Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

How I Write

How I Write artwork

Michael Arndt: Oscar-winning Writer Teaches Storytelling

Sep 23, 20261 hr 17 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Big thanks to Alpha School for being the presenting sponsor of this episode. When I was in school, I constantly found myself thinking: “We can do so much better than this.” Alpha School is what I wish existed back then. Kids learn everything they need in only two hours per day, so they can spend the rest of the time actual learning life skills: public speaking, building a business, negotiating, etc. If you want your kid to love school and join classes that rank in the top 1% nationwide, Alpha School is the place to be. Learn more at ⁠https://go.alpha.school/howiwrite. Michael Arndt, the Academy Award-winning screenwriter, is on the show today to teach us how to write great stories.We started the conversation by discussing his time at Pixar. I asked Michael, "You worked on movies like Toy Story 3. What is it about Pixar's DNA that has made them so successful for so long?"We also discussed Little Miss Sunshine, the movie that won him an Oscar in 2007. He has read thousands of screenplays, so he understands what distinguishes a bad screenplay from a good one. As a script doctor and storytelling scientist, he's here to teach us how to write great stories. Transcript 00:00:37 Pixar’s secret sauce00:05:28 What makes a Pixar-level team00:08:37 What a Pixar meeting looks like00:12:46 The hardest part of storytelling00:16:51 Bad writing costs more than we think00:19:23 How to spot a good script00:21:28 What makes a great villain00:25:25 Why act one matters so much00:29:27 The rollercoaster framework00:31:37 Characters that Michael admires00:38:07 The writing advice you should ignore00:41:40 Outdated Hollywood rules00:47:06 What it felt like to win an Oscar00:52:33 Why AI won’t ruin movies00:56:58 What Japanese films taught him01:01:30 How to diagnose a story01:09:00 Your hero doesn’t need flaws01:10:40 Advice for beginner writers David (00:37-00:43): Tell me about Pixar. What is it like working there? Why has Pixar been so successful for so long? What makes it different? Michael (00:43-02:42): I think Pixar truly cracked the code of storytelling. When I first arrived, I wondered what their secret sauce was: the people or the system? After about six months, I realized it’s both. You need the system in place, and you need the right people. When I wrote Little Miss Sunshine, I was a total prickly loner. My attitude was, “Everybody shut up and leave me alone.” They hired me after reading the Little Miss Sunshine script as a sample; they didn’t even know it was being made. My agent asked if there was any reason I couldn’t move to San Francisco if I worked at Pixar. I wanted to work for them and write, but I lived in New York. I asked if I could stay in New York, and my agent responded, “No, that’s not how they do things. You have to be in the building.” This was part of Steve Jobs’ philosophy, and I believe it was core to their success. You’re in this large building, making very difficult and complicated movies, but the great thing is that three or four films are always in development simultaneously, and everyone helps each other. The core of their process is iteration: you create a rough version of the movie seven or eight times before moving to final animation. For Toy Story 3, I wrote the first draft, and we created what they call a set of reels - a rough animatic of the movie. Based on the feedback, I wrote another draft, or sometimes ten more, before making a second set of reels. The Pixar system is iterative: you write, direct, and edit, then repeat the process. This allows you to hyper-focus on every aspect. It’s a way to beta-test your story. You put it in front of an audience, and you can hear their reactions. If you write a joke and nobody laughs, you have direct proof it’s not funny. David (02:42-02:44): So you invite people to watch the early versions of the movie? Michael (02:44-03:37): Exactly. Their system operates in a series of concentric rings. The first set of reels, which is usually quite terrible, is shown to 20 to 30 people. You always want to preserve fresh eyes, so you invite people who have never seen the film before. For the second screening, a few more people attend; for the third, a few more. By the seventh or eighth screening, you’re showing it to as many people as you can possibly gather. They are extremely patient, giving you three years to develop a good story. It’s a very forgiving process where you’re allowed to fail. One of their tenets is to “fail as quickly as possible.” Just get it up on its feet and don’t hesitate. David (03:38-03:44): Tell me about how Pixar would break down a movie into, say, 20 to 25 different sequences. Michael (03:44-05:28): It was interesting. Because animation is so labor-intensive, they had to break down the script into 25 or 30 different sequences. When discussing the story, you’d talk about what happens in each sequence. The first act would typically be five or six sequences, the second quarter (what they call 2A, up to the midpoint) would be five or six, the third quarter five or six, and the fourth quarter five or six sequences. This method provides a clear way to break down a story, ensuring you always have a specific goal. For instance, the end of sequence six leads to sequence seven, and the end of sequence seven leads to sequence eight. However, this breakdown was primarily for production, allowing them to track which sequences were finalized and working, and which were still problematic. Films were made non-sequentially. For example, the first scene in Toy Story 3 that was finalized for production, where they’d say, “You’re done, you don’t need a guide anymore,” was when Woody wakes up in Bonnie’s room. He tries to figure out how to get back to Andy, uses the internet to find his location, says goodbye, and then learns about Lotso. That sequence was called “MapQuest.” I did about five or six drafts of that simple scene, so it was finished first. The last sequence I worked on was the staff meeting scene, which is right at the beginning of the movie. Those are the hardest scenes to write because you’re juggling so much exposition. I did about 60 drafts of that scene. David (05:28-05:50): How does Pixar balance the nurturing support needed for creativity with the pressure of making a Pixar movie? How do they balance that motherly support with the expectation that “this isn’t good enough,” telling you to make it great and keep going - which is more of a masculine toughness? Michael (05:50-06:49): They trust the process; they believe the process will work. What was interesting was I remember being in story meetings where they would say, “For where you are in the process, you’re fine.” A lot of the story still wasn’t working, but we were one year into a three-year process. Based on their expectations and experience, our progress was acceptable. There was an unhappy side to Pixar: directors getting fired off projects and being replaced. You always felt like a sword of Damocles was hanging over you. At a certain point, you needed to make something work. I lived in fear and terror for three years that I was about to get fired. The other thing is they emphasize that storytelling is a team effort. It takes everyone. It’s not just your problem to solve; it’s our problem that we’re all trying to solve together. David (06:50-07:07): What does Pixar understand about the structure of teams to make it work? It seems like a lot of group collaboration leads to a regression to the mean, but Pixar appears to be a crazy exception. We were just talking about The Beatles as a four-person team. Michael (07:07-07:07): Yes. David (07:07-07:13): What is required in a good team, from what you learned at Pixar, to make people more creative rather than less? Michael (07:13-08:37): I think the main thing is that it was non-hierarchical and democratic. You could go to an early version of Wall-E, which was a really difficult script to write because you have a hero who can’t talk. You have to tell the entire story visually, which is incredibly hard to do. The main thing … Get full access to David Perell's How I Write at howiwrite.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Michael Arndt, the Academy Award-winning screenwriters on the show today to teach us how to write great stories. We started the conversation talking about his time at Pixar, and I said, Michael, you worked on movies like Toy Story 3. What is it about the DNA of Pixar that has made them so successful for so long? And then we talked about Little Miss Sunshine, the movie that won him an Oscar award in 2007. This is a guy who's read thousands of screenplays. He's got a good sense of what makes for a bad screenplay, what makes for a good one, what's the difference between them.

SPEAKER_00He's the script doctor, he's the storytelling scientist, and he's here to teach us how to write great stories. Tell me about Pixar. What is it like working at Pixar? Why has Pixar been so successful for so long? What's different about it? Oh, my God.

SPEAKER_01I think Pixar, to me, I feel like Pixar really kind of cracked the code of storytelling. And I think that one of it is, well, first, of all, I'll tell you this. When I got there, I was like, what's the secret sauce? Is it the people or is it the system? And after about six months, I realized it's really both. Like you got to have the system in place and you got to have the right people. You know, when I wrote Little Miss Sunshine, I was... Total prickly loner. I was like, everybody shut the fuck up and leave me alone. They hired me having read the script of Little Miss Sunshine, but they didn't even know it was being made.

SPEAKER_01They just liked the script as a sample. Like my agent said, oh, if you work at Pixar, is there any reason you can't move to San Francisco? And I was like, well, I'd love to work for Pixar. I'd love to write for them, but I live in New York. Can I just stay in New York? And my agent was like, nope, that's not how they do things. You've got to go there. You've got to be in the building. And this was sort of Steve Jobs' philosophy. I think that it was sort of the core of success is that, you know, you've got, you're there in this big building and you're trying to make these movies that are very difficult and complicated to make.

SPEAKER_01But the great thing is that there's always three or four films that are all in development at the same time and everybody's helping each other out. Core thing is that they make a movie, they have an iterative process. So you make a rough version of the movie seven or eight times before you go to final animation. So we made Toy Story 3. You know, I wrote the first draft. We made what they call a set of reels, which is a rough animatic of the movie. And then based on the feedback that we got to that, I wrote another draft or 10 more drafts. And then we made a second set of reels.

