For years I have been trying to write a Religion and Aliens: Theosophy post to continue my Religion and Aliens series (see below for all the posts), but the topic is a huge rabbit hole that is too hard to sum up. Thankfully, Matt Osborne, who recently wrote about Harmonalism and Disclosure Day, was able to do a podcast episode with me which is not only the next best thing, but perhaps even better. Harmonalism is a religious effort to bring science, the occult, and religion into “harmony” with each other. While many of people will know this as New Ageism, Osborne points out that this effort can be traced back to Emanuel Swedenborg (1688-1772), and has its roots in America since Benjamin Franklin and Johnny Appleseed. In this episode, we go from Swedenborg to Theosophy to its effects on science fiction to Contactees to how Steven Spielberg has made our modern understanding of what aliens look like (and why “Grays” no longer have huge noses). For Matt Osborne’s Substack links check out: For the text-based Religion and Aliens posts, check out: * Ancient Faiths of Ancient Egypt, Zoroastrianism, and Ancient Greece * Bab Faiths * Black Hebrew Israelites * Dharma Faiths of Buddhism, Hinduism, Jainism, and Sikhism * Catholicism * Outside Mainstream Catholicism * Eastern Orthodoxy * Islam * Judaism * Native American Religions * Protestantism and Other Christian Faiths * Theozoology and World Ice Theory * Twentieth Century Faiths of Nation of Islam, Scientology, & Falun Gong Additionally, check out my look at the “Aliens are Demons” argument and my podcast interview on the subject. Get full access to Patrick Abbott, Sci-fi Author at www.patrickabbott.net/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Hello, everybody. I'm Patrick Abbott, author of the Fallen series, and today I have Matt Osborne. Matt, how are you today? I'm great. Thank you for having me on your show. Thank you for being on. And one thing I just want to point out is how excited I am for this interview. So often I've written objectively about what various religions thought about aliens and also kind of taken on sort of the reaction to that where Christians think aliens might be demons and I take a different view.
SPEAKER_00Well, you are really, really good into the research of basically, and we'll get into this, the theosophists and just sort of the alien UFO religion that isn't so much Scientology but fits into a grander scale. And it even ties into Disclosure Day that just came out by Steven Spielberg. So first off, what's going to make this interview interesting on your end?
SPEAKER_01Well, I'm about to tell you about the academic picture that I've come to understand about UFO religion, that actually UFOs started as religion, that UFOs came to the 20th century as a religion, an all-American religion, an old-time religion. So we're going to have a great talk today about the origins of UFO belief and how they predate Roswell. The myth, the story that It wants to tell about itself right now.
SPEAKER_01This all starts in 1947. But then you have people say, no, wait, it started in 1937 with Mussolini or something. There's a new story that they want to tell. Everybody's got a new story. This keeps happening. But we keep hearing a new version of this story because it is a story. And like any good myth, it's being retold.
SPEAKER_00Yep, and especially on the religious end, we get this sometimes in competing claims of prophecy, where someone will say, yes, that story is true, but I have a story that conveniently predates that story, even though I'm just saying it now. So I've seen also a lot of that in the UFO alien case. But before we get into that, can you tell us a little bit about yourself and how you got interested in the subject? Sure. Let me just scroll up my notes here. I have little notes here just to make sure that I don't miss anything.
SPEAKER_01When you ask me, for example, what my interest in flying saucers is, I get that question sometimes. Like, are flying saucers interesting at all? Were you ever interested in flying saucers, Patrick?
SPEAKER_00So I've in my family, there's been some high strangeness that there were weird lights in the sky, especially on my father's farm. And I'll link to that. There was a weird light that scared him. And he was the sort of person who would run out with a shotgun that shined. Patrick Abbott, Sci-Fi Author
SPEAKER_00You just described all the elements of harmonialism.
SPEAKER_01Harmonialism is what we're here to talk about. We're here to talk about a religious movement that is among us. And the flying saucer is an icon of knowing, a way of knowing,
SPEAKER_00to use finger quotes,
SPEAKER_01that moderns use, that is a sign of the belief that faith and science can be harmonized That's where the harmonialism comes from. And what I discovered after reading just far too many scriptures by flying saucer prophets is that this is a religious movement, right? And that's its icon. It's called a harmonialism. Harmonialism, it's one of the most important unacknowledged forces in
American religion. and it's where we get quote unquote new age and that's another rebranding thing people start calling it new age to make it sound new but it's not new it's always been here you remember the X-Files episode where Deep Throat says they have been here for a very long time the Harmonialists have been here in America for a very long time and one of the things that you just mentioned was this bricklage effect
SPEAKER_01as it's called I'll explain that later The point is that you're taking science fiction, right? You're responding to science fiction. You're plucking cultural materials out of the air. And on top of that, you're having experience. Okay, that's the key ingredient. You've got to have an experience. There's always an experience that underlies the belief. So it's experiential religion that is using cultural materials from around it. And then there was a second element that you mentioned.
SPEAKER_00interest in hard science?
SPEAKER_01Yes, science. You always bring in the science. Science, science fiction, and experience. That's harmonialism in a package.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so that's a really interesting point that you brought up because I recently read the latest edition of Skeptic Magazine, and a lot of the articles in it were just how UFOs are the Steve McLaughlin Steve's predate 1947, predate really even the Second Great Awakening.
SPEAKER_00It's a really long story that not just interests of, hey, are there beings out there, but they fit religiously. Can you tell us a little bit about just where the whole idea of not only could there be life out there, but could there be life as a sort of spiritual being be out there?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, Americans have communed with aliens through spiritual means from the beginning of the nation. All right. The flying saucer grew out of expressly spiritual ideas that were seeded in American soil from the beginning. And it's a very vacant soil, and it's got Native American already going on. And if you read about the frontier, the religious frontier,
SPEAKER_00that that's a Frenchy way to pronounce it,
SPEAKER_01that, you know, he came to America from France, and Alexei de Koukvi responded to the frontier as this, chaotic religious environment, a very febrile place where native belief and Neoplatonism sort of swirled in a kind of estuary, right? And this evolutionary environment was going on. One of the key figures in this time is a fellow named Emanuel Swedenborg. We can get to him in a minute.
SPEAKER_01The thing to understand is that Johnny Appleseed, whom you've heard of, Oh yeah, I know where this is going and I was going to ask, so keep it going.
