In this special episode, law professors Josh Kleinfeld and Ilan Wurman sit down with Adam Biggs of the University of Austin, at Texas (UATX). The new school has made waves since the concept for it was introduced in 2021 and the institution enrolled its first class in 2024. Now, UATX wants to go even bigger: it wants to start a law school of its own in the near future. Why does UATX think a new law school is necessary? Is the ABA accreditation process corrupt? Will the Texas Supreme Court accredit a new law school now that several Democrats have won seats on the court? More foundationally, what do they plan to teach at UATX? Our hosts engage in a deep discussion over what legal education should look like. What's the purpose of the case method? Should the law school teach natural law? Our hosts also discuss among themselves the importance of academic freedom. Yes, it's one value, but is it the ultimate value? Is a university allowed to have a mission? Might saving Western civilization require promoting some ideas but "cancelling" others? Where does academic freedom fit? This is the rational - and based - discussion of the future of legal education and Western civilization that you won’t hear anywhere else. Be sure to LIKE, SHARE, COMMENT, and SUBSCRIBE to rationally BASED! Subscribe to our Substack! New Podcast Episodes every Thursday morning, find us on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or on YouTube! Follow us on social media on Instagram, X, Facebook, and TikTok!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome back to Rationally Based, a podcast about law and politics on the edge. I'm Elon Norman, a law professor at the University of Minnesota Law School.
SPEAKER_01I'm Josh Kleinfeld, Rams Professor of Law at Scalia Law School.
SPEAKER_00And we are joined today with a special guest, Adam Biggs, from the University of Austin at Texas. We are excited for a discussion about the future of legal education, the future of higher education generally. So thank you for joining us in this special episode. And let's dive in. All right, Josh, where should we start?
SPEAKER_01Why don't we start with you, Adam? And uh just tell us a little bit about yourself and what you're building in Texas.
SPEAKER_02I'm the general counsel at the University of Austin. We are a um relatively new university, and we are building a law program. And right now I'm one of the people leading that charge, and that's why I'm here to talk to you all today.
SPEAKER_01Can you uh can you tell me a little bit about what you've already built in the undergraduate program and now how you're expanding it?
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. So founders of the University of Austin, Barry Weiss, Joe Lonsdale, Neil Ferguson, um, they essentially decided that the university system status quo wasn't working anymore and that it wasn't an option to rebuild within. It's time to build something brand new. So they created University of Austin. They launched it. We have three classes currently, and the overall premise is the idea about the fearless pursuit of truth and the ability to have civil conversations in classrooms to debate some of the biggest ideas in the history of the world.
SPEAKER_02We have a Western civilization core called Intellectual Foundations, where every single student, whether they're in STEM or whether they're in um philosophy or the humanities, they all take it. Great books focused, Aristotle, everything you would normally associate with that kind of Western canon great books curriculum. And then it takes a particular pivot after those few years where students can take whatever they want. We have a lot of students focusing on entrepreneurship, innovation. And it's generally the idea is to take classical knowledge and bridge it to the future and apply it in the modern world because the understanding is once you have these ideas and you have these foundational truths, it's going to ultimately create the leaders and the citizens that this country needs.
SPEAKER_02And so we are absolutely committed to that. We're tuition free because debt really defines destinies. And we believe that very, very firmly. So being tuition-free is a humongous part of that. And through our gracious donors and their generosity, we'd be able to do that for all of our students moving forward. So it's a wonderful experiment down in Austin.
SPEAKER_01It's uh it's awesome. And one of my, I will say, one of my uh best friends' son uh goes to University of Austin as an undergraduate. He's had the experience of a lifetime, it is working, it is working for him in an incredible way.
SPEAKER_02That's great.
SPEAKER_01Um, so I you know, when I think about starting up a law school, I think of it in the context of the intellectual history of American law schools. It's an interesting history. Uh, so you know, Abraham Lincoln didn't go to law school. He apprenticed with a senior lawyer. He kind of learned the tools of the trade and he went into practice. And that was how it was done up until the mid-19th century in America. And the the story of how that changed. Um essentially, even when Lincoln was getting his start, there were classes that you would take.
SPEAKER_01Mostly you'd apprentice. But in the big cities of America, in Chicago and New York, um uh lawyers got together and said, Well, there's a few things where we need some book knowledge. And they started teaching classes. They formed um uh corporate organizations, and eventually they got bought or they merged with existing universities. But it was still a sort of a nascent class-based professional education, a little bit like learning woodworking, learning a trade, um, until Christopher Columbus Langell, and he had a theory.
SPEAKER_01His theory was that uh um law was a science, not in the sense of a natural science, but an organized body of knowledge, what in Latin they called skiantia, just a systematic body of knowledge. They would have said philosophy and history is a skiantia. And uh his thought was that um there are principles embedded in the cases of the common law, that the skill, the intellectual skill of a lawyer is to extract those general principles from the cases and then to learn to apply them to future cases in a way that would be essentially a kind of deductive logic of law.
SPEAKER_01He wrote the first uh case book, it was a contracts case book, and it was that um that melding of these nascent law schools um that had merged with universities with his theory that kind of founded a real academic discipline, and that became uh uh modern law. I I myself, at Scalia Law, teach at one of the relatively younger.
SPEAKER_00Wait, before we get there, but by the way, Josh, I think there's the story's a little more complicated. I've been reading a lot about legal education in the uh in the 19th century, and uh law before the case method, before Christopher Columbus Langdell, what a great name, by
SPEAKER_02the way,
SPEAKER_00um uh was also considered a science, but it was a different kind of science. There's actually a super interesting book by Stuart Banner. I don't know if you've uh The UCLA historian. Yeah, the The Decline of Natural Law. And he explains, you know, there were law schools in the early 19th century. Most people didn't go. You still had a large apprentice method like Lincoln, you could still be self-taught in law, but James Wilson, you
unknownknow,
SPEAKER_00taught at a law school uh in the 1790s, George Wyatt created a law school, it's uh uh basically taught law lectures in Virginia, and it wasn't considered a science. And it was intimately connected to natural law. And the question is, you know, why do you have positive law? Well, positive law specifies the natural law, it fills gaps in the natural law, the natural law fills gaps in the positive law. What's the purpose of human law? Well, you have to understand, you know, the human condition and human nature. There are certain things, if human beings want to exist together in harmony, in close proximity, you know, uh and flourish and preserve their survival and existence, certain rules need to be met.
