Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

rationally BASED

rationally BASED artwork

Episode 45 | Midterm Madness Redux

Nov 5, 202645 minAudio

Susan Collins lost in Maine after years as the most moderate Republican in the Senate. Across the country, Republicans ran solid candidates and still underperformed. In Alaska, “Decoy Dan” Sullivan remains on the ballot with thousands of votes while Mary Peltola leads by a few hundred. Hosts Kathryn Johnson and law professors Joshua Kleinfeld and Ilan Wurman give their high-level thoughts on the results - and an update on the Alaska decoy. On the results: Ilan argues the lesson is to scrap primaries and bring back smoke-filled rooms. The Democrats have already done it twice - replacing their primary winner with Kamala Harris, and forcing out their own nominee in Maine before a convention picked the replacement. Kathryn sees a different problem. The candidates were fine. Republicans simply did not show up at the levels they did two years ago, while Democrats did. Josh treats the result as a reversion to default American habits: non-ideological voters focus on practical problems and personalities, then go back to sleep once the immediate chaos fades. The deeper clash with the Left, including the emerging Red-Green alliance, has not gone away. The task is to build an anti-Left politics that still registers as practical to voters who do not think in ideological terms. On Alaska: The second ("Decoy") Dan Sullivan is not ordinary third-party ballot stacking. Nor is it "fraud in the inducement." It is fraud in the fact - deceiving voters about which candidate they are choosing. That fits the federal statute against a candidate fraudulently misrepresenting himself as acting for another candidate on a matter damaging to that candidate. It may also fit 18 U.S.C. § 241, the conspiracy-against-rights statute long used against ballot-stuffing schemes that injure the right to vote. With Peltola ahead by roughly 600 votes and Decoy Dan holding more than 3,500, the Senate could refuse to seat her under the Elections Clause. But Democrats will be in charge, so of course they won't. This is the rational - and based - discussion of the midterms, primaries, turnout, and election integrity that you won’t hear anywhere else. Be sure to LIKE, SHARE, COMMENT, and SUBSCRIBE to rationally BASED! Subscribe to our Substack! New Podcast Episodes every Thursday morning, find us on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or on YouTube! Follow us on social media on Instagram, X, Facebook, and TikTok!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Welcome back to Rationally Based, a podcast about law and politics on the edge. I'm Elon Werman, a law professor at the University of Minnesota Law School. I'm Josh Kleinfeld, Rouse Professor of Law at Scalia Law School.

SPEAKER_00And I'm Catherine Johnson with Center of the American Experiment.

SPEAKER_01Katherine, what's on deck?

SPEAKER_00Well, we're fresh off the midterm election, so we're going to start there. We'll give you our high-level thoughts on the election and what the heck happened. Second, we'll talk about Maine and some takeaways there and Susan Collins. Third, we'll give you a few updates on the whole decoy Dan Sullivan debacle. Yes, we think he did commit some crimes. I think you'll enjoy this episode.

SPEAKER_01Thanks for joining on this special midterm episode. Let's dive in. Well, as always, please hit that like and subscribe button. Boy, do we have an episode for you today. I think we're gonna start with elections. So reflections on the elections. I wanted to get us started here. There are a couple things that I want to talk about legalistically.

SPEAKER_01Uh, well, legalistically and institutionally. There are only three elections that I really cared about in terms of the Senate races. Uh I'll only talk about two today. The Michigan one, you know, I also really cared a lot about. Uh, but uh let's talk about uh Maine first and uh then Alaska. So first in Maine, Susan Collins, the most moderate of all Republicans, lost after uh years in the Senate. And, you know, what is sort of the takeaway uh here? Here's my takeaway.

SPEAKER_01This isn't so much Susan Collins as just the Democrats played uh an amazing play here, which is get rid of primaries. I want that to sink in. Get rid of primaries. Why do we have elections to decide who the candidate of a particular party will be in the general election? Okay, why should we let a narrow and highly ideological group decide uh you know who the general election candidate will be for everyone else?

SPEAKER_00So obviously, but primaries are open to everyone.

SPEAKER_01Um, well, it depends on the state. That's not usually true. In most states, you have to pick a party. Yeah, I mean, they're open primary states, that's true. And then it's even worse. So then you get a bunch of what Democrat voters deciding who the craziest Republican is that they're gonna vote for in order to tank them. Like the whole thing doesn't make sense. Bring back the smoke-filled rooms. Why is this proof of that? Not because Susan Collins was a bad candidate, but Ken Paxton, clearly, you know, John Cornyn, you may not like him, you may not think he's maggot enough, but he would have won. He would have won.

SPEAKER_00No, disagree so hard. Disagree completely.

SPEAKER_01He almost certainly.

SPEAKER_00Republicans, Elon, Republicans didn't turn out. That was our issue. Republicans were not motivated to go vote. You think Cornyn would have motivated the Republicans in Texas?

SPEAKER_01I think I think there is a substantial number of Republicans, establishment like Republicans, who stayed home and who would have gone out to vote for John Cornyn.

SPEAKER_00Establishment Republicans.

