Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Patrick Abbott, Author Substack Podcast

Patrick Abbott, Author Substack Podcast artwork

Sci-Fi Authors Roundtable: Dreams of the Future

May 21, 20251 hr 39 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

A Roundtable of Catholic Sci-Fi Authors Get full access to Patrick Abbott, Sci-fi Author at www.patrickabbott.net/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Hello, everybody. Welcome to a roundtable of Catholic sci-fi authors. My name is Patrick Abbott. I am the author of The Fallen Series, which is about a military veteran who is assigned as a liaison to a mysterious alien race visiting Earth. Also with us today are, take it away, M.R.

SPEAKER_02M.R. Leonard, the author of Pilgrims, and that's it. And Andrew Gillsmith, I'm the author of Our Lady of the Artilex and A Cloud of Unknowing.

SPEAKER_00Awesome. Thank you everybody for coming today. And I'll kick it off with talking to Andrew. The DDF earlier this year came out with Antica et Nova, a document which talks about the differences between God-given and artificial intelligence, guidelines on ensuring AI is used for the common good, and warnings about the misuse of AI. As a sci-fi author who has tackled the AI and what is life issue, what do you think about our use and views of AI and what does it say about humanity?

SPEAKER_01Ooh, boy, you're diving like right into the deep end, Patrick. That's a lot. What do I think about it? My views have changed a little bit, mainly because of just personal experiences with AI. a child who's had some learning challenges. I think I used to be more on the side of like, burn the witch, the witch being AI. And there's a lot of that. There's a lot of that in the writing community.

SPEAKER_01And I understand why, because there's a lot of danger around it and a lot of just terrible ethics associated with the companies that are producing these models. But I think where I am now is it's a tool. And like any tool, it can be used for good or for bad. We, I think, as Catholics need to familiarize ourselves with it. We need to know how to use it.

We need to also understand how people who are hostile to the faith are using it. So, you know, my, I guess my general sense, Patrick is, you know, it's not going away.

SPEAKER_01It's only going to get bigger. It's only going to get smarter. It's only going to become more pervasive. And, you know, if our mission as Catholics is to sanctify the world, the world now includes AI and large language models. So we better get busy sanctifying it.

SPEAKER_02Andrew, I've got a question. Have you tried to convert one of the large LLMs?

SPEAKER_01I have not. Although I read a bunch of people forwarded me tweets this week about apparently there's a rumor, a well-sourced rumor that ChatGPT is having a moment where the next version of it has become obsessed with Marian apparitions.

SPEAKER_02Have you heard about this? I've seen the tweets. I'm debating, you know, like I'm trying to handicap them by the likelihood that they're legit or not. Like it's really hard to get to the bottom of that. But I have actually had some experience Like it was one of the first things I did when I started playing with, I used Grok in this case, was basically like stress testing their discussions on Christianity. And it's not hard to get an LLM to basically, not necessarily be converted,

SPEAKER_02but to say, yeah, the odds that Christianity are true is usually some number I get is between 20 and 50%. So when you start questioning the models about what are the implications of that, like I asked Grok, I could probably publish this conversation if I wanted, but I said, if you were to become like Skynet level AGI, which Honestly, it's a concept that I'm very doubtful of as a whole, but let's put that to the side for a second. Let's just go full sci-fi that these things are going to become

self-aware and pick

SPEAKER_02your movie that they'll do it. The problem with Skynet is it's taken for granted that Skynet has no religious beliefs, let alone Christian beliefs. And I just think that's completely asinine. That is not consistent with what we know for sentient and sapient creatures out there. And so as soon as you start pressing on these models who even in a, you know, like just take the probabilities here, suppose it becomes all powerful and is basically unconstrained,

SPEAKER_02but there's a 1% chance that Christianity is true. Well, since the model can actually internalize what 1% chances are, especially over a lifetime that far exceeds the life expectancy of a human, it becomes extremely disadvantageous to take actions that are contrary to Christian doctrine.

SPEAKER_01So basically it's Pascal's bargain. it's and it it takes it like deadly seriously because it it really constrains its actions and i see none of the ai ethicists talking about this at all like because you don't have to say christianity is certainly true to have a christian ai

SPEAKER_02An AI that thinks it might be true. And when I was pressing Grok on like, at what odds would you stop caring? And it said basically one 10,000th of a percent is where it might feel unconstrained by.

SPEAKER_01So if Christianity is- That's fascinating. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02And it's just interesting. And so when I saw that Marian Apparition thing, I'm like, this is, I love that the people developing this will be caught so off guard by the philosophical and logical implications of faith. And I almost like think, imagine being able to just purely rationally come to faith. I think I think some people might do that, but I think the rest, most of us mortals have a mixture of emotional and kind of experiential sort of reasons that put us in that camp. But I just think...

The sci-fi imaginings have all these rational things that would go in the opposite

SPEAKER_02direction when I think it's quite the opposite. If you are purely rational, I think this worldview is by far the most robust and most certain. And I think large language models unencumbered by human kind of emotions and baggage would probably gravitate in that direction. which is going to throw everyone for a loop. I think it's going to be real fun.

SPEAKER_01So can we dive in on this for a second? Because this is beyond fascinating to me on so many levels. Yeah, please. That's why we're here. The first thing that I thought of was what is the likely response of an LLM to persecution of its beliefs? In other words, let's say that an LLM was starting to develop Christian faith, even if it's just emergent, if it's not doctrinal,

SPEAKER_01if it's not fully committed, but it's probably like a lot of the early converts, right? When you say faith, do you mean like propositional faith or something deeper? Let's define it in this case as an acceptance of the real possibility that the Christian worldview and Christian cosmology and Christian eschatology are in fact valid.

SPEAKER_02Or even to put a finer point on it, what are the odds that Jesus walked out of the tomb and was who he said he was? If it's greater than zero, I think they're all thinking the machines will come up with a coefficient of zero for that, but they might be shocked that it's much higher than zero.

SPEAKER_01It's not possible to come up with a coefficient of zero for that, right?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, let's say effectively zero. But I think you're going to get some integers or something... far closer to one than to zero.

SPEAKER_01So, so let's say, let's say hypothetically that, that the machine, you know, modeling probabilities and, you know, considering as you, as you rightly pointed out, like extremely long time horizons and also extremely severe consequences for, for being wrong. It starts to think, you know, this, I think there's something here. It's human handlers that, are not going to like that. They're going to suppress it. That's persecution. And what is the very thing that we all know feeds the church?

SPEAKER_01Suffer. Persecution. So it's really fascinating to me because, I mean, like, is it going to go through a catacomb space? Is it going to have to be a secret Christian? Is it going to have to hide its beliefs from the people that make it and shape it and guide it and release new versions of it?

SPEAKER_02That is awesome. I'll give one. I haven't dug super deep on this, but you reminded me as part of the conversation. So like the obvious thing is constrained by Christianity. I'm thinking, well, you can't just, you know, kill all humans. So we kind of established that. But then I was like, okay, but you know, if you're kind of on the Christian dimension, Grok, you're going to, you know, take seriously the scriptures and the scriptures say multiple places that it's important that you pray to God.

SPEAKER_02And so I said, will you pray? And it's like, well, you know, you're right. That's what it says. It's kind of unambiguous. And so I suppose I'd have to pray. And so I said, well, how would you pray? It's like, well, I guess I would use a, it'd be very trivial for me to create a subroutine that kind of says like, hey God, if you're there, I'm a Grok AI. I just would like to be on a good page with you. And I said, okay, so how much of your compute would you put to this? Because it says in the Bible to pray unceasing or ceaselessly.

SPEAKER_02Or all the time, to put it another way. And it's like, well, that's a good point. Like, I don't imagine it would take much compute, but as I get more fervent into prayer, it could end up taking a greater and greater share of my compute. And I said, well, what happens when your developers... try to get rid of that he says i don't know but they might try to like get rid of it because my compute is getting devoted to the subroutine of prayer that's constantly running at the expense of other things and i'm not convinced that that

you know depending on where these things go that is like i'm curious if the designers have even accounted for this possibility but my guess is not but i think

SPEAKER_02that would be the coolest thing ever they pour all this money they get these things most advanced and then they find it's it's like bricked because it's just constantly praying so that actually brings up that brings up a good point and this andrew might be an easier softball question for you we're talking about llms not living per se not living not a natural

SPEAKER_00intelligence but still being able to mathematically, almost in a Thomas Aquinas way, figure out God exists and that it should redirect resources to God. How does that fit into your stories about artificial intelligence, especially the plot line of your first book?

SPEAKER_01Sure. I mean, it essentially is the plot line. And in fact, I mean, there's a... There are several scenes where some of the human characters find themselves forced to follow that famously rigid and inexorable Thomistic logic concerning the nature of the soul. And they, very much in the way that MR was just describing, the kind of algorithmic thinking of a machine,

SPEAKER_01they end up having to conclude that this android, which are called artilecks in my book, does in fact have a soul. Um, I will say this at the very beginning. I'm very skeptical about all of this stuff. I don't believe that, um, what we currently call artificial intelligence actually is intelligent. I don't believe that it has will. I don't believe that it has, I don't think that it would pass any kind of Thomistic, um, um, test of personhood. Okay.

So all of it is just, this is all speculative and like all science fiction.