SPEAKER_01What's great about the Pixar system is that you You write, and then you direct, and then you edit, and then you write, and then you direct, and you edit, and you write, and it's an iterative system. So you're really able to really hyper-focus everything. There's a way that you beta test your story. You put in front of the audience so you can hear the audience react. If you write a joke and nobody laughs, you just have proof. It's not a funny joke. So you invite people to watch the early versions of the movie? Totally. And their system there is that it's sort of a series of concentric rings.

SPEAKER_01So the first... Set of reels, which is usually pretty terrible. You show to 20, 25, 30 people. And then you always want to preserve fresh eyes, right? Because you want to have people who've never seen the film before come. So the second screening, you'll have a few more people come. The third screening, a few more people. By the time you get up to your seventh or eighth screening, you're showing it to everybody and his grandmother that you can pull in. They're just extremely patient. They give you three years to come up with a good story.

SPEAKER_01It's this very forgiving process where you can fail. One of their tenets is fail as quickly as possible. Just go out, get it up on its feet, and don't hesitate.

SPEAKER_00Tell me about the way that Pixar would break down the movie into, what, 20, 25 different sequences?

SPEAKER_01You break down the script into 25 or 30 different sequences. And to talk about the story, you're talking about, you know, what happens in each sequence. You know, the first act is going to be five or six sequences. The second quarter, what they call 2A up to midpoint is going to be five I feel like that's a very, like the way of breaking down a story. So you always have a very clear goal. Like at the end of sequence six is going to lead to sequence seven. End of sequence seven.

SPEAKER_01It was mostly for production. That was mostly done for production so that you were always keeping track of what sequence was fixed and working and what sequence was still problematic. They got made... Uh, non-sequentially. So if there was a, I'll just give you the example. The first, uh, scene, uh, in Toy Story 3 that got finaled for production was, and, and they're like, you're done. You don't need to write any more of The scene was when Woody wakes up

SPEAKER_01in Bonnie's room and he's trying to figure out how to get back to Andy and he goes and he goes on the internet and he finds where he is and then he says goodbye and then he learns about Lotso. The sequence was called MapQuest. I did about five or six drafts of that. And it was a simple scene, so it got finished first. And then the last, I think the last sequence that I was working on was the staff meeting scene, which is right at the beginning. Those are the hardest scenes to write because you're juggling so much exposition in those scenes.

SPEAKER_01So I did about 60 drafts of that scene.

SPEAKER_00How does Pixar balance the kind of support, the nurturing that you need to be creative? And also just deal with the pressure of making a Pixar movie. How do they balance that kind of nurturing motherly support with kind of the, dude, this isn't good enough, make it great, keep going, which is more of this like masculine toughness.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, they do it. They have the same trust the process, like the process is going to work. And you know, what was interesting was I remember being in story meetings and they would say, for where you are in the process, you're fine. Like a lot of the story still doesn't work. Like some of the Some of the story still isn't working, but we're one year into the three-year process, so based on our expectations or based on our experience, where you are is fine. There was sort of an unhappy side to Pixar, which is directors getting Fired off a project and getting replaced

SPEAKER_01by other directors. So there was a, you know, you always kind of felt like, you know, there was a sort of Damocles hanging over you. Like you kind of like, at a certain point you needed to make something. I know, I know. I lived in fear and terror for three years that I was about to get fired. And the other thing is that they just say, you know, storytelling is a team effort. Like it takes everybody. So it's not just your problem that you've got to solve. It's like our problem that we're all trying to solve together.

SPEAKER_00What does Pixar understand about the structure of teams to make it work? It seems like a lot of crap is made by groups and collaboration. There's kind of a regression to the mean. But Pixar seems like a crazy exception to this. We talked about the Beatles before, Floor Herson team. What is required in a good team from what you learned at Pixar to make people more creative rather than less?

SPEAKER_01I think the main thing is that it was sort of non-hierarchical. It's democratic. And so you could go to, I'll just say, an early version of WALL-E, which was a really, really difficult script to write because you have a hero who can't talk. So you just have to tell your whole story visually, which is really hard to do. The main thing is that you're... You're really investing the director with all the authority, right? He's not getting notes from executives.

SPEAKER_01He's not getting notes from producers who are saying you have to do this. He's not getting notes from marketing people. Like it's really the final decision comes down to the directors, but everyone Yeah. I can choose like, okay, I like this. I don't like this. You know, I think I'm going to make this work. I don't know. We've already tried that. You know, I can't make that work.

SPEAKER_01To me, the thing that was so great about it was that it was a creatively democratic system where a good idea can come from anywhere. And you were very open. People, there just wasn't a lot of ego there. There was sort of a soft taboo about claiming credit for any one idea because it was like, it wasn't you that came up with the idea. It was like, we came up with this idea.

SPEAKER_00Can you take me into what it's like being in a brain trust meeting? Like if I'm in the room, what is it like? Who's there? What's the conversation? I'll give you a great example.

SPEAKER_01This is my, I could be wrong, but this is my recollection of the origin of Spanish Buzz was I wrote a first draft of the script and it was based on the treatment that Andrew Stanton did. The twist sort of halfway through was that Buzz gets reset back to his original factory settings and he becomes a space rancher again. And so that's how I wrote the first draft. And then There was an offsite meeting where I'm telling you, it was literally for like three days, two or three days. It was like, everybody left Pixar. They went to a, like an inn in like Napa Valley.

SPEAKER_01And we sat in a giant conference room of around a giant team. And again, like 25 or 30 people who had all worked on the Toy Story films sitting there trying to help me fix my first draft of the script. I know. And it's just like you couldn't get a bigger set of training wheels. And all these fucking smart people who know these characters like the back of their hand are all trying to help make something better. And my recollection about the origin of Spanish Buzz, which may be Maybe wrong, but this is what I remember was at a certain point,

SPEAKER_01John Laster goes, you know, we've done turning Buzz into a space ranger before. It feels like we're just repeating ourselves. Is there something else, you know, that we could do? And so people just started throwing out ideas like fast motion Buzz, slow motion Buzz, you know, electrified Buzz or something like that. And I was sitting next to Andrew and I just said, Spanish Buzz, like that. But it was like a little joke that I had between the two of us. And Andrew went... A Spanish buzz to like the whole room and everybody like all the animators like, oh, I know that we can make Spanish buzz funny.

SPEAKER_01And it was a great example of you needed one guy to go, you know what? This is a problem that we need to fix. I was John. You got one idiot who comes You need another person to go, yes, that's the right idea. And it's really that creative ferment, the fact that you can have half an idea and somebody else would come along and give the other half the idea, that it's just such a luxury. It's so great. And it teaches you humility. It really teaches you humility because a lot of times you think you're right. And then after 10 minutes, you go, oh, wait a minute.

SPEAKER_01I'm thinking of everyone else's right and I'm wrong. And it gets you over that writer ego that the writer always has to be right about things.

SPEAKER_00So what is the core thing that John Lasseter understands about stories that more writers need to know?

SPEAKER_01John was a freaking genius at if we screen an early version of something, either from Pixar Or from, for Disney feature animation would bring something up. Usually, you know, the first draft is usually shit. All first drafts are shit. And there were screenings. I walk out and I'd be like, I don't know what to say. Like, I don't, I have no notes. Like I, like there's so many problems with this. Like there's, there's an infinite number of problems and I don't even know where to begin. Like, I don't know how to talk to this director or like what can be done to rescue this thing.

SPEAKER_01And John was great about getting everybody in the room. And I'm just like, I don't want to be here because I have nothing to say. And John would be like, why do you want to make this movie? What was the or he would he would pick up a little detail. He goes, I love what you did with this thing. I love this detail that you created. I love that your character does this. Tell me more about that. And he was so good at like dialing into why do you want to tell the story? Why is this important to you? Like going like, let's go into the heart of. Going back to the very beginning of the process, why did you decide this was something, a story that you wanted to tell?

SPEAKER_01And then based on that little kernel, he could coax out, you know, how can we make this more emotional? How can we make this more meaningful? How can we get the audience on board with this character? And I think that he was so good at... Running meetings and getting people to open up and share and then connecting your personal experience, like what you actually believe about the world, what you actually believe about how we should live our lives with what was up on screen and trying to get those married together.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, when I had Andrew Stanton on the show, what really stuck out was how much he was able to distill the stories that he was telling. Like I asked, what is the core thing about Wally? And he goes, Wally is all about one sentence. Irrational love defeats life's programming.

SPEAKER_01And you hear that, you're like, ha. But here's the thing is that it sounds so simple to get down to a bumper sticker like that. That's actually kind of the hardest thing to do in a story. I think the biggest misconception that people have about writers and storytellers is that you know what you want to say when you start out. No, the reason you're writing, if you knew what you wanted to say, you would just sit there and write it all out trying to figure it out. Yeah, exactly. And I think that It's actually a very, very helpful exercise to challenge yourself to distill everything down into a bumper sticker because that becomes your North Star in your story.

SPEAKER_01That becomes a thing that you can judge every scene in the story is like, is this serving our North Star or is it not serving men? What's the bumper sticker, Little Miss Sunshine? The bumper sticker is that basically fun is more important than winning, you know?

SPEAKER_00Ah, that's basically it. Right, so you have the family dancing at the end. They're not going to win.

