Minor schedule change: I’ll be publishing mailbag responses on Friday instead of today (which means there’s still time to get questions in). I hope everyone has a restful and reflective Juneteenth. I had the opportunity on Wednesday to chat live with Andrew Weissmann, the former federal prosecutor and legal-affairs commentator, whose new book Liar’s Kingdom proposes ideas, inspired by foreign democracies, for amending our own laws to impose civil or criminal consequences on political candidates who tell Trump-like lies about elections. Andrew crafted his proposals carefully to pass muster under our Constitution. They are thus meant to serve both as actionable responses to Donald Trump’s ongoing campaign of post-2020 lies, and as realistic prescriptions for discouraging copycats in the future. But the book hit the shelves just a couple weeks before Republicans in California and across the country asserted new false claims of fraud, in the vain hope of overturning the results of the Los Angeles mayoral primary, and installing a defeated GOP candidate on the general election ballot. I was reading Liar’s Kingdom as that happened, and borrowed from it heavily in writing this piece, which argues California Democrats should pass a law that would effectively disqualify these election liars from seeking office in the state on future ballots. So I wanted to both run my idea by Andrew, and stress test his more considered ones, which would, of course, be challenged and exploited by the very people we both seek to deter. Off Message is a reader (and listener) supported hub for ideas and strategies to defeat fascism and rebuild democracy. Join us. Some highlights: * Andrew explains why we shouldn’t simply assume that bad-faith actors would exploit election truth-in-advertising laws, either to disqualify innocent opponents, or tie them up in court. (20:11) * What can we do about softer forms of election denialism, which may not entail telling black-and-white lies, but can be just as corrosive to democracy? (31:26) * Would a civil disqualification penalty for telling election lies wipe out all the Republican officeholders in Congress who’ve echoed Trump? Or would this new framework be purely prospective? (39:42) * Why Brian has a musculoskeletal anatomy poster behind him. (51:10) * How the law and democracy together can work in tandem to make American politics much more honest than they are. (51:39) It was a wonderful discussion, and I hope you’ll watch or listen, here or on your favorite podcast app. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.offmessage.net/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Hey everyone, I'm Brian Beutler. I'm the publisher of the Off Message newsletter, and I'm delighted to be joined this morning, well, I guess this morning my time, by Andrew Weissman, whose own Substack is called Behind the Headlines. Andrew was a federal prosecutor for many years. He was one of the lead prosecutors on Robert Mueller's team investigating The first Trump campaign and Russian interference in the 2016 election, which is a role that earned him a spot on the second Trump administration's blacklist for mean lawyers.
We were discussing, I thought he might be off the list, but apparently he's still on it. But we're here today because he's written an important book called Liar's Kingdom.
SPEAKER_01I recommend it. It's about how to deter and defeat election lies using the law. But it's a breezy read for non-lawyers. I've already borrowed heavily from it in an article I wrote last week called Disqualify Spencer Pratt, which we'll get to in a bit. Beyond the specific topic matter, I like the book for other reasons. One is that it's very handy. What I try to do here is is sort of take an inventory of things that I know from years of recording which is about Congress and procedure and elections
and look for tools that can help create obstacles to anti-democratic forces. I often think of that scene from the movie Apollo 13 where the crew's going to suffocate and they need to filter the carbon dioxide and have like a hose and a
SPEAKER_01sock and some duct tape. And Andrew's book is kind of like that, like how do we assemble a protective mechanism from the tools we have on hand? But it stems from Andrew's practice and the study of law. and then the other reason is that it packages discrete and actionable remedies for democracy once this administration has passed which is an exceptionally broad category obviously because so much will need to be rebuilt and it will need to be rebuilt more robustly than it existed before and so I see the
book as a kind of model for other experts with different bureaucratic and technical knowledge like
SPEAKER_01there should be a book like this or protecting public health from various cranks or for protecting the treasury from looting, either private profit or for impoundments or for whatever else. And that way, if there's an opportunity to rebuild in two and a half years, the people in charge will be able to move. quickly. So that's my review of the book. As Trump might say, I give it my complete and total endorsement. And so, Andrew, if you wouldn't mind just fleshing out the idea a bit more than I just did, like talk a little bit about how specifically you propose
deterring and defeating
SPEAKER_01election lies. And then let's talk about how you go about implementing it and what pitfalls we ought to be looking out for and sort of stress test the idea.