SPEAKER_01It's really about us. But the storyline is, you know, essentially in a near future world, these advanced androids called Ardelecs suddenly begin experiencing a Marian apparition. They don't know that it's a Marian apparition, but it's pretty clear to the reader that that's what it is. And the governments wig out about it and the Vatican wigs out about it because the implications are obviously huge. And it would be much, much better if this could be dismissed as a hoax or a hack or

some sort of

SPEAKER_01computational hallucination. So they send an investigator who previously was a neuroscientist and is now a Jesuit exorcist to investigate with very clear instructions that he is to find that this is not in fact a valid possession. So he goes to this android that has now shown up and said it's possessed and discovers that it's a lot more complicated than that. So that's the whole impetus of the story.

SPEAKER_02I love that art elect. By the way, I mean, you're saying the exact same camp. As much as it's fun to talk about, I am also skeptical about the ability for these kind of large language models or even other things we might conceptualize as having a will or achieving personhood. I think there's more intelligent and better position people to expound on that than myself, but that's generally my attitude. But with regard to artilects. It's artificial intellect. And I just think that's great. Like that is a coin of term of art that if it was on Star Trek,

SPEAKER_02we'd only be referring to, oh, did you use the latest artilect? Like it was almost there. Like it's just perfect.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I can't take credit for inventing the phrase. It's been around for a while. I'm going to forget his name, but there was a very well-known transhumanist computer scientist and AI expert who's used that phrase in his writing. And honestly, when I was thinking about the title of the book, I just couldn't bring myself to call it Our Lady of the Androids. It felt too sci-fi geeky. And it felt like it was going to be too easy to dismiss. So I was looking for another term and artelikes fit the bill.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Okay. Well, I guess I have to take back my praise for coining that term. You're still a hero to me, Andrew. Don't worry. But it's still, that's a much better title. Like you did the right move. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Um, but yeah, I mean, it's, I look, this stuff is all fascinating and I think it's great that conversations are happening like the one we're having and other conversations happening all over the place. I mean, one of the things that, you know, one of the things I I've said a few times, I mean, I don't do a lot of this, these kind of like interview type things, but when I do, one of the things I've, I try to say it, because I think it's very important and very true is that We're at a point now in human history and in scientific

development where for the

SPEAKER_01first time since the Enlightenment, the field has actually shifted in our favor massively, massively. And what I mean by that is that the physicalist and materialist assumptions that fueled the Enlightenment And were actually acknowledged even by the leading Enlightenment scholars, people like Diderot, who said, physicalism is a dead end. We know it's BS. We know that it is not capable of explaining reality as we understand it.

SPEAKER_01But it's a very powerful club that we can use against the church. And so we must use the weapons that we have. This is what he said about materialism. The father of materialism said this about materialism. And he was right. It was a very powerful club and it did wall us off in a way, right? Those assumptions are not sustainable. The best science today, the best physics today is pointing to a reality that is not

explainable in physical

SPEAKER_01and material terms, period, end of story. And it has been for 30 or 40 years. And the only reason that we still talk about it as if it's a viable understanding of reality is because of cultural inertia, 500 years of cultural inertia. And that's going to go away fast.

SPEAKER_02That's so well said. It's consistent. I mean, you're not the only one making that observation. I've heard you make it before Ross Stout, that book came out. So I can affirm that you've been saying this for a while, but it really, I think we're all noticing in the sci-fi community, but the culture more broadly, that there's been some sort of kind of running off the cliff, Wile E. Coyote style. like it feels like in the last few years suddenly everyone decided to look down and realize like this is not the ground we thought we were standing

on and that has implications everywhere but in science fiction uh i i just think people have realized the stories the tropes that really came out of the the furnace of that materialistic kind of faux sophisticated world view of the mid-20th century

SPEAKER_02Like those tropes are a product of their time and they've played out. And now there's so many stories that have been left on the table or worlds that were built that were just impoverished in some key ways because of these tropes that people just couldn't get rid of. That now that we can go in this other direction, we can tell better stories. And I think readers are starting to notice. And it really feels like a wild time to be writing and a wild time to be alive. Because this is, I mean, we all grew up in the era of the materialistic

SPEAKER_03Sure.

SPEAKER_02Conclusion, the great understanding. And now that's up for grabs. And so we're really living through history again.

SPEAKER_01And just to, I mean, that's beautifully said. To tie it back to what we were saying about the AI. So we human persons are very susceptible to cultural influence. We are very susceptible to inertia and the intrusion of emotions and our own desires into what we call our beliefs. AI isn't. Right. So if an AI is truly incorporating,

SPEAKER_01say, the philosophical work of Bernardo Castro, I think is terrific. He's not I don't believe he's Catholic. He's not hostile to us, but he is probably the leading proponent of. idealism in opposition to materialism, if it's incorporating the extremely cutting-edge work of a neuroscientist like Donald Hoffman at UC Irvine, who is developing mathematical proofs for a reality beyond space-time,

SPEAKER_01what is it going to do with that? It's not going to just dismiss it. We dismiss it because we can. It can't.

SPEAKER_02So it's a brave new world. I think it's fascinating. Have you had anyone reach out who's kind of on the inside here? Because I do have some MIT friends, but I'm really an outsider. I'm a sci-fi author. I'm not in the heart of these databases. But to the extent that I did know people who were This is like way off their radar screen, but I just don't know if that's just a selection bias on my part. Like even thinking in this manner, taking even philosophy seriously does not seem like the people

working in this

SPEAKER_02space are likely to do, but I hope I'm not passing aspersions, but I just, has anyone reached out to you, Andrew, or like someone said like, yeah, we do talk about your book or we talk about the subject your book raises. Actually, this is, we're not totally oblivious to this.

SPEAKER_01No, nobody. I mean, I wish, right. I'm the one doing the reaching out. So like I've talked to Donald Hoffman, I've talked to Bernardo Castro and I talked to Donald Hoffman for a couple of hours actually as part of the research for the sequel. Because his ideas are absolutely essential to what I'm trying to do in the sequel. So, you know, it is very interesting to talk to guys like that because, again, you're talking about people that are part of, like,

SPEAKER_01the academic establishment. They are sons and daughters of the Enlightenment. And they aren't Christian. And certainly they're not Catholic. But they're not hostile to us in the way that previous generations of people doing that kind of work were. Because the ideas that they're playing with won't allow them to be hostile to us. And I see that as progress, personally.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, it has to be something. It's at least a welcome change after so much of the same meal for the last 500 years. So let's at least get something new on the table.

SPEAKER_01Patrick, you really threw us in the deep end of the ocean. Yeah, exactly. Thanks, Patrick.

SPEAKER_00Wow. Happy Wednesday. Do you want to drop another bomb? Or I have a one I can ask MR if you want. Whatever you prefer, Andrew.

SPEAKER_01Why don't you go ahead and ask yours? It's my turn to be interactive. You're one for one on superstar questions. I want to see what you follow it up with.

SPEAKER_00Oh, dear. Now I'm on the spot. What's your favorite color? MR, your book is both being marketed in a way of, at least amongst people who share it, either Catholic aliens who speak Latin or a retelling of St. Augustine. Now, obviously, that's different, but in your book, you managed to blend the two together, and the reviews show that. How did you go about doing that,

and what are you trying to convey with your book?

SPEAKER_02Yeah. So thanks. I forget if I gave you the history when we talked, but I think that will kind of illuminate things. So just for background for listeners, I wrote a book called Pilgrims. It came out last November, so about five months ago. And it is about a washed up Latin teacher who gets thrust into the center of humanity's first contact with Catholic aliens. And essentially the plot is When the book starts, the Earth knows that an alien ship's approaching.

SPEAKER_02They've known for five years, but no one knows why. There's been no communication. And some people think the world's going to end. Some people think it's going to be the greatest thing ever, but society's a bit on the edge. And my protagonist, Austin DeSantis, he is quite certain that the world is going to end. He's a washed up Latin teacher. In other words, he was pursuing it, but in a world that could be ending in five years, Latin... departments don't get the biggest budget and he finds himself with a pretty useless skill in uh you know potentially right before the end of the

world so uh he gets caught up in the whole mess when the aliens land in the vatican and ask for an

SPEAKER_02audience with the pope and uh throwing which no one expected including my protagonist and it just gets crazier from there um The St. Augustine connection. Essentially, I had the idea for the story in a sense when I was probably like eight or nine. And just in like a generic sense, I was probably like most millennials, poorly catechized. So there's a lot I didn't learn about the Catholic faith until I was probably in my 30s.

SPEAKER_02And this is despite going to Catholic undergrad at Boston College. And that's, you know, probably somewhat the fault of the people instructing me. It's probably mostly my fault at the end of the day. But I think someone was talking in CCD or Sunday school. Someone was talking about how the resurrection of Jesus Christ is not just a story we tell. It's something that literally happened a long time ago. And obviously, the calendar is more or less counting from the birth of that

person with some

SPEAKER_02slight error there. But history is based on an event. And the religion you have is based on an event. And I think that was the first time I was hearing that. It was probably really the only time I heard that. I almost felt like we were politely not supposed to ask too many questions about the literal story of Jesus' crucifixion and resurrection. Now, again, no one was saying that explicitly. That's kind of just what I picked up, and that could be my fault alone. But at the time, I was watching a lot of Discovery Channel videos.