SPEAKER_00You know, certain rules about deception and keeping promises, certain rules about violence and restraining violence and so on. And law and custom and positive law was all understood to sort of be about um specifying and figuring out what those fundamental principles of natural law were that the positive law was supposed to try to effectuate. Now, of course, sometimes you know the connection between the positive law and the natural law could be um, you know, tenuous. But from from my reading of that history, the reason the case method developed was because that older view of law as a science of natural law actually was abandoned.
SPEAKER_00They stopped believing in natural law. And so they said, well, you know, so as Banner describes in his book, is like now that you had this explosion in law publishing and you actually had a bunch of cases to actually read, you know, it sounds quaint, you know, by our lights today, but in the 17th century, in the 1600s, like so many case reports, how's are we ever gonna figure this all out? You know, well, in the 19th century, that was also a problem. And Banner describes that it was thought to be this move away from principles of law to precedent. You can just sort of focus on the cases.
SPEAKER_00And so uh when natural law starts disappearing for various reasons, various other reasons. Well, what do you do with law? You know, what do you do with all these non-positive law cases, the common law? Uh you have to develop so so there was this argument that, well, the cases have their own internal logic, and law has its own internal logic, as you described. But then my thinking was always, okay, but where does that come from? It's gotta be connected to human nature in some respect and natural law, right?
SPEAKER_00Why are contract laws the way they are? Well, because human nature is a certain way. And if we're gonna live successfully in close proximity to each other, you know, the positive law or the customary law of contract law has to be of a certain type, right? And so it seems to me that Langdell was trying to keep science, uh, law as sort of a science and a discipline in an era where natural law was being forgotten about. That quickly exploded into something else entirely, which is judges just make things up, you know. So it seems to me you're describing a halfway point of where the case method originated as kind of like this replacement for natural law.
SPEAKER_00Well, the law could have its own logic wherever it comes from. We don't have to call it natural law. And then eventually that got displaced by legal realism, but this we still do the case method, right? So it's like a super long, I mean, it's all a way of asking maybe how do you conceive of legal education? Yeah, where's that? But Josh, you asked the question. I was just so pointing that. That
SPEAKER_01first of all, that was fascinating. And I haven't read Strobanner's new book yet. So that was really, really interesting. But but I think what both Elon and I are getting at is that uh legal education happens in the currents of larger bodies of thought about the nature of law, about what the discipline needs, about what it's missing. I'm sure UATX was founded with some of those ideas in mind. So can you tell us a bit about, you know, what's the need? Um, what are you building and why?
SPEAKER_02So I I think that the first thing is, and this all reminds me of our intellectual foundations curriculum that our undergrads currently take. They're reading these foundational texts and the the intellectual inheritance of America and understanding these concepts from the beginning. And again, these are just the undergrads. The law program is going to have a deep understanding that goes even further about Blackstone. The this isn't the inheritance of these particular principles that will appear in this law school.
SPEAKER_02So I think you have to understand this if you're going to have a frame to analyze constitutional questions of the modern day. You have to have a grounding somewhere instead of just I think just flying across willy-nilly and kind of under trying to understand it only through cases. And this philosophical underpinning is really critically important. I mean, the the need is ultimately these, you know, these civic centers, this is what they're doing across the country. They're trying to do some of this. We are an independent entity that does not rely on an overarching public or private university.
SPEAKER_02So we can embed this in the architecture of the program itself, in the actual law program. And the idea being we are going to spin out people who are gonna have a view and way of interpreting the law that is going to understand the tradition and the history, not just modern case law and things like that. Because you have to have that if you want to ultimately succeed in what this project is, is understanding the constitution from the place that the framers would have understood from.
SPEAKER_00I could can you imagine a 1-0 coming to the University of Austin or University of Minnesota or Scalia Law School, actually more plausible. And instead of torts, contracts, property, and civil procedure, what a criminal law or criminal.
SPEAKER_02Yeah,
SPEAKER_00you know, it's like here's a class on Blackstone and the natural law. Here's uh a class on Bracton, you know, and uh customary law. You have to learn a little HLA heart, and
SPEAKER_02yeah,
SPEAKER_00that would be kind of interesting. And then you understand why contracts is the body of law the way it is, why torts as a body of law is the way it is. Of course, this rejects all sort of like realism thing, but like, I don't know, I I that would be really fun. When I was in law school as a one-el, I'm like, okay, property contract, yeah, but but why? Why are we doing all this? Why do the cases you know they say, oh, policy, you know, they they say, well, judges make policy on the margins. Okay, on the basis of what? Why is this a better policy or a worse policy? And it's like it would be helpful if you had some philosophical grounding in the natural law.
SPEAKER_02So
SPEAKER_00I don't know, have you have you have you guys explored actually writing a curriculum yet? Or is that what you are you're doing?
SPEAKER_02So we have a we have a rough idea of where of where we want to go. I think obviously we are currently, as you know, searching for a dean. So the dean will ultimately
SPEAKER_00you should tell us about that too, but
SPEAKER_02absolutely will. But I want to I'm gonna finish up on this. So the dean will ultimately have a lot of influence on this. We also have some incredible folks that are kind of helping advise on on these pieces. Um, you know, amazing jurists like we have Judge Ho, Judge Thapar, Judge Oldham, that are they will ultimately also have a decent amount of feedback on this. And I know there are they are some of the best in this area in understanding these bigger, bigger concepts. A fun story. So at UETX, we do convocation every year for undergrads, and the new students walk across the stage, a big party, and they hand them a copy of the Odyssey.
SPEAKER_02You know, this is the beginning.
SPEAKER_00And
SPEAKER_02they walk through graduation. I'm sure we're gonna do something wonderful about concluding that journey home. I have had thought of a fun idea for the law school is you walk across the stage, we bring you into our community, and we give you some version of Blackstone's commentaries. Here you go. This is where it starts. And you supercharge that at the very beginning. So even if you come in from a school, you don't have this philosophical background, you get it very quickly. I think that is the sort of thing that really is true to our mission and how we understand how this program will operate, setting a tone from the very beginning.