SPEAKER_00Johnny Appleseed was a Swedenborgian missionary. So Benjamin Franklin was one of the first 50 subscribers to the first English
SPEAKER_01translation of the works of Swedenborg published in the United States. So the people who created the American nation at its founding already had this belief so it's always been with us as long as we've been a country God bless America and you know what it boils down to is that this Swedenborg fellow he adopted this Neoplatonic idea of the ascent if you read the Neoplatonic writers and I'm going way back Polybius what they have is these spiritual journeys
it's clearly a symbolic ascent right they go up to heaven they meet angels that sort of thing
SPEAKER_01Swedenborg says that he met Jesus. Jesus appeared to him in the middle of the seven years of war. And I want to put a pin in that. We'll get back to that. Because war keeps showing up as a character in this story. Harmonialism is very concerned with preventing the war, the end of the world, right? Harmonialism always wants an apocalypse that it alone can prevent by bringing us into harmony with the universe, right? Cosmic Harmony. So this Swedenborg fellow is part of this Neoplatonic revival
and the Neoplatonists have a spirit ascent journey story which he takes on and it becomes one of these
SPEAKER_01potent forces in American religion in the 19th century. Everybody is responding to Swedenborg. Now, that doesn't mean that they like Swedenborg. There are reactions to Swedenborg as well as, you know, positive reactions. There are negative reactions. And, you know, there are modifications. There are people, interesting, you will find this very interesting, in the spiritualist revival who, guys like Arthur Davis Jackson and, of course, Helena Blavatsky,
SPEAKER_01they both claimed Swedenborg as a spiritual mentor. That is, that he had appeared to them as a force ghost to tell them, to give them the updates from heaven, you see. So they could tell you what was real and what was not better than Swedenborg because they had the real Swedenborg, you see. And this process unfolded throughout the 19th century until people forgot Swedenborg. And it's interesting because Emerson, Ralph Waldo Emerson, thought that would happen. Transcendentalism was one of the reactions to Swedenborg or one
of the religious
SPEAKER_01ideas that included him among their reactions, I'll put it that way. So he had this long century of impact on the intellectual, spiritual foment, but also the literary foment. I can talk, for example, about Mark Twain, Honoré de Balzac, as well as all these religious writers. You have literary figures, H.P. Lovecraft. They're all impacted by Swedenborg and this long century of
reactions to Swedenborg. So it's shaping the public imaginarium at the same time that mass culture and mass
SPEAKER_01literacy are happening and people are inventing science fiction. So the influence on science fiction has been profound and science fiction has had a feedback loop relationship with harmonialism. This has always been the case. You cannot find a sort of harmonialist free science fiction. There's always somewhere, there's something And you can, well, we'll talk about some of the traces as we go. But yes, the long impact of Immanuel Swedenborg is that by having Jesus
appear to him and
SPEAKER_01then going into the heavens through astral travel, spiritual travel, using his heart as a hyperdrive, he was able to visit other planets. and meet people there and find out about their societies and then write about them as a scientist. That's he. He was a scientist, at least as that word was understood in the 18th century. He wrote countless books about minds, right, and very hard science observations, measurements, that sort of thing.
SPEAKER_01And he had expanded into anatomy and he had developed an idea that arts of the body correspond to God, that there is a doctrine of correspondences involved in all living creatures. And this comes out to be very influential in the long-term development of harmony. And in fact, it's been restated by David Grush. So it's still a lot.
And if you ask me, okay, wait a minute, what does that have to do with the UAP Disclosure Cult?
SPEAKER_01It has everything to do with the UAP Disclosure Cult.
SPEAKER_00Can you describe a little bit of Swedenborg's beliefs, how he sort of married the occult and esoteric Christianity and aliens and just how the disclosure cult has really borrowed from that?
SPEAKER_01Sure.
SPEAKER_00One second.
SPEAKER_01The thing to understand is that Swedenborg and the Neoplatonists were concerned with the heavens as proof of God's existence. Swedenborg was a Protestant Christian man, very deep, profoundly Protestant man. And, you know, he had some anti-Catholicism, and you find a lot of that actually in especially German Rosicrucian stuff going on at the same time. The 17th century is this period of time when it's very
dangerous to think out loud
SPEAKER_01about esoteric religious thought. So, you know, that's the environment in which he wrote. He was a courageous man in that sense, and he could have only happened in London as he did with a free press. So while everybody's reacting to Swedenborg, they're all thinking about the heavens as proof of God's existence because that's the through line of his writing on heaven and hell as the name of the biggest work. And the guy wrote millions of words, just volumes and volumes of words.
SPEAKER_01And the reasoning is that the sky is full of planets. Now, you find this phrase fixed stars, you find it a lot in this period of the 19th century. Fixed stars, that's not scientific. But that's a pre-scientific understanding, a Neoplatonist understanding of stars as the fixed objects in the sky, right? But the planets are the things that move. The planets create astrology by their movements while the stars are fixed. But Every one of them, they reasoned, has planets.
SPEAKER_01And so there's all these planets. Well, that's a lot of space to just leave empty. It would be a waste of space. Surely God has filled all those planets with life. That is the reasoning of the Neoplatonists as expressed through Swedenborg and recycled through the American religious 19th century. It's the idea that God would not leave so much space empty of life. Life on other worlds exists, and that proves God exists. If that makes sense, what they're doing is trying to prove God in a very Christian
way.
SPEAKER_01Now, at the end of his life, interestingly, there is this very strange imbroglia because the man was associated with diplomacy and sort of cloak and dagger stuff as well during his lifetime. And the Seven Years War had broken out despite his best efforts to maintain the peace of Europe,
SPEAKER_00basically.
SPEAKER_01And that affected him, I believe. It profoundly shaped him. That's why he went on his spiritual bent. But in the meantime, this foment is producing an idea of That life on other worlds proves God exists, but ultimately during the 19th century, that idea gets taken up by people who are reacting to it, remember, and some of them react against it. Some people are out to unsettle Christianity. Some people are out to dethrone Christ.
Some people are out to expand the meaning of God to be bigger than the God of the Bible.
SPEAKER_01to make the God of the Bible somehow subordinate to a new God. That emerges in the 19th century. It doesn't define all of Harmonialism, but that Harmonialist current produces reactions that eventually run contrary to very core Christian ideas. One of those is reincarnation. Americans, I don't know if you're aware of believe in reincarnation at a much larger number of Americans believe in reincarnation today than they used to.
SPEAKER_01I believe in 1950, it was 3% of Americans. Today, it's about 30% of Americans. So what has changed about our American beliefs that allowed for this idea of reincarnation to come in, where people are not necessarily Disbelieving in Christ, but they are picking up the new belief of reincarnation. What's going on there? That's harmonialism. That's the harmonizing effect of trying to bring all the religions together.
SPEAKER_01And at the end of his life, Swedenborg was trying to do that. He was trying to incorporate Kabbalistic Judaism, esoteric Islam, and Protestant science into a religion. So yeah, this is a long story, but it's still happening. We're still doing it, and that's the actual, let's call it, I won't call it a conspiracy, but if you're looking for the real story,
SPEAKER_01it's this impulse, this harmonialist current and religion in America that produced the belief in the flying saucers and produces Disclosure Day.
SPEAKER_00So I really like how you brought up how various groups had reactions to Swedenborgism, whether adopting elements or rejecting elements or maybe a little bit of both. In America, we've had, especially during the Second Great Awakening, where we had that religious churn on the frontier, Mormonism adopted some elements of, well, God is so great that there's life on other planets and that other planets have other gods within the whole God world. Theology. You had Thomas Paine,
who openly embraced the idea of life on other worlds and used that to bash
SPEAKER_00Christianity. What other groups have really adopted Swedenborgism during that time, leading up to the Theosophists?
SPEAKER_01Well, yeah, there's a lot before we get to theosophy. Mormonism is impacted by Swedenborg. That doesn't mean that it's a Swedenborgian religion, and I don't include Mormonism or Latter-day Saints in Harmonialism. What's interesting is how modern-day Mormons so frequently turn up in Harmonialist circles, right? So it's part of the belief package for Mormons that not all Mormons adopt. I don't want to sit here and say Mormons believe this,
Mormons believe that.
SPEAKER_01But what you're referring to is the idea of metempsychosis, the idea that we are reincarnated on other worlds.
SPEAKER_00This is something that still shapes harmonialist belief today.
SPEAKER_01And it is a key contrast with It brings the conflict they want to avoid, yeah Right, because they're pacifistic.
SPEAKER_01They want to avoid a fight. It's not just the Mormons. It's spiritualism. All the seances. All the animal magnetism that you read about in Edgar Allan Poe. Faithism. Maybe you've heard of faithism. Urantianism. Seventh-day Adventism. Transcendentalism, Unitarianism, Vegetarianism.
SPEAKER_01That's one of the reactions to Swedenborg. He was not a vegetarian. He was not an ascetic at all, but it was his sort of intellectual, spiritual children in the United States a century later who invented vegetarianism. And actually, there's a quote of Joseph Smith reacting to Swedenborg, being asked about him and saying, effectively that he didn't buy into the whole vegetarian thing that Swedenborg's followers were doing. It wasn't something that Swedenborg did.
