0:00Is one of the quantum advantages that quantum networks have. And security is an interesting point because in the Internet, in the evolution of that network and the networks of networks, security wasn't really front of mind and it was kind of tacked on at the end. And there are plenty of vulnerabilities and security on the Internet today. And so we do have an opportunity here to really build these security first principles into the quantum Internet as it evolves. Welcome to Impact
0:30Quantum. Hello and welcome back to Impact Quantum, the podcast where we explore the emerging industry that is quantum computing. We don't need to be a physicist. You just need to be curious about the technology. And. And with me is the most quantum curious person I know, Candice Giuli. How's it going, Candice? It's going great. Thank
1:03you, Frank. It's going great. Today we are going to be speaking with Michael Kubadoo, who is the co founder at Alero Quantum Technologies. How are you, Michael? I'm doing great. Thanks so much for having me here today. I'm really excited to have this conversation. I'm a big fan of the podcast and really honored to be here as a guest. Thank you. Thank you very much. It's always good to one find out we have fans and then two to meet one.
1:36So Alero, I'm looking at kind of their just basic talk. This looks really interesting. It's a quantum networking company. So for those may not be in the know, what exactly is a quantum networking company? So quantum networks are new kinds of networks where traditional networks send zeros and ones around. And quantum networks, while they can send zeros and ones around, they can actually send qubits or quantum states over these channels. And those channels could be fiber, they could be over free space.
2:10So it's really a way to communicate quantum data across distance. And so to build a company around quantum networking. There are many pieces of technology that comprise a quantum network from different kinds of hardware, different components, but then all of the software stack, the whole networking stack that really drives what we can do with these kinds of networks. And that's what we focus on at Alero. Interesting. So what role? I'm thinking about networks and
2:40so it just makes me think naturally of entanglement. So what role does entanglement and quantum repeaters play in making these long distance quantum networks possible? That's a really great question. And similar to the evolution of the Internet, and there were different generations on the way to the Internet that we, we know and love today. You know, it really started as, you know, a network
3:10for Science exchange and to share data across distance between labs. No one really envisioned the applications that we know and love today. And we see the same kinds of trends in, in quantum networking. And the key resource in the Internet is again, these zeros and ones and how fast you can send them, where those zeros and ones can. Can reach over a certain distance. And those are the services that, that really
3:40underpin all the great applications. And the same kind of analog applies to quantum networking, where, as you said, entanglement is one such resource, that different applications can use entanglement in different ways. Now, there's a lot more complexity with entanglement than zeros and ones. Right. There are different kinds of entangled states. This notion of fidelity, or the quality of entanglement, where there really isn't that quality of a 0 or a 1 in classical networks. So it is a different paradigm. But some analogies do apply. You can
4:14view entanglement really as a resource that the network is providing, and then you can build services and applications on top of that entanglement. But there are different generations of quantum networks, too. Quantum networks have been demonstrated now for decades. And the first generations were really about just sending single qubits or single quantum states and superposition across this network. And what you mentioned as entanglement is really what we see as the next generation of quantum networking, the kind of quantum 2.0 of networks where now we can have not just single photons or single
4:47qubits, but now entangled pairs or larger clusters of qubits that are entangled with each other and have this special correlation across distance. And that opens the door for all sorts of applications in security and computing and sensing in others. Interesting. So does that mean that this would be impervious, or I'll use that term with a little asterisk, because we don't know yet, really, does this mean that snooping would automatically be detected because you're
5:17sending the superposition so it's inherently secure? Absolutely. That's really one of the big promises. One of the quantum advantages that quantum networks have. And security is an interesting point, because in the Internet, in the evolution of that network and the networks of networks, security wasn't really front of mind, and it was kind of tacked on at the end. And there are plenty of vulnerabilities and security on the Internet today. And so we do have an opportunity here to really build
5:48these security first principles into the quantum Internet as it evolves. But that's absolutely right. These quantum physics principles, like entanglement, superposition, the no Cloning theorem, these core principles of quantum physics really drive those security properties. So as you said, spoofing or eavesdrop detection, where you can actually detect when there are some adversaries or some funkiness going on on the network that will produce patterns and measurement results from these nodes that
6:21can really detect when those things are going on. It's interesting where as you introduced this podcast focusing on quantum computing, these sensitivities of quantum states are actually a bug in quantum computing because they're very hard to control and you want a computer to be reliable and robust and isolated from the environment. This kind of noise is a bug for computing, but it's actually a feature for networking. You know, this fragility of quantum states, the sensitivity to its environment is actually what unlocks these security
6:55principles and this new kind of quantum advantage. So eavesdrop detection, spoof detection, these things are really baked into the physics itself. So theoretically it's impervious. But who knows what, who knows what conversation we'll be having in 10 to 15 years about that? Yeah, yeah, that's a great point. You know, security, they're all, you know that theoretical security is one piece of the puzzle, right? And at the end of the day, to build a quantum network, you know, it sits in a box somewhere, there's some collection of hardware, there's the
