Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

First One

First One artwork

The new Democratic majorities -- and the Courts, with Chris Cillizza and Steve Vladeck

Nov 11, 202648 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.stevevladeck.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01We are live. I am Chris Lizza. That is Steve Vladeck, a man of many titles, my favorite of which is the Agnes Williams Sesquicentennial Professor of Federal Courts at Georgetown, which is among the best titles there is.

SPEAKER_00It's certainly among the longest.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, certainly, definitely among the longest. Steve is also the author of One First, which is a terrific Substack on the courts. The Supreme Court, the Constitution has over 108,000 subscribers. So if you are not one of them, trust me, we're going to talk about some things Steve wrote. Yeah. There about the election in the courts. He is also the author of a forthcoming book, which I'm going to pre-order after I get off of this. The Court We Need, What's Really Wrong with the Supreme Court?

SPEAKER_01It comes out May 4th, 2020. I mean, there you go. May 4th, 2027. Steve wrote a book called The Shadow Docket, which basically, I think for the layman, established what the shadow docket was. It's obviously something Donald Trump has used extensively. Um, so that book would be called The Court We Need, What's Really Wrong with the Supreme Court, May 4th, 2027. You and I should pre-order this. Um, I will put a link in while Steve is talking. I will find the pre-order and I will put it in the chat.

SPEAKER_01Um, All right, so Steve, let's talk about things. I said, let's knock out some things that I get asked all the time about the court post-election, particularly with Democrats now in control of the Senate, which is, is Samuel Alito, and I guess, well, let's just throw in Clarence Thomas. Are they going to retire either one or both? Oh, thank you, Steve. There's the book. Either one or both of them going to retire between now and the end of the lame duck, And when presumably Donald Trump could pick a replacement conservative,

SPEAKER_01that would be more easily confirmed.

SPEAKER_00Go. Short answer, Thomas, no. Alito, I say only a slightly larger chance than Thomas because there's no way to have a lower chance than no. There's no number less than zero. There's no number less than zero. You know, Chris, Thomas isn't going anywhere perfectly. Because he wants the longevity record. And, you know, that's probably, I think, May of 2028, if my math is right. And, you know, even before that, he has said, you know, his plan is to leave the court horizontally.

SPEAKER_01It's such a weird way to put it, but yeah, I get it.

SPEAKER_00It is a weird way to put it. It's also like David Suter's old line that if cameras were ever to roll into the Supreme Court, they would roll over his dead body. Yeah. So Alito is a little more complicated. I mean, I think the odds are very close to zero. Okay. And indeed, I think if you were going to, he would have said something by now. But it's worth taking a beat to talk about why. The first reason, I think, is more your universe than mine, right, which is the politics.

SPEAKER_00So, you know, Senator-elect Brown will be sworn in very soon, I think.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, because he will be sworn in sooner, for people to understand. He'll be sworn in sooner because he's replacing— He's serving out the final two years of J.D. Vance's unexpired term. That's why Sherrod Brown is up in 2028. So all the six-year people will be sworn in after Sherrod Brown. Go ahead. Sorry.

SPEAKER_00That's a great clarification. Which means right off the bat, you're down to a 52-48 majority in the Senate. Yeah. That majority depends on, you know, Susan Collins. It depends on Murkowski. It depends on Tillis. It depends on Cornyn. And so already it's a very different Senate than it would have been three, four weeks ago. I also think, Chris, any effort on the Republicans' part to visibly jam through a confirmation at this late date is only going to further embolden Democrats.

SPEAKER_00To push for more extreme court reforms not necessarily next January when they have majorities in both chambers of Congress but come 2029 And, you know, this to me, I think, is the real way in which what happened last Tuesday changes the entire specter of this whole conversation, which is that my own view, and you're the expert, I'm the amateur, is that one of the things Tuesday dramatically raises the odds for is a Democratic trifecta in 2029. Sure. Absolutely. Absolutely.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, it's not a sure thing, but they now control two of the three. I mean, that's a hell of a lot better than zero of the three, which they did on November 2nd.

SPEAKER_00And if they end up with 56 senators, which I think is- Which they will. They will. Yep. So if they end up with 56 senators, that's a margin to even lose a few seats in 2028. And so the reason why I say all this is because if you're thinking remotely strategically about what Supreme Court reform looks like come January of 2029, I'm not sure if you're Alito that you want to basically sort of give more ammunition

SPEAKER_00to the most radical, progressive court reformers by doing something so transparently cynical to sort of build more generational conservatism on the court. So I think it's both the short -term politics, Chris, which are shifting by the day and I think that's the long term politics, which is that if you are in any way worried about You know, court reform not just at the margins but like dramatic court reform becoming more and more of a thing in a democratic trifecta in 29.