So he had a limited understanding of Swedenborg, but he knew who Swedenborg was.
SPEAKER_01He knew about this Neoplatonist idea of life on other planets. So that's the way it has impacted various utopianisms, utopian movements, Rosicrucianism, Freemasonry, both shaped by Swedenborg. There are actually Swedenborgian rights that you undergo in those systems. Esoteric religion in general, the biggest one in this story is theosophy. And that is, of course, Helena Blavatsky, Charles Ledbetter, and Charles Sutherland,
SPEAKER_01and all these guys who were into the whole list that I just gave you. Right? You have people who are part of that. intellectual, spiritual foment of the 19th century that includes, that wants to incorporate Christianity. Because if you're going to explain the universe, well, it's got Christians in it. You have to explain Christianity in your story of the universe, right? That's just logical. But what you end up doing,
SPEAKER_01of course, if you're Helena Blavatsky, is you start retelling the story of Christ. Christians don't want that. They don't like that. And this is where we get into the problems that show up in harmonious narratives. And we'll talk about these more later. But let me just point out really quickly, there is a phenomenon that I call space Jesus. I'm going to use this term freely. Space Jesus is not the Jesus you believe in if you are a believing Christian. I am not referring to the Jesus you believe in,
and I'm not making fun of that Jesus.
SPEAKER_01Space Jesus is my term. for the Harmonialist Jesus.
SPEAKER_00Jesus as an ascended master sort of thing.
SPEAKER_01Yes, yes. Jesus as an ascended master, which emerges from theosophy. Now, so we've come all this way. Who are these ascended masters? There are so many of them, aren't there? There's an infinite number of ascended masters, almost like angels. They're angels, right? And we know this because so many of them are departed masters from Earth. Spiritual Masters from Tibet that you have no clue why Blavatsky is listing them. Who this person is, what did they do? You know, what is she doing there?
SPEAKER_01She's trying to syncretize. That's the word. She's syncretizing all these different religions into a harmonious picture of spiritual ascension. And this new story of spiritual ascension is the one, and we have to use capital letters, ascended, masters, right? Because it's always capitalized. And it's this whole idea of a metaphysical meaning that is
built into the term.
SPEAKER_01And it's supposed to carry this package of belief. One of the things that emerges out of this theosophical foment, and you find it by the 1930s, it's abundant. You can find it in the works of Guy Ballard, who we'll talk about. This idea of spiritual spaceships. that these are space vessels, spiritual vessels that bring spiritual beings back and forth to Earth. See, the Ascended Masters, they ascended in these spiritual vessels and then they come back to Earth.
SPEAKER_01And then, you know, there is an idea of teleportation as well. Teleportation shows up in the works of Charles Fort. He invents this term and almost immediately there is Guy Ballard, theosophist, talking about teleportation. Talking about becoming a Force Ghost, and this is where we get really interesting. Guy Ballard. If you want me to talk about Guy Ballard, I'll go ahead and do that now. Entertain me. Your listeners will find this entertaining. Guy Ballard not only taught that you could ascend through the
atomic accelerator to
SPEAKER_01become a Force Ghost, but also that you could fire bolts of blue lightning from your fingertips. And this was invisible to everyone else, but it was visible to you because it was real. You were shooting physical blue lightning from your fingertips. And this was how you made an imprecatory gesture towards your enemies, you see. He taught his students, he called them, to basically be the emperor, shocking their,
SPEAKER_01like, lightning, blue lightning. He taught them to shoot blue lightning at their enemies. And it was part of these imprecatory prayers that he used to try to destroy Franklin Roosevelt and stuff like that. He was a very weird guy. But the point is that he also told them that they could wield St. Michael's sword. St. Michael's sword is made of blue flames.
and he taught them to visualize wielding a sword of blue flame physical in their physical hands they were wielding a sword of blue flame and he would have them go through the streets like this wielding the sword what does this sound like Patrick
SPEAKER_00I'm gonna ruin it for everybody but Star Wars yeah yeah and it turns out that actually George Lucas is familiar with Theosophy not simply through the works of Joseph Campbell but he's actually directed an episode of Young Indiana Jones that is about Theosophy so yes George Lucas is very familiar with the story of Theosophy and he would have to know about Guy Ballard because his career
SPEAKER_01was centered in Los Angeles now Los Angeles at that time was already Tinseltown. And so you can find him. He did a good job of publishing himself. There are still recordings and images of him out there that you can find because of that distribution. So George Lucas had to know about Guy Ballard. I don't think he could be familiar with Hollywood of the 1930s
and not know about Guy Ballard. And it's happening at the same time as Flash Gordon and the same time as Buck Rogers. And, you know, these are not necessarily theosophical religious programs, right?
SPEAKER_01But there are little elements that are creeping in. They're creative elements because what's happening is the science fiction is incorporating an idea. Okay, that's cool. I'm going to use that. That's what we see in George Lucas. We see the science fiction creator who's making fiction, who's trying to entertain us, right? I'm just telling a good story. And what are they doing? They're borrowing something cool that they got from history. And it doesn't matter where they got it. I'm not against it. I'm just saying that we haven't identified this before.
SPEAKER_01It's an unidentified flying inspiration that we have now identified. is Guy Ballard and this weird cult called the I Am Activity, which needs to be a movie. You could actually make Indiana Jones and the I Am Activity. That is the missing Indiana Jones film, I'm telling you.
SPEAKER_00It would be better than The Kingdom of the Crystal Skull. Can you tell us a little bit about the I Am Activity? Miles better. Oh, what a weirdo.
SPEAKER_01Guy Ballard and his wife Edna. If you look up Ballard v. United States, the he was dead when it happened but there was ultimately a Supreme Court verdict with Edna Ballard's name on it because it is a precedent in our religious freedom story basically what happened is that they were accused of fraud and by fraud I mean a religious fraud hucksterism send me your money good things will
happen which we see
SPEAKER_01all the time You see it all the time. And the reason we can see it all the time is because the Supreme Court ruled as a result of the ballots that it is a violation of the Constitution, the First Amendment, to Don't inquire in a court about the depth of someone's belief. That is, if you say you believe in Christ, then I don't have to make you prove it, or I can't make you prove it in court.
SPEAKER_01If you say I'm a believer in Muhammad, you're a believer in Muhammad. If you say that you are a theophist, then you are one, right? It is an identification narrative, right? of confession, that you must be free to say what you believe without being tested in court as to whether you really believe it or not. That was the problem in the case, is that the fraud trial had tried to show that they did not
really believe what
SPEAKER_01they were selling. And that's what makes it fraud. And the reason why religious people can go on cable television and ask you for your money is because of this Supreme Court precedent Now Guy Ballard and his wife, their story begins actually when he owed a whole lot of money to people in Chicago for a gold lake, finger quotes, that he had found in Colorado He sold shares in this gold lake
and then he
SPEAKER_01absconded off to California And on the sides of Mount Shasta, which is still a New Age Mecca It's one of the New Age Meccas that I write about in this book He had an encounter with the Count of Saint Germain Do you know about the Count of St. Germain?
SPEAKER_00So, just for listeners, the Count of St. Germain is allegedly an immortal who moved around courts of Europe, probably based on a real person, but there are stories that have built up around him, especially in Rosicrucian, esoteric Freemasonry, and Theosophist that he is an immortal. Some people try to claim that he is basically an ascended master from another world. Other people say he was the wandering Jew who was cursed by Jesus and then learned the secrets of immortality.
SPEAKER_00A lot of different backgrounds. Did I get it right? You did. Let me remind you of another figure in the 20th century that got wrapped up in kind
SPEAKER_01of similar mythology, a guy named Elvis.
