Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Real Estate Development Insights

Real Estate Development Insights artwork

(22) It Is The Best Time To Become A Real Estate Developer (Potentially!) - Josh Kaufman of InnoDev Partners

Feb 18, 202553 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail In this episode of the Real Estate Development Insights Podcast, I sat down with Josh, a seasoned executive in the housing development industry, to discuss his journey from a high-profile corporate role to co-founding InnoDev Partners. They explore the complexities of Toronto’s housing market, the concept of missing middle housing, and the importance of transit-oriented developments. Josh shares his experiences and vision for creating affordable housing solutions, shedding light on the alignment between municipalities and developers aimed at addressing the housing crisis. This episode provides invaluable insights into the ever-evolving landscape of urban development. Why is now the best time to become a real estate developer? Why are purpose-built rentals the best opportunity to pursue for developers right now? How to select a site for your following real estate development projects to increase your odds of success? What is the role of transit in the success and future of rental projects? Transition to Residential Development Opportunities in Transit-Oriented Development Navigating Policy Changes and Incentives Site Selection Criteria Lessons from Past Corporate Life Revenue Expectations and Project Design Achieving Early Alignment in Projects InnoDev Partners is committed to pioneering sustainable construction methods that minimize embodied carbon while creating integrated urban environments. They aim to design spaces that foster holistic living, working, and shopping experiences, with high walkability, convenient transit access, and a focus on inclusivity. For more information, please refer to RealEstateDevelopmentInsights.com Join Our Workshop: MultiplexWorkshop.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hello, everyone, and welcome to another episode of the Real Estate Development Insights podcast, where we bring you ideas, experiences, and best practices from the real estate development industry. My name is Payam Noursalehi, and I'm your host here. My guest for this episode is Josh Kaufman. Josh has over 30 years of experience in real estate and land development projects across country, including the U. S. He has worked in the U. S. and he has worked and he has held a whole bunch of senior roles and levels in some of the major companies that, in Canada at least, including Rogers Telecommunications, Smart Centers, Dream, Fusion Homes and Starlight Investments and like I mentioned, he's been in very high leadership roles and he has been involved in many, many different projects in this 30 years.

I met Josh or we connected with Josh a few weeks ago or a few months ago. Through the, the virtual world and our shared interests in providing housing and midrise projects. And after a couple of discussions, it became evident to me that some of his experiences would be very relatable to our audience here, because coming from that high profile corporate life, he at some point dec, decided to transition or make a change. and become an entrepreneur in a sense for himself and started a company called InnoDev Partners where they are doing now developments of their own and on a multi family residential scale.

And podcast we dive deep into why he did that, why he thinks this is the best time to become a real estate developer in Canada. And the window for that opportunity might not last too long. Why he thinks purpose built rentals are way to go, and what are the advantages of doing those types of projects, at least for the foreseeable future. And he also has a very deep understanding of how the regulations have changed. What the incentives look like in terms of what the government is trying to achieve and how you can line up or the way he puts it, how can you align your project and your team to meet those objectives so you can also benefit while providing a service and making a profit, but you can also streamline the whole approval process and get the most out of those regulation changes and opportunities that are out there right now.

We do talk about, opportunities in Very specific transit oriented development areas, which is now a very hot topic. We get into how they go about selecting a site, how they go through. The coordination and gaining alignment with the municipalities and also their internal team, the consultants and investors to make things happen faster. And he also brings, like I mentioned earlier, that he brings some valuable insights from his past corporate life in terms of how to think of a project from a revenue perspective to begin with, not from a cost perspective.

And like always, you can refer to our website more information about our guests and this episode. Real Estate Development Insights dot com, Real Estate Development Insights dot com. That's all one phrase and I hope you enjoy listening to our content and learn from them and if you do, please remember to subscribe to the show or even better, let your friends and colleagues know and it would really help us grow the show. Thank you very much and we appreciate your support.

PayamHi Josh, welcome to the show. How are you doing?

Josh KaufmanHi, Payam. Nice to see you. Thanks for having me on the show

PayamThank you. Thank you for being here. so you and I met not too long ago through the world of social media and through our shared interest in providing housing in the City of Toronto and missing middle and the mid rise buildings. And, before we dive too deep into what our shared interests look like and what you're doing, why don't we start by giving our audience a little bit of introduction about who Josh is, what you've been up to for the past two, three decades, and then we'll go from there. Great

Josh KaufmanPayam Well I appreciate it again

Payamthank you for the audience

Josh Kaufmanwill try not to make it too

Payamboring for me it's exciting and

Josh Kaufmanand

Payamdoes

Josh Kaufmanspan

Payamthree

Josh Kaufmanuh, three

PayamI'll start off from the

Josh Kaufmanfrom the beginning

Payamfrom a family of home builders when you're working with that family of home builders

Josh Kaufmanof

Payamfor those out there. that are listening know

Josh Kaufmanknow

Payamyour weekends are

Josh Kaufmanare

Payamwith

Josh Kaufmanwith

Payamfrom homebuilding site To homebuilding

Josh Kaufmansite to construction site and different materials and meeting different people, through your family, essentially, your family becomes in some cases, the projects and the trades that you get to know. And for me, that was a big part of it. being, getting that exposure at a young age. So I'd say from my earliest memories, go back to probably the age of seven and eight, being on job sites, taking whatever task was given at me, probably more in a volunteer or voluntold effort. I don't think there was much in the way of compensation, but it gave me an opportunity to get exposure to see what was happening and talk to the trades.

