Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

rationally BASED

rationally BASED artwork

Episode 47 | Smoke-Filled Rooms and Climate Litigation

Nov 12, 202656 minAudio

Should the parties pick their candidates in smoke-filled rooms, or does that just hand control back to the elites? And can Boulder, Colorado sue Exxon and Suncor for the costs of climate change? Hosts Kathryn Johnson and law professors Joshua Kleinfeld and Ilan Wurman take on both issues on the latest episode of Rationally BASED. First, Ilan revisits the discussion from the midterms about primaries. He argues that pure majoritarianism has always had defects - faction, self-interest, the capacity for depravity - and that the Founders designed representation to refine and enlarge the public views. Primaries hand the nomination to the most ideological sliver of the electorate. Conventions of delegates embedded in their communities might better reflect what voters actually want. Josh’s response is that elite control is the deeper problem. On immigration, racial preferences, crime, schools, and more, elite institutions have overridden clear popular majorities for decades. Who's right? Next: Boulder is suing fossil-fuel companies under state common-law theories - public nuisance, trespass, unjust enrichment - for local costs it attributes to climate change. The causation chain is extraordinarily thin; the companies are a tiny fraction of global emissions. The legal theory is also thin: Boulder is abusing an old and venerable doctrine, nuisance, and twisting it for Leftist ends. But the federal preemption defenses are pretty weak. The cleaner objection may be that the claims are so detached from traditional nuisance and trespass that allowing them to go forward would be a due-process problem - liability without preexisting law. But are there risks to that approach? Would it hand too much power to federal judges? This is the rational - and based - discussion of populism, elite power, and climate litigation that you won’t hear anywhere else. Be sure to LIKE, SHARE, COMMENT, and SUBSCRIBE to rationally BASED! Subscribe to our Substack! New Podcast Episodes every Thursday morning, find us on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or on YouTube! Follow us on social media on Instagram, X, Facebook, and TikTok!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02Welcome back to Rationally Based, a podcast about law and politics on the edge. I'm Elon Werman, a law professor at the University of Minnesota Law School. I'm Josh Kleinfeld, Ralph's professor of law at Scalia Law School.

SPEAKER_00And I'm Catherine Johnson with Center of the American Experiment.

SPEAKER_02Hey Catherine, what's on deck?

SPEAKER_00Well, we're finally turning back to the Supreme Court. We're circling back to a blockbuster case that was argued in October, involving whether Boulder Colorado can sue energy companies for climate change. We've listened to a lot of commentary on this case, and we don't think the pundits are getting it quite right. So first, we will talk about the ridiculous factual and legal claims. Second, we'll talk about the federal defenses at the court. Third, we'll tell you how we think the case should be resolved. But before all that, Elon, you wanted to talk a little more about populism, so we will start there.

SPEAKER_02Let's dive in. Well, as always, please hit that like and subscribe button. Really, really uh helps. Follow us on Substack, rationally based at substack.com. Stay in touch with us. Give us give us those uh reviews and ratings. They really help with this early stage of a podcast. Catherine, you're a little under the weather.

SPEAKER_02Thanks for joining us anyway. How are you feeling?

SPEAKER_00Uh like lower energy than Jeb at his lowest of energies. But uh I will get through it for the rationally based squad. Thank you. But if I do fall asleep, no one say anything. And we'll just afterward have him. Isaac can cut me out, maybe. Okay. So just let me sleep if that happens.

SPEAKER_02Low energy, Jeb. I that's a nice throwback. Um, well, I'm we are glad you're here to help us through this episode. I will do a little bit of setup setup here. We are not a Supreme Court podcast. Um many of our competitors focus on the Supreme Court, which is you know great for that purpose. We are uh a podcast more broadly about political ideas and legal ideas, law and philosophy, and just more general trends in law. But occasionally there are really interesting things that the Supreme Court is doing, not often, but sometimes. Uh and we wanted to circle, start circling back to some of those cases.

SPEAKER_02And there's one we've been wanting to talk about for a long time, the Sun Court case, which is sort of about climate change. And as Catherine suggested in the intro, we think people are getting it wrong. But I got, you know, some people were talking to me about our midterm episode. Uh, and uh, you know, some of them told me that I should have pushed harder on both of you, actually, and that the um my claim about the primaries that we should get rid of uh primary elections, direct primaries, uh, was a good one. And I just kind of wanted to resurface that. So I wanted to revisit that discussion briefly. And uh, Josh, you had mentioned that you know you are a populist, you're for populism.

SPEAKER_02And if you have, if you get rid of these primary elections, all you're gonna do is have elite control over uh the parties. And you made a good point about how we have all of these issues that people really want, and they never seem uh to uh you know uh uh to get effectuated uh when these politicians are elected. And in that respect, recall that I said that Trump's election was salutary in a way, right? You don't want elite control, you don't want the government to be controlled uh by a small uh cadre of wealthy and politically powerful elites who only serve themselves.

SPEAKER_02That's true. That's always been true. That's always been the risk of an aristocratic, monarchical government, you know, corrupting itself into an oligarchy or a despotism, right? But we don't necessarily want to fall in the other extreme, right? It's not like pure popular passions and pure populism is also an unadulterated good, is it? In other words, the question has always been how do we create a government of the people, by the people, and for the people, but one that is attuned to the flaws of people and of human nature, right?

SPEAKER_02So there's no question that our government has to be popular, republican. James Madison said this in Federal's uh 39, and if uh I pulled it up here, so if if you'll let me read it, it says the fur he said in Federal's 39, the first question that offers itself is whether the general form and aspect of the government be strictly Republican. It is evident that no other form would be reconcilable with the genius of the people of America, with the fundamental principles of the revolution, or that honorable determination which animates every votary of freedom to rest all our political experiments on the capacity of mankind for self-government.

SPEAKER_02If the plan of the Constitutional Convention therefore be found to depart from the Republican character, its advocates must abandon it as no longer defensible. So they wanted popular government because they had seen the problems that arose from aristocratic or monarchical government. But the problem is, as Madison said, and Hamilton said, and others said, you know, there are also defects to popular rule because people have this capacity for self-government, Madison said, but they also have a capacity for an astonishing amount of depravity, right? And so in Federalist 455, Madison said, as there is a degree of depravity in mankind which requires a certain degree of circumspection and distrust, so there are other qualities in human nature which justify a certain portion of esteem and confidence.

