The Real Reason Democrats Fear Accountability Politics
30 minAudio
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net Last day to take advantage of this post-election discount. Things are starting to get real. I hope you’ll join us. Happy Veterans Day readers. I got to connect live yesterday with Pete Dominick to discuss my New Republic cover story about the limits of congressional accountability power, and divisions within the House and Senate Democratic caucuses over how aggressively to wield it against the Trump administration. One thing I was able to stress here, which I wish I’d thought to write explicitly in the piece, is that Democrats aren’t fearful of learning the whole truth about this criminal regime - they’re not stupid, they know derogatory information hurts Republicans. As I explained to Pete, they’re scared of the rocky road to discovery. We covered a lot of ground outside the four corners of the story, including progressive insurgencies past and future, the House GOP leadership election, the similarities and differences between Jim Jordan and Steve Scalise, Stephen Miller’s promotion to chief of staff, why the Jordan-Miller “barking mad” style of leadership is a poor fit for their jobs. One brief section that got overtaken by events: We recorded this before Republicans blocked Pete Hegseth’s impeachment, in a vote that ended in embarrassment for Democrats. But everything else holds up. I hope you’ll give it a watch or listen. For those who prefer to read, I’ve pasted a Claude-formatted version of the auto-generated transcript below the fold.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01All right, here we go.
SPEAKER_00We're live. Oh, yeah. The brilliant, the beautiful Brian Beutler and one of my favorite, if not one of the top, one of the top.
SPEAKER_01You gotta just say straight up favorite. Like there's no coming, you know.
SPEAKER_00I'll tell you who I like. It's just a lot of white guys. There's a lot of white guys I kind of came up with. But I mean, I love that you and Greg Sargent wrote this article. And I love that you guys have kind of a mutual respect for each other and a history because I think Greg and you, Brian, are two of the best. Let's put it that way, which I think gives a lot more weight to this article. You see how many people have already shared it. It's just out today. The New Republic, the cover story there. Let me see if I can share it just so people see what it looks like as they're walking in here. It's titled, Trump has a secret plan to evade accountability.
SPEAKER_00Will Dems defeat it and... Pretty big deal, pretty deep dive, and we're going to get into it. So who else do you like besides Greg, obviously? Who do you like to read and talk to? You've got a huge following now at Off Message. People get a lot of their information from. Who do you trust? Who do you think is credible?
SPEAKER_01I just spend all my time writing, and I don't have enough time to read. You know, Greg and I collaborated because we kind of came up in the same... We were both at different times, TPM alums, right? And so I still use TPM as like a major, major resource. Talking Points Memo, great.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01And then I was at the New Republic before he was at the New Republic and still have great friends there. So I read a lot of their coverage. You know, it's a lot of the same people that I've been reading the whole time, even though like the whole ecosystem has been shattered into a million pieces. The people who are really good Uh, 10 years ago are still pretty reliable now. And that's the universe of people who didn't need Donald Trump to come along to let you know that there was a democracy problem in America and it was located
SPEAKER_01in the right wing.
SPEAKER_00Well stated. Yeah. Before Trump came along, there were a whole bunch of pretty smart, credible voices that were saying that. And you, of course, were one of them. Before we get to this really important article, I just got to ask you about the breaking news that Jim Jordan has been elected by his colleagues and his peers of integrity in the Republican minority to be in the next Congress. They've elected Jim Jordan to be The GOP leader, you know what that job requires. It's the minority and so on. But you also know Jim Jordan pretty well.
SPEAKER_00What's your reaction to GYM Jordan? I guess the skeletons in the closet aren't maybe skeletons. They're not holding them back, I guess.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, Jim Jordan is like just a fanatic and like an abrasive person. And Trump has wanted him, I think, to have leadership roles in the Republican Party all along because he's totally loyal. And because he operates in this authoritarian way where it's not like trying to persuade members of the party that a certain approach is good, but that they will do it or there will be consequences. Right. And so I assume that that's why in this moment, Jim Jordan wins the election over Steve Scalise.