SPEAKER_00I don't know that you want to do the thing that is most likely to – Yeah, don't poke the bear.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, don t poke the A little bit more on Alito, Steve. He came out, and you're going to know this far better than me. I know he came out at some point in the fall and said, I thought about retiring earlier in the year and decided against it. Can you just feel, I know that that happened, but I don't know the circumstances. And does that, is there a possibility that decision changes in the wake of last Tuesday in this next month?

SPEAKER_00So I think it was in his interview. I mean, it was part of his book tour. I think it was in his interview with Jan Crawford Greenberg. That's right. Yes. Before Jan had an awkward tweet. Yes. And, you know, the thing is, what he says in an interview is not a contract. It's not binding. Like, you know, no one can say you can't resign because you promised you wouldn't. It's like when people say, I won't run for president.

SPEAKER_01It's not a legal contract. Barack Obama said it. Everybody says it.

SPEAKER_00Or we have no reason to consider a change in the managerial position of this team at this time. Right. He's the manager today. So, you know, there's nothing formally stopping Alito from announcing tomorrow that he wants to retire pending the confirmation of his successor. I just think that this is a context in which the politics really shifted probably faster than he anticipated, certainly faster than I did. Where Chris, if the Republicans had held the Senate narrowly,

SPEAKER_00he could have retired any time in the next two years. If it had been a narrower Democratic majority, he might've said, well, you know, I'll take my chances. But it's just – it's the scale of the Democratic route that if I were Alito and And if I were worried about the future of the court And whether all of my big decisions are going to be quickly undone by, you know, four new Democratic appointees in 2029, that's, I think, what would be, you know,

SPEAKER_00even if you were otherwise thinking about it, and maybe he's not, but even if you were seriously considering it, that would be the reason why I think it's now too late.

SPEAKER_01But last one on this, and then we'll move on. How much, because you have insight into this that I think very few people do, the court, particularly Chief Justice Roberts, makes it very famously has made a big deal out of, you know, we don't pay attention to the politics, but they, I mean, I think that's broadly bullshit, but because like, how could you not? But how much does an Alito or a Thomas... How legacy-focused are they to your point about, okay, well,

SPEAKER_01these rulings that I think are really important that I played a central role in, if I leave, could be undone in a way that if I stay, probably won't be. How forward-looking are they about, number one, what they've done, what it means, maybe what's coming down the pike in terms of cases they're likely to see? Is that a big part, a small part, or no part of their calculation when they think about when they leave?

SPEAKER_00I think every justice, Chris, is thinking about their legacy. But I suspect that they think about it in very different ways. So, you know, I don't imagine that Clarence Thomas sits around worrying about individual rulings, you know, being sort of undermined, sort of repudiated because, you know, his, I don't know, his legacy already is less about particular opinions and more about a sort of broader jurisprudential philosophy. And longevity, right, to your point, and just being there for a really long time.

SPEAKER_00Right. Which, you know, if he gets to May of 2028, like, no one can take away from him, at least, you know, until we have another justice surfer 36 years. You know, I think it's a much bigger deal for Alito. And not because Alito sees himself as an institutionalist who's worried about, you know, a political reality where the court is weakened, but because Alito, I think, views has his legacy. Dobbs, which he wrote... Right. You know, weakening and eviscerating the Voting Rights Act in a series of rulings

SPEAKER_00that he either wrote or joined. Did he write Kelley, Steve? So Kalei was Alito. Yes. I think it was Alito. Was it Robert? It was Alito. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I thought so, but I knew you'd know. Yeah. I mean, that's another huge, I mean, it probably didn't have the impact, at least in the near term. I mean, it basically drove black voters to the polls, but it's a hugely, we've talked about this, hugely significant.

SPEAKER_00He has a number of significant religion cases that he's written, Chris. I mean, like the, you know, if I'm Alito, like my legacy is my opinions. Okay. I don't think he's worried about a retirement that would be transparently political, for instance, choosing to retire during a Republican presidency. But I do think that he would actually understand the stakes of retiring in circumstances where he is guaranteeing that there will be even more of a sort

SPEAKER_00of retaliatory momentum the next time the Democrats are in a position to do anything about it. Got it, okay. And I don't think that's good—like, to be fair, like, you know, no matter how people try to spin it will be an obvious, immediate provocation and galvanize moderate Dems to sort of be more radical on court reform.

SPEAKER_01And your point, I think, is the numbers, I think the 56 in the Senate is really important and it. It was so clearly, last Tuesday was so clearly, every number demonstrates this, a repudiation of kind of Trump and Trumpism, that to then be like, okay, let's jam this guy in here, like it- Now, Steve and I are both big baseball fans. There are a lot of unwritten rules in baseball, right? Like if you're up five runs, you don't steal or the next guy gets hit, whatever.

SPEAKER_01It is not a law or a rule that you can't do this. They could try to jam it through. We have seen Donald Trump stretch norms and traditions a lot, but it would not be in the sporting tradition to have that happen.

