In a Tennessee manslaughter trial, the judge barred the jury from learning that the deceased - the defendant’s sexual partner of two years - was a biological male who identified as a woman. The appeals court reversed, holding that biological sex was relevant to whether the defendant reasonably feared imminent harm. Duh. The Left claimed the ruling created a “trans panic” defense. It did no such thing. And isn't this all obvious? How could a courtroom turn into a vehicle for the propagation of such fundamental mistruths about human nature? Two law professors also published an article arguing that the Supreme Court’s transgender cases undermine sex equality - a claim that only works if sex is not binary. The problem is, their own footnotes said the opposite: sex is dimorphic, determined at fertilization, and defined by reproductive function. This is a reminder of how thin the line between scholarship and advocacy can become when an academic field treats a contested ideological claim as settled fact. Hosts Kathryn Johnson and law professors Joshua Kleinfeld and Ilan Wurman take on both issues. This is the rational - and based - discussion of biological sex, criminal justice, and the legal academy that you won’t hear anywhere else. This is the rational - and based - discussion of the midterms, primaries, turnout, and election integrity that you won’t hear anywhere else. Be sure to LIKE, SHARE, COMMENT, and SUBSCRIBE to rationally BASED! Subscribe to our Substack! New Podcast Episodes every Thursday morning, find us on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or on YouTube! Follow us on social media on Instagram, X, Facebook, and TikTok!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Welcome back to Rationally Based, a podcast about law and politics on the edge. I'm Elon Werman, a law professor at the University of Minnesota Law School. I'm Josh Kreinfeld, uh Rouse Professor of Law at Scalia Law School.
SPEAKER_00And I'm Catherine Johnson with Center of the American Experiment.
SPEAKER_01Catherine, what's on deck today?
SPEAKER_00Well, we've got two topics on transgender issues. First, in a murder trial, a judge excluded information related to the biological sex of the victim when it seems pretty relevant to me. And then some law professors got in hot water for making a claim that gender isn't binary and is just assigned at birth. Problem is, the sources they cited said that gender is binary and is determined at fertilization. Whoops.
SPEAKER_01Well, this is a slightly shorter episode because we couldn't cover these topics last week because of the midterms. So we hope you enjoy uh this episode dedicated to these two transgender issues. Let's dive in. All right, well, don't forget to hit that like and subscribe button. Catherine, where should we start?
SPEAKER_01Originally, we were going to do some sort of fun segment on leftist legal lunacy, and then we decided wait, all of our segments are kind of about leftist legal lunacy. So we need a better recurring segment because it's not a recurring segment of the whole podcast, it's about leftist legal lunacy. Nevertheless, there's a lot of leftist legal lunacy on this whole episode. This one might take the cake, though. So, Catherine, set it up.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, if you guys have ideas for our recurring segment, you should put them in the comments on our YouTube page because yeah, we need something like a little bit better. And I feel like there's got to be someone in our audience who is a little more creative than the three of us. So go over to our YouTube.
SPEAKER_01Hey, I thought of a I thought of a pretty good one last week because remember, we talked about Dan Sullivan and Josh talked about Boris Visnevsky and how actually it was straight out of Putin's playbook. So I think we should start doing a recurring segment called Who Did It First? Putin or the Democrats? I do like that. That would be a good one. I can't promise we'll have content every day about that. But our audience, if you can see parallels between Putin and the Democrats, of which there are many, please do let us know and we will highlight that on our podcast.
SPEAKER_01But Catherine is absolutely right. You should reach out to us on our Substack. We can stay in touch with you there, rationallybase.substack.com. You can comment, you can send us questions. We're always happy to tackle audience questions on air. We haven't gotten any such audience questions um in several weeks. So please uh feel free to ask us about anything that we are um talking about on the show. Okay, so what takes the cake this week, Catherine?
SPEAKER_00All right. Well, we're starting it off with a little bit of true crime here, I feel like, which is kind of fun for me.
SPEAKER_01Or false or falsehood crime. I mean, I don't know what's true about this. We'll see.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so in Tennessee, there was a man who has been convicted of voluntary manslaughter after a jury rejected his claim of self-defense. The deceased, the defendant's reported sexual partner for two years, was transgender. So it's a biological man who identified as a woman. Obviously, this is a terrible situation. Someone is dead and justice must be served, but that has, of course, been made harder by the left because the first part of this craziness came during the actual trial.