SPEAKER_01They're going to lose, but they're going to lose in the funnest and most spectacular way possible.

SPEAKER_00What is the core lesson?

SPEAKER_01Oh, it's the impermanence of all things. It's letting go, like the wisdom of letting go. And I think that... You know, I say in my video that I made about Toy Story 3 is that we all go through our lives like having these very close relationships with people, you know, and it's your best friend forever when you were 12 years old. It's your high school sweetheart. It's your buddies in college. It's your the coworkers of that first crazy job that you had. And you form these really tight bonds of attachment with them.

SPEAKER_01And then at a certain point, your best friend moves away. Your girlfriend dumps you. You move on to a different job and you go like, was that even real? You know? And... This is what Woody is facing is that like I me and Andy were like this for 12 years or 18 years. Right. And now he's going off to college. And like, did that just mean nothing? Like, am I just being thrown on a scrap heap? Like, was that all that all those emotions? The conversations I felt with Andy, all that love that I had for him, you know, and this is what Lotso says, if your kid loves you so much, why is he leaving?

SPEAKER_01You know, and what you realize is that as you go through life, sometimes the most loving thing you can do to somebody is to let them go and move on. And that's where the, you know, the epiphany at the end is, you know, Andy's mom says, I wish I could always be with you. And Andy says, you will be mom. And you're just flipping the meaning of what it means to be there for someone. From the sort of the literal thing to the more poetic or metaphorical thing.

SPEAKER_00This episode is sponsored by Alpha School. When you think of school, what comes to mind? For me, it was lectures, homework, being stuck at a desk. And the worst part is that it doesn't even work. 54% of Americans read below a sixth grade level. That's over half of Americans. We need something new. And that's why I'm excited to have Alpha School as the flagship sponsor of How I Write. At Alpha, you go to school, you get all your academics done in only two hours per day so that then you can spend the rest of the time learning life skills like running a business,

SPEAKER_00writing a musical, giving a TEDx talk. You know, the kind of things that make you a capable and well-rounded person. And it's working. They have the academics figured out. Alpha classes test in the top 1% nationally, and more than 90% of students say they love school. Now, I used to live in Austin, where Alpha School started, and I was consistently blown away by what was happening there. I personally mentored a bunch of the kids, and what stuck out to me is how much their team believes in the potential of kids. Alpha's approach,

SPEAKER_00and the success it's already having, is why it's the most talked about K-12 school in the world right now, and also where I want to send my kids to school one day. So if you want to learn more, visit go.alpha.school slash how I write. There's nothing more expensive than bad writing and nothing cheaper than good writing.

SPEAKER_01If something is written badly, especially in the movies, you're spending $100 million making a movie. If it's badly written, you know, it's not going to do as well. It's not going to last as long. I'll say that. It won't last. I do think that good writing tends to last longer than bad writing. People are hesitant to spend money on writers or writing because a lot of times it's a very uneven payoff. Sometimes you can spend a lot of money and you get a draft turned in that's not any good. David Perell's How I Write.

SPEAKER_01You know, we would have worked our brains out. We would have worked just as hard as we did, but it would have been a bad movie, you know, or it'd been a mediocre movie. And if you had given us two years, it would have been like a, you know, B minus movie. But we really needed three years to make it whatever it turned into. You were a script reviewer. I was a script reader, yeah. Talk about that. I read a lot of screenplays. I went to film school. I got out. I wanted to be a director. The directors that I really admired were the ones who wrote their own stuff. So I was like, oh, I'll do this writing thing for a while and then I'll turn to How hard can it be?

SPEAKER_01And then just to learn how to be a screenwriter, this was before the internet, so it was actually hard to find screenplays. You couldn't just go into a store and buy them. And so I got a job. I was just like, I should just get a job reading screenplays. So I got a job as a freelance script reader, 50 bucks a script. You go in there, you pick up a stack of scripts, you go home, you read them, you write like a page and a half synopsis and then a half a page comment on it. And you usually it's like, you know, thumbs up, thumbs down. Or, you know, maybe in the middle.

SPEAKER_01But I did that for about, oh my God, off and on I did it for about 10 years, you know, and I probably read, I'm guessing about a thousand screenplays. And there were a handful that I really wholeheartedly recommended that were great. I read Election, you know, when I was working for Matthew Broderick, I remember sitting on the Ultron and reading Election thinking, oh, wow, this is really good. And I went in the next day and I was like, you should read this script. And then a couple of weeks later, he was like, you know that script you told me I should read? He's like, I think I'm going to do it.

SPEAKER_01So that was one of the few times the system sort of worked the way it was supposed to.

SPEAKER_00And what was true about great scripts, great stories that the mediocre ones

SPEAKER_01don't have? Two elements, two things that you just sort of felt or they had a smell for them. Number one, well, the good scripts felt like they were set in the real world. They were located in a specific place with specific characters. So a bad script would just be like generic American city and generic American character. And a good script would be really rooted in what that local location was. So it was the specificity. And then the other thing that I came to realize or I came to feel was that a lot

SPEAKER_01of scripts felt like they were imitation movies. It felt like they were just... What the writer was trying to do was just to do a saleable facsimile of a genre of movies that they had seen, right? And so it was sort of set in movie world and not a real world, and it felt like a fake story rather than a real And there's just a way when you're a reader that you can kind of feel, and I guess as an audience member, when you're sitting in a theater, you can kind of feel when something is a real story as opposed to a fake story or

SPEAKER_01a simulation of a story. The heartbreaking thing about being a script reader is you say no to like 90, 95% of the stuff you read. And I finally, I mean, the way I just sort of dealt with the guilt of it, the survivor's guilt of it was like, if you're trying to tell a real story, like you can kind of feel it.

SPEAKER_00Can you be... What does a fake story feel like versus a real story?

SPEAKER_01I would say a fake story is one where you're, I'll just give you an example, which is you meet your hero and he's kind of a shallow jerk, right? And he goes through the story being a shallow jerk, but his flaws are very obvious. And then at the end of the movie, he learns a lesson that you could see coming a mile away and he becomes, he's no longer a shallow jerk, he becomes a decent person. But the meaning of your story is just a fairly banal cliche. But good writing is the backstage conversations

SPEAKER_00that you have. It's the stuff that you really believe in and that you're taking a risk by expressing it. We're talking about the lessons that you learned reading all those screenplays. What did you learn about what makes for a good fill-in? Not all stories have to have villains, right?

SPEAKER_01But a lot of stories do. And I think your villain can be the centrifugal center of your story. And to me, at least, the reason they're the centrifugal center of your story is because they represent the apotheosis, the quintessence of the negative values in your story, which is the thing that your hero is struggling against. And I think that your villain can be, I mean, obviously, like Darth Vader is a villain who's all about violence and domination. That's a pretty easy villain. You have Gordon Gekko, right, who is the guy who's like greed is good. Greed works.

SPEAKER_01Greed purifies. What's great about a strong villain is that they have a very clear and compelling worldview. And in a way, what you want to do in a story is make it seem as though even though the villain is being a bit of a dick, even though the villain is not a nice guy, his worldview is right.

SPEAKER_00Like it's irrefutable. You can't argue against it.

SPEAKER_01You know, we did this with Lotso on Toy Story 3. At a certain point, he says, you know, your kid is going to grow up and leave you, and toys are just trash waiting to be thrown away. And at that point in the story, they're standing over a dumpster. Like, it looks like they'll never see Andy again. You go, well, he's being kind of a dick about it, but he's right. He's basically right. Yeah, a good villain... It doesn't have to be necessarily super powerful or super malevolent. They have to be super convincing. They have to convince you that their way of seeing the world is right.

SPEAKER_00One thing I'm hearing you say is that there's almost three things that you have in a story. You have, say, the main character, but the main character, in order for them to feel real, alive, they have to be reacting against something. And so there we're talking about the villain. Yeah. But then there's also the reaction against the world.

SPEAKER_01Is that right? Yeah, no, this is something I just made this new video about how to write a good first act. And this was the big discovery for me in making this video, which I'm hoping to be finished in a couple of weeks, is that a lot of times... Again, I hadn't quite appreciated how often your hero and the world they live in are two sides of the same coin. And a lot of times you're introducing the world as a flawed world. And let's just say a slightly poisoned world, right? It's poisoned by greed or it's poisoned by racism or it's poisoned by like whatever. But your villain then represents the antidote to that thing.

SPEAKER_01So for example, Katniss Everdeen, like you introduced the world of Panem, right? And it's this repressive yada yada. And Katniss Everdeen starts off as a normal character. She's just a normal person. But the inciting incident, getting drafted to the Hunger Games, is going to set in motion a process whereby she becomes the antidote that's going to try and bring the system down or at least start the revolution. So, yeah, that was really, really interesting to me that a lot of times when you're trying to figure out what your story is or who your hero is, your hero is the antidote to the problems that are in the rest of the world.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I was thinking about Martin Luther King and Abraham Lincoln. Like, you can't really understand them without understanding the context of the world that they're reacting to. The thing that they're fighting against.

