Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Patrick Abbott, Author Substack Podcast

Patrick Abbott, Author Substack Podcast artwork

Two Sci-Fi Authors Talk End Times Prophecies

May 24, 20261 hr 2 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Science fiction authors Patrick Abbott and Schalk Holloway make their own worlds, sometimes with apocalypse for the sake of enjoyable fiction. Yet these two Christians, one a lay Catholic American and the other who sometimes serves as a guide for others in a vast South African Pentecostal community, are well familiar with those who claim the End Times are upon us, whether the Rapture, Blood Moons, The Warning, Gog and Magog, UFOs upending Christianity, and more. Join us as we use faith and God-given reasoning to tackle the prophets of doom. Get full access to Patrick Abbott, Sci-fi Author at www.patrickabbott.net/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Hello, did you know the world is going to end? Yes, whether it is Jesus coming back, the rapture, or something else, like the warning, it is coming, and it is coming in 1976, 1988. 1991, 1994, 2000. It is coming in 2011 with the rapture. It is coming in 2020 with the warning and it is still coming. It's also coming in the form of UFO disclosures that will rock Christianity to its

SPEAKER_01core or so people think and claim. I'm Patrick Abbott, Sci-Fi Author of the book Fallen. I've also been trained and formed in Franciscan theology and today I'm joined by Shaq Halloway. Shaq, how are you sir?

SPEAKER_00Good Patrick, thanks. And it's wonderful to be with you again. We could do another chat before the world ends.

SPEAKER_01Schock is a great sci-fi author. I'm going to link to some of his good stuff too in our previous interview. But Schock and I were both connecting about how there's been more and more predictions by various people, especially involved with UFO claims that this is going to rock Christianity to its core. And while the news might make this sound new, For us, it's something we've seen for years now. And it's the same thing over and over and over again.

SPEAKER_01And with myself, I grew up in the household having books from my parents about Nostradamus and The Late Great Planet Earth by Hal Lindsey. And I don't know if my parents really believed any of it. I strongly doubt it. But for me, it was good because I could see these claims that at first would get me worried. Then I'd look, Hey, wait a minute. That was last year. That was 10 years ago. It didn't end. And it gave me the idea to look at things critically. And especially as stuff began new and new and new again,

SPEAKER_01I realized it was just the same thing again. Seriously getting into my own religion of Christianity and being hey, there's actual warnings against this and then getting trained as an analyst up how would they know this? What is their evidence? What is their argumentation? It really served to be a guard against these end time prophecies and I want to share my perspective and shock all the way from South Africa has his own unique perspective and before we get into his experiences and his great knowledge shock do you

want to tell the

SPEAKER_01audience a little bit about yourself and how you have your expertise

SPEAKER_00Oh, great. Thanks, Patrick. So apart from the fact that I've been writing for quite a long time, so first published in 2015, my first book was actually basically a walk through the Bible. So it was a book that starts from Genesis and just goes all the way through and that we had illustrated. And that book is now The official curriculum of a network to which I belong. It's 2000 plus congregations. And it's also been translated into multiple languages.

SPEAKER_00So that was actually my first book. And then from there, I've written quite widely from my professional career in terms of operations that I used to be part of within the law enforcement environment and then training pertaining to that. And then also the science fiction side. Me and Patrick were just chatting about it, but I'm sort of on my fifth practice novel, trying my end at fiction, but not convinced I'm where I want to be at yet. But yeah, I've studied twice.

SPEAKER_00I've studied, I've got two rounds of theology behind me. One was more charismatic leaning, one was more Pentecostal leaning. I didn't actually finish the Pentecostal one, so I just want to be upfront about that. But I've been part of ministry now since about 2005. And like I say, our network, which is quite a big, quite a significant network in our country, they actually commissioned me to write the book, which is now the curriculum. So it's not that I'm coming from nowhere. And yeah, but my ideas and my thoughts on a lot of these things aren't

necessarily strictly

SPEAKER_00Pentecostal. And so even though I come from a Pentecostal background, I do think about Scripture slightly more critically than a lot of my brothers do. And I'm very, very outspoken in terms of the whole end times nonsense and all these guys prophesy things and it just doesn't happen. So I'm quite vocal and comfortable being vocal in that area of scripture.

SPEAKER_01So when it comes to people's, I'm going to say, eagerness to embrace end times predictions, whether it is strictly religious, whether it is sort of a religious definition, Tied in with almost sci-fi elements like aliens or AI or even secular people who just embrace this end times thought. What's going on in their head?

SPEAKER_00So I think one, obviously this is a complex topic, Patrick. So it's probably better to think in terms of streams, different streams or pathways that speak to or from this issue. But I think the dominant one that I see is fear-based. And I had a mentor that used to say, fear is a very tiny, tiny little spirit. You know, it'll work its way in through a crack in the door. But when it's in, it just sort of grows tentacles and it starts to influence

everything. But the reason I think fear is the dominant one is that I've got people that have

SPEAKER_00been dissampling for many years. And the moment there's some sort of end-time prophecy, you can just see, oh, it sort of grabs a hold, it sort of gets its claws in them again. And usually they're very mature, they're very stable, they're going through their Christian life feet solidly on the ground. But the moment somebody comes and says, here's the date, you know, it's almost like Patrick Abbott, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick,

SPEAKER_00Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi Author patrick, Sci-Fi that anything that we start from fear is probably not the Spirit of God in any case, you know? And there's a lot I can say in making that claim,

