Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Off Message

Off Message artwork

Is Progressive Dominance Of The Democratic Party Inevitable?

Jul 23, 202613 minAudio

This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net Thanks to everyone who watched in real time, and to those who left questions for me on Notes or in the live chat. I explain/confess at the top of the video why I opted for the live format this week. In this case it was more out of necessity than anything else. But I do enjoy the added spontaneity of the live mailbag as a departure from the sometimes-tort…

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00You know, my normal writing budget during the week. So that's part of the reason. The other part of the reason is I'm actually just trying to practice this sort of like talk to no one. I've been just trying to imagine like a close friend or my wife like on the other side of the monitor here so that I can maybe like try to develop a more conversational voice when I'm speaking impromptu to an empty room. And I think that that might be a useful skill to develop. So that's part of it. But the main thing is that the World Cup, Screwed up my workflow over the weekend.

SPEAKER_00So normally I do my, write most of my Monday piece on Sunday. And when I sit down to write, you know, that's sort of my cue to also send out the mailbag prompt. But because I knew I was going to spend a lot And that meant that I just never really sat down to do any work on Sunday. And so you didn't get a prompt. And that's why I'm taking your questions here instead of, you know,

SPEAKER_00having a little bit more time to think through my answers and write them down. So that's my throat clearing. I do have some questions from Notes, and I got the chat going here, so if people want to drop questions into the chat, I will try to take those too. I'm going to aim to go for about an hour, but we'll see. Maybe if there are not enough questions, we'll be shorter. And if there are a lot of good questions, I've got a little bit of spare time, so we can go a little over. Okay, the first question I have from Notes is from somebody who calls themselves Hugs.

SPEAKER_00Who asks, I was wondering why you said on the podcast this week that leftists shouldn't have primaried Dan Goldman. Leftists correctly note that Goldman didn't endorse Medicare for All when he was first elected. He actively argued against it. Doesn't support raising taxes at the state level. Refused to endorse Mom Donnie in the general election, citing anti-Semitism concerns. Wouldn't refer to the West Bank... So, the litany. He's also voted to condemn Rashida Tlaib and voted in favor of greater surveillance. Momdani won that district by a huge margin.

SPEAKER_00I don't think it's crazy for leftists to want somebody who is a better ideological fit. I just... I don't have the transcript of what I said on the podcast in front of me, but I remember it because it was just a couple days ago. And I think you're over-reading my intent in saying that. I have said elsewhere that if I lived in that district, I probably would have voted for Brad Lander in the primary over Dan Goldman for some of the reasons that Huggs mentioned in the litany. And for different ones, too.

SPEAKER_00I really appreciated that Dan Goldman back in 2016 19 signed up to lead the investigative work for the first Trump impeachment. But that was also like a leadership controlled exercise. It was not an open ended inquiry. And so the fact that they turned to him sort of signaled to me like in hindsight, That this was somebody who was going to be sort of obedient to the leadership, who wanted to be a team player in that sense, maybe rise up through the ranks of leadership. And over time, I kind of lost trust in that leadership.

SPEAKER_00And so for that reason, too, I think if I lived in Manhattan, lived in that district, I would have voted for Brad Lander. What I was getting at is that, you know, the fights that Mondani picked with incumbents in New York City will result in people who are Further to the left of the incumbents being elected, but it's not going to be a huge... Change the ideological makeup of the house in a super appreciable way. The squad will grow from whatever it is now, three, four members to seven, eight members.

SPEAKER_00And the number of votes that there will be for progressive ideas that have experienced resistance from the leadership will be slightly larger, but it's not going to really make that much change. What I was trying to convey in the podcast is that So if progressives want to make the most difference in places where they are confident they can win, the people they want to pick off are less like Dan Goldman than they are like Josh Gottheimer,

SPEAKER_00there's a congressman, I think, whose name is Ed Case, who represents a very progressive district, but is not very progressive. And then you're making a real change. You're causing the average progressiveness of the House Democratic Caucus to move to the left, for real. And that's all I meant. It was not like I thought that... I wrote a long piece about, you know, what I admired about what Mamdani did and also my misgivings about it. I can try to pull it up if people have patience and assuming Hugs is here and wants to read it.

SPEAKER_00But it's about, you know, like I think that what Mamdani did is interesting. It was, you know, ruthless. Oh no, how did I do that? Hang on one second. I will try to get that piece into the chat without causing a bunch of interference in my AirPods. But I think what Mondani did in New York was impressive. It was, like I said, it was like ruthless. And not in necessarily a negative sense of the word.

SPEAKER_00But it conveys a desire to wield power in a way that seems off-kilter to me from where I think Democrats really need to change their theory of power. It is a play for more left-wing clout in the Democratic Party on issues of policy rather than to make the Democratic Party I think they're wrong. I think they need to study that issue properly.

SPEAKER_00A bit more closely and realized that accomplishing the things they want to accomplish, along with the things I want to accomplish, requires wielding power in a slightly different way than Mom Donnie was doing. But I didn't have a big problem with Brad Lander primarying Dan Goldman as just like a decision of the left. That seemed totally reasonable to me. Okay. Next question is from Matt. I'm sorry if I mispronounced, Leishoff Sullivan. Who asks, what are your thoughts on the Markey-Molton race?

