Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Impact Quantum: A Podcast for the Quantum Curious

Why Quantum Computing Is Closer Than You Think

Apr 30, 202650 minVideo
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In today's episode, we dive deep into the rapidly evolving world of quantum computing with Tal David, co-founder and CEO of Quantum Art. From the earliest days of quantum theory to the edge of commercialization, Tal David shares insights on technological breakthroughs, scaling challenges, and the journey from academia and government policy to startup innovation. We explore what it takes to build the world's best quantum computers, the shrinking resource requirements for breaking cryptography, and why now is such an exciting - and pivotal - moment in the quantum industry. Whether you’re a quantum curious newcomer or a seasoned expert, today’s conversation unpacks the real-world impact, technical nuances, and bold ambitions shaping the future of computation. Links Tal's LinkedIn Profile - https://www.linkedin.com/in/tal-david-5340b423a/ The 50 most promising Israeli startups for 2026 https://www.calcalistech.com/ctechnews/article/p9n9w144o Watch on YouTube - https://youtu.be/oOyhUIYKaeI Time Stamps 00:00 Career journey and startup motivation 06:32 Origins and development of quantum computing 08:14 Quantum computing advancements 13:18 Scaling challenges in quantum computing 15:41 Hybrid quantum-classical computing systems 19:08 Challenges in developing novel tech 24:48 Stabilizing qubits in a vacuum 27:23 Connecting ions with laser plucking 31:33 Transition from vinyl to digital technology 35:51 Military experience fosters responsibility 38:18 Israel's emphasis on academia and industry 41:21 Future of the quantum industry 44:07 Launching new cloud service 48:56 Candace and Frank's Quantum Podcast

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show.

0:00Went from, is this really possible? To now we're at the point of not only is it possible, but it's going to need less resources and qubits than we thought. And I mean, what a time to be in this industry. Yeah, I'm not sure it's that surprising. You know, my partner, co founder and chief science officer Professor Roya from the Weizmann Institute of Science, always says now he, when he was young, he had a Commodore 64.

0:31Welcome to Impact Quantum. Hello, and welcome back to Impact Quantum, the podcast. We explore the emerging industry and field that is quantum computing. We don't need to have a PhD, even if it helps. You just need to be curious. And with me is the most quantum curious person I know, Candace Gooley. How's it going, Candace? It's great. Today is like the first

1:05truly warm day we have had in April. And it makes me believe that this is not going to be a fall spring in Montreal. We're going to actually finally get some warm weather. So I'm very excited today. That's cool. I had to drag my tomato plants inside because we had a frost warning here. So there you go. And they're, they're so delicate. In the very beginning, everyone's, everyone's doing their, their early planting inside the house right now, getting all the little, all the little buds ready. So I'm very excited about today.

1:35We're going to be speaking with Tal David. He is the, he is the co founder and CEO at Quantum Art. Oh, very cool. Hi, Tal, how are you doing today? Hi, guys. I'm good. Thank you for having me. Awesome. So what does Quantum Art do? Quantum Art is a startup company building the world's best quantum computers based on trapped ion qubits and with unique and proprietary engineering. Map

2:05on how to scale up quantum computers. From the small systems that we have today, which are very impressive, but not yet doing commercially interesting stuff, to large enough systems that still retain the base performance, but now would be able to tackle the world's largest compute heavy tasks. Oh, very cool. So it's not, it's not a. It's not an art art company. Sorry, sorry.

2:35Yeah, it's true art and engineering. Fair enough. I'll go with that. So you've moved between academia, government, and now you're involved in startup leadership. So what has changed in how you think about impact across all those worlds? Well, you know, there are different types of impact, different places in your life. When I did my PhD, the thing that interests me most was tuning the knobs and taking graphs and measurements and stuff like that.

3:07And then when I went to the industry, I wanted to do stuff that actually get used by people around the world in products and create value. And then when I moved to government, I wanted to move policies and processes and arrange for large scale programs to be advanced. And then at some point you understand that doing things from within government has its own, own specific dynamics and maybe we could do things even faster and better than that. And then I decided

3:40to go outside of government again and form a startup as a very, very deep technological project, but something that can also go and do impact and create value in the world. And it's like having a baby all over again. Right? It's building it from scratch and trying to understand what it wants from you when it cries. And then getting it all grown up and hopefully going to graduate school someday.