7:26software that runs it. So there are many other attack vectors to think about. But at its core, you know, that's where we really derive a lot of the security value is from that physics itself and using that physics for security. Whereas, you know, security today in the Internet, it's really based on math and assumptions about computational complexity and all sorts of. Whereas this is really a physics based approach. So for those listening and for Candace and for Michael as well, if I sound a little grumpy about that, it's not the concussion or the funky glasses. It's because I
7:59remember sitting in a training class for Windows NT, maybe 92, 93, and the instructor, who might have been a Microsoft employee, I don't remember, had basically boldly proclaimed that because it was based on the new NT kernel and various security features of that, that computer viruses would be impossible to make in the future. So again, I didn't really buy it at the time, sound a little far fetched, but
8:29I kind of sort of believed it. I was kind of on the, I was a bit in a state of superposition about it, but obviously as time moved on, clearly, you know, the anti kernel and you know, Windows XP and et cetera, et cetera have not been immune to malware. So that's why it's not that I don't trust it or I don't believe in the physics. It's just like you said, at some point this has to sit in the physical thing and what sort of software vulnerabilities will be covered. But it does give bad actors a much
9:01bigger hill to climb in order to mess with your network. That's right. And I think this is where a healthy dialogue around the security of these quantum networks. You know, what applications it's being used for, for what kind of data, what parts of the network are we talking about, what critical infrastructure is it, you know, electric grid, is it securing financial transactions, government communications? There are all sorts of security requirements and compliance and different regulations around
9:35what security means operationally to these stakeholders. So that's a really healthy conversation and one that's worth having on the international stage as we start to think about standards and how to roll this out in the right way to make sure these networks can talk to each other securely, even if they're using different approaches to build quantum networks. So that's a really healthy conversation, and that's what I think we can expect in the coming years as this technology really matures. But, you know, we all really agree on this kind of,
10:05you know, the driver, the core principles of using physics and the laws of physics for security first. And, you know, it's a lot harder to break the laws of physics than it may be to find a side channel attack. Right. So, you know, but this is the discussion we need to be having. It's like, what, what do these attack vectors look like? You know, what do quantum adversaries look like? What do we project our adversaries will be using as new tools? Is it AI? Is it quantum? Is it some mixture of both to try
10:35and attack these networks? Is it to read communications off the wire, or is it easier to blackmail someone? Right. You know, but these are. These are practical considerations that we have to think about, you know, in the coming years as we start to really roll this out in production. It's really exciting. Everything that it's touching upon, it's quantum networking. What advice would you give to a researcher or an entrepreneur who's passionate about entering the space?
11:08That's a great question. One thing that's important to know is that quantum computing is coming. And even experts within the field couldn't say that confidently even a few years ago. It's no longer a matter of if, but a matter of when. And I think all the great advances in error correction have really made the case that quantum computing is really on a trajectory
11:38to hit the stage in production sooner than than we thought, which is great. But you know, with any sort of emerging technology with this kind of power and potential, you know, we understand that this, in the wrong hands or in adversarial hands, can be used to, to attack, you know, the digital security that we rely on today. So we need to prepare for that. Now the question becomes how do we prepare our networks to become quantum safe, to become
12:09quantum resistant, to become quantum secure. And you hear these words thrown around a lot, but that's extremely important for governments, for critical infrastructure, our energy grids, our banks, to really think about migrating to a quantum safe, a quantum aware posture for their cybersecurity. The attacks are ever changing and we're seeing this play out on many different stages in military contexts and political conflicts, in hacks, right? There are all
12:40sorts of cyber attacks. And now with AI playing a big role as well. It's not just quantum. Just have more awareness that technology is moving very rapidly at an increasing pace. And we need to prepare our networks and our critical infrastructure, not take it for granted and be proactive about it and don't be reactive. So that's the advice, I'd say, just awareness around these attacks, preparing for that, and doing research into what's out there
13:10to protect these networks. Where does having this physics layer make sense for your data, for your kind of network? There are a lot of organizations figuring out right now, how much of my stuff do I want in the cloud versus on prem, how much do I trust these big hyperscalers and cloud vendors? And so as they're going through this migration, figuring out, okay, how much AI am I going to adopt, how much cloud am I going to adopt? Where does my network security lie in
13:40that? It's all a related problem. It's very hard to decouple. So this is not a problem that's decades out that it's fun to think about and a good exercise. Now this is something that's very important and a complex topic to start breaking down. So even just doing the inventory of what's in place right now, what am I using for security? Who wrote that code? Was it a decade ago and is that engineer still on staff? Is it written in an old programming language that I don't have an engineering team to support?
