Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Mythic Mind

Mythic Mind artwork

193 - Kierkegaard on Man's Highest Perfection

Oct 5, 202655 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Watch the video: https://mythicmindfellowship.com/kierkegaard-on-mans-highest-perfection-mythic-mind-ep-193/ We are pressed to dissolve into the mass, to wear a demographic as a self, or to win identity from whatever community we most esteem. Kierkegaard’s answer cuts the other way: the glory of the human being is to recognize utter dependency on God. In Mythic Mind episode 193, Dr. Andrew Snyder is joined by Zach and David for an Exploring the Psyche conversation on Kierkegaard’s discourse “To Need God Is a Human Being’s Highest Perfection.” They push past the easy proverb that a person needs only a little, through Job and vanity that can even dress itself as renunciation, to the Christian claim that greatness is not pagan self-sufficiency but knowing how much we need God. Along the way: first self and deeper self, the moving wheel of fortune versus the eternal, inwardness against self-enclosure, Christendom versus contemporaneity with Christ, and why casting Kierkegaard as a secular existentialist misses the Christian (even Boethian) grain of the text. Topics include needing little versus needing God, praying for the powerful because they need God most, grace and being capable of nothing, the hard wine before the good wine, and how anchoring in God frees the temporal self for real community rather than atomism. Get the book: Eighteen Upbuilding Discourses by Søren Kierkegaard https://bookshop.org/a/129785/9780691020877 Join the Mythic Mind Fellowship: https://mythicmindfellowship.com Fellows and Companions can join The Psychology of Søren Kierkegaard: Life in Anxiety and Despair, beginning the week of October 4, plus Academy courses, Inkwell essays, and the fuller life of the community. Listen to and watch Mythic Mind podcasts: - Mythic Mind - Mythic Mind Games - Mythic Mind Movies & Shows #MythicMind #ExploringThePsyche #Kierkegaard #ToNeedGod #Philosophy #Theology #Psyche #ChristianExistentialism Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/mythic-mind--5808321/support.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1There are pressures all around us, and within us for that matter, to become one of the masses, to identify ourselves first and foremost as a representative of a demographic identity group, as victims of disenfranchisement from forces outside of our control, or simply the internal drive to be someone in the eyes of whatever community we most esteem. However, when we lose ourselves to the mass, when we fundamentally define ourselves in relation to others who inhabit this moving world, We do just that. We lose ourself, the self that

Speaker 1we are as an individual before God. Kierkegaard faced this issue within the Christendom of the Danish Lutheran state church. To be Danish was essentially to be Christian, which is to say that it required nothing of inward appropriation or of becoming, as he called it, contemporaneous with Christ. In a true Lutheran spirit set against his contextual Lutheranism, Kierkegaard insisted that Christian faith was not something we wear that grace was not something that we wear, but that the truest condition of the human glory was just that. It

Speaker 1was a continual gift of God. He maintained that the glory of the human being is that we are able to recognize our utter dependency on God. Indeed, that we are nothing in ourselves, that we can do nothing and be nothing apart from this dependency. But in our self-insufficiency, we can find the eternal strength that anchors our identity in God, and in so doing, it grounds our engagement with the moving world. I'm Andrew Snyder, and this is Mythic Mind, Exploring the Psyche. Today, we're discussing Kierkegaard's discourse, to need God is a human being's highest perfection. Today,

Speaker 1I am joined by Zach and David.

Speaker 2Welcome.

Speaker 3Now, this is a 30-page story.

Speaker 1Dense text, as Kierkegaard's texts are always dense and abstract, although this is the easy one compared to what we're going to be doing for our course. As David was mentioning, the concept of anxiety is not an easy summer read, but it's the fall now, so that's okay. So maybe we just start at the beginning. Kierkegaard starts off with this phrase, man only needs little and only for a little while, something like that. That's a proverb that he throws out there. That's where he starts. What do you guys think he's doing with this introduction? What's he setting

Speaker 1up or what's he trying to accomplish? Why is he talking about this?

Speaker 4One note that I took was he says, one says it to oneself, even on a lucky day, since the human heart is very deceitful. It's all too eager to take high-mindedness in vain and is proud of needing only a little while using much. And that kind of hit me. Yeah. It's like, I could do without all these, I don't need all this stuff, but I'm sure glad I have all this stuff.

Speaker 3Right. And that's something that Kierkegaard very often does.

Speaker 1He takes this kind of proverbial wisdom that makes us feel wise, but then he pushes us to question, what are we actually saying? What do we actually mean? He's always going to push us in that inward direction to pull off the mask or the veil to you know, bring in some Lewis imagery.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 3Zach, do you have anything to add to that?

Speaker 2I also underlined that phrase. So I don't think I would say anything different than was just said.

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 1So and he really emphasizes the fact that this is a kind of proverb that we tend to say, that we tend to use tritely. But it's a reality that we're inevitably going to learn in this life that we are going to suffer, right? We are going to encounter loss. We might not necessarily learn to be contented with that loss simply by virtue of losing, but we are going to learn how little we actually need. Things will be taken away. We will suffer. Eventually we're going to die. Like that's just the reality of this mortal life. And

Speaker 1so as things are taken away from us, We won't necessarily learn this wisdom in a deeper way than the kind of trite, superficial glib way we might say it. You know, just like it's really easy to give that kind of wisdom to somebody else who has suffered. But it's a different thing to really not only learn that, but embrace that reality. But ultimately, that's not even where he's trying to push us. That's the starting place. He's trying to get us to move in that inward direction. But where is he taking us from there?

