Big thanks to Alpha School for being the presenting sponsor of this episode. When I was in school, I constantly found myself thinking: “We can do so much better than this.” Alpha School is what I wish existed back then. Kids learn everything they need in only two hours per day, so they can spend the rest of the time actual learning life skills: public speaking, building a business, negotiating, etc. If you want your kid to love school and join classes that rank in the top 1% nationwide, Alpha School is the place to be. Learn more at https://go.alpha.school/howiwrite. Andy Weir is on the show today, and he's famous for books like Project Hail Mary and The Martian, both of which turned into iconic movies.In this conversation, we discuss science fiction as much as writing. How does he come up with new ideas? What makes for a good plot? How does he think through the science itself, bending reality in fun and playful ways?This interview does have some spoilers! So, if you haven't read the books, you might want to do that before you listen. However, if you love writing and don't care about spoilers, this conversation is for you. Transcript 00:01:02 How Andy turns ideas into books00:07:45 Why you should avoid flashbacks00:11:07 How to make readers trust your story00:16:55 Give your character one fear00:23:55 How he wrote Rocky00:28:32 You should plant clues for your reader00:30:38 Why Andy avoids symbolism00:33:42 How The Martian became a bestseller00:45:44 Do you need a publisher?00:49:46 Two rules for a great plot00:53:54 Is sci-fi really a genre?00:59:10 Will AI write better than humans?01:06:13 Andy’s heroes and recommendations David (01:02-01:12): I want to hear about how you approach the premise of a science fiction book. Let’s start with Project Hail Mary, but I’m interested in any patterns we can draw between your different works. Andy (01:12-03:32): It usually starts with me daydreaming about interesting science. I’ll think, “Wouldn’t it be cool if this happened?” or “Wouldn’t that be interesting?” For Project Hail Mary, the kernel of the idea began with a desire for a mass conversion-based fuel - something that could turn matter into light for propulsion. This would be incredibly fuel-efficient. Initially, I considered a mad scientist inventing it as a great breakthrough, but that strained credibility a little. Perhaps they found an alien spaceship with the fuel, but then they’d use it up, and that would be the end. I wanted it to be an infrastructural element that humanity could mass produce and manufacture. What if the fuel itself had a mechanism for making more fuel? You could shine light at it, turning that light into mass, then trigger a reaction to convert the mass back into light, working back and forth. Again, that felt like a hand-wavy tech. Plus, people would probably be far more interested in the alien ship itself than just the fuel. While it’s cool to show its capabilities, the alien ship it came from would likely be more interesting to readers. Then I thought, “If it makes more of itself when given energy, that sounds like life.” What if it’s a life form that uses mass conversion? If it’s an alien life form, how do we acquire it? Why does it possess this ability? Those questions answered themselves: I decided it’s a microbe, a mold that grows on stars and then spores out, just like terrestrial mold. It needs to reach other stars, and the only way to do that is through some form of propulsion. So, it ultimately evolved mass conversion. In the back of my mind, I realized we’d have to ensure none of that got onto our sun because that would be catastrophic. That was the story. They don’t find the spores; they only discover it once the sun is already infected. Things started to snowball from there. Now, Earth faces an existential problem. I wanted them to use the astrophage. So, I decided there’s one star that’s not affected, and they need to travel there to investigate. Fortunately, they have astrophage. David (03:32-03:40): So, break this down for me. What about that premise makes it work? What are the different parameters? Andy (03:41-04:57): In terms of storytelling, there are definite stakes: the potential death of billions of humans. An extinction-level event on Earth would cause billions to die. Humanity would survive, but it wouldn’t be great. The stakes are very high because humanity is at stake. It’s a desperate mission, not a well-organized endeavor. They have a limited amount of mass they can send all the way out there, making the stakes desperate. A very small number of people are tasked with saving the world, which sounds like an exciting story, and it allows me to do all my sciencey stuff. I had always wanted to do a first contact story, and all these elements came together. Hail Mary was actually a pastiche of several story ideas I had that I glued together and then sanded off the seams. For instance, I always wanted to do a first contact story. I liked the idea of a mass conversion-based fuel. I had an unrelated story that I abandoned earlier about a woman who was given godlike authority over all governments to solve an existential crisis, and that’s where Stratt came from. David (04:58-05:04): How do you think about stakes? Stakes strike me as the propulsion of the story, the thing that keeps it going. Andy (05:04-05:09): This is the first time I’ve written a story where the stakes are all of humanity. David (05:09-05:09): Right. Andy (05:09-05:37): Before, I tended to like personal stakes. In The Martian, it was one guy’s life, and that was it, but it kept you interested. In Artemis, the stakes are just Jazz Bashara’s well-being. She wants to improve her life, and if she gets caught, she’ll get deported back to Earth, and her life will be ruined. She wouldn’t even die, so it’s even lower stakes. But this one, I thought, “All of humanity.” David (05:37-05:38): Is that easier or harder? Andy (05:40-05:55): In this case, it was easier because that’s the emergent problem that arises. However, I sometimes get a little tired of science fiction feeling like it has to have global stakes. David (05:55-05:56): Right. Andy (05:56-06:17): Love stories, action movies, and dramas don’t need planetary stakes. People don’t feel the need for them in those stories. But for some reason, in science fiction, the fate of the world often literally hangs in the balance. I don’t know why those two are linked. I’d like to try to keep the stakes lower. David (06:17-06:21): When you come up with a premise, how do you then go from premise to draft? Andy (06:22-06:44): Generally, I think about the major turning points of the story. There are typically four or five events that create an interesting plot arc. Then I just start writing. I make things up as I go along. I know I need to get from one plot point to the next, but I’m not sure exactly how we’ll get there. David (06:44-06:51): What’s an example from Project Hail Mary where you knew the key turning points, and then what were some of the fun diversions along the way? Andy (06:51-07:45): At the beginning, I decided he would wake up with amnesia, having no idea what was happening. The first thing he needed to do was figure out he was on a spacecraft. In the movie, the Hail Mary is a huge ship with lots of windows, but in the book, he’s in a sealed environment. There’s no reason for windows on the ship; they have cameras. There’s no reason to add weak points like that. So, his initial task is realizing he’s on a spacecraft. Once he does, he needs to realize he’s in the Tau Ceti system, not Earth. That’s a significant reveal. The next big reveal involves flashbacks related to Astrophage, which I tease out for the reader. Then, the next major reveal is Rocky and the arrival of another ship. They go through their first contact process, and by the end, they’re able to communicate. I had to figure out how they would achieve that. David (07:45-08:05): How do you approach building the human character early in the book? It starts with basic questions like… Get full access to David Perell's How I Write at howiwrite.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Andy Weir is on the show today, who's famous for books like Project Hail Mary and The Martian, both of which turned into movies. Project Hail Mary with Ryan Gosling as the star, The Martian with Matt Damon. In this conversation, it's as much about science fiction as it is about writing. Yeah, I asked him about his process. How does he come up with new ideas? But also, I had to ask about science fiction. What makes for a good plot? How does he think through the science itself and bending reality in all sorts of fun and playful ways? And what you're gonna notice about Andy is that he's extremely enthusiastic about what he does.
SPEAKER_01He just loves this craft. And then also, I never thought about this, but he doesn't really think of science fiction as a genre. He thinks of it like a setting. Like, for example, you won't just have science fiction, you'll have science fiction with a love story, science fiction with a thriller, science fiction with a drama. And I will say, this conversation does have some spoilers. So if you haven't read the books, you might want to do that before you listen to the conversation. But then, hey, if you love writing, you don't care about spoilers, get to it right now. This conversation is for you.
SPEAKER_01I want to hear about how you think about the premise of a science fiction book. Let's start with Project Hail Mary, but I want to see if there's any patterns that we can draw between your different books.
SPEAKER_02Well, usually it starts off as like, I'm just daydreaming about interesting science. And so I'll think about like, oh, wouldn't it be cool if this, or wouldn't it be cool if that? For Project Hail Mary, the kind of kernel of it started with, I'd like us to have a mass construction So I thought like, okay, I could have a mad scientist invent it. And then it's like this great breakthrough. I'm like, eh, it strains credibility a little bit.
