Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

How I Write

How I Write artwork

Gillian Flynn: How to Write Thrilling Stories

Oct 28, 20261 hr 22 minAudio

Big thanks to Alpha School for being the presenting sponsor of this episode. When I was in school, I constantly found myself thinking: “We can do so much better than this.” Alpha School is what I wish existed back then. Kids learn everything they need in only two hours per day, so they can spend the rest of the time actual learning life skills: public speaking, building a business, negotiating, etc. If you want your kid to love school and join classes that rank in the top 1% nationwide, Alpha School is the place to be. Learn more at ⁠https://go.alpha.school/howiwrite. Gillian Flynn is the author of one of my favorite books of all time: Gone Girl. Before the episode, I wondered who I'd be meeting. What kind of person could write such a crazy, bloody mystery? She ended up being super fun, light, and down-to-earth. We spent the whole time talking about her passions: books and the craft of writing a great novel.After Gone Girl became a hit, she decided to turn it into a movie. She wrote the screenplay, teamed up with David Fincher, and the movie was nominated for an Oscar. I asked her to share what she learned from Fincher, why she writes like a method actor, and how she approaches plot, character, and the beginning of a novel.Here's my awesome conversation with Gillian Flynn. Transcript 00:01:03 How Gillian’s books build suspense00:05:16 Your setting needs to be intentional00:08:24 Why we crave dark stories00:13:23 Writing about female evil00:20:27 What makes a good character00:24:35 Write three good pages00:30:56 How to beat writer’s block00:33:32 Gillian’s writing techniques00:37:23 Is the slow burn dead?00:40:04 Mistakes screenwriters make00:42:59 Lessons she learned from TV writing00:45:05 The scariest kind of horror00:46:20 How she comes up with names00:51:02 Are we all performing now?00:56:23 Writing books vs movies01:02:22 Write like a method actor01:07:23 How to nail your book’s opening01:10:06 Use mystery to move plot01:12:17 Make readers argue01:15:33 Feedback she often gives to authors01:18:05 Writing advice for aspiring authors David (01:03-01:21): In your stories, there’s a sense of impending doom, a beat that keeps building. You know the bass is going to drop, the hammer is going to fall. It just builds and builds. Is that something you do consciously? Gillian (01:23-02:14): That’s an interesting question. The answer is no. I am never consciously building suspense, ever. To be honest, it would make me sound cooler if I said I did it on purpose. I feel like I’m building a story, layering crisis upon tension, unsettling moments, and weird twists. I want it to be an unraveling that leads directly to awfulness. I like the sensation of knowing you’re being pulled with a rope around your waist toward a dark corner or a closet, unable to control it, slowly, deliberately, to mess with you. It’s as if the creature in the closet is enjoying your fear. David (02:15-02:20): So with this dark corner, this creature in the closet, are you consciously thinking, “We need to get there slowly”? Gillian (02:20-03:46): Yes. What’s the most anxiety-inducing thing to do? Dish it out in little pieces. That includes little twists, turns, and crazy moments. For instance, with Gone Girl, you have Nick. His wife is gone. Now he’s flubbing the interview with the cops, making himself look bad. Then he takes a selfie, accidentally flirting with someone bringing him a hot casserole. It’s that sensation of people getting in their own way and contributing to the problem. I enjoy having my characters suffer. In Sharp Objects, Camille is a tortured character. She’s self-harmed; she’s back in a bad place. She makes decisions, then tries to undo them as she solves the mystery. I like putting those little tweaks of a person’s own character in the way because I always feel there’s a reason for the phrase, “he’s his own worst enemy.” There are a million times a day when I think, “Gillian, why do you always do that? You’re going to do this someday and end up in prison because why can’t you stop?” I say that all the time to myself. David (03:47-04:00): Wait, so is that something you’re conscious of? Say you have a character, and these are the ways they’re “killing themselves.” Do you then smash the plot against those character traits to bring it to life? Gillian (04:01-05:16): If you ever want to edit me, I would love your help, because you’re really helping me figure out how I’m doing things. Yes, I think that is what I enjoy doing. I always say my thrillers are character-based. That is the one thing I insist on. Throw me whatever genre you want. If you want to call me a mystery writer, a thriller writer, or say I just do this or that, that’s fine, as long as you acknowledge that I’m character-driven. The twist of Gone Girl wasn’t the reason I wrote it, truly. It’s the idea of building a character. Writer Scott Smith does it better than anyone in the world. If anyone wants to read The Ruins or A Simple Plan, I cannot recommend them more. Scott’s one of my favorite writers, and that’s what he’s great at: everything that happens is the character’s fault, yet it’s just them being themselves. It’s about how different people affect each other in certain situations, creating this crazy miasma that we’re all trying to make our way through. You meet bad people along the way, you do bad things, and that’s what interests me. David (05:16-05:34): Earlier, I asked in what ways characters smash against the plot. In what ways do they smash against the world they’re in? Take Gone Girl, for example. You’re in the Midwest, in Missouri, having moved from New York. What is the role of setting in your books? Gillian (05:35-08:24): Setting is very important to me. All three of my books have been set in either Missouri or Kansas. I started with Missouri. I initially wanted to set Gone Girl in Chicago because I was interested in a big city vibe. I’ve lived here for 20 years, and it was originally set here. I wrote a hundred pages in Chicago, but it didn’t make sense. Amy had to be pulled from her beloved New York to somewhere she didn’t want to be. Chicago offers too much opportunity to remake oneself, which is exactly what a sociopathic narcissist like Amy would socially like to be able to do - to drop people and burn them. They need room to play. I needed her to be dragged somewhere else and feel resentful about it. I thought, “Someone from New York would not like to be around a bunch of Missourians.” That would be great. I do love the Midwest, partly because a writer can play a lot with it; it hasn’t been overused. It’s not Southern noir, which is its own thing, nor is it big city noir. New York, for me, was harder to write about in Gone Girl than any part of Missouri. New York has been written about and portrayed in movies so much that everyone thinks they know what it is, even if they’ve never lived there or visited. You have an idea of New York, whereas, unless you’ve lived there, you don’t know what a specific area of the country in the Midwest is like. I’ve embraced it because you can make it more gothic. I feel like I have more authorial vision, the ability to create a fictionalized version, and have people who call us a “flyover state” think, “Oh, maybe it is like that.” It freaks people out more because they’ve never seen it before. When I moved to New York as a young magazine journalist, people would ask, “So you’re from Kansas City?” It was as if I was a strange breed of creature. I would mess with people, saying things like, “Let’s get some pancakes, kill a puppy, and rob a liquor store because that’s what we do in Missouri on Saturdays.” They’d reply, “I respect your culture.” I feel like you have a license to play a lot with that setting. David (08:24-08:39): What is your relationship with darkness and evil? It feels to me like you’re comfortable exploring those themes in a way most people aren’t. Most people have an aversion; they get too close to the devil... Gillian (08:39-08:40): ...and they run the other way. David (… Get full access to David Perell's How I Write at howiwrite.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Gilliam Flynn is the author of one of my favorite books of all time, Gone Girl. Coming to the episode, I was like, who am I going to get here? Who is the kind of person who could write such a crazy, bloody mystery? And she ended up being super fun, light, down to earth, and we spent the whole time talking about what she loves, which is books and the craft of writing, how to write a great novel. And after Gone Girl became a hit, she decided, hey, let's turn this into a movie. So she sits down, writes the screenplay, teams up with David Fincher, and that movie ended up getting nominated for an Oscar.

SPEAKER_00So I said, hey, you got to tell me what you learned from Fincher. Why you write like a method actor, how you think through plot, character, the beginning of a novel. And she said, I'll tell you all that, but also what it's like once you get to know your character so deeply that you're at the supermarket or something, and all of a sudden it's like they're there with you. You can actually hear them talking to you. And that's when I know that I have the character down. So here's my conversation, my awesome conversation with Gillian Flynn. The place I want to start is in your stories,

SPEAKER_00there's like this sense of impending doom where it's like this beat or like this bass that sort of keeps building. You know that the bass is going to drop. You know that the hammer is going to fall. And it just sort of builds and builds. Is that something to do consciously?

SPEAKER_01What an interesting question. I know the answer is no. I am never consciously ever, to be honest, make me sound cooler if I said I did on purpose, but I'm never consciously building suspense. I feel like I'm building a story and I'm trying to put like crisis upon, tension upon, unsettling upon, you know, Weird twists and turns and so have it be this kind of unraveling that's actually heading you toward awfulness.

