Did the people of Middle-earth know how their story ends? Rev. Jeffrey Wade joins Andrew Snyder and Josh to discuss his master's thesis on eschatology in Arda. His question is not only what Tolkien believed, but whether the inhabitants of Arda themselves know their telos: the promise of resurrection, reunion, and the setting right of all things. Letting the text stand on its own rather than reading it through a scholar's agenda, he argues that this hope is woven into the story from the Ainulindalë onward. One striking thread is water. The music of Ilúvatar lingers in the waters of Arda, and Rev. Wade traces moments of grace and eucatastrophe that happen near water, from Bilbo's riddle game and Lake-town to the Ford of Bruinen, Nimrodel, and Mirrormere. He also shows how hope is handed down through song and story among Men, hobbits, Dwarves, and Ents, and points to the Athrabeth Finrod ah Andreth in Morgoth's Ring as one of its clearest statements. The conversation then asks how much of this hope survives in Peter Jackson's films and why Hollywood struggles with virtuous characters. It closes with Rev. Wade's story of how the films led him to the books, and why he calls The Lord of the Rings a love letter to creation. Rev. Jeffrey Wade is a Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod pastor in Iowa, with an MDiv from Concordia Seminary (2014) and an MA in Language and Literature from Signum University (2025). Chapters 00:00 Introducing Rev. Jeffrey Wade 01:12 The thesis: do the inhabitants of Arda know their eschatology? 03:21 Reading theologically and letting the text stand 05:24 Water and the music of Ilúvatar 07:28 What is Arda? 11:12 What makes this approach unique in Tolkien scholarship 15:50 Best sources: the Ainulindalë and the Athrabeth 19:57 The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings: hope at the water's edge 23:33 Why water? Baptismal echoes 24:22 How the hope is handed down: lore, song, and catechesis 27:51 Bombadil vs. the Barrow-wight: hope vs. despair 29:20 Eschatology in the Peter Jackson films 34:26 Can film viewers catch it? Hollywood and virtue 37:00 Recommended reading on Tolkien and theology 39:50 How the films led Rev. Wade to Tolkien 43:36 Closing Get the book: Morgoth's Ring (J.R.R. Tolkien): https://bookshop.org/a/129785/9780261103009 Get the book: Tolkien's Theology of Beauty (Lisa Coutras): https://bookshop.org/a/129785/9781137553447 Get the book: The Flame Imperishable (Jonathan S. McIntosh): https://bookshop.org/a/129785/9781621382942 Get the book: Tolkien On Fairy-stories (J.R.R. Tolkien): https://bookshop.org/a/129785/9780007582914 Join the Mythic Mind Fellowship: https://mythicmindfellowship.com/membership Listen to/watch the Mythic Mind podcasts: - Mythic Mind - Mythic Mind Games - Mythic Mind Movies Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/mythic-mind--5808321/support.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Welcome to Mythic Mind, a special episode. Today we are joined by Josh Traylor, who many of you will know if you've been around here for a little while, but also we have Reverend Jeffrey Wade with us. Reverend Wade is first and foremost the husband of Christine, father of five. with two awaiting the resurrection, which is a reality that I know very well, and three who already love cuddling up with a good book. And pastors in Iowa is a member of the Lutheran Church in the Missouri Synod, which is the right kind of Lutheran. Following an MDiv
Speaker 1from Concordia Seminary in 2014, he continued his postgraduate work with Signum University, completing an MA in Language and Literature in 2025. He desires to connect people to the hope written in creation, which manifests in the great works of art throughout history. When he's not doing any of the above, he's an avid gardener, landscaper, and is always seeking to finally perfect his salsa recipe, which I would say is still part of finding the hope written in the great works of art in creation. So, Reverend Wade, Josh, thank
Speaker 1you for joining us today to discuss your thesis on eschatology in Ardo. So why don't you begin by just telling us a little bit about that, kind of what you've been working on, what led you to that idea?
Speaker 2It's been something that's kind of been in my head for a long time. And I'd recently re-listened to the Mythic Mind podcasts on the films. And I definitely have problems with them, but I'm an apologist because ultimately they brought me to the text of Tolkien themselves. And the idea... that there's more to life than what you face every day, that there is a purpose underneath all things. And so, Syngham University itself was started by the Tolkien professor, Dr. Corey Olson. And I was an avid listener of his
Speaker 2podcast following that and following the reading of the texts. And I knew there was something I wanted to dig at, something I wanted to garden with, if you will, about how Tolkien spoke of hope. And so. I went into Signum and applied, knowing that I was going to talk about either Tolkien's theology of resurrection, the undoing of all sad things, the promises that were in the undercurrent of his work. And it started, actually, I
Speaker 2went back and looked and counted at my word count for this dissertation level of work. And my poor thesis director, Dr. Breton Dickinson, reined me in from, I think, 118,000 words in. down to 23,000, down to the required 15,000 to kind of encapsulate that idea. And the focus of it ultimately became the unique perspective of, do the actual inhabitants of Arda know their eschatology? Do they know their telos at the end of all things, that there is the promise
Speaker 2of the resurrection, that there is an idea of heaven? And if so, is there evidence within the text? And so that ultimately became what my thesis point I think, successfully answers well.