SPEAKER_01I always feel like Robin Hood is a really interesting figure because Robin Hood in the class Right. Right. He comes in, takes over England and then institutes this reign of abusive and unfair taxation. And that in itself, like that sense of injustice in the world,

SPEAKER_01like this abusive, excessive taxation is the thing that radicalizes your hero. He's got to leave his castle. And go off to live in Shorewood Forest, get a band of radicalized thieves together, and they're going to rob from the rich and give to the poor. But what's interesting is that the world itself has created Robin Hood. Like the injustice of the world, the pervasiveness of the injustice of the world has created Robin Hood,

SPEAKER_00that character. Tell me about this idea about how if there's a problem in the second or the third act, often people go, they try to fix the second or third act, but often the problem is just back in the first act. I am such a believer

SPEAKER_01in that. And I think that Billy Wilder has this very famous quote that if you have a problem in your third act, the real problem is in your first act because they're sort of bookends to each other. But I will go further. I'll say that if you have a problem in your second act, the real problem is probably in your first act. Your second act is just an expression of whatever you set up in your first act. So if you set up all your ducks in a row, right, when you get to your first act, right, but boom, you're here a shot out of a cannon. They have a clear goal. They have a clear long-term goal. They have a clear short-term plan for achieving that goal. You're going to go ABC through the second act.

SPEAKER_01If you get into the second act and you're going like, okay, wait a minute, what's at stake? What am I rooting for? You know, what is this story really about? That's because you haven't set up things properly in the first act. So I, again and again, I just feel like, I mean, this is why I want to make a whole I love this video about this is because I feel like first acts are very easy to underestimate in their importance because I think first acts are inherently deceiving. They're almost always entertaining. If you sit down and watch a movie, the first act,

SPEAKER_01you're meeting new characters, you're getting into new situations, and it's all kind of engaging. You're getting new information all the time in every new scene, and so it's just automatically entertaining. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And you're telling a story. I guess what I'm going to be thinking is, okay, where is this story going to end? What is going to be the pivot point in this story that makes people say, whoa. And then the beginning of that story sets those

SPEAKER_01things up. The main thing though is, and this is a point I make in the video, is that the number Number one, the first commandment of storytelling is make us care. So you've got to make your audience care about your lead character, and then you've got to make them care about the story. And so if you're sitting at a bar with your friends, I'm just totally making this up, but you go, oh my God, I got to tell you a story about what happened to me yesterday, which is I was I was doing X, Y, and Z, and then I encountered problem Q, which was totally unforeseen. If I didn't fix Q, X was going to happen or P was going to happen. And so I tried to fix Q, but then unexpectedly, like this other crazy thing.

SPEAKER_01And now I was even more in the hole than I was at the beginning. And then things kept getting worse and worse. All you're doing is you're establishing a sympathetic character, you, and you're establishing that they have a problem that they're trying to fix. And then you're establishing all of these unforeseen complications that come out of that. But you want to be pulling the thread of engagement with your audience forward. So they're going, OK, well, what happens at the end? He was just trying to, you know, go to the airport to pick up his girlfriend. And, you know, that was your goal. And then you got you ended up getting out of a carjacked in Brooklyn or somewhere like that.

SPEAKER_01But you still got, you know, if you don't

SPEAKER_00meet your girlfriend and her parents, then you're not going to get married in your scoots. One thing you hear in bar stories that you don't really see in movies as much is you just tell them about the end. You tell them about the climax. Like, if this actually happened to me, I once pissed my pants on the giant Dipper roller coaster in Santa Cruz. It's brutal, sitting next to a stranger at summer camp. You want to hear that story, right? But you hear that all the time when you're at a bar. You don't see that as much in movies.

SPEAKER_01Here's the thing. You don't have a captive audience in a bar. They can always get up and walk away and go get a drink. The audience in a theater has made a deal with you that they're going to sit there and in the first 10 minutes, you're going to make them care about the story. So I think that I feel like the first 10 minutes of a screenplay are sort of the most free... Oh, yeah.

SPEAKER_01A story is like you put your lead character into a roller coaster and you send them up the big hill of the roller coaster and you're ticking upwards and you're getting all this like narrative energy, like latent emotional energy. You're stacking, stacking the deck together. Of like whatever the character wants, whatever they're passionate about. And when you get to the top of the hill and you come over the top of the hill, like the rest of the story stretches out in front of you. That's the first act break is when you just start going down the hill and you're going through all the twists and turns of the story. What makes this analogy work is...

SPEAKER_01The first thing you have to do as a storyteller is to get your audience on board in the roller coaster car with your hero. You've got to get them so that they're wedded. They're sitting right next to the hero so that when you go down the big hill, you're right there with them. When you go through the loop, you're right there with them. There's a big difference between standing on the ground in the amusement park and watching somebody else ride a roller coaster. You know it's very thrilling for them, but it's not thrilling for you. You're just watching them from a distance.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Audience automatically have a defensive barrier. Audiences are automatically like, you know, I've seen a gazillion movies. I've seen a gazillion heroes. Like make me like this guy. And so you've got to actively take steps. You've got to have your hero do something or say something that's going to get your audience to go, oh my God, I love this person. Oh my God, this person is cool. Like, oh my God, I want to find out what happens next. But that was a mistake that I saw made over and over again in all the scripts that I was reading was just to presume audience sympathy for your hero. Just to think, you know, we all love our heroes. Like we sit down to write our story. We wouldn't write the story if we didn't love this hero, right?

SPEAKER_01But as a writer, I think the most important thing, and this is something that's so easy to miss because you automatically love your hero. You've got to Find a way, you've got to do something that's going to get your audience to sit up, take notice and go, oh, this character is just different. Not only from any person I met, but any other character I've seen on the screen. I think that's going to help a lot to get you into the rollercoaster car so that you're with them for the rest of the story.

SPEAKER_00Who's a hero from a story that you just love? Not in the sense like I love that hero, but you think that the writer, the creators of that story just nailed it.

SPEAKER_01I think Phil Conner in Groundhog Day. Groundhog Day is such a brilliant screenplay. It's so great. But it's a character who actually does start off as a bit of a shallow jerk, right? And you just kind of like him because Bill Murray is so funny and so A guy who is always living in the present, always living in the future, always living in the future, always living in the future. He's like, he hates his present life. Right. And all he's thinking about is I'm going to move on from here. I'm going to get a network job or something like that. So what do you do with a careful like that? You trap them in the present.

SPEAKER_01You trap them in the same day. So they just have to live in the same day over and over again. Here's one of the things that's really brilliant about Groundhog Day is that you get your second act problem, which is he's trapped in the same day and he doesn't know how to get out of it. And what's great is that you never explain the rules of it, right? You're, you're as an audience, you're with him going like, how does he get out of this? Like, how does he resolve this? And then so about at the midpoint, you go, he's, you know, he's, he's falling in love with, uh, Andy McDowell. And you think that true love is going to save the day. Right. And so there's. The way in which he's working on this problem,

SPEAKER_01he's going to try to make Andy McDowell fall in love with him. And then at the end of the act, he succeeds. He gets Andy McDowell to fall in love with him. And we've all been trained by movies to go, oh, like true love is going to triumph. And he waits up the next day and it's the same thing. And she's forgotten everything.

SPEAKER_00And is it too far to say that the lesson from that is that a character has to have some kind of weird thing about them? Maybe has to is too much. But is it too far to say that a character often has something about them that they're stuck in this way and then you push? I now divide stories into two categories, or let's say three categories, and I call them

SPEAKER_01The war movie and the therapy movie, right? The war movie and the therapy movie. So let's say the therapy movie is Finding Nemo is a perfect example of a therapy movie. You have a guy, he suffers a trauma in the opening prologue of the movie. He's traumatized. And therefore he decides in order to be a good dad, I'm going to do everything I can to protect my son. He picks up that last little egg and goes, I promise nothing bad will ever happen to you, right? And then, you know, for that character, what's the worst possible thing? His son gets taken, well, his son swims up and says, I hate you, dad.

SPEAKER_01Swims out, gets taken away. And now he's got to A, go rescue his son to save his life, but B, win his son's love and respect back. In the course of that second act journey, he's got to face his bias towards safety, right? And in the third act, he's got to let his son go. He's got to So it's a therapy movie, and he's coming out of it and learning how to get over his trauma, basically, or heal his

SPEAKER_01Zinnerwood or something like that. So again, I call it a therapy movie because all the conflict in that story is happening within the main character. The opposite of that, I'll just, I'm going to pitch you a hypothetical story, right? This is the war movie now. This is the war movie. There's a little girl. She lives in a Warsaw ghetto. She's 12 years old. The Nazis come in, kill everyone she knows, her family, friends, everybody, right? Put on a train, send her Auschwitz. She goes to Auschwitz, goes into the showers, right? And inexplicably, like, she survives. There are examples of that. A few people survive.