Josh KaufmanAgain, even at a young age, and as you got older, you start to get, you know, less medial tasks, more deliberate.

Payamtasks

Josh KaufmanYou start to shadow the trades and learn from them, but I would say the majority of what I focused on was a single family residential with my family. my father was a pioneer of the time of something known as infill housing. We started off with that and slowly I got exposed to other types of infill housing. It came from what was once, let's call it a single family, then became a semi detached house, and then slowly it, mothballed into townhouses and then larger communities.

Josh KaufmanSo I like to say that my family was on the, cutting edge of doing missing middle housing, which is essentially what it was, going into built up environments and creating these new opportunities to create housing choice, housing variability, and housing affordability. I had the bug early obviously. Given that exposure and it led me down the path of an education at Western Ontario, then went to Ohio State University and got a master's in city and regional planning.

Josh KaufmanSo the focus was urban planning. My career started off in Las Vegas, working for the Southern Nevada Home Builder Association, doing government affairs work, writing policy briefs, learning about The business by way of relationships with the municipal and state officials. So I had exposure to that, came back to Toronto and got a little bit further into, more of a project management. I was doing a lot of telecommunication management. It was all related to real estate.

Josh KaufmanBut it was a little bit of a different angle. over the years, I moved into, different areas focusing on communication, whether it was, working, in New York, back in Toronto, but it was communications focused. I would say for the first, it was called five to seven years. in 2005, I had the good pleasure of Uh, folks from a company called Smart Centers, and I really got my first taste of development on a large scale because I was doing at that time was commercial shopping centers.

Josh KaufmanAnd I would say that's called the typology being single story retail commercial boxes may not have been the most exciting. I don't think I was winning too many design awards for what we were doing. But what I took from it was an exposure. To various municipalities, and I had an opportunity to deliver those boxes or those retail centers, to different places. And those relationships I still hold today, wherever I worked. following uh, and that was about.

Josh Kaufman10 years of my life, I moved on to, work with Dream and my focus on Dream was also commercial and retail environments, whether it was in Toronto or whether it was working in markets like Saskatoon, Regina, Calgary, Edmonton. much of this was new, Commercial development, supporting the new communities that Dream was embarking on. It wasn't about buying a parcel that they didn't have a connection to.

Josh KaufmanIt was providing the amenities and the commercial and retail fabric to support the homes that they were developing within their communities. It was a great experience. You know, I always remember, working in, Places like Saskatoon where I'm getting off the plane and I should have shouldn't let me step back a bit. And I remember the person that I reported to was a great leader by the name of Jason Lester. And I remember the, one of the first days that I met him and he told me about the projects I'd be working on. and he said, have you been to Saskatoon before?

Josh KaufmanAnd I said, no, well, do you own a parka? I didn't quite understand what he meant at that time until I got off the plane and I landed in Saskatoon and I don't think there was any jacket I could have bought or parka I could have bought that would have kept me warm enough at minus 50 degree temperatures. It was quite quite amazing. That said, no matter what environment I was in with Dream, it was a great experience. We were thankful. We delivered some great projects, again, both Toronto with projects like the Canary District that I had a big part of in terms of that evolving retail to, again, markets in Western Canada and prominently in.

Josh KaufmanAnd the prairies. All that was great. worked on some phenomenal projects. And then I had an opportunity to turn my attention to more back to my, let's call it original roots, which would be residential. So, channeling back that. That, you know, infill developer that was my father, my family and working with them. And here's an opportunity to go ahead and do infill development. and I was working with a great company, Starlight Investments and, the related affiliated company being Starlight Developments. we were building.

Josh KaufmanPurpose Built Rental Projects across the country, And I had a phenomenal opportunity. A lot of it was, let's call it Call it the tower in the parking lot, as opposed to the tower in the park. Because many of the projects were existing sites that Starlight had owned, existing buildings, and there was opportunities based on the fact that these were projects dating back to the 60s and 70s, where there was excess parking or excess land that one could introduce. Infill developments. There's, there's that word again, infill.

Josh Kaufmanso I had that opportunity to work with them for five plus years and it was great. The markets I was exposed to was, everything from predominantly BC. So it's called Vancouver Island, lower mainland BC, and then moved my way over obviously to do a lot of work with, where our headquarters are, which is Toronto and, Ontario. so great exposure. All that was Purpose Built Rental, I would say helped deliver thousands of units, and made our, our mark, Starlight being the largest asset manager and owner of Purpose Built Rental properties in Canada, and one of the largest developers, gave me an opportunity to get released.

Josh KaufmanSpread my wings and touch several projects. I think in our heyday, there was probably 80 plus projects that were on the books for, for development. So just a tremendous opportunity. recently, Parting from Starlight, I looked to create something of my own and on my own meaning with a partner and someone that I've had a relationship with for as a friend for 35 plus years, Plus years, we had an opportunity to really do our own thing and address housing the way we want to.

Josh KaufmanAnd that was the creation of InnoDev Partners. And InnoDev Partners really was about finding projects that are in Transit rich, amenity rich locations that are promoting walkability that have less dependency on a vehicle. I believe that this is a huge opportunity that for the community, especially in the purposeful rental side, that is wanting to live, in the city and afford life in the city, there's a huge opportunity.