SPEAKER_00but probably, you know, your best point of departure for a faith-based life is not fear. And so the moment that you're realizing, okay, but the root of this driving force within me is fear, So, in Christianity,

SPEAKER_01There are a lot of prophecies. Some are big long-term, massive impact, Isaiah. Others are just references in the Acts of the New Testament where Paul visits a house where there's prophets in them. We know nothing about the prophecies that they give. It's just that they're prophets. And then you have the Book of Relevation, which is a lot of times obsessed over, misinterpreted, and battled over just what the meaning is. Yet in Matthew 25, 13, probably the most famous line when it comes to prophecy,

SPEAKER_01when Jesus is talking about his return in the end times, he says, And this is the RSV version. Watch therefore for you know neither the day nor the hour, which is a pretty hard stop of you're not going to know when the end comes. Yet here we have people looking for signs and wonders, hearing rumors of learning of wars and rumors of war, trying to say it's coming very soon. or it is coming on this particular date,

SPEAKER_01even though that goes directly against what Jesus said. So what's going on in the people who make these claims?

SPEAKER_00Well, I think you're touching on probably the most crucial dynamic within the conversation, and that is how did we get to a broad faith community where something explicit like that can be said and then just ignored? You know, because that's a very real question. Is the same person that will say that from the Bible they surmise the following date or the following signs will ignore a very explicit command

within Scripture as

SPEAKER_00well. And so there's a very selective usage of Scripture within our faith environment, unfortunately. And I mean, that's probably one of the biggest accusations against Christianity is like, which one's true? You know, which one is now the right one? Because we've got all of these different types and styles and formats and beliefs and so forth. But essentially, I think the moment that you've got a person, any person that goes and says, you know, I'm I'm comfortable adhering to an interpretation or using the

scripture to form an

SPEAKER_00interpretation, but I can just very plainly ignore this one here, then that's a massive red flag for me. Because even if we're not able to accurately or easily interpret scripturalistically, the moment that I'm comfortable Not doing that. So the moment that I'm comfortable saying this one I'm going to contend with because this one serves my ministry, but this one I'm going to ignore because this one doesn't serve my ministry. That's the actual problem, not the interpretation.

The problem lies within the prophet that's willing to selectively choose something

SPEAKER_00that strengthens his own point of view, his ministry, but selectively leave something out. And I mean, that's quite a broad problem. If you have to think about... Let's say Jesus in Matthew 23 where he says, call no one rabbi, okay? Because you've got one teacher. And the New Testament, because technically Jesus is still ministering in the Old Testament, if that makes sense, even though the Gospels are in the New Testament in terms of the Bible.

SPEAKER_00But in the New Testament, we don't have rabbis, but we've got pastors and teachers and prophets and everything. So the New Testament version of that would be call no one pastor, if that makes sense. Jesus says don't fall into the positional label trap, but still everybody calls everybody pastor. So all of these scriptures, whether we deem them to be

SPEAKER_00very important or less important, but we selectively pick, you know, and that does seem to be something prevalent in these guys that are with all the end time prophecies is they'll pick things that strengthen their argument, but they'll disregard things that they've done. And even if you go and read a little bit earlier in that section in Matthew, where Jesus is speaking about you'll receive the same sign as Noah.

And he speaks about this idea of one will be taken away and one will be left behind. So we take that scripture to try and support the false doctrine of rapture.

SPEAKER_00But if you think about Noah's time, who remained and who was taken away? It was the righteous person that remained. It was the unrighteous person that was taken away in the flood. Okay, we agree on that. So when Jesus is saying one remains and one gets taken away, he's actually saying the righteous person will remain and the unrighteous person will be taken away, which is completely the opposite of what these guys teach. You know, they teach that the unrighteous person will remain and the

righteous one will be

SPEAKER_00taken somewhere. You know, I don't even know where they want to take them. So there's this very clear... If you just treat the Bible sensibly and responsibly, there's these very clear indications of how we should think about the end times. But what you'll find is you'll find that these end time prophets, they sort of just selectively pick whatever strengthens whichever bias they've got or whichever message they've got. And I think that's That's the dynamic.

The more important question is why did they get away with it, if that makes sense.

SPEAKER_00Systemically, why are they not being able to account? Because biblically, what you'll find is you'll see that we are accountable for each other and to each other. So if you, that is Patrick, if you start doing something awire, Me that is skulk is supposed to grab you by the shirt and say stop it now okay and then we sort each other out and you submit to me and I submit to you and we figure out how to go forward okay but the idea of mutual submission

and mutual correction

SPEAKER_00is intrinsically part of Christianity But what you'll find of these end-time profits as well as they're very much solo operators. You know, they're not in submission anywhere. There's nobody that can sit them down and say, listen, man, stop it now. You're talking nonsense. Either that or they'll hook up with people that are doing exactly the same. So it'll be sort of like a kindred spirit thing going there. But I can give you five people in South Africa now that you can call and

SPEAKER_00My testimony speaks for itself, so I don't have to try and convince you, but if these guys had to phone me and say, Skulk, stop it now, I'll stop. It doesn't matter what it is, because we understand the biblical principle of mutual submission and of mutual instruction. And so we basically built our lives like that. That's the ecclesiological part of this conversation. But these end-time guys, they're not necessarily accountable to anybody, you know, so they can just do what they want, say what they want, and there's nobody that can correct them.

SPEAKER_00And that's actually one of the significant issues.

