What happens when a lay Catholics, a Protestant with a pastoral background, and an Orthodox priest and a layman get together? They talk about C.S. Lewis, Narnia, the Space Trilogy, and how Lewis has influenced them. Go beyond the talk of Netflix’s adaptation of The Magician's Nephew with this panel that pushes through the wardrobe. Here’s what you can expect The panel includes Stuart D. Brooks of Sowing Wonder. He’s an Orthodox layman and currently writing a fantasy trilogy. John Paul Hare of Ruminations and Reflections. He’s a Catholic layman and has written essays about C.S. Lewis’ work as well as other things. Eric M. Hamilton of Pyrite Dreams. He’s a Protestant who was a pastor and is a published author. Father Justin of Geek Orthodox. Father Justin is an Orthodox priest and self-described geek who is also a published poet. Patrick Abbott of Patrick Abbott, Sci-fi Author (me, real original name for a Substack, eh?). Patrick is a Catholic who writes science fiction and humorous urban fantasy as well as objective non-fiction investigating sci-fi related topics. Get full access to Patrick Abbott, Sci-fi Author at www.patrickabbott.net/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Hello, I'm Patrick Abbott. I'm a Sci-Fi Author at patrickabbott.net, and today we have a panel talking about C.S. Lewis and Narnia. A little bit about myself. I'm an amateur writer. I've written some books, including The Follower, I'm a huge fan of C.S. Lewis, his messages, his morals, and the great stories that he has told in fiction.
SPEAKER_01And I wanted to get together a great panel of people to discuss Lewis, their impact or Lewis's impact on them, as well as some of the stories Lewis has told and what they want to focus on about Lewis. So enough about me. I want to introduce some of the other people where they'll talk about themselves briefly and also tell us why this conversation is going to be interesting. Eric, can you kick us off? Sure. So I am Eric M. Hamilton. I am an author.
SPEAKER_01I've written a few different books, mostly in the alternate history variation, but I am working on a fairy tale. And yeah, C.S. Lewis. I'm sure we'll talk about it more, but C.S. Lewis has had a profound effect on my life and my spiritual journey and also my writing journey.
SPEAKER_01So I'm very much looking forward to talking about C.S. Lewis with everyone.
SPEAKER_00Thank you. Stuart, do you want to introduce yourself now? Hello, of course. My name is Stuart. I love... Beauty and poetry and I love art and whatnot. I run a Substack called Sewing Wonder. It's all about trying to remind us how wonderful reality really is and that being ultimately connected to God and what he's given us and how ordered the world is. I'm specifically in love with nature and story.
SPEAKER_00And those are two things which I see God showing himself in, in a very woven, tapestry-like way. I'm an Orthodox Christian, just a layman, but here I am. Thank you for joining us.
SPEAKER_01John Paul, how about yourself?
SPEAKER_03My name is John Paul Hare. I run a small Substack called Ruminations and Reflections. I've done a little bit of writing there just on some different aspects of Catholic life, some reflections on friendship and I've also delved into a little bit of writing also inspired by Lewis, similar to Eric there, drawing on his unfinished C.S. Lewis first semester as one of my electives.
SPEAKER_03In my junior year, my senior year of college, excuse me. And that was a thoroughly enjoyable course, especially after growing up, having Lewis read to me by my mother at first and then going on and reading him myself as I got older. So he means, his writing means a lot to me. It's definitely helped me develop my philosophy. Faith life and has had a profound impact on how I see and relate to our Lord.
SPEAKER_02Thank you. And Father Justin? I'm Father Justin. I'm an Orthodox Christian priest. I run a small Substack called Geek Orthodox, where I reflect on how my tagline is the geeks have inherited the earth. The geek subculture has kind of taken over the world for better and for worse. And so I want to kind of reflect on that. Yeah, C.S. Lewis is huge for me. I would say that the two writings that kept me Christian as I was starting to come into my own and think about what I actually believed were probably the Gospel
SPEAKER_02of John and C.S. Lewis' Mere Christianity. And then I I love the Narnian Chronicles. I love the Sci-Fi Trilogy. I've read most of it. There's a few of his scholarly works that I haven't managed to finish yet. And I often say that while Lewis didn't make me orthodox, he made it possible for me to Partly because he did such a great job of rooting and grounding himself in that common Christian tradition that is a part of all of our heritage.
SPEAKER_01Agreed. And just having this panel of Catholics, Orthodox, and Protestants on together, we got a good trifecta going on so we can explore it from all angles. And I want to kick things off. The thing that really brought us together, or at least gave me the idea to give this call out, was Netflix interpretation of Narnia and just what we've seen about it isn't really positive for us as C.S. Lewis fans. So I want to throw this question out for anybody who wants it. And then once you're done,
SPEAKER_01other people can jump on and add their own thoughts or address what you say. What about Narnia sticks with us and what makes us
SPEAKER_00so passionate about these tales? I think I've got an answer for that, or at least my answer for that. What about C.S. Lewis sticks with us? When I read Narnia, it doesn't cause me to escape from this world in the normal sense. It's more like it causes me to escape deeper into this world, not all the way to another one. You go to Narnia. But you find that Narnia is like where we are in certain ways.
SPEAKER_00It's not a place that you go to leave this world, but you come back to the world after going to this marvelous place and you look around and you think, well, it's all just about as marvelous as the stuff that I just read. And it brightens the inner life to an appropriate degree, not as though to... You know, convince us that Christianity is cool or but to to kind of grow up inside of us the reality that it actually is that this other world is something that we're participating in in a in a very strange way and a wonderful way.
SPEAKER_00I'd say I could go on, but I think I think that's what I've got to say for now.
SPEAKER_01So, Patrick, I've been thinking about this and and maybe some other people can because I've seen like specifically related to like the Netflix adaptation. Some people will say, oh, well, it's just a fantasy book. And, you know, when you make an adaptation, And I think maybe in part, and this might get to kind of what Stuart's talking about, is that there's something that's underlying the Narnia that's more than just a fun fantasy.