Josh KaufmanAnd I think that the vehicle sometimes becomes, let's call it a disincentive to affordability, given the high costs associated with owning and operating a vehicle. So if we can create projects that are going to be, closer to transit. that have less dependency. That means we, as a developer, don't have to deliver as much parking. And I would say parking in some cases is the,

Payaman obstacle. It can hinder the project. I want to, just before we dive into the specifics of the projects that you're working on, I want to kind of zoom out a little bit. And for our audience who might not necessarily be familiar with our ecosystem, our construction development ecosystem in Toronto, or even Canada for that matter, I want to zoom out and point out to you A transition here. Right. Because that's the part that when you and I were talking was important to me. And I think it's important for our audience and our, also our community and society to see this because I think it brings up inspiration.

PayamAnd what I'm talking about is that, you named the companies that you've worked with. You've been doing this for the 30 years, like you mentioned, you worked with. Starlight, you've worked with Dream, you've worked with Smart Centers, and for those of our listeners, who don't know, these are some of, if not the biggest or the largest companies in their own categories, they are one of the maybe top five, right? And so you have had a pretty lucrative and high profile executive lifestyle through the corporate world. And you picked this timeline, which my understanding is that it's been less than six months or around six months ago when this transition started happening.

PayamTo transition from a high profile, high corporate C suite person into someone who's now going to be in the trenches, doing pretty much the same thing you were doing but without all the backing, that tells me you're seeing something Some sort of hidden opportunity, or maybe it's not even hidden, it's some sort of an opportunity you're seeing here that tickles you enough, if that's the right word, tickles you enough to say, you know what, I need to try this, this is the right time. What is tickling you?

Josh KaufmanGreat question. I would say that you're right. There's a lot of. Deliberate action to what we're doing at InnoDev Partners. I, for, I would say, although I've been exposed to municipal approvals in different municipalities and policy for so many years in different developments, never have I seen so much alignment between municipalities, the province, and the feds with the private development community as of now.

Josh KaufmanAnd I say that is because I've seen a history of things that have been happening over the past couple of years let's focus on Purpose Built Rental as an example. You saw in September of 2023, The elimination of HST on stabilized assets following construction. That was huge. That was a huge, huge cost savings that would have made the difference of a project sometimes being successful or not. So now there are conditions associated with that, which is you do have to put a shovel in the ground.

Josh Kaufmanby December of 2030, and you have to be completed by December of 2035. Cross our fingers. I hope though that program, doesn't die shortly thereafter, and I'm hoping it gets extended. But I saw that as a short window of time to go ahead and work over the next five years to do whatever I can on as many projects to get shovels in the ground and deliver the housing that I can. Number two. We saw municipalities start to look at development charges and let's call that line item related to municipal approvals, differently.

Josh KaufmanYou saw a reduction happening in development charges if you choose to do certain types of purposeBuilt rental. Further reductions if you are doing So I saw that happening. I also saw the province stepping up in a huge way and trying to put policy together and through different bills that are promoting intensification around major transit station areas. So I saw that. Well, now we've got Big brother, big sister, big mother, big father, what do you want to call on top, basically saying to the municipalities, thou shalt promote intensification when you're in proximity to transit and the transit proximity being within that 800 meter radius.

Josh KaufmanSo I saw that as a huge opportunity. So we want to build more housing when we're close to transit. In addition, we also saw municipalities be given the right to eliminate. parking minimums when you're within those areas. So there's now again that we talked about that huge cost associated with below grade with it's up to you as a developer to determine whether or not the market condition can support minimal parking. And if it can, again, there's a huge cost savings that come with it.

Josh KaufmanIt may not be like I'm a guy who came around from the Back in, call it 25 years ago, when the parking ratios were on the commercial side, starting with a 4, 4. 5 per thousand square feet, huge parking lots that we had to do, more urban scale, getting towards 3, 2. 5, residential. Two, one and a half, one if you're lucky. So we started to see that and again huge disincentives for development on the purposeful rental side. Yes, it's an amenity if you're in a suburban area, suburban context, but if you're in an urban area, you've got access to transit.

Josh KaufmanYou don't need that parking the same way that? it was designed. It just, it didn't make sense to me. So I saw that policy changing as well. i started to read further into what was going on, then you start to look at things like financing and I saw what was happening with respect to from on a federal level with CMHC and the different programs that they were promoting for construction financing and take out financing and holding assets long term. So I saw something all happening. All these stars were aligning in different places.

Josh KaufmanAnd then the last thing about it was when I started to have discussions with municipal officials and provincial officials and MPs and MPPs at a federal level, what I started to see here is it was the discussion wasn't about, jockeying for position to talk about what I was trying to do. It's how quickly can you build it? How quickly can we put shovels in? What do you need to make your project viable so that you can go ahead and put a shovel in the ground? And that was a narrative that didn't exist, I would say, a year, year and a half ago.

Josh KaufmanSo all these things were kind of just permeating and I started to say and percolating and it felt like this was the right time. Can I design projects that are going to be quickly approved, because whether it's by way of variances or rezonings, or even if I hope it wasn't being an official plan amendment, but if I had to go through that process, can I do it in a quick way, Can I make sure that the scale that I'm building at fits in with the urban fabric? Can I develop a project with a performa that works where I'm not going to be pushing too much cost below ground, and I'm focusing on what's happening on the quality above?

Josh KaufmanAnd can I be in dense areas? And that's really where I wanted to focus the efforts of the company. So my partner and I set out on a journey to make sure that we could find those parcels. So from our first step in, whenever we look at a project we're always starting with our finger on the map as to where is transit. Where is the higher order transit? Whether we're on Metrolinx line, or TTC, or some other higher order transit, or LRT if we're in Mississauga, or we're in a GO line, obviously, in a secondary market, we're always focusing on that because it's about going ahead and having quick accessibility to that location, which means we do not need to go ahead and focus on that vehicle.

