0:00That person happens to be there and he absolutely hated Quantum Healing. And I was like, so what are you doing here? But then he was, again, I know he is a big scientist, but he was like saying, yeah, this is technically, this is a scam. And we talked like for a few hours. I couldn't convince him. He couldn't convince me, but that, that's the mentality of some people. Again, I cannot be sure if it's right or wrong. Curious. What a strange little factoid, because I've heard that too
0:32through completely different contexts where there's a lot of disbelief in quantum annealing, yet it's proven commercially at least to be one of the, one of the more popular options. Whether it's real or not might be up for debate. That's fascinating. Speed is just a byproduct. Alireza Khodayi, senior quantum computing scientist at Nelnet, on why a consistently biased forecast beats a lucky one and where quantum actually pays off in finance.
1:03Quantum Podcast, turn it up fast. Candace and Frank blowing my mind at last. Quantum Podcast, they're breaking the mold. Science has got beats to fold. Hello and welcome back to Impact Quantum, the podcast where we explore the emerging industry of quantum computing, where you don't need to be a PhD in physics, you just need to be a little bit curious. And with that is the most With me is the most quantum curious person I know, Candace Cahouli. How's it going, Candace? It's great. I'm really excited to record again, and we have a really interesting guest today.
1:36We're going to speak with Alireza Kodai, and I— please excuse me for any mispronunciation there. And he is the senior quantum computing scientist at Nelnet. How are you today? I'm fine, thank you. How about you? I'm good. The sun is shining. No complaints here. Yeah. Also, thank you for having me. No problem. That's a very cool title, by the way. Senior Quantum Computing Scientist. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you. So what do you do as a— in that role?
2:08Because it sounds descriptive and vague all at the same time. Yeah, sure. So I start with the quantum computing part. When you think about it, quantum computing, it's a newer paradigm that we have after all classical computing that we have been using for probably 3 decades now, seriously. So with quantum computing, we are— there are myths about quantum computing. I would say the first advantage is not necessarily
2:40the speedup. It's about the problems that classical computing start to reaching the ceiling of the computational power, so they cannot solve it as effectively as we expect. And there are few fields so far that quantum computers is getting proofs that probably they are the better chance. And those fields include pharmaceutical, molecular,
3:13design, and also in logistics, aviation, finance, all those sort of things. But when you think about it, in any of these fields, the algorithms we do essentially boils down to a few mathematical problems, most of which is optimization. There are other things like Monte Carlo simulations and things like that. So basically what I'm doing is applying the quantum computing and quantum algorithms to financial
3:43problems, if that makes sense. So it— okay, so it does make sense. So how do you determine which quantum algorithms have genuine commercial potential versus those that are scientifically fascinating? Yeah, that's a great question. And this is actually one of the challenges that I have. And I guess every practitioner in quantum computing has,
4:14because quantum computing, most of it so far have been in labs and R&D initiatives. Now we are getting transitioned into real-world commercial application of it, which you need to explain the money value of any quantum algorithm you want to use in any industry for people that are not necessarily quantum computing scientists or even close to that. People like CEOs, CFOs, these people just know
4:45about the business, not necessarily the technicality of quantum computing. But back to your question, at least in finance, we have certain problems that If you make a little bit, like a fraction of a percent improvement, that translates to a lot of money. You can think about the modeling of risk in different forms. You can think about the deriving prices for things like bonds or
5:15securities. And a lot of these examples necessarily not a better prediction, I would say, It's more about more consistency. For example, my own PhD was on forecasting volatility using quantum algorithm. And one of the results that I've seen that makes me interested to continue that research was when you use quantum algorithm and you do the forecasting of volatility, you can have a
5:46consistent bias forecast, but it's consistent. So you know if it is overestimating or underestimating. then you can offset it. But if you use classical algorithm with the same problem, sometimes you get very accurate forecast, sometimes you get very bad forecast. So when you get the result, you are not sure how much you can depend on it. So I would say in any case, when you see a problem that is, that is mathematically
6:16problematic, that makes it inconsistent results, or you have mathematical intractabilities like it is not differentiable, it is getting to plateau on optimization space, you would refer to quantum. Okay, so it was a long answer to a short question, but yeah, feel free to ask me more. First question I have is, I'm coming hot off the heels of being at KubeCon last week, and the question there is, was all about how do you
6:49get AI proofs of concept into production, right? I would imagine, and that's got its own challenges attached to it, I would imagine that we're having similar kind of discussions, or will have these, plenty of these discussions when it gets to how do you get a quantum computing solution into production, right? It goes from one thing to have a proof of concept, the POC. How do you get this thing into production when— Not a lot of people understand it.