Speaker 4Yeah, there were several points where I thought, okay, here's the point. And he would say, though, that like, no, that's not it yet, though. That may be like the beginning of the thing. But he did talk about who is more wretched, the one who has experienced not having things and difficulties in their life, or the cowardly weak fool who doesn't perceive that his comfort is a fraud, that it's of little benefit when calamity strikes. that this is the rare instance. Yeah, which I thought is a

Speaker 4great point.

Speaker 2Yeah, I underlined where he talked about time taking things little by little from us. And then on the next couple of pages, I took note of a Job reference and put that in my margins a few times throughout the essay. I don't want to jump too far ahead, but whether he intended it or not, he talked about, you know, renouncing wealth or renouncing things, you know, renouncing vanity by an even greater vanity, you know, kind of

Speaker 2similar to how we opened up. And so I thought of Job in contrast to someone like Francis of Assisi or someone who, you know, renounces great wealth. And we typically think of that as maybe a really noble or pious act. And I just, as I read the essay, I started contrasting that with Job who really didn't renounce anything but was put through this trial or cross by God. So those were just some things I started thinking about as.

Speaker 4He got rolling.

Speaker 3Right.

Speaker 1That even our renunciation of wealth can actually be born of vanity. It can be a pursuit of vanity so that now I can be known as somebody who has renounced wealth, whether that be to the masses or even just out of my own pride and pursuit of self-worth, this idea that, well, I can do something by myself, which that is really what he's getting at as vanity. And I love this comparison he puts, makes in, let's see, I'm pulling my notes here. But he basically talks about

Speaker 1how for the pagan, the God is great because it doesn't need anything. And next to the God would be the wise man who knows that he needs very little. But for the Christian, that's not enough. For the Christian, the mark of greatness is precisely the fact that we recognize how utterly dependent we are. We recognize how much we need, not of earthly goods, obviously, but how much we need of God. He really drives in this Lutheran

Speaker 1spirit of that you have nothing except for the grace of God. That's why I think it's not wrong to really cast Kierkegaard as a Lutheran to the Lutherans with this kind of emphasis that he gives us.

Speaker 2Yeah, and this... Hong edition is the one that I'm using. So on page 300, just sort of unpacking what you were talking about, you know, having only the grace of God. I did find it interesting when you started talking about, I don't know if we'd call it a paradox, but just this idea of being contented with the grace of God. It's sort of a surprising way of putting things. And, you know, it's that thing, if one has God's generous favor, like that, there's really nothing else that's needed. And it's

Speaker 2kind of an absurdity, I guess, is the word I was looking for, to have to content yourself with having everything. But that's just kind of a concession to our, I guess, our pride and our struggle in our current condition where that's where the need for contentment comes from. But I just found that idea very interesting that I've always only thought of it through, you know, while we're journeying through the difficulties of this life, be content, you know, with

Speaker 2the grace of God. But really it is funny to think about that.

Speaker 4You know, yeah.

Speaker 1Yeah, it's another time where he really makes us question just the way we talk about things, the greatest things that we can say, well, even if I lose everything else, well, at least I still have God. At least, what more could you have? It's like he uses the imagery of, well, at least I get to feast in the kingdom of heaven. It really demonstrates the absurdity of the way that we tend to talk about such things.

Speaker 3He really makes us to take it seriously.

Speaker 4Like when people say, all we can do is pray. That's an amazing thing that we can do that. That shouldn't be, well, I've run out of other options. So I guess I'll ask God to help me with this.

Speaker 3Right. Yeah.

Speaker 1And he talks about how it's part of the liturgy. It's common to pray for the king by name. He says, you know, we tend to pray for the suffering masses as just that with the belief that God knows the individual situation. But we really pray particularly by name for the king precisely because of the difficulty that such a person has in recognizing that they need God. And, you know, he says that, well, maybe we pray for the king

Speaker 1because if things go well for the king, it'll go well for me. That's not really intercessory kind of prayer that the church fundamentally be involved in. But if we really appreciate that as intercessory. kind of prayer for the good of the ruler, for good of the elites, essentially, we're doing it because of the dangerous position that they're in and not recognizing that they need God.

Speaker 4Yeah, I really liked that, that the higher a person stands, the more he needs God. It's not because they're a celebrity, so I'm gonna pray for them by name. It's because they need God the most. And I think keeping that in mind, like when we pray for leaders is just really a valuable thing that I had not really, really thought of before. There were a lot of moments while I was reading this where I was like, wow, I see why Andrew had committed himself to studying Kierkegaard.

Speaker 1Yeah, he just does that again and again, just makes us kind of see with new eyes the things that we've become used to in a very mundane sort of way. He helps us to take them seriously and have that inward appropriation. And really by emphasizing this fact that the Christian greatness, the human greatness, isn't recognizing our dependency on God. And the fact that the more that we recognize that, the more we recognize that we need dependency on God, the more we recognize we need God. And so there really is no true contentedness for the one who is

Speaker 1content in God. because there's this ever-growing desire for recognition, a greater appreciation for that differential between where you are and who God is. It's this kind of longing that builds a certain kind of angst that wants you to keep wanting more and more and more. That holiness doesn't become content with itself. It's only content with God, who is always going to be other than where you are. And so there's this healthy kind of Christian anxiety that he's commending to the saints. And that really just recast

Speaker 1the entire way that we are engaging with the world, because our first and foremost, our struggle is not against the external world, whatever that may look like, whatever enemies or struggles we may have in this world, that first and foremost, our struggle is with ourself as we keep ourselves from achieving that which we most desire. And so that internal struggle really takes priority between what he calls the first self and the deeper self. The first self is being that part of us that lives on the surface, that lives for popular acclaim, that lives for financial gain, whatever.

Speaker 1It's part of this moving world. But this world does what moving things do.

Speaker 3It moves.

