Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Off Message

Off Message artwork

Are Democrats Ready For Oversight And Accountability?

Aug 20, 202634 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net Thanks to everyone who watched in real time, and to those who left questions. Think we’ll do these about once a month going forward, not counting special impromptu streams. Especially now that I’ve moved my home office into a room with decent lighting and gotten out from in front of the dreaded Brown Curtain.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00All right,

SPEAKER_01we are live. I'm just going to give it a minute for the chat room to fill up a little more.

SPEAKER_00And then I'll start answering questions. How's everybody doing? Okay, there you go. Yeah, it's almost Friday. That's where the...

SPEAKER_01Some likes, some smiley faces, whatever.

SPEAKER_02All right, that's good. Everyone, it's Brian from Off Message. Doing a mailbag live. I think I'm going to aim to do these about once a month. The, you know, I should say like opinion overall among the readership seems to be more anti than pro, but not like I hate it, more like I prefer... Reading the mailbag to watching it or I don't have time to watch or that's just not how I consume media.

SPEAKER_02So I like the written version, but you do you. And then about one out of every four responses has been pretty enthusiastically pro the live mailbag. So at that ratio, I figure once a month, those people get a treat. The rest of the time, I'll write answers to the questions. So I'll do it. It's August 20th. I'll do it again in September once a month from here on out. All right. The first question,

SPEAKER_02I don't see any in the chat yet, but you can feel free to throw questions in there and I'll try to get to them. I'm about an hour. But I got questions from the thread on Sunday. And the first one is from Charles Kuffner. Who says there's a lot of talk about reforming SCOTUS in various ways. And while that's all good, it's not enough. I live in Texas. We have the awful Fifth Circuit over us. One of their justices writing about mail-in ballots. One of their justices recently wrote, mail-in ballots are prone to fraud.

SPEAKER_02And voting by mail jeopardizes election integrity and democracy itself. So basically just like reciting Trump talking points that are false. Not to mention single-judge divisions at the district level where the likes of Matthew Kaczmarek can give Ken Paxton and the Alliance Defending Freedom concierge service on whatever they want. We need to talk more about and have a plan for fixing these problems as well. Do you have any insight on this? Yes. I mean, those are like very well-stated complaints, like the accurate complaints.

SPEAKER_02Part of the reason they feel so cute is that Republicans control the Supreme Court. So getting things in front of the Supreme Court quickly where they think they can make new law or rewrite the Constitution, it's easy when you can just start with Matthew Kaczmarek, get his ruling upheld by the Fifth Circuit. It's controversial. It upends standard practice in the United States, so it makes it the Supreme Court quickly. And so... Expanding the Supreme Court would tend to just diminish this phenomenon a bit

SPEAKER_02or change it at least because Republican activists would be hesitant to put things in front of the Supreme Court when the Supreme Court might create law that they don't want as opposed to what they have now, which is the Supreme Court that will make law that they want.

SPEAKER_01But Lower courts can muck things

SPEAKER_02up if you're trying to govern. I mean, sometimes for good reason, but just for argument's sake, we're talking about judges operating in bad faith in Texas. So my view on this is that you should think about court reform in terms of Fixing the immediate legitimacy and corruption problem on the Supreme Court, and then separately, probably separately, fixing the sort of structural problems with the judiciary.

SPEAKER_02And these are related, but they're different, right? Adding four seats to the Supreme Court doesn't structurally change anything. I mean, do you have to change the structure of the dais or whatever to add four seats? But the process by which the courts operated would be unchanged. It would just require... Seven votes to get a majority as opposed to five. And that is... Super important. And I think would need to happen very quickly if you couldn't think ahead to 2029.