SPEAKER_02I'm like, okay, maybe they found like an alien spaceship and that's the fuel. And I'm like, well, then they'd use up the fuel and that would be it. I want this to be an infrastructural thing that we know how to mass produce and manufacture. Okay, so what if it's like a fuel, but the fuel itself has a mechanism for making more fuel? Like you shine light at it and it'll turn that light into mass and then you do something and it'll turn the mass back into light and it works back and forth. And I'm like, again, that's sort of a hand-wavy tech.
SPEAKER_02And also people would probably be far more interested in the alien ship that they found rather than the fuel. I mean, it's cool to show what you can do with it, but the alien ship that it came from is probably more interesting to the reader. And then I was like, well, it's something that if you give it energy, it makes more of itself. That sounds like life. So what if it's like a life form that somehow uses mass conversion? If it's an alien life form, how do we get it? Why does it involve that? And those two things kind of answered themselves in that it's like, well, I decided it's a microbe.
SPEAKER_02It's like a mold that grows on stars and then it spores out just like mold does and it needs to get to other stars. The only way to do that Is by, you know, having some sort of propulsion. And so it ultimately evolved this mass conversion. And then in the back of my mind, I was like, well, we'd have to make sure none of that crap got onto our sun, because that would be really bad. Okay, that's the story. Okay, that's the story. We're going to go back. They don't find the spores. They only discover it once the sun's already infected and stuff like that. And then I was like, okay, then things start to snowball from there.
SPEAKER_02I'm like, okay, well, now they have this existential problem to Earth. And I'm like, okay, well, I want them to use the astrophage. I'm like, okay, well, I'm going to say there's this one star that's not affected, so they want to go there and find out. Well, fortunately, they have astrophage.
SPEAKER_01So break this down for me. What about that premise makes it work? Yeah. What are the different parameters?
SPEAKER_02Well, definitely in terms of like storytelling, there's stakes. And that's the
SPEAKER_01death of
SPEAKER_02humans. Well, a lot of humans, yeah. Like an extinction level event on Earth that will cause billions to die. Humanity would survive, but, you know. It's not great. So the stakes are very high because humanity is at stake. It's like this desperate mission. Like it's not like a well-organized thing. They have a limited amount of like mass that they can send all the way out there. So that makes it desperate stakes and a very small number of people are tasked
SPEAKER_02with saving the world. So that sounds like a pretty exciting story. And I get to do all my science-y stuff. And I'd always wanted to do... A first contact story. And so all these things came together. Hail Mary was actually kind of a pastiche of a bunch of story ideas I had that I glued together and then sanded off the seams. So for instance, like I always wanted to do a first contact story. I liked this idea of a mass conversion based fuel. I had an unrelated story that I abandoned earlier about a woman
SPEAKER_02who was given like godlike authority over all the governments and everything like that to solve an existential crisis. And so that's where
SPEAKER_01Strat came from. And how do you think about stakes? Stakes strikes me as the propulsion of the story, the thing that keeps it going.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, in this particular case, this is the first time I've written a story where the stakes are all of humanity.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_02Right? Before, I tend to like personal stakes. Like, in The Martian, it was one guy's life. That was it. But, you know, it kept you interested. And Artemis, the stakes are just Jazz Bashara's, like, well-being. She wants to, like, improve her life. And if she gets caught, she'll get deported back to Earth. And, like, her life will be ruined. But she wouldn't even die. So it's even lower stakes. Mm-hmm. But this one, I was like, that all of humanity.
SPEAKER_01And is that easier or harder?
SPEAKER_02I mean, in this case, it was easier because that's kind of the emergent problem that arises. But I guess I would say... I get a little tired of science fiction feeling like it has to have global stakes. Love stories, action movies, dramas, they don't, none of them need, people don't feel the need to have like planetary stakes. So when you come up with a premise, how do you then go from premise to draft?
SPEAKER_02Well, I generally, in my mind, I think of like, what are the major turning points of the story? So this, this, like four or five events that happen in the story that make for an interesting plot arc. And then I just start writing. I kind of make stuff up as I go along. I mean, I know I need to get from here to there, you know, to this next plot point, but I'm not sure exactly what's going to get us there.
SPEAKER_01So what's an example of that? In Project Hail Mary, you knew that you were going to go from here to here, and then what were some of the fun diversions?
SPEAKER_02Well, at the beginning, I decided that he's going to wake up, he's going to have amnesia, he's going to have no idea what's going on. And the first thing he needs to do is figure out that he's on a spacecraft. In the movie, the Hail Mary is this huge ship with lots of windows and stuff, but in the book, he's in this sealed... There's no reason to have windows on the ship. They've got cameras and stuff. No reason to add these weak points. Yeah, so the first thing he has to do is realize that he's on a spacecraft. Then once he does, then he needs to realize that he's in the Tau Ceti system, not Earth.
SPEAKER_02Then he's like, okay, so that's a big reveal. And then, you know, the next big reveal are these flashbacks related to Astrophage and teasing that out for the reader. Then the next big reveal is Rocky, the arrival of, like, another ship. They do their cool first contact stuff, and at the end of that, they're able to communicate. So I needed to come up with how they do that.
SPEAKER_01And how do you think about early in the book building up the human character? It starts off, okay, what's two plus two? And then there's all these moments when he's trying to figure out, okay, how do I know that? I'm a school teacher. And so there's certain things that he knows. There's other places where he has amnesia. And then all of a sudden you're really beginning to develop a relationship with him. How does that unfold?
SPEAKER_02It's a pretty cheesy trope, and a lot of writers have done it, is like giving your character amnesia right at the beginning means that the audience experiences the information coming in as the character does. So there's no information that the character has that the reader doesn't, as opposed to if he was just had all of his memories and was a dedicated astronaut working on this stuff. I have to exposition all the backstory that led to that. Amnesia is a cheesy trope I advise people not to do, but I did it. And flashbacks annoy the hell out of me in fiction, but the book is all just flashbacks.
SPEAKER_02And so for flashbacks, I felt like I kind of reluctantly did it. I felt like I had to do it, though, because if you told the story linearly, then there'd be all these characters, including Strat and everybody else, in the first act, and then you wouldn't see them again. And then you wouldn't even get to Rocky until like beyond halfway through the book. And it's just like, yeah, it just like, I really needed to tell those two stories at the same time. And so that's what I did and it worked out.
SPEAKER_02But I guess the thing about flashbacks that bugs me is oftentimes in stories, flashbacks are used to kind of make you do your homework. It's like, here's a character, there's something really interesting going on, yada, yada, yada. Three weeks earlier. And he's just some guy, you know, and he's like, his wife is nagging him to get a better job or something, you know, whatever. It's like a flashback that is for expositional purposes like that. It's kind of like you're out playing with your friends and your mom makes you come in and clean your room.
SPEAKER_01So what's the difference between a flashback that works and one that doesn't work?
SPEAKER_02Well, what I hoped to do with my flashbacks was make sure that the plot was always advancing and things were changing. And it wasn't just a mechanism to tell you about the character's backstory or his relationship with his daughter or something like that. That has nothing to do with the primary action sequence. So I tried to tailor my flashbacks to be he has a flash of memory that is relevant to what he's doing right at that moment. Which kind of makes sense from a fictionalized version of Amnesia.
SPEAKER_02He's like, I'm working on this. Oh, wait, I remember, you know. And then you get that flashback. So it's pushing the story forward and also unfolding mysteries that are happening in the book. Like the reader is getting a sequence of questions being raised and then answered and new questions being raised in the flashback sequences themselves. Hmm.
SPEAKER_01I like what you said about the flashbacks are causing an underlying change in the story. That seems important.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And it's not, although they all happen in the past, from the reader and the main character's point of view, this is new information. All you know for sure is that The events of the flashbacks will ultimately lead to this guy being on the spaceship. But you don't even know that Earth is at stake. And bit by bit, you find out all this information and see how they get more and more desperate and start to do all these things. And that's kind of what I was shooting for.
