Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

First One

First One artwork

First One: A Run on the Bank—Why Weil Fell

Nov 10, 202640 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this episode of “First One,” the (fairly irregular) podcast companion to the “One First” newsletter, Steve sat down with Karen Vladeck (a lawyer-turned-legal recruiter and the founder and managing director of Risepoint Search Partners, which moves partners and associates between firms) and Jonah Perlin (Steve’s Georgetown Law colleague, the host of the How I Lawyer podcast, and a close watcher of the legal market). Together, they explain the sudden collapse of Weil, Gotshal & Manges. A law firm’s collapse may seem like an odd subject for a “One First” podcast, but it affects the whole legal community - and has lessons that may well be relevant to non-lawyers, as well. The conversation opens with how fast it all happened. As Karen notes, Risepoint had placed two lawyers at Weil in the 90 days before the collapse, and another candidate received a Weil offer just two weeks before it. Jonah had a former student due to start there within weeks, and some lawyers started the very week the firm fell. Jonah also makes the case that this “overnight” collapse was decades in the making. Since 2008, Weil’s profits per partner had grown at about half the rate of its competitors’. From there, the episode traces Weil’s history. Three Jewish lawyers founded the firm in 1931, when many Jews couldn’t practice at the white-shoe Wall Street firms, and it became an elite New York institution. Marty Ginsburg led its tax group for many years, and the firm later expanded to Washington and then abroad. Its signature practice was, ironically, restructuring and bankruptcy. Weil represented the debtors in six of the ten largest U.S. bankruptcies, including Enron, GM, and Lehman Brothers. The firm ranked 29th on the 2025 AmLaw 100, with roughly $2 billion in revenue and about 1,200 lawyers. No firm of that size has collapsed since the rankings began. Next, the episode looks at how BigLaw itself has changed. Steve notes that lawyers and whole practice groups now move between elite firms far more often than they did 20 years ago. Jonah compares this to NIL and the transfer portal in college sports, with one big difference. When law firm “players” leave, the “fans,” meaning the clients, go with them. Karen adds some nuance. Some firms still have institutional clients who stay no matter who leaves. And homegrown firms like Wachtell, Susman Godfrey, and Kellogg Hansen have thrived with little or no lateral hiring. In her view, Weil’s problem wasn’t slow lateral hiring as such. The problem was that its main competitors, including Kirkland, Davis Polk, and Cravath, were hiring laterals heavily. The heart of the episode walks through what press reports say happened, with the caveat that none of us were in the room. Jonah frames it as a run on the bank in three steps. First, in September, a longtime corporate partner who reportedly ran the corporate group as his “fiefdom” left for Cravath with a team. Second, reported merger talks with Willkie Farr went nowhere. Third, the longtime chairman’s chosen successor reportedly decided she didn’t want the job, which Jonah calls the straw that broke the camel’s back. Karen points out how puzzling the timing was. Partners were still arriving, including one who started the Monday before the collapse, and to many people the moves looked like normal turnover. Building on Matt Levine’s “Money Stuff” column (Steve can’t resist pointing out that Matt was a law school classmate), the guests discuss how shifting perceptions can drive a run even when the money is still there. That leads to one of the episode’s central points: Weil isn’t Dewey. Dewey had made risky bets and was insolvent. Weil isn’t. It’s paying its employees for 90 days and offering stay bonuses through January 15 to wind down client work. So why did Weil wind down when other firms survive similar comings and goings? Jonah points to its long lag in profits per partner, which makes it harder to attract and keep top talent. Karen points to governance. Two people reportedly dominated the executive committee, and one of them had left. Ordinary partners didn’t have enough information, and they learned of the wind-down only after the executive committee had already voted. Her warning to firm leaders is blunt. If a tiny group runs a big firm, even a $2 billion firm can fail when that group cracks. Steve then raises a question closer to the usual subject matter of “One First”: Firms have faced threats from the government and some have given in. Could Weil’s collapse leave other firms even easier to intimidate? Jonah argues they were already in that position. When firms are just loose collections of lawyers with their own books of business, they go into “save yourself” mode, and that shaped how some responded to the executive orders. He points to John Morley’s work on how law firms die, which he says plays out the Weil story almost exactly. The episode then turns to the lessons to be learned from Weil’s collapse. Karen argues for real succession planning. She notes reports that the longtime chairman had hit the firm’s mandatory retirement age of 68, and she urges term limits for leaders, younger voices, and broader representation on executive committees. Jonah warns that if every partner becomes a free agent, the model that let BigLaw grow faster than almost any other industry can’t survive. He predicts a “barbell” market. At one end are mega-merged firms that provide back-office support while partners “eat what they kill.” At the other end are smaller firms. His advice to law students is a reversal of what he used to say: pick people, practice groups, and the ability to bring clients with you, not firm names. The episode also covers what’s happening to Weil’s lawyers now. Karen says she has never seen other firms scramble like this for talent. Gibson Dunn has reportedly taken about 100 finance lawyers, Davis Polk is reportedly taking a large litigation group, and the would-be successor is rumored to be in talks with Kirkland. Many partners are getting raises. Mid-level associates are seeing signing bonuses and guaranteed bonuses not seen since 2021, and one candidate got an offer within about 12 hours. Karen’s biggest concern is for incoming first-years and roughly 100 future summer associates. She offers them encouragement through the story of a friend who didn’t get a Weil offer in 2008 and went on to build a thriving bankruptcy practice. Jonah gets the last word on the bigger picture. For Weil’s own lawyers, he thinks the collapse may not be a big deal overall. Andrew Granato’s 2023 study found that former Dewey associates made partner at about the same rate as associates from other firms. For the industry, though, he calls it “massive.” He rejects claims that AI caused the collapse, but sees AI as one of several forces reshaping legal practice. If a behemoth like Weil wasn’t too big to fail, any firm that loses its lawyers’ confidence could fail. His closing thought is that firms must build better structures, training, and retention rather than lean on their founders’ legacy. And he suspects many firms, like Weil, would rather “die prestigious” than survive below the AmLaw 100. We hope you find this episode of “First One” interesting, and we (especially Steve) would welcome ideas for topics to explore (and guests to explore them with) in future episodes. If you’re not already a subscriber to “One First,” please consider becoming one: Either way, we’ll be back Thursday with our regular “bonus” issue - this one celebrating the fourth(!) anniversary of this whole enterprise, which officially hits tomorrow (Wednesday, November 11). Stay safe out there. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.stevevladeck.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Hey, everybody. It's Steve Vladeck. Welcome back to First One, the fairly irregular podcast companion to the One First newsletter. It is Friday, November 6, 2026, and I'm really excited to be doing this episode with two of my favorite people. Favorite person number one, wife, you want to say hi?

