Watch the video: https://mythicmindfellowship.com/the-conflict-in-the-lord-of-the-rings-is-about-god-according-to-tolkien-mythic-mind-ep-199/ When Tolkien was pressed to say what the conflict at the heart of The Lord of the Rings was finally about, he pointed to God. In a note now published as letter 183 in Humphrey Carpenter's collection, he said the war is about God and his sole right to divine honor. Sauron desired to be a God-King. The War of the Ring is first a war over worship. This episode shares a lecture I recently gave at Huntington University on divine honor in The Lord of the Rings, the topic of my forthcoming book, reproduced here with their permission. I follow that claim through three lives, each brought by the One Ring to a decision about whom they will honor. Sauron began as a gifted servant and fell by loving order more than the One who orders all things. Too ashamed to return for judgment, he poured his own power into the Ring and bound himself to a thing that could be lost. In grasping for power, he was grasped by it. Augustine, in the City of God, describes the same diminishment: the one who tries to be his own light turns from the light that would have made him shine. Boromir is a valiant man whose virtues, ordered toward the wrong end, became the doorway of his temptation. He wanted to save Gondor and came to call a stolen thing a gift. After he tried to take the Ring from Frodo, he named his sin, spent his life defending the hobbits he had wronged, and received from the true king an honor he could never have taken for himself. Frodo came to the Ring by inheritance. He accepted a burden he did not choose, learned pity on the road, and failed at the Cracks of Doom. The Ring was unmade through what Tolkien called eucatastrophe, and the mercy Frodo had shown while he was still free saved him when he was no longer free. The honor given him afterward belongs to the king who gives it, and the maimed hand became the title of his glory. The desire that ruins Sauron is common to every human heart. We may never hold a ring of power, but we are daily offered something that promises to make us masters: the chance to order our small worlds according to our own wisdom, or to secure some genuine good by grasping at the apparently necessary means. True honor is received and given, and it is grounded in God, who alone has the right to divine honor. In the questions that follow the lecture, we turn to Gollum's part in the unmaking of the Ring, Leaf by Niggle, the problem of orcs, and why Frodo leaves the Shire. Chapters: 00:00 A lecture shared with permission 01:13 Why The Lord of the Rings began to matter 05:09 The conflict is about God 07:16 The Ainulindale and the first discord 09:15 Why honor must be grounded in the good 10:36 Allegory, applicability, and the Ring 12:50 Honor grasped, tested, and given 13:49 Sauron loves order more than the One who orders 22:02 Boromir is tested and rises by confession 30:30 Frodo receives a burden and shows mercy 34:36 Failure at Mount Doom and the meaning of mercy 39:01 What these three lives show us 42:05 Questions from the audience 55:52 Fellowship close Related videos: Tolkien's Long Defeat: Northern Courage and Christian Hope (Mythic Mind, ep. 75): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zQZuCpAd8t8 On Fairy-Stories: Subcreation, Escape, and Consolation (Mythic Mind, ep. 36): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a0hIBT-Ncss The Lord of the Rings with Mythic Mind: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kAvqcTcYbcE 📚 Books discussed The Lord of the Rings by J.R.R. Tolkien: https://bookshop.org/a/129785/9780544003415 The Silmarillion by J.R.R. Tolkien: https://bookshop.org/a/129785/9780544338012 The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien (revised and expanded edition, edited by Humphrey Carpenter): https://bookshop.org/a/129785/9780358652984 City of God by Augustine (Penguin Classics, trans. Henry Bettenson): https://bookshop.org/a/129785/9780140448948 Join the Mythic Mind Fellowship: https://mythicmindfellowship.com/membership Listen to/watch the Mythic Mind podcasts: - Mythic Mind - Mythic Mind Games - Mythic Mind Movies #MythicMind #Tolkien #LordOfTheRings #DivineHonor #Philosophy #Theology #Silmarillion #Sauron #Boromir #Frodo Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/mythic-mind--5808321/support.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hi there.
Speaker 2I was recently invited to speak at Huntington University on Divine Honor in the Lord of the Rings, which is the topic of my forthcoming book. And they graciously allowed me to reproduce that for you here. So I hope you enjoy.
Speaker 1Dr.
Speaker 3Andrew Snyder is a philosopher and theologian with particular interest in the theological imagination of C.S. Lewis and J.R.R. Tolkien and the theology of the self in Soren Kierkegaard. He teaches philosophy and Christian thought at several universities and leads the Mythic Mind Fellowship, which pursues wisdom through primary and secondary worlds with podcasts, articles, and focused studies. He is the author of the forthcoming book, Divine Honor in the Lord of the Rings. He earned his PhD in theological
Speaker 3studies from Regent University and lives in Williamsburg, Virginia. Please join me in giving a forester welcome to Dr. Andrew Snyder.
Speaker 1All right. It's been a harrowing journey today that brought me here between delayed flights, missed flights, and many hours in the Atlanta airport. But I suppose a harrowing journey is very fitting for our topic today, talking about the Lord of the Rings. Now, I hope you'll forgive me that I'm going to stick to my notes more so than I normally do at a presentation like this. I normally like to keep things somewhat organic. But if I speak extemporaneously on this topic, I'm not going to get through my introduction. Today, I am here to talk to
Speaker 1you about Lord of the Rings, which is a story that is special to countless readers, and I'll even include movie watchers and everyone who has in some way interacted with the material that Tolkien has given us. For my own part, I didn't grow up reading Tolkien like I know many people did, probably some people here have. Of course, I was familiar with him from a young age. I've always enjoyed Peter Jackson's movies, and I still do despite my gripes now as a reader. But I didn't really take up and read Tolkien until later in life, close to finishing my doctoral work. For reasons I'm not going
Speaker 1to get into at this moment, I found myself in the most difficult season of my life at this time. Now, I had theology that could account for something about the reality of loss and suffering in relation to the goodness of God. And doctrine is important. We need good doctrine. But also, we need to be able to experience the goodness of God during the dark nights of the soul. And that's not always the same thing as confessionally having the right doctrine as important as the confessional doctrine is.