SPEAKER_02Because we talk a lot about formation above training, and it's not a degree program in that sense. It is about forming an individual. And I think starting the journey with, say, Blackstone is I think a pretty good place to start.
SPEAKER_00It's
SPEAKER_01interesting because if if the school was grounded in a sort of um resistance to legal realism, uh I can see the virtue
SPEAKER_02and
SPEAKER_01seeing legal realism as sort of associated with whatever has gone wrong and the sort of willfulness of judges and law and the and uh but legal realism is also just a description of how doctrinal law is an incomplete description of law. And I don't I don't think you'd want to just will you tell me is the goal to reject legal realism and have a school that rejects legal realism, or is it is it something And
SPEAKER_00Josh, for our audience, can you define legal realism? Yeah,
SPEAKER_01legal realism is the idea that the law pretextually determines the outcome of cases, but in reality, uh the outcome of cases is largely discretionary and a matter of judges' policy preferences. It doesn't necessarily assert that that is how it has to be or should be. Uh it asserts that that's the reality of our present situation.
SPEAKER_00And of course, like the even legal realists can't quite escape natural law in a way. And in Banner's book, just to go back to this, uh what I found fascinating is the legal realists got very defensive after World War II, because in some respects, you know, it's it it arguably lent some authority, legitimacy to totalitarianism and authoritarianism. And so the legal realists would say, well, you know, even on our view, like, yeah, judges are just doing things on the basis of policy, but it should still be good policy. And it's like, okay, well, where does that come from?
SPEAKER_02Right?
SPEAKER_00So even they couldn't escape some normative grounding for like what is the purpose and function of law. But it's more your your point is more of a descriptive account of what judges actually do. But even if that's true, like, yes, judges make some discretionary policy choices on the margins of new cases. And that was true historically. It's just when they tried to do that, they tried to say, okay, what is the natural law say about this? What is certain fundamental facts of human nature? What result is necessitated from that situation? Uh, whereas legal realists maybe there's some other preference that's going on.
SPEAKER_00I don't know. Do you do you uh
SPEAKER_01Yeah, listen, I I I think it's fascinating because there are these huge philosophical currents coursing through American law uh positivism, realism, natural law, um, Dorkinian interpretivism, critical legal studies. And I guess the question when you really start a new law school that's totally innovative and being built from the ground up without sort of without sort of reliance on our settled expectations of law schools, is are you dedicated to one of those schools of thought or principles?
SPEAKER_00And you could teach the other ones too, to be clear, right? You don't have to cancel them out of the curriculum, but you're gonna want to promote, presumably. What are your thoughts?
SPEAKER_02Well, I I think this is this is very evident in our, let's say, our economics currently. So you can't understand like free market economics if you don't understand these other models. Like we, I mean, ultimately, one works and one doesn't, but you need to have a full 360 view of what the world looks like and be able to argue those topics against each other. So I don't think there'll be any sort of like this one, not that one. But I think to be a school dedicated to preserving the protections of a constitution, I think anything that teaches that a judge's policy preferences get in there, I just I don't think that's compatible because the structure of the constitution, it's not, it's not supposed to be this way.
SPEAKER_02I talk to people all the time. It's like, why are judges doing this? Why are they doing these things that just seem so not based in the text, the history, the tradition of these provisions and reaching further and further and further? It's because, I mean, obviously the structure of the government, but Congress can't do anything. Okay, well, they're supposed to, I mean, in my view, it's like that is the most powerful branch in a way. They should be legislating, they're closest to the people. Okay, they can't do anything. The president can't get anything through. So presidents are forced to use executive action, use the levers available to them. What it ends up creating is then the judiciary disagreeing with them and them becoming the most powerful branch in government.
SPEAKER_02I think that is a fundamentally problematic world to live in. And I think if you have curriculum that teaches that that is in any way, shape, or form the way we should operate, uh, I think that is incompatible with the idea that we are here to preserve our constitution and the history of constitutional order in this country.
SPEAKER_00I I love that. So, in a sense, you know, I you know, here's the mission I can get behind, right? Like a law school founded on the idea that law has a purpose, a function. You know, uh what do you say in philosophy? Teleology. A
SPEAKER_01teleology.
SPEAKER_00A teleology. Uh and you know, it's it's not just, you know, whatever the majority says is is right and just or whatever. It has a purpose and a function, and uh, you know, and that is reflected in customary law, this disciplines of one L contract towards property, and so on, recognizing we also need positive laws, however, what is the best way to do positive laws when people disagree on the margins over what natural law is, what these principles are, and so on. And then what are the purposes of constitutions?
SPEAKER_00Constitutions are there to preserve, you know, free societies and balance self-government and liberty and conduce to human happiness. And you could believe all of those things and you could teach that in the first semester, and then everything else, you know, you'll have a worldview that frames it, other than judges are just these philosopher kings. So, like, I I can really get behind a mission like that. Listen, you mentioned the dean would have a lot. And Josh, I know you had some questions about the dean search. Um, did you have anything else you wanted to ask before? Uh, because I was curious about the dean seems at this point. Because you know, you know, this is as always on the rationally based podcast.
SPEAKER_00Um, we just go, right? And so we have like a two-page outline for this discussion. We've totally jettisoned it in the first, you know, how long have we been going? 20
SPEAKER_02minutes.
SPEAKER_00Um, but but I am curious about the dean search. Um you know, what kind of role will this new dean have? What are you looking for? Josh, you pulled the description, didn't you? And you said you were intrigued by it. So I was
SPEAKER_01um you ask you ask applicants, what would you build and how would it differ from law schools that exist?
SPEAKER_02And
SPEAKER_01I'm curious what kind of answers you're getting and what you're looking for.
SPEAKER_02We're getting a lot of very good answers. Interesting. There's there's quite a bit of variation in some ways, but that's why we asked the question. At the end of the day, we want somebody who is a builder, who is mission-aligned with the university, that we are here to understand uh the foundational uh principles that make America great and moves it forward and makes it like we're gonna continue to flourish for 250 more years. But we also need somebody who's not just gonna revert back to higher education, the status quo.