SPEAKER_02Democrats control the presidency, House, and Senate. And you could do that with a one-page piece of legislation. And then it'd be done, right? And then there'd be four vacancies in the Supreme Court. Those would have to be filled. And then the Supreme Court could get— the newly constituted Supreme Court could get to work quickly overturning bad precedent and basically just getting out of the way. You know, judicial review is— The Supreme Court, because of how Republicans have commandeered it,

SPEAKER_02Stands as a kind of permanent inquisition against Democratic legislation. So any big law that Democrats pass, you can count on it to be frozen in some form or fashion by a lower court and then reviewed by the Supreme Court, which will be hostile to it. And that's not the way it's supposed to work. It's like, it's not the way it worked until, I mean... In modern history, at least until like the Roberts Court era. So you need to solve that problem quickly because other things need to happen, right? Like if you're going to do statehood for Washington, D.C.,

SPEAKER_02this Supreme Court would, I think, in bad faith stand as a real impediment to that. They'd be like, oh, the Constitution says 10 miles square. And so the state of D.C. can't be a state. Sorry. You know, and what do you do then, right? You haven't changed the Supreme Court. You passed your statehood law. They immediately overturn it. There go two senators, there goes the enfranchisement of 600, 7,000 residents of Washington. But I don't think that has to be the end of the story, or necessarily should it be, right? Because, you know, people are worried about,

SPEAKER_02so you add four seats to the court, next time there's a Republican trifecta, they'll add another four, and you're just kind of on this race to the bottom. And that doesn't, like, disturb me the way it disturbs some people, but it's not optimal, right? Like, Ideally, if we're going to have a rule of law system, you want judicial institutions that have credibility across the ideological spectrum. And so there needs to be a reckoning for what's happened over the last 20 years or so. But from there, I don't think it's necessarily like the end of the story.

SPEAKER_02You should endeavor to... Modify how Supreme Court appointments work, how much power lower courts have, what jurisdiction they have, essentially like, are they really allowed to just second guess everything that Congress passes or is their jurisdiction more limited? Do some things that pertain to federal matters have to go straight to the D.C. Circuit or can they run through Texas?

SPEAKER_02Those are all ideas that are out there about, and these are structural reforms. And I think once you've solved the immediate problem of the Supreme Court standing as this bad faith inquisition against Democrats, you can ask Republicans, look, are you interested in fixing this for all time? Or do you want to get revenge on us next time you have a trifecta? And I don't know what the situation is going to be in 2029. But if it's, you know, if Republicans are,

SPEAKER_02if Trump ruins the Republican Party and they're looking for, you know, any kind of olive branch to hold on to to steady themselves so they can rebuild, it's not crazy to me to wonder if they'll, you know, come in To negotiate. And then you could do that stuff. And it would be useful for them, too, because they would eventually want, you know, reconstitute themselves, gain power. And they would be able to kind of count on like small-D democracy letting them govern.

SPEAKER_02So, I mean... This may all be wish casting, but yes, you're right. Like there are problems below the level of the Supreme Court. They don't go away just because you pat the Supreme Court, at least not entirely. And so they should be dealt with. But I don't think at the expense of making it so that a democratic trifecta drags its heels on court reform, on court expansion at the top, because the window will close and then you will get nothing. Okay. Scrolling, scrolling.

SPEAKER_02David Vandenberg asks, what are the keys to making Trump's corruption... For example, the fact that this crypto venture now has legal status as a bank, which I find amazing and terrifying, and ICE and related conduct, the shock gloves, the DOJ probes of left-wing activists in Minnesota added in my mind broadly. How do you make these salient among a majority of voters? How do we get to a place where a majority of the country, ideally an overwhelming one, says, by God, we can't have this and acts accordingly accordingly?

SPEAKER_02Um, why is there any time being spent on reliving woke one, however defined, instead of all the various and sundry regime horrors? Okay, I sympathize with this. Um, I had bookmarked Ellis Weiner's question, which is about, um, I'm sorry, but I don't know if it's Weiner or Weiner. Ellis's question about, um, the democratic oversight agenda if they take the House. And these are sort of related questions. In some ways, Ellis's question answers David's. Um, Because the

SPEAKER_02reason there's discourse about woke one versus the various and Sunday regime horrors is that Democrats are at a low ebb of agenda setting power right now. They don't control the House. They don't control the Senate. And so their attention grabbing methods are limited. Right. Right. They can do things like Keith Ellison in Minnesota just sued. He's the attorney general in Minnesota. He just sued Greg Abbott in Texas to get an ICE agent who committed crimes returned