4:12I mean, that's a good way to put it. Right. Because there's certain advantages to, I, you know, I live in the D.C. baltimore area. Right. So there's certain advantages to being part of the government ecosystem and there's certain disadvantages of it. Right. And there's certain advantages of the entrepreneurial world and there's a lot of disadvantages too. Right. So it's, and I think governments around the world are, are because technology is such a foundational aspect of a modern economy. Whether those are gpus, quantum

4:43computers, or you know, pick your, your tech it. I think everybody's trying to figure out how do you get, how do you combine the two? Like how do you get the best of an entrepreneurial with the kind of the, the aspect of government. Yeah. So first of all, I'm not alone, right. I have amazing co founders and I have an outstanding team and I'm just here moving papers around the desk. But I think that taking the experiences from different places along the, along the path

5:16allows you to form a more complete holistic picture and understand what are the rights, what are ways to move or to motivate processes, depending on what kind of processes there are and who you're talking with. Okay. In Quantum, what we're doing is hard, hard tech. There's a lot of work to do in the lab, which is quite deep and, and difficult to understand for a lot of people. But again, when you want to raise money to do, to

5:46enable the company to grow, when you want to get to the relevant funding, which at this point is still very much tied governmental funding and stuff like that, it helps a lot to understand how the language of going in those corridors needs to be what motivates the people there, how the processes behave and what's the dynamics in order to be able to get to your goals and in a focused, meaningful way. But it's not only

6:16about one person. You need to assemble the best team on the planet if you want to win in this game for sure. Was there a moment when quantum stopped feeling like research and started feeling like something that must be built? Well, in general in the industry, I would say that the idea of quantum computing was coined by Professor Richard Feynman in the early 80s when he said, well, if nature is quantum, let's, let's build something that simulates it

6:48quantum mechanically. That makes the most sense, right? And then quantum computer was a nice esoteric idea for a couple of decades until in the mid-90s, Professor David Shore from University at Yale came up with an algorithm that is now known as Shor's algorithm to factorize large numbers into their prime factors, which is at the heart of decrypting most of the public key distribution methods that

7:20we have today. And that was the first time that an actual, practical, meaningful, commercially viable and also scary application came about that said, hey, there's something to do with this crazy science thing that might drive it into applicability. And from there I think that from the mid-90s until let's say the 2000 and tens, there was technological advancements to show whether this thing could be built. Because we're working with

7:50quantum systems, they're difficult to do. A basic building block in a quantum computer is the quantum bit or qubit. And Shor's algorithm envisioned a computer that would need like a billion quantum bits in order to run that kind of algorithm, in order to break RSA 20, 48 or, or equivalent. So we spend a lot of time trying to understand if this thing could be built. In the last decade or so, I think the question moves from can this thing be built at all? To when will be able to see

8:24that computer at scale. And there are two opposing trends going to the same goal in this sense. One trend is that the technology is maturing enough and starting to scale up enough in order to start doing meaningful, interesting demonstrations of applications in 2025. We have a bunch of those. For example, from JP Morgan Chase working with Quantinum's trapped ion system, and from Google Quantum AI with their superconducting qubit system

8:55that shows initial signals of usefulness, not just tailor made demonstrations of the potential of quantum computers. And on the other hand, we have an opposing trend which is really hot. In the last few months of working on the algorithm aspects of quantum computing and trying to narrow down the requirements of what is actually needed from the computer in order to realize these algorithms. And so, for example, in Shor's algorithm, we've gone down in the last couple of years from a billion qubits to a million qubits to 100,000 cubits. And just last week, there was

9:28a paper by a very serious group that showed that in some instances, they could go and solve and break RSA 2048 with only about 10,000 physical cubits, which is amazing, the rate of advancement. And so when you bring all of these two trends together and you pour in a lot of investment, both from governmental programs and from the private and public investors in the market, it, it builds up momentum that shows that we are right, right before a big break of

10:01applicability of this technology in the next two, three, four years. And the forecast is that it will impact huge, huge markets in the trillions of dollars in value. I mean, that's absolutely insane because it went from is this really possible? To now we're at the point of not only is it possible, but it's going to need less resources and qubits than

10:32we thought. What a time to be in this industry. Yeah, I'm not sure it's that surprising. My partner, co founder and chief science officer and Professor Ruiz from the Weizmann Institute of Science, always says that when he was young, he had a Commodore 64. Commodore 64 had 64 kilobits in the computing power. And in a matter of, I know, 10, 20 years, with the invention of the integrated circuits and

11:03transistors and stuff like that, the amount of computational power of classical compute went up by four orders of magnitude. Okay, so humanity knows how to do these big jumps. I think that the difference here is that because we are more advanced in technology and in modern times, the pace of progress is accelerating even faster than what we've had 50 or 70 years ago. And secondly, because of the properties of

11:34quantum physics, the computational power scaling is at some point exponential. So the benefit that you get from each jump in the capabilities of the technology is really, really tremendous. So I'm not, I'm not sure if it's that surprising that we're moving ahead that, that fast. If you talk to people inside the business, they will tell you about the difficulties and how complicated it is to get to, to commercial viable grade scale and so on. And this is what we are here to solve. But I think