SPEAKER_00Sure. Well, thank you so much for having me. Thank you for all those comments. I really appreciate the fact that you said that this is something that non-lawyers can read, and that is thanks to a fantastic Fantastic, fantastic editor at Little Brown. People who are listening may know the whole backstory that Little Brown really stepped into the breach when my prior publisher got scared off by one of the Trump
executive orders and was like we're too scared essentially to touch this and so Little Brown stepped in and thank god they did because I had such a great great working relationship with an editor to make this something that everyone can read
SPEAKER_00anyway to get to your question um I do this podcast with Mary McCord where every week we cover sort of the latest legal news that we think is most salient, obviously, since the Trump 2.0 pandemic. administration it's you know this is drinking from a fire hose and but like this week I was struck by the number of stories that we covered and the podcast by the
way is called Maine Justice where it's just all about lies here's just one quick
SPEAKER_00example the Department of Energy was The head of the Department of Energy had said, no, no, no, we've been canceling grants, but it has nothing, nothing to do about where the companies are located and whether the grants are in blue states or red states. And the head of it's like, no, no, no, that's outrageous. We would never do that. Well, one of the stories that happened this week was that the Trump administration lawyers conceded Oh yeah, no, that is why we did it.
SPEAKER_00And $81 million of grants, this is just one tranche, were reinstated by the judge when the government's own lawyers had to concede that, yes, they were actually targeting these companies because They worked in blue states, which is just unreal. Even if you leave the legality part aside, just like who thinks that way? But also to the point that it meant that the person who said, no way, no how, we never would decide it this way. Well, that wasn't true.
SPEAKER_00And so I was very struck by the fact that we have this Deluge of political lies by candidates, by people in office. Obviously, this is not the first administration to have political lies, although I do think we have it on an extraordinary basis for a whole variety of reasons that I talk about in the I look overseas to see what other countries have done and what
are possible models,
SPEAKER_00ones that I think might work, things that I think might not work, compared to... Brian Beutler Brian Beutler
SPEAKER_00Again, not opinions, not I'm pro-abortion, I'm against abortion, I'm for immigration, I'm against immigration. All of those are opinions and you might have various views, but that's not what I'm talking about. I'm talking about false factual representations that are intentionally false, not just wrong. And the government would have to show that. That's one bucket. The second bucket is a disqualification where, and admittedly this is easier at the state level than at the federal level because of existing case law.
SPEAKER_00But an example of that from overseas is England and Brazil. Let me just tell you about England because a lot of people think, oh, well, it's England that so much of our legal system comes from that English heritage. They have a law that if a candidate for office Intentionally lies About their political opponent They cannot be They cannot win They cannot hold that office The last time that was applied The
person who was found to have intentionally lied Won that election And the court said you cannot
SPEAKER_00sit Brian Beutler brianbeutler So those are the two models that I talk about and really stress the anomaly that while we criminalize and civilly regulate all sorts of
Intentionally False Factual Speech, we do not do it with respect to politicians.
SPEAKER_00And while there are definitely upsides and downsides to my proposal, I'm enough of a lawyer to engage in that kind of thinking about... It was true when you're in government. You think about what is the proposal? What are the downsides? What are the upsides? And if they're downsides, how do you mitigate it? And is there a way to mitigate it sufficiently that the upsides are worth it? That this is one where we really stand out among so-called Western democracies as a
SPEAKER_00country that is not taking action to deal with a problem that I think is going to be with us certainly in my lifetime if we don't do something. So I don't think I'm spoiling too much to say that you look abroad for how they
SPEAKER_01handled this in countries where they had successfully addressed it. And then you kind of run it through the filter of our constitutional system to come up with ideas that you think could pass constitutional So I kind of want to just stipulate for the purposes of our conversation that you're right about that, that we could create at the state level or at the federal level new law or series of laws that deter election lies just as you described.
