0:00when I was in high school, I read a book, it's called Programming the Universe by Seth Lloyd. And he was an MIT professor, amazing book about how you can see the universe from the perspective of quantum computation. And I was really intrigued by this idea. I wanted to learn more about how regular computers work. So I went to computer engineering, you know, department and finished my bachelor's, entered my masters
0:31with an intention now to understand how quantum hardware works. As a result of that, I realized that there is a lot of potential there and there is a lot of problems you can solve. So this is how I end up in 1QBit. Welcome to Impact Quantum. Hello and welcome to Impact Quantum.
1:01Quantum, the podcast where we explore the emerging industry that is quantum computing, where you don't necessarily have to have a PhD, though it probably helps. You just need to be curious. And I think that's what really matters. So with me, I have the most quantum-curious person I know, Candace Cahouli. How's it going, Candace? It's great. It's great today. Beautiful day, blue skies. It's wonderful. I'm very excited about our conversation we're going to have today. We're going to be
1:31speaking with Severin Ballinuck. And he is a research software developer at 1QBit. How are you today, Severin? Great. Thank you. Very excited to be here with you guys, and I'm ready for your questions. Awesome. Awesome. And in the virtual green room, we were talking about this is how the discussion these days is less about AI, but around AI and quantum. And I also hear a lot in terms
2:03of quantum for just quantum's sake, but also quantum in the phase of AI. Do you think that— all right, what's your take on that? Is that a way for quantum founders to get some of that sweet AI venture capital money, or is it— is there some meat behind it, or possibly both? Yeah, I would say that let's start with Distinguishing these 2 concepts, there is like a thing that's called quantum machine learning or, you know, quantum AI, and there is
2:36another thing that is AI for quantum computing, and that's different things. Quantum machine learning is basically how we imagine quantum computers to do machine learning for us, as you know, and engines. And AI in quantum is the way we use machine learning or AI to assist support and accelerate quantum computing development in terms of software, in terms of hardware control, in terms of computing itself. And I think a big
3:07chunk of what we are hearing about AI and quantum is around this topic of how AI can help quantum computing. What do I mean by that? From my personal experience, my thesis project at University of Waterloo was about how we can use machine learning to classify quantum states. Yeah. So we collect images from quantum computer, it's, you know, atoms. We have images in black and white colors and all the atoms are in different colors. You
3:39can classify those things with machine learning algorithms because hardware in those labs are, you know, limited, capability is not as advanced as we would want, but machine learning can assist with that. Same goes for quantum hardware, setting, you know, you can have machine learning algorithms help your experiments to set up or calibrate your quantum hardware. So that's, I think, the bigger picture about how AI can help quantum computing. Quantum ML is more
4:09theoretical concept, and I didn't expect it to be a hype topic or something implementable anytime soon, but it's still exciting to see how it develops. So yeah, I think it's a real thing. A lot of companies right now hiring, you know, AI specialists to run, you know, let's say agentic solutions or agentic autonomous AI labs in quantum research teams, which help them to, you know, surface the area, implement papers, test ideas. And that's at least real for me.
4:43Okay. So what first attracted you to quantum computing? Say it again. What first attracted you to quantum computing? Oh, I think the great idea of how you can invent a new age of computing. Because when I was in high school, I read a book, it's called Programming the Universe by Seth Lloyd, and he was an MIT professor. Amazing book about how you
5:14can see the universe from the perspective of quantum computation. And I was really intrigued by this idea. I wanted to learn more about how regular computers work. So I went to computer engineering, you know, department and finished my bachelor's, entered my master's with an intention now to understand how quantum hardware works. As a result of that, I realized that there is like a lot of potential there and there is like a lot of problems you can solve. So. This is how
5:44I end up in 1QBit. Oh, very cool. Yeah, go ahead, Candace. I'll just say, like, what skills proved to be the most valuable that weren't taught necessarily in quantum courses? I think the most valuable skill in quantum world is surprisingly networking. It's not necessarily like how you program or what theoretical approach do you know for a certain platform,
6:15but it's how you communicate with people, how you express your ideas, and how you can actually help teams. And in order to understand how you can help, you have to talk to people and understand what is needed in this or that team, in this or that company. And it actually helped me and my lab at University of Waterloo. It's called Primory Institute Quantum Intelligence Lab was, you know, a heart of this environment where we had a team of researchers who specialize on, you know, machine learning applications in physics in general. And we
6:48tried to connect with hardware people to see how we can help them, how we can assist this quantum computing development. And this is basically like how a lot of companies hire. They hire people who understand the context, who talk to others, who have network and are able to deliver what's needed. So yeah, I would say go to conferences. You have to understand other people's work. Don't be hyperfocused on, you know, only like coursework because it's only half of the story.