7:19Yeah, the fact is— sorry, go ahead. So if we expect a production or we define production at the level of classical computing, honestly, I don't think you get any production with quantum computing. But if we just narrow down the definition to, hey, I have this algorithm, I want to use it in a real-world application, and The production is not here, like something like you have, I don't know, fault tolerancing, or if something goes wrong, there is a failover because most of the
7:52quantum vendors, they have their own stack, they have their own software library, and they are not necessarily uniform. You can do things in Qiskit or PennyLane, but essentially when you have a quantum software running on a machine, There is no guarantee that you can run the same quantum software on another machine with the same level of quality or efficiency or whatever metrics you have, right? Which is one of the big aspects of production, meaning that you go in
8:26production level, you don't rely, you don't depend on the hardware level. You can maintain a quality of service that is guaranteed, right? With quantum stacks so far, I would say we cannot guarantee that because the results would be different based on many things. The noise pattern that we have in quantum hardware, the length of the circuit, the number of qubits, so many variants. But we are getting there. And I have seen many trends
9:00that they work on things like the quantum compilers, quantum orchestration level that basically sit on top of the quantum hardware to abstract away differences in hardware and get to the point that you can send a job to be run on a quantum machine regardless of what is the underlying stack is. So we are, we are getting there. You talked about consistency and then you
9:33mentioned risk. So can quantum computing help us understand uncertainty? Yes. When you think about quantum computing, it's essentially a probabilistic computational paradigm, which is very different from classical, which is like deterministic computational paradigm. And for any quantum algorithm, for any— I would say even any quantum operation that you do. I give you a very
10:07simple example. So when you use classical computers, you can do 2+ 2, they have a definitive answer, right? Quantum computers are not built for that kind of definitive computation. It's more about you do your operation and then at the end of operation, you measure your qubit, which is the equivalent of a bit. And the result of the measurement comes in the terms of probability or a probabilistic distribution function, PDF, right?
10:40So it's essentially a probabilistic computational paradigm, and hence it natively embeds all those nuances of probability paradigms. For example, I earlier mentioned Monte Carlo simulation. If you want to do it with classical computers, you have to do it a lot of times, right? Sampling, basically. sampling the discrete points, while with quantum computers you have the whole continuous space covered in one
11:12qubit and then you measure it. So essentially you are not doing discrete steps, you just do the operation once and then you get the result. In that sense, you can say it's more speed, but again, as I said, it's I guess speed is just a byproduct of what we do in quantum computers. We have a lot more advantages than speed. Interesting. Is your
11:43LinkedIn headline image kind of implies that you're in a finance company? What sort of opportunities and risks does quantum computing open up for the finance world? I start with opportunities. I would say the best opportunity for financial practitioners, and I'm saying this because I have worked with a variety of financial domain experts, risk analysis, whatever. The first one I already told you, the consistency of the
12:15results. They would love to see something consistently biased rather than having something that, you know, inconsistent. But then beside that, I would say there are certain mathematical problems that if you do it with classical computing inference, you don't get even— and in some cases you don't get— you cannot get any result. And optimization is one example.
12:46If you have like a non-convex optimization problem, no matter how much GPU or how much computational power you throw at it, you cannot solve it because it's mathematically not possible to do it with the algorithms we do in classical. Or another thing that frequently happens in finance, and especially in risk forecasting, is the plateaus that comes in optimization space in which you lose the gradient.