SPEAKER_01And so someone takes her, you know, smuggles her out of the camp and goes, I'm just going to keep you here. You're going to be nice and safe and warm and you'll just, like, live out the war here, like, safely. And she goes, no. I'm going to, like, this world is so fucked up, I'm going to go to Berlin, I'm going to find Hitler's bunker, I'm going to kill Hitler, right? Okay, there's a great, like, that's a great motivation, right? You have a totally unjust world, you have this character who's been unjustly acted upon, that character has I'm going to infiltrate his bunker. I'm going to kill Hitler, right?

SPEAKER_01That character has no internal drama. They don't need to become a better person. They don't need to fix themselves. The conflict, the problem in the story is in the outside world. The drama is just trying to fix what's wrong with the world. That's a very extreme example of something where the character doesn't need to be complicated at all. All she's doing is trying to go kill Hitler, and we can all root for that. But it's very different from Marlon in Finding Nemo, who's just trying to fix something inside himself.

SPEAKER_01I think that I'll just say Casablanca is sort of the middle way, right? Which is that you got Nazis and World War II and yada yada. But also Rick has this sort of flaw inside him, right? That he's got to fix at the end.

SPEAKER_00And if I gave you a story that lacked those external stakes, how would you coach me through adding them back in?

SPEAKER_01It's interesting. A lot of times what you're doing is you can set up a story that has like a personal external set of stakes. Um... So I'll just give you the example of Toy Story 5, which I helped out a little bit on. The initial conception of that was that, oh, it's Jesse lives in Bonnie's room and Bonnie's playing with all the toys. And then suddenly this device comes in and now Bonnie doesn't play with the toys anymore. She only plays with her lily pad device, basically.

SPEAKER_01And it's a problem, but it's only a problem within the So what happens is Jesse goes next door and sees these kids playing on a device and she's like, what are those kids doing? And another discarded toy goes, don't you know, like the age of toys is over. Kids don't play with toys anymore. Like it's an extension. And she's like, no, I don't believe you. I don't believe that that's true. And he goes, go, go up on the roof and take a look. And there's a scene where she climbs up on the roof and she looks down at all the houses in the neighborhood and every single house has a little And

SPEAKER_01then she looks around and she sees Bonnie's room, which has an orange light, and Bonnie is still playing with her toys. And you just go, oh, now you're taking what was at stake within Bonnie's room and making the stakes global. And going, like, if you're going to solve this problem, you can't just solve it for your individual hero. You've got to solve it for the whole universe you've created.

SPEAKER_00Earlier you were talking about how there's an implicit contract in a movie that the audience will give you 10 minutes or something. Is that still true in the Netflix day? And regardless, did Netflix and streaming services, did they change how movies need to be made?

SPEAKER_01I think that I've heard all these stories. I haven't worked for Netflix. I've heard all these stories about you need to kick it off. You need to start with action. You need to kick your story off as quickly as possible. And you got to keep reminding your audience what the movie's about because they're going to be looking at two other screens while they're watching Netflix. I'll just say that's not the business I'm in. Like I'm in the business of telling a good story. I just saw a video actually on YouTube where somebody was talking about inciting incidents. And this person's advice was you got to get to your inciting incident as quickly as possible, right?

SPEAKER_01You got to get your story kicked off as soon as possible. I think that's absolutely the wrong advice. I think that's terrible advice. And I think that that's a note that I hear over and over again, which is you got to get your story started and You gotta get your plot set in motion as quickly as possible so your audience will care. The note under the note of that is you gotta get your audience to care. You gotta get your audience to care about your hero. I will argue that there's a lot of great movies where you're just spending 20, 25 minutes Learning about your hero, learning about their world, learning about what they want, right?

SPEAKER_01And then the inciting incident is actually going to happen about 25 minutes into the story, and your hero's going to dither, dither, and then the first nap break comes on page 30. So you have a very short period of time between your You care about what's going to happen to them. So I think that this person, whose video I just saw, was mistaking creating action for getting your audience on board

SPEAKER_01with your character. I'll just give you the example of Tootsie. In Tootsie, the inciting incident is about 20, 22, 25 minutes into the film. It's, yeah, the character... He's an actor in New York. He doesn't want to be rich and famous. He doesn't want to be a star. He just wants to be a working actor in New York. That's all he wants, right? So what is the worst possible thing for that character? You just have him go to his agent and his agent says, Noah will hire you. Noah will hire you. You're too much of a pain in the ass. It doesn't matter if you don't want to be rich and famous. Like you, your dream of being an actor is over.

SPEAKER_01It's only like four minutes later that he's like, oh yeah, like I'm going to get hired. And he puts on a dress and a wig and he goes off and now he's an actor and you're into your second act. A lot of people feel like you need to get your story started right away. And I'm like, I think that's a mistake. If you're playing the long game and you want your story to be remembered, if you want your story to be one of the few stories that year that people are going to go back and rewatch, you want to tell a really great story. And I think part of how a real great story works is that, again,

SPEAKER_01you're just making your audience care and you're building a world with enough specificity and you're building your character with enough specificity that the problem that you're going to introduce... Let's say Andy's going to college, is going to hit them, your audience on a visceral level, and make them care about what happens to these toys. And I think part of the charm and just sort of the beauty of great storytelling is those opening 10 minutes where you're not sure what the story's about, you're not sure what's going on,

SPEAKER_01and you're asking all these questions that you're not answering right away.

SPEAKER_00Are there other things that are tropes, common ways of thinking in Hollywood that you just...

SPEAKER_01You know, the big thing is you lob the softball across the plate. I'm going to go for it. The big thing is when people say, oh, I'm just trying to create entertainment. I'm just trying to make an entertainment movie. That drives me crazy because I think that stories... In essence, have to have some meaning to them. The more meaning you can put in your story, the more relevant it's going to be on it, the more they're going to remember it. I think that there's a couple of ways you can create meaning in a story. There's, as we've talked about, the therapy model, right,

SPEAKER_01where something trauma happens to you, you respond in an unhealthy way, and then the rest of the story is getting over that unhealthy way of responding to trauma. It's just, you know, psychoanalysis 101. Another way of creating meaning is, and this is what I talk about in my video on endings, is that you're creating two competing value systems. And usually they're not equally weighted. Usually you have a dominant system of values in your story and you have an underdog. So I think like with Little Miss Sunshine,

SPEAKER_01what I talked about, I mean, this is why I wanted to write Little Miss Sunshine was we are in this culture, right? That sees life as a competition where like everything is divided between winners and losers, you know, and the, and the whole goal in life is to be a winner and avoid

SPEAKER_00being a loser.

SPEAKER_01A lot of times in a story, you're sending two trains at each other, or you're sending two competing value systems at each other that are going to collide at the climax of your story. And this is what my video on endings is really all about, is that you want it to seem, if you You want to create maximum emotion and maximum meaning at the end of your story. You want to make it seem like your hero has been defeated externally, defeated internally, emotionally, but also been defeated philosophically. That's a really crucial thing. You want it to seem like the villain was right.

SPEAKER_01The greed is good. That might makes right. I always love the moment in a movie where the villain turns the hero and goes like, listen, I'm sorry to burst your bubble. I'm not a bad guy. This is just the way the world works. Grow up. If you can flip things at the last moment, and it gets very complicated here, but if you can flip things so that you go from external, internal, and philosophical failure to external, internal, and philosophical success in 45 seconds or less, then that's what I call an insanely great ending.

SPEAKER_00Okay. So define those internal, external, philosophical. And then what I'm taking is the flip. They should happen as concurrently as possible. So then you just get the whole peniotic.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I think that I'll just try and make this very brief. Your external stakes are anything outside your hero in the world. You want to rob a bank. You want to get the million dollars. You want to blow up a bridge. You just want to do something in the outside world. And the crucial thing is that it's usually a binary pass fail thing. So you're either going to blow up the bridge or you're not going to blow up the bridge. You're either going to get a million dollars or you're not going to get a million dollars. You're either going to kill Hitler or not. You're going to kill Hitler or you're not going to kill Hitler. But you have a very clearly defined goal, you know. And in order to end the war, you got to kill Hitler. So your long-term goal is to end the war.

SPEAKER_00Your short-term plan is I'm going to go find Hitler and kill him.

SPEAKER_01Your internal stakes are the emotional stakes of your story, right? And it can be romantic love. It can be parent-child love. The example I use is in Rocky. He's trying to win his own self-respect. Like he sort of considers himself a bum in the neighborhood. You see this on the waterfront too, right? Like he's like, I could have been a contender, you know? So he's, he's losing his own self-respect and in the climax of the story, he gets his own self-respect back. And then the philosophical stakes of the story, this is where I feel like a lot of films or a lot of stories are not as clear

SPEAKER_01or articulate as they could be because a lot of times The way you're creating a meaning in a story is by pitting two competing value systems against each other and having it seem like the dominant values are going to prevail, you know, and just like the underdog values are going to get wiped. And then, you know, this is the trick of a good ending is having the underdog values prevail at the end.

SPEAKER_00I'm trying to figure out how to frame this question, but if you want people to feel emotions, you want them to laugh, you want them to cry, whatever it is, what is the line between Being too desperate. And like now you're being sentimental in a way that's annoying or just like trusting that it's going to show up. It's amazing. You really got to earn it. Like I noticed that with Little Miss Sunshine, it's funny. But in all these very subtle ways where I was laughing, but no one's laughing. But I'm like, that's a funny thing that's happening.