Speaker 1And that is something that Tolkien helped me to experience through his writing. I found myself drawn to the Tolkienian world through certain voices that I had followed on X or then Twitter at the time. And eventually, on what felt like a whim that I now recognize to be a turn of providence, I purchased the books and I began reading. From the first pages of the Fellowship, something began to stir in my soul, and I knew that I was engaging with something real even though I didn't yet have the right vocabulary for really knowing what that
Speaker 1is in an articulate way. But I did know that I was on a path. In particular, it was Tolkien's interweaving of sorrow and joy that drew me in. His entire world is saturated with the sense of longing that even in the happy times is unfulfilled. This is, of course, the longing for home. It's a longing for the ultimate consolation and the remaking of what has been bent. The good times of the story are truly good, but they are also echoes of a greater reality to come. Even
Speaker 1the bad times are reminders that goodness is real, indeed, even more real than the darkness, because there is light and high beauty forever beyond the reach of the fleeting shadow. And that is something that often we don't recognize until we find ourselves in a dark and forsaken land. As Haldir says near the end of The Fellowship of the Ring, the world is indeed full of peril, and in it there are many dark places, but still there is much that is fair, and though in all lands love is now mingled with grief, it grows perhaps the greater. That
Speaker 1Christian hope, that sorrow, is not incongruous with joy, but indeed it is necessary for our fullest experience of joy is what most resonates with me when I read The Lord of the Rings. Now, there are, of course, many readings of the Lord of the Rings that might be offered, attempts to get at what Tolkien is fundamentally telling us through this story. Some readers have found in it a parable for the world wars, while others have found in it an ecological lament, or a meditation on friendship, or simply a great adventure of swords and orcs and walking trees.
Speaker 1And each of these readings touches on something real in the story. However, When Tolkien himself was pressed to say what the conflict at the heart of the story was finally about, he did not point to politics, to industry, or even to freedom. He pointed to God. My purpose today is to take that answer seriously and to follow it through the lives of three characters who are each brought by the alluring power of the One Ring to a decision about whom they will honor. The answer that Tolkien gave to what the fundamental conflict is in The
Speaker 1Lord of the Rings comes to a response that he wrote to W.H. Auden's review of The Return of the King, which appeared in the New York Times book review in January of 1956. Tolkien's note, now published as Letter 183 in Humphrey Carpenter's collection, was apparently written for his own satisfaction and wasn't actually sent to anybody. Tolkien was not writing this for a certain audience. He was more thinking aloud about the nature of the story that he has provided. And this is what he had to say. In the
Speaker 1Lord of the Rings, the conflict is not basically about freedom, though that is naturally involved. It is about God and his sole right to divine honor. The Eldar and the Numenoreans believed in the one, the true God, and held worship of any other person an abomination. Sauron desired to be a god-king and was held to be this by his servants. If he had been victorious, he would have demanded divine honor from all rational creatures and absolute temporal power over the whole world. The war of the ring then is not first a war of territory, nor even
Speaker 1a war of liberty against tyranny, although it's certainly both of those things, but it's rather a war over worship. Sauron does not merely want to rule, he wants to be honored as only God may be honored. Freedom matters because the human person was made to give honor freely to the one who deserves it, and it is this honor that actually precedes true freedom. Those who grasp for divine honor are grasped by it in turn, and they are diminished into shadows of what they were meant to be.
Speaker 1Those who give honor where it is due find, to their surprise very often, that they are given an even greater glory than any that they could have taken. And this claim about divine honor is not an isolated remark that we find in one obscure letter from Tolkien, but rather a thread that runs through the entirety of his legendarium from the first page. Going to the Anilindale, which is the creation account that opens the Silmarillion, which, if you don't know, comes before in Tolkien's chronology, The Lord of the Rings, even though it was published afterwards. In fact, it was published through the help of his son after
Speaker 1Tolkien's death. But the material in the Silmarillion long predates the material of The Lord of the Rings. And in this creation account, the Einor, which are the great spirits that are something like angels in Tolkien's story. they sing the great music before Iluvatar, who is the one, the god of Tolkien's cosmos, who Tolkien is very explicitly trying to portray as essentially the Christian god. Because for Tolkien's story, I mean, he's not simply creating a mythology, although he
Speaker 1is doing that, but he wants to create a mythology that is at least congruous with Christian doctrine. He makes the point to say in one of his letters to his publisher that, that even the Valar who are involved in the creation of the world, he says he wants to present them in a way that is congruous with belief in the Blessed Trinity. And so even though he's telling a fictional story, he's not doing theology, his fictional story is meant to be a sub-created world that has a relation to the world that he knows as a Christian. And so Iluvatar the One has all of the Ainur
Speaker 1singing their song around him, and this is part of the design of creation. Their song is a response of praise to the theme that he has given them. However, Melkor, who is a Satan-like figure in his story, is the mightiest of the Ainur, and he wove into the music themes of his own imagining. And Tolkien tells us that he sought therein to increase the power and glory of the part assigned to himself. The first evil in Tolkien's world, therefore, is not an act of violence, but it's an act of misplaced honor. And every evil that follows, from the
Speaker 1fall of Sauron to the pride of Numenor, to the fall of Sauron the Wise, to the greed of a hobbit by a riverbank, is in some measure an echo of that first discord. We must also be clear about what evil is, because that helps to explain why honor must be grounded in the good. Tolkien does not believe that there is any such thing as absolute evil in a world fashioned by a good god. Being is good. He writes that, in my story, I do not deal in absolute evil. I do not think there is such
Speaker 1a thing, since that would be a zero. Evil is not a rival substance, but a privation, a good thing twisted out of its proper order. And so there's always some good to be found, even in the darkest of deeds, even though we're dealing with misplaced affections and inverted purposes. As Tolkien wrote to his son Michael in 1941, you have to understand the good in things to detect the real evil. Order, service, and the love of one's home are all good things, but as with all good things, they become bad things when they're removed from the proper
