Big thanks to Alpha School for being the presenting sponsor of this episode. When I was in school, I constantly found myself thinking: “We can do so much better than this.” Alpha School is what I wish existed back then. Kids learn everything they need in only two hours per day, so they can spend the rest of the time actual learning life skills: public speaking, building a business, negotiating, etc. If you want your kid to love school and join classes that rank in the top 1% nationwide, Alpha School is the place to be. Learn more at https://go.alpha.school/howiwrite. Malcolm Gladwell is on the show today and he's one of the most influential nonfiction writers of the 21st century. You know him from books like Outliers, The Tipping Point, and David and Goliath, as well as his essays in The New Yorker.I told Malcolm, "I want to learn one thing from you: how you tell a story like you do. What is your process? How do you find the facts, craft the narrative, and conduct your research? How do you weave it all together into a compelling story that resonates, changes worldviews, and is easy to remember?"If you want to learn to tell a great story, you're in the right spot. Here's my conversation with Malcolm Gladwell. Transcript 00:00:38 How are puzzles similar to writing00:04:55 Why specificity matters more than knowledge00:12:28 How Malcolm wrote his new book00:17:02 Stop readers from leaving00:19:28 What he learned from John le Carré00:23:58 What he learned from Michael Lewis00:27:15 You should engineer your curiosity00:30:59 Why memory is underrated00:33:37 Give readers a big why00:38:15 How to make readers cry00:41:29 What audio formats mean to him00:45:57 Leave room for uncertainty00:48:37 Pace your story like a runner00:53:02 Say more with fewer words00:55:24 Malcolm’s writing advice for beginner writers Enhanced Transcript Speaker headings and timestamps preserved, language edited for readability. David (00:38-00:47): My first question concerns the connection between writing and puzzles. In what ways is writing like constructing a puzzle for you, and in what ways is it different? Malcolm (00:47-01:47): That’s the pleasure of it. It’s about assembling pieces. Some pieces come from me, some I collect, and some I’ve had in the back of my head for a while. I arrange them in my mind and on the page. When I’m deep in writing, I often have the sensation that when I get up and go outside, I don’t know where I am. I’ve thought about this a lot, and I believe it’s because I’m using the exact same part of my brain for writing as I do for my sense of direction. To know where you’re going, you visualize a series of steps in your mind that lead to a specific conclusion. When I’ve so thoroughly exhausted that particular module of my brain through writing, I can’t navigate when I go outside, even in a more trivial way. I’m disoriented for a couple of minutes before I finally realize where I am. David (01:48-02:03): Following that point, and extending the sense of direction analogy, do you believe there’s a certain amount of daily time or consistency you need in your writing to maintain that sense of direction and spatial awareness of where you are in the piece, while holding all the necessary information in your head? Malcolm (02:04-02:52): Unfortunately, very little of my life is given over to writing, far less than I would like. Most of my days are spent either reporting or arranging to report. Logistics and background preparation consume an enormous amount of time. So, actual writing is relatively rare. However, when I’m in the middle of a writing session, as I am right now, I notice how quickly I get into the flow. It takes a couple of days, but by day three, everything starts to make sense again. I’ve engaged that muscle. Some fiction writers write every day; I’ve always been fascinated by what that would feel like, because I’ve never done that. David (02:52-02:53): That daily consistency. Malcolm (02:53-02:56): Except when I was a newspaper writer, but that’s a different type of writing. David (02:57-03:05): I’ve heard you say that most writers overestimate how much writing they can get done in one day. So, despite your current schedule, is there still an element of consistency you aim for? Malcolm (03:06-04:12): The neurological notion of chunking is crucial. One comes to understand what their “chunk” is. In classic chunking theory, the expert is someone whose chunk is larger than everyone else’s. For instance, a great basketball point guard’s chunk is the entire court simultaneously. They can look at it and make sense of the whole thing. An eight-year-old playing basketball, however, has a chunk that’s just the player in front of them. As a writer, I believe you learn to understand your own chunk - how much information you can process and make sense of within a given period. I always know very clearly when I’m done for the day, when I’ve reached the point of steep diminishing returns. It’s when I realize I’ve exceeded my maximum for that moment. David (04:12-04:17): Has that maximum increased over the course of your career, similar to a runner’s endurance? Malcolm (04:17-04:54): It’s a little bigger than it was. The challenge is that we have far more distractions now than we did earlier in my career. However, my levels of self-discipline have probably increased. I’m certainly much more efficient than when I started out. Initially, I was quite a slow writer. I remember working for six months on my first magazine article when I was twenty or twenty-one years old. I wasn’t working on it every day, but it took a long time to get it finished. Today, I would have completed that in a week. David (04:55-05:06): Talk to me about the idea of looking for people closer to the front lines. You once described it as seeking out individuals who are almost five levels down in an organization. Malcolm (05:06-12:28): I’ve always been fascinated in storytelling by specificity. When I think about what makes somebody interesting or funny, it is almost always their particular talent for bringing specificity to what they articulate. My favorite joke, one I think about every single day, is by the comic Demetri Martin. It’s the greatest joke of all time. His setup involved thinking of phrases whose meaning was altered by adding the minimum number of words. He’s obsessed with language. One of his best examples involves a restaurant bathroom sign that reads, “Employees must wash hands before returning to work.” He adds, “Especially Earl.” It’s one of the greatest literary jokes of all time. It’s brilliant because you immediately imagine Earl. In an instant, you know Earl, and suddenly the idea of staying in that restaurant becomes impossible. You have to leave. I’ve thought of that joke often. I realize that when I respond to people or friends I find interesting, it’s because they bring that level of specificity to their conversation. Specificity doesn’t require you to be smarter or necessarily more informed than anyone else; it simply makes you more interesting. Part of what makes eavesdropping on a conversation so much fun is the sheer amount of specificity. You have no context. Women, in my experience, are actually better at this than men, and for a good reason. Now that I am married with children, I understand why women have more specificity: they need it. You listen to conversations with no relevance to you, simply because you’re attracted to the specificity of it. When someone says, “And then she called me, and this is what she said,” you are riveted. I remember interviewing one of the guys from Vampire Weekend for two hours. At least half of the interview, he discussed a single line in a song. He used this incredibly specific piece of music and lyrics to talk about his entire experience. It wasn’t intentional; he just happened to want to focus on that particular detail that day. Rick, especially, kept prodding him for more and more detail. It was fantastic. When considering whom to interview, you don’t want the most impor… Get full access to David Perell's How I Write at howiwrite.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Malcolm Gladwell's on the show today, who's one of the most influential nonfiction writers in the 21st century. You know him from books like Outliers, The Tipping Point, David and Goliath, his essays, and The New Yorker. And I said, Malcolm, I want to learn one thing from you. I want to learn how you tell a story like you do. What is it that you do to find the facts, find the narrative, do your research, and just weave it all together into this story? That's compelling, that brings me through, that changes my worldview, that's easy to remember. I want to know how you do all that. And if [music]
SPEAKER_01the connection between writing and puzzles. In what way for you is writing like constructing a puzzle? In what way is it different?
