The Affordability Mirage, A.I. Safety, And The Collapse Of Sacred Assumptions
38 minAudio
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net The veteran progressive policy hand Bharat Ramamurti joined me Friday for a long and in depth conversation about two issues confounding Democratic Party assumptions about governing and politics: The cost of living, and the nature of advanced artificial intelligence technology. We pegged our conversation to Bharat’s recent article, “The Affordability Mir…
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Hey, everyone. I'm Brian Beutler. I write the Off Message newsletter, and I am here with my pal Bharat Ramamurti, who writes The Bully Pulpit. And we've been talking about doing another one of these for a while. And then he wrote a piece recently called The Affordability Mirage that I thought we both thought would be perfect to sort of reconvene our discussion. And I... I want to kick it to you, I think.
SPEAKER_01Let me do it this way. Let me read... A section of your piece that I think will situate us, and then you can tell us a little bit more about it. So you sort of start the piece this way, right? Let's say that a sequence of events come to pass and our new Democratic president declares the following at their second State the Union address in 2030. Under my leadership, we've tackled the biggest costs facing American families. As a share of disposable income, the cost of groceries is now the lowest it's been in 30 years.
SPEAKER_01Average rental prices in the 50 largest metro areas have declined three years straight. And growing incomes and improving fuel efficiency mean gas is taking up less of the family budget than it did before the inflation spike of 2021. We have more work to do, but the cost of living crisis is behind us. This president will be wildly popular in cruising toward a strong midterm performance in reelection, right? I doubt it. Because all of those affordability claims describe the situation today. And yet, consumer sentiment is in the toilet.
SPEAKER_01Everyone thinks everything is too expensive. What did you conclude about this, and why did you write the piece?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so, you know, for folks who don't know, I spent three years in the Biden White House working at the National Economic Council. And we would always put out these data points about how, because incomes were growing, Even though we were seeing a big spike in costs, people were actually coming out ahead, right? There wasn't actually this crunch happening because growing incomes were absorbing a lot of the higher costs that people were facing. And it was wildly unsuccessful. People were understandably very frustrated about the economic circumstances,
SPEAKER_00very concerned about the cost of living. And all of that has persisted and in fact gotten worse under the Trump administration. But again, if you look at the economic data as I laid out in that little intro piece that you read, Even today, even with all of the ridiculous things that the Trump administration has done to raise the cost of gas, to raise the cost of goods through tariffs and so on, the affordability story based on the data is still not that bad compared to times the past. And yet the cost of living is the top concern,
SPEAKER_00actually a higher concern today than it was in 2022 when inflation was 9% year over year. So... I don't doubt that there are affordability concerns and there's obviously costs other than housing and gas and so on. But if you look at the data on personal satisfaction, optimism, trust in government, there's actually a two decade story here. That's really the thesis of my piece. You go back to 2006, roughly speaking.
SPEAKER_00Since 2006, every single year that they've polled people, what percentage of you trust the government to do the right thing most of the time? That number has been under 25% for 20 years straight. And it was 50% as high as in 2000. It was 80% in the 1960s. The percentage of people who feel that their kids will be better off financially than they are, it's 25%. It used to be 50% in 2000. It was 75%. So, the title of my piece, The Affordability Mirage,
SPEAKER_00The thesis is basically, yes, we should focus on affordability and trying to address these costs that are obviously being recognized by people as a big concern. But there's a deeper frustration here that predates any of these inflation issues that we've been dealing with for the last five years. And I think it's really important for Democrats, the party that I'm part of, to try to not just address affordability narrowly, but try to address this broader problem, this broader decline in pessimism
SPEAKER_00I think only then can we really say that we're turning things around and addressing the fundamental problems that people have. So just one more point on this. What do I think is actually driving it if it's not just purely cost of living issues? I make the point in my piece that I think a lot of it is inequality. You know, there's a really robust academic literature showing that countries that are more unequal are more unhappy. And that is true if you look at historical data within the United States.
SPEAKER_00It's true if you look at cross-country data as you compare inequality in the United States to Western Europe and Asia and so on. This is a very consistent finding. And basically what they find is that as inequality goes from basically, let's say if zero inequality goes up a little bit, people actually get happier because they say, oh, you know, it's possible to move up the ladder, right? I see people who have more than me, but it feels attainable to me for me to be on that path. So, for me...