12:08that this is truly an exciting time. And if you look at the next until the end of this decade for sure. This will be the ChatGPT moment, so to speak of Quantum or some people call it Q day or all sorts of silly names like that. Y2Q. This is Y. This, this is, this is a truly exciting time to be at. Interesting. So because you mentioned Commodore 64, my focus thing is not working, working. But this is the Commodore 64 reference manual. I, I was looking around for it and I realized I put it

12:40back up on the shelf. But no, it's. And you know that, I know that sounds like a bit of a segue, but you know, when I read this, I got, I read this book, this is a book on registers and things like that. Honestly, when I read this when I was like 11, it made, most of it made no sense to me. But I was curious and that curiosity led me to figure out what was what some of those things meant like words like parameters and you know, all those things didn't really mean anything to me at the time. And I think there's a good parallel there for

13:13this. Right. That curiosity tends will take you through the difficult points. Yeah, definitely. Maybe one more point to make about that. Yeah, that the challenge in quantum computing is how to scale up the, the systems, as I said before. And when you hear that sentence, it tells you or it throws you in the area of hardware, right. How many transistors can I put inside the chip? Or how many qubits can I put in my quantum processing unit? But it's not only there

13:43because it just reminded me when you said that when you brought that book of how to write code lines and logic gates and so on. And now what we're doing in quantum computing is really at that point we're taking logic gates and comprising algorithms from them and so on and so forth. And part of the scale up challenge is also to scale up the quantum software and the compiling capabilities and automate the design but now of quantum algorithms.

14:14And this is another exciting trend. And there are a few companies, including in Israel, that are doing amazing stuff on how to go from back of an envelope kind of things, which is nice to begin with, to actually doing large scale quantum algorithm development that you would not need to understand at the level of the individual gate what happens under way, way under the hood in the quantum computers. And this is something that is also part of the scale up, scale up challenge that we're facing as an industry now. So you describe

14:47quantum art as a full stack. What does that mean in practice? Not just technically, but Phil Philosophically, yeah. So there are full stacks and there are full stacks. And everywhere, everywhere you think that you end and you said, okay, this is the full thing. Then someone comes and says, okay, but you need to look at it from broader, broader space. And I'll explain what I mean when I say full stack. What we mean is that the product is the whole computer, the hardware layers, the software layers, and even the application layers. Although we don't necessarily

15:20need to be an application developer per se in order to develop the whole product, which is the computer. And the computer can act as a standalone device that you deploy to the customer, or it can stand in your lab and provide quantum computing services over the cloud. Both of these models are viable and happening. Why do I say that this is not necessarily a full full stack? Because at least in the near future, in the next 10, 15, 20 years, as quantum computing scales up gradually, it will still be operated and

15:53maybe forever it will still be operated adjacent to a very strong classical computer, let's call it an HPC or something like that. And so you could say that the combined hybrid system of classical plus quantum working together, that is the true full stack. So it depends on where you stop along the way. But there are companies that are doing specific layers of the stack, for example, doing only the quantum error correction protocols, or doing only the electronics that are driving the pulses that operate the quantum bits

16:26inside. But companies like us, and there are a few tens of companies like us, not many in the world in different qubit technologies are doing the whole package, the hardware, the software and applications, all under one roof. And it doesn't mean that we need to do everything and anything by ourselves. If we don't need to reinvent the wheel, we'd rather collaborate and integrate. And we're doing that extensively, both in our home country in Israel, and also abroad in the US and Europe. Interesting.

16:59A lot of companies optimize only one layer. Why take on the complexity of the entire system? Yeah, that's a good question. We started out based on 20 years of research at the Weizmann Institute of Science. And the forte of that research group was in coherent control method for quantum systems, how to extract the most out of the physical system. Okay. And this has aspects in the lowest level of software or compilers that interact

17:32immediately with the quantum bits themselves. You know, in classical compute, you have computer software engineers and you have hardware engineers, and they say hi in the corridor when they meet each other, but they're not intimately connected. In quantum computing, it's all still, maybe it will be different in the future, but it's still now very tightly and intimately connected. And once you have that layer of the qubits and the lowest level of software, building this, the rest of the aspects of the quantum

18:02computer above it is an easier task. And we can do that in collaborations. And having a full computer puts you at the top of the food chain or the value chain, if you would say, because you can provide the full solution and then access the best value or upside to the investor, investment made by our investors, or to the markets that will create revenue in this industry. So we thought that when you have the heart or the core of the quantum computers