SPEAKER_01And I think that that might all be rooted in that it's not really fantasy, it's a fairy tale, as Lewis like sets out and says that it is. And one of the things, and I think maybe this is also an Another thing is that the older I get, the more like C.S. Lewis kind of implies, the more I appreciate fairy tales, because I think that is the fairy tales, even though they're fantastic and they're a world that's different than our own, they're meant to tell us something.
SPEAKER_01They're meant to warn us. They're meant to make us notice things. And that is like the big thing about Narnia and Aslan, but also all the other things that are in Narnia. Narnia maps onto the world, the real world as it is, then you become more appreciative of it. And I think maybe that's why when changes are made, Right.
SPEAKER_01I'll just quickly jump in before other people pick it up. I think you're right, because a lot of times people don't understand that fairy tale quote, that we as a society have lost the understanding of fairy tales and fantasies being different, the importance of morals. And that in early Christendom and early Christianity, you had what could be described almost as fairy tales, St. Brendan and the Mermaid. In one sense, it was true, the morals behind it.
SPEAKER_01Or St. Jerome talking about St. Anthony in the desert and his encounter with mythological creatures. It all points back to Christ and that the story itself is important. And that if we try to explain it away or just make it a different story, we lose that point.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I'm currently writing a piece in my Substack about that's kind of diving into some of what Stuart and Eric just said, where Lewis is deliberately writing in a not only fairy tale, but in a kind of medieval register. That comes out most in Prince Caspian, of course, but he and Tolkien essentially established the modern genre of fantasy and did so hearkening back to the Middle Ages for a reason. It was at that point,
SPEAKER_02or at that point, there was an integration between faith and the real world, so to speak, that got disrupted by the rise of modern science and by this scientific materialization. They were both instincts of ours to control things. So we can control the world through some sort of technique or methodology combined
SPEAKER_02with our understanding of the world. But there was no assumption that there was, okay, there's the material world and that's safe and there's the supernatural world and that's unsafe. No, it was like the understanding was the medieval. And one of the concerns I think that we have when people just decide to use Right on, yeah.
SPEAKER_01And John Paul, I wanted to give you the option if you wanted to answer the question too.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so I kind of looked at it a little bit, similar vein, but perhaps a slightly different perspective. I think for me, growing up with the Chronicles of Narnia, it resonated because we were, you know, we were children. My brothers and I, when we listened to it, when our mother read it to us, And so we got to hear and walk through these stories with children who were our age. And we grew up in different times, of course, but we were able to relate to children from our world who went on to this fantastic fairy tale adventure.
SPEAKER_03But underlying all of that is this... This great mystery of faith, of belief, and it resonated deeply. It helped us really come to terms with this exists in our world. And I think you hear that especially at the end of Prince Caspian. You've learned about me here in this world, and now it's time that you come to know me by another name in yours. And so that realization, even as a boy hearing that, it's like, this is what Lewis meant. And to have all of that mystery, that wonder taken away or dulled in a sense,
SPEAKER_03it really diminishes the story and it actually takes away a lot of what his whole idea was, which is encapsulated in that one quote. I think to go out from these books, from this fairy tale that you've entered into and to Learn to know Aslan by the name that he has in this world. That's how I see it anyway.
SPEAKER_00Thank you. Stuart, do you want to say anything? Yeah, he was just giving me thoughts, you know, by speaking. Yeah, Lewis seems to do that intentionally in the books. He's weaving it in there to recall the reader himself. Through Narnia back into the real world, but the real, real world, not the one that we've assumed that we've got understood, you know, we've seen all of it, but the strange world that we're actually living in and one
SPEAKER_00which ultimately reflects the beauty and the highest things in Narnia. It's impossible not to see Jesus in Aslan. Absolutely.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that was also, John Paul said something, is like, to really get Narnia, you know, Jesus Christ is everywhere in those books. And it really is, they are stories about Jesus and God. And that is also another, I've seen a quote by the director of this new Narnia. She's like, I don't, I can't remember exactly what it was, but it's something like, I don't really, I think Jesus is creepy or something.
SPEAKER_01I can't remember exactly what she said.
SPEAKER_03People who, she said something along the lines, I'm sorry to cut you off, people along the lines of her who say, you know, Jesus Christ is my Lord and Savior. She finds that specific sentiment creepy and off-putting.
SPEAKER_01Right, yeah, but that's, yeah, that's exactly, yeah, that's the exact quote I was thinking about, but that is Narnia, right? Like, that is who C.S. Lewis was, that is the story that he's telling, and so it sounds like somebody who absolutely doesn't even understand what Narnia is, and I think it's just, like, you can't, You can't tell Narnia and take out Jesus Christ and still have Narnia.
SPEAKER_03You can't tell the Bible and take out Jesus and still have the Bible. The analogy there is so strong. And there are people who kind of belittle Lewis. Yeah. We become cynical and jaded and we lose that sense of wonder
SPEAKER_03unless there's something that comes along that helps us kind of regain some of it. But to take that away, to have that wonder and to say, no, what you're seeing, what your imagination is creating for you as Lewis is putting these words on the page, none of that matters because it's not really Jesus. That's wrong. That's not what he intended at all.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's interesting. I'm sorry if I'm taking a little much, but there was one more thing I was thinking about because, John Paul, you said you came to Narnia as a child. I didn't read the Chronicles of Narnia until I was in my 20s. I had taken a fantasy lesson. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01In the Narnia books that was so comforting to me as an adult and helped me like think about ways in which to understand like some of these actually really very big concepts that we struggle. Absolutely. It reminds me of what Lewis actually wrote to Lucy. I think, was it his niece? Goddaughter. Goddaughter.