Speaker 1Yeah, so it's an interesting idea because people who know Tolkien well know that there is an eschatology in the text or that you can derive from the text, perhaps. But the question of how prominent is the eschatology within the actual world, like how well is it known? What about that was compelling to you? Is it simply a literary interest or what led you to that angle?
Speaker 2It's something that I... and my wife especially picked up over the course of time, is you have to look at everything theologically. And I mean, I get the conceit that I'm a pastor, and of course I'm going to say that, but doctrine is just simply a matter of living. And if God himself wrote the doctrine into creation, wrote it into our lives, then I didn't have the vocabulary of this at the time, but we as sub-creators, if we are going to create works of art, there's going to be truth that are revealed within it. even when
Speaker 2we're intending it, even when we're unintended it, it's just there. And so the thesis argues over the course of its wonderful 15,000 words that you can find the trace elements that it's just there as Frodo and Sam are writing the Lord of the Rings, which is the one thing that was arguably the most difficult because there's countless volumes written about Tolkien and his theology and I listen to podcasts all the time that are advertising that Tolkien said
Speaker 2in a letter that the Lord of the Rings is a fundamentally Catholic work. And then you read a different scholar and it's a no, it's Norse and pagan mythology. And the conversation seems to have shifted to what did Tolkien write in the work as opposed to what does the work actually say? And so I tried to throw out most of what I read from scholars talking and bringing in the Tolkienian baggage and in their readings of the Lord of the Rings, the Silmarillion, Melkor's Ring, and
Speaker 2the subsequent histories of Middle-earth, to really hit at the point of, is there evidence for the characters themselves knowing this? And right away there's a thread of, anytime they're near water, something good happens. Whether you want to call it providence or eucatastrophe or some sort of recovery, escape, and consolation, it always occurs near water. Well, then you pull back to the Silmarillion, And you see that, well, they all say that music of Ionor, or the music of Iluvatar
Speaker 2was always present in the water. And you pull back that Olmo has all of these heraldic moments where he appears and gives some sort of divine message to the characters or the inhabitants of Arda within the text. And you've got the foundation for it. And so that, what Dr. Rasa would say at the seminary is the gospel handle. And so if you found where the handle is, how God is consistently communicating how Iluvatar is communicating with the inhabitants through the Valar, through the music of the Ainur, well,
Speaker 2there's got to be a pattern. And you trace out the pattern and you see that it's not just a coincidence. It's written into the story. And it's true for every race, every inhabitant of Arda that is there. Even when it is negative in the judgment of the Barrow-White or the judgment against the Nazgul or the trolls and the like, there's clear line that ultimately, as Sam said, all sad things will become untrue and there is a reunion that will come.
Speaker 1That's good. I think a good demonstration of why your approach is worthwhile and why it's needed, because it really helps us to see the revealed theology within the legendarium in a way that kind of guards against proof texting to say, you know, here's how I'm going to insert my ideology over what Tolkien is doing here. It's a way of looking at what has Tolkien done. And in so doing, we get a better insight into the mind
Speaker 1of the man precisely because we're not starting with the mind of the man. So that's good. Josh, I know you have some questions. You want to hop in with whatever you have in mind?
Speaker 3Yeah, of course. And you certainly already answered some of them and kind of incorporate them into your introductory comments. So thank you for that. That being said, just for the background of somebody who may be listening but doesn't know what the word Arda means, could you give your best brief explanation of that? And, you know, I want to explain like why that isn't like just another land like, you know, Rohan Gondor or even the Shire, right? But what that overarching realm actually is.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's a great question. Uh, you're approaching it only from the Hobbit to Lord of the Rings. I would encourage you to read the Silmarillion, uh, cause I think that is the only book I finished and that immediately picked back up again and read it again. Uh, cause it is beautiful and Arda is essentially the entire world, uh, that middle earth is a part of. And so it'd be referring to the United States or great Britain, uh, and the like as the country, the place in which you live and abide and, uh, where day-to-day activities occur. whether it's gardening or warfare, Arda is the entirety of
Speaker 2the creation itself. And so all analogies eventually break down, but think of Arda as earth and middle earth as your country that you're in. And why it's important is that it's not a localized salvation, if you will. And so as you approach from the inhabitants and the characters you grow to love and the individuals that inhabit this land, uh, it's the story for all of creation itself. And it's pastor hat on is it's equating John three 16 for God.
