you remember, I. A couple years ago, they, they removed, at the city of Toronto, they removed the minimum parking requirements for, for developments downtown.
AshAnd a lot of people assume that by getting rid of the parking requirements, that's going to basically cause nobody to propose any parking whatsoever. And I don't think, I didn't think that was gonna be true, but. We have the data to bear it out. And what looked, what, if you could, if I can describe the graph for you, the number of parking spots per dwelling were declining before they got rid of the, the parking spots or the parking requirements, the minimum parking requirements.
AshAnd not just were they declining, but the number being proposed per project was very tightly around the same number, just under one to 0.5 spots per dwelling unit. But after. If they got rid of the parking, the minimum parking requirements, while there were a lot more projects that had zero or close to zero parking, there were also a lot more variable. There was a lot more vari variability in terms of parking spots being proposed. So actually the parking, the total number of parking per unit actually increased somewhat after they got rid of the minimum parking requirements.
AshThis is an unintended consequence. Of changing a policy, which you see all the time because policy is very complicated. But by getting rid of the floor on, or sorry, I should say the ceiling on the on parking requirements, it actually freed up and allowed more experimentation and more freedom to, to test and to, to propose different parking mixes for different developments.
PayamSo let me recap just to make sure I get it right. I got it right. So you're saying once they on average. The parking was going down, like you were gonna get less parking per unit before the, the regulation happened, but as a result of the regulation, not now, people actually have the option of either have no parking or have as many as you want to fit your needs for the project. And basically what you're saying is that it's balancing, its other out in such way that the end result is actually better in terms of parking availability when compared to what it used to be, or it would've been prior
Ashto
Payamthat. Yeah. Did
AshI get it right? That's exactly right. By getting rid of the parking minimums you that gave you just, that gave developers just a number to aim for. And sometimes that number was good, sometimes it wasn't. But now when you don't have a specific number to aim for you, you're free to experiment. You can actually make decisions based on what you think the project needs as opposed to what the city needs. Interesting. So that gives you a lot more variability based on the specifics of the project. We get, we actually ended up with more parking being proposed per units.
PayamThat's a very interesting observation. 'cause I can tell you on the background on the projects that I've been involved in or I've been involved in right now, you definitely see a big, very big difference. There are certain size lots in Sierra, Toronto and GTA that is near impossible. It would've been near impossible to make a project work if you were to keep the old ratios or parking spots. It was, we've used stackers, parking stackers, and elevators and everything else, which just comes with it. Great cost to the project and very complicated systems for operation of the future building.
PayamBut now to your point, we have projects that are maybe have six surface spots for 50 units, and then there are other projects where they can do more and they're doing more and they get, they're hoping to get premium. So now that you mention it makes perfect sense to me. Do you have any other policy examples that you wanna
Ashshare with the audience? Sure. Again, this is from, this is Data from 2023 that we published in 2024. The name of the article is Policy Matters, published on Urban toronto.ca. There was a bill pass at the provincial level called Bill 1 0 8, the More Homes More Choice Act, and part of that bill was a policy around TSAs Metro Transit Station areas. Where the idea was to allow for more density around these transit station areas. And again, they had this policy with the intention of getting more proposals there.
AshBut when we looked at our data after they proposed, after they passed Bill 1 0 8, to have this requirement for developments around m TSAs. We actually saw fewer units being proposed around TSAs in the city of Toronto. And the reason for that, I believe, is because the language around that bill was ambiguous. And the proof for this is a year later when they passed the, what was called Bill 25, the more homes I. Built faster acts. They cleaned up the language around MCSAs, and after that we saw a sharp increase around mm-hmm.
AshProposals around m MCSAs and the city of Toronto. So again, so policy matters.
PayamYour, your intention policy does matter.
AshPolicy definitely matters, but it's more than just your intention with the policy. The specifics matter too. So they intended to have more, more proposals around transit areas with deal 1 0 8. It actually backfired. They had fewer, and then they fixed their mistake. With Bill 23 and then we saw more proposals.