SPEAKER_00That's the pleasure of it. It's assembling pieces. Some pieces come from you, some pieces you collect, some pieces you had in the back of your head for a while and you have to kind of arrange them in your mind on the page. When I'm deep in writing, I have very often had the sensation that when I get up and go outside, I don't know where I am. And I've thought about this a lot and I think it's because I am using exactly
SPEAKER_00the same part of my brain for writing as I do to make sense of my mind. Of direction, right? The same thing. In order to know where you're going, you have to visualize in your mind a series of steps that lead to some. And I've so kind of exhausted that particular module of my brain in writing that when I go outside and have to do it again, even in a more trivial way, I can't do it. It takes me like two minutes and then finally I realize where I am.
SPEAKER_01On that point, do you feel like, let's follow the sense of direction analogy, do you feel like there's a certain amount of time each day, a certain amount of consistency that you need in your writing to maintain that sense of direction, that kind of spatial awareness of where you are in the piece and holding all the information in your head?
SPEAKER_00Well, unfortunately, very little of my life is given over to writing, much less than I would have thought. Most of my days are spent either reporting or arranging to report. Logistics consume an enormous amount of, and the kind of background stuff. So writing is not rare, but relatively rare. But when I'm in the middle of it, I do notice, like I'm in the middle of a little writing chunk right now. And I do notice how quickly you get into the, takes a couple of days,
SPEAKER_00but by day three, it's all starting to kind of make sense again. You've used that muscle again. Like some fiction writers write every day. I've always been fascinated by what that would feel like because I've never done that. That consistency. Yeah. Except when I was a newspaper writer, but that's a different kind of writing.
SPEAKER_01I've heard you say most writers overestimate how much writing they can get done in one day. So there is an element of consistency, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. You know that neurological notion of chunking? Yeah. I think you come to an understanding of what your chunk is. In classic chunking, the expert is someone whose chunk is larger than everybody else. You know, the great basketball point guard, his chunk is the whole court simultaneously.
SPEAKER_00Everyone on the court, all at once, he can look at it and make sense of the whole thing. The kid, the eight-year-old playing basketball, his chunk is the guy in front of him, right? So I do think that as a writer, you come to understand what your chunk is, And how much information can I make sense of in a given period? I very clearly, I always know when I'm done for the day. And where I'm into steep, diminishing returns. Because I realized, oh, I've exceeded my maximum by the moment.
SPEAKER_01Did that maximum increase over the course of your career like a runner?
SPEAKER_00It's a little bit bigger than it was, I think. The problem is that You know, we have way more distractions than we But I do think my levels of self-discipline have probably, I'm certainly a lot more efficient than I was when I started out. When I started out, I was quite a slow writer. I remember I worked for six months on my first magazine article. I was 20, well under 20 years old. But I wasn't working on it every day, but it took a long time to kind of get it out.
SPEAKER_00Today, I would have done that in a week.
SPEAKER_01Talk to me about this idea of looking for people who are closer to the front lines. I think the way you put it, it was almost people who are five levels down in an organization.
SPEAKER_00I've always been fascinated in storytelling by specificity. When I think about what makes... Somebody interesting or funny, it is almost always that they have a particular talent for bringing specificity to what they're articulating. My favorite joke of, I think about this joke every single day, the comic Dimitri Martin has this joke, which I think is the greatest joke of all time. The setup was he was thinking of phrases that have their meaning altered
SPEAKER_00by the addition of the minimum number of words. So that's his setup because he's obsessed with language. And the best of his examples was when you go into the bathroom in a restaurant and it says, employees must wash hands before returning to work. So the words he added to that are, employees must wash hands before returning to work, especially Earl. Which is the greatest, I think it's one of the greatest literary jokes of all time.
SPEAKER_00And it's great because immediately you imagine who Earl is, right? In an instant, you know Earl. And also suddenly the notion of staying in that restaurant becomes impossible. Like you can't, you have to leave, right? You can't stay. It's so good. And that, I've thought of that joke so often because it's like, and I realized what makes people, when I respond to somebody or friends of mine, Who I Find Interesting. It's because there is, they bring that level of specificity to their conversation.
SPEAKER_00And it's that specificity is not, you're not specific or use specifics when you're smarter than anyone else or even necessarily more informed than anyone else. It's just if you're more interesting than anyone else, right? It's the thing that makes you interesting. And all kinds of people bring part of what makes eavesdropping A conversation so much fun is how much specificity there is. You have no context, right? Or women are actually, in my experience, better at this than men.
SPEAKER_00There's a far more specific, for a reason now that I am married and have children, I understand why women have more specificity because they need to have more specificity. But the reason why do you listen, there's no reason, nothing that is being said is of any relevance to you. But you listen because you're attracted to the specificity of it. And then she called me and this is what she said. You're like riveted by that. And I remember once doing an interview with one of the guys from Vampire Weekend.
SPEAKER_00It was two hours and at least half of the interview, he was talking about one line in the song. It was everything he wanted. He was using this incredibly specific bit of music and lyrics to kind of talk about his entire, not intentionally, he just happened to want to focus on that that day. And we just, Rick especially, just kept on prodding him to get more and more and more and more and more. It was fantastic. So the thing about people who are, when you're thinking about who to interview, you don't want the most important person.