SPEAKER_00Well, so I'll go a half step further, right? I mean, I think, Chris, we're about to see Senate Republicans violate a bunch of norms to rush through a series of nominees to the lower federal courts over the next couple of weeks. Reflecting, I think, the probably correct if unfortunate calculation that those norm violations are not going to galvanize like mass public opposition and criticism on the theory that like in the lower courts, the gloves are all off. I do think that for as much as we live in a time of the obliteration of norms,

SPEAKER_00this kind of move, right, although perhaps perfectly defensible legally, will have such obvious, you know, race to the bottom consequences. Totally agree.

SPEAKER_01And while Donald Trump would be fine with that, ultimately, Alito has to make the decision, right? I mean, that's the thing. It's like Donald Trump doesn't care. Right. He'd be thrilled to fill another Senate, another Supreme Court.

SPEAKER_00It's just Alito, I think, probably is more. And Chris, it's not just Alito. I mean, yes, Alito has to make the decision. But then to go back to the math we started with, then you also have to have at least three moderate Republican senators, including the lame ducks, you know, endorse this norm destruction. And, you know, maybe Collins and Murkowski and Cornyn and Tillis would have gone for this before last Tuesday.

SPEAKER_01It's hard now. And they owe no loyalty to Trump at all at this point. Yeah. All right. Let me. Yeah. Right. McConnell. Great point. Let me reset quickly. We are talking to Steve Vladeck, who is the semi Agnes Williams sesquicentennial professor of federal courts at the Georgetown Law School. Amazing. He I love Steve even when he was at the University of Texas. But now that he is at my alma mater, I love him even more. He is the author of The One First, Substack, already over 108,000 subscribers. You should be one of them.

SPEAKER_01Trust me, it is invaluable. He is also the author of a number of books, including The Shadow Docket, but his forthcoming book, The Court We Need, What's Really Wrong with the Supreme Court, is out May 4th. If you scroll up in this chat, Steve has posted a link where you can pre-order the book. Steve, I want to talk about something you wrote today. It's a two-parter. Let's start with the first one. The midterms in the courts, part one. You wrote this the day after the election, so a week ago. And you just go through a bunch of things that, you know, everyone's talking about,

SPEAKER_01okay, what does this mean for Democrats? What does it mean for Republicans? But it obviously has massive implications across the landscape. And you pose a bunch of questions. And I'm Let's just go through a few of them. We don't have to go through the whole thing. I did link for people who want to read the piece. It is in the chat. So your first question, and we've been talking a lot about the future makeup of the court, but the current makeup of the court is the makeup of the court. And the first question you ask is, how and whether and if this election changes the relationship of the Supreme Court

SPEAKER_01to Donald Trump? Explain. Explain.

SPEAKER_00Sure. I mean, so you and I have talked about this before, that there's obviously we've seen over the last two years a run of decisions where the court has gone out of its way to enable President Trump. You know, not uniformly. Trump has lost a couple of big cases in the court. He lost the tariffs case. He lost birthright citizenship. He lost Lisa Cook.

SPEAKER_01All of which, by the way, if you had been listening to our Substack Lives between Steve and I, Steve predicted. And Steve, by the way, too, is correct. I always feel like people only remember your predictions when you're, for me at least, your predictions when you're wrong. Steve also predicted the cases that Donald Trump would win in front of the Supreme Court. So again, if you were interested in this stuff, you should pay attention to Steve. Go ahead. I'll pat you on the back so you don't need to.

SPEAKER_00Um, next thing I know we're going to be giving odds and I'm going to be going on, you know, Kornheiser's podcast to talk.

SPEAKER_01Next, next prediction by Steve, the Mets win the world series next year.

SPEAKER_00Not so much. Bet beyond her. So but, but so Chris, I mean the, the sort of, the question is, you know, one of the defenses of the Supreme court's behavior over the last two years, when there were so many cases where it enabled Trump, um, Was that the court was engaged in a form of institutional appeasement. That, you know, without Congress serving any kind of checking function, John Roberts and Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett all sort of understood at least implicitly that there was only so much capital that they could spend

SPEAKER_00on reigning in President Trump because they were sort of fighting a rear guard action because they were

SPEAKER_01basically by themselves.

SPEAKER_00You know, I struggle with that argument. But if that's what was happening. Well, wait, Steve, can I just quick question?

SPEAKER_01And this doesn't mean that they didn't think that. But they are lifetime appointees. He literally no one can remove. I guess. Can they be impeached?

SPEAKER_00They could be impeached. I mean, it's never happened. Right. Once in American history. Right. Samuel Chase. Great nickname. Old Bacon Face. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I want to be new Bacon Face. I want that to be my nickname.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, but anyway. Really? No, not really. So, but Chris, they can be marginalized. And, you know, I think the concern was that without the backing of Congress, right, a Supreme Court that is repeatedly thwarting the executive is basically sort of daring the president to call its bluff and to stop following its rulings. Because if Congress isn't going to backstop the court, you know, who will?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, if it's two on one, if we have three co-equal branches and it's two on one, it becomes more problematic.