SPEAKER_00Part of it is addressing affordability, yes, but part of it's also got to be addressing this massive pre-tax inequality problem that we have in the United States where for every dollar that we generate, more and more of it is going to a very narrow slice of people at the very top of the income distribution.
SPEAKER_01So let me talk about sort of like our big picture agreement. And it spans both the concept of the affordability mirage. And I think basically everything that you proposed, both on the direct cost of living side and then on the inequality side, I think that we are basically... I think the most important thing we can do right now, people in our position, is to convince Democratic policymakers and even Democratic messengers
SPEAKER_01and strategists that the mirage is a real thing. I still hear from pollsters and the consultants who've used their polls. I heard this in my crooked media days. I hear it now that inflation... Explains everything, and they know that's true because they heard people say it in focus groups, right? Like, you ask people, you know, what's going on? What do you think about politics? What do you think about the situation in America? And they come back with this answer, and that tells them that fixing the problem really is a mechanical matter of getting
SPEAKER_01the prices down or at least, you know, getting their real wages or something up to where they're saving money again even if the sticker prices didn't fall. And I don't think that that is likely to be true, right? And part of the reason I think it's unlikely to be true is that after the inflation spike in the binary, you had something like that, you know? Real wages outpaced inflation.
SPEAKER_01The economy was doing really well, right? And people were getting madder and madder and madder about it instead of less and less and less mad. And so... Obviously, I think that if a Democrat comes to power in 2029, ideally with control of Congress as well, they should do the direct affordability things. And to me, those are things like, obviously, get rid of the tariffs, like change the tariff regime so that it can't be abused in the way Trump has abused it.
SPEAKER_01Tax the bejesus out of extremely rich people to get inflation and interest rates down. Give people back the healthcare that Trump took away. Give people back their SNAP benefits. Pass another supply-side bill on housing, probably. You should just do those most because they're good, right? But you really should not bank all of your political hopes and aspirations on the idea that that will fix the malaise. Yes. Because... Because when elements of those things were coming into place, it didn't work.
SPEAKER_01And then, you know, like, it's not like Trump has done some things to make the problems, those problems worse. Like Biden was getting things under control and then Trump instituted policies that re-exacerbated them, right? And so I think it makes some sense that you would see Some, you know, some discontent in the polling about him, right? That makes sense to me.
SPEAKER_01But what you see instead is people thinking a economic status quo at the end of 2024 that was quite good, they thought that that was like a recession or a Great Depression. And now, even though it's a little worse, they think it's much worse. And that means to me that there is a, Policy is not what people are responding to. Immediate term policy is not what they're responding to. And you need some sort of more capacious vision. If you want to solve that problem so that you can do a better job of making
SPEAKER_01the public happy with how you're governing, it's not going to be taking these survey data returns and focus group returns entirely literally, right? There's something else happening.
SPEAKER_00I think it's just important to situate all of this in the last 30 or 40 years of economic policy in this country, which, broadly speaking, has seen an erosion of the rights of working people and an expansion of the rights of corporations. Starting in the Reagan era, corporations have gotten more and more power and more rights, and you've seen their share. There's this concept called the labor share of income and the capital share of income. For every dollar, what percentage goes to capital, what percentage goes to labor? And, you know, it's a tricky measurement question and people dispute some of the elements of this.
SPEAKER_00But broadly speaking, the share of every dollar that's generated that goes to labor has gone down steadily for the last 40 plus years. And more and more of that has gone to capital. Now, you could say you can solve that with taxes. And I support changing our taxes on capital income, wealth tax and so on to try to solve some of those issues on the back end. But I think what people are responding to more than anything is the changes on the front end. I think people would rather that they get more labor share of income in
SPEAKER_00the first instance rather than getting less and less and then getting tax credits from the government to make up for that. Even if financially it comes out the same way, there's something psychological, and I think about dignity, about feeling like you have power and control over your life, about Feeling like your job values you properly. All of that goes into getting that first cut of that dollar before it goes into the pockets of shareholders and executives and so on.
SPEAKER_00And so Democrats have been talking about these concepts for a long time. The PRO Act, so it's easier to unionize. Getting rid of non-compete agreements so that corporations can't limit your ability to go find a better paying job. You know, even broader concepts of worker power, you know, sectoral bargaining, workers on corporate boards. There are lots of ideas that lots of other You know, highly developed Western democracies adopt. In fact, I would say it's commonplace in those other countries.