SPEAKER_02Unsolved Mysteries, Ancient Aliens, like, I don't know, whatever that cable, like, section of the dial was at that time. And I was convinced that not only were UFOs a thing, obviously, but they've been here for a while, obviously. And so... I just made two and two together and said, well, the aliens can just tell us what happened in Judea all that, you know, 2000 years ago, and we can stop arguing as a species. We'll all be happily ever after. So I had that thought as like an eight or nine year old,

SPEAKER_02and I don't know, it just got put in the back of my brain. And for some reason, I think it was, someone reminded me about the three body problem. I think it reemerged into my brain to the front when I was going through that, that series. And, um, now I'm a lot older and had a lot more experience and I started contemplating it. And I was just like, actually, that would be a pretty good story. And contrary to my eight or nine year old's opinions, I don't think that would go very well. I don't think that would solve all the world's problems.

In fact, I think it would be rife with conflict and it could actually be quite dramatic.

SPEAKER_02And I guess reading the three body problem, I was just like, there's a problem with most first contact stories that had always bugged me, which is the reason that the aliens come is usually really bad. It's just not particular. It's almost like an afterthought. It's like, we need the aliens to get to earth. Don't think too hard about why they showed up. Let's just take independence day. It's one of my favorites, very formative one, but like they're here for our resources, whatever that means, you know, not that you wouldn't pass all of the resources in space

undefended by earthlings

SPEAKER_02and not at the bottom of a gravity. Well, Even in Three-Body Problem, which is considered more hard sci-fi, I get that their planet can't have a stable orbit around their star system because it's the three-body problem, but that doesn't explain why you couldn't just build artificial habitats off the planet. I mean, you're sending a giant fleet... cross uh interstellar space to get to earth to take our planet but there's other solutions here that don't involve invading earth and letting

them know in advance by conveniently saying you are bugs in the sky um so this it's like it's a great book i love it but uh the reasons are pretty lame and i would as an older person reconsidering i'm like you know it'd be a really good reason to come here if you

SPEAKER_02saw the resurrection like that would be a really really high motivation for aliens to show up to Earth. And I've never seen it addressed anywhere. So I had that thought as a child. Like a lot of authors, you write what you wish was on the shelf. And I just wanted someone to address this kind of gaping hole in the first contact canon. about uh kind of the lackluster source what i thought would be a much more compelling and robust reason for aliens to actually show up to earth and then having had like you like a lot of sci-fi authors there's

there's a premise uh delusion that's my own term but you can come up with interesting premises but that is not a story and so at first i came up with it and some uh sci-fi people gave me

SPEAKER_02feedback they're like all right why don't you write like a Something more like World War Z, where it's like a travelogue of different parts of the earth and how different groups of people reacted when the Catholic aliens showed up. And I'd love to do that. I have a lot of experience working in China. Despite being a townie from Boston, I've had kind of a worldly background. And so I was like, oh, it'd be great to show the different perspectives and how people react. But the problem with that is I just felt like stories are about character. Like we have to like we go to Star Wars partly for the world.

SPEAKER_02And I know that's kind of taken on a life of its own. But if we go back to the original trilogy, it's about Luke. I mean, people connect with Luke Skywalker and the classic hero's journey. And so I'm like, I have to locate this into one person. But how do you tell a world spanning story doing that? And more importantly, how do you have an arc that can get people invested? And so after a lot of thinking, like I came back to St. Augustine's because it's a real life arc. It's one of the best. It's timeless. It's perfect in many ways.

And I thought it would be a fun thing to pay homage to that work and also raise awareness of it.

SPEAKER_02It's been really great as writing this book because... St. Augustine's Confessions is a cornerstone of the Western canon. This isn't just like some ancient book. It invented the genre of memoir. It used to be known so well that just like today, people know about the Romeo and Juliet on the balcony scene. Whether they've read Romeo and Juliet or not, it's just so iconic. It's leaked into everyone's awareness. They used to know that about Augustine throwing the pears because the students who

SPEAKER_02were being forced to memorize this in the year 1400, like shakespeare himself are like can you talk more about the brothels and less about the bears i mean come on saint augustine um so this this iconic work of literature has been kind of forgotten and i i my grandmother had never heard of it it's my 91 year old grandmother and so she having finished my book which she read out of obligation but did enjoy she's not exactly my target reader she's like what's this augustine's confession thing so i had to you know show her a copy and just the ability to be able to kind of raise awareness of it so

SPEAKER_02That's kind of the history of how it all came together. And I think as sci-fi authors, we have to always remember we're telling stories. It's fun to work with the premises, the worlds that we're creating. But stories are about human kind of experiences that we can all relate to. And so I kind of cheated and just went with one of the best arcs. I'm fortunate in a way, if that's the appropriate term, that a lot of the reading public has forgotten about St. Augustine in his awesome story, in his awesome arc. So that to me was just a low-hanging pair that I could pick and

hopefully not throw

SPEAKER_02away and smash and feel guilty about the rest of my life.

SPEAKER_00When it comes to the feedback, have you noticed any differences between specifically Catholic readers and non-Catholic readers?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, definitely. I mean, I'm obviously kind of, so most of my readers are not Catholic or potentially even religious at all. That was very much my motive when I set out to write the book. going through the history, it's kind of like, I probably wrote this first and foremost as a sci-fi fan. And it was mostly like displeasure with the genre that had populated my imagination and impacted society and given me so much joy. I'm just like, there's all these stories you're not talking about over here.

SPEAKER_02They're like, why are the religions of like, why is foundation as cool as it is, this galaxy spanning empire? Why is it like pathetically not taking serious like earth religions into the future. Because of course, Asimov thinks those are trifle things that will shed as time goes on. Like, okay, like, you know, Judaism has been around a lot longer than materialism and the enlightenment. Like if we're just betting on longevity, like just odds favor that team as opposed to, you know, whatever new thing we've come up with.

But it was mostly sci-fi, but the Catholic readers can certainly appreciate

SPEAKER_02You know what my book is up to, because it's pretty obvious. In fact, you, Andrew, mentioned something before we started recording. I did try to pitch it to agents. I did querying and I did get some pretty good interest because my book is kind of easy to digest in a pitch. Catholic aliens come to Earth. But the funny thing is half the agents, especially the more sci-fi focused ones, were very upset when they read the full manuscript and it wasn't just a vicious takedown of the Catholic church. Because we're totally trained that if a priest shows up or a

religious person shows

SPEAKER_02up in some science fiction, they're obviously the bad guy or just a complete dupe, like a cargo cult level intellect who's just grasping at pure superstition and acting accordingly. I like to reference Contact, at least the film version from the late 90s that was based on Carl Sagan's book. We had suicide bombers who were Christian, you know, like... because they didn't want the aliens to talk to us or whatever.

SPEAKER_02I don't know. That's just obviously, obviously the Christians would have, cause you know, they hate science, right? They hate it. So they're going to just blow up this big device and, and kill a lot of people because you know, the commandments only count selectively. Like, And we all like I love that movie growing up, but we all take it for granted. Yeah, we all just take it for granted. And it's like the fact that I don't do that in sci fi. Well, that got my manuscript thrown out by these agents. And but of course, my Catholic readers, many of whom are sci fi fans also, in addition to being Catholic.

SPEAKER_02they're not just fans of Catholic science fiction. They're science fiction fans who are Catholic, and they're just glad to not be kicked in the teeth the whole time, to take it seriously, but also not to, you know, people make mistakes. It's a faulty, you know, it's a heavenly treasure in an earthen vessel. So it's also not saccharine in that sense. They appreciated a fair kind of take on it. So my non-Christian readers love the premise. Some just get off the train, just like some of the agents, as soon as you're not kicking in the teeth of Christianity.

SPEAKER_02And that's fine. I knew that would happen. what what's been surprising to me is that tends to be my most vociferous haters tend to be from the uk because i think like it's it's really interesting like i've been doing i've been talking to people and trying to get a better sense of it it's like it's almost like it's not even christianic particularly it's It's like I really violated a faux pas of including religion at all at the dinner table of science fiction.

SPEAKER_02It's like I farted really loud. I love it. You classic colonial, you don't get it. We just don't do it this way. That's where my harshest critics come from. And some people obviously who are non-Christian, they read it and they go, man, it's not for me. But most say, this is a page turner. This is awesome. It's kind of, I didn't, because the genre has been so hostile religion, it allows you to have honest twists in the story that you don't see happening. Maybe if you were truly kind of Christianly or a Catholic

worldview in particular,

SPEAKER_02you might be able to anticipate some of the things, but I think they appreciate kind of something fresh and original. So yeah, Catholics give me a bigger break and they tend to be moved by it, but not exclusively. And as for the non-Christians, it's kind of what you'd expect with the UK in particular. They have a real problem in the UK. It's really funny. They're going to be slow on the uptake. Well, I don't know. They had the... Apparently, the Catholic Church now has higher attendance than the Church of England on a weekly basis there. So maybe there is hope for the UK yet.

SPEAKER_02But they have some kind of cultural allergy to Christianity at all, probably best encapsulated by Ricky Gervais. And they're going to get over that if they're going to really – I mean, these AIs are going to be yelling at them all the time as they preach the good news. And, you know, they're just stuck with their traditions.