SPEAKER_00And the judge at trial, who was Judge Carlin Addison, excluded all evidence that the deceased who had a gun was a trans biological man. So she said it wasn't relevant to the self-defense claims. But as far as the jury knows, this was simply a case of a man shooting his female girlfriend when the truth is much more complicated. And it seems to me that that kind of makes a difference. No, if it's physically a man or physically a woman that you are defending yourself against.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so Tennessee Appeals Court thankfully held that the trial court was wrong because the biological sex of the deceased was relevant. Well, because for self-defense claim, you need to have reasonably believed there was an imminent danger of death or serious bodily injury. And it makes a different case if the person who is threatening you is another man and not a woman. Duh. After the appellate court granted a new trial, the left lost its mind. And that's the real reason this news is uh on our radar today, because the left is now claiming that the appeals court ruled that the killing may have been justified just because the deceased was trans.
SPEAKER_00Obviously, that's deliberately wrong, politically motivated, misleading. It's a misreading of the ruling. Josh, as the criminal law expert here, please take over with what is going on.
SPEAKER_02Well, I'm gonna I'm gonna talk about some rules of criminal law and evidence, but I think the bottom line is simple. The question is, is biological ident sex and trans identity, so the fact of a biological man presenting as a woman relevant to the reasonableness of the defendant's fear because of size and strength and aggression patterns and that sort of thing? Or is saying we the defense want to present evidence that that this um that the person killed was a man and uh was in fact trans, is that just inviting, you know, what you might call a trans panic defense that the judge rightly excluded?
SPEAKER_02And should the jury be able to decide for itself, hear the evidence, and make a decision itself about whether trans was a factor or the fact that the um the you it's weird because it's like the victim who is also the aggressor, the the person who is claimed to have been the aggress aggressor and spurred the self-defense. Um uh, does that person being a man matter? So ask yourself this if you were a juror, you were sitting on that jury, and you were trying in all sincerity to do justice, would you want to know that the person who died was in fact a biological man presenting as a woman?
SPEAKER_02Would you consider that relevant or is it irrelevant? All that matters is that the person in question had a gun. And by the way, that's the situation. So the decedent, the uh person who was killed, had a gun, was in a relationship with the person who so they both had guns, and uh the boyfriend shot the girlfriend or boyfriend or whatever you want to call it. So this is a tale of three statutes. Um first of all, there's the Tennessee Criminal Code, section 3911, 611, and it's what it's the piece of the code that defines self-defense in cases of deadly force.
SPEAKER_02And there are basically three conditions. The person using deadly force and self-defense has to have a reasonable and genuine belief about imminent, serious bodily harm. Okay, so each of those is a separate element, right? I have to, like if I'm in a big argument with Catherine and I use deadly force, I have to be in serious, imminent danger, or imminent danger of serious bodily harm, which means not a slap to the face, like it means like a stab to the chest or something.
SPEAKER_02And it has to be reasonable, that is, I have to have good reason to think that she's gonna assault, and it has to be genuine. I have to genuinely believe it. So those are the three conditions for Tennessee self-defense.
SPEAKER_01Josh, can I stop here just for our audience so they understand? I know a lot of times we talk about federal law. Here, Josh meant to mention the Tennessee Criminal Code, and that's because basic assault, battery, you know, murder, thing, homicide are governed by state laws, and they're generally going to be the same in the various jurisdictions or very similar because it's all comes from the sort of the same common law. But so this is probably similar to what we'll see in all the other states, but that's why Josh were focusing on the Tennessee criminal code, right?
SPEAKER_01And yeah, thanks for that clarification.
SPEAKER_02100%. I'm I'm discussing Tennessee criminal law right now. Uh the Tennessee Rules of Evidence, Rule 401, says the trial court should admit all relevant evidence, and it defines relevance in a really broad way. And Rule 403 says even if evidence is relevant, it can be excluded, and now I'm going to quote the crucial language, if its probative value is substantially outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice.
SPEAKER_01And that's the same as the federal rules of evidence, actually. Right? 401 and 403 seems the same rules numbers.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Okay, so here's a here's the here are the questions. It sets up the questions. Is the fact of the decedent being a biological male relevant to the defendant's reasonable and genuine belief that he was in serious uh and imminent danger? Is the fact of being trans relevant to the case at all? Is the fact of being trans so prejudicial as to outweigh the evidence? So the first question, relevant to a reasonable and genuine belief of harm, that's about whether this qualifies as self-defense.
SPEAKER_02The next is trans relevant, that's about rule 401. Is being trans so prejudicial as to outweigh relevance? That's about rule 403. So here's what defense counsel said. I'm gonna quote it. Quote: The relative strength of biological males and females was relevant to self-defense. It at least goes a little bit to whether my client, the defendant, was in fear and how much fear he was in and why. Here's what Judge Addison said in response. I'll quote it again. I just don't believe that gender is relevant here.
SPEAKER_02Someone in possession of a firearm is in control of a deadly weapon. Whether that person has a vagina or a penis has no bearing on the deadliness of a firearm. We will not speak about gender identity or assign sex at birth. We will address the decedent as according to the rules that that person lived by, Ms. Paris Nicole Lee.