Josh KaufmanNumber one. Number two, we're also making sure that the scale that we're building it is fits in with the environment that we're in. They're not all mid rise buildings. Some of these are going to be townhouses. Some of these will be four story, ten, twelve, fourteen, plex buildings. So we're really trying to be open to look at different verticals and different opportunities that come across our plate. We believe in delivering housing. Every new housing unit that we can develop. Okay, is good stock that we need to bring into the market.

Josh KaufmanWe may not resolve the housing crisis ourselves, and I can tell you that we're not going to, but we can hopefully go ahead and do our part to go ahead and get

PayamYou can make a dent for sure. And I'm very happy the way you summarize the events over the past year and a half or two years, which I totally agree with you. and, we, on this podcast, we've had many guests, talking about different aspects of it, different from a development side, from the approval side. And I have to admit, there's a lot to vent about when you go through the approval process. Still, there's tons of inefficiencies. But at the same time, everything you just said is true, which is basically, it seems like finally, after thousands and thousands of hours and repetition of the same message, it seems that it's breaking through, things are happening, things are lining up, and I think one thing that I'm noticing in what you just said, and I totally agree with, and it makes sense to me, is that if you have this, now necessarily you don't need to be greedy.

PayamYou don't need to be pushing the envelope. Whereas, I know, especially or specifically in some of the projects that I had known about the past few years, on the condo world, like you're always trying to push. And I can't blame the developers per se, because they go through six years of approval and they need to make every single dollar to make it work. But at the same time, what you just said, which resonates fully with me, is that you're saying I'm not bound to project typology. If I'm going to go there and you're going to go on timeline, if the townhouse is going to get approved within eight months, let's do a townhouse.

PayamDid I get that right? Is that the approach?

Josh KaufmanYeah, I mean, listen, the scale has to make sense. Of course, we know there's only so many hours, In a day, so it has to be meaningful. I know that I don't. Want to be focusing on single family homes and semi detached houses, where I started my career. And that's just because I think we're not to be making the impact that we need. And I do evaluate that time horizon. We have five years to go. Before some of these incentives really fall off. So if this is our time, let's make sure the projects make sense.

Josh Kaufmanyou know, what he didn't talk about yet is things like construction costs. So at the end of the day, that plays a lot into it. So sometimes the projects that make sense to result because you're introducing things like stick or wood, where otherwise you're, Typically using concrete cast in place or steel. So being able to go ahead and adjust your program, based on the opportunity. And again, give an example. I'm working on a project right now where it's a 16 plex and the 16 plex is a 4 story building.

Josh Kaufmanand we know that the policy allows us to go ahead and build, up to 6 storeys. Well, actually as of January 1st, I guess we can go now up to 18 storeys with mass timber. I have to look at it from that perspective and say, okay, number 1, is there a cost savings of working with them? Is there a quick turnaround that I can bring from not having a long approval process and being able to deliver product to the market? maybe quicker than going ahead and doing a 12 or a 14 or 15 storey building. becomes the opportunity.

Josh KaufmanWe're a small company, we're a new company, so we have to be careful with the types of projects that we embark on. But I think that if we can hit some key markets, and again, for me, I'm focusing on where transit is, I think it makes a lot of sense. And we're already seeing those opportunities right now. We have our first few projects that we're working through right now and hope to have more.

PayamRight. And I want to go back to how you go about selecting a site and what you look for, because, in my experience, making numbers work for these infill mid rise projects that are very necessary and are missing, the famous or infamous missing middle, it's really hard. And, you might be close to transit, but pick up the right lot size, the right intersection, if you may, and the right location. Maybe walk us through that. How did you go about those criteria? How did you select the sites or are selecting the sites right now?

PayamGive us a little bit of

Josh Kaufmanyeah. yeah. So, as I said before, it's a little bit you know, of course, we look for where the opportunities are. unfortunately, in this, in this time, in this precarious time that we're in, we're seeing a lot of product come through, whether it was prior condo sites that have been zoned and gone through approval process, and for whatever reason, a developer may have got in trouble, and they're looking to unload the site. So we're looking at And we catalog them and we're putting them very carefully on a map. We add a pin for everyone that we see.

Josh KaufmanSo we mark where it is, but we start off with a base map that has concentric rings around every one of those major transit station areas. So, our focus is to start within that concentric ring and to make sure that we are wanting to explore all opportunities that exist there. Typically around those Transit hubs, there's a lot of amenities, whether it's retail, commercial, and other offerings that are not just all residential or industrial. So I think having that is really important. So again, those 2 criteria are really important.

Josh KaufmanWe also look at the school districts that we're in. So we want to make sure that we're close to schools. We're not there to be delivering Let's call these micro units, bachelor apartments. We want to make sure that we're delivering for families. We do. We do. We want to deliver for families. So if a family is going to be renting, we want to make sure that they can also walk their children or their children can walk themselves if they feel safe to do so, to school. And without any qualm about it. So you got all those criteria kind of circulating, and that makes really a good site.