Speaker 2So love the entirety of the world in this way that he gave his only begotten son for them. But ultimately salvation is for you by the work of Jesus Christ. And so both are true, but one takes a global approach and explaining the gospel. And one is a direct proclamation to an individual. And so you walk that fine line by saying, Well, of course, Aragorn is saved. Of course, Frodo and Sam and all the characters you grow to love are indeed redeemed and vindicated in the end. That's
Speaker 2a great eucatastrophe, the one deep cord. But it's not just them. It's all of creation being set right. All of the world is being redeemed.
Speaker 1As Tolkien says at the end of Unfairly Stories, that God is the God of men and of elves. It's all of reality falls under who God is, even in this subcreated world, which I think should be mentioned in Tolkien's mind is an ancient form of our own world. He's trying to write a mythology about of this world. And so there is a certain continuity between the theology that we get within the legendarium and Tolkien's own Christian
Speaker 1theology that, and this obviously isn't controversial. I mean, Tolkien talks about this very explicitly, but, you know, he says that, you know, he created the Valar, which for those who haven't read the Silmarillion are sort of like these angelic figures who aided in creation. And he says that he wanted to make them in such a way that they could be accepted alongside the blessed Trinity. And so in Tolkien's own mind, seeing this as an early version of our world, he wants to make it at least not contradictory to establish Christian doctrine, even though he's not first
Speaker 1and foremost intending to write a Christian story. So I think that that should be said. Josh, do you want to continue? I know you're in the lead interview here, even though I've been taking over.
Speaker 3And I feel for the comment to take the conversation in the direction you guys want, but I did want to, you did a good job, Pastor Wade, on mentioning your thesis and even giving some background on methodology. And I was going to ask you about that, so I'm glad you already talked about it. But more specific and pertinent to your thesis, on page five of the thesis, you argue that your treatment is unique to the scholarship, right? And you cite people such as unlike Bradley Berzer, Austin Freeman, and Jonathan McIntosh, who perhaps all talk on very similar
Speaker 3theology and Tolkien broad type of themes and ideas right in the legendarium. So that being said, what is it exactly that you say makes your treatment of this more unique?
Speaker 2Yeah, that's appreciate the question. Everyone I've read, and as I said, this has been a 10-year process for me, is thinking through and maybe cheating and waiting for Signum to get accredited to make sure that the MA was a legit MA or any kind of fudge work you wanted to do with that. But this idea fascinated me in this question specifically. And so I've just been doing what pastors do and buying book after book after book and using my JSTOR subscription to its fullest. nth degree
Speaker 2to get article after article. And I found a pattern where there was two major approaches for most articles is either someone approached it with an agenda in a social way. And you mentioned Bradley Berzer. He very much has an agenda writing his book. That is fantastic. And his argument is valid. And I tend to agree with it more often than not. but he's clearly articulating and pushing back against more postmodern liberal readings of Tolkien and trying to
Speaker 2articulate and argue that point specifically because of who Tolkien was and because a devout Roman Catholic would never argue that the other is welcome and the other should find themselves within the world of Middle Earth because of Tolkien's tradition. And so it often defaulted to what point a person approach the text with. And even in shorter articles, like wrote this down, Tom Emanuel's essay, that it's ultimately about nothing in itself. He draws on the parallel that stop
Speaker 2bringing your baggage or your agenda to Tolkien. Let the text stand. And I got to credit Tom Emanuel for that, for really pushing into me that let the text stand. Let the text stand as it is. And so the unique perspective I have is doing my best to only allow outside scholars to comment on the text when it is applicable and necessary. And out of the articles that I read and out of the long form works, I'm assuming in most cases dissertations that were then published, rarely
Speaker 2successfully pulled it off. And I'll caveat that to saying, I don't know if I successfully pulled it off. I think I did a workable job for it. But the primary sources ultimately are the ones that should speak for what the theology of Middle Earth is. If a Lutheran can pick it up and say, hey, this is clearly Lutheran theology, and a Roman Catholic can pick it up and say, oh, this is clearly pre-Vatican to Roman Catholic theology, and a wild liberal theologian can pick it up and say, oh, no,
Speaker 2this is clearly affirming any ideology that has popularized now in the 21st century. that's more likely our baggage and our presuppositions as opposed to what the text actually says.