PayamIt's interesting point you're bringing up because one of our previous guests on the podcast mentioned, and he would, he put it differently, but his point was that we are some small, incremental changes might actually hurt the cause then rather than big, slow changes. If you don't do something, to your point, if you do something but you don't do it right, you think people think you've done something but you actually didn't achieve anything. Versus maybe wait under six months, but do something that makes a huge difference. So with that question, I want to go to one of the most recent changes that I'm excited about, but I'm still waiting to see if there's any real pickup on the market.
PayamAnd that's, that's the multiplexes. We've had episodes here. We've talked about multiplexes and major streets. It seems to me and some of our previous guests here that still in your words, needs to clean up. It seems like it's, it's good intentions and it has potential benefit to it, but I don't know where do we stand on that? Do you guys have any insight to, have you tracked it? Have you looked at that before?
AshSo just a couple quick points for me is that first of all, the data that we track at Urban Toronto is, again, just to re reiterate, is for bigger projects that require an official plan, amendments or rezoning. A lot of the multiplexes that are being proposed are through the minor variances. We don't track minor variance projects so much. There are a few that we track there. There are also a few multiplexes that we're tracking, but, but as a proportion of our database there are small. And that's fair
Payambecause at least for now, I would say that at least that's fair. At least for now, because I, like I said, we keep hearing that there might be more of them coming, but to your point, maybe it's just, so far, it's a blip in the on the radar. Right. And who knows, maybe it might change in the future. Okay. That, but, but again, just
Ashagain, just for the policy on the policy angle for multiplexes, as soon as the city of Toronto passed their, their bylaw for allowing six plexes, it was immediately challenged by residents who took it to the OLT. And that's part of the policy making process here in. In Toronto or in Ontario I should say, that so much of local decisions have to end up going through the OLT for approval or refusal, et cetera, so that you have to look at OLT decisions as well.
AshAnd we do track OLT decisions through our, through a data service, but it's complicated.
PayamIt's complicated. It's complicated. The whole matter is complicated and like it or not, this complication and complexity is what's causing us, at least in part, to be behind on the curve on the supply. And that's, with that, I'll go into the next question. You, we talked about the mi macro level and we talked about the, the overall trends and policy. What are some of the biggest challenges that you see out there? And I asked that with a question with the background that we see a lot of. Points being discussed on social media, on, on, other than social media and all types of media about the housing crisis, affordability crisis, supply chain issues, but again, you guys have the data at your fingertips.
PayamWhat do you think are some of the biggest challenges we face today? Edward, do you want to go for that or,
Edwardthere there's, there's a number of factors. Economics is certainly an issue. We've seen the investor market disappear and with the higher interest rates and the decline currently, that's a big factor in why we're not seeing applications coming like we were a few years ago. Construction starts are definitely down. We track cranes, construction cranes in our database, and the number is starting to come down as projects are completed. And newer projects are not being started, so that, that's definitely an issue.
EdwardWe certainly have labor issues as well, not enough workers and de certainly a lot of the trades people were, are getting older and as they retire off, younger generation isn't following up. There certainly needs to be a look at. The building efficiency itself, if you're doing everything by hand, and I know it's improving, but I'm sure there, there needs to be ways of looking at automating stuff a little more and, and trying to increase the efficiency of the building process. So those are a couple of issues that are certainly looking at us right now.
AshI'll just add onto that. So two weeks ago, excuse me, we published the reports. The headline is that the UT Pro report shows Toronto Construction still lags behind new population growth. This report was a response to a report by the Center for Urban Research and Land Development at at Toronto Metropolitan University, where they reported. Huge population growth, not just for the city of Toronto, but the GTHA and compared it to other municipalities. And even though we had this big growth in population, housing starts, were down as, as Ed mentioned.