SPEAKER_02Hi, everybody. Karen Vladeck here.

SPEAKER_00And what do you do?

SPEAKER_02Oh, we're going straight into intros?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02No, you got to say like purpose of the pod, say who our other guest is. Now everybody's waiting on the edge of their seat. They don't know who it is.

SPEAKER_00I thought that we were doing intros first, but okay.

SPEAKER_02Well, if you had done or run a show, we would have known, Steve.

SPEAKER_00Yes. You know, I was twiddling my thumbs all week. So the reason why we're here with our dear friend, Jonah Perlin, who I'm going to introduce in a second, but just so we've removed the suspense, is because we actually have been wanting for really about a week and a half now to talk about the collapse of Weil Gottschall, the mega law firm. And You know, that seems like sort of a bit of an unusual topic for a One First type of podcast. But actually, I think it has real reverberations for the whole legal community. And so I wanted to talk to the two people I know who understand the law firm universe the best.

SPEAKER_00But when they weren't available, I went with the folks who are closer to home. So, Karen, who is the founder and managing director of RisePoint Search Partners, and my Georgetown Law colleague, Jonah Perlin, who in addition to being a full-time law professor and the impresario behind the How I Lawyer podcast, is also, I think, a real close watcher of the legal market. So, hello to you both.

SPEAKER_02Hello, Steve. See, we don't even have to do our bios now.

SPEAKER_01This is great. I love it. Thanks for having me. It's always nice to be able to hang out at your date nights.

SPEAKER_02It's 10 a.m., everybody, just so you know.

SPEAKER_00In our life, we call that date, it's just a date, right? Right after this, we're going to go see the Elizabeth Holmes documentary.

SPEAKER_02Oh, we should do that. That'd be fun. No, this is great. I'm in.

SPEAKER_01Thanks for the invite.

SPEAKER_02Also, I just want to say it was very funny because basically, and we'll talk about throughout this podcast how quickly this all unfolded. But, you know, usually Steve is the one who says to me, like, hey, have you seen the news? And in my world, this is all we were thinking about for a long period of time. And I said to Steve, like, how crazy is this? And he actually didn't know what I was talking about, which I think is kind of was the impetus for this podcast, right? Because there's so many people who follow legal scholarship and legal news so closely, but really were not dialed in to what was going

SPEAKER_02on in this particular instance. So- Just to give a tiny bit more background about myself, I am a legal recruiter, lawyer-turned-legal recruiter, who recruits partners from one law firm to another, essentially, for a living. And we have a team that also recruits associates. And Weil had been a very long-time client of RisePoint.

SPEAKER_00So much so... You might say that they've been a client for a while.

SPEAKER_02I said you get one punt. You get one Weil pun and that was it. So good job. One of the things that I think we should talk about a little bit later on in the podcast, but just to give you a preview, the reason that this was so crazy was how quickly it went down and that we had placed two people at Weil in the 90 days prior to the collapse, meaning two lawyers had started at Weil. And two weeks before the collapse, we had a lawyer get an offer there.