Speaker 1It's a very Lutheran approach to the text, right? We're going to set aside all this classicism here and get back to the original text.
Speaker 2Yeah, Ad fontus.
Speaker 1Right. It's a very Lutheran approach to a fundamentally Catholic text. I think it's a good point. It's so easy to read our ideology into the text, especially because Tolkien says that he's not setting out to write an ideological tale, which means it's very easy to turn it into an ideological tale of various contradictory varieties. And so, yeah, I definitely appreciate that. Josh, do you have something else?
Speaker 3Yes, Andrew, you stole my Lutheran joke, so no further questions. No, I'm just kidding. So, Pastor Wade, what parts of the entire legendarium do you think are the best places to go for supporting your thesis, and why are those specific parts of the Legendarium the best support that you could choose to support your thesis?
Speaker 2I think the best supports in general are the texts of the Aenolindale itself. Everything is laid out there remarkably clear. The story of creation, the three songs, the final promise of the deep chord, the setting of all things right, It's all within the first 15 pages of the Silmarillion, and it's just a matter of, is this fleshed out, or does this appear in the text that people are more familiar with, in The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings? And you see the fingerprints of the Annalindalee
Speaker 2everywhere within it. After that, with just that understanding and just that reading, you get really the full picture, and then it becomes fleshed out, through the text of the Hobbit and Lord of the Rings especially. But there's an ancillary text that is more difficult to find, and it's in one of the histories of Middle-earth. And Christopher Tolkien notes that in the footnotes for it, and it's in Morgoth's Ring, and what you have is the Athrabeth Finrad Andrath,
Speaker 2and I know I'm going to say it wrong, But that short story in there of the conversation that the Elven King Finrod has before going and dying at the hands of Melkor and the human Andret speaks of this hope in spades. And you have the perversion of Melkor that takes place, how he has created a cacophony within the music, especially in the minds of the men and created disharmony between the elves and men. And his goal is to twist and pervert the the gifts that Iluvatar
Speaker 2has given all of creation, and to twist the promise, essentially. And that dialogue between the two of them once again plays out in spades. And Christopher Toltean notes in this footnote on the text that this would have fit in somewhere and probably should be in the Silmarillion, but essentially Dad didn't get in time to actually put it in there in its proper place. But that is... I would say the two brightest and clearest articulations of the hope, uh,
Speaker 2and Tolkien goes so far in, uh, Melchor's Ring, uh, to underline that, uh, Iluvatar would one day, uh, become incarnate and dwell within the land of Arda, uh, to dwell within creation itself, uh, in order to bring about, uh, that day. And it's, for the complaints that I've heard, uh, from Tolkien and Lewis scholars, that's, uh, akin to the Voyage of the Dawn Treader, where I'm known by someone else's name in your land, here played out in spades.
Speaker 2And so this is clearly, as what Sam says, it's all the same story. This is all the same promise. And so for the mind of a Christian, our mind is immediately drawn to what we confess in the Creed every week, the resurrection of the dead and the life of the world to come. And it's right there, ripe for the pickin'..
Speaker 1Yeah, I mean, that line you were alluding to in the author, Beth, where he says, they say that the one will himself come into Arda and heal men and all the marring from the beginning to the end. Just this clear Christian hope, which very firmly situates Arda in this pre-Christian version of this world that we live in, and that anticipates the revelation of Christian truth. And of course, a world that anticipates the revelation of Christian truth is, in fact, a Christian world by nature. And so you know, all of these arguments about how it's fundamentally pagan or whatever,
Speaker 1it's just the founding in it when you actually get into not even what Tolkien said about the text, but what Tolkien said within the text. Yes, okay, granted, we're not dealing strictly legendarium at this point, but nonetheless, that same idea in less explicit terms is very clearly in the text, especially if we include the Silmarillion, going back to the I Know and Delay.
Speaker 3So going perhaps for maybe more familiar and concrete examples of this as well, as far as places in just the Lord of the Rings book and in the Hobbit book, where do you think would be the most prevalent places in those for perhaps those who have not read the Silmarillion and especially not the histories, which would be less commonly read?