SPEAKER_01And so I want to just kind of imagine the world. Brian Beutler brian
SPEAKER_00for a medication or watches TV and sees advertisements. It's truth in advertising. You can't put anything you want on your pill bottle. You can't have a commercial which says anything it wants. There's all sorts of regulations. This is a truth in election advertising.
SPEAKER_01Right. The book has all kinds of excellent analogies to, you know, we talk about free speech all the time as if there's literally nothing you could say that you could get in trouble for here. But that's clearly not true. And you run through it in the advertising context, in the fraud context, in the obstruction context. But so we have these truth in advertising laws. We have the ability to disqualify people who have lied about the outcomes of elections or the way elections work, right? So I guess the first question I have for you is about whether a
law or set of laws
SPEAKER_01like this can be written in a way that ensures against weaponization, against bad faith actors. So here's a hypothetical. Yeah. So we've made it a disqualifying offense to lie about an election. But we haven't yet fixed some of the other election fairness issues that we have in this country. So we still have gerrymandered maps. We still have voter suppression. And by and by, a Democrat loses a close election. And in losing, they say, you know,
maybe in figurative terms more than literal ones.
SPEAKER_01You know, Republicans stole this from me. If they hadn't rigged the system, I would have won this election. Like most Democrats don't talk quite like that, but they do have real grievances along these lines that are not lies, right? Stacey Abrams was, I think, rightfully aggrieved about the election. She I'm
Well you know so this issue comes up all the time in the criminal law when you have
SPEAKER_00a charge of somebody making a false statement. It's very very factually dependent on what exactly did the person say and then what was their intent. So if somebody let's just take the somebody like Stacey Abrams says you know I This election was essentially stolen from me because of the various ways in which there was voter suppression. And that bucket obviously could include a whole variety of things.
SPEAKER_00And if she were able to say, Well, I was talking about the gerrymandering. I was talking about steps that you have for voter qualification that helps suppress the black vote. I was talking about ads that undermine the Brian Beutler
There was fraud in the 2020 election and I won because there's no way that Joe Biden got that many votes and dead people were voting in Detroit and more people
SPEAKER_00voted in Philadelphia than there are registered voters and et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. You would have to show in that situation if you were the government that A, that those statements were false and that they were intentionally so. And usually the battle is more about is it intentional or not. And this is something that Jack Smith, if we'd ever had a trial, was going to need to show that it was intentionally false when he was making these
SPEAKER_00statements. And he has described both in various interviews and in his report Why and how he was going to be able to prove that including people on the inside talking to him and telling him and giving him data and things he said both even before the election that he was going to say that there was fraud in the election. etc all sorts of ways that you go about proving intentionality and so I I find that
I'm going to turn it back to I find the harder issue and I do address this this
SPEAKER_00sort of There is no new check that doesn't have the possibility of weaponization. And somebody who, in fact, just wants to disqualify their opponent raising this claim. And there's no question that this weapon, if it's deemed, or this tool will be weaponized in the way that we have seen the Justice Department currently completely weaponized.
by in my view by Pam Bondi and Todd Blanch and by Donald Trump and Kash Patel while we're at it and in a whole variety of ways and so the question is are there enough checks and balances and I think there are a variety of answers to that but let me
SPEAKER_00just give one potential answer which is a concrete data point I'm from New York. New York, as many people know, I like to say that I'm an inveterate New Yorker. And I think I've told this anecdote before, which is I lived in Washington for 10 years and I kept on telling people I'm an inveterate New Yorker. And one of my old New Yorker friends said, you really can't say that anymore. Which is like a, you know, if you're from New York, that's like a dagger to the heart because you think of yourself as,
SPEAKER_00you know, a New Yorker for life. I've noticed. I've noticed this about New Yorkers. Exactly. and so New York has a statute that says that if you are a public official elected or not just a public official if you are convicted of a criminal offense obviously you get due process you get to defend yourself if you're convicted of a criminal offense you are automatically removed from office
SPEAKER_00Period, the end, out. It is considered so antithetical to what it means to take an oath of office and who you should be. And we do not have the problem anymore. Brian Beutler
SPEAKER_00Brian Beutler brianbeutler Brian Beutler Brian Beutler
SPEAKER_00Brian Beutler Brian Beutler
We live in a world where the two parties don't operate in equal measure of good
SPEAKER_01faith, and that if you enact this law to deter the kind of corrosive lies that we've been living with, then the people who tell the corrosive lies are going to go start trying to say, well, you know, this and that and the other thing that the Democrats are complaining about and how we conduct ourselves, those are, you know, those are casting down on elections, and we're going to try to disqualify all of them, and then they end up in court, like for and I guess I wonder if there's a way to tweak the proposal
such that if you do this frivolously like maybe not a disqualification penalty but a financial penalty anything to make it like you only use this if you're really after something real
SPEAKER_01not just to tie your opposition up in court forever
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, there is something right now, which is Rule 11 sanctions, where if you are bringing a case that is frivolous, that you can be sanctioned. And there are various judges now who are looking into that. Brian Beutler
You could also do something which happens in the civil law where the pleading has to be the actual facts alleging why this is false and why it's intentionally false.