SPEAKER_01Explain this to me. Earlier on, you were talking about credibility, credibility in a sci-fi story. Are there things that you need to do early in a story to build trust with your audience?
SPEAKER_02I guess, yeah, building trust with your audiences, they need to be, you need to not ruin their immersion, their suspension of disbelief. And for me, one way... David Perell's How I Write.
SPEAKER_02I kind of skimmed those paragraphs, but I'm sure it's right. And that's great. If somebody, like, believes me enough and their suspension of disbelief is untarnished, and then they can just skip over the physics and assume I'm telling them the truth, that's great.
SPEAKER_01I think that a place that you really do this is early in Project Hail Mary, like 80 pages in or something. You give the example of how light works with microwaves. And I read that. I was like, OK, that's interesting for the story itself. But also, I didn't quite realize that's how microwaves work. So it's like tethered to reality, even though it's science fiction. So why don't you read this and then we can talk about it?
SPEAKER_02Sure. Yeah, um... That's true. And yeah, I've heard people have talked about that specific line a lot with me. They're like, I never knew that about microwaves.
SPEAKER_01What matters to you with exposition?
SPEAKER_02So I kind of have this love-hate relationship with the show-don't-tell doctrine. You know, everybody always tells writers, oh, show-don't-tell. Don't just tell, you know, the audience something demonstrated or show it. But I have so much, like, deep scientific stuff in my stories. How am I going to show that? So I end up with a lot of direct exposition. Like, just straight up, The main character or someone else is just telling the audience,
SPEAKER_02hey, the reader, here's how this works. Here's why. And that's what this guy is doing. So I think that like the old, you know, show don't tell adage needs to have like a little asterisk on it where it's like, okay, but if you can save yourself 10 pages by having one paragraph of direct exposition, just do that. And, um, I get away with that by usually having a first-person conversational narrative. And it's kind of like the main character is talking to you.
SPEAKER_02And you can just easily just kind of phase into that character straight up explaining science. Like, why is this first-person narration suddenly just explaining how microwaves work? Why? But the only way for that to catch you off guard is if you step back and think, wait a minute, who is a first-person narrator talking to? So you're accepting that this is some scenario where someone is telling you this story. Well, if you can accept that,
SPEAKER_02then you can also accept that the person telling you the story takes a moment to explain something. You can get away with that a lot easier in first person than you can in third. And then the final thing is exposition can be a little boring, right? If you're just reading information, it starts to be like a Wikipedia article. And so the way to get past that is I've found that humor, like humor just gets you past it. Readers will forgive any amount of exposition if you make them laugh about once a paragraph.
SPEAKER_02They'll be like, oh yeah, tell me more about, you know, tell me more about heat transfer coefficients. That stuff's funny as hell.
SPEAKER_01So you must do a bunch of rewriting to make it funny.
SPEAKER_02I mean, I'm a naturally smart-ass person, so usually those comments come naturally. But sometimes I'll be like, eh, this is going a little bit long without a zinger or something like that, and so I'll find a way to work one in.
SPEAKER_01I can totally see that. Just hanging out with you, there's a combination of enthusiasm and just playfulness that is definitely in the narration.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Friends of mine who read my books say, like, I could just hear your voice. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. This episode is sponsored by Alpha School. When you think of school, what comes to mind? For me, it was lectures, homework, being stuck at a desk. And the worst part is that it doesn't even work. 54% of Americans read below a sixth grade level. That's over half of Americans. We need something new. And that's why I'm excited to have Alpha School as the flagship sponsor of How I Write. At Alpha, you go to school, you get all your academics done in only two hours per day so that then you can spend
SPEAKER_01the rest of the time learning life skills like running a business, writing a musical, giving a TEDx talk. You know, the kind of things that make you a capable and well-rounded person. And it's working. They have the academics figured out. Alpha classes test in the top 1% nationally, and more than 90% of students say they love school. Now, I used to live in Austin, where Alpha School started, and I was consistently blown away by what was happening there. I personally mentored a bunch of the kids, and what stuck out to me is how much their team believes in the potential of kids.
SPEAKER_01Alpha's approach, and the success it's already having, is why it's the most talked about K-12 school in the world right now, and also where I want to send my kids to school one day. So if you want to learn more, visit go.alpha.school slash how I write. And as you're thinking about character building, how does that play out?
SPEAKER_02Well, I consider character depth and complexity to be one of my weakest aspects. I want to get better at it. I'm a very plot-driven author. My stories generally have a pretty well-defined sequence of events that all make sense. Each one leads into the next one. And so that that I feel like I do reasonably well. But the characters having a lot of depth and complexity, it's like it's like sometimes I kind of wish the characters could just be machinery
SPEAKER_02that is also part of the story. But, you know, having real human emotions and and. A connection that the reader can make with the character and understand what this person is going through, empathize with them, self-insert, all that stuff. That's more challenging for me, I think, than it is for other authors. And I'm always working on it. I'm always trying to get better at it. But I think even the most generous reviewers would say, like, eh, you know, he's got work to do on that front.
SPEAKER_01With Grace, as you're building out Grace's character and you're thinking through the dialogue and how dialogue reveals character, What were you focusing on there?
SPEAKER_02Well, Grace was the first time I ever made a character out of whole cloth. The Martian, Mark Watney is just my personality. Just straight up me on Mars with all of my good aspects magnified. Like I'm kind of smart. He's really smart. You know, I'm kind of funny. He's really funny. And then all of my flaws removed.
SPEAKER_01Superman Andy.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. The idealized version of me is Mark Watney. You know, like Mark Watney probably isn't afraid to fly. Right. He's an astronaut. Right. And he doesn't get, you know, if I was stuck on Mars, I'd probably just sink into a deep depression and die. Right. You know, but so that was Mark. Jazz from Artemis is more like the the less idealized, realistic version of me from when I was her age. Because when you think Saudi woman who grew up on the moon, you think, oh, this guy. Right. Clearly.
SPEAKER_02Exactly. But her personality is, the core aspects of her personality have nothing to do with gender or ethnicity or anything else, and are the same as the problems that I had when I was her age. Immature for my age, always trying to take a shortcut rather than just doing the work, like lazy, kind of unethical, disappointment to my father, like all these things. But yeah, and so that's why I'm like, okay, now I'm going to base a character on More the real me because I was shooting for more complexity, depth, flaws, stuff like that.
SPEAKER_02I think I overshot. I made her a little too flawed and I made it difficult for people to root for her. I got a lot of feedback in that sense that people are like, I had a tough time rooting for Jazz because she was just kind of the architect of all of her own problems. It's hard to root for someone who's just their own worst enemy like that in a book. I mean, better writers can make that work, but I was, you know, experimenting. I just went too far. So for Grace, when I was coming up with his character, I said, all right, I want to make a character from whole cloth.
SPEAKER_02I want to make him not me. He's not based on me. So I said, like, what's a core trait of his that I can give him? And I decided he's afraid. You know, he's so non-confrontational as to be, like, almost pathological. He's, like, very, very afraid of conflict. He's afraid of being challenged. You know, he was in academia. He made a paper. It got challenged. And so he left.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_02And he went to teaching middle school, which is where a bunch of kids, like he made sure he was kind of the cool teacher. So the kids think he's awesome. Nobody really challenges him or pushes back on anything he does. You know, that's kind of his personality. And he also found that he really loves being a teacher. Right. And so then I said, like, okay, well, that has other knock-on effects, right? Like the fun thing about how he never swears. And he always has these ridiculous, like, substitute swear words like fudge and gosh and what the heck, you know?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I remember when we...
SPEAKER_02When the movie got greenlighted, Ryan emailed me. He's like, hey. Ryan Gosling. Ryan Gosling. In Hollywood, you sound like such a douche, but it's just normal. In Hollywood, everybody calls each other by their first names.
SPEAKER_01It's not like your buddy Ryan emailed you. Ryan Gosling emailed you. Ryan Gosling emailed you.