Speaker 1context and sought apart from that which makes good things good. the same thread can be followed into the hearts of the heroes as well as the villains. Tolkien's great wrongdoers are those who attempt to ascend to a godhood that is not theirs to claim, but his heroes are tempted in the very same way, and their shortcomings come from the same root. The difference is not that the good characters lack the desire for power, but rather that they learn, often painfully, to surrender it, that they might gain the true power of virtue through rightly ordered affections. Now, an
Speaker 1obvious objection arises at this point from those who are at least a little bit familiar with Tolkien. In fact, if you've even read the foreword to The Fellowship of the Ring, because Tolkien insisted in the foreword that the story is neither allegorical nor topical. And he famously added, I cordially dislike allegory in all its manifestations. However, that sentence is immediately followed by the critical clarifier. I much prefer history, true or feigned, with its varied applicability to
Speaker 1the thought and experience of readers. He continues that applicability resides in the freedom of the reader, while allegory resides in the purpose domination of the author. Thus, Tolkien does not reject the idea that his story touches on the reader's own life, but he rejects a kind of control over the reader. Gandalf dies and returns in glory, but Gandalf is not Christ. Frodo bears a burden on behalf of the world, but Frodo is not Christ either. Aragorn returns to his kingdom and sits on the throne, but he also is not Christ. What Tolkien gives us is
Speaker 1not a set of symbols to be decoded, but rather a world in which the deepest realities of our own world are at work. Creation and fall, pride and humility, mercy and grace. Although it may be presented in a secondary world, any genuine truth runs through all worlds and thereby becomes of concern for the reader wherever he finds himself. And so the one ring provides a uniquely revealing lens through which to view the souls of those who encounter it. The ring is not a neutral object. It is the
Speaker 1concentrated will of Sauron to be honored as a god-king. And so every character who meets it is confronted, whether knowingly or not, with the question of divine honor. To desire the ring is to desire, in some measure, the place that belongs to God alone. To refuse it is to confess, albeit with the limited theology of a pre-Christian world that Tolkien gives us, that such a place is not ours to take. The ring offers to each character exactly what his or her heart most desires. And in doing so, it reveals whether that heart is ordered toward
Speaker 1the honor of the one, or the exaltation of the self. Now, in my forthcoming book, I follow 12 characters divided into three sections, each of which corresponds to a different response to the question of divine honor. In part one, Honor Grasped, we consider characters that reach for the honor that belongs to God alone attempted to grasp it. Here we find Sauron, Saruman, Isildur, and Gollum. And I will say that it's debatable whether
Speaker 1or not Isildur actually belongs in this section. But part two, honor tested, turns to those who were brought to the very edge of falling and whose stories reveal the drama of the temptation itself. Here we find Boromir, Faramir, Galadriel, and Bilbo. Part three, honor given, considers characters who in different ways gave their honor away and so received a greater one. Here we find Gandalf, Tom Bombadil, Frodo, and Samwise Gamgee. And today we're going to take one figure from each of these sections as a demonstration of the thesis. We're going to look at Sauron who grasps, Boromir who
Speaker 1is tested, and Frodo to whom honor was given. Now we begin with Sauron because his story is the pattern for every story that follows in grasping at power, at the power that doesn't belong to the one who's grasping. If you know Sauron chiefly as the great burning eye of the Peter Jackson films, then you may think of him as a force of pure destruction or nihilistic rage. However, if we consider Sauron as Tolkien presents him, then we find that he began as a good and a gifted servant who fell by loving order more than the one
Speaker 1who orders all things. What made Sauron evil is that he loves lesser goods such as order and even the healing of a ruined world above the good from which they come. At the root of the matter, Sauron loves himself above Eru Iluvatar, the god of Tolkien's world. Sauron demonstrates the thesis in its negative form because he shows what becomes of a creature who will not receive honor but insists on seizing it. Sauron belongs to a class of beings that Tolkien calls the Maiar, which are something
Speaker 1like lesser angels who serve the Valar, the great powers of the world. As with all other created beings, Sauron was originally good. He first served Ale, the Valar most concerned with craftsmanship. Early in the history of the world, Sauron fell into the service of Melkor, whom the elves named Morgoth, a name that means something like the dark enemy. Even so, Tolkien tells us that Sauron was only less evil than his master, and that for long he served another and not himself. Obviously, serving the villainous Morgoth was not a great move. It's not usually a good thing
Speaker 1to be a disciple of the devil. However... he at least had tethered himself to a perceived good beyond himself. And that's at least better than being totally isolated in self-referential existence. He at least knew the value of service, even though it was disordered in accordance with his misaligned affections. However, Sauron's long road would eventually lead him from serving a self-worshipper to becoming one. Sauron's other great trait, good trait even,
Speaker 1was a love of order. Order is good because it reflects the wisdom of the one who orders all things toward himself, and so it's meant to be received and cultivated rather than imposed. Tolkien wrote in his notes on Alden's Review that Sauron had gone the way of all tyrants. Beginning well, at least on the level that while desiring to order all things according to his own wisdom, he still at first considered the economic well-being of other inhabitants of the earth. According to his own wisdom here holds the seed of the entire tragedy of Sauron. When we
Speaker 1love order more than the one who orders, we inevitably come to love our own ordering. And the good of others becomes a pretext for the exercise of our own will. C.S. Lewis says something very similar to this, that the worst tyrants are those who act out of goodwill for those that they mean to rule. The decisive moment came at the end of the First Age when the host of the Valar defeated Morgoth and cast him into the void, which is why he doesn't appear except for brief mentions in the Lord of the Rings. Sauron at this time
Speaker 1was offered the very thing that he most needed, a return to the judgment of the Valar, and he refused it. As Tolkien writes in of the Rings of Power in the Third Age, Sauron was ashamed and he was unwilling to return in humiliation and to receive from the Valar a sentence. It might be of long servitude and proof of his good faith, for under Morgoth, his power had been great. Too ashamed to turn himself over for judgment and too fond of the power that he had held, Sauron isolated himself from the goodness that could have secured
