0:00But when a quantum computer is ready, we will be able to break that encryption. And with that, we will be able to read or to see information or private information, government secrets that are being sent and received through the internet. So Q-Day, as it's called, is not something that we know for sure when it's going to happen. We know it's going to happen. We know that AI is accelerating that day. And it's better
0:33for all of us to be prepared. And the risk is there. And yeah, we need to be prepared. And we are offering that to the organizations we talk to. Quantum Podcast, turn it up fast. Candace and Frank blowing my mind at last. Quantum Podcast, they're breaking the mold. Science has got beats to fold. Hello and welcome back to Impact Quantum, the podcast where we explore the emerging industry of quantum computing and what that means for the future of
1:03security and computing and generally what careers will look like in a quantum era. And with me is the most quantum-curious person I know, Candace Cahouli. How's it going, Candace? It's great. Thank you very much for asking. I'm really excited about today. Now, the way he pronounces his name correctly, he rolls his Rs, so it sounds much better. But I'm gonna try. I was suitably— I was impressed in the green room. Right, the rolling of the Rs is just beautiful. So we have Pablo Carrillo, and
1:34he is the founder and CEO of Cubris. How are you today, Pablo? Hey, Kandace. Hey, Frank. I'm doing great. Really thrilled about this conversation. And yeah, my name is Carrillo. It's Spanish, so it's a bit difficult to get it, but you will get it at some point. Just get it. It's beautiful. I love it. I love it. Pleased to be here. Yeah, no, I'm sorry, go ahead. No, no, pleased to be here and looking forward to our conversation today. Awesome, awesome. I'm very curious to hear about
2:07you and what you're doing. I think we did have a little bit of a conversation in the virtual green room, and tell me what it is that you do. Well, we help sectors, not companies, but a sector to migrate to post-quantum cryptography. We do this because we learned it the hard way. We went, we started conversations with banks, financial institutions, and other organizations that are already thinking or planning about migrating to PQC. And we
2:39found that our proposal landed, everyone was on board, but then nothing happened. And that's because they were asking us, who else is doing this in our sector? Is there a regulation? Why do we need to do this? They know, I mean, the why, the technical why is there, but not something that really gets the buy-in from the board to start moving. So we understood that we needed to go to a higher level, and it's the regulators
3:12who are planning to migrate all the sector. And we learned that in the Middle East, where we are having active conversations with the central bank. They are planning to migrate around 20 banks that are part of their, of the country. And we decided that that was the best approach for us and a differentiator approach, because this is going to be more efficient than rather than going Organization by organization.
3:44So for our listeners who are new to the topic, can you define post-quantum cryptography? Yeah, I don't want to get that much technical here, but basically today we use classic encryption and the encryption we use for communications and every data transfer is using Let's say a type of algorithms that at this point are not breakable, but when a quantum computer is ready,
4:16we will be able to break that encryption. And with that, we will be able to, to read or to see information or private information, government secrets that are being sent and received through the internet. So Q-Day, as it's called, is not something that we know for sure when it's going to happen. We know it's going to happen. We know that AI is accelerating that day. And it's better for all of us to be prepared.
4:48And the risk is there. And yeah, we need to be prepared. And we are offering that to the organizations we talk to. Have you noticed that there's been a shift, I would say maybe in the last 12 to 18 months of the urgency of this? Because I remember talking about this and I'm sure there are people that when Shor's algorithm came out were sounding the alarm in the '90s. But I remember people starting to worry about this maybe going back 6 to 8 years ago. And
5:19I've noticed in the last, definitely last year, the panic on this is been turned up, not to 11 just yet, but yeah. Yeah. And we started reaching out to companies last year around this time. And even the last few months has been, the acceleration has been higher. I think it's due to the fact that the big companies are moving. They are starting to talk about this. Google is starting to talk about this. The big banks are starting to
5:52plan. So that creates this maybe nervousness in the companies. So they start like, if they are moving, then this is real. Right. Because I remember we had a conversation with a bank CISO and we proposed our services and he was telling us like, who else is doing this? Because they wanted to know, despite they were a big bank in their country, They were asking who else in the world is doing this. The
6:23CIOs or CISOs, they don't want to risk and start doing something that maybe gets stuck. But when the big companies start to move, everyone should pay attention and start moving. You know, I'm questioning what usually prompts an organization to begin this PQC journey. What we have seen is that the trigger is usually regulation, despite— rather than
6:55an initiative like a real threat. Because when they need to comply with the regulation, they just need to do it, even if they don't necessarily think about that. So when the regulations, the regulation gets out, They can ask for a budget because this isn't— this is sometimes it's expensive. The first step is the main one because you need to know all your assets, everything that is exposed. So that first