SPEAKER_00Brian Beutler Brian Beutler brian.com
SPEAKER_00And to be clear, what I'm saying is if this had happened and somebody was convicted of a felony and was a New York public official, they would not be able to hold office. That is a state law And there are obviously 50 states There are lots of states That can have all sorts of different roles It's much more complicated At the federal level As to adding restrictions And also removing somebody from office because it raises some
thorny constitutional
SPEAKER_00issues as to whether the criteria in the Constitution are exclusive. Would it take a constitutional amendment? I'm very much trying to come up with things that do not take constitutional amendments because of how hard it is. It's not that it can't happen. It's just like that is a high hurdle. So I guess it's like a relief to you as a New Yorker that Donald Trump cannot now
SPEAKER_01become like mayor of New York City or governor of New York. He's disqualified in those offices.
SPEAKER_00I would say for many reasons.
SPEAKER_01You know, there's there are lots of reasons aside from legality that I don't think he's
SPEAKER_00particularly popular in his former hometown.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I've heard that. So, I think that your answer to the previous question probably gets at the next one. What about perspective lies that are meant to subvert faith in elections but aren't specific to a current result, right? Because Trump will say, the only way I can win is by, if they cheat, right? Or I'm sorry, the only way I can lose, right, is if they cheat. And when he says that, it's bullshit at least, if not a lie.
But when I say that Donald Trump right now is setting things up to try to steal the
SPEAKER_01midterms if he can, that's real right that's not a lie but it is a warning about the risk of a stolen election and like well I'd like there for I'd like to there'd be a penalty for his tactic it's hard for me to think of how you penalize his sort of perspective lying in a way that would keep it kosher for me to say that hey like watch Republicans they are trying to steal the midterms So that I think is going to be much more of a opinion as to
what you think is going to happen.
SPEAKER_00Anything that's in the future is going to be an opinion. Brian Beutler Brian Beutler
SPEAKER_00Brian Beutler I'm talking about facts the election was stolen is a good example of that or we did not target
SPEAKER_00and grantees based on the states they were in. That's a specific thing where you're saying this specifically happened and the issues are, is it true or false? And then what was your intentionality? Did you just make a mistake or was it something that you knew you were deliberately lying about? And so... A good example of that is everyone who's listening has had to have heard about the whole slush fund.
SPEAKER_00And the slush fund issue was, to me, was predicated on two falsehoods. One of them was that there was some wrong. Brian Beutler Brian Beutler
SPEAKER_00Brian Beutler brianbeutler Brian Beutler
The second type of falsehood is that the money that we create the slush fund and
SPEAKER_00the money that we have is going to be used for victims. Brian Beutler The president thinking and thinking they should be treated as victims, that's his opinion. That's not a false factual statement.
And when I'm thinking about, okay, how would you apply what I'm saying to that situation? I can readily distinguish sort of what I call lie one from false statements two about whether you are going to describe people and see them as victims or not. That to me is a subjective view in the same way that you can have subjective views about whether you think the Constitution protects a woman's right to choose or not.
