Watch the video: https://mythicmindfellowship.com/the-death-of-ivan-ilyich-am-i-guilty-mythic-mind-ep-194/ We all know we will die one day. It is another thing to consider that it is I who am going to die. In this Mythic Mind conversation, Dr. Andrew Snyder (professor of philosophy and theology) is joined by David and Jack to read Tolstoy's The Death of Ivan Ilyich. We trace a man who did everything "properly," climbed the ladder, decorated the right house, and still ended up utterly alone, until suffering forces him to ask the one question he has always avoided: am I guilty? Topics include how ordinary people keep death at arm's length, why suffering can become a grace, and what it means to finally take responsibility for the life you've lived. Along the way we find Tolstoy reaching some of the same places as Lewis and Kierkegaard by a very different road. Related: • Kierkegaard on Man's Highest Perfection (Mythic Mind, ep. 193): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lJXOC2PfR3M • Till We Have Faces, Part One: Orual Behind the Veil (Mythic Mind, ep. 114): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1KhXO9V0PRw Get the book: The Death of Ivan Ilyich and Other Stories by Leo Tolstoy https://bookshop.org/a/129785/9780140449617 Join the Mythic Mind Fellowship: https://mythicmindfellowship.com/membership Listen to/watch the Mythic Mind podcasts: - Mythic Mind - Mythic Mind Games - Mythic Mind Movies #MythicMind #Tolstoy #DeathOfIvanIlyich #BookClub #Philosophy #Theology #CSLewis Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/mythic-mind--5808321/support.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1There are very few short stories that carry as much depth of insight with such brevity of words as Tolstoy's The Death of Ivan Ilyich. This is a story that's ever timely, as it deals with the psychology of dying, or perhaps more importantly, the responsibility that we have to live a life worth living in relation to the inevitability that we are all mortals doomed to die. I sometimes teach a philosophy course called Life, Death, and Meaning, and I'll typically begin the course by asking how many students know that they will die one day, and they all raise their hands, and they kind of laugh about it.
Speaker 1But then I follow up by asking, how many of them have considered that it is they who are going to die one day? This seems to be the same question, but it lands in a very different space. The existential import of this question is critical to the life of wisdom and responsibility. As we discuss the character of Ivan Ilyich today, many Lewis readers will see similarities to Mark Studdick, who was carried by the whims and delusions of society until he was confronted by the real and forced to ask the question regarding humanity. who it is that he is supposed to be, who he always would have been
Speaker 1if he had embraced his human calling. If you have not yet read The Death of Elon Ilyich, then I strongly recommend that you remedy that soon. There will, of course, be spoilers in this episode, but the main spoiler is contained in the title of the story, and so I don't believe that spoilers will really matter that much for this one. So it's up to you if you want to pause this to read and then come back later, or if you want to listen and then pick up the text. Either way, this is Mythic Mind. I am Andrew Snyder, and today we are discussing Tolstoy's The Death of Ivan Ilyich. Alright, joined today by David and Jack,
Speaker 1both of whom I believe just read the story for the first time, is that correct?
Speaker 2Okay, perfect.
Speaker 1And so I just read this for the first time, I don't know, a few years ago when I was teaching that course and I was looking for some good texts. And I came across this and, you know, I'm not an expert on Russian literature or Tolstoy in particular. This was the first Tolstoy text that I read. And since then, I read a few more of his short stories. But instantly, I knew that this was something special. It's the kind of book where you get to the end and you just have to sit there for a little while. Or at least that was my reaction. You know, go back and read that final chapter, the final few chapters a
Speaker 1couple of times, just let it sit with you. And, you know, it takes obviously a certain talent to leave that sort of reaction with a short story. But I think this did this quite well. And so I'd love to hear, before we start to trace the life and ultimately the death of Ivan Ilyich, what are your first impressions of reading this story?
Speaker 3I had no idea where it was going to go. And I, like you said, after it was over, the next day, I just went back and read the last couple of chapters again, because I just wanted to make sure it sunk in. Because a lot of leading up to that is just kind of building to this climax that's so moving. I had my wife read it. She reads pretty quickly. And we discussed it a little bit today as well. Yeah, I don't want to go too much into it right now. But Yeah, I'm glad that
Speaker 3I read it.
