Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Off Message

Off Message artwork

Lindsey Graham’s Prophecy Finally Came True

Nov 5, 202620 minAudio

This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net Thanks to the many hundreds of you who watched live. Many new horizons just opened, so we’ll be covering a bunch of unexpected terrain over the coming days, weeks, months, and even years. If you’ve ever thought about signing up, or have been a member in the past, intending to return at some point, I want to make pulling the trigger a little easier now that so many big changes are coming. Your readership keeps me fulfilled. Just this week, through a dense fog of exhaustion, we hit Trump accountability, billionaire taxes, the problem of the New York Times, a potential head start on democracy reform, right-wing conspiracy theories, and the post-election future of A.I. In response to queries from people who prefer reading to watching or listening, I’ve also copy-pasted the auto-generated transcript below the fold. Apologies for the lack of formatting - maybe I’ll vibecode an app that renders it in a less choppy way. Thanks for riding through history with me.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Alright, welcome people. I'm going to give it one second. Hey John, how are you doing? I should call out more people who I know in real life when I see them. When I see them join. Okay, that's enough. Hey everyone, it's Brian from Off Message. We're doing the live mailbag, I guess a day early, but I'll publish the video on Thursday, so the schedule's normal. And now we have election results, and they were very good.

SPEAKER_00And so I have a bunch of great questions from the thread, which I posted before the election, and many of them are still, you know, relevant. So I guess I can start there. But since kind of a lot's happened since then, if people want to drop new questions that they have in the chat, I will try to kind of toggle back and forth or something and aim to go for about an hour. And I'm just going, I'm coming in cold because I've been, you know, pretty busy with the election stuff. But I'm just going to start from the top and work my way down.

SPEAKER_00So the first question was about Abdul El-Sayed and Haley Stevens, but then retracted after the Michigan Democratic Party kicked Haley Stevens out. So... So nothing about Haley Stevens, but there's a follow up which says, what is Mallory McMorrow's future? I think she got pushed out of the race by fake polling and has comported herself really well in the election since. So with the benefit of perfect hindsight,

SPEAKER_00I think Democratic Senate recruiting and Senate tactical decisions are I mean, obviously still pretty good. The election was a historic landslide, but, you know, it was so big that it has, I think it's fair to say it had very little to do with things like what kind of ads candidates run, how much money was spent where, right? This was a realignment of the electorate, right? So that overwhelms everything. And, but, you know,

SPEAKER_00And you can see that with a little bit more money here and there, some races that didn't go over with the wave probably could have used a bit more money than Texas, which turned out to have way too much. You know, right? Like if James Tallarico is winning by 12, you could do all kinds of things there. He could have beat John Cornyn. He could have won with way less money. He could have, you know, endorsed... Transgender surgery is for everybody and still won.

SPEAKER_00Like, it was that kind of environment. And so, but, you know, you can't really fault Chuck Schumer for not anticipating that. But I do think you can fault him for endorsing Haley Stevens when... Mallory McMorrow was there for the plucking, right? She is more charismatic. She was not next in line. I don't know enough about her electoral performance, but Haley Stevens' was not good before this. She was not a particularly gifted electoral performer.

SPEAKER_00So that was bizarre. And... And I think, you know, I am very happy with how the Michigan race came out. So it's not like I'm saying it would be better if it were this way. But I think if if he had just stayed out. I'm not sure Stevens even gets in, but McMorrow probably wins that primary. And then all the stuff that happened at the end of the election just doesn't come to pass. Whether she has a future in the party, I think is it's very hard to see.

SPEAKER_00The election result changed a lot. It will probably change who chooses to run for president. It brought a whole bunch of new talent into the party. We're going to find out over the course of the next couple of years who should run next time Michigan has an open Senate seat or whatever. I just don't know. She comported herself extremely well after losing that primary and then through all the sabotage that Haley Stevens tried to bring.

SPEAKER_00And I think that that speaks super well of her and to the extent that there are, you know, jobs available in the next presidency. You know what I mean? Yeah. She should not be forgotten for everything that happened, from the fake polls that screwed her over to Schumer's shitty choices to her conduct. I think she, like, multiple gold stars. Okay. What do you think the first Dem accountability priority should be?

SPEAKER_00So... But I think that they can start today. I mean, it gets hard when they take over because there's so many different committees. You can do a bunch of things at once. And also, you know, for me to say then like Jared Kushner versus Elon Musk, it's like really hard to pick. But I think it would be a good idea for Democrats to begin signaling things like

SPEAKER_00the ballroom is never going to be built. Period. Like, we can't file that lawsuit until we take over, but it's coming. And while it's pending, we're going to defund it in appropriations, you know. And if you contributed to the demolition of the East Wing and the construction of the ballroom, we're going to get that stuff. So that's not, you know, the most important accountability item they have, but it's something that they can start with, right? I also think that... That states can, to the extent that their procedures allow it,