AshAnd there are certainly some macroeconomic factors, but one thing I pointed out to in, in this article is that. These macroeconomic factors like interest rates and inflation, they affect the whole country. But housing starts in Montreal and Vancouver were actually up year over year in 2024 compared to 2023, whereas they were down in Toronto. So any problem that Toronto is having with respect to housing policy, with respect to housing construction, I think points to the problem is not macroeconomic.
AshBut microeconomic in terms of the local conditions in the city as opposed to things affecting the country as a whole. And again, I point to the fact that Montreal and Vancouver had had more construction over the last year than like an increase in construction compared so the year before. Whereas Toronto had a decrease.
PayamI guess one thing that I would be interested in knowing, and I don't think you guys track that, is the length of application processes in these cities is an application process to, does the application process take as long in Vancouver as it does in Toronto? I actually don't know the answer to question.
AshSo we don't track anything outside of the Southern Ontario region, so I can't speak to what's happening in Vancouver and Montreal authoritatively like that. Within the GTA, every municipality is different and even within the same municipality. But like Toronto, it greatly depends on a lot of factors for how long it takes something to be built. And there was actually a major policy change over the last year to push for faster decisions from the municipal level. And you see now in the city of Toronto, way more refusals at city Council.
AshFor project proposals, which then are forced onto the OLT to make a decision, and that's just a response to provincial policy to force faster decisions. So instead of the old game being negotiating for months or years, they just outright refusing add counsel and then there's a settlement agreement often, or a little bit more unfrequently. The OLT makes a hard decision
Payamand I think, you know what? Now that we're talking, I would say, I want to segue into, I'm a potential developer. I'm an investor. I wanna start the project. I want to go buy a piece of land. What's the best way for me to use the platform? What is the best options for me to start? Or the questions that I should be thinking of getting answers from your platform. And one of the first things that comes to my mind is that, okay, I want to go pick up two lots on Gerard Street or Royal York Road in Atoka, or somewhere in I in Toronto.
PayamAnd I wanna put together a performer. That has obviously a period of assumed period for the approval processes. Is there any option or is that, walk me through that process. I don't know if you have anything that you can share in terms of steps, but it would be great to see, okay. Like these are the things you can get from the platform to help the decision making process for putting together a performa,
AshI guess I could talk to that as a developer. You could use our, our map. To check out the site. So you go to Urban Toronto ca, you click on the map and then you would drag the map along to see what's actually happening in that specific area. And you can see not just what the proposed units are, what's under construction, what's complete. A lot of the complete projects we have in our database going back five or six years. And that gives you a general idea. But as I mentioned, we have multiple data products.
AshYou could do that for free on Urban Toronto. Do ca right now. But the amount of data you get is very limited. You're not gonna get the number of units, for example, that are being proposed to get the number of units, you're gonna have to look at our, our pro subscription. And that's gonna give you not just the number of units, but the gross floor area and, and a lot more. I. Information there as well. So, okay.
PayamSo I can go there and see what, what else is happening in the area that I'm looking at. Buying a personal line. Yeah, exactly. So that's one of the, one of the benefits is there, is there anything else I can get to help that decision making process?
AshSo the other thing you can do, actually, ed mentioned leads. So we track every company that's mentioned on an application submission as well as a lot of the companies that show up during the construction process. Our focus isn't so much on the trades, but the. On the development team, the engineering companies, and the planners and developers and architects. But if you are a developer and you want you like a specific building, you can use our platform to see who the, who did the architecture, who did the planning, who did the engineering, the site plan, all that stuff is, is on our platform as well.
AshYou can use our website basically as a way of looking at the portfolios of the other. Not just developers, your competitors, but the,
Payamit gives you a feel, it gives you a heat map, I guess, uh, one, one thing I would be curious, going back to the approval process, that that would be good to, if I could figure out, okay. How long does a typical application take or an average takes in, let's say in the topic for a building to get approved versus let's say downtown core?
AshI don't know. Can I pull that up? So we track application submission dates, and then council decision dates as well as the OLT decision dates. And then the status as well. The status with the council is, it's under review, is it's council refused, council approved, OLT, approved settlements, et cetera. So you can get a sense of
Payamthat. Okay. You can definitely
Ashtrack all that information. It is, again, in my sense, it's very idiosyncratic. It's highly specific to that project, but, but you could. Go into it yourself and see if you can find a pattern that I couldn't.