Josh KaufmanAnd then based on the location, we look at in terms of, well, let's understand what the land price is. Let's see in terms of what would need to, what we would need to achieve to go ahead and make sense of this project. What typology are we working within? What building material are we working within? Are we working in stick? can we explore steel? Are we definitely in a cast in place environment? What are the constraints that exist? And all that really gets built up to really form essentially the project performa

PayamMm hmm,

Josh Kaufmanat the end. Of course, we want to make sure that we have a good handle on the market. Condition that we're in as well as the affordable condition. So we're looking at rents and we're looking at sale prices. We want to make sure that obviously it's an area that can support, the performa. we don't want to go ahead and reach too far in terms of rents and revenue that are unattainable. It should be attainable. It should be something that is not, let's call it, working within a small ring of opportunity. We want to obviously cast the net as large as we can, so that we obviously, we have a lot of people that can look for this opportunity on a rental basis.

Josh KaufmanNow, we're talking a lot about rental because that's really where our focus is right now. there are opportunities that we've looked at for doing condo, and strata titled, and, To be honest, we can't make sense of it right now in this market. So, as a result, we're, we're trying to stay away from it. it's a different equity stack, and it's a different type of performa doing purposeful rental versus condo, but we believe that there's enough interests to promote and deliver this type of projects. So that's our focus.

Josh KaufmanSo I would say 1 thing as well. That's that I've learned over the years is also that you can't design, and you can't develop projects and performance off of an Excel spreadsheet. You really got to have all the disciplines come together. and I'll give an example. we had a project that was stuck. We were looking at it. It was a 10 story project, and it was going to end up being, cast in place and we ran the numbers and and ran the numbers and it just wasn't working. Whatever we did, this thing just couldn't pencil out given kind of the market.

Josh KaufmanRents and revenue expectations, or net income, I guess that was coming from this. at the end of the day, we worked with some great trades and great contractors and on, on re imagining the project, and saying, Hey, listen, maybe you got to go ahead and drop your expectations. Maybe you don't go ahead and build to the utmost highest end of the density scale and soften it, come down a little bit. So maybe as opposed to call it seven times, go, Down to four times and built a six story building, out of stick with concrete cores. so that was interesting. All of a sudden, the numbers started to make a little bit more sense as we started to evaluate this project.

Josh Kaufmanso my point is, I'm saying is, I can't do it on my own. we all, it's, we're part of the team. We may be the developer. We are the ones taking on the risk, ultimately. But I think bringing the right people in. People to the table that can help us in that process is really important, and that's from the consultants, that's the contractors, that's the lenders, that's in some cases also the municipality. I mean, they're at the end of the line, they're the

PayamFor sure.

Josh Kaufmanso making sure that whatever you're designing works for them as

PayamIt's a team sport. This thing that we do in the development and construction is definitely, I know on multiple projects we've ended up with like 25, 26 different consultant disciplines. And that's just the consulting part of it. So there's definitely no shortage of people and expertise that is needed on a project. And like you mentioned, the municipalities and the city, the town or region that you're working with, it's a team sport. They eventually should benefit, like they will benefit from these developments and it's just, I think the word that you mentioned, alignment, which is becoming more and more, I guess tangible these days that, okay, like we're aligning as opposed to five years ago where you would have been a More so, consider it an evil developer who's here to make money and disrupt the neighborhood.

PayamI think that notion is gradually fading, at least a little bit. And we're becoming part of the solution, if you may. Which, in truth, from my perspective, at the very least, developers are a very important service provider to the community as a whole. Because, like you mentioned, there's a lot of risk involved. Anyone who's ever looked at a performa knows the amount of risk that is involved. And, I want to Go back, I want to dig into your past corporate life a little bit. Having been in that role that you, like you mentioned, at some point you had 80 projects on the book for, I think you mentioned it was Starlight.

PayamI don't know if you were involved in all of them or not, but I would assume you had a, Rolodex or directory of projects that you could have heard about or learned about. Were there any top, let's say 2, 3, 5 serious mistakes, or flags, or red flags, that you saw and you say, you know what, when I start my own project, I make sure not do this, and don't do that, and the other one. Does anything come to mind?

Josh KaufmanYeah, no, so I'm not going to focus on anything that was let's call it a failed or mishap of any of the companies I work for. I'm going to turn it around a little bit. And so I'll say from this respect, I've learned what can make a project even more successful. at the end of the day from the way that you, you envision a project from the beginning. And I think that's important to understand. It starts with, with understanding. And what I've learned is you start with the, the, the revenue expectation.

Josh KaufmanYou really need to understand in terms of where that project is going to hit in terms of your market rents, maybe a price. Portion of it's affordable rent, your average rent, seeing where that is. And that starts it off first. Then you can, there you, you've already started to kind of evaluate kind of your, the one criteria that's really important. And then basically your stack falls from there, which is your costs. So everything has to fit. So as opposed to doing it the other way around, where you're designing a project, you got these beautiful towers that are going to cost you.

Josh Kaufman5. 50 a square foot to go ahead and build a beautiful, shiny glass towers, but the project can't be supported by the market rents in that particular location. So then the whole effort was futile. So you're better to go ahead And set your expectations differently. Okay, maybe we can't go ahead and put that shiny glass tower in Guelph or in Cambridge, because the market rents are never going to be at a point where you can, at least in what's called foreseeable future, at a point where you can justify.

Josh Kaufmanthat costs. So again, you lower your expectations and you design accordingly. And I've done that a few times. but let me, I'll tell you, there's always something that comes up. And I remember it was, and I don't mind giving you his name. the chief responsibility officer at Dream, a gentleman by the name of Michael Cooper. He's well known, well established, one of the most successful people I know in this business. And a comment that he made to me once was, you know, remember that it's a, it's a privilege to work in the municipalities that we're in.