SPEAKER_00and this requires getting a little bit granular, states like Virginia and New York and the people who just won in states where there will be new trifectives can start getting their effects in order to restart the gerrymandering process. Not necessarily because it's going to be seen through to the end, but to basically... Sooner than later make Republicans in Congress a proposition like let's do national nonpartisan gerrymandering now in a way

SPEAKER_00that Donald Trump can't sabotage and take that off the plate of a future Democratic president who needs to do broader democracy reforms or we're going to gerrymander the bejesus out of the states that we want in the states that we didn't get around to last time. Yeah. And so you make the threat credible by starting now. There's just like if you're creative enough, you can come up with a lot of ideas. So I guess just the umbrella would be don't they should not be thinking

SPEAKER_00about what what they'll do on January 4th. They should be thinking about what they should have said when they won their elections last night or what they'll say tomorrow with the benefit of a little bit of sleep or something like that. But yeah, they should basically set the chessboard now. Okay. Bill asks, I've read you call for the need to tax the bejesus out of the wealthy

SPEAKER_00to help remedy impending federal debt issues, not to mention to deal with wealth inequality. Yet I look at California's Proposition 40, the one-time billionaire tax, and how the state's political elite, Newsom Becerra, Karen Bass, have lined up against it. Our two senators were noncommittal. Without the open corruption in one party and mere lip service to change from the other, where do you see this heading? A worse than Trump authoritarian, a French style revolution. It I agree with the sentiment totally. Prop 40, I believe went down so

SPEAKER_00There will not be a one-time billionaire tax in California. I would have voted for it. And I think that your instincts are right. We should wonder whether the people who oppose this in California would really be all for it if you had some sort of national initiative to tax wealth of the ultra-wealthy. But not necessarily. And here's the thing. I wrote about this in a newsletter a few weeks back, a mailbag, I think. You can go look it up.

SPEAKER_00That bill, I'm sorry, that ballot initiative was not perfect. I mean, there was no way to do it great because A, there's a problem with the fact that it's a statewide wealth tax and If you're very rich, you can move. Now, the way this measure was structured sort of deterred the tech billionaires from just up and leaving because it was retroactive to this year, which is almost over. So they're going to fuck off to Lake Tahoe in Nevada or whatever, but still have to pay the tax.

SPEAKER_00Why would they go to the trouble? But in principle, the problem with statewide wealth taxes is that if you're very rich, it's trivial to just move around. And that is much less of a problem if you have a national tax. And so I think the question is like, To what extent was the California establishment opposition to that about the practicality of a state-level tax versus

SPEAKER_00about what they think should happen to billionaires? And I don't think it's totally clear. And also, I think that the economic conditions that Democrats are likely to inherit in two years are going to make some more radical ideas almost inevitable. And so, yeah, I wouldn't sweat it too much just because the California thing went down and it went down in part

SPEAKER_00because prominent California Democrats opposed it. I just don't think it's... I don't think it follows from that that Democrats won't be able to do a big high-end tax increase when they come in, in part because they'll be under real fiscal pressure to do it, and in part because, as you say, the political demand for it is crazy. But the election went so well nationally that I'm interested to see how the oligarchy responds, right?

SPEAKER_00And that could bolster the case for Trump. Could turn on them. Things could get completely crazy. Okay, let's see The electorate wants stuff, says no, not me. It costs 5% to borrow money. Are the people who just won control of Congress prepared to re-liberalize to grow the economy? The low-hanging fruit is repeal of tariffs and unblocking the undocumented labor supply.

SPEAKER_00Are they prepared to even do that? What else are they prepared to do to liberalize, to grow the economy, to pay for stuff? What should they be preparing to do? Yeah. So the tariffs is a big thing. I obviously have no idea how long Trump's He's not acting sane, but like his slightly subdued tone is going to last because, you know, he's a predator. And so he'll eventually start doing reckless things. But there's going to be a debt limit that has to be increased.

SPEAKER_00And so there will be an opportunity to do a real high stakes economic reform. Right. And so that could include restrictions on tariffs, which I think will have pretty significant bipartisan buy in after last night. Yeah. And it can include other things, right? Like if you restore the Obamacare subsidies, you know, that's not bringing costs down in like a disinflationary or deflationary kind of way, but it makes people's pocketbooks feel heavier.

SPEAKER_00And yeah, you know, I do think that there's a permitting reform bill that's basically ready to go that I think is basically a pretty good bill. And That would, over time, lower people's energy costs. All they have to do is pass it. It's sitting there. I think that the leadership, if nothing else, wants to be seen as attentive to people's pocketbook issues much more so than

SPEAKER_00Anti-corruption, backward-looking accountability stuff, which I think is a mistake on the politics and on the, like, what is most important for the future of the country score, but that's where their head's at. And so, yeah, I think that they will use a lot of clout to try to do things that Both reduce inflationary pressures, right? And also get money out to people so that people can get that stuff

SPEAKER_00that you rightly point out they want. All right, Brendan in comment says, hi, Brian, I'm writing a letter to my new rep, Sam Forstag. If you were me, what would you want to tell him? I wrote just before coming on, I published a new piece. It's for subscribers only. There's a preview. But I hope folks will read it. That's more about the new state reps, but it follows.