SPEAKER_01I know, I know you're excited since this is your wheelhouse, but because James Tellerico, some people probably rightly believe he's kind of like the devil incarnate. Okay, I don't know if I would go that far, but obviously, like he's super, super weird and scary in many ways, his views. Okay, they would have come out, but they couldn't because Ken Paxton has a bunch of issues. Politics is local in this respect, right? Anyway, I don't know that he would have won, but it he he he could have. And I think he might have. But the point here is the main Democrats literally in their primary elected a psycho Nazi, you know, Graham Platiner and like a woman abuser and everything.

SPEAKER_01And so what did they do? They said, you know what? After the elections were over, now we'll replace it with someone whom we didn't have time to like test and to air. There wasn't enough time for many negative ads. And so they had this smoke-filled room, not really, it was a big convention, but of party uh, you know, sort of establishment types, and then they ran that candidate, and the candidate actually won, showing what that people don't actually care whether primaries are democratic or not. If the primary is not democratic, no one's gonna lose sleep over it in the general election because the general election is what's democratic.

SPEAKER_01And you know when the Democrats also recently did this? Do you remember anybody? Anybody? Kamala Harris. Joe Biden, Kamala Harris. That's what they did. She lost! She lost. Yes, but Joe Biden would have been shellacked even more. And I don't think it's even a question.

SPEAKER_00Okay, the new guy also in Maine is sleeping with his cousin. Like, this was not a great candidate pick. Okay, let me give you a completely opposite example. Here in Minnesota, we have these, you know, people get together, the parties, and they endorse their candidates, and then we have a primary. For the first time ever, Republicans broke from the endorse party candidates, where is exactly what you're talking about. People from the party, the most extreme, probably because they care the most, endorse the candidates they like. Then at the primary, way more people show up and they end up endoring picking candidates for the first time ever who were more to the left.

SPEAKER_00Michelle Defoya, much more moderate. Michelle Defoya got 200,000 fewer votes than the insane radical right-wing guy who ran two years ago because Republicans didn't show up. And that's the moral of the story. And the Republicans that didn't show up are the ones who were upset that Trump didn't live up to his promises, that Trump hasn't put America first. He's focused on this war in Iran that has made prices go up, that people can't really understand why he is so focused on things outside of America. The issue isn't that establishment people didn't show up.

SPEAKER_00Look at all the establishment candidates we had. We had them all over the country. We had establishment candidates look at Michigan. We had the perfect establishment candidate. Didn't work, didn't work because Republicans didn't show up, and it's our fault.

SPEAKER_02Okay. So, Catherine, I wait, can I interject here? Because I really want Catherine's take on something. It's a question, Catherine. Um had Trump stay, you know, when I when I think about um uh ways in which Trump retreated from certain campaign promises, you know, you might you might focus on immigration and deportations after the events that happen in in Minneapolis, right? Um there was a sort of backing away from that. Backing away, frankly, from the fight against universities.

SPEAKER_02Uh um you could talk about the getting involved in Iran, I guess. And I guess I'm wondering if your take on it is that if those things hadn't happened, do we do Republicans win the midterms or at least not lose them so badly? Like, is this really a problem of like the way you seem to be presenting it is the people who are really hardcore conservatives um felt betrayed and so didn't show up and didn't vote. And I'm just wondering if that's if that is in fact your take, if they could have been motivated otherwise if Trump had had different policies in the first two years.

SPEAKER_02And um, if that's empirically supported. Because as I understand it, there were, you know, uh about 10 points of voters who showed up and voted for the other side. There was great turnout.

SPEAKER_00Well, that that is my take because of the numbers that I've seen. But, you know, it's obviously still, I mean, we still haven't I I guess it's only the day after the election. But I think that's what we're seeing is that Republicans didn't show up because they weren't motivated. Or it seems like there is some evidence that, yeah, they showed up and voted for Democrats. And I think a lot of that comes down to the state of the economy, affordability issues, and the war in Iran and people feeling like, yeah, Trump just was not focused in his first two years on the issues that they elected him to care about.

SPEAKER_02So can I ask you something? Um, and then I want to come back to the primaries things. I totally disagree with Elon too for different reasons, but you know, that'll make this fun. Um, J.D. Vance put out a big tweet today on X, or a big post on X, or whatever you call it. And uh here's what he said. He's clearly sort of positioning himself for the race in 2028, and he's creating a lot of airspace between himself and Trump. And here's something he said: I'm gonna quote our voters showed up. And the above four reasons, namely, end the war, focus on cost of living, put America first, change our relationship to Israel, uh, are why many of them voted for Democrats.

SPEAKER_02So the idea is that, you know, this was not a turnout thing. It was that Republicans voted for Democrats because they felt betrayed on those four issues. What do you think?

SPEAKER_00I don't know. That could be true. I don't feel like I've seen that evidence yet, but maybe it's just because I haven't looked for it. Um, I think it was more so that Republicans stayed home from what I'm seeing in the numbers in my state. But that could be totally different. I think in general, though, he's right about the reason people either didn't vote or did vote for Democrats, like completely flopped sides. Um, I think he's right. I think he identified the right reasons. The the part that I'm scared of, of course, is now we're starting like a civil war in the GOP, right?