SPEAKER_00And now sex at birth, that kind of gives away the plot here of which side she's on.
SPEAKER_01Just to be clear, these we've talked about this on the podcast before, right? The Kissinger quote that maybe it made sense 60 years ago. I've been thinking about this, Josh, right? The quote you hate, the aphorism you hate, that why are academic disputes so bitter because so little is at stake and you think that's dangerous because you know they don't actually just grow up and go into the real world, they become the real world. This is an example of someone who went to, I don't know, Williams College or Scripps College or some insanely left-wing school, took all the gender studies, and then somehow became a judge, and now literally says things like sex assigned birth in these judicial opinions, which is kind of crazy.
SPEAKER_01And of course, you know, like, oh, the role they lived by. Well, I pretend that I'm a child, or I'd like to think that I'm a child. Oh, you killed a child. Like, is obviously we wouldn't do it there, right? But okay, we're Josh has more to say.
SPEAKER_02I have a million things to say about that, Elon, because it's not just this judge, it's our entire society. Like, how did we get all this madness about race and gender and oppression and all this stuff? Well, those ideas became totally dominant in the universities in the 80s and 90s, and now every people grow, absorb those ideas, go out into the quote unquote real world, take it over and occupy positions of power. And everybody's like, where did this crazy wokeness come from? Like it happened yesterday, right? It happened because of universities, because actually, universities are the most important institution in the world.
SPEAKER_02Maybe that said, um, I want to just uh then quote the appellate court. Here's what the appellate court said in reversing the trial court quote, while a gun might equalize differences in physical strength and size, there are other inherent physiological differences between the sexes that science continues to reveal and that we choose not to ignore. And as to bias, the danger of bias ran both ways in this case. The court was there making the point that, like, okay, maybe there'll be biased against the trans uh decedent, but they the jury who's biased in that case might equally be biased against the trans the trans loving dis defendant, right?
SPEAKER_02The person who is in a relationship with the trans decedent. So, anyway, this is all very tangled. What I come back to is this. So far as the jury knew, this was a guy in an argument with his girlfriend, a biological woman. She had a gun and he shot her dead. And that isn't the real picture. This is a human situation. There's texture to a human situation. In general, I don't like it when law excludes evidence, when the law leads to an exclusion of evidence, or when judges choose to exclude a lot of evidence.
SPEAKER_02Uh, a lot of character evidence gets excluded, a lot of history evidence gets excluded. Now I don't agree with that. But in general, when when lawyers know a version of the situation that the juries don't know, right? So the lawyers, if they're talking about with each other, are saying all sorts of things that the jurors never heard, that detracts from justice. It does not add to justice. But in this case, it's it seems really significant. I mean, sure, both have a gun, but I think the propensity to use it is higher with a biological man.
SPEAKER_02And I would rest my case there. And if I was on the jury trying to do justice, I'd want to know. And I imagine you feel the same, and that's your answer. So, you know, the larger point is it goes to this problem of pervasive dishonesty. The left's agenda is to change how we use language and change how we report facts to fit their conception of justice. And it makes life just be in a function. So you read stories in the newspaper about some act of violence, some true crime, a criminal act, right?
SPEAKER_02And they won't mention that the perpetrator was trans. Or you'll read about some act of violence, and they won't mention that the perpetrator, because it's not just trans, they won't mention that the perpetrator yelled Alu Akbar before they do it. They just do the reporting and leave it out. You know, I get reports of crimes on campus, and it's like, it's just like an assault was committed here at such and such a date, and I'm like, well, wait, what happened? And they leave all the relevant details out because what? The details are uncomfortable because of racial reasons or gender reasons or Islamic reasons or whatever.
SPEAKER_02So in the criminal context, those deceptive practices, those misleading practices lead to serious, serious miscarriages of justice. But in general, it leads to this experience of life in a funhouse mirror where like the official story isn't the real story, and you've got to kind of dig to find out what the real story is. And personally, I just hate that. My my sense of like, like we need a society committed to truth, and truth implies not just not strictly lying, but a certain level of disclosure and candor.
SPEAKER_01Okay, Josh, I I'm learning about criminal law on the fly, actually, listening to you a little bit. And I have some questions. So you mentioned that a lot of evidence, and by the way, to our audience, you know, sometimes we have notes and some semblance of a script, but you know, sometimes we like to surprise each other uh with uh what we hear and conversation. So you said we exclude too much evidence, including character evidence. And did you say propensity evidence? So is it your view that rule 404B is wrong or 404A is wrong?