13:16Again, no matter how much GPU you have, when you lose the gradient on a space, you cannot continue. So you lose— you end up with non-convergence of optimization. So these are certain mathematical problems that you cannot solve efficiently or you cannot solve at all with classical computer. And then you have to approximate, you have to get proxies close to the solution, but you are not getting close enough
13:48to the actual solution. And again, this is finance. As I said, I get a small percentage of improvement translates into probably more money. Yeah. Interesting. So what would meaningful quantum advantage look like in finance? That's a tricky question because I know there are proponents and opponents of quantum advantage in general. But again, depending on how you define the quantum advantage,
14:21the way I would define it is something that gives you a competitive advantage to your opponents in the market, right? And again, we are not talking about a big advantage. It could be very small, like marginal. Advantage. And as you know, in financial market, everyone that has survived, they are almost at par, right? So imagine all those big bankers or regional bankers, and anyone that survives
14:53means that they partition market between them. So now imagine one of those parties have a little bit of competitive advantage with regard to a better estimation of the risk or a better pricing. So imagine you, you are a bank, right? You want to give the loan and then you want to suggest a better interest rate considering all the factors that everyone else does. But then you want your interest rate to be more appealing to the customer, right?
15:24So you have a better way of estimating the risk. So your risk premium is more tailored to your customers. So most probably they, they take your offer, right? And then you can get a bigger portion of the market. And this is just like a simple example. Another example is if you are issuing securities and you have a better way of, you know, incorporating everything in it— what is the market expectation, what is the risk, whatever— then
15:54you're offering in terms of price is much more appealing than the others. So I would say, at least for myself, the expectation of quantum is not abruptively big. It is just whatever you can do on top of whatever you are already offering. A better accuracy, a wider outreach because you have included many factors in your conclusion. in your offering, things like that. I would say it's changing
16:27future, but for now, again, back to what we discussed, because we don't have that much of production-level software, production-level model, that's as we can do now. So we talk about quantum computing and we talk about AI as separate technologies. What happens when we begin combining quantum algorithms Wow, you get the big brother.
16:59But joke aside, I have been in this conversation so many times from the different perspectives. One question I always get is like how AI can help quantum computing to progress and vice versa, how quantum computing can get AI progress, and then now you are throwing in the finance, and then it becomes even more complicated. But I guess it is not mutually exclusive. All those fields can
17:29help each other, especially AI and quantum. We already have these quantum machine learning, and it's not just a concept, it's an actual thing, right? There are many algorithms, machine learning algorithms that run on quantum from scratch or quantum enhanced or quantum inspired like tensor networks. So each of these is like a different paradigm of introducing how quantum can contribute to AI. The other way around is
18:00also correct. I have seen many algorithms, for example, estimating or forecasting the noise pattern in quantum machines so we can have a better or a more reliable quantum Computation. What else? From AI to quantum, I have seen many— not many, actually. I have seen a few efforts for using the AI to design the quantum circuit and then try AI
18:31to come up with the best circuit given some metrics, the number of qubits, whatever. And then so you don't have to do like a trial and error as human. Right. So these are the ways that these 2 fields can help each other. But of course, finance can get help and get contribution from both sides. As a matter of fact, I'm working on that intersection as well. I've been working on a few projects that use a combination of AI and
19:01quantum forces to further enhance financial algorithms. But I would say the problem of working in finance in industry is that you cannot publish many of this, right? And this is not just me. I know many friends that work in other financial institutes have big achievements, but all we can do is just talking about it. You cannot, you know, talking about how we did it. Yeah, I mean, it's a very competitive industry, right? When quants first came into being, quants would figure things out years before anyone else
19:35and they would not share it. I would imagine it's the same setup. You're describing a very similar dynamic here, right? You may have figured out how the market works, right? How to predict it, but no one's necessarily going to want to shout that from the rooftops. Yeah. Yeah. That's so true. And it breaks my heart. I did a PhD. I shared the knowledge. I read the knowledge shared by the others. But I guess that, as you said, dynamics in industry, especially in finance industry, is