Speaker 1Yeah, it does have that kind of slow and meandering build at first, but as you get closer to the end and he's dealing with the crisis or not dealing with the crisis until he finally has to deal with the crisis, it just gets so psychologically intense until that resolution, I suppose, at the end. But Jack, what were your first thoughts?
Speaker 4I would say I had a similar reaction Reading this, I couldn't tell where it was going. I obviously knew that he was going to die and that he was approaching his death. But I was stunned by this turn in his personality, in his person, that occurred totally within the mind, basically on the prompting of this random peasant that he happened to interact with. And the kind of grace that Gerasim's character shows towards him that ends up
Speaker 4saving him on some level from despair, as it were. That really struck me. And I was also intrigued by this because I knew going in, I've never read any Tolstoy before, but I knew going in that Tolstoy had some rather unconventional, to put it nicely, heretical, to put it meanly, views on Christianity. And so I was wondering what he was going to do with that. But this strikes me, this story in particular, strikes me as quite
Speaker 4Christian in its essence. And I think it kind of betrays this propensity among this sort of upper middle class of Russian society that you also see portrayed in Dostoevsky to sort of just fill themselves with this vacuous life of chasing after meaningless things. And then when they approach death, You see this with Ivan Karamazov in the Brothers K. They're just faced with the harsh reality of what's actually happening to them in their end, and they have to
Speaker 4do something with it. And it's not very pleasant. Those are my first thoughts.
Speaker 1Yeah, and it's very much in keeping with what I understand of Tolstoy. Like I said, I'm not an expert in that Garrison is the only good character, the peasant, right? Not any of these society people. Tolstoy, who very much identified with the peasant class, I mean, he was regularly trying to give away all this money, but his wife put some restraints on him. He just very much identified with the working class. And so it definitely makes sense that that would be the hero of the story. And kind of leading up to his introduction, let's go back
Speaker 1to the very beginning, which I really, this is perhaps one of the best ways to have a very existential novel in that we begin outright with, here's what's going to happen. Now let's get on the inside of how we got there or the process of getting there. You know, we know from the title that Ivan Ilyich is going to die. But the way that it begins with that news and then backtracking. But maybe we should talk a little bit about his colleagues. So what were his colleagues like here when they discover the death of Ivan Ilyich?
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 3They're just, well, somebody's dead, but it's not me. And who's going to get his position? That's mainly it. And I do really appreciate that the story starts this way with it being outside of his head, because otherwise we might sit here and debate whether or not, well, were these people really all petty and selfish or was it just an image that he was projecting onto them? But no, like, you know, his wife is only interested in one of his colleagues insofar as he could help her figure out
Speaker 3how to get some more money now that he's gone. And since he couldn't, then she It was clear that she was not interested in him anymore. But I think about that because I'm a sound man at my church. So I have to, sometimes I get asked to run the sound for funerals during the week and I'll take a lunch break and go run the sound for a funeral for someone I don't know. And you see how different people behave before it starts. Some people come in and they're kind of laughing and talking with people that they haven't seen forever, just kind of forgetting the reason that they're meeting there. So I thought that was a
Speaker 3pretty realistic aspect of the story.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1I mean, death is, it's such a strange thing. Cause I mean, well, there's just, it is a strange thing. Like it is, it doesn't seem natural. And of course, from a Christian perspective, ultimately it's not natural, which is why it feels that way. But, you know, I mean, there's some question even regarding what are you supposed to do in that situation, even if you want to do the right thing, but these people aren't people who seem to really be asking that question, right? They're only concerned with what is society demanding of me. which I think we've probably all been in there in some situation of, you know, I ought to do this thing because it's
Speaker 1expected of me, even though internally it really doesn't mean anything to me. But what I really appreciate about Tolstoy is that the villains of the story, if we can use that word, are essentially ordinary people. And so that is something that very much calls us to that sort of reflection. And so they are concerned about all these things that surround Ivan Ilyich's death, but none of them are actually concerned about the death of Ivan Ilyich precisely because they refuse to be concerned about their own mortality. As David said, that line that comes up a few
Speaker 1times in this first chapter, it was him that was dead and not me. Anytime Peter Ivanovich, who is the closest thing he has to a friend, starts to have some reflection on his own mortality, he instantly pushes that away. There's a great line where he says that he's looking at the body of Ivan Ilyich that the dead always send like a warning to the living or something like that. And he says, but that seemed terribly inappropriate. Whenever he's close to having a moment of reflection and an awareness
Speaker 1of his own mortality, he instantly finds so much to push that aside.