14:14So those questions, just doing the surveying, the inventory can take a long time and it's very complex. So getting started on that process today is really critical. And that's the practical advice I would give. Then it sounds like you're describing sbom or secure bill of materials is going to be a part of a. And that makes sense, right? Like it makes. So for those who don't know, we'll have to explain that because my wife works in IT security. So I kind of, I kind of know some of the goings on in terms. But one of the,
14:45I think that, I think you're right. I think we have to have a, as a society, you know, that is increasingly reliant on this technology and to have very frank conversations, no pun intended, about how we secure infrastructure. Right. I mean, look at the chaos that having us east one of us going down caused. All the way from, you know, oh, you know, websites go down all the way to, you know, some people had IoT devices that were basically locked including. And I'll pick on them, I'll pick on them for many
15:18years to come. Is the smart bed. Apparently there was a smart bed that was collecting, you know, measures how well you sleep and all that. But it would not do anything unless it could talk to us east one. And you know, we're recording this a day after a massive Verizon outage. Right. Right. So it, you know, we need to understand what our know, vulnerability of it because, you know, for all we know, these are just
15:49natural happenings. Right. Not a coordinated cyber attack, for all we know. Right. We'll never, you know, what will we ever really know the full truth? Maybe. But, but Candace shaking her head no, like I probably not. But you know, but I mean, what if this was, you know, what if this was a coordinated attack? Like how, you know, how vulnerable are we really? Yeah. And another, you know, point to that, to that end is around,
16:21you know, attacks that are happening now that, that we don't even know about, that we can't see directly that aren't, you know, taking user facing applications down and you know, making a big fuss in the public eye. You know, there are adversaries out there that are just harvesting data. They're, you know, even if they can't crack it yet, they're harvesting it. And some years down the road when they have access to these, you know, high scale compute systems and quantum computers, they'll be able to, you know, look back in time and crack that communication.
16:54So this is especially important for, you know, the kinds of data that you want to keep secret for a very long time, whether that's, you know, sensitive financial records, if it's medical records, if it's Government communications nation secrets. Right. These, there are certain classes of data that you want to remain secure for decades. Right. And so, but that's a threat that's happening now, the harvesting, you know, it opens you up to this kind of attack at some point in
17:25the future. So a lot of what we do and we engage with these security stakeholders is to just make them aware that this is happening and you know, to drive the urgency to be proactive today and making them understand that, you know, these kinds of attacks that aren't visible are still happening. And we do have a lot of dependencies on, you know, certain cloud infrastructure, data centers, physical infrastructure and these undersea cables. Right. You know, we need to think hard and take a close look at what are our
17:57dependencies, how do we mitigate them and what are the attacks that, that take priority. Right. That's a good way to put it. And I know Candice is itching to ask you questions and I don't want to monopolize your time, but after Candace's, I want to go through your because one, your website's awesome and two, I have some questions about some of the use cases because those are things I never considered and those look awesome. Sorry, Candice, go ahead. No, no, it's totally fine. So let me ask you, so what
18:28role do you see simulation in hybrid classic classical quantum systems playing in building and testing quantum networks before large scale deployment? Yeah, it's a great question and that's really why we've spent many years building a very robust simulation platform and a product, as you said rightly so. This is a complex technology,
18:58it's one that's evolving. As Frank mentioned, there are other use cases beyond security that I'd love to get into. But you know, we have, we have to coexist with what's here today. Right. We can't lay down a whole new infrastructure just for quantum. There's fiber in the ground. It's very expensive to lay new fiber. There's technology we can leverage today. Let's use it. There are lessons we can take from the Internet. There's you know, classical security and math based security
19:29that, that we use every day and every time you see that lock icon and your URL, that's encryption and we need to coexist with those mechanisms. It's well baked and very prevalent throughout. That's really the role simulation can play is to help figure out, okay, as I start implementing a quantum friendly or quantum enabled infrastructure, how does it coexist with what I have today? What fiber am I Using in the ground.
20:00What does it look like to introduce quantum devices onto my network? How can I combine these new quantum security applications with my existing security applications? You mentioned smart beds. Am I going to get qubits to your smart bed? Probably not. There's no quantum WI fi. And so what that means is, you know, when we talk about rolling out quantum networking and quantum security, quantum encryption, it needs to be
20:31deployed in the right places for the right use cases. And over time that may grow. But we know that not everything is going to be quantum. The quantum Internet is not going to replace the classical Internet by any means. It is going to augment it. It's going to add new capabilities for certain applications, certain parts of the network. But classical networks will absolutely play a role in our future. And so we need to coexist with what's there.
21:03Simulation is really critical to address those questions, to figure out how to build these hybrid networks where parts of your network are just classical, parts of them have quantum communication on it. How can those nodes talk to each other end to end in a secure way? So it's the networking, the protocols, the security, but also the physics. Right. We need to model how these networks work, what kind of hardware you, you actually need to build a quantum network for a certain scale, what kinds of rates and fidelities you need.