18:33in the boundary between quantum hardware and software, this is enough in order to build the rest around it and just go with it. That's interesting. It's a full stack approach, which, you know, Candice is right. Like, you don't typically see that. You typically see people specialized. And I think maybe that's just. Maybe that's just a function of how immature generally the industry is. And I don't mean that as a bad thing of being immature. I mean, immature compared to. It's the most mature it's ever been, but I mean immature in the

19:04sense of. Compared to, you know, conventional computing. Maybe I'll give it a little bit of color onto that. And that is that because this is a very novel technology, it's in an embryonic phase, if you like. You'll get hurdles along the way. Okay? You'll get unexpected stuff and bottlenecks and challenges. And as much as you come to this problem with multiple tools in your toolbox of innovation and creativity,

19:38you have a better chance of going over these hurdles and on the way to the next challenges. And if we have innovation that comes from both the hardware and the software parts, it could serve in order to overcome challenges in a better way and go faster. If you have a particular problem. For example, we are tuning lasers that are interacting with our trapped ion qubits, and you need that particular system to be extremely stable. Any instability translate immediately to lower

20:11fidelity or quality in the logical operations and lower performance because of that. There are some ways to solve this in hardware. You're doing extremely sophisticated and advanced optical design of your laser system. But maybe you could relax the requirement on how stable you need to be from a theoretical algorithmic approach or from their architecture of how you build the QPU and attack it from the algorithmic or software layers. So if you have the capability to do both, you're equipped in a

20:44very good way in order to Tackle the unforeseen challenges in the future. So if someone only understood one thing about your architecture, what would you want that one thing to be? Yeah. So as we said, the challenge is scaling up. Today's quantum systems are tens or maybe 100 qubits. We need to get to thousands, tens of thousands and ultimately millions of qubits. So how do you do that while retaining the best

21:15performance in trapta and qubits? This is the qubit modality or technology that has been around I think the most. And it's leading in performance at base scale in all of the major parameters like the coherence times and the fidelity and the connectivity between qubits and so on. The shortcomings in the approaches taken by trapped on quantum computer companies are that the speed of operation of Trapton qubits even at base scale are slow relative to other qubit technologies. And as you scale up,

21:49this becomes even a more complicated problem. Secondly, there are no good recipes on how to get to very large number of qubits before getting to problems in maintaining the all to all connectivity and so on. What quantum art is doing is, is using coherent control methods of extracting the most out of the qubits in order to reduce the time, reduce the footprint of the qpu. Which means that for a given system size we can go larger

22:19while improving the connectivity between qubits by hundred folds. So we are tailoring an architecture that looks at the best performance qubits and solves the shortcomings on the way to scalability. Now that we are seeing in other approaches, this is what we're doing. So if your architecture is built around scaling, what's the hardest thing about scaling that isn't obvious from the outside? Oh, I think the challenge is obvious. It's stability,

22:52stability, stability. You need to have these things extremely stable to have extreme well controlled optical delivery system. I described before that we have a laser beam interacting with a qubit, right? This is a nice fun story. But when you have 100,000 qubits, will have 100,000 lasers, how do you stabilize them? How do you control them? How do you make them carry out the logical operations that comprise an algorithm at that scale in a very good stable way without

23:24needing to recalibrate like a billion constraints all of the time. So the issue is how to enlarge the number of qubits, but do it in a very, very stable way so that we keep the base performance that we have. So it's like, I imagine interference might be a problem. Interference is interference a Problem? Interference with what? With the outside world, different lasers and things like that. Like do the cubits interfere each other or is that not. I think less so.

23:56The laser beam diameter is about one micrometer. The size of an atom is almost nothing. So we just need to take care that the spacing between qubit and Next qubit about 5 microns. And you're pretty much okay with that. Of course there are nuances around this thing. I think it's in, in the stability of the system, in the overall operation, in crosstalks between different segments in your quantum processor, that

24:27kind of stuff. Interesting, interesting. What about like, I was talking to someone else and they had a very finely tuned, like an earthquake basically meant they had to like reset everything. Is that something you have to worry about or is that not a concern? Well, it depends. It is a concern. We're working very hard to stabilize and to isolate the system from the environment. Our qubits are held in an electromagnetic trap in an ultra high vacuum chamber.