SPEAKER_00He wrote to her at the beginning of one of the books, you know, why am I blanking now? That's crazy. He wrote to her, someday you'll be old enough to read fairy tales again. I think we've, as a people in the modern world, we've kind of put a ceiling on what we think reality is. And it stops at the top of humanity. And that kind of boxes in our tales. And I hope that they're not doing that to see us to the Chronicles of Narnia. Because if you do this to it, it's...
SPEAKER_00It's meant to burst the seams. It's meant to go out into the very highest things. You're supposed to wander into Narnia or Tolkien's Middle Earth, and you're supposed to find reality there. It's an experience. There's something about, not necessarily what we call fantasy books now, because sometimes people just write whatever and think that that passes for it, but These books were so connected.
SPEAKER_00They had such an intuition and were given such a vision for what reality is that when they made something up in the sort of tradition of myth-telling, of fairy tales, that their fairy tales can actually kind of lead you home. You can go in there and find reality there. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Very well put, and I want to thank everybody for answering that question. Now shifting gears to a little bit more of a sci-fi, but still grounded in reality, is that the space trilogy of Out of Silent Planet, Palandria, and That Hideous Strength have been getting some buzz in social media lately. Not nearly as much as Netflix Narnia, but people have been talking about it, especially That Hideous Strength. What about the series of three different books has value for us today?
SPEAKER_03I wrote a paper, and this is how I ended up on this panel in the first place, was referencing this very paper in high school. So we're talking 12 years ago or so. The space trilogy and specifically about how the meaning of Elwyn Ransom's name changes, evolves throughout the course of those three books. The prompt for the paper essentially said there's a Trinitarian aspect to his name, to how his character is portrayed.
SPEAKER_03And when you read the books through that lens, you see this very paternal sense come out in Out of the Silent Planet. You see this filial... You really see the sun in Paralandra, and you see the Holy Spirit in his behind-the-scenes seemingly passive, but in reality very active in a hidden way characterization. You see the Holy Spirit there, and it's... And so his...
SPEAKER_03Each characterization is his way of being the instrument of God, so to speak, in Lewis's kind of portrayal, if you will. It's a very rich, vibrant tapestry that he weaves throughout those books, especially Perilandra with how vibrant the colors are as I imagined them when I was reading it. But I see specifically in Hideous Strength, you know, a great, what's the word, similarity to the times that we're living in right now. There's a lot of interesting parallels there that I found even 12 years ago when all
SPEAKER_03of the technology that we have around us today that permeates our daily lives was only... Just beginning to be talked about even. I saw parallels there with the Institute making its machine-man amalgam. They were trying to animate that man's head in that lab. Very much to me at the time, it screamed artificial intelligence. And even more so today, I think we see that even more as we're talking about making AI very much...
SPEAKER_03Personal, relational, all these things that they're trying to do, especially with the growth of AI chatbot friends, partners, so to speak. Lewis saw it 70 years ago, 80 years ago, but he didn't have the language to actually describe what he foresaw at the time because computer technology was in its infancy at the time. So it's very much to me, it speaks specifically hideous strength. As I said, it's very much parallels what we see today.
SPEAKER_02You could easily take some of Elon Musk's rationales for colonizing Mars and, you know, map them onto what Dr. Weston says out of the silent planet. It's like, it's actually a kind of uncanny. It's like, wait, was he cribbing from that? He very well may have been. Who knows? Yeah, yeah. And then, of course, the whole transhumanist agenda, which has come into the fore in our modern days. Yeah, it's very much, I mean, I kept thinking about which one is it?
SPEAKER_02One The characters describing this society on the far side of the moon, the dark side of the moon, where they've basically eschewed any kind of biology because biology is kind of icky. Yeah. The macrobes, I think they're called. Is that it? Or the great life? Yeah, very relevant in so many respects. And I really, really, really hope and pray that nobody even tries to ever film Perilandra because you cannot capture the beauty of innocence that Lewis actually manages
SPEAKER_02to capture in that book. I don't think you could capture that visually. We just wouldn't translate onto the screen.
SPEAKER_03No, I think it would be cause for near occasion of sin at minimum to try to capture that. I think just because of how Lewis envisions it and how we're encouraged to envision it ourselves. But it's, as you said, it's this perfect innocence. And I don't know how he did it. I know.
SPEAKER_00It's magical. It really is. Yeah. What affected me most about Paralandra was the... The way that he frames what we call spiritual warfare, I at the time was, I mean, I think we experience it all the time, but I don't think I was even like really aware of the effects of That were in my life. But there's something about how, you know, I forget which character, I think it's C.S. Lewis himself who's trying to go to Dr.
SPEAKER_00Ransom's house right at the beginning of Paralandra. And, you know, even the road there, there's something that's like spooking him, trying to make him feel like turning back. Maybe I shouldn't go ask for advice. I forget what it was he was doing even. He was going to ask for advice or talk to him, a friend, and everything about the aesthetic and the experience. And when he finally arrives at Dr. Ransom's house, Dr. Ransom says, I knew they would try to prevent you from getting here, but...
SPEAKER_00I kind of knew that you would make it anyway. And so that sort of, that unfolds throughout the rest of the story because there's this malevolent force that possesses, right, Weston? That's right, yeah, Weston. And at a certain point. And just the... That fear that comes onto Dr. Ransom at a certain point near the climax, like there's a moment where it strikes fear into him through this creature that's nearby.
SPEAKER_00It's kind of a complicated book to describe, isn't it?
SPEAKER_02I find it fascinating that the resolution of that spiritual warfare is a fistfight.