SPEAKER_02And how is this depravity reflected in democratic politics? Well, factional spirit, you know, of tribalistic voting, putting one's own self-interest ahead of uh the common interest of the whole people. So how do you do this? Well, the the founders wanted to, they thought the representative mechanism would refine and enlarge the public views, right? It's you filter populism, you filter popular passions. Federalist 10, right? The whole point is you want to create Republican remedies for the diseases most incident to Republican government, right? So it's a balance.

SPEAKER_02I kind of like the old mixed regime of the British Constitution, except they kind of messed that up, you know, the lead up to the revolution, where you know, you want the people to be a check on the elite and you want the elite to be a check on the people, this old mixed government, which we don't really talk about because we don't really talk about classes of men anymore. Uh, but uh, you know, there is a lot going for that for millennia people thought in in those terms since Aristotle, right, and the best regime. So, Josh, okay, that's enough of what I wanted to say. My question to you Are you jettisoning all of this that the founders believed in in terms of yes, popular government, but we need to control popular passions as well, in favor of some unadulterated populism?

SPEAKER_02You know, the people can vote for really terrible things. Uh, they could vote to redistribute wealth, they could vote, uh, you know, basically create a majority tyranny. Are you? Are you just uh that's just not the concern you have right now, but long term you that's a concern of yours? What is this motivating uh desire when you say, you know, you're a populist um in this in the sense that we were talking about last week?

SPEAKER_01Well well, thanks, Elon. I I do appreciate the invitation to talk about this larger theme. I'm uh I'm a populist. I'm trying to be um uh to help craft the sort of intellectual backbone of of right-wing populism and uh and think through what that means. And so these are really welcome questions, they're hard questions. Let me start by being clear about what I'm defending and then why I'm defending it. Because if I I have to be clear about what I'm defending, first of all, I'm not saying there are no occasions where voters get things wrong.

SPEAKER_01Voters are fallible. I'm not claiming they're infallible. I'm not saying there's no room to structure democratic governance, right? I mean, we should have structures in democratic governance. Uh, the party system is a structure. Federalism is a structure, right? We um we decide on what level we should have popular control, you know, local or state or national. And I'm finally, maybe most importantly, I'm not saying there are no sacred rights that are beyond majority control.

SPEAKER_01I don't think the majority should get to decide what religion I have, for example, or how I live in my family, or something like that. There are there are such a thing as truly sacred rights. What I think you're getting wrong is how bad elite control is. And, you know, when you think about your sort of romance for the mixed constitution of the British, how bad that was and could be again, how bad it would be in our system. Uh, so my argument here starts from a think about how bad it could be. So my own story about this, my sort of journey to this perspective politically starts with racial preferences and communism slash socialism.

SPEAKER_01Start with racial preferences, right? It every institution I have ever been a part of throughout my entire life, whether it was, you know, a law firm or a school or a university or a, I don't know, um, when I go to the post office, so when I buy a Coca-Cola and I interact with the company of Coca-Cola, every single one of them is doing racial preferences. They are selecting students that way, they're picking partners at the law firm that way, they're picking corporate leadership that way.

SPEAKER_01The federal government does that, right? At least it did until this iteration of the Trump administration. The federal government has formal preferences for contracting with businesses that are minority-led or women-led. And as we'll talk about later in the uh actually in the separate episode, um, um the federal government encouraged the formation of racial affinity groups. Do you know that racial preferences are opposed by about 80% of the American public and have been in every poll ever testing it, and have been in every referenda that ever put it to a vote?

SPEAKER_01In fact, racial preferences are unpopular among racial minorities. They are unpopular, for example, among black Americans. Racial preferences, which I think are injustice of the first order, because I care so much about racial justice, I really do, but I don't agree with that conception of racial justice. Racial preferences are an elite preference that have been imposed throughout our society in the behavior of government and in uh uh the behavior of private institutions, notwithstanding the people's stable supermajoritarian opposition to it.

SPEAKER_01And because of the people's stable, supermajoritarian opposition, it almost never gets through legislation. It's done in the background by administrative agencies passing regulations or by private entities making policy. Communism socialism. Communism socialism has been incredibly popular with intellectuals and always has been. Always I have books on my shelf right here. 1848, that was when the communist manifesto was written, The Intellectuals and The Revolution of the Intellectuals, the beginning of communism.

SPEAKER_01Friedrich Hayek, The Intellectuals and Socialism, Whitaker Chambers Witness about the romance of 1930s intellectuals with communism and their readiness to forgive Stalin's purges on that basis.

SPEAKER_02And to our listening audience, Josh has just been um retrieving books from his enormous bookshelf library.

SPEAKER_00I'm impressed you can find them in this selection, Josh. I mean, oh my gosh.

SPEAKER_01I know my bookshelves. Where's that other one? It's called The Reckless Mind. It's about the intellectuals. It's by Mark Leela. Whatever. I can't find it right now. That one I can actually can't find. These are all in my Cold War section.

SPEAKER_00Um I organize my bookshelves by color.

SPEAKER_01Okay, so here's my point. Um, these two things, which are probably the worst things in the last hundred years, um, the uh uh communism socialism on the one hand and uh racial preferences and racial balkanization on the other, um, they are both intellectual elite obsessions. Um they have to do with moral self-esteem and social credit and self-protection, right?

SPEAKER_01I mean, how how is it that we have these racial preferences that are so insulated, right? That and the major majorities are against it, but elites are for it. Well, for some elites, by by being for communism or for racial preferences, they think I'm helping the unfortunate. That makes me a good person. That's moral self-esteem. Or other people will think I'm a good person. That's that's social credit. Or I don't want to talk about this because I don't want to be called a racist or, you know, um told that I'm hard-hearted or something like that.

SPEAKER_01That's self-protection. And in every case among the elite of Trump, immigration. Immigration is one of your issues that you care about most. Half of Americans opposed um the excesses of immigration going way back into the 90s. Uh, by the way, overwhelmingly in the Republican Party, when we were getting, you know, the Bushes who were all for untrammeled immigration, Republicans opposed uh immigration. Uh they thought it was excessive. And almost all Americans opposed illegal immigration when both parties were turning a blind eye to it and Democrats were absolutely opposing it.

SPEAKER_01The elite of both parties didn't care. The fact that it has economic consequences for working class Americans, they don't care. They're not a working class Americans. Wait, wait, let me just give one more example. You're also really interested in homelessness and social disorder, right? With tolerance of crime, going back to the 1970s and again in the 2000s with the crime wave we saw with BLM, social disorder, vandalism, thefts of her business, um, people, you know, camping out in the parks and ruining our cities. What the elites do is they buy their way out, they give themselves, again, moral self-esteem, social credit, and other people have to actually use the subway, right?