20:07different. I would say even a patent application, having a patent is another thing in most cases in finance because you don't want to share it. You are more running on the trade secrets rather than patents. Again, difference from other industries like pharmaceutical chemistry. Most of the engineering fields, they just share but patent it. Finance is not like that. But I guess eventually people,
20:38even though separately, come up with the very similar ideas at the end, and then probably they converge at some point. Everyone uses whatever algorithm for quantum optimization, so it's not a secret anymore. You will see it. It just appears everywhere. I guess that also has happened for optimization using discrete algorithms. Everyone knows about that, which is a good and bad thing at the same time. I remember probably 5 years ago,
21:08it created a hype. Hey, let's apply QAOO to optimization and boom, you get your best algorithm. And then later it turned out that it's a hype. You can have some advantages, but not as big as you might expect it. But again, yeah, this is a work in progress, how you contribute, how you let the others know without losing your secrets. That's a big question. I'd be so curious, what does a typical day look like for
21:42someone doing the kind of work you're doing? I would say, of course, R&D is a big part of it, right? So You learn from the field and then you come up with some ideas, some hunches that, hey, if we can apply this and that to such and such problem, we will get some advantage, right? So you have to experience that as well and repeat it enough times to be sure that, hey, yeah, there is some advantages. It is
22:15not just by chance or it is not because of noise. Which is funny. Sometimes you get some advantages because of noise, and then when you repeat it, it just fades out. But then the biggest part of it is not technical. It's about convincing people in leadership, executives that don't necessarily care what is your new solution or new approach is about. It's about how much it can save
22:45money or how much it can generate money. All right. So you have to translate all those technical advantages into some keys, some PKIs that they can understand and they can appreciate. At the end of the day, it is not important how much I am excited as a quantum computing scientist. It is important, at least in industry, it is important that you be able to explain those results in a simple language understandable by
23:17business side. And you can provide enough proof for that. So it is at least as important and as big as the technical part. Sometimes it's much more even challenging. And as far as I can see, people like me, they always have challenge and sometimes trouble in that part. Anyone that reads a technical paper can come up with ideas, execute them, get some results, but then how you translate it to something understandable and money-wise,
23:50at least in finance again. So yeah, I imagine translating these terms for mere mortals to someone who's in the C-suite who may not be a quantum physicist, particularly in finance. Oh yeah, that's got to be a tough— that's got to be a tough part of the job. So to be honest with you, I just predicted this when I was doing my PhD, I happened to start an MBA and got an MBA with a specialization in finance
24:21for one big reason, that I'd be able to translate what I get from technicality results into some finance. So I tried to make myself prepared for this, but even with 2 advanced degrees, I'm sometimes— I'm more— not sometimes, most of the times I'm challenging to explain it. And then I realized this is not just me. So I happen to be in a few external consortiums and roundtables that try
24:53to progress quantum computing in finance. And I can name the name, but I don't think it's proper for here, but I will assure you that big names, like very big names that you know in finance, they have the same problem. There are people, they have decades of quantum teams. I know a bank, a few banks that have been invested in this billion dollars. They have quantum teams for decades. Still, they have this challenge, how to translate the results
25:23that talks to some financial experts and financial executives. So we have a big way to go in that regard. That makes sense, right? And you look at the big names that have publicly announced they have a quantum division, I can't imagine that every one of those CEOs or board members is familiar with the inner workings of quantum physics. But kudos on you for getting the degree to be ready for it because you saw that coming. A lot of technologists don't see that if they can't communicate what they know, they're left on an island on
25:56their own. Yeah. Again, probably it was by chance that I thought about that and got my MBA. You're definitely right. Yeah, I have seen many people, very intelligent, very smart. Very good in their field, but then they can communicate in a way that they educated for. They can communicate in terms of technical papers, journal articles, but doesn't communicate with business people. Even in startups, I've been consulting some startups, the same problem, right?