SPEAKER_02So this is why in our world, it's so crazy. Jonah, what's your sort of initial, this was so crazy moment before we dive into what happened?

SPEAKER_01Sure. So what I think is really interesting, and this is like one of those classic stories where an overnight thing that happened actually took 20 years or arguably 80 years to happen. But it looks like from the outside, as you said, Karen, right? Like I have a student, a former student who was scheduled to start there in a couple of weeks. They had people on LinkedIn I saw who had literally started the very week that they collapsed. But at the same time, right, that collapse, a lot of the indicators are quite old and quite clear in retrospect,

SPEAKER_01which is what I think is really interesting, right? 95 year old law firm. One of the biggest in the game, but also, and we can talk about the details, but one data point that I think is interesting is if you go back to 2008, so 2008 to the present, they were growing at about half the rate of most of their competitors in terms of profits per partner. So that's an almost 20-year variable, but then it collapsed overnight.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. So let's talk about the history. So as you said, it was founded in 1931. Yeah. At a time where a lot of Jews were not permitted to practice in more of the mainstream white shoe Wall Street firms. And so three Jews formed Weil Gottschall and it became... A very elite New York City law firm. You know, Marty Ginsburg, Ruth Bader Ginsburg's husband, was the head of the tax group there for many, many, many years.

SPEAKER_02It starts to expand in the 1970s when they opened a Washington, D.C. office. And then in the 90s and early 2000s, it opens internationally. Ironically, the signature practice of Weil for many, many years was its restructuring and bankruptcy practice. And It represented the debtors, meaning the folks filing for bankruptcy or restructuring in six of the 10 largest U.S. bankruptcies ever in the history of the U.S. bankruptcy system.

SPEAKER_02And so, you know, we're talking it represented Enron, it represented GM, it represented Lehman Brothers. And so to have a firm that was so dialed into what causes collapse of companies from the macro perspective is really crazy to see where we are now. One of the things, just more on background of it, one of the ways that the legal industry measures, I don't want to use the word success because I don't think success is the right word here, but sort of measures profitability and prestige is a ranking

SPEAKER_02that we refer to as the AMLAW. It is short for the American Lawyer, which is a magazine I wouldn't call it, it's not a trade association, it's like literally a magazine about the practice of law in the US. And it comes out with these prestige rankings every year, one of which is its revenue ranker, right? So Weil was ranked in 2025 as number 29 on the AMLA 100 firms.

SPEAKER_02It had $2 billion in revenue. And so when we're talking about whether Weil is a quote unquote small firm, the answer is absolutely not. It's one of the top 30 biggest firms in America. It had 1200 lawyers, 1000 legal professionals. And so just to set the stage for people who are not lawyers, this is so monumental because we have not seen a firm of this size collapse. Really almost ever in our modern day legal system since the AMLA has been ranking firms.

SPEAKER_02So I wanna start with that.

SPEAKER_00Steve, go ahead. I guess I wanted to ask both of you a question because My understanding as someone who is far more of an observer of these developments than both of you is that there's been a real shift in the last 20 years in the volume of lateral movement, especially among elite law firms, however you're going to define that term. And, you know, when I was in law school, those many, many eons ago, right, like,

SPEAKER_00I think it was still the norm that folks would go to one firm and that would be their career. And my sense is that part of how we got here is that it's much more common today for individual lawyers or for entire groups to move from one big firm to another than it was 20 years ago. Is that right? And do you have thoughts on, if so, why that's happened?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, I'll just jump in. I think the example, and this may be too simplistic for those that are familiar with this, but I'm sure there are a lot of people who are listening and saying, I don't really totally understand what that means. This is basically NIL, what we're seeing in college sports for lawyers. So the idea is in the old version of all of this, and if you're not a sports fan, maybe that's another reference that's hard, right? The old version of this was when people would go to interview for law firms. So they'd be a 1L or a 2L at a big firm, and they really wanted to get the job.

SPEAKER_01And the partner asked you, where do you see yourself? What do you want to do? The answer was to be your partner. That was such a cliche answer, but it was a way of showing that where you start is where you spend your career. You build your partnership, everything's set up, and the brand belonged to the firm. As you mentioned, Steve, and I want to hear Karen's take because she does this much more than I do, right? Especially over the last couple of years, and it's happening for partners, it's happening for associates, the idea that you stayed at the firm and didn't walk your business

SPEAKER_01and your profitability out the door because that's where you were raised had sort of gone out the window. And you have sort of like we're seeing in college sports, right? This idea of a transfer portal, and it's even less organized, and the dollar signs are even bigger, right? And just to finish the analogy and tell you where it doesn't actually work is unlike in sports where if everybody leaves the Michigan football team, fans are still going to stay with the Michigan football team.