SPEAKER_01And there's like, I guess, if you want to like strip what you know about Jim Jordan out of the equation, there is a logic after a party loses a big election for the old leadership team to be swept out and for I think once upon a time, it would have been a really big deal. If the Republican Party in the first Trump administration had switched from Paul Ryan to Jim Jordan, then you'd say, whoa, the party is really doubling, tripling down on MAGA and Trumpism. And this is a milestone on an unexpected path.
SPEAKER_01I think at this point, The difference between Scalise and Jordan, just as far as outcomes, what is the Republican minority going to do? It's very small. Everyone with any reason left in that party was just wiped out in this election. It's going to be an extremely right-wing rump party. And so whether the leader is an abrasive guy who makes them do far right things
SPEAKER_01or a more polished guy who makes them do far right things, I don't think it really matters that much. And then you can look at it at another level where it's kind of like an error, right? There's a lot of things to say about Stephen Miller becoming White House Chief of Staff. But one is that it's just a mistake politically for Trump to define the party by these things. Assholes, right? Like the part, the country just kind of just said, we're tired of all the assholes. And, and like, I'm not saying that Steve Scalise is some, like appealing figure,
SPEAKER_01but he can behave himself a little bit. You know, he, he, he's not, he doesn't have the sex abuse stuff in his past that you were alluding to early. He has other stuff. But like, if I was trying to help the Republican Party put a better foot forward, I wouldn't put the Say
SPEAKER_00more about Steve Miller, real quick, Stephen Miller being the chief of staff. What does that role mean? And what does it mean that he is in it? You just said, you know, after the election, it seemed like there was kind of a reaction. Less assholery. And then they, you can't think of a bigger asshole by every definition of asshole. The only way you can make it worse is say, you know, as Hakeem Jeffries has said, that he's a white supremacist and others have as well. Hakeem Jeffries is like, I can't work with him. He's the Speaker of the House or he's going to be likely.
SPEAKER_00And so what does that mean that Stephen Miller is, is it too far? Is it hyperbolic, say like the second most powerful man in the world, a cartoon villain, a caricature, somebody would used to make fun of and now is raised to this position?
SPEAKER_01I mean, I kind of think it depends on how checked out Trump is and how just invested in his ballroom or whatever else, your vanity projects he is. If he's sundowning for the next two years, the chief of staff really does coordinate the activities of the government. And when there's dispute within the administration over what course to chart, What's supposed to happen is the chief of staff presents the dispute to the president and the president picks a path.
SPEAKER_01Right. If Trump is unable to do that or just is, you know, doesn't really understand the stakes of things, he's easily manipulable. Like Stephen Miller will be have presidential level power and he but he's unaccountable to any voter. And so I think it sort of depends on whether he views it as his last two years to make an imprint on the country, in which case, like, it's almost like mass shooter or school shooter psychology.
SPEAKER_01It's like, I like, this is it. This is like my last stand. Right. So I'm just going to do what I want, no matter its effect on the Republican Party, because After this, I'm out anyway. Right. Or whether he is invested in the continuity of the Republican Party project, in which case he'll be impacted by political considerations. Right. And he must know he's not an idiot. He must know that his vision for the country is super unpopular. But yeah, it's like it's a hard job.
SPEAKER_01It's like it's it's harder probably even than being Speaker of the House. Speaker of the House has got a lot of members. And you're supposed to try to get them on the same page. The chief of staff coordinates agency action. Right. And so the direct reports are like cabinet secretary. So it's a smaller group, but it entails managing what they call the interagency. Right. And the interagency process is famously hard because.
SPEAKER_01This department has these prerogatives and this other department has conflicting prerogatives and the policy pits them against each other. And how do you make the government work well when people are upset? Right. And Stephen Miller, like Jim Jordan, is just like, fuck you, do it. Yeah. Is his approach to management. And like that is like a recipe for the government to kind of unravel a little bit. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00This is a good question from the chat to get into your article at the New Republic. But Karen says in the chat that she'd read, and I'd heard this too, that Stephen Miller and Russ Vought, who is the head of the Office of Management and Budget, Christian Nationalist, the architect of Project 2025, had planned to basically run the country without Congress, even though they're in the majority. Had you heard that reporting? Is there anything to... Truth to that or concern about it?