SPEAKER_01And we have that in Catholicism, too. In the United States, there was Our Lady of Bayside, which was It was in certain circles, especially in the 70s and early 80s, and the bishop came and did an investigation and was, these end times prophecies of yours of nuclear war and whatnot, I'm not buying it. The claims of miracles happening here, I'm not buying it. and that helped for a lot of people but then you just have them as you say they

more or less cut themselves off from the mainstream church gathered like-minded people around them and in something similar that happened in Wisconsin they got basically alternative Catholics what are known as old Catholic clergy that are outside the hierarchy just one way or the other got religious orders and did their

SPEAKER_01own thing And they use that to build up, as you say, a consensus around them. And it reminds me of the Old Testament of the prophets of Baal. So when people say, oh, there's a consensus about the rapture from prophets or a consensus on the Catholic side of the warning from these people who are having prophecies. Well, whoop-dee-doo. I mean Plato himself could tell you democracy is stupid because if you get stupid people you're going to get stupid results and the Bible warns yeah liars and false

prophets will support each other because that builds a network in and of itself too and from a completely secular point of view I see people instantly just saying well is what the saying prophet true on XYZ therefore he or she must be true on aviancy

SPEAKER_01and that's not a good way to go about thinking it you should be going in objectively even if you ignore Matthew 25 13 and be what is the evidence being cited and then making a series of hypotheses one could be what the prophet claims two three and four can't just be the opposite but it could be what else could be going on could this be random chance could there actually be some sort of Small level conspiracy. Who knows? But nobody takes the time to do deep think.

SPEAKER_01They look at just what the profit claims. And especially if things go right, the profit will talk about that. If things go wrong, the profit won't talk about that. Just move on to the next thing. And so if you're just looking at the profit's message based on what the profit says, it's going to be a selective self-feeding feedback loop that just will lead you astray.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, I mean, even there, you have to probably ask the first question, you know, what is, you know, are prophets in today's age biblical? You know, because there's certain theologies that say, you know, the last generation was tied to the First Testament church, you know, first generation church, not First Testament. Just for your listeners, just remember, I'm Afrikaans and I fake being English really well, but...

SPEAKER_01Your English is a lot better than my Afrikaans, so no worry there. And apologies even for getting your name wrong, Skulk. There are Dutch people where I'm from and they have your name and it's Schalk and I know you told me it's Skulk, so bear with me listeners.

SPEAKER_00So first of all, I would say, and I mean, this is just a comfortable conversation, so I'm not going to make like in-depth scriptural defenses of everything I'm saying, but biblically, yes, definitely there is a mandate that people can prophesy or that there are prophets even up until today. And apart from the biblical mandate, what you do find is you do find experiential proof that it is the case, that you do find people that are especially in tune with God and able to discern from him prophecies.

And then you can go and you can say, okay, well, how might we think about prophecies themselves?

SPEAKER_00And there's probably two notes that I'll just drop into the conversation. One is the fundamental purpose of all prophecy is not the prediction of future. but it's turning the hearts of people back to God. So you have to understand that that's the goal of prophecy. The goal of prophecy is to look at a people or a person or people group and the purpose of this prophecy is to work in the heart and to turn the heart back to God. In the moment you get that, a lot of the prophets and the prophecies biblically sort of

snap into that mold

SPEAKER_00very easily. And then you have to say, okay, then in terms of prophecies themselves, you've got... The Gift of Prophecy, which is in 1 Corinthians 12, and you sort of, you catch there that it's an encouragement gift, okay? And so it brings life, okay? And it's very much tied into Revelation, and the way that it encourages very much, you know, can be that it touches on something in your heart or very close to you,

SPEAKER_00and God just speaks life into that, okay? So it's a very encouraging act that happens in The Gift of Prophecy. And then if you start speaking about prophets themselves or the more, I don't want to say the more serious side of prophecies, but there definitely is something that we would call directive prophecy. And directive prophecy has to do with direction, okay? And that's where something is declared that's meant to steer or it's meant to bring something into alignment or it's meant to show a goal that you

can move towards,

SPEAKER_00okay? We don't chase prophecies. But prophecy can very easily be directive as well. And so within those constraints, definitely, you know, there's space for prophecy, there's space for the ministry of the prophet to function there. What you don't see biblically is you don't see anything predicting dates. You don't see anything predicting, you know, the end time or Christ is going to return now or... the whole Blood Moon thing that we went through.

SPEAKER_00None of that features biblically. So there's no actual scriptural mandate for that. And so then already we have to start saying, okay, but is it then something that should be happening? Even though Jesus explicitly says, stay away from predicting dates, you don't really find a mandate for that model or that type of prophecy within the Bible itself as well. And yes, you can make an argument that some of the Old Testament prophecies are predicting,

SPEAKER_00you know, what's to come. But also there is a very good argument that a lot of that was fulfilled in Christ and in what he came to do, even though it's not, even though everything hasn't been fulfilled yet. So it's been partially fulfilled and some of it is now in process. But still what you don't find is you don't find that. In our country we've got an artist called Dani Boota, and I've got no opinion on him. He's been in our country and ministering for many years, so I'm going to share objectively just what happened in our

country last year.

SPEAKER_00Another pastor in our country had a dream that he said was from God, and he interpreted this dream that on the 23rd of September, 2025, Patrick Abbott, Sci-Fi Author Patrick Abbott, Sci-Fi Author Patrick Abbott, Sci-Fi Author He experienced in many different ways confirmation that this

date is accurate.

SPEAKER_00The 23rd of September 2025 crisis is returning. And he's got a great big following. And so a lot of people bought into his date that he gave. Obviously, there was material lost because people sold stuff, people quit their jobs, you know, all sorts of stuff like that happened. And then when it didn't happen, at least he, he owned up and said, he's sorry, he got it wrong, you know? So, so that, that's, that's now great that he did that.