SPEAKER_02Ryan Gosling. No. But anyway, he sent me an email saying like, all right, it got greenlighted. Let's make this fudging movie. And I'm like, all right, you're already in character. Good work. Good work. But yeah, and so I put that together, just have a fun character quirk. And also by having him never swear, that means in the early parts, he's just never swearing and using these silly substitute words. And he's like, why am I doing that? And it's this weird trait until you figure out that he's a teacher and then it makes sense. Yeah. And so you're talking about creating characters.
SPEAKER_02That was his core trait is that he's afraid of things and non-confrontational. So this scenario that he's in is the exact opposite of everything he's ever wanted. Like, he's never wanted to be critical. He's never wanted to be the linchpin upon which important things hinge. He wants to be—and he's also, like, just generally doesn't want to die, right? He's not this brave, bold person who wants to go out and die for humanity. He said no. Spoiler. And they forced him to go.
SPEAKER_01And is that something that you're trying to do when you set up a character to basically say they're like this, their fears are that. Now let me put them in a situation where all of a sudden they need to confront those things.
SPEAKER_02Uh, somewhat with him. I wanted him to undergo change. I wanted him to be a different person at the end of the story than he was at the beginning, right? And so I set him up as this fearful person initially, and my original plan was just, okay, and then at the end he gets forced onto it, and that was... That was just going to be a trope inversion. Like people are going to assume as we see that he was afraid, he was afraid. And then you see he's on the ship and then he finally makes the noble decision to join the crew after the other two die and stuff like that. That's what everybody's assuming is going to happen. But I flipped it on its head and he got forced to go and stuff like that.
SPEAKER_02His actual character change only happens when he has to decide between Rocky and himself. And in the book, it's even more extreme than in the movie. He is under the impression that he's sacrificing his life to save Rocky. Because he figured by doing that, he has no hope of surviving because he wouldn't be able to have food long enough. And it wasn't just Rocky. It was Rocky's entire species. Because if Rocky died, his species would die with him. And so he figured, I have the option of sending the Beatles back to Earth, saving all of humanity.
SPEAKER_02And then if I go save Rocky, I sacrifice myself. And I save not just my new best friend, but also billions of living beings that So, making Rocky was fun because I started by saying, like, I don't want any restrictions on this. I don't want him to have to be comfortable in our environment. I don't want anything like that. In fact, I'd rather he wasn't. I started off with what was believed to be at the time a real exoplanet
SPEAKER_02in orbit around 40 Eridani. They believed that there was a planet in orbit that I made into being arid. It has since been proven that that was just kind of a mathematical error, and there's no planet there. But let's get past that. So his planet, I used the real information we had at the time of that exoplanet. And it was like really close to its star. And it had about eight Earth masses. And I'm like, okay, if I assume that it has about the same density as Earth, then it's going to have about two Gs on the surface is what it works out to be.
SPEAKER_02So these aliens are probably stronger than us because they live on a surface with two times our gravity. Okay. Then... It's really close to the star. How do you, and I'd already also already decided that all life in the, in his life, our life, oh, that came from a panspermia event. So that means life only evolved once at Tau Ceti and it spread out and seeded Arid and Earth and a bunch of other things. So actually Rocky and Ryland are distantly related, like billions of years ago related, but yeah.
SPEAKER_02And so I'm like, contrary to Grace's paper, The whole Iridium biosphere does rely on water. So I'm like, I need liquid water on that planet. But it's like really close to the star. It's closer than Mercury is to our star. So how do you have liquid water on a planet?
SPEAKER_01What was orbit like 48 days?
SPEAKER_02Something like 46 days, something like that. It's incredibly close to the star. And I thought, okay, so how do you have liquid water on a planet that close to the star? I'm like, well, for starters, water is liquid. So I said, like, let's say the surface temperature on that planet is like 200 degrees Celsius. It's like 400 degrees Fahrenheit or thereabouts. But you could do that if you have like 29 atmospheres of pressure. Water is liquid at 200 Celsius.
SPEAKER_02And so I'm like, OK, so they have a really thick atmosphere. I'm like, how do you keep a really thick atmosphere if you're right next to the star? Stars basically sandblast atmospheres off the planets. That's what happened to Mars. But it didn't happen to Earth because we have a strong magnetic field to, like, direct that solar wind around us. So I thought, okay, let's give ARID, like, a hella strong magnetic field. Also, I realized with an atmosphere that thick, I said, like, sunlight probably wouldn't even reach the surface. So I'm like, okay, their biosphere is going to have to be kind of like an ocean. Like there's stuff like with the atmosphere is acting like an ocean.
SPEAKER_02There's stuff in the upper atmosphere that is getting hit with light and things below that that eat it, things below that that eat it all the way down to the apex predators on the ground. So then I'm like, okay, design a creature that lives in that environment. Well, there's no light. There's a huge atmospheric pressure. And then I just went to town having fun with speculative biology and I came up with the iridians. And then as you begin to think about Rocky, do you have the name in your head? That was, I didn't, I didn't have his name.
SPEAKER_01Because in the story, the name unfolds. Yes. And then also, do you have a clear sense of personality, that Rocky's going to be likable, the kind of golden retriever dog energy?
SPEAKER_02I wanted him to be likable. I sure did. He's like a friendly alien. And He ended up with this kind of personality that was like really lovable, largely because of his limited English vocabulary. But if you actually pay attention to the things he says to Grace in the book even, he's actually kind of grumpy. He's actually kind of grumpy and he kind of insults Grace a lot. The two of them have this kind of relationship where they're buddies, they're best friends, they die for each other, but also
SPEAKER_01they're like, okay, dude, you're pissing me
SPEAKER_02off. There's one exchange I wish had made it into the movie where Grace is up and he's doing something on the whole and he has to wait for some epoxy to harden, some epoxy resin to harden. And Rocky says, like, why, you know, why are you not back yet? He's like, I have to wait for the epoxy to harden before I can do the next step. He's like, it's very important we get this done soon. And Brian's like, okay, okay, I'll wait faster. You know, and I just thought that was like, that's, that's like important. They're like a bickering old couple sometimes.
SPEAKER_02So that was actually more the dynamic I was shooting for. But he's also just really lovable because of his linguistic quirks, like saying something three times if he wants it with a lot of emphasis and things like that.
SPEAKER_01The thing that's going through my mind is you're asking, what if, what if? And you're kind of playing, playing. You're finding all these new neighborhoods of exploration. And then you end up there. You're like, okay, does this work? I like this place. How do I make it work? And then you're... Constantly trying to do that or something.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah. And things don't show up in my head as a fait accompli. I'm like, okay, what if this? And I'm like, well, it's kind of unsatisfying because it's way too linear. And I'm like, okay, what if this, but that? And so they can't just solve it the easy way. Oh, okay. Well, now you have to do some crazy stuff. And, you know, so I do care. I speculate on curveballs and stuff like that. And what's kind of interesting is like, Like, for instance, in The Martian, I could set things up.
SPEAKER_02I could say like, oh, things are getting too easy for him. I want something to go wrong here. And I'm like, I'm going to have this thing break down. But... It's not going to come out of nowhere from the reader's point of view. I'm like, you know, 80,000 words into the book, but I want this thing to break. So I'm going to start, I'm going to go back into the earlier parts of the book and seed that. It's like, oh, this thing was like acting up a bit. And, you know, so you get to go back in time as the writer and, and, and set up the hints that this is going to happen.
SPEAKER_01Can you talk to me about the spreadsheets that you use, how you track all this?
SPEAKER_02Well, I have for any given book of mine, I have like a bunch of Excel spreadsheets. Project Hail Mary probably had the most. I have like spreadsheets for calculating a mass conversion fuel spacecraft. It's called a relativistic rocket equations. I mean, I didn't have to derive them. Other people worked them out, but I had to convert them into Excel spreadsheet form and So that I could put in, oh, this is the fuel to mass ratio and everything like that. And how long does it take? And all the stuff about astrophage, I was looking at, well, how much energy can they absorb if they're on the surface of the sun?