Speaker 2Yeah, the Hobbit is definitely a trickier text to work with in regards to this. And so the theme of water and the music of the Ainur playing out in the water and by means of the water is what you're looking for. And so when Bilbo wins the ring from Gollum and stumbles upon it at the side of the water, that would be an example. When Bilbo first approaches Rivendell and the first thing he hears is the waters of the waterfall and then immediately feels peace. That
Speaker 2would be a fingerprint. When you've got the dwarves and Bilbo returning to Erebor for the first time, or Bilbo going for the first time, you have the first thing they see is the beginning of the running river. When Smaug is defeated, it's in Lake Town upon the water. So the Hobbit, you have to look for connections directly to where are the significant events occurring. And it is often... fairly near water. In The Lord of the Rings, it becomes far more apparent. Not just Frodo being overcome and
Speaker 2standing up to the Nazgul at the Fords of Bruinen. That is a definite example of it, though. At the River Nimrodel, after the apparent death of Gandalf in Lord of the Rings, they're refreshed and they're able to carry on their journey to make it to Lothlorien. Those all occur at water, and the depths of Khazad-dûm, Gimli needs to stare at the pool that is there, and there is peace, and sings Durin's song, which alludes to the last day that is coming when the waters, or the
Speaker 2crown will be woken up from the waters. You've got countless examples of those events taking place near water, from real tiny things like the steam that Aragorn boils the herbs in afterward, and just the smell of the water, and the smell of the steam, and the feeling of it upon Frodo, heals him and revives him a bit after Weathertop, to arguably the most beautiful example of this, of Aragorn unfurling the sigil of the king, coming up
Speaker 2from the corsairs of the southern coast of Gondor, and Aramir exclaims, just with joy, laughter, that the king has returned upon the water. And it's a constant thread through Lord of the Rings that these moments are all take place. And what is the water? What inhabits the water? It's the music of Iluvatar, the music of hope and restoration. It's all there. And it compels you to the eschatology
Speaker 2that the greatest, whether you want to use it as an adjective and say eucatastrophic providence, or whether you want to just throw it out there as the noun, this is the eucatastrophe of the sad thing becoming untrue. Water is unequivocally involved in each and every time.
Speaker 1So why do you think that is? Why is the music of the Aenor, why does it reside chiefly in water of all substances?
Speaker 2Well, the cheat answer is because that's what's recorded in Silmarillion. The dangerous answer to bring in the presuppositions and baggage is, well, this is how you are brought into the church and Roman Catholic theology and even Lutheran theology is through the waters of baptism. And so you were born from a father and mother in the waters of the womb, and you're born to Father God and Mother Church in the waters of baptism, and that ultimately is what adopts you into the family and all but guarantees you the promise
Speaker 2of the resurrection and paradise.
Speaker 1Now, to really get to, and we can continue to get on these periphery issues, but as far as your exact thesis, it's clear that this old hope is present in the world that Tolkien's given us. How much clarity do you think the inhabitants actually have of it?
Speaker 2Yeah, that's a great question. So part of my thesis articulates that this has to be handed down. This has to be catechized from generation to generation. And you see it very easily in Gondorian lore and history, whereas Aragorn is familiar with the old tales, the creatures who go dark and bump in the night that are that predates Sauron and his reign. So clearly he's been catechized in the lore of Middle-earth, the lore of Arda, and the old tales that have occurred. But what you get fascinating
Speaker 2is that you expect that of the line of Numenor, of the line of the king, if you will. But Rohan also demonstrate this. And so when Aragorn pulls out the sword and warns the people outside of Theoden's hall, just don't, don't drop this. Don't let this touch the ground. Cause this is the sort of, uh, prophecy, if you will. And, uh, the regular guard says it's like all the old tales are, are flying back to our, uh, four of you are right into our face. And so even the common man, uh, knows,
Speaker 2knows the tales, know the story. And Aragorn points out specifically in the text, uh, that it's passed down through of all things song. And so the music is captured, uh, within the water, uh, And the elves, first awakening mankind, are sung to and being given visions and dreams and awakened to wisdom, I think is the exact word, of what creation's purpose is, of what the telos is, or the fulfillment of all things, will be at the end. And it's immediately put to music, that it's sung and
Speaker 2inculcated and catechized into generations and passed down, whether you're a highborn or a lowborn. And you get further evidence of that, uh, when Bilbo was in Rivendell with Frodo and he goes, well, if you're traveling about the land, make sure you bring back the old tales, the old songs, uh, that I may be unfamiliar with. And even the hobbits have that music. Uh, the Dorbs are an extra unique case because they're not the children of a Luvatar, just men and elves are, um, being fashioned, uh, I'm blanking
Speaker 2on the Valar, the fashion, the Maulay, uh, being fashioned by Aulay, uh, because he desired to create in the best possible way and use the gifts that Iluvatar gave him, uh, nonetheless, their eschatology is communicated through Durin's song and the promise that occurs, uh, the restoration of all things. Uh, Treebeard mentions this to Marian Pippin in regards to finding the Entwives, uh, and as Ents do, they sing song through it, uh, that, uh, they have to lose all that they've gotten, uh, in this world for them to find and be reunited with
Speaker 2the Entwives at the later world. He doesn't have the word for it, but the idea of it and the reunion is captured in the song. And so it's the Lutheran answer through catechesis and through repetition and through the handing down from one generation to the next of the great stories, the great hope, the great promises that are given again and again.