SPEAKER_01So that's an externalities issue. They could impose the cost on you and take the credit for themselves. So so I have much more to say, but why don't I just pause there for a second so you can get a word in? But this is about all of these, like, how many awful things do we have to see before we realize that the structure behind all of those awful things is elite power?

SPEAKER_02I agree a hundred percent with the problem. I don't agree with the diagnosis because actually, all of those things got substantially worse. Communism and its its effect on the Democratic Party, racial preferences and its effect in the Democratic Party, sort of in the culture, crime, all of that got worse in the 70s. We only got nationwide direct primaries in the 1970s.

SPEAKER_01Wait, so you're making a causal connection between nationwide direct prime uh primaries and all the bad things in the 70s? Like, where do you get that from? There's a lot different thing.

SPEAKER_02Hold on, hold on. All these bad things you're describing came after direct primaries. Okay. That doesn't mean direct primaries cause them. Uh I I know, but yesterday, last time, when I talked about how direct primaries are a problem, you were worried about elite control. Well, getting rid of direct primaries or having direct primaries hasn't solved any of the problems. In fact, all the problems you highlighted happened after. And so it's not an attack on direct primaries. The things that you just articulated are not attacks on direct primaries. And in fact, I think direct primaries are part of the cause, the problem, right?

SPEAKER_02Um, and I just want to do a quick shout out. Joe Postel wrote an excellent article yesterday, last night for when we're recording this, not sure exactly when we will uh release this, on Civitas, where he explains how conventions actually were democratic, they were deeply representative, right? Because they were, you know, although we joke about smoke-filled rooms, actually they were elected by local and state parties to go to a convention, and they actually met the candidates over three, four days. And so it wasn't just you know, wealthy people paying for 15-second ads, right? That you know, uh you actually got really good quality candidates and they cared about the general election.

SPEAKER_02That's that kind of process is what led to Democrats, from Harry Truman to John F. Kennedy, to being incredibly anti-communist, right? And it was only, and it they believe in things like law and order. But actually, there's something about the primary system where it allows these intellectual elites to join forces with the most, you know, sort of rabid part of the progressive left that shows up in the left wing primaries, right? And all of a sudden you get all these crazy ideas that weren't plausible before. Like McGovern, you know, almost getting elected or whatever his name was in the 70s because of, you know, uh uh these this primary uh sort of process.

SPEAKER_02And so uh it just seems to me that actually it allows the elite to hijack Democratic Party candidates, whereas historically, you know, you got people who were not super pro-immigration on either side. You just limited immigration. You had people who were pro, you know, being tough on crime, you had people who were against racial preferences, racial preference, all these things that you've highlighted emerged after. I'm not saying the direct primary caused them, but getting rid of the direct primary isn't gonna like make it worse. Okay, but you don't have to make it a lot better.

SPEAKER_01You don't have direct primaries in Europe, for example, right? You have party control of candidates, it's really parties running against each other in parliamentary systems. And what do we see over there? You know, we have wild, overwhelming immigration that's really transforming these much smaller countries because it's not a one part per 300 million, right? A million people in a country of 300 million. It's like 10 million in a country of 50 million. It's totally transformative, right? So that's immigration in Europe. Voters in Europe are overwhelmingly against the scale of immigration.

SPEAKER_01But both parties are routinely opposing them. It's changed a little bit in recent years, and the courts are opposing them. So what's happening in Europe with immigration and with the total transformation of those societies, which used to be torchbearers for the West, let's not forget the scale of what we've lost. They they used to be torchbearers for the for the Western world. Now they are in danger of falling completely. And voters have been frantically trying to control it, and the elites won't let them, right?

SPEAKER_01The courts won't let them. So uh Brexit. Do you know that Britain didn't just vote for Brexit once? There was a whole series of elections following the first election in favor of Brexit. Britain was trying to take itself out of the European Union consistently, every time voters got a chance to speak to it, and people of both parties were trying to prevent it as well as the courts. I was in the Philippines giving some lectures, and it was so interesting. Um, I asked uh, this was shortly after Duterte was elected, and I asked uh a woman, you know, I said, you know, you have daughters.

SPEAKER_01Uh Duterte is well known as this, you know, womanizer and philanderer. Uh, why do you support him? And she said to me, When you're actually afraid of being raped, you do not care if he has mistresses. And I thought, she said, and she went on to say, you care about whether he gets control of crime. And I thought, huh. Has Philippines had a crime wave? So I looked into it. Yes. The Philippines had a massive explosion of crystal meth, leading to a massive crime wave. So then I asked one of the leading legal officials of the prior administration, the one before Duterte, what were you doing about drugs and crime?

SPEAKER_01He said, we didn't think about it at all. I didn't even know drugs was an issue. Well, that's amazing because drugs was the issue. That'd be like being in America in like 2021 and being like, I didn't know COVID was an issue, right? It was the issue among ordinary Filipinos. But the elite don't even notice it. So when you get the structures you like, the you know, party picks the candidates kind of structures, it doesn't fix these problems. The better way to think about it, Elon, is that the the tendency, the proneness of all societies to come under elite control is just a constant.

SPEAKER_01And all societies are prone to it. But the nice thing about genuinely we the people driven democratic processes is every once in a while the people can break through and elect a Donald Trump, who is not a standard form Republican, who is not a Bush.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I I actually disagree pretty strongly with uh ever, you know, not the idea that you're saying, but again, the diagnosis, right? There are lots of reasons that Europe is going through what it is, including like the European Union stopping them from doing things, their courts stopping things from doing their government from doing things, right? I just don't connect to party control. And there are other reasons why here we have we would have decentralized party control, right? Every city and locality would have a different party. We just have a different system altogether. But it strikes me that the convention system actually worked. And there's nothing particularly democratic about you know letting 10% of you know uh the most ideological oriented pick these parties.

SPEAKER_02Once in a while, you have a stroke of genius and of luck, like 2016 or something. But anyway, let's let's move on. This is a much longer discussion. We got let's let's Josh, let's move on because we we've got to do the boulder thing. And I just want our audience to know that like this is a longer theme of our podcast. We're trying to figure out you know, what is the role of populism versus elite control, popular passions? That's what you know, we're trying to create an intellectual defense of a lot of the MAGA movement. Um, but there are also excesses of the MAGA movement, just like there are excesses of populism, and we and Josh and I don't agree necessarily exactly where the line is.