SPEAKER_02How long does it take in to get fully enriched? And then for iridians, I mean, I had spreadsheets all about their biology, how much food energy they have to take in to operate their bodies.
SPEAKER_01What is the self-conception of what you're trying to do? Is it, I'm really interested in these fantastical worlds and I want to go explore them for myself? Is it, I think science fiction is important for the world? Hey, I just want to give people interesting stories. What is the self-conception of your
SPEAKER_02work? I just want to make something that's entertaining. I just want people to have fun when they're reading my stuff. And as you know, I have no ulterior motive and I don't even have any sort of moral or underlying, I don't even do symbolism or Even symbolism that's not political. I don't even do symbolism of any kind.
SPEAKER_01There's nothing deep or... Astrophage is not an allegory for climate change.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, nor is it an allegory for Ryland's inner emotional turmoil or anything like that. So it's absolutely possible to write a book with all sorts of symbolism and metaphor and stuff like that that has no political connotations at all. They could all be about the internal feelings of the character or... Like basically metaphors for things that are going to happen later in the book. And there's all these sorts of things that clever writers can do. And I don't do any of that. I'm just like straight up, here's a sequence of events. It's almost like I'm, I'm journaling real events.
SPEAKER_02You know, it's like I'm writing an account of events that occurred, you know, not, not trying to spruce it up or snazz it up. But, um, So mainly I want to write things that are entertaining. But also a big thing for me is I kind of realized this after the fact, three books into it. Apparently, I like to take very well-trodden science fiction territory and do it my way. Like the idea of somebody stranded on a planet is not new.
SPEAKER_02In fact, I think the first fiction novel ever written was probably Robinson Crusoe, right? I mean, like that, and that was the plot. No, it's the exact same thing. So that's not a new plot. And people in trouble in space is not a new plot. But I did it my way with the scientific accuracy and everything like that. And then the idea of like, you know, a first contact story is like not new at all. That's everywhere. But I did it my way. I'm like, well, the alien can't just stand around in an Earth's atmosphere. You need to have like some sort of barrier between the two.
SPEAKER_02And no, you don't have a common language. You have no way to communicate at all. And I'm like, this alien is very alien. It doesn't have a face. It doesn't look anything like a human. So you've got to get past all that.
SPEAKER_01And you talk about entertainment there. Did you have that same desire? Is that what you're going for with The Martian early on? Or is it like, now I'm a successful writer. I can really just focus on entertainment.
SPEAKER_02No, I mean, The Martian, I was also just helping to entertain. That's it. I mean, I think that's what most writers want, is they want people to read their book and enjoy that, right? There are some people out there who write for the cathartic release of getting these ideas out of their mind and onto the paper, and I don't care if anyone ever reads it. I'm not one of those. I want people to read my stuff and then tell me it's awesome. You know, I need that sweet external validation.
SPEAKER_01Let's go back to The Martian, because I think that story of how you wrote it, how you published it, how you revised it, how it went from the internet to a book is something else.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well, at the time, I always wanted to be a writer, but I also... So I liked regular meals. So I was a software engineer. And even earlier in my career, in my life, rather, I'd ended up with a bunch of money because I got laid off at just the right time from AOL to force me to cash in my stock options so that I ended up with like a bunch of money. And so I had like three years of runway. And so I said, like, I'm just going to take like a sabbatical and write.
SPEAKER_02And I wrote a book and like nobody was interested in it. It wasn't, it wasn't the Martian. It was the standard tale of woe that every writer has of like no publisher was interested. No literary agent was interested. So I went back into the, um, Back in engineering, which was fine because I really liked that. I really liked programming computers. It was a fun job. Even after the Martian was successful and in theaters, I was still working at my engineering job because I liked it. Anyway, so I started working on the Martian just because I came up with the idea of like,
SPEAKER_02oh, how could it, you know, the mission to Mars and something goes wrong. And then we have a guy who's stranded there. That sounds interesting, what clever stuff, you know, do this, do that, solve this, solve that. So I got to writing it, largely because I had moved out to Boston to do, like, to take a job there, and I didn't know anyone there. So I had, like, no social life. I had nothing to do outside of work.
SPEAKER_01So you just wrote?
SPEAKER_02I just wrote. Yeah, I didn't have anything to do at all. Like, I'd get home and I'd Nothing to do until then, until work started the next day. And so I just, I started thinking about The Martian and started writing it. At the time, I just said like, I'll just post it to like basically a blog post and I'll make it a serialized story. Kind of like the old days of like, you know, Sherlock Holmes was serialized storytelling in the Strand Magazine. It's like, yeah, if you wanted to read Sherlock Holmes back in the day, you'd be reading,
SPEAKER_02you know, a little bit of it at a time and then eagerly waiting the next Strand magazine when you could read the next chapter. How about that? Yeah. So I'd post a new chapter about every... And I told everybody, hey, you know, you're basically watching me write a book. So these chapters aren't canon. Like if I find out something's wrong, I can go back and fix it, you know, and I might make substantial changes to chapters. If I do, I'll let you know. Wow. Wow.
SPEAKER_02About one a day on average. But then they would, they were reading it and they enjoyed it. They were sending me feedback and that helped buoy me, you know. And then also they'd tell me any science errors because my hardcore fans were nerds. And so they double checked my math. And so it ended up getting really accurate. Anyway, eventually I finished the book and I finished the last chapter and I said, okay, guys, there it is. I'm glad you all enjoyed that. I'm going to start working on a new story now. And here it is in its entire form and enjoy.
SPEAKER_02And people said like, well... I love your book, but I hate your website, which is fair. Like I'd made it just in Notepad with direct HTML tags and stuff. It was just like a Soviet tractor factory of a website of just white background with blue hyperlinks. And that was it. And they said, can I get your book in like an e-reader format? I'm like, sure. So I figured out how to do that. It's easy enough. You just save it as that format in Word. And then there you go, e-reader format.
SPEAKER_02And then I get more emails of people saying like, hey, I love your story. I hate your site. I see that you have it available in e-reader. And I figured out how to self-publish it. Kindle Direct Publishing, KDP, through Amazon, which is nice. You just post it there. They check in 24 hours to make sure it's not goat porn.
SPEAKER_02And then, or don't judge. Or if it is goat porn, they want to categorize it as goat porn. But anyway, they check it and then they put it up available. And I'm like, but you're not allowed to give it away. You have to charge at least a dollar. Because Amazon sells Kindles as a loss leader. They lose money on every Kindle they sell.
SPEAKER_01And then they make money on the e-book.
SPEAKER_02And then they make money off of you buying books. Sure. So the last thing they want is a gigantic library of free books. Yep. Then people will just buy Kindles and get the free books. And then Amazon will be like, oh, we lost money. We don't like that. So you have to charge at least some money. And so I charged the minimum, which at the time was 99 cents. So I'm like, okay, everybody, you can read it on my website. You can download the e-reader version from my website, or you can pay Amazon a buck to put it on your Kindle for you. And people paid the buck. So it became one of the top-selling
SPEAKER_02Top-selling sci-fi e-books. And were you promoting it or anything? No. Wow. Well, what happened was I had a very evangelical fan base. So also, I think what happened was all throughout this process, I was a successful software engineer. I was like architect level. I was doing good in my career. I had money. I was fine. And people would periodically say like, hey, I want to donate. You know, I want to donate money because you're writing stories that I enjoy and I'm getting them for free. I want to donate money. I'm like, I don't want money. I probably make more than you.
SPEAKER_02I don't feel right about that. You know, I mean, I wouldn't say that, but, you know, so if you want to donate money, donate it to cancer research in my name or something, please. You know, it's like, but I don't, I didn't provide any mechanism by which people could donate or anything like that. So I guess when I started, when I put that book up, people said like, ah, now here's an opportunity for me to give money. I'm going to buy the book, even though I've already read it.
SPEAKER_01One dollar.
SPEAKER_02For a dollar. But everybody did that and they all did it kind of at once. So Amazon's automated system went, well, this is selling well, which popped it into the list of like top sellers, which got other people's attention, which so it snowballed from there. Yeah, it was not, it was almost astroturfing, but not intentional. You know what I mean?