SPEAKER_00We have none of those things in the United States. And you've, as a result, seen this decline in the labor share of income. And I just think that what I worry about is, as you said, every single pollster and every single consultant in America is telling their candidate, just talk about the cost of living every day. And I might not even dispute that as an effective campaigning approach. But if you then come to office, the Democrats win in 2028, and they do only the things that you described, which are good things that will help relieve some of the pressure on family budgets,
SPEAKER_00I still think that there won't be a big political reward there, right? That's why I call it the mirage, right? People will go towards those solutions and find that it's actually illusory at the end. And I really think it's important. I actually think for campaigning, it's important That somebody articulate a broader vision that's not just, I'm going to bring down your costs, but is rather, especially, and we'll get to this with the explosion of AI and some of these other things, saying, we want to restore more control over your life. We want to give you more control over your career.
SPEAKER_00We want to make sure that for every dollar that you produce as a worker, you get a bigger share of that. So I want to believe that...
SPEAKER_01That your theory of the case is right, and that if Democrats enacted that program as opposed to the more direct bringing sticker prices down or bringing real wages or real income up, the numbers would come back into alignment, right?
SPEAKER_00And I'm not here to say that I'm confident that you're wrong,
SPEAKER_01but I still don't quite think it tells the story that I see in the data. I take the data that you cite in your piece showing what you call it, malaise. It's a trend. It's over 20 years. You can see it. The reason I'm concerned that a pre-tax, pre-distribution agenda would fix this problem any more than a You know,
SPEAKER_01post-distribution agenda is two things. One is that there was compression of inequality briefly in the Biden period. And like people kind of hated it. At the very least, it did not offset the general trajectory of sentiment during his presidency. So that's the narrow one. The other is that, you know, I can grok the 20 years of kind of increasing pessimism.
SPEAKER_01I think it's maybe even particularly acute among people around my age, right? Because... Every generation is kind of sold. It's like, work hard, play by the rules, go to college, you know, and then you will become more prosperous, the country will become more prosperous. And I think to a lot of people my age, that translated in our heads to jobs we like, thus the ability to afford a house. You know, the good life as we kind of imagined it in maybe a fictionalized way.
SPEAKER_01And that what What we've gotten is a form of prosperity that is like, you can get sushi in any strip mall in any part of America, and you can get craft coffee on every main street, right? But houses are not cheaper. They're more, you know, it's much harder to get a house. And if that had been the deal as presented 20 or 30 years ago, people have been like, that doesn't sound like what I'm going to want.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_01I'm gonna want, like, the ability to take vacations and save for retirement and have a family and, you know, and so as the picture began to emerge over those 20 years, like, I know, because I felt that even though my life has been quite, you know, like, a blessing, right, that the deal was not as I had conceived it. And this is a common sentiment among my peers, even, like, reasonably affluent ones. Yeah. But then... Like around 2021,
SPEAKER_01something much more abrupt happened, which is that throughout that whole 20 years, despite people saying these things about how their children are not going to do as well as they did and so on, throughout that whole period, consumer sentiment basically tracked what you would expect it to track based on what GDP numbers were, what What labor market numbers showed, what inflation showed, right? And then that correlation just cracked apart, like very dramatically and abruptly.
SPEAKER_01And I don't think that you can tell a 20-year-long story about that. I don't think it's like it pent up and pent up and pent up and pent up and then suddenly in 2021, everyone was like, I'm done. I'm like, everything's bad and I'm just gonna say it's bad. And so it makes me worry that looking for any, whether it's post-tax or pre-tax, any economic answer to this question, why did Americans suddenly start thinking that everything was terrible in the country? Is going to work, that there is also like a mediagenic component to what happened.
SPEAKER_01And I think that there can be like, like a lot of the things that you said, I think can be just as easily explained in a mediagenic framework. Like you're talking, you described it as an inequality phenomenon where people see how much wealth at the top Like correlates to like a better quality of life and it's kind of everywhere. But like I think that they see that on their phones, right? Like if you live in a place that's been kind of stagnant for a while,
SPEAKER_01All your neighbors are dealing with that stagnation too. And you probably don't get this sense that like, wow, like all my neighbors are doing better and I'm being left behind. But when you look at your phone and it's like Jake Paul in a Ferrari and you think he's this really cool guy. Right. You realize that there's this world out there of people just like gobbling up money and like living this dream life. And that can create the psychological... Break that you were describing as a pure artifact of inequality economics.