Speaker 1We definitely see that the more noble a person is or people are, the more in touch they are with the ancient things that are still very much alive in the world. A good contrast between eschatology and nihilism is that contest between Tom Bombadil and the Barrowhite when the Barrowhite song or poem, I can't remember exactly, but basically it's talking about how we're headed for basically unending death, essentially, of just cold despair. But then Bombadil pushes back with
Speaker 1a reminder about the mending of Arda. And so it's like, you know, all the good guys, all the noble figures are emboldened with this hope that there is light and high beauty forever beyond the reach of the shadow, that the shadow is but a fleeting thing and that there is a goodness that endures forever and in the end will engulf the shadow. You can't really understand the nobility within the legendarium apart from an affirmation of the hopeful eschatology that is at play. Otherwise, it just doesn't make sense. You...
Speaker 1you would only have the northern long defeat, but not the eucatastrophe that Tolkien puts again and again in his story.
Speaker 2That was the hardest darling to kill, because the first draft of it I mentioned was like 9,000 words longer, and it was looking at specifically the conversation with the Barrow-White and Tom Bombadil and dialoguing their songs, and that word count will get you.
Speaker 1It always hurts to cut Bombadil.
Speaker 3Thinking of cutting Bombadil. Do you think that we see any traces of this sort of eschatological knowledge in anything that we can identify and observe in the Peter Jackson movies? Assuming and knowing that it's very, very, very, very, very unlikely that he had any intention to do so if it is there.
Speaker 2Yeah. Cue your long pause on that. There is a weird, and again, I'm an apologist for the movies. I can't say it was deliberate assassination of the gospel, essentially, to kind of use short shrift for that or shorthand for that. But The moments where you would expect that to be played in spades have been snatched from the film. And I was talking about this with a couple of friends because there was a Babylon V had posted a meme
Speaker 2about how Moses said, you shall not pass. When he threw down the 10 commandments, Mount Sinai, and it was sent to me and I did the kind of dirt it out on him. And I was like, well, actually Gandalf doesn't use the imperative. He uses the indicative because that is just simply what is true. He doesn't need. uh, to forbid something that just simply cannot be done, uh, in general and consistently in the film. Uh, and we'll put the best construction on this for dramatic tension, uh, or for creating, uh, uncertainty in the minds of the viewers,
Speaker 2the moments where that should have been very clear, got muddled. And, uh, my wife makes fun of me all the time because we'll get to the part where, uh, then they actually penetrate, minister it. And the Nazgul takes Gandalf's staff and breaks it. And that is egregious. And, uh, like I'll pull it off and I've already trained my kids to wait because we watch it every year on Thanksgiving. And it's just a tradition we've had for 15 years now. And I
Speaker 2pause it there and I'm like, this is what actually happened. They could not crush the threshold because the gates of hell cannot overcome the kingdom of heaven. And so like, even that they're at the gates, they're at the threshold and they're Yeah. Anyway, as a side note and tangent to that, are there moments in the films where this is played out in spades? You can see the fingerprints of it. And one of the most beautiful parts of the film is Sam's conversation with Frodo. And you only
Speaker 2get this cut in the extended edition, I think, of Return of the King, where he points out the little moments where, look, Mr. Frodo, the the king has his crown again because sunlight broke in through the shadow of Mordor on one of the kings of Numenor, I'm sorry, one of the kings of Gondor's statues' head. And you see the fingerprints of the eschatology, of the hope that all sad things will become untrue in brief glimpses through the films, but not like you do within the text.
Speaker 2They often undercut it for words whatever reason they have chosen to undercut it.
Speaker 1Yeah. I mean, I'm also, I'm a big fan of the Jackson movies, but compared to the text, so much is undercut. It's brought to a lower register. The, a lot of the theological weight is, is taken away so that, you know, Aragorn isn't the great King coming into his kingdom. He's the very much reluctant King who has to be forced into that role against his will, which is, The fact that the movie Aragorn is so ashamed of his lineage that he would be like Isildur doesn't really make
Speaker 1sense where later at the Argonaut, he's bowing before the statues. So it's just this mismatch where I guess out of a appeal to our democratic egalitarian tendencies, we want to bring everyone down a little bit. But even still, just by telling the story, the basic story of the Lord of the Rings, we do get these patterns of renewal and restoration and hope. And so even though, yeah, there's nobody saying what's going to happen at the end of Arda or this version of Arda, I think that just
Speaker 1by telling the story, you still get that Christian reminder of hope and restoration and that all sad things will come untrue, that there's a place across the sea where our wounds can be mended. And so I do think that just by the nature of the story itself, we have that kind of eschatological hope, even though it is definitely dampened in the movies.