SPEAKER_00I mean, he's already distancing himself from Trump. DeSantis, I think, did a really crappy thing and on the day of the election went out and distanced himself from the Iran war. He saw the wave coming and said, I'm gonna go against the party, which I did not appreciate, even though I think he's right. Um, so we already see everyone trying to distance themselves from Trump. Donald Trump Jr. retweeted that and said, you know, 100% correct. So I think they're set, I mean, we're set up for kind of a civil war within uh the Republican Party, which obviously scares me to some degree.

SPEAKER_01Okay, so let me just say uh one thing, and then Josh, I want your take on the primaries. I think it's a mistake to say Republicans voted for Democrats. I think what you say is people who voted for Donald Trump and Republicans in 2024 did not vote for them now. Because there's a substantial number of Americans who really are up for grabs. Their votes really are up for grabs, which is why I think having more sensible candidates, I'm not saying they have to be conventional establishment Republicans who just believe what the Democrats believe. I don't believe in that. I think Donald Trump, to some degree, was actually salutary to the Republican Party.

SPEAKER_01Because before then, it's just like, you know, I heard Governor Orquist once saying, you know, uh, it's very easy to compromise when Democrats want to spend 10x and Republicans want to spend 6x. Okay, compromise at 8x. Okay. Everyone just wants to spend. But when one side wants to do totally other things, then all of a sudden, you know, compromise becomes more difficult. And I do think that Donald Trump was salutary in the sense of placing uh at the core of one of the party's uh concerns of working class Americans that have been ignored uh for a long time.

SPEAKER_01I think that was salutary. But I also think um because these voters are up for grabs, you know, pri I I'm not saying this works immediately. There'll have to be a transition period because the people who run the party are also kind of crazy, right? But as a general matter, the people who run the party who are actually in the party offices want the party to succeed. And they're thinking who can win the general election because they're practical, right? It doesn't matter if you know the ideological purists are the ones who are on the ballot if you get a 55-45 Senate in the other direction. It just doesn't matter.

SPEAKER_01Politics is the art of the possible. And I think if the parties decided through internal mechanisms who the candidates would be, we would have people who were more palatable to get those voters who were up for grabs, who voted one way in 2024 and the other way in 2026. It wouldn't have worked universally because, again, a lot of the promises that were made just weren't kept. So that's my key.

SPEAKER_00You are describing, though, Elon, the theory that every Republican in Minnesota had going into this election and it failed. I'm just telling you, like that was our theory was that we needed to get away from the party endorsement and go to the primary. And we did. And then we elected or nominated people who were much more in the middle we thought would capture those middle-of-the-road kind of people whose votes were up for grabs. Didn't work at all.

SPEAKER_02Josh. On the primary thing or on my big reflection?

SPEAKER_01Uh start start with primaries because it's more focused, and then why don't you tell us your big reflections and then we'll talk about Alaska?

SPEAKER_02All right. Well, the the primary thing, listen, when parties decide candidates, then what you have is elite control of democracy. You have an elite of the Republican Party, it's going to be a lot of corporate interests and you know, um, other kinds of sort of um the billionaire class and so on. You have an elite of the Democrat Party that will be some of the same people on the other side, as well as some celebrities and some academics and that kind of thing. And they decide who they like and what choices to give to voters, and then voters are looking at these two candidates saying, these have nothing to do with me.

SPEAKER_02They neither of them has any real understanding of my concerns or responsiveness to my concerns. We are just, you know, Schumpeter described this, Joseph Schumpeter, the the political, I think of him as a political philosopher. He's I guess he's an economist. He described this kind of system where you have two competing elites and they compete for the vote of the people. That's a terrible way to do democracy because it's not a democratic way to do democracy. The people need to select the candidates if there's going to be genuine choice in the in the general.

SPEAKER_01So I just theoretical reasons I just hate what you're proposing. How about the people start a different party? How about all those crazy primary voters start the workers' people's party and make it sound not communist?

SPEAKER_02And then what you're describing is a system where there comes to be an elite of that party and they select a candidate and present it to the people. You know, I I believe I'm remembering this correctly, that in Venezuela, the party control was so complete that they just had a sort of treaty between the two parties that they would uh share power on a regular basis. They just change who got to govern on a regular basis. So you choose your candidate who went to Exeter, and I'll choose mine who went to Andover, and they'll trade places every four years, and it's just a deal between the elites and society.

SPEAKER_02What we need is genuine populism, which is the opposite of what you're describing.

SPEAKER_01Too bad we don't disagree. I'm right. What are the uh bigger uh what are your bigger reflections on the election?

SPEAKER_02And then I want to talk about Alaska. So I've been I've been reflecting on the midterms um uh a lot and trying to trying to think about what I can offer that isn't obvious to everyone. I I mean everyone who's listening to our podcast has a views of inflation, Iran, and so on. They can see that just as clearly as we can. I kind of feel like my value add is this intermixture of political philosophy with practical politics with law. And from that place, as I reflected, I came up with a sort of warning and proposal.

SPEAKER_02And I want to put it on the table and hear your reactions to it. So I think what we saw in this election was a reversion to default American political habits, which is when thinking about politics to focus on people, like do I like Obama, do I like Hillary Clinton, do I like Trump, and to focus on very specific problems and specific failures in a pragmatic way. So, like open borders, it's a problem. Too many immigrants coming in, no school choice, it's a problem. War in Iran going badly, it's a problem.