Speaker 2Uh, and it's almost comical, but also obviously very insightful.
Speaker 3And the way that he's constantly thinking about what's happening right now, is it going to affect my ability to play bridge this evening? Yeah.
Speaker 4There's a kind of, um, I feel like the characters in this kind of upper-class Russian society have this tendency to do whatever they can to avoid asking themselves these kinds of questions. They're horrified of death, and so they flee from it. And so whenever they're faced with it, they do whatever they can to strip it of all its meaning. And one thing that I think is a keen insight of Tolstoy's in this is that there's nothing glorious about his death. It's just a normal guy getting
Speaker 4very sick and suffering a lot and then dying. And that's it. It's very ordinary death, something a lot of people will undergo. And the thing that kind of, I'm sorry, I'm going to go back to Gerasim because he's such a compelling character, is that he doesn't do anything except this small little service of sort of providing some comfort for this man, whom he doesn't really know that well, and just being with him. And so it seems to
Speaker 4me like Tolstoy is showing us that when faced with death, we don't have to try to solve it. We don't try to have to resolve it. That tension is going to be there, but the right thing to do Which Gerasim does is to simply be with someone in that circumstance in the same way that Christ was with us to the very end in death itself.
Speaker 1Yeah, it makes sense that Gerasim, given his station, would have a much more difficult time avoiding the reality of death. That surely the peasant class experienced death on a more regular basis than the upper class, middle upper class. And so he has that kind of wisdom, that memento mori wisdom that comes along with recognizing mortality. You know, at the end of this first chapter, when Piotr, I think it was Ivanovic, is standing nearby. Yeah, he's standing nearby and he says, you know, nasty business or something like that. Just basically making general small talk, like something you might
Speaker 1say at a funeral. And there's some response by saying, it's God's will, sir. It will come to us all. And so he just, he has that insight, that wisdom. And so later on, after he has this or pays this great service to Ivan Ilyich, Ivan Ilyich eventually asks, why are you doing this? And his response is, well, I'd like to think that someone would do this for me when I'm in this situation. And so he has that just humility and that recognition of the frailty of life. And so that paired with a basic golden rule ethic
Speaker 1allows him to do this kind of service that you could never do unless you are willing to come to terms with your own mortality. You can only have compassion to the extent that you're able to place yourself in that situation. But I do think that it's such a great, like dark comedy when Peter Ivanovich is talking with his wife, his widow. He's like so concerned about like the springs and the cushion that he's sitting on. There's emphasis on all these things that don't matter in like a hyper fixated way. And then finally, when they do find out,
Speaker 1you know, that it was just about getting money, then they both just instantly want the conversation to end, but they still have to continue through some formalities until they find a way out. It's a very funny scene, as dark as it is.
Speaker 4I think an interesting thing that I noticed was that one of the things about Gerasim's act of love and Ivan's reception of it is that it's totally undeserved. In his final weeks and final days, the treatment that he receives from Praskovia, from Peter and all of his friends from his daughter is something that he sowed and he's just reaping what he sowed throughout his life. And he realizes that at the end, and it takes a lot
Speaker 4of torment for him to finally come to that conclusion because he runs away from that conclusion. He's like, that doesn't make any sense. I did everything right. This doesn't make any sense. I've, I did all the right things. I hung out with the right people. I, you know, I got the good job. I made the money. You know, I rub shoulders with the right people. How can it be that I deserve this? But he eventually is forced into that conclusion.
Speaker 2And so that lends.
Speaker 4A sort of greater power to Gerasim's love by virtue of the fact that it's totally undeserved. If he had not been there, that would have been more expected, I suppose. Someone in that sort of moral state is probably more likely to die alone, divorced from the kind of companionship that one needs in their final hours.