SPEAKER_02And it's just an ongoing debate that I think we should be having. But we promised Supreme Court, and you know, I don't care that much about the court, but Catherine, you want to set up our actual topic for the remaining 25 minutes or so?

SPEAKER_00Yes, happily. So, not related to anything we've been discussing so far, but like I said in the intro, we've seen a lot of people talking about this issue and either uh getting it wrong or just not really getting to the heart of the matter. So we're a little late on this one, but Elon, at least you felt the need to weigh in here. So Boulder County and the city of Boulder are suing Suncor and Exxon, two fossil fuel producers and their subsidiaries. Over alleged local harm and damage resulting from climate change.

SPEAKER_00When I first read the complaint, I thought this lawsuit was insane and based on complete inaccuracies about the climate, I would add. But here's their theory, Boulder's theory in a nutshell. A, Exxon and Suncar and Suncor produced and marketed large amounts of fossil fuels. B, combustion of those fuels contributed to global greenhouse gas emissions. C, greenhouse gas emissions contributed to climate change. D, climate change increases the likelihood or severity of wildfires, droughts, floods, and other events, requiring Boulder to incur costs to repair damage from such events.

SPEAKER_00Conduct environmental studies and implement prevention and mitigation strategies. And E, therefore, Exxon and Suncor contributed to and caused Boulder's associated environmental expenses and should pay up.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. So by the way, A through D, totally right and plausible. Yes, they make fossil fuels. I don't think that's disputed. Yes, fossil fuels contribute to greenhouse gas emissions. Yes, greenhouse gas emissions have some role to play in global climate change. And climate change increases the likelihood of all those things, I think probably.

SPEAKER_00D, I would say, is still up in the air.

SPEAKER_02Okay, Catherine's a science skeptic here. No. Totally, totally, totally fairly legitimate, right? I just want to be clear that there's a gap in the reasoning, Josh and Catherine, right, between C and D, right? Because greenhouse gas emissions, yes, do contribute to climate change. But how much of a contribution, which I know we'll get into slowly. So like to go from greenhouse gas emissions contribute to climate change and that climate change increases X, Y, and Z, itself there's a gap there in reasoning between C and D. But there's a huge gap between D and E, which is, you know, therefore Exxon and Suncor contributed somehow.

SPEAKER_02Uh, right.

SPEAKER_00Well, even if you even if you think that climate change does increase the likelihood of severe, you know, events like wildfires and droughts and things like that, we have no idea by how much and what there are plenty of other factors at play there.

SPEAKER_02Exactly. Okay, Josh, what's your take on this uh crazy lawsuit? And then we'll do some law too.

SPEAKER_01Well, you know, uh, let me start with a confession. I have a soft spot for clever plaintiffs' lawyers. Uh, you know, often those those suits that my fellow conservatives hate are are grimy, but they're so creative and so entrepreneurial. I just I just kind of like that. Uh but this is not that. This is politics by other means. These are progressives who can't get their way through legislatures, who can't get their way through the democratic process. So they bring outrageous legal claims, counting on politicized judges, which they themselves appointed, right?

SPEAKER_01Because there's Colorado with Colorado judges, um, which they themselves appointed to let them have their way through the courts because they can't get it through the democratic process. So, you know, there's two problems here. First of all, they can't prove that climate change caused Boulders problems, and they can't prove that Suncor and Exxon caused the climate change that caused Boulders damage. So, like a fundamental principle of civil suits for damages, like all torts, right? Is that you have an injurer and an injury, and you have to show that the injurer caused the injury.

SPEAKER_01Like, like the structure is you have an someone who did the injury, someone who suffered the injury, the victim, and there was a causation between the two. And that's what creates this chain of responsibility where I can say to you, oh, you know, you burned my house down, you owe me money. I suffered an injury, you were the cause, you owe me money for my lost house, right?

SPEAKER_02And Josh, it torts in torts, there could be multiple causes, right? Which is what happened here. And so I think what tort, the restatement of torts says, and the general law of torts says if you are a substantial factor in bringing about, right? It has to be like a substantial factor. A substantial factor. Exxon? Substantial factor in bringing out like Boulder's injuries? Anyway, Josh, go ahead.

SPEAKER_01So I just think those principles are fundamental to justice as well as to law. They're sometimes altered by statute. But here, the causation structure is totally shattered. So the theory of the plaintiffs is that Exxon and Suncor um led to fossil fuel being used, and fossil fuel led to climate change, and climate change led to Boulder having like more fires or something. So Suncor and Exxon owe Boulder money. But Suncor and Exxon produced a tiny fraction of the overall fossil fuel.

SPEAKER_01So, according to the complaint, this is the complaint, this is their complaint. Exxon contributed 16 billion tons of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere since 1988. And Suncor an additional 2 billion for 18 billion total. There are 3.3 trillion tons of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. There's over 1 trillion tons since 1988. So this is the tiniest fraction of emissions. You can't prove those fossil fuels, that fossil, well, let me put this even more broadly.

SPEAKER_01There are questions about whether fossil fuel leads to climate change, period. I'm not going to pretend to resolve those scientific claims here. I guess maybe I lay them somewhere in between you two where I tend to, I do want to believe the science, but the scientists in this context are the same people and the same class of people who have been unreliable in other contexts. So I just want to maintain a little reserve of skepticism in case it's called for. I'm inclined to believe this body of science, but I reserve a little bit of skepticism because of bad past experiences.

SPEAKER_01In any case, even if it's true that fossil fuel leads to climate change, you can't prove that climate change caused the particular problems Boulder is experiencing, or that Exxon and Suncor cause the particular problems that Boulder is experiencing. And plaintiffs, the plaintiffs didn't even try to tie their uh the defendants' contributions to the specific, like specific environmental events or harms because it's impossible. What they're really just saying is you know, Exxon and Suncor are big corporations, they're fossil fuel companies, they're bad, we hate them, let's sue them and make them pay.

SPEAKER_01And what this really is, is not a serious suit. They know that it's a political demonstration to their constituencies through the courts. It's a politicization of law. It actually has more in common with just the endless lawsuits pursued against Trump in the uh years before his second election than it does to any kind of serious suit for injury.

SPEAKER_02So, Catherine, um, what are the actual state law claims here? Did any of them seem plausible to you as a layperson?