SPEAKER_01And obviously, like, what you're saying is true about the inequality, but it's like we've developed parasocial relationships with people who are fabulously wealthy, and it's making us think, why can't I have that? Sure. And, you know, like, I tell this story... I think, you know, one thing that happened is the internet broke the economics of media about 20 years ago. And then the correlation still held between macro data
SPEAKER_01and consumer sentiment throughout most of the next 20 years. And then, as I said, in 2021 or so, it fell apart. The correlation fell apart. I think that the second thing that happened is that Very rapidly accelerated by COVID. People started getting their sense of things, both about how Jake Paul lives his life, but just everything from like short form video on their phones. And when I was a kid,
SPEAKER_01like 16, 17, I knew that like the economy was experiencing a boom, the Clinton boom. Yep. Because when I would, like, one of my parents would drive me to school or one of my friend's parents would drive me to school and, like, AM news radio would be on and every 15 minutes they'd do the market report and be like, you know, another record day on Wall Street. And so, like, The same information, there were only a handful of places where people got economic news.
SPEAKER_01They were all saying mostly the same thing. It was all mostly rooted in facts and good data, some of which came from the government, some of which came from the private sector. And there wasn't this very loud counter story that like, oh, no, actually everything's terrible. Now we live in a time where most of the information people are being bombarded with is telling them that everything's terrible. And they don't get a consistent read of what's actually happening. And so you get this phenomenon where in those same polls where they're saying everything's terrible,
SPEAKER_01they will say that their personal circumstances are actually all right. But that they think that beyond the horizon, things are really bad. And so... It's not that I'm trying to argue that Democrats should come to power and not do the things that you said, because I think that they're good ideas. But I think that they have to go a step further, too, and start thinking about, like, why do we have this crisis of epistemics in the United States? And, like, actually around the world, right? Like, one of the things that makes me attracted to this theory is that
SPEAKER_01the whole world's kind of going crazy and electing these, like, meme-ish, you know, politicians who On the basis of how they vibe on the internet. Maybe that problem can't be solved, but we should aim for a sort of kind of solidary project of trying to get everyone back on the same page about what's real in the world. And that if we don't do that, then we might have an insoluble problem.
SPEAKER_01And it's really just like... How can you get the phones to say nice things instead of doerish things? Yes. And so I want to throw that back to you to hear whether you disagree or whether you think that I'm overreading or whether you think that these analyses can be synthesized.
SPEAKER_00I would. So I agree, but I still hold on to my argument and I'll explain why. So I agree that the combination of Yeah. We're a traumatic thing, and it takes time to process that and live through that.
SPEAKER_00In the same way that it takes an individual person time to do that, I think it takes time for a country to do that when you go through a traumatic set of events like that. I think we're still working through that. And I don't doubt that phones exacerbate these problems. What I think is notable is that there's heavy social media usage in a lot of other countries. Every other country lived through COVID and an economic downturn and a recession and an inflation spike. In fact, many other countries had worse outcomes on both COVID and on dealing with inflation.
SPEAKER_00But you don't see the kind of sharp decline in these metrics of happiness and so on that you do in the United States. And I think that the distinguishing factor is the level of inequality that we have. You know, we have the highest level of wealth inequality in the entire OECD. We're leaps and bounds ahead of any other country. On income inequality, the only country, OECD country, that's worse than ours is Chile. We're ahead of everybody else in terms of income inequality. And so, yes, people in other countries are consuming short-form media.
SPEAKER_00They're always on their phones. I'm sure that the news media is very negative. It's certainly the case in the UK when I've been there. They're negative everywhere because negativity sells. But what distinguishes it is that the acute level of inequality in the United States makes all of those experiences worse, in my view. And so, yeah, I think we got to deal with these problems holistically. And I don't think any one of these things is a silver bullet. But what I feel confident about is that a very narrow affordability agenda is unlikely to be The silver bullet is unlikely
SPEAKER_00to end up saying that lifts us out of this malaise. And, you know, one of the points that I made in my piece, which, you know, I'm a history guy, but it was important to me. If you go back to the founders, right, and what they thought the goal of government was in the United States, it wasn't just let's provide material prosperity to Americans, right? They were very informed by John Locke and by Aristotle and this concept that As Aristotle wrote about it, that the concept of government, the purpose of government is to help the citizens lead happy, fulfilling lives.