SPEAKER_00And, but then he went on to say, but he doesn't see himself as a false prophet because he still works very hard to, to bring people's hearts back to Christ, which is, which is done, you know? So how do we, how do we now approach it? Because you, you, you get a person that has falsely prophesied a date A lot of people have experienced material loss. He's apologized at least because a lot of these guys just disappear. They just ignore it and carry on with their nonsense.

SPEAKER_00But at the same time, he also asks us not to label him a false prophet because he made a mistake. So, I mean, where do you then fall on? How do you approach that? It's a complex thing. He's got a whole testimony of ministry that you sort of want to say, okay, but, you know, he's faithfully ministered over many generations, you know, and we want to honor that. And he's apologized for wrongfully putting out a date.

SPEAKER_00But on the other side, he's also wrongfully put out a date, you know, and that's something that Christ himself said we shouldn't do. So... I mean, even last year we had a supposed, I don't even know about this, like 23rd of September, by the way, is my birthday. So on the 24th, I had a buddy phone me up, he says, he's so glad we're still here. I'm like, what are you on about? He's like, no, dude, didn't you follow Donnie Berta? I'm like, no, man, I don't follow things like that. And then he told me about it, and I said, well, who knows, maybe we were left behind.

SPEAKER_00Maybe you think it didn't end and it did end.

SPEAKER_01God took the two people in the world who deserve to be saved.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, you know what happened to us in the COVID year, Patrick? My wife and I, up until then, had the tradition in December of doing just like a basic strategic plotting of our year. And I mean, this is something that many households do. But December before COVID, I'm telling you it doesn't matter how many times I try to sit down and hear from God, what am I supposed to be doing in that year, 2020?

SPEAKER_00He just didn't say anything, okay? And so after a while it becomes quite tense in the household because my wife wants to do strategic planning and I'm avoiding it because I'm just not experiencing God saying anything specifically for the year. and it got to a boiling point and I went to sit again with the Bible and I said, Lord, you have to speak to me. My wife's going to, you know, we have to sort this thing out now. And so he gives me that scripture in, is it in James, that says, don't be arrogant and say next year you're going to do this and

you're going to do

SPEAKER_00that because you don't know. Say God willing. So I go back to my wife. I say, I'm very sorry. This is the scripture that I got. And she just throws the books around, clamps the doors closed and He's fully convinced I'm on holiday. I don't want to do this thing. And I'm just trying to say, I'm sorry, I don't know what to tell you. God isn't saying anything. This is what he's saying. Anyway, so it turns into a bit of a thing in our household. And then COVID happened. And we went through two lockdowns. I had to close down one of our businesses.

I had to take over another business from somebody that couldn't run the thing. Nothing, nothing that we would have penned down in December would have penned out.

SPEAKER_00Nothing, okay? And so, by some grace of God, I was accurate. You know, I didn't know about COVID, but the Lord was saying, don't waste your time writing stuff down. Okay. However, all of my buddies in ministry had prophetic words and stuff that God said over that year. And none of it, well, very little of it came to pass. And I would ask them about it. I'd say, but you heard wrong. No, things change in the spirit, all sorts of airy-fairy nonsense like that.

SPEAKER_00And I'll tell them, but that's not the case. And they don't own up to that. You understand? And that's a worrying thing. I mean, if it's friends of mine, you know, we can sort each other out. But the fact that probably 80% of Christianity had some sort of word for COVID here that didn't pan out. It just didn't happen because nobody saw COVID coming. Okay? So it's not just, we can't just always point our fingers at the end time prophets,

SPEAKER_00this is a systemic issue, is that we've cultivated in some way a very risky environment within the church, meaning the universal church, whereby we hear things from God and we have to ask ourselves the question, is this thing that we've heard, is it accurate or not? And how do we check that? And what do we do when very clearly we were inaccurate. Those are serious questions that the church has to contend with

within herself,

SPEAKER_00I think, if we want to be credible to anybody outside of the church.

SPEAKER_01So that's really interesting to put it that way. And I look at it from an analytic point of view, all the way back to the man who thought the world would end in September. We don't factor in the thought we could be wrong. Scott Adams once said that being right and being spectacularly wrong feel the same way. And as analysts, we take really good pride in what we will assess the future will be. And we talk about our tradecraft and we talk about this and how

we weighed all the evidence.

SPEAKER_01And a lot of times we can get married to that analysis. But one thing that is in a very good way is we are forced to make alternatives. Basically, what would I need to see if I was wrong? and that's a really good check and i think it's also good to keep humble both for people and people who believe god is talking to them what if i read it wrong what if i heard something that was wrong what if somebody told me something and he or she was wrong and we as creatures don't really do that and i

think that's an

SPEAKER_01important thing to do and when it comes to people who really either obsessed about trying to find the next end time prophecy or big prophecy or get really scared by these people who say the world's going to end, might as well sell all your things. What would you tell them to do?

SPEAKER_00I think, and you could speak to it from another point of view as well, but I think the New Testament actually has a very elegant solution. One thing we need to, if we just sort of step back into the deeper theology and just ask, but what changed from the Old Testament to the New Testament? One layer of that answer is that in the Old Testament, God called individuals and you would see the Spirit of God ascending and ascending

SPEAKER_00from them and they would basically accomplish something. Okay. But in the New Testament, God is called... And so the theology switches from individualist theology or individual-focused calling and theology to a body-focused calling and theology. And this is a very fundamental shift, and it's key to understand before I can sort of layer what I want to say on top of it. But in the New Testament,

everything works through the framework of the church. And what I mean of that, I mean the framework of commonality and the framework of unity. So there's very little precedent in the New Testament for anybody hearing or doing

SPEAKER_00something on their own. If somebody is operating Dr. Justin Marchegiani The New Testament is of having multiple witnesses to the same testimony.