7:25discovery is what triggers everything. And the process of migrating could take years because it's not something that is only about you. It's everyone that you are connected to needs to be compliant. or needs to have the same level of security. If not, you are vulnerable. So regulation drives this. And in some other cases, we have seen that market differentiation, they want to tell their clients, and that's something difficult to tell because you can tell your clients that you are more secure. But when you say that, also you are
7:58exposing like, oh, so I was not that secure. Like if I am a bank, like now I'm more secure. So before we were not as secure as you are saying that we are now. So it's a complex conversation to have even with your clients because you don't really know how they are going to take this. But of course, it's a differentiator and you can tell your clients that you are creating a new version of your bank, of your online banking to protect their assets, protect their information. So yeah,
8:28I mean, first of all, regulation, and then there are other factors. But mainly regulation. What— how would you say, how do we know? So this is kind of the thing that always bothered me, not bothered me like in a bad way, but kind of like, how do we know something is quantum? Because I used to hear this term quantum resistant, right? And then it switched to post-quantum cryptography, given that there's no real quantum
8:59computer today, and I'll put that in air quotes, and before you start writing hate mail, listeners, dear listeners, I mean, how do we know it's really going to be safe, right? Like, I like the term of quantum resistant because I thought that was a little more realistic, but how do we know? Well— Or do we not know? We're making best guesses. I think the algorithms,
9:30the organizations, NIST, who approved the new algorithms to encrypt data, they chose the best human creations because all these new algorithms were created by humans. They tested them as possible, of course. But what you're saying, your concern, I think your concern is, is a concern that everyone has had in the space. I even think and ask myself that. And to be honest,
10:04I think we have risk and we have mitigated as much as possible the risk, and we have tools that help us mitigate it as much. We cannot be really or 100% sure about that until we get a quantum computer and someone tries to break one of these algorithms. I think that's what we as engineers do well, and cryptographers. I don't consider myself a cryptographer, but you try to
10:35mitigate the risk. You try to find something to protect yourself as much as possible. And then once the technology, the attacking technology is ready, you can start improving what you already have. But I think that it's a great starting point to defend ourselves against this threat. Interesting. What do you think surprises your customers the most once they begin assessing their cryptographic infrastructure?
11:11It's getting to know that they have more assets than they thought. Because most of the organizations, they don't really have a full inventory of all their assets. So once they find out, that's something that changes the scope of the project. Because they think like this is a short project, some like a few assets to protect, but then they discover there are more. And with
11:45AI, now that the AI, the agents, they get connected to our tools, that increases the number of authentication connections that we have. So you are creating with AI, we're creating more assets or more vulnerabilities because every one of these AI identities that are created to connect are also encrypted and are also vulnerable. So we're creating assets every day.
12:17So that's why this first step is, is key for the project, key for scoping the effort, and also the most surprising part of it. Well, you mentioned financial services and you mentioned the government. I'm thinking about perhaps what other industries are falling behind or are especially vulnerable. Well, we have in the health sector, hospitals,
12:50insurers, because they handle sensitive data. in other, any, anything in the government that is related to your identity, your personal records, but health and also utilities, electric companies, the electric grids, the water providers. Critical infrastructure. Critical infrastructure. Yeah, that's the name. Because right now everything is exposed. I mean, it's not exposed, but it's connected to the internet. So you
13:22are vulnerable. If someone gets in, they are going to be able to even to control the data, even to control operations. So everything will be at risk at this point. There are some regulations that are already in place for those sectors, but the migration is going to— it's not— the schedule is not that demanding as in other sectors because right now, like, all the focus is in government and and financials
13:53because it supports the others. But yeah, I mean, any health record needs to be held for 10, 15 years depending on the country. And if we are having a quantum computer in 5 years, that data is going to be exposed. So yeah, those are like the main sectors that are being impacted by this. Plus anything that people, like, even people's like private photos, like I can
14:26easily imagine, you know, Apple iCloud, right? At some point consumers are gonna demand that data is also, right? I, you're right. Like obviously you're gonna start at the government level, then critical infrastructure, but then I think ordinary civilians, regular people are gonna demand this, right? Yeah. Yeah, and that could be, I think about like it's been even exploited in a way for knowing better your consumer
14:57trends or patterns. Because right now, when you interact in social media, you have, you are revealing your behavior with and your interests. And that helps the algorithm put in front of you some ads. But if I find a way to secretly know more specifically what are you searching, what are you reviewing, what are you buying specifically things, I will be able to create like more specific campaigns based on some data that you may
15:30not be sharing all the time on the internet. Can organizations upgrade gradually? Or does everything have to change at once? I could say that you can have waves in which you migrate. Because at this moment, nobody is— no, not nobody, but not all the organizations are moving at the same pace.