SPEAKER_00It is. He decides to punch, well, he chases after Weston because it's like... The guy's experimenting on the frogs, he's gone completely psychopath mode, and in fact he's trying to, not coerce, but battering and arguing Eve into going and setting foot on the island, which is the equivalent of taking the fruit, right? Where it's like Ransom realizes it's like I'm essentially in the Garden of Eden
SPEAKER_00and this serpent is trying to do what it did to Earth and my arguments aren't working. This thing is smarter than I am. I think I just got to go kill this. It's such a crazy thing. He chases him through water and everything and batters him. And then it tries that last tactic, this getting in his mind and striking fear into his mind. And he says, no way. Like he realizes you're trying, you're messing with my head to make me afraid.
SPEAKER_00And it's using something that's not even actually, it's a creature that's, Unfamiliar to Ransom. And so there's a reason to be afraid of it, sort of. But it's not actually dangerous. But it is like messing with his mind to make him view it in this terrifying way. And it's the same thing as like Lewis walked to Dr. Ransom's in the beginning. Just this... And it just illustrated it so perfectly for me, this concept of the fiery darts, which we are always under fire from.
SPEAKER_00I refer to Ephesians 6, where the enemy lobs fiery darts at us. And, well, we have a shield of faith, but you kind of got to raise a shield. You got to realize that No, I can't just give in to these thoughts, these thoughts and these feelings that come over me. They can't be allowed to stay. There's like a fisticuffs that it has to come to where it's like, no, you can't be here.
SPEAKER_00To be so afraid, that is not in accordance with what I believe at the bottom of it. And so shield of faith, what do I believe? And fight it. And yeah, that truly changed my life more than most books I've ever read. In fact, Paralandra did. I read Screwtape Letters before and that one didn't do it for some reason. But Paralandra, it just, you know, it's, yeah, changed my life.
SPEAKER_01I agree with your estimation of Paralandra. I just actually read the trilogy last year. So that's also like, One of the things I feel like I came to it late, but I also like that's I feel I saw a lot of the things like I really agree with everyone here about like the idea that these books are about spiritual warfare and especially in our day and age of the scientific age of the modern age,
SPEAKER_01like especially where like so many of the villains You know, they dabble, especially that it happens in that hideous strength. They at once will basically like dismiss spiritual things, but then they're also engaged in malevolent spiritual things at the same time, which I think is like it is the this just basically the the Paralandra was a revelation to me in reading that. And part of because, and that's the one, I still think you should read all of them, but Paralandra was so, it put the central element
SPEAKER_01Problem of sin, as you said, it's basically a retelling of the Garden of Eden, but it makes it like, I don't know, you know, how many times do we read through Genesis 3 and it's like, okay, I know the story. Let's just keep going. And even people who don't care about the Bible, everything, they know that story. And it's a weird story and it doesn't really make sense to us. But then C.S. Lewis has this way of not only making it like so captivating. But then describing it as like, this is the most important event ever.
SPEAKER_01This is the place where on the planet of Venus, where it could go the way that it goes on Earth, that did on Earth, or it could not. And you become so invested. It is like, even though I know the story in Genesis, I become so invested in it. I'm
SPEAKER_01having a hard time bringing words to it, but it is this like, I had new appreciation for the book of Genesis after reading Paralandra. And I also feel like moments of Job as well, the kind of suffering that Ransom goes through in Paralandra, like There's so much Bible-infused in these books, but it's so well-hidden. It's hidden for those who don't really know their Bible very well,
SPEAKER_01but for somebody who does, it is really mind-opening.
SPEAKER_02It's interesting in C.S. Lewis' letters when he's reflecting on the reception of Out of the Silent Planet. He was actually surprised at how few people got the religious references in it. It was kind of at that point that he realizes, hey, wait, I can smuggle in quite a bit of theology without people actually realizing it. Yeah, I love Parallelander. It's C.S. Lewis rewriting Paradise Lost while channeling his mentor, George MacDonald. It's absolutely brilliant.
SPEAKER_03I wonder if well-hidden isn't so much the word as well-integrated. I think that might be a better term for what we're talking about. It's so intertwined with the fantasy, the fairy tale, that it becomes integrated. Which is what we're called. We're called to become integrated. That's our ultimate goal is full integration with Christ. And obviously we won't attain that in this life. We hope and pray that we shall in the next and we shall live well enough in this life that we shall be able to be integrated in the next.
SPEAKER_03But I think Lewis certainly achieved something closer to that in his writing than perhaps most other authors ever could, certainly in this vein.
SPEAKER_01It's definitely something you don't see in much modern Christian fiction, that a lot of times the criticism is right. It's just so overbearing, so placid over that the story is really a setup for a sermon, where in Tolkien or Lewis, it is so well integrated. Almost to the point where you don't have to believe to enjoy it, but it's also kind of a backdoor way to get those moral messages in as well.
SPEAKER_02And if I may just insert one more thing from the same series of letters, he actually writes to Tolkien, he says, It looks like we're going to have to write the kinds of stories that we enjoy because nobody's writing them. That's actually what gives rise to this. They just wanted to write the kind of stories that they really enjoyed. I think is one of the reasons why it's not a pamphlet. It's not a tract. It's great literature.
SPEAKER_01And that's what got me into writing as well. And I think, Eric, you shared the same story with yourself that we wanted stories that weren't just What's something about C.S. Lewis' work that has you particularly focus on? And how have you expressed that, whether through fiction, nonfiction, sermons, essays, open floor? I'm particularly fascinated with how he connects with
SPEAKER_00True myth, or the concept of true myth, that all the stories are in some sense reflecting the main story. That's been massive for me, and that has a way of making my world feel more like a woven tapestry. My internal world, and then if I create outside of that, then maybe my external world, if God would bless it. I'm also writing a fantasy story, and I've spent a lot of time, like,
SPEAKER_00I have I have some favorite podcasts, you know, Great Tales podcasts, and I read a lot of, we all read a lot of this stuff, it seems like. The old stories, the Odyssey, and all those things. And this concept of a descent into Hades, and a rise from it, and how Christ is the perfect instantiation of that. Where these other men, or... Orpheus, all these people who descended into Hades and Rose.