SPEAKER_00Well, we were gonna focus on the nuisance claims, I think, after this, but Boulder also brought claims for trespass, unjust enrichment, and civil conspiracy. Basically, the trespass claim is that the companies caused physical things like floodwaters, hail, invasive species, and so on to intrude on Boulder's government-owned property. And no, I don't think that makes any sense to me based on everything we've said so far. I don't know, is there anything else to say on those claims? I know you want to get into the nuisance ones in particular, but what about like trespass?

SPEAKER_00Can a civil conspiracy? Or like can can climate change trespass?

SPEAKER_02Well, uh, to be clear to our listeners, a flood can create a trespass. Like if you release a dam from your property or uh you're upstream and you cause flooding lower down, yeah, that is a physical trespass, actually. If you throw a golf ball, you know, at a neighbor's house to annoy that person, but you don't physically enter, that's still a trespass because there's that physical invasion.

SPEAKER_00But what's what they're saying is like it's a naturally occurring flood in this case, right? There isn't a person doing the flooding.

SPEAKER_02Right. Well, the point it goes back to the causation question, right? Where the 0.1% contributed to a slight increase in the severity and risk, and therefore X, Y, or Z flood should be paid for by Exxon. I don't know. Josh, what do you think about the unjust enrichment stuff and all that?

SPEAKER_01Well, it's it's definitely not. I mean, unjust enrichment is characteristically for a situation in which you don't have a formal contract, but courts say there's an implied contract so as to prevent um so it's so as to provide some sort of restitution. So it's like if I buy a house and I overpay the escrow due to a typo, the seller has to return the overpayment. It's not designed for you made money and I don't like it. And trespass, like you're right that the core of Catherine's right, that the core of trespass is an intentional invasion of plaintiff's land.

SPEAKER_01You're I agree with you, Elon, of course. No one could disagree that that it it's Wait, stop right there.

SPEAKER_02No one could disagree with Elon. I don't know what else you were gonna say.

SPEAKER_01Let's just take that out of context and use it for everything, right? Um but uh there's uh forms of trespass that um don't involve direct body-to-body physical contact, like me walking into your house or something like that. But it still requires a direct causal chain between the actions of the defendant and physical events that occurred um with the plaintiff, right? So, like, well, if you and Catherine both live on the river and Catherine dams up the river and it causes a flood on your property, yeah, that was she did something physical on her land that affected your land physically.

SPEAKER_01That counts as a trespass in law.

SPEAKER_02But again, it's not just like actually, she did breathe and therefore um could contribute some amount of carbon dioxide to the atmosphere.

SPEAKER_00Have they thought about suing cows?

SPEAKER_02I know, right? Well, can I ask you, Josh, about unjust enrichment? Yeah, is has Boulder been unjustly enriched by all the benefits of fossil fuels and energy? And should that be should that be a compensating factor, right? In other words, if you want to go after me, okay. And Josh, we were talking a little bit about this before. You asked, you know, shouldn't they have to internalize the cost, right? Try to steel man the argument on the other side. And it's like, well, wait a minute. What do you mean internalize the cost? Look at all the benefits that you know have have accumulated to a wide variety of people, including Boulder, because of the Industrial Revolution and energy products.

SPEAKER_02So what do you mean they have to internalize this cost, right? We've all been enriched because of fossil fuels. So haven't aren't we the ones who have been unjustly enriched if they're the ones who have to suffer, you know, pay for the five.

SPEAKER_01I guess they have a sovereign immunity defense, right? But it's kind of, I mean, Exxon should hire you. You can sue Boulder for good question.

SPEAKER_02Is there sovereign immunity if you bring a cross complaint against a sovereign who's prosecuting you?

SPEAKER_01I actually don't know the answer to that question. I I have never seen that procedurally before. But okay, so unless we get into some legal weeds here, could I just say something about Yeah. I I want to say something a little bit bigger about climate change and lawsuits, right?

SPEAKER_02And then and then I will talk about my public nuisance and the federal claims and why I think everybody's been wrong about this, so our audience gets what I promised them. Okay, Josh, go. Um bigger picture of climate change.

SPEAKER_01Bigger picture. So you know, we all know that um we're in the midst of a huge controversy about climate change and how to deal with it. And um Democrats want to have more substantial environmental regulation to prevent it, and and Republicans, by and large, do not. And my claim about this is procedural. The place to resolve that is in the democracy and the elected branches. You, if you know, if Democrats get a supermajority, they've just gotten a huge majority, uh, then you pass some legislation. That's the right way to do this. If they don't, they don't, right?

SPEAKER_01But it's a democratic resolution of a major clash about environmental issues between left and right. What bothers me is that you see environmental progressives keep trying to make an end run around that. So, like the EPA under Biden said, we're in charge of climate change and we're gonna do radical, revolutionary stuff in climate change because Congress ain't doing it, so we the EPA should do it. But based on what authority, right? They claimed authority from the Clean Air Act and the Clean Water Act to get into and to control the climate change debate.

SPEAKER_01Why? They said it explicitly. They said we can't, Congress won't do it, so we're gonna do it. But Congress not doing it is because they didn't win enough votes. They didn't have the votes to do it in Congress. And now what are we seeing? We're seeing a um um a super blue city bringing litigation in its own super blue courts to try to take this over again from Congress, again, even from the state legislature, trying to get the regulation they want through legal means.

SPEAKER_01And we all just have to recognize that this is this is an abuse of the legal system for the sake of a political goal. They're perfectly entitled to pursue the political goal, but do it in the democracy, in the democratic branches where it belongs and not through, you know, back end channels through administrative agencies like the EPA, which is in charge of clean air and water, not climate change. When the clean air and water bills were passed, they were not about climate change. It wasn't on the horizon at the time. And not through contemporary courts using like super weird creative, I don't even want to credit it as creative, just super bizarre, uh legally unmoored theories of trespass and nuisance.

SPEAKER_01And on that, can I I pass it to you, Elon, to talk about the nuisance thing.

SPEAKER_02Direct primary populism disagreement, Josh, water under the bridge. I thought that was awesome. Fire. Okay, so let me By the way, I like the water under the bridge. That's kind of a good idea. Yeah. Yeah, the water was caused by climate change. Did you know? That's why it went under the bridge. Actually, no, I guess the water would go over the bridge if it was the climate change. Anyway, all right. So the you if you watch an earlier episode of the Ration Based Podcast, we actually explain the controversy over the EPA and the Clean Air Act, because the Trump administration reversed that finding. But basically they said the carbon dioxide was a pollutant, even though under the Clean Air Act, even though ordinarily, you know, you think of a pollutant as like an impurity in the local air, you know, like sulfur dioxide or nitrous oxide or whatever.