Speaker 1And so that's not a place where you can ever anchor yourself. It's not a place where we can ever find true contentment. So we always have this deeper self that's sort of calling us, that's pulling us back, that's reminding us, this too shall pass. You know, there's a story about, and I have no idea if this is true, but I've heard it repeated in countless sermons about how when the Roman emperor was going on their victory parade that they'd have somebody in the chariot saying, this too shall pass. And whether that's historically accurate or not, I

Speaker 1don't know. But I think it is a good bit of wisdom that part of us knows that, right? Part of us knows this world is fleeting. And part of us is always reminding ourselves of that if only we would listen.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 2It's something like you're, you're only a man or something, something like that as well. Yeah.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 2I was reading that in the sun eater today, so I was just smiling. To your, to your point, I underlined on the middle of 306, if he believes that he lacks only the means, then he still believes in himself. So it's just another aspect of, you know, what you were describing with changing fortune, you know, whether it's access to means or different circumstances or, whatever, it's not a path to true contentment.

Speaker 3Right.

Speaker 1When we are doing our study on those two books, when we get to the sickness unto death, he identifies that as a form of despair where we're basing our entire life on possibility, what could be. We're not recognizing what is, we're just casting our entire identity on the moving wheel of fortune and where that might bring us. This is exactly why I think in many ways is better to cast Kierkegaard as a kind of Christian stoic

Speaker 1than an existentialist in the way that word has come to be known through the likes of John Paul Sartre and whatnot. That, you know, when I was doing my dissertation on Kierkegaard and I was reading countless scholars that have written on him, almost everyone, probably at least three quarters of the contemporary scholars I've read on Kierkegaard tried to cast him as essentially a secular existentialist who just happened to use some of the Christian language of his time. But I think it's actually far more fitting to link him with Boethius or something, with how much he's trying

Speaker 1to disassociate our core identity from the moving wheel of fortune, trying to ground us in this eternal reality that we necessarily know as humans. This is that deeper self that gives us that discontentment with the moving wheel of fortune, even when things seem to be going well. And I mean, of course, the more that we push that down, perhaps the more temporary happiness we can feel. But eventually the reality of the human soul is going to reassert itself. This is why you have people who are at the top of their field and then commit suicide or throw it all away to drugs and whatever, you know, whatever

Speaker 1bad choices they want to make. That part of us is calling us back from identifying ourselves with the moving world, even in the good times. And it's very dangerous to quiet that.

Speaker 2Yeah, I have not ever been able to get as consistently into Kierkegaard as I would like, because sometimes I've dabbled in different summaries or articles about him, or I've listened to part of a biography. And it often has, it just hasn't rung true a lot of times where the little that I have read, it doesn't feel like we're talking about the same guy. Could some of that have to do, or some of, I mean, I'm sure most of you write on him at a scholarly level have taken in a lot of his corpus, but could

Speaker 2it be that they focused more on his esoteric writings and maybe aren't reading enough of almost his more sermonic type of writings? Could that be part of why they think he just sort of has a Christian veneer or.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 1I mean, even it's more, I think, I think a lot of it just comes down to not reading him in his context because he is somebody who engages in excesses of rhetoric sometimes and, But he's doing that for a purpose that he's not writing within the context of 21st century postmodernism. He's writing many times against the rationalism of the Danish Lutheran Christendom. And so sometimes he does push heavily into the subjective kind of language that you

Speaker 1would get from the likes of a John Paul Sartre. But I think that when you understand him in context of what he's actually doing and you weigh his more extreme rhetoric against what you tend to get more consistently in Kierkegaard, such as in this discourse we're looking at. I think this is pretty consistently Kierkegaard, that the more extreme parts of his rhetoric can easily get pulled back into an Orthodox Christian position. But I think that, honestly, a lot of scholars just want to claim him as a postmodern of sorts, because he is the father of existentialism.

Speaker 1And so there's a certain... call or a certain pull for them to claim him for their side and basically just cast him as a secular existentialist. But even if you read Jean-Paul Sartre, like in his Existentialism is a Humanism, which is one of his more well-known writings, he says very clearly that I am not writing in line with Christian existentialism. He distances himself intentionally from Kierkegaard, but nonetheless, a lot of contemporary scholars try to bring them back together nonetheless. And I think it just comes down to

Speaker 1bad scholarship, honestly. Like, if you just read Kierkegaard with any real length, it's pretty obvious that he's a Christian, like a real Christian. That's kind of his whole thing. And so I just have to cast most of contemporary scholarship on Kierkegaard as bad faith, as inauthenticity. It just doesn't ring true, which is part of what made my dissertation so worthwhile. easy to write because it's a minority position that seems so obvious. Yeah, it's a good question

Speaker 1that I continue to struggle with.

Speaker 4Yeah, I mean, even the whole premise of this whole essay, it's to need God. It's like, I don't know how you would come about it like that. But yeah, in philosophy classes I took, everyone in the class was projecting their own beliefs onto whatever philosopher we were studying and not really looking at the environment that they were in, because I didn't know any of that about Lutheranism or the tendencies of Lutheranism that he was coming up against. So that's interesting to me.

Speaker 3Yeah. Yeah.

Speaker 1It's very easy to project your own philosophy onto whatever you're reading. I'm just like, whenever I teach the death of Ivan Ilyich in my class, my philosophy class at the state university, almost every time, like, the majority of the class thinks that the message initially is you need to go.

Speaker 3Live your truth. That's not at all what it is.