7:20Interesting. Um, I think that really points to the idea that even if you are a physicist, you do to really get the most out of this opportunity, 'cause I really think this is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity. You know, we're too young, we were born too late to take advantage of, you know, the transistor revolution, but I think we're just in time for this quantum computing revolution that we're seeing.
7:55Yeah, I think that's about right. But, you know, some estimates could vary a lot. Right. Similarly to how people, you know, predicted AGI to be a thing in a couple of years. Right now, a lot of people predict Q-day to be, you know, around the corner. Right. Q-day basically, like, means that quantum computers would be able to actually, like, break RSA encryption or something along those lines. It's not necessarily that, actually. We could spend another 10 years solving certain problems in quantum computing and not getting
8:29that. So we definitely at the start of something big, but it's really hard to tell if it's going to be in the next 5 years or in the next 18 months, as a lot of CEOs like to say. Yeah. Yeah, it's very hard to predict the future, right? Isn't that a Feynman quote? Predictions are hard, especially about the future. But I also, I also think, though, we're either at or very near an inflection point where this is going to become very real. Real, right? And it's always a good time to be in the IT security business, but it's probably a
9:02really good time to be in the getting ready for quantum, right? Because whether Q-Day happens next month, next year, next decade, one of the funniest things I heard, I live in the DC area and somebody was saying, this would've been maybe 8 years ago now, that you really need to start preparing for They didn't have the cool Q-Day name yet, but it basically said you need to start upgrading your encryption algorithms to be more quantum resistant. Yeah. And somebody in the audience kind of called him out. It's like, this
9:35is the time the estimates were the 2040s, right? And it was like, come on, do we really need to worry about this? And he said, he says, no, you do, because you all, everyone in this room, because it was all government IT people, everybody in this room knows how slow government IT works. Exactly. To be ready for a problem in 20 years' time, you need to start 15 to 20 years ahead of time. Yeah. It sounds about right. Yeah. Where's the lie, as they would say? So what's your take
10:08on where the industry is now? Do you really think that— because there's always irrational pessimism, then irrational exuberance, and then a little bit of irrational pessimism. again, right? And you're right, like, AI is a perfect example of this, right? It went from, we're 10 to 20 years away from AGI, then all the usual suspects in, you know, the AI kind of top-tier people are saying, we're only a couple of years away. And then when the money starts running out, they say,
10:39well, hold up now, right? Do you really think— what's your take if you had to guess? And we're not going to hold you to it, right? This is— No, there are no experts, right, in terms of this. But do you really think— you think it's a problem that we're going to face in the remainder of this decade, or is this more of a problem for the 2030s? It's really hard to tell. Again, I agree with you 100%. I will slightly refer to what governments right now are aiming to predict or to stimulate people to do.