SPEAKER_02You don't think of like oxygen, you know, like a chemical in the ambient air. Carbon dioxide is just a chemical like widely dispersed throughout the ambient air, throughout the atmosphere. It is not a local impurity of any kind. And so it really doesn't fit. And the Trump administration reversed it. But as Josh said, it's an example of abusing, you know, the veneer of plausible legal argument in order to advance an agenda that you can't win at the polls or you can't win in Congress. Exactly uh the same thing here. It's the weaponization of law. And let me give you an example why. So the central claim here is public nuisance.

SPEAKER_02Why uh uh am I so passionate about this, as you will know from a prior episode of, again, the rationing-based podcast, uh, I have filed certain lawsuits against municipalities arguing that public homeless encampments create public nuisances. Um, and so one theme of my the next few minutes is going to be how public nuisance is in a long-standing, venerable common law doctrine that really has a role to play here uh in enforcing the basic social compact and social order, but the left refuses to use it in the way it actually was intended to be used and insists on using it in these totally crazy ways.

SPEAKER_02So, what is a public nuisance? So a private nuisance is an interference with your use and enjoyment of your own property. Okay, usually it's a non-trespassory uh invasion. So a trespass is an invasion, right? But if someone just commits noise, like your neighbor commits, you know, uh engages in a loud noise, a party every two days at 10 p.m. till 2 a.m., that is a nuisance. It's a non-trespassory invasion of your use and enjoyment uh of your property. Odors, you know, from the asphalt plant or something like that could interfere with the use and enjoyment of your own property.

SPEAKER_02A public nuisance is a similar interference, but with a public right. It is an interference with a right that the public has to some public good, like access to roads, access to the navigable waterways, access to the streets, right? So a public nuisance is defined under the restatement uh as a restatement of torts, which is this restatement of the law. I mentioned it earlier on the podcast. It's an unreasonable interference with a right common to the general public, such as when conduct involves a significant interference with the public health, the public safety, the public peace, the public comfort, or the public convenience.

SPEAKER_02Let me give you an example. Uh several examples, okay? Your right to use the sidewalk. If someone puts up a physical obstruction on the sidewalk, uh and you have a right to use that sidewalk, that's a public nuisance. They are interfering with the customary use of the sidewalk. If someone's building, business is spilling over and blocking the sidewalk, again, that's a nuisance. If a street vendor is blocking an ADA access point, you know, that is a nuisance. A bad odor that affects the whole neighborhood could be a public as well as a private nuisance. Uh classic examples, body houses, houses of ill repute, uh, would be um public nuisances because they would interfere with the comfort and enjoyment of the neighborhood.

SPEAKER_02Uh obscenity playing a local movie theater, a restaurant that attracts teenagers and their hot rods. There is a case, you know, that they would throw beer cans on people's property. You know, this is these are cases uh from the 60s and 70s. A dilapidated building that might might catch fire, right? What's the point I'm trying to make? Public nuisance should be used more. It should be used by conservatives like me and my firm, where we're going after, you know, this these cities and these homeless encampments. Public nuisance is a way where you can police the right of other individuals uh to sort of engage in their businesses and their enterprises and their right without interfering with your rights.

SPEAKER_02It is literally sort of the line. It is the root of the state's police power, it is the root of the state's obligations under the social compact to make sure that we can enjoy our life, liberty, and property rights. But the left refuses to use public nuisance laws. And they and Josh mentioned the breakdown of law and order. You know, they literally refuse to uh you know enforce public nuisance laws, enforce basic law and orders, and instead what they do is they use public nuisance to go after gun manufacturers for gun violence, which again, like forgetting the causation problem, totally outside any of the classic, you know, sort of concrete things that cause a public nuisance in your neighborhood, like that obstruction or that odor coming from that factory, right?

SPEAKER_02These are the things that create these public uh nuisances. Uh and similarly, here uh they are totally abusing it uh to go after the you know the the greenhouse gases, which again are sort of ambient throughout the air. It's not the kind of thing, this localized thing that creates a widespread interference with the convenience. It is simply, you in other words, the wider spread the problem is, the more global the problem is, the more it is not like a judicial injury of the kind like here's a concrete thing that you're doing in this concrete space that is interfering with the use and enjoyment of public spaces from the surrounding neighborhoods.

SPEAKER_02That is kind of what public nuisance is. Instead, you know, the more you globalize or nationalize the conduct that's at issue and the harm that's at issue, you're clearly actually just trying to do something legislative as opposed to address some sort of judicial injury. And so they're abusing that. Okay, let me stop there, get reactions, and then if there are any. And then in the last few minutes, I just wanted to explain why this case is even at the Supreme Court, which is probably what our audience was listening to. Any reactions, or should I just keep going? Am I on a roll?

SPEAKER_00Well, my only I would just add a comment because I had to start Googling while you were talking. A body house, in case you were born this century, is a brothel. Okay. I had no idea what that meant. And we actually have those now in Minneapolis. We have these like bathhouses that they're trying to build, they're bringing them back. So maybe this is something uh us conservatives can use as a as a response. But yeah, just a little lingo.

SPEAKER_02I probably meant to say brothel, and I just forgot the word brothel.

SPEAKER_01But b body, B-A-W-D. Body house was used in a lot of like 19th century novels. So, way to go. Uh, you uh you and the Bronte sisters can give you. Now you know what I'm reading. Um, but I do have one response just real quick. Um first of all, you you know, last episode you were really gracious, and and you said that you know, you some of the things I said about criminal law was an education for you. So I just want to give pay it back and say that was incredible. That was super interesting for me to learn all about nuisance because you know, obviously, I just know the outlines, and that was a really, really expert exposition of how nuisance law works and how it's supposed to work.

SPEAKER_01And as you were talking, I had a thought. Um, you know, I I often feel like when I'm sort of contesting uh politically or legally with the left, I'm like, wow, we are just not using concepts the same way. Like um you use the word racism for things that I think are not racist, or you use the word sexism for things I think are not sexist, and vice versa. Uh uh, or you use the word genocide for things that I think just don't count as genocide.

SPEAKER_01And and or or you use the word protest for things that I call harassment or civic terrorism, like constantly these differences in how we use basic words and basic concepts. And I was struck at how, like, you know, when you think about nuisance, uh you think about, for example, the homeless encampments all over our cities, which I agree, I agree with you, by the way. When they think of nuisance, they think about, I don't know, Exxon and Suncor producing fossil fuels.