SPEAKER_00And it's this kind of subtle humor. It's a really tricky thing

SPEAKER_01in that, like, you know, the most deadly thing about a bad screenplay is that it feels contrived and I know exactly where it's going. So you've got to, you can't, the main thing is like either not overselling the humor or not overselling the emotion. A lot of it happens. I remember when I was writing the scene in Little Miss Sunshine where Dwayne has his freakout, right? And he gets out of the van and he runs down the hill and he turns to his family and goes, I hate you people. You're all fucking losers. I'm not getting back to you. And he goes, mom, just leave me here.

SPEAKER_01Just leave me here. You know, I don't want to, I don't want to be your family anymore. As a writer, you paint yourself in your corner, you go, oh God, how am I going to get out of this? I was like, okay, Olive walks down the hill. She's obviously got to be the one who, who, who convinces him to get in the van and go with them. And I remember writing the scene and go, okay, what does Olive say to Dwayne? And I was like, no, the best thing is that she says nothing. All right, you gotta tell me, what is it like to win an Oscar? It's just terrifying, basically. You feel like if you say something stupid or do something stupid, that's all you're gonna be remembered for for the rest of your life.

SPEAKER_01So I know a guy at Pixar who, Gary Riestrom, was the sound engineer. He worked with Spielberg, he worked with James Cameron. But he's won seven Oscars. And he said to me one time, he goes, you know, every single time they open up the envelope and I go, oh, God, not me. You know, because now you're going to have to get up on stage. You know, I'm a writer. I'm not an actor. Like, I don't want to be up in front of the camera. So you're just like, don't fuck up. Don't fuck up. Don't fuck up. Like the whole time you're walking up the stage, you're like, just don't fuck up. You know, and I had really memorized the speech because I didn't want to fuck up.

SPEAKER_01So so I actually I'll just tell you. When you go, when you're nominated, they really drill into your head. You get 45 seconds. That's it. Like we're cutting you off after 45 seconds. So like, you know, write down a speech and memorize it. So I wrote down a speech and then I was just working at Pixar. Every day I drove into Pixar, I would just recite the speech over and over again for like a month, basically. So when I finally got up on the stage, there could have been bombs going off in the theater and I would have just kept coping because I had just totally memorized the speech.

SPEAKER_00I like the way you talk about your dad, you know, with dad and spirit.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, yeah. No, my dad was, I mean, the whole thing of pushing the bus to get it started, that was, that came from my dad, that came from our real life. We, we had a VW bus when I was a kid and we were all up in Maine and the clutch broke and somebody told my dad, well, you can, you know, and my dad was I was like, I need to be at work, you know, like on Monday morning. You can go from second to third. Yeah, you can go from third to fourth without a clutch. But you need to start up in third gear. And the only way you can start up in third gear is to push the bus. And my dad was like, kids, get in the car. So, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01And that's the best part of writing is finding those things that happen to you in real life. Someone made a joke once that writing is taking the most painful, personal, humiliating moments of your life and turning them into money. Which is not quite what I did, but it's the essential insight is to take these like, you know, we had the horn used to get stuck on our VW bus. It's very embarrassing to drive around your hometown with a horn that gets stuck. So, but you put all that, it's amazing. You put all that into a movie and people just recognize it,

SPEAKER_01even if they haven't done it literally themselves.

SPEAKER_00So as you're writing a movie like that, did you kind of feel like, wow, I really got something here? Or was it? It actually was exactly

SPEAKER_01like that. I think that I had written five other scripts before that. And I think that my problem had been, A, I was making imitation. And B, I think I started with plot rather than characters. And Little Miss Sunshine was the first time that I started with characters rather than plot. My fear before I started writing it was It was such a slight story. It was so small. It's just a road trip. And I was like, oh, I'm going to write 65 pages, a 65 page script.

SPEAKER_01It's just going to be too short. But having that slight story allowed me to just have the characters talk. And once they started talking to each other, I was like, this is working. I can tell this is working. And I got halfway through and I called up my brother and I was like, this is it. I'm writing the script that's going to really work.

SPEAKER_00What did you learn from your brother about writing? Because he just came on a new book about writing, huh? Yes. Thank you for mentioning that. That was not a nudge for the plug at all.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, I was coming on this podcast and yesterday I was like, God, I wish I had something profound to say about the act of writing itself and how It occurred to me, I realized, oh, I actually have a brother who's a professor of literature and philosophy, and he wrote a book called The Philosophy of Writing. And like you go back to like Marcus Aurelius or Montaigne. They were writing to understand themselves. That's where Montaigne's essays come from. That's where the Marcus Realist's meditation comes from. And my brother's basic point is that writing is a sort of form of,

SPEAKER_01writing is a form of thinking and it's a way of thinking, you know, About yourself and figuring out sort of who you are and what you want to be. But I think that he actually talks about the act of writing as a sort of practice daily meditation on who you are and what you like. It's an investigation in what you really think. And it actually, reading that book, changed my perspective on writing itself because I used to think that you sit around and wait for an idea to come and then you write it down. And his perspective is that the act of writing itself is going to generate ideas

SPEAKER_01and make you figure out who you are.

SPEAKER_00I'll just say in a little Miss Sunshine, I thought that the Obi-Wan figure, the mentor,

SPEAKER_01And I figured that out like a year after the film came out. Like you often don't really know The meaning of the story that you're writing until like, you know, a year or two after the movie comes out and they go, oh, that's what it means. But I think that was a good example of me just like following my gut instinct and having things inexplicably turn out well.

SPEAKER_00How is AI going to change storytelling?

SPEAKER_01I'll give you a very practical answer, actually, which is right now a low budget film is circumscribed in time and space, especially space, because Because like a typical low budget film is like two or three characters and one location, right? Because you just don't have the budget for more than one location. Even when I got to Pixar, I remember I was like, hey, it's computer generated. We can do anything. And they're like, actually, no, like we actually have to build Every location in the movie, that costs money.

SPEAKER_01So like, you know, the fewer locations, the cheaper it's going to be. You're always trying to limit the locations that you have. I read that this new Doug Liman film, which is called Killing Satoshi, they shot it all. And they did it all in like 20 days. Like they did it really quickly, but you bring the actors into a gray stage and you capture the performance. Like it's real writing, like real human writing and real human acting, right? It's just there to capture the performance and then everything is filled in later

SPEAKER_01on, the lighting, the backgrounds, everything. But what that allows you to do, and one of the reasons they did it was because it had like, you know, 150 different locations. And so So to make that movie in practical terms with 150 locations, what AI is going to allow you to do, it's going to free up or it's going to change storytelling in that it's going to allow you to hopscotch through time and space very quickly. And it's going to liberate films from the financial concerns. I wrote Little Miss Sunshine because the first act is the dinner table.

SPEAKER_01The second act is a VW bus. And then, you know, the budget went up when I got to the third act, which was, you know, but it was essentially three locations. But now it's interesting that you are going to be able to do something like, let's just say, Alice in Wonderland. In every new scene, you can have a new location in it. And it just sort of frees you up. When I talk to people from Hollywood, they seem

SPEAKER_00so pessimistic and scared about AI.

SPEAKER_01You're not like that. What accounts are the difference? What are you seeing that Hollywood isn't seeing? I guess the basic thing is that I think AI is going to allow you to bring down costs significantly.

SPEAKER_01Films now are so expensive. We spend 90% of our time chasing a green light, trying to get a green light from the many people. And there's a ton of films that just don't get made because it becomes too expensive. And I think that, again, I don't want to adjudicate the legal issues. I don't want to adjudicate the labor issues. That animated film that won the Oscar two years ago, which is called Flow, was made in Latvia. I think the budget is like three and a half million dollars. It was an odd little story because it's about a dog and a cat on a raft in a world

SPEAKER_01that had flooded, right? I mean, you know, Pixar films cost $200, $250 million. But if you can reduce the cost, I think that, you know, there's a lot of people at Pixar who want to be directors. But if you have a $250 million movie, you can only make, only one guy gets to be a director. And I think that maybe a lot of those won't be great. But again, I think, you know, audiences...

SPEAKER_01Are thirsty for authenticity. I think they want to hear an authentic human voice and I think they want to see real people like up on the screen. But I think it's going to bring the cost down. And this is, you know, again, beyond the legal issues, beyond the labor issues. If you just look 5, 10, 15 years down the road, if it brings the cost of filmmaking down as dramatically as that, you're going to see an abundance of films, but you're also going to see abundance of creative freedom. What did you learn from the movie My Neighbors the Yamadas?

SPEAKER_01Oh, that's really, that's a great question. You know, I, I had the idea for Little Miss Sunshine in my head for like a long, long time, and I just hesitated to write it because it felt so uncomfortable. Like it's, it's like if you like had a lab experiment to come up with the least commercial idea, it's just like a fail, an ensemble picture about a family, like in a child beauty pageant. Like if I pitched that to Warner Brothers, they would laugh me like out of the office. And so I had a bunch of other ideas. I quit my job. I was unemployed at that time. Cause I quit my job to just spend like one year writing.