SPEAKER_00Like those are things that are not false Brian Beutler Brian Beutler brianbrian.com
SPEAKER_00Brian Beutler Why are we exempting them from the analysis that we apply to all sorts of other people,
SPEAKER_00corporate executives, people who speak to Congress, people who are interviewed. By former when I was a prosecutor or an FBI agent and you lie to them if you apply to a bank for a loan all of those are situations where we criminalize intentionally false factual statements I'm glad you knew the distinction because Trump Trump makes such a perfect test case of this because the lies he told after losing in 2020 were so cut and dry.
But it makes me wonder about maybe what maybe it's like the opposite problem, which is that you can do a lot of damage to democracy and cast a lot of doubt on the integrity of elections without telling black and white lies the way Trump did.
SPEAKER_01Right. Were you at the Justice Department during the U.S. Attorney scandal 20 years ago?
SPEAKER_00I was. I was working for Director Mueller. I think when that happened, I was his special counsel.
SPEAKER_01Got it. So you weren't in Maine Justice, right, where I think the scandal was located. But there was... My recollection of the situation has been a while is that you had this sort of messaging or propaganda infrastructure on the right and a lot of it was situated in the Heritage Foundation and mostly the purpose was to suggest that election fraud was rampant and they did this in order to justify voter suppression measures but then it turned into this kind of pressure on U.S.
SPEAKER_01attorneys to bring actual cases and And so this is like misleading conduct, it's abusive conduct, but it can happen without anyone telling a Trump-style lie that this specific election was fraudulent and the loser won and the winner lost. And I'm wondering if the TIA or the Weissman Act do anything about that kind of corrosive innuendo that isn't really...
SPEAKER_00I have two comments on that. One is that depending on what someone says at the time, it could catch people who are selling intentional lies either to perpetrate the wrong or to cover up the wrong. Because as you know, sometimes it's not what you did, it's what you did after you did the thing that you did. It's the cover-up that gets you, not the underlying crime.
And a lot of times the cover-up does have intentional lies and so it could catch it that way.
SPEAKER_00The second thing is that I wouldn't mind if the debate were, oh, we're now in a second level, which is, are they saying something that is a factual statement, not an opinion, and is it intentional? In other words, that discussion moves us into a different direction. Sphere where it's like okay we've already accomplished some deterrent where people
know do not there's real cost to lying to the American public and can I give you an example of what I think now this is an opinion but I think that Donald Trump
SPEAKER_00I think Donald Trump is extremely aware of this distinction. And why do I say that? And I do talk about this in Liar's Kingdom. Let's go back to the first impeachment. That's the one where Donald Trump's on the phone with President Zelensky in Ukraine and has the so-called perfect call. And there's then an impeachment and then there's And Donald Trump publicly is saying over and over again and
loudly with his bully
SPEAKER_00pulpit megaphone, which is entitled to use, that this was the perfect call and there was no quid pro quo. And he says all of that about not just it's a perfect call, that's nebulous, but that there was no quid pro quo, even though it seems You know, to me, it seemed plainly obvious that that's exactly what was going on, which is like if you announce that there's a fraud investigation so that I can then say Joe Biden is under a criminal investigation in a foreign country,
SPEAKER_00then you will get the congressionally mandated military aid, which, by the way, in retrospect, was just so critical for them to have. And Donald Trump said all of that publicly. Because that is not in this country a crime. It is not actionable. But you know where he did not say that? He did not say it to Congress. He did not testify either in the House or the Senate.
SPEAKER_00He didn't even submit A statement Whether sworn or unsworn Saying I was on the call This is what's going on Here's my evidence All of that If he had submitted a statement That Brian Beutler brianbeutler
SPEAKER_00to the public said, well, that's not a crime. And so, you know, but he admitted it when he was sort of finally being questioned in a setting where it would have been a crime to lie. Howard Ludnick could be another example of that. He is the Commerce Secretary who very famously recently went on air and touted, I remember hearing it at the time, and said he and his wife went to the Epstein house and we were, essentially, I'm going to paraphrase, but we were so disgusted. Imposted by what we saw and there was a massage table like
right out in the open and I think it was the living room and the dining room and we just went like we're leaving and we never want to see him again and oh can you imagine it's just awful
SPEAKER_00and I mean he really gilded the lily and we all know that That is, to put it bluntly, inaccurate. And he had to know that wasn't true because he, in fact, had business dealings with him. And then he turned his yacht around with his family members on it to spend time on the island and also brought, I believe, his babysitter at Jeffrey Epstein's request.