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 1I mean, Ivan Ilyich is somebody who, despite the fact that he's well-placed in society, he is terribly alone. He has no real relationships with those around him, with his colleagues. He has no real relationship with himself. There's a mention at one point in somewhere in the second half when he says the last time he can remember being really happy was when he was a child, kind of before he got caught up in the throes of society and checking off all the right things to hit this level of success or this version of success, which is what
Speaker 1led him to develop the relationships that he had and to engage in the activities he engaged in, which reflecting back, he knows were immoral, but everything is done with white gloves or whatever the French phrase was that they give us. And so everything's done in the way that society does things. And so that itself was its own justification, which means he had no real ethic. He had no real transcendent sense of right and wrong until the end when he starts asking, wait, am I guilty? But before that point, he has no real place to think of guilt. It's just a matter of what is going to advance my
Speaker 1vision of what my life is supposed to look like, even to the point of marrying Praskovia, where he meets her and says that she's fond of him. She's agreeable enough. And so they got married. That's their great love story. He met her, so they got married.
Speaker 2It seemed right.
Speaker 1But it becomes clear that neither of them really like each other. And as that becomes more and more evident, he just checks out more and more. There's this line where it says something like, it never even crossed his thought that this doesn't have to be like this. And so he just increasingly pours himself into his work with people that he does not have relationships with. And so at home, at work, wherever he is, regardless of what success he's achieving, He is fundamentally alone, and he dies alone,
Speaker 1at least regarding his earthly relationships.
Speaker 3Yeah, and when it talks about how he feels about his work, the thing he likes about it is the fact that he could be unjust to any of these people and get revenge or do anything he wanted to do. Not that he did, but it is that feeling of power that about being this judge or was it sort of a judge or some kind of a, I don't understand. Yeah, some kind of magistrate, yeah. Yeah, 1800s Russian legal stuff. But, you know, so even when we do the right thing,
Speaker 3like justice is a good thing, our motives can still be completely selfish and impure.
Speaker 1Right, like a petty dictator, he relished in the fact he could destroy someone's life if he wanted to, but he's so noble.
Speaker 2That he wouldn't do that. Right, right.
Speaker 1Which really tells me he essentially is a tyrant, but he's too much of a coward to actually act on that. Which might be a good thing for society, but it's actually a defect in his soul that keeps him from doing that.
Speaker 4Yeah, he's the ultimate petty tyrant.
Speaker 2Exactly.
Speaker 4Not actually of any significance.
Speaker 2Right, he'd be good in HR or something. Yes, exactly.
Speaker 3Well, he says about what caused his death, you know, what is it all for? It really is so. I lost my life over that curtain, as I might have done when storming a fort. Is that really possible? How terrible and how stupid. It can't be true. It can't, but it is. All of that of him kind of building his nest the way that he wanted to for his family to come and really wanted them to be super impressed with it. And then the bit about he thought it was fantastic, but it was really just exactly
Speaker 3like every other person's house that was of the same social class as he was. They put these things around thinking it looks impressive, but they're all just going through the exact same meaningless motions, basically.
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 1He really wanted to stand out by looking like everybody else in his class.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 1Which, I mean, I think it's significant, you know, what caused his sickness was that his servant wasn't hanging the curtains or something exactly the way he wanted them to. And so he takes over, and in grasping at control is when he fundamentally loses it.
Speaker 2I think.
Speaker 4Another thing that might be going on in this story, and it's more implicit than explicit, there seems to be something like.
Speaker 2I don't know.
Speaker 4I'm a little bit tentative in making this claim, but there seems to be something like a theodicy justification for suffering. Because it seems to me like, you know, Ivan could have died suddenly, not from a sickness. He could have fallen off his horse or something. And that would have just been that. And would that have done him any good?
Speaker 1No.
Speaker 3So.
Speaker 4Given the assumption that he's going to die, what is the best way for him to go out for someone of his spiritual state? The suffering that he experiences is what brings him to the brink of finally realizing what kind of person he is and repenting of it. I don't know if that is exactly something that Tolstoy would have intended, but it seems to be there.