SPEAKER_01Uh or what did you mean by excluding character evidence? So to the before you to the uninitiated to our listeners, rule 404 basically says uh you cannot prove, uh you cannot use the fact that someone has committed similar crimes in the past as evidence that they committed that same crime or similar crime on this particular occasion, right? Because it makes some sense, right? Lots of people commit crimes, I guess. The fact that you have committed a similar crime, say, three times before, doesn't mean you did this one the fourth time.
SPEAKER_01Now there are lots of exceptions, like if you had a modus operandi, like an MO, like all three crimes were done exactly the same way, right? In some sort of some sort of signature weapon, and then the fourth crime was similar, that's an MO, and you're allowed to introduce that.
SPEAKER_00But as a but if you just rape a bunch, that doesn't count. You just can't bring in the other rapes because that's exactly right, Catherine.
SPEAKER_02It's by law, the evidence is excluded. So if someone has been convicted three times of like child sexual assault and they're being accused a fourth time, the jury isn't allowed to hear about the prior three times. And yes, Ilan, I do disagree with that.
SPEAKER_01Interesting. Could you just give me like a nutshell on that? I mean, that's super fascinating. I've always it's never sat comfortable with me, actually. So I'm curious.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, uh first of all, I admit the considerations are on both sides. So I don't mean to say, you know, this is outrageous. Here's the reason, Catherine, why that evidence is characteristically excluded. It seems like when juries hear that somebody has been convicted of doing the crime before, that's it. They won't hear anything else. They are convicting for sure. Like nothing will talk them out of it at that point. And so it's it's like this evidence is too strong. It's toxic, it it give it deprives the accused of the right to have a a real hearing on whether they did it this time.
SPEAKER_02And I get that, and it's reasonable. But here's the thing that always bothers me. You know, when Al Capone was convicted of tax evasion, you realize he was a celebrity gangster? The whole country knew Al Capone was a gangster, but we couldn't prove it. Um ever seen the Wire, right? The TV show The Wire? The whole neighborhood knows Omar and Avon Barksdale are the leading drug dealers in town. And you see the police in Baltimore getting these elaborate warrants and listening to and spending a year plus doing a special investigation with a big team so that they can prove it.
SPEAKER_02I think this is in fact that piece of that's accurate, right? There are so many instances where it's sort of like everyone in the community knows, sometimes everyone in the country knows that um a certain person is a gangster, a criminal leader, whatever, and it's so difficult for prosecutors to prove. What I take from that as a theoretical matter is our standards of evidence are too high. We need to reduce them so that convictions aren't quite this difficult.
SPEAKER_02I fully believe in beyond a reasonable doubt, but some of this is going to the point of beyond a shadow of a doubt. And we do not need an evidentiary standard that's beyond a shadow of a doubt. It's beyond a reasonable doubt.
SPEAKER_01I love that explanation, Josh. That is learning in real time for me. I really appreciate that discussion. Uh, I want to move on to the other topic. So the only thing I'll say about this is I just want to emphasize that it's one thing if they wanted to refer to the decedent as the decedent, the decedent, the decedent, such that no one knows what the sex is. Of course, everyone would be like, well, that's weird. Why aren't we talking about the decedent? But to but it's not neutral, right? By saying you're female, they think you're a biological female. And that goes back to your point. So they weren't being neutral.
SPEAKER_01I still think it would be wrong if they simply said the decedent, the decedent, the decedent, leaving people to guess, right? Because it's obviously prohibitive one way or the other. But they actively lied. And what bothers me about this whole thing is the legal system, the adversarial process, is geared toward truth. That's why we do it. It's the search for truth through zealous advocates on both sides. And when judges exclude evidence like this, it which is common sense to everybody, it is literally using a system geared toward the pursuit of truth in service of lies. And that really doesn't sit well with me.
SPEAKER_01But okay, we uh can I add something about that?
SPEAKER_02Because I I completely agree with you, and I think that's a really, really good distinction between simply excluding and then insisting on something that's misleading. Yeah. Right? Uh, because notice what the judge said. I mean, let me go back to that quote. We will not speak about gender identity, we will address the decedent according to the rules that that person lived by Ms. Paris Nicole Lee. That's the way that's a good thing. So you are, you are speaking. Yes, you are speaking about gender identity then. And and what it even means is the defense attorney was required to refer to this person as Ms.
SPEAKER_02Paris Nicole Lee. The defense attorney, so adversarial process is about each side making its best case, right? The prosecutor is there with a job, and the prosecutor's job is to say this was not a genuine case of self-defense. This was a case of, you know, pure murder or voluntary manslaughter based on provocation or whatever it was, right? But the defense attorney gets to say, no, it was the decedent, or even, you know, but when you exclude the evidence and insist on the lie, it's not even the decedent.