SPEAKER_01I mean... That's sort of been their MO since day one in 2024, like the idea that Congress doesn't matter. Congress didn't matter for the last two years because Republicans were refusing to utilize Congress, right? The story is going to change now. Now, like what I expect is that they are going to continue. They will abuse as much power as Democrats let them, right? And so...
SPEAKER_01There's a big question here is how hard are Democrats going to push back and how much power are they going to be willing to use if Russ Vogt and Stephen Miller say, this we're going to do unilaterally, that we're going to do without your input. And at the end of the day, Russ Vogt is an impeachable officer of the United States. So that's one thing. And nothing that they want to do can be done without money, and Congress controls the money.
SPEAKER_01At some level, this whole system works on a level of commitment to the continuity of the project of the United States. And so if Miller and Vogt say, I don't care about your impeachment power, and we are just going to keep spending money even if you don't give us any, and then... Congress doesn't impeach or Republicans provide the votes to acquit, then you're in a horrible constitutional crisis.
SPEAKER_01Or if they provide the votes to convict, but those people refuse to leave office, then you have a question of like, what are the men with guns? And you get it.
SPEAKER_00You get into all that by talking about the major tools that Democrats have that are called inherent contempt, impeachment, and the power of the purse. And you unpack them in this really great article that you've written with Greg Sargent. Everybody should read this because there's a billion voices in politics and everybody's got an account. And everybody's posting on whatever their favorite social media account is, their snap judgment of any number of things. It's really important for people to understand all of the details and nuance
SPEAKER_00that reporters like you and Greg understand intimately about how it works. Explain it to us so we can see what the approach is. What levers they have, what choices they have, and then, as you guys kind of write about, how these Democrats fall into different categories. But let's start kind of at the beginning here. The title is Trump has a secret plan to evade accountability. Will Democrats be able to defeat it? Soon the Democrats will have real power, but they can't think that means the crisis is over. It's not. They need to use that power to bury Trumpism once and for all.
SPEAKER_00First of all, didn't Trumpism get buried on election night? Isn't MAGA repudiated and over, Greg? It's dead. I'm Brian.
SPEAKER_01OK, so it's not dead because the election was not a vote of no confidence in Donald Trump that effectuated his removal. He still has two years in power to abuse power or to try to make a political comeback or both of those things. Right. And so if you want to discredit MAGA and Donald Trump for all time, you have to like you need the opposition party, the just one power to be willing to corner him, maybe maybe get him out of office before the end of his term,
SPEAKER_01but be thinking in terms of utilizing Legitimate powers of the Congress to limit the amount of damage he can do, maybe push him back and maybe go even further than that. So to spoil like the first teaser in the headline, Donald Trump's secret weapon, The secret weapon is what you were alluding to, what the questioner was alluding to about Russ Vogt and Stephen Miller maybe planning to govern without Congress, is that when Congress comes in bent on accountability through normal oversight,
SPEAKER_01through normal appropriations process, et cetera, the president can just say no. I mean, not supposed to, it's not legal to say no, but they control the personnel, they control The documentation and they control the guns.
SPEAKER_00And and so if Democrats are thinking we're going to get the Epstein files,
SPEAKER_01we're going to end these revenge prosecutions, we're going to rain in ice. If the president says like hell you are, then The status quo continues. Right. And it's back in Congress's court. And the majority has to decide whether they're willing to make a very big escalation in in the procedural powers that they're willing to use.
SPEAKER_00And that escalation. Sorry, go ahead. Those were the.
SPEAKER_01And so it's you hit a wall real quick. Give me those documents. No. OK, like we're going to subpoena them. We defy your subpoena. The normal tools of oversight kind of stop working or slow down them.
SPEAKER_00And to make things happen on any kind of reasonable timeline,
SPEAKER_01Congress needs to be willing to use the three levers that you just cited. So that's inherent contempt, impeachment, and the power of the purse. And so we run through those. Inherent contempt is Has fallen into disuse. It hasn't actually been used in almost 100 years, but it has been upheld as an inherent power of Congress by the Supreme Court many times. And basically says Congress can compel compliance with its own commands.