PayamYeah. Okay. That's pretty good. Is there anything that have been surprising to you? We talked about policy side effects that. You were, we were not expecting, or the policy makers were not expecting. Are you seeing any surprising trends or events in the background that maybe it's not necessarily visible to
Ashthe public? Ed mentioned the cranes, so a lot of people just look at the cranes and see, oh, there's a lot of cranes. But we're, we track the cranes quarterly we act. We actually have our next step crane report coming out next week and. The trend generally has been downward for cranes and for the reasons Ed mentioned earlier. Lot of projects finishing, not a lot of new stuff coming online. The other thing I've mentioned is that Toronto is shrinking, whereas other cities across the country are growing. So I. Can't blame macroeconomics for that.
AshAnd
Payamwhat about for sale products versus rental products? 'cause what I'm seeing on this side of the table, talking to developers, many people are just switching their projects. Projects from a condo to a rental. Do you see the same on your side?
AshThat's, so that's a very interesting point. So last year, both the federal and the provincial governments announced cuts to sales taxes for, for purpose-built rental. And a lot of people assume that this is going to build. More rental projects. And in a sense it did. It did cause more rental purpose-built rental projects to come online or be proposed, but it was at the expense of condo projects. It was a trade-off, so a project that was already penciling. To be built as a condo is now slightly more profitable to be, to be repurposed as a purpose-built rental.
PayamThat was something which is not necessarily a bad thing. It is. We've had a void in the industry for decades in terms of purpose-built rental, so it might give, uh, a little bit breathing room for that sector to catch up. While other macro factors in your words might be able to
Ashadjust themselves
Payamin the next few years.
AshSo it's not a bad thing, but it's not what it was intended intention was. We get more housing being approved. Uh, but it, I see it's basically the same number. It's just the type has changed.
PayamYou're saying it doesn't necessarily help the overall supply numbers, it just shifts from one, one bucket to the other. Exactly. Okay. But I guess the idea behind that is that if you're doing a rental, you could potentially have options of making it more affordable, and that might eventually help the affordability side of it, versus if you're paying 7% on a mortgage, on a condo as a, as an investor. You probably don't want to rent it out very cheaply versus if you're getting financing from CMAC to do a rental project is you're probably, you probably have more breathing room to do that.
PayamIs that a fair assessment?
AshI don't think that was the intention behind it. I can also talk to the fact that a purpose-built rental tends to be a bit more. Expensive than condo rental for the same, true, very true, uh, price, even though we don't track this, part of the reason is purpose-built rental tends to be premium rental, and there are reasons for that, but it's a bit out of the wheelhouse that we track here at Urban Toronto. But it's, when it comes to affordability, what ultimately depends what ultimately affordability depends on is the quantity of housing available and shifting it from condo that a retail investor has put up for rent versus a.
AshPurpose-built rental managed by a corporation that got CMHC funding. To offset some of their costs. I don't think that's going to make a, a noticeable difference. Interesting.
PayamInteresting.
AshBecause again, the quantity of housing is the same, whereas the population is, I,
PayamI guess it goes back to the whole supply demand.
AshSupply and demand, everything that's
Payameverything goes back to being supply and demand. Okay. Going back to Edward, I wanna talk to you about the form. Because, and I'm hoping you can help with this and on a bigger scale of things, big bad developer, big bad developer. That has been the perception that has been very popular in many parts of the world, I would say, and especially here and the whole nimbyism that is very popular jargon these days or have been, and it's also a scapegoat for many other things. And where do you stand on that?
PayamHow do we help that? And I come from the perspective of a developer, which is someone who's putting, and I'm not necessarily talking about very established, highly funded and institutional developers. I'm talking about an entrepreneurial group that are putting together a project and they, it's really hard to make numbers work for them. Risk takers, how they, how can they do better? Where do, how do we help that process?