SPEAKER_02Because a lot of academics you speak to, it's you hear their plan and they'll say things like, we're gonna have this office and that office, and we're gonna do this and this. It's like, well, that just sounds like what it used to be because we don't we don't do that at UATX. It's not our thing. Um, you can ask any of our faculty members. It's there's we do these things differently because the status quo is broken. And we need people and we need to actually understand, be able to peer past the resume and understand how do you think about these things? How do you view this university and this law program's role in the broader society and how it's going to distinguish itself and also serve as a model for other entrepreneurial innovative schools, whether it be a status quo, legacy university, or a brand new startup?
SPEAKER_02We are the ones who can do this. And so I think ultimately we've seen a lot of great things. Some folks talk about uh accelerating the program, putting in particular um courses, some interesting ideas about what if we did programming where we brought in the best judge in this one particular area for three weeks, and the students were with that person for three weeks straight. That is the only course. Kind of interesting models about how to structure the curriculum. But overall, the the response has been fantastic and some really great ideas.
SPEAKER_02It's gonna be honestly hard to sort through them and find the right person.
SPEAKER_00I love the three-week point. In law school, I most most law schools are on the semester system. We were on the quarter system. I favored the quintile system. By seven weeks, I was bored, you know, any particular subject. So yeah, you know, um no, that's that's that's
SPEAKER_01it seems like from a I'm sorry, you know. No, no, no,
SPEAKER_00please.
SPEAKER_01It seems like the hardest thing from a practical standpoint. Mean there's the vision part,
SPEAKER_02and
SPEAKER_01then there's a pragmatic part. And the pragmatic part is all about credibility, right? Because you need to take, you need to find a law dean who's got serious credibility in the
SPEAKER_02field.
SPEAKER_01You need to attract some professors. Law professors are different. I'm also a philosopher. Law professors are different from philosophy professors in the extent of options they tend to have. And so you've got to attract them away from other universities or law firms or career paths they could take. And then you've got to get students who, if they're good students, they have other options. And at every point, and and of course, I'm sorry, one more point on the on the chain, right? So you attract the dean, you attract the professors, you attract the students. And then you have to sell it to potential employers, law firms, government offices, U.S.
SPEAKER_01attorneys' offices, for example, potentially bar associations all around the country. So it's a it's a giant game of credibility chess when you look at it from a purely pragmatic point of view. How do you build the credibility?
SPEAKER_02It's a great question. It's something I think about literally every day because it has so many different tentacles into different areas. But a lot of it harkens back to UHCX to begin with. The ability to they, these are all things that were said when this place first started.
SPEAKER_00True.
SPEAKER_02You're not going to have any students, you're not going to have anybody who leaves the tenured positions. Lo and behold, people leave tenured positions to come take a risk because they are mission aligned, they're willing to get in there and do something fundamentally different. Students, year after year, we are increasing the number of people who apply, visit, and actually ultimately enroll with our SAT scores getting close to the elite universities, if not higher than some of them. Because these kids in our admissions process, wanting only their test scores, they say, here it is. We don't want your grades, we don't want essays.
SPEAKER_02And these high horsepower people, year after year, it's growing. More of them are showing up. So I think you take the same model and you you bring it over to the law program. So the dean is a critical piece. That dean must represent something bigger than themselves. They are the founder in a way. They have to stand up in front of a room, regardless of the audience, in front of judges, in front of employers, in front of donors, and they have to carry themselves in a way that is a magnet for those people, and then obviously families. Say somebody could say, I will send my student there, or convince a young person who may say, I have an option to go to Chicago, or many of these other, there are still good law schools out there.
SPEAKER_02You have to have the right person, but you also have to have the person that has an inspiring view of how we're gonna move forward, and that has to be things need to change. We're at a generational inflection point, and things have to change, and we are gonna do it, and we are gonna win.
SPEAKER_00Can I ask you? I I know it might be a little off track, but it's based on something you said. UATX generally, and and this will go into the law school mission, presumably as well. Is you know the mission of an institution of higher education like yours to just create the free marketplace of ideas and let people debate this idea of you know academic freedom and any subjects are sort of you know up for grabs and so on. That's how we sort of perceive of the modern university, except, of course, this idea of academic freedom just leads to ideological homogeneity because people just say, well, if you think differently than me, you must be an idiot, and therefore I'm not gonna hire you into my department.
SPEAKER_00And in fact, we get ideological uniformity rather than this thing, the genuine academic freedom. Uh on the other hand, there is something to universities having ideological views and promoting a certain vision of the world. So, uh, you know, Oberlin College, Hillsdale College were founded as abolitionist colleges. The abolitionists, because we talked about this on the rationally based podcast before, not prison abolition. Slavery abolition, like real abolition, actual, actual abolitionists.
SPEAKER_00It's a good
SPEAKER_01part of abolition.
SPEAKER_02You
SPEAKER_00know, if George Fitzhugh, you know, had come and said, Oh, I would love to teach the positive good theory of slavery in a course on natural law, you know, did the founders of Oberlin, did the faculty have to be like, sure, academic freedom? Like, no, of course, there are some ideas. Maybe, maybe I'm gonna get in some hot water here. I guess what I'm saying is maybe there are some ideas that should be canceled. It's just the problem in the modern university, they're canceling all the wrong ideas. And as we've talked, Josh, before on the podcast, academic freedom is of value, but it's only one value, right?
SPEAKER_00So I guess my question to you at UATX generally, and of course how it would spill into the law school, is is this idea of the university just to restore this idea of genuine academic freedom, which the modern university pretends to this standard, but actually doesn't uh meet it in any way? Or is it we have some kind of mission and we want to promote that mission, and that means some things are gonna be out and other things are gonna be in. And within that in, you know, there's a range of reasonable debate. Like I most I think the way I've asked the question, I've talked myself into that latter model.
SPEAKER_00But I want you to tell me what you think the answer is and what you guys are striving for at UATX.