SPEAKER_00And this is a crucial thing, is that if something is of the Spirit of God, it means that whoever is tapped into the Spirit of God should be receiving the same message. So if me and you are fairly mature believers and we are attuned to the Spirit of God, because there's work, not work there, but you need to be attuned. You need to be in tune with the Spirit of God, walking in pace with Him. You can be out of sense of the Spirit of God. but let's say the two of us are quite mature and we walk quite

closely and consistently to the Spirit of God then on a very deep level we'll sense the same thing we might bring different gifts or different layers or different specialities to the thing that we are sensing but most probably we'll be sensing the same thing

SPEAKER_00okay so in our church community There's no, and people struggle with this still, there's no pastor, there's no presiding pastor, there's no one leader. We do have individuals that do have leadership giftings, that they lead from their gifts, they're not leaders. But when we make decisions and when we're discerning, we do that as a community and we do it together and we don't run away from each other. So there's nothing in our community of one person hears something and everybody follows him okay if somebody hears something we

take it to the community and we submit it to them and we pray about it together and we work through the scripture together and we discern together and so that is what actually creates safety within the body of Christ it also creates humility because you have to if you're serious about this you have to be willing to give up whatever

SPEAKER_00whatever illusions of grandeur you're holding onto and say, but I'm going to submit to the guy next to me just as much as he submits to me. So that I would say is the dominating discipline you find in the New Testament is that we're not supposed to have individuals discerning or receiving messages solo. There's supposed to be a communal process of discernment And even if we disagree on certain levels, we work it out together.

SPEAKER_00So even if me and you come together and we say, but, you know, we're feeling there's a change happening in our community or there's a change happening in our relationship, what does it mean? We stay connected. And even if it means we have to intention fight that thing out, we do that. That's what community is about. That is what we find in scriptures, that we do it together. I think the moment that you find somebody operating on their own,

it's a massive red flag the moment that you find a presiding pastor is not accountable it's a massive red flag the moment you find any sort of centralization of authority or power it's a massive red flag because fundamentally the body of Christ is built to be a communal structure that works in unity and the patience and discipline of working towards unity is what brings the checks and balances to make

SPEAKER_00sure that these aberrations don't exist however You know, that's the ecclesiology from scripture. But I mean, if you think about society today, I mean, the proliferation of social media just completely goes around it. It's not necessary anymore because you can just set up a YouTube channel. You can just set up an Instagram channel, you know, and for me coming from a combative training background, you know, we had really high standards for our training because I worked

operationally and if

SPEAKER_00the training doesn't work, I'm not going to come home, okay? So we had really, really high standards for our training, but then you'll find 10 other guys starting up combative trainings and farms training, and you wonder, but where's this guy? Who is he? Where is he from? What has he done, you know? But you can open a channel. I mean, nobody can stop him and say you can't have a YouTube channel or you can't have an Instagram channel, you know? So it's the sort of same dynamic within the church.

SPEAKER_00If I disciple somebody new and it happens, they'll always ask me, so who can I watch on YouTube? Who can I watch on Instagram? Then usually what I try and do is I try and steer them away from consumption, okay? Very important, from consumption. Because the problem of consumption is you're going to start watching whatever you're biased to or whatever you're used to, which is already problematic. And also you can't really disciple somebody

you know over YouTube it has to be there has to be human contact and so what we do is is we say no just just come into the community and we make sure that that person is exposed to the community and that we build relationship with him realistically from different from different angles and so there's a there's a critical mass uh already of quite mature believers and then you just bring somebody into that

SPEAKER_00environment and the sort of community would would would sort them out because I can't tell you how many times these young believers will send me a video of Instagram. What do you think of this guy? The guy is just talking nonsense or send me a YouTube video. He says this and this and that, but it's nonsense. But unfortunately, just our society works sort of circumvents the biblical principles of unity and of discerning things together and of submitting to each other.

SPEAKER_01Right. It's almost like independent publishing that once the thresholds that were so high are now so low, as you point out, anybody can have a social media account. Anybody can have a podcast. Anybody now can reach anybody, including, oh, I can get a pastor or priest to endorse my point of view. And in the past, that was, oh, wow, that means you must be really well vetted. People know you, things like that. We all know there's lower standard people out there that you can easily find and

endorse you.

SPEAKER_01And it becomes that almost consensus of the false consensus of, well, people who already agreed with me now agree with me. And I even create a book with citations. And who's actually going to check? It's not a real peer review. It's not critically challenged. And as others have pointed out, the podcast circuit has made things worse because I say this interview interviewing you the second time the big podcast basically just interview themselves the medium podcast interview

themselves the niche podcast

SPEAKER_01interview themselves it becomes a feedback loop and yeah the algorithms promotes basically radicalism in belief and radicalism in just saying things. And standards have absolutely collapsed. We've seen people who were once thought about as normal go to, okay, so they're more on the wing, but still in it, to absolutely crazy. Candace Owens. Tucker Carlson in the United States was once a mainstream news guy.