11:11And what I mean by that, there is a lot of government grants or government programs that stimulate or motivate quantum companies to deliver something, you know, deliver a scientifically reasonable quantum computer or utility-grade quantum computer. And they're usually saying something like 2033, 2035, maybe 2037. So based on that, I assume that to have something at
11:42least scientifically meaningful, and by that I mean to build a quantum computer that would be useful at least for scientists to, you know, benchmark their assumptions or, uh, software or just, you know, run experiments, the '30s is the more adequate and visible timeline. But when we talk about actually useful quantum computer that would be able to solve real-life problems, it's way harder because It's not just a question of engineering, it's also a question of algorithms. So we didn't have useful algorithms to solve a lot of problems
12:16that our, that real world needs to solve. So yeah, that's my perspective. Yeah, I guess it's very easy to get caught up in the security aspects of this, the Q-Day aspects of it. Yeah, and you know, the worst part is it's not just that we need to move from regular encryption to post-quantum encryption, it's also the fact that A lot of people or governments are collecting a lot of data from the internet that is encrypted, and they would be able to decrypt it at, you know, at some point in the future. And that's also a thing that we need to
12:50keep in mind. It's not that we just need to, again, be ready. We need to understand, like, what will happen if everyone would be able to, let's say, break internet encryption that was collected over the last 10, 20, 30 years. That's a real thing as well. Interesting. Do you— sorry, Candace, I don't want to hog the mic. It's all good. Do you think AI will help build useful quantum computers faster? I think so, yes. I mean, because it's easily the most important thing for,
13:23you know, research, because AI is able to write, AI is able to review, and AI is able to brainstorm ideas for the research. And the goal of the researcher in the company is not to, you know, invent a wheel. It's to find a good paper, find a good problem, and find a way to deliver a product. And in order to do that, you need to again read a lot of papers. You need to implement some of them. You need to test them, and you need to understand who needs what from
13:57us. Like, if you're a software company, you will write software for other quantum companies, or you can write software for, let's say, you know, financial companies and, you know, quantum-inspired portfolio optimization algorithm, stuff like that. And in order to do all of that, you need a regular research cycle, and research cycle could be accelerated or, uh, could be improved by AI. And I mean like LLMs, chatbots, stuff like that, AI agents.
14:29So which is currently overhyped? Is it quantum for AI or is it AI for quantum? I think AI for quantum is overhyped, I guess in a good sense. We haven't seen the results of any kind from it at this point, but at least people invest money, at least people hire for this position. So I think it's it's a valid hype point. We will test this idea and we'll see, is it like actually useful for research or no in a couple of years?
15:01Quantum for AI is way less discovered field, and I don't think quantum computing would be able to meaningfully show anything useful for AI necessarily. I, I've seen interesting papers recently about it, but it's most of the work that is done in this quantum for AI field is purely like theoretical or purely like a showcase of, oh wait, we can do something with quantum computers that will help LLMs or will help, you know, AI
15:35in general, but it's not something that people will, you know, use on a day-to-day basis. Yeah, it's purely scientific from my perspective. Okay. Okay. Interesting. We were talking also in the green room about nation-states taking a real interest in, in this from a perspective, right? There's at least 3 quantum corridors
16:06in Canada, probably more. Where I live in Maryland has actually become very popular with the quantum development, actually multiple sites now. There's one in College Park at the University of Maryland, which is by DC. DC folks will notice where the IKEA is. And Frederick, which is closer to where I live, they're building out a big quantum campus that they're going to build out over the next 10 years or so. And there's obviously Boston has a pretty good ecosystem. New
16:39York does come up a lot, as obviously Silicon Valley as well. So what's your take on that? Is that— what's your take on kind of like that bigger picture of governments are really worried about that? Do you think they're trying to like make this a big thing, or do you think they see, hey, you know what, we missed out on the Silicon Valley revolution, the dot-com revolution? We may or may not have jumped on the AI bandwagon, but this is the next bandwagon. Well, it could be
17:12that. I see it as another attempt to unite companies or unite people around the bigger and more challenging and less clear perspective of quantum computer. It's— I see it as an attempt to build, you know, a Project Manhattan. For nuclear research, but in quantum computing, where we just accelerate the field by financing or intensifying companies to deliver something meaningful in a certain
17:46timeframe. And as a result of these investments, actually something cool can happen. Because again, as I said before, like a lot of research is just trying to find something new again, you know, scientific novelty and scientific novelty could be done by you know, people hours. And it's not something we can predict. And I guess the government strategy right now is we can invest more money so we can give more resources to researchers, we can hire more