25:00In order not to have, you know, we have, we're arranging in this trap that's an electromagnetic trap that forces the ions in the simplest of configurations to form a line of individual ions, one after the other. An ion 5 micro distance, an ion 5 micro distance, and so on and so forth, hovering in the vacuum. And the reason that we need them to be in the vacuum is that we don't want to have, you know, a stray atom coming from out of nowhere that's not related to our qubits and impinge and collide with our qubits and force us to restart the calculations or something like that. So our vacuum is

25:33about 12 orders of magnitude less than the atmospheric pressure that we know each other from around us in normal environment. So we are investing a lot of effort in stabilizing and isolating this environment and lowering the electrical noise and laser noise and phase noise and stuff like that. But this is part of the job. So you talk about going from tens to thousands and even

26:03eventually millions of qubits. What actually breaks first? When you're trying to scale what breaks in what way? In terms of, you know, I think in terms of, in terms of the hardware. Right. In terms of, I don't know where you're going to say topology. Like what, what is, what's your, I think really another way to rephrase this. What is the number one challenge to scaling? Is that a better way to say an alternative way to say it? Like, what's the number one engine? Is it an engineering problem?

26:33Is it, is it A physics problem, or I guess they're kind of related. But like what starts. It always starts from the scientific problems or risks, and then goes to engineering risks. But let's look at the basic way of how quantum computer based on trapped iron works. Okay? We have this string of individual ions. Each ion is a qubit. We're defining the 0 and 1 logical states in internal energy level pair inside the ion. And with a laser, we can tune the the logic state to be at 0 or

27:07at 1, or in a quantum superposition of 0 at 1 at the same time and so on. That's the basic thing, operations on single qubits in order to do logic, now we need to do logic gates. This is an operation on one cubit that is dependent on the state of another. So we have these two ions and there are two internal energy level pairs and we need to connect them somehow. So we need a mediator or a data bus in order to do that. And our mediator is common motion. Like when I pluck on a guitar string, I excite all these modes of motion in the string,

27:40right? Then I pluck using lasers on this ion string and induce motion. If I've had only two ions and only one dimension, they could either move in phase like that, or out of phase, okay? As much as I add more and more ions, and I also work not in one dimension, but in three dimensions, I add more and more degrees of freedom, okay? And handling a lot of degrees of freedom becomes a serious control problem. Now, for many, many years, all of the quantum industry, not only in

28:11quantum computing based on trapped ions, but in all of the modalities, was looking for what would be the simplest set of logical operation or the simplest gate set that would be universal, meaning that you can comprise any algorithm out of it, and it turns out to be only operations on single qubits or pairs of qubits. And with these two LEGO bricks, you can comprise any algorithm from. So first, what we said is working with the simplest set does not necessarily mean that you're making the most out of this

28:41physical system. And so what we're doing, instead of working on 1 Qubit or 2 Qubit in series at a time, one by one, we're operating large scale multi cubit gates, which means that instead of shining our lasers on two qubits at a time, we're shining our lasers on dozens of qubits at once. With a sophisticated spectral engineering of the laser in all degrees of freedom, of amplitude, time, phase, frequency and so on, to essentially drive all of these Degrees of freedom at once to complete one big fat operation that comprises

29:15all of these possible pairs that we otherwise would have done in series. So when we're doing that, we can cram in one physical operation what we would need. A few tens or a few hundreds or up to a thousand sequential operations. So we save up orders of magnitude. And time is also relax the requirements on error. Because we're doing just one operation instead of hundreds of them. But this is nice only for a time when you want to go to even larger number of qubits. Then the number of degrees of freedom becomes a limiting factor

29:49again. And then what usually people are doing is that they separate the quantum processor into different interaction zones or different traps. And they move the cubits in between them mechanically, physically. They shuttle the cubits around. You can imagine an array like the streets of Manhattan. And you're moving the cubits from one place to another in order to make them connect and, and interact with each other. And this is a nice idea, but it takes a long time because moving things mechanically is a slow process always, certainly when you're moving quantum systems, which are very delicate and prone to heating. What we are doing in

30:21quantum art is replacing the cubit shuttling idea by. By a sophisticated optical segmentation of our quantum processing unit and then reconfiguring how we are connecting the qubits together. So it kind of reminds of how FPGA work in electronics, right? You have a certain configuration of the hardware. Then you give a command and the hardware reconfigures. So we're doing the same by having a long ion chain, optically segmenting it a few tens of key bits at a time. And, and then just reconfiguring where this optical segmentation

30:54occurs. And this move the quantum information between the segmented trap into the new configuration without having to need to move any qubit around mechanically. So we save orders of magnitude in time again. And we can get extreme connectivity done in one fast operation. And this will enable us to go and be very modular, to go to very large number of qubits, which, while retaining a very small form factor. This is at the. That's 80,000. That's cool. I hadn't thought about that. Like that Actually physically moving

31:28things, there's a cost to that. I mean, a time cost to that. Yeah, probably an energy cost too. I mean, it makes sense, right? Like it's in time and energy and also in. In protecting the information. Let's, let's go back a little bit. Or maybe now it's Coming back to vinyl records, if you had vinyl records and you had a scratch and you'd hear that scratch, right? But when you move to DVDs, you need that scratch to eat one hell of a scratch in order to listen to it, to hear it. Because the amount of data that you could cram into that could