Speaker 1Yeah, I mean, I think something like the gift of existence, which very much includes suffering, is most certainly part of the story. Something that Ivan Ilyich could not experience until it was forced upon him, until he was forced into a place of utter despair. He had to recognize the guilt that he has in isolating himself. He had to recognize his own isolation, which isn't something he recognized before. Like all of these things had to be forced upon him. And ultimately it was a grace, but he had to
Speaker 1go through this despair first. or at least the recognition that he had always been in despair, which is the kind of language that Kierkegaard tends to use, which is very much sympathetic to what Tolstoy is doing here, that you have to recognize your utter inability to carry your own existence before you can recognize what existence is all about and cast yourself into the arms of grace, essentially. I love just this descent into despair, this descent into madness.
Speaker 2That we get.
Speaker 1He's dealing with a few different questions that continue to spiral further and further down. So like the first question he's dealing with is, am I sick? And he kind of goes back and forth on that of, you know, I'm pretty athletic. Like I'll recover. It's fine to know I'm obviously sick. And then the question becomes, am I dying? And that's something that the doctors refuse to deal with. You know, he'll ask them, is this serious? And they say, that's, irrelevant to this. It's irrelevant to the case of what's wrong with you. That's all we care about. And so the question becomes, am I dying? And eventually it becomes, yes,
Speaker 1I'm dying. And then the question is, did I live in the way that I wanted to? And then what is it that I do want? And then finally, the most important question he asks is, am I guilty? It's at that point where finally he's able to break out of his isolation. Because to actually be guilty, you have to be putting yourself in relation to something that's transcendent, something that's beyond you. That's what makes you guilty. And so in recognizing his guilt, he was finally able to break out of his isolation and discover that which he fundamentally needed. And there's just so much in that of value and in demonstrating the kind of isolating impact of suffering,
Speaker 1the fact that no one around him could possibly understand what it is that he was dealing with. And in a certain sense, that's true. And so he finally recognizes that he has this great wisdom about mortality that none of these other fools around him have. And so he's raving about how foolish they are, despite the fact that exactly who he was like five minutes ago. So there's just so much like foolishness and despair that ultimately leads into wisdom.
Speaker 2And so there's a lot to deal with here.
Speaker 4I have to wonder, do you guys think that, I don't know, something that I was thinking was maybe lacking is missing? You know, he figures out his problem in the final pages and it's kind of resolved. Maybe it's simply that he didn't have time to think through this. But you know, there's not really like an Ebenezer Scrooge turn towards love for the people that he has previously done wrong. Namely his wife and all of his colleagues
Speaker 4and all of the people that he's interacted with. He spent his life abusing them, not in a very obvious way, but in the sort of nefarious way of, of neglect and selfishness and sort of instrumentalizing his relationships with others.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 4I wonder like to what degree would, would he have repented in that way had he lived longer? Or if that's just something that Tolstoy left out for some reason or another, I guess what I'm saying is that in his sort of epiphany about his own soul, there's not a, He doesn't go the next step and say, therefore, I've done all of these people wrong. He kind of almost looks down on them for not figuring out what he only like you just said five minutes ago. He only
Speaker 4just figured out. And even to the very end, like his last interaction with his wife is pretty cruel. If I recall correctly, he doesn't speak nicely to her and he kind of resents her for being the way she is.
Speaker 3Yeah. There are several times where it describes people coming in and talking to him or looking at him in a way, and it's saying that, and he hated them for it. Yeah. But then at the end, when his son comes in, he feels sorry for him, and his wife looks at him, and he feels sorry for her, like he's actually got some compassion. And he tries to say, forgive me, but doesn't quite manage to get it out. But then I love the line that he knew that he, whose understanding mattered, would understand, which... Brought tears to my
Speaker 3eyes when I read that.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 4I must confess, I forgot about that moment.
Speaker 1Yeah, it's really not until the very end. And I think that where things get set up for the ultimate resolution are when his wife implores him to take the sacrament. And he does so. But at first, he does so just because it seems like something he should do at this point. He doesn't really have anything else to do. And then even after taking it, thinks that maybe I'm actually getting better for a moment. But that doesn't happen. But then we're told that he suffered for three days, right? And so there are going to be a lot of
Speaker 1gospel connections here in that at the end of the third day, he experiences a kind of resurrection even in his death, right? That's when suddenly death is no more, right? Where's the fear of death? It is no longer there. Death is no longer there. And so even in his dying, he's experiencing a kind of resurrection. And of course, the final words that he hears is somebody nearby saying, it is finished.