SPEAKER_01And to have that sense, I like the sensation of knowing you're being pulled toward the dark corner or the closet and with a rope around your waist and not being entirely able to control it, but it's pulling you very slowly to mess with you. Like the creature in the closet is enjoying your fear.

SPEAKER_00So what's going on? So there's like this dark corner, the creature in the closet, and you're thinking we got to get there slowly or something?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'm like, what's the most painful, like, anxiety-making thing to do is to make it go, dish it out in little pieces, and, you know, that includes little twists and turns and... And, you know, for instance, with Gone Girl, it's, you know, okay, here's Nick. Okay, here's Nick's wife is gone. Now he's flubbing the interview with the cops and looking bad. And now he's taking the selfie and flirting, accidentally flirting with someone with a hot casserole to bring him.

SPEAKER_01You know, it's like, just like that sensation of people getting in their own way and contributing to the problem. Is what I enjoy to have my characters suffer. In Sharp Objects, Camille is a tortured character. She's self-harm. She's back in a bad place. And so she's making these decisions and then trying to undo them as she's trying to solve the mystery. And so I like putting those little Tweaks a person's own character in the way.

SPEAKER_01Because I always feel like, you know, there's a reason the phrase is like, you know, he's the worst enemy. Like, there's a reason there's that phrase. There's a million times a day where I'm like, Gillian, why do you always do that? You know, and it's like, you're going to do this someday and you're going to end up, you know, in prison. Why can't you stop killing? I say that all the time to myself.

SPEAKER_00Wait, so this is good. So is that something that you're conscious of? Like, say that you have a character. These are the ways that they're killing themselves. And then do you almost smash the plot against those character traits in order to bring it to life?

SPEAKER_01If you ever want to edit me, yes. I would love your help because you're really, like, helping me figure out how I'm doing things. But, yeah, I think that is what I enjoy doing is, like, you know, I always say my... My thrillers are character-based, they're character-based, they're character-based. And that is the one thing I insist on, is like, thrill me whatever genre you want. Like, if you want to call me a mystery writer or a thriller writer or I just do this or I just do that, that's fine. As long as you acknowledge that I'm character-driven and that I'm not,

SPEAKER_01you know, it wasn't like the twist of Gone Girl was the reason I wrote Gone Girl. It truly was not. And it's the idea of building a character and, you know, a writer like Scott Smith does it better than anyone in the world. You know, if anyone wants to read The Ruins or A Simple Plan, I cannot recommend it more. Those are, I mean, Scott's one of my favorite writers and that's what he is really great at is everything that happens is the character's kind of fault. But it's them just being themselves and

SPEAKER_01in certain situations how different people affect each other and this crazy miasma that we're all trying to make our way through. But, you know, you meet bad people along the way. You do bad things. And that's what interests me.

SPEAKER_00In what ways, so I asked there, in what ways do the characters kind of smash against the plot? In what ways do the characters smash against the world that they're in? So you have Gone Girl, you're in the Midwest, you're in Missouri, they've moved from New York. What is the role of setting in the books that you're writing?

SPEAKER_01Setting's big for me. So far I've always, all three of my books have been either Missouri or Kansas. Culture.

SPEAKER_00Missouri.

SPEAKER_01The true local. Wow. Look at this, everybody. For real. Missouri. I started Rain Gone Girl, I wanted to sit in Chicago, because I was interested in doing kind of a big city sort of vibe, and I live here. I've lived here for 20 years now, and... It was originally set there and I wrote it, you know, I wrote 100 pages in Chicago and it didn't make sense because Amy has to be, Amy has to be pulled from her beloved New York to somewhere she doesn't want to be.

SPEAKER_01And Chicago is too much, it has too much opportunity to remake yourself, which sociopaths like to be able to do. I love the Midwest, and I think... In part, it's because you can play, a writer can play a lot in the Midwest because it hasn't been overused.

SPEAKER_01It's not, you know, it's not, you know, it's not Southern noir, which is its own thing. It's not big city noir. I mean, New York is, New York was, for me, it was harder to write about in Gone Girl than any part of Missouri because New York has been written about and put in movies so much. Everyone thinks they know what New York is, even if they've never lived there and never even been there. But you have an idea of New York, whereas... In a way, you don't have, you know, unless you've lived there, you don't know what this little specific area of the country is. So I've kind of grabbed onto it because you can make it more gothic

SPEAKER_01and you can make it like I can I feel like I have more authorial vision or the ability to. To create a fictionalized version and have people who call us the flyover state to go like, oh, maybe it is like that. I don't know. It freaks people out more because they've never seen it before. When I moved to New York when I was a young magazine journalist, I remember people would be like, so you're...

SPEAKER_01You're from Kansas City. And it was like I was this strange breed of creature. And, you know, I would just kind of mess with people like, well, let's get some pancakes and kill a puppy and rob a liquor store because that's what we do in Missouri on Saturdays. And be like, I respect your culture. So I feel like you have this license to play a lot with that setting.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I have always been, and my theory is that there are two kinds of people in the world, and there are people who like to flip over the rock and see what's under it, and people who do not.

SPEAKER_00Not me. Not you? No way. Really? No way. That's what's crazy about why I love Gone Girl so much, is I do not like flipping over the rock. Right. But Gone Girl's an investigation of the underside of it.

SPEAKER_01Okay. Well, that surprises me. Do you like horror movies?

SPEAKER_00Oh, love horror movies. See, I hate horror movies.

SPEAKER_01Love horror movies. You'll have to come to our annual Gorbeque if you're available on Halloween where we all dress up and watch horror movies all day and eat greasy, scary, bloody-looking barbecue.

SPEAKER_00I will do it one time. Okay. You have a one-time valid token.

SPEAKER_01We're going to be watching The Thing, though, and Alien. There's going to be a lot of things exploding out of people's bodies while you eat the ribs. That's the key. This is from your dad, like, put horror movies on you. Is that right? Yeah, it's so true. I mean, I really think that is part of the reason I have a very comfortable relationship with the dark and with scary stuff is because my dad was a film professor when I grew up and he was very great about taking me to films. That was kind of our father-daughter thing is to go to the movies together.

SPEAKER_01Now, that said, he also... Possibly, looking back, as my mom would say, it may have erred in taking me to some movies when I was way too young. I think I was seven when I saw Alien, and I was absolutely terrified. I remember him saying to me, well, Gilly, we're going to go see Alien today. Now, Alien's really important because it has what's called a heroine, a female hero. It's important for you to see it.

SPEAKER_01And I think that's how he justified it to my mom afterwards after he handed me back to her.

SPEAKER_00And I'm like, oh, Ruplino, save Jonesy. So when you watch a horror movie, when you investigate The Underside of the Rock, do you enjoy it? Like, what is the emotion, the feeling that you're having?

SPEAKER_01I enjoy it. I mean, I'd prefer to say... It's research or, you know, I look at it a little bit and I pull back or whatever. But I'm just, I'm very comfortable with it. I watch way too much true crime. I watch way too much scary stuff. But, you know, I like romantic comedies too, but I really like the scary stuff. And I think it gives you a vocabulary to talk about anxiety in a way. So which I think is healthy for everyone. I have a theory that why true crime is so...

SPEAKER_01The audience is so largely women. And I do think it's because women, you know, someone told me the other day, he was like, men have sports as their fallback at a party. And women now go to true crime. And I thought, that's not wrong. I feel like the more conversations I have as far as like pure, hey, how's it going? What are you doing? What are you watching? Yeah. Here's so much true crime stuff. And I do think it's because women can use that to sort of analyze relationships,

SPEAKER_01danger, talk about that fear of what it's like to move through the world as a woman where you really always have to think and are taught to think, unfortunately, like you may walk out of your house and there's a possibility someone may want to take you and you'll never be seen again and you'll, you know, horrible things are going to happen. I mean, we just learned that. We, you know, you can't walk through a parking lot. You're not allowed to. You're weren't fatalized by force, by necessity. And I think...

SPEAKER_01Hopefully you go through your life and you aren't overly scared. You can still do all the stuff. I still walk to the parking lot. I just tell people I'm walking to the parking lot. Men don't understand that as much. My husband's six foot two guy. I'll be in a hotel like, I just got here at 7 o'clock. All I want to do is take a run on the beach. Well, why don't you? Well, of course I can't. He's like, oh, right, don't do that. What are you thinking?