SPEAKER_01And then you had the book deal after that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So first, well, then it was just there and it was selling really well. And it was selling hundreds of copies a day. And then it got the attention of a literary agent named David Fugate. And he said like, hey, do you have an agent? Because I think I could probably get you a print deal for this book. And I said, like, no, you want to be my agent? He's like, sure. And then, like, pretty quickly, he had, like, Random House, you know, on the line and interested in making a print edition. And at the same time, Fox came and said, we're interested in securing the film option on it.
SPEAKER_02So... That sounds exciting, but film studios do that all the time. Anything that's remotely successful, any form of fiction, they'll secure the option. The option is a much cheaper version. It basically says like, hey, we'll buy the rights for you for like $200,000. We're not going to give that to you right now. What we're going to do is say, here's a contract that we can execute at any time by giving you $200,000 to secure the rights. Here's a different contract that says you're not allowed to sell the rights to anyone else for 18 months except us.
SPEAKER_02And if you agree to this little contract, we'll give you like $25,000. Okay. There's actually a lot of writers who make a lot of money off of cycling options. If you imagine you're a writer with like 30 books under your belt, you've been doing it your whole life,
SPEAKER_02you're at retirement age now, and you've got like 30 books, and the studios don't want to let them go. They have to rebuy the option from you every 18 months or the rights come back to you. So you're getting like $25,000 per book per 18 months. And, you know, if you've got a huge catalog of books that they don't want to let go, then you can just make passive income from that. The, you know, Fox came and they were interested in the film rights. And so I'm like, talk to my agent. And then my agent said like, well, here's a film agent I can recommend.
SPEAKER_02And so then how you had a film agent and everything, the book deal and the movie deal came four days apart. That was all in one very eventful week. Wow. Yeah. But again, the movie deal was at the time, everyone's like, don't get excited. Like, Studios always buy up the rights to everything. Yeah. Yeah. And then, yeah, then once the book came out, it was like, you know, New York Times bestseller list.
SPEAKER_01From The Martian, from Project Hail Mary, are there moments when the Are there any moments that stand out to you? Like, wow. Okay, this thing is real now.
SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, for The Martian, everything was new to me, right? It was all very exciting because this was a dream of mine my whole life was to break into publishing, you know? And now I had a publishing deal and they were going to make my book. And that to me was, I wasn't even thinking about movies. I was just really excited about someday there's going to be a book with my name on it in a bookstore, you know? And so for me, when they first sent me like a proof of the physical book, It's like, this is my book. Here's the cover. Here's my picture on the back. And here's all the words.
SPEAKER_02And it's like, I wrote this. And that was really cool. And then, of course, with The Martian, they kept creeping more. Movies are never just like, green light. It's like they just creep more and more toward being more and more likely to be produced until eventually they happen. They tip at some tipping point. And so for The Martian, they said like, well, it's looking good. You know, like, you know, Fox is kind of like thinking about funding it. And it's like, OK, good. It's like, well, we've got Ridley Scott set to direct and Matt Damon set to star
SPEAKER_02and We've got Jessica Chastain now. And I'm like, well, this looks like a great cast. And they're like, yeah, if we can afford them. And then it's like, you know, and then eventually he's like, okay, they're making sets. And I'm like, well, that's pretty good. Like, that's a pretty good thing. But all the contracts and everything activate when you have the first day of filming in the can, which means once you've done one day of filming, All of the stars, all the contracts activate. So you're on the hook to pay them the entire amount. If you decide after one day of filming, nah, we don't want to make this movie, then the actor's like, fine, you still owe me the entire amount.
SPEAKER_02And so once we had the first day of filming in the can in The Martian, then I knew, okay, they're making the movie. Because at that point, even if they did want to back out, it's cheaper to just make the movie and put it up there to cut your losses. So... Real quick, can you make
SPEAKER_01that sound again? Yeah, I don't remember what I... That was an amazing sound. That?
SPEAKER_02The, like, reverb.
SPEAKER_01I'm good at sound effects.
SPEAKER_02I'm good at sound effects. I don't know. Good at writing, good at sound effects?
SPEAKER_01Do you have other specialty sound effects?
SPEAKER_02I don't know. I can talk like a Dalek. You like Doctor Who? Bring it on.
SPEAKER_00Extaminate! Extaminate! Woohoo!
SPEAKER_01I'm a science fiction dork is what I am. Explain this. In other interviews that you've done, I've seen you talk about, basically say, hey, I think traditional publishing is great, which is funny because you're sort of the canonical story of the benefits of self-publishing.
SPEAKER_02Well, I would disagree. Hugh Howey is the canonical definition of the benefits of self-publishing. Like, he went all the way on it. But I prefer traditional publishing because the publishers are this marketing and publicity machine that no one person could ever match. Now, you have someone like Hugh Howey. He actually can match it. He's a guy who can do everything. So... Power to them. But I don't want to do any of that stuff. I just want to write.
SPEAKER_02So for me, I love having skilled people with connections all over the literature industry doing all that stuff.
SPEAKER_01And what do the publishers do? You talk about their marketing machinery. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Publishers, obviously, they make physical print copies of the book. They also make sure it gets into all these bookstores all over the place. They say like, hey, you know, Barnes & Noble, carry it here. And they'll go talk to like Waterstones and, you know, in the UK. Or they'll talk to like Target and Walmart and stuff like that. Try to get them on their displays and try to get them in their bookshelves and stuff like that. So they'll go around aggressively... They also market it, which is just straight up advertising.
SPEAKER_02They'll put ads and stuff inside publications that are likely to have chronic readers in them. And then they also have... So they'll reach out to New York Times Book Review. It's like, hey, can we send you an advanced copy of this and you can review it? Or hey, we'll make Andy available for interviews and stuff like that. In fact, this interview itself. I did not coordinate with you at all? You didn't coordinate with me at all. You coordinated with PRH's publicity group.
SPEAKER_02And that's what they do. Like all that stuff is stuff that I certainly could not have done on my own. I mean, I could have like bungled around a bit, but yeah. So that is a, you know, it's a book is a product and having an entire company market it and publicize it. And that company has like literally over a century of experience doing just that. It's good for your book.
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm. So if I come to you and I said, Andy, no one's reading my stuff. No one's reading my stuff. I actually think it's decent, but no one's reading my stuff. Can you help me get my book in front of people? How would you coach me if we're sitting down over coffee?
SPEAKER_02I get asked that a lot from various people. I wouldn't make any attempt to like developmentally edit your book. I would just say like, I'm going to take your word for it that it's good. Like you feel like it's good. Everybody feels like their book is good. So first thing I would do, I would advise you to do is send it to literary agents and see what they have to say. You know, you'll get rejected a lot, but maybe you can break in that way. And if you can't, then e-publish it. And one thing that helped me a lot was I posted a lot of free literature to my site,
SPEAKER_02just short stories that I'd written. I made web comics for a while. I did all sorts of stuff. I built up an audience. And so I had like a small following to start with. So if you get a small following, that can grow into a larger one. But there's, I don't, yeah, I'm not like a marketing guru. I don't know how to advise people how to like get their book out there and get more people reading it. All I could do is say like holistically,
SPEAKER_02if you make a lot of content, Like short stories or whatever, if you like doing that, I like doing that, then you can build up an audience over time. Take me back to plot.
SPEAKER_01What do you think that you really understand about plot that helps you to do it so well?
SPEAKER_02Well, I guess just a lifetime of consuming, you know, entertainment media, like reading a lot of books, watching a lot of movies has given me, unintentionally given me a good understanding of plot structure. And one thing I really enjoy, there's a few things I enjoy as a consumer reader or viewer that I try and I'm like, I love it when this happens. And I'm like, so I want to make that happen for my readers, right? So one thing I really like is when something...