Speaker 3I appreciate you bringing up Scrooge, Jack, because I was going to mention that, that he doesn't have an Ebenezer Scrooge, you know, throw open the windows and just love everybody moment. By the time he comes to this realization, he can't get any earthly benefit for that realization at all. As far as everyone else knows, oh, man, it was terrible. He just screamed for three days at the end. But it says that time was like nothing to him during this last few hours. But I don't know. I like
Speaker 3that it's not about, and he lived happily ever after. I mean, I'm sure.
Speaker 4It wouldn't be Russian if it was.
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 3But it's still, he came to the most important understanding of of himself and his needs at the very, very end. Right.
Speaker 1And I think that ultimately the story Tolstoy is telling is not about his relationships with other people. They serve to indicate the relationship that he has internally with himself and finally with God. And so it's really about Ivan Ilyich more so than it is about Ivan Ilyich's relationships. But I think that's a good point that David brought up, that even when he desires their forgiveness, he can't really get that. All he has is repentance before God. That's all he has. And that, I think, makes for a
Speaker 1more profound story.
Speaker 4I will say it's quite sad. In my translation, it doesn't translate that last phrase.
Speaker 3As it is finished. So I didn't catch that.
Speaker 4Yeah, mine says it's no more, which is... So I did not catch the allusion to the Gospels.
Speaker 1Right before that, it says, at least in the translation I'm reading here, It says, it's finished, said someone over him. He heard those words and repeated them to himself in his heart. And it says, death is finished, he said to himself, it is no more. And so, yeah, so the final words that he, interesting. Well, I hope that this translation is correct because it's a very powerful idea that those are the final words he hears and that resonate within him as he dies.
Speaker 3I don't think the three days can be any kind of an accident and all of that. It doesn't seem like it. Yeah. Y'all got me thinking more about How do you say his name? Gerasim. I don't, I don't know how to pronounce it.
Speaker 1I say Gerasim, but I, I, I've just come to accept my level of Russian pronunciation of the.
Speaker 2Names of the story.
Speaker 3All right, let's read a Japanese book sometime. My pronunciation will be better, but he, he has nothing to gain from what he does. And I was thinking about how it's almost humiliating the way that he is helping him, but he's willing to do it. You know, he's like putting his legs on his shoulders and, It's very obviously not a physical, he's not helping him physically because he couldn't just prop his legs up at the exact same angle. It was the physical contact with this compassionate human being that relieved his suffering.
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 1And that he was able to look on Ivan Ilyich at a time when Ivan Ilyich could no longer even look upon himself. You know, there's a scene where he is refusing to look in the mirror because he just can't look at himself anymore, seeing the death in his own face. Yeah.
Speaker 3Yeah. And you were talking about him only remembering that he was happy when he was a child. There was a part where he's kind of caught in this loop. He starts getting nostalgic for his childhood, but he won't let himself think about that. He doesn't want to think about that. So he tries to think of something else. And that still brings him back to this moment when he was happy. It's like he's maybe starting to figure out Like, what is it about all of my life since then that has not brought me happiness? When he lost that childhood sense of what was valuable, maybe.
Speaker 4It is much like the ghost of Christmas past, honestly.
Speaker 3True.
Speaker 4I mean, you know, because Scrooge kind of faces the same question because he has delightful childhood and there's a lot of suffering in it, but there's a lot of compassion and love in it. And he meets his wife, but that doesn't work out. And it's because of his greed. And so that kind of retrospective on not just, oh, I've been miserable. Woe is me. But specifically, I was happy once upon a time and now I'm not. Why
Speaker 4is that?
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 1And at first he refuses to deal with that because it forces responsibility on him that he's not yet ready to accept the fact that it's not just that he's had such a miserable life forced upon him, but he made bad choices that led to a miserable life. that he didn't even recognize to be miserable until this point. When now he's asking, what is it that I want? And what is it that I should want? There's that great internal monologue, or maybe he was talking to himself aloud, I don't know. But where he asked that question of, what do I want? Will I want to live? Live how?