SPEAKER_00And there's a long-running view that the Supreme Court can win battles with the executive branch. It just can't win a war.

SPEAKER_01Okay. That's interesting.

SPEAKER_00Got it. And so, right, against that backdrop, you know, the question is how much of what the court's been doing over the last two years was because of that and not because of actual sort of sympathy for the substantive program of the Trump administration. Right. And we're about to find out because, you know, now the court has friends, right? The cavalry is here. Yeah. Now the court doesn't have to worry about the absence of Congress. Now that sort of the tables have turned. And so I think, you know, the first point is if the court was worried

SPEAKER_00about spending capital it will have a lot more to spend against the Trump administration Right. Come January. The second point, though, is that the court also now has to worry about Congress. So right. Congress. Yes. An active Congress actually serves two different functions. One is to backstop the court and the other is to basically loom over the court. Yes. And so now back to the Alito conversation. Right. There's not that much the court can do. I'm sorry.

SPEAKER_00There's not that much Congress can do without the presidency. But, Chris, there's one pretty important thing it can do, which is not fund the court. And so, you know, the one weapon that congressional Democrats will have over the court as soon as next January is the spending power. So all of this, I think, just really changes the institutional politics of how the Supreme Court views its relationship with President Trump because, one,

SPEAKER_00it should be emboldened to rule against Trump more often, and two, it now faces potential consequences if it is perceived as being too in the bag for the current administration.

SPEAKER_01We talked a little bit about this looking at a Democratic trifecta in 20 – the possibility of a Democratic trifecta in 2029. You mentioned it in the piece about court – and you mentioned court reform. Democrats are obviously much more gung-ho about court reform than Republicans. That's sort of putting it – that's putting it mildly. What they can do in the near term in terms of controlling Congress but not the White House is funding, right? Cut off funding, limit funding, et cetera, et cetera. Can you make, Steve, broadly of some of these broader proposed court reforms?

SPEAKER_01Is there any, the one I'm obviously thinking of is adding seats to the Supreme Court, but can you walk people through the things, serious Democrats have talked about? Not like a thing that somebody on Twitter said they should do. We'll add 400 seats to the Supreme Court, right? Serious court reform proposals and what the likelihood is if any between now in 2028 and what the likelihood might be in a trifecta. Can we take – it's a slight side rule but I think it's worth it. No, no.

SPEAKER_00I think its important. So serious court reform proposal really run the gamut and they include Chris some forms of expansion. I mean, I think one of the things that's happened in the last couple of years is that expansion has moved from a radical view to an increasingly sort of, I wouldn't say mainstream, but popular view, right, within the Democratic caucus, where you now have members saying publicly, we should add seats, even if they don't sort of always get into the details of how.

SPEAKER_01And that is an act of Congress would do that, Steve?

SPEAKER_00Okay. So the size of the court is controlled by Congress. The Constitution only requires one justice. We have to have a chief justice. Okay. Every other piece of that's up to Congress and has been. Congress has changed the size of the court seven times in its history, although not since 1869. But, you know, Chris, there are so many other things Congress could do. Congress could reassert control over which cases the justice is here. Something that was – Congress had full control over the court's docket until 1891

SPEAKER_00and then sort of gradually relinquished it over the course of the 20th century. Congress could reassert control over the standards that justices apply in these cases. Congress actually has the power to basically say, you can't interpret the statute to mean X unless this is true. Right? Congress can take over more control of the budget, right? So the justices' salaries are protected by the Constitution. You can't cut their salaries. But that's only about, Chris, 2 .8 % of the Supreme Court's annual budget.

SPEAKER_00The rest is discretionary appropriations. And, you know, the thing is Congress actually used to do a lot of this. Congress, as I mentioned, used to control the docket. It used to controlled the budget. Used to control when the court sat. It used To Control Chris Where The Court Sat, Which Was In The Capitol Till 1935.

SPEAKER_01I think people don't realize that. I think most people assume the Supreme Court is laid out in the Constitution and you'd have to amend the Constitution, which we all know is a gigantic pain in the ass that is almost impossible at this point. And that's not the case. I did not know about Congress being able to determine which cases they heard.

SPEAKER_00That and there were 1891 the court had no control over its then Chief Justice and former President William Howard Taft led the charge for all of that to happen But, you know, I think everything in moderation, like the pendulum swung too far from no discretion to complete discretion. Interesting. So, you know, when we talk about court reform, like I think there's a tendency on the part of folks to think it's expansion

SPEAKER_00and term limits or bust. Right. And there's such a larger menu than that. I mean, there's like a silver diner menu of options here that should all come into play, Chris, once you have a trifecta.

SPEAKER_01So until they have that, Trump could just veto it and they don't have over they don't have they do not have the two thirds they would need to override the veto.