EdwardFirst off, big bad developer. Urban Toronto is very much pro development and that's what we were founded for. We were not, NIMBYs don't do very well in the urban Toronto forum. We are, we can be very critical about design, we can be very critical about a lot of things, but for the most part, our four members are very interested. They want to see more of it. Uh, and we are very much, uh, backing. People who are building the buildings and and doing that.
EdwardSo we support all developers for the most part. So the Forum is a, a place to really just talk about what's coming and what's being promoted, what's coming. And again, we can be critical of what we consider poor design. There are certainly developers that, that don't put a lot of effort on that side of it. They're in a rush to, to build and move on. We're called Urban Toronto, so we're not, we're interested in the built form, how it fits, how it integrates into neighborhoods and all that kind of, I. Our mandate is certainly a lot broader than NIMBYs.
EdwardPeople do come on the form, and they don't generally last very long because most of the 98% of our members are very much interested. They just want it to be good. We want it to be built well and want it to add to the city and not just throw something up to make a quick buck and move on, because it's gonna sit there for a long time and we're gonna have to look at it. I think I had a conversation with one of the presidents of one of the big companies years ago now. And he told me we used to hate going in the forum because it was just criticism of a project and we decided to up our game and they did.
EdwardAnd their projects are now being widely applauded or certainly they put the effort in to improve what they were putting out. And so I think we made a little bit of a difference with that, probably more than a little bit. That's,
Payambut that's good to know. That's good to know because like Ash was just mentioning a lot of these projects, if not all of them do, end up going through the appeal process and the committee committees and ties probably more than what we need them to be. Like the numbers. And you can feel like most of them should be able to just go through and Yeah, it's, it's good to know. I, obviously, I cannot claim that I'm an active member of your forum, but I've definitely gone through your pages and I've seen comments and I would agree with what you're saying that a lot of people. It seems like they, they have inherited the spirit of journalism and they want to just be reporting the facts as much as possible and, but with opinions, which frankly, I personally go on your website, and sometimes I'm just like, how is that other project doing in such and such location?
PayamJust go there, just. To see if someone has uploaded a new picture of the progress, Is there anything I didn't ask you guys that we should be talking about?
Ashas I tried to emphasize, in fact, I don't think there is anybody who does what we do in terms of tracking the application process on the, the rigorousness that we track it with. The scale that we track it with and the intent to standardize it with the same, the same intention we have. We have a data team. Now, it's not a lot of people think that we're just pulling information just from the forums. We are not, we are, we are getting information a lot of times, very early, but it is public documentation. Everything we're going off of is public documentation. But as I said, public documentation is inaccessible, even though it's public.
AshIt's difficult to to parse. It's difficult to read, it's difficult to find. Sometimes we go through all that trouble of finding it, parsing it. Inputting it into something that you can easily search for, easily build a reports based out of, and then easily I. More easily and more confidently make your decisions with.
PayamOkay, perfect. Thank you very much. And you did mention something about the information products, I think is the data products. What did you refer to?
EdwardYeah, so we, again, we have two, two sort of sides to the company. One side's the marketing side, and one side is the data side. And last year about over 50. Just around 50% of our revenue was coming from data products, and UT Pro is the big product that people should be reaching out to us about if they want to know more. There's 5,700 projects. We're currently tracking 5,000 companies. Each project we're tracking 104 to 44 specific data points, so there's a lot of information there. And it's a one-stop shop.
EdwardPeople can get everything they need without, so it's a big time saving for anybody that's trying to do any work with this. That's pretty good. That's true. I do have a, I do have another tangent now I'm thinking. So I don't think most people realize really how big this industry is and how big Toronto has grown since we even started and even before that. So I remember the 1980s when there was a lot of development in Toronto. I remember the nineties when there was. Very little. And when we began in 2002, if there was a proposal for a 20 story building, people in the forum would go crazy'cause there wasn't much happening.