Speaker 1Live as I always have? And suddenly, as I always have is no longer what he actually wants, which is part of the beginning of his descent, but ultimately what's going to lead to his redemption is that recognition of personal responsibility that I am guilty.
Speaker 3Yeah, there's even that part where he's talking about how he did things that he was ashamed of when he was a student. But now that he's out in society, he's finding all these people did that too, and they don't feel bad about it. So he doesn't feel ashamed of it anymore. There's just a whole sequence of events like that in his life. So much of it reads like a cold obituary, just stating things. Boring facts. He had this job. He wanted a better job. He moved to this job. He demanded this much money and he
Speaker 3got it. And these things happen. But his life is not actually improving. He's not enjoying his life anymore through any of these steps.
Speaker 1Yeah, it's I mean, I just can't help but to relate him to Mark Studdock in that hideous strength. I mean, when he's Mark Sudeik initially, he's not a bad guy necessarily, but he doesn't really well, he's a man without a chest. He doesn't know who he is. He doesn't really know what it means to be human. He doesn't know what he's supposed to be doing. I mean, he's a sociologist after all. And he he just gets swept up in this world of opportunity.
Speaker 2And there's that. Big crisis.
Speaker 1Well, actually, I guess it's not a big crisis, but it should have been a big crisis when he's told to write that newspaper article ahead of time. And Lewis says this is like a crossing the Rubicon event here where once he did this major thing, well, now it's really easy to do things like that. And so Mark Sudeik ends up essentially in hell entirely of his own making. And that emphasis on personal responsibility for the greatest suffering in your life is such an important idea when it's so easy to just play the victim and say, woe
Speaker 1is me. Fate has forced this miserable life upon me. Instead of stopping to think about all the various choices that you've had that have led you to this moment. Again, maybe you've been dealt a particularly bad hand by fortune, but nonetheless, you are responsible for how you choose to relate to that hand that you are dealt. And that is, it's a freeing concept because once you recognize the guilt that you have for your life, well, maybe now you can actually seek atonement and start making things right. So it's a very, it's a powerful message.
Speaker 4I hadn't made that connection to Mark Stuttig, but when you mentioned it in the intro, I immediately was like, oh, that totally makes sense. One thing that strikes me is the difference between Lewis's approach and Tolstoy's here in the sense that, you know, Lewis, who is steeped in medieval thought and then applying that sort of framework to this speculative science fiction that is ultimately like, it turns quite
Speaker 4horrific in the latter half of that book, especially. That medium is starkly different from this 19th century realism of Tolstoy that is very kind of, you know, I love Lewis and I love Tolkien and I love medieval literature and I read all of these things a lot. And I don't spend a lot of time reading like this kind of realist fiction But when I do, when I read the greats, Dostoevsky and Tolstoy and Charles Dickens, I'm struck by their ability to imbue very, very mundane things
Speaker 4with incredible amounts of meaning. And Tolstoy does this very just expertly in a way that comes to the same conclusion as Lewis, but in a very different way.
Speaker 3And just for the record, that scene where Mark is being tested, and refuses to stand on the crucifix is just some of Lewis's best writing. I think I just love that whole scene so much where he's like, so what if, and I can't quote it exactly, but you know, I mean, just because the straight may always get beaten, there's no reason not to go down with it. Why, why stand on the side of evil just because good is always going to be defeated. And that's kind of just a resigning to, I'm going to do the right thing,
Speaker 3even if I don't benefit from it.
Speaker 2It's a very puddle-glum moment. I'm going to choose a straight even.
Speaker 4If there's no straight. That scene is so symbolically rich and it's interesting because Mark Stuttick is not expressing any kind of faith in Christ at that moment. Not in a substantial sense of I believe that he is God and I believe that he's going to resurrect from the dead. But it's more of a sort of I'm going to express solidarity and stand with this, this broken man on the cross, even though I have, I don't believe that
Speaker 4he's going to win. And, and Tolstoy is kind of does the same thing in the sense that there's no resolution to Yvonne's death. He dies.
Speaker 3That's it.