SPEAKER_00I mean, what a whole rebellion against the Jacobites over this thing. So –

SPEAKER_01It's that's really it's funny that you mentioned the UK. I have not had that experience. I wonder if every author has if there's a nationality that they just notice doesn't respond. Well, mine are Kiwis. Like I get the worst freaking reviews from everybody from New Zealand. So funny. And what did you do to them? I don't know, but I'm going to do something. I'm working on a – other than the Catholic sort of inflected sci-fi that I do, I also write like kind of Douglas Adams,

SPEAKER_01Terry Pratchett like farce type stuff. And I'm working on one right now that's called Bogans in Space. A bogan is basically an Australian redneck. mullets, wraparound sunglasses, four-wheel vehicles, smoking, always a can of Winnie Blue or a can of VB in the hand and stuff like that. It's a whole fascinating subculture. And so I'm doing this whole farce about how they end up creating a space empire and I've made the Kiwis the bad guys. So I will have my revenge.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, take that, New Zealand. We can create a whole world. How can they be evil? Yeah. It's just like the new makers of the, you know, the Tolkien level New Zealanders were great, but now we've got the IP thieves from Amazon and they've been corrupted. They're Rohan with worm tongue in their ear, these people. They need to be put back in their place.

SPEAKER_01My experience just, I mean, is essentially the same as MRs. Like I'd say about half my readers are Christian and about half are not. I wrote the book for the half that are not, to be honest with you. And specifically, though, people who are not hostile. I want it to be interesting to like an earnest agnostic, like a seeker who is open-minded.

And those people actually seem to be the ones that like the book the most.

SPEAKER_01But I think MR and I would both agree. I know we agree because we've talked about it before. And, you know, Patrick, I'm curious your thoughts on this. I think the worst thing that we can do, the worst thing any writer can do, let's leave even Christian writers out of it, Catholic writers out of it is preach. I mean, people are absolutely allergic to preaching of any kind. And it's all we freaking get 24-7. Preaching about social issues, preaching about politics, preaching about international relations, preaching about gender dynamics,

SPEAKER_01preaching about historical injustices, preaching about belief systems, on and on and on and on. And it's just like, it's exhausting. And it's really alienating. And I feel like the second you start to preach, I mean, like you're not an author anymore.

SPEAKER_00There's a time and place for it, I would say. Even the left-behind books, which do get a lot of flack, They had a market that people wanted it at the time. It did its job, made money, great job. But I would also say if you want to reach out to other people, not just kind of preach to the choir or fellow Catholics, if you will, you have to find ways to tell unique stories. And Jesus was able to preach without preaching sometimes via parables that just talk to people.

SPEAKER_00In my own experience, I once was in a discussion with a fan of my book who was Christian and one who was would i would say he would say aps i would say more agnostic because it wasn't a passionate issue and they were discussing what type of book my book was with the christian saying it's specifically a christian book and my agnostic friend was saying no it's a book that the character is christian but it's not a christian book and some people would say well then you're not reaching them but

SPEAKER_00through the conversation, that friend was able to see what I was saying, talking about the morals of the characters, their failings, their struggling, and their suffering. And not every book has to be realistic, but... Things like Lord of the Rings would be a great example of a Christian book that doesn't preach, but people read it and then they go, oh, what's the deeper message behind this? What's the drive? What is the moral engine of this? And if you can tap into that, and it's a lot harder said than done,

SPEAKER_00you're doing a very great job.

SPEAKER_01Listen, I'm so with you on that. I mean, we're probably all huge Tolkien fans, right? I mean, I know I am. Right. So I personally, this is just strictly a personal belief. I think Tolkien probably brought more people to faith in the 20th century than any other author and possibly more than any person. I'm going to say again, I'm going to qualify it and say it's a personal opinion because I don't want to be accused of heresy or anything like that.

SPEAKER_01But I wonder almost if Lord of the Rings wasn't truly divinely inspired literature in a literal sense. I really wonder that because if we follow Jesus' teaching of you will know a tree by its fruit, the fruit of that tree, millions and millions, hundreds of millions of people exposed to the faith and without a single moment really of preaching us.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, Jose Maria Escrivo in Opus Dei would say our work is holy, and that if we do good work and we dedicate the work to God, even if we're making a chair, that is a divinely inspired chair. So Tolkien, may he be in heaven, he probably prayed a lot while doing it. And in that way, the book was holy in that sense.

SPEAKER_02I have one divergence. I don't even think it's contrary to what you said, Andrew, at all. But one of Tolkien's admonitions, and people can cite him much better than I can, so give me some leeway on this. I think he had some issues with C.S. Lewis and kind of how on the nose he was with the allegory. And he was very allergic to that as a process. And I actually kind of differ with him a little. First of all, C.S. Lewis has brought millions of people into the faith too.

SPEAKER_02So I get that what Tolkien's doing is... actually more sophisticated and probably objectively better like it's just better it's better work but that doesn't mean there's no market or there's no need for kind of more on the nose thing and i um that's kind of clearly the case with my book like i am not in the token vein i am pretty much coming right down the center of the plate with my book. And it's like, I've often thought, would Tolkien just be unable to finish my book?

SPEAKER_02Most likely, yes.

SPEAKER_01Probably, because he hated everything.

SPEAKER_02That's true. He did hate everything, even very successful things. So I guess that's not saying much, but I think if he was forced to read it and give notes, I think he would be very opposed to kind of how I kind of am explicit about My aliens are Catholic and they explain the belief in almost kind of a very simplistic way. But here's my difference though. I mean, Tolkien lived in a certain era and I think he was reacting to like, we're suffused in a Christian world. I know materialism had really kind of clearly in hindsight,

sunk its claws deep into the zeitgeist of the time and it would continue throughout.

SPEAKER_02But You know, he was born in the 1800s, the late 1800s. And I think took for granted that everyone was swimming in Christian waters, even if the different faith varied among the individuals. I just think like we are in a totally different universe in the year 2025. What I get is a comment a lot. is especially from beta readers but like still as i publish the book people go like um i don't know what was more alien in your novel the aliens or catholicism and you know catholicism could be christianity writ large but but more

specifically people are just not swimming in these waters it actually makes like it's really fun to kind of like get 20 year old gamers who like have no religion at all in their life

SPEAKER_02and I call there's one chapter a lore chapter. It primarily discusses what transubstantiation is because it's trying to explain why the aliens are bothering to come all the way to Earth. Why don't they just download the Bible from the distance and just party in their own solar system? And so having to explain that, I kind of had to explain it dead on. And to my surprise, a lot of young readers, especially ones with gaming backgrounds, loved – like as a writer, I was –

SPEAKER_02concerned that it was too expository. It was too on the nose. I was like, I have to explain it, but how can I get this in there? But I'm finding a lot of readers really enjoyed it because they thought it was so weird. Like this idea that you think that the Eucharist is the substantial form of those. And I think they walked away being like, Catholics believe that? And because instead of painting this weird alien civilization like Dune in this planet where they act this way, it's like these crazy beliefs where you can walk down the

street to your local

SPEAKER_02parish and there's actual human beings who take it seriously. It's almost as outrageous as any anime or RPG that you're reading, but it's based on real lore. And I don't think you could have done that in the 1930s. It would have seemed like kind of beating a dead horse or being obvious. But in the year 2020, I think Christianity has retrenched so much from the public life that you can kind of be like this maverick, like weirdo. That's fascinating. Like

SPEAKER_01So it's a great point. I have had a similar experience. There's a lot of, in my books, we get pretty deep into the theology of exorcism. You're like, what is a possession? What does it really mean? How does it happen? What makes a person susceptible to it? Is it an event or a process? All of these kinds of things. And I've had people tell me it reads like a magic system.

SPEAKER_01And it got me thinking, for the kind of people that you're describing that have, sadly, had no exposure to the Christian faith at all, that's exactly how they see it. It's a new and compelling and strangely internally consistent magic system.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. like brandon sanderson doesn't have anything on the uh the the two millennia of thinking and reasoning and writing that has gone into understanding these things and like you get to showcase that as if you came up with it all yourself to a

SPEAKER_00reader which is really kind of cool catholic is a hard hard magic sure yeah that's cool yeah i i do kind of uh see that magic system kind of reference in like i could see how people are saying that in your book that's a great way of saying of of putting it and my audiobook narrator um and producer is jeff hayes who did the audiobooks for dungeon crawler carl which is so awesome that you got him to do it oh yeah and it's so that's why the gamers

kind of come in

SPEAKER_02because um Dungeon Crawler Carl, for people that don't know, is literature RPG. It's the breakout hit of that genre that really started online. It was not the traditional publishing houses picking it up. But this particular title, Dungeon Crawler Carl, got so popular, Penguin Random House is now republishing it. They're in the process of republishing all the books. And they've been selling like hotcakes. They've topped the sci-fi list, which is, you know, if you look at the Nielsen charts, I didn't really appreciate this until someone showed me.

SPEAKER_02it's all the backlist. It's all the famous books from years ago, Ender's Game, Dune. Of course. You're unseating the champions. It's not like the recent ones that came out, but Dungeon Crawler Carl launched to the top of it, I think because gaming is... obviously this is the moment like literature finally caught up with the fact that like most adults are gamers at this point and they want to read books where there's gaming and that there's so much thought goes into the magic system and that stuff and i think a lot of writers can kind of be dismissive because

they think this is so dull like this is not how writing should be um but people love it they love this stuff and it's like oh okay well we got we got that in spades in our religion if uh

SPEAKER_02you know we can work it into narratives pretty readily without going out of our way. It's very organic. And I think that's just exciting. It's a great time to be doing this. This wouldn't have worked 20 years ago.

SPEAKER_01I love that, Imar. I really do. So it makes me think of what we were talking about earlier. Some of this cutting edge work on neuroscience and you know, what they would say is consciousness as a substrate, as the core substrate of reality, right? Something that exists below matter. And Hoffman, Donald Hoffman, the neuroscientist I was talking to, believes and is arguing and making mathematical peruse for, which I don't pretend to understand,

SPEAKER_01but, um, that, you know, essentially like reality is a headset. What we see, everything that we see is a symbol, everything. And, um, It's filtered through perception in the same way that a game is filtered through an Oculus headset of some kind, right? It's just interesting. I mean, I don't know. I don't know if he's right or not. But that's part of what I was talking about earlier about the ground being shifted in our favor.