Speaker 1his redemption. Had he submitted, he would have lost his standing and gained the virtue of humility and with it the true order that he craved. Here, the thesis that I'm providing is shown at its root because Sauron could have received honor as a humbled servant, but he chose instead to keep the power that he had grasped. During the Second Age, Sauron's desire for order again moved him to action. Tolkien insisted that at the beginning of that age, Sauron was not indeed wholly evil, not unless all reformers
Speaker 1who want to hurry up with reconstruction and reorganization are wholly evil, even before pride and lust to exert their will eat them up. His sin was not that he had wished the world to be healed, but rather that he wished it to be healed by his own hand, on his own schedule, and to his own glory. Calling himself Annatar, the Lord of Gifts, Sauron came among the elves, and then in secret, in the fires of Mount Doom, he forged the One Ring to control all the other rings of power. Sauron's order was a counterfeit of the created order, with himself set at the summit where only
Speaker 1God belongs. Tolkien explains that Sauron had been obliged to let a great part of his own inherent power pass into the ring, so that the ring in Sauron's, sorry, so that the ring was part of Sauron's own being, externalized and bound into a golden band. In a 1958 letter, Tolkien added two sentences that helped to sum up this tragedy of domination. He says that a man who wishes to exert power must have subjects who are not himself,
Speaker 1but he then depends on them. In seeking to bind all wills to himself, Sauron bound himself to a thing that could be lost. And in grasping for power, he was grasped by power. And in so doing, he lost the very freedom and isolated liberty that he sought. Iluvatar gives real being to his creatures and shares his glory without losing it. But Sauron, by contrast, could only extend himself by diminishing others, and in so doing, he diminished himself. With his defeat at the hand of Isildur at the end of the Second Age, Sauron was reduced to the
Speaker 1shadow that he had, in fact, already been for quite some time. He was reduced to an obscured image of what he was meant to be, an agent of glory that reflected the divine honor above him. Augustine explains this well in City of God. By aiming at more, a man is diminished. When he elects to be self-sufficient and defects from the one who it really is sufficient for him, this then is the original evil. Man regards himself as his own light and turns away from that light which would make himself a light if he would set his
Speaker 1heart on it. In his secret evil, Sauron turned away from the light of God that gives life to the soul, and desiring to be his own light, he became a mere shadow alongside Morgoth before him. By nature, he was greater than any of his would-be servants, but by consequence of his lust for self-sufficiency, he became nearly nothing. Sauron's long habit of grasping finally blinded him to the one possibility that could undo him. At the Council of Elrond, Gandalf explains the one hope of the wise. The only
Speaker 1measure that he knows, that Sauron knows, is desire, desire for power, and so he judges all hearts. Into his heart, the thought will not enter that any will refuse it, that having the ring, we may seek to destroy it. Once someone loves only power, then they can only understand the love of power, and so humility becomes unthinkable. When we refuse to honor God as God, we do not merely sin against the light. We even lose our capacity to see by it. As the psalmist says, in God's light,
Speaker 1we do see light. The final doom of Sauron came, fittingly, not through a great show of force, but through the weakness that he could not comprehend, as lowly hobbits of the Shire escaped the vision of his great eye. When the ring was unmade, the shadow of Sauron rose over Mordor one last time, reaching out, as Tolkien says, a vast threatening hand, terrible but impotent, until a great wind took it and it was blown away and passed. Real strength comes through the humble path of virtue that surrenders
Speaker 1power only to receive it anew in the right way. Sauron is the first and clearest pattern of honor grasped But not every character who reaches for that honor ends where he ends, as we will see with Boromir. Boromir, heir of the Steward of Gondor, is the one member of the Fellowship who openly argues that the ring should be used, and the one companion who tries to take it from the bear by force. Many readers, largely inspired
Speaker 1by the film, remember Boromir chiefly as the traitor of the Fellowship, as a Judas-like figure. However, if we consider Boromir as Tolkien presents him, we find that he is neither a traitor by nature nor a weak man, but rather a valiant and honorable man whose very virtues, ordered toward the wrong end, became the doorway of his temptation. Boromir does not seem to desire to be worshiped as a god-king, but he desires instead to save his people. And his temptation is to secure that genuine good by
Speaker 1grasping at the apparently necessary means. In his story, we watch honor grasped become honor tested, and honor tested become, at the last, honor received as a gift. Now to understand Boromir, we must begin with the office that his family held. For nearly a thousand years, Gondor had been without a king, and the city was ruled by stewards who swore to hold rod and rule in the name of the king until he shall return. A true steward holds in trust what belongs to another, and his honor lies not in possession, but in faithful keeping. This is
Speaker 1precisely the station of every creature before God, for we hold our lives, our gifts, and whatever authority we are given as stewards rather than as owners. Boromir grew up chafing against this station. Faramir recalls that when the brothers were boys, it always displeased Boromir that his father was not king. And Boromir once asked their father, how many hundreds of years need it to make a steward, a king, if the king returns not? Denethor answered, in Gondor, 10,000
Speaker 1years would not suffice. Boromir does not hate the good, but he is impatient with his station. The true answer to Boromir's question is that no length of time converts a gift into a possession, because the one who gives remains the giver. Boromir's valor was real and demonstrated on many occasions. However, a man who is accustomed to taking what he desires, even good things for good reasons, is poorly prepared for the day when he meets a thing that must be refused. And that day began at the
Speaker 1council of Elrond. When Elrond counseled that the ring must be sent to the fire, Boromir asked whether they should not think that the great ring has come into our hands to serve us in the very hour of need. He continued, valor needs first strength and then a weapon. Let the ring be your weapon, if it has such power as you say. However, the ring is not a neutral object to be handled, and Elrond answers that it belongs to Sauron who was made by him alone and is altogether evil. To use it is not to borrow a weapon from the enemy, but to take up the
Speaker 1enemy's own will. Boromir bowed his head and said, so be it, though his heart, as later events show, did not bow with it. The hour came much later beneath the hill of Emonhen when Boromir found Frodo alone on the hillside. And there his argument from the council returned with all the force that had gathered in secret. True-hearted men, they will not be corrupted, he said. And then he named the ring's gift, I say, a gift to the foes of Mordor. Then he turned the argument to himself.