SPEAKER_00And that's why I started with the funding, because like the one right, the one piece of legislation that has to go through between now and twenty twenty nine for the court is its budget. And so, you know, if the Democrats wanted to try to rally around one pressure point from the Supreme Court's perspective come next January. Right. It would be. Do we want to look any more closely at how we're spending money on this institution?

SPEAKER_01Have we seen that? Has Congress done that in the 20th century, Steve? Have they said, okay, you're spending too much money or we're giving you half as much as we gave you before?

SPEAKER_00So Congress used to do two things that it stopped doing. It used to actually mess with salary increases, Chris, as a cudgel, right? So you can't diminish- Not for the justices, but for the staff. No, for the justices too, right? Because the Constitution says you can't diminish their salary. Oh, you could limit the raising. Right. So really fun example. I mean, this is very small, but in 1964, Congress gave the entire federal government a long overdue post-World War II deflationary pay raise.

SPEAKER_00And the nine federal employees who got like the smallest pay raise by percentage were the justices because Congress was mad at them about Reynolds versus Sims, the redistricting case, right? The Congress deliberately gave the justices $500 less than it gave lower court judges. Bigger deal, Congress used to mess with the justice's pensions, right, so there was no Yeah. Retirement system for Supreme Court justices till 1937, which meant justices were often dependent upon Congress, um,

SPEAKER_00for the terms and conditions in which they could retire. There's Chris, there's a statute from 1882 where Congress says, Hey, Ward Hunt, uh, we want you to retire from the Supreme court. If you'll leave in the next 30 days, we'll give you a pension love Congress. Amazing. But that's but that was how we rolled. Like no one thought that was a weird statue.

SPEAKER_01I feel like people don't know. By the way, let me echo Natalie, who says, damn, Steve, this is so informative and interesting. Yeah, look, I said this to Steve beforehand. So, you know, I'm not bullshitting you just in public. Like the reason that I love doing these is because for me, I learn stuff every time. And the guy's knowledge is like encyclopedic. I mean, like it is it's remarkable. Not that I can't recall Ward Hunt off the top of my head, but I cannot recall Ward Hunt off the top of my head. So, okay, so, but you said in the 20th century,

SPEAKER_01we have seen Congress do some things to limit budgetary, like discretionary budgetary spending for the Supreme Court. When was that?

SPEAKER_00So, I mean, it was the salary thing in 64 was the last. Okay. Salary thing.

SPEAKER_01Okay. Got it. So that impacted the justices directly. Got it. Which is a good way to change behavior, by the way.

SPEAKER_00Chris, another thing, and this goes to a question that Kathleen asked in the chat. I mean, another thing that Congress used to do is Congress used to make the justices come across the street every year and testify in support of their budget. That's so interesting. Those hearings actually were often very substantive. So in March of 2001, Anthony Kennedy walks across the street and is peppered with questions by Jose Serrano, a Democratic congressman from the South Bronx, about Bush versus Gore, right?

SPEAKER_00And like, you know, It's almost like Michael Corleone in Fredo. Like, you broke my heart. Totally.

SPEAKER_01Totally.

SPEAKER_00And, you know, Kennedy spends 10 minutes, like, explaining, like, we understand that we only have a reservoir of trust and that we draw down on that reservoir. Like, it was a remarkable exchange. This summer, right, Justices Kagan and Barrett went to testify in support of the court's budget. It was the first time that any justice had done so since 2019. It was the first time in the Senate since 2011, right? So more of that.

SPEAKER_01I totally agree. More accountability and more transparency.

SPEAKER_00And this is so, you know, not to sort of be self promoting, but this is the book, right? So like the book that's coming out in May is basically making this argument that like, if we actually look back at our history, we have lots of lessons for how the Supreme Court was made to look over its shoulder. And, you know, whatever folks think about expansion and term limits like there are also additional things we can do that might not be quite as controversial or toxic that I think would have

SPEAKER_00at least comparable effects on restoring that accountability.

SPEAKER_01I want to, So we're talking with Steve Vladeck, author of One First on Substack, and Steve, you wrote two pieces about the midterms in the courts. The second piece focuses on a less sexy but potentially more important topic. We spent a lot of time talking about the Supreme Court, and obviously that is an object of huge fascination for both of us and a lot of people, but can you talk about You mentioned in passing that you're going to see, it's very likely in this lame duck,

SPEAKER_01Republicans as they lose control of the Senate will rush through and try to confirm a ton of lower court federal judges between now and the end of the lame Can you talk about the midterms and the lower courts? Because we don't really focus on them. Again, for me, the lower court, the federal courts below the Supreme Court are to me in my world, like state legislatures. They're really, really important. But the average person, even who cares about politics,

SPEAKER_01it is very hard to get them to care about it. So can you talk about the midterms and the lower courts and your broader kind of Yeah, I mean, so, you