SPEAKER_00to the island. So none of that is consistent with we never wanted to see him again. But again, that making a false statement publicly is not actionable in the way that Brian Beutler
And we can construct it to make the world that we want to live in and to create
SPEAKER_00incentives, positive and negative, to be able to... And I teach to wonderful young students and I'm always telling them that is like, you know, think big and think about what world you want to live in because you're in a field where that's possible. It's not like science has a very different and wonderful mission, but it's not subjective in the way that law is.
I think you can see it too in the distinction between what Trump was saying after the 2020 election and what his lawyers were saying in all those lawsuits that they filed and lost is that if they had been basically taking dictation from Trump and
SPEAKER_01then saying those things to a judge without evidence, that would be sanctionable, right? Absolutely. They drew a pretty firm line.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's a great point. So one of the remarkable things in those, what is it, 61 cases, I believe, right after the election, is in many of those, the judge is like, well, are you claiming fraud? And the lawyers are like, uh, no. um and that's because there are consequences because lawyers are officers of the court and if you lie to a judge there can not only can that be criminal but you also you can have your bar license pulled um either permanently
or at least
SPEAKER_00temporarily you know ceg rudy giuliani yeah uh Would there be an ex post facto issue with people for all the lies that have been told up to this point if you were to pass the kind of laws that you're talking
SPEAKER_01about where you didn't retroactively sanction the old lies?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, with respect to criminal law, absolutely. You cannot go backwards. And I'm enough of a, you know, people know me as a, mostly because of the role I had as a criminal prosecutor, but I also was a defense lawyer for 10 years. Absolutely. Criminal laws cannot work retroactively. Civil laws can. But criminal laws definitely should not. I mean, that is... The whole idea is that you should have notice of what the law is. And so you can't just say,
oh, by the way, let me just tell you what you did before.
SPEAKER_00We're now making it a crime. And that would never go in this country. There are very strong rules on that, on the criminal side.
SPEAKER_01But if the disqualification you have in mind is a civil penalty... I ask this because you have set aside since we've dealt with the innuendo question you have all these people they say Joe Biden was certified the winner of the 2020 election and they're propounding the lie without lying right but you still have a lot of people in the current Republican Party who are all in on the Brian Beutler brianbeutler
SPEAKER_00Let me just put it this way. I am not proposing that people have to take a loyalty oath and that it's like, oh, you have to say X or Y. I mean, for one thing, they could take the Fifth Amendment and say, I'm refusing to answer because a truthful answer would tend to incriminate me, assuming we had this law going forward. Yeah. And so I'm trying to not sort of say, oh, you have to say X.
SPEAKER_00And this is that the government is dictating what the truth is. I'm modeling this on a system where you can have a false statement law and then it's left to a jury and a judge to assess whether that's been proved. But it's very different than... The German model I speak about, where in Germany there is a law, it's true in other parts of Europe as well, where the state has said that it is a crime to deny that the
Holocaust existed in a
SPEAKER_00public situation. And that has been held to be constitutional and consistent with their free speech rules because it rubs up against other constitutional provisions. Brian Beutler brianbeutler
SPEAKER_00Brian Beutler You don't have to say X or Y. If you choose to lie, then there can be consequences, both criminal and whether you can hold office. But you can still say those things. We're not stopping you. Brian Beutler
The reason I asked about it in the context of retroactivity is that if the law were
SPEAKER_01to pass as you envision it, and then you were a person who lived in Lauren Boebert's district, you would be like, I'm challenging her as she runs for re-election. I'm also going to try to get her disqualified because from 2020 through 2028, she was propounding the same exact lies Donald Trump was propounding. There's a bunch of people in Republican politics who meet your criteria. Yeah. So here's an easy way to deal with it.
SPEAKER_00This is what I would say is the easiest way to deal with that is, I mean, so you don't have to deal with the retroactivity issue. Let's assume that we now have a law that either criminalizes and or disqualifies. And there's a new election in five years. And you are running against me. And you say to me as part of the election, Well, was there fraud in the election or not? Right? And if I say,
yes, there was fraud in the election, like you've got a new statement.