SPEAKER_00Now is the time to express to newly elected leaders an expectation that bygones won't be bygones, that conflict isn't to be avoided, that a lot of bad things that did a lot of harm to the country happened. And There has to be pressure brought to bear on the leadership not to bypass a lot of it for whatever it is, making the party seem more attentive to kitchen table issues and that you expect him not

SPEAKER_00to Just give away his vote to Hakeem Jeffries to be Speaker for free. Now look, they're going to come in with something like 258 members. Jeffries is going to win the Speakership. But there should be whatever it is, 40-ish. Democrats in this new caucus who are willing to say, hey, I am concerned that you are taking the gas off accountability already. And that's not okay. So we need some enforceable commitments from you.

SPEAKER_00That can be commitments in the rules to give the oversight and judiciary and Homeland Security Committee chairs free reign. Staff for investigative work. I mean, that's a start. There's also, you know, they should be putting together a national nonpartisan gerrymandering bill right now to present to Republicans

SPEAKER_00as a take it or leave it proposition. And I think there's a decent chance Republicans will take it given the damage Democrats can now do If they restart the recriminations from Trump's gerrymandering blitz, then Trump might veto it. But if there's a veto-proof majority, they can override it. And if not, the Democrats in the states need to go ahead with the gerrymanders. But one thing you could tell them is get moving on that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And, and that's not, you know, it's not like accountability and the like digging for dirt stuff, but it's, it's important and get getting it, getting it done now is a real down payment on the kind of democracy reforms that are gonna be necessary in 2029. David, I'm sorry if I pronounce it wrong, Miesk or Mieski asks what the odds are that the newly damned Senate will abolish

SPEAKER_00the filibuster during the session despite not being in a trifecta. I know you wrote about this several months ago as just something to show resolve and kind of get out of the way for future legislative action. Yeah, there is a case for not doing it, right? Like the future is unwritten. And it would be a real own goal if they did it during divided government. Trump vetoed all the bills that they passed with their majority rules votes. And then they lost everything in two years.

SPEAKER_00And so then Republicans came back and were able to use, you know, they wouldn't have to abolish the filibuster themselves. It would already be done for them. I think that's extremely unlikely given how last night went. Like, I don't know what kind of catastrophe would have to befall the Democratic Party for them to lose the Senate after this. So yeah, I mean, my preference would be for them to just do it. I think that the odds of them doing it are medium. I mean, higher than they've ever been in the past, still less than 50%. They're not going to want to do it.

SPEAKER_00They desperately still don't want to get caught being pugnacious with Republicans. But If their economic agenda and their oversight efforts run into obstruction, such that the only way to get accountability or to get Trump to stop breaking the law is to defund an agency or something like that, but Republicans can still just filibuster that in the Senate,

SPEAKER_00then Then I can imagine them just being like, screw it, we're doing it. We can't let the filibuster be the way Republicans allow this crime spree to continue. And so, yeah, I'll call it 32%. But I wouldn't be surprised either way. I could see both paths. Matt Colbert or Colbert. I don't know.

SPEAKER_00I love his questions, though. With how crappy The New York Times political coverage has been over the past 10 years, I'm wondering if there's an opportunity for some elite dems to get together and send the gray lady a message. Don't get me wrong. The time does great reporting. I'm a subscriber. But from Hillary's emails to is Elon Musk really conservative to bizarre decisions about what not to cover, it's getting pretty untenable. What if someone like Jamie Raskin or Chris Van Hollen came out and said, you know, the New York Times depends on the Democratic primary electorate to keep them economically viable.

SPEAKER_00Our folks are the only ones subscribing to newspapers these days. At some point, we need to have a conversation about what the heck is going on at the Times. So I wrote about this basic thing when they went all in in Alaska to try to seemingly they just decided that they wanted to try to pick off Mary Peltola in it.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Real Reason Democrats Fear Accountability Politics

    Nov 11, 202630 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net Last day to take advantage of this post-election discount. Things are starting to get real. I hope you’ll join us. Happy Veterans Day...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Limits Of The Possible In 2027

    Oct 15, 20266 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net Last video mailbag before the election. We’ll reconvene shortly afterward. Thanks to everyone who tuned in live. And for subscribers that...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Socialism Of Fools

    Oct 9, 202635 minAudio

    Had a good live chat Thursday with my pal Alex Wagner, covering the whole political waterfront. Special thanks to all who watched or listened live. In order we discussed: * Is veganism any weirder than eating...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Affordability Mirage, A.I. Safety, And The Collapse Of Sacred Assumptions

    Sep 21, 202638 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net The veteran progressive policy hand Bharat Ramamurti joined me Friday for a long and in depth conversation about two issues confounding...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Why Did Democrats Leave The Hegseth Impeachment Plan To Thomas Massie?!

    Sep 17, 20261 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net Thank you to everyone who tuned in live. We’ll do one more of these before the midterm

    Credit the people on this episode