Speaker 1What could not Aragorn do? Or if he refuses, why not Boromir? The ring would give me power of command. And so, much as Gollum himself often did, Boromir begins talking to himself, convincing himself as a fragmented person of the thing that he has set out to do. and he strode up and down, Tolkien tells us, in his talk, and he cast down Mordor in his own mind, and he became a mighty king in his own envisioning, not to rule over as a tyrant, but to rule benevolent
Speaker 1and wise. Boromir does not imagine himself to be a tyrant, but as a good king. However, a good man does not become a good king by seizing a power that intrinsically belongs to the enemy. but he instead becomes at best a new enemy who believes himself to be benevolent, which is precisely why Gandalf rejected the ring when it was offered to him. When Frodo refused, the mask of counsel slipped away entirely, and the language of gift gave way to the language of right. It is not yours,
Speaker 1save by unhappy chance, Boromir said to Frodo. It might have been mine. It should have been mine. Give it to me. With that, he leapt at Frodo, and Tolkien writes that his fair and pleasant face was hideously changed. A raging fire was in his eyes. Frodo escaped by putting on the ring, and Boromir, cursing Frodo and all the halflings, fell sprawling onto his face. Tolkien writes, for a while he was as still as if his own curse had struck him down, which, of course, it had. And suddenly, under the weight of his own lamentation at
Speaker 1what he had done, he wept. Yet the man who now was humbled into the dirt, now finally was beginning to have his heart humbled to match the movements of his head. He cried, what have I done? However, his remorse was not yet complete for he spoke of a madness that took him over rather than personal accountability for the agency that he had enacted in the wrong direction. And so with Sauron before him, shame prevented him at this point from facing the judgment that he desperately needed. You cannot find atonement until you first recognize that it
Speaker 1is you who are guilty. Orcs soon came upon the company and Boromir went after Merry and Pippin. Aragorn found him sitting against a tree pierced with many black feathered arrows. With many orcs slain about him, Tolkien then narrates the turning point of Boromir's story. Boromir opened his eyes and strove to speak. At last slow words came. I tried to take the ring from Frodo, he said. I am sorry, I have paid. His glance strayed to the fallen enemies, 20 at least lay there. They have gone, the halflings.
Speaker 1The orcs have taken them. I think they are not dead. Orcs bound them. He paused and his eyes closed wearily. After a moment, he spoke again. Farewell, Aragorn. Go to Minas Tirith and save my people. I have failed. Boromir's first words here before he reports the capture of the hobbits, and before he asks anything for his city, are his confession. Within the limited theology that he has, his three short sentences hold something of the shape of true penance, of true repentance. He names his sin, he demonstrates genuine contrition,
Speaker 1and then he does what he can to make amends for his failing. Boromir does not claim a debt anymore, but now he instead pays one, and the coin of his payment is his own life spent in defense of the small folk that he had wronged. The final exchange between Boromir and Aragorn shows two very different measures of victory. Boromir judges by the outcome of the day, and so he says, I have failed. However, the priestly figure of Aragorn in this scene answers with words that even still
Speaker 1continue to bring tears to my eyes when I engage with them. No, he says, and taking Boromir's hand and kissing his brow, he continues, you have conquered. Few have gained such a victory. Be at peace. Minas Tirith shall not fall. Then Tolkien adds simply, Boromir smiled. Aragorn does not deny that Boromir fell, but he names the greater battle that Boromir has won, the battle over his own soul. It is fitting that Aragorn, the heir of Isildur, and the true king whose return the stewards had sworn to await,
Speaker 1speaks these words. For with that gesture, the king gives freely the honor that Boromir could never have seized for himself. Boromir's story shows how honor grasped may be tested, lost, and recovered. He fell by loving Gondor more than the good that makes Gondor good, by trusting his own valor as a guarantee against corruption, and by calling a stolen thing a gift. He rose by confessing his sin plainly, by paying in service what his grasping had cost, and
Speaker 1by receiving from the king's hand an honor that he could never have taken. Where Sauron would not let go of what he grasped, Boromir grasped at the ring, fell, and lived long enough to make amends by his great deed and his confession. Now we turn to honor given. Frodo of Bag End carried the ring of the Shire to the cracks of doom, and in the third part of the book, where we are focusing on honor given, his story holds central place. However, Frodo's story does not end in the triumph that we might expect of a hero.
Speaker 1At the very edge of the fire, he claimed the ring for himself, and the ring was destroyed only because Gollum bit it from his hand and fell into the chasm, through what Tolkien would refer to as a eucatastrophe, the sudden, unexpected, happy turn. Frodo's story, therefore, shows us that honor is not finally the wage of success, but is a gift received by those who accept their burden in humility, show mercy along the road, and spend themselves completely in the task that they have been given. Having Frodo, the central
Speaker 1protagonist of the story, or at the very least one of the central protagonists, ultimately fail at the very last moment helps to really drive in the fact that for Tolkien, the ultimate hero of the story is not, in fact, Frodo or any of the Fellowship. The ultimate hero, the ultimate protagonist of the entire legendarium is God, who providentially works all things together for his glory. and he uses the people that he has chosen to play particular roles within that story. Frodo came to the ring by inheritance
Speaker 1rather than by a seizing. When Gandalf revealed that it was the one ring of Sauron, Frodo answered as nearly everyone answers who was handed a burden that he did not choose. And we are all very often handed burdens that we do not choose. But he responded by saying, I wish it need not happen in my time. Gandalf replies by saying, all we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given to us. Then Frodo asked, why was I chosen? Gandalf explains, you
Speaker 1may be sure that it was not for any merit that others do not possess, not for power or wisdom at any rate. Thus, the choosing comes before the merit, and the burden is actually a gift before it can become an achievement. As Gandalf explains, there was a power at work in the ring's movements toward Frodo. And of course, he's referring to the providential hand of God. Frodo may not have had perfectly established theology at this point to articulate what was happening, but he humbly received providence with
Speaker 1the honor of a servant's heart. Frodo's acceptance of the ring at the Council of Elrond was neither eager nor heroic in the usual sense, but it was free. Frodo longed to remain in peace in Rivendell, but at last he spoke as if some other will was using his small voice, Tolkien says, and Frodo responded, I will take the ring. though I do not know the way. Tolkien later explained in a 1963 letter that Frodo was given grace, first to answer the call at the end of the council,
Speaker 1after long resisting a complete surrender. Thus, grace did not replace Frodo's choice, but it rather enabled it, so that the words were truly his own, and that is the epitome of a free choice. The whole of Frodo's road to Mordor and back again would serve as an education in pity. At Bag End, Frodo had said of Gollum that he deserves death, and Gandalf had warned him that the pity of Bilbo may rule the fate of many, yours not least. Later on, Frodo overcame Gollum with the