SPEAKER_00Or I say, I'm refusing to answer that. I mean, okay, like you kind of win the debate then at that point. Right? I just feel like there's a way because we're dealing with this salient fact you can just re-up it and say well what's your position and see what people say and if they end up having to be mealy-mouthed about it. We've at least moved the debate because they're not willing to
just go flat out
SPEAKER_00with what I'll call the Trumpian. There was fraud in the election and this is what the Dominion voting systems did and this is what two Georgia election workers did. All sort of very specific things that can be proved to be false.
SPEAKER_01Point well taken. So your book is Proposes specific federal reforms um and because of that and state and state and it well yeah you're beating me to the point okay sorry but these the laws that you're talking about are federal so they would they would have to wait until 2029 or or beyond you know that There could be analogous laws governing state elections. And as it happens, I was reading your book just as Republicans started applying the 2020 playbook to the Los Angeles mayor's race.
SPEAKER_01And I run a bit hot. So I was like, aha, like, Andrew's put this idea out here. They're basically running a test of it. Let's have it out, right? Like we can kill two birds with one stone. Like California can fix the problems. It's like logistical difficulties counting ballots without doing it under the shadow of election lives because they could simultaneously say, Brian Beutler brianbeutler
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I assume that the lie about the 2020 election is one that we are going to be living with for a long time. So there's a lot where... I didn't imagine it was going to happen exactly at the time. But like, you know, when Donald Trump started railing about the Brazilian judicial system, it was as I'm writing my chapter about Brazil, which, you know, I was like,
SPEAKER_00OK, this is very timely. And so I This is one where you can see Gavin Newsom, I think he must have been reading about it and thinking about it because he tweeted on, I believe it was X, because somebody sent it to me. I'm not on X. You can make your own decisions about whether you want to be on X or not. So I think that it is certainly a strategy.
SPEAKER_00I'm not a political analyst, so I'm going to leave to you the wisdom of it and the timing and the strategy calls because that's not my forte. And as I keep on telling Nicole Wallace, I really try and stay in my lane because otherwise you're hearing from me that in something that I don't really have anything particularly unique or an expertise to offer as opposed to sort of the law world where at least
hopefully I have some
SPEAKER_00knowledge on that that's different that I can apply to a situation.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I wrote it and then I started thinking, you know, if Newsom were to sign a TIA-style law now in a manner designed to tell people like Spencer Pratt, what you're doing is disqualifying yourself from future elections, that Republicans and Brian Beutler
But that's where this is where I will say the last couple episodes of Maine
SPEAKER_00Justice, we deal with this. This is what courts do all the time. Courts deal with facts and law. And So that when you are saying something that is factually false, so when we did one of the other issues we dealt with this week was the president issued an executive order saying that we need to have trust. Truth in terms of our history be done by our national parks.
And truth in our history, he claimed, was eradicating any mention of slavery, of women's suffrage what we did to indigenous people and the court dealt with that and said that's not truth that's essentially me paraphrasing that's not truth that's a lie and this is one where there's nothing like having a judge turn to you and say
SPEAKER_00okay brian what what's your evidence like what do you got So it's the difference between being able to spout off and say so-and-so won and being in a court of law. And as I said, I think that's the reason that you saw and you still see people perfectly working. Brian Beutler
The lawyers didn't actually say there's fraud in a whole series of them because the
SPEAKER_00judge is like, what's your evidence? And they're like, no, no, no, we're arguing about some smaller things about access or the counting of certain ballots, but we're not saying there was all this fraud. Because in courts, that's subjective, oh, who's going to decide? The courts are the system that we have created for adjudicating what do we do when there is someone saying X and someone saying Y when it's something factual. And so we have a system that's already been created that we can
take advantage of.