SPEAKER_02And so it's a very problem-solution-oriented relationship to politics, right? People, problems, solutions, that's the American common sense approach. But the great issues of our time are ideological and have to do with a much larger and older clash of left and right, right? So this, you know, 1789 version of the left or 1848 version of the left we have inherited in the United States. We call it woke, uh, we call it DEI.

SPEAKER_02Woke and DEI are new labels for old things, right? What are the old things? It's uh it was called political correctness and identity politics a generation before that. Before that, it was Marxist, it was pro-communist. Before that, it had a different name, but it's the same trend of a large left-wing uh perspective on politics, which is deeply anti-American, which is anti-religious, which is uh anti-capitalist, which is anti-individualism, and which is uh takes this view of the world where the way to do justice is to fight for whoever is the most oppressed group.

SPEAKER_02Now we have a variation on that. It's the red-green alliance, right? That's something we've the red-green alliance is a term from Europe. It's been a dominant force in European politics for a generation. Red represents the left, green represents Islam. It's the traditional color of Islam. And the um alliance between the like the French left and the Islamic forces of France, or the British left and the Islamic forces of the UK, or the uh German left and the Islamic force of Germany, this is defining European politics, which is why they have a name for it, the Red-Green Alliance.

SPEAKER_02Well, Madami El Sayyed, Ilan Omar, it represents the Red-Green Alliance in the United States. Now, I am talking big picture ideological clashes, right? The left and its enemies, the left and Islamism uh in alliance against the right. Americans don't like to think this way. They don't like to think in these very philosophical ideological terms. It's unnatural, and they revert by instinct to I don't like Trump, El Said seems okay, Mundami seems like a nice guy, housing is too expensive, food is too expensive, maybe this will work, like all this practical stuff.

SPEAKER_02Gas is too expensive, whatever. That's a mistake. I think that Biden went so far in the woke direction that even very normy Americans who were sort of normally not attuned to ideological issues were like, wow, something weird is going on. Like this trans stuff is weird, this open border stuff is weird, like all of it. This doesn't, this doesn't feel right. And they sort of awoke from their slumber and uh woke up to the weirdness of ideology.

SPEAKER_02And that's why Trump could have a winning pitch when he said, let's come back to common sense. But now they've slumped, they're in slumber again. They're back to the common sense perspective, the pragmatism perspective. You know, my favorite t-shirt says, sure, it works in practice, but does it work in theory? I find that hilarious. Uh in this case, that is good. That is really good. It's really good. That is really good. The the practical perspective is missing something. And that's why I have a warning here.

SPEAKER_02Uh, because this reversion to common sense pragmatism is dangerous precisely because the underlying ideological threat has not gone away. It's gotten worse. This is not your mother's Democratic Party. This is a DSA party. This is a party that is explicitly pro-Islam, that is explicitly anti-American, I should say pro-Islamism, pro-the aggressive uh form of Islam that wants to uh dominate, not just be present, uh, that is anti-American, that is extreme on issues of trans and all other issues of group-based politics.

SPEAKER_02Like this is a very extreme manifestation of the Democratic Party. It's been taken over by its most left-wing elements. So, and people, I hear people say things like, oh, good thing Trump beat DEI. Good thing woke is over. Man, that was weird. That's ridiculous. It's ridiculous. Woke is not over. DEI is not over. All the same people who believe all the same things believe it as fervently as ever, and they are not powerless and they are not defeated. They took a beating in 2024 and they are right back in 2026.

SPEAKER_02So you can't sleep on the ideological threat and revert to pragmatic politics when the ideological threat is still there and is still present. So, okay, so last point about this.

SPEAKER_00Um Josh, real quick, do you think anyone else in the world has ever bought that t-shirt except you?

SPEAKER_02Uh there are other philosophers. I know, I know. It's it's the real me. Uh okay, so what's the task after defeat? I think we need to do two things. One is assemble an ideological view that is truly anti-left, yet appealing to a large uh share of the American population. Right? So that's a work uh for intellectuals as well as practical political people to say, okay, the left is an ideological enemy.

SPEAKER_02What is an ideology that both appeals and is responsive? This happened before Reagan, like when Republicans and conservatives were totally out of power, Carter was in office, there's a guy named Frank Meyer who came along with this fusionist idea, it was brilliant, of putting together basically libertarianism with religiosity and saying this can be a winning coalition. And he put that together intellectually, and boy, did it ever work. It worked for two terms and then a third term with the first Bush and two more terms with the second Bush.

SPEAKER_02It was a really successful coalition. We need to do that again. And lastly, that new fusion, it has to be expressed a lot more concretely than I have expressed it in my sort of monologue thus far, right? Sure, someone like me is going to express this in terms of large-scale ideological clash that isn't going to sell with the American people. We need to find durable, popular issues that are, as it were, the carrier pigeons for these larger ideological ideas, uh, things that will defeat the ideological left, but in a way that is linked to concrete policy like school choice or border control or protecting women's sports and assemble a new view, a new coalition, and people to carry that particular torch in the next election.