16:03And yeah, waves. are something you can think about, but at some point you will need to cover everything. The ideal will be that everyone will decide at some point to do it all together so everything is protected, but it's not technically feasible. And even I was discussing with a colleague the other day, and he and one of his partners, they did some research and some estimations. And there are not even the amount
16:34of cryptographers or companies that are focused on PQC. There are not enough companies in the world to cover all the work that needs to be done. So yeah, the wave approach is the best for now. But if a sector or an organization starts getting behind, There will be a moment in which a lot of organizations need to do it all at once. It's certainly a growth market,
17:06I think. Yeah. What would— oh, go ahead, Candace. What are the most common misconceptions organizations have about PQC? I think that one of the, the one that I have heard the most is that it's like sci-fi, that Q-Day is not coming, that yeah, this sounds great, but
17:40we don't think this is really coming. We have heard this. And also the the lack of ownership inside an organization. It's not that PQC needs to be a different role, but the real ownership comes from how we secure our data and how we envision the future threats. So they think that for now, as Today
18:12is everything is okay. There's nothing wrong that's going to happen in the future. So they relax and as they don't see any other companies doing the same, they don't do anything. So not seeing the competitors doing the migration or starting the migration is something that is keeping organizations back from starting. And another misconception is that that. If there's no regulation, they don't really need to do anything.
18:44It's a shame, but sometimes it's like they need this push from a regulator to start doing things. Interesting. So you think it's a push, not a pull, like people aren't pulling themselves, or is it a little bit of both? Yeah, I mean, I think they are curious. They are quantum curious or peaky curious. Yeah, yeah, yeah. They are not necessarily Because they are exploring, they are asking for some information. I mean, they are shopping around, like seeing if something convinces
19:16them to do something or how they can position PQC as a market differentiator, but not as a real need. So I think they are just finding, finding, I mean, fooling around and finding out. Right. So the regulator is, is the, is at the end of the day is the organization that is going to push everything, everyone to do that. And in emerging markets, where is our focus? Despite there are not many regulations active in
19:48emerging markets in Latin America, Middle East, Africa, what is happening is that the first world countries, G7, they are moving already. And as in financial institutions, you have correspondence, you have transactions. they are going to be forced into this. In that case, they are going to be pulled because if not, we're going to have 2 different banking systems or financial systems, one that is quantum ready and another one that is disconnected from it because they never migrated. So
20:22that's something that we, that we see, something that could happen if sectors do not migrate at the same time. How— I'm thinking about AI and the role that AI will play. I wonder, how is AI changing the way organizations approach post-quantum cryptography, both in identifying risks and accelerating migration?
20:52Right now, there are many inventory tools that use AI. To help improve or accelerate the inventory. And that helps because when you don't have like all the infrastructure of a Big 4 company, you use this type of tools that help you get inventory ready. And also it helps you identify easily or map easily what algorithm is better depending on the type of asset you have.
21:25So in that way, AI is helping optimize how we're going to protect against quantum computers. And organizations are not using directly it. It's the companies that are assessing or creating this or running this inventory assessments. Those are the companies that are using AI. A company like a bank or a healthcare company, they
21:57don't necessarily see AI in the same, like, for a, like, as a catalyst of security or as something that can help them improve security right now. Interesting. What led you into What led you to pursue this as a career? Because post-quantum cryptography as a— or quantum-resistant cryptography,
22:30theoretically, I guess it's been around since '94 with Shor's algorithm, theoretically, but wasn't really, I think, a viable career path until maybe 10 years ago. How did you get here? I'm just curious. I think curiosity. Took me here. I have a background in project management and operations and have worked for software companies, the public sector in my country, and in
23:01different software projects. And I just got curious about how can I use that experience to be— how can I use that experience to build something that will help us be ahead of the technological advancements? So that somehow brought quantum computing,
23:35brought PQC, and not because I am a cryptographer, but it brought the idea of This is not a cryptography problem. This is a coordination problem, a governance problem. So with my experience, I saw myself and I saw the company as the orchestrator that helps put everything in place to help with the migrations, to help with identifying what needs to be done, and then getting those things done, even by ourselves or with partners. In
24:07each region or in the world, because there is room for a lot of businesses, a lot of companies to take part in this process of migrating to PQC. So you have companies that are only focused on inventory, other companies that are focused on migrating algorithms, other companies that are focused on the hardware part of it. So this is a And then you have to sell this to the board and you need to have someone inside the company who, inside the