SPEAKER_00He still lives, walks among us Right,
SPEAKER_01right, yeah, for like 30 years That was a joke cover At least once a year on the Weekly World News There would be a cover about Elvis being spotted alive somewhere He's definitely alive, he's among us And then one day they announced that Elvis had actually died, right? He was like 103 or whatever So he couldn't be alive anymore They gave him some incredible age They did the same thing with Hitler Right? Hitler's still alive. Elvis's still alive. Down in Argentina, yep.
SPEAKER_01Yes, it's this whole, it's a trope. And Count to Saint Germain is kind of the original trope of that, if you will. He keeps showing up. He's another one of these figures that Helena Blavatsky says, oh yeah, I've met the Count St. Germain. Guy Ballard's like, oh yeah, I've met St. Germain. They've all met St. Germain. And this is where the cult of St. Germain became insanely popular for a minute in America. There were like a million believers. There were about 100 million Americans and a million believers
to some level in
SPEAKER_01this new fad cult. There are people who are at least interested in
SPEAKER_00There was even a Leonard Nimoy in search of about him, as I recall.
SPEAKER_01Yes. So, you know, there is this still some amount of fascination that has existed around this by not enough. We're not aware of him enough,
SPEAKER_00this guy Ballard and St.
SPEAKER_01Germain, because that's what theosophy became in the 20th century. If you go to a Christian theosophy, like, oh, I'm Elizabeth Clare Prophet, If you go to her compound, you'll see Saint Germain on the altar and Jesus will be there in equality with Saint Germain. What's that about? Again, it's this harmonialist idea of putting Jesus in equality with other figures. So that was kind of the challenge that Guy Ballard was
presenting to American Christianity.
SPEAKER_01He had to have an admixture of Christianity in his religion. He had to at least include Jesus somehow because that's what people expected. That's what Americans expected. So again, we come back to this idea of harmonialism has to include Jesus. It can't not include Jesus. But in doing so, it ends up challenging the traditional Orthodox Jesus. And so that is a significant tension that keeps coming back. But you're
So, at first it was who were the theosophists, and then we started talking about them.
SPEAKER_00A good segue into kind of the next portion would be, and you've touched a little bit on this, and I've also talked to Sarah Light Waller about this in her Rocketeer podcast. There's a lot of big theosophist influence in science fiction, early science fiction. Some of the theosophists wrote science fiction, and others who weren't theosophists borrowed heavily from theosophist ideals. Why do you think that is?
SPEAKER_01Well, because it's cool stuff, right? Like shooting laser beams or wielding swords of blue flame or all these ideas, telekinesis, teleportation, Cool stuff. So, you know, it makes perfect sense, actually, that people incorporate it not simply into their belief systems, but into their imagination, whereupon when people apply science, because they're mixing, they're harmonizing the science with this stuff,
SPEAKER_01they might actually come to some sort of creative fruition. And you see that, for example, in the story of Jack Parsons. Jack Parsons of the Jet Propulsion Laboratory When he asked Marjorie Cameron, Babylon, the woman at the center of his little story with L. Ron Hubbard When he asked Marjorie Cameron for a sign of her religious beliefs, she responded with a description of a spiritual spaceship from theosophy.
SPEAKER_00Could you describe what exactly a spiritual spaceship is?
SPEAKER_01This was an idea. Usually they were cigar-shaped. They also became round. They became saucer-like. But the idea was that they brought the Ascended Masters back and forth like a bus,
SPEAKER_00right, from Venus or wherever. The Lords of the Flame, according to Helena Blavatsky, they lived on Venus.
SPEAKER_01The Theosophists kept trying to locate, you know... the sort of local command post of the Galactic Federation on Venus. They kept trying to do that. And so, yes, it's very influential stuff. People come away from it thinking, okay, now I can make a story out of this. And maybe they're just making a story and it's fine. But people come away thinking, I'm going to make a new religious story out of this. And that's clearly happening because people incorporate
cultural materials,
SPEAKER_01Patrick Abbott, Sci-Fi with science. People are fascinated by science and they're trying to turn science into something real. And that's how this spiritual spacecraft develops. Ballard is talking about them.
They come actually from earlier theosophists that sort of describe this idea.
SPEAKER_01And, you know, even into the 1960s and 70s, you know, some flying saucers were not saucer-shaped, they were cigar-shaped. They continued being these theosophical objects, and a lot of early flying saucer-related stuff came with swirls, like a swastika, which, ooch. We don't do that anymore. We can't have swastikas anymore, even though that is part of the symbol of the Church of Theosophy.
SPEAKER_01Something happened that made the swastika no longer acceptable but you still see theosophists using it in the 1950s with their flying saucers and see that's it that's a telltale sign they're carrying over the belief There needs to be a full study on the use of swastikas in the 1800s and where they
SPEAKER_00came from, because where I had my wedding reception on the floor, there were swastikas, because it was a cool thing in the late 1800s. In the early 1900s, a church was built where I just visited a friend who was ordained a priest. There's swastikas on the floor. So it's like, oops! But that's a really good point about the unpleasantness in the mid-30s and 40s, which leads to The whole UFO aspect that people started reporting new trends of seeing stuff in the sky.
Some of it was the Foo Fighters of World War II where we thought it might be a new
SPEAKER_00German weapon. The Germans thought that might be a new Allied weapon. In 1946, there were the Ghost Rockets, which may have been the Soviets testing out some German technology, maybe not. And then in 1947, we have the Arnold sighting that the term flying saucer comes from What's your take on this sort of trend of starting to see stuff in the sky? And do you consider the Foo Fighters and Ghost Rockets in the same cultural trend of seeing stuff in the sky?
SPEAKER_00Or do you really see the Arnold sighting as something new?
SPEAKER_01I see it as an experience. Remember, experience is one of the three things, right? And that experience becomes spiritualized. Well, let's talk about the experience, because the earliest, or I won't say the earliest, many years ago in my military history research, I accidentally came across a Zeppelin battle that took place in the sky off Australia in 1918.
SPEAKER_01It was exactly... like some sort of video game or something. Zeppelin's having a battle, but it was clearly fabricated, right? Somebody may have seen this, seen this quote unquote. Maybe they saw a storm in the sky. I don't know. Somebody saw something and it became a Zeppelin battle in the sky. So people were doing it before World War II, but hang on just a second.
SPEAKER_01The key thing to understand is that before 1903, it's very unusual to see material objects in the sky that are not creatures like
SPEAKER_00birds. It's very unusual to see an object in the sky at the beginning of the 20th century.
SPEAKER_01That changes. That changes a lot. The key driver of that change is warfare. And now we get into my military history because we have to talk about the balloon going up. That's a military phrase. The balloon goes up means that the battle begins. Well, in the 1930s, people invented the weather balloon. There was a Frenchman named Robert Bureau who first invented the radiosonde
SPEAKER_01electronics, is what it's called, that make a weather balloon useful. It goes aloft. And it tells you, ping! And then you're able to tell where it is, and you're able to get information from it. That's the whole purpose of sending the balloon aloft, is to be able to get remote information. And if invention happens, it's rapidly developed by the end of the 1930s, just in time for war. And in wartime, of course, having been through the experience of World War I,
SPEAKER_01everybody's ready to go to war with lots and lots of airplanes. So you have, at the beginning of the war, in 1939, hundreds of airplanes going into the sky every day. Probably by the middle of the war, you have many thousands every day. And by the end of the war, it is tens of thousands of airplanes going in the air every day. So you have more and more people going up into the air. You have more people with eyeballs looking around, and a lot of these aircraft have very large crews,
SPEAKER_01and it's war, so people are looking around, right? You've got to watch out for the enemy. So you have suddenly a whole lot of observation, and the sky is now full of first scores, then hundreds, probably a thousand weather balloons a day worldwide. That's what's happening with Foo Fighters. It was a weather balloon.