SPEAKER_01Josh, let me just say before getting Catherine in there, like all that sounds really amazing and right, but it's not the job. Of the next candidate. It's not the job of the Republican Party. It's actually the job of us here. It's the job of whoever has been infecting K-12 education over the last two generations, right? It's that's what this task really is, right? Because the problem is it's easy to win elections when you've won all the other institutions that then shape the people who will be voting in those elections.

SPEAKER_01And what you're describing is less a party platform and more, how do we stamp this out root and branch, you know, from uh the underlying institutions? And we start by talking about it. We start by having this podcast. Hopefully, more people will listen to this podcast. We talk about all those issues that you uh uh describe, but like I don't know, what you've just just described is dark in the sense that it is a generational project, it is not something that the Republicans can just assume the mantle of in 2028 and win, right?

SPEAKER_02Well uh conquering the institutions, taking back the institutions as a generational project. Um, coming up with a new vision, though those things can happen really fast, right? Bill Clinton repudiated a tradition of democratic politics that were more left-wing, and he became the torchbearer of the party and he won an election, and everything was different for a long time after that, right? So I think it can happen pretty fast. I do think it's sort of shared labor, like um it ha it involves people who are intellectuals kind of kind of thinking about what a new fusionist idea could look like that would win the American people and that would um uh repudiate the left and what issues that's associated with, and then some charismatic uh elected uh leaders to run for office and carry that that uh that viewpoint forward.

SPEAKER_02And you know, we need to, we we had a sort of we had the Reagan viewpoint, the Reagan ideology, which I don't use in this case as a bad word or word of opprium. It's just a set of linked ideas. And then it was sort of toned down and carried forward by both Bushes, which is 12 years of presidencies, right? And then Trump overthrew it. I think his overthrowing it was really important and really necessary for the reasons you talked about earlier, Elon, that that um uh it it had become so corporatist that it was just completely out of touch with real American problems.

SPEAKER_02And and it was also kind of cowardly. I mean, on these issues of identity, they were like, we're gonna talk, we're gonna talk economy, we're gonna talk foreign policy, we're gonna avoid issues of identity like the plague because someone might call us names, right? So Trump came in with courage and he talked about those cultural issues and he pushed back on them and he um um rethought some of the economic premises in ways that were much more responsive to working class concerns, and that was awesome. Now we're coming to the end of the Trump era and we need to rethink things and we need to uh come up with a new vision for the Republican Party.

SPEAKER_02Because make no mistake, this was a repudiation of the Republican Party at a very, very large scale, right? And we that means that we need to, we're in the wilderness and we need to do some hard thinking. What do you think, Catherine?

SPEAKER_00Well, I agree. I think I'm just yeah, I think that we have to make sure we take the right lessons from um the repudiation, which is the part I'm nervous about. Um, I think uh there's a lot of people who you can already see the infighting want to claim it's because of I see people claiming it's because of like ICE action. I mean, the thing that really got Trump elected, promising to deport people. Now people are saying that that is the reason that people didn't come out to vote. I just don't buy that. And so I think there's gonna be a lot of discussion about why it is that people really pushed out the Republican Party.

SPEAKER_00And I hope we can get to the source of uh the truth.

SPEAKER_01That is a good point, which is the electorate can be schizophrenic, right? It's like, oh yeah, of course we've got to stop the border, of course we need large amounts of deportations, but not anybody who came before 2019 or you know, not if we have to detain someone who's been here since 20, you know, 2000, right? And so it is a bit schizophrenic. They want, you know, everything and the moon, and it's like, well, you know, these require some some costs and some exaction, right, to accomplish. So that's super interesting.

SPEAKER_02Could I I I completely agree with you, Elon, and and and and you, Catherine, about like taking the right lessons from this. But part of what's going on there is that the American people want things, but they are very, very attached to the value of compassion. So they do not like all the illegal immigration. Uh, there is a solid uh segment of the public, probably a majority, that is even in favor of deportations. But if it seems hard-hearted, if it seems cruel, if it seems violent, they will turn against it, right?

SPEAKER_02If you show them pictures, I mean it's that compassion switch, right? And one thing I think that the left and uh generally the Democratic Party and the liberal movement, the progressive movement, like all of those kind of broadly on the left side of the spectrum pieces of the political puzzle, they have done such a good job of owning compassion. Right? Now, I've talked about this on the pod before. I think a lot of that compassion is fake compassion. I think that if you look at their compassion, it has, it has um, there's always like a shadow in it.

SPEAKER_02There's always some hard-heartedness in it, you know. Uh performative, maybe. It's performative. Sometimes it's also just hardening your heart, right? So compassion for the criminal offender, none for the crime victim, compassion for the um black oppressed, not for the uh oppressor because of his ancestors. Right, right. So maybe you're you're so concerned for the Palestinians, but not for the Jews. You're so concerned for the uh uh black applicant to an elite school, but not for the Asian. I mean, it's almost these in these competitive situations that define the world, a lot of their compassion is actually just, I'm in favor of this group and against that one.

SPEAKER_02But I think that what the right needs to do is instead of saying we don't care about compassion, which will never sell with women and won't even sell with all men, we need to own compassion better. And that goes to, yeah, yeah, deport people, but at every stage in it, show compassion in such a way that we don't lose the people who care about that the most.