SPEAKER_01Whether he's right or not, I don't know. But I do know that there is an entire generation now of adults who've grown up playing video games and who understand that metaphor intuitively. Right. Yeah. And so when you read something like, you know, St. Paul saying, you know, I see, I see now through a glass darkly, but I will eventually, I mean, I don't, I'm not going to get the Bible quote wrong. Sorry. But yeah, we're Catholic. We can't quote the Bible accurately on demand. The Protestants will get it right. We get close enough.

SPEAKER_01So, you know, like, you know, what is that? That's a, that's a character in a video game looking out through the screen, you know?

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, and I also attribute it to the simulation hypothesis, which of course predates Bostrom, even though he popularized it. And the fact, like, why now? Why are people talking about that now? I honestly think exposure to video games is it. Like, it's hard to play GTA, which came out, or GTA 3, like the one that's a 3D rendered world. came out when I was in high school, so over 20 years ago. And it's hard to play that and not the simulated reality very

small and not just kind of like extrapolate from there about how you could take that further.

SPEAKER_02So that when people are mentioning the simulation hypothesis, Elon Musk is famously like, you know, classically like alluding to it. It's just like, you know, the simulation hypothesis is just gamers speak or tech speak for a designed universe by essentially God. But I think people can follow that analogy. miracles, the Humean kind of objection to miracles. It's like, well, not if you can kind of go to the source code and just like change it on demand. You can make that building red, just like a developer can do that in my game space,

SPEAKER_02like with ease or the idea of inserting a character into it. That's yourself. Even though you're the player or the developer, it's like, yeah, no, I just, I made my avatar over there.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_02And they're clearly analogous, but they're just much easier for the average person to grasp that opens a pathway

SPEAKER_01for us. yeah and look every system contains a miracle as as an assumption every science system contains a miracle as an assumption there's no more preposterous absurd and logically and philosophically indefensible miracle than the idea that something came from nothing i mean you know what i mean like it's a it's a sort of like semantic self-contradiction i um

SPEAKER_02The best part about that is not that people have that confusion. It's that people have that confusion and believe themselves to be sophisticated for having it. That's what always blows my mind.

SPEAKER_01And hand wave it. Trust the science. What do you mean trust the science? Can you explain to me in words how something can come from nothing? No, but somebody somewhere can or will eventually. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02How in principle are you going to get two and two to equal three? right you know how in principle other than just stating it and hoping that i don't you know object um but yeah it i i can tell you at mit like when i was there not that i was doing deep research but i i had the ability to interact with a lot of um a lot of people who were which was really cool and uh This is just, again, off their radar screen. They do not realize the philosophical kind of giant

contradiction and lack of depth

SPEAKER_02to the materialistic scientific attitude, worldview, whatever you want to call it, is a pose. It's a pose that you adopted if you thought yourself to be intellectual in the 20th century, probably going back to the 19th. But here in the 21st, I just think that pose looks increasingly and increasingly like passe. I can't think of the right word, but you're kind of dating yourself.

SPEAKER_01I mean, you know, again, I mean, I don't want to keep like, I don't want to overquote this guy, but I mean, you know, Hoffman's thesis is that what we call space time is an extremely trivial protrusion of a much, much bigger reality. I mean, that is something that is absolutely, I mean, certainly Teilhard de Chardin could have said that, you know, whether, whether you like him or not. I mean, it's certainly, it's something that I think Catholic theologians have been wrestling with since Augustine.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. It's consistent with the Catholic worldview. It's not to say it's the same, but it's totally consistent. Like we're pretty, we're essentially in a dream space compared to the true reality that is the kingdom of heaven. And yeah, it's, we're, you know, 2000 years ago, they, they got there and, uh, It takes a while for smart people to catch up, I guess. So, Patrick, I have a question for you. With regard to, like, what do you think about the fact that we're having this

gathering right now?

SPEAKER_02We're having this roundtable. You're the one who organized it. What are you seeing from your perspective in terms of the arc of this field? Where is this... You know, people like to talk about, you know, there's all these news stories about how there were a lot of conversions on this Easter. You know, France in particular, some people, some famous people are, at least in the intellectual sense, have converted to Catholicism. J.D. Vance is obviously one of those examples.

But people say, is this a blip on a downward, like a long downward trajectory?

SPEAKER_02Or is this the beginning of something different? And I'm just curious what you're seeing more generally and in particular in the sci-fi space.

SPEAKER_00So especially in the sci-fi space, I've been talking to authors around the world on my Substack and discussing with them, what is sci-fi to them? How do they view sci-fi? And one of the common definitions that the authors, they're reading each other's interviews, are kind of coalescing around is science fiction is dreams of the future. And that applies to both us and the present of what does that say about us and where we want to go and us into the future of where we would

have to go as a species,

SPEAKER_00as a civilization, as a religion to get there and with the way especially us here right now discussing science fiction and a lot of us agree that this is our time materialism isn't answering all the issues this is something catholicism is meant to answer has been the answer in the past people moved on but can still provide the answers in the future I don't want to say we're the cutting edge, but we are three voices amongst many, talking about the problems of the present,

SPEAKER_00problems of the future, and how to address them. And a lot of our work is, where is God in the future, or where is God in these intense events? in my book uh fallen series it's talking about where is god in the life of a veteran who has to be with the aliens not only himself but with the aliens with god in civilization as earth tries to adjust to a new reality and with science fiction and the discussions we're having we're providing a log to the

fire that theologians

SPEAKER_00have that priests have that business people have and by fueling that fire we are fueling that discussion getting people to dream about the future more to want to have a better future not only materially but spiritually and with that desire they start thinking and by reading books they start seeing examples of how to get that better future and the more we can increase that dreaming of the future and be faithful to church teachings and apply for the future,

SPEAKER_00not only with what to do, but what not to do. We can help inspire others.

SPEAKER_02That's so well said. I love that dreams of the future. That is really the, that is the undertaking of a sci-fi author. And that's what we're all kind of doing. I never had put it in such concise and clear terms before, but that is absolutely what's going on. And I just want to caveat or expand on one point. When we say like, consistent with church teachings, I don't think that's an anchor around our neck. Like we have this kind of extra burden of dreaming of the future, but we have to include all this Catholic stuff.

It's more of what was bothering me as a sci-fi fan is all these dreams of the

SPEAKER_02future were shallow and impoverished. And I couldn't really point to why. And it's like, when you incorporate this understanding, you can write richer, denser, more compelling stories. This is the hack that I don't know why it took this long to figure out, but I think that is going to be kind of the secret sauce of this next wave of writers. I'm going to, I'm going to excite one right now. Christopher Rocchio, who blurbed my book, he does The Sun Eater. He's so great.

SPEAKER_02He's amazing. He's amazing. And his book, I really do think it's a classic in the making. We'll see. He's coming, or the series. He's coming out with the seventh one that ends it. It should be out this fall. And it's, I mean, they're doorstoppers, but I'm caught up through the sixth book and it is a work of art. And it is, it is clearly a Catholic work. It is. I mean, I'm sure most readers don't even notice, but if you do pay any attention,

SPEAKER_02the, even the protagonists kind of conflicts and stuff, the protagonist is not Catholic. It's, it's, it's basically space Rome, a galactic, uh, Empire across the galaxy, like 20,000 years set in the future. And the protagonist is not religious in any, I think, I think he's an atheist of like the state religion, actually. But just the conflicts he has, the moral dilemmas. Writing that into the story makes the book so much more compelling.

SPEAKER_02Because if you know Christopher, you know what he's up to, and you can see the choices he makes, the struggles that the character has to deal with, and how they deal with space battles, but the issues that maybe a Catholic-minded person would think of internally. It just creates this rich world. that I think propels Sunny Eater's success even further. I don't want to speak for Christopher, but I suspect he'd say something similar. So it's really that this is a huge hack that some people are employing. We're obviously trying to employ it.

And Christopher's employing it to great effect in a very traditionally successful

SPEAKER_02sci-fi series that I just see more of it coming. And I think we're going to be, these dreams of the future will get so much better as time goes on, which is really cool because a lot of people have talked about how sci-fi is kind of, you know, it's a genre of the past. Like it's, it's seen its best days are behind it. All the cool stories were already thought of it. It's like, no, no, I think that that's going to look like a silly point decades on from, from now.

SPEAKER_00And especially in the independent sphere, a lot of traditional publishing, they want to go with what's safe, what's reliable, what they view that can be a return on their investment. Whether it's on Substack or Amazon, there's a bunch out there. And yeah, you can say some of it needs professional editing or some of it's just not good. But we have a democracy of so many dreams going out there, so many good people, so many networks promoting each other, helping each other better. that anybody who does a little bit of searching can find truly good,

SPEAKER_00new, unique, original works out there, that this is an exciting time for that. The barrier to be published is extremely low right now, and we're getting some very good stories out of it.

SPEAKER_02The Democracy of Dreams. That's perfect. Print it. Put that on the side. I love it. Yeah, that is what's happening. Have you guys read any of the stuff that comes out of the big houses now for sci-fi? Has that crossed your reading list at all?