21:36There are all sorts of trade offs when designing a quantum network. And so simulation is really critical not just in planning and designing a quantum network, but figuring out how to scale it, how to introduce these new applications, simulating new kinds of protocols beyond just symmetric keys and encryption keys. So there's all sorts of use cases for quantum simulation that is much cheaper than actually acquiring some of this quantum specialized hardware, which could be quite pricey in some cases.
22:08Okay, interesting. Go ahead, Frank. All right, I'm chomping at the bit because one, one, your website's really well designed. And two, networking quantum computers, solving the scaling problem. That is the one that blew my mind. If you're watching the video, you can see when I really click through that, that is a, that is an amazing concept where, you know, it reads like. And I don't know how, you know, you know, is this happening now where I could have, say, if I have a quantum computer, I can
22:42network with that with another one and I can have basically clusters of quantum computing, which is not something I heard a lot of people talk about yet, you know, they always show like, here's our chandelier, right, you know, and all that. But like the whole idea of having like, basically an entire, you know, cluster of these chandeliers. How real is that? Yeah, that's a great question, and I'm glad we have an opportunity to talk about how quantum networks really
23:12enable quantum computing. So quantum networks are not just good for security, and they're not good just for long distance communication. What is a data center? A data center is a network of clustered compute resources, even GPU clusters. You know, there's the famous saying, the network is the computer, right? The same principle applies here for quantum computing. You know, the conversation, as you pointed out, used to be, my qubit is better than yours. My, my material, my platform has better fidelity, or it's faster, or it's this or that, or it
23:45can run longer circuits. There are all sorts of metrics that the quantum computing community would talk about. Now we're entering a phase where, you know, we used to have small, noisy, intermediate scale quantum computers, which could have maybe a dozen qubits, and they're very unreliable and noisy. But really, over the past years, since we started Alero, we've seen the amazing advances in quantum computing where now we're at the orders of hundreds or
24:16thousands of qubits. We now have error correction, we have, you know, some level of protecting against noise. And so the conversation is starting to shift from here's why my qubit is better than yours to here's why my path to scalability is better than yours. And I think that's the critical transition in the dialogue that we're seeing. It's all about scalability. Now that I've achieved the error correction threshold, I can build a logical qubit. How do I scale to millions and millions of qubits? And the same
24:50thing with classical computers and GPUs and CPUs, there's no monolithic single chip that runs everything, right? A data center is a network of small computers. And the same thing applies to quantum computing. So now that opens all sorts of fun questions around what does that quantum data center look like? What does the quantum network look like to actually communicate qubits across different quantum computers? And that's some of the networking
25:20problems that we solve with rstack as well. How to manage quantum traffic between computers, how to manage all the scheduling and the different timescales that these quantum computers operate at? How to provide this reliable entanglement as a service, as a resource to these different compute clusters? There are all sorts of interesting questions from, you know, not only a physics aspect, but the whole networking stack, the compute stack, to support it and just to throw another curveball in there we have GPUs to play with as well.
25:52Nvidia has invested a lot of, you know, money and resources into playing a big role in really pioneering how quantum computers will interact with their GPUs. Right. So you're going to have this hybrid quantum data center. You have quantum computers, you have GPUs. You might have different kinds of quantum computers playing a role. You have CPUs, you have networks that are quantum networks that are classical. They all need to work together, they all need to be orchestrated and play this complex dance with each other so we can solve really
26:26large scale and impactful problems. Wow. I'm sorry, Candice. I'll say. So from your perspective, what are the most realistic near term use cases for quantum networking beyond the pure research? Yeah, great question. There are all sorts of applications for a quantum network. And you know, one
26:56common misconception that we face is when folks hear the word quantum, they either think about a Marvel movie or something mythical and very far off into the future. There's that camp, there's the other camp that's quantum aware and they hear the word quantum and they think about quantum computing. And that's really dominated the, the airwaves and, and the discourse for quantum technology, and rightly so. It has, you know, many huge potentials in, in solving problems exponentially faster than, than other kinds of
27:30computers. That's great. But one thing we face is that to build a useful quantum network, you don't need a quantum computer. There are other kinds of quantum devices, special quantum lasers and detectors and other sorts of optics and photonics that you don't need a full scale quantum computer to do these security applications. For example, to generate secure keys between nodes, to have a secure link. You know, you don't need a quantum computer to do that. So those are the use cases that are near term those ones where we don't rely
28:02on error correction and fault tolerant quantum computers. We just have security and key generation and these other sorts of applications. In the near term, I think in the medium term, we'll see other kinds of security applications, not just for keys, but to actually use the quantum channel to encode our sensitive data. So using what's called quantum secure direct communication, there's teleportation, there's new kinds of authentication methods. So we
28:36can actually use these quantum networks to verify location and to verify the position of nodes on a network. This is something you can't do classically. So this is a way that quantum position verification has this non spoofing property. To it, which is really nice. So we expect that in the medium term as well. And then in the long term we can think about distributed quantum computing where you're connecting quantum computers over a long distance. There's
29:06great applications not just in computing, but the security of that computing as well. So who's going to own these quantum computers? Is it the cloud titans? Right. If so, how do I actually securely send my, my algorithm, my computation to the cloud, to the US Quantum east one and get those results back securely? And doing so without showing Amazon or showing the cloud vendor, what is my algorithm, what's my proprietary data that I'm putting into that quantum computer? So quantum networks can
29:39also help out with the security of those large scale quantum computing use cases. But that's in the longer term. So to answer your question, in the tldr, security is near term and over time there are all these other sorts of applications in computing and sensing, even some far fetched ones as well, like quantum money. There's the potential to have more trustworthy elections and leader election kinds of applications, secret sharing, there's all
30:11some really cool distributed protocols we can use entanglement for and we're really excited about those. But you know, as a company we have to be focused on what's here today, what's commercially viable, what are folks interested in, what is the market telling us they need and how can quantum networks serve those needs. So that's front of mind for us, you know, on the day today. But you know, of course we spend some time researching these long term applications. Yeah, it's interesting you mentioned quantum money. Is that some kind of crypto thing?