26:27You have a best algorithm and then you want to get some funds. So how you communicate to the funders? Right. That's a big challenge as well. That's a good point. That was the whole joke of The Big Bang Theory, right, is that they could not communicate with normal people, right? Yeah, exactly. Sorry, Candace, I cut you off. No, no problem at all. Was there a particular problem in finance that made you think this is exactly the kind of challenge quantum computing might eventually help us solve? Yes.
26:59I mentioned that in an earlier conversation, but any— I think any problem that boils down to a mathematical intractable problem, it's better to be challenged with quantum. And I give you a few instances. I gave a few already. So if you have a mathematical problem that gets non-convex at some point, or gets disjoint in their space, or gets the— cannot be differentiated mathematically, like you
27:33cannot get the derivatives on it. There are a few features I can actually name, like mathematical features. If you see those mathematical red flags in your problem, then you can think about quantum computers because those red flags eventually cause your classical algorithm to a stop at some point and then get to the quantum. And from the classical point of view, it also makes sense. Every time in mathematics that
28:04we fail to get a deterministic answer, you sort of just resort to statistics instead of mathematics. Now that we cannot get a definitive answer, we just talk about probability. of this answer being the answer that we are looking for, that kind of talking. And then quantum computing, as I said, is the best probabilistic computational paradigm. I guess in summary, when you don't get a definitive answer in any problem, including in finance, quantum
28:37computing is your friend. And the other way around, I have to say, if you know you can get the deterministic answer for any problem, you won't bother quantum computing. If you're doing like arithmetic or deterministic algebra equation solution, you're better off with the classical. Interesting. What's the big challenge to getting funding, right?
29:09For not just for a startup, but for within a bank. I would imagine the big players in the finance world are already invested in quantum because they see the writing on the wall. But there's probably a lot of smaller players that are— they're still trying to ingest AI and figure out what AI means for them. What does that pitch look like roughly? Oh, to be honest, I wouldn't pitch a thing that promised a lot from quantum because the first thing you get in answer is that, why not AI?
29:41Even the problem you're saying is already solved by classical computing and you can see it's working. So why bother with quantum? Which I don't necessarily agree with, but answering to those questions require your audience to have some technical knowledge that you cannot create within a pitch, right? So my strategy is not getting to that conversation from the start. And I have seen this strategy from many other people.
30:13For now, at least, we can think about quantum processing unit, QPU, as something like GPU. So you resort to it when it is needed. And when, as I said, when your classical computation was having some problem that you could say it's good for quantum resort. The same thing in pitches, right? So if I go and say, hey, I'm building this company that can give you,
30:44I don't know, an algorithm that does arithmetic problems, not arithmetic. So I'm giving you a concrete example. I can solve the Black-Scholes model with quantum and with classical. So if I go build a startup saying that, hey, I do it classically, but then I have a QPU involved that solves it even better in cases that classical gets stuck. They buy it much more than if I say I'm going to have a startup that have a
31:17product that solves the Black-Scholes model with a quantum approach from scratch. That would be super hard to justify, honestly. Because as I say, we will say, hey, yeah, we can already solve it with classical. And, but by the way, Black-Scholes model is for deriving the price of security. So it's a very common popular problems that almost everyone knows in finance. But yeah, I guess again, the summary is I would start with quantum as an
31:50additional computational unit rather than from scratch quantum. Again, that breaks my heart. That's where we are now. So during a financial crisis, institutions need to understand their exposure very quickly. Could quantum computing eventually help financial organizations respond faster to rapidly changing markets? Definitely. And I'm glad that you asked this because that was one of the conclusions of my dissertation. One thing that
32:24I concluded was the— what I called it the agility of the algorithm, meaning that, so when you think about the volatility, volatility, what is volatility? It is the changes in the price of an asset, right? And then when you look at the volatility as a time series, like how volatility changes for a certain asset, for a certain stock over the time, right? You can see variations, right?