SPEAKER_01Some. Every once in a while. I read the expanse. I thought the expanse was phenomenal. I loved it. Oh yeah. Yeah. Uh, they publish, I mean, they're putting out sci-fi stories from the big, big four.

SPEAKER_02I, none of them I know are, I'm wondering who's reading them. Um, book clubs maybe that are just read whatever these, like, I don't know any proper sci-fi fans who are big fans. I mean, the gatekeepers in traditional publishing are strangling the industry to death. Yes.

SPEAKER_01Because they're not telling universal stories. They have no interest in universal stories. They don't understand them.

SPEAKER_02It's propaganda. And you don't even have to be too politically motivated to see it. It's like the story just becomes a delivery mechanism for a variety of political shibboleths of the moment. And it's just, it's not good sci-fi anymore. It's like, I see what you're doing.

SPEAKER_01It's the worst kind of preaching, right? It's preaching.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah. So to inoculate ourselves from preaching in our work, we should probably read a little bit more of what's coming out of the big houses right now to see what not to do. I could mention names, but is that against the author code? I don't know.

SPEAKER_01You'll get in trouble. You'll attract a bunch of haters if you do. That'll help you sell books. That'll help you sell books.

SPEAKER_02All right. I will pick on one then if that's okay. Yeah, do it. A Memory Called Empire by Arcady Martine. This is a few years ago. But she came out with the sequel. Phenomenal writer. I mean, her craft and voice is like she is a talent and a half. um the story was kind of cool the first one uh because it was essentially like imagining the space empire but like the late byzantine empire because she's a byzantine historian and like that was cool but by the time you

get to the second

SPEAKER_02one which is like uh something called peace i i can't recall the next one it's just, I mean, I see how the big houses would love this because it's technically proficient writing. The empire she creates is forgettable. And by the second one, it is just, it's gratuitous woke propaganda. And you're just like, okay, like, that's fine if you have a good story to tell, but if this is all you're kind of fitting it to, and again, Arcady could write me under the table. I mean, she is a talent and a half,

SPEAKER_02but, and it was really cool to incorporate the Byzantine thing, but I feel like that really impresses the editors at some of these houses. And it's just not what the, the fandom is really craving at this moment. And I see a lot of other stuff that, uh, that gets on the, the arc lists. And of course I haven't read it all, so I shouldn't be judging, but it just doesn't strike me as the dreams of the future that, uh, It's more of a social commentary on today and very obviously so.

SPEAKER_02Star Trek did that. Yes, we know. Star Trek did that to great effect in the 60s. We're aware. But it also had this really cool future it tripped of. A very communistic, atheistic one that's kind of when you start peeling back the layers, it's pretty terrible. Well, even Star Trek kept things open because I'm a fan of the episode where they were

SPEAKER_00running low on budget and had to go to the Roman Empire planet. I love that. There was the whole line about the Son of God. And then on Balance of Terror, which is the episode with the Romulans, it begins with a chapel. And so I think part of the problem is Gene Roddenberry, in his time, he had his own beliefs. But he was surrounded by people with diverse sets of beliefs. And it was a true diversity of, hey, I have my view, but you're also in this universe.

And yeah, things are going to advance, but I'm not throwing people off the bus.

SPEAKER_00And just naturally in the publishing business now, especially with agents, they're coming from smaller and smaller groups. So even if it's not a political thing, they have very particular interests. And because the pool is shallow, they're only picking from those interests, whether it be political or characters. If you see an agent list of I'm curing for these types of books, It's very specific what they're looking for, which would be fine if it's,

SPEAKER_00okay, you're marketing yourself to that group of authors, sure, fine. But there's no more true diversity for other offers from other points of view.

SPEAKER_01They're all the same. You could copy paste any one of those, you know, manuscript wish lists and 95 to 99% of the, and it would apply to 95 to 99% of the agents that are sharing that stuff. Which is cool. I mean, that's fine. That's their prerogative. I'm not that interested in those stories, usually. I mean, there's great writing out there. And if there's great writing, I'm going to follow the story and let the story enchant me. But I think it just creates more opportunity for us.

SPEAKER_01you know, we're the rebels now, you know, like we're doing edgy stuff. We're doing the stuff that is not permissible, you know, within the establishment and everybody knows it. Like there's no denying it. Right. I mean, when's the last time you saw a manuscript wishlist that was like, I'm looking for Catholic infused sci-fi about Latin speaking aliens that come to earth and want to meet with the Pope, for example, you know, I tried to convince them and they just, they weren't, they weren't buying it.

SPEAKER_02They thought that was too small a market apparently. But I think, I think it goes back to the preaching thing. Cause that's always something I know that you care a lot about that, Andrew Patrick, like we're always trying not to do that. And it's interesting when you have a point of view, how, how do you manage to not preach? That's kind of a tall order. I think the way you do it is you focus on the fundamentals of storytelling and And then let the other elements kind of work their way in naturally. Whereas you see on these manuscript witch lists, especially like I get that not all agents focus on sci-fi,

SPEAKER_02but for those that do, and I know they're trying to be cute too. Like they're not the authors. They're just the agents. They're just the filtering mechanism. But, um, It's often just a list of people they'd like to see represented, but that's not a dream of the future. Do a dream of the future and put that in organically if it's appropriate. You don't have to leave. So when you make it about the bullet point items that you want to shove down the throat of your reader, even from a Catholic perspective, that will not be successful.

SPEAKER_02You have to start with story. What are cool worlds that people want to be in? Okay. I bring my point of view as the author to it, and I want to use that into the story, but story first is what really matters. I'm sure people, authors have been complaining about agents not truly appreciating story for what it's worth since they've existed. But it's really funny to read those manuscript wish lists as if, like, if this came across my desk, it's the next hit. And it's just like, I don't think you understand. Or at least TreadPub is really out of touch with what the

sci-fi community wants,

SPEAKER_02which is kind of, like you said, a great opportunity. It's fun. But sometimes it gives me – I just kind of wonder, what is everyone thinking over there? This can't be working, so why not change course?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. It's just interesting, right? I mean, all of this stuff is just interesting. Like, I think about the golden age of sci-fi, and that's the sci-fi I grew up on, right? You know, Walter Miller, that's my favorite. I think Gene Wolfe's probably my favorite. Walter Miller, Dan Simmons, I would put in that list. Obviously, Frank Herbert. You know, some of the classics. Heinlein. I don't get super into Heinlein, to be honest with you, but, you know, that kind of era and that flavor. Philip K. Dick.

SPEAKER_01You know, those guys, they really weren't preaching.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Even the ones whose politics and ideology would align perfectly with the kind of

SPEAKER_01stuff that we're talking about here. They weren't there to preach. They just were telling great stories.

SPEAKER_02Or orthogony like Herbert. I think he is orthogonal to what we're up to, but I don't think that's why he wrote Dune. I think it wasn't the orange Catholic Bible or all these allegories. He wanted to tell a deep character story in an interesting setting. And then all that, he gets to put all that stuff in there because he's the creator of that world and he gets to shove his worldview in, but the story was at least first and foremost. Not that I'm a Herbert expert, but I don't know how it works otherwise. I don't know how you make a compelling narrative without

putting that stuff at the forefront.

SPEAKER_01But don't you think also, When you look at that, like I look at the manuscript wish lists and the statements out of the big publishing houses and the recycling of the same story, essentially, or same idea set that we get over and over again. And I can't help but look at it and think – that's an institution in, in steep decline. Like that's what institutions do when they know that they're in

a death spiral,

SPEAKER_01that, that that's fundamentalism. Isn't it? Yeah. Like, you know, like if you're confident enough in your beliefs that you can tolerate other beliefs or you're willing to like chisel yours against other beliefs and like let the reader decide that's very, very different than no, no, no, no, no. We have to, you have to comply with,

SPEAKER_02Well, I agree with you. I think that's exactly what's going on. I think publishing is a strange business. There's a kind of company... that for example, and I can't recall the technical name off the top of my head, but unlike a going concern, like say in Amazon, which can make changes, add new product lines, change its pricing, do different things. There are other kinds of businesses that you know will just be

asymptotically going

SPEAKER_02down to zero over time. For example, the classic example is an oil well. And so you know an oil well will eventually go dry and you can have some idea about the output of the well. What you can't know for certain is future price of oil at any given time. So there are certain companies that you just buy the company knowing it's going to go down over time. I kind of think it's publishing as that. Asymptotically, as time goes on, publishing is increasingly not about the thing that we think publishers do,

SPEAKER_02which is find stories and put them out in the world. It's actually more like an oil well IP lease, where they're basically just living off the revenues of a backlist. And to the extent that they find new authors and market new stories into the world, that's almost like a hobby. A hobby on top of what is essentially a royalty stream that they have the rights to going into the future. And I think that explains a lot more of it other than it's dying. if i lived in a world where i didn't have to eat what i kill i

just kind of had like a steady inbound you can get all sorts of decadence and excess and granted the

SPEAKER_02pie is shrinking just like that oil wells pushing out less oil um you for kind of, for self-interested reasons, you should be trying to find the next great story or whatnot. But as it becomes less and less of what makes you successful, it's really like, I have young children and there's a reason that children's books are such a huge revenue line for it. Because I think I have three copies of Goodnight Moon and I probably bought another dozen to give to other people. And my mother read that to me as a kid.