SPEAKER_01The fans in this analogy are actually the law firm's clients and they leave with the players when the players go to the other team. So that is just like a humongous change in how the sort of biggest cases, most high moneyed lawyers have changed. And we've been seeing this for a number of years. I don't know if that sound right to you, Karen?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think it's, as with everything in law firm life, I think it's slightly more nuanced just because we're talking about different practice areas, different, you know, there's a huge range, right? And there are certainly firms that still have what we call in the industry institutional clients, right? A firm has been servicing a client for so long that it doesn't really matter whether one particular lawyer leaves, that client is going to stay at the firm because there's 50 lawyers that work

SPEAKER_02on that client's portfolio. And so one person leaving doesn't make a difference. But I think when we're talking about the while situation, you know, A lot of people have said and pointed to the fact that Weil was sort of slow on lateral hiring over the last 20 years as a reason for why it collapsed. And I don't necessarily think that it was so much that it was slow on lateral hiring because we have seen Highly profitable firms that have hardly any lateral hiring, right? You take a firm like a Wachtel, right?

SPEAKER_02Wachtel is just now in the entire history of its firm over a hundred years starting to take in laterals for the very first time. But they have been highly profitable with a 100% homegrown model, right? Sussman Godfrey. Sussman is, you know, has insane success over the last 20 years. They also don't take laterals. Kellogg Hanson here in D.C., they really don't take laterals, right? So there certainly are firms that have done a good job. The problem was is that Wiles' main competitors – Which were a Kirkland,

SPEAKER_02a Davis Polk on the corporate side. They were taking a lot of laterals and a cravat. And I think that that was the start of the key to what led to the collapse. So I think, Jonah, do you want to start to talk about a little bit Now, I will say this. None of us actually know what happened in a while, right? We were not in the executive board meetings. This is all what has been reported in the press. So from an outside perspective, we are really repeating what we know.

SPEAKER_02But, Jonah, do you want to sort of share the story of allegedly what led to This October situation with Weil and why we saw what can really only be deemed as a run on the bank when it came to talent.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So obviously, as you said, Karen, right? We only have what's been reported. And unsurprisingly, when you have a firm of this size and scale and money and most of the people were not in the room when this decision was made, I think there's this view that law firm partnerships function kind of like everybody gets into a room and they talk. We're talking about a firm of 1,200 lawyers. So it's very hierarchical. And there's a lot of he said, she said, behind the scenes reporting.

SPEAKER_01Thankfully, we have great legal reporting, so we can sort of figure it out. The timeline that I think is relevant is actually quite short on this, right? So the key, as you said, Karen, right, the key is those firms that function on an institutional client model tend to be successful because of, but not Directly related to every individual partner's book of business. Yes. There are also firms and I would put Weil in that category where their primary value is they have sort some partners that bring in X

SPEAKER_01and other partners that ring 10X and other They're partners that bring in a hundred X And they get a percentage of their comp, their compensation, based on what they bring into the business, right? And so Weil had a large, specifically a large corporate partner who left in September, longtime corporate partner at Weil, who left in September to go to Cravaff, right? Another, maybe the most well-established white shoe law firm in New York City, and he brought lawyers with him.

SPEAKER_01That's why I think the bank run analogy or metaphor works nicely. He brought with him a large chunk of the deposits that they were counting on every single year.

SPEAKER_02Yes. And Mike Aiello, who we're talking about, is the partner who went to Cravath. He was at Weil his whole career, which I feel like is extremely, extremely important. And from what the reporting has been indicating and what we sort of know internally from folks who have worked at Weil is he basically ran the corporate group and it was his fiefdom. So what Mike Aiello wanted, Mike Aiello got. And he was extremely close to We had Barry Wolf, who was the long-time chairman of Weil.

SPEAKER_01Right.

SPEAKER_00But to pick up on the bank run, though, because I want to sort of ask a question as you keep going and just sort of fold this in. Because my law school classmate, Matt Levine, who writes the super popular column, Money Stuff, he wrote a whole piece about this and made the same bank run analogy. Part of a bank run is not just that a large depositor takes their deposits, right? It's that the media or something else is involved in stirring up public concern and That the rest of the deposits are unsafe. So can you sort of fold that into the narrative of what happens next with Weil?

SPEAKER_00Sure. So I'll do it pretty quickly, right?

SPEAKER_01Step one is the big depositor leaves. And we know that the sort of denominator or the pie that then is going to be set... The second thing that happens, and this is not uncommon in today's day and age, especially when a big partner leaves, is you say, okay, well, if we're going to lose that big partner's business, maybe we can merge with another large law firm to, again, rethink our profitability, remake our business case to clients, remake our business case to our internal lawyers that we want to keep in our fold.

SPEAKER_01Publicly reported there were merger discussions with another large law firm, Wilkie Farr, and the media was sort of following all of this, right? And those merger talks ended up going nowhere, or at least ending prematurely. There was reporting about other potential merger talks. And so step one is the big one walks out of the bank. Step two is the way we're going to refill the coffers of the bank is

SPEAKER_02There's also one piece of this, which I think is really crazy, and this is Steve's point, I think, is that even when Mike Aiello left, he went to Cravath. At the same time, there was a Cravath partner who had been at Weil previously, that now that Mike Aiello was gone, he went back to Weil. There really was this sense, at least among the legal community in Our neck of the woods that everything was fine that while, right? It was just like frictional. It was a round table of recruiting, which is what I see every single day in my job.