SPEAKER_01So I think it gives us a way to kind of deal with that little anxiety that always has to be with you. If I'm walking down the street, I have to be aware of what's behind me. I have to keep an ear out. You're always keeping one little piece out. And I think there's a relief in actually being able to talk about what if the worst thing does happen. Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_00Tell me if you agree with this or disagree with this characterization. So I was talking to a friend and I told her that you were coming on the show and she was like, oh man, I cannot wait for that. She understands feminine evil better than anyone I've ever seen.

SPEAKER_01Thanks to your friend.

SPEAKER_00Agree? Disagree?

SPEAKER_01Agree. Agree. Yeah. I mean, I have... Thought a lot about female evil, and in a way it was because I just felt that we weren't properly represented. I felt it was being a little sexist to think that only men could be evil. I always was kind of pushing back against that idea of like, well, women are too kind. A woman would never do this. She would never hurt someone. It was like, number one, that's just...

SPEAKER_01It's demonstrably incorrect if you look anywhere around the world and if you talk to any woman who knows other women. I feel like it was really almost damaging to not be looking at that because in a way it leaves women with only this idea of seeing in film or TV or books themselves. Female characters who are helpmates and female characters who are, you know, helping the husband out and, you know, bucking him up, keeping him in line or fighting him.

SPEAKER_01And, you know, even if she's tough, she's the one who gets to, like, punch the bad guy in the face and, like, take that, you know. And I remember at the time when I was writing Sharp Objects, it was kind of the height of, and I don't call this Chiclet, but I do call Chiclet the... The sort of shopping and shoes and how to get a man. Those kind of books. And Chiclet was at its height and everything was about. And it was fun. It wasn't like I was angry about it.

SPEAKER_01But at the same time, I kept thinking, well, where are the stories about people that are more like me who don't care about shoes? And... I don't know if the camera caught that, but, you know, and have dark sides and have seen dark things. And I just felt like it was important. And so it really was part of the reason I wrote Sharp Objects was to examine what violence looks like with women.

SPEAKER_01You know, I felt like we know plenty of antiheroes. You could name, I mean, almost every book written by a man is practically an antihero. Like some of the larger books when you break them down. And I thought, how many antiheroines, as my dad would say, are there out there? And can we think about and talk about? And so I really just wanted to write about that. And that's kind of how the whole thing started. The male antihero is a trope, right?

SPEAKER_01You know, like, we all grow up, you can name a zillion, any cowboy movie, the antihero, any gangster movie, any, you know, any of the... Deep literary fiction, you know, there's often an antihero. And that was, you know, readily, you can see that and name that and point it and talk about it. Whereas women were just kind of left out. I mean, I was an English major in college and then in journalism. And I just kept thinking, we're really missing something here.

SPEAKER_01As a whole, you know, and not like I'm trying to make myself sound like I was out to do this important thing and change society. But in a way, it was it was like there's darkness here to be examined in a new and interesting way. And I if someone's not going to say something about it, you know,

SPEAKER_00I'll raise my hand. And what tools does the form of the novel afford you to look at that clearly and to kind of rotate feminine evil as you're examining it from all these different layers and perspectives?

SPEAKER_01A novel is wonderful to have that. Having adapted two of my novels and knowing how you have to change things to make it work on screen, I can say the novel is a luxury because you can go inside someone's head. So it allows you to really get in there and you can, if you're with one of the characters, you have more of an idea of how they became that, the way they were. You know, I feel like if you kind of go back to anyone's childhood,

SPEAKER_01you at least have more of an understanding of who they are and appreciation at least as opposed to just writing them off. And that's kind of what I wanted to do with my character, the female character, is to be able to... Have it be more layered. I don't want to just write, like, she's a crazy evil troublemaker. That doesn't interest me. But it does interest me as, like, tortured, you know... Lashing out, hurt, angry, sad, and acting on in a way that you don't see women traditionally act.

SPEAKER_01We're supposed to nurture, find the best out of people, and theoretically we are at least. We're the ones who are supposed to smooth things over and comfort over here and tend over here and And, you know, and take our lumps and put on our big girl pants and all that stuff. And, you know, I was like, well, I don't know about anyone else, but I act horribly a lot. I'm not a murderer, but if you take that 20 times more, you know, then you can get there.

SPEAKER_01And so, you know, it's sort of like I just wasn't seeing any women who weren't anything more than like lovably stupid.

SPEAKER_00I guess. This episode is sponsored by AlphaSchool. When you think of school, what comes to mind? For me, it was lectures, homework, being stuck at a desk. And the worst part is that it doesn't even work. 54% of Americans read below a sixth grade level. That's over half of Americans. We need something new. And that's why I'm excited to have AlphaSchool as the flagship sponsor of How I Write. At Alpha, you go to school, you get all your academics done in only two hours per day so that then you can spend

SPEAKER_00the rest of the time learning life skills like running a business, writing a musical, giving a TEDx talk. You know, the kind of things that make you a capable and well-rounded person. And it's working. They have the academics figured out. Alpha classes test in the top 1% nationally, and more than 90% of students say they love school. Now, I used to live in Austin, where Alpha School started, and I was consistently blown away by what was happening there. I personally mentored a bunch of the kids, and what stuck out to me is how much their team believes in the potential of kids.

SPEAKER_00Alpha's approach, and the success it's already having, is why it's the most talked about K-12 school in the world right now, and also where I want to send my kids to school one day. So if you want to learn more, visit go.alpha.school slash how I write. So what matters as you're thinking about a character? Is it, hey, they got to be lovable? They have to be likable. They have to be interesting. We have to be able to relate with them. So even if they're evil, we need to see, hey, this is why they're acting evil. Like, what is the thing that matters as you're beginning to structure a character?

SPEAKER_01I say nothing matters except are you interested in knowing more about this character? I absolutely, I'm sure this will not surprise you, reject any notion that my characters should be likable. I flat out reject that. And I think I have proven that that is a correct assumption, like that people just want a character who is interesting. They don't need a female character who That is likable. And I remember when we were shopping around Sharp Objects

SPEAKER_01and I had written my first book and I had my first agent. I was like ready for bidding more. And we got so many rejection letters that were that basically said. Men don't want to read books by women. And women don't want to read books by women who are writing about characters that are aspirational. Women want to read, this is what I was told, women want to read about characters that they want to be like. And so they want to read about Bridget Jones because ultimately...

SPEAKER_01They, you know, everything turns out great for her and she's adorable. But they wouldn't want to read about Camille Preaker because she's, you know, Camille Preaker. And I just said, I just don't believe that that's correct. And I'm the one thing I'm proudest of with Gone Girl is that we prove that I think once and for all that that is absolutely fucking wrong.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And what makes a character, hey, I want to read more about this person.

SPEAKER_01I think it is trying to figure out what their motivation is. Who is this person? When I'm reading a character that I'm really gripped by, it's because I want to know what's driving them. It's because I don't understand them. I'm usually more interested in characters that are I mean, a lot of people find a lot of comfort or interest or things to dig in with there. I usually tend to be more interested by characters that

SPEAKER_01I feel like they have a secret or I'm trying to figure out what happened or they're making strange choices. Not all adding up here. Exactly. Exactly. And that to me is always what motivates me to learn more about a character, I think.

SPEAKER_00Tell me about this photo.

SPEAKER_01Oh, oh my gosh. My diabolical little girl. Isn't that a great photo? Yeah, I looked at that photo a lot while I was writing sharp objects. Yeah, I just, I love it. It's called Livia for the Empress Lydia, who was notably diabolical. And I just love it because to me, this little girl just looks like, with the braids and everything, she's got the little pinafore and she's everything a little girl should be.

SPEAKER_01But there's something in her eyes and that purse of her lips that's just like, I'm going to fuck you up. That was ammo. That was like in sharp objects. Like that was a lot of that idea of like just because women and girls present one way, like the don't don't assume that that's all there is is ribbons and bows and little dresses.

SPEAKER_00And so that photo like embodies that idea.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. For me, it really does. I haven't seen that photo in a while, actually. I'm glad to see it again. I think I have a print of it somewhere. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's haunting.

SPEAKER_01It's haunting, right? There's something about her eyes floating near the top of her the pupils floating near the top of her eyes that really always gets me.