SPEAKER_00They don't do so in such a way which even offers the concept or even offers salvation. It's a shadow of a more complete picture, which would be Christ descending and destroying Hades, setting the captives free. And C.S. Lewis seems to see Jesus. He talks about it. He says he's like history. He's like the myths, but there's nothing just like him.
SPEAKER_00It's almost like he's all of it. He's the center of all of it and the perfection of all of it. And yeah, that's one thing about C.S. Lewis that has impacted me a lot is his view of the world and of God and how he interacts with story. And places Jesus as the true myth. Yeah, that's one thing I'm in love with.
SPEAKER_01So I could, I'll just really quickly, a lot of my writing is silly and satire is a big amount of what I write. And I think sometimes when I tell people this, they don't quite believe it. But everything that I write, I start with, I try to start with some kind of truth and ground it in a biblical truth, even if I'm going to be making fun of something or writing something that somebody would say is, I think there's legitimacy to pure enjoyment as well.
SPEAKER_01But I think what we've been talking about, the truth, I try to have what I write reflect some kind of truth. And also, even if nobody else sees it, but I know it is there, that's important to me. And actually, I think it helps me in the creative process, because it helps me also feel like, why am I even writing the thing that I'm writing? Because if I can say, well, it's reflecting some kind of truth now.
SPEAKER_01Even if it's a small truth, it makes it valuable. And so that's something that I think I, at least in part, get from C.S. Lewis.
SPEAKER_00As a writer of fantasy, I mean, you write sci-fi, Patrick and Eric, and maybe others of us write things along those lines. But there, I don't know how to describe it, but there's It comes from somewhere. And I believe the purpose is similar. If we are to do it ourselves, the purpose is similar to what C.S. Lewis has done. To make a door to a place which is a door to Christ.
SPEAKER_00Somewhere where you pass through it yourself. And in the writing process... To do it this more organic way which they experienced. C.S. Lewis would talk about when he was going to write the Chronicles of Narnia, the first image that popped into his head was a fawn with an umbrella with a lampstand in the middle of The woods, the snowy woods. And that picture grew in his mind like a seed.
SPEAKER_00And he just wanted to add to it and connect all these images that kept coming because he was going to a place and he was seeing the things himself. And that's the sort of literature which I think Tolkien and Lewis were... Or writing where it's not just trying to pull something out of the head and make something up, but it's a sort of collaboration and a collaboration with God because the writer is going to a place. They've never been there either.
SPEAKER_00In the imagination, they're going to a place and they're seeing these characters and in some sense it's happening to them just as much as it's happening through them. And I don't know if I've gone off track from the question, but I just got wrapped up in the beauty of it. And we can go there and then by our going there, then other people can... And it's such a remarkable thing that we sometimes might take for granted.
SPEAKER_00It is a sort of magical thing. It's as if that world really is a place and really has things which are of great use to us.
SPEAKER_02I could go on. There's so many different things that I am indebted to C.S. Lewis for and that I love. But on that note, I would say it's fascinating to me that both Lewis and Tolkien eschew allegory. John Bunyan's Pilgrim's Progress is a brilliant work for, you know, what it is, but it's that one-to-one correspondence is where
SPEAKER_02The world that's being portrayed is absolutely subservient to the world of ideas and only there to portray that world of ideas. Whereas Lewis and Tolkien are world building. They're building ideas. And ushering us into an entire world. And in many respects, it's much more similar to one of Lewis's favorite works, The Fairy Queen by Edmund Spencer, where the world is very clearly allegorical, but it has a reality.
SPEAKER_02So even as the Red Cross Knight, who represents St. George, who represents England, who represents Protestantism, is fighting against this dragon who's spewing papal bulls at him, it's still a fight between a knight and a dragon. So the world itself has a reality to it that Lewis and Tolkien, as I say, are ushering us into in their worlds. And so they want to kind of avoid just a simplistic one-to-one correspondence, but they want us Yeah.
SPEAKER_02We think we already know. We know all about Jesus. We know all about reality. But it's being presented in a way that's unfamiliar to us and at the same time inspires wonder and reinvigorates that wonder. And so it's, yeah, it's just, I think it's that sub-creative process, as Tolkien described it, is something that is given to us by God as we were made in his image.
SPEAKER_02That ability to create, that ability to interact with the world in a way that we alone see and then can somehow share with others imaginatively. And yeah, anyway, so that to me is like, if there's one thing that has been amazing. The major arc in terms of my own engagement and love of Lewis and Tolkien, for that matter, it's that foundation of modern fantasy, which is more than just escapism. It's showing you the world that you're in in a way that illumines the real world.
SPEAKER_02And when you step out your door and see the trees, you see, ah, there's an end. Or there's the dance of the trees around Aslan.
SPEAKER_03John Paul, did you want to add anything or are you good? I was just thinking about how we've been talking about this creating with idea and we're creating under and we really function, especially as writers, whether we're writing fiction or nonfiction. The idea of the seed being planted is evocative. We're co-creators with God. He's given us this idea. He's planted within us the seed of, you know, What about this? And we get to then explore that idea and build that.
SPEAKER_03And even I think Lewis actually describes it in The Magician's Nephew and the creation of Narnia. You see very clearly it's similar to the tapestry he weaves in Perilandra. This development of this blank canvas that essentially that that. Narnia is at first. And as Aslan begins and then continues his song of creation, the world grows. It blossoms before our eyes. And you see this incredibly beautiful, rich canvas unfold before you as a reader.
SPEAKER_03And I'd love to know I think that would just be—and I think, though, at the same time, if we're engaging in writing ourselves or in some other form of art, whether that be writing music or, you know, performance of some sort or painting or anything along Very well put. And it also sets up the next question.