32:02compensate for errors that you had in a very good way because you did things at the speed of light in very high resolution. So our ideas go towards that kind of way of thinking. And instead of doing things very slowly that take time, that you cannot put a lot of information at a given footprint or area because you have to have these mechanical grooves of the vinyl records in that analogy and you're moving to things that move at

32:33the speed of light. You don't need to move things mechanically and you can more easily go into protecting the information and doing more information activity operations per unit time or per unit area. I guess it's kind of, it's kind of like solid state drives versus you know, the spinning disks. Right. At a much larger scale or smaller scale, but the same idea. Yeah, maybe that could be. It's a good analogy or maybe a bad analogy, I don't know. But.

33:06So you're currently building in a space with some very large players. What's your unfair advantage? Yeah. So specifically in trap time. Quantum computing is a quite small, tight knit community. Most of the companies came out of NIST in Boulder, Colorado, where my two co founders, Amit and Louis came from in the early 2000s or from the University of Innsbruck in, in, in Austria. So everybody knows everyone, it's tight knit community.

33:38Everybody is coming from the same kind of origin. I think what we bring to the table is two things mostly. The first thing is the innovation and creativity in how to do the scale up. No one in the industry is doing our multi cubit case, no one in history is doing our optical segmentation and so on. And we're not treading on the same beaten path, so to speak. And we did that both on the basis of working in the trenches in academia

34:09for 20, 20 years and establishing these coherent control methods, and also by being a second generation company. We had the privilege of looking at what are the other people's approaches and trying to identify where we think that they have shortcomings and provide solutions to them. That's one thing. And the other thing is that we're Israelis, we have chutzpah. We are used to work in fast, efficient processes.

34:39Everybody knows everyone. You went to the army with the same people. You worked with in the university and then came to the industry. And so doing things fast and relatively lower cost and innovative and creative is something that Israelis have in a very good way. And I think this is part of what we bring to the table, at least in the technological phase at the beginning. Interesting. I grew up in New York so I knew what chutzpah means.

35:10So did Candace. Ken grew up in New York too. So. No, I mean it's, it's. And I think one of the things I remember reading like the, the everybody knows. You bring up a good point. I think one of the reasons the startup ecosystem in Israel is so good is because you have that kind of that mixing pot of different people who come in and they serve together for, you know, I don't know what the requirement is but like, you know, whether it's a year or two years, but like you kind of build people, they use that as an opportunity to build out their network. I remember reading this whole thing about startup ecosystems and things like that.

35:42It's really when you, you get really innovative companies when people that ordinarily wouldn't mix or meet do meet and they exchange ideas. That's just. Yeah. When I was in the Ministry of Defense and we had joint collaborations with people from the US services we always had these kind of jokes that the people from the army and the people of the Air force said if the Israelis would not bring us to the room together, we would not know each other. Right. So that's part of it. But I think it's not the only thing. I think that there is

36:14necessity and there is also the fact that people are coming from the military is that they're getting a lot of responsibility, huge responsibility at a very early stage and they mature and they're not afraid to do things that require a lot of guts to go ahead and do that. And if an 18 or 19 year old woman or man in the intelligence

36:47units of the IDF are doing amazing, you know, 007 kind of fantasy work that we've seen in the last month or in the last two years around the globe. And these are the same people that they're doing that at age 19 or 20 and then they go out to the world and they bring the courage to do stuff. The ability to drive processes that are very meaningful plus the innovation that is coming

37:18from necessity being the mother of all invention. And then they can have a good time in driving this to applicability. Plus if you're an actual life threatening situations, the idea of risking everything and starting a company is Pretty low on the adrenaline list. And I also think too that, you know, one of the things that militaries tend to excel at or good ones do is leadership training, right? Leadership discipline, that sort of thing that I think really sets apart or sets people up for success

37:51post military, right. To start a company, to do this. Right. And again, like, you know, if you're doing life threatening neighborhood. So I don't know about discipline, but. Yeah, but. Oh, I mean, I think it's, it's an interesting, it's an interesting melting pot in terms of like, you know, ideas training that these kids get right at, you know, early in their, in their, in their lives. Another thing, another thing and, or rambling on this, but another thing of

38:23the, the ethos, the ethos of Israel is that Israel is, is like an island country, right. We're surrounded by unfriendly neighborhood. Although I hope that we will be able to be smart enough to have more friendly neighbors and be friendly to them as well. And the country has until recently had no natural resources. The only thing that we had is the brains and the people and heads. And

38:54so I think that's also part of it. And the forefathers of the country understood that they need to invest in academia and in industry. The first classical computer in Israel was built just 10 minute drive from here at the Weizmann Institute of science in the 1950s. Right. That was less than 10 years after the Holocaust. The country was just established, people were getting food stamps and a group of people was building one of the first 10 computers in the world.