SPEAKER_00Beware. So with you and your process, how much of it is, oh, the joy of typing at the computer versus this like dogged stubbornness of just keep going, keep going?

SPEAKER_01It's both. It's both. The one thing I always say to people when they say they want to be a writer, how do you be a writer? I always say you have to write. You have to sit in the chair. It's going to be painful. You're going to have a lot of days where... It's just miserable and you don't know what you're doing and you feel like you're writing 100 pages in the wrong direction. And you may be. I mean, I really, truly wrote probably three Gone Girls a total of before I figured out.

SPEAKER_01What that was, what I was dealing with, what I was wanting to write. And so I always think a lot of writing is stubbornness. A lot of getting published is just being a stubborn human who's like, I'm not going to let this book beat me. Like, this book wants to beat me. And just keeping at it. And I think some of it is the joy of writing. And no one would do it unless there weren't The wonderful joys of it. And boy, when you're hitting a streak and you're, you know, there's nothing better.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. It's like, oh my God, so brilliant. It doesn't matter. So, you know, maybe you'll look at the next day and be like, what have I done? What is this? But that's the fun of it. And there's certain... You can tell when a writer's enjoying themselves, I think. To me, I can always tell when a writer's like... Doing our version of, like, pirouettes and dancing and, you know, floating through the air and a murmuration of birds and, like, just, like, showing what we can do.

SPEAKER_01Like, showing off and enjoying the art of writing. I think Martin Amos, when Martin Amos is cooking, is, like, you can feel him, like, kind of pounding his chest. Like a gorilla. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Like, this is... And they're like, let's

SPEAKER_01go, Lauren, go. You know, Joyce Carol Oates, who's my favorite writer, does that a lot. I mean, Fox that came out last year has half a chapter, maybe more written from the point of view of a dog, which you would think would be silly. But in her hands, in her brain, it becomes this... Where you're like, I guess I know what it's like to be a dog now because she's so good. And you can tell she's just doing it because it's fun. I mean, I don't know that that's for sure, but it feels like she's just doing it to see if she could.

SPEAKER_01And I love it when writers are just like, I just really want to write this. And when you have enough of those scenes, then you have your book. Sometimes I just have days where I'm like, you know, Just write three good pages. It doesn't have to move the plot forward. It doesn't have to establish anything. You may not even keep it. Just sit down and write three good pages that make you happy just for the joy of writing.

SPEAKER_01And that is my other tip for any writers. You're going to have plenty of days, but if you can literally just every day say, I'm just going to write three pages that make me happy that are something to do with this book. And Cool Girl started out that way. I mean, Cool Girl was a writing exercise because I was stuck and I didn't know what the book was. And so I was like, I'm just going to write one writing exercise. And it was back... Nick and Amy had many iterations. At one point, Amy's parents ran a bespoke dating agency where they guaranteed...

SPEAKER_01That they would match couples up for life, and again, you would get married, and that felt too on the nose. And then Nick and Amy were competing, like, magazine columnists for the man and the woman's side. I was like, nah, I'm reading an Aaron Sorkin script. And then I figured out, but ultimately, I was like, oh... Amy is going to write about women's issues for a women's magazine. I'm just going to write what an essay of hers in the magazine would sound like

SPEAKER_01and would be like. So I wrote an essay called Don't Call Me a Fucking Cool Girl. And I wrote it in, like, full-on screed. And in one afternoon, just, like, pounding, I mean, full-on. When I get writing, I know when I'm writing and really kicking it Because I start sweating and I start hatching. I get very physical about it. I'm like a method writer sort of.

SPEAKER_00And I was like, just this angry screen. And then

SPEAKER_01my husband was very afraid of me that day. But then I finished it. And my whole rule with myself is you can't use any writing exercises in a book. Because then you're writing it for the book and you're not writing it for the... It's badass. I mean, the language is so forceful.

SPEAKER_00The writing is cool.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. It really was one afternoon. And I don't think I changed much that I remember. And I didn't. I certainly, you know, it's not presented in the book as a separate thing. It's just woven in. And I was, I just went back and forth. Like, did I earn a spot here? Like, all of a sudden, she's just now randomly talking about a cool girl's screed while she's,

SPEAKER_00you know. That's kind of like your hit single from the album.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. That's why it's single.

SPEAKER_00You know what I mean? Do you feel when you're making that, like, hey, this could be the single?

SPEAKER_01No. No. I put it in because I liked it. In the end of it, I was just like, you know what? It's a page. If people don't like it, then they'll not think of it again because it's not taking up much space.

SPEAKER_00But I really like it, so I'm going to put it in. What are the other writing exercises you do?

SPEAKER_01I do a lot of... Just write one scene with this particular character that's not going to be, that's not set anywhere in the book. For instance, I have somewhere on my battered laptop, I've got like Nick's first grade... Class parent teacher conference written from the point of view of the teacher meeting both of his parents when he was little and how she was perceiving the dad in particular and and and what.

SPEAKER_01So I could get an idea and that gave me insight into Nick's relationship with his dad, which ended up in the book. But that little piece was just about to write a little section about what that was like. I've got a whole, I do have a pretty great chapter that's written from the point of view of Amy's boarding school roommate. Someday I'll just release that as like a secret of my little DVD extra track somewhere. So it's sort of like that. And sometimes it does help me figure things out in the book.

SPEAKER_01Sometimes it just keeps me writing and makes me at least, I mean, a lot of writing is managing self-hatred and living. And the loathing of not getting able to write the way you think you should have written that day and all the hopes of that day going like, where is my life going? What did this day do? But then that sometimes really saves you and you can be like, well, I am a writer. I wrote three good pages and they won't be in the book, but I can write.

SPEAKER_01And here's proof. And it did get me still – it kept me still thinking about the book. I think it's a great writer – for me, a really good

SPEAKER_00writer's block solution. Fill in the blank for me. When you get stuck as a writer, do blank.

SPEAKER_01When you get stuck as a writer, keep writing. I mean, I think that's really important to not let yourself – don't throw away the book because, you know, you've hit a writer's block. Don't start another book. That's one thing I had to learn. I spent most of my 20s learning – Don't hit a hard part of a book and just go, oh, maybe I should just write it. Maybe it's not the right book. That's why. And because then you'll write 50 pages of another book and you'll go, oh, this is hard. Oh, maybe I'm not. Maybe it's because I'm not writing the correct book. And it's not that it's.

SPEAKER_01Because writing, you're always going to hit a writer's block. In any job, you're going to hit something where you have to problem solve. And it's just another kind of problem solving. It's just writing so it feels more

SPEAKER_00personal in a way. Can you walk me through how you think about revealing information in a mystery? So you know what the answer is going to be. Then there's what's actually true. Then there's what the reader knows. And how do you think about that sequential release of info and then maybe even the art of misdirection?

SPEAKER_01What helps in a mystery is not plotting it out for me because I'm figuring out who the killer is as I'm writing it. I don't go in knowing what the end's going to be. It would be... I'm not necessarily advising that. I'm just saying that that's the way I do it and that's the way I prefer writing. So I write that way and I get to the end and I'm like, huh, that person's a killer? Weird. I did not know that. And then I have to go back and drop in the correct clues to get us there.

SPEAKER_01Like, for instance, in Sharp Objects, and I will not do a spoiler thing, but the person who is the murderer in Sharp Objects, the book was not even a character in the first draft of Sharp Objects, did not even exist. The murderer was someone different.

SPEAKER_00Wow.

SPEAKER_01That is in Sharp Objects. And I got to the end and people would be like, oh, I thought so-and-so did it. I'm like, me too. Yeah. I did too. It was crazy. And then it wasn't. So that part kind of does its work for you because that way you're not giving anything away because you've got nothing to give away. And so you're kind of chasing around, you know, you're chasing as the author down lead. So you're chasing, like, maybe this interesting character is the killer. Can I work with this ball of clay over here?

SPEAKER_01Like, this is kind of fun. And so the reader is going along with me because... I'm writing in that way of like walking in like I don't know who the killer is. And so in a way I don't have to undo anything. Now I do have to go back and do a lot of rewriting and put all those guideposts in there and make sure they're not clear. But I'm very obsessive about making sure every mystery is earned. That is one thing I am obsessively good at is like. Well, if you go back and you look at everything, you can trace, I earned it.