SPEAKER_02I mean, uh it's in our mission specifically about civil discourse and the ability to, in the classroom, we have to teach all sides of everything in a way, if if that pedagogically makes sense. So I talked earlier about economics with, you know, we're talking about Marx, but also against all the free markets thinkers that are there. In the classroom, the students vigorously debate these. I talk to students all the time, and the the professors do a fantastic job of this. It's where you won't understand what, you know, I personally, the faculty member, believes is the ultimate right answer until you really get in there and start.
SPEAKER_02And these students are free to do this and they do it. We employ the Chatham House rule also, where they they can't attribute comments from their classmates outside of the classroom. And it
SPEAKER_00it's in the rules of the
SPEAKER_02we we have we have a very I wrote this I have a very, very a very I didn't come up with this idea. I think this I inherited this, though. I was the one that put it in the student handbook. So I run the compliance program as well, and we codified it. We have very few fundamental things that have to be there that disrupt our academic environment. So we don't police everything. But this is one of them. I think this might be the number one thing. You don't attribute, you don't do the cancel, you don't record people, you don't shout them down. And um, I in my time there and before that, I've hadn't heard of no examples of that happening.
SPEAKER_02These students, even when they disagree, engage in such good
SPEAKER_00faith
SPEAKER_02and they they like each other and it may get heated, but it's it's great. But back to your question.
SPEAKER_00By the way, I'm reminded of a story Josh told on the podcast before about a former student of yours, right, Josh, who when he was in
SPEAKER_01persecuted, yeah. Yeah,
SPEAKER_00persecuted for having said a true statement, probably true statement, about uh biological differences between men and women, and you know, the Larry Summers type statement, right? And then he got hounded, you know, psychologically harassed, physically harassed as an 18-year-old, right?
SPEAKER_01Actually, it was it was like this is why
SPEAKER_00don't all schools have this? But tell the story, but I'll tell you this. Why don't all schools have this? This is great.
SPEAKER_01I had this great student, um, young guy, and um wanted to tell me about something that had happened to him. So he had come from a family of very modest means. He was the he was the first in his family uh history to go to college, and sort of a farm boy from Iowa, and he he arrived in university, and in his first week of classes, he was in an econ class, and they were talking about why men and women sort into different jobs. And he raised his hand very naively, said one of the unsayable things that everyone knows is true, which is he said, Well, maybe women are just genetically more nurturing, and so go into these professions like nursing or teaching that are more oriented to nurturing.
SPEAKER_01And um, you know, the other students took offense, which will surprise no one who knows the modern university, right? But what happened next is a startling statement in the uh cruelty of the young in an age of wokeness, right? This was a peak wokeness. They used social media to organize flash mobs wherever he went on campus, and for a whole semester, it went on for the better part of six months, you know, there would be a sighting, he's at the library, he's at the bookstore, he's at the cafe, and a group of people would organize to just shout him down and hound him out of there in a in a mob style kind of harassment.
SPEAKER_01And I it broke my heart to think of and you know, and it also brought home how much uh coercive force it takes to maintain a lie. Because of course what he said was just common sense. And this was this was the organization of social power to oppress people who have true ideas. So actually, I'm really glad that you answered Elon's question as you did, because that vigorous debate within a marketplace of ideas, where you might be a school with with a Joe Lonsdale at the foundation.
SPEAKER_01He is a free marketer, but that doesn't mean Marx is off the table. You talk about Marx in the classroom. That is the only way learning can proceed. It's also the only way scholarship can proceed. I mean, you really need that dedication to the marketplace of ideas.
SPEAKER_00You can teach Marx. Do you have to hire a Marxist professor who you know uh, you know, wants to promote this particular model? Or is that something that you could be off the table for any number of reasons, including any number of institutions teach this, or that it's actually inimical to have someone. I I don't know. I'm just asking on the fly. I'm trying to think it through. It's one thing to teach Marx and Hegel and Aristotle and Locke as part of a general philosophy course. But can you hire someone who teaches an entire subject through a Marxian lens?
SPEAKER_00Or is that different?
SPEAKER_01The way I'd answer that is it it can't be the case that when you hire faculty, you don't care what they think. I mean, we don't hire astrologers in the physics department because we think astrology is an unreasonable approach to physics. We don't hire Wiccans in the medical school because we think that's not a reasonable approach to medicine. But when you have a range of possible views, then you hire for excellence. And I guess the hard question, I don't mean to deny it's a hard question, is Marx off the table for you know a reasonable enough view of does Marx, is Marx more like a Wiccan or an astrologer than like a serious contender for the right answer about how to organize the economy?
SPEAKER_00Did I tell you the story how I swear I heard the former Dean of Stanford Law School say this at a conference on intellectual diversity, though I've not found a video about this. Is this
SPEAKER_01Liz McGill?
SPEAKER_00No, prior to they're not
SPEAKER_02gonna hire witches.
SPEAKER_00Well, when I he was asked the question of like, why don't you hire more originalists? And he said, well, it's kind of like asking the chemistry department to hire an alchemist. And it's like, oh, okay, you know, so that's of course nothing wrong with canceling alchemists. The problem is you think all the wrong people are alchemists, and they're actually doing chemistry, and you're the one doing alchemy. You know, I mean it's crazy. It's the alchemists who are running the department.
SPEAKER_01The hard question then is then if you if you form a department of originalists, do you do you say we're not gonna hire any living constitutionalists, we're not gonna hire any hard leader realists. And that's where I think you and I might diverge in our instincts. I don't know,
SPEAKER_00I don't know.
SPEAKER_01I'm not sure. What do you think?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so back to the question I initially posed with.
SPEAKER_02A couple things we touched on there, though, which is great. So, first and foremost, the one thing that has to be understood is like you can have whatever idea in the classroom, but you better bring it. You better have evidence, you maybe have to be able to prove your case because another student, whether they agree with you or not, will take you to task in that classroom. And these students are not afraid. I I would be scared, honestly, to be with some of these kids because they are so sharp and they will take down an argument if and they learn this, they knew it before they came in, they've refined it and it's a skill. And if you can't do that, you know, you're not gonna have a fantastic time if you can't defend what you're trying to put out there.
