
Elizabeth Gilbert: This is What 40 Years of Writing Discipline Looks Like
I want to learn more about who’s listening to How I Write. What kind of writing do you do? What do you like about the show, and how can I make it better? Who do you want me to interview? So I threw together a little survey. Here it is. Mind taking a few minutes to fill it out? We’re a small team, and this info helps us book the guests you want and keep making the show. Every answer helps. Big thanks to Alpha School for being the presenting sponsor of this episode. When I was in school, I constantly found myself thinking: “We can do so much better than this.” Alpha School is what I wish existed back then. Kids learn everything they need in only two hours per day, so they can spend the rest of the time actual learning life skills: public speaking, building a business, negotiating, etc. If you want your kid to love school and join classes that rank in the top 1% nationwide, Alpha School is the place to be. Learn more at https://go.alpha.school/howiwrite. Elizabeth Gilbert joins us on the show today. You might know her from books like Big Magic or Eat, Pray, Love. Her story begins when, as a teenager, she vowed to dedicate her life to writing.Decades later, I wanted to ask: What has she learned about the craft? Where does she go when the creative well runs dry? How does she tell great stories and build compelling characters? And what advice does she have for aspiring writers?I hope you enjoy this conversation as much as I did. Transcript 00:01:44 The vow she made to become a writer00:04:15 Should you get an MFA?00:05:43 Labor vs inspiration00:11:00 Don’t write every day00:20:08 Let characters take over00:24:07 Why she outlined 70 pages00:26:40 Choose your first reader00:31:26 Working at a bar vs grad school00:36:54 What she learned from Dickens00:40:20 How she does research00:50:18 Should you pursue greatness?00:56:18 The importance of fun in writing00:59:06 Has publishing gotten harder?01:04:14 Herzog’s advice to artists01:06:14 What to do when burned out01:07:57 Elizabeth’s writing inspirations01:12:06 Get out of the classroom David (00:33): Tell me about the vow you made with writing early in your life. Elizabeth (00:33-01:43): When I was about 15 or 16, I decided to commit myself to writing. I even performed a ceremony, a kind of witchy teenage ritual, where I vowed my life to it. I’m not sure how much I fully comprehended at the time, but the vow implied a commitment: no matter the cost, no matter what others said, regardless of whether I was good or successful, I would pursue writing. It felt very holy. From a very early age, the act of writing felt like my first encounter with divinity - something otherworldly, mysterious, and beautiful. It felt like a gift, and I took it very seriously. While there was much in my youth I didn’t take seriously, including my own health and well-being, this commitment to writing was different. David (01:44-01:50): Did you feel that sense of magic as a reader, or was it really as a writer where you felt that? Elizabeth (01:50-01:51): Both. David (01:51-01:51): How? Elizabeth (01:51-03:09): I certainly felt it as a reader. I was once speaking with Cheryl Strayed, and we discovered we had both done the same thing. As teenagers, we were such passionate readers that we kept notebooks where we copied passages we found beautiful. My notebooks are filled with excerpts, some four or five pages long, where I had laboriously handwritten entire sections of novels, or sometimes just a line or two. Something in me loved it so much that I wanted to absorb it. She did the same thing. The physicality of it was important. When I started writing, we didn’t have computers, so everything was done by hand. The act of writing these beautiful words myself, imbibing them, did something to me. I have a friend who is an incredible painter. As an artistic teenager, she would go to museums and draw, filling notebooks with sketches of other artists’ work. That was partially how she learned to draw. Cheryl and I were doing something similar, and it was partially how we learned how to write. Those words looked beautiful and magical to me. I wondered, “How are they doing this?” David (03:10-03:11): Who did you copy? Elizabeth (03:11-04:14): Whoever was around. I was a voracious reader, influenced by my dad. He read what men were reading in the 60s, 70s, and 80s, so I read those. Most of what was published then was written by white men of a certain age, especially since my dad was the main reader in our house. I read Philip Roth, John Updike, Patrick O’Brian, John Irving, and also Hemingway and Faulkner, as he had those in the library. I read whatever was in our house: Reader’s Digest, Women’s Day magazine, even the back of a shampoo bottle. I just wanted to read everything. When I went to college, I didn’t study English because I wanted to learn things that I couldn’t learn simply by reading. However, I obtained the reading lists for all the undergraduate English classes at NYU and read every book. David (04:15-04:24): If I came to you and said, “I want to write novels, I want to learn what you did,” would you caution me against getting an MFA? What advice would you give? Elizabeth (04:24-05:37): If you’re wealthy or receive a full scholarship, and you feel it would be great for you, then certainly. Many great writers have come out of MFA programs. However, I would beg you on my knees, plead with you as though for my own life, not to go into debt for an arts degree. Starting life as an artist in debt is a nightmare. Please don’t do that. If you are truly passionate, it feels right intuitively, and you can pay for it out of pocket without hardship, then consider it. My friend Ann Patchett believes that if they don’t offer a full ride, they haven’t truly accepted you into the program; they just want your money. If they give you a full ride, then they genuinely want you there. That’s a harsh perspective, and I don’t know the realities well enough to confirm its truth. But please, please, please don’t go into debt to be an artist. And also, please don’t go into debt to me. David (05:37-05:38): Anything else to add? Elizabeth (05:38-05:42): No, just about debt and art. Please don’t. Please don’t. David (05:43-05:52): You once shared a definition of creativity as the divine partnership between human labor and the mystery of inspiration. Elizabeth (05:53-07:04): This came out of a question someone once asked me, framing it as a binary choice. Do you believe you are the one creating, doing the work and making this thing? Or do you believe you are the channel through which inspiration pours? My answer was yes. I think it requires a mind expansive enough to embrace both realities as true. It isn’t just me. I can tell the difference between something I did and something I’m watching happen through me, and both are important. I cannot make the second thing happen. I can, however, provide the labor that allows work to happen. Anyone creative knows about times when they lose track of hours, look up to find the room dark and night fallen, without even knowing where they are. There’s a state of almost being taken over by this thing. Elizabeth (07:04-07:17): But that isn’t always the case. Sometimes it’s labor; other times it’s simply allowing inspiration to come through. Both are true, and that is what creativity is. David (07:17-07:22): When you get taken over, there’s a sense that you made something, and you wonder, “How did I do that?” Elizabeth (07:22-07:47): Exactly. If it were only about being a channel, I wouldn’t be so tired from how hard I work, because I truly do work very hard. Every artist can point to certain things and say, “I don’t remember doing that. It’s better than anything I could consciously create.” I have a feeling about one of my books: “That’s better than I can write.” David (07:48-07:48): Which book is that? Elizabeth (07:48-08:25): The Signature of All Things. It’s better than I can write; I can’t do that. I can look at my other books and think, “I did that. I sat down and, through my labor, cr… Get full access to David Perell's How I Write at howiwrite.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