SPEAKER_00It doesn't help you. You want the person who can bring the most specificity to the topic. If you're thinking of nonfiction writing as a balance between you and the material, The easiest thing for you to do, in many ways is the best thing for you to do is the context. You set up, and then what you want from your subjects is the granularity. And there's way more that's surprising and, like I did a,
SPEAKER_00I interviewed this cardiac surgeon the other day, John Puskas, who is one of the pioneers of what's called minimally invasive cardiac surgery. Huge deal in that world. He's this Canadian guy, and this is sort of important because there's a certain kind of old school Canadian who's very proper, very kind of English, but also very kind of plain spoken. It's a weird... The combination of that kind of, they're usually, I know that it's funny,
SPEAKER_00I've met this type so many times in my life. I know where they live. They live in a certain neighborhood in Toronto called Rosedale. There's something a little bit early 20th century about them. They wear proper shoes. They have a very precise way of speaking. But there's also a kind of earthiness to them. Anyway, he grew up in a mining town in Northern Ontario, but he's that guy. He now is a fancy surgeon at Emory. And the interview is, it was one of those interviews that were like, it was a 99th percentile interview.
SPEAKER_00And there's a moment in it where he's describing the problem. So cardiac surgery, bypass surgery is, I cut open your, I cut down your sternum, I pry open your ribs, the heart is in front of me, I hook it up to an external machine, and then I sew on an artery, right, that I've gotten from somewhere. He was the pioneer, one of the pioneers of what's called minimally invasive where you don't cut open the chest. You make a little tiny incision and you insert a camera and you use little thin long instruments and sometimes a robot and you sew it all.
SPEAKER_00You don't stop the heart at all. You just sew it all and the cavity is this narrow deep thing. And so there's a moment where he's describing why that's different. And he uses, there's no context. He's not talking about You know, the broader struggle to get surgeons to move. He's not talking about the long-term implication. He's talking about what it means to look through an incision that's four centimeters long and, you know, whatever,
SPEAKER_00six centimeters deep with this. And he goes on, and it's like poetry. It's like... And every, in violation, you think normally when you're, it works against you if there's too many numbers, right? Because the reader or the listener is troubled. He uses a number in every sentence, but so artfully and beautifully that it kind of builds symphonically. And you're like, he's like, everything's in centimeters too, which is just lovely that it's in centimeters, right?
SPEAKER_00Because of course that's the way He's going to think as a surgeon, right? So it's the four centimeters and the eight centimeters. And then if I move my hand, you know, half a centimeter, it disrupts my neighbor on the operating table's hand. And he's talking about how they have to kind of collaborate. And then he goes, what we're playing, you know, it's not, we've gone from playing singles tennis and now we're playing tennis. Soccer. And what's lovely at that point is after listening to him, you're like, you know this guy plays a lot of tennis.
SPEAKER_00And you realize that he's chosen that because it's emotionally important to him. Tennis is emotionally meaningful to him. And he's saying, you know, I had to give up this thing I loved and play soccer. He just kind of stopped playing soccer. He's like a patrician, Canadian. He's never been near a soccer field in his life. He plays Dennis at his cottage in Lake Muskoka. That's what he does, right? But anyway, everything about that was great because he wasn't addressing the larger stuff. I could do that.
SPEAKER_00He was like giving me the kind of bird's eye view.
SPEAKER_01I want to talk about specificity with your new book because immediately I was talking to my aunt this morning. She said, hey, what's Malcolm working on? I said, book about gun violence. And immediately when I started talking about it, I was like, OK, here's what the right is going to say. Here's what the left is going to say. And all of a sudden we start talking about abstractions and ideologies. So my question for you here is, as you investigate a topic like that, how do you use specificity to find some semblance of truth that is like under all the abstractions that we're stuck thinking in?
SPEAKER_00So there were some deliberate narrative choices in writing that book to do this, that very thing. One is that chapter where I talk about that surgeon, Eddie Cornwall, talking about the hardest case of his life. You know, Eddie is the guy who's treated more gunshot wounds than probably anyone else. I don't want to say history, but it's quite possible than anyone else in history. And he's this He is a patrician African-American from Washington, D.C. He's a very particular type who's a third-generation surgeon.
SPEAKER_00And I love that story. It's a great story, first of all, his story about how he saves his kid who should otherwise have died of gun violence. And he comes to this really bizarre, unusual interpretation of why he managed to save the kid's life. Because the kid, I won't go into it, but because the kid happened to have been Hidden a scrotum with a bullet, which he comes to understand as the key to unlocking why the kid survives. And the reason that story is so important in the context of that book is
SPEAKER_00that he takes you, physicians take us a long way from ideology. It's one of the few professions that is Uninfected by all of these kind of hardened partisan lines. And so the more I can spend time in the head of a physician, the more I forget that politics messes up our understanding of things. By the end, I hope, you're so transported that you've forgotten you had an ideological position. And also his perspective is so different from yours,
SPEAKER_00which is he just sees the fruits of He's not one charged in stopping it or he isn't getting involved in policy debates. They show up in his ER. There was a moment in that story where he says two kids come into the hospital. They were both injured because they both shot each other. And the first thing he has to do is to make sure that the families aren't in the waiting room together because they'll continue the fight.
SPEAKER_00That's the only moment where he has to step outside as possible and understand, because he understands that what he sees day in, day out is the outcome of grievances, disputes, arguments, nothing, it's not like Any grand conspiratorial violence, it's just beefs. And so he has to, he knows he has the two families potentially meeting in the waiting room and he has to send the other case, the lesser case, to another hospital to make sure they don't meet in the...
SPEAKER_01So you give that little glimpse and then you're just, but then you're down in his point of view. This episode is sponsored by AlphaSchool. When you think of school, what comes to mind? For me, it was lectures, homework, being stuck at a desk. And the worst part is that it doesn't even work. 54% of Americans read below a sixth grade level. That's over half of Americans. We need something new. And that's why I'm excited to have Alpha School as the flagship sponsor of How I Write. At Alpha, you go to school, you get all your academics done
SPEAKER_01in only two hours per day so that then you can spend the rest of the time learning life skills like running a business, writing a musical, giving a TEDx talk. You know, the kind of things that make you a capable and well-rounded person. And it's working. They have the academics figured out. Alpha classes test in the top 1% nationally, and more than 90% of students say they love school. Now, I used to live in Austin, where Alpha School started, and I was consistently blown away by what was happening there. I personally mentored a bunch of the kids and what stuck out
SPEAKER_01to me is how much their team believes in the potential of kids. Alpha's approach and the success it's already having is why it's the most talked about K-12 school in the world right now. And also where I want to send my kids to school one day. So if you want to learn more, visit go.alpha.school slash how I write. As you're writing stories, thinking through the pacing, thinking through the reveal of information, what is it that you're focused on?