SPEAKER_02That Mike Aiello left, he had... From all reports, a extremely difficult personality. There were corporate partners over the years who had left Weil because of him. And now that he was gone, people were coming back to Weil, right? I think, and that's the part that I keep scratching my head about is that there were incoming partners. I mean, shit, there was a Paul Weiss partner who started at Weil the Monday before the collapse, right? Partners were going into Weil. So what were we seeing, Jonah?

SPEAKER_02From the legal media at this time, because I think the legal media was reporting a very different story.

SPEAKER_01Right. I don't think the legal media, I mean, that's the other piece of this, right? As Steve pointed out with a bank run, right? The news doesn't, everybody thinks they know everything, but they're actually only focused on the little bit of information that they have. The other challenge here, right? So the third part of this, so one is Mike Ayala leaves. Two is you have these merger talks that sort of go away. The third story that you get, which I think ends up being maybe the, not the but for a cause, but like the straw that breaks the camel's back is, As you mentioned, right, they have a longtime chairman, Barry Wolf,

SPEAKER_01who has named a successor heir apparent. And then there's reporting that she no longer wants to be the chair. That's a huge like that. That is the is the sort of third of this trifecta of news stories that says, wait a minute, somebody who's been at this firm for a long time, who's in one of their largest sort of revenue driving practice groups, who's been bestowed this huge honor has said, hard pass. And at that point, the question is like, to me, the question with the bank run analogy is you got to be clear about who are

SPEAKER_01the depositors and who is the bank, right? The bank is the firm. The depositors that you're worried about first are the partners because the second the partners leave, and there's actually really good scholarship on this because we've had other bank run like collapses of law firms, none quite while size, right? Dewey is the most recent. We don't need to sort of rehash that, but that's whatever, 2012, something like that. We've seen once you lose faith that the deposits are going to be there, that the pie is going to be there. It might actually still be there,

SPEAKER_01but it's the perception that it's not going to be there, and you run to the bank.

SPEAKER_00That's the part that really strikes me, right? Because Weil had a ton of assets, right? It did not appear to have a ton of liabilities. And so you wouldn't normally think that that's a vulnerable institution, right? But it's like once the rails start coming off, they come off fast.

SPEAKER_02Right. This isn't a Dewey situation. Dewey, for those who don't know, was the most recent... Like truly high profile law firm collapse in the modern times. It was in 2008, but they had made extremely dicey investments and actually they were insolvent. Weil is not insolvent. It is paying all of its employees for the next 90 days. It is giving bonuses to people to stay through January 15th to help wind up client work as people are transitioning to other law firms. They are not insolvent.

SPEAKER_02And so that is the craziest part, that we have a situation where there are partners leaving and partners starting, which is very typical. And if you looked at any law firm in the last year, that has happened both ways, right? That revolving door that we've talked about, Jonah. And so in your estimation, and of course, we were not in the room where the executive committee happened. Why is Wild different? What made it so that these particular exits and entrances at the same time Led to a wrap up of the firm versus every other firm who seems

SPEAKER_02to be weathering these entrances and exits.

SPEAKER_00A rebrand, a refocus, a reshaping of something.

SPEAKER_01Right. So I would say, and again, as you said, Karen, I wasn't there. My two answers are, one, actually, this was happening for a long time, which is we know for a fact because law firms report, you know, Karen, you were explaining sort of how the MLAW 100 works. Law firm partners report what is your total revenue and how many revenue partners do you take? And then you sort of get a number. That's the profits per partner number, which is Mostly a prestige number, right? Our firm is prestigious because we make more money per partner.

SPEAKER_01They were, Weil has for a long time not been keeping up with their competitors. Now that doesn't mean, and this is critical, that doesn't mean the new partners they were bringing in, they may be making greater themselves, greater than that average profits per partner number. But if the average is not going up and you're looking at how am I going to get the best talent and how am I going to retain the best talent, that's not a great data point for you.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_01So to me, that's one for sure.

SPEAKER_02Yep. I also think from at least from what we heard, and we're not revealing any confidential information, but, you know, the executive committee at Weill was really dominated by two people, essentially, and one of those people left. And your average partner at Weill was not getting the information that it needed. Right. And so We all know that when you don't get information, you start to fill in with your own details as to what you think is occurring. And, you know, the bank run analogy is the closest one, I think,

SPEAKER_02because your average partner at Weill felt like they sort of knew what was going on, but at the end of the day, really didn't. I mean, people were finding out about the windup before... Like as it was coming down, they did, the partners, the partners did not know that the firm was winding up until they got an announcement that the firm had already, the executive committee had already voted on it. And like, you know, I think that there's a lot of law firms out there

SPEAKER_02who can take heed of this, which was, When you have a very small group of people who are essentially running a firm and that very small group either leaves or decides this is kind of the end of the road for this firm, even a profitable law firm with $2 billion in revenue can still fail, right? And like that to me is the message that if law firm leaders are listening to this is that there cannot be this tiny fiefdom In such a big organization

SPEAKER_02that is completely responsible for the longevity of a firm, because when that starts to crack, you're in a situation where an incredibly infinitesimally small number of people are essentially deciding the future of a big law firm.