Speaker 1It's that you need to deal with your guilt. But we just naturally just project ourselves looking for that affirmation. And I think that applies to PhDs, at least as much as it does to the lay or the freshman philosophy student, that we're constantly looking for that sort of affirmation. And also, I think another problem with Kierkegaard is just A lot of people, I just don't think, read Kierkegaard, but they read what people have said about Kierkegaard. And so then we just get this repeat or this echoing, even in scholarship. I mean, I've heard countless Christian scholars

Speaker 1try to cast Kierkegaard as just this radical subjectivist. And I think it's because they're all just reading each other and adopting this tradition of scholarship versus actually reading and engaging with Kierkegaard. which I can't entirely blame them because Kierkegaard, he's hard to read, right? It's easier to read what people have said about him. But if you get rid of the isms and you deal with the person himself, I think it's pretty clear where he lands.

Speaker 2I had a question on page 307, and I don't want to get us too much into the other readings that are coming up in your class, but maybe just see how much you might be willing to address this. So I'm wrestling a little bit with this contrast between being self-enclosed. So I'm sort of associating that with how he describes kind of a, almost like a demon oppressed or possessed type of state in other places, like in

Speaker 2the anxiety one, a kind of, you know, a rejection of the good perhaps, or just sort of an anxiety toward the good, perhaps like a retreat. You mentioned despair earlier, which I think is correlated with self-enclosure, but then I'm appreciating more and more that true inwardness is huge for him. I don't remember, I don't think he uses inwardness a ton, although a couple pages later I maybe noticed him sort

Speaker 2of alluding to it. Are you able to just tackle a little bit of a shorthand on being self-enclosed versus true inwardness, what that looks like for us kind of getting into Kierkegaard?

Speaker 3Yeah, so... That's a good question.

Speaker 1So elsewhere in concept of anxiety and in sickness unto death, he talks about this enclosing reserve, which he identifies as the demonic. It's where you get shut up within yourself as a way of trying to isolate yourself. I mean, ultimately from God, but I mean, from the world, you're trying to be a kind of an atomic reality. And he also identifies this with the kind of forms of self-creation because you're separating yourself from the reality itself. Whereas inwardness is kind of like the Lewis idea, further up

Speaker 1and further in, or further in and further up, that with real inwardness, you are kind of appropriating the truth of Christian faith. You're appropriating your dependency on God. You're embracing the reality that is fundamentally there, whether you recognize it or not. But in embracing that reality and embracing your dependency on God, to use the language of the discourse, you actually become more expansive. and you become better able to relate to the moving world around you. And so you inwardly embrace that dependency you have on God, and

Speaker 1in so doing, now you're better situated to engage with the world around you, to actually engage in loving relationships with other people, to engage in real community, not as a masked man, which is the language he uses elsewhere, but as someone who is engaged as an individual before God with other people. And that then gives you a framework to actually engage care about and enact justice and the various virtues in the world. And I appreciate that in this discourse, as much as he is focused on this inward embrace of our dependency on God, that's not

Speaker 1where he leaves it, right? He doesn't say that the first self that exists in the temporal world of the senses, he didn't say that first self is bad.

Speaker 3It just needs to.

Speaker 1Be anchored with a proper relationship to the deeper self. And so once you inwardly have this a foundation of who you are as a human before God, well, now you're equipped to engage with the moving wheel of fortune, whatever that looks like around you.

Speaker 3So does that answer your question?

Speaker 2Yeah, that's really helpful. It may relate a little bit to what you were talking about in scholarship, maybe on a more lay level. I have a dear friend who, when I was talking about getting into reading more Kierkegaard, one of his first responses was, if I remember correctly, I think I'm being fair. It was the idea that Kierkegaard is kind of the inventor of the individual. And it was probably said more in the sense of maybe there are some people out there who picture him, like

Speaker 2you were saying, as like all about subjectivity, but it's almost like they picture his emphasis on individuality all around like an idea of almost what he calls self-enclosure. You know, like that they're thinking of that as his concept of what individuality is but it it seems like what you're describing is important that he doesn't land there and that his emphasis on the individual doesn't at all leave us kind of all inwardly isolated just having sort of a

Speaker 2i don't know some kind of hermetically sealed relationship with god that has nothing to do with with the other creatures you know.

Speaker 1Yeah i mean A good companion to his idea of inwardness is his book, Works of Love, which I've started reading. It's a very long text, but if you just read it almost devotionally, you know, it's pretty short sections. He really gets into the communal aspects of human life that as I was just saying, that when you are properly anchored in your inward self, well, now you're actually equipped to engage with community as an individual before others, because you are first and foremost an individual before God. In

Speaker 1so many ways, even though he tends to talk in a more psychological kind of way, a lot of his metaphysics, I think, is actually very much in line with Augustine as this kind of exit-return idea that there's this back and forth kind of movement to reality, that all things proceed from God. And as we kind of move back in that direction, embracing that dependency that we have on God on a metaphysical level, well, now we actually encounter other people in the way that we're supposed to encounter them.

Speaker 3Because we have the proper locus of unity.

Speaker 1And so, yeah, on surface level, he can definitely come across as promoting some kind of like absolute atomism, but that's not actually where he's going at all. that it's a path that we have to take, leaves us to recognize ourselves as an individual before God. But once we do that, now we're equipped for real community. And that's ultimately where he's trying to take us, to a proper engagement with the world around us. Now, I won't get into right now how that tracks onto his own love life, but that's another conversation.

Speaker 4Well, I really like to quote, you were talking about, Zach, earlier, the juxtaposition of almost like a paradoxical kind of thing. I liked where he says, what is offered as comfort in life starts out by making life more difficult in order, yes, in order to make it truly easier. And then he compares it to the miracle at the wedding in Cana, that truth serves the poor wine first and keeps the best until last, whereas the deceitful world serves the best wine first.

