This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.stevevladeck.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Tonight we're here to talk with you about the Supreme Court's little gloss on Trump's executive order. What did they call it in their opinion? Wait a second. I need to actually quote this for y'all. They say, President Trump issued an executive order designed to maintain public confidence in federal elections. Now, those of you who read civil discourse know that that's not exactly how I see this executive order. Steve, what about you, friend?
SPEAKER_00Not so much, no. And one of the really, I think, aggravating things about all this litigation the administration simultaneously claiming that they're going to increase election integrity, but that the order doesn't actually do anything. Therefore, there's nothing to worry about here. It seems like you can't really have it both ways, especially as I know we're going to talk about after what happened on Friday night.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, it's sort of crazy, right? Because what they've done is, and I've written about this, Steve's written about this, they've shot the ripeness argument all to hell because the government's been arguing all along here that this situation is not ripe for a judicial decision because the government has taken insufficient steps to implement the executive order. But now we know that they've got something ready to publish in the Federal Register on Wednesday and It's important, I think, here for us to parse the cases,
SPEAKER_01by the way, that we are talking about, because there are two cases in front of Judge Indira Talwani in Boston. There is the League of Women Voters case. There is the state attorney's general case. So just to set the table a little bit. We're going to talk right now about the order that the Supreme Court has just issued in the attorney's general case. And that does not touch the nationwide injunction that Judge Talwani has issued for the League of Women Voters. But before we get too far into the weeds, Steve, help me set the table.
SPEAKER_01What else should we share with people?
SPEAKER_00I think it's exactly right, Joyce, to keep folks focused on the fact that there are two different cases that the Supreme Court's order this afternoon is only about one of them, that way too many media outlets ran with headlines that the court had cleared the way for President Trump's executive order to go into effect. That is not true, but it takes a little bit of explanation to see why. But also, Joyce, I think you and I agree the real fight is yet to come. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Most concerned it would say, but I think still purports to exert control over mail-in ballots in a way that I think is unlawful. And that hasn't been decided yet, right? Like what the Supreme Court really said today is in this one case over here, the blue states sued too early, which I think is dumb, stupid and wrong, but is also not a reason for us all to go jump off a cliff. Exactly. That's the key.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, that's the ripeness doctrine that we've been talking about at Civil Discourse, this notion that the case isn't ripe for the judge to decide yet, that the issues have to settle a little bit more. That's a doctrine of longstanding. Steve and I may not And frankly, Judge Tawani also said, at least as to elections after the midterms,
SPEAKER_01Not yet right.
SPEAKER_00Her order, her injunction only
SPEAKER_01applies to the midterm elections. So everybody, including the Supreme Court, is leaving what happens later on for down the road. Steve, let's start just with this decision we've gotten from the Supreme Court. It's per curing. There are two dissents, Justice Sotomayor, Justice Jackson. Does that mean that we know what the votes are? Is this 7-2 or explain this from the point of view of a Supreme Court expert?
SPEAKER_00So we know there are three dissenting justices because Justice Kagan joined Justice Sotomayor's dissent. A lot of outlets are reporting that that means it's six to three. It probably does, but we don't actually know that for a fact because one of the many, many annoying things about the Supreme Court's emergency docket is that unless you can use the process of elimination to count to nine, You don't know where everybody is the way that you do in a merits case. So, Joyce, I, you know, if you and I were betting— There should be
SPEAKER_01another vote there, right?
SPEAKER_00I doubt it, but, like, you know, I try to be careful. And so I usually talk about the number of public dissents in these cases as opposed to what the actual vote count was. But I think, I mean, you mentioned ripeness, and I think that, like, you know, I know your readers are Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And so the blue states were genuinely worried about like when is too early, when is too late to bring the lawsuit. Come on.
SPEAKER_01Did you know Purcell only applies when Republican votes are at stake, not when it's Democratic people's right to vote?
SPEAKER_00I like to at least indulge the possibility that there are neutral principles going on in these cases.
SPEAKER_01Even after Calais, are you willing to indulge that? I mean, you know me, I'm usually pretty neutral on stuff like this. I sort of lost good faith with the court after Calais.
SPEAKER_00I wrote in my book, I think that the election cases are the court at its worst and that for reasons that are both deeply human and also deeply exasperating, that when it comes to elections, you tend to see the least principled decisions out of the Supreme Court on the merits docket choice or on the emergency. It's a lot of motivated reasoning. But, right, but... Imagine a world in which the USPS rule, when it was finally issued, didn't do any of the things that the states had hypothesized it would
SPEAKER_00in their complaint, right? It doesn't strike me as insane. Right. Right. Right. Right. Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01It's just not a function for them. And there is, look, let's give the Supreme Court its due, because I think we should do that, the heart of their reason that they will not indulge the injunction further. I mean, there are other arguments that they toss for the government, but really what they're saying is it's a combination of ripeness and standing. And they also say that the attorneys general lack standing.