SPEAKER_00I'm an old newspaper man. So if you're a newspaper person, you're aware that your reader will leave you, right? You have a sense of fatalism about that. They'll leave you before it's over. So you're constantly in a state of anxiety about keeping them For as long as you can. And that means, you know, spending a lot of time on the beginning, obviously, but also like keeping certain kind of mysteries alive
SPEAKER_00so that the person can't leave, right?
SPEAKER_01They're kind of trapped because they need to know the answer.
SPEAKER_00It's why I like mysteries and spy novels so much because that's the game they're playing as well, right? It's the titration of information and of twists and all those kinds of things to keep you involved.
SPEAKER_01What'd you take from Lee Child? Well, Lee Child is all about specificity.
SPEAKER_00He's a king of specificity. Although you could argue that genre-wise, Day of the Jackal is the most important book of genre because Day of the Jackal is really a kind of how-to book. The whole book is consumed with the details of how the jackal goes about plotting and executing the assassination of a major political figure, right? It's like no one had really ever done that before, as far as I understand.
SPEAKER_00It's like, it's not a how-to, but it's really close to a how-to. But it took such pleasure. It luxuriated in the details. Here's the weapon. Here's how you take it apart. Here's how you put it back together. It gave you this minute-by-minute examination of this guy's day. He's moving across Paris, France. He has this much time. He meets this woman. He picks her up. She takes him home. He has to kill her in the morning. You know, this kind of like logistical lens.
SPEAKER_01That's the genius of it.
SPEAKER_00You never thought about the mechanics of beating up four men in a bar. You know the cartoon version that you see in a TV show, but it's not explained to you, and it's a trick. You know it's a trick. He writes it in such a way that you begin to believe that it's actually possible if you know what you're doing.
SPEAKER_01And tell me about Jean Le Carre and the idea of disordered stories.
SPEAKER_00Is really important because it affects the way that you appreciate the story. So those are disordered narratives. You're getting information in a not in logical order, but in an incomplete order and here Eventually he's going to fill in all of those. Narratively, there's a lot of kind of circling back and filling in holes as you get deeper and deeper into the book. Or you're learning a lot of facts in the wrong order.
SPEAKER_00That's what engages your interest. And one of the reasons that he's able to sustain that is because he's so masterful in creating So you really feel, you don't feel like you're Smiley or that Smiley's a friend of yours, but you do feel like as he's trudging through the rain on some gloomy London night with his raincoat and his whatever, you actually feel like you're walking next to him. I always feel like I've rarely read someone who so completely puts me in that world.
SPEAKER_01Is it like an arm on the shoulder sitting on the couch with you or is it something else?
SPEAKER_00I feel I kind of know, without having any first-hand experience with that world, I feel I know it. In some of his earlier books, his ability to capture the dreariness of post-war London life
SPEAKER_01It's so spectacular.
SPEAKER_00But my point is that because he can do that, it permits him, he gets all kinds of liberties. He has allowed all kinds of liberties in other areas. I have a friend of mine who was writing a non-writer, writing her first novel, and she's incredibly startlingly gifted. And I was talking to her because her gift is for characterization and her writing is like, there are paragraphs that if I showed them to you, you'd be like, oh my God, like, Jewel box paragraph. And she asked me to respond to her manuscript.
SPEAKER_00And I said, you have to understand that because that part of your writing is so good, we don't need a long, complicated, engrossing plot. We don't need that. We're happy. We're meeting these characters. We're in love with the language. Just give us enough plot. That we have a, you know, another kind of part of our brain is activated, but people do elaborate plots when they haven't mastered the other stuff, right?
SPEAKER_00They're just covering up for the fact they can't write, or their characters are cardboard, right? If you can do character like Lucari can, and if you can do mood, then you can like meander along with these kind of, these wonderfully elusive plots.
SPEAKER_01Is the point here that it really helps to have a keen awareness of what the specificity of what your gift really is and lean into that and not kind of try to do everything?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I am very, very, very late to any kind of artistic appreciation, but we moved into a new apartment in the city and I had to buy art for the first time in my life. And I bought this one painter. I put the painting in our bedroom. And I'm stunned every time I look at it by the difference between its figurative meaning and the mood it elicits.
SPEAKER_00So it's a woman on a bed. You don't see her face. And the bed is unmade. And it's ginormous, this painting. It's like four by six. And if you actually look at it really up close, it's not like it's an incredible feat of portraiture. It's not like, but the mood it evokes is so overwhelming. It just like, it's moving, it's complicated.
SPEAKER_00It's like, I've seen it now A hundred times. It has not lost any of its appeal to me. I'm just in awe of that. I was like, oh my God, like that's, wow. I feel that way about some writers. They can just do, they can do that thing so well that everything else becomes less important.
SPEAKER_01Do you know what the genesis was for the style that you developed of starting with the story and then having that story unfold? Where did that come from? Because if I look at it culturally, I think it goes back to you.
SPEAKER_00So very early in my life, I fell in love with Michael Lewis's writing. And I always thought that Michael Lewis, among others, and Janet Malcolm will be another example of this, are writers who do something that I cannot do. That they can inhabit a character and sustain your interest as they go deeper and deeper into that character. Michael does it. They do it in very different ways. But Michael... Michael can go and hang out with somebody, and he can just bring that person to life.
SPEAKER_00And he allows that person to present themselves on their own terms, which is a beautiful, generous thing he does. And that's why we're so drawn to his writing, because there is this incredible, like I say, generosity to it. He gives a warm reading of their world. Because he's chosen him, because he has warm feelings towards him. But there's not, there's very little of Michael. It's like a kind of, I once wrote something about Michael and I said that I was distinguishing Michael Lewis and Bob Woodward.