30:41Because I've never heard that before. Yeah, so it's interesting, quantum money is actually one of the first distributed quantum algorithms that was conceived of, I think it was in the 60s. I have to double check on that. But the first concepts of quantum money, yeah, it's decentralized. It's basically using essentially a quantum signature that can't be forged. So with today's digital currencies there is, you know, there
31:13are security vulnerabilities and forgery blockchain is done, you know, designed to be decentralized, of course. But with quantum money the idea is you can have these quantum signatures where you can have, you know, let's say a bank be the only ones to verify whether this piece of currency is real. So they're fun exercises in thinking about how these quantum physics principles can be used for, for money and to stop forgery. That actually inspired
31:47some of the, the work for quantum key distribution, which came later. So it's kind of an interesting evolution. And I've heard Peter Shore talk about this where there's quantum money that inspired quantum key distribution. And the folks who invented quantum key distribution asked Peter Shor to work on a security proof for it. That security proof led Peter Shor to ultimately discover Shor's algorithm, which really inspired all the quantum computing progress. So it's, it's kind of
32:18a fun history lesson. But you know, quantum money, while it's very far looking and very long term application, was one of the first ideas of quantum networking that came out in the middle of last century. Interesting, interesting. So a lot of unpack, a lot to unpack. But the short thing is, you know, when it comes to conventional networking, we all understand what a gigabit is. We all understand what, you know, megabit is like. Are there
32:49similar, like what are the speeds that we're talking about with quantum networking? Yeah, great question. There are many factors that go into determining what is the speed of a quantum network. And the biggest factor being the distance of your channel. So if we're doing this in fiber, fiber is quite lossy and we lose a lot of our flying qubits. So that really determines what is the maximum rate that
33:19we can transmit quantum data. There's all other sorts of factors, like how fast are your lasers and your entanglement sources, how good are your detectors, you know, the quality of your hardware will determine that, that rate. But there are analogs, right? We and I touched on this in a recent research paper I did with, with NIST on quantum routing, entanglement routing. And in there we start to make some analogs between, you know, metrics. What,
33:50what are the metrics we know and love from the classical Internet. So things like throughput bandwidth, you know, your typical performance metrics. Do those apply to quantum networks? In some cases, yes, it's a direct analog. In some cases, no, it's a very different paradigm. In some cases, yes, but it's a very different kind of unit. So you mentioned throughput as an example. What are the rates in a quantum network that could be, you know, qubits per second, it could be entangled pairs per second. But again, with quantum networks you have this notion
34:23of quality fidelity that you don't have in zeros and ones. So which brings an interesting question about the quality of service of these quantum networks. So some applications, they really need a very high rate of entanglement. They really need qubits as fast as possible, but they don't care that they need. You know, if they're 99% fidelity. Other applications, they don't care if it's, if it's that fast. They just need really good quality of entanglement. So building a network stack, building
34:53a network that can service these different kinds of applications. And so you can have these, these knobs that you can tune, whether that's rate, whether that's fidelity, whether it's the network complexity and the switching capabilities. There are all sorts of metrics to think about. But we started to address those questions a little bit. And I know there are plenty of groups out there thinking about quantum networking metrics and I think that's something we can work on as a, as a community to have a common language. What metrics are important, what's going to drive economic value? How do we start to understand
35:26what these metrics actually mean for commercial use? Right. I can imagine like at some point in the future you'll be like, in the distant future, everyone, distant future, I'll be in the store of a Best Buy or like Micro center and like, hey, this is the 10 gigabit, you know, and this is the 20 gigabit, you know, quantum router or something like that. Like, I mean, you're right. Like, and does it even make sense? You're right. Like we need to figure out like, you know, what numbers make sense. Right, right, right. And is it, you know, you can buy
35:58a box or a laser at a certain rate and you know, there are those kinds of components available commercial off the shelf today. You can, you know, buy a photon source that generates, you know, this many pairs per second at say a gigahertz rate or a kilohertz rate. It's tuned to this wavelength or that wavelength. Does that make sense for your application? What kinds of distances could that actually cover point to point? So there's, there's all other sorts of questions around it. But yeah, I think, you know, we're starting to see that emerge
36:29and especially over the, the past seven years or so that, that we've been working at Olero, we've really seen that trend pick up and so many amazing quantum hardware startups focused on networking that are building these entanglement sources, these photon sources, these photon detectors, the quantum switches, all the components we need quantum memories as well, quantum repeaters that are, that are being worked on. And we're seeing so much activity in that space. And as Oliro, we're really focused on
37:00kind of the networking stack and the software part of it. And we partner with as Many of these companies as we can, in these groups that have these components that we need to, to build a network and to actually operate it. So that's been really encouraging to see and I'm excited to continue that, that to watch that space and to foster those relationships with, with those companies, because it does take a village. No one company has all the right pieces, just like the Internet. There's no, you know, single service provider.