SPEAKER_01And I know that that's a joke. Ufology makes it a joke. It's actually the subject of a great song from the X-Files, right? Songs in the Key of X, Unmarked Helicopters by Soul Coughing. They said it was a weather balloon. But actually, a lot of these are weather balloons. Especially at sunset. It's very high and it's very far away, but it's also very visible because it's huge and it's glowing orange from the sunset, right? And somebody's looking out of a bomber window, right?
SPEAKER_01Like, what is that? That's how Foo Fighters happen. So, yes, again, it's a technological history. You also saw this happen again with drones recently. We had tons of drones in the sky because actually there's a lot more uses for drones now. Power line companies will use them to check the power lines after a storm to find the break, right? So you get more and more of these drones in the sky doing more things. And people say, what's going on?
SPEAKER_01I'm seeing some weird number of drones in the sky. There is a description by Mark Pilkington, for example, of something that he encountered that he didn't understand. It was the 1990s. He was, you know, somewhere that was not too terribly far away from technology areas of America. And he saw this mysterious silver ball flying through the air. Right? Like, what is that? That's weird. Well, it is weird. But actually, spherical drones exist.
SPEAKER_01They do. So he just happened to see a spherical drone being tested, most likely. So, again, observation becomes experience. Somebody sees something, they spiritualize it. That's what happened with Kenneth Arnold. It's not often understood this way, but he reported they weren't flying discs at first. I think they were objects.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, he weirdly described them as saucers moving on the water, but his original drawings were almost crescent-shaped and whatnot.
SPEAKER_01Right, right. So it's this changing, morphing thing that he sees that after seeing it, he begins to have paranormal experiences. Now, this is something that happens, it turns up in the literature over and over with Skinwalker Ranch, with all of these Harmonialists, is that once you start to believe, you start to have experiences. It's not just one, it's experiences, plural. You know, the universe sometimes lines up in strange ways,
SPEAKER_01and so that becomes incorporated into the fabric of belief. Coincidence is one of the elements of belief, right? That can't be a coincidence, but, you know, cosmic coincidence, we say. Well, harmonialism believes that if you're in tune with the cosmos, then there are no coincidences. The cosmic coincidences, they're supposed to happen. So Kenneth Arnold started to have these experiences after that
experience.
SPEAKER_01And within two years, what is he doing? He's saying these must be aliens. And I think that's a great thing to point out because at first when he's originally
SPEAKER_00interviewed in the famous audio, he talks about how, oh, it might have been some equipment and I hope to find out later today from the government what it was. Then two years later, he's very clearly on the, hey, this is a nuts and bolts UFO. Then a few years later after that, I want to say 54, 55, he's talking about they could potentially be creatures in and of themselves, spacefaring creatures. And you have at that time Carl Jung announcing to the world that a new age is at
SPEAKER_01hand, that this is the birth of a new religion, that this is the icon of a new religion, that it is people having an experience, it might even be a dream, that feels transformative, that becomes spiritualized. and there you are. You have harmonialism in one neat package. And so it's a very febrile time. The 1950s you have from 1946 through the mid-50s is a very formative time. You have L. Ron Hubbard, the Seekers in Oak Park.
SPEAKER_01You have Adamski and George Hunt Williamson. All of these guys who are theosophists Every one of them is part of some measure of theosophy. With Hubbard, it's like a cousin because he's into Thelema magic, right? Which is Crowley, Aleister Crowley had basically parted ways with theosophy to be more magical. And that's what Hubbard was into. And before the war, actually, he was a Rosicrucian.
SPEAKER_01So I don't know if you've ever checked out Rosicrucianism, but your soul, your cosmic soul consciousness is a very keen concern of Rosicrucianism, and you can unlock your powers as a spiritual being and reach out and touch the universe with Rosicrucianism. It's in their acts, right? And so all that sort of cultural material is what Hubbard's working from when he comes up with a spiritual technology. We have spiritual spaceships, now we have Spiritual Technology Okay,
SPEAKER_01again, trying to incorporate science and faith, trying to harmonize them. And, you know, the occult powers are involved because the foundational people in the remote viewing research domain, this is paranormal research, and it's the New Swedenborg. They are Scientologists. Scientology is one of the primary ways that Patrick Abbott, Sci-Fi Author,
is when the image of the alien sort of solidifies, becomes concretized as the grave.
SPEAKER_01And that's Steven Spielberg's fault. And that in itself is part of the story. But the point is that this is a process that takes place over a couple of three decades of time. And it is an intellectual, spiritual foment that the hippie love era is part of it, right? That whole energy of peace, love, and understanding of the Aquarian age, which is, again, theosophy. Just the whole project of the 1960s, late 1960s, is branded in theosophy.
SPEAKER_01It's branded in harmonialism. Star Trek is pretty harmonialist, right? And that is something that pops up in the book, you know, The future, according to so many sources, is supposed to have anti-gravity but no money. Well, that's a belief that you find in Star Trek. It's a liberal progressive spirit taken to the future to almost a spiritual level
SPEAKER_00where it's not just, hey, the government got rid of money, yay. It was this original, we've moved beyond the spiritual need for money and that drive. Yes, exactly, exactly We've moved beyond greed because we are in harmony with the cosmos And,
SPEAKER_01you know, we can talk on and on about Star Trek It's not, Star Trek is not all harmonious I'm not making that argument But if you have watched enough Star Trek You notice that almost all, probably 90-95% of the aliens are humans in makeup Right? That's harmonialism That's the Harmonialist perspective all the way back to Swedenborg, is that the world is full of, or the universe is full of humanoid or human-like creatures.
And that's where we get theosophists coming up with all these cockamamie ideas
SPEAKER_01about how we may have evolved from star beings.
SPEAKER_00So that's an interesting thing.
SPEAKER_01Ancient astronaut stuff. because Star Trek The Next Generation definitely went down that route because you can say at first well especially with the first series it's cheaper yo but they actually did an episode of Next Generation where they find the race that event yes
SPEAKER_00All the Romulans, the Klingons, and the reason why you look like us, or look so similar, is because you look like us, and you evolved from us, and we are your... I forget the exact words used, but it was definitely sort of an ascendant master, and I hope you go along the way we have set out for you.
SPEAKER_01Yes, yes. All of this stuff keeps popping up from time to time in these science fiction franchises. And that's because the influence of harmonialism is there. There's a moment in my book where I literally say, we have just reached the main deck of Babylon 5. Right? Because of that resonance. And you're right. It's there everywhere. It's not just writing. It's not just television and film. It's music. Okay? Like, Gustav Holst was influenced by Theosophy.
SPEAKER_01So when you're listening to The Planets, you're listening to You're listening to Theosophical Influence. And then, you know, the History Channel basically is the Theosophy Channel, as far as I'm concerned.
SPEAKER_00RIP History Channel. I loved you in the 90s. Yes.
SPEAKER_01So yeah, it's a process, and that's all in the book. And we should probably talk about George Adamski real quick.
SPEAKER_00So that was going to be my next question. In popular culture, especially right after the Arnold sighting, right after Roswell, What flying saucers were, were a big, huge question. There was a poll in Tampa Bay's newspaper where most people were saying it's either misidentified, Russian equipment, American equipment, and in the general... In general, like, immediate news sense, you don't see mentions of aliens. However, break, break,
SPEAKER_00break, starting in the late 40s, you get George Adamski, who claimed to be a contactee. You start seeing a heavy push in sci-fi, specifically tying in The Flying Saucer with aliens. And that's sort of, as we, by 1952, The Day the Earth Stood Still, that's the dominant thing. Who's George Sadamsky and how did it just completely take over the mindset of flying saucers?