SPEAKER_02Right. That way it doesn't feel like
SPEAKER_02Everything is logically sensible from one event to the next. I really like that as a reader or viewer. I really like it when I don't need to just suspend my disbelief and accept that, oh, and then right when everything was going fine, it gets struck by lightning. You know, it's just like, I don't like that. The other thing I love, absolutely love, is when the main characters in a story outsmart me, the reader. Like when I didn't see that coming, being surprised, right?
SPEAKER_02And I didn't see that coming, but I could have. Like in retrospect.
SPEAKER_01The seeds were always there.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. In retrospect, I had all the information to work that out, but I didn't. So in a way, it's almost like a murder mystery thing, like where you're trying to figure out who did it before the detective does. But in this, I think one of the greatest examples of this in writing for me, in terms of my enjoyment, was in Breaking Bad. There's a scene where Gustavo Frise has captured Heisenberg and taken him, and they're going to kill him. They're going to shoot him. And he knows this. And I'm like, how's he going to get out of this? Like, there's no way to get out of this. They're going to have to have some...
SPEAKER_02Deus Ex Machina happen. Like right before they shoot him, you know, the main drug dealer guy is going to have some problem. He's like, ah, you can't kill him. I need him to solve this problem or something like that. It's not going to be something proactive that Walter White does to save himself. It's going to be something outside of it and it's going to feel unsatisfying. I was wrong. What happened was Walter White said, if you let me live, I'll give you Jesse Pinkman. I'll serve him up on a planet for you. He's like, okay. You call him and lure him somewhere. And he's like, okay.
SPEAKER_02And so they call Jesse. He's like, Jesse, you got to kill their cook. They got me. And so Jesse goes over to their drug manufacturer guy and shoots him in the head. Now Walter is the only guy they have that can make drugs for them. And so he just like saved his own life. He just succeeded. And I was like, he proactively came up with a plan and saved his life. And that plan makes sense. Everything makes sense. And I didn't think of it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I love it when I didn't think of it. That is one of the biggest things I've learned from doing the show is... How many of the best writers have just read and read and read and read? And I think a lot of younger writers underestimate how well read and well studied a lot of the great writers are. And I think they often overestimate how much of that is like, I've broken down like this novel and that novel and stuff like that. It's just, no, I've read like 10,000 books over the last 40 years.
SPEAKER_01And I have this deep intuitive understanding of how plot, character, whatever it is, how that works.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think that's a big part of it. Just consuming the media that you want to someday make is kind of an obvious thing. Like, you know, what do they say? Never trust a skinny baker, right?
SPEAKER_01Right. I think that's right. Can you take me through some of the great science fiction writers who you admire and talk to me about what in particular they did so well, what you took from them?
SPEAKER_02Okay, well, let's start from, I guess, the top, in my opinion, is Asimov. Isaac Asimov is my favorite author. You know, he's the one who wrote the robots, the, you know, iRobot, all that. But the three laws of robotics are what he made. You know, no robot can harm a human or through an action allow a human to come to harm. Second law is a robot must obey orders unless it conflicts with the first law. Third law is a robot must protect itself unless it conflicts with the second or first laws. That was it. So he made these rules. He's like, these are the rules.
SPEAKER_02And then iRobot is all a story about what happens when you mess with any of those rules a little bit. There's one of the stories is about a robot that was like really, really expensive. So they gave it, they made its second law of robotics. Sorry, they made its third law as important as its second law. So its desire to self-preservation was as important as obeying orders. And some guy, it was on planet Mercury and the robot's nickname was Speedy.
SPEAKER_02It can move very fast. And these guys had told it, oh, go get a sample of these crystals out on the surface. And Speedy was designed to be able to handle mercury and stuff like that. And he went out and then Speedy identified that the crystals emitted this radiation that would destroy his positronic brain. And so he went, uh, and then you get caught in a loop. He's just started running circles around the thing because he was given an order to go get them. But his third law says, don't go any closer. Right. And so he was just stuck in this loop. And ultimately the guys are like, huh.
SPEAKER_02Okay. And they had these slow robots with them that they could ride. And they rode these slow robots to the entrance of a cave. It's bright sunlight out there. It's Mercury to Amelia. And so the guy goes, oh, the first law is still more important, right? So he won't allow a human to come to harm. So I'll just step out into the sunlight. So that sort of stuff, when all the rules have been handed to you as a reader, the rules of this fictional world, and then you get to see how they play out. And so at the Asimov,
SPEAKER_02he was one of the first guys who would do these, like, here's a set of rules. That's all we're doing. And we're going to examine what happens if these are the rules. Also, he was like one of the first science fiction authors, I think, who really was willing to mix genres. Like he was one of the first people. I've always felt that science fiction isn't a genre. It's a setting. So saying science fiction isn't like saying action. It's more like saying Chicago. Because you can have a science fiction romance.
SPEAKER_02You can have a science fiction action movie. You can have a science fiction drama. You can have, you know, any type of movie, any genre that you think of, you can make a science fiction version. And Asimov made a science fiction noir detective series, Caves of Steel. And the grizzled detective Elijah Bailey has his robot partner that he doesn't like very much, and they solve murders. And so that shows that, like, science fiction's a setting. Noir detective is a genre, but the setting was science fiction.
SPEAKER_02Anyway, that's Asimov. Clark was really good at extremely hard sci-fi. He was good at like saying like, okay, we're going to follow all the laws of physics. We're not cheaping out on anything. And so like one of his that I really liked was Rama. Which is where, well, it turns out to be this alien cylindrical probe comes into our solar system. This is in the future when we have like regular space travel between the planets and stuff like that. And Rama's screaming and like it's coming very fast in our system and it's on
SPEAKER_02a trajectory to just do this hyperbolic... And so it was just this group of basically, I think, like a ship full of people who were just supposed to be delivering cargo from point A to point B. But they were the ones who were in a position to be able to catch up to it, to go look at it. And so they went and go look at it. And inside they find out it's like sort of a biosphere inside of all these weird alien things.
SPEAKER_02And it starts to get more and more active as it gets close to the sun. And then they find out and they eventually detach from it. They find out that really Rama didn't care about us at all. They didn't even know it's not even reacting to the humans. It was just here to like pick up some energy on the way by the sun. That was it.
SPEAKER_01But his core thing was the really hard science.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, really hard science. And Rama was this big cylinder and it rotated so there was a centripetal gravity inside and it was really cool.
SPEAKER_01When you speak, there's such a joy, there's such an enthusiasm. So when you think about science fiction, I want you to fill in the blank. It's like the joy of blank. Discovery? The joy of discovery.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think it's really exciting when you, well, in real life, it's really exciting if you discover something new. And in science fiction, if your reader vicariously gets that high if the character discovers or figures out something that no one else in the world has figured out. Do you feel threatened by AI? Not really. Not right now. It's possible that in the future, in fact, I think it's inevitable that in the future,
SPEAKER_02AIs will be able to write better stories than humans can. That's sort of a bleak assessment, especially from a professional author. But I think just because it's not something I particularly want to see happen doesn't mean I'm going to pretend like it won't. It's like you can see a lot of people out there, cab drivers and truck drivers, saying like, oh, you know, self-driving cars are never going to become a thing. It's like, no, I think they will. You just really don't want them to. I forget who said it was Carnegie, I think, maybe, or somebody else who said,
SPEAKER_02it is very difficult to convince somebody of something when their livelihood relies on it not being true. Um, but I try not to be blind about it. I think it's only a matter of time before an AI can read the Library of Congress, you know, every book that's ever been copyrighted and every, every review written of every book, and then put together like a book to say like, here's, here's a book that I'm pretty sure would get good reviews. And I think you'll enjoy it. And then the next step that I think is going to happen is tailored fiction.
SPEAKER_02Um, Eventually, your computer is going to know you very well based on your search history, your order history, you know, whatever. It's going to know everything about you. And it is going to have its own AI that runs locally rather than at a data center somewhere. And once the technology advances at that point, and it will write a book for you, for you, that maybe nobody else would like, but you will love it. So this is, and then later, once computers become more powerful, it can write a movie for you.