SPEAKER_02In terms of hiring and everything else, I think a fundamental problem in current universities is this idea of like viewpoint diversity. We've heard it recently, viewpoint diversity, we're gonna have it, and it's used as a license to just kind of do whatever you want, because the idea is it's not like Noah's Ark. We don't need two of every type. Every school curates a curriculum that is geared towards something like Chicago, for example. They, you know, they're supposed to have a view of how they're doing these things, and you can teach these topics, but there's nothing that says you have to go hire the critical theorist just because, and I think it's used as a license for mischief with some of these universities because viewpoint diversity can mean a lot of different things.
SPEAKER_02And a lot of times, I think with these universities, they're getting away with stuffing one side of the V politically and saying viewpoint diversity, viewpoint diversity. But okay, great, you have one person you've hired in the sociology department that believes something conservative. That that is that viewpoint diversity? I I don't I don't know. And so I don't think there's an obligation to do that because every university has the right as an institution to be able to frame its mission and frame what's what it is for in a general sense, in terms of this is the body of knowledge we believe that young people should learn.
SPEAKER_01Yeah,
SPEAKER_02um, you don't want to have it be um ideological captured one way or the other, but you have to really refine it.
SPEAKER_00I I love this. I I want to talk about the ABA a little bit because uh I want to talk about your announcement, but just like I can't leave this topic quite yet. This is this is fascinating. I hope our listeners are genuinely
SPEAKER_01hard. I mean, the tokenism you point out is is terrible, right? And by the way, it also leads to a lot of the people who get hired as the tokens, like the token originalists at an otherwise uh progressive school, will often be the least combative, the most mild, the most acceptable to the left. Because the what you do with a token is you get the person who gives you an excuse to be exactly what you were
SPEAKER_00the
SPEAKER_01whole time. At the same time, the research on um scholarly and educational rigor is that when you are in a monolithic intellectual culture, I I there's a certain anecdote I tell all the time on the pod. I'll tell it one more time because it's apropos. Uh there was an experiment some social scientists did where they got a bunch of people together and gave them a survey on what they thought about climate change. And one is someone who's a complete climate change skeptic, you know, it's a total myth.
SPEAKER_01A ten is someone who thinks it's an emergency, you know, stop everything, change the economy. We need to deal with climate change. They got all the fours and put them together to talk about climate change for an hour and a half, and all the sixes and put them together to talk about climate change for an hour and a half. And get and then they redid the test, and all the fours had become twos and they were absolutely sure of it, and all the sixes had become eights, and they were absolutely sure of it. In other words, being in an ideologically monolithic environment makes people much more extreme and much more sure of their views.
SPEAKER_01And you can see that in the modern university where you put together, I mean, the numbers at places like Harvard and Yale are approximately 97 and 98% of the faculty are progressive.
SPEAKER_02Yep.
SPEAKER_0197 to 98% of the faculty, and something like 95% of the students, at that point, you're creating a radicalizing monolith. And um, you can't do that in the other direction and expect to get better scholarly and educational outcomes, but you also don't want to give up your mission altogether.
SPEAKER_02You
SPEAKER_01don't want to give up your standards and start hiring the Wiccans in the medical school or the alchemists in the chemistry department. And so these questions just become very, very difficult to navigate. I'm curious how you think about that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, I worked, I was previously at UT Austin and at the Attorney General's office before that. And, you know, I had a great mentor who always talked about hive mind
SPEAKER_01and
SPEAKER_02making decisions in executive leadership roles about hive mind is bad, even if ultimately the the overall consensus is go this way, this is the way to do it, whether it's file a lawsuit, employ a policy. You have to have somebody there to steel man this with you and understand and be the dissenting view. And
SPEAKER_00if
SPEAKER_02it's one versus 50 in a faculty lounge, I think that one person's gonna get overwhelmed. And then what you're describing is also the fundamental flaw that's gonna be the idea of again, like DEI for conservatives is what I've heard it described before. It's
SPEAKER_00like,
SPEAKER_02okay, we hire the three people, they're conservative in three.
SPEAKER_00Three.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00One. The
SPEAKER_02search is gonna last several years and there'll be a new president by this by the time it gets over. But the idea being that what are those three people gonna do? I mean, they're gonna enjoy whatever particular field they're in, they're gonna go to conferences, but are are they gonna change the culture and become more of a robust exchange of ideas? I don't think so. What I think you see for the most part is they become the at best the curmudgeon
SPEAKER_00who's
SPEAKER_02saying there's something wrong here, there's something wrong here. And that doesn't actually change the culture, that just becomes social media fodder in a way.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And we're talking about fundamentally changing and creating an actual place where ideas are sharpened with other ideas. And that's what fundamentally I think is, I'm gonna say I think it's impossible at current universities in the current sense, with a few exceptions, obviously.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I again this is hard. This is really hard. And um, I think your university, if I may humbly submit a suggestion, should be for the advancement of Western civilization. And an ingredient in Western civilization is the pursuit of truth, which requires academic debate within reason. But just like a free marketplace of ideas does not have to invite someone who would like to abolish that free marketplace, because you just like you know, do you have to allow into a democratic process a political party who would like to end elections?
SPEAKER_00No, it's self-defeating. There must be parameters. And the question is, you know, what advances Western civilization? What is the range of academic freedom that really allows for this genuine pursuit uh for truth? Maybe Western civilization is wrong. Maybe it's a mistake, but you know what? Let other uh civilizations make that argument, right? We live in this society, in this civilization, and we believe it's worth defending. We don't have to reinvent the wheel, you know, with every, you know, redefend Western civilization, you know, every moment against all the possible alternatives.
SPEAKER_00We live in the West. This is our civilization. We can start with that as a baseline. And then the question becomes which fields, you know, are out of bounds? And quite frankly, I think Marxism, Marxians are probably out of bounds because, you know, if they get a majority, um, then Western civilization is over. It's like, okay, let them found their own university and their own civilization, but I don't have to give them room, you know, in the faculty lounge. If you believe Israel is an imperial colonialist project, you know, then like I'm sorry, I don't, you know, we don't really need to hear that. We can have a reasonable debate over Israeli geopolitics and the treatment of the Palestinians or what have you.