32:56And then you are trying to forecast, meaning that you are looking at the past data and then try to forecast the coming day's volatility, right? I use the same algorithm solved with classical and quantum. Everyone knows in finance, again, GARCH, G-A-R-C-H. So you can implement GARCH with classical computing. And you can say it has a certain accuracy, it has a certain metrics when it's solved with classical, and probably you can hit that
33:28accuracy better or worse with the quantum. But something that is for sure is your quantum algorithm reacts to the fluctuation of the price, of fluctuation of the seen volatility, much more faster than classical. Meaning that I, my quantum algorithm responds to those fluctuations faster than classical. I actually have some graphs and results, and I'm not sure if
33:58this podcast would have any visual components, but— Well, we could share it and we could just give people a link to the YouTube version. We do that. Okay. Yeah, that's a good idea. So you will see how, so imagine that you have these fluctuations and then your classical GARCH is more like averaging out those fluctuations because it doesn't have that speed to capture everything. On the other hand, quantum is just almost
34:28exactly fluctuating, your forecast fluctuating with the realized volatility, which something that I didn't expect honestly. And then I had to do it too many times to be sure that this is not a noise artifact or whatever, but then I realized no, this is actually a real thing. It's more agile in capturing it, and also because you are measuring the circuit at the end, you can measure it with different ways. I managed to incorporate the regimes
35:00into measuring, so you can say hey, I'm an expert. I believe that market is in bullish regime now. With that context, what is the forecast of volatility? The same market may be analyzed by another expert as not being bullish. It could be bearish in their opinion. Then you can run the same quantum algorithm on the same time series and you get a different forecast with the context of
35:30bearish. So that's another— context still matters. Oh, yeah. Yeah. That's another thing you cannot get from classical large. So, yeah, because we are doing measurement and we are doing— we are dealing with a natively probabilistic computational paradigm. Right. Interesting. It's giving a long-term weather forecast. Sorry, Ken. It's okay. No, it's okay. When, like, hey, this is what it's like. This is what the winter is going to look like in a non-El Niño year. This is what it's going to look like in
36:03an El Niño year. This is what it could look like in a super El Niño year, which is exactly right now. Yeah, like a scenario, given like scenarios, and then what happens based on that scenario. Yeah. How is it different than Monte Carlo simulations, or it's not the same but similar? What, the forecasting of volatility? Yeah, based on that. Based on context, is that— When you do volatility forecasting, you have to include some feature of
36:36volatility, like volatility clustering or memory to volatility because of the market behavior. So imagine the volatility, like the volatility memory of market. What does it mean is if you have a volatile day today, your tomorrow would be much more likely volatile than if you had a calm today, right? So it's kind of market has a memory to volatility for a while, right?
37:06If you have volatile today, then probably coming next days would be volatile as well, right? That, that, and as a matter of fact, the GARCH model has a term for it. In Monte Carlo, what you do is you are picking the points, sampling the points based on a uniform distribution. You don't have any— what is the technical term for it? So you don't have any assumptions. You would say that's the same likelihood if
37:37today volatility is the same as the next day volatility, right? So you are not assuming anything different. You're just taking randomly taking points. While in GARCH model, and basically in any statistical model, you have baked in some assumptions, some, some things that you have seen in macroeconomics or microeconomics, you have baked them into your model. And then what you want to do is trying to find the parameters of model.