Speaker 4You know, there's this understanding that you have to go through that. And there's no sort of, I don't know. Resolution is the best term I can think of for it.
Speaker 1Yeah, it's, I mean, it's a very imminent, very existentialist kind of faith resolution that we get here in that, you know, throughout the story, there's no real theology posited apart from the general societal stuff that they happen to engage with, you know, they go to the funeral and Peter does the sign of the cross and he's obviously not a very religious person. He's just doing the things that are expected of him.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 2And so there's really no religion. It's kind of like Tolkien, right?
Speaker 1Where he says that there's no religion in the story because it's the entire story that that's largely what's happening here.
Speaker 2And I don't know, I think.
Speaker 1This makes for a much better Christian story than when people set out to write Christian stories in, you know, in our own era. No, no newsboys at the end. And I think that that makes for a more compelling narrative.
Speaker 2Indeed.
Speaker 3Yeah. And it's it's no accident that his job is in law, but it hadn't really occurred to me until we're talking about it now. But there's the part where, you know, he's saying there's, you know, something's wrong. Maybe I didn't live as I ought to have done. But how could that be? Because I did everything properly. And like whatever definition of properly is, I don't know. But he says the judge is coming. The judge is coming. The judge, he repeated to himself. Here he is the judge, but I am not guilty. And so, like so many people have done to him, he's standing before God and
Speaker 3declaring his innocence. It's just good writing.
Speaker 1Yeah, that always gives me the chills at that moment when he who formerly celebrated the fact that he held justice in his hands, that now it's standing over him, which is Apparently, I just relate everything to Lewis, but it kind of reminds me of the end of Till We Have Faces, where she has this complaint, and then finally she brought forth before righteousness itself, she is brought to account. And I don't know, it's a very, very powerful moment.
Speaker 3If we were held only to our own standard that we have for other people, we couldn't stand up under it.
Speaker 2Well, do we have anything else to say?
Speaker 4That's all I've got.
Speaker 3Yeah, I'm glad I read it.
Speaker 1I mean, I think it's definitely a short story. It's a novella that could easily merit a week on each chapter. But I feel like as far as a general approach goes, I think this was good. Yeah, I definitely recommend everyone read it. I mean, I've read it several times now, and it never ceases to strike at me because like many of these characters in this story, that it's very easy to have these insights into deeper things, insights into yourself and your immortal condition, and then go about your
Speaker 1life and just forget it. I mean, I don't know what Ivan Ilyich would be like if he recovered and went about his life, you know, would he fall back in old habits?
Speaker 2Would he not?
Speaker 1I don't know, but I know myself and I know how easy it is for me to fall right back into the mundane, acting as if things will continue forever, essentially as they are now. But of course, We know that's not the case, but we need to constantly remember what we've forgotten. As Lady Philosophy says, remember who you are. Or also Mufasa, I guess.
Speaker 3All right.
Speaker 1Well, thanks for reading this. Thanks for stopping by to chat. And we will do it again sometime. Bye.
Watch the video: https://mythicmindfellowship.com/the-conflict-in-the-lord-of-the-rings-is-about-god-according-to-tolkien-mythic-mind-ep-199/ When Tolkien was pressed to say what the conflict at the heart of The Lord of...
Watch the video: https://mythicmindfellowship.com/you-have-forgotten-who-you-are-mythic-mind-ep-198/ Boethius has lost his place in the world, and Lady Philosophy tells him that he has forgotten who he is. Fortune had...
Watch the video: https://mythicmindfellowship.com/who-failed-anakin-skywalker-mythic-mind-ep-197/ Right-wing X has been full of pro-Anakin posts, including one Elon Musk shared of an AI image of Emperor Anakin with...
Watch the video: https://mythicmindfellowship.com/kierkegaards-concept-of-anxiety-anxiety-is-not-an-ailment-to-be-removed-mythic-mind-ep-196/ Today I'm giving you a free look into my Mythic Mind Fellowship course, The...
Did the people of Middle-earth know how their story ends? Rev. Jeffrey Wade joins Andrew Snyder and Josh to discuss his master's thesis on eschatology in Arda. His question is not only what Tolkien believed, but whether...