SPEAKER_01So Congress says you give us those documents and you say no, it's not like You're toying with a future prosecution. It's not like you're toying with an order from a court that you have to do it. It's like Congress can go send the cops after you and hold you in confinement until you do what you're told, right? More recently, members of Congress have talked about using this authority to levy fines against people who are in contempt of Congress,
SPEAKER_01but As originally utilized, it was literal confinement, you know, like in a cell or in a room, any room that's available on Capitol Hill. So that's something that they could do if people in the executive branch or outside allies of the president are defying congressional commands.
SPEAKER_00You then mentioned impeachment and you give some historic precedent on that. You can threaten executive branch officers, officials with the prospect of removal and places Congress at the height of its constitutional authority. And we've seen this in the past. Obviously, in the recent past with Trump, but people don't talk about cabinet secretaries as much. This week, we saw articles of impeachment introduced for Pete Kegseth, the DUI hire, Pete Kegseth, who came out, by the way.
SPEAKER_00A belligerent this morning in a Pentagon press conference. He took six questions. Those six questions were from friendly reporters because reporters don't really have access to the secretary of state. And it was his first press conference, by the way, I think in six months in during a war. It's just completely unprecedented. Thomas Massey brings articles impeachment. Anyway, that's just the most recent is yesterday. How else do you think impeachment will or should be used, wielded by Democrats? They have the power.
SPEAKER_01I mean, we argue in the piece for it to be wielded promiscuously and and, you know, you can see the argument for taking it to Donald Trump. Right. If if Pete Hegseth gets a little deeper into into trouble with this impeachment, one defense he might offer for himself is I was just following orders. Well, whose orders? Right. Donald Trump's. Right. So. The whole when when Democrats toy with the idea of wielding impeachment,
SPEAKER_01but only against the cabinet secretaries, they're going to run into this question. It'll reporters will ask it of them. Members of their own caucuses will ask it of them. I'll certainly ask it of them. Like if you're going to impeach Todd Blanche. For running the Justice Department exactly the way Donald Trump instructed him to. Why is Donald Trump harmless from impeachment? Why isn't it really his fault that things are going this way? But the reason we, unlike the brewing conventional wisdom in Washington,
SPEAKER_01don't think impeachment is an unwise approach, A, is because it was effective in its own ways against Trump in his first term. But B, as you mentioned, it puts Congress at the height of its constitutional authority. So where inherent contempt relies on compulsion and like physical compulsion. What impeachment does is invoke a basically Congress saying we're in an emergency and we are shifting into hyperdrive. Right.
SPEAKER_01And so what that means is courts will move quicker to adjudicate questions of privilege and things like that. And also people, you know, witnesses
SPEAKER_00or people implicated in a corruption scandal or whoever will feel a greater compulsion
SPEAKER_01to come forward to not obstruct the Congress. And so you saw this in Trump's first term, where in his first for the first nine months or so of 2019, after Democrats took back the House. They weren't trying to do much oversight. And whenever they tried to do oversight, Trump would just say no. And then there'd be this, okay, we got to go to the courts. The courts are going to take forever. When the Ukraine scandal happened and they initiated an impeachment inquiry, everyone came out of the woodwork.
SPEAKER_01And it wasn't because they sent the sergeant at arms after them. It was that the people who knew what had happened realized that something really grave was afoot. And Congress was taking it seriously. And whether it was patriotism or their concern about their future professional livelihoods or whatever the motive, it made them do something, get involved, get engaged in the investigative process in a way that Trump had been able to keep
SPEAKER_01a lid on, right? And so if Russell Vogt or Todd Blanche or Donald Trump decide to say in a manner that's completely lawless, Congress is like, we're not going to cooperate with you in any way. Impeachment is how you would get people who had reached the end of the line with Donald Trump coming forward and saying, hey, here's the scheme they're up to. Here's the proof that they're knowingly violating their oaths of office.