SPEAKER_01Which is the second to last question. So you mentioned co-creators, the seed. Well, how has C.S. Lewis been a seed for you with creation, whether you're nonfiction or fiction? Tell us about a story you wrote or a writing or a sermon or just an essay you wrote. Give us a little synopsis of it. And I'll share one with mine of A C.S. Lewis-influenced tale, An Odd Pilgrimage, is about an old-believer Russian priest who,
SPEAKER_01through just being at the right or wrong place, but really right place at the right time, begins to time travel while he's searching for his son, and it's revealed to be a scientific experiment. And it's just that sort of, this is an adventure for a man who really is changed by that adventure. And I really had C.S. Lewis in mind, Narnia, and I want to say Out of Silent Planet, but the scientists weren't hostile. It's just something epic happens to you on a religious nature and it changes you.
SPEAKER_01And C.S. Lewis allowed me to explore that in a sci-fi mindset. I wouldn't have probably thought of it without him.
SPEAKER_00So I wanted to know what else you have done because of C.S. Lewis. I could go first. I was struck by John Paul when he mentioned the word joy. He rang some bells, right? He was surprised by joy, that concept. That technical term used by Lewis to refer to that spike of yearning that one gets when they really encounter something beautiful or something like a song that for
SPEAKER_00a second it makes you Feel like you have everything and then it flies away. And if you go back to the song, you don't necessarily find it there. But this song of a different world is coming through all the beautiful things which we experience. He talks a lot about that in The Weight of Glory as well. But that, I feel like... Experiencing that and hearing that from Lewis and then, you know, listening to and reading Tolkien's works and seeing it played out in a similar way,
SPEAKER_00this yearning and calling through light and beauty. That has really inspired me for my book. And I guess I should explain the core image of my book, like how Lewis experienced the fawn with the snow and the lamppost. I would drive to work Every day, eastward, crossing the river in Minneapolis. And there's this tower there, up on the horizon, peaking above the trees. And it's white and it's simple.
SPEAKER_00And it has a green roof that's kind of shaped like a, you know, they call it Witch's Hat Tower, but it's really Prospect Park Tower. It's just, they refer to it that way colloquially. But As I would drive towards it, it would be so beautiful and there on the horizon and something, a directing of yearning in some kind of way. But as you approach, you get too close and you pass under an overpass and the trees are too tall now and you can't see it anymore. And it gave me this idea of a tower that you see on the horizon.
SPEAKER_00And maybe the people around you don't even know it exists. Or maybe you ask them about it and they're like, yeah, I went out after it one time. But, you know, there's this experience that happens when you go out after it where you don't find it where it seems like it should be. You go out in the direction. You make sure your footsteps are all aligned. And then you get there and it's, where is it? And then you see it on another horizon where it's this sort of the kingdom of God.
SPEAKER_00Is near to us, it's at hand, it's in us, it's in our midst, but it's also just there. For me, just outside of reach, the fullness of my yearning goes out and it's, life is all grasping. I mean, for air, but, and surely something's actually taken hold of in the seeking of God. But that's this sort of journey that my book is the first of a trilogy.
SPEAKER_00It's called The Green Roofed Tower. It's not done yet, but I've been working on it for a long time. It takes place in a whole different world and different nations and gnomes and giants and fire and ice and all that good stuff. And yes, that's what I'm working on. And yeah, got about 27 chapters out of 33. I'm working on it. You're almost there.
SPEAKER_01Eric, how about you? What is Seed of Lewis with you? Well, you know, I was thinking about something else, but I'll talk about the book that, so I'm working on a children's fairy tale book that is inspired by a lot of different So it's called The Wrong Unicorn. And one of the things I was struck about
SPEAKER_01By the Narnia or one of the details of Narnia is, you know, the kids come into this world and they become kings and queens of Narnia. And I, I, I, and, and there, there's a whole bunch of reasons for that. And that, you know, that, that is perfectly fine in Narnia. But I was, I was thought about like, what if somebody went to a place like that and they, they thought that they were going to be king or queen, but then they, they're not. And I guess kind of like one of the one of the big thoughts of Scripture
SPEAKER_01that I think about in that is where John the Baptist says about Jesus that he must increase and I must decrease. And and so at least in part, that's that's where this this. Yeah. Maybe you thought you might have deserved it or at least for one part
SPEAKER_01of your life you had that high of being the top. And so that's at least that I'm working on. Hopefully eventually I'll finish it, but we'll see how it goes. But that's my Lewis-inspired book that I'm working on. The struggle is real.
SPEAKER_02Father or John Paul, how about yourself? Well, I guess I do a fair bit of apologetics in my work. And in that regard, I'm very much inspired by Lewis. All of my youthful attempts at being a fantasy author, which I actually documented in a Substack post, all of those were inspired by Lewis because when I grew up, I just wanted to be C.S. Lewis. But I guess in terms of actual output, literary output, I have finally finished my very slim volume of poetry, My Heart Leaps Up, which...
SPEAKER_02I'm a traditionalist in terms of my approach to poetry, and in part, thanks to Lewis. Lewis actually wanted to be a poet before he wanted to be any other kind of author. He was maybe not the world's greatest poet, but I kind of appreciate there's a poem that he writes in response to T.S. Eliot's The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock, which is also a brilliant poem, where he says, I am so coarse the things the poets see are obstinately invisible to me. For twenty years I have stared my level best to see if sunset any sunset would suggest a patient etherized upon a table.
SPEAKER_02In vain, I simply was not able. To me, each sunset looked far more like the departure from a silent And he goes on from that to talk about traditional imagery in poetry, which ties into the whole myth-making and mythopoies. And I appreciate that. I've always hated this, the movement towards the modern, which just simply feels compelled to trash everything that's gone before.