37:31There's no one company that can do it. All right? It takes components from all sorts of vendors, takes contributions from standards organizations, from software companies, from hardware companies to build a network that we can actually use. You've mentioned several different metrics. Is there a single metric you trust most when evaluating the maturity of a quantum system, or does it always depend on the context?
38:02It's a really great question and a timely one that, you know, we're working on in some industry consortium, and I was just at a conference last month talking about this exact thing. Like what, what are the important metrics? What is the common language and the definition of these metrics? I think it will be some combination of these performance metrics like rate, like fidelity, and like distance, because those are the. Broadly the things we care about. Right. How,
38:32how broad is this network? You know, what geographies does it cover that tells us what kinds of applications we can think about. The rates and the fidelities tell us what kind of, you know, service quality can this quantum network provide? If it's too slow or if it's not good enough, then, you know, we can't rely on the security of these things. Or we. That that's not fast enough to connect quantum computers over this distance. Right. So knowing that is really critical, but I think it will be some combination of
39:04speed, of quality, and of distance. Interesting. Wow. I mean, there's a lot to consider here. Right. Like it's not just about. And one of the other use cases. I know we're running low on time, so I have to probably have you come back. Quantum sensor networks, which, if I, if I were to posit what quantum networking is for, is you want to be able to sense the state of the particles and the entanglement and then be able to send that state over a. What, over a wire?
39:38Bear with me over something. Right. And then it be preserved on the other side where it could be read or whatever, done whatever with. Is that. Is that correct? Yeah, there's. So quantum sensors are arguably the most mature subfield of quantum technologies. And quantum sensors have been around and, you know, we're Talking about clocks, we're talking about magnetic sensors, sensors for electric fields,
40:08RF sensors, all sorts of sensors that have been worked on for decades and deployed and used today in systems that we, we use every day. You know, gps, Right. So quantum sensors are very mature. But when you bring up networking quantum sensors, that's, that's really an interesting intersection point of these two fields where quantum sensors are great at measuring, you know, something very locally with great degrees of precision. But when we think
40:38about networking these together and maybe entangling an array of sensors over a network, that opens the door for some really interesting applications, both for geodesy, for mapping, for not relying on gps, for sensing fluctuations in the magnetic field and the electric field. Doing better astronomy, how we collect light from stars and using entanglement to process that light in better ways so we can have higher resolution for, say, black hole
41:10imaging. There are all sorts of deep science questions that can be answered with, with quantum sensors in a distributed setting, which is a really, really exciting frontier that the community is thinking about deeply. Oh, because the earth rotates, so you could have a couple of these sensors. So that way you're always pointed at the same thing in space. Right. And one, yeah, one first example of this is ligo. So, you know, basically we have these telescopes
41:41collecting light from stars. And the way things are done today is that, you know, this light is collected, that data is processed using classical computers. And all those telescopes around the world will share their data, they'll bring it together, they'll aggregate it and they'll process it and try and generate an image or some kind of data, you know, end result for science. Now, how quantum changes the game there is, you know, if these telescopes are actually entangled with each other,
42:12you can process that light in a very different way. Instead of just post processing it on a classical computer, you can use these, these global entangled states to sense that light in a very different way, to process it in a very different way. Ultimately, with the quantum computer, they're all, you know, sorts of new features. You can think about sensing and imaging for astronomy in that, in that application. So yeah, it's a really, really interesting space. Wow, that's funny. Sorry, Candice, I'm just going to say. No,
42:46I'm taking it all in. I'm taking it all in. So what kinds of measurements become possible with quantum sensor networks that simply can't be done with classical sensing systems? Yeah, it's a great question and I think the field is thinking deeply about this question, you know, where, so there's Kinds of evolutions of this whereby, you know, we can have one sensor that's great for many applications. Say it's an
43:17inertial sensor that's awesome for, you know, aircraft and it has applications on its own. Then the next generation is, okay, what if we have a network of sensors but there's no quantum connections between them? They're just, they're individual quantum sensors that are, that can exchange data with each other classically. So that has, you know, some advantages there just as, as an array. And then the next generation is, oh, what if they are also entangled with each other? And then you can get more advantage.