SPEAKER_00They did. And I think those two things, Joyce, are related because the argument that the court made was that until we actually see the rule and until we actually understand how this is going to work in practice, what these states are worried about is hypothetical. And we don't allow lawsuits based on hypotheticals, which, you know, as a neutral principle is usually true. And so I think, again, what I find maddening, and I wrote a post about this for my newsletter a couple hours ago,
SPEAKER_00what I find maddening about all of this isn't any of this in the abstract. It's that we have a final rule now. The thing that made these cases, the condition that made these cases premature is no longer present.
SPEAKER_01I don't think it's snarky, by the way, to put this in the context of what's going on in Nevada and other states where DHS has been claiming tons of people who aren't citizens are voting. And then it turns out in the case of Nevada, which is now very clear, where the state's election officials push for more data on that, it turned out DHS was forced to walk it back. It wasn't tens of thousands of people. It wasn't even a couple of hundred people. They couldn't even come up with names. These are the people that under Trump's executive order are going
SPEAKER_01to write these lists of eligible voters, which I think boggles the mind beyond belief. But let's talk about the technical issues here, because we're talking now about the Supreme Court's decision in the Attorney General's case. The Supreme Court has said, we don't think That the challengers will succeed. We think that the government will succeed because there's a lack of standing and a lack of rightness. But we've also got this injunction in the League of Women Voters case.
SPEAKER_01Does the analysis that the Supreme Court is applying in the Attorney's General case apply to the League of Women Voters case? I mean, I'll just say, I don't think it does. What do you think?
SPEAKER_00So it certainly doesn't directly. And indeed, it's worth noting that the Supreme Court did not do what the Solicitor General had asked. The Solicitor General had specifically asked the court to actually reach and decide the substantive issues presented in the application so that whatever the court said would bind Judge Talwani in the League of Women Voters case. All the court said, right, was the government's likely to succeed on ripeness, the government's likely to succeed on standing, and also there's irreparable harm.
SPEAKER_00Two of those won't apply at all to the League of Women Voters case. Those are different plaintiffs. They have different concerns about the injuries. Their injuries accrue at different times and in different ways. And Joyce, in any event, their injuries are now ripe because of the USPS final rule.
SPEAKER_01And I think that's also lawyer talk for saying they have a better standing argument, or at least a different standing argument than the attorney.
SPEAKER_00Right. Right. Right. To just give such superficial, unpersuasive,
SPEAKER_00knee-jerk consideration to the Trump administration when it comes to irreparable harm. And so what that tells me is that on the irreparable harm piece, the government's going to have a thumb on its scale when the League of Women Voters case gets to the Supreme Court. But I don't think anything else in today's ruling prejudges the League of Women Voters case, Joyce, especially because— By as early as tomorrow morning,
SPEAKER_00we expect Judge Talwani to block the final rule itself, right?
SPEAKER_01The government has until 8 a.m. tomorrow morning to respond. Judge Talwani has said she'll rule before the Wednesday deadline for this to go into the federal register. So it's now, you know, Judge Talwani versus the Roberts court. I like her a lot. My money's on her. Unfortunately, she doesn't get to have a 10th vote. I guess this is one of those nights where we've got to just make bad jokes so that we don't cry. But look, here's the question that I really wanted to ask you, Steve.
SPEAKER_01Why is the Supreme Court willing to change the election rules so close to the election? We are under the three-month mark. The Motor Voter Act says that states can't even change individual voters' eligibility this close to The Supreme Court is going to let the Trump administration—and remember, there's this whole constitutional thing at work, right, where it states, not the feds who run elections—they're going to let this unreliable executive decide who is and who isn't eligible.
SPEAKER_01They're going to do it right on top of an election where there's not time to correct the list. I mean, what the hell is wrong with John Roberts and his majority?
SPEAKER_00It's a good question. I have been trying to figure out the answer for a while, and I haven't got it yet. I think a couple of different things are going on, Joyce. President Trump won election or re-election in 2024, has always gone out of its way to, as you mentioned earlier, issue rulings in election cases that have the remarkable tendency of benefiting Republicans and harming Democrats.
SPEAKER_00And many of those rulings, although not today's, are often even totally unexplained. So that was already there. I think the other part of this, and this I think also dovetails with the ballroom case, is that the court is, or at least the conservative justices, the Republican appointees, are basically acting as if we're living in normal times. And so they're rigidly applying procedural requirements for plaintiffs to challenge the executive branch. They're relying on standing. They are overstating irreparable harm.
SPEAKER_00Whether they're doing that because they actually believe the administration's right on the merits in these cases or whether they're doing that choice to minimize the number of head-on confrontations between the Supreme Court and the Trump administration, I think probably depends on which justice we're talking about and in which case. But my real concern is that I don't think I'm very worried.
SPEAKER_00That there would be five votes to say, oh, well, it's too close to the election because one of the stupidest things about the Purcell principle is that it disempowers lower courts from acting in the run-up to an election, but it doesn't disempower the underlying government actors, even though the whole theory behind Purcell is supposed to be minimizing disruption in the electoral process.
SPEAKER_01Look, Chris Hill was always the misbegotten bastard child of a court that wanted to screw with elections. Apparently, I have no filters tonight, y'all. I apologize. Steve, I see that we have a question from George Conway. George has entered the chat with, I assume that this is a rhetorical question. George, I also note for the record that your autocorrect does the same thing that mine does, turning the word rule, R-U-L-E, into Ruhle, R-U-H-L-E, our friend Stephanie Ruhle's last name, which my autocorrect does that constantly.