SPEAKER_02And, you know, there's lots of modernism. So we actually just build on that. But that instinct to destroy that or to put down that which went before is, I think, an unfortunate one whereby we kind of enmesh ourselves in Whatever time period we have to be in, with a sense of chronological snobbery that Lewis would condemn. So anyhow, it's a traditional poetry, mostly with a little bit of modern, very short. And it's kind of my life's work,
SPEAKER_02I suppose, because I'm not a great or very well-disciplined writer.
SPEAKER_01It's hard to do. It's hard to do. So no worries there. Eric and I can both agree on that. And Stuart, I think you're finding that out as well.
SPEAKER_03How about you, John Paul? And I'm kind of coming at this from the idea of Lewis's own...
SPEAKER_03The war really made him very cynical. He became an atheist for a while, and then eventually, I'm kind of exploring some of the ideas.
SPEAKER_03I don't have the same story, so I don't have the same lived experience to draw on that I think Lewis would have had he lived long enough to write the story. But I'm trying really to draw from what we know of his life as a model for how her story would have unfolded had he been able to write it. And putting in some of my own experiences of grief and loss as kind of the starting point for where her journey back to faith, back to Narnia begins.
SPEAKER_01Thank you so much. Now the last question, which is two part, and we need a little to spice this up a little bit. So this will do it. I will put links to everybody's substacks here. But the second part is tell us about your substack, what it's about, get people interested in it. But the first part, the part that should make some discussion, which order should the Chronicles of Narnia be read? Take it away.
SPEAKER_02I'll jump in with both. I think there's a good argument to be made for both in that if you read So if you read them in the order of composition, they go from simple to complex. And so if you're reading it to a young child, then starting with the Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe is actually a good idea because it's the simplest one and it's the easiest one to get into. And then going through it in that order of composition is great. On the other hand, it totally makes sense to read them chronologically, even if it does kind of change the advent of Professor Diggory,
SPEAKER_02Professor Kirk, who then is kind of what Is it retconned as Diggory? So I think it's actually kind of fascinating that in the very first book, he has no experience of Narnia as far as we know. But then later on, after the composition of the magician's nephew, now all of a sudden he believes in Narnia not because he believes in general, but because he's actually been there. So it's an interesting, I think it'd be nice to preserve both. So start with the order of composition and then go back and reread them in chronological order.
SPEAKER_00At I think I'd agree with that. The question is sort of like, should you read the Bible starting with the Gospels or starting with Genesis? Yes. Probably first with the Gospels and then go back to Genesis. I mean, depends. I don't know. But I think of it similarly to that question. I think that you handled it perfectly, Father Justin. We'll let everyone answer that question first.
SPEAKER_01Actually, that was basically what I was going to say. But yeah, Father Justin said it a lot better than I said. I think there's, especially if you have not read the Chronicles of Narnia, I think starting with The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe is definitely the best place to go. But you will probably feel compelled to read them over and over again. So why not switch it up the second time?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, there's no real reason to not go back and forth between the two orders as you read. They're so rich, even for as simple as they appear at first glance, there's so much depth to them that you'll never go back and read them and not walk away with something new in each rereading.
SPEAKER_01I want to say I'm so disappointed that this didn't make a fight. Father, I can tap into my ancestors who were Puritans and be like, this is a priestly trick. They had a perfect set up. Nice try.
SPEAKER_00Now the second part, tell us about your substacks. Well, I run a Substack called Sewing Wonder. I post a lot of art quite frequently, and it's not just Because I think that it gathers attention. I just, I started doing that before I really realized that. I think that it's the same philosophy that's in my book. I believe that beauty and goodness and truth can draw one up the In a sort of way that some people are converted by truth,
SPEAKER_00just learning raw things and being convinced. And other people, it just zaps you. You experience something through beauty, through the glory of God. Perhaps through the beauty of the reality that he's made such a sacrifice on our account, amongst other things. But the Substack is, I wrote something about the worth of myth, you know, and in this context, it's my most popular article.
SPEAKER_00I also wrote something of a sort of vision for the 2030s, a positive vision, a possibility where if we turn away from our phones a little bit and turn ourselves toward craft and toward the glory of God and toward working with our hands, I think that we could have something like a renaissance almost if we just weren't looking at our phones as much, something like that. There's more to it than that, but... And then right now I'm writing something about St. George,
SPEAKER_00who is my patron saint, but an interesting part of St. George and one that I relate to, strangely enough, but the fact that he, we know that he was a Roman martyr, a Roman soldier who gave up all of his belongings and his status and everything to be a Christian, to be called a Christian and ultimately tortured for life. I want to say almost a year. It's a really brutal martyrdom he experienced. And we know that that is a reality, a historical reality.
SPEAKER_00And then we also have this legend of St. George, which pops up, which I also on some level believe. You know, it's kind of a one foot in, you know, maybe he really did slay a dragon. I wasn't there, but on some level I choose to believe it, you know. And that legend sort of grew up in, or we first started seeing it in the 1100s or so in Georgia, I believe. But who knows? It could be much older. It could actually be his tale.
SPEAKER_00And there's this sort of interesting ambiguity where it's like the Orthodox Church, we call him George the Dragonslayer. This is who he is. He is. And on some level, I believe that. You know, I believe that he actually slayed a dragon, but there's this, it's fun that there are, you know, some people think of it as two men, but that it's not two men. It's one man who, yeah. But why I relate to that, he slays a dragon,
SPEAKER_00he's a knight in this other version of the tale, he saves a princess, but this might be a lot to explain in one thing, but I'm realizing this halfway through, but really it has to do with my own interaction with the Rationality and coming to the end of myself in a sort of way, realizing that it's a lot more of it is mysterious than I set out to think. I thought that I could pin things down.
SPEAKER_00I've got these three verses to say this is necessarily the case, but maybe there's just a different type of knowledge. Not like a Gnostic thing, but like a... I don't know if I'm making sense even. I'm still trying to work it out in my writing.