SPEAKER_01And with impeachment, you're always up against the two thirds problem in the Senate. You need 67 votes to remove some to convict them on impeachment. Democrats will probably have 56 votes. That means they would need 11 Republicans. It's tough, right? It's like genuinely hard to say that at the end of the day, impeachment would work to remove those people from office, but it would certainly work to Let the public know about the scale of the emergency.
SPEAKER_01So that's that's and if the if the malfeasance was severe enough, you could imagine, especially after an election like this, many Republicans deciding we can't tolerate
SPEAKER_00the impeachment vote that could be taken on Pete Hegseth this week, however, is for this Congress, the one. Was it 19th? Where Democrats haven't been seated yet, haven't been sworn in, and yet it's led by a Republican. Will there be enough votes in the House, much less the Senate, to remove Pete Hegseth from being the Defense Secretary?
SPEAKER_01So I think there will be enough votes to pass the impeachment resolution in the House. What's supposed to happen then, and that's for a few reasons. One is every Democrat's going to vote for it. Two is that I don't, I don't know how easy it's going to be for Mike Johnson, who I don't think has much power, authority or influence anymore, to get all these Republicans who just lost their seats to fly back to Washington to do a favor for Pete Hegseth. You know, I don't know.
SPEAKER_01It's possible that that the whole band will come back together and the party will take a unanimous vote other than Thomas Massey to say, yeah, we like Pete Hegseth and we're going to protect him from this impeachment. So I think but I would not predict that the resolution will pass. What's supposed to happen then is it gets referred over to the Senate. As I think you were suggesting, the 119th Congress is about to in the House is about to dissolve.
SPEAKER_01But the Senate is a rolling body, right? Like it. It not every seat is up for election every two years. And so it's it's what it's called a continuing body. Right. And so they can try that impeachment immediately or they can wait. So if it goes it carries over.
SPEAKER_00That's right. I heard that explained yesterday, I think, by Massey. If they vote now, it carries over to the next Congress and the next Senate, which will be a different makeup entirely, would vote. I'm sorry to cut you off. Is that what you're saying?
SPEAKER_01Well, yeah, I mean, I think it would be up to John Thune, right? So he's the Senate. I heard he might not be.
SPEAKER_00I heard this question. Did they vote on that today?
SPEAKER_01Well, he will be Senate Majority Leader for the next two months. So if next week the House impeaches, or if this week the House impeaches Hegseth and they refer it to John Thune and John Thune decides, let's do a trial, let's acquit him real quick, then it's done. Then it's over.
SPEAKER_00What do you think Mitch McConnell have to say?
SPEAKER_01I think you can make hand gestures.
SPEAKER_00So we covered two of the main tools you talked about. Inherent contempt, which is a phrase most of us haven't heard. Obviously, impeachment, one we're more familiar with. But Congress also has and this is the third that you guys write about in your New Republic article, which is so, so good. Nobody should go. Read it and subscribe, of course, to Brian, if you aren't already, is the power of the purse and that Congress has a lot of power just in spending power. They can withhold that. I've heard a lot of people say they'll defund ICE right away.
SPEAKER_00But explain how this next Congress, led by Democrats, should use that tool.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So ICE is a little complicated because in this past Congress – Republicans used a different kind of process to sort of pre-fund ICE for five years. So the issue with ICE is that its funding is not really going to expire. And to defund it, you'd have to claw back that money. That's going to be tough. I don't want to... But I think that's important.
SPEAKER_00That's why reading this article and talking to you is important because people campaigned on defunding ICE. They got huge rounds of applause and a lot of people are posting about it. Can't wait till ICE is defunded and all that. But it's not that simple and we should explain that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, so ultimately, whether it's defunding ICE, which I stipulate is tough because of how it's pre-funded. But if Russell Vote is withholding FEMA money, From blue states still or grant funds from states with Democratic senators like they were doing all of the last two years. Or if Todd Blanche is withholding the Epstein files or if he's continuing to try to prosecute Donald Trump's enemies or any of these kinds of authoritarian abuses
SPEAKER_01that we've been laboring under for the last two years. What we mean by utilizing the power of the purse is that The operations, those are only things that Trump officials can do because the government is funded. The operations of the government are funded on an annual cycle. And sometimes they kick the can a little bit, but basically you have this annual appropriations process. The operating budget of the government is going to expire on December 11th in this lame duck.