SPEAKER_01Now he literally will just say things that are demonstrably false, like Epstein winning the lottery with no evidence, no proof that 10, 20 years ago would have basically got him kicked off the news media and nobody would pay attention to him. But now that social media algorithms reinforce themselves, well, here we are it's really sad to see and it makes things difficult and people are just naturally looking to the screens for entertainment not

reading books or just looking scrolling for the next thing letting the algorithm choose we have people who just stumble on to things and like oh yeah he was right about this other thing

SPEAKER_00why isn't he right about that well I mean another layer to that is uh like one of the gents I'm journeying with now. We had a conversation a couple of weeks ago about something he posted. It was a WhatsApp story that he posted. And it's a really beautiful little story that the original poster came up with. But he was grounding it in a scripture and that scripture is

not what that means.

SPEAKER_00You understand? So now you're sitting with Now he's sitting with this added layer of yes that sounds great and it's very encouraging but it's not what's said there you know and that's another problem that we're facing it's not just the guy that's you know just all our you know the end times prophecy just talking nonsense it's this person that's coming with a very encouraging message but it's not really what the Bible is saying there you know and

SPEAKER_00And that becomes challenging to manage as well, because if you think, and I'm quite outspoken about the fact that I think we need to move past Christian fundamentalism. I just don't think it's helpful at all. The reasons that kicked it off, we can spend hours on that. I'm not going to go into that. My position is very simply that Christian fundamentalism is a waste of time and it causes more problems than than it causes anything good.

My official position is just, I'm not a big fan of Christian fundamentalism.

SPEAKER_00And if you look at the internal evidence of the Bible, meaning how the Bible speaks about itself, there's two very important themes that you need to always bear in mind. And the one theme is that in the Old Testament, there was a tradition of teachers, the rabbi, and even before that, the priests would also teach. But in the New Testament, you basically have the calling of a teacher. You have the seat of a teacher, somebody that's called to teach. And it dovetails very closely with elders.

Elders are mandated to teach and to make sure that false doctrine doesn't enter into the church. And so your first question is that, you know, if the Bible really was such a simple doctrine document to understand why would God himself through the ages include the necessity

SPEAKER_00of having good teachers, you know? So we have to contend with the fact that most probably there are individuals that need to help us delve into and understand scripture better. And then if you go a little bit further, you'll see that Peter speaks about Paul's writings and then Peter says Paul's writings are difficult to understand, okay? So, if Peter says that, and I mean Peter walked with Christ, so if Peter says that, then we have to understand that,

SPEAKER_00okay, it means that there is some work necessary to understand Scripture accurately. There's good principle, good ameneutics, good studying required to actually understand Scripture properly. Fundamentalism says no, even a five-year-old child should be able to understand the Bible or just take it as face value. Fundamentalism is very skeptical of any form of hermeneutic or interpretation. They almost see it as elitist.

But the moment you do that, you collapse the possibility of accurate discernment.

SPEAKER_00It just falls flat. You can't accurately discern anymore. Because if we come back to the principle of many witnesses, bearing the same testimony gives us accuracy, which probably from the analyst side you can speak to as well. But if there's a car accident outside and it's just me that sees the car accident and I give you my account, you have to take my word for it, okay? But if there's five or six different witnesses to the car accident, all of a sudden you can start to generate a more accurate

picture of what happened

SPEAKER_00there. And so the same with scripture. You can't just have one person cherry picking something and saying, I'm taking this at face value. You need to have good principle and you need to have good discipline and communal witnessing and testimony to what is accurate. But the philosophy of Christian fundamentalism sort of collapses that. You lose all of that. So a little side point,

and I'll bring in Islam to actually back up your point there.

SPEAKER_01When I was in Afghanistan the first time, I was invited to the Quranic study group that the Afghans and other Muslims from other countries had. And they knew me, they knew I was a devout Christian, but they really respected that I could deal with them on a person-to-person and faith level. And a Wahhabi who was educated in Qatar brought up how Islam The Quran is a book and you can read the book and God speaks to you and you just know it. And the Imam who was from Afghanistan brought up, that's foolish.

SPEAKER_01I can read a doctor's book and it doesn't make me a doctor. And then he pointed it to me and said, even the Christian knows that. And he went on a little spiel about how Christians have elders called bishops and that they interpret the Bible for the people and that they go through school and it's really, really hard. and so it's a universal thing that hey we have been touched by the divine in one way shape or form or we at least believe we have and It's really hard.

You have people who disagree with what the law said, even in the Old Testament. And you have the need for witnesses and multiple people because it's really, really hard.

SPEAKER_01And there's nothing wrong with that. And I guess when a prophet, a false prophet presents something, it's an easy answer and it makes you feel good. It shows, oh, there is a plan. Oh, it is easy to understand. Away I go. So in the United States, it's been kind of a busy year for prophecy and it's a bit tiring. In January, when we had the military operation that took the Venezuelan President Madero, for about a day or two,

certain Catholic priests were sharing alleged prophecies from a woman in Venezuela

SPEAKER_01who said, the world is going to end in World War III and World War III will begin in Venezuela. Then the United States and Israel start bombing Iran, and all of a sudden, even from government officials, you had, oh, this is Gog and Magog, and this is a type of the eternal battle against evil. Same things I remember when we were going in against Iraq in 2003. And then just recently, as I've mentioned before, About two weeks ago,

SPEAKER_01three weeks ago, we had Christian pastors claiming they were at secret government meetings. Turns out it was an Airbnb in Tennessee where the government allegedly told them, oh, these UFO files are going to change everything and it will challenge Christianity. Now's the time to really, really brace your congregation for the new truth. And it's almost Gnostic, Theosophist in a way. What are you seeing in South Africa right now?