SPEAKER_00Uh but you know, um if you believe America is fundamentally and ultimately evil such that it should be, you know, uh or Western civilization should be destroyed or erased, like I mean we don't have to give you a room in the faculty curriculum. Now what fields fit that, I don't know necessarily. I have some it's exposed. Okay, look,
SPEAKER_02say
SPEAKER_00that
SPEAKER_02and then I'll touch you about the API. The particular thing you mentioned right there is that Marxists can go found there in universities. I'm sorry to tell you, there's already several. That's right. That's right. That's right.
SPEAKER_00Josh is fortunate not to teach at one. Uh meaning, but I did hand
SPEAKER_01I did.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I didn't I left it at some cost. Because I didn't want to be at a place like that anymore.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. No, that's right. Okay. Uh I don't want to go too much longer, maybe 10 more minutes. So tell me about the American Bar Association. So you are trying to cut out the ABA from the accreditation process. What's wrong with the ABA from your perspective? You had a, I think you had a piece uh kind of talking about this, and what is your alternative path? I think it's a Texas Supreme Court, right? And are you a little nervous about the recent election and whether that changes that prospect? But tell us about the ABA and the stranglehold it sort of had and your perspective on that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I'm sorry you just want to go a little bit longer because I could go, we could talk for three hours about this because it's almost easier to say what's not, what what what works with that, because that list is so much shorter. Uh it really it has it's a professional group that exercises monopoly control over an entire profession and it's state-assisted. Every state almost every state has given up its authority to say we know what a good lawyer is from a good law school to this group that has certain constituencies that they are helping to economically as well as politically enrich themselves.
SPEAKER_02I mean, it's clear as day. Look at the product. Bill Clinton's DOJ sued over this and said
SPEAKER_00I didn't know that.
SPEAKER_02Yes, they brought a antitrust lawsuit saying you are increasing the wages, you're essentially doing things that are detached from the educational product.
SPEAKER_00Wait, how isn't it a cartel? It is price fixing. Or I guess they don't fix prices, but
SPEAKER_02but it's not
SPEAKER_01supply. And in fact, if you look at the uh archives of ABA proceedings, there are explicit statements throughout their history that they need to restrict the supply of lawyers in order to keep the fees high.
SPEAKER_00That's fascinating.
SPEAKER_01There's no doubt about it. It was explicit.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and so and so like you can look at this now. I think the FTC, I think there's several um U.S. attorneys that have put things in on this when some of these states are debating whether they should create alternative paths. Because in reality, a lot of these states that create these alternative pathways in are not saying you can't be ABA accredited. Like if you choose that, and that's your lot in life or your law school, you want to be restrained to one model, have at it. But the idea of creating other pathways that are credited by other individual other institutions, including state supreme courts, that's all they're saying.
SPEAKER_02Because the ABA at its core dictates the model of legal education. And it is elitist model that it's one size fits all, and it encourages absolutely insane cost on two schools themselves. It stifles innovation and it It does not allow you as a dean of one of those law schools to really engineer a different innovative product. And the people, this hurts. Like, you know, people get hung up on the ideology piece. Like, oh, they have these left-wing requirements.
SPEAKER_02Yes. I mean, that that speaks for itself. But I think at its core, we need to all focus on I would say the AVA is one of the primary cost drivers for the cost of legal education. The massive full faculty requirements and the limitations on the amount they can
SPEAKER_00teach.
SPEAKER_02I mean, their definition of full faculty.
SPEAKER_00Well, that's the one part of the rules. You like it's support.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00You know, I don't want to teach more of the next credits, you
SPEAKER_02know.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. But but then the key
SPEAKER_02being like, I think that I think the maybe the FTC is like, so like our model, for example, outside of this scheme is going to be practitioners, the actual subject matter experts coming in, and like there's limitations on how much they can teach in the first year. You can't tell me if I bring a federal judge from the Fifth Circuit to teach con law who deals with this every single day that they can't teach in the first year. And the big excuse they'll give you is oh, you can get a waiver, you can get a waiver. We would have to ask for a waiver out of all of their requirements because they're all pretty much bad. I mean, it it's unbelievable.
SPEAKER_02But you
SPEAKER_00know,
SPEAKER_02you see.
SPEAKER_00You're not looking for a variance. I'm looking for this whole thing not to apply to me. You know, so it doesn't make sense. Exactly.
SPEAKER_02And that's a response is well, you can ask for, you know, fiddle with the edges here, and yes, oh, somebody does it a little bit different. But like we need a wholesale teardown of this. There are certain institutions in this country that are worth saving, reforming, and then some that need to be burned down.
SPEAKER_00The
SPEAKER_02ABA is in the category of burned down. That's my thought about this, and I think that's why we're not asking their permission
SPEAKER_00to
SPEAKER_02do this.
SPEAKER_01Let's let's let's build this up for our audience a little bit. First of all, is the ABA private or public or both?
SPEAKER_02It's it's private, but it wields a lot of public power.
SPEAKER_01Make sense of that for me? How does that make sense? Make sense of that for them.
SPEAKER_02So uh it's a professional organization of lawyers that are dictating the rules for law schools who produce those lawyers.
SPEAKER_01Okay, so that's that would be private. That would be a group of lawyers get together and say, let's form an organization to sort of certify law schools as high quality. So far, it should be private. How does it get its public role?
SPEAKER_02State Supreme Courts throughout this country, um, depending on, you know, up to 60 years ago in some instances, said the state supreme courts have the inherent power to decide in almost every instance what is a sufficiently adequate law program. That leads to the people and the gatekeeping of who could take the bar exam. So state supreme courts used to say these schools are sufficient, their students can take the bar exam. From the bar exam, that is the ability to practice law in the states.
SPEAKER_02And so you would be able to say go to X Law School in Texas and then practice in New York or somewhere else. The problem is those state supreme courts have then abdicated that role to the ABA, a third party, so to say who is the stamp of approval.
SPEAKER_01So the state supreme courts got in the habit of saying anyone and only someone who goes to an ABA accredited law school is eligible to sit for the bar.
SPEAKER_02Correct.