SPEAKER_01I'm very big about, have you earned this thing that you want to have? You have to earn it. And whether it's the suspense, you have to build it up correctly. And so I think... Writing it through, not knowing the ending, and then going back and doing all the rewrites for me is really helpful because it can at first be a big creative gush, and then it can be more strategic

SPEAKER_00with the clues. Who taught you about earned mysteries? Where'd you pick that up from?

SPEAKER_01I think it was just because I love mysteries. And I read, you know, it started with Agatha Christie when I was, you know, a kid. And I love her so much. And I remember even as a kid reading some mysteries or watching some mysteries and going like, well, how would I have known You know, I mean, just absolutely always felt like a customer who had been cheated, you know. Feels cheap or something. Yeah, it feels cheap. It feels absolutely cheap to me. I don't like those. I don't like to read those books. Like, surprise, you know, it has to be. And again,

SPEAKER_01it's because those books probably aren't character driven usually if they're kind of doing a big Shazam out of nowhere.

SPEAKER_00So then are you writing the book and you're feeling the... The epiphany or something with us. And then you're like, that's it. And then you're kind of writing. Is that the feeling?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, you got it. It really is like that. It really is sort of like, oh, yeah, that's fun. Yeah. I mean, for a writer, you have to kind of like your own company and have to be able to step away and be like, is that cool? It's not cool. No, that's cool. You know, like, I think I got it. And that's a great moment when you... Feel like you've nailed something, like ever figured out something.

SPEAKER_00Early in a book, how do you think about the pacing, the exposition, needing to set up the context? This is the characters. Because we live in a culture that's so fast now. So much advice. Fast.

SPEAKER_01Get to the point fast.

SPEAKER_00Dive into the narrative. Start with the part where they're being eaten by the bear, right? Like, right to it. Yeah. Like, the beginning of Casino Royale.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00But Gone Girl's not really like that.

SPEAKER_01I mean, it kind of is, but also, I don't know, it's a little bit slow. No. It is. That first part is, until the big twist, is very, very slow burn. And I, you know, to be honest with you, it was lightning in a bottle. Yeah. I'd be interested if it were released now, if people would feel that first part was too slow. The way our society has gotten more quick moving,

SPEAKER_01and like you said, I do TV and movies too, and the note we get most often is the audience is going to turn it off if something doesn't happen in the first five minutes. There's no such thing as slow burn anymore. I completely disagree with that. I think that's wrong. Once again, I completely... We're not giving humans enough credit.

SPEAKER_01You have to torture people for a while. You have to like lead, you know, I always say the first part is like the clicks of going up a roller coaster when you really don't want to be on the roller coaster. And it's just like, you're getting click, click, click, click, click. Yeah. And it's like going, going. And, you know, I had so many people tell me like, I was pretty close to putting it down. Like, because I was like, where is this book going? I don't know. I'm sick of this relationship. And then, you know, I was a young man who said that part.

SPEAKER_00Sick of hearing about this couple of nerds.

SPEAKER_01All their love crap. But I don't know of people today. The Atlantic just did a whole cover story called The End of Reading. It's a terrifying time to be a writer in a way. But at the same time, I don't think that we're giving our readers and our audiences enough credit as far as that they will do a slow burn as long as When you

SPEAKER_00were a TV critic, what was the thing that you would see in movies, you would see in TVs, you would see in stories that just piss you off the most? Like some stupid trope, some dumb cliche that just made you want to take your computer and smash it against the window?

SPEAKER_01Oh, my goodness. I can think of a zillion, but the only thing that's coming to me right now that still remains my pet peeve and that I still have to deal with sometimes is characters into phones when they go, hello? Hello? Hello? Hello? And it's like someone's hung up. It's like you're not building any suspense. You're just yelling into a phone. And I don't like when we're seeing plans on screen. Or when it's not explained. I hate it when it's like, Well, it's great to meet you.

SPEAKER_01Let's get coffee. Good, I'll call you. And it's like, they haven't exchanged phone numbers. I get really like the OCD writer in me is like, but how will they do that? That hasn't like you're cheating. Like at the same time, no one wants to hear people exchange phone numbers and contact information. But so it really does come down to that sort of thing of like making sure things are nailed down. I mean, as wild as my books get, I mean, we have children with missing teeth and lakes and we've got, you know, Gone Girl, which is bonkers, I will be the first to admit, goes to a bonkers place.

SPEAKER_01I think people go there with me because I nail things down, the logistics and the realities of it so that it does feel real. So if you went into my basement, my unfinished basement where I had a little creepy mother-in-law apartment when I was writing Gone Girl, it was, and to call it an apartment, it was a room. And I would just, to remind myself to nail things down, I would always go just write something down, a sticky note, stick it on the wall.

SPEAKER_01So you'd see these fluttering sticky notes everywhere of reminding myself of everything. Yeah. Yeah. It's funny because I don't necessarily like to do research. I'm not a person who talks to a zillion cops and does ride-alongs and does that

SPEAKER_01because I don't consider myself someone who writes procedurals. So I'm not as interested in trying to nail down the cop work. But that said, I don't want to get wrong. So I always write my books and then I go back and talk to people and I'm like, How do you think your writing is different because you did all that writing about film and TV? You stripped that out of the bio. How is your writing different?

SPEAKER_01Like, would I even be a writer? Would I be an author? I don't know. I think the 10 years of magazine work at a weekly magazine where I was, you know, Entertainment Weekly writing about film and TV and books and thinking about film and TV and books and what made something good or what made something not good and particularly tricky when I became the TV critic was trying to figure out why A TV show was a C. We would grade on A to F, obviously.

SPEAKER_01The A's were really obvious and the D's were really obvious. It was like, what makes something a C, a C minus, a C plus? What didn't quite happen? And that was where I felt like I did a lot of growing as... A writer, the writer of what I do now is doing all that thinking about, you know, oh, it's because they put just a placeholder scene where there actually should have been a rewrite of that scene.

SPEAKER_01And or that type of thing. And also the other thing that working for Weekly taught me was that there's no muse that's going to come and save you. Like, it's never good. That's not going to happen. You can't wait until you're in the mood to write. Like, writing is a job. Writing is not. I mean, it is also, I like to think, an ardent vocation, but... It's a job. If you want it to exist, you have to treat it like a job. And, you know, so it definitely taught me, like,

SPEAKER_01you may not be in the mood, but if you start, you may start getting that motion going. Or you may have a crummy day and you're going to have to go home and have dinner and work two hours tonight to get it correct. But that idea, it demystified writing in a really helpful way for me.

SPEAKER_00Oh, that's a good turn of phrase. Can you tell me more about what tools from horror you brought into your books?

SPEAKER_01For me, the horror that scared me most was not as much the, um, not the serial killer stuff, like, um... I worship John Carpenter. Halloween is my least of scariest. I'm scared the least by Halloween of all his amazing movies. It was less that. It was more about that idea that something... Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Talk to me about what's in a name. Like if I think of Gone Girl, I almost think of there's Carthage, which is a name that you see and you're like, whoop, that was a deliberate choice. You don't come to that by accident. And then there's like Nick, Amy, which I'm like a little bit more nondescript. And then there's like The Bar, which is deliberately bland. So talk to me about all those.

SPEAKER_01Well, you know, Carruthers obviously is my ode to Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf.

SPEAKER_00So when we see that, are we, like, do you expect the reader to be like, oh, I know what that's an ode to? That's just me

SPEAKER_01having fun. That's for you, okay. A couple strange things that really influenced Gone Girl and certainly Who's a Vader Virginia Wolf was one of them. That incredibly toxic marriage of two people who still can't stop playing fucking games with each other. Oh my gosh, if I could see... The London Gillian Anderson version coming up. I'm trying to figure out how to get there. So that was like a fun little thing that I threw on.

SPEAKER_01But weirdly enough, there is a Carthage muster up. Yeah. On those lonely little days that just sort of amuse yourself to make you laugh. Like there's a weird, Desi's weird mom who didn't make the cut into the movie for space.