SPEAKER_00know, the lower courts, and I principally hear, Chris, mean the district courts, the trial courts, you know, sort of the first line of defense in the federal court system, have really been in a remarkable position over the last two years because they have been flooded and, like, you know, numerically overwhelmed with lawsuits against the Trump administration. And some of that is because of how many things the Trump administration is doing. Some of that's because of technical quirks in immigration law that makes it hard to challenge some of those policies on a wholesale as opposed

SPEAKER_00So you've had lower courts with, Chris, literally thousands of cases. I would just have to say, really probably the best and most effective check On the Trump administration over the last two years. Trump has lost a ton of cases in the lower courts, you know, for all of the alarming examples of noncompliance and defiance that the reality is that the typical order is getting enforced. Yeah. You know, think about the law firm cases where the firms

SPEAKER_00that President Trump singled out through executive orders successfully challenged those executive orders and have been exempt from those orders as right. I'm like so many examples of lower courts holding the line. But you know, this was true for the Supreme Court. The lower courts have been doing this alone. And indeed they have, I think in various And so what's really striking to me is that the midterms, I think, take a ton of pressure off the lower courts

SPEAKER_00because they don't have to worry anymore about going it alone. They don't have to worry about Chris Congress, which had spent a fair amount of the last two years going after the lower courts. One statistic, which I think you'll find interesting and maybe mind-boggling, there are now 13 federal district judges Please assume just for adverse,

SPEAKER_01adverse rulings viewed as adverse to the Trump administration.

SPEAKER_00So with one exception, I think there's one judge in that pile who probably should be impeached for misconduct. But 12 of the 13, it was for ruling against the Trump administration. Yeah. And, you know, that's part of a pattern where, you know, we've seen the general counsel of the Department of Homeland Security have a worst of the worst thread on Twitter about district judges. We've seen Republican members of Congress put wanted posters outside their offices with pictures of federal judges who have ruled against the Trump administration. And so, you know, lower courts have been under attack from almost every direction.

SPEAKER_00Even as they've been holding the line, and this is not just Biden appointees or Obama appointees. These are judges from across the geographic and ideological spectrum. Someone like a Judge Patrick Schiltz in Minneapolis, like a dyed-in-the-wool conservative Scalia clerk. Or a Judge John Bates here in Washington. These are not bleeding hearts. They've been under really unprecedented attack, and now they have reinforcements. And so I think, if anything, it is going to make it easier over the next two years for federal courts

SPEAKER_00to just do their job, which is a nice development.

SPEAKER_01Can you explain, I see a few people asking in the chat, can you explain the volume and scale of the number of nominees that Republicans will try to get through at the lower court level between now and let's call it all month from now when the lame duck ends? Are we talking about a wholesale, are we talking about 10%? Where does it land?

SPEAKER_00It's not a huge number in absolute terms, Chris, right? I mean, I think by the time we're done, we're talking about like maybe somewhere between 15 on the lower federal courts. It's just it is I think a pretty shameless breach of norms because to do this, the Senate Republicans are going to have to actually breach a couple of norms about the scheduling of the nominations process right?

SPEAKER_00About sort of how long they have to give the opposition between – Because they don't have

SPEAKER_01the time to do it on the normal schedule.

SPEAKER_00Right And so and so like the reality is like some of these folks could have gotten through under the normal rules anyway. You know, probably by the time we're done, Chris, 10 to 15 will get through who shouldn't have. And in absolute terms, that's not a huge deal. It's just, I think, a good example of how even the sort of lame duck Senate Republicans understand that the lower courts are such an important site. And so most of the cases that matter the most, right, Like we focus on the Supreme court judges, perhaps never

SPEAKER_01same thing.

SPEAKER_00Yep. And so most of the cases that matter the most are touched by the Supreme Court.

SPEAKER_01I think people do not realize that it is so important. Okay, I want to look forward to what we expect if we can sort of handicap what the court might take up. But before we do that, I have one question I get a lot, Steve, and I always forget to ask you. Let's say that in March 2027, for whatever reason, health decision, a seat comes open on the Supreme Court.

SPEAKER_01Democrats control the U.S. Senate. Donald Trump is still the president of the United States. How is it within the realm of possibility that Democrats pull an extended Mitch McConnell and Merrick Garland and simply sort of refuse all the way? So I'm saying May of 2027, refuse all the way until November 2028 to hold hearings and to go through the confirmation process. Is that unlikely?

SPEAKER_01Better than 50%, better than 70%, like where does that land? And obviously we are speculating people.

SPEAKER_00We don't know, but it's possible. So I don't know if this is going to help or hurt my answer, but I think it depends on whose seat becomes vacant. Okay.

SPEAKER_01No, of course, that makes sense to me.

SPEAKER_00Right. Because I think the reaction is very different if it's to fill, for example, Justice Sotomayor's seat or to fill Justice Thomas's. Got it. You know, I could easily see a universe in which Democrats would be willing to provide a somewhat normal process to a—Chris, this is the key word, right? Mainstream Republican nominee If it's for a seat already held by a Republican appointee. If it's a Democratic appointee, I think it's straight McConnell.