18:16researchers, and as a result of that, something actually useful can emerge. And this is like a valid thing to do. And I think it's great that governments and again, like private equity, as investing in this idea because a lot of people didn't believe in, you know, nuclear power. Right now it's really hard to convince people that quantum computers would be useful, but we never know until it's actually built and we can run experiments on it. Because like the only way we can do meaningful science is
18:47when we have something we can work with physically. And until we just do it on paper, I do not expect any crazy breakthroughs happening. The most important thing for now is to find the platform that will be the most, you know, reliable, scalable, and accessible to people and to labs, and then build a quantum computer from it to then run a number of experiments, research cycles, and, you know, getting something unique and novel from it. So that's my perspective,
19:21and that's why I do not expect anything crazy from purely scientific or purely software research, because this is like how science works, in my opinion. It should be done on the real thing. Absolutely. So I was looking at your LinkedIn profile. You're the 2nd person I've ever met, and both of them have been guests on this show, that programs in Julia. Oh, I was like, because that's not a name you hear a lot, and Julia at one point was going to be the next great language. And I'm
19:52not saying it's not a great language. I don't wanna start a language— Hopefully. I don't wanna start a language war or anything like that. I'm way too mature for that. But I find it interesting that the 2 people in the QAM space have chosen Julia. Why does— why do you— why— what, have you seen a lot of Julia in your work? It says you do low-level development in Julia. And why did you pick the language or did the language pick you? Well, I would say my introduction to Julia happened at Perimeter Institute when I took like 2 courses there. One
20:25was about numerical methods, and those numerical methods were taught in Julia. From my perspective, and again, I'm not an expert in Julia, I have— I'm, I would rather say I'm a beginner in Julia, but Julia was introduced like a language that can improve speed of your emulation simulations and linear algebra-based calculations. So it's not for, you know, machine learning type thing. It's more for Monte Carlo
20:56simulation, stuff like this. It's also useful for quantum in general, and we have some software written in Julia, but I wouldn't say it's mainstream. still most of the things that is done in quantum or in science in general are written in Python because it's, again, like easier to understand. There are like way more libraries in Python and there are a lot of like frameworks that help your Python code to be transformed into a product. So Julia is like gaining a lot of traction,
21:29but we still like need more people and more projects to be converted into Julia or written from scratch in Julia. But yeah, that's, uh, that's something that is popular in quantum and in theoretical physics circles, at least from my perspective. All right, so that makes— I'm going to bump up Julia on the learn list. Yeah, I think so. I think so. I mean, it's pretty easy to learn it. Yeah, when I say it was meant to be— I'm sorry, but when you think of Jupyter Notebooks, the first 2 letters are for Julia.
22:03Julia Python R was originally the, um, was originally what it was built for. So, like, Given that that has been the de facto tool for data science, it's kind of surprising that Python kind of took all the oxygen out of the room, but we'll see. Well, yeah, there are reasons for it, but not to start again a language war. No, I don't want to start a language war. I was just saying like, yeah, yeah, it was posited to be the next big thing and it just maybe just, maybe it's not washed out, but washed up,
22:35but maybe it's just its time hasn't come yet. How about that? Yeah, I mean, exactly. It takes time. It takes a lot of time because it's not just that you can or should write just one project in Julia, it's that the whole lab should be run in Julia, right? And like a lot of code that people write for research should be done in Julia. And it really takes time. It's similar to how previously people worked with like C and my prof, like Roger Melchior, he started as a
23:05C language like researcher, and then he migrated to Python and Julia, and it took, you know, a decade, maybe more. So yeah, you know, maybe a quantum computer will be built at the point where Julia will become more mainstream. Yeah, people's habits are hard to change. Sure. Do you think that Julia is well suited to create these hybrid classical quantum workflows? It's really hard to tell, really hard to tell.
23:38Again, it all depends on what skill set would be in demand because previously, again, a lot of companies in quantum computing like wrote a lot of stuff in C++, let's say, but then you're not able to find a ton of C++ developers that are also good in physics and quantum computing or in in machine learning. And all of those people tend to know Python. And if you have like 7 years of experience in Python, it's really hard to
24:12convince you to switch to Julia just because Julia is a good language. That's why I, it's hard to predict. If companies started to scale in one language, it's highly unlikely that it will change. We should see like new companies pick Julia as a default language because a number of reasons. And I just don't see that number of reasons to emerge because, you know, Julia community should grow and we should see like a lot of like libraries, a lot of existing guides, and we should see a lower barrier to
24:45entry because right now it's a bit hard. Like recently I read Julia docs again and I just, you know, usually I just watch YouTube videos to get myself familiar with concepts really quick. And there is not too many, there aren't too many, you know, Julia tutorials. And that's, you know, the first step that we need to pass. We should have more workshops in Julia. We should have more Julia, you know, sponsoring events maybe. I don't know.