SPEAKER_01But I remember Nick, you know, she's kind of doing this weird, slightly flirty, slightly predatory, slightly bitchy thing with Nick and fucking with his mind. And then he gives her a hug goodbye and he says that she smells, she smells faintly vaginal. That was just me in a bad day. That was just me typing away like, ah, screw it. She probably smells like a vagina. I don't know. And it got me through that. That's my other tip for writers,

SPEAKER_01want to be writers, is amuse yourself along the way because it can be lonely sometimes. Yeah. That was Carthage. And then Nick and Amy, I really cannot remember at all why I named her Amy. I just don't remember how she... I wanted them to have normal names. I just liked the name Nick, too. I thought Nick... I surveyed a lot of people about Nick in particular, and I was like, what would a likable guy's name be? And I got the weirdest,

SPEAKER_01I was going to name him Ben originally, which would have been fun for Ben Affleck, but It would have been easy for him to go by. But too many people liked Ben's in my various research. And everyone had a reaction to Nick. It was everyone either knew Nick and he was the greatest guy and they loved him. Or it was like, you can't name him Nick. Like, oh, I knew the biggest check as he was Nick. And so I was like, that's kind of fun. I'll do it. I'll call him Nick. So I did that. That is, I think, where Nick came from.

SPEAKER_00And then the bar. Like a nondescript name.

SPEAKER_01I guess...

SPEAKER_00Actually, instead of going there, is there a generalizable principle that you have when thinking through names of places, of people?

SPEAKER_01One of my very favorite things that I'm writing a book is to name my characters. So I could talk about this with you all day. I love names. I love naming. I like making up city names like Wind Gap. For in sharp objects like Kenneke, Kansas and Dark Places. And for characters' names, I always go on the Social Security Baby Names website, which is the greatest website if you like names because you can cross-reference by state, by time period, by decade.

SPEAKER_01The most popular names, it goes from one to a thousand of every year. And so I like to be year specific, you know, because like right now, like my generation, I'm Gen X, Jennifer's, so many, you know, a zillion Jennifer's. If you saw a three-year-old named Jennifer today, you'd be like, what? A great name, but you know, you don't, they're in the wild, I'm sure somewhere, but very rare. And so I like going, okay, how's my character? All right, what might their name be?

SPEAKER_01And if it's not one of these in the top thousand somewhere, then do I want to name them something really unusual? But like, so I do like that specificity.

SPEAKER_00Talk to me about finding your voice as a writer. Like in what ways is that like a worthy thing to think about? What ways is it total hoopla? But I want to layer on, you've said some really profound things about how laced with pop culture our world is. You know, like you think about, okay, somebody died. It's no longer, this is my reaction. It's I'm so conscious of Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Be shocked or joy, truly joyful in a way they would have been 100 years ago at seeing an elephant or seeing something because we've seen everything there is to see everything. And that was 12 years ago. I mean, and, you know, that was before social media, you know, the real rise of social media, the real, you know, I had the luck of writing Gone Girl before any of that. So I don't have to even deal with that, worried about like, how would social media handle this? I would, you know. But it is trickier and trickier. I think Nick says in the book,

SPEAKER_01it's harder and harder to be an actual human anymore because you're constantly examining yourself, or at least I am. It sounds like we're similarly. Wait, did I... Happy Anniversary.

SPEAKER_01I remember we were at a little gathering and someone was passing around little gifts for the bride or something. And I opened the one that was really lovely. And I did this thing that I have never done before since, which was to go like, and as if I was about to start crying, like, oh my gosh, thank you guys. And I caught myself doing it. I'm like, I'm only doing this because you always see women start to cry and go like, oh. And, like, dab napkins away.

SPEAKER_01And, like, I don't cry that way. But Allison and I was doing, I was being performative. And now I think I don't, I mean, I worry about my sweet children and keeping them their weird, adorable, kooky, dark-natured selves and not having them just be regurgitating reactions that they've seen on social media or something. I think it's really important.

SPEAKER_00In Gone Girl, I think you went a step further where you said, I've literally seen it all. And the worst thing, the thing that makes me want to blow my brains out is the secondhand experience is always better. The image is crisper. The view is keener. The camera angle and the soundtrack manipulate my emotions in a way that reality can't anymore.

SPEAKER_01I mean, I think that's why we're all, you know, addicted to... Social media and YouTube and all the things is it often is better. I mean, in the same way you paste over a memory and if it was good, it sort of gets dreamier and dreamier and you forget the lost luggage of the trip or whatever it was that was the bummer and you have that kind of memory that you've polished. I think that Even better is seeing someone else's version of your memory

SPEAKER_01that has now been, you know, sound corrected and, you know, visually framed and made perfect. And, you know, we... I think we're, in a way, we're risking losing our imaginations because we have such an influx, such a firehose of content that is coming in our eyeballs at any given second. And, you know, it was like, you know, the trend when people were watching,

SPEAKER_01this one drove me crazy, when people, the trend when people were recording... The kids or someone who hadn't seen Star Wars finding out Luke, I am your father. For a while, at least in the parent group, was like a big thing of like recording while someone saw it. And you started seeing people that were clearly faking being surprised at the I am your father moment. And then you had people talking about whether or not they were surprised and you were, and we were reacting to our stuff. And it's this sort of like...

SPEAKER_01Um, where, you know, where is the real reality? Uh, once you've, you know, passed the seven-year-old kid who actually was having his own reaction, but you made it a weird thing, too, by recording it. Like, he knew something. He knew he was supposed to have a reaction because you were recording it. So you're there. You're now influencing that, too. It just is kind of like nesting dolls of madness to me.

SPEAKER_00How is writing a book different from writing a movie? Like what does a movie afford you that a book doesn't?

SPEAKER_01I felt really and still do so lucky to have gotten to adapt Gone Girl to be able to have those two exact.

SPEAKER_00Also to work with David Fincher. That is so cool.

SPEAKER_01It's okay. We were talking about like liking a movie enough to see it multiple times. I got to tell him the story when I met him.

SPEAKER_00Well, yeah. I mean, I went to Gone Girl. I remember I saw it with my friend Garrett in Pennsylvania and I went one night and then I went the next night and then I read the book in like three days and I was just like, holy cow. It was like a shock to my sister. It was like an electrical jolt. It's been like 12 years and I still feel it viscerally. It just makes me so happy. Thank you. God, that story is fucking awesome. And I do not swear a lot, but that story is worthy of the F word.

SPEAKER_01Well, mine was Seven because I got to tell Fincher when I met him, I had moved to LA right out of college, right out of KU. And I decided to take myself to the movies because that's what I do. And I saw Seven in the theaters. I went out to get in my car and I saw the next showing was coming up and I'm like, I think I'm just going to go back in and watch that. So then to get to have David Fincher be directing Gone Girl was unbelievable. Like fill this like full circle of like coming back to L.A.

SPEAKER_01I want to go back to my little 22 year old scared self and be like, it's going to turn out OK. You know, this movie you're seeing. But that part was really, really neat. So to get to have Fincher, to get to write both sides and really, I do feel like that way I can actually really speak to what makes one easier, does one thing better than the other. And certainly with Gone Girl, the trickiest part was Gone Girl so internalized.

SPEAKER_00So internalized.

SPEAKER_01So much character size. And we had actually shopped it all around town. I thought it would be a movie. It was a number one book for weeks and weeks and weeks. No one wanted it. No one wanted to buy it. No one wanted to be my agent. No one wanted to buy it because they thought it was not adaptable. Everyone kept telling us it was not adaptable. And it was number one on the bestseller list, I think, for 10 weeks by the time anyone wanted it. Everyone was just like, no, you can't do it.

SPEAKER_01They have a point. They were ultimately wrong, but I totally see it. I do begrudge the publishing industry saying men don't read women's books because that's a lie that women don't read non-aspirational women. I do not blame the idea that it would be hard to adapt. But I felt like there was enough there and there was enough plot there. You got a massive amount of plot. I mean, that's a piece of clockwork. Something's always moving and happening. So I knew I had that. And I knew I had some interesting characters.

SPEAKER_01And I was kind of like, I think. I do think this can happen. And thankfully, Fincher read my first script and was willing to work with me. And he was the greatest collaborator a person could ever have. What'd you learn from him? Oh, God. Like everything I know about screenwriting. I mean, truly, I cannot... Just I'm so grateful. We have the same kind of dark sense of humor.

SPEAKER_01We liked the same things about the book, which isn't necessarily you would think would be a given, but it really I've learned is not a given. Some some directors come in and it's like this because something's going to be a hit or they can, you know, cast a big name or, you know, they could see it like it's a A commodity, whereas he came in like actually really knowing and liking the book. And in fact, the first thing he said to me was because I made it exactly 120 pages. Everyone says, you know, that's 120 pages.