SPEAKER_01I'd give myself a year off. I'd saved up a little bit of money working as assistant on Godzilla. And, and I was going to spend that extra savings just on a year of writing. So I wrote like a bunch of other scripts first. And then I was kind of out of ideas and I just still had this like child beauty pageant idea in my head, but I was hesitating. And then it was in the summer of 2000 that the Museum of Modern Art I did a retrospective of Studio Ghibli, and I went there, and that was the first time I saw Totoro. I saw a double feature of Totoro and My Neighbors the Yamadas,

SPEAKER_01which was two blockbuster films, two of my favorite films of all time. What came out of that was My Neighbors the Yamadas is just about a typical Japanese family. They're not that special, but it's done with so much humor and warmth and empathy that That I thought, oh, like every family has a story to them. Every family has a bunch of great little moments that are going to be entertaining and that are going to engage you. But for me to go, I think this is going to be funny. I think I can write, I wanted to write a school comedy about a family. Like, I think I can do with this.

SPEAKER_01And so it was, but I wouldn't have done it without Iseo Takahata and My Neighbors the Amadas.

SPEAKER_00You talk about My Neighbors. You talk about Late Spring. What should storytellers in America be learning from Japanese films? Oh, my God.

SPEAKER_01That's such an interesting question. I think that what's interesting to me, and it sort of contradicts all my videos about screenwriting, are about hooking your audience, making things happen, getting people to care, having this propulsive sense of story momentum. The other side of storytelling, and this is what I love about Ozu, it's what I love about Miyazaki, is the gentleness of the storytelling. I recently watched the opening act of Totoro again, and nothing happens in it.

SPEAKER_01Almost nothing happens. Two little girls move into a house in the country. They go, they open all the shutters. They see those little bunnies, dust bunnies scurrying around. They meet the neighbors. But in terms of actual storytelling,

SPEAKER_00almost nothing happens.

SPEAKER_01A lot of times in Western storytelling, it's a competition of selfishness. It's like, I want this, but I want this, you know, and we're going to struggle to see who's going to get what they want. And it becomes this ego competition. And a romance can be like that or a friendship can be like that. And, you know, you put the friendship at stake or you put the romance at stake because it's competing selfish interests. This is what's great about Fate Spring, right? Is that the daughter is growing up, you know, she lives with her dad still. And at a certain point,

SPEAKER_01you know, an aunt shows up and says to the dad, you're being really selfish because you're keeping your daughter here at home. She's looking after you. You know, she says she loves you, but you need to, you know, she needs to go off and live her own life, you know, and you're being selfish by letting your daughter like stay here. You got to get her married so she can live her own life. And so he goes to his daughter and is like, okay, you need to get married. And she's like, no, I'm so happy being here with you. I couldn't be happier. I'm just going to stay here. That's all I want to do with my life. So she's being selfless, right? She's just like, I want to stay here and take care of you and look after you while you get older.

SPEAKER_01And he's being selfless because he's like, no, you need to go start your own life. And what's great in late spring, I don't want to ruin the ending because Which is one of the greatest endings of all time. It's such a, it's such a heartbreaking ending. And the final closing scene is the quietest. It's not a big bang. It's not, but it's, and so I think what we, what we learn is number one, sort of that you So it's actually this, it's an inversion of the Western model. You actually have this competing selflessness. How do you

SPEAKER_01Study a story. Thank you for asking this question. I have, I mean, again, I started off as a script reader. I read a gazillion stories. You know, when you get a story or you get a script that doesn't work, like, it's very easy to get confused. Like, it's very easy to go, I don't know how to make this better. You can also be very superficial. Like, I didn't care about your lead character. I lost interest. Those are all superficial no's, you know? And what I learned to do as a script reader and then subsequently as a script doctor now.

SPEAKER_00A script doctor. That's good. Yeah, yeah. No, that's what they call them. Tagline.

SPEAKER_01That's what they call them. Ruth Michael Art, the script doctor. Oh. I'm not the first. I'm not the first. People use that line all the time. You come in and you just give me a script. I'm going to, I feel like I'm almost like a story mechanic at this point. I'm going to put the whole thing up on blocks. I'm going to open up the hood. I'm going to go look at like the engine that's going on. There's a couple of questions to ask yourself. The first question is what is at stake in this story, right? That's what I find useful about breaking it down. Not just like what's externally at stake in the story. You want to go blow up the river Quai or you want to take out the guns of Navarone

SPEAKER_01or whatever it is. Uh, what's internally at stake in this story? Like it's not just Marlon going and saving Nemo's life. It's also winning his son's love and respect back. That's even more important, right? But then also asking what's philosophically at stake in the story, because that's going to really help you sharpen the meaning of your story. So if you can just go there and write down what's at stake in your story, that really helps to clarify what your story is about. You don't have to do it this way,

SPEAKER_01but almost as a thought exercise, A way to anchor your story is to get to the end of your story and go, now, what is the worst possible thing that could happen in all three sets of stakes? Well, let's do Finding Nemo. What's the worst thing that happened accidentally? Nemo gets killed, right? He promised his son, I will always take care of you, and then Nemo gets killed. The worst thing that could happen emotionally is that he never wins his son's love and respect back. He goes to save his son and his son like, fuck you, you ruined my life. And then philosophically, Marlon...

SPEAKER_01Always remains an overprotective parent. He never gives Nemo his independence. Nemo always has to stay under his thumb, right? And you could actually have an interesting bad ending of Finding Nemo where Marlon succeeds in protecting Nemo. He succeeds externally in saving his life, but he fails philosophically because he remains an overprotective parent, and therefore he fails emotionally because he doesn't win his son's love and respect back. A lot of times I feel like one of the ways to drill down to actually what is important in your story is to ask yourself,

SPEAKER_01what's the worst possible thing that could happen externally, internally, philosophically? And a lot of times what you're trying to do is make all those things happen at the same time. And if you can do that, you're having a true low moment. And I think that one of the things you, then sort of the magic of storytelling is if you can turn everything around and have everything go from the worst possible thing to the best possible thing of 45 seconds or less. That's all. That's why I made that video about endings. So, and then... Part two, I'm answering part two of your question, which is what else do you look at?

SPEAKER_01I'm a big believer. There's an organic logic to storytelling. And I will credit the screenwriter, David McGee pointed this out to me. He said, in screenwriting, we have this vocabulary. You have your opening, you introduce your hero, you introduce the world they live in, you have a stable sense of self, a stable sense of what the world is, and a fixed set of expectations for the future. Your inciting incident is the thing that comes along and disrupts all those things. Disrupts the future, disrupts your sense of self, disrupts your sense of what the world is. I'll just use Hamlet, for example. You meet Hamlet. He's dissatisfied,

SPEAKER_01Denmark is a prison, kind of upset that my dad died and my mother has just moved on, but what can I do about it? The inciting incident is the father's, the ghost of the dead father appears and goes, I didn't just die, I was murdered, you know, and now you got to go avenge my death. And then in the wake of your inciting incident, your hero a lot of times doesn't know what they want to do, right? They're sort of thrown into this, they're not sure either A, should they pursue a goal or B, how to pursue that goal. So Hamlet says, maybe this is a demon tempting me. Maybe Claudius is And I'll be able to tell.

SPEAKER_01So the vocabulary that we use in storytelling echoes or mirrors the classic vocabulary of storytelling, of fairy tales. So your opening is once upon a time. There was a person, there was a place, there was a daily routine, and there was a fixed set of expectations of the future. Once upon a time, there was a little girl who lived out of And every day she rode her horse and fed her horse and dreamed of being, you know, something. And then one day, someone or something arrived in her life and opened up some sort of opportunity.

SPEAKER_01So the vocabulary of fairy tales mirrors the vocabulary of storytelling in that your opening is your once upon a time. And then one day is your inciting incident. And therefore your hero embarked upon a journey like Hamlet. So the quest began. So the quest began. That's your first act. Suddenly, without warning, is kind of your midpoint. Something unexpected happens. Your second act break is, and then there was no going back. It's just like the Death Star is coming to blow up the Rebel Base. The Rebel Base is trying to blow up the Death Star, but they can't exist in equilibrium under One of them is going to survive and one

SPEAKER_01of them is going to get destroyed. So your second act break, I think people misunderstand what a second act break is. A second act break is not the worst possible thing happening to your hero. The second act break is actually forcing the stakes of your story to go. You're either getting a positive or negative, right? You're either going to get what you want. You're going to blow up the bridge or you're not going to blow up the bridge. You're either going to win this girl's love or you're going to fail to win this girl's love. Or you're going to win your dad's respect or you're not going to win your dad's respect. So your second act break is out of the frying pan into the fire but forcing the stakes of the story so that...