SPEAKER_02Ms. Lee, Ms. Lee, Ms. Lee. The defense attorney has to play along, which undermines the adversarial truth-seeking mission.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you can at least say, you know, if the defense had said Mr. Le, Mr. Lee, Mr. Lee, and the prosecution had said misli, missly, missly, at least that's zealous advocacy on both sides, you know, and the jury can't figure out what's happening. Okay, uh, we had another related topic, and I will set this one up. Uh, it's a related uh transgender issue. Uh, I want to be slightly delicate here. Uh two law professors who happen to co-host um, shall we say, a competitor podcast. I should say two of the three who host a competitor podcast.
SPEAKER_01We're not talking about advisory opinions. We already kind of uh Josh uh uh criticized um uh our friendly competitors over there uh on a recent issue. My goodness, what was it? Oh, the DOJ lawsuit in Alaska. That's that's what it was. Uh but this is a different podcast, and if you if you know, you know. And if you don't know, you can find out. It's not that hard.
SPEAKER_00Less friendly.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, they're definitely less friendly. Um less friendly, yes. Um anyway, they got into some hot water. Two of the three uh professors got into some hot water uh at this point, two weeks ago, probably. You know, uh we've been pushing the story off a little bit. Um but the The expose came from a Substack called Bad Facts. And I just wanted to give a shout-out to that Substack, which is called Bad Facts by someone named Glenna Goldis. So I really recommend that Substack to everybody. And the article in question, so these law professors wrote an article in the Supreme Court Review, whose editors are prominent University of Chicago law professors.
SPEAKER_01And they're also been getting some heat for this too. And look, it's obviously true that not every footnote is site-checked before a piece is accepted, let alone after it's accepted, when it comes to sort of a peer-review journal, right? It doesn't have the normal process where students go through every citation and so on. These are run by law professors, not law students. But the problem here.
SPEAKER_00Wait, wait, the journals run by professors are less fast than the ones run by students? Is that what you're saying?
SPEAKER_01That's actually hilarious. And yes. So yes. So there, so the it's kind of funny when you point it out, Catherine.
SPEAKER_02It's pretty crazy.
SPEAKER_01It's actually pretty hilarious.
SPEAKER_00I do remember my husband on law review. That was like one of the big jobs was checking citations, and you'd always be like, oh, it's it's such a, you know, it's a whole process.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's like basically testing whether you can endure that level of boredom for the sake of professional advancement. And you prove that you can and therefore get more jobs where you get to be bored for the sake of professional advancement.
SPEAKER_01Yes. So I know a lot of our listeners are probably law students and recent law graduates, but if you aren't, most law reviews are run by students and the students select it, and the students do the site checking and the blue booking, so the proper formatting and editing. And the advantage of that is that the students are really scrupulous about all of that stuff. But the disadvantage is what do students know on the selection front, right? Like what do they really know? I, however, we're not going to defend law reviews here. I, however, am a defender generally of student uh run law journals, uh, just because I don't think they are any less ideologic, any more ideologically captured than faculty-run law reviews.
SPEAKER_01So ideologic ideological capture is sort of a constant. And I do think there's more diversity, and so you have more of a chance of breaking in. And I will uh uh also add that uh I think law professors should do a better job at communicating ideas to students. And if the students can understand it and understand the novelty, that is a a good test. Okay, okay, but let's get to the story, right? Yeah, sorry. Okay, all right. So um anyway, so this was a faculty uh run publication, so peer review and accepting, but then they don't, you know, really sideshick things.
SPEAKER_01But really, this should have come through in the selection process itself. Why? So the piece is about uh the whole article is basically about how the Supreme Court's trans cases fundamentally, transgender cases, fundamentally undermine sex equality. That's the argument. The piece is called Scrimetti Trump and the coming sex equality realignment. But to say that the court's trans cases uh undermine sex equality, that can only be plausibly argued if you think that sex is not binary, right? So it relies on this factual premise, right? Because if you uh it requires you to believe that you are discriminating against a sex or a gender that is transgender or you know, this non-binary, something other than male and female, right?
SPEAKER_01Because if sex is binary, then prohibition on trans participation in sports isn't actually discrimination, right? Because if you're a biological male, you have your own sports team. It's the male team, right? If sex is male and female, then that's not actually discrimination. Keeping boys out of girls' sports is not discrimination. Um, banning, this is the Scribetti case, transgender procedures for minors isn't sex discrimination if sex is binary, right? It says nobody could do this of either sex, right? So the whole premise of the argument depends on believing that that basic intuition about human biology is false.
SPEAKER_01Right. And so that is sort of a central claim of this uh paper. But that still is not the real thrust. The real thrust of this is sorry, I know, I'm getting just so animated. Uh so the real thrust of this is they when they finally cite some literature for the proposition that you know sex is not binary, and therefore all of the claims of this piece make sense. They cite two sources that say the opposite, that actually sex is binary, and actually it is determined at conception, right?