39:25So people had vision and we're standing on the shoulders of these giants. I think that's also part of it. And this also serves the fact that the Israeli government knows how to do short cycles of transitioning things from academia to industry and pushing the industry forward. We have a lot of support from the Israeli government in doing that. Then you see a lot of the smaller countries around the world or a lot of the smarter smaller countries around the world do this, right? Singapore, right. They. You said something that a Singaporean government official once told me a

39:58long time ago that, you know, we didn't have any resources. We were an island. They, in that case, they were the word literal island. Right. So they realized they had to develop their people. Right. And you look at the success of Singapore, I was listening to a podcast. They have discipline. They do, yeah. Discipline is an important thing. Right. You know, Taiwan as well, right. Like, you know, speaking of disputed territories. Right. We're hitting them all today, Candace. I know I know we're not gonna, but you know TSMC was founded by, I forget the guy's name,

40:31but he was a well established guy in Silicon Valley in hardware manufacturing. And, and they basically really Taiwan leadership realized that they needed to, they needed to build out a much smarter, more intellectually focused in country manufacturing. Right. And, and you know, you know it's a legendary now tsmc. Right. So it's an interesting, I mean. All right, I think, I think investing in people is, is, and if you do it smartly is always a good investment.

41:03Sure. Everything starts and ends with people. Yeah, yeah. For now, until the AI robots take over. But you know, then we'll have other problems. Do you think the industry will converge on a dominant modality or will multiple architectures coexist long term? So I think depends on what long term is. Certainly now we have a few tens of full stack companies and we have over a thousand quantum companies in general. This will scale down and converge I think to a handful of companies.

41:36I think that in the short and medium term there is no reason that there will be a single winner takes at all. There is a big enough blue, enough ocean out there, but there will not be multiple vendors of each modality. For example, look at the aircraft industry. How many aircraft manufacturers you have in commercial aviation you have a few but not many. Same in classical compute you have a few but not many. So we will get there. Will it be only one technology? Could be,

42:07but in a very long term, I think not in the foreseeable future of the next one or two decades because we are still in the ramping up. And while we are ramping up, although quantum computing is a universal platform, it could solve any algorithm on the way there. There are, you know, nuances and there are, there's a grayscale and advantages and disadvantages, different modalities for specific applications. And I think this is the era that we're getting into first.

42:41That's a good way to put it. I, I think that eventually I think we're really in this. You know, you mentioned the early computers when there's only like maybe 10 or 12 of them around the world. Right. I think we're not quite that early on, but we're definitely in the transistor ish era. Like yeah, that's a good example. If you would take a few years before the transistor and you look at the ENIAC, for example, that had, you know, vacuum tubes and if you would bet on a company building the world's best vacuum tubes, what would have Happened.

43:14Okay, so we're not there yet. We are now at the. There are few technological alternatives. There are pros and cons. Ours is the best. So if you bet on anyone, bet on us. But we need the technology to grow up a little bit more and start to converge before we anticipate a winner. And even if we have a winner, in the transistor era and the integrated circuits, you had CPUs and then GPUs, now TPUs and so on. And that also evolves. So I guess that we

43:47have a little bit of ways to go before we see convergence to fewer modalities. Interesting. I'm sorry, Candice, I don't want to hog the mic. It's all good. When you're designing architecture, how do you decide what not to build? What gets intentionally left behind? Yeah. So nothing should be left behind if you're doing the full step, Right? Okay. But you need to be very focused in what you need to do in order to show the added value that you

44:18are bringing to the table and not do more of the same that other people are doing. And then you're not special and you're not bringing value. So we're focusing on the core of our products in the coherent control methods that I described before. And so, for example, when we're now about to launch our cloud service soon, there are a bunch of people out there who know how to establish this cloud layer of interfacing and authentication and billing and security and stuff like that. I don't need to do that by myself, although I can if I have to. Similarly,

44:52there are very deep technological problems in certain layers of the stack, for example, quantum error correction. So we are doing quantum error correction internally for our specific architecture, but we'd rather collaborate with companies like Kidma in Israel or riverlearn in the UK or others that all what they do is specialize in that particular layer of quantum error correction and bring that and integrate into our solution. So you need to balance between what you're doing in house and you're not letting anyone else