SPEAKER_02That you can watch and enjoy. And you'll be sitting there watching, like, you know, the 19th sequel to that movie that you asked the AI to make. And you'll be, like, absolutely, like, entranced with it. And anyone else who tries to watch those will be like, you know, okay.
SPEAKER_01Well, I think that there's going to be a battle here between what do we value more? Do we value, like, with Project Hail Mary, for example... It matters to me that somebody else can read the book and we can have a conversation about the book and the different characters and we experience the same thing. Obviously, you did not write that for me. You did not write that for the person who I'm talking to. You wrote it for people because you thought it was a great story. So there's something really nice. We have that in Harry Potter, Lord of the Rings with the shared experience.
SPEAKER_01We can all talk about the same thing. And then on the other side, there's something really nice about the story. Individuality of everything, the metaphors that are used, the exact level of difficulty in terms of how well things are explained, how elementary it is. And so the question is, what do we want more? Do we want more of the shared experience? Do we want more of the individuality?
SPEAKER_02My guess is both. You don't have to give up one to get the other. But I do think it'll be AI doing both. There'll be someone who prompts AI, hey, make a book that a lot of people can read and then discuss and enjoy. And it will. I do think that human-written stories will eventually... I don't know if it'll happen in my lifetime. Maybe it will. But they'll eventually be kind of an artisanal thing. It's kind of like... You can get your portrait painted right now.
SPEAKER_02You can go to a professional, very skilled artist, and they will paint your portrait. Probably they might use a photo for reference so that you don't have to just sit there. But they'll paint with acrylic paint or oils even, and they'll make a very good representation of you, and you can hang it up in your house. But most people just hang a picture, right? And then also... As with all things, the industry changes, but there always ends up being more people.
SPEAKER_02So it's like, I saw this thing talking about pilots, right? It used to be every aspect of a plane was controlled by the pilot. Now more and more of it is done by computers. You can push a button and the plane lands, right? And so you might think, well, that's going to put pilots out of business. But the end result was more pilots because you need pilots on the plane. And that automation made it so that people could make more planes and more flights could be there because you don't have to exhaust the pilots as much.
SPEAKER_02And so the end result of this automation that replaced pilots was more pilots got jobs. It's a weird scenario. So I think what will happen is, as is usually the case, when something gets automated, the people who used to do that manually become the people who run the machines that do the automation. So people who used to work on an assembly line transitioned into controlling the machines that run the assembly line because there's always going to be some kind of expertise that's needed.
SPEAKER_02So in the end, it's like, yeah, you can tell the AI on your computer to make a good story that people might enjoy. But a professional author is somebody who understands how these AIs work. They've learned that skill set and they have their own pre-existing skill set of how storytelling works. They can guide the AI to make a much better one. Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_01When I think of AI, I think of it on two vectors. I think in terms of speed and quality. I definitely feel like I can get certain places way faster, like definitely strong conviction. I'm still not sure when it helps me produce something better versus when I would just produce something better on my own. And all this to say, in books, would you now brainstorm and sort of think through ideas with AI or are you like, no, I'm not going to use AI right now?
SPEAKER_02I don't know. It's an interesting question. Definitely not right now. AI is just not good enough at that sort of brainstorming and open thought. I've messed around with AI just to find out how well it can write things. And I was like, write a story, write a short story where these events happen.
SPEAKER_01And it does, but it just, I don't know, for lack of a better term, it has this AI accent.
SPEAKER_02Totally. I had a friend of mine who he really loves superhero stories and he's not a good writer and would not claim to be. That's not his job. But he likes superhero stories like written in fiction, like not just comic books, but you know. And so he came up with an idea that Like for a story, and he had an AI write it. So he told the AI the beats, and then the AI wrote it. And he's like, what do you think? And I'm like, this is crap. It was very unpleasant to read because the AI would go into great detail on things
SPEAKER_02that weren't as important. It kept kind of repeating information. It's still too rudimentary, but those problems will be overcome eventually. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Reinforcement learning is a pretty powerful tool.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and then, like, I mean, you can already, I mean, AIs can already make music pretty well and even emulate the styles of well-known musicians.
SPEAKER_01So what I want to do is I want to go into inspirations, and I want to start off with astronaut John Young. Why do you like him so much?
SPEAKER_02He passed away not too long ago. He was always my favorite astronaut of all time. You know, he was the commander of Apollo 16. Okay, he went, he walked on the moon, right? And they have their biomonitors and everything that they monitor all the time. And usually during the launch phase, their heart rates go like up into the 140s, you know, because you're on a rocket that's launching off of the earth and you're leaving and you're going to go to the moon.
SPEAKER_02That's exciting. John Young's pulse never got above 70. So he's just like, I'm on a rocket. Just up he goes. Wow.
SPEAKER_01He was just a very, yeah. Why is he your hero? What does that say
SPEAKER_02about you? I don't know. I guess he's just so stoic and unflappable. And he had experience doing all of the early NASA stuff, the really exciting stuff from the 60s. I don't know. He was a part of everything from the very beginning all the way into... Like the space shuttle era. And he walked on the moon. There's only like 12 people who've done that.
SPEAKER_01Let's end here. What are your favorite science fiction books? The writers, the books, what do you love about them?
SPEAKER_02Well, if we're going of all time, of all time, then we're going for the holy trinity of Asimov, Heinlein and Clark for me. Just for reasons we discussed earlier in this interview is just like Asimov because he properly identified science fiction as a setting rather than a genre and went all sorts of directions with it. And he liked to do that one little tweak. Here's a tweak to the rules, and then we'll see where it goes. Heinlein, because he was just wildly speculative, he's like, okay, let's say we can travel from planet to planet.
SPEAKER_02Let's not worry about the technology. You're not going faster than light. We're not breaking any rules here. But then what? Then what happens? Are there pirates? What happens? How's that work? Let's talk about that. So he'd come up with all that cool stuff. And then Clark, because of his very scientific approach and somewhat realistic approach to things like, Eh, yeah, maybe aliens come here, but they just don't care. I mean, he also wrote 2001, right? And that's, again, you don't even know really what the aliens are. They're just so foreign and non-understandable.
SPEAKER_02It's like, okay, here's a monolith. What'd it do? Oh, it shot a beam of energy at Jupiter. Okay, let's go to Jupiter. Yeah, there's a big monolith in orbit here. What is the point of the monolith? I don't know. Okay, well, what does it do? The monoliths don't seem to care about us. And it's like, okay, there's like billions of monoliths showing up in Jupiter right now. What's happening? Jupiter is igniting into a star. That shouldn't happen. The monoliths? I don't know. You know, and it's just how confused we'd be by sufficiently advanced technology.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And then one book to start with? Just one recommended book? I'd go Caves of Steel. Okay. Usually I say iRobot, but if you want a book with a... iRobot is an anthology, a collection of short stories. All in the same setting, but different characters, different events. So if you want a book book, a narration that starts as a middle and an end, Caves of Steel. And if you like it a lot, there's like several more books in that series of the same characters. So you can, you can grab a big bag of Cheetos and get to work.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Well, I got to say, what stands out to me is just the enthusiasm that you have for this. And it's cool because you have the enthusiasm. It shows up in your process, but also it really shows up in your books, in the way the characters speak, in the way the books feel. And it's great to meet you. Thank you.
I want to learn more about who’s listening to How I Write. What kind of writing do you do? What do you like about the show, and how can I make it better? Who do you want me to interview? So I threw together a little...
I want to learn more about who’s listening to How I Write. What kind of writing do you do? What do you like about the show, and how can I make it better? Who do you want me to interview? So I threw together a little...
Big thanks to Alpha School for being the presenting sponsor of this episode. When I was in school, I constantly found myself thinking: “We can do so much better than this.” Alpha School is what I wish existed back then....
Big thanks to Alpha School for being the presenting sponsor of this episode. When I was in school, I constantly found myself thinking: “We can do so much better than this.” Alpha School is what I wish existed back then....
Big thanks to Alpha School for being the presenting sponsor of this episode. When I was in school, I constantly found myself thinking: “We can do so much better than this.” Alpha School is what I wish existed back then....