SPEAKER_01You know, some of it is actually obviously like being legally clever and just trying to get their political will met. But some of it might be like part of this broader pattern of just like in this era of political polarization, the way we are using basic concepts is coming apart. And they think of something as a nuisance. They don't pursue all the things that really are nuisance, according to people like the three of us. And they do pursue things that we wouldn't think of as nuisance at all. I mean, think about like like I would love to see the International Criminal Court indict Hamas for genocide, not Israel.

SPEAKER_01We're using it in opposite ways.

SPEAKER_02I just had a thought. So we're remember from last time to our audience, we're trying to come up with the recurring segments that uh will draw attention. We've got some good suggestions so far. We might start introducing them. Why don't we do another one? Okay, I'm gonna test this, field test this live on air, too. Okay, so our audience tells, what about the Orwell Award? Like every couple episodes, we give an Orwell Road award where it's like, this is the most, so it's kind of like leftist legal lunacy, right? Except everything we talk about is leftist legal lunacy. Everything we talk about is often about the left's abuse of language, but this is kind of a connection, right?

SPEAKER_02They're literally abusing language, like Orwell, you know, suggested um uh in his essays, and of course in 1984, by basically saying, Oh, this is a public news. It's like, no, you're warping the way we think about language to uh in this sense. Just just a thought. Maybe Boulder, Colorado is the first recipient of the Orwell Award from the Rationally Based Podcast. Just a thought.

SPEAKER_01Okay. That is fire. I love it. I think I like it even more than who did it first, the left or Putin. Putin. Oh, that's still good.

SPEAKER_02And so we'll be a rarer segment. But okay, so who did it first, Putin or the Democrats? Chances are Putin did it first. Uh no, no, uh, the depth, wait, yeah, Putin did it first, and the Democrats liked it, right? That's the that's copied it, right? Or, well, we'll have another one uh, I think next week. So, okay. Well, listen, we're coming up on 50 minutes here, and we wanted to keep these episodes a little bit shorter. So let me just say, why is this even in federal court? What are even the federal issues? Because this went up in state court under state law claims, as Catherine listed uh a bunch of those public nuisance.

SPEAKER_02What's the federal issue to get in federal court? You need a federal issue to review. So, what is the federal issue? Well, they came up with a bunch, some court uh an exon came up with a bunch of federal defenses, which all kind of suck. Am I allowed to say that word on this? Yeah, that's family-friendly.

SPEAKER_01You're definitely allowed to say that.

SPEAKER_03Suck? Yes, they all suck is allowed.

SPEAKER_01They stink, they're terrible. Oh, come now. Um you are you are so prudish. It's so unexpected. Well, just in public, but okay.

SPEAKER_02So, you know, in private. No, okay, anyway. Uh, so I I again they're grasping at straws, but let me grasp at a better straw. Okay, an argument that no one's talking about. So I want to tell you the quickly the three theories and then why I think they're wrong, and then my theory, what they should, you know, they should have hired me to make this argument. If you're listening out there, and then I want to get your reaction. Okay, so one, they made this like equal sovereignty extraterritorial argument that like Boulder is attempting to regulate things extraterritorial. And that's crazy. That's wrong. Why? Um, because states have a police power over health, safety, welfare, and morals.

SPEAKER_02And therefore, if you are polluting, you know, in Colorado, in Boulder, uh, they can go after you for that pollution under classic theories of tort, including if it were truly a public or private nuisance claim, like a legitimate one, they could do that. Right? The problem is it's illegitimate. I just to be clear to our audience, we just argue that the claim is illegitimate, but it's illegitimate under state law. It doesn't mean the federal government can just come in and say, oh, it's illegitimate. Well, that's a matter of state law. The state courts have allowed it, right? So to say that they have uh, in other words, they have this regulatory power.

SPEAKER_02And if it happens to affect interstate commerce, so what? Congress could come in and preempt them if it wants, right? And and but it didn't. So the fact that there's an effect interstate, there is an effect on a national business, doesn't mean a state doesn't have this local police power over health and safety, right? And assuming, presuming it's generally exercised, so that's pretty weak. They have this super weak speaking of preemption, right? A foreign affairs preemption argument, just this idea that, well, the president has foreign affairs powers and you're interfering with his ability to negotiate climate change treaties.

SPEAKER_02That's preposterous. First of all, Catherine, did you know I have a new book called The Constitution of 1789, a new introduction? No, I've never heard of it. I explained that there's no actual foreign affairs powers, at least Congress has most of it. But the point is Congress hasn't, again, preempted it. It isn't just this like dormant preemption where no one's allowed to do things that affect foreign policy. Of course, states are allowed to do things that affect foreign policy if it's legitimately within their uh state powers, including regulating pollution. The best possible case is this Clean Air Act preemption.

SPEAKER_02It's the most plausible. Suncor is basically arguing that interstate pollution was historically governed by federal common law, and that the Clean Air Act, which displaced federal common law, um uh basically uh doesn't uh uh um uh allow basically the Clean Air Act takes over whatever federal common law was before. And so there's no room for the states here to regulate greenhouse gases. Why is this argument problematic? Aside from the fact that the Clean Air Act doesn't really explicitly set aside state tort claims, right?

SPEAKER_02Josh raised it earlier. The Trump administration's position is that carbon dioxide and greenhouse gases are not pollutants under the Clean Air Act. Whoops! Whoops! If that's true, then how does the Clean Air Act preempt regulation of greenhouse gases? It is a huge problem for the theory, right, on that side. Okay, huge problems, and people think this is probably not gonna go well for Suncor and Exxon uh as a as a federal legal matter, but let me try one legal theory by the by no state shall deprive any person of life or business, right?

SPEAKER_02A collection of persons, businesses or people too, okay, of life, liberty, or property without due process of law. Even under the narrowest procedural reading of due process of law. What is due process of law? It means there must be law established in advance that you have violated before the state can come and take away your life, your liberty, or your property. This theory is so crazy on the basis of general tort principles, on the basis of pre-existing Colorado tort principles, that the Supreme Court of Colorado, the courts of Colorado, are literally making up law on the fly in order to deprive Exxon and Suncor of billions of dollars in private vested property.

SPEAKER_02In other words, a state can have such a crazy and extreme interpretation of its own law that it effectively is creating new law on the fly and thereby violating due process of law by retroactively applying that new and crazy view of their own law to the parties before it.