SPEAKER_01So the two uh lessons for those following at home of the podcast so far is Republicans are right, but need to focus on messaging and compassion in particular and get rid of open primaries. Uh okay, primary elections. No, I'm just kidding. All right. So we do want to focus on law, and uh we uh are trying to keep this special election episode a little tighter, so we don't want to go too much longer. So let me uh take this back to Alaska. Um, and in the previous episode and other podcasts have been talking about this, you know, we talked about Dan Sullivan, uh, both Dan Sullivan, the real Dan Sullivan, and decoy Dan Sullivan.

SPEAKER_01Uh, and we proposed that they may have actually been committing crimes and so on. And so I also posted a little bit about this on X and got some you know blowback from people who apparently have no reading comprehension skills, but maybe it's me who doesn't have the reading comprehension. So I don't know, but there's a lot of developments have been there uh on that story. So uh a few things I wanted to mention. First, I wanted to give a shout out to Harvard Law professor Steve Sachs, uh a the Scalia chair uh at Harvard Law School and a co-author of Josh. If you go back to our previous episode on Give Parents the Vote, great episode.

SPEAKER_01Uh Josh and Steve wrote that article together. He made a really insightful point on X that I wanted to highlight. He said that in elections, we are very much used to what is called in the law, fraud in the inducement. Okay, so we are used to that, right? So everybody knows that candidates are lying about their positions and beliefs to get elected. But that's okay, joke's on us. Like we we know that you're lying to us in that respect. That's called fraud in the inducement, right? But fraud in the fact is very different, right? Duping everyone by making them think someone else is the actual candidate is actually so that you're not actually voting for the person you think you're voting for is totally different in kind.

SPEAKER_01And actually, Josh, correct me if I'm wrong, but in criminal law, isn't there a difference between fraud in the inducement and fraud in the fact? I I don't remember exactly from my criminal law class in law school, I'm not a criminal law person, but you know, fraud in the inducement to get someone to sleep with you. Like, I'm sorry, that's not sexual abuse. Um, it's you know, it's not sexual assault. Fraud in the fact is trickier, though there are some jurisdictions where it's like if you have a twin and you pretend to be the other person, so your twin's wife sleeps with you. I mean, there are cases like that, or like you come in in the dark and sh, you know, she thinks it's her husband, or you know, like uh and so but if you just lie and say, like, oh, I'm really wealthy to get someone to sleep with you, that's fine.

SPEAKER_00Because exactly. Yes.

SPEAKER_02Yes, that is fraud in the inducement about that. On um some one of the dating websites uh um did an analysis of its data. I think it was OKCupid or something. I I don't know if that one's still big. I'm sort of out of the game for a long time now. But uh happily married, happily but they they found that men's height, it the the men on their website were on average two inches taller than the national average, which is like impossible on a population scale.

SPEAKER_02Like it was just like mass lying about height. And there was something about women too that was like the original.

SPEAKER_01Because those because the the two, if you're two inches taller than the natural average, you probably have less need to be on the apps, right? That the shorter gets. So it's actually extra lying. It's not just two inches of a five. That's possible. There's probably five inches of lying.

SPEAKER_02All over the world, there is this. If you survey people about how many people they've slept with, men report much higher numbers than women. Much higher numbers, like three times the numbers uh that women report. And the question that it turns out to be mathematically impossible within a fixed population, on average, both sexes need to have slept with the same number of people unless you have like a lot of sex tourism or something like that. So um we know mathematically that it's untrue, but the question has always been which sex is lying?

SPEAKER_02Or is it both? Are they both equally lying? And okay, we now have the answer. Uh, it is women who are lying about that one. Uh exclusively. Well, let me almost entirely.

SPEAKER_01Let me rein it back in. But I thought that that was a pretty good point about fraud in the inducement versus fraud in the fact. I also think like some people were defending this as like, oh, ballot stacking is common. Like, yeah, it's common to recruit candidates of different parties that might attract like certain voters to those particular ideas, like the Green Party or the Libertarian Party. That's not deception, that's just smart strategy. This is deception and shame on all the people uh that were involved. Okay, now we talked about this on the last episode. Um, Dan Sullivan may have committed a crime. Uh, and I posted the the decoy Dan.

SPEAKER_01Decoy Dan, excuse me. I yeah, who am I even talking about? That's the problem. Decoy Dan Sullivan may have committed a crime. We talked about this, um, I think it was uh uh I don't have the exact number in front of me, but 50 USC something we we talked about on last episode, and you can see it on X where I posted it. Uh, here again uh is the language. No person who is a candidate for federal office shall fraudulent fraudulently misrepresent himself or uh any committee or organization under his control, as speaking or writing, or otherwise acting for or on behalf of any other candidate on a matter which is damaging to such a candidate.

SPEAKER_01A lot of left-wing people came out of hiding on my X feed and said, Well, he is really Dan Sullivan, so how could he be you know uh committing a crime here? And it's like read the statute. Yes, he really is Dan Sullivan, and he's hoping to confuse people by misrepresenting himself as the other Dan Sullivan. It literally fits the language, and so I think uh he committed uh a crime there. I also wanted to, and I wanted to defend that position that we took. I also think um people are talking about 18 section 241, which is a much more severe felony.