SPEAKER_01It's usually a page a minute. Yeah, the script. Sorry. It's usually a page a minute. So everyone said, don't go over 120 pages. That's a two hour movie. If you go any longer, they're going to think that you're this darling novelist who can't kill her babies. And so I was like, okay. And I didn't. And the first thing David was like, let's put more of the book back in here. Like, let's see how much we can put in. Yeah, it's like a two and a half hour movie, yeah? It's still not a short movie. He works harder than anyone I know. He doesn't phone anything in.

SPEAKER_01He, even down to an insert shot, you know, he doesn't. He doesn't mess around, and I appreciated that. He's always willing to go back and see, like, is there more to be gotten out of this? And he's almost like... At least with my experience, I don't want to speak for his experience with anyone necessarily, but I felt like he was a great editor. The way a book writer has a good editor, that he performed that function for me.

SPEAKER_01And to me, that's asking the writer questions, pushing a little bit. Why is this happening here? And if you can't articulate why something's happening... Then it probably shouldn't be there. And I mean, I learned that from him because he was really collaborative and willing to work with me. And I would get partway through articulating why I liked a scene or a moment or whatever. And sometimes by forcing me to articulate it, Made me hone it better.

SPEAKER_01It's like, oh, right. That's what I'm trying to do. Like, he made me have to say it out loud and explain it. And now I've got a better awareness and it's going to be a better scene because of it. Or we get partway through and be like,

SPEAKER_00oh, crap. Fine.

SPEAKER_01Fine. It goes. Fine.

SPEAKER_00What makes for a good narrator? I feel like you've had a lot of fun with narration over the years.

SPEAKER_01I enjoy first person just because I think I'm a voicey author. I like voice. That's what attracts me to the writers that I read is a big voice.

SPEAKER_00How they speak. Like their voice.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, like the writer's voice. Yeah, exactly. Exactly. And so you can, you know, for me, you know, it goes back to like,

SPEAKER_00look at me having fun. The old gorilla.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. Like this is so much fun. You can really like. Show off, I guess, in a way. I mean, I think you can, in a big, loud

SPEAKER_00look at me sort of way. But so many writers try to do that showing off the gorilla look at me, and it sounds so writerly, like it makes me more puke. So, like, what are they doing wrong that the writers you like are doing right?

SPEAKER_01I wonder if it's a self-consciousness and intention question. You know, I think if you're out to say... I'm going to write this in a really big voice. You're probably not going to write it in an authentic really big voice. You're faking it. It's sort of like I always tell people not to chase the trends when they're trying to get published. Don't write about vampires just because Twilight was huge at the time. You can't... Chase things or try to imitate. And so I think if people are trying to do this big,

SPEAKER_01daring voice, they're probably getting in their own way because they're being self-conscious about it. Like you have to find the voice and then that voice is big. You can't just say... I will write this in a deliberately loud, ostentatious way.

SPEAKER_00Is that something you consciously tried to cultivate? And if so, is that something that you're conscious of? Like you have the voice defined? Or is it like, I feel it a little bit more intuitively? Or is it like, I don't really think about it, but it just comes out? There's a certain...

SPEAKER_01Organic nature to it as far as it sometimes just comes out, for sure, as you're trying to figure out a character and what they might sound like, what they might think like. And the more you can get in that brain, I think the voicier it will be. So I think some of it, again, is like earning the voice. The more time you spend with that character, the bigger their voice is because it's bigger in your head. I mean, I knew I had Amy. When I was standing in the supermarket line one day and this woman was in front

SPEAKER_01of me at a 10 item line with like 22 items or whatever. And I was like, oh, Amy would not like this as if she were really my friend. I mean, like as if I were going to call and be like, bitch, there's this lady in front of me. You would not believe this. And the same with Camille and Sharp Objects. I knew I had Camille figured out when I was thinking about Camille. I remember I had a day job,

SPEAKER_01so I was working at Entertainment Weekly, and I was hanging out filming Jackass the movie with the Jackass guys. I'm in New Zealand with the Hobbits.

SPEAKER_00You worked on the Jackass movie?

SPEAKER_01Oh, yes. What? ! We should find my article that I wrote on it because I think it was a cover story. And it starts out with Pontius was, I don't know why I'm lowering my voice. But Pontius was swinging his, yeah, exactly. Don't listen to this part, kids. Swinging his penis around in front of me. He had this trick that they'd be like, Pontius, do the helicopter, do the helicopter. So I'm getting the helicopter, duh, getting helicoptered on Jack is the Movie.

SPEAKER_01And then I'm like going back to write this really dark scene about like death and murder and children missing teeth and everything. I close my eyes and I still have the image of Pontius's penis going around and around. So it was a weird time, but I remember I got really busy with all the silliness. Yeah. But I would think about Camille. I would think about Camille. I would think about what I would tell her almost of different things. And I would still, even while all that madness was going on, I was writing sheriff objects because I felt I just had her.

SPEAKER_01I felt like I owed her almost. And so her voice, I think, comes from that. So you have to be willing to... Give yourself over. I mean, I'm making it sound almost mystical, magical. It's not. But like, you know, it is sort of like method acting in a way, I think, at least for me, is like really putting that person in my skin.

SPEAKER_00Tell me about this. With the beginning of a book, how much do you think about those first words, those first sentences, those first paragraphs, like creating the mood, creating the key that the book is going to be in?

SPEAKER_01At first, I don't think about it much because it can be really intimidating to say, like, I am going to write the first sentence on my book. So I never even think of it that way. I always picture myself that I'm diving in a few paragraphs along. And then I often go back and I put the first paragraph on it. Once I'm completely done with the book and sort of like go in that way. Like, what do I want the theme to be? With Sharp Objects, I didn't. My husband like absolutely hates the first sentence.

SPEAKER_00What did he say?

SPEAKER_01It is, I think it was, my sweater was new, stinging red and ugly, but let me see if I, yep, that's the one.

SPEAKER_00That's the one.

SPEAKER_01I got it. That, you know, he's like, it just doesn't do the book justice. Like, he's like, all your other first, um, First sentences are like so good. He's like, I don't know. You should have gone back and fixed sharp objects. But that was before I knew him. So with Gone Girl, I like the first sentence of Gone Girl.

SPEAKER_00When I think of my wife, I always think of her head, the shape of it to begin with. Oh.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think that sets off a, once you know who Nick is, you know what direction that's coming from. It gives this mildly uneasy thing of, well, why is this man thinking of the back of his wife's head?

SPEAKER_00So what's the rule of the five questions where he says, what are you thinking, Amy? The question I've asked most during our marriage, if not out loud, if not to the person who could answer, I suppose those questions storm cloud over every marriage. What are you thinking? How are you feeling? Who are you? What have we done to each other? What will we do?

SPEAKER_01I think those are the questions of the book. I think it starts answering those as you go. To me, that establishes the mystery of what the book is. The book's mystery is what happened to Amy, but it's also what happened to their marriage. And I think, again, having written it at that time when I was a to-be or recently married woman, I was asking those questions a lot. You know, I was sort of like, okay, what does it mean to be joined with someone for life?

SPEAKER_01And that they do change you and you change them. And, you know, if it's toxic, then you're each getting poisoned back and forth.

SPEAKER_00What makes mysteries such a good way to do character study? Oh.

SPEAKER_01Best way, it's such a great way to do characters today for someone who doesn't know how to write a novel. I tried for so long to write sharp objects, and that was, I wanted to write about female violence and generational and cyclically and what that looked like, and I... But I didn't know how to do it. And so basically it would be a series of conversations where people would be like, what's up with women and violence? And the other character would be like, eh, it's horrible. We're really violent as it turns out. People don't think we are. And then the other, I mean, he was like...

SPEAKER_01Awful. It was awful. And then I would be like, this isn't working. I moved them to another room and they would just keep talking about it. At one point, there was a bird that was trapped in the character's house and they were attacking the bird. I mean, it's just, it was going nowhere. And I read my friend Dennis Lehane. He wasn't my friend at the time, but Dennis Lehane's Mystic River. I read it through the night. It was one of the very few books I literally can say I read in one sitting. I just read it all the way through the night. Came in to work the next morning. I was exhausted, but it was kind of exhilarated because I'm like, I got it.

SPEAKER_01I figured it out. Dennis Lehane has shown me the way. As you do, Dennis. A mystery can give me the Engine, Discipline, Why Those Words?