SPEAKER_00And they're totally different. For Watergate, you don't want Michael Lewis. Because Michael, remember Nixon's secretary was Rosemary Woods. And I said that if Michael was doing Trying to break the Watergate story, he would never get past Rosemary Woods. He'd spend his whole time, he'd fall in love with her, he'd tell her whole story. It would go on, it would be a completely different story. It would not be about Watergate, right? He would like find his own little, the thing about the Woodward thing is, Woodward finds the real important story and like gathers an enormous amount
SPEAKER_00of information in service of that. Michael, he wants to carry, you know, he fell in love with the character and like will give you that, bring that character to life in a lovely way. I can't do that. I don't know how to, I could never write an entire book about one person. I try, I actually tried. So my long answer to your question, why do I tell stories that way? Because I don't think I can tell stories in a conventional way.
SPEAKER_01How much stock do you place in kind of the intrinsic entertainingness of the subject? So I'll give you an example. Michael Lewis finds Billy Bean who's taking sports analytics, applying it to baseball, and it's numbers, numbers, and more numbers. If I look at that, I'm like, interesting story, not going to be a riveting narrative. He found a way to do it. Is that a skill that he has? Or do stories carry this kind of intrinsic entertainingness?
SPEAKER_00In his case, it's a skill he has. I will turn down a story if I don't think it has intrinsic interestingness.
SPEAKER_01I mean, the story of how they got turned into a movie is so many people tried and failed.
SPEAKER_00They went through draft after draft. The film was filmed and then it had to be massively re-edited for the exact reason you just stated. The story is not intrinsically interesting. Michael made it interesting, right? I don't have faith that I can make something interesting. That lacks some fundamental, crucial narrative element into a good story.
SPEAKER_01When we were talking earlier, you talked about the increase in discipline over the course of your career and your ability to sit down and be more efficient. So we take that on the side. But also in preparing for this, I was like, the level of curiosity that you have, the number of subjects that you've explored is just so vast. And in order to get there, you have to place a lot of weight on what's in the periphery of your vision. And so how do you crank up, crank down your peripheral awareness? Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Well, that's changed over the years. One of the things I do now is I very deliberately try and do things professionally that get me exposed to. So I do a podcast with IBM called Smart Talks at IBM, which is basically me interviewing or telling stories about some of their clients. Now, it sounds... One responds to me, why would you do that? I actually think it's essential to my practice because It's not
SPEAKER_00a world I would otherwise have any exposure to. I try and build into my life things that compel my curiosity in certain directions. The podcast is the same thing. I have a certain amount of episodes I have to do. I don't know at the beginning of the season what they are. And so I am compelled to look everywhere. That's a very, very useful kind of compulsion that I have built into my life.
SPEAKER_01What are you doing as you're looking? Is it like find the story, find the interesting, find the one-liner? What is the, ah, I got it. Like what enters your mind right before you say, ah, I got it. I think I found the thing.
SPEAKER_00It's funny because I've started to do this thing recently in the last couple of years where I find someone and without any agenda whatsoever, I say, let's meet. For as long as we want. Let's just get together once every three weeks and talk for two hours. And I gather 15, 20, 25 hours of tape. And I was inspired to do this because of the Paul Simon thing. Because with Paul Simon, I went to him and said, I'd love to do something on you.
SPEAKER_00And he was like, sure. And then I thought I'd meet with him twice. And at the end of every meeting, he would always say, when are we meeting again? He was just enjoying it. And I was enjoying it. I didn't know where it was headed. And each time I interviewed him, we interviewed, me and my friend Bruce did it, we found out more stuff that we didn't know we were going to find out. And so I began to make that part of my kind of intentional practice. I've done this now four or five times. What I'm doing now, I figured out why I was doing it probably in hour 12.
SPEAKER_00It was a, I was talking, it's a guy who's an ICU doctor, and I really literally had no, I had used him on another story, thought he was an interesting guy, proposed that we just talk, had no, had zero feeling about where I was going to head. In hour 12, he tells me about, he testified in a lawsuit in a murder case.
SPEAKER_01I was like, oh, tell me about that.
SPEAKER_00And he goes, The prosecution called 50 expert witnesses. The defense called one. I was that one witness and we won. I was like, oh, there we are. Oh, yeah. That's it. That's it, baby. That's it. And it turned out, wow, was that it, is all I have to say. Because then I just went back and like, okay, I know what I want now.
SPEAKER_01In your conversations with Paul Simon, you have a line that really stuck out to me. You say, I've always thought that memory is under-theorized in the creative process. Talk to me about that.
SPEAKER_00It dates back to this thing that I first learned about with somebody was interviewing Larry Bird, basketball player. In the course of the interview, they asked Larry Bird about a game he'd been involved in,
SPEAKER_01like 15 years before.
SPEAKER_00And he reconstructs the game in insane detail. And then I learned that actually lots of guys can do this. Bill Russell, you know, being interviewed, remembered he was in his 80s at the time, reconstructed in exceedingly precise, accurate detail the circumstances of a game he played as a kid in college. And I began to think, oh, so this must be constituent of These people at the top, that their memories are serving some essential function in there.
SPEAKER_00And you can think of some of the obvious ones if you're a basketball player, or it goes back to chunking. It's how you increase the size of your chunk, that your memory is serving as a kind of archive of patterns. So you have so many patterns in your head that there's nothing, you can use them. Even when you seem to be in unfamiliar territory, you're in familiar territory, which if you're a basketball player or a golfer, it was incredibly useful. But I also began to wonder that With Paul Simon,
SPEAKER_00his memory for the music of his youth, I mean, he was in his late 70s when we talked, and he would have insanely, incredibly precise memories of the B-side of a 45 that he played when he heard when he was 11 years old, and I realized, oh, you know, that must be a key part of Particularly of how he is able to remain so creative for so long that he's drawing from this.
SPEAKER_00He can draw effortlessly and precisely from an enormous archive, which gives him... He's his own walking LLM, right? He just has infinite resources in terms of summoning facts and riffs and musical ideas. Like I said, I don't think, maybe I haven't looked hard enough, but I've seen surprisingly little theorizing about that because it seems
SPEAKER_00to be really important.