Speaker 1Yes, that is a fantastic line. That's so obviously true that if you look at all the influential movements of our age and the influencers and the ideas that seem really attractive, they get the clicks, they get the easy follows that appeal to the first self first and foremost, right? It sounds really good. You know, take this solution and it's going to fix your problems. But reality, if you want to fix your problems, if you want to fix your most basic human problems, Well, you got to do

Speaker 1some hard work because ultimately you're looking in the mirror. You are the biggest problem in your life. You are the one that's ultimately holding you back from fulfilling your destiny as a human being. And that's going to involve some hard work. You have to get through the poor wine before you discover what's actually worth imbibing. And it's not going to be popular, but that shouldn't be surprising for a Christian message. I'm seeing as the symbol of our faith is the cross for a reason.

Speaker 4That's good. Well, he spends a lot of time talking about how the highest goal is to be fully convinced that you are capable of nothing at all. And he talks a lot about that. I mean, that is so unlike anything that you hear. I even see it theologically. You know, when people are horribly offended by Calvinism, I think largely because it removes the what they perceive as

Speaker 4their freedom to choose. But when you really think about your freedoms, like I didn't choose when I was born, who I was born to, where I was born. I mean, all of these things are the grace of God. Every little aspect of my life that allowed me to even know who he is, is grace. And I think about that when I think about that I'm capable of nothing. And I think of Ephesians where he says, you know, he has put good works in our path that we would walk in them So I'm not doing God a

Speaker 4favor even when I do a good thing. He has given me the opportunity to participate in his plan. And I think a lot of that is an important thing that even a lot of Christians could really grasp a lot better.

Speaker 3Yeah, absolutely.

Speaker 1We need that continual reminder of what real grace is, that even the faith that we have is not our own, but is a gift of God. And that's something that Kierkegaard talks about in, you know, I thought about working this into the course, but it's gonna be too much to do fear and trembling as well. But that's a good follow-up to what we're doing in the course, which is where he's focusing on the idea of faith, drawing from the scenario of Abraham and Isaac, about the apparent absurdity of faith that sacrifices that which it most loved

Speaker 1with the confidence that in the end, you'll get it back more your own, precisely because you've given it.

Speaker 3Up in faith.

Speaker 1And even in that context of you have to take a leap into the not.

Speaker 3Actual absurd, but the apparently absurd.

Speaker 1He also looks at that from the other side and says that even when you take that leap, ultimately, you're taking the leap by the grace of God. And so he simultaneously has this strong existential focus on the decision that you have to make. But at the same time, sometimes in the same breath, he emphasizes the fact that if you take the proper leap, It's still the grace of God working in you. Both of those are true at the exact same time. You know, God is working in us, but also we're working out our faith with fear and trembling. And both of those are true at

Speaker 1the exact same time. And so, you know, when we're talking about these conversations, you know, who moves first, God or man, I mean, ultimately what we need to be concerned about is what is the choice in front of you? Make the choice in its ado and make your calling and election sure.

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 1Both things are true at the same time, but fundamentally, we need to be concerned about the choice in front of us rather than the eternal perspective that we don't necessarily have access to. But kind of along what you were just bringing up, there's this great line toward the end. At this point, we can just jump around, but he says that there are many who otherwise remain unconcerned about God, but still do not fail to enter the house of the Lord, that many people are going through the motions.

Speaker 3There's this great line from.

Speaker 1A Johnny Cash song, where he says, I sat outside the church house where the citizens like to sit. They say they want the kingdom, but they don't want God in it. I think that's, it's a very easy temptation to, especially in our age of indulgence and radical subjectivity, this, you know, there's no king and everyone's doing it right in their own eyes. It's easy to pine for the days of Christendom But what's much healthier is to pine

Speaker 1for the reality of Christ. Those aren't necessarily the same thing.

Speaker 4Right. I wonder that, you know, church attendance falling and things like that. I feel like the true church is always a remnant. And we live in a society where in earlier decades in my childhood, going to church was just something that more people felt that they should do. whether they really believed it or it was any importance to them or not. It's just the same way that people used to dress up to go to the grocery store, you know, and now they go in their pajamas. It's, it was a changing times and I'm not, I don't know,

Speaker 4God saves and the visible size of the church to us, I'm not convinced represents a loss of the actual Christianity in the world, but. I don't have the stats or anything, of course, how could you? But that's just a suspicion I have.

Speaker 1Yeah, I think that the core cultural and theological issues aren't, I mean, there's surely some overlap, but they aren't the same circle. And so we can at one side say that, yes, in many ways, things are worse than they were under American Christendom. But as far as the core matter of the reality of faith, I mean, I don't know that we can necessarily say that. I mean, as you said, we can't say one way or the other. But the point is that no matter what culture does, God is going to preserve his church, that he is going to

Speaker 1extend grace to those who he extends grace to, and that he's going to offer salvation to anyone who would have it. And so ultimately, God is going to preserve his people. And on our side, recognizing where real faith lives is often easier in the absence of institutional Christendom. That was certainly Kierkegaard's position, which is why He very often went hard against Christendom for the sake of Christianity. I assume he wouldn't have such rhetorical excesses now versus his own age, but I think that the principled point

Speaker 1that he's making definitely still stands.

Speaker 2I was going to ask that question. Could you go just a little further into that, Andrew? It does seem like he would still be teaching us about true inwardness, but what might he do differently in our circumstance today? Since currently, even though we're not completely bereft of a great influence of Christianity on so much of our self-understanding, but when I read a little bit of the Claire Carlyle biography, I was struck by how many Christian structures were still front and center in his life. The connection

Speaker 2that he had to a few clergy, the churches that he attended, and just kind of recognizing that Denmark then versus us now you know, there's, there's much, much less public institutional strength to Christianity. How can we still get his message? Is it just kind of like turning down some of the rhetorical excess or, because I do think that sometimes there's this almost convincing ourselves that it's actually good to try to destroy all the duplicitous cultural Christianity that,

Speaker 2that we can, so that we can prove that we're like really committed and, So maybe I'm starting to answer my own question. I think that maybe he would question our vanity in doing that a little bit. It seems like he would point out the dangers of just resting and never becoming, did you say contemporaneous with Christ? Is that how he puts it? But maybe he would say, well, but don't go crazy like trying to tear down every bit of support you have from your Christian inheritance, because that's probably just you being vain.