Josh KaufmanAnd I took that to heart and I've always kept that with me wherever I am. So I may be angry and upset of how long something is taking to go ahead and build, but remember at the end of the day, it really is our privilege. And so we, we are the ones who are privileged by working in that municipality. What I'd say is,

PayamMaybe elaborate on

Josh KaufmanWell, I mean, it's okay. So yes, are coming in to build in their community. Okay, they're allowing us and they're giving us the approvals to enable us to go ahead and build and develop housing in their community. They don't have an obligation to let us go ahead and develop. So that becomes the opportunity of it's a privilege. So, but I also would say something, which is important to note is, and you talked about alignment before. I think at the end of a project, you are always going to reach alignment with the municipality that you're working in, because it's built, you were at the groundbreaking ceremony together, you finished it, and you're at the ribbon cutting ceremony at the end, and you've got your alignment.

Josh KaufmanBut what's changed is the fact is, and what I've seen in my career, is that alignment. is happening sooner in the project. You're getting alignment at the beginning. Okay, we know what you want to build. How do we go ahead and execute on this project? We're not debating and navigating and negotiating for years upon years to eventually get to the same outcome. That's the, you're not, not doing that anymore. So let's, we, we've set the policy in motion. We've, we've set the bar where we need to try your best to work within it.

Josh KaufmanYou may need some variances, you may need some zoning amendments, but then the day we're going to go ahead and get you to a place of alignment that much quicker. Okay. So from a timing standpoint, what's changed is that the approval process can happen that much quicker. I have seen mistakes over and over, whether it was my own projects or projects that others have done, where they've tried to go ahead and ask for the moon, and they got shut down. They, you had the community that was up in arms, you had, I wouldn't say even it's NIMBY, just it was a, a disconnect on, on what the, called that plan function needed to be.

Josh KaufmanAnd as a result, the projects were delayed. It took years to go ahead and get the approvals for that project and put that shove on the ground. So by getting that alignment earlier by, let's call it putting the bar up a little bit higher by allowing things like intensification, reducing the parking minimums, things like that, getting things like, let's call it 45 degree angular planes and issues like the shadow, trying to minimize some of those impacts as much as you can, really has created a better environment for going ahead and getting alignment sooner, if that

PayamThat's great. And I'm gonna, I'm gonna ask you to follow that train of thought because my, my next question is, we've discussed all the good things that happened so far. And if, if we were to give you a magic wand and say, Josh, make this alignment better, what are the next two or three things that need, it would be great if they fall into place and align?

Josh KaufmanOkay, well, listen, there's there's no shortage of of press and stories and discussion, whether you're in social media or any print that relates to, the high Cost and fees on two fronts. So I'd say development charges and municipal fees are still one of the largest costs that we have within a project. Okay. I'm not against the notion of growth paying for growth, but it has to also be manageable. And the project needs to go ahead and be able to, respond and accept that charge to make the project viable.

Josh KaufmanUnfortunately, there are too many projects that We're shelved because DC's got out of whack. Toronto was one of the highest. York region's also right up there. We need to find opportunities to decrease that and lower that. The same way that we found creative ways with respect to things like financing, where we've been able to go ahead and take advantage of different programs, whether it's through CMHC or through our lender relationships, we need to do that as well on the municipal level. So they've made their mark, they've started, and I, you know, obviously I, I commend them on what they've done, seeing some of that discounts is, let's call it the first step to get in there.

Josh KaufmanAnd I think it's going to improve over time. So from the magic wand, let's call it, that's the first trick I'd also like to, deal with the, the second, I would call the number one cost outside of land, is your hard cost, is your construction cost. we've seen this softening, I would say, and some of the costs coming down, maybe for the, it's called the lack of starts. so you're starting to see some of those numbers improve. But we're still not there yet. We still need to go ahead and get back to where things were, let's call it, in five, six years ago.

Josh KaufmanSo how to get back to those numbers would make sense. We know that revenue is not a never ending uphill, especially when it comes to rental or in terms of revenue for Strata. So I think we have to ensure that we're Making projects work in the present value environment that we're in. Okay. So there's so much guesswork that happens right now on a project performa, especially related to costs. So as an example is, we don't know, is escalation going to be 2%?

Josh KaufmanIs it 3%? Is it 5%? You know, I'm pretty sure in COVID we saw crazy. numbers between 7 and 10%. It was nuts. Yeah. So being able to kind of see it come down, something that is Measured, something that is predictable is really important as well. I think being able, so that, that's, that's something else. I think on the magic wand side, let's call it, let's call it predictability in terms of construction costs and a decrease across the board, I think is necessary. I think the third thing that I'd like to see happen is go back to this We know that there are stringent rules and timelines that everyone can abide by.

Josh KaufmanSo, I'll give an example. Years ago, working with another great company that I mentioned before, being SmartCenters, I had the good fortune and the opportunity to work on a project which was Known as the Toronto Premium Outlets. If you've been there, it's a phenomenal project, in Halton Hills, uh, and

Payammall or outlet set

Josh Kaufmanyeah, Americans, American style concept of, of premium retail in an outdoor shopping environment. So, still unenclosed, meaning unenclosed, meaning you're accessing from the exterior. You don't have common areas that you're going into for the most part. and, and it's, it was a. The reason why I mentioned this, is because it was the first time that I ever worked on a project where we had different levels of government, all involved in the projects. So from the municipality, that was the approval agency, which is the town of Halton Hills.