Speaker 1drawn blade of Sting, and as he stood over the creature, he seemed to hear Gandalf's words from Bag End echoing in his mind, and he answered them aloud, lowering his sword. But still I'm afraid, and yet, as you see, I will not touch the creature, for now that I see him, I do pity him. Frodo's pity was not an absence of fear or a softening of judgment against this creature that had very real crimes, but rather than a decision to restrain his hand from a judgment that was not his to make. Mercy, like every virtue, must be practiced
Speaker 1before the hour of its greatest need, because in that hour we may have nothing left but what we have already become. That hour came in the chambers of fire within the mountain, and there at the very edge of the chasm, Frodo failed. In a voice clearer and more powerful than Sam had ever heard him use, Frodo said, I have come, and then, but I do not choose now to do what I came to do. I will not do this deed. The ring is mine. And these words here, I do not choose, are actually particularly telling
Speaker 1because Frodo was no longer the free hobbit who had chosen on Amun-Hen, but now he was broken beneath a weight that no mortal could bear. Then Gollum bit off Frodo's finger and with the ring upon it and dancing with his prize, he stepped too far, toppled, wavered for a moment on the brink, and then with a shriek, he fell and the ring went with him into the fire. When Tolkien was asked about the meaning of the scene, he admitted that Frodo's failure, he admitted that Frodo did fail, but he didn't soften that. But then he explained what
Speaker 1saved both Frodo and the world. But at this point, the salvation of the world, he writes, and Frodo's own salvation is achieved by his previous pity and forgiveness of injury. Tolkien continues, to pity Gollum, to forbear to kill him was a piece of folly, so it seemed, or a mystical belief in the ultimate value in itself of pity and generosity, even if disastrous in the world of time. He did rob him and injure him in the end, But Frodo was injured by a grace. That last betrayal
Speaker 1was at a precise juncture when the final evil deed was the most beneficial thing that anyone could have done for Frodo. By a situation created by Frodo's forgiveness, he saved himself and was relieved of his burden. The meaning of Mount Doom is that the mercy that Frodo showed when he was free saved him when he was no longer free. Gollum's final deed remained an evil deed, but by grace it came at a precise juncture, and so providence brought good out of evil without making the evil good.
Speaker 1Tolkien wrote in the same letter that the catastrophe exemplifies an aspect of the familiar words, forgive us our trespasses as we forgive them that trespass against us. Lead us not into temptation, but deliver us from evil. Freddo had forgiven his trespasser and he was delivered from the evil that he could no longer resist. On the field of Cormelon, the host of the West greeted Frodo and Sam with drawn swords and trumpets, crying, praise them with great praise. Then Aragorn bowed his knee before them and taking them by the hand, Frodo upon his right and Sam upon
Speaker 1his left, he led them to the throne and setting them upon it, he cried again to the host, praise them with great praise. Honor of this kind cannot be seized because it belongs to the one who gives it. And here it is given by the rightful king to those who had served the whole world in humility. The minstrel of Gondor sang, a Frodo of the nine fingers in the ring of doom. And so Frodo is honored by the name of his wound and the maimed hand that bore the mark of his failure became the title of his glory. Tolkien named the grounds of this honor
Speaker 1in his letter, writing that Frodo's humility with which he began and his sufferings were justly rewarded by the highest honor and his exercise of patience and mercy toward Gollum gained him mercy. His failure was redressed. Thus, Frodo's honor is grounded in what he chose and not in what happened to him at the end. Sauron demanded worship for a power that was never rightly his, but Frodo was praised for a weakness, which honestly confessed, and a faithfulness
Speaker 1that had spent itself to the end. Divine honor belongs to God alone, but the honor that a creature receives is the fitting recognition of a life given back to God in faithful service. Frodo did not cling even to the reward that he had rightly earned. Before he sailed into the West, he told Sam, I tried to save the Shire and it has been saved, but not for me. Frodo's rest was not finally to be found in the Shire, the Shire that he had originally sent out to preserve. Frodo did not originally leave to save the world. He
Speaker 1originally left on his quest to save the Shire, but now the Shire he recognizes was not saved for him. And so he sails off into the west, leaving it as a victory for others. We have followed the ring now through three lives, and in each of them we have seen the same truth from a different side. Sauron fell by loving order more than the one who orders, and by refusing the humiliation of repentance. And so the one who would by his own light become a shadow
Speaker 1scattered by the wind. Boromir fell by loving Gondor more than the good that makes Gondor good, and he rose by confessing his sin and laying down his life, so the honor that he could not seize could be given to him by the true king. Frodo received a burden that he did not seek he showed mercy that every prudent voice would have forbidden and he failed at the last and yet he was saved by the mercy that he had shown and so he received honor from the king True honor is not grasped, but received and given.
Speaker 1And it is grounded in the good, in God himself, who alone has the right to divine honor. The desire that ruins Sauron is common to every human heart, We may never hold a rig of power, but we are daily offered something that promises to make us masters. We are daily offered the chance to order our small worlds according to our wisdom and for our glory, or to secure some genuine good, maybe a family, a church, or a nation, or a cause, by grasping at the apparently necessary means. When we seek order apart from the one
Speaker 1who orders, we do not become masters. We rather become dependent upon the very things that we seek to control. When we surrender our power to God, we gain the true power of virtue, which is the freedom to live in harmony with our design and to reflect a glory that is not our own. These three are only part of the story. In my full book that's forthcoming, Sauron stands beside Saruman, Isildur, and Gollum, and a key difference among them is how much virtue remained to restrain the grasping hand. Boromir then stands beside Faramir, Galadriel, and Bilbo,
Speaker 1who were each brought to the edge of the same temptation. And Frodo stands beside Gandalf, Tom Bombadil, and Samwise Gamgee, the humble gardener whose faithful love is one of the clearest images in all of Tolkien's writing of a heart rightly ordered toward what is above it. The movement from the first part to the last is therefore a movement from the darkness to the light, from grasping to giving, and it traces the whole drama of the human heart, a drama in which each of us is a participant. Now, Tolkien did not write an allegory, and we have not
Speaker 1treated his story as one. However, he did write a story that is ultimately congruous with our own in the primary world. He wrote a story about God and his sole right to divine honor. And it's my hope that by following these lives through the shadow and the light, we may learn more clearly how to give that honor ourselves. Thank you.