SPEAKER_01We've talked a lot about specificity, and obviously that's a big part of your writing, but then there's the other side, which is general observations, broad points, and how do you think about the balance, the interplay, the harmony between the two of those?
SPEAKER_00I think that you have an obligation, if you do my kind of writing, to give people tools to organize their experience. So you, and also things are much more powerful if I give you a kind of overarching why or overarching kind of, that's a way of, it's not just a way of making sense of the world, it's a way of also of retaining the information. So if you're nervous about your viewer abandoning,
SPEAKER_00your listener or reader abandoning you, then I think you try harder to give them something to hold on to, a place to file the information you're giving them. That other part, that kind of like, that sort of superstructure is a kind of crucial part of ensuring you're heard. And so I've kind of, I don't do it as much as I used to. I think I overused some of that. I got very cute with the things I would, you know, I'd always come up with fun names for things.
SPEAKER_00And got a little out of hand. But I think the impulse was correct, which is that you do want to organize experience for people because people are very poor, you know?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I caught this example from Blink. And I was thinking, what is this? I feel like you're setting the premise. Maybe I'm right. Maybe I'm wrong. I'm curious to hear how you think about it. But you write, we live in a world that assumes that the quality of a decision is directly related to the time and effort that went into making it. We believe that we are always better in gathering as much information as possible. We really only trust conscious decision -making, but there are moments, particularly in times of stress when haste does not make waste, when our snap judgments and first impressions can offer a much better means
SPEAKER_01of making sense of the world. The first task of Blink is to convince you of simple fact. Decisions made very quickly can be every bit as good as decisions made cautiously It's like setting the premise, here's where we're going to go. Talk to me about that.
SPEAKER_00What you're reading in that is echoes of my newspaper past. You wouldn't do that in a newspaper in a non-exact way, but the intention is very newspaper-y. Here's where I'm going. You know, I'm going to be as clear and as organized as possible in the way I'm going to tell this story so you can, you know, get out of here quickly and go on to reading other parts of the paper. Like it's very, that kind of,
SPEAKER_00There's a certain kind of lurking behind that is the anxiety of the writer's anxiety of being abandoned. As I've gotten further and further away from newspapers, I've lost a little bit of that.
SPEAKER_01As I'm older,
SPEAKER_00I tolerate a lot more ambiguity in my writing. So there's not a lot of toleration of ambiguity in that.
SPEAKER_01Now, the way you're talking there reminds me of comedians. The comedians, when they come on the show, they talk a lot about their nervousness, their anxiety about the lack of a laugh. And a lot of them say, it's taken me years to get to a point where I can go 30 seconds without a laugh, a minute without a laugh, so I can get into deeper stuff in my comedy.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's funny that so many, I'm obsessed with Bill Cosby, and so many of those comedians, there's a whole group of them for whom he is the gold standard, he's the one new. And a lot of it is that the amount of self-confidence he had on stage was astonishing, right? His ability to delay, and he's sitting on the stage, he's not standing, he's sitting on a stool
SPEAKER_01No, there's something, there's a rhythm
SPEAKER_00to what he was doing, which ran so counter to the kind of anxiety that you're talking about. And that's why so many comics were drawn to him. They're like, oh, I don't have to be this kind of nervously pursuing the laughs. You know, look at Bill. Bill, you know, Bill has his own problems, obviously, but, you know, look at him. And that revolutionizes comedy, right? The chill comedian. You know, wow, what a kind of oxymoron.
SPEAKER_01It feels like we're a little bit over-indexed on humor relative to other things. I was thinking about why. And we live in a very fast culture. It's very quick. It's kind of warp speed. And the thing about comedy is you can get comedy fast. You can't get other virtues fast. And maybe that's why we're so indexed to comedy.
SPEAKER_00And this always gets me in trouble with comedians who I admire tremendously. But getting someone to laugh is just way easier than getting them to cry. I mean, it's not even close. Much of laughter is like cheap and kind of, you know, sometimes it's meaningful, but other times, a lot of times it's not. It's just kind of like a side effect of the way people process unusual bit of information. Tears, on the other hand, now that's a serious business. There's a moment in what I think the best podcast I've ever done was,
SPEAKER_00came out last year, and it was called The Alabama Murders.
SPEAKER_01It all builds to a moment in the eighth episode.
SPEAKER_00This woman who we've gotten to know was the protector of this guy on death row in Alabama and tries to save his life. And we learn that she's failed. And she's describing the moment when she learns he's been executed. And we've been building towards this for seven episodes. So that's three hours. And I don't think there's any way to listen to that and not cry in that moment.
SPEAKER_00Part of the reason that was powerful because, going back to what I was saying earlier, she's one of those people I sat with for hours and hours and hours. And she told that story in maybe hour 15 of our get-togethers. So I had earned that moment from her. It wasn't like she just came out with it. We'd established a level of rapport and trust over repeated meetings as we finally got to the emotional core of this. And she described sitting in her home in Brooklyn, and she gets a call from death row in Alabama saying that Kenny, Kenny was going.
SPEAKER_00And she says, and I'll never forget, this is the thing that makes you cry. She says, I said, what did you do when you heard? And she said, I do what I always do. I lit a candle and said a small prayer. It's that you realize, oh, this is not her first case. She has tried to save the lives of many people on death row before, and she always fails. And then you're like... We've just been with her with one case for, and now you suddenly learn at the emotional crux, this is not a one-off.
SPEAKER_00I do what I always do. I do what I always do. And it's like, to this day, I hear that and I'm just like, that's insane. I remember when I, was a wreck when she was saying that, because I had been with her for like 12 hours. And I realized, listening to the tape, that I needed to organize the story around that moment. And the organization meant three hours of run-up, thousands and thousands of words of getting there. Because I knew if I got you there, then you understood what I was doing.
SPEAKER_01Talking to you, I really feel what audio did for your experience. For you as a storyteller. I mean, I can feel it and I understand it now. Like, obviously doing so much writing early on and then the podcasts and how podcasts and music and sound can deliver information and hit all these emotional frequencies that I think are harder to hit in the world of writing.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I love it. Audio so much. It's so, I think it's because so much, I think I process, I don't think I'm alone. Like many people, I process so much information orally, particularly powerful information. When I think of my mother, I think of her voice. She's a very distinctive voice. I always say to friends, I describe my mother, and I always say, I wish you could meet her.