SPEAKER_00And I would say right now, at least at the district court levels on the federal side, we are seeing judges who of all political persuasions standing up for truth and law i uh i see a question
SPEAKER_01here it says is brian at the doctor because behind me is this i am I normally work in a little home office, but my internet is not traveling at this, so I had to scramble to move to this little nook in my kitchen where we, for whatever reason, have hung this thing up. My health is fine. Thank you for your concern. I appreciate that because I want to believe that this problem is addressable without it just spiraling into a new he-said-she-said kind of
thing where they
SPEAKER_01attack a good-faith effort with a bad-faith effort. And I think a huge... Brian Beutler brianbeutler Brian Beutler
You can't have it be the case that Democrats appropriate funds for everyone or respond to disasters in every state while Republicans deprive blue states of their
SPEAKER_01share, right? That doesn't work. And that ends in national divorce or a war or whatever. And you can't have the law apply equally across partisan lines of the Democrats and then have Republicans pardon insurrectionists while charging peaceful protesters and because they're supposedly members of Antifa. That doesn't work either. And so in 2020, before the election, so this was before Stop the Steal got underway, I wrote a piece about how Democrats should seek to govern
because Biden was ahead.
SPEAKER_01It seemed like he was going to win. They should seek to govern in a way that defers bad faith using politics, right? Right. And I wanted them to be experimenting with legislation, you know, make it, remove the president's discretion to withhold disaster relief from blue states, etc., etc., etc. And so that Republicans would have to compete on the merits, right? Like, they would have to politic on the basis of honest, you know,
SPEAKER_01spun, but ultimately honest appeals. It hadn't occurred to me way back then that one could use, like, the actual justice system. Brian Beutler
Politics and shame and rhetoric and these other kinds of intangible things getting
SPEAKER_01us there without a kind of, you need a carrot and a stick, it seems to me.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think that's right. And just as a sort of concluding piece, I mean, I'm a lawyer and I'm at heart very much an institutionalist. And so I do think about how do we make our systems better? How do we make our systems harden the target and make it harder to infiltrate democratic institutions? And it's not a failsafe, and certainly my book is not by far the only thing that is
needed. And there are lots of important reforms that I think we're going to have to undertake.
SPEAKER_00But systems... should be working for us. At the end of the day, we're all humans, that humans can figure out ways to get around institutions and to undermine them, but we certainly don't have to make it easier for them to do that. And if I had one message to people, even if you thought, okay, well, Andrew's idea is interesting, but I'm not sure I'm convinced—
SPEAKER_00Is that, that's of course totally fine, but I think that we're going to be living with the problem of sort of political lies and sort of Trumpism for a long time because he is, people are going to emulate what he has done. It's been successful and people are going to try and do it. And so we cannot, if we get out of this in the next two years, we cannot just be thinking, okay,
SPEAKER_00we're done. Let's pretend that this never happened. Brian Beutler It is living in denial is not going to be the answer if we get
out of this and
SPEAKER_00pretending that it never happened. And so whether you think this is among the package of what's needed or something else, it's great for people to be thinking about it and also staying engaged. There's no more important time to be doing that. Amen Well the book is called Liar's Kingdom Do you happen to have a copy on hand
SPEAKER_01that you can hold up? I do My left button upstairs with all the technical gremlins chasing me out of my office I do There it is. Congratulations. It's number one bestseller. It is. You don't need me to help you sell copies, but I want to because I think it's important. No, thank you. And I also want, whichever your publisher, your first publisher was who got the willies and dropped you,
SPEAKER_01I hope that they noticed that they missed out on a bestseller. I'm sure they did. I'm sure they did. We can't disqualify them from publishing, but maybe they can learn the normal incentive way that when a good idea comes before them, they shouldn't avoid it just because it might piss off Donald Trump. Right. Totally great.
SPEAKER_00Well, thank you so much and thanks to everybody for joining in.
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net Last day to take advantage of this post-election discount. Things are starting to get real. I hope you’ll join us. Happy Veterans Day...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net Thanks to the many hundreds of you who watched live. Many new horizons just opened, so we’ll be covering a bunch of unexpected terrain...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net Last video mailbag before the election. We’ll reconvene shortly afterward. Thanks to everyone who tuned in live. And for subscribers that...
Had a good live chat Thursday with my pal Alex Wagner, covering the whole political waterfront. Special thanks to all who watched or listened live. In order we discussed: * Is veganism any weirder than eating...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net The veteran progressive policy hand Bharat Ramamurti joined me Friday for a long and in depth conversation about two issues confounding...