SPEAKER_01And so here is uh the claim that is made in the paper. Even putting aside the social category of gender, the executive order, this comes in apart when they're talking about one of the EOs from the Trump administration, does not offer a remotely coherent definition of biological sex, which the scientific community understands to encompass a collection of characteristics, including the hormonal, anatomical, and genetic. Footnote. In fact, as experts note, it is impossible to identify a conception, the sex of developing reproductive cells. Footnote. Okay, so this claim to be clear, I think is central to the whole piece, but certainly central to the claim in the middle part of the piece about the nature of the executive order.
SPEAKER_01Okay, so here is what one source says, one of the footnotes says. Quote, the term sex should be used as a classification, generally as male or female, according to the reproductive organs and functions that derive from the chromosomal complement XX for female or XY for male. The other source says sex is dimorphic. Di meaning two, like right. Dimorphic, innate trait defined in relation to an organism's biological role in reproduction. In humans, primary sex determination occurs at fertilization and is directed by a complement of sex-determining genes on the X and Y chromosome.
SPEAKER_01So both claims that they made about not being binary and not being determined at conception were wrong. Now I guess my. Yeah, yeah, yeah. No, I'm done. I'm done.
SPEAKER_02Josh, go. I'm trying to unleash you. Go. Well, all I wanted to say is the claims were not just wrong, they were contradicted by the author's own footnotes. So they cited things that showed their claims to be wrong while claiming those things to be true.
SPEAKER_01So what is it, Josh? What does it say about the state of the legal academy? Okay, when so central a fact to the author's criticism of, in that case, of Trump EO and I think much more broadly, uh, to their argument is a statement of fact that is so contrary to what everyone knows and understands to be the truth, right? How can that just slip by in a peer-reviewed, you know, Supreme Court journal? Now, look, a lot of some Supreme Court uh journals, uh Supreme Court review papers are solicited. So it's possible it was solicited and they just submitted it, and it was because it was solicited, it was accepted.
SPEAKER_01I don't know exactly what kind of peer review it went through. But again, what does it tell us about the state of legal academy? Josh, what do you think?
SPEAKER_02You know, what a for me, I'm curious whether you agree with this, Elon. You know, I've been in academia for my adult life, and one of the lessons that I have learned, unhappily, is that the line between scholarship and propaganda is thin. Uh it's not a bright line, it's not a wall of separation, it's delicate, and people cross it piece by piece by degrees. Okay, so legal scholarship is allowed to have a normative perspective.
SPEAKER_02You're not just like reporting the results of an experiment. You know, we write with a certain kind of perspective on law, on politics, on all sorts of things. And part of what we're trying to do is develop that perspective in the context of an, you know, an argument that is that is well supported by facts and law, right? So we are responsible to the facts and law while trying to develop our normative perspective on things. And that's legitimate, right? The problem is it is so tempting to start um selectively presenting facts and law or spinning facts and law in a way that supports your particular position until by degrees you yourself can transition from doing genuine scholarship, which is truth seeking, to doing a kind of propaganda in an academic tone of voice.
SPEAKER_02And so, you know, what's happening now with like gender and trans issues, it came earlier to the field I started my career in, the field of criminal law. I kind of cut my teeth in the pre-tenure years in criminal law. It came with police and prison abolition. So criminal law has been for literally centuries, going back to this Italian name Beccaria before America was founded. Criminal law has always been a field devoted to milder punishment. It has always reflected the sort of progressive aversion to force.
SPEAKER_02Beccaria, back in like I think the 1760s, wrote the first tract condemning capital punishment, and it went totally viral in the 1770s. I mean, all of the founders had read it and had opinions about it, and they had differing opinions, by the way. Like Jefferson disagreed with Franklin, disagreed with Madison, disagreed with Hamilton. They were all talking about it and disagreeing about it. It went totally viral. So what happened was this like long-standing progressive aversion to force grew and grew and grew in the criminal field until it sort of crossed a certain Rubicon and it became: let's abolish criminal law, let's abolish police force, let's abolish punishment.
SPEAKER_02And that's obviously insane, right? Like I could just walk out of this room right now, my office, and I could go down to the street and I could grab someone and be like, hey, what do you think of abolishing prisons? What would happen? And they'd be like, Well, I think there'd be some bad people who had committed a lot of crimes, right? Everyone knew that, except academics who somehow didn't know what everyone knew. It was as though, in the field of physics, like everybody knows about gravity, except the professional physicists who are like, no, actually, if I drop this coffee cup, it will float because there's no gravity on it.