SPEAKER_02to Minnesota, right? That's a legal process. It's not super flashy, but it's interesting, right? And it has gotten some attention. And then obviously, John Ossoff on Friday did. And so now, you know, Republicans are trying to make this so like, oh, was that inappropriate? But it's drawn attention to this question of who's Natalie Harp and why does Donald Trump need the security blanket and why is he like,

SPEAKER_02So obsessed with his ballroom and the plane that the Qataris gifted him and stuff like that. It's not impossible to break through. It's just much, much, much, much harder when you can't make news events happen through the oversight process. And so I think that step one towards rebalancing this and like... In a way that feels more appropriate, right? Like we're talking about woke one when all this horrible stuff is happening. I mean, the context is that Democrats are just finishing up primary season and the question

SPEAKER_02of whether some candidates have... Made themselves unelectable with their track records is sort of at the forefront of everyone's mind, right? That's the agenda. And Democrats don't have gavels in Congress to be like, hey, we can, like, that's an inside conversation for adults. Like, let's have a hearing about ICE or whatever. And so the change will happen after the midterms, assuming Democrats take at least one Either the House or the Senate.

SPEAKER_02And I think they will. Ellis's question is, if and when that happens, what can they do to block Trump and his agenda, specifically as regards Trump's open corruption, Iran, Todd Blanchett's corruption and probable perjuries, Epstein's And the RFK Jr. Campaign of Disease. If the short answer is hold hearings, okay, but how am I supposed to get any work done if I'm watching them all and gobbling popcorn? So...

SPEAKER_02Hearings are a part of it, and they're like step one, right, of any kind of effort to rein these things in or impose accountability without controlling the executive branch. Basically, I guess, maybe more like step two. Your committees get constituted, you get the majority powers, you get investigative staff. They ideally come in knowing some stuff about all of these issues,

SPEAKER_02depending on which committee they're on. They endeavor to get more information. The chairman request or subpoena records. And then they put together an investigation, the beginning stages of an investigation where they try to figure out what happened behind the scenes that the public doesn't know. And then when they have enough information that they know that they can command a hearing, right? And not get surprised by a witness being like,

SPEAKER_02no, actually you have this all wrong and everything's above board. Then they do a hearing and then Then there's invariably, especially with Trump, some kind of clash over what documents Congress is entitled to, whose testimony they're entitled to. And my concern is that Democrats aren't thinking about and aren't prepared for and aren't willing to really escalate in that conflict, right? The...

SPEAKER_02Similar to the steps where you do an investigation behind the scenes, you do a hearing, and then you angle for accountability. Someone's trying to hide something, you're trying to get a document pried loose from the executive branch somehow. There's a similar ladder of conflict where you start with, in an ideal world where you have Congress that's doing an investigation in good faith and an administration that's trying to govern mostly in good faith.

SPEAKER_02You start where committee staff negotiates with executive branch staff over what will be produced. And all that stuff comes to Congress and it forms the basis of an investigation. But then even like in a realm of good faith like that, there will be friction about certain information, certain documents, certain people's testimony. Like, are they legitimately covered by a state secret privilege or executive privilege or whatever?

SPEAKER_02And if there's real dispute about that where the Congress feels like, oh, I can't, we can't do this investigation without information. Then there's subpoena power, there's various forms of contempt, right? You do civil contempt where you ask a judge to resolve the issue. You do criminal contempt where you refer whoever's not complying with the subpoena to the Justice Department. And then there's inherent contempt, which hasn't been used in like 150 years, where you

SPEAKER_02compel directly what you want. And that can include actually like... Jailing or confining a witness until they break. And what happened in 2019 and 2020 is essentially that Trump threw up many more roadblocks than is normal to oversight. And the Democratic response generally, not entirely, was to let the courts sort it out. And that meant that most investigations hit a brick wall, that things played out in courtrooms,