SPEAKER_00Many people I know say that in theory they'd be in favor of a challenger to Markey on the basis of age alone, if nothing else, but they don't like Molton. I feel like Molton could be an early test run of whether the I'm tired of losing winnable races over stupid shit and fighting moderate message can win a Democratic primary. I think I read the situation a little different in that maybe I'm being a little bit too literal here, but Democrats are going to win this seat whether it's Moulton or Markey.

SPEAKER_00And if Moulton wins and then becomes senator, he's not going to make the Democratic Party so much more center left or move the party to the right incrementally enough to change its nature in a way that will test the sort of, I call it popularist or moderate theory of like why Democrats are losing winnable races and how to move them kind of culturally closer to the center. So I don't think that it's much of a test case. For the theory in that sense.

SPEAKER_00I see it as sort of having the same lowest stakes of the Goldman Lander primary that we just talked about, but with the valence reverse rate, like Goldman lost to somebody challenging him from the left. Markey faces a challenge that I think he's going to win from his right. And what I find striking about this race is that you see that the The establishment in the party, the centrist faction in the party, they're miffed about situations like the Lander-Goldman situation where

SPEAKER_00a leftist challenger emerges, they have allies in DSA or on the progressive wing of the Democratic Party, they all rally behind that person, that person wins, and it moves the party further to the left. And here you have an opportunity, right, for the Those moderns do the opposite thing, right? Like really try to rally to make Seth Moulton happen. But like, I don't see it. Like I looked up because I was writing about this earlier this week or last week

SPEAKER_00to try to ascertain how much Insurgent, counterinsurgent, moderate and centrist support Moulton has to sort of oust an incumbent senator. And they're not showing up for him, really. I mean, they're giving him money, and he's got some endorsements, for sure, from, like, unions in Massachusetts. But, like, you do not see Jared Golden on the stump for Seth Moulton in Massachusetts, which is, like, he's retiring, like, He could cross the border from Maine and try to help.

SPEAKER_00They could try to build a groundswell. And they are not showing up for their own people in the same way that progressives are, but they could do it. It probably would not be the same kind of enthusiastic populist-seeming, big crowds thing that progressives can do because progressivism is a more aspirational ideology than moderatism or whatever. But they could try, and they're just not doing it. And I feel like if you're going to get mad at what the progressives are doing

SPEAKER_00because you feel like it's making it harder to beat their challengers, then why not show up for Moulton and just kind of even the score? That's my main take on the Moulton-Markey situation. I agree with you that part of the reason Moulton is... He's struggling a bit to the extent that he's struggling. I have not looked at the polling in that race in a few days. Moulton is an imperfect vessel for this reverse primary from the right model.

SPEAKER_00He is younger, which should be an asset because Markey is quite old. And he is more conservative than Markey, which is what the centrists or moderates want. But he's a pretty eccentric guy. Yeah. He has a history of attention-seeking behavior that has not worn well with party leaders, really anyone, right? He mounted a challenge to Nancy Pelosi for speaker with no theory of the case and no... And I think as a result, like,

SPEAKER_00He went away whatever power the Blue Dawn faction might have had to extract some concessions or whatever. He also did this covert fly-in, if I'm remembering right, to Afghanistan with a Republican, also former military guy, during the Afghanistan evacuation that turned into a security problem because they didn't tell anyone And suddenly you have these congressmen in danger and resources had to be diverted to assure their safety.

SPEAKER_00It has not made him a lot of friends. And so he was probably, I don't know offhand who else would have been available to challenge Ed Markey from the right as a younger candidate. But Moulton was not like, he was going to have a hard time. Okay. Okay. Elliot from Notes asks, what did you make of Mamdani's subtly subversive answer about the Democratic Big Ten in his New York Times interview? Yes, I read that. Yes, full stop. This is Mamdani.

SPEAKER_00Yes, full stop. I'm not interested in expelling people from parties. I think that's what you do when you can't win the debate within the party. Elliot goes on, he seems to be saying that he doesn't need to expel moderates because the left is going to win the internal argument and make moderates junior partners in its coalition. Do you also interpret him as saying that? I don't think so. I think that's a little bit of an overread.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Real Reason Democrats Fear Accountability Politics

    Nov 11, 202630 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net Last day to take advantage of this post-election discount. Things are starting to get real. I hope you’ll join us. Happy Veterans Day...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Lindsey Graham’s Prophecy Finally Came True

    Nov 5, 202620 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net Thanks to the many hundreds of you who watched live. Many new horizons just opened, so we’ll be covering a bunch of unexpected terrain...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Limits Of The Possible In 2027

    Oct 15, 20266 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net Last video mailbag before the election. We’ll reconvene shortly afterward. Thanks to everyone who tuned in live. And for subscribers that...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Socialism Of Fools

    Oct 9, 202635 minAudio

    Had a good live chat Thursday with my pal Alex Wagner, covering the whole political waterfront. Special thanks to all who watched or listened live. In order we discussed: * Is veganism any weirder than eating...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Affordability Mirage, A.I. Safety, And The Collapse Of Sacred Assumptions

    Sep 21, 202638 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net The veteran progressive policy hand Bharat Ramamurti joined me Friday for a long and in depth conversation about two issues confounding...

    Credit the people on this episode