Speaker 4We now have about 15 minutes for people to ask questions of Dr.
Speaker 5Snyder.
Speaker 3If anyone wants to throw their hand up, I will run over here and let you.
Speaker 1Ask a question. Thank you so much.
Speaker 6I have never understood why Frodo didn't succeed in tossing the ring in or why if he failed, why Golub didn't come out of the woodwork and do the right thing and be the hero. probably because I haven't read the Silmarillion. So I just want to thank you for putting the pieces together for me. I don't know if you have any other thoughts on that scene, but that was wonderful.
Speaker 1So I thank you. Yeah, my thoughts are you should read the Silmarillion.
Speaker 6What did Tolkien mean, I think, by, like, Gollum eventually destroying it?
Speaker 7Was it that, like, selfishness eventually in the end destroyed itself?
Speaker 1Yeah, it's a great question and a great answer. And this, again, is a theme that goes all the way back to the beginning of the Silmarillion. When Melkor first rebels against Iluvatar, against God, and tries to change the theme of the music, orienting it around himself, Iluvatar responds to Melkor saying, basically, whatever you do, I'm going to bend your music back around to ultimately serve me. That, you know, you in all of your evil strivings of vain glory are ultimately
Speaker 1just going to end up creating more beautiful music as I providentially work your aims for good. And, of course, we see this very clearly in the Christian story. That, as Peter says in his Pentecost sermon, that God delivered Jesus over to sinful men so that he would be crucified, right? Ultimately to achieve the eucatastrophe of our story, right? And so, ultimately, evil defeats itself. And this is very much a theme that's at play in Tolkien's story as well, that evil is ultimately self-consuming. And so, it's fitting that it is
Speaker 1the selfish greed, this Melkor or Sauron-like tendency in Gollum that ultimately is going to be the undoing of the ring. Wonderful.
Speaker 3Other questions people may have?
Speaker 4Was that look at allegory, his long diatribe on his dislike of allegory, was that a direct little rib at his friend, C.S.
Speaker 2Lewis?
Speaker 1Yeah, famously, Tolkien wasn't a huge fan of Narnia. A little bit on the nose. But, I mean, I think that even that is a little bit overblown, but it's certainly safe to say that Tolkien was much more wary of allegory than Lewis was. Although we do need to give Lewis his credit, though. If it weren't for Lewis, we probably would not have The Lord of the Rings. It was always Lewis who was pushing him to get it published and was really his biggest fan along the way. So let's not be too hard on Lewis here.
Speaker 3Well, on that note, I always like to steal a question. If someone loves The Lord of the Rings and they've read The Silmarillion and all of that, what else would you have them go to? What other authors besides Lewis would you say they can find such depth of philosophical and theological thought?
Speaker 1Trying to put someone else on the level of Tolkien. That's a tough one. Yeah, when I first read Lord of the Rings, I mean, that was really my awakening to really literature as such. You know, I did my graduate work was in philosophy and theology. And so, you know, I was very much a nonfiction reader. But it was really Tolkien who first awakened me to the power, the truth that can be found in fiction. And so I went straight from Lord of the Rings to Submarillion to, you know, some of his other work. But from there,
Speaker 1it really opened me up to other readers. I mean, I'm a... Big fan of Tolstoy and Dostoevsky. Obviously Lewis. Definitely if you like Tolkien, then pick up George MacDonald. If Tolkien's the father of modern fantasy, MacDonald's definitely the grandfather. So yeah, pick up MacDonald. That would be a good follow-up if you're into this vein of writing. Other questions?
Speaker 3I was wondering when this was coming.
Speaker 8Allegory, leaf by niggle.
Speaker 1You want to comment on that?
Speaker 7Seems a very important part of Tolkien's work, which in effect he's denying.
Speaker 1Yes, leaf by niggle is the one clear allegory that Tolkien gives us of his own life. But that I think is exceptional, not only because it's allegorical, but also it's his own attempt to... work out his own creative autobiography, really. And so Tolkien worked on a lot of stuff, but didn't get nearly as much published as what he was working on, which is why we have far more books after his death than before. And in Leaf by Niggle,
Speaker 1he's just trying to piece together his own creative process and come to terms with the fact that he's never going to create within his mortal lifespan all the things that he wants to create. And so he's trying to deal with his relationship to beauty and to art more generally. And so Leaf by Niggle, he says, came to him basically all at once. He just woke up and he had this idea that he wrote out. And it's just all about him kind of coming to terms with the eternal reality of beauty that he is related to in his work, even if he never actually finishes his work in this world. He is engaging with something that is
Speaker 1eternal and something that's even heavenly, and as much as he's related to true beauty. And so Leaf by Niggle, I think, is different because he didn't think... I want to write an allegory about beauty. It was more of an autobiographical reflection that naturally is going to have this allegorical component to it. And so I think that personal relationship he has with it really sets it apart as something unique and kind of strange for his corpus.
Speaker 5So I understand the idea that evil, right, has some twisted goodness in it We were wondering where you would put the orcs. And particularly like the hybrid orcs of Saruman and you know, was there goodness? Was there goodness in servitude? How would you identify that?
Speaker 1Yeah, that's a good question. And Tolkien himself actually struggled with this issue. Which is why, if you look in the various unpublished drafts, you know, go through the large history of Middle-earth collection where you have all these unpublished thoughts he was working through, he never knew exactly what to do with orcs. If you look at the account that was published in the Silmarillion by Christopher Tolkien, we find that orcs are actually corrupted elves who learn to fear the light. And so in that sense, we have this clear idea of a perversion of something that is good. But then the question is, do orcs retain some element
Speaker 1of that goodness, something like an elvish soul that could be redeemed? And Tolkien seemed to indicate no in the way that he wrote orcs. But he continued to. struggle with this idea. I think that I hate to speak for Tolkien where he didn't come down very clearly, but I think the best I can make sense out of what he would give us is that theoretically it'd be possible, even though it never happened. It's kind of like what Gandalf says of Gollum, that there's still some corner of
Speaker 1his mind that is still his own. And it's possible he could come to repentance and experience redemption. However, it's very unlikely because that component of his will is so minute at this point. And so can an orc be redeemed? In the way that Tolkien writes them, it's at least very unlikely. But, there's still goodness in them in that they exist. And existence itself is a good thing because Tolkien is not a dualist, right? He's a Christian. There is only one good that is, and that is God.