SPEAKER_00And that's where Jefferson got the pursuit of happiness line in the Declaration of Independence. And Madison talked about how the purpose of government was to deliver safety and happiness to its people. And so I think that there's a strain of thinking among some people in the Democratic Party that says, look, We got to deliver material prosperity. We got to keep pushing incomes up. We got to keep pushing costs down. And that's our job. And happiness, fulfillment, those are things that are up to religion, community, family, and so on.
SPEAKER_00Those are outside the purview of government. I think it's really important that we view the purpose of government as creating the conditions in which people feel fulfilled. I also think it's important for political success because there's Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And trying to harness all those feelings that I talked about, the resentment, the despair that you see in the data on highly unequal countries. And so this is not a four-year project. I view it as basically a counter-Reaganism project that's going to take many years to unfold. But I think the goal has to be trying to Address some of the fundamental unfairnesses in our economy that, yes, you know, are about the cost of, that will lead to good outcomes on the cost of housing and the cost
SPEAKER_00of these other things. But I think part of it, as you also said, is that, you know, there are a lot of things even beyond housing where you're competing for a limited set of goods. Like your favorite music act is in town doing a concert. You know, you want to go to a baseball game. You want to go to Disney World. All of those things have basically been bid up Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_00When your favorite act comes to town, people are feeling priced out and excluded from those types of things, too. And I think that that has a psychological effect. And, you know, addressing inequality is one way of bringing that into control. You know, I think that you also need to have a much more robust government role in each of these things, right? Like, why are we so reliant on the private market to build 5 million additional homes? Like, yes, we can do zoning reform. Yes, we can make it easier for private developers to build.
SPEAKER_00But there was a time in this country where we would build, the government would build lots of housing in the places that it wanted to build more housing. You know, we can still do that on a quicker timeline and at lower costs than relying on the private market. So there's lots of other examples of trying to have a very muscular approach to delivering the kinds of economic outcomes that I think will help. But to your point, and I completely agree with it, you know, this is not just an economy story, right? There is a almost moral, As you said, epistemic crisis that we're dealing with.
SPEAKER_00And I think it is critically important that we deal with it. And I know that we're going to transition to an AI conversation, but I think the trends on AI are only going to exacerbate these problems unless we get a handle on them.
SPEAKER_01I will get us to the AI part of the conversation. What you were saying tracks a debate that is underway, or maybe it's over now, between Chris Murphy, who has a book on government sort of creating the conditions that allow people to pursue happiness, and some of his neoliberal critics who are basically like, people should not look to politics to find fulfillment. And I think they're kind of talking past each other like, Senator Murphy used some kind of evocative language like the cult of the common good.
SPEAKER_01And nobody wants to be in a cult, right? Well, some people do. And then I think because there is this debate underway, this factual debate within the party that some of his critics were quick to jump on that. But you can kind of see his side of the story prevailing in some sense. In this public rebellion against data centers, right? Because if the name of the game in politics,
SPEAKER_01if the way to win is just to increase prosperity everywhere you can, then building data centers, especially now where people have a lot of leverage over the technology industry to get them to You know, bring in a lot of revenue, pay for their own power, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. Like that would be a shoe. Like Donald Trump would be doing really well in the polls right now. But what you're finding is that people like this does not fit their image of what the good life.
SPEAKER_01Is to have their local economy subsidized by the data center that is using a lot of water, say, or is ugly. Or maybe they're a little bit more high-minded and high information about it. And they're like, this is powering the AI engine that is going to disemploy everyone in this town. And it's a danger to society or whatever. Why do I want to be a part of that? And so I do agree that...
SPEAKER_01That, like, if you think about the affordability mirage as a problem that you can kind of hack away at with pie wedges the way Al Gore used to visualize about, like, tackling climate change as opposed to, like, it's an epistemic problem and we're never going to solve it without fixing the phone problem. Then you definitely do want to do things like what you were describing. I think one big one that I'd add to your list... Is that this 20-year trend of pessimism spanned the Great Recession and then COVID, right?
SPEAKER_01And those were, I mean, I was just kind of new in the labor force when the Great Recession hit. I was, I guess, 25. And I was well into my career when COVID hit. And, you know... I'm doing fine. I'm not complaining, and I'm not one of the biggest worriers out there. But I don't know if the life I have mapped out for myself can survive a third shock like that.