SPEAKER_01Democrats can wield a lot of influence over that.
SPEAKER_00They will have a government shutdown December 11. I mean, you're saying that's a big deadline. December 11 is a big date. And what? Yeah, go ahead.
SPEAKER_01So if Democrats say we will not extend funding for the government if it funds the Iran war, then Republicans have to decide. Defund the Iran war, which voters say they want or shut down the whole government. What are they going to do? I mean, it's kind of going to be in their lap. You can recapitulate this process over and over again. You can fund the government in short increments. And then you can say, no funds can be used for what Todd Blanche is up to.
SPEAKER_01If he withholds the Epstein files, his plane is grounded. Interesting. If Stephen Miller is ignoring congressional, is ignoring the law in any way, really, The whole executive office of the president will not be funded. We will pass appropriations bills that fund whatever, you know, Social Security administrative offices or the national parks or the Department of Agriculture. But we are not going to fund those things or we're going to include specific language that says you don't you can't use any money for that.
SPEAKER_01Then you kick it over to to Trump and he has to either agree or disagree. But the whole thing works on money. And if you take the money away, then either it stops or they have to enter like a further mode of lawlessness that would put them. Sort of squarely and impeachable territory.
SPEAKER_00Okay. I just got to get this one off my chest, not specifically. Well, I guess it does pertain to the article, which I read and everybody should read in its entirety. Read the article and discuss it before you spout off on things. Greg and Brian are really the very best. And this is a deep dive and they talked to a lot of people for it and they really know their shit. But it's this corporate media question I heard this weekend. I heard it from both On Face the Nation from Margaret Brennan and then Kirsten Welker asked a question on Meet the Press and everybody in corporate media is asking it. And I don't like it, Brian. I don't like this. Every asking every Democrat they talk to, will you go after accountability or affordability?
SPEAKER_00I think that's journalistic malpractice. It's a shit question. Every reporter knows that both responsibilities are directly related to Congress. I think every reporter should be called out. I don't mean to be too harsh, but that's like that's this binary that that media tries to make to get you on the record as saying one or the other. It's not a one -or -the -other question. Democrats doesn't answer that rightly, it's on them. I think many of them have. But of course some of them are like, well, I don't want to look backward and I don'T want to look backward and you know I don't wanna get retribution. Accountability is not retribution justice is not wrong Like there have
SPEAKER_00to be consequences And that seems to be what a lot was The the election was about but what do you make Of just that question being A false one accountability Or affordability
SPEAKER_01brian I mean, obviously I agree with you that it's a false binary. I think that there is a contingent of Democrats that are concerned about the perception that they're expending more of their resources or their time investigating Trump or engaging in partisan fighting with Trump than with kitchen table style legislating, trying to get more people health care and things like that. And That's not really a either or thing.
SPEAKER_01What I worry about there is that if Jamie Raskin hits paydirt with the Epstein files or whatever, or with this new scandal with Jensen Wong and NVIDIA, we don't have to go into all the details, but like if they had paydirt in these investigations and suddenly all the news can talk about is accountability, it's going to create the perception, right, that Democrats are only focused on accountability and not affordability. And there are some Democrats who fear that. And they're going to try to lean on the leadership to say, like,
SPEAKER_01don't go whole hog against Trump. I think we've got to be alert about that. But the binary is false because
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net Thanks to the many hundreds of you who watched live. Many new horizons just opened, so we’ll be covering a bunch of unexpected terrain...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net Last video mailbag before the election. We’ll reconvene shortly afterward. Thanks to everyone who tuned in live. And for subscribers that...
Had a good live chat Thursday with my pal Alex Wagner, covering the whole political waterfront. Special thanks to all who watched or listened live. In order we discussed: * Is veganism any weirder than eating...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net The veteran progressive policy hand Bharat Ramamurti joined me Friday for a long and in depth conversation about two issues confounding...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net Thank you to everyone who tuned in live. We’ll do one more of these before the midterm