43:51So the advantages come in precision and in accuracy. And as you have these sensors working together, you can actually enhance the precision that way. So there's something called the standard quantum limit where there's a square root performance benefit with the number of sensors you have. So if you have K sensors working together, you can get that square root K advantage in your precision and accuracy. So there are, you know, there's a lot of great theory kind of backing this up.
44:21I think the field writ large is thinking about, you know, what are those killer applications, you know, in the near term, in the medium term, you know, we have quantum networking on its own as a field, we have quantum sensing on its own as a field. So how do we intersect these, these two timelines and roadmaps and technology to actually work together to solve certain problems in science and position, navigation, timing and astronomy, all sorts of application areas.
44:53Wow, that's cool. I mean, I just, it's just mind blowing. Like what? Because you know, you hear about the hype about quantum computers, you don't think about the networking. Right. Networking doesn't always come up in the hype cycle. Right. However, very clearly, like you said, like, you know, you don't need to have a quantum computer to do quantum networking. Right. I would imagine that these photon generators and things like that, they probably don't need to be super cooled. Guessing. So you could have this
45:23today with relatively modest comparatively investment. Oh yeah, that's definitely right. Yeah. Quantum computers probably cost on the order of tens of millions of dollars and quantum networks orders of magnitude less than that. And there are off the shelf components you can buy and start to piece together these networks. There are all sorts of quantum photon sources and entanglement generators and photon detectors, all with different trade offs. Right.
45:54Some are tuned to certain wavelengths. Right. They want to operate in the telecom regime. Others are great for visible light and free space. And that may lend itself better to say A satellite link or an inter satellite link. Some lasers might be better for fiber networks. Some lasers are faster than others, but generate a different kind of entanglement. So a lot of what we think about is like, okay, you have this landscape out there of all sorts of components and different approaches to generating quantum light. How do we stitch them together? How do
46:28these components actually interoperate with each other, not just at the physical level, but over a network? How can they communicate with each other? What is a quantum network node? It's a collection of dozens of these things, right? You're going to have switches and photon sources and detectors. But it needs to be useful. There needs to be some logic, some control, some timing and synchronization infrastructure that actually supports all of these great applications. So that's what we spend most of our time thinking about, is building out these abstraction layers in the network stack to actually get these
47:01components to talk to each other in a useful way. Wow. So this seems to me like this could be a burgeoning career field. Really, like a quantum network engineer? Absolutely, yeah. And I think that's testament to how we've built our team and grown the team over time. It takes a village. And I think within all the subdomains of quantum. I would say quantum networking is the most interdisciplinary. We have folks on staff that are the PhD quantum physicists, but
47:32we have folks that worked in classical networking and built the products that power the Internet. They know what it takes to build a network stack. They know what it takes to deploy a system in a data center or for a telecommunications company. What does it take to have five nines of service reliability? That's something in the classical networking space is a must have. So taking those lessons learned from the classical networking world, combining that with the quantum expertise, and of course all of the amazing backgrounds we need to actually build products and reliable
48:06software products. So we have traditional software engineers, but out in the field, we're going to need traditional fiber engineers as well. So that's something that I'm excited to see over the coming years, is a workforce development for quantum networking and having upskilling programs to make this less daunting, to lower the barrier to entry. There are so many great engineers out there, and they don't need a PhD level quantum education to be
48:36to have a career in quantum networking. There are trade schools that train fiber engineers today, and those folks can be absolutely useful with minimal training, you know, to set up this infrastructure, to monitor it, to, you know, go out and learn how to, you know, fix some issues. That we might see in the network to do updates, to do, you know, ads and changes, and to scale the network. There are all sorts of field engineering that we're going to need to really make this a reality. You know, we talk about the quantum Internet. We're well, well away from that. But,
49:10you know, right now we're, we're at the point where you do see these metropolitan regions, these local area networks. There's dozens and dozens of them around the world. What's the natural next step is to start connecting them over longer distances. And you know, that that's how we're going to get there. But it, it doesn't take only quantum PhDs to do that. You know, we need practical engineering expertise, we need classical engineering expertise to really make this a reality. It's a good way to put it. As I like to say, someone has to rack them and stack them. That's right, yeah.