Speaker 2Yeah, I can't credit myself for this. I was on the discussion on the film that you guys had had a few weeks ago or months ago. I'm way behind on podcasts. But pointing out that even the makeup done on Frodo as he was traveling to the Grey Havens, he was very sunken and sullen. And then at the moment he gets on the boat and turns, he's youthful and vibrant again. There were deliberate choices within that. And it is there. You just have to be a close watcher as opposed to a close reader.
Speaker 3Do you think somebody could pick that up in the films without having actually read the text itself or even being exposed to these ideas?
Speaker 2It is definitely possible. And I say that simply because it is the films that captured my imagination and enchanted me so much that it forced me to want to know more. And so there was clearly something beautifully done that Jackson did that inspires goodness, truth and beauty, and even justice in that sense. And so it is there. But I don't remember who pointed it out, and all credit to them. And I am so sorry I forgot your name. But Hollywood can't have a virtuous character. They
Speaker 2become dull and flat. The recent Superman film is a clear example of that. This is why everybody loves the Joker in The Dark Knight and not Batman, because that's chaos. That's the growth. And being confronted with it, with a static character, is boring. And we love entertainment more than anything in our world.
Speaker 1Yeah, I mean, it's the same reason why Faramir got the treatment that he received. As you said, I mean, Hollywood just doesn't tolerate virtue because... There's this idea that people want to see themselves in the story that they're engaging with. And even though that's said a lot, I'm not even convinced that's entirely true. I mean, nothing stands out more than an absolutely virtuous character, just simply because
Speaker 1they aren't typically represented. And I think that we all naturally want something to look up to. We all recognize that there is such a thing as goodness. I deal with this all the time in my state university philosophy classes, so I'll try not to go off right now. But even the people who say that there are no such things as real ideals, that there's no real thing like truth, goodness, and beauty, you ask them in the next breath, how many of you appreciate justice? And everyone raises their hand because something within us craves these things that we've been
Speaker 1propagandized to reject. And so, you know, I'm not entirely convinced that people wouldn't be more drawn to Bookfair Amir if only they knew that he existed. And so, I don't know. I think that a lot of Hollywood's decisions are not even so much reflecting the market, but actually formative of the market. It kind of, I guess, feeds back and forth on that. But I might be going a little bit off track here. Josh, do you have any other questions about Tolkien?
Speaker 3Yeah, I was going to, regarding sources now. As far as texts that deal with theological matters with Tolkien, which ones would you recommend the most? Because I know one or two that I have in mind, but yours might be different than mine.
Speaker 2Yeah, the one, especially in regards to the thesis, that I found most helpful is, there are a couple. One is Lisa Kutras' Tolkien's Theology of Beauty, Majesty, Splendor, and Transcendence in Middle-Earth. She was an invaluable resource for the beauty that is in sorrow and how the turning of the darkest moments of Melkor end up being the crescendos of Iluvatar. And that's by Paul Grave McMillan in 2016.
Speaker 2Jonathan McIntosh's The Flame Imperishable, Tolkien, St. Thomas, and the Metaphysics of Faerie is by Angelico Press in 2017. That was just a joy to read, and that was one we're not quite like the Silmarillion. I would often read a chapter and be like, let me narrate this and probably read this again and go back and catch it again, because Lutherans and St. Thomas, but you get that. It was a joy to read, and the privation of evil as a corruption, and he does a great job of
Speaker 2articulating how The opposites of troll are the Ents, or I should say the opposite of Ents are the trolls. Every man has a Boromir and Denethor. Every hobbit has a golem and the like. And so he does a fantastic job articulating how that plays out. But just go into that one knowing that that is a dense, dense read. Other than that, Verlin Flieger's commentary on fairy stories and her annotations for it were fantastic. fantastic. I was wonderful
Speaker 2to have her as a professor, and I think she was fair theologically and remarkably articulate with where Tolkien was coming from in terms of unfairly stories. The other source that, once again, is often ignored is Melkor's Ring, which is where you can find the Athrabeth of Finrad and Andrath, and that would be I think the easiest ones to approach to kind of give you an idea of where
Speaker 2my thesis was coming from.
Speaker 1Yeah, that Imperish Wolf. book is great. I really enjoy that one. Also, just read the whole History of Middle-Earth. That's my recommendation. Get it right back there on my bookshelf.
Speaker 2Yeah, that one's at home. I'm in my office because I became a Luddite when we moved to Iowa. Got no internet.