25:16But yeah, it's all part of the popularization. And sometimes a language is just at the right place at the right time, right? I'm not, I'm a Python developer, but Python I think was uniquely suited because a lot the mathematical sciences and bioinformatics, as what I understand is what really drove it, was that there was already a lot of these scientific libraries before AI really kicked off, and it was just in the right place at the right time. Yeah. You know, and it
25:47was a multi-domain language, so like you could do different things with it. And so that meant that you had web developers that About the talent pool, like you said, right? How many, how many physics physicists are really good in programming in Rust, right? Yeah. Probably not a lot. Probably not a lot, right? So like, they're gonna take the tool, they're gonna take their languages and tools with them. And, you know, I mean, maybe, I just think it's
26:17interesting, like, you're, you know, the second person in this space that uses Julia. So maybe, maybe they'll bring that with them as these things roll out. So let's do a little quantum reality check for a second. What do you think is the biggest misconception people have about quantum computing? Let me think about it. I think the biggest misconception about quantum computing is that if we will build a quantum computer tomorrow, perfect quantum computer, that we will be able to actually break everything and take advantage of
26:48everything just the next day. It's actually not quite true. And we have 2 sides of the coin, hardware and software, and there are a ton of work that we have to do on the software side to make use of quantum computer properly. And for example, we have a quite short list of useful quantum algorithms, and this is something we need to improve on, and it's really unclear how to improve on that because we don't have a real quantum computer. And
27:19when we see a lot of like news about Google building a new chip, Microsoft building a new chip, and it will, you know, disrupt industry or something like that, even if it's true, even if it's actually working, it's not going to happen, you know, the next day. And people tend to measure things in, you know, physical or logical qubits while we also take into account how is our, you know, quantum operating system is doing. And
27:50that's, in my perspective, is the biggest misconception. Yeah. Okay. So what are industry insiders discussing about quantum that the public rarely hears about? I think the biggest topic that insiders are discussing, at least from my perspective, is like, what's the next big platform? For the last, I think, 10 years, most people tend to lean towards superconducting platform or architecture
28:23since, you know, Google investing in it, IBM investing in it, other big players developing this platform and investing money in it. But right now it's not as clear, and I think a lot of, you know, underdogs emerging. And the biggest topic that I'm encountering is neutral atoms and trapped ions. They're, at least from my perspective, again, the next big candidates for
28:53a scalable and reliable quantum computer. Of course, they have their problems, but we tend to discuss more about, we tend to discuss more how neutral atoms are going to conquer the world or how trapped ions will be developed and why they're more promising. And I think it comes from the place where, you know, superconducting architecture hasn't delivered on the promise. And that's why
29:25the discussion happens. Yeah, I think for the longest time, I think superconducting qubits were the only game in town. not the only game in town, but they were definitely the most promising. And then all of a sudden you hear about photonics, trapped ion, cat qubits, and there's at least, I know I'm leaving out some off the list, but— Yeah, NMR also was there. And what was the Majorana? Yeah, yeah, Majorana qubits, Microsoft thing. Not familiar with it, but I know there's like a lot of controversy.
29:57Yeah, I was inside Microsoft when some of that controversy started. And, but I mean, they haven't made this announcement yet. Yesterday, actually, we recorded this on June 3rd, and yesterday at the Build conference, they said something to the effect about there's a Majorana 2. I haven't followed up on it. So clearly, whatever they had issues with, they've, they've, they've, they're moving past it now. We would hope, if the press release is to be believed, but— That's right. But I don't know, like, I've been intrigued by photonics, if I'm being honest.