38:10In other words, you already know what is the mathematical expression of the volatility. You just don't know what are the coefficients. To put— to plug into that mathematical expression. In Monte Carlo, on the other hand, you are looking for the PDF, probability distribution function, of a problem, right? You don't have any mathematical expression. You just want to see what that curve looks like, and then what is the mean of it? What is the
38:41variance like? Statistically speaking, it's pure statistic. Rather than mathematical modeling with unknown coefficients, like different degrees of uncertainty. I mean, you are totally uncertain about some process, you do Monte Carlo. When you think about it, but you don't have complete understanding, then you try to have a mathematical model, but with some uncertain components in it. And then try to find those components
39:13with whatever things that you do. It could be optimization, could be Monte Carlo, could be anything. I hope I did a good job. I think so. I think I understand. I think I understand. Yeah. Awesome. If you could challenge one widely held assumption about quantum computing in science— I'm sorry, in finance. What would it be? You cannot tell. I'm just putting myself into a lot of risk now
39:45because I know this subject has too many lovers and haters. I would say you cannot tell in an isolated case if quantum optimization has or has not an advantage, because I have seen people dividing on this. People think that quantum optimization has absolute advantage in finance. And some people say, no, it absolutely doesn't have any advantage or proven advantage in finance. I would say it is not
40:18true in either case. You should really look at your problem. You look at your mathematical properties of the optimization space you try to solve, and then start imagining if it has or has not. More specifically, I have seen, again, I don't want to name the names, but I talked with a gentleman. He's a very good scholar and in industry, in academia. He believed that quantum annealing used for optimization
40:51is a scam. Basically, that was what he said. Really? Yeah. And he says anything that quantum annealing can do in optimization, We can do it with imaginary time transformation of whatever. People are tough in that. And then we, of course, on the other hand, we have people that say, hey, quantum approaches, whether it be annealing, whether it be gate-based, I don't know, amplitude estimation methods are silver bullet
41:22to any optimization problem. So I stay in middle and I guess I'm getting punches from both sides. Interesting. No, I think there's an interesting use case there because there were an interesting story there, not use case, where a lot of people hate on a particular company whose their sole job is, I'm not going to name names, but their sole, their sole claim to fame is quantum annealing. And they get a lot of hate in a lot of the Reddit forums and various places on the internet. And I
41:54never understood it. But I guess if people don't believe in the process of annealing, yeah, natural. Plus for now they're one of the top names in the field as a company. So it's like the top guy always gets made fun of. Yeah. As a matter of fact, I got into that conversation in some of the conferences specifically for quantum annealing. And then that person happens to be there and he absolutely hated quantum annealing. And I was like, so what are you doing here?
42:24But then he was Again, I know he is a big scientist, but he was like saying, yeah, this is technically, this is a scam. And we talked like for a few hours. I couldn't convince him. He couldn't convince me. But that, that's the mentality of some people. Again, I cannot be sure if it's right or wrong. Curious. What a strange little factoid, because I've heard that too through completely different contexts. where there's a lot of disbelief in quantum annealing, yet it's
42:56proven commercially at least to be one of the, one of the more popular options. Whether it's real or not might be up for debate. That's fascinating. Yeah, again, as I said, for some problems like— what is the name— barren plateaus. If you have a lot of barren plateaus in your optimization space, Quantum annealing may help you, may help. There are other factors to count in. So you cannot say it never helps. You cannot say it always helps.
43:28But then people, I guess they are not, I don't know what they think. They looking for a smaller version of justification. And in the sense that they just lose track of other factors that may involve. But yeah, definitely you're right. Annealing is one of the more arguable quantum methods. And it's not just annealing. In gate-based models, we have other algorithms that— I'm giving an example. TensorFlow— sorry, tensor networks
43:59are not quantum at all, right? They are based on GPUs. But then there are people saying that whatever you do in certain quantum algorithms, you can do with tensor networks. So that bunch of quantum gate-based Algorithms are not necessary, and then the same thing happens there. Interesting, fascinating. Yeah, great questions. I put myself in a lot of danger here.
44:32You have to go to the Quantum Witness Protection Program. Oh yeah, like Saul Goodman, right? He's in Nebraska, right? Yeah, yeah, exactly. Yeah, so we have the history of being. and protection problem. People trying to throw tomatoes at me if they see me. Maybe they'll be quantum tomatoes. They'll either burst down into nothing or burst down into tomatoes. Yeah. I'm gonna hush now so Candace can ask a question. No, I'm— I've asked. I've—
45:03I'm filled with interesting information. I think this has been absolutely fascinating. I'm really happy that we got to dig into finance now. I think it's really great. Yeah, it's often cited as one of the top use cases for quantum finance, pharma, and a few other things. Logistics and recently aviation. And then there is a defense which I never touched, but I heard about that. But yeah, we probably want to have a second episode on quantum finance. Sure. I'm just joking, but yeah, if you're— We'd love
45:36to have you back. This is a fun conversation. We'd love to have you back. And in there, I can tell what is quantum finance, which is a little bit different than quantum algorithm in finance, right? There's a thing as quantum finance. Interesting. Where can folks find out more about you? Oh, didn't get the question. What do you mean? Oh, I'm sorry. Where can folks find out more about you and what you do? your own?