SPEAKER_02And it took a long time for courts to weigh in on the Supreme Court to ultimately weigh in on what must go to Congress from either the executive branch or private companies holding Trump's records or whatever. And I don't think it's going to fly for the Democratic majority given how little trust their own voters have in them. Or the leadership or whatever to do that all over again, right? And so they should be thinking about what they're going to do

SPEAKER_02when Trump actually increases the level of resistance to oversight, right? Like his Office of Legal Counsel just in the last week or two has issued an opinion that basically says private advisors to the president, right? Are covered by executive privilege, which is, I mean, like, legally, it's bullshit. But what it does is it gives somebody whose testimony is being compelled from the private sector a legal cover to say, hey, I can't testify about this, even though I'm under subpoena or whatever. And then the courts have to first adjudicate the question of

SPEAKER_02whether executive privilege applies before the investigation can move on. And if... If Democrats intend to just go through the normal motions when Trump is going to extraordinary lengths to conceal information, people are going to get frustrated and wonder why they aren't doing more. And so I would like to see them revive inherent contempt. And, you know, like, how exactly would that work?

SPEAKER_02I mean, Sergeant at Arms... Goes and nabs somebody and holds them in a room. They were talking at one point about garnishing people's wages. I don't know how they think that they could make that happen. But I think a big one is getting comfortable with the idea that large swaths of the executive branch will be unfunded, right? So take the Todd Blanche example from Ellis' question. His corruption, his probable perjuries. Like his perjury... There's not going to be much to be done about it other than expose it

SPEAKER_02until Democrats are in power in the executive branch. And even then, Trump... So he may not ever be held a criminal account for perjury, but I think there's a good chance he will never practice law again after this term. But he is currently violating the Epstein Files Transparency Act, right? And if those files don't get shaken loose before power changes hands... Democrats can basically be like, we can't fund the offices that are involved in this cover-up.

SPEAKER_02And that's going to be messy, right? Like, that means that you go into the appropriations process, you zero out funding for the Attorney General's offices, other offices, and then, what? So Trump vetoes the appropriations bill or the omnibus or whatever, and you have at least a partial government shutdown. You have to just be willing to live with that, right? And defend it. And if Trump insists that the rest of the government has to be shut down because parts of the Justice Department are shut down,

SPEAKER_02that's something he has to live with. And, you know, the public needs to Go to him and say in the cover-up. But I don't feel like Democrats have shown that they're prepared for that, right? Like they just bypassed their last opportunity

SPEAKER_02use this same leverage to try to, what I had suggested was to try to secure the election. They extended government funding past the election and they did it into the lame duck period. Instead of into the new year. So we're going to hit a funding deadline after most likely Democrats have retaken Congress. And like, They're not going to work with Susan Collins on defunding DOJ to get the Epstein files, right? They're just going to extend funding again, right? And so there won't be a leverage point to try to pry information loose from

SPEAKER_02the government for months and months and months and months after they take back over. And then like the other tool they have is impeachment. Which was the exception in 2019, too. Impeachment doesn't, like, inherent contempt is like a guy with a gun, maybe, shows up and is like, you're under arrest until you testify. And, like, I get why people are a little squeamish about that. Impeachment doesn't, like, magically make Congress stronger. It doesn't imbue them with more manpower or anything like that.

SPEAKER_02But it does put Congress at the height of its authority, basically. And so what does that mean? Is that, like, We saw this with the impeachment of the Ukraine scandal is that Trump had been doing a really good job suppressing oversight. And then Congress went into impeachment mode and people came from the administration and testified a mix of voluntarily and under compulsion. And the reason is, is that, well, I think part of it is psychological.