30:30That's an interesting concept. I agree with that. From my perspective, Xanadu is doing a great job with photonics and how they run the company overall. So good for them. Waiting for the big release of the quantum computer, I guess. Right, right, right, right, right. So if you saw— oh, I'm sorry, go ahead. No, that's all fun and games until you Until you actually ship, right? Until you ship. So if you could solve one problem in quantum computing,
31:02what would it be? So amazing question. I would say error correction. I see like we are talking about error correction a lot, and I think if we are able to solve error correction, and again, It's really tied to a platform, and error correction for one platform would be completely different from error correction for another platform. I mean, like superconducting qubits versus phonics versus trapped ions versus neutral atoms. They all build
31:36differently to some extent, of course, and error correction would be different. That's been said, if we can have error-correcting code that will allow us to run circuits without a huge overhead and without actually bottlenecking us, that would be a big unlock. Yeah, that's a good way to put it. And I think whoever cracks that problem first, because it is hardware or maybe not hardware dependent, but approach dependent, whoever cracks that first, whichever one of these platforms
32:07cracks that first, is probably going to be the lead for at least half a decade, maybe longer. Could be that. So you've been involved with open source quantum initiatives. Yes, that's right. Why is open source important for the future of quantum computing? I think open source is quite important for a number of reasons. First reason is the missing translation layer in quantum field. What I mean
32:37by that is we have scientists, they are focused on delivering novelty. We have business people who are focused on return on investment product, but all of that thing, all of those things are usually targeting other developers or other scientists. And if we talk about financial district, if we talk about drug discovery, if we talk about other industries that are slightly interested in quantum computer
33:07or want to hear something from it, they are locked and they are not able to see what's going under the hood of quantum companies because it's, you know, intellectual property, no one will disclose it. Quantum companies did some consulting to private companies for a while, but it's going downwards. And where open source comes into play, open source is actually able to show people, okay, this is What hardware are we using? This is all details about
33:37hardware, and this is like realistic way to a better hardware. And open source could be way more, again, like open and clear and not biased towards its own solutions or its own stakeholders, because when you have a lot of you know, open source contributors, all of them are able to access hardware or able to access experienced teams of scientists. They can
34:08help quantum field as a whole because like real projects are super challenging to find in quantum computers to get experience, like learning online courses or, you know, passing online courses are not enough to be, you know, a quantum developer or to be a scientist. Usually you need to go to university, but if we have open source projects, you can contribute to open source and get that real experience, get that real connections that I mentioned earlier, and you can understand what's actually needed in the field. And I feel like it's extremely
34:43useful and perspective, or it's extremely good way to build part of the field. It's similar to how we have, again, macOS and Linux, right? It's Linux is not dominating personal computer field, but it's crucial part of IT infrastructure and for the reason of being open source again. No, that's a good point. I think open source has really, I think, changed the
35:13game in terms of how people look at not just software development, but also kind of ownership of products, right? One of my One of my biggest aha moments of, and I work, my day job is Red Hat, right? So you can see the fedora behind me. Right. But I cut my teeth on Microsoft tech during the Ballmer era where Ballmer had some unsavory things to say about open source. But like over time I kind of realized like open source, if you're building platforms that enterprises are gonna rely
35:46on, it's gonna be common infrastructure. To have closed-door meetings where massive decisions are made, AKA killing Silverlight, killing Windows Phone, right? Both things that directly impacted— Personal to you. Personal to me and impacted my economic situation is just not a stable place to build on. Now I understand why. I mean, I'm sure backroom closed-door meetings happen. positive they do. But, you know, look at what happened with
36:19Node.js a few years ago. The Node.js community was very unhappy about the direction of Node.js. So they got so unhappy, they forked the project to io.js. And then ultimately the brains behind Node.js kind of said, all right, we messed up. Let's get everybody back into the fold. But having that leverage or the threat of that leverage, I mean, it changes the power dynamic, right? And if I'm, if I'm a CTO and I'm a bank or whatever, I don't, I have to have a lot
36:49of trust in that Company X is proprietary software isn't gonna just end the product one day, right? Yeah. And that until that happens, and I think the demise of Silverlight and a lot of other things that were killed, not just Microsoft, but licensing drama with other vendors and things like that. I think has really made open source a viable option because while forking a project is a big deal and starting up a new thing and changing your infrastructure, the fact you can do it
37:22helps people sleep at night. Not that it's a great idea, but the fact that you have, as a consumer of technology, as a user of technology, some of that power is a little more shifted in your favor, right? Mm-hmm. And the smart companies that are selling this stuff know, like, not to abuse it to the point where they push people over. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, I agree with that 100%. And like another point could be that open source kind of keeps other companies in check about what they promise in quantum computing field,
37:56because we can see it with AI again, to draw another parallel with AI, we have closed source LLMs and we have open source LLMs. And we know that open source LLMs are, they are quite behind from the cutting-edge models. At the same time, they are, you know, keeping up. And when we hear, oh, you know, everything and everyone will be replaced in the next 18 months, we know it's kind of not true because we see open-source, you know, models are
38:27just not able to support that breakthrough. And in big industries, there is, you know, no one single breakthrough that changes everything. It's the It's a development, it's a process, and when you have open source, you have more visibility into field as a whole, and you can tune your expectations accordingly. And I think for other big, big tech or other fields, or for government, it's extremely important to have that visibility into the field.