24:38organization, who is going to be responsible for moving things ahead. So I saw myself like that element in this ecosystem. Have you ever come across organizations and when they assume that they're ready for it, but they're actually not? Fortunately, I mean, yes, but not in the way that we may think. They feel ready because they think nothing is going to happen ever, not
25:10because they have done anything. Okay. So they don't think that the Q-Day is coming or anything like that. So they say, no, we're going to be good, we don't need that, or it's not a priority right now. So not really. I haven't seen a company that say, yeah, we're ready. I have seen big organizations like Santander Bank in Spain, which I think they are leading a bit this migration in Europe and in the financial sector. And even
25:42them, I mean, I think they feel that they are doing a great job, but I don't think they feel 100% confident that everything is already done and they don't need to get worried about anything. I think that someone that understands The complexity of this, which is the organization part and everyone migrating, I think once they have done their part, I think they will be more concerned because the others are not doing their part and that puts themselves at risk. So
26:13that coordination is which is needed more and more to get us ahead of Have there been any common lessons that you've learned from working with early adopters? Yeah. Usually the lesson is we should have started earlier because there's a lot to be done. Yeah. And also,
26:47From the budget perspective, starting, I mean, it's a consequence of starting earlier. If they have started earlier, they would have now more budget allocated to do this in a, to not be in a rush, like to be more organized, to do it in more phases. And so it's easier to allocate budget. So those are like the main points that all these early adopters have in common. Is
27:18it really, you think it'll be part of the role of the CISO to address this, or is it going to be requires everybody to play along? We have seen that everyone needs to play along. This is a company effort, but everyone is, of course, like the accountability part falls on the CISO, but Everyone needs to take part. Everyone needs to be on board with the idea and know the impacts
27:49because when migrating to a new algorithm, computing time is going to be increased. So maybe the user experience is going to be impacted a bit. So everyone has a say, but I think that everyone needs to be on board too. So what skills should cybersecurity professionals begin developing today, thinking about forward thinking to
28:22quantum and PQC? I could say that we will need to be able to— sorry, my English betrayed me. My— We will need like some kind of white hat quantum hacking or penetration testing. We need that. And I mean, a real like hands-on with a computer. Like the fact of not having a quantum computer now stops us a bit. You can try to simulate it
28:55with the IBM's quantum services or Google's quantum computer services. Those are simulators that you can run now, but at some point we will need people in the cybersecurity space that are able to do penetration testing. And also, I wouldn't say that at some point we will need to create new algorithms to protect ourselves, but that's, I think that in
29:25Cryptography is going to be always a race between how far the machine can go. So we will— quantum computers can keep improving. So we will need to create stronger encryption. So that's something that's going to evolve in time. So cryptography, I think that's going to stay here with us forever. We don't know what what's possible yet. And once,
30:00right now, AI is accelerating quantum, but once quantum starts accelerating AI, I think there will be more risks, more threats. And yeah, I would say that someone in the space will need to get to understand better quantum computing and its capabilities for breaking encryption. Hmm. What can we do as consumers, right? I have a bank, I have everything the average person would have.
30:30What can consumers do to encourage their banks? Banks are probably already doing it, right? But like other organizations to upgrade their encryption algorithms. I think consumer demand is gonna have to accelerate this. Is that even possible? Like, are you gonna look like a crazy person? Like, I'm not, not that I'm gonna go down to my supermarket or my bank and say like, We need quantum, post-quantum encryption, cryptography, right? Like, what could the average person do to— 'cause there's really 2
31:02stories here in my mind, at a minimum of 2 stories, right? Like, one, career-wise, right? Like, what can you do today to have a fulfilling career in quantum, post-quantum cryptography, this kind of space? And then 2 is like, what can I do to protect my data? What, how do you, like, what? Yeah. To me, that's something I don't think anyone's really thought about. Do we need consumer education? Obviously, that's going to have a long— that's a long cycle. But like, what can— and the people listening to this are savvier than the average
31:33consumer, but like, what can people who are a little more savvy do to, you know, when they go to Thanksgiving with their relatives, they talk about this? Like, what does that look like? I think, yeah, I know that the listeners are savvy enough to have a password vault and that kind of things. But even if these tools that we use or these places where we go and our information is not protected, that changes everything because there's not much we can do directly with the company.