SPEAKER_00And by which I mean, I don't mean that you need to see her to understand her. You got to hear her. Are writers undervaluing audiobooks? Oh, massively. We do all our audiobooks using real tape. So if I interview you in the course of the book, then I use that tape for the interview. It's like an audio documentary. It's like an extended podcast. The idea that anyone would ever do a nonfiction audiobook any other way is madness to me.
SPEAKER_00Why? Why bother? Why are you reading the quote from somebody? It's audio. Play me the tape. Let's hear them. Like, what are you doing? In the audiobook for American Way of Killing, I have a friend, Drew Holcomb, who's a singer in Nashville. Really, really, really, really interesting guy. And I called him up. I sent him the book. And I said, read the book, and if there's any music of yours that suits,
SPEAKER_00I want to use the music. Oh, cool. So he reads the book, and he used the music back. He said, yeah, there's a song I wrote called Troubles, and I think it works. And so I said, okay. And then I looked it up and listened to it, and I was in tears. It's like, oh my God. So now the book begins with him singing Troubles. He does in two and a half minutes what I couldn't do in the book, which is he set the mood. It's going back to what Lee Child says he can do. Using that song at the beginning, like, oh, okay, I'm in it now.
SPEAKER_00Because the song is all about a... Drew's taking his kid to school and he hears about a mass shooting. Out of school. And he drops his kid off and goes home and writes this song. And that emotional, that was the space he's in. And it's this kind of lament. But I don't want to do that. I don't want to have to do that. It's wrong. Why at the moment when I'm dropping my kids off, am I hearing about 25 kids killed in Texas or something?
SPEAKER_00And that is exactly the emotional register I wanted in the book.
SPEAKER_01And it was there.
SPEAKER_00Why would I do the audiobook without that song? It's crazy. I would have paid him. Don't tell him this. He gave it to me for free. I would have paid him an infinite amount of money for the rest of that song. It's like, name your price, Drew. Dude, I need it.
SPEAKER_01I can't do without it. So how do you produce your audiobooks? Is your thinking through, okay, my book comes out September 29th. You finish the book when? And how is your process different to produce that?
SPEAKER_00Only in the sense that I'm collecting all my tape as I go along. And when I'm writing, you'll notice in American Way of Killing, in the print version, when I have large groups of text, it's like a screenplay. There's a lot more quoted, chunks of quoted speech in it. It's influenced by the fact that I'm thinking about it as a bit of audio as I'm writing it.
SPEAKER_01So really the audiobook begins...
SPEAKER_00Audiobooks have definitely changed the way I write books. In some of my books, I've sold more audiobooks than print books.
SPEAKER_01I think of Talking to Strangers as an audiobook. Yeah, that one sold way more, which is very unusual. Tell me about this quote. It's a mistake to make up your mind too soon.
SPEAKER_00From everything, from everyday interactions, if you just delay your conclusion in an interaction, you're so much better off. You're talking to someone, they seem distant and hostile. Your normal reaction is to take on bridge. Just delay it. And what you find out invariably is, you know, something terrible has happened in our life. It's got nothing to do with you. The penalties associated with premature conclusions are just so large. And you just invariably end up being defensive and protecting something in the back
SPEAKER_00of your mind. And I did that with Tipping Point. I fell in love with broken windows. I mean, how many times have I regretted that? It's just dumb. Why are you in year four of the New York City crime turnaround? I backed a horse in retrospect.
SPEAKER_01I was an idiot. Why would you do that? You're four. I was in my 30s. I had plenty of time to wait. Right. How do you think about neatness in terms of storytelling? Kind of the meandering, the on one hand, it's like a good story has like it's it's it's clean. It's neat. It's simple. On the other hand, the world is so messy. It's all over the place. And if you're just like, it's messy and all over the place, you're like, well, thanks, David. But that didn't help me at all. And how do you think about the balance between those two things?
SPEAKER_00You can satisfy the demand for neatness with your characters if it's not there in the story. So going back to the example I gave of my friend who wrote that book where the characterization and the language is so beautiful, my point was
SPEAKER_01you don't need to plot. It's the same way.
SPEAKER_00If you want to tell a story with an indeterminate ending, just make sure that I have a satisfying encounter with a character. Because the character, characters have, it's possible to land somewhere with people. Right? In a meaningful way. You're not necessarily resolving all their ambiguities or complexities, but you can give people a, if I've given you a sense of who that character is, then you're fine with uncertainties
SPEAKER_00in the kind of broader narrative. You know, a lot of science writing is that it is, I meet someone who's trying to unravel a mystery, And by the end, we haven't unraveled the mystery. Maybe we got a little closer. We'll get there maybe. But if the character is compelling, I'm fine with that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. You've obviously studied so many musicians and I think of basketball. We talked about Larry Bird. We talked about Bill Russell. How much have you thought about your own career as... Like an athlete or musician, that kind of intensity, that discipline, that persistence of improvement, all of that.
SPEAKER_00A little bit in the sense that I'm a runner. Running is all about, I'm a distance runner. Distance running is all about the controlled release of effort. Yeah. That you're titrating. It's an exercise in titration. Very, very sophisticated physical titration. And you're in mile one. You can run a lot faster than you're capable of,
SPEAKER_00but you deliberately don't because you want to be around for mile 10. Jakob Ingebrigtsen loses the 1500 meters in the last Olympics because he miscalculates by literally half a second about how he titrates his energy over the first two laps, and he knows it. So he goes out in his first lap, and he sees the split, and he knows he's doomed. He's leading at that point. He's the greatest distance 1500-meter runner in the world.
SPEAKER_00He is trained for this moment. He goes out and those of us who are runners saw that spit and they were like, oh, we all knew it. Like it's like, and so the whole, the race suddenly becomes incredibly fascinating. He's managing the consequences of his misjudgment. He failed to titrate his energy as exactly as, and the margin of error is as tiny to the untrained eye. Like he's fine, still leading, looks relaxed or strutting away, but we all know reckoning is coming. How does that apply for you as a writer?