SPEAKER_01I think it's from the Ku Klux Klan Acts or the Enforcement Acts in the 1870s, but this is called a conspiracy against rights, and it basically makes it a crime to quote conspire to injure, oppress, threaten, or intimidate any person in the free exercise or enjoyment of any right or privileges secured to him by the Constitution or laws of the United States. This is a serious felony. You think KKK violence preventing people like black people, the freed people from going to the polls. Now, as an initial matter, my gut is there's no way that Dan, the decoy Dan violated the statute. Because again, when I read injure, oppress, threaten, or intimidate, I think like, you know, I'm gonna shoot you if you come vote for the candidate.

SPEAKER_01I know you what your politics are, right? I think of physical violence. And that probably is the correct original meaning of the statute, what they probably had in mind. If you just look at it, injure, oppress, threaten, or intimidate a person. It strikes me as physical violence or some kind of coercion. But it has been interpreted to it cover things like uh ballot stuffing. So if you stuff a ballot, right? So you literally steal an election by putting in fake ballots.

SPEAKER_02What do you think about the word intimidate? Because like imagine that the KKK, instead of uh trying to back in back in the days of Reconstruction, if the if KKK people, instead of you know beating up black people who are trying to vote or threatening their lives, what if they threaten their jobs or their economic, their ability to earn a living? Like if you vote, if we see you in that line to vote, we're gonna make sure you never work in this town again. I mean, that strikes me as a violation of the statute.

SPEAKER_01I agree. So I think I overclaimed when I said physical violence or injury. Um, I do think to threaten or intimidate can include sort of economic consequences. I agree with that. I still think that is a classical tangible type of injury, like physical or economic harm, the kind of injury that would be recoverable in like tort or something. That's how I read it. But how would you get to the ballot stuffing case? Well, you would say the right to vote has been injured, right? And it's like, well, I kind of see that, but it doesn't fit with oppress threaten or intimidate, right?

SPEAKER_01So I anyway.

SPEAKER_02Um like confront.

SPEAKER_00Oppress to me as a normal person seems like obviously they're trying to oppress people and like keeping them from voting, doesn't it?

SPEAKER_01Or deceive them in how they vote? Oh, okay, yeah, fair enough. So my my instinct is that it wouldn't cover these situations. But if you want to say you are oppressing them because you are denying them the right to vote by basically faking ballots, and so they effectively don't have the right to vote. Uh it's just like if that was what the statute was was really aimed at, what would you would have said is anyone conspired to deny this right to someone, right? And that's not what it says. It's not saying conspiring to deny, it says injure a press fight or intimidate.

SPEAKER_01Look, so fair enough, you guys have come up with arguments on the text of why I'm reading it too narrowly. But the point is, you're right in terms of the case law. The cases have long interpreted this to include something like ballot stuffing. And um, so you know, fine. And and actually uh it was used. Who was that? There was some guy uh who uh did a joke tweet uh where he's like, don't forget Democrats vote on Wednesday, you know, or something like that. Obviously joking. And he was prosecuted under this statute, I think. And or or and there was also something like uh He like went to jail, I think, under Biden, didn't he?

SPEAKER_01Correct. And he appealed, I think, successfully on First Amendment grounds. So anyway, the point is like I'm less skeptical that he has injured or oppressed them by denying them the right to vote. Uh but again, if ballot stuffing works, if saying something like Wednesday, vote on Wednesday is covered, then I think Dan Sullivan, decoy Dan may be covered under this statute. But again, I read the original words a bit more narrowly. But if if it is narrow, then I don't think there's a general federal criminal prohibition on ballot stuffing. And maybe that's the problem, right?

SPEAKER_02But but here's the thing it's not just decoy Dan here, because we now have clear information from this New York Times story, assuming true, that uh there was a conspiracy to deceive voters on the part of the Piloda campaign, right? So it's not just about this dude, this otherwise trivial dude who would have lived and died in obscurity if not for this, uh, if not for this mass deception of Alaska voters. It's not just about him, it's about a campaign finding him, searching for him, uh, in order to deceive the voters.

SPEAKER_02And so the criminal effects, if there's any crime at all, it's a lot bigger than decoy Dan. It encompasses a lot more people. What does that mean for the election? Probably nothing. Probably if she wins, she still wins. And it's really distressing because uh last I checked, she was ahead by 600 votes. And decoy Dan pulled.

SPEAKER_01Catherine pulled the numbers. What are the numbers?

SPEAKER_00I just updated them again to see if anything else has come in. So we're recording this on Wednesday, so maybe by the time you listen, you all will know. But he, Mary Piltola is only ahead by about 600 votes, and Dan J. Sullivan, Decoy Dan, has 3,583 votes. So as we know from the original lawsuit, wouldn't this mean if it was successful that uh there would be some kind of relitigation of the election?

SPEAKER_02But it probably wouldn't reverse the election.

SPEAKER_01I mean, well, there's one thing that could there's one thing that could reverse it. And so, Josh, I agree with you, you can't reverse it at this point. But you know what? The Senate could refuse to seat her. Now it's never gonna do it, but hear me out. A sensible, healthy institution would do it. The Democrats already have 54, maybe 55. Do they need the 56? You know, the Democrats could say, hey, you know what? We really agree that deception is bad and we are gonna fall on our swords for our democracy here because you already have 55 seats. Do you really need that 56 seats?