SPEAKER_01And it strikes me as a reasonable hypothesis that part of the reason why pessimism is not as severe a problem in other countries is that they have robuster safety nets, right? And that if you were a Democratic president trying to fix the malaise problem, you would want to both communicate about it in this way and also provide the safety net so that you can say to people, like, we've all lived through the kinds of experiences that can completely derail your plans in life.
SPEAKER_01And my job as president, our job as a party, is to... Fix our system so that you will have the confidence that if another bad thing comes out of nowhere, you will be okay. And the fact that none of our politicians can say that honestly, but the politicians abroad can, probably goes some way to explain why this disparity exists. I want to say one more thing to segue us in the AI conversation about...
SPEAKER_01The difficulty in getting people to accept the affordability barrage thesis. And it's very frustrating to me because I've been on this like vibe session kick for several years now, right? And I have like a little community of wonks and nerds where we're all kind of on the same page about it. But broadly speaking, people on the left of center are really hostile to this idea, I think. Part of it is like what I was saying about people in democratic politics who want to trust the numbers.
SPEAKER_01Part of it is that there are in the like liberal and neoliberal wing of the party, there's like great desire to believe that the things we were talking about, like making sure GDP is good, making sure that the labor market is solid, were sort of like the skeleton keys to electoral success, right? Like if you get into power and you manage those things well, you're going to get reelected. And then on the left, there are a lot of people who believe politics resides downstream of economics and
SPEAKER_01that you need, you know, to forge working class solidarity, do, like, structure the government in a way that helps the broad middle and working class and not the rich. And if you do that, then politics is solved, right? Yeah. The hostility you get to the affordability mirage thesis I think comes from the fact that it is a kill shot at their fundamental assumptions that help them make sense of the world.
SPEAKER_01It's obviously not as dramatic or anything like that, but the rejection you get, the sort of reflexive, that's not true. Look at the housing numbers. Look at these numbers. Of course people are miserable. It's like, It's inspired by the same kind of terror that drove people to invent epicycles, right? You know, to sustain the assumption that the sun revolved around the earth and, like, let's throw Galileo in the house to rest for the rest of his life. And, like, that sounds like craziness to us today,
SPEAKER_01but if you try to place yourself in the shoes of people back then— And think how terrifying it must have been for the whole society to have to confront for the first time the possibility that humanity wasn't the center of the universe. Like, of course they freaked out about it. And I think that there's a similar, small-scale freak-out about the affordability mirage thesis. And I think we need to crack that. We need to figure out how to persuade people It is not a betrayal of any kind
SPEAKER_01of ideology to acknowledge that there's this problem here, this anomaly, that things are not working as we expected they would, but that we should be trying to get it back on track. And here are some ideas to do it. I think that it's probably an easier sell than, well, I don't know. There's something similar happening in the AI realm. And I have encountered a lot of,
SPEAKER_01ever since the Hugging Face attack and like kind of getting my head around what happened there, I've been writing more about AI as like a genuine, like a real thing that is a real destabilizing force in the world and possibly even worse than that. And I've encountered a lot of resistance to this. That it's all, this is like hype from a corrupt industry and any damage that's done is the result of their recklessness and not the technology itself being a genuine step change
SPEAKER_01in anything we've seen before. And I think they too are kind of struggling with Having to confront the possibility that this is real. This is happening. And it's easier to cling to the belief that no, this was all just a bunch of people who, for decent reasons maybe, we all think are terrible, like pulling another fast one to try to rip off the public or whatever.
SPEAKER_01And I'd like to hear your thoughts on If you want to talk more about the affordability side of it, sure, but about getting people to come to terms with scary ideas that are like right in front of us.
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net Last day to take advantage of this post-election discount. Things are starting to get real. I hope you’ll join us. Happy Veterans Day...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net Thanks to the many hundreds of you who watched live. Many new horizons just opened, so we’ll be covering a bunch of unexpected terrain...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net Last video mailbag before the election. We’ll reconvene shortly afterward. Thanks to everyone who tuned in live. And for subscribers that...
Had a good live chat Thursday with my pal Alex Wagner, covering the whole political waterfront. Special thanks to all who watched or listened live. In order we discussed: * Is veganism any weirder than eating...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net Thank you to everyone who tuned in live. We’ll do one more of these before the midterm