Josh KaufmanTo the Ministry of Transportation that was involved because we were on Highway 401 and, we were, adjacent, to the on ramp at Trafalgar and 401. So they were an approval, obviously, authority. We had the Conservation Authority that was involved as well. So you name it, they were, they were involved, but what was different about it, where it would make many people. Shake, because of all the, let's call it, red tape that you have to go through, I didn't have that experience.

Josh KaufmanI had a phenomenal opportunity, which was, we had a period of 13 months to go ahead and get this project approved, from ideation all the way through to getting a building permit. And we set that timeline at the beginning. We had a great road map that was involved, delineating everyone's role and responsibility across the chain. So it literally felt like it was a relay race. You received the, whether, whatever it was, the submission from the city.

Josh KaufmanThe city had their prescribed timeline. They were, everyone was incented. There was a, let's call it a huge economic impact that came from this amazing retail, first of its kind in Canada opportunity. So everyone was incented to make sure it happened. you know, you didn't want to be on the end of a call with a counselor if you're a municipal staff, because something wasn't getting done in the timeframe. So everyone was driven in the same way. At the end of the day, it all got done and there, there were many, you know, issues that came along that we had to navigate and go through and, and I definitely had a lot more hair back then.

Josh Kaufmanthat said, that said, it was success. every project can have that same amount of success if we all get together from the beginning and we agree on what everyone needs to do. within the chain And then you take full responsibility for your role within that. There's no, Hey, I couldn't get to it. I'll get to it. It's the bottom of my pile. I'll get to it in, a couple of weeks from now because of other other priorities. No, no, we established the priority. We knew we had dedicated teams that were there.

Josh KaufmanWe had a liaison. That was working with them in the municipality to ensure that on a weekly call that I was having that things were going in the right cadence and process. that was it. There was no strong arming that was coming. We were all just working in complete alignment and it got it delivered. That's the way you deliver projects. We all know that we have a critical role to play. So given we all have a critical role, take responsibility for the role that you have. Agree on your timelines at the beginning, and whatever it takes, make sure that you deliver.

PayamI really like that concept because it also touches on something else that has been happening at least in Toronto for the past few years and that is the feeling of being on the same team. that you're talking about in that particular project It's not been very common these days. It hasn't been common for a few years at least, at least in my experience. That is, for whatever reason, we ended up in a situation in past few years that you have the private sector, development sector, the builders and investors, it almost on an opposing team.

Payamto the municipal body and the city staff and councillors. And I don't want to overgeneralize this and it's not obviously everywhere. But the general feeling, even, and I'm gonna also hold the public sector and the private sector probably equally responsible for this, at least from my perspective. That it was, okay, we need to go to the city and fight it. And that terminology percolated and was everywhere into these discussions. And there was, it was, And I would really like to see that change to your point. And maybe that's part of this alignment that's happening.

PayamThat is, you know what, we actually are on the same team. As a municipality, we have an issue. We have, we need more housing for our people in this community. And here's a risk taker or a developer who is willing to be participating in the solution and provide housing units. Let's work together. And yeah, that would be great if that happens. From that, I want to segue into Again, your past experience, maybe, and even talk about that project, because one of the other challenges that we have is dealing with very large consulting teams, very large design teams, too many stakeholders.

PayamLike I mentioned, there could be dozens of them. Do you have any magic sauce? Is there any tricks or experiences or things that you've learned through the years and say, you know what, forget about it. We talked about external stakeholders per se. Let's talk about internal ones. Let's talk about the immediate ones, the ones that you deal with on a daily basis. Do you have any word of advice or any experience you can share with us?

Josh KaufmanSo a couple things I would say that, having the, opportunity to work across the country. I got a chance to see how different municipalities operate and what the requirements are at different stages of the approval process. So when you're in BC, in many municipalities that you're there, or even in Western Canada or the prairies, you know, you've got your zoning process that you go through. and they, they typically, let's call it, they put a, a circle around what's involved to get through zoning.

Josh KaufmanThey defer many of the technical, technical detailed reports to your site plan. you've got the, the, the present bylaw that you're obviously looking to, but the execution is all coming by way of site plan. So there's not a lot of, let's call it, work being done. Within, let's call it the Approval Authority, we're getting rid of the, let's call it the, those technical reports on the front end, and we're bringing them to, let's call it the, let's call it the back end as you're going through your site plan and going towards your permit.

Josh KaufmanA very important thing, because it helps the process. Also, your approval agency being counsel, which is the elected official that has to oversee and approve. It's letting them be an expert in what they do, which is they're looking at kind of the overall vision. They're not getting into the technical aspects. They're not reading reams and reams of reports that they don't understand necessarily and nothing as a dig against them. The reality is they are quite technical. After all my years doing half the reports, I don't understand still.

Josh KaufmanI do my best, but the reality is it's

PayamVery true.

Josh KaufmanTo go ahead and make a decision on something that maybe they're not so as informed from? So, you're better off to go ahead and say, let's we've hired great staff. These are experts at what they do. Let them go ahead and, Basically, inform what's required. Let's delegate authority to them to go ahead and get through the process, reviewing the documents, the technical studies that are there, knowing that we have caught a upper tier approval by way of counsel that sets the call, the vision for what we need to do. And the rest becomes the staff. So then now we've dealt with the zoning.