SPEAKER_00Can I sort of ask a question about that? I mean, it strikes me, you know, my work is much less adjacent to these issues than Jonah's yours or Karen's yours. It strikes me that we are in a fascinating period of time in general when it comes to law firms as institutions and when it comes to law firms as, how do I say, as in a position to be sort of instrumental players in our governmental system.

SPEAKER_00We've seen threats against law firms, we've seen law firms capitulate. Am I wrong to be worried That the collapse of Weil makes other law firms potentially in an easier position to be intimidated and threatened and messed with.

SPEAKER_01I mean, I think it shows actually that they were all that they're the big law firms are already in that position. And this is just a continuation of that story. Right. It's once you lose. I mean, John Morley wrote a Law Review article about this years ago. Where he sort of talks about how law firms die. This is long before Wile, but if you read it or read a summary of it, he wrote an op-ed about it recently. You will see it basically plays the Wile story out to a T. And the reason is, I think, if firms lose sort of their...

SPEAKER_01If all firms are is a soft collaboration of lawyers with books of business, they are... They are exponentially more at risk for sort of feeling like, oh, we don't know if we're going to be here tomorrow. So we need to do everything we can to save ourselves. And when you're in save yourself mode, you make decisions like the last time I was on your podcast and we were talking about the executive orders, right? The idea of like firms having power as firms has been a problem, I think,

SPEAKER_01for a lot longer than we'd recognize. And this is just one example of what can happen when that's the case.

SPEAKER_02I think that that's exactly right.

SPEAKER_00So I guess, I mean, I guess this is sort of my last question because I know we don't want to keep people, you know, too long. So what do we do about it? I mean, Karen, you mentioned, you know, a minute ago, firms being wary of having fiefdoms that have too much power. What's the alternative? I mean, if you are giving advice to a big law firm or to a junior associate or anyone in between about how to avoid being wild, like, Where do we start?

SPEAKER_02I mean, I think that their entire industry is devoted to this. So I don't know if I can give you a one minute compilation. But I mean, look, I think we saw a really good example of somebody who had been at the head of the firm for an incredibly long time. And, you know, people are saying this is not necessarily me saying this, but like that. He was ready for the firm to essentially wind down because he was not going to rule it anymore.

SPEAKER_02And he was 68. They had mandatory retirement, which we haven't really talked about on this podcast yet, but mandatory retirement. Many, many law firms have 68 or 69, sometimes 70 as a required retirement age for partners. Barry Wolf hit the required retirement age. And people are kind of saying like, you know, He decided that whether it was conscious, subconscious, like without me and Michaelo, this firm doesn't exist anymore, right?

SPEAKER_00So more succession planning.

SPEAKER_02Absolutely. Younger people need to be in the room. I don't know how else to scream it from the rooftops. It doesn't need to be the person with the largest book of business who is ruling a firm. It needs to be people who are, A, cycling out. There is absolutely no reason to have the same managing partner for 20 years, period. That's just for any organization. We need to have younger people in the room. We need to have more representation on the executive committee. And I think firms that do a really good job of that are seeing success, right?

SPEAKER_02You need to have more representation in the room where decisions are being made, in the room where it happens.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think Karen's 100% right about that. And then the question becomes, right, if everybody is truly a free agent, right? If everybody can truly say, wow, I had a really good year. This is my year to change teams. If that's the only thing that's in their mind at that moment, then the whole model that has allowed big law firms to survive and grow at a rate we have never seen that goes way beyond inflation, that goes way beyond almost any other industry over the last 50 to 60 years,

SPEAKER_01that model will not be able to survive. Full stop. And I think at that point, you end up, unless something changes, you end up with kind of a barbell effect. You end up with firms sort of merging and merging and merging and then basically being like the management general. They provide the back office. They provide the hiring. They provide the healthcare. And it's everybody sort of eat what they kill. Or you have smaller firms where you don't have to worry quite so much about the succession planning and the winding it down and all of that.