SPEAKER_01Are they talking about what we're talking about in America? Are there other prophecies going on that's hitting your radar? Well, let me just make a small disclaimer and just so that I say something and don't look

SPEAKER_00completely foolish, I'll add something to the conversation. I'm not on social media. I don't watch news. Good for you. My philosophy in life, and it's served me well, is if it's really serious, somebody's going to phone me. The second one is that everybody that needs to know Al to get me there, knows where I am. And there I'm speaking about, you know, obviously more serious things.

And the third thing is that if somebody jumps over my gate, it's sorry for them.

SPEAKER_00And that's sort of my philosophy to life. So I can't really speak to what's happening in South Africa. I live a little bit like a hermit. And people have opinions on that, but I struggle tremendously with just other exposure to things and I need to manage myself well. And part of managing myself well is that I've got a, I don't have a and have a small life. I'm very tied into my community.

SPEAKER_00I know people from all walks of life. I'm very much settled into our broader community, but it's face-to-face. It's in contact like this. I honestly don't know on that level. Let me speak to something that you did mention. If we have to think about Rodley, what is the purpose of teaching?

SPEAKER_00Okay, let me touch on that. What is the purpose of teaching? Okay, we sometimes, and I think it's a post-Enlightenment thing, we sometimes get stuck in this idea that teaching is about imparting information, it's about transferring information, okay? And so what we find is the church is very much shaped or she has been shaped to receive information, okay? And whether that is via social media,

SPEAKER_00whether it's in the pews on the Sunday, we have, we meaning us that are elders, we have built a church that is passive and that consumes information, okay? But if you have to consider what we find in the New Testament, and we have to look at the mandate of those that are called to minister to the church, we see that there's a lost conversation on maturity in the New Testament. And you'll see that the writer in Hebrews,

SPEAKER_00in Hebrews 5, he'll make the statement, he says, by this time you ought to be teaching yourself. So the biblical expectation is that by this time, by a certain time, a believer should be mature, okay? And Paul really takes that theme as well, you know, to task, and he speaks about wanting to feed you with faster space, with solid food, but you can only handle milk, you know? But you find a very rich conversation in the New Testament

about this idea of

SPEAKER_00spiritual maturity, of a believer maturing, okay? So now we've spoken about this dynamic from the point of view of the false prophet. But we have to ask ourselves, why are believers just taking this? You know, why are they sitting there and they're just consuming this information and allowing this information to throw them around like a ship in the wind? Because that's what happens. But spiritual maturity is the thing that brings stability to the church.

SPEAKER_00Spiritual maturity is the thing that causes a believer to be upright, consistent, not to fall around, not to be blown around like a ship in the wind, okay? But we've somehow lost the conversation of maturity in the church. I mean, how many people do you hear speak about maturity? I mean, we just don't find it. They'll speak about leadership, they speak about gifts, they speak about profits, they speak about all these things. But there's a very firm, clear line on the topic of maturity in the New Testament that's

just gone away.

SPEAKER_00Okay. And so I think, you know, thinking about whether it's the gent or the imam that spoke to you, or whether it's us speaking about this topic, you know, we We have the tradition of teachers or people that need to teach on the one side, and we've got the tradition of sort of the communal discernment. But for me, that's a believer. I need to be growing into maturity. And so the question is, okay, but what is maturity?

SPEAKER_00Maturity is two things. Maturity is number one. I am able to accurately discern what God is telling me. whether through good biblical interpretation, whether through prayer, whether through speaking to the brothers. But I am tasked, 50% of my maturity relies on whether or not I can accurately discern what God is telling me. That's gone missing in the church. The biggest percentage of church is dependent on somebody telling them.

SPEAKER_00They're not able to actually do the discernment themselves. The other half of maturity, the other 50% is that once I've actually discerned what it is that God's leading me, I am disciplined in being obedient, okay? And so that's what maturity is. Maturity is, I can hear accurately, but also I'm obedient in that which I hear. And that's a very critical conversation because if you're asking me how do we stop people from

SPEAKER_00running after these false prophets. The conversation we have to have is maturity, is who runs after these prophets? It's the immature believer. It's the believer that's still a baby. It's the believer that's influenceable by nonsense, okay? And there, I think, is the monumental challenge in the church, because number one, we're not even talking about maturity. Number two, It's the job of the elders to actually build maturity. The elders aren't even talking about maturity.

SPEAKER_00And I think there's something, you know, to be said there that individual believers understand that there's a biblical call to mature sooner rather than later. Maturity isn't something that we need to, yes, we'll work on it our whole life, but it's not something that we're aiming for when we're 80. The writer in Hebrew says, by this time, meaning there's an urgency for me to mature. But unfortunately, the largest part of the church is dependent on information from

outside.

SPEAKER_01And that's a very good point. And I think it actually ties in well with one of the things a lot of people misunderstood about Pope Francis. He talked a lot about discernment. And some people interpret that, oh, people are just going to do what they want and justify it. But he mentioned in a very Jesuit way of formation is key and utmost importance. Because a lot of times the encounters that matter for a Christian Aren't what we would consider big things where you can consult

the church or

SPEAKER_01consult your brothers even, but it's the little things in life, what you do, whether it's reaching out to a homeless person or finding an alternative way to support him, or whether it's what you say at work, do you gossip, things like that. It truly is the small things that add up that can outweigh even big choices you make every day. And he stressed the importance of discernment. And it wasn't until I actually read sort of a lot of Jesuit

theology and talked

SPEAKER_01about how it is a key utmost importance to develop yourself, to be able to discern how you need to be well formed that it clicked in my brain. And that's a really good point, and I want you to bring it up. I want to thank you for bringing that up. When it comes to the actual end times itself, and this might be a good way to end our conversation, I'm reminded of two sayings. One was from my mother, who told me, it doesn't matter when the end times are. You could die today, you could die tomorrow, you could be hit by a bus.