SPEAKER_01And the clause in the constitution that allows them to do it, the clause that allows them to do it is each house shall be the judge of the elections, returns the qualifications of its own members. Article 1, section five, clause one, which again, Congress can't you know expand the qualifications for office. So the constitution says you must be a citizen for extra number of years, you must be of a certain age, and you must reside in the in the state, an inhabitant of the state. Okay. They can't add things to that, like saying, oh, you must be a member of a district or you must own property. But they can say you were not properly elected because you conspired, you committed fraud, and you conspired to deceive voters.

SPEAKER_01They could do it. They could do it, but it would be the new Congress, and so of course, uh they won't do it. But Democrats, think about it. Healthy institution. We are at about 40 minutes. I I know we wanted to keep this special election episode short. Uh, but we did talk about law as well. You know, various federal criminal statutes. We talked about the constitution just now. Any concluding thoughts that you guys really want our listeners uh to take to take away on this special election episode?

SPEAKER_00I'll add one more thing that I thought was interesting that I haven't seen a lot of people talk about yet. Um, and I don't, I didn't put the states right in front of me, but there are a number of states where what I would call more conservative ballot measures actually passed while they elected um representatives who are against those measures. So, for example, like the trans men in women's sports, there are states where measures saying, no way, not gonna happen here in our state, passed, but they elected radical Democrats who have said, I think there should be men in women's locker rooms.

SPEAKER_00I can't square that. It's very confusing to me. And I saw that also with voter ID and some other things. I don't get that. And so, I mean, one of my theories here in Minnesota for a long time has been that are most of the people in Minnesota want to elect Democrats who do conservative policy. When you actually pull them on their beliefs, people are much more conservative than how they vote. And why is that? I I don't know, but there's something to be said, I think, Josh, for your theory and the theory we've talked about here on this show before that has to do with compassion.

SPEAKER_00They think Republicans are too mean, uh, something like that. And I think there's a missing messaging there where we're not lining up the policy with the people correctly. And I haven't seen people really talking about it yet, but I'd love for that discussion to keep going because I think that's very interesting.

SPEAKER_02Um, well, I know I agree with Obama years. Go ahead, Josh, you first. Sorry, it's happening again. Um I I agree with you, Catherine. I think that that there's something missing here where people, you know, lots and lots of Americans do not agree with um oh, take uh racial preferences. Racial preferences have been pulled every way since Sunday, and they've been tested in referenda after referenda, including in very, very liberal uh states like California, for example, and Michigan.

SPEAKER_02They always lose. Racial preferences are durably unpopular with the American people. For 40 years, about 70 to 80 percent of America has been against racial preferences. And guess what? They are universally used in institutions and they are supported by the entire Democratic Party and quietly not opposed until Trump by most of the Republican Party. People do not agree with it, but somehow it keeps on going. And that's not the only example of it. The trans issue now is similar, right?

SPEAKER_02They are um the open borders, the immigration issue is similar. So what's happening is that there are these policy positions and values that are popular, but they're packaged in such a way that people are like, oh no, not that. That seems, again, I think compassion is the critical thing. That seems hard-hearted, that seems mean. And I don't think the Republican Party is or should be or should allow itself to be seen as mean or hard-hearted or lacking compassion.

SPEAKER_01Well, I think the Obama administration years might be an example of this, right? Every time Obama's policies have been on the ballot in the midterms and so on, um, they have lost, right? They lost all the time. But there was something about like electing the first African-American president where it's like an act of compassion and rectifying past harms and so on. So I think that's actually support for this. Well, we are out of time. Thank you for joining us on this really special uh election day. A little sad, but very special election uh day episode from the Rashley based podcast. Don't forget to hit that like and subscribe button. And we'll see you next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Episode 48 | Conservative Legal Education?

    Nov 19, 202652 minAudio

    In this special episode, law professors Josh Kleinfeld and Ilan Wurman sit down with Adam Biggs of the University of Austin, at Texas (UATX). The new school has made waves since the concept for it was introduced in 2021...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Episode 47 | Smoke-Filled Rooms and Climate Litigation

    Nov 12, 202656 minAudio

    Should the parties pick their candidates in smoke-filled rooms, or does that just hand control back to the elites? And can Boulder, Colorado sue Exxon and Suncor for the costs of climate change? Hosts Kathryn Johnson...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Episode 46 | Sex and Scholarship

    Nov 9, 202642 minAudio

    In a Tennessee manslaughter trial, the judge barred the jury from learning that the deceased - the defendant’s sexual partner of two years - was a biological male who identified as a woman. The appeals court reversed,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Episode 44 | Midterm Mayhem

    Oct 29, 20261 hr 12 minAudio

    A Brazilian Supreme Court justice who used to be Lula’s personal lawyer ordered the polls kept open for two hours after they were supposed to close. Another ordered the opposition candidate, Bolsonaro, to surrender his...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Episode 43 | Guns, Religion, and Immigration: The Rules Just Changed

    Oct 22, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    Trump’s Office of Legal Counsel has been on a tear, and hosts Ilan Wurman, Kathryn Johnson, and Joshua Kleinfeld explain the big developments. Guns: OLC announced that the federal ban on selling handguns to...

    Credit the people on this episode