SPEAKER_02How can uh how can the people who are supposed to know the most about this be the ones who get it exactly wrong? And the so-called experts become the most misleading people on earth. But that's the thing. You move step by step until you cross a certain threshold. You know, Hegel has this great image in his logic, uh, uh, the philosopher Hegel, where he says, if you pluck enough hairs off a man's head, eventually he's bald. Right? So you keep, you keep biasing in the favor of no force, no force, no force, no force.
SPEAKER_02And also criminal law is racist, it's racist, it's racist, until eventually you're like, just get rid of prisons and police altogether. And then you're not doing scholarship anymore, because you're saying insane things. You're doing propaganda. And this is happening across academia, especially in the humanities and social sciences and related fields like law, but the hard sciences are not always immune. You know, you look for a historian these days and you get history with a social justice mission. You look for a, you know, a literature professor, you get Shakespeare with a social justice mission.
SPEAKER_02I met a law gender and feminism scholar back in 2015, and I asked her, I was like, what's your big idea? What's your project? And she said, gender is oppressive, eliminate gender. The goal is to eliminate gender. So this is really dangerous because academic fields seem secondary and irrelevant and not the real world until you find out that they're everything about how we see the real world and down, they're upstream from everything that happens in the real world. And when academic fields become dedicated to social justice projects rather than truth, the result is to is that you start insisting on the lies, the universities start slipping from truth-seeking to propaganda, the media follows suit, uh uh Hollywood, the cultural um creators follow suit.
SPEAKER_02And by degree, you have a society that looks like the Soviet Union, a society devoted to propaganda. So here's my closing thought on this, and then I really want to get your responses because it's I didn't intend the monologue. But we need a new conception of corruption. When people talk about corruption, they think about quid pro crow, you know, monetary corruption. You paid me for the use of power, right? But we need a concept of corruption that's corruption of mission. If your mission is to be a truth-seeking expert in a subject, right, and you're supposed to be uh teaching the truth and looking for the truth, it's a corruption to substitute a social justice mission.
SPEAKER_02If your mission is to play the violin and conduct the orchestra and make beautiful classical music, it's a corruption to mix that with a social justice mission. If your mission is to report the facts and be a good journalist, it's a corruption to mix that with a social justice mission. It's complicated because people are allowed to have normative perspectives, but we we need this expanded definition of corruption to deal with what's going on in academia and in the larger society.
SPEAKER_00Well, it's interesting, Josh, because people talk about this a lot, I think, with um politicians in particular get blamed for you know taking things too far and things like that. But I think if the same thing has happened in academia, I mean, look at they're taking it from academia, right? Yes, you know, abolishing enough of the blame, the professors.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely.
SPEAKER_00Because when my sister was in college, let's see, she's eight years older than me. We laughed and laughed because she had a professor who refused to write the word women with men in it. It was like with a why. This was a trend for a while. You wrote women with a why. Okay. By the time I got to college, you know, eight to ten years later, oh, things were way worse than that, right? So it just kept escalating. I wonder if part of that is like, is there an incentive in academia, would you say, to kind of carve out your own thing? Like maybe people just kept wanting to do more and more because they needed something new to write about.
SPEAKER_00And it's led to academia kind of becoming extremely left because people need a new material or a new niche for them to, for them to, you know, pontificate on. Does that make sense?
SPEAKER_02I think there's some of that. I just want to say, I have spent my whole life hearing about outrageous things being said and done in universities, in academia, and conservatives laughing at it. And then it takes five to 15 years and it has taken over the world. And it's not funny anymore, it's scary and powerful. And that is the pattern of things. Stop laughing. Anyone who's in the ambit of my voice, stop laughing at the craziness in universities and realize it's the most important thing in the world.
SPEAKER_01And I just want to be clear about this. The abolish, we we hear this today politically, is I think Josh, what you're referring to. There are literally people campaigning on, like, oh, we need to abolish prisons. And that sounds crazy, but actually, what you're saying is the criminal law field has been doing that for decades now and has sort of crowded anybody else out. And so they, when you push comes to shove, they'll say, Well, we don't actually mean abolish prisons. But then it's like, well, you do because you're releasing everybody on like a no-fault bond and you're giving them ridiculously low punishments.
SPEAKER_01And then that's effectively the same thing as abolishing prison. We don't want to send anybody to prison unless you're a white guy who committed a sexual assault, which to be clear, if you're a white guy who committed a real sexual assault, you should go to prison. But so should everybody else. And so it all starts there. I'm reminded of a law professor at your institution, Josh, who recently posted on X, when I say abolish ICE, I mean abolish it. Like get rid of the whole thing, you know? And it's like, so he's literally starting uh this academic craziness that then spills into you know the academic discourse.