Speaker 1And so anything other than that must be a privation of some kind. And so to be is to participate in goodness because there's no other source of being. And so on the ontological level, the source that they are orcs are good in that they exist. Can serve is good, but even their service is pretty bad, which is why they're always killing each other. So even their service isn't very good, but to the extent that it is there, I would assume he would say that is good, even as Sauron had some goodness when he served Melkor. However, I will say that we don't get loving orc families in Tolkien like in Rings of Power.
Speaker 7Okay, so my question is that towards the end of Return of the King, Frodo ends up leaving for the Undying Lands, which is kind of like a sword of heaven, but isn't at the same time And in doing so, he leaves behind a bunch of people that he loves. And then you also see on the flip side of that, Sam go back to the Shire and live this loving life. And so what is the theological meaning behind that for him leaving, yet at the same time also leaving behind something that is still good and beautiful in terms of Sam and the Shire?
Speaker 1That's a good question. And I think it is important to note that the very end of the Lord of the Rings, it ends with Sam, right? It ends with Sam in the Shire in this very domestic kind of setting, this very ordinary, mundane kind of setting, which is not exactly what you would expect. You would expect that the end would be Frodo sailing off, but it's actually the end is Sam living his life in the Shire. And remember, as I said, that's what Frodo set out to save. He set out to save the Shire. And this very much speaks to Tolkien's localism and his value for the
Speaker 1domestic kind of life that Frodo saved the world, not by saving the world, but he saved the world by saving his home, by saving the Shire. Now, why wasn't Frodo able to enjoy that? Well, I think there are a lot of things going on here. For one thing, that Tolkien, a man who served in the war and lost nearly all of his friends in the war, he was somebody very much acquainted with the reality of a harrowing journey. And that, as we see in Frodo, there is no real going home when you've been through certain situations.
Speaker 1And so I think that Frodo, well, he was not Fundamentally learning how to live well, although he did that I think in Frodo we really see the journey of learning how to die well learning how to let go of this life and in so doing actually hold it all the better and to actually Redeem the goodness of this life and so in talking In Frodo rather we really see the account of somebody who? spends himself entirely
Speaker 1for a good that he doesn't even get to enjoy. And so he's a symbol of this sacrificial love that actually makes ordinary life possible. And if you don't have the example of the sacrificial hero who surrenders all, well then there's no longer going to be anything to save. And so I think he provides that example of the life that gives it all. And even Sam, if you look at the appendices, eventually he finds his way to the undying lands as well. So even the domestic is not going to last forever.
Speaker 9Two statements that you made. Evil is privation of good. And as Gandalf put it, the ring is altogether evil. How do you reconcile those two things? How can the ring be thought of as a privation of evil or a privation of good.
Speaker 1Yeah, it's a good question. And I think what that would mean is the ring, you know, as an object isn't evil, as a material object. But what makes the ring evil is the purpose that it is set to. And what it is set to is this grasping after divine honor. It is Sauron's will to be God-king. And that itself is a movement away from the ordered being of the cosmos established by and ultimately for God. And so Sauron, in his will, is directed toward the void. It's a grasping after something that doesn't exist because there
Speaker 1is no reality apart from that which is established and ordered by God. And so when Genoff says that the ring is wholly evil, I think what he's really referring to is what the ring is teleologically, what it's aimed toward. What it's aimed toward is this grasping after divine honor. And so the ring itself is a material object. I don't think it's evil. I don't think that's what he meant. But what he meant is the ring's purpose in stepping outside of divine order That is the nothingness that Sauron is grasping after as well as those who would seek
Speaker 1to usurp that power.
Speaker 8So I noticed in the honor given category you had for what the characters that you intend to write about for that, you have Tom Bombadil listed. I'm curious as to why you would choose him over someone like, say, Aragorn.
Speaker 1Well, for one, I'm not going to write a Tolkien book and not include Tom Bombadil. He's just such a great character. I mean, that's a fair question. I've really tried to focus on characters that have some direct engagement with the ring in a clear crisis kind of way. And I mean, sure, you could say Aragorn did and that he was in the Fellowship of Frodo for a time, but we never really get Aragorn having a direct, clear, precise crisis moment with the ring. And so that's why I just didn't include him. Obviously, I could include any
Speaker 1character in his legendarium, and obviously Aragorn's an important character, but I try to focus on those who have a clear and precise connection to the ring itself, and we just don't see that very clearly with Aragorn.
Speaker 3All right, well, let's give Dr. Snyder one final round of applause.
Speaker 2Thank you for listening to the Mythic Mind Podcast or watching over on YouTube. If you appreciate what we do here, then I welcome your support over at MythicMindFellowship.com. And of course, your support will also enable you to participate in the full life of the fellowship, joining our private Discord server and participating in our regular live conversations, which happen usually at least once a week, if not more than that. And so I hope to see you there over at MythicMindFellowship.com.
Watch the video: https://mythicmindfellowship.com/you-have-forgotten-who-you-are-mythic-mind-ep-198/ Boethius has lost his place in the world, and Lady Philosophy tells him that he has forgotten who he is. Fortune had...
Watch the video: https://mythicmindfellowship.com/who-failed-anakin-skywalker-mythic-mind-ep-197/ Right-wing X has been full of pro-Anakin posts, including one Elon Musk shared of an AI image of Emperor Anakin with...
Watch the video: https://mythicmindfellowship.com/kierkegaards-concept-of-anxiety-anxiety-is-not-an-ailment-to-be-removed-mythic-mind-ep-196/ Today I'm giving you a free look into my Mythic Mind Fellowship course, The...
Did the people of Middle-earth know how their story ends? Rev. Jeffrey Wade joins Andrew Snyder and Josh to discuss his master's thesis on eschatology in Arda. His question is not only what Tolkien believed, but whether...
Watch the video: https://mythicmindfellowship.com/the-death-of-ivan-ilyich-am-i-guilty-mythic-mind-ep-194/ We all know we will die one day. It is another thing to consider that it is I who am going to die. In this...