38:59Yeah, it's a good, it's a good counterbalance to hype. Yeah, exactly. So you've mentioned Julia, we've mentioned coding, we've talked about open source. What additional tools should an aspiring quantum developer be learning today? I think paper implementation is the big one. Coding, yeah, I think it's part of the coding. What else could it be?
39:36Probably learning a little bit of how to translate a lot of these abstract concepts into something more people can understand. Yes, I would say so. I mean, the verbal ability is the big one. You should be able to communicate ideas clearly for sure. So like, I mean, there are like a number of things to To this, and being a researcher means one, you understand the math, you understand the physics, you are able to do your own research. And I
40:07think this is the big one, actually, being able to do your own research. So like defining the problem, finding a good problem you want to research or you want to solve, do like literature review, talk to peers, understand what was done, what could be done. By you, and finally, the implementation. So you should be able to implement parts of other papers, and you should be able to, like, implement a solution that would be clearly understood by other people. I think it's a big thing as well.
40:37But again, it's only for theoretical quantum researchers. But if you are a hardware, you know, experimentalist, they have to have another set of skills. And I have no idea how that works in detail. That's a good point because we're so new at this. This is such a new field that the line between hardware and software is not as well established as it is in, say, software, right? You can have a data scientist and someone who's an AI researcher. They clearly know CUDA. They clearly know the math behind it, but are they going to
41:10basically, are they going to go down to Micro Center and like get their own GPU and build their own? Probably not. Probably not. Yeah, we, we know we take regular hardware. for granted, right? Just exists. It could be better or worse, but we still can work with it. And quantum computing is the whole other, you know, aspect of, of research again. For now. For now. Maybe in 50 years we'll all be sitting back in our lawn chairs, retired and kind of laughing at, do you remember when— remember before Julia
41:40got famous and we had to worry about hardware? And— Yeah, I hope so. I hope so. I work every day to, you know, bring that day closer. Right. So which industries do you think will see quantum value first? It's a good question. I feel like material science for sure. And our open source hardware prof gave an amazing lecture 2 years ago, I think, about how quantum
42:13computers can actually give— provide value to science. And we can use quantum computers as a platform to explore how, you know, atoms evolve or how quantum systems evolve. And that can give us certain insights about material science. That's one argument. Second argument is financial field. I think quantum-inspired portfolio optimization algorithms is the big one. But again, it's theoretical. I do not know if it's actually useful
42:46now, but I'm hearing a lot of it. all the time. And quantum sensing is the third one. And I think quantum sensing has been around for a while, and it actually, you know, generates money. But I do not know, like, any particular details about how it works or who is interested in that. But that's pretty much 3 things that I can remember. Okay.
43:16What's one prediction about quantum computing that most people would disagree with today, but you believe could become a reality? I think that quantum computing can deliver unexpected results that are impossible to predict now, but for a curious scientists are desirable. So my point is that quantum computers is like another piece of
43:47technology that we haven't explored fully. And a lot of people, they straight own an opinion that quantum computers are like either useless or will not deliver anything meaningful even if they're built. But my idea is, or my prediction is, that once we will build a quantum computer, we will see another unlock in certain, you know, fields of research or in material science or in something else. And like, this is
44:20basically a promise of, you know, quantum computing that I'm following. Okay. So if a 16-year-old student is listening to this episode and wants to work in quantum computing someday, what should they start learning this week? I would say programming language for sure. You should start with Python. You should explore some quantum courses.