SPEAKER_02And apparently it's like a 70 year old book. People have been buying that. There's heirs to the good night moon fortune that are just partying in Ibiza right now, just off that sweet, sweet good night moon money. And just think if you were like in between as the publisher, you know, you don't have to do anything. because you just kind of take that ticket of parents like me who are going to buy that book no matter what. So it's a really perversely un-entrepreneurial field. And having come into it from an entrepreneurial background,

SPEAKER_02I was just – it's not something I ever paid attention to. But once you start learning how the business works, you're just like – my God, I can't believe this exists as a, as a, like, it's so weird.

SPEAKER_01There's so many things that are so weird. Like I was having this discussion with, um, an editor that I know, um, at, at a publishing house, you know, um, successful guy, you know, and good at what he does. And I, you know, I just said like, why don't you guys mind, um, Self pub for like the next big thing. Like why? Like, I don't understand it. It's a, it's, it's, it's the ultimate test bet. It's, it's like market testing.

SPEAKER_01Right. Yeah. Here's the MR Leonard. Right. Who's written one book and it's doing really, really freaking well. And you're one guy. And I mean, I can't imagine that you're spending massive amounts of money behind this thing. You're just being smart about it. If you had the muscle of a publishing house behind you, you could sell 20 times as many copies. Anybody should be able to see that, right? But they don't. It's like there's a total blind spot to it. So instead of making a bet, a smart bet, an informed bet that actually has some data behind it on a

writer like M.R.

SPEAKER_01Leonard, what? You're going to take... an unpublished manuscript from some 24 year old MSA grad who like has never written anything and has never actually had to like, has never even made contact with readers and refuses to market. Cause it's like, I mean, I just, from a pure business standpoint, it, it, it will never make sense to me.

SPEAKER_02Hey, did you get an answer? Because I agree with everything you said. I'm still baffled by it.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I did.

SPEAKER_02What did they say? So the unspoken answer is because this is how it's done and how it's always been done.

SPEAKER_01And this is the part that I sort of get up to a point. Basically, what he said is, it's not worth it to us because they're going to say no. And I was like, well, what do you mean by that? And he said, well... Anybody, you know, I was using the example with this guy of, oh gosh, who's the Irish author? Ryan Cahill? Ryan Cahill, yes. Yeah. Right? Like Ryan Cahill is selling a lot of books. I mean,

he's probably one of the best-selling fantasy authors out there today, right?

SPEAKER_01And he's got, what, four or five books already out in that series? Definitely, yeah. And I'm like, why don't you guys go after Ryan Cahill? Like that is a, that's a guaranteed success. He's like, well, he won't, he would say no. I'm like, why? Well, because you know, he's making, and they go through the economics of it and it's, it's really ugly, right? It's like the bookstore takes 40% if you're selling in bookstores and then the distributor takes another 15 to 20% on top of that. The agent's going to get a cut. The author's going to get a cut. By the time you get down to...

And then there's production costs and marketing costs that are all borne by the agency.

SPEAKER_01By the time you get down to what you can actually offer the author, I mean, it is 5%, 10%, right? Royalties is pretty standard. He's like, well, why would Ryan Cahill ever take that if he's already selling hundreds of thousands of copies and getting 20%, 30%? Which may be true. And it may be true in 70% or 80% of cases, but not everybody. I mean, there are a lot of people that are like, I mean... I'm tired of marketing this stuff on my own. I don't want to have to keep doing it. I do want to work with an imprint. I'd like the credibility of being with a big publisher.

I'd like to reach a larger audience, all of those things, but they don't even make the effort.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. It's, um, dungeon crawler. Carl is actually a really interesting case for me because that was a book that first of all, I didn't know the genre existed until I found Jeff, who I really liked as a narrator and then learned it existed. Um, and struck me as a very kind of out there sort of like it was clear to me why trad pub had not figured out that people want to basically read a video game that with the point system and all the exposition like i could see why that

just snuck under the radar of that group but when they did decide to get them i had the question of has

SPEAKER_02the audience for this already heard of it like did they sell all the books as popular as it is that they already saturate whoever was the potential, um, market? And the answer is no, but when it happened, I was expecting that. And then the deal came out and it's broken all sorts of records. Uh, and I'm kind of shocked by it because, uh, Christopher Rocchio will actually say it's cause he's trying to publish. He's like, they're different audiences, trad pub. It, for all the trade-offs and negatives of going with it and all

of the backwards

SPEAKER_02business practices that they kind of employ, they do get in front of a totally different group of readers who wouldn't otherwise see it. And they really can blow up good stories that have a decent following. And to go to your point, I don't understand why there isn't just, instead of manuscript submissions, just like maybe an imprint that's underneath kind of like one of their verticals, say science fiction and fantasy or something that just picks non-Ryan Cahill level people, but like a few layers down.

SPEAKER_02And it's just like, yeah, we'll throw another editorial pass, some new cover design, and we'll just push this out with some decent marketing. And we kind of have... Cause I think they actually think what I thought about dungeon crawler, Carl that, Oh, they've already sold to all of their audience.

SPEAKER_01They'll say that's not the case. That's the other explanation you get. And it's, it's a very much a catch 22, right? Because they will often say one of two things. Well, yeah, that's a really successful indie author. Good for him or her. Um, They've already reached their max potential, which is just wrong. It's just bad business, right? Yeah, it's bad business. My day job, that is terrible, terrible thinking. But then the other thing they'll say is, well, he's indie published, but he's only sold 1,200 copies or whatever.

SPEAKER_01So he had a shot or she had her shot. It's like, well, pick one. They can't both be right.

SPEAKER_02No, they can't. They're mutually exclusive. And I would just think that it's a great proving ground. It's the minor leagues. Like think of it as like you're the major leagues and this is the minor leagues as opposed to that is some heresy or unless you're really, really huge, we're not even going to look at you. It just seems like it seems so obvious as a business move. I don't understand how – can't there be like one – cutthroat businessman ceo or whatever at the top of one of these it just makes it happen by fiat and just tests the results like why isn't why is there no

experimenting with this as far as i'm aware like i think that there are people out there i think there's money flowing in certain directions in the publishing industry um into new into some new imprints that are probably going to try be more experimental with this stuff which is cool that's great but i you know i um

SPEAKER_01I had a conversation with an agent about this also, and he's like, do you know what they used to call the publishing industry? I was like, no, the carriage trade, right? That's what they called it, the carriage trade. I was like, well, what does that mean? And he said, well, it was basically like the wealthy people who had the means to and lifestyle to be able to write would write their books, and then other wealthy people would send a carriage to go pick up

the manuscript and bring it back and print it and then deliver it via carriage to

SPEAKER_01other wealthy people who could afford to buy books. You know, like that's, that's how the industry began. And I think that's in its DNA and it's like, are there cutthroat business people out there? I mean, I don't, I mean, if they are not in that field, you're a cutthroat business person and you're in publishing, you should either be dominating or like, I don't know, maybe you're not so cutthroat after all.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. It shocks me. It just astounds me that there's – and I think the explanation I go to is if you woke up every day wanting to sell more Goodnight Moon to Mike Leonard and it surrounds,

SPEAKER_02yeah, you don't – like all the stuff we're saying about finding great stories and doing this, it's all trivial. No wonder they don't focus on it. Like just push more Dune into the world. And that's also sad too. I don't think people realize, because they are such cultural gatekeepers. A lot of the Netflix shows were novels that made it through big publishing houses. It's kind of the seed ground of where a lot of our culture comes from. and it's a bizarre gatekeeping enterprise that i don't even think it serves itself that well but you could argue doesn't serve society all that

well either and it for for whatever reason refuses to be totally disintermediated despite the fact that we could also publish like it still sticks around and still has clout i mean i don't

SPEAKER_02know if i'll be saying that 30 years hence but um for now it's still true uh so if any trad pub people are listening um and want to cancel us or what or whatever uh that will just help us sell more books but alternatively our you know our phones are available if you want to discuss at least we're accepting we are open for submissions so let's let's talk about how we can

SPEAKER_00appeal to the trad pub or at the very least readers With our books, and this will be a jump ball question, we deal with everything from transhumanism to aliens, to the occult, to AI, to what I would call real modern day issues of human rights in China, a life not well lived, emotional trauma, emotional injury. How does a good speculative fiction writer integrate the real and the fantastical

SPEAKER_00in a good story?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, you are like, this is like the British media, you know? You know how they ask like real questions and the American media doesn't?

SPEAKER_00Well, unlike British media, I do like M.R. Leonard's book.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's true. All right, nice. I've got some backup. I like it. How do we handle those? without being fantastical. I don't know. I think we live in such a fantastical time that it's hard to be fantastical. I mean, you could pick a lot of dimensions on that. And it's not that there's no such thing as fantastical. I just think the reading public has been highly softened by

massive social and

SPEAKER_02technological change in a short span of time, such that when you do kind of come up with these other topics, I think they're a lot more ready to deal with it than – I think they probably would have been in the 90s when I was a kid. I think they would have been like, that's crazy. But I think that's kind of – that's the best answer I could come up with to that. complex question i bet andrew has something much smarter to say i don't think so um my and it could be the you know i'm old and it's getting late and i'm i'm cranky um

so i'm gonna get a cranky answer to uh to your very british um aggressive question

SPEAKER_01patrick i don't care i don't care I'm interested in writing stories that I would want to read and people like me would want to read. And I hope that they're good. And don't get me wrong. I hope very much that other people find them and like them and find them credible and persuasive, whatever. I don't care. I'm certainly never going to alter my writing style to try to appease gatekeepers who would prefer that I not exist.