SPEAKER_01But that position, Elon, it's very creative. Um, that due process argument would give federal courts tremendous new power over state courts and state law. I mean, essentially what it says is if a state, any state, starts doing something under its own law, its own courts, its own law, everything state-contained that is sufficiently new, then it's a deprivation of due process of law if the federal courts say it is.

SPEAKER_01And I really fear that theory even more than this lawsuit.

SPEAKER_02I'm okay with that. I'm actually okay with that theory because do you want to be, you know, sent to court on some kakamimi theory, and they're like, you know, I need to come up with the, you know, the obvious example is um, you know, supposing jaywalking is not a crime. Someone can't just say, oh, Catherine, you jaywalked yesterday. Bad idea. We're sending you to the Tower of London. No, you you can't do that. I can't think of an example at the top of my head where something would be so crazy uh that it'd be so outside the realm of the pre-existing law where this would be applied, but that's all the more reason to do it. I just think it would be so rare, right?

SPEAKER_02I just cannot imagine federal courts. Everyone recognizes that common law moves in a piecemeal direction, that sometimes judges have to exercise discretion and exercise a little bit of policymaking. But at the end of the day, the reason we let them get away with it is because common law courts are deciding, you know, cases based on pre-existing principles, right? And so when you have some new case, a first impression, it's a small extension. You know, the plaintiff has a plausible claim here. This is so implausible that literally the court system in Colorado has been hijacked by a bunch of left-wing activist judges who all went to college in these crazy schools and learned these crazy things, as we talked about last time, and became the real world.

SPEAKER_02And now we're just trying to punish Suncorp based on this ideology, anti-climate ideology.

SPEAKER_01I don't disagree, but uh but just think about how this could be weaponized on the other side, right? So just imagine our federal courts go in the other direction, they become more left-wing, which could easily happen. Look at the midterms we just had. Look at, you know, we don't know who the next president will be. Let's imagine our federal courts go much more left-wing, and then think about how this theory could be weaponized against Tennessee and Florida, as like these holdout states that are not going with the blue wave. And um uh those states start doing things uh internally with their law, and the federal courts start saying that violates federal due process.

SPEAKER_01You know, there's this old joke in in the law uh due process is the last refuge of a scoundrel. Because it's like if you have no other legal argument to make, you make a due process argument. Um it's I I feel like that's where we're going here. But it but it shows up.

SPEAKER_02This, I agree, I agree, but I I will say I've not fully thought out this idea. And so I appreciate the live feedback. Audience, please let us know. Um, yes, I agree that the due process clause is sort of the last scoundrel or last refuge of a scoundrel or whatever you said, but that's because we're used to the left making things up. And how do they make things up? They go to things like due process of law. Well, what I said today was they're also making things up with public nuisance, but there is a legitimate role for public nuisance that we should recover. And you know what? There's a legitimate role for due process, which is if you totally make stuff law up on the fly, you know, you cannot deprive someone of a vested property right based on a violation of some newly made law that you've made up.

SPEAKER_02Otherwise, it's just a retroactive ex post facto law. And so that is my theory. I haven't thought out all the implications. Maybe it's crazy, but I suspect I'm still right. Josh, Catherine, last words.

SPEAKER_01I think a better solution to this problem is for businesses to just pull out of blue states. I mean, if basically if blue states are going to impose this kind of insane liability on businesses, the solution is for businesses to pull out of doing business in those states. That will carry consequences for the blue states in question. And that seems appropriate to me. They they um uh make a political choice. The political choice is really, really hard on businesses that do business there. So the businesses pull out, and then the state has to live with its political choice or reverse it, and that's just internalizing the costs of their political decisions.

SPEAKER_01I think that's better than expanding federal control over states. I mean, your theory is really interesting. I'm intrigued, but I think that's the better solution.

SPEAKER_02Actually, they should stop selling their products. They should stop selling energy and fossil fuels into Colorado because unless they do that, there will still be a grounds for jurisdiction. And so, all right, you don't like climate change, try living without fossil fuels for uh years.

SPEAKER_01That's not how that works. Yeah, that's what it's Catherine. What do you think?

SPEAKER_02Catherine looks like she's gonna keel over from her uh, you know, fever or whatever it is. So bring us home, Catherine.

SPEAKER_00Thank you for a little bit of a cold sweat breaking out. But I I think what one thing that's interesting here in Minnesota, this is my second daily segment here in Minnesota. What we're doing is also insane. Um, but they're trying to retroactively tax these same companies like Exxon, these fossil fossil fuel producers, um, retroactively tax them for decades of this, you know, climate change um that they've caused. And so maybe that is the way forward if you're a crazy lefty who thinks this is the right thing to do. I don't really see how retroactive taxes uh are constitutional or legitimate, but um that's another theory they're trying.

SPEAKER_00And so I'll be interested to see how that plays out here and maybe that's the way for them to go and chase them out that way.

SPEAKER_02Well, that sounds like another topic for the rationally based podcast on our next or future episode. Thank you as always for sticking with us. Send us feedback, hit that like and subscribe button, give us a rating, and we'll see you next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Episode 48 | Conservative Legal Education?

    Nov 19, 202652 minAudio

    In this special episode, law professors Josh Kleinfeld and Ilan Wurman sit down with Adam Biggs of the University of Austin, at Texas (UATX). The new school has made waves since the concept for it was introduced in 2021...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Episode 46 | Sex and Scholarship

    Nov 9, 202642 minAudio

    In a Tennessee manslaughter trial, the judge barred the jury from learning that the deceased - the defendant’s sexual partner of two years - was a biological male who identified as a woman. The appeals court reversed,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Episode 45 | Midterm Madness Redux

    Nov 5, 202645 minAudio

    Susan Collins lost in Maine after years as the most moderate Republican in the Senate. Across the country, Republicans ran solid candidates and still underperformed. In Alaska, “Decoy Dan” Sullivan remains on the ballot...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Episode 44 | Midterm Mayhem

    Oct 29, 20261 hr 12 minAudio

    A Brazilian Supreme Court justice who used to be Lula’s personal lawyer ordered the polls kept open for two hours after they were supposed to close. Another ordered the opposition candidate, Bolsonaro, to surrender his...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Episode 43 | Guns, Religion, and Immigration: The Rules Just Changed

    Oct 22, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    Trump’s Office of Legal Counsel has been on a tear, and hosts Ilan Wurman, Kathryn Johnson, and Joshua Kleinfeld explain the big developments. Guns: OLC announced that the federal ban on selling handguns to...

    Credit the people on this episode