Speaker 4Is that fair?

Speaker 3Yeah. I mean, yes.

Speaker 1I mean, Kierkegaard, he appreciated beautiful things. And in the, especially the context of the European tradition, that means Christian things, right? Like Christendom isn't necessarily in itself a bad thing. It's the tendency to conflate Christian faith with Christendom.

Speaker 3That's the bad thing.

Speaker 1And so, no, I mean, he never says go burn down the churches or like go deface Christian art or anything like that. And I think, I mean, I don't necessarily like that. speaking for him. But from my understanding of Kierkegaard, I think looking at the world today, I don't think he would at all have a problem critiquing our decadent postmodern culture, even as he was very critical of the romantics of his own day with their romantic excesses into subjectivity. But I think that he would maintain

Speaker 1the same position of our principal concern should be the inward appropriation of the Christian faith whether we are in a context of institutional Christendom or not. I think that right there, it really is the main crux of the issue, that he was never against Christendom for Christendom. He was against the conflation of Christian faith with Christendom. And I think that reality stands. And so perhaps today, I mean, his principal warning to Christians might be, you know, don't stake your Christian witness on the reinstitution of Christendom. that

Speaker 1we're going to take over the institutions and re-Christianize things. I think that he would very much be opposed to that sort of idea. Not that Christians shouldn't be involved in the culture in some sense, but in our involvement with the culture, in the movements of the first self, make sure that that is first and foremost grounded in the eternal realities that your deeper self is in touch with, the more central part of what it means to be human. And so I think that really doesn't change based off what the culture looks like around us.

Speaker 2Is it fair to say, in a good way, he's a broken record, just saying, know thyself, know thyself, know thyself, in the true sense, like I'm kind of wrestling with that. I don't remember if it was in this essay or if it was in Anxiety, but he said something like, Socrates has been badly misunderstood or misinterpreted. Because I'm looking at, for instance, page 313, it contrasts knowing oneself in relation to something else versus knowing oneself in relation to himself.

Speaker 2It seems like his concept of inwardness is really meant to unpack the true.

Speaker 4Aim of knowing oneself.

Speaker 2And it just seems like maybe whatever context he's speaking to, that's pretty core. He feels like that's a way we have to go through that, like you were saying, right? To really come out the other side to something stable and rightly ordered.

Speaker 4Is that fair?

Speaker 2And I guess I would just ask you, like, what is that sort of what you're talking about with your students? You know, they read something and they kind of think know yourself is essentially shorthand for like, go find yourself, go live out your own truth or something like that. But that's just not it's not what he's that's not what he's talking about. Like he's talking about reorientating ourselves. Yeah, I'll let you I'll let you tackle it.

Speaker 4Sorry.

Speaker 1Yeah, I mean, he definitely has great appreciation for Socrates at the beginning of the concept of anxiety. And he says that Socrates was great because he knew what he didn't know. And that brings us to that know thyself. Don't define yourself according to external realities, how you're viewed, what you're viewed as knowing.

Speaker 3I mean, what Socrates, his whole mission that ultimately got him killed.

Speaker 1Was that he went around to the supposed experts who claimed to know things, and to claim to be experts on things, and he would ask them clarifying questions until it became obvious they had no idea what they're talking about. And he did this enough times and irritated enough people that they sentenced him to death instead of actually dealing with what he's exposing, which is their ignorance. But where he distanced himself from this sort of Socratic wisdom, and I should say that his dissertation was on Socrates. He's very interested in Socrates. But where he distances himself from

Speaker 1that Socratic enterprise is that ultimately Socrates only knows himself as a negative relation to truth. He knows that he doesn't know, and that's more or less as deep as he can get, which is why in the Greek tradition that they tend to identify evil with ignorance. Whereas Kierkegaard says in the Christian understanding, we identify evil with sin. It's that we know fundamentally who we are as an individual before God in a way that Socrates doesn't. But

Speaker 1that differential between kind of our understanding of ourself and the reality of who we are before God is not mere ignorance.

Speaker 3It's transgression. It's sin.

Speaker 1We have guilt that needs to be overcome principally through atonement, which he talks about in the concept of anxiety. And so he takes the Socratic wisdom, but he grounds it in a very Christian reality. And so it's deeper, I would say, than Greek wisdom. We're going deeper than the foxes can dig.

Speaker 4It all comes back to Lewis.

Speaker 3All the time. All the time.

Speaker 1It really is a shame that Lewis didn't read more Kierkegaard. There's one passing line in one of his letters, I believe, where Lewis says that basically he could never get into Kierkegaard, so he didn't. But there's so much commonality between them, if you really look at what they're saying.

Speaker 3That's how I feel, too.

Speaker 2This same friend is very into Lewis. and he kind of mentioned that. And I think he's just sort of adopted that view where it's like, I just can't get into him. And I was like, yeah, but like the more you read of Kierkegaard, it seems like if you would have spent some time unpacking him, it would have been like a really nice marriage.

Speaker 3They have a lot of overlap. I know. It was, oh, who was it?

Speaker 1Man, I just drawn a blank, but it's actually one of the, the inklings who first had Kierkegaard translated into English, which is interesting. I can't remember who it is, but it was one of them.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 4Well, He starts this long metaphor of the self grappling with the self on like page 308. But I really loved this whole section where he's saying, if he himself, even before the eye aims at something to make a conquest, wants to capture the eye so that may belong to him and not he to the eye. If he grasps the hand before it grasps for the external so that it may belong to him and not he to the hand.