SPEAKER_01That is your end times. People will be trying to look for years ahead, worry about today, do the gospel today, believe today, pray today, do acts of charity today. And then, especially for Italian and Italian-American Catholics, there's a famous saint called Padre Pio from the mid-20th century who's famous for saying, pray, hope, and don't worry. And it's just trust God and things will happen.

But as long as you focus on the most important bit, don't worry about it.

SPEAKER_01What advice would you give to people who are anxious, whether it's end time prophecies or just other prophecies?

SPEAKER_00Well, if you look at scripture, 1 John speaks about this very deep truth that perfect love drives out fear. And so it's as we really get to understand, you know, the father and live deeply and intimately with him that all forms of fear are able to resolve and we are able to yield from them because fear can be complex. It can be from trauma. It can be from old wounds. It can be from very valid circumstances.

SPEAKER_00But if you want to mature, you have to grab of fear and you have to work with it. You have to understand that fear is not from God, especially oppressive fear, especially the moment that you realize that this thing that's called fear is driving my behavior, it's driving my thinking. We have to understand it's not from God. And I think especially Christians that catch themselves caught

in that loop or that fear, My hope and my prayer would be that they realize that anything that starts from

SPEAKER_00that position of fear is most probably not the Spirit of God. And that won't solve everything, but may that put them on a path where they start asking the questions, why am I struggling with fear in this regard? And something that I'm working through with a couple of my members in our community is that for us that come to God later in life,

we still think that we're walking on a tightrope and we still think that we might

SPEAKER_00very easily fall off, you know, and lose our salvation, you know, whatever that might mean to somebody, but we feel the tightrope. And I think sometimes the fear is based on that, you know, am I and God really okay? Are we really okay with each other? Whereas if you look at the Jewish mindset, you know, for the Jew in the Old Testament Bible now, God is always the God that saves, He's always the God that forgives, He's always the God that redeems, He's always the God that provides.

SPEAKER_00And whatever situation or phase of life they find themselves in, the one thing that they never do is doubt whether He's their God. And I think sometimes for us that come to Christ later, we still have those doubts. and you know we need to work with that question how settled are we in God how deeply are we rooted in him and is he rooted in us you know how real is he to us

and we have to we have to journey on those those questions we need to settle for ourselves the question of God and ourselves and the fact that he will always be the God that forgives he will always be the God that redeems he will always be the God

SPEAKER_00that provides I think we have to we have to I can possibly end the conversation on a lighter note and tell you how many times I've gotten into trouble for what I'm going to say now but usually if somebody tells me, you know, Christ is coming soon and I'll say, no, I don't know And they'll be like, what do you mean? I said, no, we're all going to be dead long time.

SPEAKER_00He's still not going to be back. And then they'll start getting angry at me. And I'll say, listen, I'm not fighting. I'm just telling you, we're all going to die and he's not going to be back for long. And then they'll be like, how do you know? I said, no, how do you know he's coming soon? But usually at some stage they'll ask me, but what are you going to do if you're wrong? Then I said, I'll apologize to him when I see him. But usually that doesn't end the conversation well. But I think I told you before we started this talk,

my only purpose for teaching on the end times is to deliver people from having to

SPEAKER_00think about the end times. I don't teach about it for any other reason than delivering people from fears and worries about the end times. I think how you summarise it is a very good way to leave people is just live your life, you know, live within. Mature, you know, and just forget about all this nonsense.

SPEAKER_01As they say at the end of Mass, go forth and do the gospel. I want to really thank you so much today. I'll include links to your websites and books. So thank you again so much.

SPEAKER_00Thanks, Patrick. Yeah, it's always fun. I appreciate you. Thank you.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. C.S. Lewis Panel: The Meaning of Narnia and Other Questions

    Oct 13, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    What happens when a lay Catholics, a Protestant with a pastoral background, and an Orthodox priest and a layman get together? They talk about C.S. Lewis, Narnia, the Space Trilogy, and how Lewis has influenced them. Go...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Podcast Episode: Harmonialism and Aliens

    Jun 24, 20261 hr 28 minAudio

    For years I have been trying to write a Religion and Aliens: Theosophy post to continue my Religion and Aliens series (see below for all the posts), but the topic is a huge rabbit hole that is too hard to sum up....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Do Aliens Exist? Conversation with Patrick Abbot

    Feb 22, 202651 minAudio

    Get full access to Patrick Abbott, Sci-fi Author at www.patrickabbott.net/subscribe

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Interview with Sister Allison Regina Gilot

    Feb 18, 202635 minAudio

    In our conversation, Sister Allison Regina Gilot discusses her life as a nun who is an author of vampire fiction. She describes the importance of integrating Catholic themes into her stories. We discuss her writing...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Interview with Catholic Sci-Fi Author Eric Sammons

    Nov 26, 202523 minAudio

    I was able to interview Eric Sammons, long time Editor-in-Chief of the Catholic Crisis Magazine and now a science fiction writer. His first sci-fi piece, Shard of Eden, is out now. Get full access to Patrick Abbott,...

    Credit the people on this episode