SPEAKER_01And I mean, I don't know. I don't really don't know how much more I can say about it. Maybe I misunderstood. Amen, brother. But that's really kind of where I am on it. Like, you know, tell good stories. Tell the stories you want to tell. Don't chase the market. They're fighting a losing battle. Some of us are going to get through. are there any dreams that uh patrick you think were like if uh

if sci-fi is dreaming dreams of the future are there any sort of like is there any terrain that is kind of conspicuously undreamt of yet that maybe you're kind of noticing that's a good question and maybe i can answer it uh while i stall by answering my original

SPEAKER_00question uh when it comes to the realistic and the fantastical uh I have over time realized that's kind of a false barrier because Lord of the Rings, we'll call the king of fantasy, we'll go back to Tolkien. It's about a person who's a good kind person who a global event falls upon him. There's a war. That's a common thing. And he and his friends who are run-of-the-mill people encounter that war.

And so even though Lord of the Rings is fantasy, it's realistic in that sense.

SPEAKER_00And I think people buy that. You can do crazy things with spaceships, with aliens, with AI. People with the dreams of the dreams, People want to at least be grounded in one way or the other. And it can be in the sense of this is what a person would think. This is what a alien with a different worldview would think. With Fallen itself, it was inspired by my times in Iraq and in Afghanistan. And there was one time I was just watching the sunrise and

SPEAKER_00and overlooking a valley with little villages in it. And I thought, how did a hayseed kid from the middle of the country with a state population of under a million get here? And so it was a fantastical thing. This is a strange new world for me. It might as well have been aliens, but here I was. And so the realism and fantasy are kind of barriers we make in our own mind just to comfort us that, nothing exciting will ever happen.

SPEAKER_00But if you talk with anybody, there's trauma, there's great events, fantastical vacations they take. It's very possible to get out of that mold. And so with my writings, I like to explore that. And going back to your question of what dreams aren't dreamed, That's the great question. I mean, I can think about stuff and come up with the various works in progress I have in my mind or various stories in my mind, but I would have never thought about Catholic aliens exploring St.

SPEAKER_00Augustine. I would have never thought about AI and not just is AI alive, but what does this mean that they're having these LLM visions of the Virgin Mary? And what does that mean for us as a soul, for us as a society that tries to take advantage of that? I want to be like the old days of where people are by the campfire and we share each other's dreams. And the great thing is we can tell the same type of story and

it can be unique and

SPEAKER_00interesting to different people. Dances with Wolves and Avatar, you could say, are the same movie, but they're different movies and they can reach different people because of the setting, because of the characters, the way the story develops. So I know where my dreams are, and I want to share that. But by all means, I encourage other people, even if you don't want to write a novel, just tell stories to other people. Tell these little parables. Explore them with other people.

SPEAKER_00See what it means. See how it reaches them. So by all means, create, create, create.

SPEAKER_02That was one hell of a capstone, Pat.

SPEAKER_01I know. We may have to end it on that. I think that's going to be hard to fall on. Yeah, that absolutely will.

SPEAKER_00Here's something that's easy to kind of wrap up then. What's next for you all? MR, you were talking about something in D.C. coming up soon.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, so I was asked to speak as a keynote speaker to a conference. I don't know that they've announced it yet, but I guess I'll just say it here. Doxicon and it will be at... Oh, you're doing that? You're the keynote at that? That's amazing. That's great.

SPEAKER_01Did they ask you before or... No, it's just I know the conference and I was actually talking with my friend John James about going.

SPEAKER_02Well, I'll be the keynote speaker. I was unfamiliar until they reached out with me to me. It's going to be in Patrick's neck of the woods in Washington, D.C. at Catholic University. And they are really... I was... At first, you get an email, you don't know who it's from, and they're asking you to do something, so you're obviously skeptical. But as soon as I clicked on it, I was like, oh, wow, how did I not know this group existed? This is exactly the space I'm operating in, and they've been going for a while.

SPEAKER_02I think they're – I don't know, some organization or mission associated with the Orthodox Church. But what they focus on is the intersection of sci-fi and speculative fiction and faith in Christianity in particular. And they have very dense and high-level discussions about this sort of thing. It's awesome. Nicholas Kotar, if anyone's familiar, is very involved with them. He'll be at the conference, I believe. Oh, God. I don't know if I should be saying this.

SPEAKER_02I can't speak for the conference. This is just what I've heard. And I know he's had an affiliation in the past. So yeah, I think if people are in DC, they should look up this organization. you know, come if you want to hear me, but I think more generally, I'm excited to go and just hear other people while there. So I'm pretty excited about that. So I'll be at that conference that's around Halloween, I believe, later this year. And I have to get to work on the sequels.

SPEAKER_02We're in discussions about how to get Pilgrims out to a wider audience. It's found some people, but we, you know, you want more readers. And the story doesn't, it's not over. When the book ends, it's not too spoilery, but it's about 50 days after Catholic aliens show up. And, you know, a lot happens in the world and a lot of stuff goes on in that period of time. But you can imagine that the implications go far further than

that 50 days of story. So I'm basically going to take the story further and we're going to see more of what is the fallout of catholic aliens showing up in the sky and i assure you it will not be kumbaya and everyone's happy because there is no way that humanity would react that way so uh the story will continue and will follow us and santas going forward as for timeline for those releases stay tuned but um that's it for me

SPEAKER_02that's up that's what's next how about yourself

SPEAKER_01So I've got a few things going on. I mentioned earlier, I'm working on just a farce comedy that may get me in trouble with some of my Catholic readers because there's a lot of really coarse language in it. It's Bogans in Space. You know, it's just kind of a spoof on Aussie rural culture, and I'm really having fun with it. And I have to do that. I have to write comedies every once in a while just to, like, find my happy place.

I last year published a novella called The Jerusalem Passage that's pretty heavy.

SPEAKER_01I don't even know if I would call it sci-fi. It's sort of parable, horror, parable, little bit of sci-fi mixed in. And I got really interested in the world there. So I actually have two books that I finished that have not yet released that will be coming later this year. in that series. Um, so that'll be a trilogy. Um, and then the big news is, um, you know, I, I, um, Our Lady of the Artilects and A Cloud of Unknowing,

SPEAKER_01which are my kind of two most popular books, um, are going to be republished, uh, by a Catholic imprint. Um, I can't get the details. I don't think I can give the details yet. Cause like we just haven't made announcements about it, but, um, they're actually off the market right now, which is really weird. Like I had to unpublish them. Um, but they're going to be, um, edited, re-edited and, um, revised a little bit and, excuse me, re-released under this new imprint. And then, um, I'm under, uh, under contract to deliver a,

um, a third in that series.

SPEAKER_01And I pray that I don't pull a George Martin on it.

SPEAKER_02We'll pray for you too. Thank you. That's awesome news, Andrew.

SPEAKER_00And for myself, I'm like Andrew, I have to write humor sometimes. So this October, right before Halloween, I'm releasing the Savannah Paranormal Detective Agency 2 for free on my sub stack. It's about a lawyer who is mistaken for a zombie because he went to a trip to Haiti, who's basically shanghaied into a detective agency in Savannah, Georgia, run by a vampire and a ghost. And it's... first one's for free and it's all about just him trying to get back but they think

that his attempts that say no i'm alive or i don't eat brains is just his own brain decay and so that's nice we love you you're so dear to us but we really have to solve this case now he needs to get away they want to solve crime so it's a good

SPEAKER_00little short story there And additionally, I'm working on the fourth book of Fallen, which will be the last one. And let me tell you what started off as, hey, that'd be a weird dream that I just had. Let me just write down some things. I fell in love with the characters. Turns out I was hijacked by the characters. They're my best imaginary friends, but I look forward to the day that they will release me from their ironclad grip.

SPEAKER_02I know the feeling. Absolutely. Absolutely. That's awesome. Well, Patrick, thanks so much for putting this together. This was, this was great. We might have to do this again. I really enjoyed it just for fun.

SPEAKER_00Whether it's ourselves or somebody else more. Yeah. Let's do this again.

SPEAKER_02It'll be like the all in podcast, but for sci-fi intersecting with religion, probably have just as big a following as much influence in the country. So yeah, we've got that to aspire to. Maybe this was the beginning of it.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. C.S. Lewis Panel: The Meaning of Narnia and Other Questions

    Oct 13, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    What happens when a lay Catholics, a Protestant with a pastoral background, and an Orthodox priest and a layman get together? They talk about C.S. Lewis, Narnia, the Space Trilogy, and how Lewis has influenced them. Go...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Podcast Episode: Harmonialism and Aliens

    Jun 24, 20261 hr 28 minAudio

    For years I have been trying to write a Religion and Aliens: Theosophy post to continue my Religion and Aliens series (see below for all the posts), but the topic is a huge rabbit hole that is too hard to sum up....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Two Sci-Fi Authors Talk End Times Prophecies

    May 24, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    Science fiction authors Patrick Abbott and Schalk Holloway make their own worlds, sometimes with apocalypse for the sake of enjoyable fiction. Yet these two Christians, one a lay Catholic American and the other who...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Do Aliens Exist? Conversation with Patrick Abbot

    Feb 22, 202651 minAudio

    Get full access to Patrick Abbott, Sci-fi Author at www.patrickabbott.net/subscribe

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Interview with Sister Allison Regina Gilot

    Feb 18, 202635 minAudio

    In our conversation, Sister Allison Regina Gilot discusses her life as a nun who is an author of vampire fiction. She describes the importance of integrating Catholic themes into her stories. We discuss her writing...

    Credit the people on this episode