SPEAKER_02It's like, this is an impeachment inquiry. And maybe the information I have will help exonerate the president or whichever official is being impeached. Or maybe I know that something really bad happened and Congress has to know. And under normal oversight, I might not Also, you know, if Congress is investigating the impeachment of somebody, their arguments in court, both for a decision in their favor and that the court needs to move faster,

SPEAKER_02much stronger. But to unlock that kind of abstract form of power, you need to be willing to Do impeachments like and not just one when your hand is forced because a whistleblower comes forward. It's like, oh, he's cheating in the election. And if we don't impeach him, then, you know, he's just going to steal it. Like there are many, many, many officials in the administration right now who have committed impeachable offenses, including the president. And you have to be willing to hold process under those terms to unlock that kind

SPEAKER_02of authority and And they don't even want to say the word impeachment. So I'm not super hopeful that they are, they have a strategy in mind for how to overcome the bad faith obstruction of oversight that we can count on Trump deploying. And, you know, and so I'm going to have to write a bunch of fucking frustrating articles about, you know, them betraying their promises and stuff like that.

SPEAKER_01But I mean, I hope to be proven wrong. Okay.

SPEAKER_02I've been talking a lot and not checking the chat, so I'm sorry if there are questions. I don't see any questions. Come on, guys. But I do have more questions from the Sunday Open thread. Here's John C. Merfeld. He writes, I voted for David Crowley in Wisconsin's gubernatorial primary this week and was relieved that he pulled out the win. My friends and I have been debating whether Tony Evers' resurrection of Crowley's campaign constitutes meddling by the Democratic Party.

SPEAKER_02To me, meddling implies something done in bad faith or deceptively that puts a thumb on the scales of an election. I don't deny that Evers' actions swung the outcome through some combination of siphoning Hong's support and consolidating the anti-Hung vote for Crowley. I just think that's part of his job. For the party's sake, though, it's ominous if we can't agree on whether that's appropriate since something similar could well happen in 2028. Assuming you agree with the president premise, how should we make the argument that this kind of consolidation is fair play and minimize the contempt between the factions?

SPEAKER_02So I do agree. I mean, it's called the Democratic Party and it is an entity, right? It is the superstructure or not the superstructure. It is a structure on which candidates run for office and the idea that they should like... Just sit there and, I don't know, provide staff without stating any preference at all about who should represent the party. At the extremes, we know this happens because occasionally some total nutcase will run

SPEAKER_02the Democratic Party. They'll get enough signatures, they'll be on the ballot. Yeah. Under their mantle? Like, no, obviously not. Parties are much weaker than they used to be, but they shouldn't have zero strength.

SPEAKER_02And so clearly there's some role. And I don't think that there was anything wrong with what Tony Evers did. And I don't think that there's anything wrong in principle with National Democrats doing similar things. I think that the reason we're having this Kind of debate over establishment meddling is not because anyone is really seriously disagrees that parties should have a say over who represents them on the ballot.

SPEAKER_02If you imagine the left wing taking over the Democratic Party, I don't think that that's really how they feel. I think that that's a convenient argument for the time being because it helps them overcome establishment opposition, right? The issue, the reason it feels like a live question of controversy right now is that the establishment at the national level specifically It has been discredited in

SPEAKER_02the eyes of voters. And so when people voting in primaries hear that Chuck Schumer endorsed somebody or people close to President Biden endorsed somebody or Kamala Harris endorsed somebody, they don't necessarily think, oh, that's a good thing. They think you guys are the ones who lost to Trump two out of three times. And you're telling me that this is the person you want to be my senator. And because they're the most electable, but what do you even know about that?

SPEAKER_02And this other guy who you say is unelectable looks like he stands for something or she stands for something. I'm going to go with him. And I think that that's a totally reasonable heuristic for a voter to adopt. They're not saying that Democratic Party leaders should never be able to weigh in, right? They're saying, I don't trust you specific people at the top of the Democratic Party who probably should have relinquished your leadership posts after losing the second of three elections to Trump.

SPEAKER_02Tony Evers is part of the Democratic establishment technically, but like of Wisconsin, where Democrats have just been winning and winning and winning and winning, right? Like his credibility is very high. And things are going well in the Democrats' direction to this close to undoing the... The rigging of the Wisconsin democracy that began in 2010 by Republicans. And so I think that his endorsement therefore carried a lot of weight because people

SPEAKER_02in Wisconsin view him differently than they probably view Chuck Schumer. Also, that was a bubonatorial race, so Chuck Schumer wouldn't be weighing in. But the analogy holds, right? Like if... If Tony Evers had sat on his hands in the gubernatorial race, but then Ken Martin or, I don't know, Hillary Clinton or Kamala Harris, you know, had come in to say vote for Crowley over Hong, I think people would have been like, why are you here?