46:07Again, I didn't get it. So you're asking what is my work look like? Where can we— where can people find out more about you and— Oh, sorry, I was hearing work. Oh, it's okay. My LinkedIn, I post once in a while in my LinkedIn about the things that I can publish publicly. Like recently I published a few things. One was the contest I won in INQ competition, and it was like for predicting— or not predicting, it was for
46:40identifying the current market regime based on a library of regimes that we have. So imagine if I ask you, or you ask me, what regime we are living now for a market of whatever stock, I would say Based on my quantum algorithm that runs on IonQ, I would say 20%, we are in bearish. I don't know, 15%, we are in bullish. So there are probability assigned with market regimes and
47:11I do it in a quantum way. Sure. Yeah, I published the code. I published the working panel so that there's a link in my LinkedIn. You can go click on that. It gets to the Colab. execution panel, you can just select from the few options that I put there from the stocks, and then select it, and then it gives you the probability of what regimes they are in as, as today. And also it gives you a few quantum things that, you know, what, what
47:42circuit has been used, what are the parameters used in the circuit for Montenegro people. Interesting. Yeah, sure. Another thing that I, again, published in my LinkedIn is an interactive reading experiment. So imagine you have these technical paper or survey paper that has a lot of material, including mathematics, graphs, tables, along with the text. And then a
48:13lot of papers referred or cited as well. When I was a student, my main problem was like, I read the first paragraph, then I have to think about it, then I have to go chase the referred citation, and then that citation happened to be a 10-page paper by itself. Then I have to chase where in that paper the original paper means such and such. It was a lot of effort also for mathematics or graphs or whatever. Many papers, because they have a limitation of a space, they don't give you the full
48:46steps that led to that graph or led to that equation. Then I was always wondering how they derive this equation, how they come up with this. So I solved all these problems in my platforms. When you publish a paper in my platform, it goes and chases and reads all the citations, gets an idea, of what is the paper corpus underlying your paper. It visually sees the graphs and mathematics. It is just
49:16not reads the text. So you can ask it to specific questions about the graph. What does this point mean? What does this trend mean? Can we support this graph with the literature? If anyone else has come up close with this result? Or for the mathematics, you can ask simply derive this mathematics, like it's just reverse engineering the equations that you have. So it gives you, if it can find it in the references, it gives you a step-by-step derivation
49:48of the math that is given there. Again, I published it, one of my papers, and I also put the link there. I reached out to people encouraging them to convert their already written PDF papers into this interactive mode. I have a few interested people, but honestly, not as much as I expected. But I'm still trying to, to basically encourage the idea that reader should not stop at the point that author stopped in the paper, right?
50:19I may have my own conclusion at the end of the paper, not necessarily the reader agrees with, right? So the reader can investigate my paper, come up with different ideas, or even counterpropose some of the results that I claim. And that platform even makes them able to do that. They can counterpropose, they can contribute, they can add to that paper. And if it's legit, platform itself calls the original author and lets them know that, hey, we have this,
50:52it seems to be interesting, you can collaborate. Things like that. Interesting. Yeah, I can give you the link for the audiences to take a look at it. That's great. Yeah, definitely. Yeah, excellent. Any parting thoughts? Quantum finance, at first it seemed a little scary, but honestly, the way you've been explaining it, it's— again, I'm just completely fascinated by it. I think that this is really interesting.
51:24It's not going to tell you how to predict the stock market. It's not about that. Getting rid of those silly assumptions, but I really appreciated hearing everything. Thank you so much. Yeah, sure. Yeah. Thank you for having me again. It's a great pleasure to be able to talk about things that, as you said, people think it's scary, but it's not really scary. As soon as you get the concept, what is it principally about? you get comfortable with. Yeah, absolutely. With that, we'll roll the outro.