44:51Again, like, you have to do all the things step by step to learn quantum, you know, mechanics. You should understand you know, Calculus 1, Calculus 2, linear algebra, all of those things. If you want to be an experimentalist, you have to start with something that you can do at your home. And the most important thing is, from my perspective, is getting connections in university as early as you can. University of Waterloo has a number of, you know, summer programs for
45:23curious high schoolers. I've heard about that. So that's definitely one thing. If you're geographically unable to attend any, you know, high school quantum summer camps or whatever, you definitely should like reach out to people and get, you know, a real person's advice in the thing that you're interested in. Again, it's impossible to predict or impossible to understand what is needed and what you should learn. And I was, yeah, I was at the same place. I thought, well, I will learn Qiskit and
45:57I will get a job as a quantum software developer. It's not the case whatsoever. Like no one is looking for Qiskit, you know, quantum software developer. It's not a thing. You should learn another set of skills and you do not know about those skills. You do not know what you do not know. And the only way to understand what to do, like, and where to start and where to finish is to get real feedback from people in industry that are working on real problems, from profs in the labs that are building real experiments or running real experiments
46:30again. And with that, you can acquire meaningful skills and get in school or maybe, you know, contribute to open source and become, you know, valuable to the project. That's my perspective. But yeah, start with basics, programming, some math, and do something with your hands if you want to be experimentalist. I did it myself. I did, you know, like a small circuits when I was in high school, and it helped me to understand what I want and what I do not
47:02want. So yeah, definitely like be proactive, try different things, you know, break stuff, try again. That's the only way to learn. Because like field is emerging, there is no established pathway, and everyone is figuring things out on the fly. Even like large businesses, like giant quantum companies, they do not know what they're doing a lot of times, and they are again like researching things. And when you research things, you come to unexpected conclusions or
47:33unexpected ideas. So you explore them further. So that's— it's all about exploration. You should— And that, that is great. That is a great way to put it. It's all about exploration. Who knows, like, the student could be the next Mark Zuckerberg, right? Like, you know, yeah, um, you know, you may not— all I'm saying is kids aim higher than just being an employee, right? Like, this really is new. There's some kid in the garage somewhere or in the basement in Waterloo, or Montreal or, you know, Baltimore that could be the next billionaire in the space, right? Like, it
48:06really is that far out. I mean, that far new, right? It's not impossible to think about it. Difficult, but not impossible. It's true. So where can folks find out about more about you and the company you work for? LinkedIn works the best. Visit our company's website. We, I think we have a number of like workshops or lectures on YouTube as well. Oh, cool. Yeah.
48:37Yeah, that's pretty much it. Yeah, we didn't have, we didn't have an X account or anything like that. You should definitely check out Xenedus Open resources. They have an amazing tool or, you know, software called Penlane and IonQ also have a lot of like guides on their website. Our company has documentation for our product. It's called TopCat. Check that out. But again, it's more for other developers and other researchers. So if you want to start with something simple, there are a ton of like brilliant
49:10lectures on YouTube and 3Blue1Brown had a video about quantum. That's the best starting point you can imagine. Okay, good. Well, I love Three Blue One Brown. Yeah, fantastic. I think Candace actually met Grant Sanderson. Yeah, brilliant, brilliant, and very approachable. Very, very approachable. Yeah. Yeah, by the way, Veritasium as well. He came— oh yeah, University of Waterloo, I think 2 years ago. He made a
49:41video or a number of videos about quantum, so Check that out. I definitely will. All right, and with that, we'll let the outro music play. Thank you, that was great, man.
50:16The multiverse is skanking, skanking in time. Black holes are wailing in a horn line so fine. From Planck scales to planets, they're connecting the dots. Candace and Frank, they're the cosmic hotshots. Quantum podcast, turn it up fast. Candace and Frank blowing my mind. Quantum Podcast, they're breaking the mold. Science has got beats. It's bold and it's gold.