Speaker 4I just thought all that was so wonderful. And then in the end, everything's changed. The power is taken away from him and the glory, and he's struggling not with the world, but with himself. And that's kind of where this can begin.

Speaker 3Right.

Speaker 1And in that struggle with himself, he can finally master himself. He can become himself. And, you know, otherwise, when we don't have that internal struggle, when our struggle is principally seen as external, we aren't ultimately directing where we're going. We're just going where our eyes lead us. We're going where our passions lead us, where our desires lead us, where things seem shiny and interesting. But ultimately, we aren't controlling what our direction looks like. I think of in, go back to the Stoics or even Augustine, where in

Speaker 1a quotation from City of God that I reference pretty regularly, when he says that, Basically, the more vices you have, the more enslaved to yourself.

Speaker 3It's more eloquent than that, but that's the basic idea.

Speaker 1That the king, though given over to vice, he ultimately is a slave to himself, whereas the slave, if he is given over to virtue, well, now he is able to direct where he is headed and he's able to control something of his relationship to the world around him. And so that internal struggle, if it is successful, If you are ultimately relying on the dependency of God, if you are putting to death those parts of you that want to take the lead in the wrong direction, well, you actually become more fundamentally yourself. You become more free. You become stronger, as Boethius would say. This is where

Speaker 1real strength is, as opposed to how we might define it in an external struggle. Also, Charles Williams was who I was looking for before, who was responsible for getting Kierkegaard translated.

Speaker 2Okay, I'll have to revisit that. That's really cool. I had a question for you. I heard you earlier talking on the first self, and I probably need to reread this essay because I was trying to listen for some Lutheran tics or giveaways on terms. And just maybe myself, when I see first self, I'm sort of thinking of atom or maybe the old atom or the flesh uh sometimes and when you were contrasting the first self to

Speaker 2the deeper self it sounds like first self is supposed to serve a larger purpose than just to be a stand-in for the flesh or the old atom and the question i had was does first self include that? Or is there sort of another term that he uses that maybe I wasn't paying attention to like desire or something like that? And the first self is a little bit more neutral in itself or just in need of redemption. It's not really the part that has to be crucified per se. Can you say anything about that?

Speaker 3Yes. Yes. Okay.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1So in this essay, in this discourse, the first self isn't necessarily the wicked part of you. It's It's simply that part of you that is engaged with the moving world, that's engaged in temporality. And remember, even though he doesn't use the language, he very much is embedded in Greek patterns of thought. He's dealing with being and becoming here. That the first self is that part of you that's in the world of becoming. That second, that deeper self is the part of you that's embedded in the world of being that's connected to the eternal. And so the

Speaker 1first self isn't necessarily bad. It's bad when it takes the lead, right? Because now you're trying to base yourself in moving things that can never anchor identity. This is when you're in the futility of the Ecclesiastes circle, but you.

Speaker 3Haven't found your way out yet.

Speaker 1You know, I often like to actually cast Kierkegaard onto Ecclesiastes, especially in a discourse like this. where in Ecclesiastes, we're told again and again, there's nothing new under the sun and everything seems to be futile no matter where we move our direction. But that's because in that kind of cyclical life embedded in the world of becoming, well, you're living, well, you're under the sun. The solution is to get above the sun, so to speak, that is above the point of time. And so when you anchor yourself in the eternal,

Speaker 1you don't actually lose the temporal. You actually gain it in a way that you never had it before. that now what you do in this moving world from moment to moment actually matters because everything that you do is anchored in the eternal reality that faith knows. And so what you do actually matters. And so Kierkegaard is not proposing that we discount the world around us, but that we don't base our identity in it. And because we're basing our identity in the eternal reality of who we are before God, now the first self actually has a

Speaker 1context to engage with meaning in the world around us. precisely because we're not getting meaning from the world around us. And so, yeah, sin can lead the first self to silence the deeper self, but the first self isn't necessarily in sin. It just needs proper grounding.

Speaker 4Yeah, that's really helpful.

Speaker 2It helps me better understand. I underlined in the middle of 314 this sentence, and it sounds like what you are saying is that, you know, the deeper self, God works to reorient the first self so that like you said, we're able to engage with the temporal world rather than be enslaved by its enticement. So it says the deeper self now shapes the deceitful flexibility of the surrounding world in such a way that it is no longer attractive

Speaker 2to that first self. So I think attractive in kind of that enslaving, seductive sense, I guess you could say. Not to where we're just living on a higher plane purely and completely disengaged from life under the sun.

Speaker 4But I guess, you know, properly in.

Speaker 2That kind of, that relegated way, living properly, I guess, in the temporal world. Okay.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 1In Fear and Trembling, he talks about how the real authentic Christian who has given up everything and gained it back, sometimes you're not going to even be able to tell them apart from anybody else acting in the world because they're still engaged in the world, but they're engaged in a different kind of way that, you know, maybe they only know on an inward level, but you know, they're not just secluded in some kind of monastic settlement, but they're very much engaged in the world, but they have proper grounding.

Speaker 3So yeah, yeah, definitely.

Speaker 2I'm flipping the page to 316. I guess there's also sort of a contrast where we have to go from suckling at temporality to kind of getting to that the weaned stage if that makes sense is that another fair analogy where we're no longer you know he says so one snuggles at the breast of temporality and the cradle of finitude and probability sits by the cradle and sings to the child it just seems like you know he wants to get us to this place where we're not we're we're not drawing our very strength you know from

Speaker 2from these sort of shifting you know the shifting sands or whatever.