SPEAKER_00They just string it out.

SPEAKER_01They are under no... law that they have. To confirm a person or even hold a confirmation vote under a set period of time, correct? No.

SPEAKER_00And in fact, I mean this is – you know, I'm sort of going a little bit far back now but there were a couple of vacancies in the 19th century that lasted more than two years. Okay. You know we haven't had – I mean we haven 'ed a modern precedent. Yeah. The modern precedent is the Scalia precedent. And Scalia's seat, by the time all is done, was held open for 14 months between when Scalia died and when Justice Gorsuch was confirmed in April of 2017. But, you know, I think, I mean, Chris, I think a lot would come down to Who's seat it is

SPEAKER_00and whether Trump would actually be remotely conciliatory about who he nominates. So if Trump pulls the garland, right? If Trump picks like a 65 -year -old or a 62 -year So, Republican Circuit Judge who's called Republican circuit judge who's clearly right of center but who's not a radical, I think there would be a lot of pressure on Democrats to provide a more normal process than McConnell did. But if it's like a Democratic seat or if it's a Firebrand nominee, I think the politics are just, you know, completely forwarding.

SPEAKER_01And there's enough precedent to lean on. And the base would love it. Okay, let's talk about the future. First of all, fill us in on sort of the court has already heard. Where are we in this sort of year, you know, their year-long calendar of hearing, deciding, sitting, and then ruling?

SPEAKER_00So, you know, we get we get these weird Supreme Court terms sometimes, Chris, where there's a change in administration in the middle of the term. We're not getting that this year, but it feels kind of like it. Right. So the term starts in October. So we're about six weeks in as you and I sit here. Got it. Court's heard the first two of its seven argument sessions, so it's heard. I don't know, 12 or 13 cases. It has agreed to decide, I think about 35 so far. That's probably 60 % of what it's going to agree to take up this term.

SPEAKER_00What's interesting about the docket to this point is that it's pretty tame compared to the last couple of years. Not historically, like there are still some really big cases. AR-15s is a huge case. The Colorado Religious Public School case is a really big case.

SPEAKER_01And these are rulings that will come out next summer.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, no later than June.

SPEAKER_01No later than June, right.

SPEAKER_00But I do think, Chris, that the midterms, right, I think, accelerate the likelihood that there are two other buckets of cases that get to the court very quickly before the current term is up. The first are cases about congressional subpoenas, which we are heading for in a hurry.

SPEAKER_01And is the breadth and scope allowed?

SPEAKER_00The breadth and scope, the privileges that can be invoked against them. Chris, can private parties invoke executive privilege as a basis for refusing to testify before Congress? Things like that. Those will go up quickly because I appropriations cases where we have real disputes

SPEAKER_00about Congress trying to defund the president and he spends the money anyway or the president refusing to spend money that Congress has appropriated, those haven't been able to be fully litigated, Chris, over the last two years because of a series of Supreme Court suggestions that only Congress is really the right party to litigate those disputes. Well, now we're going to have a Congress that wants to litigeat those disputes

SPEAKER_00So I think— I mean,

SPEAKER_01Department of Education, right? I mean, basically, Trump was like, well, we're not using that money anymore. The whole doge, other than firing people, the whole doge thing was just saying to Congress, well, you've allocated this money, but we're not going to spend it. Which, I mean, is – again if Democrats had been in charge, we would have been in these fights a year and a half ago. But those fights are probably coming, to your point.

SPEAKER_00It's the Russ Vote presidency versus the Stephen Miller presidency. Right. Right. Yeah. And the vote stuff, the funding, the money, the budgetary stuff, you know, I think there's going to be I think the obstacles to those cases being resolved by the Supreme Court are going to be increasingly overcome. And so by the time we're done in June, I think actually the docket is going to be full of pretty big deal separation of powers disputes because Congress is going to be muscular and, you know, the administration is going to resist and those cases are going to move quickly.

SPEAKER_01I remember when we last the last several times we've talked, one of the points you made, which I thought was fascinating, was that the number of cases involving Donald Trump that gotten for the Supreme Court were historically, you know, well beyond what is we would think is many of those are were a function of his executive orders, birthright citizenship, those sorts of things. What? Is that to continue, do you think, Steve, in the next two years?

SPEAKER_01Or was that very much a kind of first 18 months kind of thing?

SPEAKER_00It's a great question, Chris. I think the answer depends on what Trump decides to do with the last two years. You know, I mean, and this is this is your bailout more than mine. But, you know, does does I wish I could say I knew? I mean, but no one does. But like, you know, is he really going to be a lame duck or is he going to double down? Right. And try to use more and more executive power to do more and more controversial. Right. Is it going to be Stephen Miller who really is calling the shots or is that just,

SPEAKER_00you know, is he going to actually sort of piss everybody off and then it falls apart? Yeah. I don't know, but like if I could see a scenario Chris where Trump tries even more aggressively or at least you know under Trump's authority the White House tries even more aggressively to do controversial stuff and that we see just as much if not more of this right kind of litigation over the next two years. And I could See a universe where it slows down a bit because Trump's heart just isn't in it anymore. Right?