SPEAKER_01Well, that's why we can check out your subsack and read about it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, anyway. I guess I'll jump in, not to in any way undermine the beauty of what Stuart just said. My reading of St. Jordan and the Dragon would be that it's a concretization of his strongholds. I think does speak to the kind of multiple layers of experience that we have, that there's
SPEAKER_02You can have it expressed in historical terms. You could have expressed in mythical terms. And those actually kind of work together rather than conflict with one another.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And it may be that way. And I guess the ambiguity that I experience is that I don't know which way to take it, but I'm going to take it. Yeah. Like he, he is a dragon slayer and he is a martyr. Yeah. Sorry. I'll go let you go.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. I did kind of mention that I have a blog, Substack, Geek Orthodox. It is kind of a blog. In many respects, in the kind of old-fashioned sense of, hey, I want to post about this, so I'm going to post about this. It's kind of unified by my identity or self-identifying, I guess, as a geek. So in the old-fashioned sense, not simply in the Socially challenged sense, shall we say, although that applies to me as well, but in the sense of wanting to geek out about stuff and actually really enjoying getting into something.
SPEAKER_02And so I talk about games and books and my attempts at writing fantasy and whatever else kind of strikes my fancy. And that I also have another Substack called Translating the Tradition. It's actually in many respects my older podcast, which is mostly just my sermons that I post online from my church. But yeah, I very much enjoyed, I have enjoyed kind of exploring things in Geek Orthodox and I had fun with the Pan as well.
SPEAKER_03Mine is ruminations and reflections, as I mentioned at the top of the podcast here, this panel. So I have explored a few different things in there. Probably my most viewed piece is on music production. So that's a part of my job is working with musicians. I do a lot of live event music. Live audio as part of my job. And so I've been getting into the studio side of things a little bit here and there. So I wanted to explore some of the things that make some of the older recorded music that either we or our parents grew up with from the 60s, 70s and 80s.
SPEAKER_03What sets it apart from music produced today and some of the techniques that people have... Yeah. You know, Christian or not, it might be.
SPEAKER_03But I've also looked at some other things, Catholic and Christian life throughout the year. I've had a series running since last December called Breathing Slowly. This world is, you know, obviously right now it's the fall and everyone is probably seeing the The onslaught of Christmas decorations everywhere, either in the stores for sale or even going up in the town around them. I'm seeing it where I live now. Some of the trees in the town center have already been dressed with their lights for Christmas and it was September when they went up. And it hurts my soul, actually.
SPEAKER_03I love Christmas. I truly do. I think... And without Christmas, Easter doesn't make any sense. Without Easter, Christmas doesn't make any sense. The two are very inextricably linked to each other. And so I started this last year as a means of basically saying, hang on a second, let's slow down a minute and just live in the seasons that the church sets out. And so I've been exploring some of that and some other things along the way. Friendship.
SPEAKER_03Hey, Patrick, thanks for inviting me into this discussion. This has been really interesting and very exciting.
SPEAKER_01And so my Substack is called Pyrite Dreams. Separate and apart from all these kind of like very important themes that have been talked about, I would say there's kind of like three things that I write on there or do on there, at least right now. I write short stories of which probably 80% of them are humorous and or satire.
SPEAKER_01And I also do book recommendations on books. And so I've also been doing that on my Substack. And those are the things that And also updates on books that I'm working on and are about to publish. That also comes up when the rare time when I'm actually having a book ready
SPEAKER_01to be published, that comes up as well. I just want to thank everybody for coming on. My own Substack is my outlet for my very wild mind. It's very original compared to all you with poetic names. Patrick Abbott, Sci-Fi Author. I figured people are going to get what exactly is in the title. Nobody's going to think, like, what does Roses in Space mean? Nope, Patrick Abbott, Sci-Fi Author. And it is a mishmash of every two weeks I publish either a short story or a chapter
SPEAKER_01in a short story that usually lasts about a month. Or objective look at sci-fi related topics. I particularly enjoy looking through the government UFO files and actually looking at what is being reported in these old UFO cases. And let's see if we can actually study them seriously. And most of the time it's, wow, wow. What modern UFOlogy says is completely different from what was reported at the time. Or one of my favorite series that I just need some more religions to look
SPEAKER_01at is Religions and Aliens. And it's looking at various religions' thoughts about the possibility of life elsewhere. Most religions are... Somewhere in the spectrum of open to the possibility, maybe, sort of, it's not a big deal. But sometimes you get extremes like Christian science, which is absolutely dead set against the idea. It's actually in their founding documents that there cannot be life on other planets. To surprises like the Blackies...
SPEAKER_01Black Hebrew Israelites who believe UFOs are real and must be the chariots of God. It's just a fascinating look. And check that out. And I will put everybody's links in the post. I will, in the next five minutes or so, once we're done, you might get an email from Substack saying, hey, do you want to be listed as a co-author on the post that I'm doing? It's really just the video itself of this panel and then maybe some clips and everybody's links. I want to thank everybody for being on.
SPEAKER_01Stay on after I end the recording and we'll just chat a little bit. But thank you so much for everybody for being here. Thank you for having us. It's been great. Thank you.
For years I have been trying to write a Religion and Aliens: Theosophy post to continue my Religion and Aliens series (see below for all the posts), but the topic is a huge rabbit hole that is too hard to sum up....
Science fiction authors Patrick Abbott and Schalk Holloway make their own worlds, sometimes with apocalypse for the sake of enjoyable fiction. Yet these two Christians, one a lay Catholic American and the other who...
In our conversation, Sister Allison Regina Gilot discusses her life as a nun who is an author of vampire fiction. She describes the importance of integrating Catholic themes into her stories. We discuss her writing...
I was able to interview Eric Sammons, long time Editor-in-Chief of the Catholic Crisis Magazine and now a science fiction writer. His first sci-fi piece, Shard of Eden, is out now. Get full access to Patrick Abbott,...