SPEAKER_01But Steve, let me read you George's question and see if you want to react to it, or maybe we'll just blow him off. But here's the question. Are the state plaintiffs precluded from supplementing their complaint to seek relief against the new USPS rule and then seek There's an appellate lawyer for you. Is that a plan?
SPEAKER_00So they're not precluded at all. And, you know, I think the short answer is I'm sure they will do that. The reality is it's not going to matter because the League of Women Voter case is now going to be first. It's, you know, it's the same judge, right? It's Judge Talwani. It's the same question, which is whether the plaintiffs are entitled to an injunction against the rule itself, Joyce, and not just against the executive order. And I think the reality is that... We will be back in the Supreme Court,
SPEAKER_00perhaps as early as the end of this week or early next week, because what I think is going to happen is Taiwanese will block the USPS rule, the Trump administration will go to the First Circuit, the First Circuit will deny a stay, and the Trump administration will go right back to the Supreme Court. And at that point, you know, then I think we've then the battle is joined. Right. And I think that's why if it's just about the merits, I think the Trump administration loses at that point.
SPEAKER_00If Purcell rears its ugly misbegotten head, I'm nervous. And I think that's that's what animated and motivated the states to try to sue so early here because they were worried about Purcell and they were right to be.
SPEAKER_01And I mean, this is what's so difficult here is that we have a court that's not behaving in predictable ways you would expect it to behave in. And yet I think that there are two glimmers of hope here or at least two glimmers of hope. Oh, Steve, you're joined.
SPEAKER_00Three glimmers of hope. Here's my eight year old.
SPEAKER_01But a future American voter, so that's always good. Look, I think we've got at least three glimmers of hope here, and I hope that I've not forgotten what they are because your daughter is so adorable. But one of those glimmers of hope is that the cases are different, that in the League of Women Voters case, there are American citizens across the country who are plaintiffs, and that may change the calculus, right? Right. One is that the court may actually respond to public outrage, and at some point it does get too close to the election.
SPEAKER_01And then there's maybe a third glimmer of hope, and that's all of us, right? This is about mail-in voting. Nothing that's happening with this executive order precludes our ability to go out and vote in person or Night, Bob. Night, Bob. Night, Bob. Night, Bob.
SPEAKER_00I guess what I would say is I suspect that when all is said and done, the ultimate impact of all of this will be relatively marginal. That even if some of the rule goes into effect, people are going to be especially careful about how they vote and when they vote and to make sure that their votes are delivered by the Postal Service and if not, to make other, outside of Oregon anyway, to make other arrangements to vote. So I think The direct impact, even if things go sideways here, is marginal.
SPEAKER_00The problem is the message and the optics and the symbolism, which is the Supreme Court should not be enabling a president, any president. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, totally agree with all of that. I'm so grateful that you made time to have this conversation tonight. Most of you know we were scheduled to talk about these cases tomorrow morning. Steve, when we get a substantive decision, will you come back? Because I tend to think that you're right. The Constitution is pretty clear on this stuff. If the Supreme Court finds some way to say that the president can now run elections, then, my friend, we're going to need to have a longer conversation. But hopefully we won't end up there.
SPEAKER_00So I will come back, Joyce, whenever you ask, but I'll just say really quickly so that maybe we leave on a bit of a dose of optimism. The Supreme Court is never going to actually say that this is legal. What I'm worried about most is the court saying that this particular And so, you know, for as apocalyptic as so many of the headlines were today, I think it's important for all of us to be,
SPEAKER_00you know, nuanced in how we talk about these questions so that if and when the Supreme Court actually really does jump the shark, you know, we'll be able to call it for what it is.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think that's great advice. Y'all, you can go back through Steve's columns. You can go back through my columns. I may try to put some links together tonight and track from the origin of this executive order, the different lawsuits, the rulings. The clear thread, though, is what's in the United States Constitution, and it does not give the president the authority to run elections. So thank you to all of you for spending time with us. This is a great week to get out and get people to register to vote.
SPEAKER_01Friday is the anniversary of the March on Washington, a wonderful time to help people register to vote and come up with a plan, maybe a plan that doesn't include
SPEAKER_00mail-in voting, just to be safe.
SPEAKER_01Steve, thanks. Give your daughter a kiss for me. She was the best addition to a Substack Live I've seen in a long time. And thank you so much to all of y'all for being with us. Everyone have a great night.
As I noted in Monday’s post, the Harvard Law Review’s annual Supreme Court issue, including my Foreword - “The Court Against the Courts” - came out last week. On Thursday, November 20, I sat down with Harvard law...
In this episode of “First One,” the (fairly irregular) podcast companion to the “One First” newsletter, Steve sat down with Karen Vladeck (a lawyer-turned-legal recruiter and the founder and managing director of...
On Tuesday morning, Cristian Farias and I got together for a quick Substack Live to discuss the goings-on in the Missouri redistricting case - including what happened in the Eighth Circuit on Monday and what’s likely to...