45:24share, and what are the things that are totally technical and you'd rather completely outsource if you can, and what are the things in between that you'd rather collaborate and tap into the best talent in the world, rather to build a very sophisticated muscle on your own. And the distinction between these three things is something dynamic. It evolves in. In time. Right. At the beginning, we've done only the core. Now we're doing more than that. At the beginning, we like. We like to do more collaboration. And we were dependent

45:55on collaboration. Today we're much more independent. It thinks that evolves as the company matures. Interesting. I know we gotta kind of wrap this up soon, so. So where can folks find out more about you, what you're up to and. And where. Where you're going? Like what. What. Where can folks find out more about. Unless, Candace, you had any other questions? Oh, no. I mean, no, I. I want. Where can people find out more? Yeah, let's find out. So Quantumr

46:28has a Wonderful website. It's www.quantum art.tech, which is kind of long, but you only need it once. We have their explanations about our technology and our architecture and our scientific publications and our press releases. It's all in there, including our job section. We're growing quite rapidly, both in Israel and abroad. So you're. You're more than welcome to check that out. We're also on LinkedIn. We're also in conferences.

46:58I think the nearest one that we have a booth and presenting is going to be at the end of June in Boston, the Quantum Tech conference there. So you're welcome to shoot us an email or come visit us. The best thing is to come visit us and see the labs in action. So if you're in the Middle Eastern neighborhood and you're not afraid, then you should definitely come and we'll be happy to host you. There's some good deals on hotels and travel these days, right?

47:28Not on airfare. Okay. Prices are out of this world. Fantastic. That's fantastic. Thank you. Thank you so very much. Anything else that you want to add? No, I'm just fascinated by this. Like, it's a. It's a definitely. I definitely want to take a closer look at your website and kind of see what sort of text, because it sounds. Sounds like you've got a lot of things already figured out in terms of. It's a long. It's a long path, though. Yeah. Yeah. Well, and also too, you know, you have, you know, whenever your company was found, I forgot the exact year.

48:00But like, you have. People have been doing this since the early 2000s. Right. This was not but a gleam in some people's eyes, you know, more than a decade ago. And, and you know, my wife actually works at nist, so it's kind of cool. You mentioned nist. Oh, which of them? In. In the one in the one in Maryland. In Maryland. But in the Quantum stuff in the joint. Quantum. No, she does it. Security infosec. I saw that. Yeah. No, but it's cool. The very hard to work from.

48:31From the outside with them. Right. That's cool. Plus, Candice's dad was a researcher at. IBM working on early. Yeah. Yeah. So kind of when it was just on the chalkboard, Right? Or whiteboard. Yeah. So cool. Well, awesome. With that, we'll let the outro. Quantum podcast? They're breaking the mold? Science and sky Beats is bold and it's gold?

49:13The multiverse is skanking? Skanking in time? Black holes are wailing in a horn line? So fine? From blank scales to planets? There can be connecting the dots? Candace and Frank? They're the cosmic hotshot? Quantum podcast? Turn it up fast? Candace and Frank? Blowing my mind at last? Quantum podcast? They're breaking the mold? Science has got beats? It's bold and it's gold?

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Exploring Quantum Computing in Finance with Alireza Khodaei

    Nov 19, 202652 minVideo

    Welcome back to Impact Quantum, the podcast where curiosity meets the cutting edge of quantum computing. In this episode, we dive deep into the intersection of quantum technology and finance with Alireza Khodaei, Senior...

    Listen to the audio

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Preparing for Q-Day - How Organizations Can Migrate to Post-Quantum Cryptography

    Nov 3, 202640 minVideo

    Welcome to Impact Quantum, the podcast where we dive into the rapidly evolving world of quantum computing and its broad implications for security, technology, and the future of work. In this episode, the conversation...

    Listen to the audio

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Bridging AI and Human Intelligence - Multicolor Lasers and the Future of Photonic Computing

    Sep 9, 202654 minVideo

    Welcome to another episode of Impact Quantum, where we explore the cutting edge of quantum computing and emerging technologies reshaping our world. Today, co-hosts Frank La Vigne and Candace Gillhoolley sit down with...

    Listen to the audio

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Quantum Security Challenges - Cryptographic Identities, AI Threats, and National Policy

    Sep 1, 202646 minVideo

    In this episode, co-host Candace Cahootie sits down with Christopher Turk, a leading expert in post-quantum cryptography at KPMG, to unpack the pressing issues facing organizations as quantum technology inches ever...

    Listen to the audio

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Building the Quantum Future -Research, Industry, and the Duke Quantum Center

    Aug 27, 202650 minVideo

    In this episode, we're joined by Rachel Noek, Senior Research Scientist and Technical Program Manager at the Duke Quantum Center. Rachel shares her journey from industry to academia, her experiences developing photonic...

    Listen to the audio

    Credit the people on this episode