49:43So we always ask this of everybody. So what is the biggest misconception that you hear out there about quantum computing that you would like to reframe or just let them know this is, this is wrong? What's one of the biggest misconceptions out there? You know, I think for many years that I've been in this space, the misconception was that there is going to be one single
50:16winner of quantum computing. There's going to be a winning platform and that's going to look like a huge chandelier that has millions and millions of qubits on it. That's not the case. The future of quantum computing is going to be heterogeneous. I think different kinds of qubits will play different roles. I think, apart from, you know, maybe certain modalities. I think broadly, most of the quantum computing approaches will need to be networked. That's the only way
50:49they're going to reach scale. The difference is how many qubits can I get before I have to think about networking? Some might be on the order of a couple thousand. Others think they can scale on a single chip or a single atomic system to say 50 or 100,000 qubits, and then they need to network. So there's some difference there. But regardless, to get to the utility scale of quantum computing, you're going to need to network them. And that's something I'd like to shed some more light on. And I'm glad
51:20the community has kind of woken up and seen the need for networking these computers together recently. And that wasn't always the case. So I still think it's somewhat of a misconception. But for quantum computing to realize that they need to network, I mean IBM just announced their plans to network their computers just to few months ago. Right. So you know, we're starting to see that shift. But yeah, shining more light on that is really important. Interesting.
51:52You had mentioned a couple times something called free space. I think I know what that means, but I don't think I do like totally. Is this kind of like white space spectrum that's available or something else? Yeah, so free space we use as a term to describe a quantum channel that's not over fiber. So okay, it's wireless now. There is a caveat there. So you know the WI fi router I'm using now can those signals can
52:23permeate through walls and things. The quantum signals, at least for quite some time, will need to be line of sight when you're talking about point to point free space. But there have been satellite deployments, we're working on some, some satellite deployments as well for quantum networks with our partners in the aerospace sector, which is really, really exciting. That's a critical part of the quantum Internet. It's not just going to be fiber.
52:53If you really want to generate entanglement cross continents, cross oceans, we're going to need a satellite infrastructure to do that. But you do need this line of sight. And so that's what free space means for quantum networking. We won't be able to have a quantity quantum WI fi unless there's some, you know, huge advancements and physics breakthroughs in terms of like microwave photons, but we can't depend on that. I think it's safe to say that, you know, the quantum communication will be
53:24line of sight. So you need to be able to see your end node. Yeah. We had a previous guest, Dr. Catania Kuntz, had mentioned that they basically has. It's whatever she uses in her research is probably not limited to some flavor of infrared light and things like that, but okay, free space. I thought when you said free space I thought you meant like spectrum that's available or whatever. The TV white space is what people used to call it, but that means something completely different. That's really cool and thank you for
53:57explaining that. Any parting thoughts? Where can folks find out more about you, more about what LERO is doing? Yeah, sure. You know, I'm really, really excited to get the chance to talk about quantum networking and its importance not just in security and for, you know, governments and companies today, but also all the cool applications that that can be derived from quantum networking. I think Security is
54:28one that draws a lot of the attention. But you know, we do play some of that fear motivation. Right. We need to prepare our infrastructure for the quantum attacks. Absolutely. Like we need to drive that urgency. But at the same time, this is an infrastructure play. Right. This is, this quantum Internet that we talk about has all sorts of amazing applications and I'm sure a lot that we haven't even dreamt of. Just like the Internet, right as it was getting started, we did not think about a Facebook or, you know, this,
54:59all the Internet services that we TikTok, brain rot, all that stuff. Yeah, probably not thought about. Yeah. You know, there's a lot of room for innovation and it's a really, really exciting field to be in. And so I really appreciate the opportunity to talk about it today. Feel free to reach out. We do also run a webinar series as well if you want to learn more about what a quantum network is. How does it work, what are the, you know, the trade offs, you know, everything from a
55:30101 to what does it look like to deploy a quantum satellite? We try and address all those topics in an educational way. So feel free to check out our website, check out that webinar series if you want to learn more about quantum networking. And as always, feel free to reach out to me as well. Very cool. Any parting thoughts, Candice? No. Thank you so much for this conversation. I think the quantum networking is absolutely fascinating and we're hearing more about it from the different perspectives. So I'm just really happy that we, we got to hear about it from yours. So thank you again for your time.
56:02Of course. It's an honor being here. Thanks so much. Thank you for coming. And I really, I really learned quite a bit today. I hope our listeners did too. And with that, we'll play the outro music. And it's gold.
56:34The multiverse is skanking Skanking in time Black holes are wailing in a horn line so fine From Planck scales to planets they're connecting the dots Candace and Frank they're the cosmic Han shots. Quantum podcast turn it up fast Candace and Frank blowing my mind at last Quantum podcast They're breaking the mold Science has got beats it's bold and it's gold.