SPEAKER_01Well, remember what I said about war. I said, let's put a pin in Emanuel Swedenborg and the Seven Years' War, which is known by historians as World War Zero, by the way. We should note that, that these world wars seem to have a sort of creative effect, let's call it. And after World War II, in this post-war moment, Theosophy is looking for a way to rebrand itself, and one of the ways that it does that is through a flying
saucer and a man from
SPEAKER_01Venus named Orthon, an Ascended Master name. Oh, it's weird how Adamski goes to Venus and keeps meeting Ascended Masters. It's weird that we don't speak of this idea as one that comes from Theosophy, right? And we really should. because if you believe that somebody got onto a flying saucer with the aliens and went to Venus in 1953, then you are a theosophist.
SPEAKER_01You're doing theosophy to a degree if you believe that. So here's the thing. Ufology wants to hang on to belief in George Adamski's flying saucer without George Adamski. Damski
SPEAKER_01occurred right after the Ivy Mike H-bomb test. That's really important, I think, because the world was suddenly facing the possibility of catastrophe, right? Armed catastrophe. The Korean War is happening. So the Cold War is actually a little hot. So, yes, there's tension in the air. People are worried about the state of the world.
And here comes Theosophy with a message that is straight off of Klaatu's speech
SPEAKER_01from the day the Earth stood still. Right? Hey, you humans, you better behave yourselves and get in tune with the cosmic harmonies. Otherwise, bad things will happen to you Because catastrophism, again, is this constant theme Remaking of the world through catastrophe is a constant theme So the flying saucer is just an icon of change, right? And so you get these weird variations on it That it could be good,
SPEAKER_01it could be bad It might be both And that is the harmonialist question, right? How is this going to turn out? Here comes the flying saucer. How is this going to turn out good or bad? And sometimes in science fiction, It turns out very badly, right? War of the Worlds is probably the best example H.G. Wells I don't think was influenced by Theosophy when he wrote War of the Worlds But, you know, that is a challenge to Theosophy That you have to incorporate the idea that aliens might be bad So you see this in the career of George Adamski
That he starts out,
SPEAKER_01the aliens are good And then slowly he says, you know, some of these aliens might be bad And it becomes a new contest for power The universe, instead of becoming all peace and light It becomes a battlefield Kind of like the Cold War So it's interesting how this sort of epistemic existence of 1952-1953 reflects in Adamski's proclamation about people from Venus. And it's interesting, the response is alternative religion believers,
SPEAKER_01esoteric religion believers worldwide, who are very, you know, there's not much interest in the old theosophy, but oh, this is new. and they are very responsive to this because it's speaking to their concerns and if you read Jack Parsons if you read the writings of any Harmonialist you're not going to find any of them that's enthusiastic about war except narratively you know in the works of Billy Meyer you have like alien planets having nuclear wars and things like that it's all very you know it's very science fiction-y
but what's happening
SPEAKER_01there is that people are Patrick Abbott, Sci-Fi Author
SPEAKER_00Then you have the 1960s coming, and you have more of the alien abduction, Betty and Barney Heel, the introduction of what would be considered the founder of the gray race of... The eyes and heads are always different, but this whole movement that leads up to how Steven Spielberg really put his stamp on it. How did that idea of aliens really stamp out the more traditional theosophists, hey, they're just better looking versions of us?
SPEAKER_01Well, you know, the universe can be a zoo, right? Let me give you a good example. About 1983, I found a book in my school library by Brad Steiger. And it was an anthology of encounter with extraterrestrials. And one of these was the story of Jennings Frederick. Do you know the story of Jennings Frederick? I have to admit, I do not.
SPEAKER_01Okay, this is one of those obscure things. You'll be entertained. Jennings Frederick was a hillbilly of West Virginia. And like so many of these narratives, he went out of his way to insist that he had never had a drop to drink in his life. He was a teetotaler. Definitely was not drunk when he saw this. How odd to declare that. Yeah. He said that he encountered a slender, green, telepathic being that resembled a stalk of celery.
SPEAKER_00Celery. Okay.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Now, this supposedly happened in the middle of 1968. On 28 February 1968, there premiered an episode of Lost in Space called The Great Vegetable Rebellion. I remember that episode. So you have this effect that television is already shaping narratives, right? So that's changing things. It's taking over from literature. It's becoming primarily
SPEAKER_01TV-driven, but there's also movies are still a big deal. So Close Encounters, it shapes our view of the alien. This starts with Betty Hill describing the aliens as having enormous noses. She compared them to Jimmy Durante, and if you look at a picture of Jimmy Durante, he was this comic character actor. He was really good. He had this enormous schnoz, and he made the nose, most of it. He would, like, turn his head so you could see how big it was, right? And then slowly, over the years, her descriptions changed.
SPEAKER_01They lost their noses. They ended up with just little nostril slits. And what's happening is that she's under hypnosis. And she's also under the influence of quote-unquote New Age religion, i.e.
SPEAKER_00theosophy.
SPEAKER_01And her view of the alien is changing over time. And the advisors on Close Encounters of the First Kind. Two of them that I can name were Harmonialists, Alan Hynek and Jacques Vallée, one of whom is still alive and still pushing the flying. And what they, of course, told Stephen King was that, you know, this is the update on what the aliens look like. And he went, OK, that's cool. And he used those aliens. This noseless, nostril slit, big black eyes, gray, shapeless sort of body
That's an archetype that he cemented in our public consciousness because after
SPEAKER_011977, all the abduction reports of the 1980s, the abduction craze, if you will, it's all great. And then And then the X-Files, right? So now it's going from one side to the other and back again.
SPEAKER_00And it's building cultural force. Go ahead. I was going to point out, people like to talk about the Travis Walton case in the 1970s, but those weren't greys. And in fact, it also involved basically what we'd consider almost theosophist aliens. At the end, he met very human-looking aliens. In other cases, I forget which one, I think it was in Florida, people who said they were fishing, they encountered robots. The abduction craze has sort of really died out as a trend,
SPEAKER_00but nobody would describe that anymore. I think even the disclosure groups would make fun of you if you said you're abducted by a robot and a Nordic-looking guy.
SPEAKER_01Right, right. So there again, what's happening is that the Harmonialists are creating new stories. These stories are new and fresh and cool. Your stories are old, stale, and pale See what's happening here? You've probably noticed literary fashions come and go There's a process going on There's a creative process that makes the older content weaker So that it has to be replaced with fresh content
SPEAKER_01has to be remixed. The ideas have to be remixed, mashed up once again. Tara Isabella Burton has a whole book called Strange Rites, R-I-T-E-S, that is all about this. And she touches on some of the areas that are in my book that I mentioned in my book where that is sort of buttressing my argument. But yes, this harmonious current, that's what it's doing. It's using this space, science fiction, science and experience, And what's the primary experience that has dissipated actually
is sleep apnea.
SPEAKER_01We have CPAP therapy now. So the abduction has decreased. There are still people who insist they were abducted. That's a whole experiential thing. And it doesn't always come from apnea. But the reason why it has declined is as a thing is because of CPAP therapy being in widespread use. That's my argument because I had issues.
SPEAKER_00That is a very interesting hypothesis. Yeah. I had some issues with sleep paralysis until I used CPAP therapy, and then it went away.
SPEAKER_01It was gone. Again, that's an experience, if not data. but that is my hypothesis for why we've seen a cultural decline and so again it has to change once more so what has happened actually in the 21st century is that with the decline of abduction with the decline of the X-Files alien relationship there's been an effort to renew the bricklage it started in 2017 with that New York Times
SPEAKER_01article and I want to point out that Of the three people in the byline on that New York Times article, two of them are harmonialists. They both have written books that are harmonialism. One of them, Leslie Keen, is a practicing spiritual medium. Okay, so again, we're here at the psychic powers. We're here at the occult and the border sciences being part of the package of beliefs. in Harmonialism.