EdwardAnd today, if it's not 80 stories, they're like, whatever. It's just another building. And in 2002 there were seven buildings in the, in Toronto and area that were over 500 feet. And there were no super talls. There was. Seven buildings in our database. Currently, I believe between under construction completed and proposed 400 that are over 500 feet and there are currently two super talls under construction in Toronto.
EdwardThat's over a thousand feet. So under construction, nearing topping off, the one will be the first super tall in Canada and one pinnacle down by Lakeshore and Young will be the tallest building in Canada soon after. And there's maybe two or three others that are in proposal about to start construction phase. The scale of it, I talked to people that I know in other places and a, we have more cranes than anywhere else in North America and certainly in the world. We're, we're up. There. You go to Chicago and it's big downtown, but you go a few blocks out of downtown and it's low-rise.
EdwardIt's very little. We have, I don't know, 5, 6, 7 downtowns in this area, the big one. But then you got North York, you got Scarborough rot, Toboco, Mississauga, and Hamilton. I remember going to Hamilton years ago when I was in the music business and there wasn't much there. And you go there now and there's 10, 15 cranes, just downtown Hamilton. It's amazing. Go to Kitchener. 50 story buildings going up in Kitchener. It's rather amazing and if it continues the way it is, it's gonna be phenomenal. Oshawa Hass got development, Markham's got a downtown Richmond Hill starting to boom.
EdwardYou go to Vaughn Metropolitan Center where there was absolutely nothing but a golf course and, uh, a driving range in a few other, a drive through theater there a long time ago. And you drive on the 400 now and it's a reasonably nice skyline and there's. 20, 30 more buildings coming. It's quite a, it's quite amazing the kind of development we're having in our region and we've had, and we'll continue to have it look like.
PayamAnd to your point, and Ash and I were talking offline about this that a few years ago when I first signed up for you, for daily emails that we get from you. The first few days were very exciting because I was getting these emails and everything as we're coming in. The second week or third week then of getting these updates. I'm like, I just, it became a little bit scary because every single morning there was a new 80 story coming in as a proposal, and then another 60 story, another added floors to another 60 story, like it just kept going and going. At some point you're like. Okay, give up. I can't even, I can't even fathom tracking any of these things, but I guess that's all good
Edwardnews. So, yeah, no, I was at Young and Sinclair recently, and so I'm looking down Young Street and the two tallest buildings, the CIBC and the Hudson Bay Tower. You can't even see them anymore. And they used to be the. The, the, like the, the twin towers of that location. They were the tallest anywhere and they're half the size of the buildings next to them now. And that skyline is ipro. This is like amazing. So yes, it's definitely happening.
PayamWe'll take that, but as a very good sign hopefully to continue. I know we're all going through very uncertain times right now. A lot at play at macro level, very macro. Level on the global level going on. So hopefully we can all weather that in one piece and things go well. Thank you very much both. I very much appreciate your time and being here. I know I've used your website and platform pretty much all of our previous guests use your systems and platform on a daily basis. So I hope that for our audience this was helpful, insightful, and appreciate your time very much.
Send us Fan Mail Where does the garbage truck go? On a tight Toronto mid-rise site, the answer can change the ground-floor layout and how many homes you can build. In episode 65 of Real Estate Development Insights, I...
Send us Fan Mail What changes when the architect becomes the developer - and takes responsibility for getting the project built? In this episode, Payam Noursalehi speaks with Noam Hazan, architect and founder of Noam...
Send us Fan Mail What should you investigate before turning a Toronto major-street property into a small mid-rise apartment project? Heather Dubbeldam and Derek McCallum of Dubbeldam Architecture + Design join Payam...
Send us Fan Mail What is changing inside Toronto’s housing approval system - and what will developers actually notice? Jag Sharma, Deputy City Manager for Development and Growth Services at the City of Toronto, joins...
Send us Fan Mail Should You Build a Toronto Multiplex? Five Questions to Answer First I run a construction company, so it may be against my own interest to say this: not every multiplex project should be built....