SPEAKER_00He wants his ballroom and he wants his arch and he wants his retirement and that's it. And I just don't know. But I think it's hard, I think, at this point to say it's clearly going to be one or the other. I just think that the odds that we have just as much litigation over the next two years are pretty high.

SPEAKER_01All right. I want to end on this. Your book, which I love, the book that is coming out May 4th, is called The Court We Need, What's Really Wrong with the Supreme Court. I don't want you to give away the milk before people buy the cow, which, by the way, you can go and do so up in this chat, and I will post it in the archive version. I'll post a link to it as well. But, Steve, what? Give a preview, you mentioned this a little bit, but give a preview of kind of the argument you lay out and to the extent that you propose fixes broadly what they look like and then we'll end.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I think, you know, we sort of danced around it already, Chris. I mean, the basic argument that the book makes is that if you're trying to figure out What's really wrong with the Supreme Court right now? Everything that folks tend to point to are all just like symptoms. So, you know, the abuses of the emergency docket, the overturning of precedent, right? The sort of taking cases prematurely. The court being in a hurry. This to me is the ethics and the personal behavior. This is all to me a court that feels like it can do whatever it wants whenever it wants.

SPEAKER_00And there's a great quote from Justice Alito in 2023 where he says, I think he said something like, I realize this is a controversial position, but I'm willing to say it. No provision in the Constitution gives Congress the authority to regulate the Supreme Court, period. Period. So that's literally incorrect. Article 3. I was going to say, I knew that from our conversation today, that's incorrect. It's literally incorrect. It's historically incorrect. But Chris, it's the zeitgeist. Yeah. The current

SPEAKER_00court doesn't worry about congressional regulation. And that actually we could do a lot to fix the court, not necessarily to get it to rule the way we want to in every case, but just to get it to behave more responsibly from an institutional perspective. Simply by restoring and reigniting those inner branch accountability mechanisms.

SPEAKER_00And, you know, if anything, the midterms, I think, add a sense of possibility to all of this because I think the politics are moving ever more rapidly in the direction of that being possible.

SPEAKER_01I think that's right. Look, every time we do one of these, I learn a bunch. Let me urge people to do two things. Number one, the court we need, what's really wrong with the Supreme Court. Steve was just giving you a preview of it. It is out May 4th. You can pre-order it. We will make sure there is a link. There is one in the chat if you are live. The other thing I really would encourage people to do is subscribe to Steve's One First Substack. Again, over 108,000 people can't be wrong. I mean, I guess they could be, but it's unlikely.

SPEAKER_01They have subscribed, and if you like what Steve has laid out, there is just no one more knowledgeable and able to talk in terms that a non-lawyer dummy like myself can understand. Steve, as always, truly thank you. The best. He is a professor of federal courts at Georgetown Law School in addition to everything else. So One First and The Court We Need. Check both of those out. Steve, as always, truly thank you. I think this is great. And for folks who are wondering, yes, Steve and I do these every couple months or if there's something really big,

SPEAKER_01I'll reach out to him if he's not too busy. So yes, we will continue to do these again. Selfishly is because I feel smarter when I'm done with them. After listening to Steve, I hope you guys do too. Thank you, my friend. Always a pleasure.

SPEAKER_00Likewise, Chris. Thanks so much. Thanks, everybody.

SPEAKER_01See you everywhere. Bye. Bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Court Against the Courts: A Conversation With Jack Goldsmith

    Nov 20, 202637 minAudio

    As I noted in Monday’s post, the Harvard Law Review’s annual Supreme Court issue, including my Foreword - “The Court Against the Courts” - came out last week. On Thursday, November 20, I sat down with Harvard law...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. First One: A Run on the Bank—Why Weil Fell

    Nov 10, 202640 minAudio

    In this episode of “First One,” the (fairly irregular) podcast companion to the “One First” newsletter, Steve sat down with Karen Vladeck (a lawyer-turned-legal recruiter and the founder and managing director of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Missouri Mess: Live with Cristian Farias and Steve Vladeck

    Sep 22, 202619 minAudio

    On Tuesday morning, Cristian Farias and I got together for a quick Substack Live to discuss the goings-on in the Missouri redistricting case - including what happened in the Eighth Circuit on Monday and what’s likely to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Live with Steve Vladeck on the Supreme Court USPS opinion

    Sep 15, 202630 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.stevevladeck.com/subscribe

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Live with Joyce Vance & Steve Vladeck: Trump v. California

    Aug 25, 202623 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.stevevladeck.com/subscribe

    Credit the people on this episode