SPEAKER_01And these are the people that David Grush is hanging out with. David Grush says that he started seeking his Harmonialist gospel while he was in government. He was looking for these people. He found them. I look at them in my book. There's a whole collection of them, and so I cannot give them all equal time. But it's what you find is that all of them are doing the same thing. They're trying to bring science and religion into harmony, The occult gets in there somewhere every single time,
no matter what they're doing.
SPEAKER_01And, you know, this is related to Skinwalker Ranch. Skinwalker Ranch on the History Channel, that whole thing, it was owned by Brandon Fugel. He still owns the ranch. And he bought it from Robert Bigelow, who's one of these big philanthropists in ufology. In this particular movement, like Leslie Keen has basically been paid by this man to judge papers and things like that. So there is a small world that David Grush found, and he met all these people,
SPEAKER_01and many of them are sitting behind him in pictures of his testimony. And the two men on either side of him are people that were found by this group of people that he had found to be there at the table with him. So the whole story of how we got the hearings in 2023 and the one big hearing where David Grush says non-human biologics, right? But everything is hearsay.
SPEAKER_01But he says this exciting phrase, non-human biologics. I'm going to do that again. Non-human biologics. It's three. Do you know anything about Star Trek writing? And the rule of threes Everything happens in threes? Yeah, you want to use three words for something, right? Warp speed regulator Right?
SPEAKER_00Okay, yeah It's a writing rule in science fiction Non-human biologics We got three Yeah,
SPEAKER_01so it was sus immediately Of note When there were hearings again in 2024, hardly anybody showed up. Because it was the same thing of, I heard from another guy who heard from another guy.
SPEAKER_00Can we talk to the guy you heard it from? No. So this... Great sensational thing led up to great expectations, and then it didn't meet expectations.
SPEAKER_01That's a thing in harmonialism. It always disappoints expectations somewhere. The great disappointment. The great disappointment. It creates disappointments. So lo and behold, December of 2023, hardly anybody saw it. And they waited months to drop the video. David Grush is not speaking to Congress. He's speaking to the Soul Foundation, which is a bunch of scientists led by Avi Loeb who desperately want to believe in aliens and their ideas absolutely line up with harmonialism.
SPEAKER_01It's spirituality plus science. And in his keynote address, David Grush was expressly spiritual. He was speaking from a harmonious gospel about how the world-altering events of disclosure will change the way we think about each other, about everything, and then we'll fly around the universe in our spaceships.
SPEAKER_00Yep. And that's where a lot of the aliens or demons people are coming from, saying, look at this group that's trying to replace Christianity. That's their point. And that's built in, too, because the Luciferian Black Lodge has always sort of existed, right?
SPEAKER_01Like the Sith, okay? There's always like this element in Harmonialism of, oh, there are a bunch of evil people out there doing secret evil stuff, hiding in the shadows, being evil. That's always been present. But yes, the thing that struck me was how the spiritual side of David Grush got no attention non-human biologics the Star Trek side of David Grush got all the attention but there was this great disappointment right and it happens again and again and again
every time there's a release of UFO stuff people are like no that's a balloon that's Chinese fire lantern sort of thing the latest video of the orbs right and I don't know if you've
SPEAKER_01seen but there are Basically, what's happened is that tech bros took the quadcopter drone and they said, that looks really cool racing that around. I want to put a chair in it and fly it around. And they built them. And so they have basically flying cars and people are seeing those sometimes and be like, whoa, who is that? Right. So, you know, again, it's a technology story. It's a constant challenge of science constantly coming along
and revising our understanding of the universe so that the old stories are not any good anymore.
SPEAKER_01And the only stories that can be good have to be timeless. They have to take place in a galaxy far, far away. Disclosure Day, I don't know if you've seen it.
SPEAKER_00I haven't yet, but both people sort of into UFOs, against UFOs, and just General Spielberg fans that I know, all those who've seen it, have been disappointed by it.
SPEAKER_01Well, I won't deny their disappointment. I will say that I was personally, me personally, was not disappointed because everything was there that I was expecting. So I was like, you know, an anthropologist like, oh, yeah. Jackpot. Jackpot, exactly. So from my own particular perspective, you know, it was great, but bad film. I will say this. It manages to hold together consistently without coming apart
at the seams.
SPEAKER_01That's about the best thing I can say. John Williams, his score is probably one of his weakest efforts ever. But without that score, the movie would suck. So it's a bad score and the movie would be even worse without it. That's the kind of thing, the kind of notes that I have about the movie itself that I will discuss in my review. But the top line that I have is that the problems with the movie or the story,
SPEAKER_01as it's told in this movie, the disclosure, those problems are from the Harmonialist current. That is the Harmonialist story and the weakness of the Harmonialist story. It keeps happening that way. First of all, spoiler alert, the aliens are basically greys. They're a little different. They're a bit more ET-like than greys, but the point is that they don't look very new, okay? They don't strike me as very realistic, actually.
And the alien autopsy bits, actually, I kept expecting Jonathan Frakes to break in. That would have been pretty good But the point is that it felt dated And I've seen
SPEAKER_01other people mention this That the story feels tired out right that that's a weakness of this whole bricolage as it's called this creative mashup that starts with not starts with Spielberg but you know you can see Spielberg as one of the most important characters in this story is that he's a bricoleur a person who's recycling the story and he has close encounters right that's one version of the story and by the way
SPEAKER_01You've seen Close Encounters and you remember the final scene.
SPEAKER_00It's full of sound. Sounds and colors.
SPEAKER_01Like Theosophy has the seven rays and the sounds of the universe. Yeah, see, it's all Theosophy. Yeah, and I just want to add one of the people he had assisting him, Jacques Vallée, who was...
SPEAKER_00the French character in the movie was modeled after is active, self-emitted, Rosicrucian and he's the one who really popularized the idea of instead of them being extraterrestrials interdimensional beings he thought they were and that fits more into his Rosicrucian beliefs
SPEAKER_01And that's in my book, is that this is an evolution of the story, and that's what Harmonialism is doing. It's remixing the story, rehashing the story, recreating the story. And the problem with Steven Spielberg's new film is that it's retelling a story we
SPEAKER_00know too well.
SPEAKER_01And then it gets to the end. I'm not going to spoil anything because we don't get the spoilers. is that this message gets passed to our psychic Emily Bates character, the TV anchor woman, because the media is the hero in this story. She gets past this message and she looks into the camera and the whole world is watching her face as she says, listen. And then the movie ends.
SPEAKER_01What's happening here? we don't get the disclosure of the message because the message is boring if you read George Adamski the books that he wrote are full of these just dime store theosophical ramblings that supposedly come from the mouths of the aliens like what the fuck sorry but these boring ass speeches that's what you're going to get after listen you're going to get
SPEAKER_01Some sort of profound fortune cookie type theosophy.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I guess that would take away from kind of the appeal that if it's just, hey, there's a great ascended master out there and we should be open to him... that can get people to be, oh, what does the Ascended Master, what is this belief? Let me search for it. But if it's just, hey guys, you burn too much carbon and just kind of be nice to each other, yo, that leads to a disappointment. Right, right.
SPEAKER_01You know, prophecy is always dangerous, right? When prophecies fail, they have to be explained away somehow. And the normal way that It gets explained away as, you people were so good with your worshipfulness of the cosmic harmony that you prevented this disaster. And you find that over and over again, for example, in the cult of Billy Meyer. We can talk, we could probably have a whole podcast about the cult of Billy Meyer. And your listeners are thinking, who is Billy Meyer?
SPEAKER_01If you remember the poster of from the wall of Fox Mulder's office in the FBI basement. That is his photograph. Billy Meyer took all of the greatest UFO photographs. There's a cold complaint in Jung about how nobody seems to be able to take a good photograph of a flying saucer. He took such, quote-unquote, good photographs that people were convinced they were real. But here's what's interesting,
SPEAKER_01and I recount this in my book, is if you go back and you watch the TV special that was made by the Genesis 3 project by Wendell Stevens and all those guys who popularized Billy Meyer's work in the United States, they replicate his method of using fishing lines. to hang a flying saucer in the sky, a model, and take pictures of it. They replicate this method, and then they are really disturbed at how good their photographs turn out. These are just as good as his photographs,
so they have to come up with a way to explain it. And what they do is they use a computer, because it's 1983 and computers are magic.