SPEAKER_01My big question is the other one you asked, Steve, which is like, what do we tell people going into this market? What do we tell the junior lawyers? What do we tell the lawyers from 10 years from now? To me, the law students, the future law students, to me, the message of this for future law students is that you should not, and this is different advice than I gave for a long time and that was given to me when I was going through this process over a decade ago, is you should pick people Yeah. Over firm names. Because ultimately,

SPEAKER_01the idea of people and retention and development and all of those things are far more important than the firm's handful of clients. And Karen's right. There are firms that function as institutional clients. And a lot of those firms are structured such that the lawyers say, we all win because we do that. But I think that's becoming less and less common. And as a result... Picking people, picking practice groups, picking areas of practice, and picking the ability to bring clients with you is going to be the key

SPEAKER_01to the realm for being a lawyer for the next 25 years in this business, rightly or wrongly.

SPEAKER_00And Karen, what about they who are still or were until recently employed at YL? What happens for them?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I will get to that question in a minute. I want to add what Jonah said is like, you know, now, because this is this talent or this NIL, right? I totally agree with you. I think that there are some. Lawyers who say, let me go to the most prestigious firm and if you did that in a while situation, you would have not been in a great, great situation. You need to attach to individual partners and people to the extent you have that ability and you have that ability and it's hard to do as very, very junior associates. It takes time. Yeah. It takes time, but people will always have

SPEAKER_02the ability to take you with them. And we are seeing that right now. So Steve, to transition to your question, I would say that I am speaking certainly just for the RisePoint team, but we have never seen a moment like this in terms of other law firms truly going insane trying to grab up the wild talent. And that is both at the partner level and at the associate level. Many firms are taking essentially big, big parts of the firm. So Gibson Dunn has reportedly taken 100 wild lawyers in the finance group.

SPEAKER_02Kirkland, Ramona Nee, who is the woman that we referred to that was supposed to be the heir apparent. It is rumored that she and an enormous group is in talks to go to Kirkland. Davis Polk is taking a very large litigation group. And there is talks for other groups going elsewhere and individual partners are going elsewhere. I'll be 100% honest with you. Ironically, many of them are getting raises, right?

SPEAKER_02It is a crazy situation, but many of those partners are actually going to be in better situations than they were in while. Honestly, even more so, the mid-levels are getting offers that I haven't seen since the heyday of corporate hiring in 2021. We are talking about enormous signing bonuses. We're talking about guaranteed big end-of-year bonuses. There's so much hiring going on right now, and part of it is that Particularly in these complicated finance practices,

SPEAKER_02it is very hard to get lateral associates that have been trained in a way that these very prestigious firms want to see. And in litigation, too. Litigation, there's more of them, and so it's not quite as competitive. But in finance, we are seeing just insane... Offers in a way, I mean, Steve has heard me say this, like we submitted somebody at 4.30 on the day that the firm collapsed and by 9 a.m. the next day, that person had an offer. They interviewed that night and had an offer. In my line of work, that is legitimately unheard of.

SPEAKER_02You do not get offers in 12 hours. It does not happen. And so I think the mid-levels are going to be, mid-levels and seniors are going to be completely fine. The people that I truly, my heart goes out to and I do not know How they are going to necessarily rebound from this is the incoming first years who were supposed to start this week. Some of them are able to go with groups. Right again, Jonah, the tie to someone who you trust. And so they had already summered at Wild. They were able to build relationships with people.

SPEAKER_02And some of those partners are going to take first years. And incoming law clerks, et cetera. The summer associates for this coming summer, right? So Steve, your students, Jonah, your students, the current 2Ls, they, I hope, have enough of a runway and bandwidth that they will be able to scatter to the wind, right? There's probably about 100 of them. I'm hoping that some other law firms increase their class size by a couple. But those are the people that I worry about, those right at the very outset of their career.

SPEAKER_02And if any of them are listening to this, I will tell you a very brief story, which is that one of my absolute best friends, who is now a bankruptcy partner with legitimately a $20 million practice, he is doing so fantastically well, was a summer associate at Weill Gottschall in New York in 2008 and got no offer. And because it was the summer of 2008 and they offered about half of the class. Steve doesn't see what I'm talking about. I'm not going to mention him by name, but he's an amazing person. He is so successful.

SPEAKER_02And I know it doesn't feel like this now, but so much of what happened in his career later was fueled by the fork in the road that he took. And he ended up clerking for a bankruptcy judge and Everything really, really worked out. And I know that it might not feel like it's going to work out right now, but it actually is. And Joan and I have talked about this on How I Lawyer and so many other places that do not let this one hiccup or bump in the road derail you. But yes, Steve, to answer your question, I think the partners and mid-level associates are going to be just fine,

SPEAKER_02if not ironically coming out ahead.

SPEAKER_00Joan, I guess I'll give you the last word. And I guess my question is maybe a A bit of a repeat, but also framed a little differently. In the grand scheme of things, how big of a deal is while unto itself versus how much is it showing us much larger, deeper problems in the world of big law that it would be probably wise for people who are smarter than me, maybe not you, to actually figure out how to try to address on a structural level?