SPEAKER_01So that, and then, and then the climax is just the resolution, you know, and it doesn't always have to be positive. Why do you call it all or nothing? All or nothing. Why do you call it that? One of the problems in storytelling is having a muddy and fuzzy set of stakes. You know, your era's goal is to make the world a better place, you know, and the way he's going to do that is by spreading song everywhere, you know, like that's a vague and muddy goal. And there's, there's not a binary pass fail thing. So a lot of times what I'm doing is going like, how can we make Whatever the hero's goal is super specific

SPEAKER_01and how can we make their plan to achieve that goal super specific. When you come to me as a script doctor and go, how do you make this script better? I'm going to look at all those pressure points in the story. Those are the tempo moments where the direction of your story changes. Right. So once upon a time, your hero is living this life of steady sort of unsteady equilibrium. And then one day the direction of the story changes. Right. And so your hero embarked on a quest. The story direction changes again. The midpoint reversal happens. Story changes direction again. But I will go and look at each one of those temple moments and try

SPEAKER_01to sharpen them up and make them as distinct and powerful as they can be. And now I'm a big believer that you just want a clean trajectory from one temple moment to another. Hero's Journey, overrated or underrated? A little bit above, I'd say. I think that there's a way, obviously there's a gazillion stories and a gazillion movies. I should say that like a movie is not just an illustrated screenplay. Like a movie can be just an experience and it doesn't even have to tell a story. So like narrative is sort of the necessary evil that we have to do to like keep

SPEAKER_01the audience watching. But not all stories have to work that way. And not all stories have to be a hero's journey. And especially, I really strongly believe this, not every Every hero has to be flawed. Like your hero can essentially be innocent and the world outside them is flawed. And what your hero is doing is going and fixing what's wrong with the world. That's what happens in Star Wars. Luke is not a flawed character. The world itself is flawed and he goes and he blows up the Death Star. It's overrated if you think that's the only kind of story there is, but it's underrated in terms of like the power of the underlying principles,

SPEAKER_01which I, again, I think speak to just the organic logic of storytelling. I could be wrong about this, but I do feel like, again, you go back to fairy tales and the vocabulary of fairy tales. Stories are a way of thinking and making sense of our lives and especially adjudicating meaning and especially meaning between competing value systems and competing visions of how we should live our lives. We can either be the dude or we can be the Big Lebowski, right? But you can't be both and you've got to decide, do you want to be the Big Lebowski?

SPEAKER_01And just be all about achievement and making money and winning respect? Or do you want to be the dude who's just going to sort of float through life and take things as they come, but also be the kindest person in his universe because he has no ambition?

SPEAKER_00Last question. I come to you and say, Michael, Michael, I want to be a writer. I want to be a writer. I want to be a writer. Sit down, buy a cup of coffee. What do you tell me? Go watch all my videos on YouTube. I will say about your videos, if you like this and you want to get really technical and in the weeds, you want to see charts, diagrams, graphics, go watch Michael's videos.

SPEAKER_01They're all free and they're just the videos that I wish I had had when I started out. The number one thing I would counsel is... I remember when I started writing and I sort of made a commitment. It's like if I'm going to be a writer, I'll probably write a screenplay a year and I'm probably going to live for 50 more years. So I'm probably going to write 50 screenplays. And when I started out, I bought a book that had listed every major screenwriter in all their credits. And what was great about that book was it showed all the scripts

SPEAKER_01that they had written that got produced, but it also showed all their unproduced scripts. Right. And so it was really amazing that someone like William Goldman, who wrote Butch Cassidy and All the President's Men and The Princess Bride, three absolute like Hall of Famers, had a list of like 15 scripts that he had written that never got made into movies.

SPEAKER_00I was at Eric Roth's house. Same thing. He wrote Benjamin Button, won the Oscar for Forrest Gump. Forrest Gump, yeah. I couldn't believe how many unmade movies he had written.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. So I think the main thing is, And realistically, I remember thinking, well, I'm going to probably write 50 scripts in my life. And if I'm lucky, five of them will get made into movies. And if I'm lucky, one of them will be a good movie. And I think that having that realistic sense that, you know, if you're a startup founder, you're going to probably fail like six out of seven times, you know, and the seventh time it's going to do it. It's kind of the same with screenwriting. Like you're going to write, you know, I wrote 11 scripts before I sold my first script.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I And it's just like, you got to be patient. And I think my number one thing is you got to be humble. I'll just say when Kurosawa won his Oscar, you know, and he was at the end of his life, he made all these incredible films. They call him up, they give him an honorary Oscar. He gets up there, he's in his 80s and he stands up and he goes, I don't feel I could deserve this yet because I'm only beginning to understand movies now. And I'm like, if Kurosawa can be that humble about movies and storytelling, we should all be humble. And, uh, you had that, you mentioned to me that great quote from Billy Wilder.

SPEAKER_01Billy Wilder said like, he was talking about the audience. He goes, the audience individually, they're idiots. Collectively, they're a genius. And I think you have to respect the genius of the audience. The audience is smarter than you. The audience knows more about storytelling than you. The audience is going to be able to see through your little bag of tricks. And so I just think good storytelling is really, really hard and it takes a long, long time. I wrote a hundred drafts, a little bit of sunshine, you know, before it went into production. It just, so my, my main advice is it's a lifelong commitment.

SPEAKER_01It's a craft that you learn. It's the same with playing a musical instrument or learning to be a chef. There's just a craft and it's going to take you about 10 years. To learn that craft, but then also be humble because telling stories is one of the most difficult things to do and one of the most important things to do. And so to recognize that what you're trying to do is... So hard. And there's so many people trying to do the same thing, but it's also, it just requires almost masochistic degree of humility that you're always going to go, how can this be better?

SPEAKER_01How can this be better? And, uh, uh, but you got, you know, if you love stories and you love movies, it beats working for a living. You know, I guess that's what I would say.

SPEAKER_00I mean, it's amazing, right? You think of the Odyssey, you think of the Epic of Gilgamesh, you think of all these, what do we know about so many of these cultures? Nothing. But then we know their stories.

SPEAKER_01Stories have lasted longer than like the oldest cathedral. You know, the Epic of Gilgamesh is what, like 3,000 years old or something like that? Yeah, stories, like a good story. Is going to last frickin' forever. And it will be this enduring monument to, like, after the cities are dead and buried, and after, like, you know, the Great Pyramids have fallen, like, there will still be Shakespeare, you know, when you're out on... The Crab Nebula or something like that. And so stories are actually the most enduring artifact of human culture.

SPEAKER_01And they're the most important artifact. The way we make sense of our lives, the stories we tell of ourselves about our own lives makes I think my brother in his book, he says, we all live in darkness. We all actually don't know how to live. We actually don't know who we are. We don't know who you are individually or as human beings. Are humans selfish or are they altruistic? And stories are a way of figuring that stuff out. So stories, not something ancillary to our existence.

SPEAKER_01Stories are existence. Stories are how we... Stories are really important. If you want to be a storyteller, God bless you, but be humble because it's really, it took me, again, I wrote 11 scripts before I sold my first one.

SPEAKER_00Good stuff. Great to meet you, man. And your YouTube channel?

SPEAKER_01You can just Google Michael Lawrence Screenwriting Videos. And I also have a website. The name of my company is Pandemonium Inc., I-N-C. So you can just go to pandemoniuminc.com. There's my script. My scripts are there. My videos are there. I have a list of 17 books that I've read that really changed the way I think about the world. So it's my list of top books to read. I have a mock-up of a four-page outline. So this is how I organize stories. Any job I do, I'm going to do a four-page outline of it. That's mocked up on my website.

SPEAKER_01And I also, every time I hand in a script for feedback, I have a little reader questionnaire that I give to anyone who reads my scripts. So there's a mock-up of a I'm going to read your questionnaire. So there's a bunch of, not just the videos, there's a bunch of little tools, screenwriting tools on my website, pandemoniuminc.com. Thanks, Michael. Thanks so much.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. V.E. Schwab: The Architecture of Great Writing

    Nov 18, 20261 hr 32 minAudio

    I want to learn more about who’s listening to How I Write. What kind of writing do you do? What do you like about the show, and how can I make it better? Who do you want me to interview? So I threw together a little...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Elizabeth Gilbert: This is What 40 Years of Writing Discipline Looks Like

    Nov 11, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    I want to learn more about who’s listening to How I Write. What kind of writing do you do? What do you like about the show, and how can I make it better? Who do you want me to interview? So I threw together a little...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Malcolm Gladwell: The Most Useful Hour You'll Ever Spend on Storytelling

    Nov 4, 202658 minAudio

    Big thanks to Alpha School for being the presenting sponsor of this episode. When I was in school, I constantly found myself thinking: “We can do so much better than this.” Alpha School is what I wish existed back then....

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Gillian Flynn: How to Write Thrilling Stories

    Oct 28, 20261 hr 22 minAudio

    Big thanks to Alpha School for being the presenting sponsor of this episode. When I was in school, I constantly found myself thinking: “We can do so much better than this.” Alpha School is what I wish existed back then....

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Dean Koontz: This is What Mystical Writing Feels Like

    Oct 21, 20261 hr 13 minAudio

    Big thanks to Alpha School for being the presenting sponsor of this episode. When I was in school, I constantly found myself thinking: “We can do so much better than this.” Alpha School is what I wish existed back then....

    Credit the people on this episode