32:05Right. So I think this goes back or falls back to we as citizens can demand from our governments and from our lawmakers to go and create the regulations needed to force everyone that is handling our data to migrate to this. And I mean, that could sound like also like something like this crazy guy is coming to say that we need to create a PQC readiness law. I'm pretty sure if I ran down to my local bank branch talking about
32:38rent, you know, I would probably be on the news that night and not for any good. Yeah, but I think at the end of the day is having an opportunity to share with the people you talk about this threat and getting everyone, making everyone conscious about the risk. And that could start moving like a community to demand this from governments. Right. Because you can really,
33:08like as an individual, you cannot do much. But as a community, there are more possibilities, there are more opportunities to get things done. And maybe it's not something that is going to happen. I think about my country and emerging markets. Our countries are like laws and regulations are the things that are, I could say, are
33:39not prioritized as they should. So we prioritize lawmakers like our Congress, usually in my country, they focus on other topics and not necessarily this type of threats. They don't even have the technical foundation to present a law like this. But I think that we as individuals can share what we know, can start building from the streets, from our neighborhoods, from our cities, and demand
34:12the government to start doing this. But yeah, I think this is a long way, but we need to start. It's definitely a long game, right? Like, I was somewhere and this was 4 or 5 years ago and they were saying like, you know, we need to start doing this. This is before This is before kind of the, the recent last couple years where this has become more and more of an urgent kind of topic. He was talking about like— no, it was 2015. He was talking about post-quantum
34:45cryptography and saying like, look, I know it's going to be years away, but it was a government IT forum. And he was saying like, well, you know, you know how quickly government moves, right? Yeah. If you want something done in 20 years, you got to start today. Yeah. Something to that effect. And no, you're right. And legislators are barely getting— if you hear the conversations going on around Capitol Hill, listeners, some listeners will know, but I used to work at Microsoft at the K Street office and work with lobbyists. These people are
35:17not technically savvy, and that's being generous. I would say of every elected official I met, there were probably only about 2 And let's just say it's like I've met 100, right? It's 2% or less, I would say. Yeah. Are technically savvy in any meaningful way. And if you watch some of the things going on now about AI and GPUs and things like that, you can tell they're not exactly, they're not exactly on the ball. And I would say that quantum is probably the wave beyond AI
35:49that they're even less aware of. Yeah. And now the focus is AI. Right. Now everybody's attention is on AI. Yeah. Yeah. So they are creating laws about everyone is thinking about how we're going to regulate this. How is this going to prevent me to lose my job or how am I going to be protected from not being unemployed or how my data is going to be protected. So
36:19I don't really think that there's going to be enough attention to PQC from legislators at some point, but I just hope that we start talking about this and at some point it will have the space it deserves. So if every CIO and technology leader listening could accomplish one thing in the next 6 months to improve their quantum readiness, what
36:52would you want that to be? I would want them to start their inventory and to know where the threats are. And with that knowledge, I think they will have a scope and roadmap to what needs to be done and how much it's going to cost.
37:23And an inventory could take 6 months, 1 year. I mean, it depends on what tools you use and how fast you move and how you map everything. So I think it's a good timeline to start To start this, this long process. Cool. I don't have any more questions. I think this is awesome. So what it is, what do you do and what does your company do to— feel free to pitch your product because folks have been kind enough to listen this long. Thank you. We've
37:56been talking to them, but, but no, I'm curious, like, what's your solution? We don't have a specific tool. what we do is we help a sector migrate in emerging markets, migrate to PQC. We do this by using inventory tools. I mean, we are open about that. We don't have like, we're tool agnostic. Then we map everything and we plan with the sector the roadmap to the migration. And we use waves. We
38:28have different ways to approach this. So we can do it, we do a pilot, check the pilot, and then we move on with all the sector. We do this using pods and waves. So we migrate the biggest organizations in the sector, let's say like a central bank. We start migrating the biggest banks and then we move to the smaller ones and start migrating everything. And then we help inside the organization to sell the
39:01PQC migration and we help establish the processes to keep compliant with everything. And then we work with the sector, with the organizations to maintain because one thing is to migrate, another thing is to migrate— sorry, to maintain. And basically that's our our proposal. And we're focusing on emerging markets. We try to be more efficient than Big 4 consultancy companies.
39:35And yeah, we are expecting or expectant about the regulations in these markets. Regulations are not coming out, but we're ready even to help create those with the regulation, with the regulators. So yeah. Cool. That's great. So if people want to find out more about you and more about your company, where should we send them? We can, well, you can find me on my LinkedIn, Pablo
40:07Carrillo, and also cubrews.com, our website. You can check it and you can send me an email at pablo@cubrews.com and we can start the discussion.