SPEAKER_02What expertise do you think you bring to this decision? So that's honestly how I see it. And the precedent here, I think, is 2020, right? Where, like, We'd all be living in a different world if everything that happened in 2020 happened exactly the same, but Joe Biden had been 68 instead of 78. But what happened at the end of that primary, let's tell the story of the whole primary, because the fact that Biden was 78, I think, would have doomed him in that primary,

SPEAKER_02except that he had high name recognition, right? So he gets into the race in 2019. It's a very lackluster campaign. But he polls like at 30% because he has the highest name recognition. And so you interview voters, you conduct surveys, you can find evidence that no one's really enthused about this situation and But also they don't know who anyone else is except Bernie Sanders, right? And for that reason, you know, that's why Cory Booker's campaign ends and Harris's and all these other Democrats can't get fundraising because Joe Biden is just up at

SPEAKER_02the top and nobody wants to donate money to a presidential primary campaign that can't break 10%. So that's why it comes down to Biden and Sanders eventually. And it comes down to because two younger Democrats, Buttigieg, And Amy Klobuchar, they think Biden is a safer bet. They drop out, they throw their support to him, and it turns things around for him after he's lost like three primaries in a row. And so there's the establishment like meddling in the primary.

SPEAKER_02And it really does save Biden. Like he was gonna lose. And instead he becomes a nominee. But then instead of creating permanent contempt between the factions, it turns out because they work together, because Biden's a pretty affable guy, there's probably a small element of sexism in there somewhere. Unlike in 2016 when Clinton and Sanders just clashed forever,

SPEAKER_02Biden and Bernie Sanders were able to get together, reestablish a friendship, a partnership. They did these... Biden-Sanders unity task forces where Biden picked some people, Sanders picked some people. They got into rooms together to come up with a consensus agenda kind of across all issues. And it made for factional peace. It was good enough for Biden to win the presidency. And the truce really held all the way through until Biden had to drop out.

SPEAKER_02And I think that model has not been discredited by the fact that Harris ended up Losing the 2024 election. I think you're kind of seeing an ad hoc congressional version of the same thing kind of taking place now with the DSCC and Chuck Schumer coming in and endorsing Abdul El-Sayed, who they obviously didn't want to win that primary. And, you know, like, we'll see how things look after Labor Day.

SPEAKER_02But I think that Some of the tension we've been living through for the last month or so is gonna feel like distant memory come September, October. And it's because there's really actually no problem. With how progressives are trying to help their candidates and establishment figures are trying to help establishment candidates. Sometimes establishment people win, sometimes the progressive people win. Then they come together, they figure out where their common ground is and they run on that. And that'll happen, I think, again, in the 2028 presidential cycle.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Real Reason Democrats Fear Accountability Politics

    Nov 11, 202630 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net Last day to take advantage of this post-election discount. Things are starting to get real. I hope you’ll join us. Happy Veterans Day...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Lindsey Graham’s Prophecy Finally Came True

    Nov 5, 202620 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net Thanks to the many hundreds of you who watched live. Many new horizons just opened, so we’ll be covering a bunch of unexpected terrain...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Limits Of The Possible In 2027

    Oct 15, 20266 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net Last video mailbag before the election. We’ll reconvene shortly afterward. Thanks to everyone who tuned in live. And for subscribers that...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Socialism Of Fools

    Oct 9, 202635 minAudio

    Had a good live chat Thursday with my pal Alex Wagner, covering the whole political waterfront. Special thanks to all who watched or listened live. In order we discussed: * Is veganism any weirder than eating...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Affordability Mirage, A.I. Safety, And The Collapse Of Sacred Assumptions

    Sep 21, 202638 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.offmessage.net The veteran progressive policy hand Bharat Ramamurti joined me Friday for a long and in depth conversation about two issues confounding...

    Credit the people on this episode