Josh KaufmanFirst and foremost, out of the gate, the zoning is done. And now we just work through on the site plan side. I think you've got the opportunity. It hasn't addressed your question of how to reduce the number of reports, but all what I've tried to do is get rid of some of the hurdles in the front end that are sometimes the most, timely and occupy so much amount of time on the front end. So I think if we could do that, like they do it in BC, it may, or in Western Canada, it makes a lot more sense.

PayamI think my take on that is that it changes your risk profile earlier. Like in that, if you do it the way you describe, if I understand it correctly, you're basically going through the approvals on the zoning side quicker and faster, which is a big deal, which is a big deal. And by the time you're past that hurdle, your entire risk profile for the project changes. You know you have a certain level of comfort within your entitlement process. And then now Dealing with the technical stuff at SitePlan, which most of the time it ends up being that way anyways.

PayamYou have to deal with it. You still have to go through three submissions of SitePlan anyways, right? Might as well not hold up in the early stages.

Josh KaufmanThe Kind it's Kind of like a conditional approval. You got your zoning, but it's conditioned. You still got to do all the necessary study works to justify, obviously, the development. So, all I'm saying is, but we take it out of the public domain. We haven't put it in a place where it's leading, leaving it to a counselor or a council to go ahead and discuss. It allows staff to be part of the process early. They don't have to worry that they're writing these big reports anymore that are going to council. They can work with you and the developer. Let's refine that we need to.

Josh KaufmanAnd I think you'll get a better result right now. it's, it hasn't got there. And again, I do see if you look at your timelines on approvals of zoning, that's called in Western Canada versus Eastern Canada. It's remarkable in terms of the difference. It's definitely a shorter time frame. Now, I think with what Has happened recently in terms of policy directives, whether it's coming from the province or led by the municipality. I think some of those studies are starting to fall off. If obviously, there's not the same interest or the same concerns as a shadow impacts, as an example, then you don't have to do as much evaluation at that point.

Josh KaufmanSo, I, think that there's certain studies that at the end of the day, technically have to still go forward because you have to make sure that it can be supported. You want to make sure that the servicing is there to support your development. You have to justify it. You can't get around that. You got to make sure that your road network can go ahead and support where you're in. You want to make sure that it's safe to go ahead and operate if you have a vehicle in terms of the ingress and egress coming out. I get all that. You want to make sure, obviously, things fit in from a planned function. All that is necessary. but there's. Trust me, reams of other studies that we all end up having to do and consultants we bring on, that it costs a lot of money and it takes a lot of time.

Josh KaufmanSo it's listen, all this takes time. So I think, as I will continue to say, I still feel that it's a privilege that I can work in these municipalities. I uh, you set up Perfectly before. I do think you're starting to see municipalities, uh, reciprocate with that same statement.

PayamLet's do it together. Let's do it together.

Josh Kaufmanour municipality. So if we're both privileged, let's work together.

PayamLet's be on the same side. Let's be on the same team and perceive it as such, and act as such, and then let's get this thing done. Because frankly, it's somewhat embarrassing to look at the numbers and see, like, are we having all these issues in Canada? And then we're supposed to be one of the leading countries in the globe. Anyways, that's a different discussion. I don't want to go there too deep. This has been really informative and thank you for your time. Is there anything that I haven't asked you or any final thoughts that you want to share with our audience?

Josh KaufmanI'm really delighted that you've created this forum and opportunities for people that are passionate about housing that can come together, whether you're a big developer or a small developer, but focusing on this necessary part of housing. And I think having more of this discussion is also going to get people thinking and operating in a different way as well. So if I can be able to impart some information from what I've said to you during this time, I've done my part. And again, thank you for the opportunity.

Payamyou. Thank you very much. I agree, like this is a conversation and one of the reasons, one of the main reasons we're doing this is that there's only so much nagging you can do on the sidelines. Listen, people have to change and then it takes other people like yourself to change. we want to be part of the solution and we're trying to promote that. So thank you very much Josh. This has been really helpful

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. (65) Toronto Mid-Rise: What’s Changed and What Still Holds Projects Back? - Claire Malcolmson

    Nov 12, 202633 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Where does the garbage truck go? On a tight Toronto mid-rise site, the answer can change the ground-floor layout and how many homes you can build. In episode 65 of Real Estate Development Insights, I...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. (64) From Architect to Multiplex Developer: Lessons from the Site - Noam Hazan

    Oct 27, 202639 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail What changes when the architect becomes the developer - and takes responsibility for getting the project built? In this episode, Payam Noursalehi speaks with Noam Hazan, architect and founder of Noam...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. (63) Building Small Mid-Rise in Toronto: What Developers Need to Know - Heather Dubbeldam & Derek McCallum

    Oct 7, 20261 hr 5 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail What should you investigate before turning a Toronto major-street property into a small mid-rise apartment project? Heather Dubbeldam and Derek McCallum of Dubbeldam Architecture + Design join Payam...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. (62) Toronto Housing Approvals: What’s Changing - Jag Sharma - Deputy City Manager - City of Toronto

    Sep 22, 202647 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail What is changing inside Toronto’s housing approval system - and what will developers actually notice? Jag Sharma, Deputy City Manager for Development and Growth Services at the City of Toronto, joins...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. (61) Should You Build a Multiplex? 5 Checks Before You Commit

    Sep 9, 202641 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Should You Build a Toronto Multiplex? Five Questions to Answer First I run a construction company, so it may be against my own interest to say this: not every multiplex project should be built....

    Credit the people on this episode