Speaker 1Yeah, I think this is where the concept of anxiety becomes helpful as he builds out this idea some more that we're born like children, pretty much just know finitude. They know it's right in front of them. They know what they sense. It's I mean, you can start to introduce some more lasting, eternal, deeper things as they get a little bit older, but they're not really operating on that level. But it takes a certain kind of awakening to recognize that. your potential as a spirited being that

Speaker 1chooses how they orient themselves and how they're related to the world and to God and all these sorts of things. But that's not how babies operate. And so just looking at human life on a basic temporal scale, yeah, we're born into finitude. And that awakening to possibility, that awakening to infinitude is something that develops as we become aware of ourselves. I'm going to try not to spoiled too much of the concept of anxiety here, but he talks about how Adam was created in this sort of childlike

Speaker 1innocence and didn't really become aware of his potential until he recognized that he had a choice in front of him. And this is where we start to get into some Lutheran territory about the law inciting sin or because of our recognition that, oh, I have the potential to sin. But that awakening out of that sort of innocence, just being in the finite world.

Speaker 3And I think that's some part of what he's getting at here.

Speaker 2Just to put a cap on this thought for me, probably saying weaning might not be the greatest because like you said, you're sort of getting into this idea that you can kind of like address a baby or a child, you know, directly and start introducing the higher things. But he says later in this paragraph on 316, he said it was the deeper self that had sat beside him at the deathbed in self-denial's hour of death. So maybe contrasting kind of the cradle with the way that the

Speaker 2deeper self can actually take you through that final trial, that transformative trial, prepare you for it. That just puts a little more distance where it's birth and then looking at death. I think that's probably a good one for me to take away.

Speaker 1Yeah, and that's good that the more that we approach death, the more that we at least should recognize the realities of the deeper self attest to that we are passing things that the temporal world, especially our life in the temporal world, it is fading. Like it's not where we can ultimately find identity in any kind of lasting, meaningful sense. And so if there is meaning to be found, it's going to be in the reality of the deeper self knows.

Speaker 1But at the same time, that doesn't lead us to despair of the external world. And I want to keep emphasizing that. He says that in Fear and Trembling, he makes the point that the person of faith is eternally young in that we never despair of our temporal existence. But when it is based in faith, well, we don't depend on it either. It's just we forever recognize the reality of the moment that we are given. Well, is there anything else from this essay that, I mean, I

Speaker 1know we hit the main point, but is there anything else that you want to mention?

Speaker 4I mean, there are some other great quotes that I underlined. One of the things I loved was near the end where it says, until he stands face to face with the judge who passes judgment on him, but not on the one who truly has God as witness, because where God is the judge, there is indeed no judge if God is the witness. I really like that. That was awesome.

Speaker 3Thank you. Thank you, Chris Farley. Yeah, that is a great line.

Speaker 1And I think it's a great place to wrap things up that in the end, our only hope is in our dependency on God. Like that's all we have in life and in death. I think of that great opening to the Heidelberg Catechism. This is something along those lines.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1And so I think that this is a great opening in introducing some of these main ideas that are going to get tease out in more detail, as well as some more obscurity in the concept of anxiety and the sickness unto death. But when people ask me where to start with Kierkegaard, I often recommend this essay precisely because he's laying out about as directly as Kierkegaard does some of his main ideas that are going to get teased out in those more difficult texts written under pseudonyms and whatnot.

Speaker 1But also, I mean, the larger... 18 upbuilding discourses that this is based in. It is also a good way to start with Kierkegaard. But I definitely look forward to getting into the main Kierkegaard study on the concept of anxiety and the sickness and the death. I will be starting that the week of October 4th. And so anyone who's listening to this who isn't currently eligible, there's still time to become a fellow or companion of Mythic Mind and enjoy us on this study, as well as the various.

Speaker 3Other courses that are already available. So thank you, Zach. Thank you, David. And I will talk to

Speaker 4You next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 199 - The Conflict in The Lord of the Rings Is About God, According to Tolkien

    Nov 16, 202656 minAudio

    Watch the video: https://mythicmindfellowship.com/the-conflict-in-the-lord-of-the-rings-is-about-god-according-to-tolkien-mythic-mind-ep-199/ When Tolkien was pressed to say what the conflict at the heart of The Lord of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 198 - You Have Forgotten Who You Are: Boethius' Consolation, Book I

    Nov 9, 202620 minAudio

    Watch the video: https://mythicmindfellowship.com/you-have-forgotten-who-you-are-mythic-mind-ep-198/ Boethius has lost his place in the world, and Lady Philosophy tells him that he has forgotten who he is. Fortune had...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 197 - Who Failed Anakin Skywalker?

    Nov 2, 202630 minAudio

    Watch the video: https://mythicmindfellowship.com/who-failed-anakin-skywalker-mythic-mind-ep-197/ Right-wing X has been full of pro-Anakin posts, including one Elon Musk shared of an AI image of Emperor Anakin with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 196 - Kierkegaard's Concept of Anxiety: Anxiety Is Not an Ailment to Be Removed

    Oct 26, 202634 minAudio

    Watch the video: https://mythicmindfellowship.com/kierkegaards-concept-of-anxiety-anxiety-is-not-an-ailment-to-be-removed-mythic-mind-ep-196/ Today I'm giving you a free look into my Mythic Mind Fellowship course, The...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 195 - Eschatology in Arda: Did Middle-earth Know Its Ending?

    Oct 19, 202645 minAudio

    Did the people of Middle-earth know how their story ends? Rev. Jeffrey Wade joins Andrew Snyder and Josh to discuss his master's thesis on eschatology in Arda. His question is not only what Tolkien believed, but whether...

    Credit the people on this episode