SPEAKER_00I've thought about that as a kind of useful lesson for thinking about what it means to tell a story that's satisfying. I think people are much more sophisticated in how they consume narratives than we realize. People shut off when it ceases to engage them. And one of the things we're picking up on is That pace, if your pace is wrong, if they feel like you're anxious or you're front-loading too much
SPEAKER_00or you're holding too much back for reasons that aren't justifiable, they get frustrated. I'm an extreme example of this. You know, read a 400-page thriller and I will stop reading on page 395 if I think, if they violated those rules. Okay, that's insane, really? I've done that so many times. I'm like, I'm done with you. I cannot believe you just did that. What are you doing?
SPEAKER_01Just walk away disgusted. If I get 395 pages, I'm making it to the end.
SPEAKER_00I have a stack of books, which I've read almost to their end, but then stopped because I'm just so pissed off.
SPEAKER_01What are your other reading pet peeves?
SPEAKER_00Well, I dislike in thrillers. I hate the multiple endings. I think you got one shot. You don't need four twists. If you have four twists at the end of a thriller, you're a bad thriller writer. You just lost confidence. That moment, you can sense when the writers lost confidence in their material. Movie makers, this is even more. Absolutely. Or the editor or the studio chief, you can see where they lost confidence and you're just, all of the air goes out of the room at that point. You just want to leave. You're like, You guys don't believe in this story. Why should I? Yep. Right?
SPEAKER_00And when they do that thing with the tacked on endings and the like, aye, aye. If you can't find a way out of the problem that you've established for ourselves, what are you doing? Why did you even start?
SPEAKER_01Sometimes you're watching a movie and you're like, ah, the studio watched it and someone high up thought there was a hole in the story. And you can tell because like the register of the writing is different or something like that. And they plopped it into the script and you hear it. And sometimes it's a voiceover, like it's the narrator doing it. And you'll be in the movie and you'll be like, there it is. Come on.
SPEAKER_00They got nervous. And like, you got to trust that. You have to have faith in your story if you're going to tell it properly.
SPEAKER_01What did you learn from songwriters? Has songwriting, the lessons from there, come into your work?
SPEAKER_00Just the economy of expression. It's the same reason, on a more extreme level, why I'm so fascinated with ads. Because the economy is... Extreme in that instance. I've got 30 seconds or I have a minute. The idea that you could do something meaningful in that time is just, to my mind, fantastic. The constraints are, there's a Heineken ad that I love so much that I tracked down the guy who did it and just interviewed him for no reason.
SPEAKER_00I never used the tape. It's the end of the night. They're all tipsy at a bar. They're taking a cab home, as they should. And they all start singing along in a sort of slightly tipsy but kind of fantastic manner. And then halfway through, the grumpy cab driver turns it up and joins in. That's the ad. So good. It's so good. It's a minute. It just summons so many things are happening that warm your heart, right? It makes you want to go out and get a Heineken.
SPEAKER_00It's like they had fun. It's two roles and a guy, so sex is not complicated. They just had good, honest fun. They're taking a cab on, which they should. They're singing in public, which we all want an excuse to do, and they converted the cab driver. Like, six, five things.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. What I love about comedy and what I love about songwriting is if it works, it works. So there's that song by the Black Eyed Peas. Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, and Thursday. Friday, Saturday, Saturday, and Sunday. All they did was say the names of the days in a week. And yet, it just works. I love that song. I got a feeling. And... I just really love the idea that if people like it, then it's good.
SPEAKER_00I was thinking of, there's another great Days of the Week song from the 80s, the chorus, isn't it something, something, something, Thursdays I'm in Love? Friday I'm in Love. Friday I'm in Love. It's a great, yes, when they work, they work forever.
SPEAKER_01Last question. If you go to a high school, you go to a college, or let's put it like this, you're given the ability, the opportunity to basically teach a semester, class on writing, to do what you've done. What do you tell them? How do you structure the curriculum? What are the core lessons that you're trying to give them? I thought about this.
SPEAKER_00It's all about asking questions. Everything begins with your ability to ask questions and to understand what the point of a question is, to understand where a question comes from, to appreciate what's interesting in someone, to be generous in that process, to understand that it's about them, not you. It's just everything flows. I would just do endless versions of question-asking. I would have... I would have the kids go home and I would have them interview their parents
SPEAKER_00and bring the transcripts back into the class. I would go through the transcripts. I'd have them write articles that were just versions of transcripts. And understand that writing an article about someone or something is simply a version of the interview, right? It's the interview is everything. And then you're just filling in the blanks. It's fine. If I'm dealing with a 14-year-old, That it begins with someone else giving you something. I think kids think the burden is on them and that's why they're so inhibited
SPEAKER_00when it comes to writing. I don't know what story to tell. We're not asking you to tell a story. That's the last thing I want. No, other people have stories. Go and find out what they are. Go and Why do so many people, when you ask people after their parents have passed, every single person I've ever talked to about this said, oh yeah, I never talked to them about that, I wish I had. Just get to class, sit down with your parents, Take out your phone, just record,
SPEAKER_00have them do 45 minutes, run it through an AI transcript thing, come back with a transcript tomorrow, and let's make a little article about your parents and where they came from. That's where we, that's day one. And then we just build from there, right? And then the last class is I bring in someone who has a secret. Class has to figure out the secret. I'm not telling you anything else. And they sit in the middle of the room and we just see if we get there.
SPEAKER_01I would love to take that class. Malcolm Gladwell, thank you very much. It was great to meet you.
I want to learn more about who’s listening to How I Write. What kind of writing do you do? What do you like about the show, and how can I make it better? Who do you want me to interview? So I threw together a little...
I want to learn more about who’s listening to How I Write. What kind of writing do you do? What do you like about the show, and how can I make it better? Who do you want me to interview? So I threw together a little...
Big thanks to Alpha School for being the presenting sponsor of this episode. When I was in school, I constantly found myself thinking: “We can do so much better than this.” Alpha School is what I wish existed back then....
Big thanks to Alpha School for being the presenting sponsor of this episode. When I was in school, I constantly found myself thinking: “We can do so much better than this.” Alpha School is what I wish existed back then....
Big thanks to Alpha School for being the presenting sponsor of this episode. When I was in school, I constantly found myself thinking: “We can do so much better than this.” Alpha School is what I wish existed back then....