SPEAKER_01Yes. I mean, with... With the caveat that Karen just made of the folks who I also feel for, who are sort of the people caught in the middle of this moment, the fact that so many of these folks have already landed on their feet and we haven't even written the story yet actually tells me that the collapse of Weil for Weil's lawyers... Is not going to be that big a deal on balance. And actually there's a great, and I know this is like having two law professors on the podcast, but there's actually somebody who wrote an article, Andrew Granato wrote an article about 12 years after Dewey collapsed.

SPEAKER_01How did those individual lawyers end up? And sort of studied based on their bios, like did they land on their feet? And the answer was they basically had just as high a became part, like the associates just had the same partner rate Yeah. If they had been at any other firm.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Wow, that's great data.

SPEAKER_01I love that. It's a really cool study, 2023. But ultimately, so to me, the collapse of Weil is actually less about the Weil lawyers. I think in some ways, as we're talking about it, like my views are crystallizing a little bit. Like in some ways, I think Weil just wanted, they were more comfortable dying as the prestigious law firm they were than trying to become a new style law firm. And instead they were sort of like, well, there's nothing to save here. We're all just going to leave and we'll end up on our feet.

SPEAKER_01And so to answer the first part of your question, Steve, that means it really doesn't matter much at all for the lawyers. For the industry, I think it's massive, right? And we are facing a world where there's a lot of uncertainty. You know, I was really glad to see that the immediate takes that I read that were like, AI caused the collapse of Wile. Like, I could not think that is further from the truth. But AI is just one Real example, and there are others, of changes in society, changes in the practice of business, which has an effect on the practice of lawyers.

SPEAKER_01And if this behemoth, it's sort of like going back to 2008, like if this behemoth wasn't too big to fail, any law firm could fail at any moment if they lose the confidence of their lawyers and those lawyers feel like there's not enough value in the quote unquote firm. And so to me, it's both, right? The lawyers will probably end up on their feet, but it absolutely should be a warning sign to anyone who is even remotely an institutionalist who thinks, I care about the tradition of my law firm.

SPEAKER_01I've made sacrifices for this firm. I've taken less money. I have done more work. I have done all these things. And to me, I think Karen's answer is the best answer. If you want to keep your firm, you need to do it not by looking at the three other people who founded it, but actually building in Better structures, better training, better retention. And ultimately, I think other firms, other lawyers would absolutely make the choice that we would rather have our firm die prestigious than survive below the MLaw 100.

SPEAKER_01I'll stop there.

SPEAKER_02Damn, Jonah. No one can see me because it's a podcast, but I was nodding vigorously with everything that you were saying because that is a perfect ending. So yeah, we should do this more often, guys.

SPEAKER_00I'm in. All right. Well, as the person I don't want to talk about law,

SPEAKER_02I don't want to talk about substantive issues. This is way more fun.

SPEAKER_00Well, next we can talk about law schools and legal education and how all that's going. Because Joan and I have some thoughts on that as well.

SPEAKER_02I'll just be the moderator on that one because I have no thoughts on that.

SPEAKER_00Seriously, Karen and I can trade roles. All right. Well, thank you, everyone, for listening. I hope you found this useful and illuminating. I certainly did. Thank you, Jonah Perlin, for taking the time. Jonah, where can people find you if they want to know more about your work? Thank you.

SPEAKER_01That's the classic podcast pass. I moderate. I lead a podcast called How I Lawyer. You can find me anywhere under my name, Jonah Perlin. But keep listening to Steve and Karen. That's my parting advice.

SPEAKER_00And Karen, I think I know people can find you. Tell people where they can find you.

SPEAKER_02My company is called Rise Point Search Partners. We're at risepointsearch.com. You can find me on LinkedIn, Karen Vladeck, or on Blue Sky, KSVESQ.

SPEAKER_00And if you're listening to this, you already know who I am and how to find me. So thanks, everybody, for listening. Thank you, Joan and Karen. And as we like to say, stay safe out there. Karen, this is where you usually say bye.

SPEAKER_02Oh, bye. No, I say bye, y'all.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Court Against the Courts: A Conversation With Jack Goldsmith

    Nov 20, 202637 minAudio

    As I noted in Monday’s post, the Harvard Law Review’s annual Supreme Court issue, including my Foreword - “The Court Against the Courts” - came out last week. On Thursday, November 20, I sat down with Harvard law...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The new Democratic majorities -- and the Courts, with Chris Cillizza and Steve Vladeck

    Nov 11, 202648 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.stevevladeck.com/subscribe

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Missouri Mess: Live with Cristian Farias and Steve Vladeck

    Sep 22, 202619 minAudio

    On Tuesday morning, Cristian Farias and I got together for a quick Substack Live to discuss the goings-on in the Missouri redistricting case - including what happened in the Eighth Circuit on Monday and what’s likely to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Live with Steve Vladeck on the Supreme Court USPS opinion

    Sep 15, 202630 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.stevevladeck.com/subscribe

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Live with Joyce Vance & Steve Vladeck: Trump v. California

    Aug 25, 202623 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.stevevladeck.com/subscribe

    Credit the people on this episode