SPEAKER_01We don't have time to get into this. I do wonder, Josh, if there is some jurisprudential background. Like, you know, historically, like what is law? People would say things like this Austinian, well, threats backed by force, something like that. And Catherine and I debated this is international in the context of is international law real on, I think it was episode seven or episode five, really early on. Super early. But there is kind of an interesting thing. Like, uh, does the people do the people who believe prison in prison abolition, they just don't believe in organized sanctions?
SPEAKER_01And does that follow that they like don't believe in law, or are they just all Hardians and like you don't actually need organized sanctions uh for there to be a system of law? But even Hart, you know, HLA Hart basically says, well, you don't need organized sanctions, you know, necessarily for it to be law, but most legal systems have organized sanctions because you realize that the half of society, the 90% of society that's willing to cooperate is not going to last very long if they don't punish the 10% who are not willing to cooperate in following these rules without those organized sanctions, right?
SPEAKER_01I just wonder, I'm those are very ad hoc thoughts. And and I wonder if there's some like jurisprudential connection here to this debate over what law is and if you need sanctions, but maybe it's just not that deep and it's just all ideological. I'm inclined to say it's not that deep.
SPEAKER_02So I'm inclined to say it's not that deep. So this is you know hypothesizing about causes of complicated things, and that's always hard. But um the people in question don't have well-developed views of Hart versus Austin and other jurisprudential issues, and particularly a lot of them are in philosophy departments or history departments or or public health departments or literature departments, so they don't have any views whatsoever about these jurisprudential matters. It's and and Catherine, to your point, there is an incentive to be innovative and to sort of take things farther in, but but I that's not my sense of why this is happening.
SPEAKER_02Here's why I think it's happening when you exclude the other side in an institution, people radicalize each other. So it's all about the marketplace of ideas, it's all about the diversity of voices. I I think I might have mentioned this on this pod before, but there was an experiment where they gave a group of people, like a big group of people, uh, tests of what they think about climate change. And they, if you know, if they were the biggest climate change alarmist based on their answers to the test, they'd get a 10.
SPEAKER_02And if they were a total climate change denier based on their answers to the test, they'd get a one. Then the researchers took all the sixes and put them in a room together to talk about climate change for an hour and a half, and took all the fours and put them in a climate change to talk about to put them in a room to talk about climate change for an hour and a half. And guess what? The sixes took the test again an hour later, and they were all eights and nines. And the fours were all ones and like twos and threes, right? People radicalize each other. So what happened in universities?
SPEAKER_02Well, try this. You take criminal law, and it's always got this progressive leaning, you exclude everybody who is for tougher punishment or believes in moral responsibility or believes in retribution or believes in simple incapacitation for the sake of public safety. You take them all out of the field. You deprive, you starve the field of their input, and you create a group of people, every one of whom thinks that the biggest issue is race and racism and that force is wrong, and let them spin around in conferences for about 15 years.
SPEAKER_02And guess what? They will come out of it thinking that we should just abolish the whole criminal system because it's irredeemably broken and racist and has no good to perform in the world. And by the way, get a few crazy physicists together who deny the concept of gravity and put them in a room for uh, with no other physicist being like, hey, I think gravity is a thing, like it's one of the fundamental forces. They will deny the reality. The power of killing the marketplace of ideas is a power to transform ideas.
SPEAKER_01And so just to bring it back and to close out this episode and to our listeners, that we hope you enjoyed this shorter episode because we couldn't cover it because of the midterms last time. Actually, give us feedback on if you like the shorter sort of format. But let me just say that we were talking about this claim that sex is not, in fact, binary and not determined at birth. And now you've got a whole uh discussion of the state of legal academia and how people can believe such crazy things. As always, I really enjoyed it. Thank you for uh tuning in, and we will see you next time.
In this special episode, law professors Josh Kleinfeld and Ilan Wurman sit down with Adam Biggs of the University of Austin, at Texas (UATX). The new school has made waves since the concept for it was introduced in 2021...
Should the parties pick their candidates in smoke-filled rooms, or does that just hand control back to the elites? And can Boulder, Colorado sue Exxon and Suncor for the costs of climate change? Hosts Kathryn Johnson...
Susan Collins lost in Maine after years as the most moderate Republican in the Senate. Across the country, Republicans ran solid candidates and still underperformed. In Alaska, “Decoy Dan” Sullivan remains on the ballot...
A Brazilian Supreme Court justice who used to be Lula’s personal lawyer ordered the polls kept open for two hours after they were supposed to close. Another ordered the opposition candidate, Bolsonaro, to surrender his...
Trump’s Office of Legal Counsel has been on a tear, and hosts Ilan Wurman, Kathryn Johnson, and Joshua Kleinfeld explain the big developments. Guns: OLC announced that the federal ban on selling handguns to...