SPEAKER_01But there's another piece to it, isn't it? And it's the federal funding part.
SPEAKER_02Yes.
SPEAKER_01Do you want to talk about that a little bit?
SPEAKER_02Uh
SPEAKER_00is federal funding tied to the ABA?
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. If you go to an ABA accredited, so um the Department of Education uh will give loans to you for your law school education if you go to an ABA accredited. So it's
SPEAKER_00to the students. So the students. So you cannot get a federal loan to go to law school unless it's ABA accredited.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02But it's a little different than that. So it's all about Title IV funding. This is gonna get way deep in the weeds. You may want to edit this. Because you
SPEAKER_00don't want. No, no, no, I'm
SPEAKER_01not gonna do it.
SPEAKER_00I'm trying
SPEAKER_01to simplify it a little bit. And I was simplifying a little bit. But you don't want
SPEAKER_00federal funding, right? Don't you want to be like Hillsdale?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well, we
SPEAKER_00I mean, you know,
SPEAKER_02we don't want to want to be like Hillsdale, but we appreciate Hillsdale. In the
SPEAKER_00sense of, in the sense of, I don't want a dollar of federal funding. You could your your your students go for free.
SPEAKER_02Exactly. And we also we disclaimed all federal money, including grants. So we we didn't want the strings attached to it.
SPEAKER_00We
SPEAKER_02know
SPEAKER_00they come with conditions.
SPEAKER_02Exactly. And and we ultimately are independent, fiercely independent, and we will we will never go down that route. But the point being, Title IV funding, student loans. That's the Department of Ed says, ABA, right now you are the sole accreditor of law schools. We will recognize you. You are it. What that does in a few different angles is it makes it so no one else is willing to try to stand up and say we'll do it better, because what are you gonna do? Invest$3 million,$4 million standing up for an organization knowing that this one accreditor is the only game in town.
SPEAKER_02On top of that, um, but that creates this prime position for the ABA. They are it. And so the state Supreme Court says, look, they're it. This seems like the way to go. They are the only ones.
SPEAKER_01But that means that both being able to sit for the bar and being able to get student loans depends on ABA accreditation. And so both from the federal angle and from the state angle, the ABA is being stood up as essentially the monopoly certifier. Now, what happens when you have a monopoly certifier? Well, one thing they try to do is drive up costs, right? They drive up their constituency as the law schools themselves, they're trying to drive up the cost of your legal education. So what do they do? They say you can't have a two-year degree, only a three-year degree.
SPEAKER_01And they invent pretext for why that's the case. Well, you need this class and this class and this class and you need this amount of experiential education. Maybe it's educationally justified. More likely it's not. In any case, it's incentivized, right? So they have an interest in driving up the cost of legal education. That restricts the supply of lawyers, which keeps lawyers' fees high at whose expense? At the expense of all those small business owners who might need a lawyer that doesn't cost$300 an hour or
SPEAKER_00more.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Well, I so would you be the first to break away from or are there other law schools that have sought some other pathway? Actually, I just read a story about this. Arizona just approved, the state Supreme Court approved Grand Canyon University.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And and so
SPEAKER_00uh without the ABA, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Well, there is Arizona's always been so fascinating to me because they they've done some things that I'm like, this is I guess it's because it's just kind of like the true Wild West. They will take they will take innovative approaches. Well, they'll take innovative approaches, and I like that. And Grand Canyon, I've what I've heard about it, it's I'm
unknownsure
SPEAKER_02it'll be a great program. It'll be geared towards uh, I think it's online learning and a lot of uh more, I believe there's a Christian angle to there somewhere. But so schools have done this. Um there's a Nashville school law also in Nashville that produces like strangely a lot of lawyers in Tennessee that go elsewhere. It's meant started as an like an executive ed program. So it's a very interesting model. I would argue there is no going back to argument high-profile, credible uh law school that can do this because there's so many blockers.
SPEAKER_02So, like, yes, I think Grand Canyon is going to produce a massive amount of lawyers that will help in Arizona. That's great. Nashville School of Law. We want to be national because this is a national problem. This is not just a Texas or just a Florida issue. We have to crack the portability as well, because this is a problem for America, not just affordability, access to justice, as some like to say, but also like the degradation of the constitutional system we have. We have to have fighters that will go out into all of these states that will hold government accountable, will preserve the structure, the history, and the tradition of our constitution.
SPEAKER_02So we are gonna do it differently. We're gonna be bold and we're gonna go for it. We're gonna swing for the fences. And
SPEAKER_00when can we expect an announcement of a new dean? Next year, two years? What's the we
SPEAKER_02would look we would shoot for early next year.
SPEAKER_00All right. Well, I think we are out of time to our audience. I hope you enjoyed this special episode with me and Josh in studio, together in Washington, D.C., and with our guest, Adam Biggs from the University of Austin. Uh at Texas, or how do you describe it? UATX or
SPEAKER_02UATX. UATX is the easiest way to go.
SPEAKER_00University of Austin, UATX. Thank you for the wonderful discussion. Hit that like and subscribe button. As always, leave us a review, leave us a rating, follow us on Substack, rationally based.substack.com, and we will see you next time.
Should the parties pick their candidates in smoke-filled rooms, or does that just hand control back to the elites? And can Boulder, Colorado sue Exxon and Suncor for the costs of climate change? Hosts Kathryn Johnson...
In a Tennessee manslaughter trial, the judge barred the jury from learning that the deceased - the defendant’s sexual partner of two years - was a biological male who identified as a woman. The appeals court reversed,...
Susan Collins lost in Maine after years as the most moderate Republican in the Senate. Across the country, Republicans ran solid candidates and still underperformed. In Alaska, “Decoy Dan” Sullivan remains on the ballot...
A Brazilian Supreme Court justice who used to be Lula’s personal lawyer ordered the polls kept open for two hours after they were supposed to close. Another ordered the opposition candidate, Bolsonaro, to surrender his...
Trump’s Office of Legal Counsel has been on a tear, and hosts Ilan Wurman, Kathryn Johnson, and Joshua Kleinfeld explain the big developments. Guns: OLC announced that the federal ban on selling handguns to...