SPEAKER_01Because I think that they force you to have a plot. My thoughts don't come with this plot. I think of the character first, and then I'm making up the plot to go along with the character. So I'm creating the mystery as I'm... You

SPEAKER_00have your own imprint called Gillian Flynn Books and the lines on the site at the top, they say stories with teeth, biting, voice driven and thrilling. And then at the bottom it says designed to start conversations and leave you reeling. Why'd you choose those words?

SPEAKER_01Because the most important thing to me when someone reads my book is not that they like it. It doesn't bother me if you don't like my book. And that may come from having been a critic for a long time. And I really believe if you could dish it out, you should be able to take it. And reading my own reviews, sometimes I'm like, That's not fair. That's incorrect. Oh, that one. That's right. You're right. You caught me like that part sucked. Yes, you're correct.

SPEAKER_01Critic. So I kind of kind of the ability to kind of like distance myself and appreciate it. And so people come up to me like at readings and like. Slammed the book down. Like, I hated this book. Like, I'm only here because my book club made me calm. And like, this is worse. I hated this book. And I'm always like, tell me. What do you hate about it? Let's get in there. Because to me, it's great. Like, it's like, because you thought about it. Right. It didn't. I would much rather have that than have, like, I liked it.

SPEAKER_01No, or like, I liked it. It's good.

SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_01And you don't think about it again. It just goes water through your head, and it was a great experience, and you don't think about it ever again. I don't want that. I want people to think about what I write on some level. I want them to be entertained by it, and I want them to think, hopefully, and want to talk about it with someone, want to debate it. I like conflict. I like being conflicted about a character, liking them and not liking them, or not knowing if they're good or not, and being frustrated by them. All those things, because that's kind of closer to reality than, yeah.

SPEAKER_00And then with the input, you're trying to do that for other books.

SPEAKER_01Yes. Yeah. So that's what I want to have.

SPEAKER_00Maybe I'm inferring that you think this is important to do not just for you books, but like we need more of that. We need more of that.

SPEAKER_01Well, especially right now as all the consolidation is happening, happening as all the fear about the future writing and the future reading and the future, you know, art is happening. Yeah. People are scared and they're wanting to only give contracts, you know, to writers who are already established for some reason, like already have another platform somewhere or very kind of easily consumable, edible products.

SPEAKER_01That'll be like a quick hit. The weirder and quirkier and outsidery and the stuff with strange angles that I tend to like, people aren't taking as much of a risk on them. Would someone have published Sharp Objects now? I don't know. I don't know if they would have.

SPEAKER_01If they really were thinking that that belief were still in place, that women would only read aspirational, would they have taken, even bothered to take a risk?

SPEAKER_00And now with the books that are given to you, what pieces of feedback do you find yourself giving the most to authors? Voice. Give me more voice. Give me more voice.

SPEAKER_01And I want to be very clear, I am not their editor. I read it and I give feedback, but it's very general. And then an editor actually does the hard work. So I don't want to take anything away from the wonderful editors at Zando that handled that. But yeah, it's often like, trust your voice. Like, you didn't give me enough here. And they often say, like... No, I thought I was giving too much. And it's like, no, no, no. Let's revel in it. And I like those stories.

SPEAKER_01But it's usually already there. To me, it's those books where you do think about it. You do talk about the characters. Every book I've published, and I'm so... Proud of those books on the imprint are books that I would pick up and give to someone else with saying like, it's going to be a trip. Or saying like, you're going to love this. Like, the narrator is insane. Or you won't believe this. Or like, it ends up at, you know...

SPEAKER_01The craziest place you'll ever, you know, like that kind of thing. Not, not like, not, I, I am sure you will like this because everyone likes this.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I guess. And I want to get that book. I guess what I'm trying to work out is, let's say that I submitted something, you're like, dude, give me more voice. I want to hear more David. I want to hear more David. I guess my worry is then in the next draft, I would almost become a caricature myself, be too much, and also be insincere. So like how do I get – how do I crank up the volume dial on voice while maintaining the sincerity, the authenticity, almost the integrity of that?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Great question. But I think really it's having that confidence of knowing your character or your place or whatever it is that you're jammed as making you write that book. I will probably want more of it because that's where the writer is usually their most confident. They're feeling their happiest. They're feeling their most – Themselves and authory and it's like live in that space. I can feel it. The voice is a little watery over here.

SPEAKER_01I don't think you're as confident over here. Like get confident about it. Whatever it takes for you to be confident in this section of your book that it belongs in your book. You need to justify it. Give me more.

SPEAKER_00Right. Last question. You're invited to go teach at Northwestern, do a semester class on writing. Oh, please. Teaching people to do what you do. How do you structure the curriculum? What do you try to get the students to understand?

SPEAKER_01How would I structure it? I think the way I would structure it is really a lot of in-class exercise writing and then sharing. And this is coming off the top of my head, but I do think that You learn – writing is something you learn the best about by writing, and I really do think that. I spent – I don't know if it would be called wasted time or unnecessary time, but on reading about how to write. Yeah, write like on – Okay,

SPEAKER_01I can't start yet because I need to, there's one more book I should probably read to figure out how to write. And the answer is there's no correct way to write. These books are like Stephen King's On Writing and Lamas Bird by Bird. These are amazing books that helped me be a writer and they're amazing. But then you do at some point have to write. And so I think that exercise of writing quickly and saying and literally being like, okay, here's the topic. It's a father and daughter story.

SPEAKER_01And she's 13 and she just got her period and there's no mom around. Write that scene and see what people come up with. And that way they can figure out what their strong suits are. Of course, it has female blood and awkwardness and darkness in it. And the mom's dead and he killed her. Write the scene. You know, and I think that way. Anyone who wants to write, anyone's a good writer, has their strong points and their weak points. I always think my weakest point and my least fair part is the plot.

SPEAKER_01And that way I have to trick myself. That's why I write mysteries because I like mysteries. So I could trick myself into actually making a plot. And some people, it's going to be the voice. Some people, it's a sense of place or internal dialogue or whatever it is. But that way each student could kind of slowly figure out during the course of that process Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I am so jealous of. I think she is one of the great writers, not the great thriller writers, but the great writers working today. I cannot do what she does. She mostly moves in the, she's moved aside, but certainly started on the mystery genre. And I would read her stuff and just be like, curse you, Atkinson. Like, you made me cry and weep and laugh within the... Span of three pages. I mean, I go back and I will reread her stuff to go, how did this magic happen? So it's people that do the things where I'm just like, I'll never get there.

SPEAKER_01I mean, I know this. I've got my own thing I'm good at. I'm not sad about it. But like, I will never be at her level. I just don't have that game.

SPEAKER_00Never be able to cook that sauce. Never. This was so fun. This was great. You're the coolest person. You're so talented.

SPEAKER_01When I finish my next book at some point soon-ish, I'm coming back. Let's go. Yes.

SPEAKER_00So great to meet you. You too. Thanks for

SPEAKER_01having me.

SPEAKER_00Thank you.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. V.E. Schwab: The Architecture of Great Writing

    Nov 18, 20261 hr 32 minAudio

    I want to learn more about who’s listening to How I Write. What kind of writing do you do? What do you like about the show, and how can I make it better? Who do you want me to interview? So I threw together a little...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Elizabeth Gilbert: This is What 40 Years of Writing Discipline Looks Like

    Nov 11, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    I want to learn more about who’s listening to How I Write. What kind of writing do you do? What do you like about the show, and how can I make it better? Who do you want me to interview? So I threw together a little...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Malcolm Gladwell: The Most Useful Hour You'll Ever Spend on Storytelling

    Nov 4, 202658 minAudio

    Big thanks to Alpha School for being the presenting sponsor of this episode. When I was in school, I constantly found myself thinking: “We can do so much better than this.” Alpha School is what I wish existed back then....

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Dean Koontz: This is What Mystical Writing Feels Like

    Oct 21, 20261 hr 13 minAudio

    Big thanks to Alpha School for being the presenting sponsor of this episode. When I was in school, I constantly found myself thinking: “We can do so much better than this.” Alpha School is what I wish existed back then....

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Jodi Picoult: The Writing Habits Behind 50 Million Books Sold

    Oct 14, 20261 hr 14 minAudio

    Big thanks to Alpha School for being the presenting sponsor of this episode. When I was in school, I constantly found myself thinking: “We can do so much better than this.” Alpha School is what I wish existed back then....

    Credit the people on this episode