Speaker 1Well, Josh, do you have anything else?
Speaker 3I think I'm satisfied. Is there anything else you all want to touch on?
Speaker 2I think I'm all right.
Speaker 1Let me ask you this. Why did the Jackson films, like what about them inspired you to take up and read?
Speaker 2Ooh, that is a, I think a more personal question than you realize. I have, uh, in short for my own life, um, I'm routinely told by my parents that, uh, my first word was books and just books, books, books. And I have lost myself in fiction all of the time and coming from a complicated childhood and family. Uh, with a lot of estrangement, uh, and my, my own father has now passed, uh, dealt with addiction issues and, uh,
Speaker 2a variety of other, uh, vices, uh, which he eventually overcame, but I did not find out he had overcome them until he had passed. And, uh, which is good because I'll see him at the resurrection and he will meet two of my children before I will. Uh, but books were often an escape. And so whether it was dumb things when you're at 10 years old of reading Goosebumps and just getting lost and thinking like, well, my life's not as bad as Horrorland or something like that, always spoke to me in that way. And I had never
Speaker 2heard of The Lord of the Rings whatsoever. So I had gotten lost in Narnia and wandered that several times by the time I first encountered Lord of the Rings at 2016 years old when the first film came out. And I went to the theater by myself because I was like, I don't want anybody to see me go watching a fantasy film. What if this is dumb or ridiculous or whatnot? And I just couldn't simply stop talking about it. And then I realized that, oh, this is a book. And it drove me right to the text. And so before even having the words of Tolkien and
Speaker 2on fairy stories, that good literature, good fiction is a means of recovery, a means of escape from whatever it is you're facing and a consolation that at the end of the day, evil does not win. That imperative had already been upon me and had already driven me through the dumb happy endings of Goosebumps to the wonder and charm of A Wrinkle in Time to what would it be like to be a king or queen of Narnia and all of these things. And ultimately, the way I
Speaker 2sell it is when I first encountered Lord of the Rings, I have bought several copies from people who had not read it. And I have routinely catechized, my elders of congregations and people I've encountered with it. If you want to see the heart of God and understand the triumph over sin and death that Christ has given us, but you're afraid of the Bible or you're afraid of the book of Concord or something like that, pick up the Lord of the Rings and you're getting the exact same
Speaker 2message in a sometimes far more entertaining way that'll communicate the fact that ultimately the all sad things will become untrue. And so I don't think I've offended anybody in my answer, hopefully, but, uh, or outed myself out too much and doxed myself in my family history. But, uh, you, you see the heart of God and the Lord of the rings. And I have not encountered, uh, another great work that has done it in such a revealing way, uh, with the caveat
Speaker 2that I read east of Eden when I was like 20 and I have not revisited it since. and try as I might, something in life always prevents me from finishing the Brothers Karamazov, but I'm 100 pages in this time, and so I will get to it. It could have some run for its money, but I think it's the perfect text. I don't think there's a clearer love letter to creation as a sub-creator that has ever been created.
Speaker 1I think that was a great response, and it's one that any thoughtful reader of Tolkien certainly will recognize, that it is just the perfect example of escape, consolation, recovery, as Tolkien talks about. And that's certainly something that I experienced as well, which I thought about echoing some of that, but honestly, I think that is the perfect way to end this. Yeah, I don't want to water that down.
Speaker 1So thank you, both of you, for joining me. And I Look forward to hopefully talking to you again sometime.
Watch the video: https://mythicmindfellowship.com/the-conflict-in-the-lord-of-the-rings-is-about-god-according-to-tolkien-mythic-mind-ep-199/ When Tolkien was pressed to say what the conflict at the heart of The Lord of...
Watch the video: https://mythicmindfellowship.com/you-have-forgotten-who-you-are-mythic-mind-ep-198/ Boethius has lost his place in the world, and Lady Philosophy tells him that he has forgotten who he is. Fortune had...
Watch the video: https://mythicmindfellowship.com/who-failed-anakin-skywalker-mythic-mind-ep-197/ Right-wing X has been full of pro-Anakin posts, including one Elon Musk shared of an AI image of Emperor Anakin with...
Watch the video: https://mythicmindfellowship.com/kierkegaards-concept-of-anxiety-anxiety-is-not-an-ailment-to-be-removed-mythic-mind-ep-196/ Today I'm giving you a free look into my Mythic Mind Fellowship course, The...
Watch the video: https://mythicmindfellowship.com/the-death-of-ivan-ilyich-am-i-guilty-mythic-mind-ep-194/ We all know we will die one day. It is another thing to consider that it is I who am going to die. In this...