SPEAKER_00Yep. Shall we ask the computer?
SPEAKER_01Nobody in America knows what a pixel is. So when a guy who has no expertise in digital forensics gets up and says, yes, you can see from these pixels that this and this and this, it's charlentry, right? It's a magic act. Sooner or later, it always ends up as a magic act. Sooner or later, the magic box is empty. That's the problem for Harmonialism is that the magic boxes are eventually exposed as empty. And what the Disclosure Cult is going through these days is the
problem that Arrow
SPEAKER_01and Dr. Sean Kirkpatrick thoroughly investigated everything they possibly could. They didn't find any missing government compartments. They didn't find any giant Steven Spielberg, George Lucas Warehouse with the missing Ark in it. They didn't find any of that stuff. And it turns out that David Grush was demanding access to programs that don't exist. And there are a few reasons why this happened. I discussed them in my book. Part of it is that this has been an in-joke.
SPEAKER_01This has been a form of hazing in the military for decades. Blue Yankee, I think it was called. Yeah. So David Grush basically has this collection of hearsay And he's asking for permission to access programs that don't exist. He's denied access to programs that don't exist. And he's like, cover up! And lately, we've also been seeing this whole list of supposed scientists. It's supposed to be 14 or 15 now scientists. Scientists.
SPEAKER_01That word does so much heavy lifting. Scientists who've disappeared, who were supposedly involved in UFO research, but actually know Very few of these people were involved in anything that could be called UFO research and almost all of these deaths and disappearances have been explained. There was the unfortunate case of the woman who took her life in the desert and they just found her body. So, you know, this is not unearthly. It's not mysterious.
SPEAKER_01It's people seeing false patterns. Why are they seeing those false patterns, though? It's because The mystery box is empty. There's no hidden chamber with the flying saucer in it, and they are dealing with that disconfirmation. How do you deal with that disconfirmation? Through denial. You say, the truth is being covered up. The story now is that they're interdimensional, that the evidence was given to corporate entities in the 60s or something,
SPEAKER_01so now the truth has been outsourced.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's amazing because it's a real radicalization, too, that the tempo is speeding up, the stakes are speeding up. Meanwhile, you have people who were in the camp, I would say, of UFOs, Stephen Greenstreet, Nick Pope, who recently passed away, who were calling this out saying, hey, guys, you're just doubling down on things. This isn't the serious study we want. and they became almost anathema.
SPEAKER_00Steve Greenstreet has completely broken away. Nick Pope, before he died, wrote for Skeptic Magazine basically saying, hey, this disclosure movement is probably the last breath of an alien cover-up idea just because of the craziness of it all.
SPEAKER_01Yes, yes. And see, that again goes to the Harmonialist story has now worn itself out. It's worn out its energy, and that's the problem with Disclosure Day. If this movie had come out in 1985, it would be seen as a landmark film, perhaps. But it is coming out now, and our expectations are much higher. And we've had too many disappointments with David Grush, with Disclosure.
and you know the people I think who reject Disclosure Day hardest like I heard Nerdrotic you know who I love Nerdrotic but he was saying like you know the good stuff was withheld basically I've heard this from a couple of different influencers on YouTube Neon Clownfish TV is also like the good stuff is being withheld we're
SPEAKER_01not being shown the good stuff what if there is no good stuff That is the question my book poses, is that what if the good stuff is actually a belief? It's an article of belief. It's unfalsifiable. And so that's the spiritual biography of The Flying Saucer is this belief. Where does it come from? It has a history. And that's basically what I've done. I've told that story as a longue durée history. And as far as I can tell, this is the first time anyone has ever done that.
SPEAKER_00And on that note, you keep referencing the book. When is it coming out? You tell me. I am at the point where I am making the final little edits to perfect the book proposal.
SPEAKER_01Because the book proposal is what's going to sell the book. I do have in mind people to send it to. I have a marketing plan. Just not ready to pull that trigger just yet. But the book is together. You've read a chapter of it. and it's a whole consistent narrative so it's ready to go to someone as a book project I just haven't finished the proposal yet well let me know when it's good to go and I'll help promote it where can people go to read about
you your works and
SPEAKER_00things like that
SPEAKER_01Well, you can find my writing on these topics at osborneink.com Osborne, Inc. is where I write about just about everything that isn't war. And then if you want to read my military history writing, you can go to polymology.net. Polymology is a scientific study of war. And I'll provide links to that as well, but continue, please.
SPEAKER_01crossover, or maybe not a surprising amount of crossover. And it keeps happening. For instance, Jung and Vallée both point to the Nuremberg pamphlet. We should talk about the Nuremberg pamphlet sometime. I can conclusively prove to you that the Nuremberg pamphlet is about the French wars of religion. It has nothing to do with flying saucers. If you know anything about conflict history, if you know about the wars of religion breaking out at that time. It makes perfect sense, but it does not make any sense as a story of flying saucers.
SPEAKER_01It does not. So, you know, it's just one example of the curious crossover. We talked about balloons, right? Weather balloons and the Foo Fighters. These curious crossovers that happen. I don't know if you're aware, but the U.S. spy balloon war against the Soviet Union continued for decades. And it was incredibly expensive for the Soviet Union trying to shoot down these balloons. And it is probably the origin of all the Soviet UFO stories, right?
SPEAKER_01They went to incredible lengths to try to stop these balloons. And that's all secret history. So suddenly a Chinese balloon shows up in the sky. Everybody loses their mind. But there's a secret history going back before Roswell, see? And nobody's ever told it.
SPEAKER_00So it's important to tell these stories. And as we found out that Chinese spy balloon that everybody obsessed about and led to the Great Freakout where we were using Sidewinder missiles against Boy Scout balloons over the Great Lakes, that wasn't the first Chinese balloon either that went over or near U.S. territory. And just for people's reference, the Nuremberg pamphlet, that's also known as the Nuremberg Chronicle, and that In it documents, I think,
SPEAKER_00about the 1560s, the strange orbs that were over Nuremberg, Germany, reportedly.
SPEAKER_01They're very clearly cannonballs.
SPEAKER_00This is the moment that artillery warfare was born. So, yeah, they're cannonballs. Yep, and as we talked before about cargo cults and things like that, people see things, it gets spun in the retellings, people sometimes even know what it literally is, but will put on that spiritual twist to be, this is the big emphasis to learn about.
SPEAKER_01Yes, you're right there.
SPEAKER_00That is the story of Harmonialism in a nutshell. And I just want to thank you so much for your time. This has... been one of my most enjoyable conversations. We can talk anytime Patrick, it's been fun. Yeah, this is a pleasure, have a great one.
What happens when a lay Catholics, a Protestant with a pastoral background, and an Orthodox priest and a layman get together? They talk about C.S. Lewis, Narnia, the Space Trilogy, and how Lewis has influenced them. Go...
Science fiction authors Patrick Abbott and Schalk Holloway make their own worlds, sometimes with apocalypse for the sake of enjoyable fiction. Yet these two Christians, one a lay Catholic American and the other who...
In our conversation, Sister Allison Regina Gilot discusses her life as a nun who is an author of vampire fiction. She describes the importance of integrating Catholic themes into her stories. We discuss her writing...
I was able to interview Eric Sammons, long time Editor-in-Chief of the Catholic Crisis Magazine and now a science fiction writer. His first sci-fi piece, Shard of Eden, is out now. Get full access to Patrick Abbott,...